Skip to content

Bonus: “Messy Tales,” an Excerpt from the Prof’s book, Been There, Done That

History That Doesn't Suck

Hosted by Greg Jackson

34m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

Greg Jackson reads the introductory chapter of his new book, Been There, Done That: How Our History Shows What We Can Overcome, published by Simon & Schuster on June 16, 2026. He explains that the book grew from a growing sense of despondency he noticed in classrooms and on tour, where people kept asking how long America has left. The book covers eight chapters from the early republic to the cusp of the 20th century, arguing that today's challenges—fake news, contested elections, political violence—have direct historical parallels.

The chapter's central story is Ben Franklin's 1782 fabrication: after accidentally handing over private negotiation notes to British commissioner Richard Oswald, Franklin printed a fake "supplement to the Boston Independent Chronicle" at his Paris press, complete with invented atrocity stories and a forged letter from John Paul Jones, to shift public opinion in America's favor during peace talks. The supplement was republished in British newspapers.

Jackson makes two core claims: that cries of unprecedented times are overstated, and that reports of the republic's impending death have been greatly exaggerated. He frames the book around "a duality of admiration amid imperfection," arguing that patriotism and confronting historical failures are complementary rather than contradictory.

  • Ben Franklin printed a fake newspaper in 1782 to influence peace negotiations with Britain, demonstrating that disinformation is not a modern phenomenon. 9:23
  • The book argues that today's political challenges—fake news, contested elections, political violence—have direct parallels in the early republic and 19th century. 22:14
  • Jackson defines fake news as intentionally false stories packaged to look like news, distinguishing it from mere error or bias. 30:23
  • The book deliberately excludes the Civil War, arguing it was too catastrophic to be compared to present-day challenges. 23:43
  • The book's framing is that love of country and facing its darkest moments are complementary, not contradictory. 31:31

Highlights

  • 9:23

    Franklin's Diplomatic Blunder in Parisstory

    On April 18, 1782, Ben Franklin accidentally handed private negotiation notes to British commissioner Richard Oswald at the Hôtel de Muscovie in Paris. The notes referenced patriot seizures of loyalist property, which would damage the American cause.

  • 13:35

    Fighting Paper With Paperstrategy

    Franklin decided to counter his mistake by printing a fake newspaper supplement at his private press in Passy, France, using his decades of typesetting skill to create a convincing forgery.

  • 15:08

    The Fabricated Atrocity Listdata

    The fake supplement included a letter itemizing "43 scalps of Congress soldiers, several hundred scalps of farmers, 88 scalps of women, 193 boys' scalps, 211 girls' scalps, and even 29 little infant scalps." The entire story was pure fiction.

  • 19:33

    Founding Father Spreads Disinformationinsight

    Jackson reveals that Franklin mailed the fake supplement to colleagues with a wink, and it was republished in British newspapers. He calls it "an astounding act of founding fake news" made while the American experiment verged on collapse.

  • 22:14

    Two Core Arguments of the Bookstrategy

    Jackson states his two main claims: today's cries of unprecedented times range from grossly overstated to simply not true, and reports of the United States' impending death have been greatly exaggerated.

  • 23:43

    Historical Parallels to Present Challengesdata

    Jackson lists specific 19th-century parallels: the mudslinging election of 1828, the corrupt election of 1876, the deadly Louisiana elections of 1872, the Preston Brooks–Charles Sumner caning, and the Baltimore riots of 1812.

  • 31:31

    Duality of Admiration Amid Imperfectioninsight

    Jackson argues that love of country and facing the bleakest moments of history go hand in hand, following the founders' own admission of a "more perfect" rather than "perfect" union.

About this episode

Been There, Done That: How Our History Shows What We Can Overcome, Prof. Jackson’s new book publishing June 16th, takes us on a chronological journey—from the very start of the republic in 1789, through the end of the nineteenth century—while telling stories not heard in the podcast, tales that engage such topics as political violence, fake news, and contested elections. Pre-order a copy ⁠HERE https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Been-There-Done-That/Greg-Jackson/9781668062609⁠ or come see him on ON TOUR. https://www.htdspodcast.com/live-shows

Transcript

0:00
34:37

5,336 words · 1 speaker

Speaker names marked are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.

Topics

  • American Political History
  • Disinformation
  • Founding Era
  • Constitutional Republic
  • Liberal Democracy
  • Historical Parallels
  • Ben Franklin
  • Political Violence

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated