Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger New Job, New Options About this episode I'm about to start a new job and I need to decide if I want to participate in the defined benefit pension plan. Or should I use the defined contribution plan? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 How could market forces impact investment strategies? Tune into The Angle from T. Rowe Price for sharp insights on today's key trends. From the blue economy and AI to the impacts of policy shifts. The Angle brings you an information edge with thought provoking questions to changing market themes and gives curious investors dynamic perspectives from our global investing team. Listen and subscribe to The Angle on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and learn more at troweprice.com/theanglepodcast.
0:30 Speaker 01 Running a business is hard enough. Why make it harder with dozens of disconnected apps? I know so many founders and managers who spend half their workday just jumping between tabs, trying to get one program for accounting to play nice with another for inventory, CRM, and HR. You end up paying thousands of dollars every month for a Frankenstein monster of software that actually slows your team down instead of helping them work. That's why you need to switch to Odoo. Odoo is an all-in-one, fully-integrated business platform that brings every single department into one clean, effortless dashboard. Instead of burning cash on bloated subscription fees for half a dozen different platforms, Odoo replaces them all for a tiny fraction of the cost.
1:15 Speaker 01 It is completely customizable, remarkably easy for your staff to learn, and designed to scale with you whether you're running a boutique startup or expanding a massive enterprise. It streamlines your entire operation from top to bottom so you can stop wrestling with your tech stack and finally focus on what really matters: growing your company. Thousands of businesses have already made the switch. Why not you? Try Odoo for free today at Odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com.
1:52 Speaker 01 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Monday, November 25th, and we are here trying to help you make better, less bad, maybe more considered financial decisions. We do that in a very, very easy way. All we have to do, we're kind of like inbound responders, like we're waiting for you to get in touch with us. So to do that, you go to our website, jillonthemoney.com. You click on the Contact Us button. Easy to do. It's always in the upper right-hand corner of the website. You complete the form. That's the email we receive. If you'd like to join us live, check the box. Mark does everything else. There's podcast links. There's blog links. There's video links, resources. Don't forget to sign up
2:36 Speaker 01 for the free weekly newsletter. Comes out every single Friday. All right. Today, we are talking to listener Jeff, who's on the line from the Midwest, Illinois specifically. We kind of feel comfortable believing there's more than one Jeff from Illinois. So I'm sorry if I've outed you, Jeff, but here you are. Welcome. How are you?
2:55 Speaker 02 I'm doing good. Thanks for having me.
2:57 Speaker 01 What's going on?
2:58 Speaker 02 Oh, nothing. Just getting ready for Thanksgiving. So just add one more stressor to the pot. Geez.
3:06 Speaker 01 Really? Wow. What a great upbeat way to start the work week. Thanks, man. Okay. And next, Jeff, bring it up a notch. Okay. You're here. You're talking to us. Everything's good. What can we do for you? We cannot take away the holiday stress.
3:22 Speaker 02 Well, I have a lot of upcoming changes, both in the work life and the home life. You know, things were pretty much on cruise control. You know, we had our typical, you know, two kids. I've been working at my job for over 10 years. Everything seems automated, financing and finances with retirement, but.
3:45 Speaker 02 Um, taking a new job position and that is gonna change some funds and uh, we have some retirement questions on how to deal with that. And then we have one more child uh, that's on the way. So.
4:00 Speaker 01 Oh, so you bought two with an option for another. Interesting. How old are the two kids?
4:05 Speaker 02 Uh, the girl is six, my son is three, and this next one is a question mark.
4:11 Speaker 01 You know, it's nice, though. That's like a decent amount of time between them. You you've certainly spread it out pretty well, as much as you can control these things. Jeff, how old are you?
4:21 Speaker 02 I am forty two.
4:22 Speaker 01 How old is your wife?
4:23 Speaker 02 Thirty five.
4:25 Speaker 01 Okay. And are you both working full time?
4:27 Speaker 02 I'm working full time. She was full time until the second one, and then she dropped down to part time. So she does about twenty four hours a week.
4:36 Speaker 01 Okay. And how much does she earn on that twenty four hours a week?
4:40 Speaker 02 Uh, she brings home about fifty five a year on that.
4:44 Speaker 01 Wow, that's great. Um, and so you're you said you're switching jobs. That's exciting. So tell us what's happening there.
4:53 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's mostly a family move. You know, that my current job, um, my schedule is completely up for grabs. You know, it's a healthcare job. So you know, I know how many hours a month I'm gonna work, but beyond that, um, I don't know, the days could be nights, could be weird shifts. I'm not home, you know, half the month I'm not home in the evening to help with the uh,
5:15 Speaker 01 Oh, no, that's no good.
5:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, dinner, bath, bed, which is kind of like the most stressful time in the house.
5:21 Speaker 01 Oh, my God, feels very lucky. All I have to do is walk the dog and feed her, feed them. Um, okay, so right now you're working full time but out of control. So um, what's your um, new, so your current salary is how much?
5:34 Speaker 02 Uh, currently it's one fifty five.
5:37 Speaker 01 Okay, and the new job will be how much?
5:40 Speaker 02 It will be 115, but that's a caveat, um, because I will bump up to about one, back up to 155 after six months.
5:50 Speaker 01 Oh, that's good. Alright, okay. So, right now with Wacky's schedule, 155 and your wife's 55, how is the cash flow been for you guys?
6:01 Speaker 02 It's been pretty good, uh, up till now. Like I said, everything has been pretty automated. You know, I, I max out my 401k. Um, she's been getting her match, which is up to 3%, and then she does another 5%. Mortgage kind of just comes out of the automated, you know, checking account.
6:21 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
6:22 Speaker 02 Um, it, it seems, it, in my mind, it sounds kind of dumb that I say it's paycheck to paycheck, but it's really not. I mean, it's paycheck to paycheck.
6:30 Speaker 01 I know what you mean. Like, once you've, you've put all this money away, then it's like, we're, okay, I got you.
6:35 Speaker 02 Correct. And that includes like, you know, I was doing 529s and we're doing a little bit into a brokerage account, so, um.
6:42 Speaker 01 Alright, let's get a grip on all this for a second. So, we've, when is this new job starting?
6:48 Speaker 02 December 2nd.
6:50 Speaker 01 Okay. Oh, it's so close. Okay. And, um, will you also have a 401k at the new job?
6:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, except it's a little more complicated because the new job is a, a state position.
7:01 Speaker 01 Ooh.
7:02 Speaker 02 Yeah, so it will have a 8% mandatory that goes to a, correct, if you choose the pension. But then, part of the question is, there's actually an upper limit to if you choose the traditional pension, which I will be making beyond that. So, part of the question is, do I choose to put, uh, the traditional pension, or do I do the, what they call, uh, RSP? Which allows me to get that 8% plus another 7% match without the upper limit of 100. Their upper limit's 115,000. So, anything beyond that, I wouldn't get any match. I wouldn't get any 8%.
7:42 Speaker 01 Interesting. Let's go back a little bit as well. How much money is in your current 401k?
7:49 Speaker 02 Um, so I have a rollover from an old job and my current, so my old rollover IRA is 256. That is in, uh, traditional.
8:02 Speaker 02 My current is um two hundred twenty six.
8:07 Speaker 01 Also traditional?
8:09 Speaker 02 Uh twenty eight of that is Roth.
8:11 Speaker 01 Okay, and your wife's retirement account, the the what she has in uh based on her part time?
8:18 Speaker 02 Yep, she's got seventy and um her four oh one and five of that is Roth.
8:24 Speaker 01 Okay, any any um old rollover for her?
8:28 Speaker 02 No, but we we do have um back a couple like a decade ago, we were contributing to our own Roth. So you know, there's an additional twenty nine K and a Roth for me.
8:39 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
8:40 Speaker 02 There's an additional fifteen K and a Roth for her.
8:43 Speaker 01 Okay.
8:43 Speaker 02 And there's an additional sixty K in uh HSA.
8:48 Speaker 01 Wow, that's good. Um who has the HSA? Did you have it?
8:52 Speaker 02 Me, yeah.
8:53 Speaker 01 Are you gonna use that? Uh do you will you have in your new plan, a high deductible health plan with an HSA?
9:00 Speaker 02 I don't I don't know. I haven't really looked too deep into that. Um there's there's a a plethora of of health options, health um care options. So I think in the meantime, we're probably take the one with the lower deductible just because we've been with the the kids. It's like we, you know, it's like an automatic six thousand dollars you're gonna spend every single year.
9:21 Speaker 01 Yep, I got you. I got it. I understand. Um you mentioned a brokerage account earlier. How much is in there?
9:28 Speaker 02 Uh twenty seven.
9:30 Speaker 01 And how about uh just plain cash, like checking, savings, CDs?
9:36 Speaker 02 Just we, I mean, there's thirty thousand in the emergency and there's typically about ten in the checking account just for who knows what pops up.
9:47 Speaker 01 Gotcha. And you also said you own a home. What's the house worth?
9:50 Speaker 02 Uh it's five hundred.
9:52 Speaker 01 And mortgage outstanding?
9:55 Speaker 02 Two sixty uh two point five.
9:57 Speaker 01 Oh my god. Okay, and is that a thirty year?
10:01 Speaker 02 Yes.
10:02 Speaker 01 Okay, great. So when you make this shift in just a few, just a week, okay? The question I have is how are you going to float the lower amount? The one, you know, that you're making forty grand less. What are you going to do in these first six months? Just like, so we can, you know, kind of just manage cash flow first.
10:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, I will. I have a lot of, of PTO in my old position that I can actually sell out one to one.
10:35 Speaker 01 Really? And how much will that cover you?
10:37 Speaker 02 That'll cover me for about fifteen thousand.
10:40 Speaker 01 Okay.
10:41 Speaker 02 And then I will also get a signing bonus. So that'll cover another twelve thousand.
10:48 Speaker 01 Oh, so you're pretty good. Do you think that you'll have to, I mean, I guess the other thing is this baby is coming and maybe your wife's income will shift a little bit.
10:59 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:00 Speaker 01 So how much do you think you will need? We just think about the first six months of 2025. How much money do you think you'll just need to have on hand? Because we know we're going to have twenty seven, the PTO and the signing bonus. But what else? Because that doesn't feel like enough to me.
11:17 Speaker 02 I don't know. I mean, we can, we can definitely reduce our, we started reducing our, our monthly like cash expenditures. Once we kind of found out like, oh, everything's coming to a head at once. So, you know, we can reduce, I think right now we almost not including, or actually, yeah, not including the mortgage, we probably spend, I think, about seven a month, seven, eight a month, seven K, eight K. So, I mean, we can easily
11:48 Speaker 01 Okay.
11:49 Speaker 02 reduce that to four K, I think.
11:51 Speaker 01 Well, we don't have to. I mean, that's a lot. It feels like that's a pretty dramatic change for you. Okay, so it sounds like the you're fairly covered in terms of this transition. And so in the new job, so are the big questions about whether to use the traditional pension or this RSP? And that's one question, right? And then the old 401k, is that just going to roll into what your traditional is right now?
12:25 Speaker 02 I haven't decided that yet. I know my my old 401 is in is at T-RO. And my current is in Merrill Lynch, which is actually they're switching to Vanguard here shortly. And I know the T-RO price I had actually read. A couple areas like, you know, once you get so money or so much money in a specific like fund or IRA, they'll reduce the fees. So I didn't know if it was a smarter move to push everything to T-RO because they've done fine with me. But I've been really lazy. I've done target retirement on everything up to this point.
13:01 Speaker 01 Oh, can we shift that a little bit? So the so what you're saying is the rollover account, you rolled over from a T-RO plan into a rollover at T-RO, right? That you're self-managing. Okay, just want to make sure I understood that. In the in the RSP, so we know that there's this upper limit for this state job, right? But we don't know, what we don't know is whether you're really going to want to stick around for the period of time that would make it kind of lock you into the pension system, which I imagine to get like the best benefits is more like 20 years. Is that about right?
13:39 Speaker 02 To get the health retirement benefits is 20 years, but the I think the actual vesting for the pension is eight to eight years, I think.
13:50 Speaker 01 Okay. Do you feel like you want to like take the risk? Like, how are you feeling about this?
13:55 Speaker 02 I think so. I mean, I've spoken to some colleagues that I've actually worked with personally at my current job that have moved over to this new job and
14:08 Speaker 02 You know, and I've done a lot of shadowing there. I've actually gone there and spent some time there. So I think that I'm very hopeful that I'll be there for the long term.
14:19 Speaker 01 Hmm. Okay, so I guess the question is, when you, if you were to use the the RSP, it allows an eight percent contribution on all of the money you have, right? Is that right? And then, and then it is a match, but tell me how the match works? Is it a straight? In other words, do you have to put in seven to get seven? Or what's the actual?
14:46 Speaker 02 No, it's an automatics. It's an automatic seven point six. So I think there's a mandatory eight percent.
14:53 Speaker 01 Yeah.
14:53 Speaker 02 That goes into this plan that they get because you don't play, you don't pay into social security with the position.
15:00 Speaker 01 Oh, I see. I got you.
15:01 Speaker 02 Then there's an automatic seven point six percent match beyond that, of which of course also hits an upper limit if you don't do the RSP version.
15:11 Speaker 01 What are you leaning towards right now? I have like a sense that you're leaning away from the traditional and I'm just want to figure out why. Cause it's because you feel like you're leaving money on the table?
15:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's the only reason why. Because I think, I don't know how many raises that, you know, I'll, I'll get in the future. I mean, that could be little, that could be many. I have no idea, but I know at some point, you know, I'm going to be within a year, I'm going to be back to, you know, one hundred and fifty five.
15:41 Speaker 01 And then you'll probably get like cost of living adjustments, right?
15:44 Speaker 02 Hopefully.
15:45 Speaker 01 Oh, stop. Okay. Um, okay. So I get where you're going with this. It's a weird thing, only because you happen to mention you're from Illinois and Illinois has a very bad pension funding scheme, which does not mean that you're, they're not going to pay it. It just means that this is why I understand this is to be a very, it's most, it's very different than many other state plans because they have such a huge pension imbalance in in the state finances. Mark, are you comfortable foregoing the guarantee of the benefit, the defined benefit plan and using what is essentially more of a defined contribution plan?
16:27 Speaker 03 Believe it or not, I'm leaning pension.
16:30 Speaker 01 You are?
16:31 Speaker 03 Yeah, cuz he thinks he's gonna be there for a while, you know, I trust him on that. It's probably gonna be a fat pension. I'm not, yeah, I know Illinois, but it, you know, I don't know. I'm gonna trust that they've kind of worked out some of their issues. It's been a while since they've been in the news. And I was reading ahead in his email, this new retirement plan, like they've already got a lot of pre-tax money. This new retirement plan doesn't have a Roth option, so he's just gonna be stockpiling more pre-tax money.
16:57 Speaker 01 Oh, that's interesting.
16:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:58 Speaker 01 Um, well, I guess the other thing would be is that if you're only making a contribution on your 115 on the defined benefit, right? If that's where it maxes out, you could then turn around and put more money in your brokerage account, right? I mean, that would free you up a little bit, cuz if you weren't putting it all away in this pre-tax RSP, you would have the cash flow to add. So I guess it's almost like a hedge in some respects. The reason why I tend to like the, the security of this state job, of the pension as an opportunity, is, you know, I think you probably are gonna stay.
17:42 Speaker 01 I feel like those health benefits are gonna be massive for you guys, and since your wife is working part-time, maybe she'll go back full-time, right? Eventually?
17:49 Speaker 03 I think so, once the youngest is in, um, probably kindergarten.
17:53 Speaker 01 So when you think about that, you know, whatever, five or six years from now, her 55, what would that go to? Would that go to 100?
18:02 Speaker 03 Probably more at that point. She gets some pretty good cost of living adjustments.
18:06 Speaker 01 Okay, would she be entitled to a pension?
18:09 Speaker 03 No.
18:09 Speaker 01 Okay, let me ask you another question. Who is the plan provider in this RSP? Where am I stuck? Cuz sometimes they plan, oh, that's not my favorite. I'm really, I am torn on this one. I really am. I think that there's two pieces of it. So I would understand it if you said, "No, I just want to make it automatic. It's easy. The money comes out." But if you would be willing to say, "I'm going to take $1,000 or $1,500 a month that will be freed up instead of putting money into the RSP, that I'll put the money into the defined benefit up to 115, but then as that money is freed up, when my salary goes up, that I would then take that
18:53 Speaker 01 money and put it into the brokerage account. That $27,000 brokerage account becomes more of like the building block of the non or the taxed retirement supplemental account, like because we don't have a Roth option for you. Although, Mark, where's the Roth, where is that Roth cutoff? Let me just see something here.
19:11 Speaker 03 230, 230 for this year.
19:14 Speaker 01 So for next year, it'll be like 240. You might be able to make a Roth contribution next year, just because your salary is going to be low. You should check that out, you know? And then if you make two Roth contributions next year, then you are essentially doing exactly what you would have done with the RSP, which is putting the extra money in and giving yourself that cash flow. If you have it, you know, I know it's going to be a lot of things that change. I'm leaning towards pension as well, but I could, you know, Voya's okay. It's not great. You've got to be careful. Those are expensive funds. Make sure you only use index funds if you are going to use it. But I am leaning towards defined benefit. Illinois is not going to welch on their payment of the existing, of the existing
19:59 Speaker 01 plan participants. More likely is they just keep watering the plan down and making it worse and worse, the younger people who come in. Now, in terms of what to do with the old accounts, I would love it if you could just all be consolidated in one place. So that traditional rollover is in T. Rowe Price. I would roll the old plan. Into that account. And then I think we should also, um, so that would be the, uh, 226 goes right into that's your current, that goes into your rollover. You've got one big fat account. Um, you move the 28,000, that's a Roth part of your 401k, move that into your, into your Roth
20:43 Speaker 01 and do this right now because otherwise it's like you lose track and we want to make sure Roth goes to Roth, pre-tax goes to pre-tax. And now I think my friend, you have graduated from target date funds and we need to get you to invest in TRO price index funds, which will be really, really cheap. And I think it's time. Mark agreed, like ready to rock. He's gonna have a half a million dollars in this account.
21:07 Speaker 03 Well, I agree, but he also says he's kind of lazy and he doesn't really want to think about it. So if that's the case, that's, that's, you know, a target date fund is, uh, for this type of person.
21:14 Speaker 01 I feel like Jeff needs a hobby. He's a little bit, um, I get it. No, I'm only kidding. Uh, if you would be willing to do so, Jeff, it will be better for you if you just, even if you said to me, like, if I look at that target date fund, you're 42 years old and you had, you know, 65 or 70% in stock, in a stock index and 30 or 35% in a bond index and once a year you rebalanced. That's it. In your retirement account. That's it. What's in the brokerage account? What do you have there?
21:45 Speaker 02 Just S and P.
21:46 Speaker 01 Okay. So what you're doing it there. Is that in TRO also?
21:50 Speaker 02 Yep.
21:50 Speaker 01 Okay. So everything has to be a TRO. Let's make that happen. Absolutely. The question about the 529, um, or, and, uh, how much money do you have in the six and the three year olds 529 accounts?
22:05 Speaker 02 Uh, the six has 20 and the three year old has 10.
22:10 Speaker 01 And are you putting money in every single month or not?
22:13 Speaker 02 We were, um, we stopped, uh, once I started crunching all these numbers, we stopped contributing to the brokerage and we stopped contributing to the, um, the 529 a couple of months ago, which I, I mean, I, the plan is probably to not contribute until, you know, my, my salary reaches that kind of max potential.
22:34 Speaker 01 And there is a benefit, right? As a state employee for college? What is, what's that benefit?
22:39 Speaker 02 50% off in state.
22:41 Speaker 01 Dude, that's great. All right, you gotta stay in this job. How long you have to stay in to get that benefit?
22:47 Speaker 02 Seven years.
22:48 Speaker 01 You're in, I'm sorry to say you're in for 18 years at least. I want that money. I mean, 50% estate university is fantastic. Six months, let's just batten down the hatches. I agree. Don't put money in the 529, don't put money in the brokerage, get your cash flow in line, do what you need to do. Go get that PTO, go get that signing bonus, right? And, and you should be okay. Now, by the end of the year, you're gonna know a lot more. You're gonna have a better sense. Once you go up to 155. At that point, free cash flow, for every dollar that you have, a free cash flow, I would love it if it went to retirement, either a, you know, you can do a Roth IRA if you qualify, right?
23:32 Speaker 01 Or you would put it in the brokerage slash 529, but it, you're, we're gonna have to wait till the end of the year to figure this out. So you could split it. That's fine with me. You can go, you know, if you said, I'm gonna put 600 a month into my brokerage account and there's 300 a month that's going into the 529, it's 100, 100, 100. That's fine. I mean, you, you still can, you don't have to go crazy saving for the 529. The brokerage is gonna be fine. Um, and then let's see if you make it seven years. I feel good about this now. I feel so good about that seven. Oh, boy. That's juicy. Um, you have three kids. You're the main wage earner. Do you, oh, have life insurance?
24:15 Speaker 02 Yes, we both have, we both have a million.
24:18 Speaker 01 Hmm, is that enough, Mark?
24:20 Speaker 03 Uh, it's not terrible. I mean, you know, it's.
24:23 Speaker 01 Does that state, if that state plan gives you a little ability to buy some cheap term also, do me a favor and grab a little bit more, like a half a million more for you.
24:33 Speaker 02 Okay.
24:34 Speaker 01 If possible. How about the, uh, magic estate documents? Done? Not done?
24:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, just, but I mean, they're pretty generic. It was just kind of like the, um, uh, I didn't even know what the online service is called anymore.
24:46 Speaker 01 Whatever, LegalZoom, blah, blah, blah, Willmaker. Yeah, fine. Okay. That's good. Just make sure you add that kid.
24:54 Speaker 02 Third kid.
24:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, remember that one? I think you're good, Jeff. I love the idea of this, like, oh, good all the benefits this guy's getting. It's incredible. It really is incredible. So if you're considering maybe shifting your career so that you go from the private sectors to the public sector, you see what we're looking at here? The value of these benefits in the near term is just huge. So give us a holler. Go to jillonthemoney.com, jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, write us a note, and come on the air and we'll walk you through how valuable those benefits really are. And it's amazing. I'm ready to go get a state job myself, Mark, right away for the next six months. How long do I have to work in the state? 20 years, basically.
25:43 Speaker 01 Sorry, that's not going to work for me. But if you're in your 40s, this is a good game plan. Some of these benefits are just incredible. So let us know how we can help you out. Go to the website, check out all of our content. It lives there. Don't forget, you can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. And lift someone up. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening. We'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous The Dimensional Approach Part Two Next Can I Retire at 55? Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated