Pod Insights If You're Listening Australia vs the Internet: Conservative kill screen About this episode Just a few months ago Elon Musk was heralded as a political kingmaker when he had a hand in helping Donald Trump win the US election. Musk has since meddled in the politics of the UK, Germany, Spain and elsewhere but has struggled to convert his political prowess into victories for his chosen Conservative parties. I
n fact, being in any way similar to Trump or Musk has been a dead weight around the ankle of political campaigns over the last few months.
It was clear the DOGE dynamism had officially worn off when federal elections in Canada and Australia saw both conservative parties lose by a landslide…
Given that Musk and the other tech bro billionaires have so much influence over how we communicate... why are they seemingly struggling to actually influence our politics?
If you're around Newcastle on the 18th of May, come along to the live show of If You're Listening at the Young People's Theatre - tickets available here: https://yptninc.sales.ticketsearch.com/sales/salesevent/149193
Follow If You're Listening on the ABC Listen app https://radio.abc.net.au/help/apps.
Check out our series on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLDTPrMoGHssAfgMMS3L5LpLNFMNp1U_Nq
Transcript 3,369 words · 29 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 ABC Listen, podcasts, radio, news, music and more.
0:08 Speaker 01 G'day, I'm Thomas O'Reeley and I'm thrilled to announce I'll now also be hosting Background Briefing. Over the past few weeks, our reporters have been investigating stories of untold power and hidden influence. Who's really shifting the dial in Australia? They're secretive by nature. From the unlikely influencers.
0:26 Speaker 00 I've rejected probably 15 to 20 politicians in the last month.
0:29 Speaker 01 To the international businessmen shunning the spotlight. All of his buddies are sanctioned. The game changers wielding serious power under the radar. We are cultivating influence. Agents of influence, an all new series by Background Briefing.
0:45 Speaker 02 This podcast is recorded on the lands of the Awabikal, Darug and Eura people.
0:52 Speaker 02 We have all just witnessed two of the worst political campaigns in modern history. It started here.
0:59 Speaker 03 Canada, get ready, our CBC News Decision Desk is ready to make a call.
1:03 Speaker 02 Just a few months ago, Canada's Conservative Party looked certain to win this election and yet.
1:09 Speaker 03 Canada's next government will be a Liberal government. It is not yet.
1:14 Speaker 02 And then, six days later, another shock in Australia.
1:18 Speaker 04 Astonishing figures, they're the stuff of landslides, except this time, unusually, it's towards rather than away from a sitting government.
1:29 Speaker 02 Again, the Conservative Coalition Party was considered a sure thing a few months ago, but.
1:35 Speaker 05 Let's just say that, I can't see how the coalition wins from here.
1:38 Speaker 02 Not only did both Conservative Parties lose, both of their leaders were thrown out of Parliament.
1:44 Speaker 06 Pierre Poliev, who may be on track actually to lose his own seat as leader.
1:49 Speaker 07 This is perhaps the story of the night. Dixon, this is Peter Dutton's seat and it appears that he has lost that seat.
1:57 Speaker 02 How did almost the same thing happen in two places at once? Well, one word was on everyone's lips. Obviously, Trump had a massive effect.
2:08 Speaker 08 Donald Trump, I think the Trump factor.
2:10 Speaker 02 The Trump factor.
2:11 Speaker 08 The impact of Donald Trump.
2:14 Speaker 02 But here's the thing, as you may recall, Donald Trump has been the President of the United States before, for four whole years. In those four years, Conservative Parties had no trouble winning elections in Australia, the UK, Germany, all over the place. But in the last four months, everything has changed.
2:34 Speaker 02 The same systems put in place to help conservative political parties win may have contributed heavily to their loss.
2:50 Speaker 02 So what is different this time?
2:57 Speaker 02 I'm Matt Bevan, and from if you're listening, this is the final episode of Australia versus the internet.
3:10 Speaker 09 All right. Hello, everyone. So my apologies for the late start.
3:13 Speaker 02 In August 2024, Elon Musk invited Donald Trump onto his social media platform X to interview him. It was a bit of a mess. Musk had taken 40 minutes to get everything working, claiming that a cyber attack had caused X's servers to overload.
3:31 Speaker 09 We unfortunately had a massive distributed denial of service attack against our servers.
3:37 Speaker 02 Outside experts said that there actually was no attack, and the problems were instead caused by incompetence and massive staff layoffs. Or, as Musk put it.
3:47 Speaker 09 As this massive attack illustrates, there's a lot of opposition to people just hearing what President Trump has to say.
3:58 Speaker 02 Sure, why not?
3:59 Speaker 09 Donald, great to speak.
4:02 Speaker 10 Congratulations, because I see you broke every record in the book with so many millions of people, and it's an honour.
4:09 Speaker 02 Musk started the conversation by talking about the assassination attempt on Donald Trump that had taken place a month earlier in the town of Butler, Pennsylvania.
4:17 Speaker 10 Take a look at what happened.
4:23 Speaker 02 Musk particularly wanted to talk about what Trump did right after being hit in the ear with a bullet, climbing to his feet and pumping his fist in the air.
4:31 Speaker 09 You were pumping your fist in the air and saying, fight, fight, fight. And I think that's, I mean, you know, the, the, the president of the United States represents America. So that's a, you know, a, a big, you know, a part of the reason why I was excited to endorse you.
4:49 Speaker 02 Elon Musk's endorsement came 34 minutes after Trump was shot that day. And really, that moment seems to have changed the world.
5:01 Speaker 11 A tweet that's just come in from Elon Musk, adding that he fully endorses President Trump and hopes for a rapid recovery.
5:09 Speaker 02 It's not just the endorsement, though. See, on that day, around that time, something very significant seems to have happened inside the algorithm of his website. This was the moment that Twitter truly died and turned into X, Elon Musk's personal megaphone. Two Australian university researchers, Timothy Graham and Mark Andreovic, found that on that day, the reach of Elon Musk's tweets increased exponentially. He went from getting about 100 to 150,000 reposts a day to 500 or 600,000.
5:48 Speaker 12 Maybe he's cleverer than he was. Maybe he's more intelligent than, funnier. No, no, it's, it's none of those things. They juiced the numbers. That's what they did.
5:57 Speaker 02 And Musk wasn't the only one to benefit from the algo shift that day.
6:02 Speaker 12 And you can see this sort of effect, not as strong, but on other right wing accounts as well, they all of a sudden started getting far more reach, far more views.
6:13 Speaker 02 Anyone Musk interacted with frequently online got a massive boost to their reach. The X account that Musk interacted with most in 2024 was an anonymous account called End Wokeness. On the 6th of September 2024, End Wokeness posted a screenshot from a local community Facebook group.
6:37 Speaker 02 A woman had posted that her neighbour's daughter's friend had lost her cat and then subsequently found it being carved up for meat by a family of Haitian immigrants. She also said that she'd been told that the Haitians had been doing this to dogs and local ducks and geese. Two days later, on September 8th, Elon Musk repeated the claims about pet cats being eaten. On September 9th, vice presidential candidate JD Vance posted about it. And then on September 10th...
7:11 Speaker 10 In Springfield, they're eating the dogs, the people that came in. They're eating the cats. They're eating, they're eating the pets of the people that live there.
7:23 Speaker 02 In just five days, this very untrue story about a neighbour's daughter's friend's cat was elevated from a community Facebook group through X to a presidential debate.
7:43 Speaker 02 And Elon's meddling wasn't even confined to the United States.
7:53 Speaker 02 Over the New Year's break at the start of this year, the British Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, took a little holiday with his family to the Portuguese island of Madeira. But his holiday was interrupted by Elon Musk.
8:06 Speaker 13 Tech billionaire Elon Musk launched an explosive attack on his social media platform X, one where he accused the Prime Minister of being complicit in the rape of Britain.
8:18 Speaker 02 Nothing quite kills the Madeira vibe like being accused of being complicit in the rape of Britain. The allegation concerned Sir Keir's time as the UK's top prosecutor between 2008 and 2013, where he was involved in investigating a decades-long child sexual exploitation scandal.
8:43 Speaker 13 His office worked to prosecute members of criminal gangs, which predominantly consisted of men of South Asian descent that had groomed, assaulted and raped young girls across England. But it was also criticised for not doing enough to help some victims.
8:57 Speaker 02 Dozens of people were convicted. Three parliamentary inquiries were held. And Sir Keir has not been found to have done anything wrong. But Elon Musk had never heard of any of this until he saw a video posted about it by a far-right British activist on New Year's Day. And if Elon had never heard of it, that must be because of a cover-up.
9:20 Speaker 13 Following Musk's recent posts, the decade-old scandal has re-emerged.
9:25 Speaker 02 The British government spent weeks dealing with the chaos. Musk demanded that King Charles sack Sir Keir, dissolve the parliament and call new elections. Now, I know that the British have a very vibes-based constitution, but I'm fairly sure that foreign tech billionaires don't usually get a lot of say in this kind of thing. Elon Musk, the world's richest man, had become a global wrecking ball, able to swing in and ruin any politician's day on a whim based on whatever little random tweet crossed his newsfeed.
10:06 Speaker 09 Hello, hello.
10:07 Speaker 14 Hello.
10:09 Speaker 09 Can you hear me okay?
10:11 Speaker 14 Yes, we can hear you.
10:13 Speaker 02 In January, he decided to ruin the day of the major party leaders in Germany by backing a minor party.
10:19 Speaker 09 The fate of the world, I think, rests upon this election in Germany.
10:23 Speaker 02 He'd thrown his support behind the far-right, anti-immigration Alternative for Deutschland party.
10:29 Speaker 14 We wish you, President Donald Trump, Vice President JD Vance, all the best to make America great again. You are the best.
10:43 Speaker 14 Make Germany great again.
10:47 Speaker 02 Following Trump's election victory, Elon Musk was seen as a kingmaker. His support or criticism were powerful potential weapons in political battles across the world.
10:58 Speaker 13 The question now, what or who will be his next target?
11:03 Speaker 02 All of this was watched with great interest in both Canada and Australia, which had upcoming elections. Musk had already called the sitting Australian government fascists over their proposed social media misinformation laws, and he had endorsed Conservative Party leader Pierre Poliev for Prime Minister of Canada.
11:25 Speaker 15 My three-year-old has just told me that he wants to go to Mars, so I guess Mr. Musk would be the right guy to put him in touch with.
11:33 Speaker 02 In January this year, Musk and Trump seemed to be on a winning streak. Polls showed Trump's approval rating in America was around 50%, and Musk's was around 45%. It felt like there were no barriers to stop them pursuing their agenda. The winds of change were behind them, and the Conservative Parties in both Australia and Canada thought, why not hop on board? The thing is, though, Musk in particular was taking a lot of his ideas from his pals on X. And as the wise philosopher Donald Trump Jr. once said...
12:07 Speaker 16 We gotta remember, guys, Twitter is not real life.
12:10 Speaker 02 Truly a 21st century Plato. After all, what are tweets but shadows on the wall of Elon Musk's man cave?
12:17 Speaker 16 Like I said, Twitter's not real life. Rest of the country's a little different.
12:23 Speaker 02 But just because people on X think that an idea sounds good, does that mean that the general public will? For instance, the now infamous DOGE, Department of Government Efficiency, was invented by an anonymous X user in August 2024 as a joke, merging Musk's favourite cryptocurrency, Dogecoin, with a story about Musk potentially getting a gig in the future Trump administration. Musk caught on, and the rest is history.
12:56 Speaker 17 So if you do choose to be the head of the Department of Government Efficiency?
13:02 Speaker 09 Yeah, DOGE.
13:03 Speaker 17 Yup.
13:06 Speaker 02 Ideas like this spread quickly, first to Trump.
13:09 Speaker 10 My administration will establish the brand-new Department of Government Efficiency.
13:16 Speaker 02 And then beyond Trump, all the way to Australia.
13:19 Speaker 18 The newly created job of Shadow Minister for Government Efficiency, an apparent nod to Donald Trump's appointment of Elon Musk as Head of Government Efficiency in the US.
13:30 Speaker 02 A large part of the DOGE cost-cutting plan was to fire a significant portion of federal public servants. This was a plan that the conservative opposition parties in Australia and Canada tried to run on as a policy platform too.
13:49 Speaker 15 We will cut the Liberal deficit by 70% by cutting back on bureaucracy, consultants, foreign aid.
13:57 Speaker 19 We'll reverse Labour's increase of 41,000 Canberra public servants because it will save about $7 billion a year.
14:06 Speaker 02 And then there's Elon Musk's idea of ending work-from-home arrangements.
14:09 Speaker 10 We will also require that federal workers must return to the office in person.
14:16 Speaker 02 Which quickly found its way to Australia.
14:18 Speaker 20 I don't think it's unreasonable that people, like in many other workplaces, are asked to go back to work for that face-to-face contact.
14:26 Speaker 02 Pierre Poliev, on the other hand, loved Musk's idea of cutting off funding to public broadcasters.
14:32 Speaker 21 I'm going to defund CBC, that's my commitment.
14:35 Speaker 02 CBC is Canada's public broadcaster.
14:37 Speaker 21 We will defund the CBC to save $1 billion. That was my commitment then, it's my commitment now.
14:42 Speaker 02 In Australia, Peter Dutton didn't pledge to cut funding to the ABC, which, to be clear, is the creator of this show, but he did call us the hate media. Forget about what you're being told by the ABC and The Guardian and the other hate media, forget about that.
14:59 Speaker 02 Cutting public servants isn't a new idea. Trump and Musk didn't invent it. But obviously, people are going to make the connection, particularly when in Australia, Dutton's Shadow Minister for Government Efficiency, or SMOGE, I guess, was photographed wearing a MAGA hat and saying this.
15:18 Speaker 22 We can make Australia great again.
15:23 Speaker 02 Even before Trump started tanking the global financial markets with tariffs, both Poliev and Dutton were keen to make it clear that they weren't directly aping Trump. In fact, a clip of Poliev nonchalantly denying that he was Canada's Trump while eating an apple went viral on X.
15:42 Speaker 23 A lot of people would would say that you're simply taking a page out of the Donald Trump book. Probably, like which people would say that? Well, I'm sure a great many Canadians, but... Like who? I don't know who, but... Well, you're the one who asked the question, so you must know somebody. Okay.
16:00 Speaker 02 But passive aggressively eating an apple isn't the same as vigorously denying any connection with Trump, and it leaves you open for your opponents to make that connection for you.
16:10 Speaker 24 But I have to tell you, speaking for myself, parial playground insults from the maple syrup mega, don't bother me.
16:21 Speaker 02 Meanwhile, in Australia...
16:23 Speaker 20 This is a cut and paste from the United States. This is cut and paste Pete.
16:27 Speaker 19 Prime Minister, why would you invite Donald Trump to Australia when you've got a Timu Trump sitting right opposite you?
16:34 Speaker 02 So, between New Year's Day and Election Day in Australia, Peter Dutton's lead in the polls over the governing Labor Party shrunk from 10 points on first preferences...
16:44 Speaker 18 He could soon be stepping into the nation's top job.
16:47 Speaker 02 To nothing.
16:49 Speaker 08 It is a time of reckoning for the Liberals following last weekend's unprecedented loss of seats.
16:54 Speaker 02 In the same period, Pierre Poliev's lead shrank even more.
16:58 Speaker 06 To blow a 30-point lead is a pretty catastrophic thing.
17:02 Speaker 02 Both parties lost, and both leaders were kicked out of Parliament. Both parties have conceded that the Trump factor played a part in their loss.
17:11 Speaker 25 Mr. Poliev continued to campaign against Justin Trudeau when the threat was clearly Mr. Trump.
17:21 Speaker 02 But both of them also kind of say it with a tone of who could possibly have predicted this? The truth is, they should have. Elon Musk is an unelected billionaire who deliberately surrounds himself both in person and online only with people who agree with him. You know what people who aren't billionaires care about, though? The price of eggs.
17:48 Speaker 26 I can't go to the grocery store without spending less than $250 usually.
17:56 Speaker 02 This is the issue that won Donald Trump last year's election. Again and again, polls say the economy is the issue for Americans.
18:05 Speaker 27 Trump's promises of a better economy hit home.
18:09 Speaker 02 While Musk might seem very important and popular with the blue tick people on the website that he owns, polls showed even before the election campaign began that Canadians and Australians did not like him. His policy ideas are just as unpopular. More than a third of Australians work from home, at least part of the time. Many say that it saves them money in the midst of a cost of living crisis. These people are especially concentrated in the parts of the country Peter Dutton needed to win votes in to become the Prime Minister. Similarly, the vast majority of Canadians support the CBC. Even among Conservative voters, only 18% support totally defunding it.
18:53 Speaker 02 Also, wanting to sack enormous numbers of public servants might be very popular on X and yet, Don Jr...
19:00 Speaker 16 Like I said, Twitter's not real life. Rest of the country's a little different.
19:08 Speaker 02 So the Doge-style policies weren't popular. But do you know what else isn't popular in Canada and Australia?
19:16 Speaker 10 I'm proud of our country, and I am a nationalist. It's a word that hasn't been used too much. People use it, but I'm very proud. I think it should be brought back.
19:27 Speaker 02 Donald Trump, a self-described nationalist.
19:31 Speaker 10 You know, they have a word. It sort of became old-fashioned. It's called a nationalist. And I say, really, we're not supposed to use that word. You know what I am? I'm a nationalist, okay?
19:43 Speaker 02 He wants to put America first.
19:46 Speaker 10 We're putting America first. It hasn't happened in a lot of decades.
19:51 Speaker 02 He thinks that for America to win, everybody else has to lose.
19:55 Speaker 10 I said, of course, I'm unpopular with foreign nations because we're not letting them rip us off anymore, folks.
20:03 Speaker 02 He thinks that America's military allies should pay for their own defence and wants to stop people investing anywhere other than the United States.
20:12 Speaker 10 We subsidise a lot of countries and keep them going and keep them in business. And I say, why are we doing this?
20:19 Speaker 02 And this isn't new. He's had this opinion for like 40 years. All he's doing now is acting on it with tariffs and expansionist threats.
20:29 Speaker 10 I think Canada is going to be a very serious contender to be our 51st state.
20:35 Speaker 02 The US dollar is falling too because the world is losing faith in America.
20:39 Speaker 28 President Trump has betrayed Canada. He's betrayed Canada. The administration's tariffs have no basis in logic and they go against the basis of our two nations partnership. This is not the act of a friend.
20:56 Speaker 02 Also, Trump always, always throws his allies under the bus, or in the case of Peter Dutton, into the blades of a waiting helicopter.
21:05 Speaker 10 Albanese, I'm very friendly with. He's been very, very nice to me, very respectful to me. I have no idea who the other person is that ran against him.
21:18 Speaker 02 So, what now? In this three-part series, we've seen that social media companies are clearly causing serious problems for democracy, both inside and outside of the United States. The free press in advanced democracies is in crisis, with big tech taking both their advertising revenue and their audiences. Attempts by Australia to fix this through taxation and negotiation have failed. So have attempts to build regulatory levies to control a rising tide of harmful misinformation. That misinformation has infected not only voters, but our political parties, who seem to be struggling to grasp the difference between popular policies
22:02 Speaker 02 and fever dreams cooked up in Elon Musk's echo chamber.
22:07 Speaker 02 Australia, with some support from Canada, has tried many ways to remedy this. But both countries are too small to take on the tech giants without help. The European Union has also had big fights with tech giants over the years. But there's very little coordination between Australia, Canada and the EU on these issues. Trump may not want countries working together, but there's no way anyone is going to be able to fix this problem alone.
22:44 Speaker 02 If You're Listening is written by me, Matt Bevan. Supervising producer is Cara Jensen-McKinnon. Audio production is by Cinnamon Nipart. We're returning to normal programming in our next episode with a look at the man leading Trump's trade war, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick. His backstory is extraordinary. He's been a hero, he's been a villain, he's been a sympathetic figure and also one of the most hated men in America. And all of that is even before he attached himself to Donald Trump. Also, if you're in or around Newcastle, we've got some good news. On the afternoon of Sunday, the 18th of May, we're going to do another performance of our live show for people who missed out on coming to the Newcastle Writers Festival
23:28 Speaker 02 event in early April. It'll be at the Young People's Theatre in Hamilton and tickets are available now via a link in the show notes. Catch you there. Please don't do an insurrection.
Previous Australia vs the Internet: Misinformation overload Next The man betting big on Trump's tariffs Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated