Pod Insights Jill on Money with Jill Schlesinger 529 Assets Not Growing About this episode With the market going gangbusters, why aren't the 529 plans growing? Have a money question? Email us here Subscribe to Jill on Money LIVE YouTube: @jillonmoney Instagram: @jillonmoney Twitter: @jillonmoney "Jill on Money" theme music is by Joel Goodman, www.joelgoodman.com. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Over the past year, we've had a couple of new babies in the family. And seeing those babies, they really just stop you in your tracks. They make you deeply grateful to be alive and suddenly put everything into perspective. It can really prompt the deeper questions like, what are you doing to ensure that your family can keep celebrating milestones, planning college dreams, and making joyful memories even if the unexpected were to happen? That's my why for life insurance. And if you've been telling yourself it's something you should have by now, you don't have to figure it out alone. PolicyGenius is an online marketplace that takes the headache out of the entire process. Instead of selling you their own plans, they let you compare quotes side by side from top insurers completely for free.
0:43 Speaker 00 Plus, you get real licensed humans who advocate for you, handle the messy paperwork, and help you lock in peace of mind fast without the high-pressure sales pitch. Make a smart move today to help protect their tomorrow. With PolicyGenius, you can see if you can find 20-year life insurance policies, starting at just $276 a year for $1 million in coverage. Head to policygenius.com to compare quotes now. That's policygenius.com. Running a business is hard enough. Why make it harder with dozens of disconnected apps? I know so many founders and managers who spend half their workday just jumping between
1:23 Speaker 00 tabs, trying to get one program for accounting to play nice with another for inventory, CRM, and HR. You end up paying thousands of dollars every month for a Frankenstein monster of software that actually slows your team down instead of helping them work. That's why you need to switch to Odoo. Odoo is an all-in-one, fully-integrated business platform that brings every single department into one clean, effortless dashboard. Instead of burning cash on bloated subscription fees for half a dozen different platforms, Odoo replaces them all for a tiny fraction of the cost. It is completely customizable, remarkably easy for your staff to learn, and designed
2:04 Speaker 00 to scale with you whether you're running a boutique startup or expanding a massive enterprise. It streamlines your entire operation from top to bottom. So you can stop wrestling with your tech stack and finally focus on what really matters, growing your company. Thousands of businesses have already made the switch. Why not you? Try Odoo for free today at Odoo.com. That's O D O O dot com.
2:35 Speaker 00 Welcome to the Jill on Money Show. It's Friday, January 3, and we are here, early days of 2025, answering your financial questions. We are trying to help you take control, to have some agency over the big decisions in your life. And you can have that. You may not get what you want, but at least give us a holler. Get in touch with us so you know what your options are. That, to me, is a way to really feel a lot better about the process. All you need to do is go to our website, jillonthemoney.com, click the Contact Us button. Let us know if you'd like to come on the air live, just by checking that box. While you're on the website, just bookmark it. All of our content gets refreshed all the time, so please do check it out. All right,
3:20 Speaker 00 let's do some emails. This is a follow up from Anonymous from Dallas, who reached out about a potential large inheritance that's more than a decade away. So Anonymous says, I asked for advice on whether my wife and I should shift from a pre-tax 401k contribution to full Roth 401k. You and Mark recommended going full Roth, and we made the switch. Mark also suggested discussing gifting strategies with my parents, who are 72 and 70. And after speaking with them, here's what they agreed to. This is amazing, Mark. You really have made a difference in this guy's life. So the parents are going to gift $8,000 each to Anonymous and Anonymous's brother
4:05 Speaker 00 every six months with no restrictions on the use. Now, wait a second. $8,000 is $16,000.
4:15 Speaker 00 I mean, they could gift more, but okay, let's just figure that out. That's that. They would also agree to cover half of my son's daycare costs totaling 750 bucks a month. Additionally, they're doubling our contributions to our one-year-old's 529 plan and will extend this to any future children. However, they would like to use a grandparent-owned 529 plan instead of adding it to our account, which has about $13,000 in it. That decision is due to recent changes that exclude grandparent-owned 529 contributions from impacting a student's financial aid eligibility. It all seems advantageous, though part of me would love to consolidate everything into our 529 for simplicity.
5:00 Speaker 00 What are your thoughts? I did not expect any of this when my wife and I had our son, so I am tremendously humbled and grateful. Mark, it's not such a big deal to have two separate 529 accounts, right?
5:13 Speaker 01 No, it's not the worst thing in the world. I mean, you know, I would rather have one, but if they're fine with it, if that's all that matters.
5:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, let's just take the money however it comes and not start quibbling over the details. I agree with you. I'd rather that as well, but eh, seems like a pretty good deal for you and I'm very happy. And I'm glad you had the conversations. Funny how you have conversations and it does lead to better decision-making, which is amazing. Uh, this is from Michael, who said, "I watched a short video of yours about not changing what you're doing with index funds, et cetera, but my concern, being only four years from drawing off investments, is avoiding some sort of crash." By the way, Michael says a bubble crash, so it depends what your bubble is in. Okay, so, Michael's in the Vanguard world and he said, "I was considered leaning to
6:02 Speaker 00 energy funds and a minimum volatility exchange traded fund. They are both managed. The latter only lost 0.16% during COVID. Another thought was just sitting on a six-month CD to let things shake out. Any opinions?" Okay, what we're really talking about is what's the proper allocation as you anticipate drawing From your investments. I think the first thing you have to do, Michael, is to figure out how much money are we drawing? What are we asking your portfolio to provide for you? And what do I mean by that? I mean, that if you're looking at your retirement planning and you say, "Well, I will be getting social security, which makes up some portion. Let's just say, you know,
6:44 Speaker 00 there's 30 grand coming in from social security, and I'll need another 70 grand from my portfolio." Okay? And let's say you have a few million bucks in the portfolio. In that case, we need to set up a system where you can provide $70,000 from your portfolio consistently. Now, if you've got, again, I'm going to just pretend, you've got $3 million in the portfolio. One thing to do is to have two years of that need, $140,000, locked down in some sort of cash equivalent like a CD, right? So you can have a one-year CD, a two-year CD, you can even have a three-year CD, just so if you're really worried about the next four years. But what I think is more important is,
7:29 Speaker 00 do you have your allocation right overall? I'm not into energy funds. I'm not into a Minimum Volatility Exchange Trader Fund. I'm not into managed funds. What I'm into is having some stocks, some bonds, some cash, maybe a real estate fund, maybe you want a small commodities fund, but boy, I wouldn't be picking out leaning on any specific kinds of funds, sector funds, because I don't think it's worth it. You don't need to. So what you're really saying is, how do I not just get through the next four years? How do I get through the next 34 years? Right? And that means that you really need to be paying attention to what it is you're asking that portfolio to provide for you in terms of income, then coming up with the right allocation
8:14 Speaker 00 to get you there. Well, this is a fascinating question, Mark. This is from Heather. The subject is 529s underperforming. How about that? Okay. Hi Jill and Mark. I've been checking on my kids' 529 plans. And with how well the stock market is doing, these 529s are barely earning anything under 10% each year. The kids are 11 and 13. The clock is ticking. I keep adjusting the investments, but I'm not having luck. Would it really be that bad to save for college in a regular brokerage account? Maybe I'm a bad picker. We have the California and New York plan. All right. Well, let me just look at the New York 529 plan. Do you want to weigh in on this, Mark? On the New York Saves 529 plan?
8:59 Speaker 00 Because this is a plan that has... What are the investments inside of the New York plan?
9:05 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah, I use the New York plan. It's 100% Vanguard. There are some target date fund options. And there's also individual fund options, if that's what you want to do. So I don't know how these plans are invested. That's obviously what's going on here.
9:21 Speaker 00 Yeah, I think she's messing with the plan. That's what I really think. So are you using a target-based plan? If you're doing a target, I still think if I look at those target funds, there are different portfolios. So let's see that like 11, which means what am I, seven years out? Right? Seven or eight years out? So I'm in 24. So that gets me to 33. Okay, so I'm going to look at this. In the target enrollment of 2033, this would probably be about what she's... I bet this is what she's in. This allocation is in the stock market, 34%. Okay, this is what the problem is. The stock market fund, the US fund, 34%. An international fund, 23%.
10:07 Speaker 00 And then bonds in the rest. So it's a 50/50 plan. So if you want, and you feel comfortable doing this, instead of like, oh my God, I'm going to like actually do the age-based plan, which is fine. Nothing bad's going to happen to you in that plan. But if you really want to go crazy, Mark, what do you do? Do you do 70% stocks? And I mean, you could do the... Vanguard Stock Index portfolio and that'll rocket for you, you know.
10:34 Speaker 01 I mean, I think this is, this is the problem with target day funds is people don't realize, you know, how they perform as soon as the way that they're designed is once the kid turns 12 or, you know, 11, 12, and from that point on, they're going to get very, very conservative. Yep. In terms of a 529 plan, it's really those first 11 or 12 years that you have the room to really make a lot of growth. That's why, I mean, I have Theo, he's 100% invested in stocks.
11:00 Speaker 00 Yeah. I mean, if I just look at the, obviously for this year, the stock index, you know, it's up, going to be up 18, 19, 20%. It's going to, that's what it's going to do. Now, if you feel comfortable doing this, then I want you to get back in touch with us because you either have to just decide like, I've got plenty of money in there. It's good. Or you say, that's going to be sort of my safer money, but I'll move some portion of this and make it more like a 70, 30 fund, but you're on the hook, that 13 year old especially. That's going to be dangerous time.
11:33 Speaker 01 13 year old, I probably wouldn't be messing around with it because it's getting close to D-Day.
11:38 Speaker 00 Excuse me. I sneezed on that D-Day comment.
11:41 Speaker 01 Got to die.
11:42 Speaker 00 Give us a holler back Heather, if you've got a question to follow up. Okay. This is from Beth. Sadly laid off, but maybe I can retire and make lemonade out of lemons. This is my kind of gal. Okay. So it says, Jill, I started listening to your podcast recently and I love the content. Thank you. I'm hoping you can help me with a tough decision I have to make, or at least give me some confidence in my financial situation. I've worked in corporate America for about 25 years and I've always done well. A few weeks ago, I was notified I'd be laid off at the end of the year. Hmm. That stinks. I'm extremely disappointed. However, the company has found a role for me that would maintain my salary. Oh, that's good. I am familiar with the role and I can do it,
12:27 Speaker 00 but not sure I want to. I'm strongly considering walking away. Oh my God. 54 years old and I'll tell you what, right now, ma'am, I'm feeling like this better be good numbers, Mark, for me to walk away. Here we go. All right. Planning for expenses of $9,000 a month. That's our, that's our bogey, Mark. Here we go. Oh, this is going to be so easy to do. The broker's account has $2.5 million.
12:54 Speaker 00 The 401k has a million and a half dollars. So again, so two and a half, let's add three. You know, there's three and a half now because we've got to pay tax on the 401k. 200,000 in a Roth pension starts in six years, $3,900 a month. No COLA, no cost of living adjustment. Social Security at age 70. Ah, I want to plan on a long life to 99 years old. I have a partner, but I want to plan without their finances. Should I take this job? Can I walk away and never have to work again? Okay, Mark, what do you think? This is a fascinating one. So $9,000 a month. We have, we know that we have $3,900 a month of that taken care of.
13:39 Speaker 00 At least, I mean, I know there's no cost of living, but that's a good start. And the Social Security at age 70 is another 3,400. So, all right, we know we have that. But we have six years that we have to spend, you know, that money. Six years times $9,000 a month. Then at age 60, we get the pension. So we have 60 to 70 pension only, right? And then 70 is Social Security. Does Beth have the ability to walk away and stick her middle finger up at corporate America and say, I'm done?
14:15 Speaker 01 If that's what she wants to do, she can do it. She has the brokerage account and that's what's going to float her for the next six years, if that's what she wants to do.
14:22 Speaker 00 I think if you want to do, again, I would make sure, if that's the case, just remember what you have to do. That brokerage account's got two and a half million dollars. We got to set this up right now so that you can have $100,000 a year come out of that. I'm saying 100 because I think there'll probably be some tax implications, right? So 100 out of that two and a half million for six years. Easy, right? No big deal. So let's just say we're now at 1.9, maybe even say 1.8 for the heck of it. Then from age, you start collecting your pension and then at age 60, you know what I would do? I would use now my 401k. I would take the money from the old 401k, which I imagine
15:04 Speaker 00 you're going to put into an IRA rollover, use that to make up whatever is the difference between your need and your pension. Okay. So it's going to be a little bit more every year that you're going to need to pull out of that 401k because we know that your pension is not inflation adjusted. There's no COLA. Then hopefully you're draining some of the money out of this account, out of the 401k while you're in a lower tax bracket. Then at age 70, you're going to add in your social security and do it again and keep pulling from that 401k so that we can get that amount down in order to minimize your future required
15:44 Speaker 00 minimum distributions. Mark, I feel like we have told somebody to really tell the boss to take the job and shove it. What do you think?
15:52 Speaker 01 You did not crush that dream.
15:54 Speaker 00 No, it's a dream maker today. Okay. Uh, this is from Linda who said, "My husband met with our fidelity advisor last week. He suggested that we put a portion of our retirement into a fixed target annuity. I've listened to your show. I know you're not a fan of annuities, but the advisor thinks this is great. I'm not a believer. Please help this 30-year married couple figure it out. We're a few years away from retirement. We've got a million dollars in our portfolio." Um, okay. So the thing is, the, the one thing I can tell you about the fidelity advisor is that the fidelity advisor is not getting paid on that piece of business. They, they,
16:38 Speaker 00 they do have a arrangement where they have these annuities that are lower cost and there's not a big fat commission involved. So that, that's one thing that makes me feel better. The problem, I think, is that what they're trying to do is give you income, which is great. I'm wondering if there's a way to do it from the portfolio itself. Now, Mark, do you have a view on this? Because, again, fidelity, it's a little different because they, this is not a big commission product. That's not the issue here. I was wondering if the husband may have said, I'm worried about income, or they're trying to figure out how to annuitize something.
17:19 Speaker 00 I still think that I'd like more information, but do you think at first blush that we should think about this?
17:26 Speaker 01 I'm not ready to say that because I need more info. I need to know how much they have and what they're spending. Are there any pensions involved? I can't say that.
17:35 Speaker 00 I think we would love more information. And please, if, even if you just said, okay, we have a million dollars, but like, is there any pension amount? What, how, what is the social security claiming strategy? And what is the rationale for this product? You know, the other thing that I have a hard time with, with an annuity, is that it is also tying up money. And I feel very concerned about losing the liquidity. And that's really what I think we should be considering. If you have a financial question, you have a life question, give us a holler, go to jillonthemoney.com and click the Contact Us button. If you don't want to come on the air, if you're a little bit nervous,
18:18 Speaker 00 give us a lot of your background and don't forget to let us know the all-important how much money you spend either on a monthly or an annual basis. It really does help in the planning process. You can subscribe to us on the Odyssey app or wherever you find your favorite podcasts. Our music is composed by Joel Goodman. Mark Talarceau is our executive producer and king of all things web. And we are distributed by the fine folks at Odyssey. Please put your hands metaphorically on someone's back, or maybe even give them a hug, but make sure you get permission. Not everybody's a hugger these days. I'll tell you, I've learned that firsthand. Change your work, change your wealth, change your life. Thanks for listening and we'll talk to you tomorrow.
Previous Am I Saving Too Much? Next Anxiety Around My Finances Page updated November 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated