Pod Insights Handsome Pretty Little Episode #68 About this episode Tig and Mae gab about age gaps, muse on how to know if someone is "the one," and give advice on connecting with wayward youths in a jam-packed Pretty Little Episode!
Handsome is hosted by Tig Notaro, Mae Martin, and Fortune FeimsterSubmit your questions to speakpipe.com/handsomepod http://speakpipe.com/handsomepodFollow us on social media @handsomepodMerch at handsomepod.com http://handsomepod.com/Watch Handsome on YouTube http://youtube.com/@handsomepodThis is a Headgum https://headgum.com/ podcast. Follow Headgum on Twitter https://x.com/headgum, Instagram https://www.instagram.com/headgum/, and Tiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@headgum. Advertise on Handsome https://gumball.fm/shows/handsome via Gumball.fm http://gumball.fm/. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Mae Martin? Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance. Not checking whether I brought my sunglasses before driving west at the end of the day? A learning moment. I'm gaining confidence in my driving, but it helps when I'm not blinded by the sun beaming directly into my eyeballs.
0:13 Tig Notaro? Yeah, checking first is handsome, so check Allstate first for an auto quote. It could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate. Potential savings vary, subject to terms, conditions, and availability. Allstate North American Insurance Company and Affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.
0:30 Mae Martin? Handsome is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online with a handy handsome website you can be proud of and show off to all your friends, clients, and loved ones. With Squarespace, you can scale up your business, claim your domain, and showcase your offerings with a premium professional website. With Squarespace's cutting-edge design tools, you can build a gorgeous online presence that perfectly fits your brand or business. Their SEO tools help your ideal audience find you. Since every dream needs a domain, Squarespace makes it easy to find the best name for your business at one fair, all-inclusive price. No hidden fees, no required add-ons. Squarespace offers countless extras like built-in donation tools for fundraising and online payments and invoicing to help you get paid on time.
1:14 Mae Martin? Squarespace makes it easy, so easy we even made a handsome website ourselves in less than 20 minutes. So what are you waiting for? Get started on your dream website today. Head to Squarespace.com/handsome for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code HANSOME to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:34 Mae Martin? This is a HeadGum Podcast.
1:37 Speaker 02 Handsome. Chat to my friends on the handsome pod. Chat to my friends on the handsome pod. Pretty little episode.
1:53 Tig Notaro? May.
1:55 Tig Notaro? Well, first of all, welcome to the Pretty Little
1:59 Mae Martin? Episode.
2:00 Tig Notaro? Yeah. I'm Tig Notaro and you're May, right?
2:03 Mae Martin? Yeah, yeah.
2:04 Tig Notaro? Okay, let's skip past all that. What was that?
2:07 Mae Martin? I mean, I wasn't expecting such a response and I'm thrilled by it because it's electrically, I'm holding a banana peel, a classic comedy prop.
2:17 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
2:18 Mae Martin? I ate the banana before we started recording and now I'm revealing the detritus.
2:22 Tig Notaro? Oh, it's so funny what you did.
2:26 Mae Martin? You thought the little dance, it was like.
2:28 Tig Notaro? Yes, I did. Of course I did. Have you ever slipped on a banana peel?
2:33 Mae Martin? No.
2:33 Tig Notaro? Do you know anyone that has ever slipped on a banana peel?
2:36 Mae Martin? It must have been a thing at some point, right? But I would think in the olden days, bananas were pretty hard to come by, pretty rare. So I don't know when that started, the banana peels.
2:47 Tig Notaro? Have I blown your mind with this information yet?
2:50 Mae Martin? What?
2:51 Tig Notaro? Bananas are berries.
2:53 Mae Martin? Stop.
2:56 Mae Martin? What do you mean?
2:58 Tig Notaro? Bananas are berries.
3:01 Mae Martin? There's no way.
3:03 Tig Notaro? Okay.
3:03 Mae Martin? Look at the shape and the.
3:05 Tig Notaro? Google that up.
3:06 Mae Martin? I mean, I want it.
3:07 Speaker 03 You're correct, Tig.
3:08 Tig Notaro? Bananas are berries.
3:10 Mae Martin? Really? But.
3:11 Tig Notaro? And you know what isn't a berry? A blackberry.
3:15 Mae Martin? What is happening?
3:16 Tig Notaro? Thomas, will you Google that up?
3:18 Mae Martin? Can I blow your mind?
3:19 Tig Notaro? Always, every day that I see you.
3:22 Mae Martin? Pumpkins of fruit.
3:24 Tig Notaro? Oh, of course.
3:25 Mae Martin? Oh, I didn't know that.
3:28 Mae Martin? Pumpkins of fruit. Wow. So banana's a berry. I guess it grows in bunches. I don't know what the qualities of a berry are.
3:35 Tig Notaro? Seeds inside.
3:36 Mae Martin? Are there banana seeds?
3:38 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
3:39 Mae Martin? Huh.
3:39 Tig Notaro? There should be.
3:41 Mae Martin? I think I've been getting some weird bananas. What I know about bananas is a lot of people die every year picking them. It's a very dangerous job. Coconuts fall on your head and.
3:50 Tig Notaro? And it's a, well, and you could slip on them.
3:52 Mae Martin? Yeah, you could slip on those peels and there's black widow spiders that live in the bunches, you know?
3:57 Tig Notaro? Oh my gosh, be careful out there. Thomas, are blackberries berries?
4:01 Speaker 03 It seems like they're not technically berries.
4:05 Tig Notaro? Thank you.
4:05 Speaker 03 Yeah.
4:06 Tig Notaro? Thank you. Okay. And bananas are?
4:09 Speaker 03 Yes.
4:10 Tig Notaro? Okay.
4:10 Mae Martin? That's so nuts.
4:11 Tig Notaro? I know. No, not nuts, berries. Yeah. One of my favorite snacks that I eat almost every day is peanut butter on a banana and peanut butter on a Honeycrisp apple.
4:27 Mae Martin? Oh, that's good.
4:29 Tig Notaro? It's so good.
4:30 Mae Martin? That's, yeah, peanut butter and bananas. I'll do a sandwich, like toast peanut butter banana and honey drizzled.
4:38 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
4:38 Mae Martin? Yeah. Come on.
4:40 Tig Notaro? Cause you don't care.
4:41 Mae Martin? I don't give a shit.
4:42 Tig Notaro? You don't, and I can tell. Yeah. I dare you to keep doing that.
4:46 Mae Martin? Yeah.
4:46 Tig Notaro? Do you like peanut butter on an apple?
4:48 Mae Martin? Yeah. I like peanut butter on most things. Yeah.
4:51 Tig Notaro? Yeah. Yeah. It's not a bad food to eat. It is delicious.
4:56 Mae Martin? I wonder who started peanut butter?
4:58 Tig Notaro? Hmm. I don't know. Thomas, can you let us know?
5:03 Mae Martin? Have we gone, I feel like we just went, we just, I feel like we just finally found Thomas's line. Like we went too far in asking him to Google who invented peanut butter. Oh, here we go. Marcellus Gilmore Edson was a Canadian chemist, a Canadian chemist and pharmacist. In 1884, he patented a way to make peanut paste, an early version of peanut butter. Oh, but the ancient Incas and Aztecs also ground peanuts into a paste centuries earlier. Of course.
5:32 Tig Notaro? Okay. So, truth comes out.
5:35 Mae Martin? Yeah. It's, you can't just patent something and then say you invented it.
5:38 Tig Notaro? Right. Speaking of Canadians, I mean, this might blow your mind. I wish Fortune was here to witness it, but I know that Katy Perry is dating Trudeau.
5:49 Mae Martin? You do, because that's huge. Yeah.
5:54 Mae Martin? They made their first public appearance, right?
5:56 Tig Notaro? Yeah. Yeah. Do you think that, like, did their marriages dissolve because they met type thing? Or?
6:04 Mae Martin? Girl, I'm gonna weigh in. I'm gonna say that they, no, I think both their marriages had been on the rocks for a while, but it does seem pretty quick. The, or is it? I don't know when Orlando.
6:18 Tig Notaro? I don't know, but like, or were they?
6:23 Tig Notaro? Keeping an eye on each other from a distance and like their dreamboat became free and they're like,
6:30 Tig Notaro? hello, I love you so and your, your legacy will be great.
6:36 Mae Martin? I mean, when I look at them together, it makes sense. It, it, it works for me. I, I hope it lasts. Uh, I want to hear what songs she writes about him. I don't know what.
6:46 Tig Notaro? Do you hope it lasts? Like, I, no offense to either of them. I don't care. I don't care if it lasts. If they broke up while we were talking, I, I don't wish anyone ill will. I just, I, I'm not invested at all.
7:00 Mae Martin? Yeah, I gotta be honest. Neither am I. I'm not that invested. Yeah. But God love them.
7:07 Tig Notaro? Yeah. And God does love them. God loves them both. They're children of the Lord.
7:12 Mae Martin? Yeah. Yeah. Who else is dating that we, that we now have? That's new and exciting?
7:18 Tig Notaro? Let's see. Who is dating?
7:23 Mae Martin? Oh, Thomas is typing. Maybe he's going to reveal, oh, Sophie Turner and Chris Martin. Sophie Turner from Game of Thrones and Chris Martin from Coldplay.
7:34 Tig Notaro? How'd you hear this, Thomas?
7:35 Mae Martin? Yeah. Why is Tom?
7:37 Speaker 03 Came up, you know, in my news feed.
7:41 Tig Notaro? While we were talking about it? Or girl, were you Googling hot goss?
7:46 Speaker 03 You know what? I think I heard about Justin Trudeau and Katy Perry and then I started kind of down a celebrity rabbit hole because of that a couple of days ago.
7:55 Mae Martin? Well, I feel like as the weather gets colder, people start coupling up. People start wanting to stay in. They want to, feeling a little lonely. It does add an element of pressure when both people in a couple are in the limelight, right? Like, or, or when it would be a news story for them to break up or date or like, do you ever think about? Have you guys ever been the subject of like a headline? You and Stephanie?
8:18 Tig Notaro? Well, didn't I tell you, this isn't a headline, but didn't I tell you when I went? On, I don't know what I was on, it must have been social media or something, but this thing popped up that said, are you involved in a May-December relationship? And the picture was me and Stephanie.
8:36 Mae Martin? No.
8:37 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
8:38 Mae Martin? And so a May-December is like an older?
8:40 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
8:41 Mae Martin? No way.
8:42 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
8:42 Mae Martin? Like an age gap relationship? Oh, my God.
8:45 Tig Notaro? Or maybe that's what they said, an age gap relationship. And it was me and Stephanie in the picture.
8:50 Mae Martin? That's insane.
8:51 Tig Notaro? I can send it to you.
8:53 Mae Martin? Yeah.
8:53 Tig Notaro? I was like, this is hilarious.
8:56 Mae Martin? Did you send it to Stephanie?
8:58 Tig Notaro? I did.
8:58 Mae Martin? Yeah, of course. What's, so what's the age gap?
9:01 Tig Notaro? Me and Stephanie?
9:02 Mae Martin? Yeah, is it 10?
9:03 Tig Notaro? 15 years.
9:04 Mae Martin? 15 years, yeah, yeah.
9:05 Tig Notaro? Yeah. Have we been in a headline? I mean, other than just like, we're celebrating an anniversary or
9:13 Mae Martin? Yeah.
9:13 Tig Notaro? we had babies or got married or, you know, any of that stuff. We're not really...
9:19 Mae Martin? It is weird, like the parasocial relationships people have. Like, I feel, I feel connected to some celebrities I've never met. Like, I like to think of myself as being very aware that I don't actually know these people. But then you see someone out and you're like, yeah, I know this person intimately. Well, like, I remember hearing David Schwimmer's voice. I was in a restaurant, I heard his voice and my, I wanted to walk up to him because I was like, I know this guy.
9:46 Tig Notaro? Yeah, but you don't.
9:47 Mae Martin? No, but you don't, you can't.
9:49 Tig Notaro? Yeah, even if you've met them.
9:51 Mae Martin? Yeah.
9:52 Tig Notaro? A time or two, you know? It's like, is David Schwimmer coming up to you? Is he reaching out to you?
9:59 Mae Martin? Yeah, I do think with the podcast especially, people do feel like they intimately know us and those can be tricky to navigate.
10:09 Tig Notaro? Yeah, but most people are cool and don't cross boundaries or get weird or, you know?
10:16 Mae Martin? Yeah, yeah, most people are.
10:18 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
10:18 Mae Martin? Great.
10:19 Tig Notaro? Absolutely, especially our handsome community.
10:22 Mae Martin? God, they're so good.
10:24 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
10:25 Mae Martin? They're so good. Speaking of which, shall we hear some questions?
10:29 Tig Notaro? Yeah, let's hear from them.
10:30 Speaker 04 Hello, Handsoms. My name is Rhiannon and my question is a two-parter. First part for Tig, I'd like to know when and how did you know that Stephanie was the one for you? And for May and Fortune, I'd like to know if you, if and when you meet somebody that you want to spend the rest of your life with, how will you know that they're the one?
10:51 Tig Notaro? Hmm. Hmm. It's, you know, maybe I've mentioned this before, but I remember years ago when I had met Nick Offerman. And he is, what? He's the one for me. Well, yeah. But, you know, he's married to the actress Megan Mullally. And I remember him talking about realizing she was the one he was gonna marry. And, and I can't quite, I want to revisit this conversation with him because it really struck me. Because it was before I had ever met somebody that I for sure knew I wanted to spend my life with.
11:34 Tig Notaro? And I remember him saying something to the effect of like, "Yeah." And then I was like, "Ah, I'm gonna have to marry her." Like, "She's the one I'm gonna marry." Like, it was something, like, it could have sounded like he's not excited, but he was like, "No, no, no, it's not that at all." It's, I think, now that I've met Stephanie and I felt that thing of like, it's undeniable, I guess. It's coming for you. It's like an avalanche. It's like, "We're getting married. This is it." And I used to always ask people, "Nick," I think that's why he was telling me. I was like, "How do you know?"
12:14 Tig Notaro? I was always wanting to know, like, how, what was, what, because it's that thing that before you've experienced it, you don't know how to know. Right. "How will I know?" Like, like our listener is asking. And I think if it is that feeling of uncertainty, then you haven't had that feeling. Yeah. You know? And I for sure had it with Stephanie. I was like, "Oh, my God, I want to marry this person." I love that.
12:50 Mae Martin? But then also, that's probably because partly you were both, you were ready for that. Like, I think, I think we get decision paralysis and that we're overwhelmed by all the options and choice and there, there are probably multiple people for everybody and, and sometimes the person who's the one is the person who you both are just like, we choose this, we want this. It's, and so we're going to choose it and keep choosing it. And then there's the thing that makes them the one is that they keep choosing it.
13:21 Tig Notaro? Well, yeah, I definitely relate to that now that like, you know, Stephanie and I are, I mean, obviously, anything in life could happen, but I feel like we're very locked in to our life and our love and family and all of that stuff. And, and yeah, you're, you're choosing, but not because it's like, we're having a hard time, that we're going to just choose to do this. And, but of course, there are times when it's hard and you, you make those choices to stay in it.
13:53 Mae Martin? Yeah.
13:53 Tig Notaro? Which is great, because you should see what's on the other side of it. And maybe there's not anything. But I didn't feel out of the gate like I chose it. I felt like...
14:04 Mae Martin? It chose you.
14:05 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
14:05 Mae Martin? Yeah.
14:06 Tig Notaro? It's like, wow, kind of like what Nick was saying, like, yeah, well, I guess we're getting married.
14:10 Mae Martin? Yeah.
14:10 Tig Notaro? You know? I want to revisit that conversation with him.
14:13 Mae Martin? Yeah, I like that.
14:14 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
14:15 Mae Martin? Should we hear Rhiannon's answer?
14:17 Tig Notaro? Yes, of course, we should.
14:19 Speaker 04 My answer to this question is that a few weeks into dating my wife, I realized that even though we spent just about every spare minute together, I never got tired of being around them. And I wanted, um, I didn't want personal space. I didn't feel like I needed any space. And so about 15 years later, here we are. I still think they're the most interesting person I've ever met. And I just, yeah, so I'm curious. Well, thank you for your podcast. You are keeping us laughing in dark times.
14:54 Mae Martin? That's so nice. I mean, it is the person you're going to spend the most time with. You have to be friends. You have to... I remember with Parv, when we lived together, we'd often find ourselves in the kitchen, like...
15:07 Mae Martin? Like losing track of time, just mingling almost like just talking would be standing in the kitchen for like an hour just talking and then was like, yeah, yeah.
15:16 Tig Notaro? I love the idea of mingling with your girlfriend.
15:19 Mae Martin? And mingling in the kitchen is crucial. Yeah.
15:22 Tig Notaro? I'm gonna invite Stephanie to meet me in the kitchen to mingle a bit.
15:25 Mae Martin? Yeah.
15:26 Tig Notaro? Before the day starts.
15:27 Mae Martin? Yeah, pretend you're at a party and you found each other and you, yeah.
15:30 Tig Notaro? That's great. Should we get another question?
15:33 Mae Martin? Yeah, let's do it.
15:34 Speaker 05 Hello, I'm Indira. Sorry for my English. I'm not a native speaker. I'm your listener from Germany. And I have a question to May especially, but I would be happy to hear the answer from any of you. So I have a niece who I could call a wayward, a troubled teenager. And I would love to build a stronger connection to her or help my mom, her grandma, to build a stronger connection to her. And the question is, what can you recommend to a relative of such a teenager to build the stronger connection?
16:19 Tig Notaro? Hmm. That's a really good question.
16:22 Mae Martin? Really good.
16:24 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
16:24 Mae Martin? I think the temptation is to be, well, I think you have to remember, so probably this person like wants to be with their friends all the time and is maybe like, I don't know what they're struggling with at the moment, but thinking, why is it that teenagers feel that pull to their friends and that that sort of individuation from family where they they feel like, I mean, I think everybody has that as a teenager, right? You get so bonded. Yes, it's so important. But thinking, well, what could we could, I have to get to know this person as an individual. What does she like to do? You know, if I want to connect
17:07 Mae Martin? with her, how can I connect with her with things that she's interested about like? Take her somewhere that is in line with her interests or and yeah, like instead of being like, why won't she come to the family dinner and like sit?
17:20 Tig Notaro? Yeah, if you're like, hey, take me to your ideal day.
17:23 Mae Martin? Yeah.
17:23 Tig Notaro? Show me your ideal day, start to finish.
17:26 Mae Martin? Yeah.
17:26 Tig Notaro? Where you want to eat, where you want to go, introduce me to your friends. I'm so curious about your life.
17:31 Mae Martin? Totally, and I think a judgment free place for her to talk. Like if you want her to open up to you, then you then when she does, you've got to hold that. Like you can't, you, you have to be non reactive, you have to listen. And yeah, because I think it's so easy to tell people to be honest, but it has to be a safe environment for them to be honest in, you know? Yeah, but that's tough. I mean, I would, yeah, I would just resist any like labeling of her or pathologizing, like just really help her to feel that this is a fluid transitional time and that.
18:11 Tig Notaro? Yeah, maybe sharing stories about your own life and naturally putting that into a conversation of times that you were maybe feeling a little off track or confused or
18:23 Mae Martin? Yeah.
18:24 Tig Notaro? troubled in some way. And I know when I've shared things with Max since then, struggles as a kid.
18:33 Mae Martin? Yeah.
18:34 Tig Notaro? They're blown away.
18:35 Mae Martin? Oh, they like, yeah, kids love to hear the stories.
18:38 Tig Notaro? Yeah, they're like, you really, Mary? You didn't, and I'm like, no, I didn't.
18:43 Mae Martin? Yeah.
18:43 Tig Notaro? They can't believe it.
18:45 Mae Martin? I would also say like, pick your battles. Like if, like this is a, like, for example, and I'm sure this is not the situation, but let's say this person's like doing coke or doing drugs or like, then if they are going to hang out with you on the condition that they can smoke a cigarette around you, like, let them do that for now, like if, you know what I mean? Or?
19:07 Mae Martin? Yeah, like pick your battles and let them, let them be.
19:11 Tig Notaro? Mm hmm.
19:12 Mae Martin? As long as they're not putting themselves in danger, or you know what I mean?
19:15 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
19:15 Mae Martin? I'm not being very articulate.
19:17 Tig Notaro? Open. I want to know who you are.
19:20 Mae Martin? Yeah, yeah, like my, my friend Carolyn Taylor, who I've talked about so much, who would just, when I was like on sofas and such a mess, and she would just take me for a burger once a month and, and sometimes we'd do laser tag or we'd do painting and it was like sober activities that were really fun and I would look forward to it and I could, I could be a mess and I could, I could smoke cigarettes and you know what I mean, but I looked forward to it all month and it was so wholesome.
19:47 Tig Notaro? I think that's great.
19:48 Mae Martin? Yeah.
19:49 Tig Notaro? Well, thanks for reaching out, asking the questions and just really, really appreciate you guys and gals and theydees and themdees and everybody.
20:05 Mae Martin? We do.
20:06 Tig Notaro? Yeah, and share our episodes with friends, help build the community.
20:11 Mae Martin? I've been really enjoying the advice questions, like that one from Indira, that's, that's juicy, or yeah, but anything.
20:19 Tig Notaro? Yeah, we remain open.
20:20 Mae Martin? We remain open. If you, if you have like an encounter with a ghost or something that you want to share, I'd like to hear it.
20:28 Tig Notaro? May's all ears and wide eyes. And go to speakpipe.com/hansampod to submit your questions. Yeah, share episodes, rate, review, check out YouTube, all of it. And I don't know, until next time?
20:47 Mae Martin? Keep it pretty handsome.
20:50 Tig Notaro? Handsome is hosted by me, Tig Notaro, Mae Martin, and Fortune Themester. The show is produced, recorded, and edited by Thomas Willett. Email us at handsomepod@gmail.com. Follow us on social media @handsomepod.
21:08 Speaker 03 What a podcast!
21:14 Tig Notaro? That was a HeadGum Podcast.
Previous Rob Thomas asks about extravagant indulgences Next Lizzy Caplan asks about first impressions Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated