
Summary
Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.
This episode explores how Jesse Merrill built Good Culture into a half-a-billion-dollar cottage cheese brand by combining a background in disruptive marketing with a personal health scare. After early career stints working in film production for Jonathan Demme and Spike Jonze, Merrill moved into experiential marketing, working on campaigns for brands like KY, Amstel Light, and Moby's tea brand Teeny, before becoming director of marketing at Honest Tea. Diagnosed with ulcerative colitis in 2015, Merrill shifted to an autoimmune paleo diet that eliminated additives and changed how he thought about food. Spotting that traditional cottage cheese was slimy, loaded with additives, and declining in popularity despite high protein and low sugar profiles, he launched Good Culture with simple, clean-label ingredients.
The guest and host explain how the brand survived early struggles—such as tight 45-day expiration dates and the pressure to meet eight to ten weekly unit sales per store—by leaning on aggressive in-store sampling and store-level monitoring. They discuss how a 2023 viral TikTok video by health influencer Laney Kate showing a high-protein ice cream hack caused sales to skyrocket and introduced Gen Z to the product. Reaching $200 million in revenue by 2025, the company partnered with L Catterton in 2026 to secure majority backing, navigating supply chain bottlenecks to capture exploding national demand.
- Address consumer confusion directly by updating packaging elements like adding clear visual representations of the product on the front of the pack. 52:07
- Rely heavily on targeted in-store sampling during early retail launches to educate shoppers and drive initial velocity thresholds.
- Keep products clean-label by avoiding added starches and chemical preservatives despite the manufacturing complexities they introduce. 43:45
Chapters
- 0:03Podcast Intro and Host Greeting
Guy Raz introduces the episode and sets the stage for Jesse Merrill’s story.
- 0:56Guy Raz’s Opening Monologue
Guy Raz outlines the episode’s focus on Jesse’s transition from film to food and the growth of Good Culture.
- 1:27Jesse’s Film Career and Shift to Marketing
Jesse recounts his early work in film, moving to LA, and discovering brand‑ambassador gigs.
- 2:38Working with Moby and Honesty Tea
Jesse details his roles at Moby’s tea brand and later at Honest Tea, building distribution and brand awareness.
- 3:15Personal Health Crisis Sparks Idea
Diagnosed with ulcerative colitis, Jesse’s health journey inspires him to rethink cottage cheese as a functional food.
- 4:01Conceptualizing Good Culture
He outlines the vision for Good Culture: clean‑label, high‑protein cottage cheese framed as a modern superfood.
- 5:03Product Development and Manufacturing Challenges
Jesse describes kitchen experiments, sourcing a co‑packer, and overcoming technical hurdles to create the final product.
- 6:24Launch at Expo West and Retail Partnerships
The brand debuts at Expo West, gains retailer interest, and secures initial distribution with Whole Foods and Sprouts.
- 9:59Scaling, Funding, and Company Growth
Good Culture expands, attracts investment, and reaches $200 million in sales before being valued at half a billion.
- 34:19First Sampling Jobs and Skill Development
He explains how sampling roles taught him grassroots marketing and led to larger opportunities.
- 50:42Strategic Marketing for Shelf Survival
Jesse discusses the need to hit velocity thresholds to keep shelf space at Whole Foods and Sprouts.
- 52:48Overcoming Consumer Confusion
The brand tackled the mislabeling issue by redesigning packaging and adding clear visuals.
Highlights
- 0:02
Managing full reclamation and shelf lifestrategy
The guest shares the intense stress of managing Whole Foods distribution under full reclamation rules and a 45-day shelf life, requiring active clearing of shelves to avoid spoilage.
- 6:21
Transition from film to samplingstory
The guest describes working as an office production assistant for directors like Spike Jonze on Jackass before transitioning to contract brand ambassador jobs handing out samples of KY lubricant.
- 12:09
Marketing Moby's tea brandstrategy
The guest explains how working for musician Moby on the launch of Teeny served as a crash course in brand building, focusing on lifestyle destination marketing and alternative distribution.
- 28:01
Ulcerative colitis and diet changestory
After experiencing severe symptoms and dropping twenty pounds, the guest was diagnosed with ulcerative colitis and successfully managed the autoimmune condition by shifting to an autoimmune paleo diet.
- 43:40
Manufacturing organic clean-label cottage cheeseinsight
The guest details the difficulty of finding a co-packer willing to produce an organic, single-serve, clean-label cottage cheese without added gums or chemical preservatives.
- 1:03:35
Viral TikTok ice cream hackdata
The guest discusses how a viral TikTok video by health influencer Laney Kate featuring a high-protein ice cream made with Good Culture caused sales to skyrocket overnight.
Quotes
“It was very hard. It was incredibly stressful for me.”
Unnamed speaker · 56:11 “I was monitoring as many stores as I could.”
Unnamed speaker · 0:21 “I started to feel higher levels of energy, more mental clarity, more strength, bloating went away.”
Unnamed speaker · 33:50 “We were launching as an organic only product. And we were launching a clean label product.”
Unnamed speaker · 43:40 “We were in a category where, you know, the shoppers had their blinders on. They were buying the same thing they had been buying for decades.”
Unnamed speaker · 51:39 “We actually, we added an illustration of a bowl of cottage cheese, which we didn't have in the first packaging iteration. There was no visual at all.”
Unnamed speaker · 52:30 “We were seeding influencers. We were building our presence on social media. We were getting a lot more PR.”
Unnamed speaker · 59:47 “We were in a disproportionate amount of the content that followed.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:07:47 “I think it's a little bit of both. But in my case, I think it was more about grit and hard work and perseverance.”
Unnamed speaker · 1:16:31
Sponsored segments
- AMEX Corporate 1:23–1:50
- TikTok 1:54–2:34
- Odoo 2:38–3:11
- TikTok 34:19–34:59
- Firefox 35:03–35:39
- Progressive 35:43–36:10
- Progressive 57:03–58:30
- TikTok 1:19:14–1:19:54
- Progressive 1:19:57–1:20:54
About this episode
Jesse Merrill wanted to make movies. Instead, he made cottage cheese cool—and built a business with more than $200 million in annual sales. Jesse got his start fetching coffee on the set of Jackass and handing out product samples for extra cash. After helping build Moby’s tea brand and grow Honest Tea, he teamed up with cofounder Anders Eisner to reinvent cottage cheese. But Good Culture got off to a rocky start. The first batch came out soupy. Shoppers mistook it for yogurt. And Jesse had just 30 days to sell his inventory at Whole Foods or risk paying for what didn't sell. Then a cottage cheese ice cream recipe went viral on TikTok, introducing millions of people to a food they'd long overlooked. What You’ll Learn How Jesse's early marketing gigs prepared him to build a consumer brand Why he bet on a category with aging customers and declining sales How Good Culture's early packaging confused shoppers How Jesse tackled a manufacturing crisis as demand soared What he looked for in an investment partner to help Good Culture scale Production Credits How I Built This is produced by Podcast Pointman and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Follow How I Built This: YouTube → @HowIBuiltThis Instagram → @howibuiltthis X → @HowIBuiltThis Facebook → How I Built This Follow Guy Raz: Instagram → @guy.raz X → @guyraz Substack → guyraz.substack.com Website → guyraz.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
14,243 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
Topics
- Good Culture
- Whole Foods
- Honest Tea
- Teeny
- Activate
- Amstel Light
- Sprouts
- Expo West
- Coca‑Cola
- Vitamin Water
Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated