Pod Insights Handsome Pretty Little Episode #31 About this episode Fortune and Tig design their own action figures and swap sibling stories on a super sweet Pretty Little Episode!
Handsome is streaming LIVE from Austin April 12! Get your tickets here https://www.squadup.com/events/handsome-streaming-live-from-austin. Handsome is hosted by Tig Notaro, Mae Martin, and Fortune FeimsterSubmit questions to speakpipe.com/handsomepod http://speakpipe.com/handsomepodFollow us on social media @handsomepodMerch at handsomepod.com http://handsomepod.com/Watch Handsome on YouTube http://youtube.com/@handsomepodThis is a Headgum https://headgum.com/ podcast. Follow Headgum on Twitter https://x.com/headgum, Instagram https://www.instagram.com/headgum/, and Tiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@headgum. Advertise on Handsome https://gumball.fm/shows/handsome via Gumball.fm http://gumball.fm/.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Speaker 00 This is a HeadGum Podcast.
0:04 Mae Martin? Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance. Not checking whether I brought my sunglasses before driving west at the end of the day? A learning moment. I'm gaining confidence in my driving, but it helps when I'm not blinded by the sun beaming directly into my eyeballs.
0:18 Tig Notaro? Yeah, checking first is handsome, so check Allstate first for an auto quote. It could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate. Potential savings vary, subject to terms, conditions, and availability. Allstate North American Insurance Company and Affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.
0:35 Mae Martin? Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance. Not checking the program before sitting down to enjoy a school play? I'm in shambles. Turns out there's no intermission during this three-hour Shakespeare adaptation, and I really need to go to the bathroom.
0:48 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, checking first is handsome, so check Allstate first for an auto quote. It could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate. Potential savings vary, subject to terms, conditions, and availability. Allstate North American Insurance Company and Affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.
1:03 Mae Martin? Handsome is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online with a handy, handsome website you can be proud of and show off to all your friends, clients, and loved ones. With Squarespace, you can scale up your business, claim your domain, and showcase your offerings with a premium, professional website.
1:21 Fortune Feimster? With Squarespace's cutting-edge design tools, you can build a gorgeous online presence that perfectly fits your brand or business. Their SEO tools help your ideal audience find you. Since every dream needs a domain, Squarespace makes it easy to find the best name for your business at one fair, all-inclusive price. No hidden fees, no required add-ons. Squarespace offers countless extras like built-in donation tools for fundraising, and online payments and invoicing to help you get paid on time. Squarespace makes it easy. So easy, we even made a handsome website ourselves in less than 20 minutes.
1:53 Mae Martin? So what are you waiting for? Get started on your dream website today. Head to Squarespace.com/handsome for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code HANSSOM to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
2:16 Fortune Feimster? Pretty little episode.
2:18 Tig Notaro? God, that gets me every time. I'm never expecting, "Pretty little episode."
2:23 Fortune Feimster? I know, and it's such a catchy tune.
2:25 Tig Notaro? It really is. We are such talents.
2:28 Fortune Feimster? Gosh.
2:29 Tig Notaro? Gosh, look at us. I know it. We're some of the best, if not the three best.
2:34 Fortune Feimster? The best in the biz.
2:36 Tig Notaro? Yeah, but you only have two of us, two of the best, and Mr. Thomas, of course, here.
2:42 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, welcome to our pretty little episode. I'm Fortune Feimster.
2:45 Tig Notaro? Oh, right, and I'm Tig Notaro.
2:47 Fortune Feimster? How you doing, bud?
2:48 Tig Notaro? I'm doing all right. I'm doing okay. Just, um, what am I doing? God.
2:57 Fortune Feimster? I know, I'm like...
2:59 Tig Notaro? I'm like... Yeah, it's, I, you know, I'm home from Toronto and home from doing Star Trek.
3:06 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
3:07 Tig Notaro? It's just so incredible, deeply incredible, to just be back in my life, you know? And that is not to say that I did not enjoy being in my Toronto life.
3:22 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
3:23 Tig Notaro? But it's just a whole different feeling to be in your own bed and see my little Cubs. Finn has braces. Just things are changing. Yeah.
3:34 Fortune Feimster? Well, yeah, it's like when you're filming, you kind of, it kind of feels like you're in an alternate universe. That like life, real life is kind of paused.
3:41 Tig Notaro? Mm-hmm.
3:41 Fortune Feimster? And it is that, such a nice feeling to get back home and get a routine again.
3:47 Tig Notaro? Yeah, and speaking of routines, how's your new routine going? Are you excited about your new material?
3:52 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, it's going good. I'm, I'm just weeks away from starting the theaters. I can't believe it's already here. When I started, it's funny that this is, was my break. There was no real break, other than I wasn't on a massive tour.
4:08 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
4:08 Fortune Feimster? But it was filled with many other things.
4:11 Tig Notaro? Isn't that, I always marvel over that. It's like, you're, you know, I was filming for six months. I put mostly everything on hold.
4:20 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
4:20 Tig Notaro? And then as soon as I wrap production... My entire calendar fills right up and I'm on quote unquote break.
4:30 Fortune Feimster? I think it's a life of, that's the life of a stand up because we just don't do one thing. But it's all luckily, it's all good stuff. Like we love doing this.
4:40 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
4:42 Fortune Feimster? You're ready to go retire.
4:46 Fortune Feimster? Yeah. So I'm, I'm excited for it. It's, it'll be good to just get back on the road and make people laugh. You know, I, I love that feeling. I want to try to be healthier though. I want to try to maintain like not. My last tour, I just, the first like year of it, I just like was not taking good care of myself and I really want to prioritize that.
5:08 Tig Notaro? What kind of shift are you wanting to make or shifts?
5:11 Fortune Feimster? Just not eating like crap the whole time, you know, like and, and not eating after the show. If I can get in like a, even a light, like 30 minute walk and uh, moving my body.
5:25 Tig Notaro? Yep.
5:26 Fortune Feimster? Um, just, just not blowing up.
5:29 Tig Notaro? Well, you're looking trim.
5:31 Fortune Feimster? Thanks. I mean, I had time to, you know, be at home and tread water. I've been doing that still.
5:38 Tig Notaro? Are you really?
5:40 Fortune Feimster? Yeah. I mean, um.
5:42 Tig Notaro? Be honest with me.
5:42 Fortune Feimster? I am at least a couple of times a week. Two, two, two minimum is what I um, try to go for.
5:49 Tig Notaro? Fortune.
5:50 Fortune Feimster? Four max, two minimum.
5:52 Tig Notaro? That is so cool.
5:54 Fortune Feimster? Yeah. It's just a good escape to like, to like med, like meditative type thing for me.
6:00 Tig Notaro? No doubt. Same. I haven't done it in a while.
6:04 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
6:05 Tig Notaro? And so I'm hoping to uh, get back into that as well.
6:09 Fortune Feimster? You gotta.
6:10 Tig Notaro? But I am a little curious about your new material. Like how and when, are you doing any shows in LA before you head out?
6:18 Fortune Feimster? I'm doing um, Pasadena this Sunday and Largo this Monday.
6:22 Tig Notaro? Okay.
6:23 Fortune Feimster? There's uh, mom stuff again. There's a couple of Jack's things. Um, several childhood stories again. And then a story about my dad. I haven't talked about him much. I'm, I'm still looking for like two stories. But I don't want them to be about my family or my childhood or Jack's. I just want them to be too independent. Something other than that kind of story, but I don't know what those are yet.
6:52 Tig Notaro? And is the story about your dad, I'm your father. I'm your father.
6:57 Fortune Feimster? No, it's a, it's a story about him going through a midlife crisis.
7:02 Tig Notaro? Oh, okay.
7:03 Fortune Feimster? Cause I realized I'm the age now that my parents were when they divorced.
7:09 Tig Notaro? Wow.
7:10 Fortune Feimster? Isn't that weird?
7:11 Tig Notaro? That is wild.
7:13 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, because I-
7:13 Tig Notaro? How old are you? Forty-four?
7:15 Fortune Feimster? Forty-four and I really thought they were so old when that happened.
7:23 Fortune Feimster? But it made me, it really put a lot of things into perspective of like, oh my gosh.
7:29 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
7:29 Fortune Feimster? Cause you, you know, I don't feel young, but I don't feel old. And it just made me go, wow, if I, that happened to me with three kids and a lot of financial responsibilities, I would, I wouldn't necessarily know how to handle that either. And they, they kind of had to, you know, trial and error, had to make some mistakes in order to sort of find the path. And I guess it makes me sort of acknowledge the, the journey not being easy.
8:01 Tig Notaro? Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's really, it's really insane to think about how much younger, like Max and Finn were talking about that. Like Max randomly said, what is the normal age to have kids? And Finn just chimed in immediately and said, thirty-eight. And it's like, first of all, you're kind of right. But also where did that come from? Yeah, in LA. But it, you know, it definitely is trending in that direction where people are having, getting married and having kids older. Of course, there are certainly people that are doing it young as well. But that was the thing to do is get married, have kids right out of the gate.
8:47 Tig Notaro? And I cannot believe, even like Stephanie blows my mind how she just walked into motherhood. Like, I don't want to say no big deal, but I, she just seemed, I, I would marvel. I was, you know, I'm fifteen years older and I would, I would be like, I'm tripping all over myself and she just seems so, she's got it.
9:10 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, that's awesome.
9:11 Tig Notaro? Yeah, it's really impressive. I mean, she was thirty when we had Max and Finn. But anyway, yeah, it's, I think about that Adele song. What is it? Basically, she's asking, I think the song is about her singing to her child, like.
9:31 Fortune Feimster? I'm sure I know which one, but it's not coming to me.
9:33 Tig Notaro? It's like her most recent hit.
9:35 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
9:36 Tig Notaro? Um, I have to.
9:37 Fortune Feimster? Go easy on me?
9:38 Tig Notaro? Yeah, go, yes, okay. Go easy on me, because it's basically like, I was doing my best, like singing that to her kid. I think that's what the song is.
9:47 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
9:48 Tig Notaro? Is like, go easy on me. I, I made the best decisions. I, I was all from love and, and I, I fumbled.
9:56 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, you know, it's the life. These things come your way and no age makes it easy, but.
10:03 Tig Notaro? No, no.
10:04 Fortune Feimster? Definitely is interesting to look back on it and the difference that being where I'm at now going, okay.
10:10 Tig Notaro? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
10:11 Fortune Feimster? I get it.
10:12 Tig Notaro? Yeah, same, same Z's. Ten years older than you. Um, but, well, cool. I, I can't wait to hear your new material and.
10:22 Fortune Feimster? Thanks. Shall we hear some questions from our pre-woke listeners?
10:26 Tig Notaro? I think we should mainly because that's what we're here to do.
10:29 Fortune Feimster? Let's do it.
10:30 Tig Notaro? Okay. Hit us, Mr. T.
10:32 Speaker 00 Hello, handsome's. This is Goldie from the Bay Area. Here's my question. If you were an action figure, what would come with you and what would be sold separately?
10:42 Tig Notaro? Oh, well.
10:43 Fortune Feimster? Whoa. Do you have an action figure?
10:45 Tig Notaro? After I did that zombie movie, Army of the Dead, um, they had sent me action figures for my character that they were making. I think there was like a game and an action. Like there was a whole thing, but I never saw it again, but I have a picture of what my action figure was going to look like. I was kind of hoping I was going to end up an action figure, uh, since I'm on Star Trek, but that hasn't happened.
11:12 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I was wondering that.
11:14 Tig Notaro? And then somebody made a bobblehead of me and sent it to me.
11:20 Fortune Feimster? I want a Tig bobblehead.
11:21 Tig Notaro? I was gonna say, I'll give it to you, but I like it.
11:25 Fortune Feimster? Keep that.
11:25 Tig Notaro? Yeah, yeah. I think just me as Tig in the world as an action figure, I guess I'd probably be walking around with a microphone because of stand up and podcasting. Or maybe I'd have like a boom microphone over me as well.
11:46 Tig Notaro? And probably an apple. I eat an apple every day. I love Honeycrisp apples. I'd have a microphone and an apple and I'd eat that apple right on the microphone and drive you batty.
12:04 Fortune Feimster? I've never had an action figure, but I am doing a voice in Zootopia 2 and I have been told I will have a plush toy.
12:13 Tig Notaro? Nice. You deserve it. If anyone deserves a plush toy, it is you, my friend.
12:19 Fortune Feimster? And I'm playing a beaver.
12:20 Tig Notaro? Of course you are. Of course you are. Isn't that amazing? Yes.
12:31 Fortune Feimster? So I'm very excited for that. It comes out later at the end of this year.
12:35 Tig Notaro? No, that's so fun.
12:37 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I think it does. I can't remember what they decided.
12:41 Tig Notaro? That's not your business to know. You're the star. You walk in, you do your thing, you walk out a toy.
12:46 Fortune Feimster? That's right. If I was an action figure, though, I think this would be my, um, what did, what do you call it?
12:55 Tig Notaro? Accessory?
12:56 Fortune Feimster? My accessory would be Biggie.
12:58 Tig Notaro? Of course.
12:59 Fortune Feimster? It would be a little Biggie and we would fight crime together.
13:05 Tig Notaro? That's really scary. Oh, my gosh.
13:09 Fortune Feimster? For those of you listening, Biggie is with me and he's karate chopping.
13:15 Tig Notaro? Or you can go directly to YouTube and see it straight away. It is some scary moves. I would have to also, I forgot to say what I would sell separately.
13:24 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
13:25 Tig Notaro? It would have to be Kitty City. Kitty City's gonna be standing around me and my apple and the microphone.
13:35 Fortune Feimster? Biggie's looking at me like, really? You got me out of my bed for that?
13:40 Tig Notaro? For those lame karate chops?
13:42 Fortune Feimster? He's like, just let me sleep already. What would be sold separately?
13:47 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
13:48 Fortune Feimster? Oh, my action figure would have its own pair of Crocs, but you could like, uh, change them out for other colors. And you could put, decorate the Crocs and stuff. That would be sold separately.
14:03 Tig Notaro? That is sexy.
14:05 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, would fight crime in Crocs.
14:07 Tig Notaro? Let's hear Goldie's answer. I love your name, Goldie.
14:10 Fortune Feimster? Mm hmm. Keep it Goldie.
14:13 Speaker 00 My answer is, in my action figure package, I would be sold with my reading glasses, my library card and my e-reader. And sold separately would be all the books. Uh, one of my favorite books of the 302 books that I read last year was Interesting Facts About Space by Emily Austin. Uh, I kept picturing May as the main character. So it's kind of fun. Uh, I also loved May's book and Tig's book. So Fortune, please write a book.
14:40 Tig Notaro? Yeah, you're gonna write a book, Fortune?
14:42 Fortune Feimster? I'd like to, one day.
14:44 Tig Notaro? Knew it.
14:45 Fortune Feimster? I think so. She read 302 books in a year?
14:49 Tig Notaro? I mean, let's be honest, and this is a, this is a compliment. Goldie is a nerd alert and so is Mr. Thomas. Thomas reads, you, you read a book a week, don't you, Thomas?
15:01 Mae Martin? I try to, yeah. I fell a bit behind that pace, but I try.
15:04 Tig Notaro? Well, you're a busy guy, but yeah. Thomas is full blown nerd alert.
15:09 Fortune Feimster? Wow, I can't, my mom loves to read. She can read a book a week as well. Um, I can't read that fast. But my, my grandmother was also that way. They both were just, could not get enough of books.
15:20 Tig Notaro? And you're like, I am my own person.
15:23 Fortune Feimster? Well, I have a little bit of ADD. Um, so I'll start reading and then just go off into the clouds.
15:29 Tig Notaro? Sure.
15:31 Fortune Feimster? So I have to really, really concentrate.
15:34 Tig Notaro? Well, we won't keep you long. Let's get to the next question so you can go back into the clouds.
15:39 Speaker 04 Hello, Fortune, May and Tig. Yes, she insists on singing. This is the siblings Eleanor and Madeline from New Jersey. We have a question for you. What is something your sibling introduced you to that changed your life?
15:54 Tig Notaro? Uh, we've never had siblings ask us anything before.
15:57 Fortune Feimster? No.
15:58 Tig Notaro? This is our first sibling duo.
16:00 Fortune Feimster? Yes. I have two older brothers, so I was always introduced to, most things I found out about were through them in childhood. Like, my brother, both my brothers introduced me to a lot of music. I don't know that I, my tastes would have been anything other than New Kids on the Block. Had they not played different, cooler music. I think my love of sports and playing sports in particular came from my oldest brother, Price. He introduced me to tennis and he would, I don't think I would have gotten into tennis otherwise. And I ended up playing my whole
16:43 Fortune Feimster? life and through college and in LA for many years.
16:47 Tig Notaro? So they basically made you gay?
16:49 Fortune Feimster? They made me gay, you guys. They made me tougher because they would beat the crap out of me, too.
16:59 Tig Notaro? Yeah, yeah.
17:00 Fortune Feimster? But yeah, I think they definitely helped shape at least some of my interests.
17:05 Tig Notaro? Yeah, same, same, same. I feel like, I don't know if my brother introduced me to Richard Pryor. We both found him together, but we just loved him so much. And we were both very into, well, he didn't introduce me to the Beatles or anything, but we were both very into the whole British Invasion of rock. Soccer, we were both wildly into soccer as kids. And I think similarly to you, shaping and, but we were, you know, only like a year apart.
17:40 Fortune Feimster? And were you guys close growing up or closer when you got older?
17:44 Tig Notaro? Well, we were definitely close, but we definitely would fight. And I think I've talked on the podcast about how I would swing my monkey around to defend myself because my monkey had a hard, plastic face and hard, plastic hands. But we really drifted in like junior high, high school days. And then when he went off to college and when my mother forced my coming out party while he was driving us in his Jeep, then we became closer. He went on his radio show and talked about.
18:29 Tig Notaro? The fact that I was gay and, and really supported me and, and has.
18:36 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, that's awesome. My brothers were never, um, big comedy guys. So I, that was, that was the one hobby that I did not get exposed to from them. That we, we did not really know much about stand up or listen to stand ups or anything like that. So I had to discover that one on my own.
18:55 Tig Notaro? You discovered comedy on your own?
18:57 Fortune Feimster? On my own. I was like, I discovered comedy. This is pretty cool.
19:01 Tig Notaro? Themester discovers comedy.
19:05 Fortune Feimster? But my brothers weren't very like art, artsy guys. They're just like more, uh, sporty guys, I guess.
19:12 Tig Notaro? There were things that like my brother would do that I remember doing because he did them.
19:18 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
19:18 Tig Notaro? Uh, he would draw motorcycles.
19:20 Fortune Feimster? Uh huh.
19:21 Tig Notaro? And so I would, I'd start, I started drawing mo-, he had a sketchbook where he would draw different kinds of motorcycles. And I was like, oh yeah, me too.
19:31 Fortune Feimster? And then you ended up getting some.
19:32 Tig Notaro? How funny. We got a question from Goldie and that is my motorcycle's name, Goldie Honda.
19:38 Fortune Feimster? That's right.
19:39 Tig Notaro? Kurt Russell is the other.
19:42 Fortune Feimster? Let's hear Eleanor and Madeline's answer.
19:45 Speaker 04 Okay. Something our siblings introduced us to that changed our life would be? Music. Yes, music. Borrowed and stolen, burned mix CDs passed from sibling to sibling has led to shared music tastes, which has led to shared music experiences because we go to as many concerts as we possibly can. Who did we see this year, Madeline? Saves the day, say anything. Mom jeans and, uh,
20:11 Tig Notaro? Oh.
20:11 Speaker 04 Love ya. Bye.
20:12 Tig Notaro? Wow. Eleanor and Madeline don't waste time. They're just like, here's the answer. We gotta go. We got a concert to get to.
20:20 Fortune Feimster? They have cool tastes in music, it seems.
20:23 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
20:23 Fortune Feimster? Those, I don't know some of those bands, but they sound cool. This is why I wish I'd had, I didn't want a sister. I feel like sisters do things like that.
20:31 Tig Notaro? Mm hmm.
20:32 Fortune Feimster? Go to concerts together and send handsome questions together.
20:36 Tig Notaro? Fortune, you sound straight.
20:38 Fortune Feimster? I'm so straight with my sister.
20:41 Tig Notaro? Oh, my God. Me and my sister are so straight and we're going to a concert.
20:45 Fortune Feimster? We're so straight, my sister and I.
20:47 Tig Notaro? You know what? I have sisters. I just wasn't, I wasn't raised with them. I was gonna say, I don't have sisters, but I do. Um, my apologies, sisters. But yeah, we were, the huge gap in age. And, um, we didn't, we just were not around each other. But, um, I was, I, I'm happy. I, I just had my brother. I think we were like, definitely on the same page with basically all of our interests, except I did secretly play with Barbies with my roughly underwear on. But anyway, um,
21:25 Tig Notaro? well, uh, that was fun catching up with you, Fortune and with Eleanor, Madeline and old Goldie.
21:32 Fortune Feimster? Goldie.
21:33 Tig Notaro? Goldie. And everyone, if you could submit your question and answer at speakpipe.com/hansampod, we would appreciate it. We love getting your questions. And remember to subscribe and, um, to the podcast and the audio as well as YouTube and share episodes with friends. Let's keep building this very handsome community.
21:59 Fortune Feimster? Let's do it. Always love hearing these, uh, question and answers.
22:04 Tig Notaro? I thought you were gonna say, I always love hearing your voice.
22:06 Fortune Feimster? And I love your voice, Tig. I love your voice.
22:12 Tig Notaro? With your Tig old biddies.
22:16 Fortune Feimster? They're in a dumpster.
22:21 Tig Notaro? Well, all that's left to tell our friends is to?
22:25 Fortune Feimster? Keep it pretty handsome. Handsome is hosted by me, Mae Martin, Tig Notaro and Fortune Feimster. The show is produced, recorded and edited by Thomas Willett. Email us at handsomepod@gmail.com and please follow us on social media at HandsomePod.
22:47 Tig Notaro? What a podcast.
22:53 Speaker 00 That was a HeadGum Podcast.
Previous Chelsea Peretti asks about auditions Next Jerry O'Connell asks about invitations Page updated November 3, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated