Pod Insights I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin Tracking lone killers: Dr Nathan Brooks Pt.2 About this episode What turns an ordinary person into a cold blooded lone killer? From the Christchurch massacre to disturbing cases of stalking and coercive control, Consultant Forensic Psychologist Dr Nathan Brooks reveals the warning signs, hidden triggers and psychological make-up of people who execute violent attacks.
Want to hear more from I Catch Killers? Visit news.com.au.
Watch episodes of I Catch Killers on our YouTube channelhere https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlq8In_ATbJnjFcb-fykqJ8HV9W9OOJWX.
Like the show? Get more aticatchkillers.com.au https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/truecrimeaustralia/i-catch-killers/i-catch-killers-gary-jubelins-new-podcast-series-and-book/news-story/6848df9e1b6feccf7508878fc0438f7f Advertising enquiries: newspodcastssold@news.com.au
Questions for Gary: icatchkillers@news.com.au
Get in touch with the show by joining ourFacebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/844896725918656, and visiting us onInstagram https://www.instagram.com/icatchkillers/?hl=en orTiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@icatchkillerspodcast?lang=en.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 11,009 words · 2 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 The public has had a long-held fascination with detectives. Detectives see a side of life the average person is never exposed to. I spent 34 years as a cop. For 25 of those years, I was catching killers. That's what I did for a living. I was a homicide detective. I'm no longer just interviewing bad guys. Instead, I'm taking the public into the world in which I operated. The guests I talk to each week have amazing stories from all sides of the law. The interviews are raw and honest, just like the people I talk to. Some of the content and language might be confronting. That's because no one who comes into contact with crime is left unchanged. Join me now as I take you into this world.
0:46 Speaker 00 Welcome back to part two of my chat with forensic psychologist Nathan Brooks. In part one, we talked about Nathan's work, the difference between serial killers and mass murderers, and the emerging trend of lone actors who go on killing sprees. In part two, Nathan talks about the Christchurch massacre, where the actions of one man led to the death of 51 people. Nathan breaks down how and why this crime occurred, and how we can try and prevent these types of killings in the future. It was a fascinating and informative chat. Have a listen to what Nathan has to say. Nathan Brooks, or Dr Nathan Brooks, I should say. Welcome back to part two of I Catch Killers.
1:27 Speaker 01 Thanks, Gary.
1:28 Speaker 00 I've got to say, I am finding this conversation fascinating. It was, yeah, working as a homicide detective, I found this inside the mind of killers, or all the type of things that you're examining, absolutely fascinating. I'm sure you're getting this all the time, but is that, the people are, why are they so fascinated with it?
1:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think unpacking what makes, you know, troubling and sometimes very violent people tick is, it is fascinating because most of us can't understand it. When we think about psychopaths, for instance, yeah, they are the ones that think different and make different decisions. And we're often caught up in our own emotions, but for some folks, like psychopathic folks, they're cool and calm under pressure. They're not burdened by the anxiety that we have. And that's hard for everyday people to understand.
2:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. I want to talk about the Christchurch massacre, which is, you know, I'm sure most people know it. I'll just read out the summary of it, just so people that haven't been aware of it are aware of what happened. So, two consecutive mass shootings took place in Christchurch, New Zealand on the 15th March 2019. They were committed during Friday prayer, first at the Alnora Mosque at Ricketton at 1:40pm, and almost immediately after at Limwood Islamic Centre at 1:52. Altogether, 51 people were killed and 89 others were injured, including 40 by gunfire. The perpetrator was an Australian man, Brenton Tarrant, then aged 28.
3:01 Speaker 00 Tarrant was arrested after his vehicle was rammed by a police car as he was driving to a third mosque in Ashburton. He livestreamed the first shooting on Facebook, making the first successful livestream far-right terror attack, and had published a manifesto online before the attack. That just sort of sets the scene. I think anyone that recalls that incident knows how horrifying it was. You've looked at it in depth. What's your take on what caused the lead-up to it? And why did it get that dramatic? And we touched on small parts of it in part one, if we could just deep dive into it now.
3:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, so before we get into it, I might caveat that I'm obviously with the New Zealand police. And this is certainly my view on the situation. It's not at all reflective of theirs. But it is a really complex case. I think when anyone carries out such a horrific mass act of violence, there are many, many layers. And what we saw in that incident and that tragic attack was that several years of build-up went into it. It wasn't something that just happened overnight. We know that Tarrant moved to New Zealand with the intention of carrying out a mass casualty attack, and that was his reason for moving over there.
4:21 Speaker 01 I believe he cited the fact that it was partly the ability to access the firearms. That was one of the primary factors. And shortly after getting there, he commenced training with firearms and acquiring tactical capabilities. But to understand him, we probably need to trace things back to his childhood. And he had In many ways, probably something that hasn't garnered a lot of attention, quite a traumatic childhood. We we've focused a lot, particularly, I think, the the media coverage has been a lot around his ideology.
4:56 Speaker 00 Um.
4:56 Speaker 01 But there are a lot of puzzle pieces that were there early on for him in his early years.
5:02 Speaker 00 What what type of things were they?
5:04 Speaker 01 So one of the things that we we look at for childhood is whether people experience trauma and the influence that that can can have on them as they
5:14 Speaker 00 Um.
5:15 Speaker 01 develop and grow into adults. And adverse childhood experiences is often a marker that we use to look at how bad that trauma is, or how how much adversity a child has had in in their upbringing. And a lot of research would say around four or five adverse experiences can have quite significant impact on someone as as they age and really shape who they become. And we we know Tarrant had a a troubled upbringing, so his parents separated, which I'll I'll just run through some of the so some of the adverse experiences are, you know, parental separation, parental mental health, uh criminality, unstable housing, financial issues, drug use.
5:58 Speaker 00 Um.
5:59 Speaker 01 So the the typical things that we that we might
6:01 Speaker 00 Understand, yeah.
6:02 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so so Tarrant's parents obviously split up, so he had the separation. His mother then uh started dating a a new individual, uh I believe it was an Aboriginal fellow, and uh he was reportedly violent towards Tarrant and his and his sister. Um and that and that abuse continued over several years. Then we also had uh his father, who suffered from mental health difficulties, um and then also uh developed cancer, I believe, for memory.
6:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:35 Speaker 01 And uh ultimately then committed suicide as well. So there were some quite notable things
6:40 Speaker 00 Significant.
6:40 Speaker 01 there.
6:41 Speaker 00 Trauma.
6:41 Speaker 01 Yeah. And and he also, Tarrant himself, was struggled to fit in socially, as as we've, which touched on before. Uh he was often bullied. He was considered to be quite overweight as well. Um and then in his late teens, he had a a big transformation and became quite fixated and obsessed about the gym and and lost quite a lot of weight.
7:02 Speaker 00 I I I think it was in your book, it was something like forty or fifty kilo.
7:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:07 Speaker 00 So huge.
7:08 Speaker 01 Yeah, quite remarkable. And and also during that adolescence, we see that some early racist remarks were were coming out in his school years.
7:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
7:18 Speaker 01 Um, which suggests there's certainly, you know, some difficulties with how he's seeing the world and people and maybe even seeing that there's certain people that that are to blame or that are causing hardships for him and that and that might have been reflective of what things were like on the home front with, uh, you know, with the the physical abuse that was happening at at home. And from from there, as he aged, I think he has spent a period being a personal trainer after high school and then he inherited a large sum of money once his father passed away. And that basically funded him to go and travel overseas for for quite a few years. And unfortunately, rather than taking inspiration from
8:03 Speaker 01 the life and the cultures and the different people, he became very, you know, cynical. And if we look at, you know, the various accounts and things that have been covered on the topic.
8:14 Speaker 00 Hmm.
8:15 Speaker 01 His views were shaped in a in a very negative manner. Um, it did coincide with while he was in Europe with some Islamic based attacks occurring. Uh, so Islamic terrorist attacks at the time. And that all sort of seemed to to come together along with his strong reliance on online groups in 4chan and 8chan and some of these other forums where he was really fueling his beliefs about the world and having those reciprocated back to him. And the classic sort of echo chamber effect started to happen from there where the ideology really got became perpetuated and it continued to get reinforced over time.
8:56 Speaker 00 I suppose what he's exposing himself to is only going to people, people that share the same ideology and that becomes that that cycle.
9:04 Speaker 01 Yes.
9:04 Speaker 00 That reinforces his belief.
9:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, and and I think the the further down that rabbit hole that you go, the more you find things that support those views. And, you know, we get that the classic distortion aspect happen where you look for things that are what you want. You look for things that reinforce your beliefs and then you ignore anything that's contradictory. And and that's what we find with with a lot of ideological aspects is people cherry pick what they focus on and that and they ignore the things that that are contradictory to that. And that, of course, can very easily then start to lead to quite extreme beliefs when you're only looking at, you know, a small fragment of an issue.
9:46 Speaker 00 Hmm. So the build up, would you describe it as a perfect storm in in terms of what the build up before he carried out this horrible act?
9:58 Speaker 01 Well, there's certainly, I think the psychological makeup, the psychological foundation was it was a big factor. So he had a lot of vulnerabilities there, clearly a lot of unresolved anger that that was never addressed. And then we add the internet piece on top of that where he's engaging in various ideological, extreme right wing views that are being perpetuated and fueled. He's then quite financially well off as well, which gave him access and capability factors. And then develops the the plan or the intent to carry out some sort of violence to avenge or seek justice for the injustice which he's perceiving in the world and then starts to
10:43 Speaker 01 begin planning and moves to New Zealand with the the intention of carrying out a mass casualty attack. And a bit like with Anders Breivik in Norway, we see this the culmination of factors come together along with the secrecy and the willingness to dedicate a couple of years of your life to carrying out such a horrific act of violence. I mean, that in itself is nearly. Unheard of and and so remarkable that someone could be so dedicated over.
11:13 Speaker 00 That obsession.
11:14 Speaker 01 To give their life to that.
11:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:15 Speaker 01 Um.
11:16 Speaker 00 Um. There were a number of inquiries that flowed on from the event. Um. Did anything jump out in the part where it could have been? I won't say prevented because as I I keep saying, it's easy in hindsight. But is there any indicators or ways that it could have been diffused, do you think? How how how could you approach it if you look back with the benefit of hindsight? Okay, when he got to this point, there should have been some intervention.
11:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's again, it's always tricky in hindsight. So the there was a Royal Commission in in New Zealand into Royal Commission of Inquiry into the attack and it's nearly a nine hundred page document which reviewed it. Now, some of the interesting findings were more around systems and processes rather than Tarrant himself. So it it looked at, you know, things. So he had a gunshot wound in the months prior to the attack. And at the time, there were no mandatory reporting practices for gunshot wounds. So that has since changed so that if someone presents to hospital with a gunshot wound, that is then passed on to to police and then followed up.
12:23 Speaker 01 Firearms register was something that wasn't strong and that's then been completely revamped to
12:30 Speaker 00 Hmm.
12:30 Speaker 01 Make access to firearms much more difficult and mental health checks and interviews and those sorts of processes. So again, another positive step that's been put in place. Yeah, and and of course, the access to guns has been reduced as well. So some of those capability and incident reporting systems have been improved. Been a lot more funding as well that's gone into violent extremism.
12:56 Speaker 00 Hmm.
12:56 Speaker 01 And I think as well that the improved police practices. And that's not being critical at all of the police practices. But unfortunately, when we have incidents, it causes reviews.
13:08 Speaker 00 Then leads to change and improvements of of course, when it when it gets that way. Not, well, I I suppose the magnitude of the the crime that he created there required that review. Lesser type of crimes, but one, you and I spoke off off camera about it and you are, you're over here and you you're going to deliver a lecture on it. Stalking.
13:32 Speaker 01 Hmm.
13:33 Speaker 00 Stalking to me is a is a major concern. What message have you got or what have you learnt about stalking? People that are prepared to stalk and o- over here in Australia and not just New South Wales, across the across the country, we've got a lot of domestic violence where unfortunately it's male partners invariably murdering female partners. And you look at it and I I can virtually guarantee there'll be stalking involved and not accepting the relationship being over and and different things like that. What what's your your assessment of stalking?
14:02 Speaker 01 Oh, look, it it's so it's so troubling and and one of the challenges with stalking is that it exists on such a spectrum from small unwanted acts, you know, repeated contact that's unwanted, all the way through to very predatory and concerning behaviours, you know, such as breaking into a house and going through a person's underwear drawer and moving things around. So it it is a type of offending that is so broad. But we need to think about it, I think, from a from a couple of different lenses. And one is, how persistent is it?
14:37 Speaker 00 Yep.
14:38 Speaker 01 And then also, how likely is it to become severe and escalate in nature? So stalking can be very broad in motivation. So sometimes it's targeted because of, you know, resent resentment towards an ex-partner. Sometimes it's revenge towards a workplace. Other times, it might be because the person's mentally unwell and they're constantly making unwanted contact because of quite a distortion about the person that they're targeting. And then other times, it's very predatory. And that can often end up in quite significant violence or even sexual offending towards the person. So it's multifaceted and it exists on a spectrum.
15:18 Speaker 00 Have you, in in your work with New Zealand Police, been involved in stalking cases and and how they played out? You don't have to identify the specific case, but stalking cases have escalated.
15:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, look, as both a consultant, forensic psychologist and also working in the police. And a lot of the times it's looking at it from a threat lens. And how concerned do we need to be about the case? And sometimes it's about understanding the motivation and the functionality of the stalking. So what is it that the person's trying to achieve here?
15:52 Speaker 00 Yeah.
15:53 Speaker 01 And why is it that they are failing to understand that that behaviour is unwanted and not reciprocated? So often there's an educational component. Then then sometimes it's looking at as well, is this going to persist? Or is this going to escalate with the stalking case? Um, intimate partner violence is is another one that we sometimes become very concerned about. Often stalking will exist amongst a range of other forms of intimate partner violence, particularly coercive control. Um, and we know that across cases of fatal intimate partner violence that around about seventy five percent of those cases have stalking in them.
16:34 Speaker 01 And often when a partner is killed or an ex-partner is killed, it's where there's been a high level of coercive control. And the victim has tried to regain a level of independence and autonomy. And that has been the final tipping point for the offender. And they have killed that person as that sort of final act of trying to have dominance and control over their lives, which is really quite horrific.
16:59 Speaker 00 Well, the scary part is the dangerous period is in those domestic violence situations when the partner is trying to leave. That's when they're at the the the greatest greatest risk.
17:08 Speaker 01 Absolutely, yeah, it it is um, it is concerning and again, education is is quite important, but the the flip side of that is it's hard to have that conversation with people as well. And should people really have to be that well educated and informed? You know, everyone has a has a right to safety in in many ways. And unfortunately, uh, we still have, you know, huge concerns with people willing to to take matters into their own hands and become violent.
17:36 Speaker 00 Do you do you think, and I'm I'm talking for um, New South Wales or Australia?
17:43 Speaker 00 Maybe relevant to New Zealand, whether the courts fully appreciate the nature of it. If if someone, even the public's perception, it's almost a joke, like, oh, I've got a stalker. And we saw the laugh.
17:56 Speaker 01 Yeah.
17:56 Speaker 00 But I've had so many people contact me when I was in the police as police work. But people contact me post-police, reaching out and they've they've got a stalker and no one seems to take it seriously. And they're they're terrified. Do you think the courts take it and the police take it seriously enough stalking?
18:14 Speaker 01 It's it's hard to give a blanked answer to that, but I, with what you're saying, there are, of course, many cases where people just go, it's unwanted contact. They'll stop or they just dismiss it. And that's that's where stalking becomes a problem because when we dismiss it, it keeps going.
18:33 Speaker 00 Yes.
18:33 Speaker 01 And we need to make sure that we're putting the right level of response to a situation.
18:39 Speaker 00 Yeah.
18:40 Speaker 01 And the temptation is unfortunately to water down the seriousness of it. And that, of course, allows it to keep going. And then before you know it, it's three months, then it's six months, then we've hit a year. And that's a really reinforced and ingrained pattern. And the person may, or the offender may have had quite a bit of, you know, feedback that this is a successful way to keep that person in their life by that stage.
19:04 Speaker 00 Well, I I think, and this is when I'm giving people a advice, if if they got a stalker, if they make contact and it does end up in court, their concern is that brings this person back into my life. And so the stalkers achieve what they want to achieve. So it's a hard, hard thing to police. But it's something that I've always thought they were red flags to me when I saw it in any capacity of an investigation, if someone was stalking someone, being told, we don't want to speak to you, stay away from us, and they ignore that, that is a that is a warning sign. Am I on the right track there?
19:37 Speaker 01 Like, it's. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, you look at things like approach behaviour, you know, how much are they prepared to, or to what extent are they prepared to approach the victim, to be intrusive towards the victim? Are they engaging in surveillance-like behaviours? Are they entering the person's residence? And also factors such as, you know, mental illness can play a role, personality disorders. Um, and. We look at as well, you know, are they deterred by things such as court orders?
20:05 Speaker 00 Hmm.
20:06 Speaker 01 Uh. If it keeps going after court orders again, that's, that's very troubling.
20:10 Speaker 00 Well, I've had people that, uh, the victims of the stalking that have come back to me when the courts haven't gone hard on the stalker. The stalker comes back to them just laughing going, look, the courts don't even care. And it, it empowers them. On, um, coercive control. We've relatively recently had that start to come, uh, come into play, legislation to come into play. I haven't seen it actually play out in court, so I, I think a big part of it is going to be how the police use it as a tool. I think it's a powerful tool. Is coercive control legislated over in New Zealand? Is that something that's, uh, come into play over there?
20:44 Speaker 01 No, it's, it's not legislated over there yet. And remarkably, we don't actually have a stalking law or stalking charges yet. So there's, there's been talk that, or shouldn't say talk, it's probably a loose word for that. But there's been political movement.
20:59 Speaker 00 Hmm.
21:00 Speaker 01 That legislation is going to be proposed quite soon, uh, and then we will have a stalking law. But no, coercive control over in Australia here is, is a reasonably new charge in, in a couple of states. So it'd be really interesting to, to monitor how that goes. But the research on intimate partner violence has certainly been the big reason that we're seeing that law come in. Because it's been so, uh, prevalent, but also relevant to fatal cases.
21:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, there, there's been, uh, too, too many of them in, uh, in this country, that, that's for sure. The interview room.
21:39 Speaker 01 Yes.
21:39 Speaker 00 Um, you're working for New Zealand Police. Is that part of the role that you do? Help, uh, help investigators prepare for an interview, to sit down in the interview room?
21:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, we've been doing quite a bit of work in that space of, of, of late, over the last two years or so. And it is one of the main things that, that we're doing currently around. How do we understand the person in front of us? And how do we tailor our response to ensure that we're meeting them at their level?
22:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. I, I look, I find the interview room fascinating. That was my, that was my happy place in, in policing. I, I found it very stimulating to be in the interview room. Lot of pressure, a lot of build up and all that, but the way that you approach an investigation. I'll, I'll throw a couple of things out just for point of discussion. I I learnt from people that I looked up to as interviewers and I I've sort of tried to adopt, yeah, aspects of the way they approached the interview, but I also learnt that you've got to be, you've got to be legitimate, like you've got to be yourself in the interview room. I've seen people try to, I've tried to mimic mimic people the way they interview someone, doesn't work. I've got to be myself. I've had other people try to mimic me the way I interview, it doesn't work. So I think there's something, you've
22:53 Speaker 00 got to build that rapport with someone in the interview room. Would you agree with agree with that?
22:57 Speaker 01 Yes, spot on. I mean, rapport has become arguably the most crucial ingredient in an interview now.
23:05 Speaker 00 Hmm.
23:05 Speaker 01 And we we have come a long way. It's hard to talk about what current police practices are, but I I dare say that across Australia and New Zealand, there's a improved understanding that rapport really is a cornerstone of the interview. So it it's very hard to have a a a serious major crime interview wi- without rapport. We can't just get the person in now and go straight into the offending, straight into the issues. There's got to be a a build up to that because we can't, we can't expect someone to want to talk to us if we're not establishing rapport with them.
23:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, I I agree with that. And I, people have said characteristics of a good detective, empathy, empathy in the interview room, that of sitting down and trying to understand where this person's coming from. It might disgust me where they're coming from, I might not agree with it, but I won't show that on my face. It will be very much a a poker face in what they're telling me, so there's not judgment there. Um, to go at people, I I again, I'll just throw in some some of my thoughts on the interview room, because I'm interested in getting getting your thoughts. Some people, I'd go into the interview room and I would be very professional, I'd deliberately present professionally, because I thought that was the best way to communicate. Otherwise, I'd I'd get in there and be very relaxed.
24:26 Speaker 00 When we talk about rapport, that's the type of thing, I'm assessing the person in the way that I I want to approach. Sarah Yule, the forensic psychologist I work with, uh talk about the carrot or the stick, whether you're dangling something to them that that they want, or they're feeling, and we can't threaten people in an interview room, obviously, stick figuratively, we don't go in there with a stick. What what's your thoughts on different different approaches for different offenders? Like, there's not a one model fits all, is there?
24:54 Speaker 01 No, no, there's not. But I think there's some rules of thumb that that do hold up really well with with rapport. So firstly, we need to foster commonalities. So first principle is if if you're going to interview someone, what is it about you that's going to allow you to relate to that person? What have you got in common? So everyone should be able to find those things. Secondly, we then look at our ability to compliment the person. And I think when we say compliments, people think, oh, you know, what are you on about? You're just basically trying to praise them unnecessarily. But there's always things when we step back and look at someone's life that we can acknowledge and validate.
25:36 Speaker 01 And that is quite crucial that we still do that, that we recognise them as individuals. And as small as that achievement may be, it may be significant for them. So where is this scope to compliment and validate that person? And then the other one is humour. And that probably sounds like it doesn't belong in an interview room, but how can we find moments of lightheartedness amongst a really heavy and serious conversation?
26:03 Speaker 00 Yeah, I okay, I I get where you're coming from. And that's very much creating that relaxed environment where the conversation will be for flowing. I think the way I approach interviews, some people are very um specific word orientated, listening to your answer, what you exactly you said. I know I've got, that's what comes down because the transcripts only reflects what you said. But if I'm interviewing you in an interview room, in a in a tense interview, and this is one where it's not a lay down, Mizzie, you haven't got all the evidence, it's gonna, a lot's gonna depend on what the uh person of interest that you're interviewing talks about. It's about creating that uh creating that environment where where they feel comfortable to talk.
26:47 Speaker 00 But I'm watching their body language. Like, I might throw something out a little bit left field, a little bit strange, see see how you react. Which way do you lean to within interviewing? Or is this coming down to what I said at the start, that it's individual styles?
27:03 Speaker 01 I, I, look, I think it is individual styles and some people naturally have a really good style and some can learn it.
27:09 Speaker 00 Yep.
27:09 Speaker 01 There's, there's the intrusiveness piece to an interview as well. So when do you become intrusive about the content of that conversation? And when I say intrusiveness, what I'm really talking about is topics that are uncomfortable.
27:24 Speaker 00 Hmm.
27:24 Speaker 01 And maybe more confronting. So you would wanna start low and soft and easier conversation piece topics in the early stages of the interview. And as the rapport develops, then you can become more intrusive because there's a level of trust and respect, understanding developed between the interviewer and the interviewee. So you can't go in too hot or too intrusive.
27:50 Speaker 00 Okay.
27:50 Speaker 01 Too early because you put yourself on the back foot and you risk upsetting the person. So I, I think with the peace model, which is.
27:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
27:58 Speaker 01 Widely used, you know, really in some ways, it's a bit like a five set tennis match, where we're looking at the cumulative momentum over several hours.
28:08 Speaker 00 Hmm.
28:08 Speaker 01 And it's going back and forth. And if you do enough things the right way, it tips in your favour.
28:15 Speaker 00 And, and a lot of the public's perception is that we've got the right to interview people too. As in you're, you're obliged to answer questions. That's very much not, not the case.
28:24 Speaker 01 No.
28:24 Speaker 00 So you, you know, they're well within their, their rights. I've also found, and talk to me about the characteristics of the, the people that would buy into this, that I've sat down with people that have an arrogance about them. And that's the very thing I'm going to exploit. But like, they're dumb to sit down and have an interview with me, but they're so arrogant. They think they're going to, yeah, outsmart, it doesn't have to be me, outsmart the police, I'm smarter than you. And that's why they can't resist themselves sitting down, having an interview. Do you see that type of personality?
28:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's the tendency of people that believe that they can control the situation.
29:01 Speaker 00 Yeah.
29:02 Speaker 01 And that they can talk their way out of it, although they are the smartest person in the room. And that can sometimes bring them undone, you know, a case over in in New Zealand, which has been quite public. And there's been a Netflix documentary on it is Jesse Kempson and the Grace Mullane case.
29:16 Speaker 00 Tell us your assessment on that.
29:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, there's been a lot published and segments of the interview that have been publicly put out there of Kempson during his interview. And we certainly saw that, you know, he started off very calm and believed that he could talk his way out of it during the first interview. That ended up bringing him undone during the second interview, where a lot of those stories were then able to be corroborated. And that worked against him in the end.
29:45 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, but it's it is interesting what motivates people to sit down and and participate in the interview. What about crime scenes, your interpretation of of crime scenes? And I think a discussion initially when you came in here before on camera, talking about psychopaths, how they can, yeah, commit a horrendous crime and not be rattled by it than leave. I would see crime scenes where I I would call it like a panic crime scene. I don't think the person planned this, it shocked them that they've killed a person and the crime scene represents that. What's your your take and what can you learn from going to a crime scene?
30:24 Speaker 01 Oh, crime scenes are so valuable for, you know, anyone in the operational spaces. You nearly need to see the crime scene or at least have incredibly good photos of it to be able to form any conclusions around it. But, look, you look for contradictions ultimately in the crime scene, don't you? And sometimes chaotic crime scenes are staged crime scenes as well. And then the absence of things that crime scenes can also be very telling, so. It's sometimes it's what's not there that's important.
30:55 Speaker 00 Yep.
30:55 Speaker 01 And then the disarray as well can also be quite telling. So I know that, you know, FBI would say that you, you know, you studied the, the work of the artist, which is their crime scene to try and understand them. But I think the crime scene gives us very good insights into one, how the crime has occurred and then why things may or may not be there that should be there or have been removed from a scene. So it really looks at, you know, three stages, the before the crime.
31:28 Speaker 00 Yep.
31:28 Speaker 01 During the crime and then after the crime. And that can give us valuable information across those three. And then together you form, whether it's a profile or, you know, a working theory around the offender and how that occurred.
31:40 Speaker 00 Break down the example, or give examples for those three breakdowns.
31:44 Speaker 01 Well, so if we go back to the, the Jesse Kimson case.
31:47 Speaker 00 Yep.
31:47 Speaker 01 So it's been quite well publicised that he met Grace Mullane and then they went out for dinner and then they went back to his hotel room. Something transpired there, which resulted in, in Grace's death.
32:02 Speaker 00 Yep.
32:02 Speaker 01 Um, it certainly seems like it was probably unlikely that, that there was any intention to kill her. But then when we look at post-crime.
32:13 Speaker 00 Hmm.
32:13 Speaker 01 We see that he was very methodical after the offence and there was a lot of clean up, there was a lot of stages. It's been well documented around him. He moved her body, uh, went and buried the body, uh, cleaned the scene and there was a quite a calmness, uh, in the chaos at the time.
32:34 Speaker 00 Yeah.
32:34 Speaker 01 And that, that's rather unusual. You know, we think about someone trying to recover from a, you know, a horrific event. There's a lot, a lot of anxiety and panic and concern. It's unusual to be quite methodical and calm.
32:48 Speaker 00 Hmm. Oh, very much so. And that, that was something I always look to exploit, that mistakes are made after the, the murder has occurred or the crime has occurred. Little things like um if a murder weapon has been introduced to the crime scene, if someone's bought, if it's uh yeah, a murder's happened in the house and it's the kitchen knife from the kitchen bench that's been used as a murder weapon, that tells me it wasn't intent at the time, they're going there, something escalated, something has happened at the time, so not the planning. And uh these are the type of things you look for as a forensic psychologist?
33:23 Speaker 01 Yeah, definitely. You know how prepared and planned was someone prior to the crime? And and again, going back to, is there evidence of cleanup? And have have items been taken away from the scene? Whether it's it's weapons or belongings of the of the victim? Has the body been moved? Um if the body is there, you know, is is there a quite a bit of forensic evidence that still remains? You know, often we think loosely as a rule of thumb, you know, the the the less evidence that's at the scene and the more that has been removed, we're talking about a planned and prepared offender. Go back to the classic FBI organized, disorganized profile, which which looked at, that the organized fellows tend to, you know, come to the scene prepared and take things away and leave limited
34:08 Speaker 01 forensic evidence. The disorganized often, there's a lot of forensic evidence, things are in disarray, there can be a scrambled attempt to cover the crime up and make it look like something else.
34:19 Speaker 00 Well, I I I take a lot away from the way the bodies are disposed of too. And you you can almost see the panic in the way some bodies are disposed of, or you can see the planning in in the time. So that's that's all very telling, isn't it?
34:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, so some of them are quite superficially disposed of essentially. It's the first opportunity or they're buried very.
34:38 Speaker 00 Basically, get this body away from me.
34:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, and then others are, you know, take much longer, much more time.
34:44 Speaker 00 Yeah. Without going into methodology, is this the type of thing you sit down with police, the New Zealand police, where like they'll come to you, there's been a crime, a body's been found, they contact you and this is how you work work with the police?
34:57 Speaker 01 Yes, yeah, absolutely. So it could be in a variety of stages. It could be the homicide's just happened and we're trying to understand the crime scene and the behaviour that's happened and insights into the offender. Uh it could be that we're four weeks on and things have hit a wall and leads have run dry and we'll review the crime and look at trying to generate new lines of inquiry.
35:20 Speaker 00 Right.
35:22 Speaker 00 We spoke in part one about serial killers or the demise of serial killers, which is a pretty good way of saying that. That's good if they're reducing that. Serial sex offenders, but, um, yeah, I've worked serial sex crimes. Have they reduced like serial killings? The same things that are reducing serial murderers, reducing serial sex offenders, or is it still?
35:48 Speaker 01 Yeah, the big one would be our intruder rapists.
35:50 Speaker 00 Yeah.
35:50 Speaker 01 And it is rare for us to get a series of those these days. I think that's true across Australia and New Zealand. We would still get lots of touching based offences towards strangers, you know, bus stops, uh, those sorts of public, public areas, but the, the, you know, the rapist that's targeting strangers or going into homes is, it's much less common. Uh, that doesn't mean that they don't happen, those offences, but it's rare that they are a series now. They're often caught much quicker. And again, that's because of all the improvements in technology that we have.
36:24 Speaker 00 And just the sharing of information too. I think that's a big part because before we would often be looking for an offender that's got a certain type of characteristic about, characteristics about the way he commits a crime. Someone else in the neighbouring L A C might be doing the same thing. And in the old days, it wasn't a case that we'd be sharing the information, but, uh, we've, we've woken up to, woken up to that now.
36:47 Speaker 01 And see, New Zealand runs ViClass, which
36:50 Speaker 00 Yep.
36:50 Speaker 01 catalogues all the stranger sex offences across the country. So the, our behavioural science unit is, is keeping a data log
37:00 Speaker 00 Yep.
37:00 Speaker 01 of, you know, over a decade and more of all the stranger sex crimes. So if we do have something that comes up, we're able to draw on, you know, more than eight to nine thousand cases and look at what we know about something of a similar nature with a similar type of offending pattern.
37:16 Speaker 00 Right.
37:17 Speaker 01 And of course, if we do get something, we could also look back at whether it is linked to any other crimes as well.
37:22 Speaker 00 Okay, um. Again, excuse me from jumping from point to point, but I'm finding the whole chat very interesting. Um, mental health, what part does that play? And I've got some stats here that I pulled out of your book, so I'm hoping they're correct. But seventeen and fifty percent alone actors are suffering from a mental illness at the time of offending. Two thirds of perpetrators experiencing mental health concerns in the period leading up to their attack. So, look, regardless of the specifics of the stats, it's saying that mental health is a big thing in lone actors. What, what type of mental health issues are we looking at there?
38:01 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, it's the catch twenty two, isn't it, in many ways of mental health, because again, it's on a spectrum.
38:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
38:07 Speaker 01 And it can be all the way from psychotic based presentations where someone has completely lost touch with reality and they are, they are unaware and they don't have sound mind with what they're doing. And it seems as though uh, that is a good example of the, the Bondi junction with attack with Joel Cautier, that he was schizophrenic for a long period of time and psychotic at the time.
38:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, how, how much do you know about that particular case?
38:35 Speaker 01 Well, I think it's still emerging. I know, I know there was the recent inquiry and the results haven't been published, but the psychotic aspect and, and his long term schizophrenic diagnosis seems to be quite central.
38:47 Speaker 00 And I, I think it's already been mentioned in the public and would have been mentioned at the inquest, but the parents had concerns about him with his fascination with knives and, and different things.
38:58 Speaker 01 Yeah, and, and that's where mental health is tricky because there, there are so many people with mental health difficulties or mental illness or psychosis or schizophrenia that are never violent. So that is quite important to put into context. But you have to add layers to the mental health that then add to the potential then to be violent. So, yeah, the various issues with grievances in life, very, very, very much violent interests or things like that can then be exacerbators for the mental illness. But then we can also have things like depression that can be a catalyst for then developing a grievance and a fixation.
39:40 Speaker 01 And that can then perpetuate and grow from there. So I think mental health can be a causal factor or an indirect factor as well. And sometimes as well, we also say that there's, you know, subclinical things that are not really at the the diagnostic threshold, which drive behaviour, you know, it might be that someone really struggles with shame and envy of others and it's very likely to get quite jealous and they've got a personality that that makes them prone to collecting grievances or feeling like they've been wronged and that then walks them down that path to violence.
40:15 Speaker 00 It's sitting here talking to you, I'm getting an appreciation of how complicated it is. Oh shit. Well, if you see Sarah, you'll at the conference apologize to her. I expected too much from her. There is so many, there's so many layers and and variables, isn't it? So I can see why you you you try to structure things as best you can. It's not foolproof. But yeah, here's some indicators. This is might be the way we prevent this.
40:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think we need to be careful that as psychologists, we're not always trying to come up with an explanation to overcomplicate it. But loosely, I always go how how dialed up or are the dials for the person? So how intense are things? Then we can also think about how frequent is the symptoms or the traits? And then what's the severity of it as well? So we we'd need to look at it through frameworks that make it understandable.
41:05 Speaker 00 And and a framework makes it as understandable as best you can hope for.
41:12 Speaker 00 Leading into um the use of A I. Do you see that as as something that's going to be very much in the forefront of um criminal investigation?
41:21 Speaker 01 It's hard. I mean, in terms of the the mass casualty space, we've already seen over in the U S that people have had A I write plans around how to carry out a mass casualty attack for them.
41:32 Speaker 00 I was thinking from the good guys. You're looking from the bad guys.
41:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, offender capability enhancement aspect. And we know that that's happening already. Um. What it means for police investigations, it it's really hard to say. It it'll make some of the more boring tasks of writing up things easier, but. You know, facial recognition and those sorts of things, I think will will transform as well. So it's hard to anticipate where it will go.
41:58 Speaker 00 I I'm thinking like Vi Class that you you talk about, like if you had a an A I component assessing the all the information that might uh make it even more readily available.
42:08 Speaker 01 I think the ability to analyze mass amounts of data or information will greatly improve, but it will still require, you know, the human analyst to to develop the right meaning and interpretation of that.
42:23 Speaker 00 Um, I'm looking at getting back to and prevention is, yeah, the key of of hopefully what uh what you're achieving. And I've got a couple of headings here, but uh fixated threat assessments, fixated persons, unit need for information sharing. So three three main points. So if we're talking about preventing these type of uh lone actor attacks, breaking down those uh those three headings, like uh fixated threat assessments, how do they play play a part? And I know we've touched on it, but just breaking it down again.
42:55 Speaker 01 So fixated threat assessments really are police and mental health specialists working together to make decisions about a person of concern.
43:06 Speaker 00 Okay.
43:07 Speaker 01 That that starts by information coming in about a person and then doing a screening judgment to look at, okay, do we need to be concerned about this based on the information? Do we need to dig more? We might find that once we dig that it is concerning, then you would go through the process of doing a more rigorous assessment. Then you might look to engage with the person to understand things further. And then if you're still concerned, then it would be going, okay, let's put some wraparound support towards the person. And then you'd monitor, you'd review, and if it's still not improving, that might be then when there's more uh targeted responses that could emerge.
43:48 Speaker 00 It it's a multi-agency approach then, isn't it? It's very much, it's not not just the police, it's mental health, the health system, all sorts of uh things.
43:57 Speaker 01 Yeah, and and in this space, we've realised that it is multi-agency.
44:01 Speaker 00 Um.
44:02 Speaker 01 That we need to be very careful of silos of information being held and locked down and not being shared. Uh, Manhuram Monus was probably a good example of that, that information needs to flow to the right people. And then those reviews and those assessments then need to go back to other people in return. So we we can't be locking down on things. We need to be very mindful of, you know, gaps in practice where we don't have knowledge. Disconnects between agencies as well. And I'd probably also say that a couple of other things around bunkers. So, you know, not just doing an assessment on someone and going, oh, you know, look, that low concern. We'll just put the paperwork in the file and we're done with that. And two weeks later,
44:47 Speaker 01 there's an incident. So we can't necessarily be reassured by the fact that we've done an assessment and go, okay, we can wash our hands of that. And then the last one really is myopia, where where we simply lose focus because we're looking at this too much. Or we're not getting an outside perspective. So we're too much group think or whatever it might be where it causes us just to not to see that this is, this has changed. And probably, I think in the lone actor space, the the myopia aspect is where we may come undone again in the future because we're seeing more and more young people now presenting with risk factors and concerning behaviours that if someone had said that to you a decade ago,
45:31 Speaker 01 you'd be, you would have been horrified and you would have hit the panic button. Now that our tolerance for that.
45:37 Speaker 00 We've become desensitised to it.
45:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
45:39 Speaker 00 Yeah.
45:40 Speaker 01 So, you know, people with very violent ideations and purchasing of weapons and engagement in quite extreme gore and extremist material that are very young. Uh, it's become commonplace is not the right word, but in in the work that we do, it's a little bit more commonplace now that that is the type of person of concern that you're seeing. And the the worry then is that.
46:05 Speaker 01 We go, okay, we're so used to that now and we've seen so many of them that don't do anything. But we need to be very rigorous and understand that that could change and that could escalate.
46:18 Speaker 00 I could see people dropping their guard down because we've seen this and there's a hundred people that are like that. Why are we worried about this person? But that could be the one, one person.
46:28 Speaker 01 Yes, and I think in Australia as well, you know, we had a good, probably wake up call last, last year in twenty twenty four. So obviously we had the Bondi Junction attack, which was, which was sort of separate in some ways. But then there was the, the Good Shepherd Church. Um, a couple of weeks later, there was a, a young sixteen year old over in Western Australia that stabbed someone at Bunnings and then was killed by police.
46:53 Speaker 00 Yep.
46:53 Speaker 01 And then about six or seven weeks later, uh, it was either, was it Parramatta or Newcastle? I can't remember, a young person with a GoPro tactical vest.
47:02 Speaker 00 Yeah.
47:03 Speaker 01 Walked in with, with a couple of knives into a politician's office. And fortunately they didn't go through with the attack, but you know, within that space of two months, that potentially could have been, you know, four very serious mass casualty attacks.
47:17 Speaker 00 Um, young males in, involved in it too. What, what is the reason so many young males seem to be the, the ones that, uh, do those things that can be, um, influenced?
47:29 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's, it's, it is very concerning and I think there's been a lot spoken about men and masculinity and where are men at, at the, at the moment? Uh, a lot of them are, are searching for identity and their, their place in society and for men, when they're struggling and can't find a way to connect or can't have an intimate relationship or are unsure how to cope with their mental health.
47:56 Speaker 00 Hmm.
47:57 Speaker 01 They're not, they don't know how to communicate. It, it can take a troubling turn. And there's a lot of work, I think, for men to, to do and to find pro-social outlets to, you know, express their challenges in, in the right way because it's easy to turn to, to blame and frustration and also believe that, you know, others are, others are responsible for what's happening to you, for your shortcomings and, and difficulties. So I think there's, there's so much that we need to be doing with, with men to help them im- improve. How they handle stresses and problems in their life.
48:33 Speaker 00 Well, I I think it's in in the nature of men that they internalise too. And not creating an environment where they can express their feelings and yeah. I I think most men understand this. If you're going through an issue and your mate says, how are you going, you say, good. And that's, oh, that's good, mate. I was worried about you. And then you move on from the conversation. Where if it's, and this is, you know, um, probably been been too harsh. A a a comparison and then with females, it might be, they talk, they they, I can put my hand up, I know. My partners know more about my my friendships and life than I do. Like, they'll go, oh, your best mate's just had a baby.
49:14 Speaker 00 Did he? Who told you that? Oh, Susan told me that or some something like that. So we we need to communicate a little bit better, don't we?
49:21 Speaker 01 Males, unfortunately, they disproportionately make up the statistics for suicide.
49:27 Speaker 00 Yeah.
49:27 Speaker 01 And they disproportionately make up the statistics for violent offences.
49:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's not uh not good. With uh with the work that you're doing with uh New Zealand Police, uh can you see down down the track? Where more attention will be given to the type of work that you do, because quite frankly, listening to you uh talk about your risk assessments and and different things, there is so much work to do. Are we properly? I I think policing, and you don't have to comment because you're still employed by police. But I thought we fell behind in the forensic science field in that with DNA and all that, we didn't have the capability of properly examining a crime scene. We didn't properly resource it. With intel, probably not properly resourced. In your field, forensic psychology, do you think uh police are starting to understand the benefits as a whole?
50:17 Speaker 01 Well, look, I've I've got very complimentary things to say about New Zealand Police.
50:21 Speaker 00 So you're clever, see? Yeah, that's why you're employed.
50:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, not because they're my employer, but um look, I think New Zealand's running a really good model, which is is very positive for. Bringing expertise in. So they have a fixated threat assessment centre over there as well, which, but that's purely for politicians. So politicians that are subject to threats and and being targeted. But we have our behavioural science unit, which is very much brings specialists in for operational support. So the model over there is really strong and there's a recognition that for major crimes, the input of experts or specialists uh i- is really one of the the tools that we need to to solving these.
51:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
51:05 Speaker 01 In Australia, unfortunately, it has fallen, by the way, so we had that, but many of the units have closed down.
51:12 Speaker 00 Fixated persons unit that uh in my experience notoriously under under resource. But it was something of need that we just didn't have it. We had intel officers attached to, you know, major crime squads and and that, but we really needed someone with the expertise for specifically um fixated persons and being able to assess them properly.
51:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah. And I I look, I think it will will come back again because sometimes as in policing, it's money and resources that that dictate where things go. And look, Victoria, um New South Wales, I think Western Australia, they all had specialist operational psychology arms to them. Uh it's only Queensland Police now that that still have it that I'm aware of.
51:56 Speaker 00 How do we go backwards in a progressive field?
51:58 Speaker 01 It is, it's, yeah, because I look over in the UK, they have behavioural investigative advisers over there. So they've got specialists that that are recognised and they've done some some great work.
52:11 Speaker 00 Yep.
52:11 Speaker 01 Um over in Canada, Royal Canadian Mounted Police, they've got a a specialist behavioural unit as well. That's a mixture of psychologists and psychiatrists um providing operational support. FBI have four dedicated units towards um bringing specialty expertise in. And then you look in across all the different US states, they've got specialised threat teams and things. So. Look, it it is the model for dealing with, you know, challenging and difficult cases in policing.
52:44 Speaker 00 And UK and Canada, I've I've worked in both those areas, uh uh in policing inquiries from New South Wales. And and they're set up very similar to um what we've got uh here in Australia. New Zealand's the same and they're all moving forward with it and we're moving backwards.
53:00 Speaker 01 Yeah, one of the things that's interesting with New Zealand is it it is a small place, but there's one police service for the country.
53:07 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:07 Speaker 01 So it's just one national unit and obviously, you know, Australia has some of the challenges on a smaller scale to the US with the states at the federal level and when it's one unit, you or one one force for the for a country, then you can be a little bit more uh.
53:24 Speaker 00 United.
53:25 Speaker 01 Focus with what you're doing and.
53:27 Speaker 00 Oh, look, we're uh we're not too bad in this country compared to America. We had someone, I forget who it was, that uh his first um assignment as a police officer. Uh there was twelve people in the police force, this was in America, and he had to buy his own gun. But uh uh that was uh it was uh I remember who it was, it was uh Steve Murphy from uh the Netflix uh Narcos.
53:48 Speaker 01 Oh, yes.
53:49 Speaker 00 Uh the series that took down Pablo Escobar.
53:51 Speaker 01 Wow.
53:51 Speaker 00 And that was his uh his first uh.
53:53 Speaker 01 Gosh.
53:54 Speaker 00 First police force. Um one of the other points, and we talked on fixated persons unit, the the fixated threat assessments, need for information sharing, we talked about within uh organisations, government organisations, law enforcement agencies. But what about the public? What part can the public play in the role of uh making sure we identify these uh lone actors?
54:15 Speaker 01 Yeah, it's some ways it's the bystander challenges that we have with with crime, that that people are aware of something happening. But for whatever reason, it might be their own self doubt, it might be that they minimise it.
54:27 Speaker 00 Yep.
54:28 Speaker 01 But they they don't always report really valuable information and ultimately, you know, preventing lone actor attacks or mass casualty events is this. It's about information flowing from members of the community through to police, so that police are then able to to look over it, assess it and make sense of that information.
54:46 Speaker 00 Yeah.
54:46 Speaker 01 And a a lot of policing is about information gathering and and the public are a crucial part of that. So whether it is anything from.
54:56 Speaker 01 You know, unusual activities such as suddenly being interested in firearms or trying to collect knives and also at the same time they might be saying that they're very angry with someone or they've got a particular problem with this person or an organisation, all the way through to, you know, knowing maybe that your child is viewing some problematic and unhealthy content. So may not be always going to the police, but of course it's important that that information is shared with someone. It might be a school councillor, but sharing the information so that it's not siloed and not pocketed and allowing some other eyeballs to get across that, to make more informed judgements about then, and then if it needs
55:38 Speaker 01 to be escalated and passed on, then hopefully it does get to the police.
55:42 Speaker 00 Well, we do need to share that because quite often when you hear of an incident and then, yeah, the media have done their bit and everyone's talking about, oh, that person was always strange. He was strange ever since that he went to kindergarten. All these people come out and identify with that. That's the type of information that we've got to, got to get across.
56:02 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely.
56:03 Speaker 00 Because it's, yeah, share, sharing that information. We touched on, on the media and the copycat type situation and also about the media giving too high a profile to the people that carry out these crimes. I've thought for a long time and it's hard because there's an inquiry in mind. People want to find out and there's a benefit by putting the name out because if it's, you know, someone, man, monus, other people might come forward and say, well, he did this and did that. So you find out more information about it. But you don't want them to be put up there on a pedestal. What, what way do you think the media should treat someone like what happened in Christchurch?
56:42 Speaker 01 I think uniform policies would be ideal.
56:45 Speaker 00 So they're not competing against each other?
56:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, especially across the trans Tasman. I think we could get uniform policies that would be achievable where we need to make a decision around what we will and won't publish. Now, New Zealand made a really interesting decision to not publish Terence's name. He was. He is and will be forever known as the terrorist.
57:09 Speaker 00 Yeah.
57:09 Speaker 01 So he wasn't named in New Zealand, obviously it's very different within Australia. But that certainly, I think, took the sting out of it and the power of his actions in that he didn't receive the notoriety and it was very much victim lens focused. And that is important, the narratives and the survival stories of victims is it's probably what we want to come out of these attacks rather than it being about the perpetrator. Now, that's tricky because talking about the perpetrator does, as you say, serves some purposes where there's an understanding that we do need and it generates more information.
57:50 Speaker 01 But we don't want to sensationalise that and that, that's a tricky point, but I think if we make it heavily victim focused with basic details about the person rather than writing at length about their motivations or their ideology.
58:05 Speaker 00 Yeah.
58:06 Speaker 01 Then that's a nice balance point.
58:09 Speaker 00 We might, we might finish up here. I reckon we could talk all day. I just, you're a wealth of knowledge and you've taken me back into a world that make me appreciate how complicated is what you're doing. You're over here in Australia, you're talking at some conferences?
58:26 Speaker 01 Yes, I'm at the New South Wales Correction Conference, which is on and also we're also running a stalking symposium with a host of guests in Melbourne as well.
58:36 Speaker 00 Right. You work with corrective services, I haven't really touched on that, but what can you learn from people in prison?
58:44 Speaker 01 Oh, an enormous amount. I mean, we have individuals that are there for lengthy stints in custody and there's always the temptation to go, let's just lock them up, forget about them and not go and talk to them. And by talking to them and engaging with them, first of all, we gain a rich amount of insight from their stories and their motivations and their reasons and their pathways to carrying out their act of violence. We then can then improve our responses by learning about that. Now, the other side of course is rehabilitating them as well.
59:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
59:21 Speaker 01 Do we want to put the time and resources into them? And I think it's somewhat negligent if we don't go through the process of at least trying and certainly in the lone actor space, we've seen. Where some things have gone wrong for various reasons that people have been held on remand for long periods and they haven't had treatment. And then they've come out and they've committed a a mass attack. So that that's a whole different landscape, but probably my key takeaway is that we shouldn't just lock people up and forget that they're there. There's there's a lot of value for various reasons to to engage with them.
59:56 Speaker 00 No, that that makes sense. Can we de-radicalise people, like young people that are, it doesn't have to be age based, but can you de-radicalise someone with the proper, proper work, you think?
1:00:09 Speaker 01 De-radicalisation is an interesting one. It's topical and controversial. The UK has probably had the the most challenging implications of that. So there was there was big efforts to de-radicalise people in the UK and a lot of the de-radicalisation programmes were emerged from there and they made their way over to Australia and New Zealand. We've kind of learnt that de-radicalisation programmes don't work.
1:00:38 Speaker 00 Right.
1:00:38 Speaker 01 But part of that is they were brought out during a time when it was all Islamic inspired violence or jihadi inspired violence. Couple of years later, it had evolved and then it was right wing violence and then it was grievance based violence. So the the fundamentals of a lot of the the de-radicalisation process assume that it was just ideology that was causing violence, when actually maybe ideology was only the top layer of the problem and it didn't get to the core reasons that the person was was becoming violent. So I think we need to take a few steps back and and ask the questions of really around, you know, why was violence a solution for this person? How did they start on the pathway to violence?
1:01:21 Speaker 01 So try and get to some of the core things rather than going, okay, they just need to de-radicalise and change these unhealthy and problematic beliefs.
1:01:32 Speaker 00 Well, you haven't disappointed me because like every psychologist I speak to, there's always an if or but or maybe. But yeah, I bring it back to Sarah. She would always, yeah, that might be the case, but it could be this. And I just, can you give me a yes or no? No, I can't give you a yes or no. But I like the way your mind thinks and the work you're doing. And I think it's important work and I thank you so much for taking time out of your busy schedule to come into the studio and talk to us today. And I thoroughly recommend your book, Mass Casually, The Rise of Loan Actors. So interesting read. Where can people get it if they want it?
1:02:13 Speaker 01 So it's available obviously on Amazon and online bookstores. It'll be Barnes and Noble overseas and shortly in bookstores here. And also on the publisher's website, groundproofforensics.com.
1:02:28 Speaker 00 Very good. If people want to get in contact with you and you don't have to answer this because you might get inundated, but if people wanted to reach out to you, how could they reach out there?
1:02:37 Speaker 01 So I do private consulting work, so drnathanbrooks.com as well.
1:02:42 Speaker 00 Okay. Thanks very much for coming on. I've enjoyed the chat.
1:02:46 Speaker 01 Thanks for having me, Gary.
1:02:47 Speaker 00 Cheers.
Previous Psychopaths, murder and unmasking incels: Dr Nathan Brooks Pt.1 Next Partner to predator, my sovereign citizen ex: Scott Murrin Pt.1 Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated