Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Lump Sum or Monthly Payment? About this episode With retirement on the horizon after 41 years at the same company, is it better to take the monthly pension or the lump sum? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com.
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 We host Christmas for the family every year, and I'm always missing one essential piece, like a little extension for my dining room table. So to address this problem before the season really gets into it, I headed to Wayfair and found an awesome square folding card table that looks so much better than the plastic nonsense that I was using before. For all things hosting, Wayfair delivers high-quality, customer-trusted products for your home so you can host and celebrate without the stress. Wayfair verified items give you peace of mind because product specialists hand-vet these products using a thorough 10-point quality inspection process. Whether you're making a quick furniture swap, adding a cozy winter accent,
0:45 Speaker 00 or doing a full seasonal home overhaul, Wayfair has thousands of options tailored to every taste and budget. You don't have to take my word for it either. You can use easy search filters, view real customer photos in actual homes, and read through over 20 million verified 5-star reviews to shop with absolute confidence. When refreshing your home this holiday season, Wayfair delivers exactly what you need. Head to wayfair.com to shop all things home. That's W-A-Y-F-A-I-R dot com.
1:20 Speaker 01 Wayfair, every style, every home. This year, set up your holiday gifting with a little extra magic. The perfect shoes from Designer Shoe Warehouse. DSW's got holiday gifts and stocking stuffers for everyone on your list. And tis the season for a little self-gifting, too. Whether you bake all day, dance all night, carol all over town, or tiptoe under the mistletoe, DSW is your Designer Shoe Wonderland for comfy slippers, joyful party shoes, statement boots, and more. Shop in-store or visit dsw.com. DSW, let us surprise you.
1:57 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Thursday, May 21st, and we are here answering your financial questions. If you have one, just go to our website, jillonthemoney.com. In the upper right-hand corner, there is a Contact Us button. When you click that button, a form will pop up. That is the email that we receive. If you would like to join us on the air live, then all you need to do is check the box. Now, just big announcements here, in that we're launching a brand-new web show. Are we calling it a web show or another podcast, Mark? What do we want to call this?
2:31 Speaker 02 I would just say we're rebranding the Money Watch Podcast.
2:35 Speaker 00 Okay, we are rebranding the Money Watch Podcast. Okay, so we have another podcast, which we have previously dropped on the weekends. We are rebranding that. It is going to be called Money Moves, and Money Moves is going to have a video component. So, if you're too shy to come on audio, you're certainly going to be too shy to come on video, but we are trying to really focus Money Moves on people who are, let's call it, 25 to 45. Okay, so you're going to want to listen, anyway. You're going to want to watch. Anyone can join, but we really want to focus the program on people who are in the beginning of their financial journeys, because so many of you are incredible, you've done an amazing
3:17 Speaker 00 job, but we really thought that it would be smart for us to try to cater to a group of people who is more at the beginning of their financial journey, rather than the middle towards the end. So, the way that you can subscribe to Money Moves is by subscribing to Money Watch, because the feed's going to just turn over and become Money Moves, and we'll have all the exciting news about which YouTube channel. I don't know if it's going to live on our YouTube channel, or the CBS, or Paramount YouTube channel. I don't know a lot yet, but I know that we've been having fun making the show, and the most important thing is that one of the people involved in the show said to me, when he met Mark in person, "Oh, he's so handsome." You liked that, Mark, didn't you?
3:56 Speaker 02 Yeah, I never really get that, so I'll take it.
3:58 Speaker 00 Yeah. What do you mean? You're such a good-looking guy. Stop it. Anyway, check it all out. You know one way- To stay abreast of all of the information and all the things that we're doing is to subscribe to the free weekly newsletter which comes out on Fridays, which would be tomorrow. Okay, right now, let us go talk to one of you. It is Scott who joins us from Washington State. Hey Scott, how are you?
4:21 Speaker 03 Morning.
4:22 Speaker 00 What's going on, man?
4:23 Speaker 03 Oh, not much. I have a, had a question on, uh, buying out, uh, pension.
4:29 Speaker 00 Oh, has somebody, has your employer offered to buy you out?
4:34 Speaker 03 Yes, they can, they can take it either way. I can take the pension or I can, they've offered a buyout.
4:41 Speaker 00 Okay.
4:42 Speaker 03 Just makes me a little nervous.
4:44 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm. Uh, Scott, how old are you?
4:46 Speaker 03 Um, sixty.
4:48 Speaker 00 And you're still working, right?
4:50 Speaker 03 Still working, looking at retiring, uh, the end of the year or first part of next year.
4:56 Speaker 00 Oh, wow, that's cool. Are you married, single, partnered?
4:59 Speaker 03 Uh, married.
5:00 Speaker 00 And is your spouse still working?
5:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, she's still working.
5:04 Speaker 00 And will she retire with you at the end of the year, or will she keep working?
5:08 Speaker 03 She's gonna keep working till probably I draw social security.
5:13 Speaker 00 Oh.
5:14 Speaker 03 And then make, make sure that, uh, you know, we're still good to go. And I'm gonna take social security at sixty-two, so.
5:21 Speaker 00 Why's that?
5:22 Speaker 03 Uh, it's just kinda what I heard.
5:25 Speaker 00 Wait a minute. All right, can we, can we revisit that? I wanna get the facts down and then I'm gonna come back to social security. Okay? So, right now, if you were offered this pension by, what's the lump sum?
5:39 Speaker 03 Uh, let's see, a lump sum is five twenty-four, three eighty-eight.
5:45 Speaker 00 Five twenty-four, three eighty-eight. And what's the alternative?
5:49 Speaker 03 It is, it depends on how I take it, but if I take it with, you know, letting my spouse have it after if I die.
5:58 Speaker 00 The joint and survivor, yep, what's that number?
6:01 Speaker 03 It'd be twenty-eight, forty-seven.
6:03 Speaker 00 Through, and, and that is for your life until the end, and, and then she would then succeed you, and so then you would have that much money. Okay.
6:12 Speaker 03 Correct.
6:13 Speaker 00 Got it, okay. Now, tell us about other money you've got, you guys have saved.
6:17 Speaker 03 Um, well, I got seven sixty-three thousand in a normal 401K with the same company, so.
6:26 Speaker 00 Yep, traditional, yep.
6:27 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:28 Speaker 00 And what else?
6:30 Speaker 03 Um, my wife's got about...
6:34 Speaker 03 One eighty, I think.
6:36 Speaker 00 Mm hmm. In a, in a same thing traditional?
6:40 Speaker 03 Yeah, in a 401k.
6:41 Speaker 00 Got it. Um, do you guys have any old IRAs kicking around, anything like that?
6:47 Speaker 03 Nope.
6:48 Speaker 00 Okay. And what about money that is already been taxed, like a brokerage account, a savings account, CDs, anything like that?
6:56 Speaker 03 None of that.
6:58 Speaker 00 So you don't have like a safe money account? Like what if the, the, uh, the refrigerator breaks down?
7:02 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah, yeah. We got probably, um, I don't know, fifteen thousand.
7:06 Speaker 00 Okay. Savings. Got it. Do you guys own your own home?
7:10 Speaker 03 Yep.
7:11 Speaker 00 What do you think it's worth?
7:12 Speaker 03 Uh, well, tax guy says nine sixty-five, something like that.
7:17 Speaker 00 You want to stay in this house?
7:19 Speaker 03 Uh, for the most part, yeah.
7:21 Speaker 00 Okay. Do you guys have a mortgage that's outstanding?
7:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, we owe about one eighty.
7:26 Speaker 00 Do you know the interest rate offhand?
7:28 Speaker 03 Five and a quarter.
7:30 Speaker 00 Oh, is this a new purchase?
7:33 Speaker 03 No, we've been here twenty-seven years.
7:35 Speaker 00 You never refinanced from five and a quarter?
7:38 Speaker 03 No, I wish I would have. We kept, we kept putting it off, putting it off.
7:43 Speaker 00 Yeah. All right. Well, let's not put off the retirement because then you'll be working until you're eighty, given your, uh, background, right? So any other real estate, any cabins or vacation home or timeshare, anything like that?
7:56 Speaker 03 No, nothing that we can count yet. I mean, we've got property we're kind of taking over from her parents, but it's not in our name yet, so.
8:05 Speaker 00 Okay. Okay. But that's in the future.
8:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
8:08 Speaker 00 Do you guys have grown kids?
8:11 Speaker 03 Yep, all grown and gone.
8:13 Speaker 00 Okay. So we don't have to worry about supporting anybody, right?
8:16 Speaker 03 Nope.
8:17 Speaker 00 Okay, great. What about, um, well, it sounds like her parents or someone's still alive, but like you don't have to support aging, older parents for you guys?
8:26 Speaker 03 No.
8:27 Speaker 00 Okay.
8:28 Speaker 03 Mine are both gone, hers are alive, but they're doing well on their own.
8:31 Speaker 00 Doing okay. Great. Okay. So how much did your wife earn right now?
8:36 Speaker 03 Uh, she probably makes one fifty. She works at a hospital, so.
8:41 Speaker 00 Wow, that's great. That's amazing. How much do you earn right now?
8:47 Speaker 03 About one thirty-eight.
8:49 Speaker 00 Are you both maxing out your retirement accounts?
8:53 Speaker 03 I'm not sure what she's putting in. I'm putting in fourteen percent, so I'm not maxing.
8:57 Speaker 00 Okay, but still, pretty good.
9:00 Speaker 03 Yeah.
9:00 Speaker 00 Do you have an idea of how much you spend every month?
9:04 Speaker 03 No, that would be her alley.
9:07 Speaker 00 Any guesses? It's hard for me to figure this out without that. Do you think you spend more than like, let's say, let me give it a guess. You gotta pay a mortgage, you got your property taxes, you got your insurance, you got your bills, maybe like seven grand a month, eight grand a month? Does that sound about right?
9:25 Speaker 03 That's probably pretty close, yeah.
9:28 Speaker 00 Let's say eight. So, I guess the question is, which way does this work better for you? How do you feel about the idea of managing another half a million dollars in addition to your seven sixty-three inside of your 401k? Are you managing that money yourself?
9:45 Speaker 03 Um, I have been up until a week ago. Uh, they offered me three months free through, uh, Edelman, I think it is.
9:55 Speaker 00 Uh huh, okay.
9:56 Speaker 03 And so I took them up on, yeah, so I took them up on it just to see what happens and I get out of it at any time, so.
10:02 Speaker 00 Uh huh, okay.
10:04 Speaker 03 And I'm already in the accounts they told me to put it in anyways when I went to them for advice.
10:10 Speaker 00 That's good, actually. Did they by any chance run some retirement analysis for you? Or is it just money management?
10:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, I, I talked to them about, uh, retiring. They just crunched the numbers and said, yeah, you can go.
10:24 Speaker 00 And did they have an opinion about the lump sum versus the annuity payment? I mean, the.
10:29 Speaker 03 I didn't, I didn't ask them yet, but I need to go back.
10:33 Speaker 00 Edelman, I'm pretty sure is CFP, it is fiduciary, meaning they have to put you first. But obviously, they're, you could, one could make a case that it would be better for you to have this lump sum, add it to your 763, right? So that, you know, essentially, you just take this big chunk of money, and you'd add that half a million to it, with your wife's traditional, you put, glom it all together, that creates a payment over time.
11:01 Speaker 03 Right.
11:02 Speaker 00 However, there is something really nice about having a payment that comes to you every month. And I, and I want to, like, let's just hold that for a second. Because I think your pension amount, would it be inflation adjusted? Would it go up every year?
11:18 Speaker 03 They did get a raise of like 3%.
11:22 Speaker 00 Okay, that's good, that's good.
11:24 Speaker 03 That came, came with the contract, but I don't know, I don't know if the people that already retired get it.
11:30 Speaker 00 Okay. I would be interested to find out if the payment every month is inflation adjusted, it would be a cost of living adjustment? I'm going to guess it is. I, I'm guessing I know where you work. We would want to double check that. So, part of this is about what you think is going to be reasonable for you guys. So, let's say we have social security, we're going to talk about 62, 67, and 70. First question for you is, how's your health? Are you in good health?
12:00 Speaker 03 I'm in great health.
12:01 Speaker 00 You are, okay.
12:02 Speaker 03 Yep.
12:02 Speaker 00 So, do you happen to have the social security amount at age 62, 67, and 70? Do you have all three?
12:09 Speaker 03 I only have the 62.
12:13 Speaker 00 And how much is that?
12:15 Speaker 03 Is 2744.
12:17 Speaker 00 Okay. All right. The reason why I think, if you're in really good health, here's the premise of social security. If you are in good health, it does make sense to wait until your full retirement age, that would be 67 for you, and get more money, because that guaranteed more money will be inflation adjusted every year. So presuming you live to your 80s, which by the way, if you're in good health right now and you're 60, you probably will, it usually makes the most sense to claim at your full retirement age, all right? So, let's pretend, I'm going to make this up. Let's say that you have your pension that is at 2847 a month.
13:01 Speaker 00 If you retired at the end of this year, that would start immediately or do you have to wait till some age that it triggers?
13:07 Speaker 03 Uh, I just have to wait for um 55, which
13:11 Speaker 00 Oh, you're there. Okay.
13:12 Speaker 03 I'm past that. Yeah.
13:14 Speaker 00 So if we, Mark, if his, if his social security is 2744 at 62, what do you figure it is at 67? Like 3,200 probably?
13:24 Speaker 02 I mean, I wrote down around 35.
13:27 Speaker 00 Okay, 3,500. Okay. So then, and do you know what your wife's social security estimate is going to be in the future?
13:34 Speaker 03 Uh, I do not. I know she was a stay-at-home mom for, you know, pretty much the life of the kids. So she's missing a 20-year chunk or so.
13:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, but then she, has she been working 10 years, more than 10 years?
13:46 Speaker 03 Uh, lately? Yes, I think she's right at 10 since then.
13:50 Speaker 00 That's the determining factor and she's going to keep
13:52 Speaker 03 Oh, I see.
13:54 Speaker 00 So you need, you need 40 quarters or 10 years and then you're in good shape.
13:58 Speaker 02 Her healthcare, her healthcare job, is there any pension?
14:01 Speaker 03 No.
14:02 Speaker 00 No pension there.
14:03 Speaker 03 No, just the 401.
14:05 Speaker 00 Let's say that, what do you want to figure her social security will be at 67, Mark? 3, 3,500 also?
14:12 Speaker 02 Uh, I don't know. That might be a little high.
14:16 Speaker 00 Let's say, let's say 2,500 just to be safe. Okay? So now, let's presume in the future, you're collecting your pension, that's the 2847. Then you wait to 67, you get, let's say, about 3,500. Then she kicks in at her 67, maybe it's 2,500. So now, we're talking about pretty much covering all of your needs with your two social security checks and your pension. Not 100% because, you know, your expenses, we really still don't know. We think it's about eight grand a month, but, you know, eight will turn into a higher number as inflation takes hold. So I guess the question is, in looking at this,
14:58 Speaker 00 Do you feel like having the pension is a relief, especially in the period of time before social security, like having that paycheck? Would it feel good for you to have that 2847, then your wife keeps working, right? For, you said, how long until, until her age, what, 60?
15:17 Speaker 03 She's three years behind me, so.
15:19 Speaker 00 All right, so, so she keeps working, you sock money away, you probably can live on her salary alone. How do you feel about having that extra pension? How do you feel like about having that dependable check? That's, it's like, part of this is about your feeling, it's less math.
15:34 Speaker 03 Right, that's, that's kinda what I've always, you know, been leaning towards, so.
15:38 Speaker 00 Mark, do you think that, um, collecting the pension makes more sense for Scott and his wife?
15:44 Speaker 02 Based on everything I've heard so far, I'm leaning taking the monthly payment, especially, you know, given that it's still a nice amount with the full joint survivor benefit.
15:53 Speaker 00 I, I think that there's two things I want you to confirm. Number one is, we want you to confirm that there is a cost of living adjustment associated with that 2847. You just ask them, okay? The second thing is, I think that it would be helpful if you said to the folks at Edelman, can you run an analysis as to whether or not it makes more sense for me to collect the pension as a lump sum versus a monthly income, knowing that I really want, but tell them, I really do want the monthly income. You could tell them that. You could say, it makes me feel more comfortable. And then they'll explain to you also that claiming at 67 makes a lot more sense, because
16:35 Speaker 00 I think that you've got enough money to do exactly what you want to do. The real question to me is, you know, how do we make sure that you get through this period from age 60 to 67 feeling comfortable? And what you can, I think that because your wife's gonna keep working, you get a half, you know, however long she works, because I don't know, maybe she'll say she wants to work longer, we'll see. But let's say it's a few more years. Then at that point, you start pulling money out of your traditional 401K, you just take the money you need, a little bit at a time, to compensate you for the money that you will need to live your life. And that's, does two things. At one, Scott. Number one, it allows you to get some of this money out when you know what your tax bracket's
17:17 Speaker 00 gonna be. You're gonna get some of this out, you won't have a big surprise. And number two, it'll bridge the gap between now and social security. And then, you know, honestly, you'll probably take a little bit more out. You'll take some money out to get like, once you get to, from your age sixty to sixty-seven, then maybe you'll take some money out before your wife claims social security. And then, when she claims, I think you should be pretty close to being, close to being there. I don't know, how long do you have on that mortgage payment? What's left on that?
17:47 Speaker 03 What's left?
17:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, how many years?
17:50 Speaker 03 I think eight.
17:52 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, so that's gonna really also help your cash flow, that as soon as that's gone, that all of a sudden, obviously, your cash flow's gonna look a lot better.
18:01 Speaker 03 Right.
18:01 Speaker 00 I think it kinda works, it works pretty well. I would have them run the numbers, though. Absolutely have them run the numbers. And part of what is helpful about having an organization or a financial planner is not about the money management, because as you just found out, the money management, you were doing just fine, right?
18:21 Speaker 03 Right.
18:21 Speaker 00 You're doing just fine. But let them, let them actually crunch the numbers for you, and I think you'll be in great shape. And the only other thing I will tell you is that, you know, as you, while you're still working, any benefit that you have that you can access, for example, I don't know if you have, if you have access to legal services, but if you haven't done your estate planning, you wanna do your estate planning, you wanna make sure you have everything buttoned up, and take every possible benefit that they have for you, and I think that that will, you know, help build the case in your own mind that you're fine, and you are fine, of course.
18:58 Speaker 03 Right. One other thing I would like to mention, we have a very large school loan from my daughter.
19:05 Speaker 00 Oh.
19:06 Speaker 03 Like a hundred thousand, yeah.
19:09 Speaker 00 But you include that in like, how much money you have, you're spending every month?
19:13 Speaker 03 Right, well, yeah, we spend like, a thousand bucks a month towards it.
19:17 Speaker 00 Well, I mean, that's gonna feel a lot better after you're done with the mortgage, but you're very nice to have assumed that. Does she have a job?
19:25 Speaker 03 Who, my daughter?
19:26 Speaker 00 Your daughter, yeah.
19:26 Speaker 03 Not anymore. She's a stay-at-home mom.
19:29 Speaker 00 So you just assumed this for her?
19:31 Speaker 03 Yep. It's a parent plus loan and my wife refuses to take money from her.
19:38 Speaker 00 Oh, God. Okay.
19:40 Speaker 03 Even though she's offered, I would, I would take it.
19:43 Speaker 00 I would take it also. Uh, Mark, what should I say about this? Just let this go? Do I need to just let this go right now?
19:49 Speaker 02 Let, let this one go.
19:51 Speaker 00 Let this go. Okay, I'm gonna let this go. Because as far as I'm concerned, your wife rules on this, okay? So I'm not getting in the way of this. Um, I think you're in good shape. If for some reason you decide to sell your house or something else happens, get back in touch with us. But I'm leaning towards the pension payment as well. Have Edelman run numbers for you. And also tell your wife, if she, if she really wants to pay off that loan, she should just keep working. We'll see if that moves her, but that's really not true. Because it sounds like you can afford it. Okay?
20:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
20:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think you're in good shape. All right, man. Good luck. Stay in touch with us. Don't take that social security at 62. Hey, gang, are you tempted to draw your social security at 62? If so, I want you to join our webinar. It's coming up June 17th, next month. We've got Heather Schreiber, the queen of all things social security. She is an expert. She's gonna lay out the math for you. You've got to be a member of Jill on Money Live in order to join us. It'll cost you 45 bucks for the next 12 months. Or you can purchase a single webinar for 15 bucks after that webinar occurs. Don't forget to subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. We love to ask you to do something nice for someone else today. It will make that person feel better and it sure will make you feel better.
21:07 Speaker 00 Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous Job Market Concerns for Young Americans Next Tired but Afraid to Retire and Spend Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated