Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Has My Roth Conversion Ship Sailed? About this episode During my working life all of my savings went into a tax deferred 401(k) which is now in a rollover IRA. Is it wise to consider doing some Roth conversions? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE Subscribe to Jill on Money Newsletter YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You know, gang, I was once a small business owner and running a small business comes with plenty of challenges, but managing your numbers shouldn't be one of them. That's where Xero, that's X E R O, comes in. A financial management platform designed to take the overwhelming tasks out of your daily operations. You don't need multiple tools and spreadsheets to get a clear view of your cash flow. Xero connects your accounting, payments, payroll, and analytics all in one place using automated workflows that can save you hours of busy work. Instead of getting buried in complicated details, you get intuitive visual dashboards, forecasts, and smart insights that help you make confident decisions.
0:42 Speaker 00 While most software tries to sound smart, Xero is built to make you feel smart by turning complex financial tasks into simple routines. Over 5 million customers worldwide trust it to keep their operations moving. From a 2024 survey, 91% of customers across the U.S., U.K., and Australia agreed that Xero is easy to use. Stay ahead of what's coming in, what's going out, and what's next, so you can spend less time on paperwork and more time growing your business. Learn more at X E R O dot com.
1:16 Speaker 01 Ring Central's AI receptionist uses voice AI to answer on the first ring, so you'll never miss a call again. In just a few minutes, you can personalize your own AI receptionist to answer questions, route calls, schedule appointments, and even send texts in multiple languages. Plus, it's easy to scale. Create unlimited AI receptionists across any phone system. It's all powered by one reliable platform for effortless AI communications. See for yourself at ringcentral.com. Ring Central, voice of your business.
1:50 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Wednesday, April 8th, and we're here talking to you about whatever is on your mind financially. If you've got a question, all you need to do is go to our website, jillonthemoney.com. In the upper right-hand corner, there is a Contact Us button. When you click that button, A form pops up, it's the email that we receive. And yes, we do emails. We read them on the air because it is part of our way of making sure that shy people are served by this program. However, if you're not so shy, or you trust that we will be able to protect your anonymity, maybe by changing your name or your location, well, then just check the
2:31 Speaker 00 box. And Mark will do everything else because he is, in fact, the best executive producer in the whole wide world. While you're on the website, don't forget to subscribe to the weekly newsletter. It comes out on Fridays. Also, check out all of the other content that lives on the website. It may be our blog, or our other program called Money Watch, or videos, or resources, all sorts of stuff that lives there. Okay, today, we are talking to Carol, who joins us from the Midwest. Hello, Carol. What can we do for you?
3:02 Speaker 02 Hello, Jill and Mark. I have a question about whether I should do a Roth conversion with my traditional IRA.
3:13 Speaker 00 To convert, or not to convert? That is the question. Okay, so first of all, tell us about yourself, Carol.
3:21 Speaker 02 Okay, I am 69 years old. I retired a couple of years ago. I'm fairly good health.
3:28 Speaker 00 Great.
3:29 Speaker 02 One son, he's about, I think he's 25.
3:33 Speaker 00 Yeah, I like that you say, I think. I think he's 25.
3:35 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:36 Speaker 00 Is he launched?
3:38 Speaker 02 He's, he's launched, but he needs a little, sometimes a little help. He's still figuring things out.
3:45 Speaker 00 You've launched him, but every so often, you have to kind of drive the dinghy over, and just get over there and be like, here's a few bucks to help you with something.
3:52 Speaker 02 Yeah.
3:53 Speaker 00 But you're not doing like, you're not doing an ongoing amount, like you're not saying, oh, well, I pay for his rent?
3:58 Speaker 02 No.
3:59 Speaker 00 Okay, so you retired a few years ago. Are you entitled to a pension?
4:03 Speaker 02 I do. I get a pension, and I'm taking my social security.
4:07 Speaker 00 What's your monthly income?
4:09 Speaker 02 Well, annual 70,000.
4:11 Speaker 00 Okay, that's great. Do you, are you married?
4:15 Speaker 02 No, I've been divorced for about 25 years.
4:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
4:19 Speaker 02 Happily divorced.
4:21 Speaker 00 I love those people. They're like, no problem. All good. Okay. So does the pension and social security is 70 grand a year? Does it cover most of your expenses?
4:31 Speaker 02 It does, but I, I like to, I always seem to live just within my means. So there's not like a ton of money left over.
4:40 Speaker 00 Okay. Do you have a retirement account in addition to your pension? Because you're talking about converting, but so what kind of account we have? Do we have?
4:50 Speaker 02 I have a, so I, all my life I invested in my tax-deferred oral pay. And that is now in a Vanguard IRA. And I, that's basically, I put all my eggs in one basket.
5:06 Speaker 00 Okay.
5:07 Speaker 02 I have a very small, uh, high-yield savings of about 15,000. Um, but that's pretty much it.
5:15 Speaker 00 Okay. So you have a high-yield savings of 15,000, like, and you have a bank account that has a few bucks in it?
5:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, very few.
5:22 Speaker 00 Okay. And the IRA rollover at Vanguard, how much is in there?
5:27 Speaker 02 Uh, about 900,000.
5:29 Speaker 00 Okay. You own your home?
5:31 Speaker 02 Yes, I do.
5:32 Speaker 00 How much would you guess it's worth?
5:34 Speaker 02 Um, I guess about 500,000, maybe more.
5:40 Speaker 00 And is there a mortgage remaining?
5:41 Speaker 02 No, it's all paid off.
5:43 Speaker 00 Okay. And you want to stay there?
5:44 Speaker 02 Yes, I plan to stay here. Yes.
5:46 Speaker 00 Okay. All right. So, um, are you pulling any money out of the IRA account right now? Or is it just, you know, sort of chugging along?
5:57 Speaker 02 It's chugging along, except if I find that I want to take a little vacation and I don't quite have the money, I'll nibble at it here.
6:05 Speaker 00 Yeah, why not? Come on, aren't you entitled?
6:08 Speaker 02 I know, that's
6:08 Speaker 00 Jeez. But you don't have another account. You don't have another brokerage account and there's no big cash account that you would use to pay the tax that would be due if you were to convert. Is that what I'm understanding?
6:24 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's correct.
6:25 Speaker 00 Okay. So don't even, don't sweat this. You're not going to do a conversion. You're not a conversion candidate because it really only works if you actually are able to pay the tax that's due from an account that's not a retirement account. So if you said to me, let's just flip it around. If you said like, I had a hundred grand in a rollover and 800 grand that's in a brokerage account, then we would absolutely have you do that. But in this case, here's a different idea for you. Did you file your taxes yet?
7:00 Speaker 02 I did.
7:01 Speaker 00 Okay. Do you remember what your income was like the bottom right hand corner? You remember what that income was? Was it that 70 ish?
7:08 Speaker 02 Um, yeah, I have it right here. Taxable income was 67,000.
7:14 Speaker 00 Okay. So here's what I think might be more interesting for someone in your situation. Two choices. One is that, you know, you say, look, I need more money out of this account every year. I really do. Cause you want to have like a more, you really should have a high yield savings account. That's a little bit richer. You own a home. If something had to happen, you don't want to pull money out of the account at the wrong time. So what I absolutely would do is at least consider taking 30 or $35,000 out from that tax deferred account, that IRA rollover at Vanguard, maybe 30. I would take out an extra 30 grand every year. And you know what? For the first year or two, I might just stick it in my high yield savings account. Very boring. Have it available.
7:58 Speaker 00 Pay your taxes due. Now it's two years from now. You're 71. You've got four more years before you need to take money out through your required minimum distributions. I'll give you two choices. Tell me what you, what sounds interesting to you. You might say, well, okay, I'll just take my, I'll just keep doing, staying at the top of the 22% income tax bracket, as long as I can, I'll pull out the third, because right now the bracket goes up to 105,700. You keep pulling that money out for the next four years. You have extra money. Maybe you even have a brokerage account at Vanguard in addition to what you have in the rollover. Alternatively, what you could consider is to say,
8:42 Speaker 00 Hey, I don't want to be forced to take as much money out when I'm 75. So I think what I'll do is I will take more money out in those four years, or even in these next six years, and consider paying more than the 22% bracket. The top of the next bracket, which is 24%, I will go up to about 200,000. So what you could do is you could get more money out, but you'd have to swallow paying that tax rate of 24%. Now, it's not a terrible bet, because, you know, listen, we do need to get this account down in value before you start taking your distributions, right?
9:25 Speaker 00 By the time you're 75, when you think about it, whatever's in there, you're gonna start, you're gonna have to withdraw at, say, I don't know, a 4% withdrawal rate? Let me just look at my little chart. Stand by for a second. Let me just look at this. I think it's four... yeah. It's about 4% in terms of like, when you have to make your required minimum distributions. So, I mean, it doesn't mean that that's terrible, but like, you know, if there's a million dollars in there, if you don't pull enough money out and it keeps growing faster than what you're taking out, you'll have to pull 40 grand out. And when you're 80, it turns out to be more like 5% of the total. So getting it down, even any amount,
10:09 Speaker 00 if you could just get it down by a couple hundred thousand dollars, I think it'll be better for your required minimum distributions. And even if it just is at that 22% rate, I think it's better to do it that way. I'm not sure if that's going to like, be compelling to you or not, but I don't think converting is the smartest thing for you right now just because you don't have the money to pay for the taxes due. In one way or another, the money's gotta come out, alright? Now, it may come out in 20 years through required minimum distributions, or you can control what tax bracket you're paying that tax at. That's what I'm saying is that if you pull it out now, let's say you pulled 30 grand out
10:52 Speaker 00 and you just said, I'm gonna put it in my high-yield savings account now instead of 15 grand. I have a little bit more money there. I know it's not growing that much, but that's the safe thing to do, right? So now you have 45 grand. Next year, you file your taxes and you say, okay, what portion of that 45 grand do I, and you tell, do you file with an accountant or a tax preparer? Or do you do it yourself?
11:13 Speaker 02 I do it myself.
11:14 Speaker 00 Run it through a little filter and see what would happen if you had an extra 30 grand of income because you may want to pay some, you might want to adjust some, you know, maybe pay a little bit of a quarterly tax, maybe. I don't know. You may not have to, but I would look at that and I would also be crystal clear that like that money should be there. Let's see what the impact is on your taxes next year and then let's see how it goes. By the way, if you take the money out and you pay it at that 22% bracket, you're not going down a bracket. Given what we know now, because you have pension and you have social security, you're at least always in the 22 bracket. You just, that's your highest bracket. It's not going down. So we know that at the very
11:59 Speaker 00 least, every required minimum distribution will be at least at 22%. So you're no worse off paying it today than you would be in a few years. And that also, by the way, kind of buffers you against the growth of the portfolio, number one, and also like, I don't know, maybe tax rates are gonna go up. Mark's gonna pop in and be like, just pay it at the 24% bracket. I bet he's gonna say, Mark, do you believe that?
12:20 Speaker 03 It's a much bigger window.
12:22 Speaker 00 Okay, so what he-
12:24 Speaker 02 My idea actually was kind of to go into the 24%.
12:28 Speaker 00 If you're willing to. So the top of the 24% bracket for single filers is 201,775. So let's just say, Mark, that Carol says, I got 900 in there and right now, I am going to take out $120,000 right now and pay that 24% bracket. Would, now, now keep going for year after year. Should she keep doing it, Mark?
12:53 Speaker 03 I would. I mean, look, you're probably never gonna get all of this converted, so I wouldn't drive yourself nuts by this, but you'd be able to get a good chunk out, yeah.
13:01 Speaker 00 And I think that what that does is, again, if you feel like, wow, that screws me up and I don't want to go up a bracket or down, but I understand that, but it's only a 2% change in that and how the tax, and you have control about you paying it. I don't know if in 10 years that the country is underwater and tax rates all go up, that, you know, how do we know that you're not going to be at 24, maybe you'll be at 30. I don't know.
13:27 Speaker 02 Right.
13:28 Speaker 00 So that's the, you pay up today for the security of not being caught by surprise later if rates were to change.
13:38 Speaker 02 Okay, now, the other question related to that, so if I do that this year, and maybe not 120, maybe 80, or whatever the number is, I am worried about the safe harbor rules, and I know I paid 9,700 in taxes last year, so if I withhold at least that much, I don't have to worry about a penalty?
14:03 Speaker 00 It's 110% of that much, but I would run that, I would, I would look at your, what software are you using for taxes?
14:11 Speaker 02 The TurboTax.
14:12 Speaker 00 I would look at TurboTax and just see what would happen.
14:15 Speaker 03 And by the way, if you want to avoid even having to think about doing quarterly payments, if you're going to take money out, just do it at the end of the year.
14:22 Speaker 02 Okay.
14:23 Speaker 00 That's true.
14:24 Speaker 03 And see what happens the rest of this year. I mean, you know, as we speak, the market's down, maybe it goes down even more, it's a good, you know, might be a good year to do this, but...
14:31 Speaker 00 Yeah. I mean, I think you have some flexibility here, and you don't have to like cling to what, like, year by year, you're not, you're not, it's not like you're making a pact with us and we're going to call you in a year and be like, what'd you do? You know, and you're just saying like, generally speaking, I'm going to try to get more money out of my Vanguard IRA that has not yet been taxed. That's it. And if in one year you have some, you know, you know, you have a strange situation where something falls in your lap or some, who knows, then you can make a decision then, a different decision. It's okay.
15:05 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. Okay.
15:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, I even was thinking if I do maybe a little bit of a Roth conversion and a little bit into the high yield, then next year, if I want to do it again, I, I may have that high yield money to pay those taxes.
15:21 Speaker 00 Hang on, we're not saying do a Roth conversion, just so you hear this. You, you cannot convert into a Roth. The money you pull out, you're not going to convert it. You're just going to take it and you're going to, if anything, you're going to put it in your high yield savings account. Year two, or if you're doing a bigger amount this year, it's going to be in a brokerage account. It's not going to be a Roth account.
15:43 Speaker 02 Okay. And why is, why is that?
15:45 Speaker 00 Because the tax that would, you don't have the money to pay the tax that's due. When you pull the money out, you have to pay the tax that's due. Once you put it into the Roth, I don't think there's any need to put it in a Roth. You just have it in a brokerage account. There's, you don't have to put it into a Roth. We're not doing a conversion, just pulling the money out, paying the tax that's due, and keeping the rest. You're not putting it into a Roth.
16:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, you can't put it into a Roth because you don't have earned income.
16:09 Speaker 02 Oh.
16:10 Speaker 03 You can only put it into an IRA, whether traditional or Roth, if you have the earned income, which you don't. So therefore you would put it into a broker, taxable brokerage account. Just use, you know, you, you said your rollover IRA is at Vanguard, so you would just use Vanguard. Just open up a taxable brokerage account at Vanguard and, and just think of it as a, you know, supplemental retirement account.
16:29 Speaker 00 All we're doing is like a bet on taxes right now. And I, I think that the vast majority of the money that's in the rollover, you can get out, you'll pay the tax that's due, and you'll pay it on your time horizon. That's what we're, that's really what we're saying.
16:45 Speaker 02 Okay.
16:46 Speaker 00 And it doesn't worry, don't worry about the, I know, the Roth is great, but like you said, like, hey, I, I grew up on the whole using the tax deferred account. You didn't do anything wrong. It's good. You got money. And, and frankly, it works really well. It's like you did a great job. So I don't want you to go back, "Ah, I wish I had done a Roth." You know what? There wasn't a, like, in your career, the Roth wasn't a thing, right?
17:11 Speaker 02 Right.
17:12 Speaker 00 I don't know what you did for a living. I don't know if you were a teacher, a nurse, or whatever, that you had a pension, but like, it wasn't like every retirement account had a Roth option. It wasn't, that wasn't available.
17:22 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. No, it wasn't.
17:24 Speaker 00 So, you did an amazing job. Come on.
17:27 Speaker 03 There's no problem there.
17:28 Speaker 00 This is all good news. You're in good, you're in great shape.
17:31 Speaker 02 I'm scared of those RMDs coming in, and so I'll, I'll go listen to your advice and, and act accordingly.
17:38 Speaker 00 All right. This sounds good. All right. Carol from the Midwest.
17:42 Speaker 03 I would love to be scared of RMDs, you know? That's a nightmare I will gladly take.
17:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, it's really, nothing bad, nothing bad is happening. Nothing bad is happening. And, and RMDs are, like, even in, in this situation, if you had to spend, if you had to pull 40 or 50 grand a year out so you'd pay tax on it, you're still gonna be fine. Even if you never did a, a thing. Don't be fearful. This is all, you're in great shape. You've done an incredible job. Get that kid lunch. Stop leeching off mom for her phone service. I bet he, is he on your cellular, cellular service? Admit it right now. Yes or no?
18:20 Speaker 02 He was, but recently, he took it, he took it over the last couple of years.
18:25 Speaker 00 Oh, what a good boy he is. Fantastic. All right. Um, give us a holler back if you need anything. Hey, gang, if you are thinking about a Roth conversion, or you're just worried about your future required minimum distribution, or maybe you want to just use a qualified charitable deduction. By the way, Carol, I didn't even mention that. If you're, if you are charitable, you can give money from your retirement account straight away to a charity, and it's not considered taxable to you. So, consider that also if you're charitable. Qualified charitable distribution is something to also help get some of the money out of a retirement account. So, do check that out. But if you have a question
19:07 Speaker 00 about your situation, get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button, write us a note. If you want to come on the air, check the box. It's very easy. Don't forget that you can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Please leave us a rating and review wherever you listen. And as always, we ask that you please try to lift someone up. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous Should I Tap a CD or My Roth? Next Reset Dilemma Advice Page updated November 14, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated