Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger Additional Retirement Savings Advice About this episode Given that our retirement savings are so heavily skewed on the pre-tax side, I am wondering if increasing our Roth contributions is the right move. Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Over the past year, we've had a couple of new babies in the family and seeing those babies, they really just stop you in your tracks. They make you deeply grateful to be alive and suddenly put everything into perspective. It can really prompt the deeper questions like, what are you doing to ensure that your family can keep celebrating milestones, planning college dreams and making joyful memories even if the unexpected were to happen? That's my why for life insurance. And if you've been telling yourself it's something you should have by now, you don't have to figure it out alone. PolicyGenius is an online marketplace that takes the headache out of the entire process. Instead of selling you their own plans, they let you compare quotes side by side from top insurers
0:41 Speaker 00 completely for free. Plus, you get real licensed humans who advocate for you, handle the messy paperwork and help you lock in peace of mind fast without the high pressure sales pitch. Make a smart move today to help protect their tomorrow. With PolicyGenius, you can see if you can find 20-year life insurance policies, starting at just $276 a year for $1 million in coverage. Head to policygenius.com to compare quotes now. That's policygenius.com. If you've got a lingering credit card balance that feels like an endless loop where making monthly payments barely felt like moving the needle, you may be able to get rid of
1:21 Speaker 00 that dread completely once you start using Monarch. Instead of just showing your past purchases like other apps, Monarch has this incredible debt pay down simulator and visualizer that calculates an exact real world payoff date based on your balances. Seeing a concrete finish line on a visual timeline completely rewires your brain from this will never end to actually circling a date on the calendar. My favorite part is you can run side by side scenarios. You can tweak a monthly contribution by just 50 bucks and instantly watch that projected debt free date jump forward by months, putting total control right back in your hands. Plus, whenever you're debating an unexpected expense, you can just ask Monarch's
2:05 Speaker 00 AI assistant whether or not you can afford it without derailing your goals, taking all the mental friction out of tracking. Write your own money story with Monarch. Use code JILLONMONEY at monarch.com to get your first year of Monarch Core half off at just $50. That's 50% off your first year at monarch.com with code JILLONMONEY.
2:31 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Thursday, February 27th, and we are here answering your financial questions. If you have one, just go to our website, jillonthemoney.com. While you're there, you just click the Contact Us button. It's in the upper right-hand corner, and a form will pop up. Once you get that form, that is the email that we receive. Complete the form, and if you want to join us on the air live, you just check the little box, and boy, Mark will take care of everything right after that. Now, just a little bit of housekeeping here at the show. I want to tell you that this weekend, we are starting to broadcast
3:13 Speaker 00 on the weekends. Again, not in this feed. We are bringing our Money Watch show to the weekends, and that Money Watch show is really geared towards anyone who wants to, I think, beef up their financial knowledge. We're going to be really tackling the core concepts that you encounter in your financial life. So I want to be clear that that is in a different feed. The Money Watch show, you can actually subscribe to it on the Odyssey app. You can get to it from our website. We're still going to answer questions, but you know, if it's someone in your life is a little bit younger, just starting out, or maybe restarting their
3:54 Speaker 00 financial journey after a divorce, or something happened to them, tell them, hey, I got a show for you. It's the Money Watch show. So you can check that out. Again, you can subscribe on the Odyssey app. All right. For everyone else, here you are on the Jill on Money Show, and we are answering questions. Today, we're going to do some emails. Looks like everyone was very busy on their week of vacation. I mean, nah, I didn't take the whole week, but a lot of people had it off because their kids were at home from school. We got a lot of questions. This is from Robert, who writes, "Hi Jill and Mark. I am wondering if it would be better to withdraw $1 million from my 401K, or pull $650,000 from my Roth to help our youngest child with his first home?"
4:39 Speaker 00 We live in Washington State, so there's no state tax, just federal. We're retired federal workers and we do understand that pulling a million dollars from our retirement account would put us in the 37% federal tax bracket. You say that as a general rule to use your Roth as the last resort, but we're wondering if our situation might fit an exception. We've been doing Roth conversions since 2022, maxing out at the top of the 24% federal tax bracket. And also means that we're paying IRMA, that extra money that you have to pay for Medicare if you've got too much income. That adds $480 a month for Medicare. So they're at about $200,000 a year and Robert says he's a good kid.
5:24 Speaker 00 Uh, Mark, I must bring you on for this. Mark, did you see the New York Magazine article? About how many parents are helping their kids and we've talked about this, you know, their adult kids. Especially in the New York area and also I think on the coast, a lot of parents are helping them with these home purchases. How on earth can I with any straight face say, take a million dollars out of your thrift savings plan?
5:48 Speaker 01 Goodness gracious. I mean, that's, that's some, uh, some generous helping out. I mean.
5:53 Speaker 00 It doesn't seem like, to me, I wouldn't do that. Now, first of all, I certainly wouldn't do it all at once. So can the kid, when you say, oh, he's a good kid, what can he afford? Can it be that you just pull money out to help him with the down payment? Are you going to pay his mortgage for him? Are you buying a house free and clear? I need more information, but this is terrible. This is a terrible idea.
6:14 Speaker 01 I think they're buying free and clear and I'm just going to assume, I'm just guessing that these guys have a lot of money in, uh, in their retirement accounts and their various accounts, but still.
6:24 Speaker 00 He says he has a, he says he's got a million dollars in his 401K. If that's the only money you have and you want to pull all of that out, no, I would not do that.
6:32 Speaker 01 I don't think it's, I don't think it's all of his money. He just wants to withdraw a million from that 401K. So I'm assuming there's a lot in there, but I still wouldn't. You know, if you want to help with the down payment, okay.
6:41 Speaker 00 That seems a little excessive to me. I'm sorry. I, I'd have, that person would have to have a lot of money. Like, let's say he has $3 million and he's, you know, you do a million.
6:50 Speaker 01 Still wouldn't do it.
6:51 Speaker 00 I still wouldn't do it. I want to know more about this kid. He might be a good kid, but like, really? This is what we're doing now? I don't know. Keep renting. I'm so happy I had four-legged children. This is from Maria. "Hi Jill, I stumbled upon your podcast a few months ago." I love that. And now, guess what? Maria's a daily listener. I like how we hook them in, Mark. "Appreciate your insights and your matter-of-fact approach." By the way, Mark, over the weekend, I went out to dinner with friends of mine, and one of my friends, Rebecca, was like, "I don't even understand half the stuff you talk about with the financial stuff, but I love your interaction with the people." That's kind of fun. I mean, I like that, too. But I hope that you guys do get something out of the financial stuff. Okay, Maria goes on and says,
7:35 Speaker 00 "I'm wondering if you would provide a recommendation for additional retirement savings." Here's the situation. My husband is 60 and working full-time. Makes $140,000 in salary, about a $15,000 to $20,000 annual bonus. And Maria's 57, $116,000 salary with a $10,000 bonus. Kids launched. Hmm, I wonder if they bought them houses. Maria's mortgage paid off in three years. Home value $600,000, a car loan at 2.5%, no other debt. So check out their savings. $1 million in a traditional 401K. $720,000 in a traditional IRA. $70,000 in a Roth IRA.
8:18 Speaker 00 $30,000 in a Roth 401K. $33,000 in a brokerage account. $26,000 in a high-yield savings. Then about 18 grand in other savings checking. An HSA of $12,000. Okay, so Maria says, "I contribute 8% to my Roth, and my employer matches 9%. My husband is contributing 6% to his 401K, but no employer match. We'd like to increase our retirement contributions, and initially, we're thinking of increasing my husband's 401K to at least 10%. However, given that our savings are so heavily skewed to the pre-tax side, should we increase the Roth 401 contribution? Would that be a better option?"
9:03 Speaker 00 That is what Marie wants to know. I'll just answer for Mark, even though I know he's just about to pounce on me. They make a lot of money. They live in a high-tax state. So I know where they live. They live in a high cost of living in a high-tax state in the Northeast. They make $140,000, $160,000, $260,000. They make about $280,000. I'm still gonna go for the Roth, Mark. Would you agree with that? Ha, ha, ha. Of course you do, right?
9:29 Speaker 01 A hundred percent. I mean, that was the first thing that jumped out at me is they have almost, you know, nearly $2 million in pre-tax savings. Uh, you know, very, they only have a hundred thousand in Roth. So I think the Roth should be the focus going forward.
9:41 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Okay. So here is a message from Julie, who writes, Dear Jill, I'm 10 years into retirement and better at saving than spending. Hmm. This seems like a very common theme here on this show. Uh, Julie converted about $80,000 into Roth IRAs before taking her required withdrawals three years ago. My RMDs were $24,000 last year. It's way more than I need to live comfortably and travel. I've been putting them into CDs, but then I just pay taxes on the interest from the CDs, putting me in a higher tax bracket, and it's all so annoying. Where should I invest this money?
10:23 Speaker 00 Okay. So one thing to consider would be to just open a brokerage account. You don't need the money right now. And if you put it money into this brokerage account, what you can do is you can try to skew this a little bit towards just plain old stock index investing. And maybe you would put it into, I was going to say a municipal bond fund, but I'm really not sure what your income is. So it's probably just going to be a generalized bond fund. You're not going to trade it. Put it aside. Don't worry about it. And let's see where, where you go. I mean, it's so funny, Mark, because one thing to remember about all this is that, you know, you pile up that money pre-tax, year after year after year.
11:08 Speaker 00 And now here, you're listening to this. Julie's like, ah, it's way more than I need and it's pushing her to another tax bracket. That's why we like the Roth so much. That's the reason. This is from Steve, who writes, I have about $180,000 in 401K and profit sharing plans in four different accounts. Should I move them all to the same account where I work? Or should I leave them alone where they are? Hey, you know what, Steve? I love consolidation. As long as your plan at work is a decent plan, go ahead and do it. That makes sense to me. When I say a decent plan, do you have enough options? Are there index funds that you can use? I love the idea of consolidation, and I think having it all in one place just makes
11:49 Speaker 00 it easier to manage, much, much, much easier. This question is from Rich, who says, "Hi, Mark and Jill. I have two children, age 30 and one age 26. They are both childless right now, but we do suspect that at some point in the future, one or both will have children. Is it possible to open a 529 plan for, as they say in sports, a player to be named later? Thanks, Rich." Mark, it is possible. It used to not be. It used to be that you had to have a social security number, but it is possible to open a 529 without a social, right?
12:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's true. I know people that have done this. You basically open it in your name, and then, once the beneficiary comes along, you transfer it into their name.
12:35 Speaker 00 That's, I mean, it's very nice to do. I would always wait. I'm sorry. I feel like that's bad juju, anyway, but that's just me. Sorry. All right, last question from Fran. "I listen to a variety of podcasts, and many advertise the need for buying title insurance, so crooks don't take out loans on your home. Is it really happening? Is buying title insurance reasonable?" She gives the example of a company. All right, Mark, I have no idea. We've never had a title insurance company come to us, have we?
13:05 Speaker 01 No, I would say this is all nonsense.
13:07 Speaker 00 This sounds like nonsense. Usually, title insurance is something that you need when you get a mortgage, and it always seems a little bit, I don't, I was gonna say like a scam. It's not a scam, but it seems unnecessary. But the mortgage company, because it's a big chunk of money, wants you to get insurance because they're worried that they have too much risk, so they're happy to have you buy the title insurance. But it's such, it really is unnecessary in most cases.
13:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, I actually remember when we recently closed on our new place here, our attorney told us, he's like, "Look, in the weeks to come, you're gonna get a bunch of, well, as he said, you're gonna get a bunch of crap in the mail telling you to buy title insurance. Just throw it out."
13:48 Speaker 00 There you go. So, throw it out. All right, I hope that helps. Hey, if you've got a question, get in touch with us. Go to jillonthemoney.com. Click the Contact Us button, write us a note, and if you'd like to join us on the air, check that box. All right. Tick tock, tick tock, gang. Next week, it is the most amazing day of the year for me and Mark. We get to talk to Ed Slott, Thursday, March 6th, 7 Eastern Time. And I'd love it for you to join us at this webinar, but you can only join us if you are a member of Jill on Money Live. You know, our subscription service, 45 bucks, and you will have access to this webinar with Ed, three more after
14:30 Speaker 00 that, bonus audio and video content, the entire back catalog, all for 45 bucks for the next 12 months. So you should check that out because Ed Slott, not to be missed. You can subscribe to this show on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Don't forget to do something nice for someone else today. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thank you for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
15:01 Speaker 02 As a physician, I constantly tell women navigating perimenopause and menopause that the traditional scale simply doesn't tell the whole story. Midlife hormonal shifts change how our bodies distribute weight, making total body composition a much more clinically meaningful metric than just a single number after age 40. That's why I recommend looking into the Withings Body Scan 2. It goes far beyond the basic scale by providing medical-grade, six-zone, segmental body composition insights, including muscle mass, visceral fat, bone mass, and vascular age. Tracking bone mass is especially vital
15:42 Speaker 02 as bone density loss accelerates during menopause, raising the risk for osteoporosis and giving you concrete data to discuss with your doctor. What truly sets the Body Scan 2 apart from standard options is its advanced cardiovascular screening, including a six-lead ECG with AFib detection to give you a complete preventative health picture right at home. It brings the same grounded, data-driven clarity to your health that I strive to bring to my practice every day. Head to withings.com to learn more and use promo code UNPAUSED for 10% off. Consult your physician before starting any new health or fitness regimen.
16:22 Speaker 00 The world is changing faster than most career advice can keep up with. It's true, industries are shifting, jobs are disappearing, and new ones are just showing up that didn't exist five years ago, five minutes ago, whatever. I am Suzy Welch, and on Becoming You, we talk about how to find the work that genuinely calls you and actually pays you what you want to be paid, even in today's marketplace. When you find that intersection, the possibilities are bigger than you think. Listen to Becoming You wherever you get your podcasts.
Previous Can I Take On More Risk? Next Early Retirement From Federal Service Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated