Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
A caller named Jennifer joins the program from Illinois to ask about a deferred fixed long-term care annuity proposal from her financial advisor. At age 62, Jennifer and her retired spouse are debt-free, own a home worth $450,000, collect $75,000 annually in a survivor-benefit pension, and hold substantial assets including a $1.9 million brokerage account, $860,000 in a Roth account, a $500,000 401(k), and an inherited annuity worth $785,000. Her advisor suggests using a single year's gain of $116,000 from the existing annuity via a 1035 exchange to purchase a Nationwide long-term care annuity rider, which would immediately value $348,000 for care services.
The host and the producer evaluate whether Jennifer needs this long-term care insurance product given her significant existing wealth and family history where older relatives passed away without extended care costs. While acknowledging that Jennifer likely does not strictly need the extra coverage based on her asset level, they determine the proposal is not egregious because it leverages just one year of annuity gains rather than liquidating the entire principal. The host advises Jennifer to consider paying an hourly fee-only advisor for a second opinion to confirm the strategy provides genuine peace of mind.
- Review your annuity options carefully and consult a fee-only professional before making major changes. 6:49
- Utilize 1035 exchanges to move insurance product funds without triggering immediate ordinary income tax events. 13:57
- Consider hiring an independent expert by the hour to review complex financial proposals for a second opinion. 19:06
- Check credentials through NAPFA to find qualified local advisors who charge by the hour or project. 20:14
Chapters
- 0:03Podcast Introduction and Promotion
The hosts introduce the show, explain how to get on air, and promote upcoming webinars and subscription services.
- 1:48Mark’s Colonoscopy and Webinar PSA
Mark humorously explains his colonoscopy schedule and promotes the Medicare webinar with Marsha Mantel.
- 7:38Introduction of Guest Jennifer
Jennifer joins to discuss her inherited annuity, trust ownership, and overall financial picture.
- 8:24Jennifer’s Asset Breakdown
Jennifer details her annuity, brokerage, pension, Roth, 401(k), and home equity.
- 11:00Pros and Cons of the Long‑Term Care Annuity
The hosts debate whether the 116,000‑dollar conversion is worthwhile given Jennifer’s assets and health.
- 12:51Long‑Term Care Annuity Proposal
Jennifer’s advisor suggests converting a portion of the annuity into a long‑term care product.
- 13:34Annuity Overview and 1035 Exchange Explanation
Jill explains how annuities work, the 1035 exchange rule, and the tax implications of moving funds.
- 21:48Final Recommendation and Takeaway
Jill advises a cautious approach, recommending a second opinion and weighing peace of mind against cost.
- 22:18Show Closing and Call to Action
The hosts wrap up, remind listeners to contact them, and promote the podcast’s community and future episodes.
Highlights
- 3:03
The subscription service costs $45 for 12 months, or single-session webinars can be purchased for $15.
- 5:17
Advisor perspective on annuitiesinsight
A fee-only advisor writes in to explain that annuities are sometimes necessary as gatekeepers for clients who cannot manage the shift from accumulation to spending.
- 9:23
The 62-year-old caller and her spouse live on a $75,000 pension and $60,000 in brokerage dividends while spending $110,000 to $120,000 per year.
- 10:29
Retirement account conversionsstrategy
The caller is systematically rolling traditional 401(k) funds into a Roth account, which has grown to $860,000.
- 14:23
Tax rules on annuitiesstrategy
The host explains that cashing out an annuity triggers ordinary income tax on all accumulated gains above the original principal amount.
- 17:24
The financial advisor proposes rolling a $116,000 annuity gain into a Nationwide long-term care product via a 1035 exchange.
- 19:53
Evaluating the LTC purchaseinsight
The host and producer conclude that while the caller probably does not need long-term care insurance given her wealth, using a small gain for peace of mind is acceptable.
Quotes
“If your advisor's like, "Oh, no, I won't touch that," then you probably need a new advisor.”
Unnamed speaker · 7:01 “I would suggest that if you are looking at a product like this, that you have a second set of eyes on it, meaning a second opinion.”
Unnamed speaker · 18:53 “If you need care, you could obviously probably pay for a lot of it, because you have that pension.”
Unnamed speaker · 19:21 “I don't think you need it, because if you needed care, you could obviously probably pay for a lot of it, because you have that pension.”
Unnamed speaker · 19:16
Sponsored segments
- Jill on Money Live 1:02–1:15
- Jill on Money Live 2:54–3:18
About this episode
Our advisor is suggesting we swap one annuity for another, one that comes with long-term care coverage. Should we do it? Have a money question? Email us here https://www.jillonmoney.com/contact Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter https://www.jillonmoney.com/newsletter/substack YouTube: @jillonmoney https://www.youtube.com/c/JillSchlesinger Instagram: @jillonmoney https://www.instagram.com/jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com http://www.joelgoodman.com/.
Transcript
3,752 words · 3 speakers
Topics
- annuity
- 401K
- Medicare
- long‑term care annuity
- Rivian
- Money Moves
- Consumer Reports
- Nationwide
- 1035 exchange
- Roth IRA
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated