Pod Insights Handsome Alison Brie asks about changing your personality About this episode Alison Brie (and her cat Otis!) asks Handsome a delightful and revealing question about trying on different personalities. Plus "hide the peanut", A syrupy-sweet nickname, and some real talk about femme-ing it up in the bathroom.
Handsome is hosted by Tig Notaro, Mae Martin, and Fortune FeimsterFollow us on social media @handsomepodMerch at handsomepod.com http://handsomepod.com/Watch Handsome on YouTube http://youtube.com/@handsomepodThis is a Headgum https://headgum.com/ podcast. Follow Headgum on Twitter https://x.com/headgum, Instagram https://www.instagram.com/headgum/, and Tiktok https://www.tiktok.com/@headgum. Advertise on Handsome https://gumball.fm/shows/handsome via Gumball.fm http://gumball.fm/. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Speaker 00 This is a HeadGum Podcast.
0:04 Mae Martin? Checking Allstate first could save you hundreds on car insurance. Not checking whether I brought my sunglasses before driving west at the end of the day? A learning moment. I'm gaining confidence in my driving, but it helps when I'm not blinded by the sun beaming directly into my eyeballs.
0:18 Tig Notaro? Yeah, checking first is handsome, so check Allstate first for an auto quote. It could save you hundreds. You're in good hands with Allstate. Potential savings vary, subject to terms, conditions, and availability. Allstate North American Insurance Company and affiliates, Northbrook, Illinois.
0:35 Mae Martin? Handsome is brought to you by Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform designed to help you stand out and succeed online with a handy, handsome website you can be proud of and show off to all your friends, clients, and loved ones. With Squarespace, you can scale up your business, claim your domain, and showcase your offerings with a premium, professional website. With Squarespace's cutting-edge design tools, you can build a gorgeous online presence that perfectly fits your brand or business. Their SEO tools help your ideal audience find you. Since every dream needs a domain, Squarespace makes it easy to find the best name for your business at one fair, all-inclusive price. No hidden fees, no required add-ons. Squarespace offers countless extras like built-in donation tools for fundraising and online payments and invoicing to help you get paid on time. Squarespace makes it easy.
1:20 Mae Martin? So easy, we even made a handsome website ourselves in less than 20 minutes. So what are you waiting for? Get started on your dream website today. Head to Squarespace.com/handsome for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use offer code HANSSOME to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
1:48 Fortune Feimster? Cheers.
1:50 Tig Notaro? Welcome to the Handsome Pod. I am here, I'm Mae Martin, I'm one of your hosts. I'm joined by? Dignotaro. I am also a host. Oh, what's your name?
2:00 Fortune Feimster? I'm Fortune Beamster. I'm, I think I'm also a host.
2:03 Tig Notaro? Absolutely. We all three. I think it's safe to say at this point, you're one of the hosts.
2:09 Fortune Feimster? You guys, the host with the most.
2:12 Tig Notaro? Well, that's up to you.
2:14 Fortune Feimster? No, all of us, we're the hosts.
2:16 Tig Notaro? Oh, okay.
2:16 Fortune Feimster? And you just can hear the S, hosts.
2:20 Tig Notaro? You know, it's fine. I I'm not terribly competitive.
2:25 Fortune Feimster? Really?
2:25 Tig Notaro? I'll be honest. No, except when Stephanie wants to play 20 questions. Then my competitive side comes out.
2:33 Fortune Feimster? Hmm.
2:34 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
2:34 Fortune Feimster? What is 20 questions?
2:35 Tig Notaro? I don't think of that as a very competitive game, but. Well, her mother pointed it out yesterday because Stephanie is so good. Like if you say, oh, there is a comedian that has, you know, moved, whatever, some sort of, you put out some sort of information. And then Stephanie will be like, oh, can I guess who it is? And I'll be like, sure. Or I'll be like, oh, so and so started dating so and so. You know, how I love to gossip and she goes, she'll say, can I, can I ask 20 questions? And then I'll say, sure.
3:13 Fortune Feimster? Oh, to like, figure out who it is.
3:15 Tig Notaro? Yeah. And so, so we will play that very, she's so good, it's stupid. And so the other morning, her mother was here with us and we're having coffee, chatting. Something comes up. Stephanie says, can I, can we play 20 questions? Sure. We're playing. And then Stephanie's mother's like, whoa, gosh, you're just as competitive as Stephanie. And I was like, what do you mean? And I realized when she pointed this out, that if Stephanie asks a question, and then she asks something on top of that question, I'm like, that's your fourth question. That's not like part of your third question.
3:54 Fortune Feimster? Right, right.
3:55 Tig Notaro? And so I get really competitive with this because Stephanie is, she's so competitive. She's so good at it.
4:01 Fortune Feimster? Hmm.
4:02 Tig Notaro? But in general, I'm, I'm just not terribly competitive.
4:08 Tig Notaro? Like, I'm just not terribly competitive. Right.
4:12 Fortune Feimster? I can see that. And you'd be like, you're like, yeah, so what? I'm lost. Who cares?
4:19 Tig Notaro? Yeah. I'm lost. Who cares? No, like, I remember doing long distance cycling, sometimes for charity.
4:27 Tig Notaro? And some people, even though it's not a race, some people still race. And I was dead last and it was a four day ride.
4:36 Fortune Feimster? Oh, four days. Was that the AIDS life cycle? What is it?
4:41 Tig Notaro? One of them was, yeah. Yeah, but it's like 100 mile days that you're cycling.
4:47 Fortune Feimster? Did your booty not hurt?
4:49 Tig Notaro? Um, I mean, it does, but you also spend a lot of time training. And so you're building up to that moment. You're not just getting on the bike.
4:59 Fortune Feimster? I just pictured just getting on the bike and be like, I guess we're doing this.
5:03 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
5:03 Mae Martin? But you came dead last and you were like, yeah, whatever. I had the experience.
5:07 Tig Notaro? I came dead last, but I mainly came dead last because I blew out one of my knees. And you know, those like clip in bike shoes in the pedal?
5:18 Mae Martin? Yeah.
5:18 Tig Notaro? I rested my foot of the busted knee on the fork of my bike and use the other one to pedal nearly 50 miles.
5:29 Fortune Feimster? Whoa.
5:30 Tig Notaro? And I kept picturing that my right thigh was going to be three times the size of my left by the time I reached Portland, Maine. But that's not the only time I just, in general, I just, I don't, I don't, I just don't feel.
5:44 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
5:45 Tig Notaro? Um, work, um, sports, any, any of that kind of stuff. I'm just like, I just don't, I don't feel it.
5:54 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
5:54 Mae Martin? I think you should introduce, instead of 20 questions, I play hide the peanut, where one person hides a peanut metaphorically somewhere in the universe. And then you have yes or no questions to find this peanut. It could be in the past, the present, the future. It could be in a fictional place, a real place. And you'd be amazed how quickly you whittle down like the whole universe and find this peanut.
6:18 Tig Notaro? And you have, you have played this?
6:20 Mae Martin? This is, I play it all the time.
6:22 Tig Notaro? All the time.
6:24 Mae Martin? Yeah.
6:24 Tig Notaro? All the time. Try and pull May from the hide the peanut game.
6:28 Mae Martin? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
6:30 Fortune Feimster? Peanut.
6:30 Mae Martin? I'll hide one right now if you want.
6:31 Fortune Feimster? Oh, my Lord.
6:33 Mae Martin? I've hidden one.
6:34 Tig Notaro? I'm not good at these games.
6:36 Fortune Feimster? So we have to guess where it is?
6:37 Mae Martin? Yeah, yes or no questions.
6:39 Fortune Feimster? Um, is it in space?
6:41 Mae Martin? No.
6:42 Tig Notaro? Is it on Earth?
6:44 Mae Martin? Yeah.
6:44 Tig Notaro? Okay, then what is it? That's how I am.
6:47 Fortune Feimster? Is it in, is it in Los Angeles?
6:49 Mae Martin? No.
6:50 Fortune Feimster? Is it in California?
6:51 Mae Martin? No.
6:52 Tig Notaro? England?
6:53 Mae Martin? No.
6:54 Fortune Feimster? Is it in Toronto?
6:55 Mae Martin? Yes.
6:56 Fortune Feimster? Oh, okay. Is it in the room with you now?
6:59 Mae Martin? Yes.
7:00 Fortune Feimster? Okay, Tig.
7:02 Tig Notaro? Just tell us, just tell us.
7:04 Mae Martin? No, you're so close.
7:05 Fortune Feimster? Is it, is it, um, on, on your body?
7:10 Mae Martin? Yes, in a way.
7:11 Tig Notaro? I give up. What is it?
7:13 Fortune Feimster? In a way? Well, Tig, we've narrowed it down so much.
7:18 Tig Notaro? I don't like games.
7:19 Fortune Feimster? By we, I mean me, you've contributed nothing.
7:22 Tig Notaro? I don't, I don't like games.
7:23 Mae Martin? Where do you think I would keep a peanut? On my person?
7:27 Tig Notaro? In your shoe.
7:28 Mae Martin? Mm-mm.
7:29 Fortune Feimster? In your ear?
7:30 Mae Martin? Mm-mm.
7:31 Tig Notaro? Pocket.
7:32 Fortune Feimster? Is it in your hat?
7:33 Mae Martin? No.
7:35 Tig Notaro? Mouth.
7:36 Mae Martin? Think about the pod.
7:37 Fortune Feimster? Oh, uh, under, behind a picture frame?
7:41 Mae Martin? No.
7:43 Fortune Feimster? Think about the pod?
7:44 Tig Notaro? Ponties, it's in your ponties.
7:45 Mae Martin? It's in my ponties, it's in my ponties.
7:47 Tig Notaro? Look at that. I got it, look at that.
7:50 Mae Martin? You got it.
7:51 Fortune Feimster? I thought you were gonna be useless and then you really came through at the end.
7:54 Tig Notaro? That's truly how I play with Stephanie when she's like wanting to do, uh, 20 questions with me, you know, and then I'll, I'll guess some things. I'm like, what, what is it? What is it? I don't, just where?
8:07 Fortune Feimster? You just give up?
8:09 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
8:10 Fortune Feimster? I think I wanna, um, there's a lot of games that I used to play that I've not played in many, many years, um, and then I wanna come back to playing again.
8:18 Mae Martin? Like what?
8:19 Tig Notaro? Hopscotch, hopscotch.
8:20 Fortune Feimster? Is this any, any board game? When people will mention board games, I'm like, oh, I don't remember how that goes. Uno, I don't remember how that's played.
8:26 Mae Martin? Yeah, me neither, actually.
8:28 Fortune Feimster? I don't know, just any kind of game.
8:30 Mae Martin? I wonder if we could make a handsome board game that's like Monopoly, but all the places are, you know, there's a pontoon, you can, or, or, you know, a button factory.
8:41 Fortune Feimster? I'm a pontoon.
8:42 Mae Martin? Actually, if anyone's listening and wants to make a handsome.
8:46 Tig Notaro? If anyone's listening.
8:48 Fortune Feimster? If anyone is listening to this pod, let us know.
8:52 Tig Notaro? I love that song.
8:53 Mae Martin? Papa, can you hear me?
8:55 Fortune Feimster? Papa, can you hear me? I should text Phillip and ask Little Big Town to do a question.
9:01 Tig Notaro? Oh, yeah.
9:01 Fortune Feimster? And tell them that Handsome's favorite pontoon song is On The Pontoon.
9:07 Mae Martin? Well, why don't we get Barbara Streisand to ask a question?
9:12 Fortune Feimster? We don't have any contact with Barbara Streisand.
9:14 Tig Notaro? Yeah, what brought up Barbara Streisand?
9:16 Mae Martin? Because of Yentl, Papa, can you hear me?
9:19 Tig Notaro? Oh. Yeah, but we have to have some sort of in.
9:23 Fortune Feimster? We just did with Babs.
9:25 Tig Notaro? Oh, my God, if Babs sent in a video.
9:28 Mae Martin? I'd die.
9:29 Fortune Feimster? Hello, Handsome.
9:30 Tig Notaro? That would be, that's impossible, right?
9:33 Fortune Feimster? I think it's impossible. She's not really wanting to talk to anybody.
9:39 Mae Martin? I feel like it's actually more impossible than, say, Obama, Paul McCartney, like, the big name. Like, Babs is really unreachable, I think.
9:46 Tig Notaro? Oprah.
9:47 Fortune Feimster? She has, like, a mall in her house.
9:49 Mae Martin? Yeah. Where she can go, she has a mall in her basement where she can go shopping for antique dolls, I think. Like, there's shops.
9:58 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, my friends have been there. Because I did, I did this show called Life in Pieces. Uh, it was on CBS a few years back, and her husband was on the show. And Barbara invited the ladies of the show, but the series regulars, to their freaking house for lunch when they were doing this show, and they got to take a tour and see all this stuff. And I couldn't believe it.
10:22 Mae Martin? Oh, my God.
10:23 Fortune Feimster? I was not as, I was a recurring character, but not a series regular. So I wasn't in that, but I would have died to go.
10:31 Mae Martin? Imagine having a mall in your, a mall in your house.
10:34 Tig Notaro? I would never want.
10:35 Fortune Feimster? Very confused.
10:36 Tig Notaro? I, I'm so confused.
10:38 Fortune Feimster? She also cloned her dog, I think, right?
10:41 Mae Martin? She cloned her dog multiple times.
10:42 Tig Notaro? I can understand that. I can't understand having a mall in your house.
10:46 Mae Martin? Well, she wants to have a normal experience, and she can't just go to the mall, so she.
10:50 Tig Notaro? And that's a normal experience, is having a mall in your house?
10:54 Fortune Feimster? Memories like the corner of my mind.
10:59 Tig Notaro? I stand by guilty being the best.
11:02 Fortune Feimster? And we got nothing to be guilty of. I'm a.
11:09 Fortune Feimster? I don't remember the words.
11:21 Mae Martin? I'm amazed that she's not on the pod.
11:24 Fortune Feimster? That song is a jam, Tig, you're right.
11:26 Tig Notaro? Oh, my God, guilty. And my favorite, favorite line, or part of the song, is that make it a crime to be lonely or sad.
11:36 Fortune Feimster? Make it a crime, yes.
11:38 Tig Notaro? Make it a crime, have the police pull over and lock you up.
11:42 Fortune Feimster? Are you lonely or sad? This is illegal.
11:46 Mae Martin? But are they cheating on their spouses and they're saying, we got, we don't have to be guilty.
11:52 Fortune Feimster? Is that what it's about?
11:53 Mae Martin? I think it's about an affair and they're like.
11:55 Fortune Feimster? Oh, no.
11:57 Mae Martin? Sorry.
12:01 Fortune Feimster? I'm gonna Google this.
12:03 Tig Notaro? Yeah. Is Babs guilty?
12:06 Mae Martin? Yeah, should Babs be guilty? Um, I got an update for you guys.
12:12 Tig Notaro? Oh.
12:12 Mae Martin? Well, I don't know if it was on a Minnesota or if I was talking about how I have a foosball table.
12:19 Mae Martin? Did I tell you guys that? Yeah. And my, my friend, Matt, who lives in my back house, he's like incredible at foosball and I played him thousands of times. I've only beat him three times and it's really something he's good at. And so I Googled, he's new to LA. And I found a foosball competition in Angel City Brewery and it's the only one in LA. It's every Thursday. And I was like, Matt, we should sign up. And boy, do we take it seriously. Every morning he's like, hey, buddy, do you mind practicing with me? Like, he was really driven and we got dressed up. The day came, we were nervous. I was like, we're gonna be on their turf, whoever these foosball people are.
12:58 Tig Notaro? Turf.
12:59 Mae Martin? Yeah, like they could be like jocks or savants, like foosball savants. Anyway, guys, we won the tournament.
13:09 Fortune Feimster? What?
13:10 Mae Martin? You know why?
13:11 Fortune Feimster? Why?
13:11 Mae Martin? Cause no one else showed up.
13:14 Fortune Feimster? Oh, my God.
13:15 Tig Notaro? Congrats, May.
13:16 Mae Martin? It was so embarrassing.
13:19 Fortune Feimster? Wow.
13:20 Mae Martin? It was more embarrassing than losing was just waiting there with the signup sheet at the bar. We signed up and just no one came. And so me and Matt just played.
13:29 Fortune Feimster? Dang.
13:30 Mae Martin? Where's the foosball community?
13:32 Fortune Feimster? Where? Well, do you know the comedian Kelsey Cook?
13:35 Mae Martin? Kelsey Cook?
13:36 Fortune Feimster? Y'all might not have crossed paths. She lives in Minneapolis now. She used to live in LA, but she's an incredible foosball player and plays in like tournaments and stuff, so.
13:44 Mae Martin? Really? You know, so is Lisa Gilroy and, uh, but she wins largely because her shit talk is so funny that you're like doubled over. She does this thing where she goes, you want it? You want it? Well, you can't have it.
14:00 Fortune Feimster? So you're telling me Lisa Gilroy is funny?
14:02 Mae Martin? Oh, man.
14:06 Mae Martin? You want it? You want it? But you can't have it. I, and you can't like, your muscles get weak from laughing. It's a really good, but she is also a great player.
14:15 Fortune Feimster? I like that, the, the, um, table shuffleboard game, you know, at a bar?
14:20 Mae Martin? Yeah.
14:21 Fortune Feimster? The big, long one that you do with your hands?
14:24 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
14:25 Fortune Feimster? With the salts?
14:26 Tig Notaro? Mm-hmm.
14:26 Fortune Feimster? I love those. There, you put, there's like salt on the board or whatever.
14:30 Mae Martin? Oh, to make it slide?
14:31 Fortune Feimster? It helps it slide. I love that game.
14:34 Mae Martin? Maybe I have to get one of those.
14:36 Tig Notaro? Are you going for a full-on bachelor pad, Matt, May?
14:39 Mae Martin? It's becoming, do you almost call me Max?
14:42 Tig Notaro? I don't know. I just, my mouth is moving and sounds come out.
14:46 Fortune Feimster? I don't know.
14:49 Mae Martin? I am, it's becoming Pee-wee's Playhouse, my house. It's, I bought a Zoltar machine. I,
14:55 Tig Notaro? What is that?
14:56 Mae Martin? You know, like from Big that tells your fortune? And it's Zoltar.
15:00 Tig Notaro? Oh. So you have one of those in your house?
15:03 Mae Martin? I thought I'd ordered a full-size. It shows up, it's this big. It's, it's like,
15:08 Tig Notaro? You wanted full-size.
15:10 Mae Martin? I wanted full-size.
15:11 Fortune Feimster? I think the smaller one's better, no?
15:13 Mae Martin? Why?
15:14 Fortune Feimster? Cause it's not some giant head.
15:18 Mae Martin? I want the giant one.
15:21 Fortune Feimster? Funny. I gotta come to this bachelor pad at some point to see what's happening over there.
15:25 Mae Martin? I'll get that shuffleboard game if it'll make you come. I mean, that sounds.
15:39 Fortune Feimster? We're very mature over here.
15:41 Mae Martin? It was so pure art.
15:42 Fortune Feimster? So are you, are you loving this house? It seems like this was a good investment, huh?
15:47 Mae Martin? Loving this house. Yeah, I really am. Yeah.
15:50 Tig Notaro? And it feels like home now? Cause I had asked you in the early days, is it feeling like home? You said no.
15:55 Mae Martin? Yeah, it is feeling like home. Yeah. Yeah. And, and like a real homeowner, like stuff is breaking and then I gotta get it fixed and that kinda like it all.
16:05 Tig Notaro? It's such a, I'm, I'm jealous of that feeling of, um, the beginning of trying to make a house feel like a home. Like it's such a fun, new experience.
16:17 Mae Martin? Yeah, it really is.
16:18 Tig Notaro? Where you like go to bed at night at first and you're like, oh, this is a strange room. This is, where am I? And then boom, one day you are home.
16:29 Mae Martin? Yeah, yeah. And no one can kick you out. No landlord's gonna say.
16:34 Fortune Feimster? As long as you pay your bills.
16:35 Tig Notaro? Well, I mean, did you buy your house outright? Because people could.
16:39 Mae Martin? What do you mean? No.
16:41 Tig Notaro? All right. Do you have a mortgage?
16:42 Mae Martin? Yeah.
16:43 Tig Notaro? They could kick you out if you don't. Yeah, you have to keep paying.
16:47 Mae Martin? But I'm, who's gonna kick me out? The bank?
16:49 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
16:49 Tig Notaro? Yes, they will. Take your house.
16:51 Mae Martin? Yeah. No, I mean, I mean, I'll pay the mortgage.
16:54 Tig Notaro? The bank will be like, this is mine. Thank you. Bye bye. I already bought this. Get out of my house, bank.
17:08 Fortune Feimster? I still have so many things not on the walls at my house and I've been here two and a half years.
17:14 Mae Martin? Yes, I, maybe you need some big arts. I'm like a big giant.
17:18 Fortune Feimster? Well, I don't know if I'll end up selling this place and I kinda want something smaller.
17:23 Mae Martin? Right.
17:23 Fortune Feimster? It's, it's too big and now it's just me. So.
17:27 Mae Martin? You wanna move into my back house with Matt and his girlfriend?
17:29 Fortune Feimster? Well, that's definitely too small.
17:33 Fortune Feimster? I would like, uh, my, my last house I adored. It was the best and I made it exactly how I wanted it. It was a little too small, so I want something in between these two.
17:43 Mae Martin? It's a good, like, fresh start. I mean, I, I was post-breakup, bought the house and it was distracting and, uh, felt empowering to like, make your space your own. Yeah.
17:57 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I'm not in a hurry. It might not be anytime soon, but at some point.
18:01 Mae Martin? Tell us that you're gonna bring that fake plant with you if you move.
18:05 Fortune Feimster? This is coming everywhere with me. I love that this is.
18:08 Mae Martin? First thing you pack.
18:09 Fortune Feimster? This is how I'm zhuzhing up my Zoom box.
18:14 Tig Notaro? Where do I put my plastic plant?
18:18 Fortune Feimster? I might make this other room in here a little handsome spot with a chair and everything. You guys just wait to see.
18:25 Tig Notaro? What do you mean a handsome spot?
18:27 Fortune Feimster? Like a little corner of this room, I might put like a chair and like hang something up on the wall. Definitely the fake plant.
18:35 Tig Notaro? But I mean handsome, meaning when you record handsome?
18:38 Fortune Feimster? When I record, that will be my spot. Yeah.
18:40 Tig Notaro? Okay, alright.
18:41 Fortune Feimster? Right now, I'm just at my desk, but I might make a designated handsome spot.
18:46 Mae Martin? Do you think you'll ever move, Tig? Like, like when the boys go off to college or whatever, would you guys move?
18:51 Tig Notaro? Um, we have talked about, um, yeah, potentially selling our house when they graduate and just moving back into our office, which is, you know, just a little bungalow, um, that we love very much.
19:08 Mae Martin? It's kind of a sexy vibe, the office. It's, it's, it's unusual, the layout and there's like, it's, it's stained glass and stuff, right? It's beautiful, yeah.
19:18 Tig Notaro? Yeah, we really love it there and, um, and our, and we love where we live now. We just, I don't know if I've mentioned this or not, but we have never.
19:29 Tig Notaro? Like done our house.
19:31 Mae Martin? Yeah.
19:31 Tig Notaro? Because we moved in when Max and Finn were one and they were so nuts that we didn't even have furniture in the living room for the first, like till they were two.
19:42 Mae Martin? You've never like adultified the house.
19:45 Tig Notaro? No. And then by the time they finally kind of calmed down, we never put art on the walls. We just, we were, we just had these two little lunatics running around. And then by the time they kind of pulled it together, it was a pandemic and then we couldn't even deal with, you know,
20:01 Mae Martin? Shopping.
20:02 Tig Notaro? Doing, doing our house or having somebody come in. And then, so now we're getting to that place where we're like, Max and Finn are so chill. And the pandemic's over and let's actually do something with our house.
20:17 Mae Martin? Did you ever watch those like extreme home makeover shows where like they always, they ask the kids what they're into? And then they'll say one thing and then they'll turn the room and like they'll go, I kind of like horses. And then they'll run with it and they'll turn the bedroom into like a barn. And the kids are always like, okay, I don't know if I'm that into horses. Yeah. Maybe I'll redo your house. You tell me what you're into and then I'll surprise you with Zoltar.
20:44 Tig Notaro? Yeah. Stephanie wouldn't, that wouldn't fly with her. She's not chill with what is in the house. So I, I know right away Zoltar wouldn't fly. Or any surprises.
20:57 Mae Martin? Yeah, okay.
20:58 Tig Notaro? Not, not one surprise will fly.
21:02 Tig Notaro? I mean, to be fair, I don't know that I'd want Zoltar in the house.
21:05 Mae Martin? Yeah, that's fair. Max and Finn might be into him.
21:07 Tig Notaro? Yeah, I think for sure. But um, maybe you could surprise them and put one in there. Well, you have, they each have their own room, so.
21:15 Mae Martin? It's two, that's two full size Zoltars.
21:17 Tig Notaro? Mm hmm.
21:18 Mae Martin? That's great.
21:19 Tig Notaro? Should we um, get into our uh, question?
21:22 Mae Martin? Yes. I'm really excited about today's question asker. I feel like this has been a long time coming because this is a friend of the pod, Alison Brie. Um, oh, I already gave away her name, but um,
21:36 Tig Notaro? Still a friend.
21:37 Fortune Feimster? Still a friend. Still Alison Brie. Handsome pod and is really awesome.
21:43 Mae Martin? She's the best and she's an actor, writer, producer, best known for her starring roles on Mad Men and Community. She was nominated for a Golden Globe for playing Ruth on Glow and has appeared in films like Somebody I Used to Know and Promising Young Woman. And her new movie with her husband, Dave Franco, together, which is apparently so terrifying and I can't wait to see it. Alison Brie is asking today's question.
22:09 Tig Notaro? Nice.
22:10 Speaker 04 Hi, Handsoms, Alison Brie here. Um, huge fan Tig, May, Fortune, big fan of all three of you. Huge fan of the pod. Okay, this is Otis. My question is, was there ever a time?
22:32 Speaker 04 Was there ever a time in your life where you consciously decided to try on a different personality? And how did it go? I'll give you an example that's not my answer, which is that a friend of mine in high school switched schools, um, like sophomore year. And at the other school, she went by her middle name and just had like a totally different personality. And then when she left that school, she just went back to using her regular name, her first name. Um, have you ever done anything like that and how'd it go?
23:10 Tig Notaro? First of all, I did not realize um, that Alison Brie was gonna be a part of Kitty City.
23:17 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, she's a Kitty City gal. Otis. Otis was really getting in there.
23:23 Tig Notaro? I know. And I loved her attention to Otis when he came in for kisses when she was mid-question.
23:33 Tig Notaro? Yeah. She's got her priorities straight. Is that normal cat behavior? I thought they were more standoffish. They can be standoffish, but man, can they be snuggly, lovey dovey. And all, all three of our cats are very standoffish and lovey dovey. I've never had a cat.
23:52 Mae Martin? Otis had like a, almost a dog vibe, but that's a kind of a dog name, Otis. And then, yeah, he was, yeah. I love that question because I'm constantly paranoid that I'm accidentally changing my personality. Like, I, I feel like I have a loose grip on my personality and I'm, I'm up for it, changing like.
24:13 Tig Notaro? Is sort of, is it easily influenced?
24:17 Mae Martin? Not as much anymore, but definitely as a teenager, oh my God, like, and, and really similar experience was I would go to summer camp every summer and I'd kind of decide who I was going to be or see when I got there, like,
24:30 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
24:30 Mae Martin? what would be most useful socially. And I think I've said this on the pod, but I went to camp one summer and I go, yeah, I'm May, but everybody calls, calls me maple sugar. And everyone's like, no, they don't. I'm like, no one called me that and it didn't catch on. And then I was always acting really tortured and kind of mysterious and like, yeah, I got some stuff going on back home.
24:57 Tig Notaro? And wait, what, what made you think maple sugar? What'd you say? Maple syrup?
25:03 Mae Martin? Maple sugar.
25:03 Tig Notaro? Maple sugar was, was cool?
25:06 Mae Martin? I think cause May Pearl is my first name.
25:09 Tig Notaro? Yes, which I love.
25:11 Mae Martin? Thanks. I think it was cause um, it was middle school. So it was just in the two-year period where I had long hair, the only time in my life. And I think I was keenly aware that I, I was not feminine enough, like, and all these cool girls were in my cabin. And I thought, maple sugar sounds kind of like a cool femme name. Like I would maybe be a cheerleader or something. And it did not fly.
25:36 Tig Notaro? Give it up for maple sugar, y'all.
25:40 Mae Martin? It's such a long nickname too, like.
25:43 Fortune Feimster? It's like a drag name.
25:44 Tig Notaro? Yeah, that of my three letter name. They call me this sentence.
25:49 Mae Martin? Yeah.
25:52 Fortune Feimster? You think you were like telling people you had a lot of stuff going on back home, hoping they would be like, what's going on? Tell, tell us like, like an attention thing?
26:00 Tig Notaro? And would you tell them what was going on? Or would you make up like, well, my dad's a bandit and.
26:06 Mae Martin? I think I did lie quite a bit in around that time, like middle school era. Like I definitely had a fake boyfriend and.
26:15 Mae Martin? But it was.
26:15 Tig Notaro? I mean, don't we all?
26:16 Mae Martin? Don't we all? It was like, it was this friend of mine, Cliff Cardinal. He wrote me a letter at camp and then I decided to pretend that the letter was like my from, he was just my friend.
26:28 Fortune Feimster? Like a love letter.
26:29 Mae Martin? I had a crush on him. Yeah. And I pretended it was like, there's some stuff going on with my boyfriend. Like he's having a tough time. And I wouldn't let anyone read the letter.
26:37 Fortune Feimster? Because would not believe what is in this letter.
26:40 Mae Martin? Yeah.
26:42 Mae Martin? Burning it really quick.
26:45 Tig Notaro? It's very private. Don't even ask.
26:48 Mae Martin? And the letter was like, hey, bro, hope you're having a good time.
26:53 Mae Martin? Yeah. What about you guys? Like, I take, I feel like you were genuinely to your core, that, that cowboy person. So you weren't, it wasn't, it wasn't an affectation.
27:05 Tig Notaro? No, I mean, I definitely leaned more into it and you know, I, I was, I was a little rebel.
27:15 Tig Notaro? Chip on my shoulder. I've, you know, I'm still working through all of it as an adult.
27:20 Mae Martin? Yeah.
27:20 Tig Notaro? You gotta have your, you have to have your little shell to protect you and use your whatever personality, part of your personality to hide everything. So, um, yeah, but I, I was really, you know, the kid that was off in the woods and in the creek and smoking and failing and, um, sneaking out of the house and doing all that, you know, driving around in the car without a license when I could barely look over the steering wheel. Like that is all factual. I have many people that can back up all of this information about me. But, um, I would say like on an unfortunate kind of like.
28:02 Tig Notaro? Really unfortunate level. The times that I have changed my personality has been when I've felt fearful, you know, in like a public bathroom or something. You know, you get like weird looks or, you know, how do you, who are you? How do you identify? And I've noticed myself sometimes trying to like fem it up a little bit when I go in the bathroom, you know? And then I just think, God, it's so pathetic that, that I would have to, to do that.
28:37 Mae Martin? Yeah.
28:38 Tig Notaro? So, um, no real funny story there, but, um, but yeah, that's really the, the time that I, I, I notice it the most. And, and that's a point that I always use to people that, you know, any sort of confusion somebody has around, um, trans people or non-binary people, it's like.
28:58 Mae Martin? It ends up policing all, all women.
29:00 Tig Notaro? The whole, everybody.
29:02 Mae Martin? Like cis women as well.
29:03 Tig Notaro? Everybody, everybody, you know? And so, yeah, it's, it's just a weird little moment in life where I'm like, excuse me, come and see. Not really. Excuse me, I'm just trying to get in the stall.
29:18 Speaker 00 I just have to go peepee. I have to tinkle.
29:21 Tig Notaro? I can't believe I didn't wear my dress today because it'd be so much easier to just fling that thing up in the air.
29:29 Fortune Feimster? I've been called sir in several bathrooms and I'm like, really?
29:33 Tig Notaro? You get called sir?
29:34 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I've, I've had a woman once in an airport bathroom be like, this is the women's restroom. I'm like, yep.
29:41 Tig Notaro? I know, I've said the same thing. I'm like, oh, that works out perfectly.
29:44 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
29:45 Mae Martin? Yeah, it's, that is, it always feels like a minefield to me constantly on guard. Did you guys ever, when you first started comedy, like, and you're in, in love with comedy and you're in green rooms with more experienced comedians, like try to adopt the persona of a comedian almost like, like, yeah, good, good set. Yeah, I like the tag. Like, oh, I could, you know what I mean? Like I, I was so excited to be part of that community that I'm sure I was like. You know, with my little notebook and trying to.
30:15 Tig Notaro? And then dropping your voice a little like, yeah, yeah, yeah. Nice, nice. Sweet.
30:19 Mae Martin? Yeah.
30:20 Tig Notaro? I don't know. I don't know. That doesn't feel familiar. It doesn't feel as familiar as me saying, excuse me. I just have to get a tampon out of my purse.
30:31 Mae Martin? Yeah.
30:32 Tig Notaro? I gotta plug my cooter.
30:34 Mae Martin? I gotta plug my cooter.
30:37 Tig Notaro? You hear that in a stall in the bathroom.
30:41 Tig Notaro? Got to plug my cooter.
30:48 Mae Martin? Fortune, what about going to college after living in a small town like?
30:52 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
30:52 Mae Martin? Like, that's a chance to be a different person.
30:56 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I was like cognizant of like not changing too much because um, my mom, she listens to this, like, oh, don't worry, you're bringing this up. But my mom used to, back in the day, whenever she would, after my parents divorced, she went through a couple of relationships. And in those relationships, she significantly changed to um, be who she thought that that that those particular men wanted her to be. So that always bugged me because I was just, I didn't understand it. I was young and I was like, why are you being somebody or not?
31:39 Fortune Feimster? And in the most extreme version of that, one was, he was very conservative. I talked about this in my Sweet and Salty special where he just, like, my family had gone to Hooters their whole life and he just was like,
31:53 Tig Notaro? Oh, yeah, yeah.
31:53 Fortune Feimster? Not into that stuff. And she was like, I have never been to Hooters in front of him. And.
32:01 Tig Notaro? Although I have been to Cooters.
32:05 Fortune Feimster? And even though that story is very funny, it's based on her completely changing for this person.
32:12 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
32:12 Fortune Feimster? So I always had that in the back of my head of like, not veering too far off.
32:20 Fortune Feimster? But you know, when you're young, you're still kind of trying to find yourself. So you have to sort of try on different hats to see like, well, who am I? And so younger days, sports was a big part of my personality. But then in college, I had this weird thing. I hung out with a lot of church going people. And so I kind of tried that on for a while, like, oh, I'm a church gal.
32:49 Fortune Feimster? And yeah, that was probably the most, the biggest swing away from my personality.
32:57 Tig Notaro? But you do love the Lord, right?
32:59 Fortune Feimster? I love the Lord.
33:03 Mae Martin? But you're just looking for community, right?
33:06 Fortune Feimster? I think I was looking for community and, and my family was pretty fractured at the time. My grandmother had just passed and, and I was a bit lost. So my, my grandmother died the day after I moved into college. So I was experiencing this, um, brand new school. I didn't know anybody. I was lost. I was sad. Um, and so those are the times when you're the most susceptible to any influence. And so I met some really great people, um, who were religious and kind of was like, well, let me see what they're doing. I like hanging out with them and their church was all about family and stuff. And I think
33:48 Fortune Feimster? it like, made me want family and crave, um, that. And so I thought, well, if I do that, then I can have, I can create a family for myself one day and just, you know, eventually realized that, oh, this is not me at all. Um, but uh, yeah, and then I tried like theater um, in college too, and maybe I'm a theater kid and I liked it. But it was in, in the irony is that I act now, but I'm not a theater kid. Um.
34:21 Mae Martin? Really? I feel like you got the some theater kid and you like a musical.
34:25 Fortune Feimster? I love a musical.
34:26 Mae Martin? Yeah.
34:26 Fortune Feimster? But you know that dramatic like.
34:28 Mae Martin? Oh, right. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
34:29 Fortune Feimster? Like expressing yourself and what in big ways. I'm not quite that.
34:36 Mae Martin? Yeah.
34:37 Fortune Feimster? And so then when I moved to, when I eventually moved to LA, it was when I came out, I think. Um, was like, anything up until coming out was like, I'm sort of blowing with the wind here.
34:48 Mae Martin? Yeah.
34:49 Fortune Feimster? I come out and then I'm like, oh, I know, I know who I am. And I'm, and it just set me on this journey of like, like being so much more comfortable in my own skin.
35:03 Mae Martin? Yeah.
35:04 Fortune Feimster? Doing what I wanted to do, not trying to fit in elsewhere or, you know, it just, that was the thing that really set me on my path.
35:14 Mae Martin? Took off your bonnet.
35:16 Fortune Feimster? And took off my, and then, and I would say right in this present day time, going through all the changes I'm going through. The one thing I've realized is I know myself better than I ever have. And I am so much clearer on what I want.
35:32 Mae Martin? That's great.
35:33 Fortune Feimster? Ever been.
35:34 Mae Martin? I guess it keeps changing your whole life till, till you croak, right? We're, yeah, and that fluidity is so important.
35:43 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
35:43 Mae Martin? When you started doing comedy, did you guys try different, like, I feel like I just impersonated other comedians sometimes if I got excited about us. Like I, like trying to be like. Bill Hicks or whatever, when I was like 14 and that's like, that's not me.
35:59 Tig Notaro? Oh my gosh, can you get me some video of you 14? Doing your best Bill Hicks?
36:05 Mae Martin? Well, I used to smoke cigarettes onstage because you could still do that.
36:09 Tig Notaro? When you were 14?
36:10 Mae Martin? Yes, and I did one time get booed offstage because.
36:13 Tig Notaro? And do you have footage of this?
36:15 Mae Martin? No.
36:16 Tig Notaro? Because I'm gonna need to see it.
36:17 Fortune Feimster? You got booed offstage because they didn't like you smoking?
36:20 Mae Martin? It was a New Year's Eve show. I was 16 and me and my boyfriend at the time did like two-person stand-up. He, he was much older. We said we were siblings. It was weird. But anyway, we were smoking and we were just very like misanthropic and negative. And we didn't realize that people had paid for this $100 for this New Year's Eve gala. And everyone was making a real effort and we'd barely prepared anything and we were smoking. We thought we were so cool. And everyone was like, why is this child smoking? And what, and, and so they started going, nah, enough. And they were right. They were. They were like, enough. Enough for this, yeah.
36:57 Tig Notaro? First of all, why aren't children smoking?
36:59 Mae Martin? I know.
37:00 Tig Notaro? As a child, I don't know how, like, we were watching a movie the other night with Max and Finn. And there was chewing tobacco that some of the kids in the movie were chewing. And Max and Finn are like, what is chewing tobacco? They're nine and I was chewing tobacco. I was dipping. I was smoking. If I couldn't get my hands on any of that stuff, I would roll coffee grounds and typing paper. I was just like, how on earth? I'm truly looking at them like they are aliens. You don't know what chewing tobacco is?
37:39 Mae Martin? But these younger generations are much more pure than we were, I think. It's not in, it's not in movies as much. Like, what were you watching? The Sandlot Kids or something?
37:48 Tig Notaro? Yeah, we were watching The Sandlot. Yeah.
37:50 Mae Martin? Oh, I want to re-watch it.
37:52 Fortune Feimster? I used to watch The Sandlot back in the day.
37:55 Tig Notaro? Yeah, but they're, they're just like, and they have, they have questions about cigarettes. And I'm like, I, yeah, I guess I don't know where they would have ever run off and experimented with anything like that. But because my parents were certainly not keeping an eye on.
38:13 Fortune Feimster? But cigarettes are way more taboo now than back then. Back then, I felt like people just smoked all the time.
38:19 Tig Notaro? It was taboo for me to be eight smoking cigarettes.
38:23 Fortune Feimster? Well, eight.
38:25 Fortune Feimster? That's wild.
38:27 Mae Martin? My parents smoked in the house and yeah, it was very, it was, I mean, it was every restaurant you go to and yeah.
38:35 Fortune Feimster? But I did not miss those days.
38:37 Mae Martin? Did you always have the same style on stage or in the beginning where you're like, hey, everybody, what's up? I'm Tig. I gotta, I gotta march in that.
38:46 Tig Notaro? Yeah, I, I feel like, I mean, I was so influenced by Paula Poundstone. I always, I love Paula Poundstone's ability to write just such a solid, silly joke and then also be able to do the most tremendous crowd interaction.
39:13 Fortune Feimster? All the crowd work is unbelievable.
39:15 Tig Notaro? I mean, unreal. And I mean, I used to, she was the one comedian I would always go see. I would never miss a Paula Poundstone concert, no matter where I lived, no matter how old I was.
39:26 Mae Martin? Really?
39:26 Tig Notaro? Um, oh yeah, absolutely. And she's just ridiculous. But, um, that was my goal was to be a good storyteller, joke writer, and be able to interact with the audience. And I don't know that I ever felt like, oh, I'm just a carbon copy of Paula Poundstone. You know, I was never in like suspenders and a bow tie or anything like that, which thank God she's still wearing to this day. She has not, she is Paula Poundstone through and through.
40:01 Mae Martin? She was born in suspenders.
40:03 Tig Notaro? Oh, my God. This person is Paula Poundstone. I mean, her name says what she, I don't, I
40:11 Tig Notaro? You know what I mean?
40:12 Mae Martin? Yeah, you gotta be a comedian, yeah.
40:14 Tig Notaro? You are Paula, this is Paula Poundstone. Anyway, you know, I certainly had moments, like I was very, in like more recent comedy influence, I certainly loved Mitch Hedberg.
40:30 Mae Martin? Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah.
40:31 Tig Notaro? I mean, you know, even though I wasn't.
40:33 Mae Martin? Dry and, yeah.
40:35 Tig Notaro? Yeah, it just spoke to me. It definitely spoke to me.
40:37 Mae Martin? It takes confidence, I think, to sit, to be okay with silence, to be slow like that. And so I feel like it would take, yeah, I'm still not there where I can do that. But like, did it take you a while to settle and to know you had the skill to like, sit in that and then pull people out of it?
40:58 Tig Notaro? Well, I think for myself, like as a comedian, all the different things I've tried, from joke writing to storytelling, I've done prop stuff, not like in a traditional way of like I roll out of, you know, a case of.
41:12 Mae Martin? Tarantula.
41:13 Tig Notaro? Yeah, but I want to try everything. And then I feel like all of those roads that you go down, you still, even if it's such a leap from another type of comedy, you still find your voice in there. And I think that that's what I realized was every road I went down, here's my voice. Here's my voice. So I can do whatever I want to do.
41:36 Mae Martin? You know what I liked? I just, I keep talking about it because I'm obsessed, but the Pee Wee Herman documentary, the Paul Rubens documentary, I didn't realize that Pee Wee started as a character who was a stand-up comedian who was doing it for the first time and showing and had props that were his toys. He was kind of like, almost like a child stand, so he was in the Pee Wee suit and he'd go out and do bad stand-up and pull out like, you know, a dinosaur toy and show the audience and stuff. But I love that, that that was the genesis, yeah.
42:07 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
42:07 Fortune Feimster? I think he started at The Groundlings.
42:09 Mae Martin? Yeah, you gotta watch that doc.
42:12 Tig Notaro? I'll have to check it out. I for sure want to see that.
42:15 Mae Martin? And by the way, when I was in Nantucket, multiple people were coming up to me to talk about your doc.
42:21 Tig Notaro? Oh, really?
42:22 Mae Martin? Yeah, they're coming up going, hey, I just saw Tig's doc and I wept throughout and I was like, great. Yeah, people are talking about it.
42:31 Fortune Feimster? You find that they, oh, the new doc, I was thinking of Tig. I was thinking of your own documentary.
42:36 Tig Notaro? Andrea Gibson documentary.
42:38 Fortune Feimster? I want to see it.
42:39 Tig Notaro? You will. We're gonna have a screening in LA and then Apple bought it. So we're all very excited that it's gonna reach a wider audience, but it's, man, is it life affirming? And it really, I say to everyone, you, it's impossible to not walk out of that theater and think, what have I been doing with my life?
43:02 Mae Martin? Oh, my God.
43:03 Tig Notaro? I mean, true, but like in the most inspiring, exciting way. Of course, you have all these emotions about Andrea and their partner Meg and, and all these intense, deep, but also so, so many funny moments, but it's just so beautiful and it's just still killing it on the festival circuit. It's crazy. It's crazy, crazy, crazy.
43:28 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I, well, I'm really looking forward to, to seeing it.
43:31 Tig Notaro? Yeah, yeah. Thanks for bringing that up because I, I, tell your friends if you've seen it because it's, it's really worth seeing and so much like, so perfectly time for a big heaping pile of compassion in this world.
43:49 Mae Martin? Yes.
43:50 Tig Notaro? Is what I've seen happen through this film.
43:54 Mae Martin? I kind of feel like, because it is mainly teenagers and kids that are trying on different personalities like that. And I kind of feel like that's, that's a pretty healthy way to be because we're, we're not our personalities. Like that is, even if it's so authentic to you and not on purpose, it is sort of a performance or it's an accumulation of influences and experiences. And there is like a, a core, anyway, I just think maybe we should all be a bit more fluid about our personalities. You could wake up tomorrow, brand new day, you go, I'm really sarcastic today or like I'm, I'm gonna be a ray of sunshine and.
44:31 Fortune Feimster? Yeah. Well, you don't really know how you feel about something or if you're into something unless you try it. So I'm always like. Like, I always think, especially younger people, like, why not sign up for this thing, or join this club, or play that sport, or be in that play? Like, give it a shot.
44:50 Tig Notaro? And I stand by, there is nothing better than finding out what you cannot stand and who you are not, even more so than who you are. You know, like, I love finding out the stuff I, I never want to do again, or I don't want to be in that world, you know? Or whatever, whatever it is. I'm like, I love that as much as I love finding things that I, that make me happy.
45:18 Mae Martin? Yeah, we tell ourselves, so young, we start telling ourselves stories about ourselves, like, I'm bad at math, or like, I'm, you know, I'm funny, or I'm, you know, and, and then, that's like a little coffin for yourself, you know? You gotta break out of it.
45:33 Tig Notaro? I do stand by, I am bad at math, and, you know, my brain just oozes out of my ears as soon as I look at X plus Y times, bleh, bleh, bleh, blah, blah.
45:47 Mae Martin? You just get a handle on math in school, and then they introduce letters and words to it, and it's like,
45:53 Tig Notaro? It's not fair.
45:53 Mae Martin? Why? Or, yeah.
45:56 Fortune Feimster? And now, now my mom is being totally herself, but she has also been single for a very long time.
46:03 Mae Martin? That's, there's something to be said for the single life in terms of really being yourself.
46:08 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
46:09 Tig Notaro? Has your mother ever gotten on apps to date?
46:12 Fortune Feimster? Uh, she did it back in the day. I think, um, when she met her first boyfriend after divorce, it wasn't in an app, but they, you used to put ads in the newspaper.
46:24 Mae Martin? That's the dream.
46:32 Fortune Feimster? You're just looking at each other's grammar. Um, but yeah, she, I believe they met that way.
46:38 Mae Martin? Didn't there used to be a thing where you can, you leave a, a voicemail that's like, hi, I'm, I'm May, I like, you know?
46:46 Fortune Feimster? I think maybe back in the day, there was something like that.
46:49 Tig Notaro? And wait a minute. Right. So people would put an ad in the paper, and you don't have a clue what this person looks like.
46:56 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
46:56 Tig Notaro? You just show up. And there is someone that likes pina coladas and getting caught in the rain.
47:03 Fortune Feimster? And yeah, I, when I first came out, um, Craigslist was super popular, especially, I don't know if it was just in LA, but everybody was on Craigslist at the time. And I, I found like a soccer team and a softball league. I found Ultimate Frisbee. I, I'm still friends with some of the people I met during these Craigslist days. But I, I went on a couple of dates via Craigslist ads and no, it was the no picture days.
47:35 Mae Martin? And was it, was it shocking when you arrived?
47:39 Fortune Feimster? I mean, not one person was, it, it, it wasn't even about looks, but not one person was my type or had anything in common. I went on three dates.
47:50 Tig Notaro? What a shot in the dark.
47:52 Fortune Feimster? Could not get out of all of them fast enough.
47:55 Mae Martin? Yeah.
47:56 Fortune Feimster? Um, and then I was like, I'm not doing this again.
48:00 Tig Notaro? Do you know what? I think I'm remembering this story correctly, but of course, who knows? Um, but let's just assume I am. You know, the comedian and writer Jessie Klein?
48:10 Mae Martin? No, actually.
48:11 Tig Notaro? Okay. She's so funny, but she, she, um, I ran into her. I can't remember where I ran into her, but this was several years ago. She saw a guy in like an airport or a grocery store or something, probably, you know what? Probably an airport. I think they were running to their flights. And she thought to herself, what if he saw me and felt the same? Cause she thought she saw a little, some look in each other's eye type thing. He put an ad in the paper and they reconnected.
48:47 Mae Martin? No.
48:48 Fortune Feimster? Wow.
48:48 Tig Notaro? Yes, yes, yes. This is an actual story. And, um, they weren't a match ultimately. I think he was like a tennis player. I can't believe I remember the details. I was so blown away because they did not talk.
49:05 Mae Martin? Wow.
49:06 Tig Notaro? They just glanced.
49:08 Fortune Feimster? You know, the actor Coleman Domingo?
49:10 Mae Martin? Yeah.
49:11 Fortune Feimster? Um, he's been with his husband now, I think like 14 years. They walked past each other on a street and like kind of both clocked each other and did, I don't know. Maybe it was Craigslist. I don't, one of those sites, they put a missed connection. In there and somehow they saw it each.
49:31 Tig Notaro? Wow.
49:32 Fortune Feimster? Got together.
49:33 Mae Martin? Wow.
49:33 Tig Notaro? Wow.
49:34 Fortune Feimster? Isn't it like a needle on a haystack?
49:37 Tig Notaro? That's like crazy.
49:39 Mae Martin? We gotta bring that back, Miss Miss Connections.
49:42 Tig Notaro? Boy, have we gotten off track here.
49:45 Fortune Feimster? There's no, there's nowhere for Miss, I don't know where people go for Miss Connections now. There's no place.
49:50 Mae Martin? Have to be a website or something. Yeah, yeah.
49:52 Fortune Feimster? But that was a big thing on Craigslist too, was the whole Miss Connections page.
49:56 Tig Notaro? Let's start a handsome Miss Connection website. There we are. We found it.
50:01 Fortune Feimster? Oh no, another thing on the list that I don't know if we're gonna get to it.
50:06 Tig Notaro? Well, should we hear what Allison has to say, even though we went so far away?
50:11 Fortune Feimster? That's, that's what we do here.
50:12 Tig Notaro? That is what we do here. That's, that is the business we are in. Allison, tell us, tell us.
50:19 Speaker 04 Yeah, I've honestly probably done that a bunch, but a time that comes to mind is, uh, when I was in college, I did a semester abroad in Glasgow, Scotland. So I went to a really small school, Cal Arts, it was super incestuous and gossipy. And when I did this semester abroad at an even smaller school, the Royal Scottish Academy of Music and Drama, I made a conscious decision to just have a, a more free personality, I guess. I, I just didn't wanna be self-conscious
51:02 Speaker 04 in any way. And I figured, you know, I'm just gonna, you know, I'm just gonna be going to school with these people for like three to four months. Who cares? Like, what if I got to lose? I should just be like the freest version of myself. And, um, so I did. I just would like, the whole time I was in Glasgow, Scotland, I was having honestly the best time and, and almost being like my truest self, literally would, you know, with headphones in, I would dance down the streets, just dancing down the sidewalks. And in class, I was always like the first person to, uh,
51:49 Speaker 04 Oh my God, Maxie wants to be involved in this question as well. The first person to volunteer to try something like improvised capoeira, just like, put me in, coach, like game for anything. And the students there were like, are you like this all the time? And I was like, no, not really.
52:13 Speaker 04 Once I did it.
52:13 Tig Notaro? This semester.
52:14 Speaker 04 I would say the effect it had was that I realized that that actually is kind of my truest self and my truest personality. And so I just tried to kind of retain a lot of that in my life, uh, moving forward. And I think, I think that I have. It's a good way to be anyway.
52:37 Tig Notaro? That's great.
52:38 Speaker 04 All right, love you, bye.
52:40 Tig Notaro? Love you, mean it.
52:42 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, and you come across people, uh, in your life too, that help bring that out of you as well. That's always nice.
52:47 Tig Notaro? It is weird when somebody brings out a side of you that.
52:51 Mae Martin? Yeah.
52:52 Tig Notaro? You rarely to never see.
52:55 Mae Martin? The goofiest side, the better. Like, I, I went to a dinner party with my friend, Matt, and I guess we'd been very respectable at the dinner party, talking to people we'd never met, you know, getting to know people. And then we left and as we were walking to the Uber, he, he goes, time to be weird. And I was like, yes, that's what I want in a friend.
53:16 Mae Martin? Oh, that's a great answer though from her, yeah.
53:18 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, it is. It's nice to feel free like that, where you're like, just not really editing yourself and.
53:25 Mae Martin? Yeah.
53:26 Fortune Feimster? Yeah.
53:27 Mae Martin? I love, put me in, coach.
53:29 Fortune Feimster? Put me in. I think about try, I think about my days of attempting to be straight. That was a fun.
53:36 Tig Notaro? I can't accept that. I can't accept that. Hey guys, what are you doing?
53:42 Fortune Feimster? That's what takes the bathroom voice.
53:44 Tig Notaro? Yeah, we bump into each other in the bathroom. Excuse me. I'm sorry, I'm on a date. Oh my God, I love your flannel. Where'd you get that, girl?
53:53 Speaker 00 I love your lip taint.
53:54 Tig Notaro? You got it, Forever 21. Sweet.
53:59 Fortune Feimster? This is why I did not go on many dates with guys.
54:05 Fortune Feimster? My best acting work to date.
54:07 Tig Notaro? I know, I was gonna say, that's so perfect for Allison, just like acts like a whole different person.
54:13 Mae Martin? Yeah, and then, and then find out what parts of that you wanna retain. Yeah, I like that.
54:18 Tig Notaro? Yeah.
54:19 Fortune Feimster? Yeah. Well, I was just gonna talk about what's next, what we're, what we're up to. Um, I'm guest hosting Jimmy Kimmel, the, his late night talk show next week. Uh, July 20, let's see, 22nd through 24th. I'll be a, a late night talk show host for three nights.
54:39 Tig Notaro? That is so exciting.
54:41 Mae Martin? Can you slip in a Keep It Handsome?
54:43 Fortune Feimster? I know, I gotta, I gotta, um, so I hope our handsome listeners will tune in. Um, I'm a little nervous, but very excited. I'll be wearing some suits and interviewing some fun people.
54:57 Tig Notaro? Are you gonna bring back your pink suit?
54:59 Fortune Feimster? Not the pink suit, gonna do something different, but, um.
55:03 Tig Notaro? All right.
55:03 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, I'm pumped. This is a, it's a really cool opportunity.
55:06 Tig Notaro? Absolutely.
55:07 Mae Martin? Amazing.
55:08 Tig Notaro? Can't wait to see.
55:09 Fortune Feimster? And then I just have a stand-up, uh, July 20th, uh, in Edmonton with Mateo Lane. Montreal, July 26th, uh, and then starting in September, San Antonio, Houston, Norfolk, Richmond, DC, Atlanta, New Orleans, all those good places.
55:28 Tig Notaro? Excellent places.
55:30 Mae Martin? I'll see you in Montreal.
55:31 Fortune Feimster? Yeah, May, May and I are doing a, a gala together in, uh, Montreal, which I love Montreal. Oh, my God, it's such a great city.
55:40 Tig Notaro? It's so great. It's so great.
55:42 Mae Martin? Also the night before, on the 25th, doing a show at the Olympia for Just for Laughs. But other than that, uh, just check out, I got two new songs out on my muse, my earnest music album, I'm a TV. I got two new, uh, sad songs that I added to it, so they're on Spotify and Spread the Word, Tell Your Pals. What about you, Tig?
56:02 Tig Notaro? Well, I'd love to share with you, August 17th, I'll be at the West Hampton Beach Performing Arts Center in West Hampton Beach, New York. August 23rd, I'll be in P-Town at the Province Town, Town Hall. And then September 27th, Beau Rivage Resort and Casino in Biloxi, Mississippi.
56:23 Tig Notaro? But yeah, oh, and please, share your favorite episode. Also, review and um. Subscribe. Subscribe to the podcast and also to our YouTube page. This is a great community and we feel very lucky for all of you. And so let's keep growing it, shall we? Thank you. Great, until next time. Keep it handsome.
56:50 Mae Martin? Handsome is hosted by me, Mae Martin, Tig Notaro, and Fortune Feimster. The show is produced, recorded, and edited by Thomas Willett. Email us at handsomepod@gmail.com and please follow us on social media at HandsomePod.
57:05 Tig Notaro? What a podcast.
57:11 Speaker 00 That was a HeadGum Podcast.
57:13 Speaker 05 What's going on? It's Lamorne Morris.
57:15 Speaker 06 And Hannah Simone.
57:16 Speaker 05 And we host The Mess Around, a New Girl rewatch podcast on HeadGum. Now, here's the thing, every single week, we chat about an episode of New Girl. And we really get into it, like, we get up in there, we get up in there. You know, we reminisce about our times on set. We share behind the scenes tea, we react to rewatching episodes that we haven't seen in years. We talk about how Jake Johnson is dog.
57:38 Speaker 06 That's not true. We talk about so many memories we have of working with the biggest stars on the planet. I'm talking Prince, Taylor Swift, Olivia Rodrigo.
57:51 Speaker 05 We're just two BFFs having a good old time, okay? Sometimes we even talk to other co-stars like Zooey Deschanel, Jake Johnson, Max Greenfield, and Damon Wayans Jr., and your dad. We talk to your dad on this show as well.
58:02 Speaker 06 Make sure you subscribe to The Mess Around wherever you get your podcasts. New episodes drop every single Tuesday.
Previous Pretty Little Episode #47 Next Pretty Little Episode #48 Page updated November 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated