Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Roth Conversions Leading to Early Retirement? About this episode While I’m in the 22% tax bracket, should I begin making small annual Roth conversions? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:03 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Tuesday, January 13th, and we are here trying to help you navigate that financial journey, whatever path is in front of you. Maybe there's a few different ways to get where you want to go. Maybe you want to test some different ways out. Maybe you just need another set of ears and eyes on your situation. Mark and I are both Certified Financial Planners. We love talking to you. This program is so wonderful because you guys do all the work. We just listen to you and try to take some of the emotions out of the decisions that you are confronting. So if you'd like to get in touch with us, just go to our website, jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button in the upper right-hand corner, write us a note. If you would like to join us on the
0:48 Speaker 00 air, check the box. Mark will do everything else. Don't forget to sign up for our free weekly newsletter. That also entitles you to the blog posts that we put up there. So check that out. Okay, let's take some emails. We're starting with one from SL who writes, "I recently discovered your podcast and love your show. I've been binge listening during my driving time ever since. I find the content and your advice practical, relevant, and relatable." See, I wish this person were on the air with us, Mark. Come on, I want that. That's a snippet that we can put out there. Okay, "Please keep the content coming." All right, Mark, here's the question, "To convert or not to convert? I've gathered you
1:29 Speaker 00 seem generally opposed to Roth conversions, particularly if you don't have adequate liquidity outside of retirement accounts to pay the tax due." No, we like Roth conversions, but we really want to make sure you have the money to pay the tax that's due. And sometimes for some people, it works great, and some people need to maybe do some planning around that because it pops them into different tax brackets. So we're not against, we love conversions. We do think you need the liquidity to do this. Okay, so SL says, "I have the liquidity. I think converting my traditional to Roth could make sense to put the deferred future tax liability behind me and simplify my financial picture." Okay, 49 years old,
2:14 Speaker 00 single, no kids, targeting age 55, to be positioned financially for retirement, targeting initial $200,000 in after-tax retirement income, which I would want to keep up with inflation. Currently in the top marginal federal tax bracket. Hmm. And also state income tax about 5%. $2.7 million in after-tax brokerage account. 600 grand in money markets. Another 170 in cash reserves. So what are we looking at, Mark? We're looking at a traditional 401K that has 1 1/4 million dollars.
2:56 Speaker 00 The rest's got about like 165 grand in Roth assets, 40 in an HSA, 350 in a qualified cash balance pension. So basically, it's actually more like 1.6 million in this, in retirement assets. So, question mark. You ready to answer? Get ready. Do you think, asks SL, I should pull the trigger and convert my traditional 401K balance into a Roth? Alternatively, or perhaps in addition, should I shift my pre-tax 401K contributions to Roth going forward? That's what SL wants to know. Mark, what do you think?
3:36 Speaker 01 Well, the last part for me is a no-brainer. I, even though he's in the top tax bracket, yes, I would switch going forward. You don't need any more tax-deferred money. Whether or not to convert 1.25 million, that's going to be some check that this person's going to have to write.
3:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, here's a couple of things to consider. Because you're going to retire early, I don't know. That may be the time to do it. That's what I'm thinking. Like, think about this, SL. From age 55 to 75, like those 20 years where you will have the ability to attack that 401K, potentially at a lower tax bracket. Now, of course, as you note, you got the money that's available. If you just want to get it done, it's just like you know you're in the highest tax bracket. And I just wonder if we might get a shot to be at a lower tax bracket.
4:31 Speaker 00 So, single ordinary income at 37% is over 626 grand. So dude's making a lot of money. I think at 55, you're going to have a lot more information. I guess what's the downside, Mark, is he waits and the tax law changes. And he's screwed anyway. I think I would roll the dice. And wait till 55. You're so close. It's only six years away. So, and I would agree with Mark. Absolutely. You should put money into the Roth bucket as opposed to pre-tax at this point. Let's not compound the problem. Next up, this is an email from Chris. The subject is finding a CFP who doesn't sell any products. Oh, brother.
5:12 Speaker 00 This is a toughie. Anyway, Chris writes, hello, I listen to your shows daily and I've heard you mention a few times that people should work with fee only financial planners. Well, I'm in California and it seems that most of the folks out there are selling products or services like wealth management. I'm looking for someone who can just guide us. Any help or contacts you may recommend would be greatly appreciated. Thanks, Chris. Chris, I think it is worth going to the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors. That's NAPFA, N-A-P-F-A.org. And you can look into who will actually do a financial plan for you.
5:52 Speaker 00 There are some places that they'll just do the work. I don't know if we've looked at XY Planning. That is another firm that tends to do, I think that they, they do fee only financial planning. And you can find some information about those folks at xyplaningnetwork.com and read in on that. But I think that for many people who are willing to take a financial plan and execute it themselves, this is a really good option. So, NAPFA, or again, maybe you check out XY Planning. Both of those things are possibilities for you. Okay, this is from Brooke who writes, I'm currently contributing the maximum annual amount to my Roth 401K.
6:37 Speaker 00 In addition, 3% of my after-tax pay is converted to Roth, the most my company plan allows. This after-tax contribution is required to receive the full 7% employer match. My salary is $130,000. I typically receive a 3% to 5% raise each year. My company contributes 7% of my salary. Annually to a tax-deferred account. Plus, check this out, Mark. An estimated 13% to 15% of my salary in ESOP shares. ESOP is Employee Stock Ownership Plan. And our ESOP has historically grown at about 10% a year. Okay, here are the questions. Pay attention, Mark, because my throat hurts.
7:21 Speaker 00 While I'm in the 22% bracket, married filing jointly, should I begin making small annual Roth conversions to build my Roth basis? And that way I can access it early in retirement and reduce future required minimum distributions. Mark, answer.
7:39 Speaker 01 I don't know yet. I'm waiting for some more details.
7:42 Speaker 00 All right, let's go, go, keep going. Does the Rule 72-T seem like a logical strategy in early retirement? Mark, would you like to explain Rule 72-T?
7:54 Speaker 01 The periodic equal distributions?
7:56 Speaker 00 Yep.
7:57 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, I mean, if, I'm assuming she's already done her homework and her, her plan allows that. So, I mean, it's good to know that she has that option if necessary.
8:05 Speaker 00 So this, she says she's figured out that she could draw $40,000 on an annual basis. And she said Roth conversion with another account that would be, put me at the top of the lower bracket. And then I would supplement my income with other long-term capital gains. I've already completed $30,000 Roth conversion in '24, $35,000 in '25. Let me just get to the assets here, okay? Because I think that's easier. Okay, Brooke is 35. My goal is to retire or at least shift into semi-retirement between the ages of 45 and 50. I'm 35, I am married, my wife is the same age. We have two children that will hopefully be launched by our ages 35 and 37.
8:50 Speaker 00 We live off of $70,000 annually, no debt. And Brooke is the sole provider to the family. You ready for the money? Here we go, Mark.
8:59 Speaker 01 Wait a second. I'm just, how do they have two kids that are gonna be launched by the time she's 35, 37? Isn't that in like two years?
9:06 Speaker 00 Maybe they mean, maybe he means 45, 47.
9:09 Speaker 01 All right.
9:09 Speaker 00 That's possible. I don't know. That seems very odd. Okay. So, we have $640,000 in traditional assets, okay? 160 in Roth assets, 200 in the employee stock ownership, and $360,000 in a brokerage account, taxable. Their home is paid off, 320 grand. All right. Are we ready to start converting, Mark? What do you think?
9:37 Speaker 01 Uh, I don't know. I don't know if I would be in such a hurry to do it. I would keep doing everything Roth, obviously, which, which, which this person is doing going forward. But if, you know, if, if you know that you're gonna be retiring early,
9:51 Speaker 01 that could be the, that could be the window to do it.
9:53 Speaker 00 Right. That's what I always think is like, hey, before we start converting right this second, I mean, maybe you'll never be in anything less than the 22%. I guess you could keep doing it at 22, but if you think about it, in 10 years, what's your income gonna be? You know? And even if you get 40 grand from your 72T distribution, right? And then you're using some of your, your money in the brokerage account, you might be in a much lower tax bracket. I mean, it's possible. It really is possible that you go, instead of being in 22, I guess, I don't know, I think you'll probably be in 22 for most of your life, because that's up to about 200 and some thousand. Maybe you do a little bit to stay in 22,
10:38 Speaker 00 but once you go down, right, once you go down to 12%, that, that bracket is, as of right now, it's just about 97,000 is the top of that bracket. So, I don't know, maybe they won't make it, but maybe they could.
10:54 Speaker 01 It's very hard to do these small conversions, you know, do a little bit this year, a little bit this year, a little bit. You'd never, you know, the accounts are gonna grow at such a clip unless something, unless the economy just goes into the tank. It's, it's very hard to, you know, to get that.
11:07 Speaker 00 Move the needle.
11:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
11:09 Speaker 00 Right?
11:09 Speaker 01 Yeah, and it, the growth is gonna, you know, probably surpass whatever amount you convert.
11:14 Speaker 00 So true. Um, anyway, come on the air with us, is when I want to talk to people on the air. Steve writes, "I'm going to live with my daughter and the family, and here's what's going on. A pension of $266,000." That must be the lump sum. Uh, savings, about $200,000, 45 grand in a 403B, 116 in a rollover IRA. Hmm, house that is going for sale, $400,000, $1,600 a month into social security. I need to know how to pull all this into a trust, or do I? What do I change? Okay, let's have a deep breath here. Pension assets, retirement assets, all pass by contract.
11:59 Speaker 00 You name a beneficiary. The savings and the proceeds of the house, that's different. I don't know if you need a trust. You might, I don't know if you're talking about a trust to protect you if you needed to go into like a nursing home, or you just want to have a trust that will distribute your assets cleanly. If it's just the trust to distribute your assets cleanly, then I might just do a transfer on death brokerage account and call it a day. But I think it's worth having a conversation with your kids and making sure that you're paying what you need to pay to, you know, pay your way. I'm not sure I'd do a trust. So get back in touch with us. I'm not sure if we're doing a trust to protect assets against spending them down,
12:44 Speaker 00 or just distribution of assets for regular old estate planning. Okay, last one. Victor, I'm retiring from the military in a few years. Ultimately, should I take the survivor benefit plan? When is it okay not to take it? Should people always take it? Oh, Victor, this is completely predicated on what is going on in your life. And the survivor benefit is usually something where we tend to lean into like, if you have a spouse who's really relying on you and your spouse is younger than you, or you're married to a woman who has a longer life expectancy, we're often saying, let's do the survivor benefit. Mark, when's a no to the survivor benefit?
13:29 Speaker 00 If you have a spouse?
13:31 Speaker 01 If you have a spouse? I mean, unless that spouse also has a huge pension, or you know, is a high earner and you already have substantial amount of savings. But you know, usually, I don't know, I need to know, you know, how much of a haircut is going to be.
13:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, we like to just know a little bit more about you before we make that make that decision with you, you know, or just at least guide you. So get back in touch with us. Okay, gang, that is it. That's the program. Get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, write us a note. And if you want to join us live, check the box. Mark will do everything else. Don't forget to sign up for the free weekly newsletter. And of course, check out our subscription service, Jill on Money Live. Big changes at Jill on Money Live this year. Access to quarterly live webinars, the back catalog of those webinars, bonus audio and video content, all for 45 bucks for the next 12 months. No change there. But we are introducing a per webinar ability for you if you just
14:28 Speaker 00 want to buy one webinar at a time. Costs you 15 bucks. So pretty good deal, I think. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Try to put your hands metaphorically on someone's back. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening. We'll talk to you tomorrow.
14:54 Speaker 02 The business world is moving faster than ever. And when change hits, we need to learn in real time. On Rapid Response, you'll hear candid conversations with CEOs and leaders making tough calls about AI, human talent, responsibility, and the bottom line. How they navigate uncertainty, pressure, and high stakes moments. I'm Bob Safian, former editor in chief of Fast Company, and I'll be your host as each episode breaks down what you need to know right now. You can find Rapid Response wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Managing the Moving Parts Next Can Trump Cap Credit Card Rates? Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated