Pod Insights From First Principles Hypersonic Physics, Deep Sea Life & Princeton’s Millisecond Qubits (EP. 17) About this episode Hosted by Lester Nare and Krishna Choudhary, this episode dives into three breakthroughs stretching across aerospace engineering, astrobiology, and quantum computing. We start with a Nature Communications paper from Stevens Institute that experimentally validates a 60-year-old hypothesis underpinning hypersonic flight modeling. Then we head 3,000 meters below the Pacific to explore a newly discovered cold, ultra-alkaline biosphere near the Mariana forearc — a finding that reshapes the search for extraterrestrial life. And we close with Princeton’s millisecond-coherent transmon qubit, a materials science triumph pushing the quantum hardware frontier toward real-world quantum advantage.
Summary
Hypersonics without supercomputers — Stevens Institute validates the Morkovin hypothesis up to Mach ~6 using krypton-tagging velocimetry, confirming that “simple” turbulence models still work in hypersonic regimes and opening the door to viable, inexpensive hypersonic aircraft design.
Life where it shouldn’t exist — University of Bremen researchers uncover evidence of a chemosynthetic biosphere in the cold, pH-12.6 serpentinizing fluids of the Mariana forearc, offering the clearest Earth analog yet for Enceladus- and Europa-like conditions.
A millisecond qubit breakthrough — Princeton’s tantalum-on-high-resistance-silicon transmon hits 1.7 ms coherence, 15× the industry norm — drop-in compatible with Google/IBM architectures and a major step toward practical quantum computing.
Show Notes
Hypersonics — Nature Communications (Stevens Institute)
Deep Sea Life — Nature Communications Earth & Environment (Univ. of Bremen)
Princeton Millisecond Qubit — Nature (Transmon Hardware)
Transcript 16,131 words · 2 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Lester Nare? Guten Tag Internet, this is your captain speaking, Lester Nare, joined as always by my co-host and our resident PhD Krishna Choudhary. My friend, how are you today?
0:10 Krishna Choudhary? Doing well. You know, not as well as I could be because it's like raining and cold.
0:15 Lester Nare? It's miserable. It's a little Seattle right now in LA.
0:19 Krishna Choudhary? Oh my gosh.
0:20 Lester Nare? If this is what it's like in the UK, I understand why everyone's miserable.
0:23 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah. It also reminds me of why I moved out of the East Coast after college and back to my beautiful home of LA. And I'm not one of those guys who's like, we need this. You know, maybe, maybe like California needs this, but like in LA, the water is just going into the ocean.
0:39 Lester Nare? Yes.
0:40 Krishna Choudhary? Like the, the stuff that's coming outside of the studio is just going, like, like the rain needs to, to happen where the reservoirs are.
0:46 Lester Nare? Yes.
0:47 Krishna Choudhary? To fill the reservoirs, not here.
0:49 Lester Nare? Yes, right.
0:49 Krishna Choudhary? I don't, we don't need, I don't need this.
0:52 Lester Nare? There is a, a six to 12 inches of water flood on the road.
0:57 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, I had to jump over that. I was like.
1:00 Lester Nare? In the driveway?
1:00 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And there was a, you know, there was a timing battle there because the longer I stood to figure out how to get over that puddle, the wetter I got. So I'm like, what, you know, there's a calculation I was making, like, where, where am I okay getting wet?
1:16 Lester Nare? I, I want people to understand, like, houses don't have gutters here.
1:19 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
1:20 Lester Nare? Like, literally, there's no gutters. So everything just falls off the side of buildings. It's.
1:26 Krishna Choudhary? That's so funny.
1:29 Lester Nare? As I was, I was mentioning earlier, rain has done more chaos and damage than any other culture war issue you want to bring up about Los Angeles.
1:37 Krishna Choudhary? That's true.
1:38 Lester Nare? Rain is our number one enemy. Um, but I think, so we have a couple of good stories this week.
1:44 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:45 Lester Nare? We're on episode 17. We're about to wrap up season one, which I'm arbitrarily saying is every year is a season.
1:51 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, that's good.
1:52 Lester Nare? So we're getting close to the end of season one.
1:54 Krishna Choudhary? This is the pilot season.
1:55 Lester Nare? Pilot season. Uh, it's kind of like Breaking Bad. It's gonna be a cult classic. People thought the first season was slow and then all of a sudden it was the greatest.
2:03 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. Yeah, that's gonna be us.
2:07 Lester Nare? This week, we're gonna touch on three stories. Our first story is about hypersonic aerodynamics. So there's a breakthrough that might enable planes to fly 10 times faster than the speed of sound.
2:21 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
2:22 Lester Nare? We're gonna talk about some modeling stuff there. It was in Nature Communications, out of Stevens Institute, Jersey. Jersey's in two of our stories.
2:30 Krishna Choudhary? Jersey's in two, yeah.
2:31 Lester Nare? I know Jersey gets a lot of flack. Union County, born and raised, not born and raised, raised.
2:36 Krishna Choudhary? Raised, yeah.
2:37 Lester Nare? Not born. But, no Jersey slander will be tolerated. Story number two, we're gonna go deep in the oceans, for our deep sea life story. We found some life in these sort of very extreme areas of the deep sea that we did not think was possible.
2:53 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
2:53 Lester Nare? And there's potentially some implications for exoplanet research and the search for astrobiology and search for extraterrestrial life outside of University of Bremen. And our third story is out of our favorite.
3:07 Krishna Choudhary? It is our favorite institution.
3:09 Lester Nare? Can you blame us? You can't. It's the best, so like, we just have good taste.
3:13 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
3:14 Lester Nare? A Princeton team has built a millisecond Transmon qubit breakthrough, which is gonna allow us to actually do stuff with the quantum. I'm using the quantum as a term of art. The quantum.
3:27 Krishna Choudhary? We should trademark that.
3:29 Lester Nare? Better than we have before. So again, this is out of Princeton, in nature. Right, so our first story was Nature Communications. Our second story was Nature and Earth and Earth and Earth. But nature, nature.
3:41 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, now it's nature, nature.
3:42 Lester Nare? Nature, the real one, Princeton. This is from First Principles.
4:03 Lester Nare? So let's dive into our first story on hypersonics. So for me, as the UAP guy.
4:10 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
4:11 Lester Nare? Mr. UFO guy.
4:12 Krishna Choudhary? I thought you'd like this one, actually.
4:14 Lester Nare? Hypersonics is an interesting, so the idea of these things that travel very, very fast.
4:19 Krishna Choudhary? Very fast, yeah.
4:20 Lester Nare? Obviously, the number one arena that this operates in is military. Because hypersonics is a delivery vehicle for.
4:29 Lester Nare? Nukes especially is kind of like the thing.
4:32 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
4:32 Lester Nare? That is sought after by any sovereign nation that wants global dominance of power.
4:37 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
4:38 Lester Nare? This breakthrough, so the headline on the story is a hypersonics breakthrough could enable planes that fly 10 times the speed of sound. In nature communications from Stevens Institute of Technology, but what specifically about this? What is the breakthrough that they're alleging is happening here?
4:58 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, so you know, we want to travel faster.
5:01 Lester Nare? Yes.
5:02 Krishna Choudhary? Right? This is something that'll give us access to faster air travel. It would be really nice if we just, you know, got to go to, if I could go to India in an hour and visit my grandmother, that would be really awesome, right?
5:14 Lester Nare? Pretty chill.
5:14 Krishna Choudhary? But the age of the Concorde is gone and now it's sort of coming back. Supersonic travel is sort of coming back. Hypersonic travel is something that is on the docket, but it's a little more non-trivial compared to supersonic. Okay? So in order to get into that, there's some fundamental physics involved that I think is very, very cool. Let's talk about the Mach number, you know, about the Mach number, right? It's the ratio of the speed of your object divided by the speed of sound. The speed of sound is about 750 miles per hour. Planes usually operate at around like, what, 200, 300 ish?
5:48 Lester Nare? Yeah.
5:49 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And at the altitude that planes are at, you're, you're a little bit lower. The speed of sound is around 600, 650, right? Because the density is lower. But at the end of the day, the, the air behaves differently when you are traveling at close to or above the speed of sound. Okay? And one of my favorite movies of all time is The Right Stuff. It was a movie about the early US Army tests.
6:15 Lester Nare? Yeah.
6:15 Krishna Choudhary? Out in Edwards Air Force Base. And there's a great scene where Chuck Yeager is trying to conquer the demon in the sky. And the demon in the sky is the sound barrier. Okay? Because back then, no one had gone faster than the speed of sound. And it seemed non-trivial whether you could. Now engineers were like, of course you can, because a bullet goes faster than the speed of sound. And, uh, you know, Ernst Mach had. That famous photograph of the bullet going through the speed of sound that we had covered in some earlier episodes.
6:47 Lester Nare? Yes.
6:47 Krishna Choudhary? So it's, it's obvious that stuff can go faster than the speed of sound and the atmosphere permits it, okay? It's less obvious whether something as big as an airplane that's carrying a human being can go that fast.
7:00 Lester Nare? There's a scaling issue, a potential scaling.
7:03 Krishna Choudhary? There's a potential scaling issue because what ends up happening is when you go faster than the speed, towards the speed of sound, the disturbance, the pressure waves, the disturbances that you're creating with your object are going to move away from your object at the speed of sound. That's what sound is. Sound is the speed at which some disturbance moves through air. But if you're piercing through that barrier, right? Then the disturbance is sort of catching up with you, or you're catching up with that disturbance, right? And you're piling up air in front of you. And air goes from something called incompressible, an incompressible fluid, which is a way of
7:46 Krishna Choudhary? saying that basically air doesn't change its density as we change its pressure and temperature to something where it does. Now you can squish air, okay? And what ends up happening is at the speed of sound, you get these things called the Mach cone, where the wavefront of all of that disturbance becomes a nice little conical wavefront in your device, like right around the device that's going through.
8:11 Lester Nare? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
8:11 Krishna Choudhary? Right? This picture here is of a model airplane in a wind tunnel.
8:17 Lester Nare? Yes.
8:17 Krishna Choudhary? Where the wind is moving faster than the speed of sound, right? So then relative, the, the, the object is moving faster than the speed of sound and you're getting that really nice Mach cone.
8:26 Lester Nare? Right.
8:27 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And the angle of that cone tells you how fast you're going.
8:30 Lester Nare? Uh, so like it'll, it'll like, it'll be wider or more narrow based?
8:33 Krishna Choudhary? Based on how fast you're going. It's kind of like the wake on a boat, right? It's the same, same principle. It's like, the, the waves in the water are moving at a certain speed, but your boat is piercing through that disturbance faster than the waves can proliferate.
8:47 Lester Nare? Yes.
8:47 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And what ends up, in, in water, you're not getting this compressibility thing because it's, it's just water, it's an, it's an, it's a two dimensional sort of surface and three dimensions, so it can dissipate its energy in this like Z direction, right? But, but in sound, the energy has nowhere to go and so you're just piling up these air particles, one on top of the other, right? So that's the pressure wave that you get when you go supersonic.
9:13 Lester Nare? Okay.
9:13 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, we figured that out, obviously. We have the we have the F 16s and all of these like really nice military jets. We have the Concorde that used to be a
9:21 Lester Nare? The only commercial supersonic jet.
9:23 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
9:24 Lester Nare? That has not been replicated at scale.
9:27 Krishna Choudhary? Since, yeah.
9:27 Lester Nare? Since.
9:28 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, I think there's there's recent things coming out of Boeing and NASA that are trying to resurface that. And they're trying to make a version of the Concorde without the sonic boom.
9:39 Lester Nare? Without sonic boom.
9:40 Krishna Choudhary? Which is gonna be very cool.
9:41 Lester Nare? There is, I do know, and I because they're abusing me with advertising on X. There is a startup.
9:49 Krishna Choudhary? Uh huh.
9:50 Lester Nare? That is doing supersonic jet. They're building their own supersonic jet platform outside of the primes. I'm not saying they're accomplishing it, but that's what the advertising is putting forth.
10:02 Krishna Choudhary? I mean, nowadays with like the the access to computation and AI and all that stuff, I wouldn't be surprised if if a small ragtag team of engineers like cracks.
10:12 Lester Nare? Yeah.
10:13 Krishna Choudhary? You know, certain problems.
10:14 Lester Nare? Which is fair.
10:15 Krishna Choudhary? So so that would be very interesting. So, okay, we've gotten to supersonic, right?
10:19 Lester Nare? Yes.
10:20 Krishna Choudhary? Then there's something called hypersonic. The definition of hypersonic is greater than Mach five. So five times the speed of sound.
10:27 Lester Nare? Five times the speed of sound. Got it.
10:28 Krishna Choudhary? And there, the air behaves even more differently. Okay, the physics turns into a different animal altogether.
10:36 Lester Nare? It's kind of like levels in a video game. And like when you get to level two, it's it's harder than level one.
10:42 Krishna Choudhary? It is harder than level one. And now we're here in level two, right? What ends up happening is the physics of the air starts mattering. Before, you could just treat it as an ideal gas. Ideal gas, meaning a bunch of point particles that are bumping around. Sure, like even even the speed of sound, you can derive that. Actually, you know, in in physics, at Princeton Physics, one of the problems on the final for statistical mechanics was to derive the speed of sound from first principles. And I remember being like, thank goodness, because
11:21 Krishna Choudhary? Like half an hour before the test, I saw this derivation and I was like, I'm just gonna memorize it. And then it came up on the test. I was like, dude, I got this. And I just like just like wrote it down. And then some classmates afterwards like, what the hell is that? And I was like,
11:42 Krishna Choudhary? I just randomly happened upon that page and I was like, this is something that I should probably just know how to do.
11:47 Lester Nare? Yeah.
11:47 Krishna Choudhary? In case, and it was the exact problem. Oh my gosh, I love that.
11:50 Lester Nare? That's so amazing.
11:51 Krishna Choudhary? It's a really cool problem where you basically treat the particles like billiard balls, like an ideal gas. And you start asking like how, how the dissipation, how these billiard balls will bump into each other to create the effect of sound.
12:06 Lester Nare? Yep.
12:06 Krishna Choudhary? And then, and then how fast that sound is going to go in terms of temperature, density and things like that of the air. Right. And the mass of the particles even. You can, yeah, yeah. There's like, there's, there's terms that go into that derivation.
12:19 Lester Nare? Yep.
12:19 Krishna Choudhary? So.
12:20 Lester Nare? Yep.
12:21 Krishna Choudhary? All that is fine before hypersonic.
12:23 Lester Nare? Right.
12:24 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. When you get to hypersonic, then you start caring about what is the air made out of.
12:29 Lester Nare? Yes.
12:29 Krishna Choudhary? It's not point like particles. Most of it is nitrogen and oxygen. And those are diatomic particles, right? Diatomic molecules.
12:38 Lester Nare? Yes.
12:38 Krishna Choudhary? So diatomic molecules means you've got two atoms. Nitrogen is an N2, oxygen is an O2.
12:45 Lester Nare? Yep.
12:45 Krishna Choudhary? And those guys have other degrees of freedom. They don't just move. They also vibrate. And they also rotate. Okay. So there's other ways in which energy can affect them.
12:59 Lester Nare? And so the ways in which they interact themselves and with each other.
13:04 Krishna Choudhary? And with the object.
13:05 Lester Nare? And with the object.
13:06 Krishna Choudhary? Start mattering.
13:07 Lester Nare? Because there's, there's more complexity now at when we're starting to get into above Mach five.
13:14 Krishna Choudhary? Above Mach five, because the energy scales correspond now, the kinetic energy that you're putting into the air is now at the same regime as the energy of this and the energy of this. You see what I'm saying?
13:27 Lester Nare? Yes, yes, yes.
13:28 Krishna Choudhary? You see, that's, physics is always about. Energy scales.
13:31 Lester Nare? Got it.
13:31 Krishna Choudhary? It's like, what energy scale am I operating in? Right now, the energy in the room is at, what? Maybe 20 degrees Celsius?
13:39 Lester Nare? Yeah, yeah.
13:39 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So 270 degrees Kelvin. At that scale, the vibrational modes aren't doing much. So you can, you can, you can just use PV equals NRT and be like, this is an ideal gas.
13:49 Lester Nare? Yeah, it's fine.
13:50 Krishna Choudhary? It's fine.
13:50 Lester Nare? Fine.
13:51 Krishna Choudhary? When you get to higher temperatures, higher kinetic energies, that's when, that's when the molecules start doing this.
13:55 Lester Nare? Yep.
13:56 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And then you gotta start caring.
13:58 Lester Nare? Because there's emergent properties of the particles doing this.
14:00 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
14:01 Lester Nare? That matter.
14:02 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
14:02 Lester Nare? In the overall equation of what is happening.
14:05 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly, exactly. At a low, at a low velocity, when I'm just like moving my hand around, the molecules are just getting out of the way.
14:11 Lester Nare? Yeah.
14:12 Krishna Choudhary? But if I start moving my hand around at hypersonic speeds, the, the speed at which the, the, the energy that I'm imparting on these molecules is now making them go like this.
14:22 Lester Nare? I mean, this is the whole idea of the point that you can't just go infinitely fast. Because at some point, you start, the surface of your materials.
14:31 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, it'll start melting.
14:32 Lester Nare? Melting and breaking apart.
14:34 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, like if I go infinite, if I go really, really fast, I'm gonna start imparting energy on these materials.
14:39 Lester Nare? Yes.
14:40 Krishna Choudhary? Those materials will start imparting the energy back into the surface, the metal that I have.
14:46 Lester Nare? Yes.
14:46 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And then maybe that energy is enough to start melting the metallic stuff.
14:51 Lester Nare? The volume of that energy.
14:53 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
14:54 Lester Nare? Is getting so high that it is not ju- and there's reasons why this makes a lot of sense, but.
15:01 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, I mean, you, you, you might have read about this with like, you know, a lot of your UAP research.
15:05 Lester Nare? I mean, it's, it's this idea, it's why, it's why these, all of these like advanced aerospace platforms, when you talk about, you know, the, the M22, the M35s, sorry, F32, F22, F25, 35s, like all the, the B52s, like all these super advanced platforms, material science is actually one of the most important aspects
15:28 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
15:28 Lester Nare? of these platforms. Because we're trying to have them operate both at altitudes and at speeds and with levels of maneuverability that are pushing these limits.
15:39 Krishna Choudhary? Like physical limits. Of like the stuff that it's in even.
15:43 Lester Nare? And the, and the understanding of hypersonics, the reason why hypersonics is still the realm of massive global power nation states is because it's very complex.
15:53 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, it's very, yeah, it's very complex. All of a sudden, you, you can't just rely on the Navier-Stokes equation to like, tell you everything, right? Now, now, now it's, it's no longer just viscosity and density and pressure. There's like molecular effects. You gotta get down to the molecular level and that's why it's hard, right?
16:11 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:11 Krishna Choudhary? So when it comes, when it comes to like making something that wants to move at a hypersonic scale, there's two tyrants that you have to deal with. Okay?
16:20 Lester Nare? Okay.
16:21 Krishna Choudhary? There's two types of drag. There's a pressure drag, which is basically my, my plane is going through the air. There's higher pressure in the front because I'm piling up all the air.
16:31 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:32 Krishna Choudhary? And then I'm creating an effective vacuum behind me.
16:34 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:34 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So that's going to create a force because there's high pressure here, low pressure here, just like a piston.
16:41 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:41 Krishna Choudhary? There's gonna be a force that's gonna be like, no, I don't want you to move that fast.
16:45 Lester Nare? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
16:45 Krishna Choudhary? That's the, that's the pressure drag.
16:47 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:48 Krishna Choudhary? Then there's also skin friction drag, which is the air is moving over my body.
16:53 Lester Nare? Yes.
16:54 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And I'm, I'm like tearing the air apart in some sense because the, the part that's stuck to my, my vehicle, my flight.
17:03 Lester Nare? Yes.
17:03 Krishna Choudhary? Is gonna be moving with me, but the air away from me is stationary, right? So there's gonna be that like velocity difference.
17:09 Lester Nare? Yes.
17:10 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And then there's another thing, which is the heat. All of that energy that I'm imparting, if I'm going hypersonic, that heat is now changing the chemical structure of the air in front of me.
17:21 Lester Nare? Yes.
17:22 Krishna Choudhary? And that heat load, that aerothermal load from the viscous dissipation is gonna be something that I need to care about.
17:29 Lester Nare? Right.
17:29 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So there's all of these like little things.
17:31 Lester Nare? Yes.
17:32 Krishna Choudhary? And the source of most of my problems comes from some, something called the boundary layer. Okay? So imagine you've got an airfoil. It's like a wing.
17:41 Lester Nare? Yes.
17:42 Krishna Choudhary? What I was saying earlier is there's a thinly, there's a thin layer where the velocity shears from zero relative to me. So I'm moving through the air. I'm moving through the air. All of the molecules that are near my, that are stuck to my wing.
17:58 Lester Nare? Yeah.
17:58 Krishna Choudhary? Are moving with me.
17:59 Lester Nare? Yeah.
18:00 Krishna Choudhary? But all of the molecules that are even a few millimeters away from me.
18:03 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:03 Krishna Choudhary? Are, are gone.
18:04 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:05 Krishna Choudhary? Right? There's gotta be some continuous way. That I go from zero to my speed.
18:11 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:12 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
18:12 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:12 Krishna Choudhary? And that's that boundary layer.
18:14 Lester Nare? Got it.
18:14 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, that boundary layer turns from laminar to turbulent.
18:19 Lester Nare? Okay.
18:19 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, when it, when it fully attacks, when it fully attacks the air, it's laminar, meaning it's quite smooth. It's very smooth and it's very nice.
18:28 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:29 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, there's a continuous sort of transformation from zero to whatever my velocity is.
18:34 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:35 Krishna Choudhary? Later on, that laminar flow is going to turn into turbulence.
18:38 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:39 Krishna Choudhary? And the turbulence is going to be, there's going to be these eddy currents, there's going to be like weird, like, like circulations happening in the back of my wing. And that transition from laminar to turbulent is a very poorly understood event.
18:53 Lester Nare? I got you. Okay.
18:54 Krishna Choudhary? Okay.
18:54 Lester Nare? Yes.
18:55 Krishna Choudhary? Like, like, like seeing where that happens in my wing, how that happens when I change the deflection of my wing.
19:02 Lester Nare? Yes.
19:02 Krishna Choudhary? You know?
19:03 Lester Nare? Yeah.
19:03 Krishna Choudhary? All of these things are, are, you know, we've got models for it and we've got ways of understanding it. But at the end of the day, this is an extremely nonlinear phenomenon.
19:12 Lester Nare? Yes.
19:12 Krishna Choudhary? Which means that, you know, there's not a simple, nice, like differential equation that I can just like, solve and like, and like, I have like a solution that is like enclosed form. Okay?
19:24 Lester Nare? This makes sense. And is it also the case that because of the lack of, to be able to do hypersonics is extremely expensive?
19:32 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
19:33 Lester Nare? And it's also classified?
19:35 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
19:36 Lester Nare? And so the amount of actual source for data to inform the models is not really accessible.
19:43 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
19:44 Lester Nare? In terms of having a feedback loop for how you iterate on your model's predictions.
19:48 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
19:49 Lester Nare? And so you're kind of extrapolating from what you can get. But it's an environment because of this laminar flow to turbulent flow and these new problem sets that happen when you start going hypersonic.
20:00 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
20:01 Lester Nare? The ability to have a feedback from real world, real world data sets is kind of a, it's a little bit of a challenge.
20:06 Krishna Choudhary? It is a little bit of a challenge and, you know, I will, I will go out on a limb and say that even the classified programs haven't really crap, cracked like greater than five Mach.
20:19 Lester Nare? Okay.
20:19 Krishna Choudhary? Okay?
20:20 Lester Nare? Yeah.
20:20 Krishna Choudhary? Because, because some of this fundamental physics is just like so foreign.
20:26 Lester Nare? Yeah.
20:26 Krishna Choudhary? That like, There hasn't been fundamental research that's happened to figure that out. Maybe they've cracked it for small things.
20:33 Lester Nare? Yes.
20:33 Krishna Choudhary? Right? Missiles, okay, right? But like you're putting a human in something that's going hypersonic.
20:39 Lester Nare? Yeah. No, that's different. No, that's actually no.
20:42 Krishna Choudhary? Right. And you could be going at Mach 10. You could be going at Mach 10 in the upper, upper, upper Earth's atmosphere.
20:49 Lester Nare? Yeah.
20:49 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
20:50 Lester Nare? Yeah.
20:50 Krishna Choudhary? There's not that many particles. The density of air is low. I mean, okay, is the International Space Station going at Mach 90 or whatever the hell?
20:59 Lester Nare? Right, right.
21:00 Krishna Choudhary? It's not really a thing.
21:01 Lester Nare? Yeah, that's fair.
21:02 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
21:02 Lester Nare? That's fair.
21:02 Krishna Choudhary? But, but when densities are high.
21:05 Lester Nare? Right.
21:06 Krishna Choudhary? Then it's a different, it's a different.
21:08 Lester Nare? It matters.
21:09 Krishna Choudhary? It's a different like animal altogether, right? And even, I mean, one of the things that I would suggest is the space shuttle, for example, right? The orbiters, they had these overdesigned tiles, the heat absorbing tiles on the, on the very end. They were overdesigned because predictive models of that turbulence, of the laminar from turbulent background.
21:29 Lester Nare? Yes.
21:30 Krishna Choudhary? Were so bad that they were just like, okay, I'm just gonna make this like 10 times.
21:33 Lester Nare? Right.
21:34 Krishna Choudhary? What I need.
21:34 Lester Nare? Right.
21:35 Krishna Choudhary? Right? Because I don't know where that transition is and I don't know the physics of that. So I'm just gonna, I'm just gonna overdesign for safety reasons, right?
21:43 Lester Nare? Yep.
21:44 Krishna Choudhary? So, so it shows you that, I mean, I'm sure like the top echelons of NASA have access to some of the hypersonic stuff.
21:51 Lester Nare? But, but.
21:52 Krishna Choudhary? I don't know.
21:52 Lester Nare? No, but a key point is as far as we know, at this point in time, in the public data realm, hypersonics are exclusively for payloads like missiles, not for human travel.
22:05 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
22:06 Lester Nare? Which is a very different.
22:07 Krishna Choudhary? Those are very different things, like, like, like a human life is worth way more than some nuclear thing that I just like made as I'm, I'm testing.
22:14 Lester Nare? Yes.
22:14 Krishna Choudhary? You know?
22:15 Lester Nare? No, no, but that, that, that is the.
22:17 Krishna Choudhary? That's the key thing.
22:17 Lester Nare? That is a key thing.
22:19 Krishna Choudhary? That's the key thing. And that's where this paper comes in, okay?
22:21 Lester Nare? Okay.
22:22 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. The central challenge of hypersonic design is predicting and modeling that turbulent boundary layer, right? And this paper is doing an experimental.
22:34 Krishna Choudhary? Addressing of that, of that problem. Okay. And that's why I think it's very, it's very exciting. Okay. What it's doing is basically testing a 60 year old hypothesis. Okay. It's a, it's called a Morkovin hypothesis. And what it says is the essential dynamics of this like very high speed, high Mach turbulence is not fundamentally different from low Mach turbulence.
22:59 Lester Nare? Okay.
23:00 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. Morkovin came up with this in 1962. He was looking at some preliminary data and he said that this seems to be true. Okay. It's essentially the same. What he's saying is at high Mach, air is going to become compressible. And there's going to be all of these density fluctuations and temperature fluctuations. But what I can do is I can take the physics that I know from low Mach. And I can do a transformation.
23:31 Krishna Choudhary? Basically, I just adjust the parameters for density and I adjust the parameters for turbulence. Oh, sorry, for temperature. And I'm going to get the turbulent effects that I get at high Mach. Okay. This is a non trivial statement. Okay. Because what it's assuming is the essential physics at the, at the high scale, at the, at the vehicle level is going to be very similar. Right. It's saying all I have to do is adjust some parameters and I'll get the right physics. There's nothing like weird.
24:00 Lester Nare? That's happening. If it's raining outside, I can just put on a raincoat and I'm fine. Yeah. There are no other derivative thing, like the addition of a single item that is trivial.
24:13 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. That is, yeah, yeah. I can just adjust some parameters, right? It's not the rain is like acid rain that's going to melt my raincoat and kill me and all this other stuff.
24:23 Lester Nare? Right.
24:23 Krishna Choudhary? Right.
24:24 Lester Nare? Which, which is, which is like, it is, it is, it is filling in and it's not in this. It is saying that this maps in both domains in a way that what we're saying is that is a big deal that we're saying that.
24:39 Krishna Choudhary? We're saying that, yeah, we're saying that there's some, there's some trivial transformation. That can scale the really complex
24:47 Lester Nare? Yes.
24:47 Krishna Choudhary? compressible stuff.
24:49 Lester Nare? Into just a couple knobs.
24:50 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, into just a couple of knobs, right?
24:51 Lester Nare? Crazy.
24:52 Krishna Choudhary? And, and why that matters is because like, right now, we have simulations.
24:57 Lester Nare? Okay.
24:57 Krishna Choudhary? That deal with this kind of stuff, okay? They're called computational fluid dynamics. They basically churn physics equations in a computer and tell you how the air is going to flow around an object going at a certain speed, given the air density, given the temperature and things like that. Formula One people do it all the time.
25:14 Lester Nare? This is what video games use for like water.
25:16 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
25:17 Lester Nare? You know, like water animations and you're uncharted for or whatever.
25:21 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly.
25:21 Lester Nare? They need to use models like this.
25:23 Krishna Choudhary? They, they use models like this and like people at aerospace companies use probably more sophisticated models, but at the same of the day, at the end of the day, it's just like, it's, it's resting on this hypothesis, right? Because there's two ways to do it. There's a direct numerical, numerical simulation called DNS. That's the gold standard.
25:40 Lester Nare? Okay.
25:40 Krishna Choudhary? You're basically solving Navier-Stokes for like tiny, tiny little packets of, of space.
25:45 Lester Nare? Okay.
25:46 Krishna Choudhary? And you're, and you're getting really granular with it.
25:48 Lester Nare? Yep.
25:49 Krishna Choudhary? Doing a direct numerical simulation for something like an airplane, we don't have the computation.
25:55 Lester Nare? I was gonna say like, we barely have the computation for me to get an image of me making eggs in the morning out of chachi BT.
26:01 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
26:02 Lester Nare? Let alone this multi-point.
26:03 Krishna Choudhary? This is like, imagine every single little part of air that's interacting with every other little part of air, right? How many, how many supercomputers are there that you're gonna like rent time on?
26:14 Lester Nare? Correct.
26:14 Krishna Choudhary? To like, deal with every single iteration of your design. It's not gonna work.
26:19 Lester Nare? The, the point is classical computing does not really have the horsepower to do like physics-based or physics-level models without getting to supercomputer scale.
26:31 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly. Yeah, yeah. And there's not that many supercomputers in the world. Like, there's not one, like, just here.
26:38 Lester Nare? Right, right, right.
26:39 Krishna Choudhary? And then, and then the other, so what, what we usually do is we use something called a computationally cheap RANs. It's called Reynolds Average Navier-Stokes. It's basically a way to like blur out
26:50 Lester Nare? Hmm.
26:50 Krishna Choudhary? a lot of the physics. So on the left, you've got direct numerical simulation.
26:55 Lester Nare? Yes.
26:55 Krishna Choudhary? And on the right, you've got the Reynolds Average Simulation.
26:58 Lester Nare? Yes.
26:58 Krishna Choudhary? You can see that it's kind of a blurred out version.
27:01 Lester Nare? Yes.
27:02 Krishna Choudhary? Of the direct numerical simulation. So it's giving you a good enough answer.
27:07 Lester Nare? Yes.
27:07 Krishna Choudhary? Okay?
27:08 Lester Nare? Yes.
27:09 Krishna Choudhary? But here's the thing, every single one of those simulations, especially when you're trying to go into this Mach 5 and beyond level, it's assuming explicitly Markovian hypothesis.
27:21 Lester Nare? Okay.
27:22 Krishna Choudhary? Which is that the physics up there is basically equivalent to the physics down here, up to a certain scale factor that we can calculate.
27:30 Lester Nare? Mm hmm.
27:31 Krishna Choudhary? Okay?
27:31 Lester Nare? Mm hmm.
27:32 Krishna Choudhary? The key thing is this, no one's actually like done the work.
27:37 Lester Nare? I love it.
27:38 Krishna Choudhary? To show that that this is equivalent.
27:40 Lester Nare? Yes.
27:40 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
27:41 Lester Nare? Right.
27:41 Krishna Choudhary? That like we can assume these things.
27:43 Lester Nare? We've just sort of been like, yeah.
27:45 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. Probably. Right?
27:48 Lester Nare? We've got other things to do.
27:49 Krishna Choudhary? And then, and then came some experimental data that suggested not.
27:54 Lester Nare? Okay.
27:55 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, so there was a conflict. Experimental data came out of something called PIV, which I'm going to go into. But there on the bottom, you're seeing the red is the experimental data.
28:04 Lester Nare? Yeah, yeah.
28:04 Krishna Choudhary? And the green is the DNS, which is the Direct Numerical Simulation, the really high fidelity thing.
28:10 Lester Nare? Yes.
28:10 Krishna Choudhary? And there's a discrepancy.
28:11 Lester Nare? Yeah.
28:12 Krishna Choudhary? You see that discrepancy?
28:13 Lester Nare? And it's, it is, it is significant, statistically significant.
28:16 Krishna Choudhary? It is, it is statistically significant. You're going from something like 0.4 to like 1.1 on the Y axis, right?
28:22 Lester Nare? That's.
28:22 Krishna Choudhary? That's, that's a 2X almost.
28:24 Lester Nare? Yes.
28:25 Krishna Choudhary? So.
28:25 Lester Nare? Okay.
28:27 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
28:27 Lester Nare? Yes.
28:28 Krishna Choudhary? Now we're in a conundrum.
28:29 Lester Nare? There's a problem.
28:30 Krishna Choudhary? There's a problem, right? If we want to trust this thing, if we want to trust Markovian hypothesis to beyond Mach 5.
28:37 Lester Nare? Yes.
28:37 Krishna Choudhary? In this hypersonic regime.
28:39 Lester Nare? Yes.
28:39 Krishna Choudhary? We have to answer the question, one, is Markovian hypothesis correct? Or is, is, is the experimental data correct? Right?
28:50 Lester Nare? Right.
28:50 Krishna Choudhary? One of those two is the thing.
28:53 Lester Nare? Is the thing.
28:53 Krishna Choudhary? Is the, is true, right?
28:55 Lester Nare? Right.
28:55 Krishna Choudhary? So that was the question that these guys at Stevens Institute were trying to handle.
29:01 Lester Nare? Shout out Jersey.
29:03 Krishna Choudhary? Shout out to Jersey, because here's what they did. They said, okay, direct numerical simulation is like. Kind of the gold standard.
29:10 Lester Nare? Sure, understandably so.
29:12 Krishna Choudhary? How did they get the experimental data? They use something called PIV, which is Particle Image Velocimetry. Okay, it's a state of the art optical experiment. And here's what's happening. You got some fluid. You put in some particles. Can be dust particles, oil particles, alumina dust. And those dust are gonna track where the fluid is moving.
29:35 Lester Nare? Moving.
29:36 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
29:36 Lester Nare? Got it.
29:36 Krishna Choudhary? That's the idea.
29:37 Lester Nare? It's kind of like when you put the dye in animal testing to make the thing show up when you look at it.
29:42 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
29:43 Lester Nare? Certain areas.
29:43 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, because the fluid is just moving around on its own.
29:46 Lester Nare? But you need to be able to visualize it somehow.
29:48 Krishna Choudhary? But you need to visualize it somehow. So you're gonna put some tracer thingy that's gonna track where the fluid is moving. Okay? And it's gonna be seeded with these microscopic tracer particles. But here's, here's the problem. Those tracer particles are quite big compared to the air itself.
30:10 Lester Nare? Okay.
30:10 Krishna Choudhary? Right? The air is made out of nitrogen and oxygen. These are single molecules. The particles are made out of, let's say, 10 to the 5, 10 to the 10, something like that number of these. So there's gonna be a particle lag. There's gonna be, the air is gonna be pushing this particle. And then the particle is gonna move. And then I'm gonna image it and create this velocity field. Right?
30:34 Lester Nare? So there's a delta between the thing we're tracking and the thing we actually care about.
30:38 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
30:39 Lester Nare? Because of the scale difference.
30:40 Krishna Choudhary? Yes. That's not gonna matter at low, low speeds.
30:44 Lester Nare? Matters.
30:44 Krishna Choudhary? But at Mach 5, Mach 6, now all of a sudden, maybe it matters. That's the question. Does it matter?
30:51 Lester Nare? Does it matter?
30:52 Krishna Choudhary? Does, at high speeds, the fact that my tracer, my dust particle or whatever, is so much larger than the fluid particles themselves, does that matter?
31:03 Lester Nare? Yes.
31:03 Krishna Choudhary? And here's what they did. They said, okay, instead of having tracer particles, I'm gonna use something called krypton tagging velocimetry.
31:10 Lester Nare? Krypton!
31:11 Krishna Choudhary? They're gonna use krypton gas.
31:13 Lester Nare? Okay.
31:14 Krishna Choudhary? And the krypton atom, which is a monoatomic gas, because it's a noble gas, it doesn't make molecules. That's gonna be my tracer.
31:23 Lester Nare? Because it is closer in size to the thing we are trying to trace.
31:27 Krishna Choudhary? Track, yeah.
31:28 Lester Nare? Than the other alumina dust and other things.
31:30 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
31:31 Lester Nare? And so that we can. The point is, if we do it this way, we can start to rule out the lag problem as the source of the issue.
31:39 Krishna Choudhary? Because the krypton is just gonna be going with it.
31:41 Lester Nare? Yes, it's gonna be moving at the same level and pace and all these things as the actual air.
31:45 Krishna Choudhary? And this is the part that was like a little bit non-trivial to me, right? It's like with dust, it's really easy to set up a 2D laser field and like image the dust because the laser, remember, from first principles, how do we image something? We gotta capture light.
32:02 Lester Nare? Yes.
32:03 Krishna Choudhary? So what do we do? For the dust, for the particle image velocity, we set up a 2D laser field. The dust is moving around, the laser bounces, the light from the laser bounces off the particle and then it goes to our detector and we take an image. With a single krypton atom, how are you gonna do that? Here's what they did, and it's, I thought this was very cool. So they got a laser and they use the laser to ionize krypton. Okay? They have this two photon procedure where they focus all the laser beam into a tiny spot where the, where the krypton is getting seeded.
32:43 Lester Nare? Yeah.
32:43 Krishna Choudhary? Okay? And if two photons interact with a single krypton atom, it's gonna bump up in energy level and ionize itself.
32:51 Lester Nare? And then you're gonna be able to track it.
32:53 Krishna Choudhary? And now this krypton is an ionized thing, and when it goes back to its normal state, it's gonna release a photon. The, the krypton itself is gonna create the photon that we're gonna use to track it with. So there's like a read, so there's a write mechanism, right? We're writing the krypton, we're tagging it.
33:11 Lester Nare? Tagging it, yeah, yeah, yeah.
33:12 Krishna Choudhary? And then, and then we're reading it later.
33:14 Lester Nare? When the photon's released.
33:15 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
33:16 Lester Nare? And it's, we're basically have created read-write level permissions.
33:19 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, on like, like on an atom.
33:22 Lester Nare? On an atom.
33:23 Krishna Choudhary? And we're tracking it as it goes through this Mach, Mach 5, Mach 6.
33:27 Lester Nare? I hope people who are watching and listening to this understand how outrageous what you just said is.
33:32 Krishna Choudhary? That's so, that's so, like, and it took them 10 years to like figure this out.
33:36 Lester Nare? Obviously.
33:36 Krishna Choudhary? Like, like. Credit to them, dude. That like, that's so, that's such a cool idea.
33:42 Lester Nare? That is a really, that's actually real, right?
33:46 Krishna Choudhary? Cause, cause you gotta think like.
33:47 Lester Nare? That's really, that's clever.
33:49 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, it is clever because, because I wanna trace how the gas is moving around, but I wanna image the gas itself.
33:56 Lester Nare? Right.
33:57 Krishna Choudhary? Right? How do I image the gas? I can't image atoms.
34:01 Lester Nare? Right.
34:01 Krishna Choudhary? Right? I can image dust particles, cause they'll scatter light.
34:04 Lester Nare? Yes.
34:04 Krishna Choudhary? But if I make the atoms themselves like this, like weird, like light bulb.
34:08 Lester Nare? Yes. This, this reminds me of the story we talked about in episode 16 last week, about how we were used, the, the, the camouflage story about how we're manipulating biology in order to generate an outcome based on its existing evolutionary processes. And building into that infrastructure, uh, in order to get the outcome we're looking for. Just conceptually, it's like using the fundamentals of physics. It's like, we're eliciting the reaction.
34:38 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
34:38 Lester Nare? That then enables us to do the thing we wanna do based on the fundamental principles.
34:42 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
34:43 Lester Nare? Uh, we're not just like, we can't just force the answer. We kinda have to like work with the universe a little bit.
34:48 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. And so, and so, and krypton was the way to do it.
34:53 Lester Nare? Krypton was the way to do it. That's us.
34:54 Krishna Choudhary? I think that, I think that was really cool. And so what they did was in the experiment, they have something called the Stevens Shock Tunnel.
35:00 Lester Nare? Yes.
35:00 Krishna Choudhary? Which is at Stevens University, it was funded by the Office of Naval Research. It's an impulse facility and what it does is it creates these shock waves that move through that tunnel at like Mach five, Mach six.
35:14 Lester Nare? Right.
35:14 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So you've got, you've got some apparatus that like, where the krypton moved through the tunnel at Mach five, Mach six. You can now measure, you can ionize the krypton in one part, you can track it. And then you can get that level of fidelity that was never possible with the older method.
35:31 Lester Nare? Yes.
35:32 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And the, the results speak for themselves. You get the mean velocity curve and the krypton tugging KTV data perfectly aligned with the DNS.
35:41 Lester Nare? Right. As opposed to what we looked at earlier where there was that delta, that discrepancy. Uh, meaning we're now actually tracking in a modeling context, close to the direct.
35:55 Lester Nare? Uh, actual like the, the, the, the direct value we see in that really high fidelity gold standard.
36:01 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
36:02 Lester Nare? We're now able to kind of replicate that with like less.
36:05 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah. And now it's in the real world and we can say, okay, experimentally, we can, the model is actually tracking.
36:10 Lester Nare? The model, okay, that's, that's, you know, yes.
36:12 Krishna Choudhary? It's like, it's like the, the particle stuff that we were doing earlier with the dust particles. That wasn't good enough at these, at these velocity regimes.
36:22 Lester Nare? Above Mach five, we now have a regime, a velocity regime that can work with lower, without needing a supercomputer.
36:33 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly. We can, we can now, we can, we can rest easy that the simulation framework that we've been using.
36:41 Lester Nare? Is, is.
36:42 Krishna Choudhary? Is valid.
36:42 Lester Nare? Is lower accurate.
36:43 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah. It's like, it's, it's definitely less fidelity.
36:48 Lester Nare? Yeah.
36:48 Krishna Choudhary? But we don't have to, we don't need a supercomputer to let's say, test a bunch of designs before we like go into production. This hugely reduces the scale of engineering, right?
36:59 Lester Nare? That makes, yeah.
36:59 Krishna Choudhary? Because I can, I can now, I can now try a bunch of different things on my computer.
37:05 Lester Nare? Yes.
37:05 Krishna Choudhary? It can be a big computer, let's say, but it doesn't have to be a supercomputer.
37:09 Lester Nare? It could be an M5 Mac.
37:10 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Like it can, it, the Markovens hypothesis is now experimentally validated at Mach six.
37:18 Lester Nare? At Mach six.
37:18 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
37:19 Lester Nare? Yes, got it. And that's kind of like the, the, the key point is like, this 19 was a 62.
37:25 Krishna Choudhary? 62, yeah.
37:26 Lester Nare? Uh, uh, sort of hypothesis has now been validated a scale of fidelity, of high fidelity measurement.
37:37 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
37:38 Lester Nare? Above Mach five.
37:39 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. And, and we hadn't gotten that far before, experimentally.
37:42 Lester Nare? Experimentally, we hadn't really known is the hypersonics regime, as opposed to the supersong regime, have something where Markovens hypothesis is no longer.
37:53 Lester Nare? Valid.
37:53 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
37:54 Lester Nare? Above this limit.
37:55 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
37:55 Lester Nare? And we've now, no, no.
37:57 Krishna Choudhary? No, we're good.
37:58 Lester Nare? We're good.
37:58 Krishna Choudhary? We're good. So now it can, you know, we can start like actually pushing these measurements.
38:04 Lester Nare? Yes.
38:05 Krishna Choudhary? Right? To, to, to greater fidelity. And we can also start, engineers can be a bit more confident.
38:11 Lester Nare? Right.
38:12 Krishna Choudhary? About the designs that they produce in silica in the computer.
38:16 Lester Nare? Yes.
38:16 Krishna Choudhary? And they, and they try to validate it.
38:18 Lester Nare? Yes.
38:18 Krishna Choudhary? Right? You can now be a bit more confident about, okay, this thing works in the computer. Let's try to actually make it. Right?
38:26 Lester Nare? This is, this is.
38:27 Krishna Choudhary? I'm looking forward to it, dude. Hypersonic travel before I'm, before I'm out of here.
38:31 Lester Nare? That'd be great.
38:32 Krishna Choudhary? That'd be dope.
38:32 Lester Nare? That'd be fantastic.
38:33 Krishna Choudhary? That would be dope.
38:34 Lester Nare? That would be fantastic.
38:35 Krishna Choudhary? I mean, it's probably gonna be like $10,000 a flight, but.
38:39 Lester Nare? As we know, they always gotta monetize.
38:41 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
38:42 Lester Nare? I, I will, before we move on to our story number two, I just want, it's funny, the timing of this because literally earlier today I saw, or I think it was today, yeah, Sam Altman made this post about, uh, anyway, long story short, there's a company that has reached criticality on a, a, a nuclear reactor infrastructure that is venture capital funded. It is the first VC funded entity that has been able to show the ability to reach the splitting of the atom in a new reactor architecture. And they did it in computer.
39:24 Krishna Choudhary? Oh, okay.
39:24 Lester Nare? And then this was the first non-heat, no heat, no power, but like, I guess, physical test of that simulation. And they were able to theoretically reach that point. It is just another, all these real world examples of simulations moving to real world. And like, I don't think like the everyday person understands how much we depend on modeling.
39:47 Krishna Choudhary? Oh, yeah.
39:48 Lester Nare? And simulations.
39:49 Krishna Choudhary? It's insane.
39:49 Lester Nare? To be able to like validate ideas before we even start putting.
39:53 Krishna Choudhary? No, cuz that stuff is expensive.
39:55 Lester Nare? It's so expensive.
39:55 Krishna Choudhary? Making stuff in the real world is super expensive. So whenever people are building new chips, the first thing you do is validate it in silica, right? You have CAD designs and you have all of the software. Whenever Nvidia makes its next H4000 or whatever the hell, right? It's gonna, it's gonna create so much.
40:12 Lester Nare? Right.
40:13 Krishna Choudhary? Testing within the computer because we just know physics. At this level so well, right? We're not, we're not going into CERN.
40:21 Lester Nare? Right.
40:22 Krishna Choudhary? Trying to find the expos on. We're like, we need to, I don't know what the mass is. I know what the mass of the electron is. I know what temperature like, you know?
40:29 Lester Nare? Right.
40:29 Krishna Choudhary? Like, so, so we know physics so well that it's just way cheaper to do stuff in silica in a computer before we rig up a whole factory to actually make stuff. Yeah, you're right.
40:44 Lester Nare? Which makes total sense and it's an important.
40:46 Krishna Choudhary? I gotta, I gotta check this out. That's pretty cool.
40:47 Lester Nare? It's, it was, it was, it kind of took, took off on X earlier today. And, you know, I'm not, I did try to do some very brief validation. It does appear to be the first time that a private
41:03 Lester Nare? venture back, like investor back, like private capital has been able to do so, which is.
41:09 Krishna Choudhary? That's, that's something.
41:10 Lester Nare? And it was.
41:10 Krishna Choudhary? I always look at the comments on X.
41:12 Lester Nare? It was part of a DOE program to get.
41:14 Krishna Choudhary? Oh, okay.
41:15 Lester Nare? Three, uh, private, uh, versions of, of, uh, reaching criticality by 2026. So it's a part of a, a sort of an ongoing DOE program.
41:25 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
41:26 Lester Nare? Which made it a little bit more.
41:27 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, definitely a little bit more legit.
41:29 Lester Nare? Legit.
41:30 Krishna Choudhary? I mean, this was funded by the Office of Naval Research.
41:33 Lester Nare? Same, same idea.
41:33 Krishna Choudhary? A lot of federal government funding.
41:35 Lester Nare? It's all.
41:36 Krishna Choudhary? Another reason why we need more federal funding.
41:41 Lester Nare? All the beautiful things we love. You know, it requires.
41:45 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
41:47 Lester Nare? We're going to move on to our second story, which is about microbes.
41:51 Krishna Choudhary? And yeah.
41:52 Lester Nare? And, and, and a new biosphere, uh, where we thought life was impossible.
41:59 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
41:59 Lester Nare? Earth.
42:00 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
42:00 Lester Nare? And it has some implications potentially for astrobiology. So the, the headline on the story, life found in place. Scientists thought impossible.
42:09 Krishna Choudhary? Yep.
42:10 Lester Nare? This is a paper out of nature communications, earth and environment, a biomarker evidence for serpent tonight. Chemosynthetic biosphere.
42:22 Krishna Choudhary? Nice.
42:22 Lester Nare? At the Mariana four arc. This is out of the University of Bremen, German university.
42:27 Krishna Choudhary? Mm hmm.
42:28 Lester Nare? Many people are familiar with the Mariana trench. People sort of through a variety of sorts of, oh yeah, like there's like these hot vents and there's these things that live in these hot vents and that's the most extreme place. But, but there is something really interesting here about life defying the limits. That exists in the deep sea in this paper.
42:48 Krishna Choudhary? Yes. Yeah, I think I think it's very cool. The the core concept of is is life is constantly like evolving in places that we never thought was possible. This one is happening near the Marianas Trench. And it's very different from the deep sea thermal vents that you were just alluding to, actually.
43:08 Lester Nare? Okay, perfect.
43:09 Krishna Choudhary? Because the deep sea thermal vents usually happen at places where the oceanic crust is diverging, like in the mid Atlantic ridge where there's a there's the crusts are like splitting apart. So there's a lot of volcanic activity happening, right, right there.
43:25 Lester Nare? Yep.
43:26 Krishna Choudhary? And so there's a lot of like sulfur gas and all sorts of stuff coming out. And then all of the bacteria are are capitalizing on that. This one is a subduction zone.
43:38 Lester Nare? Okay.
43:39 Krishna Choudhary? The Marianas Trench is something where where one plate is going under another rather than two plates splitting. Two plates splitting, right? In the mid Atlantic ridge, they're splitting. Here, one is going under another, right? So so it's a little bit different, and I think that's what's really cool.
43:56 Lester Nare? That makes sense.
43:57 Krishna Choudhary? Life is constantly trying to redefine boundaries, right? We've got extremophiles everywhere. Yellowstone, the the life in the hot springs, that's something that's in every single biology textbook. You've got hypersaline ponds in the Atacama Desert that somehow managed to have bacteria. You've even got like nuclear reactor cores of power plants. They've got weird bacteria.
44:21 Lester Nare? That's.
44:21 Krishna Choudhary? And I want to cover that in another future episode because those things are very cool. This new paper, it's a landmark 2025 paper, and it provides biomarker evidence for serpentine chemosynthetic biosphere. Okay.
44:36 Krishna Choudhary? In the Marianas Trench. So the setting is something called a Marianas Four Arc. Right under Japan.
44:45 Krishna Choudhary? East of the Philippines is the Marianas Trench. And you see that like the sort of crescent of the Marianas Trench.
44:53 Lester Nare? The Captain Hook?
44:54 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, that hook is the Marianas Trench, right?
44:56 Lester Nare? Okay.
44:57 Krishna Choudhary? That is one plate subducting under another. Okay. And right, not in the trench itself. The trench is like the bottom of that subduction zone, right? Where the ocean is like a few Mount Everest's deep or whatever. It's very, very deep. Here, this is a part of the of the subduction zone that's at the top. Okay, it's only about 3,000 meters below the surface, but it's still impossible conditions. Okay. Hyper alkaline pH. So you've got 12.6 pH.
45:30 Lester Nare? Jesus Christ.
45:32 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, water is at seven and we're going to get into that a little bit.
45:36 Lester Nare? Okay.
45:37 Krishna Choudhary? It's really cold, 3.5 degrees Celsius. Right, so that's about maybe what? Uh, 40, 30, 37 degrees Fahrenheit. Very cold, very cold still.
45:48 Lester Nare? I mean, I might have surfed in that kind of temperature, but I didn't have a good time.
45:51 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly. But somehow these bacteria are living there. And there's also a nutrient scarcity. There's profound limitation, especially when it comes to phosphate. Right, there's not a lot of phosphate there. And what's what's really cool is this paper finds life there and then tries to characterize how that life is doing living.
46:12 Lester Nare? Right.
46:12 Krishna Choudhary? Down there, which I thought was very, very cool.
46:14 Lester Nare? Yes.
46:16 Krishna Choudhary? The geochemical engine is something called serpentinization. Okay. It's a reaction between water and whatever mantle rocks are down there. Because this is like very close to the earth's crust, right? So you've got water, you've got some rocks. And what what is output is a mineral called serpentine. You've got a lot of molecular hydrogen.
46:42 Lester Nare? Okay.
46:42 Krishna Choudhary? H2.
46:43 Lester Nare? Okay.
46:44 Krishna Choudhary? And H2 is a very energetic molecule, right? You can burn H2 and create energy in water and CO2.
46:52 Krishna Choudhary? So that's what's very interesting here. Okay. And the analogy is like, you know, when, when, when you've got iron and minerals, that iron splits and reacts with the oxygen and creates, creates hydrogen. Because the water, it's going to strip the, the oxygen out of the water and create H2.
47:11 Lester Nare? Yep.
47:12 Krishna Choudhary? Something similar is happening down there, right? The minerals are reacting with the oxygen.
47:17 Lester Nare? Yes.
47:17 Krishna Choudhary? In the water.
47:18 Lester Nare? Yep.
47:18 Krishna Choudhary? And liberating the hydrogen.
47:20 Lester Nare? Yep.
47:21 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. And then that hydrogen then goes and then creates methane, because there's going to be carbon there too.
47:28 Lester Nare? Cause there's a free, it's free hydrogen floating around.
47:30 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, free hydrogen floating around. And that fuel is then going to create abiotic methane. So this is not methane coming from life. This is methane just coming from the chemistry down there.
47:40 Lester Nare? Got it. Okay.
47:41 Krishna Choudhary? You know what I mean?
47:42 Lester Nare? Yeah. No, that makes sense. Yes, that makes sense.
47:44 Krishna Choudhary? And, and so that's, that's what's really interesting. We got to understand sort of the, the, the tectonic setting here in, in the Marianas trench. So I told you, right? It's a subduction zone.
47:54 Lester Nare? Yes.
47:54 Krishna Choudhary? Um, you've got, you've got one plate going under and another plate going over. And the fluids in that subduction zone in the mantle itself are what create the serpentization. You've got like a sort of chemical process that like rejuvenates the ocean floor with, with, with new chemicals and things like that. But that resulting chemical is like, the, the, the, the water there is like really, really messed up. Okay.
48:21 Lester Nare? Which, which makes sense.
48:22 Krishna Choudhary? Which makes sense. It's like way deep.
48:24 Lester Nare? Right.
48:24 Krishna Choudhary? It's, it's near a subduction zone, but the pH is 12.6. Okay. That's like bleach and oven cleaner.
48:33 Lester Nare? Yeah.
48:33 Krishna Choudhary? PH.
48:33 Lester Nare? It might cure COVID. I heard, I heard that.
48:35 Krishna Choudhary? Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
48:37 Lester Nare? So we just gotta go to the Marianas trench.
48:39 Krishna Choudhary? Right. Get it.
48:40 Lester Nare? Get it.
48:41 Krishna Choudhary? And then drink it.
48:42 Lester Nare? Yeah.
48:42 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
48:43 Lester Nare? Got it.
48:43 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. But somehow, so these bacteria don't have COVID for sure, because they live there in that bleach and oven cleaner of 12.6. And just to tell you just how bad that is, right? So the pH of water is seven, water is at a pH of seven. And what that means is pH means percent hydro- hydrogen ion. Okay, it's a log scale, meaning that water has a concentration of H plus, which is 10 to the minus seven moles per liter. Moles is a, is a unit of the amount of stuff. It, it has to do with Avogadro's number. It's about 10 to the 23 thingies, like a dozen is 12. A mole is 10 to the 23 times six.
49:23 Lester Nare? So I'm not, I'm not going to order a mole of cupcakes.
49:25 Krishna Choudhary? No, no, but you would order a mole of water, right? Oh, actually, no, a mole of water is like, I think 55 liters. So maybe not, but it's something like that. Like a mole of carbon 12 would be 12 grams.
49:37 Lester Nare? Got it.
49:37 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
49:37 Lester Nare? Okay.
49:38 Krishna Choudhary? So that means that there's about 10 to the 15 hydrogen ions per liter in just normal water that we drink.
49:47 Lester Nare? Okay.
49:47 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. Something with a pH of 12.6 means that there's 10,000 fewer hydrogen ions and 10,000 more OH minus ions. Because the oxygen, the, the H2O can split into an H plus and an OH minus.
50:04 Lester Nare? Yep.
50:04 Krishna Choudhary? Right? 10,000 more OH minus ions and 10,000 fewer H plus ions. That is an incredibly basic environment. There's all these OH molecules with a minus, right? They're an ion. They're, it's extremely reactive. And the fact that anything can just like stay stable down there is incredible.
50:24 Lester Nare? Got it. Okay. Yeah.
50:25 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
50:25 Lester Nare? So what, what we're trying to identify is the base environment in which we are trying to even operate is not
50:33 Krishna Choudhary? Ridiculous.
50:33 Lester Nare? Is not conducive to operation.
50:35 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's ridiculous. To like, to like stuff that we know.
50:39 Lester Nare? Stuff that you're afraid.
50:40 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
50:40 Lester Nare? Right, right, right.
50:42 Krishna Choudhary? So here's how they can, they, they got the sample. They have something called a gravity corer. Okay. It's a, it's a, it's a core. So what they do is they, they get like a 1.4 ton weighted steel pipe and they just shoot that down into the, into the ocean floor.
51:01 Lester Nare? Yes.
51:01 Krishna Choudhary? And they grab like two meters worth of soils.
51:05 Lester Nare? So stay in there, right?
51:06 Krishna Choudhary? They bring it back up into the surface.
51:08 Lester Nare? Got it.
51:08 Krishna Choudhary? Then they take the mud out. The mud has this blue hue, which is serpentine, blue serpentine.
51:14 Lester Nare? Okay.
51:14 Krishna Choudhary? There you can see. And the, you can do mineralogy on it. You can do X-ray diffraction and thermogradity. And you can identify minerals like serpentine.
51:23 Lester Nare? Okay.
51:23 Krishna Choudhary? And brucite and things like that. The problem, and what you want to do is you want to find life there, right? The immediate thing that anyone would do, it's like, okay, I want to find life. What do I do? I look for DNA.
51:34 Lester Nare? Yeah.
51:35 Krishna Choudhary? Easy.
51:35 Lester Nare? Yeah.
51:35 Krishna Choudhary? I look for DNA.
51:38 Krishna Choudhary? This thing has about 10 cells per cubic centimeter. That's really low.
51:45 Lester Nare? Right.
51:45 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. Usually, usually you got something like 10 to the five cells per cubic centimeter in soil.
51:51 Lester Nare? Okay.
51:51 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, soil has a ridiculous amount of cells, a ridiculous amount of DNA. This thing has only 10. So what's going to end up happening, if you try doing something like PCA, which is polymerase chain reaction, it's basically a way to amplify DNA in your sample. So whatever little bit of DNA you have, you multiply it and then you try to, you know, put it through your measurement.
52:12 Lester Nare? Yep.
52:13 Krishna Choudhary? Sticks and you try to figure out what the thing is.
52:15 Lester Nare? Yep.
52:16 Krishna Choudhary? If you try to do that, you only got 10 living cells. Most of the DNA that you're going to have is just going to be dead stuff that's conglomerated on the ocean floor.
52:28 Lester Nare? Right.
52:29 Krishna Choudhary? Right? Because the ocean has just raining dead.
52:32 Lester Nare? Dead stuff all the time.
52:33 Krishna Choudhary? All the time. Phytoplankton, maybe a whale died somewhere. So you're going to have all of this random DNA and not the actual DNA of the stuff living in there.
52:46 Lester Nare? Not a perfect analogy, but if you try to take a photo that is really low resolution and blow it up to really high resolution, you're trying to take pixels that didn't exist and make them larger. And this is just going to be a larger version of not a lot of information.
52:59 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly. Like if you did one of those like AI deep pixelizers of a really bad photo. It's just going to start making up stuff.
53:08 Lester Nare? Right? Because you don't have actual, it's, this is dead information from potentially a lot of dead stuff.
53:12 Krishna Choudhary? A lot of that stuff that's just been raining down on the ocean floor.
53:15 Lester Nare? Yep.
53:16 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So you can't really do that.
53:18 Lester Nare? Okay, that makes sense.
53:18 Krishna Choudhary? So instead, what you do is you go for trying to detect lipids, which are fat molecules.
53:24 Lester Nare? Okay.
53:25 Krishna Choudhary? Lipids are the stuff that make up. The cell membranes of your cell, every single thing has this, okay? A lipid membrane, you need a lipid membrane because how do you, how do you define life? Well, you need an inside and outside, right?
53:40 Lester Nare? It's the border.
53:41 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
53:41 Lester Nare? How do you find a country? You need a border.
53:43 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah, but how do you define life? You need a border. You need a 2D border for a 3D object, right? And that is always a lipid, a bilipid membrane, right? So, so every single thing of life is gonna have these lipids. Now, there's gonna be two types of lipids. There's gonna be the living lipid.
54:02 Lester Nare? Okay.
54:02 Krishna Choudhary? From whatever's living in there. And then there's gonna be the dead stuff that's raining down. How do we actually discern between the two, right?
54:10 Lester Nare? Yep.
54:10 Krishna Choudhary? And so here, we're gonna have two different types of lipids. There's the core lipid, which is lipids that look like this. They've got a, um, they've got a part that likes water.
54:21 Lester Nare? Okay.
54:22 Krishna Choudhary? On the top.
54:22 Lester Nare? Yes.
54:23 Krishna Choudhary? The purple one, and then a part that doesn't like water.
54:26 Lester Nare? Yeah.
54:26 Krishna Choudhary? And what you do is you make two membranes out of this. So there's a part that likes water that is facing the outside.
54:31 Lester Nare? Yeah.
54:32 Krishna Choudhary? That is facing both the inside and the outside.
54:34 Lester Nare? Yeah.
54:34 Krishna Choudhary? And then the inner part is the part that doesn't like water. So now you've got a way to separate water from water.
54:41 Lester Nare? Yep.
54:41 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So you've got a way to separate the cytoplasm of your cell, the stuff that's inside, from the stuff that's outside, based on a wall that the water really doesn't like to cross.
54:50 Lester Nare? Yes.
54:53 Krishna Choudhary? Those lipids have two parts. There's the part that likes water, the hydrophilic part, and then the hydrophobic part, which is like the part that doesn't like water. If you see those intact, that means it's pretty recent. On the other hand, if it's died for a while, those two will have clipped off.
55:09 Lester Nare? Yeah.
55:10 Krishna Choudhary? And you're not gonna see the two.
55:11 Lester Nare? Together.
55:11 Krishna Choudhary? Together, right?
55:13 Lester Nare? Yeah.
55:13 Krishna Choudhary? So you've got these intact polar lipids.
55:16 Lester Nare? Okay.
55:16 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And that's what these guys were looking for.
55:19 Lester Nare? Make, that makes sense. The point being that the, by finding these, uh, what'd you say? Bipolar lipids?
55:27 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, polar lipids.
55:28 Lester Nare? Polar lipids.
55:29 Krishna Choudhary? Mm-hmm.
55:31 Lester Nare? Both sections still being
55:33 Krishna Choudhary? intact.
55:34 Lester Nare? In close proximity, meaning that they were preserving something inside that was a bi- like a living process.
55:40 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
55:41 Lester Nare? That means it was as close to living as we can get because they're still in close proximity.
55:45 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
55:46 Lester Nare? As an organism dies, those things naturally, because they no longer need to maintain the life inside, they will part away from each other.
55:53 Krishna Choudhary? Yes, exactly.
55:54 Lester Nare? And so this is like a tangible way for us to be like, this is recently living or currently living.
56:01 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
56:01 Lester Nare? Versus this is for sure dead.
56:02 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly, exactly. Right? So that's one way of doing this.
56:06 Lester Nare? Okay.
56:06 Krishna Choudhary? The other way to do this is to actually look at the carbon isotopes in your life.
56:11 Lester Nare? Mm hmm.
56:11 Krishna Choudhary? Right? There's a, there's two stable isotopes. There's carbon 13 and carbon 12. Carbon 12 is way more abundant than carbon 13, but both are sort of mixed in together. There's a baseline, like, there's a baseline abundance of them, but life is gonna have way more carbon 12 than carbon 13 because it's lighter. And so whatever enzymatic action is happening, the enzymes are lazy and they're gonna use the carbon 12 more than the carbon 13 because the carbon 13 is harder to move around.
56:44 Lester Nare? Yep.
56:44 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
56:45 Lester Nare? Takes more energy.
56:46 Krishna Choudhary? It's takes more energy, right? And so for whatever little bit of energy you have, you're gonna usually, just by probability, fix the carbon 12 into your organic chemistry more than your carbon 12, carbon 13.
56:57 Lester Nare? That makes sense.
56:58 Krishna Choudhary? So by looking at this abundance, we can also tell whether what we're looking at is alive now or has died and is just sort of, you know, a part of the thing.
57:07 Lester Nare? Yes.
57:08 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
57:08 Lester Nare? Yes.
57:08 Krishna Choudhary? And from this, they, they found that there's, there's, one thing that was really cool is when they look at the mudline, right? They have this two meters, two or three meters of the ocean floor.
57:19 Lester Nare? Yes.
57:19 Krishna Choudhary? At the very top, that's close to the ocean floor, they don't see a lot of these biomarkers.
57:24 Lester Nare? Okay.
57:25 Krishna Choudhary? So a lot of the stuff is dead, but underneath, they're seeing living organisms.
57:30 Lester Nare? Hmm.
57:31 Krishna Choudhary? Right? So there's a living tissue that's happening underneath.
57:35 Lester Nare? There's a layer of dead stuff.
57:36 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. And then there's active biology.
57:39 Lester Nare? Underneath it.
57:40 Krishna Choudhary? Underneath it, right? And by doing a bunch of different Oxidation measurements and like HPLCs and all this other kind of stuff. They came up with a really complicated ecosystem where you can actually like find like what were the things that are making this happen? And they have an hypothesis where the methane comes from the bottom and the CO2 comes from the top and the water comes from the top. And they have all of these different mechanisms that they've actually traced through.
58:10 Lester Nare? Yep.
58:11 Krishna Choudhary? To create a magnificent ecosystem, right?
58:15 Lester Nare? This is, it, there's a circle of life just for this.
58:18 Krishna Choudhary? Just in there.
58:19 Lester Nare? Just in this area.
58:19 Krishna Choudhary? Isolated from the sun, there's no sun.
58:22 Lester Nare? Right, right, which is important.
58:24 Krishna Choudhary? This is important. It's isolated from the sun. It's completely driven by chemical processes that are happening because of the interaction between water and the earth's crust, right? And it's completely in isolation from the rest of life on earth.
58:44 Krishna Choudhary? I think that's, that's, that's a foundational claim.
58:48 Lester Nare? Because, because, and again, I think that, just to kind of parse the implications a little bit here, part of the point is for a layman like myself, a lot of times we'll think of sunlight, solar energy as being a required prerequisite for all life. And when the sun goes away, you can't have the light life because that's the only source. Yeah. It's why photosynthesis is so foundational and all this other stuff. What this is saying is independent of sunlight, and this goes back to your point earlier about why it's different than the heat vents.
59:30 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
59:30 Lester Nare? Or heat.
59:31 Krishna Choudhary? Or, yeah, yeah, yeah, or heat or the sulfur, the, the active stuff moving out. This is just like slow chemistry.
59:39 Lester Nare? Happening.
59:40 Krishna Choudhary? In the crust.
59:41 Lester Nare? And it, and it, and out of that slow chemistry.
59:44 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
59:44 Lester Nare? Crust, you still get life.
59:46 Krishna Choudhary? You still get life. They still find a way. Right? As Jeff Goldblum was saying, life finds a way, no matter where. And it's incredible how they find a way, right? There's all these adaptations that they've come up with. For example, in there, in that high pH, those lipid molecules are just going to become like soap. Right? So how do you prevent the sopification of my cell membrane? Well, instead of the estrobonds, they're using etherbonds. So instead of a carbonyl bond where the carbon is attached to an oxygen and then two groups, you've got an oxygen that's mediating that. And that oxygen becomes the anchor for your phospholipids. Not phospholipids, sorry, glycolipids, because you don't have a lot of phosphate.
1:00:28 Lester Nare? Right.
1:00:29 Krishna Choudhary? So you're using actually like sugar and a bunch of lipids to actually create your cell membrane. The other thing that's kind of crazy is that, you know, at that temperature, fat freezes, right? Butter, butter is a solid in the fridge, but that's because it's a saturated lipid. If you use unsaturated lipids like oil, that's not going to freeze. And the reason why it's unsaturated is because you've got these kinks in your carbon skeleton. You've got a double bond instead of all single bonds. And a double bond means you're going to have a kink in your carbon skeleton, which means it's not going to stack up as nicely as saturated lipids will, right? And if you're saturated, then everything's going to stack up and you're going to become solid.
1:01:12 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:01:13 Krishna Choudhary? But without the saturation, then you're going to remain liquid and you can, you can have that malleability that you need for life.
1:01:21 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:01:22 Krishna Choudhary? That's, and it's so funny that it's literally that double bond kink of, let me actually pull that back up. That was photo 12, that double bond kink of carbon in the middle.
1:01:33 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:01:34 Krishna Choudhary? Literally just that.
1:01:35 Lester Nare? Just that.
1:01:36 Krishna Choudhary? Totally.
1:01:37 Lester Nare? Change, change the entirety of the, the expanded structure that you scale up to.
1:01:42 Krishna Choudhary? It's kind of crazy, right?
1:01:43 Lester Nare? It's crazy.
1:01:44 Krishna Choudhary? Like life figures out ways to.
1:01:46 Lester Nare? It's crazy.
1:01:47 Krishna Choudhary? To make it work.
1:01:48 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:01:49 Krishna Choudhary? You know?
1:01:49 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:01:50 Krishna Choudhary? Using fundamental, it's just fundamental physics. The double bond creates a kind of weird quantum mechanical effect here, where like now my bond can't be linear.
1:01:59 Lester Nare? Right. And which means it can't, at this temperature, it can't just then solidify into a block. It has to remain in that liquid.
1:02:07 Krishna Choudhary? It's so cool.
1:02:07 Lester Nare? Yeah, I like that.
1:02:08 Krishna Choudhary? It's so cool that like life can find this out. And this has huge astrobiological implications.
1:02:13 Lester Nare? Obviously.
1:02:14 Krishna Choudhary? And for me, that's the coolest part.
1:02:17 Krishna Choudhary? The cool biosphere analog, right? Like the Marianas Trench is this first high fidelity analog of cool serpentization. In the cold.
1:02:26 Lester Nare? In the cold.
1:02:27 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, not in the hot.
1:02:28 Lester Nare? Right.
1:02:29 Krishna Choudhary? Not in these zones where the plates are drifting apart.
1:02:33 Lester Nare? And then the heat's coming out and sulfur and all this.
1:02:36 Krishna Choudhary? This is cold.
1:02:37 Lester Nare? That's actually really important. So like all of the ice moons.
1:02:41 Krishna Choudhary? Mm hmm.
1:02:42 Lester Nare? Become much more interesting.
1:02:44 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
1:02:44 Lester Nare? Because of the existence of proving that cold serpents, it's cool serpentization can have a biosphere.
1:02:50 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly, exactly. And Enceladus is a big one. Cassini actually sampled plumes. This is a moon of Saturn. And Enceladus is something where we know there's an ocean, oceanic ocean.
1:03:03 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:03:04 Krishna Choudhary? There's an ocean there, there's a crust on top. And there's so much geologic activity that there's actually geysers that shoot out plumes of stuff into the, into the, into the cosmos. And Cassini, we were lucky enough, the Cassini got close enough that it actually sampled those plumes.
1:03:22 Lester Nare? As it was flying by.
1:03:23 Krishna Choudhary? As it was flying by. And what we measured was hydrogen gas and methane.
1:03:30 Lester Nare? Which is.
1:03:31 Krishna Choudhary? Which is exactly what we have here.
1:03:34 Lester Nare? Meaning, and so like, just, I know I'm extrapolating. This is an extrapolation. However, given what we just walked through about what we've seen at these two plates.
1:03:46 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:03:47 Lester Nare? The Marianas Trench on Earth, where we were able to send down our little torpedo, pull up meters worth. The top layer was dead, but below that, the same chemistry. That exists in that region here on Earth mimics the chemistry that Cassini pulled up.
1:04:07 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:04:09 Lester Nare? And there's a direct match.
1:04:11 Krishna Choudhary? There's a direct match.
1:04:13 Lester Nare? That's not to say that there is life on Enceladus.
1:04:18 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:04:19 Lester Nare? However, the chemistry.
1:04:21 Krishna Choudhary? The chemistry is very same same.
1:04:23 Lester Nare? It's very similar.
1:04:24 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:04:26 Lester Nare? A pizza in New York is not the same thing as a pizza in California.
1:04:30 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:04:30 Lester Nare? I get it.
1:04:31 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:04:32 Lester Nare? But it's still a pizza.
1:04:33 Krishna Choudhary? But, but, but there's possibility there.
1:04:35 Lester Nare? Which is so exciting.
1:04:36 Krishna Choudhary? That was just so exciting.
1:04:37 Lester Nare? So exciting.
1:04:38 Krishna Choudhary? The other thing with Europa, right? Models predict that serpentinization is actually more probable than, let's say, deep sea vents.
1:04:44 Lester Nare? Which makes sense.
1:04:45 Krishna Choudhary? On Europa, which makes sense.
1:04:46 Lester Nare? Right.
1:04:46 Krishna Choudhary? And now we've got Europa Clipper going there. It's going to do a bunch of things. If we're going to send, you know, if we get our funding back and JPL gets its funding back.
1:04:56 Lester Nare? Need our funding back.
1:04:56 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. But if we do, then we're going to send, you know, let's say something that drills into the Europa.
1:05:02 Lester Nare? Yep.
1:05:02 Krishna Choudhary? Ocean and then tries to look for it. Well, those things should probably have a mass spectrometer, right? Because the mass spectrometer is what was used to actually characterize these lipids.
1:05:13 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:05:14 Krishna Choudhary? And these lipid biomarkers. So maybe let's not look for DNA. Maybe let's look for lipids, right? This introduces a whole new paradigm for what to even look for when we go to these distant worlds.
1:05:27 Lester Nare? That's a brilliant insight.
1:05:28 Krishna Choudhary? Looking for extraterrestrial life.
1:05:29 Lester Nare? That's a brilliant insight in that what we look for determines the results.
1:05:33 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:05:34 Lester Nare? It's the so, it's the pushback that people have given about SETI looking for radio signals. And it's like any sufficient technological da, da, da, like, would they be still using it? Yada, yada. I mean, in a, in an analog, in an analogy, what we're saying is historically, maybe we'd always be looking for DNA as the sign of life. Looking for lipids, the presence of lipids is another signature.
1:05:55 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
1:05:56 Lester Nare? That is equally relevant and viable in that search and might be more fruitful. Because even on Earth, we can see in regions that we previously believed to be uninhabitable. Life is there, but the way we found it was not through the DNA. It was through the discovery of the lipid presence.
1:06:14 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly. And like, who knows? Maybe they have a different form of genetic material, right? DNA is like this arbitrary thing that perhaps our ancestor four billion years ago came up with, right? To, to encode data.
1:06:28 Lester Nare? Right.
1:06:28 Krishna Choudhary? But there, there's, there's got to be other ways, right? It's just whoever came up with it first was like, this is dope.
1:06:34 Lester Nare? Right.
1:06:34 Krishna Choudhary? And then just like ran. And whether.
1:06:36 Lester Nare? Right.
1:06:36 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:06:37 Lester Nare? Right. We are living with the choices that the internet pioneers of the early 90s decided how a browser was going to work and how graphical user interface is going to work.
1:06:49 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:06:49 Lester Nare? That's just what it is.
1:06:50 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:06:51 Lester Nare? And now we have to deal with that. That is a very interesting story.
1:06:54 Krishna Choudhary? That was very cool.
1:06:55 Lester Nare? With huge implications, not only for, again, expanding our idea of what does life mean just here on earth, but then informing how we ask questions about the universe around us.
1:07:06 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:07:06 Lester Nare? In that same journey. Fascinating, fascinating paper. We have that one again from University of Bremen. That was in Nature Communications, Earth and Environment. This, this week of stories is fantastic. We're going to move on to our third story, our last story of the day, our Princeton story.
1:07:26 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
1:07:26 Lester Nare? We've, we've, we've kept a couple of weeks of not shilling Princeton. But like, when you're the best, things happen.
1:07:33 Krishna Choudhary? I don't know what to tell you.
1:07:33 Lester Nare? Like, it's just, it's, it's a breakthrough. And so we cover breakthroughs. The millisecond transmon qubit breakthrough out of Princeton. This was in Nature, no sub-journal.
1:07:45 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:07:46 Lester Nare? Nature mainline. Princeton's new quantum chip makes a major step toward quantum advantage. Now, in a previous episode, you explained to me the distinction between quantum advantage and quantum supremacy.
1:08:00 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
1:08:00 Lester Nare? In the context of Google's paper claiming that they've achieved quantum supremacy, which received a significant amount of pushback. But this is about Princeton's quantum computing for a new qubit. Qubit being like the fundamental unit, bit in a classical computer.
1:08:18 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
1:08:18 Lester Nare? Qubit in a quantum computer. So what is it that we, literally we, as in you and I personally?
1:08:25 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Hey, I, I donate, I donate, I donate every year. They called me up like last month, being like, hey, are you good? The class of 2014. I was like, yeah, fine, fine, fine, fine, fine here.
1:08:37 Lester Nare? As long as I get to claim that I was the one who came up with this quantum breakthrough.
1:08:42 Krishna Choudhary? So, so talk to help me understand like what?
1:08:45 Lester Nare? Talk about quantum quite a bit, actually.
1:08:47 Krishna Choudhary? We do.
1:08:47 Lester Nare? So this is, it has to be actually a big deal.
1:08:49 Krishna Choudhary? Yes.
1:08:50 Lester Nare? For you have put it.
1:08:50 Krishna Choudhary? It is, it is, it is a big deal. Yeah. So quantum computers, right? The promise is to break encryption, simulate materials. You get a better portfolio for your financial stocks because it's going to like figure out the best way to do things. And all of that relies on actually making a quantum computer, right? And making a quantum computer, as of now, it's still a hardware problem.
1:09:12 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:09:13 Krishna Choudhary? Okay. It is still a hardware problem. A quantum computer, let me just go through briefly what a quantum computer is, okay? It uses a qubit instead of a classical bit. So a classical bit is your transistor that is in a state of either I'm going to let current through or I'm going to block current. So that's my zero and one. A qubit can be in a superposition of two states. It can be in a zero and a one, and it can be in a linear combination of something in between. The other thing that's different about a qubit versus a classical bit is a classical bit, one transistor doesn't really talk to another until it's like really told to, right? It's like maybe one, one transistor flips its sign based on the state of another transistor.
1:09:58 Krishna Choudhary? And that's an explicit sort of thing that we're doing within the algorithm of whatever we're implementing. But in a qubit, the power of the qubits is that they can be entangled to one another. They are not independent, right? So one qubit can be in a superposition of zeros and ones. Another qubit right next to it can be in a superposition of zeros and ones and so on and so forth. And I can get access to an exponentially large number of states in my memory without actually having to explicitly encode each one of them, right?
1:10:32 Lester Nare? As a terrible analogy, because I'm always trying to figure out ways to think about it in my head. If you have a relay race, a four by four hundred, classical computers, you have to wait to hand the baton to the next runner.
1:10:44 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:10:45 Lester Nare? But in a quantum computer, my first lap, my first runner can have like multiple. Runs and like whichever one happens to get there first is like and so it's like you're
1:10:56 Krishna Choudhary? All four just basically cheat.
1:10:58 Lester Nare? Right, right, right.
1:10:59 Krishna Choudhary? Go through the whole thing.
1:11:00 Lester Nare? Yeah. But just as trying to like contextualize like what the difference is when you say that a qubit can be in a superposition of both zero and one, there's not, you're not waiting for the handoff in order for the next thing to do its next process.
1:11:15 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, you can do a lot of things in parallel.
1:11:17 Lester Nare? In parallel.
1:11:18 Krishna Choudhary? And, and you can access a lot of computational stuff in parallel.
1:11:23 Lester Nare? In parallel.
1:11:23 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, it's a weak analogy, but it'll work.
1:11:25 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:11:25 Krishna Choudhary? Actually. And, and at the end of the day, how a quantum algorithm works is the following, there's something that's very famous called the Shores algorithm. Okay, this is the one that all the NSA and everyone is excited about because this is the algorithm that lets you break RSA encryption.
1:11:43 Lester Nare? Got it.
1:11:44 Krishna Choudhary? But it works like any other quantum algorithm and that here's what happens, you've got a bunch of qubits that you're going to prepare in some kind of state, let's just say for, for argument's sake, I'm going to prepare them in the zero state. So they're all zero. And then what I'm going to do is I'm going to apply quantum gates to these guys. Okay. And what that means is I'm going to poke this qubit a one way, so it's going to maybe flip from a zero to a one, or it's going to flip into halfway between zero and a one. And then this guy's going to talk to its neighbor, who's going to talk to his neighbor. And all of these quantum gates are basically pokes in some way of each of the bits that I have. The, the key bottleneck is the following, okay?
1:12:28 Krishna Choudhary? My gates and my poking have to be faster than how long it takes for my qubit to forget itself. Here's what I mean by that.
1:12:38 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:12:39 Krishna Choudhary? In a transistor, if I turn it off, it's going to stay off.
1:12:43 Lester Nare? It's off.
1:12:43 Krishna Choudhary? Unless like a cosmic ray comes in and like, like, you know, the, the, some proton comes in and knocks exactly that transistor from a zero to a one, it's going to remain off and I can reliably come back and it'll remain off. This is how data works, right? Why, why is my data, or how do I store stuff? Right? This, this is the transistor is in the, in, or like whatever thing is in the zero and the one is going to be in the zero and one forever. It's not a transistor, it's solid state or whatever. But at the end of the day, I have some time horizon that is way longer than my computation.
1:13:19 Krishna Choudhary? That I know can reliably remember if it's a zero or a one. In quantum mechanics, that's no longer the case because these qubits are made out of incredibly small technologies. Okay. And so there's a lot of forgetting that happens. I prepare my qubit in a zero state. For example, let's take the extreme case of an electron that's spinning in one direction. And that's my zero. If it spins in the other direction, that's my one. Well, I need this thing to remember that it's spinning in that direction. But if there's a bunch of stuff around it, it's going to start poking it, right? There's a bunch of atoms and a bunch of little magnetic fields that the atoms create that are going to try to change the way that my electron is spinning.
1:14:03 Krishna Choudhary? So if my electron is a qubit where spinning down is zero and spinning up is one, and I prepare it in the down, it's not going to take very long for that electron to just get influenced by all of the stuff around it and forget that it was a zero in the first place. This is called the decoherence time.
1:14:23 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:14:24 Krishna Choudhary? And one of the central challenges is, one of the central challenges in creating a workable quantum computer is to make the decoherence time way, way longer than the
1:14:39 Krishna Choudhary? algorithm time.
1:14:40 Lester Nare? So, so this, this actually makes total sense. The, the point is you don't actually have like a workspace that is active for long enough for you to do like,
1:14:49 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:14:50 Lester Nare? Like valuable computation.
1:14:52 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:14:53 Lester Nare? To get an output because the decoherence time is so short. Similar to our first story, because we're at a scale now where the little stuff changes in very, very, very small things that might not have mattered in a classical system.
1:15:06 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:15:07 Lester Nare? Matter a lot in this quantum system in the same way that like under five Mach, you don't have to worry about the little stuff.
1:15:13 Krishna Choudhary? Mm hmm.
1:15:13 Lester Nare? But above five Mach, you have to worry about
1:15:15 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:15:16 Lester Nare? Stuff in a, in a different way.
1:15:17 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
1:15:17 Lester Nare? Or the details matter. And so.
1:15:21 Lester Nare? If you can increase the decoherence time, that means I can run a long-running algorithm. It's like a context window in AI.
1:15:28 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly.
1:15:29 Lester Nare? Like you, you have more time to do the thing you want to do before it forgets.
1:15:36 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, before, before it forgets, right?
1:15:37 Lester Nare? The system.
1:15:38 Krishna Choudhary? And there, yeah, yeah. And there, and there's ways to do this to get around it. There's stuff called error correction, where what you do is you like replicate the qubit multiple times. And then you have like a bunch of qubits retain that information. So if one of them forgets, you can have like the other guy. But like at the end of the day, a hardware solution is, is king.
1:15:56 Lester Nare? It's not, it's not clean.
1:15:57 Krishna Choudhary? It's not clean. Right, right. You have to do all of these contingencies. If you have a hardware solution, well, then you can implement that software solution with the hardware solution.
1:16:06 Lester Nare? Exactly.
1:16:06 Krishna Choudhary? And even multiply.
1:16:08 Lester Nare? Correct.
1:16:08 Krishna Choudhary? Right, beyond like what you were. So the hardware is always king.
1:16:12 Lester Nare? The king, the biggest fundamental limit is still at the hardware.
1:16:15 Krishna Choudhary? It's still at the hardware level. Exactly. And so there's different kinds of qubits. I just gave an illusion of the electron being a single qubit, right? Where it's like spinning one way or the other way. The one that we're talking about is actually pioneered by the 2025 Nobel Prize in Physics by these three gentlemen, John Clark, Michelle Deveray, and John Martinez back in UC Berkeley. They came up with this idea of macroscopic quantum tunneling, right? The idea was to make a quantum circuit, a tiny little circuit that had something called a Josephson junction.
1:16:47 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:16:48 Krishna Choudhary? And then you have on the order of billions of electrons that behave like a single quantum unit that are tunneling from one to the other, from one to the other, right?
1:16:59 Lester Nare? We had a great deep dive on this during the Nobel Prizes. So it is a phenomenally well-done deep dive.
1:17:06 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:17:07 Lester Nare? So please go check out our, our Nobel Prize episode on this because if you're curious about this concept of the superconducting circuits with Josephson junctions and macroscopic quantum tunneling, it is really fascinating.
1:17:20 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:17:20 Lester Nare? And we have, I think, one of the best explainer videos out.
1:17:24 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:17:24 Lester Nare? That's available.
1:17:25 Krishna Choudhary? We won an award from TikTok.
1:17:26 Lester Nare? We, we did. TikTok did give us a second place for our science content because it was so good. And I just was so fascinated.
1:17:34 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah.
1:17:35 Lester Nare? And please watch that video.
1:17:36 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly. So, so these guys sort of, you know, went. And created that thing.
1:17:42 Lester Nare? Right.
1:17:43 Krishna Choudhary? And IBM and Google now use something called the transmon design, which is a charge qubit. It's basically their design, but they've attached a large capacitor on the side.
1:17:51 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:17:52 Krishna Choudhary? And they've made it insensitive to charge noise. But this is, this is basically the qubit that they're using to make the, um, the quantum computers that they talk about.
1:18:01 Lester Nare? So currently there's not a lot of quantum computers that are being built. There's very few amount of entities that are doing so. The ones that are, like you're saying with, with IBM and they're using this particular structure for the, in order to be able to like, do the, the process that we're talking about, how, which has existed prior to the paper.
1:18:25 Krishna Choudhary? Yes, exactly.
1:18:26 Lester Nare? Like, like there, there's a platform that everyone's using saying, this is kind of the way we gotta go, everybody. This is the current state of the art.
1:18:33 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:18:33 Lester Nare? And that's what it is.
1:18:34 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, exactly. But those guys had this problem of decoherence time. This new paper that's come out, um, in nature.
1:18:42 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:18:43 Krishna Choudhary? Millisecond time scales. They're, they're getting, they're getting their stuff all the way to milliseconds.
1:18:49 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:18:49 Krishna Choudhary? And this is a victory against the materials that we're using to actually create that transmon qubit. And this millisecond time scale is about three times the time scale that was there before, the record.
1:19:03 Lester Nare? Got it.
1:19:03 Krishna Choudhary? And it's 15 times what is the industry standard.
1:19:07 Lester Nare? Okay, got it.
1:19:08 Krishna Choudhary? Okay.
1:19:08 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:19:09 Krishna Choudhary? It's very long.
1:19:09 Lester Nare? It is an order of magnitude.
1:19:11 Krishna Choudhary? Order of magnitude.
1:19:12 Lester Nare? Um, better improvements, uh, upscale. Got it.
1:19:16 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly, yeah.
1:19:16 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:19:17 Krishna Choudhary? And what they're doing is they've, uh, the, the problem is, as I was saying, right? There's these tiny defects that happen everywhere else that sort of make my qubit forget what I am. If it's a zero, it'll just go halfway. If it's a one, it'll go halfway. Um, there's all these like glassy materials. There's oxides, there's substrates that happen when I construct my chip that is gonna, that is gonna make the decoherence happen. And so.
1:19:44 Lester Nare? And just, just to kind of zoom in on that point. The point is. In the process of generating these chips, we have to make things at these incredibly small scales. Our engineering capabilities are quite good, but there are still levels of imperfection or just that the scales are so small that things happen in ways-
1:20:05 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, this is at the tens of atoms, hundreds of atoms.
1:20:07 Lester Nare? So the slightest little thing is going to, again, take our gate of our decoherence time and shrink it with any amount of 10 to the negative-
1:20:20 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:20:20 Lester Nare? -big number imperfection, which is like barely anything.
1:20:24 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:20:25 Lester Nare? Am I understanding that correctly?
1:20:26 Krishna Choudhary? But to the quantum world, it matters.
1:20:27 Lester Nare? It's everything. Okay.
1:20:29 Krishna Choudhary? You know?
1:20:29 Lester Nare? Yes, yes. So that is one of the core sources of the decoherence time problem.
1:20:36 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, is all of these little imperfections that are coming in. And so there's been a history of trying to make things better.
1:20:45 Lester Nare? Right.
1:20:45 Krishna Choudhary? Okay, when it comes to getting longer and longer decoherence times. The first platform was to try and use niobium and aluminum. The sapphire, actually, sapphire is just aluminum oxide. And that was being used. Instead of niobium, in 2021, there was a breakthrough. The same group, actually, instead of niobium, they used tantalum on the sapphire aluminum oxide. And there they got up to about 300 milliseconds.
1:21:12 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:21:13 Krishna Choudhary? Okay?
1:21:13 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:21:14 Krishna Choudhary? Sorry, 300.3 milliseconds, so 300 microseconds.
1:21:18 Lester Nare? Microseconds.
1:21:19 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
1:21:19 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:21:19 Krishna Choudhary? And then finally now, they've challenged this bottleneck. And instead of using sapphire, they're using high resistance silicon.
1:21:30 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:21:31 Krishna Choudhary? So extremely pure silicon that is high resistance.
1:21:34 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:21:34 Krishna Choudhary? And what's happening is you're superconducting stuff that's happening in the qubit. It's no longer dissipating energy into the substrate itself because the substrate has such high resistance. One way to think about it is the energy just doesn't want to go there. Right? And so it's staying within the qubit, the part of the circuit that actually matters.
1:21:56 Lester Nare? They've they've locked down their border.
1:21:58 Krishna Choudhary? Yes, yes, in some sense, exactly. That's exactly right. They've eliminated this bulk loss. And using tantalum, which is something that not a lot of people use, but these guys were using it. Tantalum turns out to be much better than niobium and aluminum. So it's this combination of tantalum and silicon. And that was super non trivial for them to actually grow. Because you've got silicon and you've got tantalum on top. There's all this like chemistry that's happening, this like kinda weird. They had to use a really ultra high vacuum before they were using just high vacuum.
1:22:33 Lester Nare? And it wasn't enough.
1:22:34 Krishna Choudhary? It wasn't enough. Yeah, yeah. So they had to use ultra high vacuum. So that when they were depositing this stuff, no weird oil was getting in, nothing like that. When it interacts with the air, nothing weird is happening. It's it's it's been a process that's been happening for quite some time, but at the end of the day, they beat that millisecond barrier. And they got to.
1:22:55 Lester Nare? The key, the point is like they had to cook up like like Breaking Bad.
1:22:59 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:23:00 Lester Nare? Like Heisman, they had to cook up the the material.
1:23:03 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:23:03 Lester Nare? That actually went into the the the thing itself, the chip itself, that is being now used to do this process.
1:23:10 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly. Like completely novel.
1:23:11 Lester Nare? It's not like you can just go like, hey Nvidia, like, hey, you know, TSMC.
1:23:16 Krishna Choudhary? No.
1:23:17 Lester Nare? And then let's.
1:23:17 Krishna Choudhary? They were doing it.
1:23:18 Lester Nare? They had to, which like I I wanna like make that.
1:23:21 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:23:21 Lester Nare? Like, that's a big.
1:23:24 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah.
1:23:24 Lester Nare? Challenge.
1:23:25 Krishna Choudhary? It's it's it's multiple groups in the university. The chemistry department was involved, the electrical engineering department was involved. Like, like, there's all these different players that were like, oh, actually, I'm really good at tantalum.
1:23:36 Lester Nare? Yeah, right.
1:23:37 Krishna Choudhary? And I'm pretty sure you need tantalum.
1:23:39 Lester Nare? Right.
1:23:39 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And then somebody else was like, put this on the silicon and you're gonna need a higher vacuum.
1:23:44 Lester Nare? You're gonna need a higher vacuum. Yeah, someone was like, you're gonna need more cowbell.
1:23:47 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. And there's all of these different, different factors that are coming in in this ecosystem at Princeton.
1:23:52 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:23:53 Krishna Choudhary? To create this qubit. And this qubit is amazing. It's got the best one. The best one had 1.7 milliseconds.
1:24:03 Lester Nare? That's crazy.
1:24:03 Krishna Choudhary? And to tell you just how how big this is, you know, before you were getting to point three.
1:24:08 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:24:08 Krishna Choudhary? The best one is now five times.
1:24:10 Lester Nare? Yeah, right, right.
1:24:11 Krishna Choudhary? And that point three was in a lab setting. It's not at the industrial setting. Okay? So you're getting, you're getting almost 20 times to 25 times the industrial setting of stuff, right? And. You might be thinking, you know, a millisecond, that's a thousandth of a second. Thousandth of a second is not very long. Well, the gates, right? The, the, the stuff that we're using for quantum stuff.
1:24:33 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:24:33 Krishna Choudhary? Is on the order of tens of nanoseconds. Right? So you can fit in a lot more.
1:24:39 Lester Nare? Stuff.
1:24:39 Krishna Choudhary? Stuff in one millisecond now. A nanosecond is a hundred thousandth of a millisecond. A millionth, sorry, yeah.
1:24:48 Lester Nare? The, the, this is actually really significant because um. It's also because it's like quant, like when you're doing, it's paralyzed, right? So it's, it's the volume of what you're actually doing. It's not like, it's not like every millisecond that goes by. Because you're now paralyzed in what you're actually doing, like the actual amount of work.
1:25:13 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:25:13 Lester Nare? The way we think about it in a classical sense. It, I, I, I don't know if I'm.
1:25:18 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, no, no, no. Exactly. You're exactly right. Like the, the, the. How do we say it? The, the, the amount of stuff you can do with this.
1:25:28 Lester Nare? The amount of tokens, the token output.
1:25:30 Krishna Choudhary? Mm hmm.
1:25:30 Lester Nare? Is, is, is not just like the same as you would get in a millisecond on a classical.
1:25:35 Krishna Choudhary? No, no, not at all.
1:25:36 Lester Nare? The token output is like running chat GPT paralyzed N number of times. And all of those token outputs get you to your derived, like your ideal whatever app. I'm just trying to talk about how that millisecond difference is extremely meaningful.
1:25:52 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly. And the other thing is, you know, getting, let's say 20 times longer.
1:25:57 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:25:58 Krishna Choudhary? In this decoherence time.
1:25:59 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:26:00 Krishna Choudhary? Adds up exponentially because, because here this is a physical error, right? This is, this is something that's happening at the hardware level, right? So all of your error correction algorithms can now take advantage of the fact that the thing that they are doing, the error correction on is itself. Not that bad.
1:26:19 Lester Nare? Yeah, it's less error prone.
1:26:20 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:26:21 Lester Nare? Right, right. It's more, it has higher efficacy.
1:26:23 Krishna Choudhary? So, so, so you're adding on exponential on exponential.
1:26:26 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:26:27 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And, and it's gonna, it's gonna be a really big thing, I think. The, the other, the other huge thing about this is this chip, um, which is it's, it's just an upgrade on the industry dominant Transmon architecture.
1:26:41 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:26:42 Krishna Choudhary? Which is the same thing that IBM and Google have been using in their current architecture.
1:26:47 Lester Nare? Right.
1:26:47 Krishna Choudhary? Right? The recent paper that came out of the Willow.
1:26:50 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:26:50 Krishna Choudhary? Quantum chip in Google.
1:26:52 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:26:52 Krishna Choudhary? It's using the same architecture.
1:26:54 Lester Nare? Okay.
1:26:54 Krishna Choudhary? So the thing is, this is something like, uh, I can take that out.
1:26:58 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:26:59 Krishna Choudhary? And I can put this thing in.
1:27:00 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:27:00 Krishna Choudhary? Right?
1:27:01 Lester Nare? All of the, outside of the chip itself, there's all of the other, the cooling system, like all of the other infrastructure.
1:27:06 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, the way I talk to the chip.
1:27:08 Lester Nare? All of that.
1:27:09 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:27:09 Lester Nare? They can hot swap the chip.
1:27:11 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
1:27:12 Lester Nare? It's not a new, it's not a totally new, uh, chip design that requires a refactoring of the rest of the infrastructure.
1:27:19 Krishna Choudhary? Exactly.
1:27:20 Lester Nare? That's really.
1:27:20 Krishna Choudhary? That's huge, actually, right? Because, because now this is scalable.
1:27:24 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:27:24 Krishna Choudhary? It's industry compatible.
1:27:25 Lester Nare? It's industry, yay.
1:27:26 Krishna Choudhary? Right? And, and so, and so if Willow just gets this design, it's gonna be a thousand times better. And Willow already is like making headlines.
1:27:36 Lester Nare? Mm hmm.
1:27:36 Krishna Choudhary? So imagine what it can do with this, right?
1:27:38 Lester Nare? Yeah.
1:27:38 Krishna Choudhary? It's really bringing us closer to that future, possibly, of where something scientifically standard could be happening with quantum computers, you know, within the next decade.
1:27:51 Lester Nare? Mm hmm.
1:27:52 Krishna Choudhary? You know?
1:27:52 Lester Nare? Mm hmm. And I, I mean, there's, again, everyone always talks about all the implications of quantum computers. The one that still gets me most excited is like the ability to create simulations and models with higher fidelity.
1:28:04 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:28:04 Lester Nare? Coming back to our first story.
1:28:05 Krishna Choudhary? New materials.
1:28:06 Lester Nare? Yeah, right, right. And like the, the things you can then.
1:28:08 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. Instead of trying a thousand different materials to see which one is the room temperature superconductor.
1:28:14 Lester Nare? You can just.
1:28:15 Krishna Choudhary? I can just like simulate a bunch and then be like, oh, these are 10 good candidates. Let me try making those and, you know?
1:28:21 Lester Nare? Because like, like AlphaFold was a lower complexity problem to like do all the folds that proteins can do.
1:28:27 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's. Still an incredible.
1:28:29 Lester Nare? Not minimizing.
1:28:30 Krishna Choudhary? Not me, yeah.
1:28:31 Lester Nare? Not minimizing, but we've already crossed that bridge. So you know what I'm saying?
1:28:35 Krishna Choudhary? You already got the Nobel.
1:28:36 Lester Nare? That's in the past. He's trying to go orders of magnitude.
1:28:39 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Now we're doing quantum mechanics, motherfucker.
1:28:42 Lester Nare? Which is like, it's a big, that's a big, these, all of these stories are actually pretty crazy.
1:28:47 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, like, so, so I think this is, this is huge. The other thing is, um, they're using silicon, right? Instead of sapphire, so instead of aluminum oxide, they're using silicon. Well, we're as humans incredible at making silicon.
1:28:59 Lester Nare? We have the whole, the whole industrial infrastructure for that is actually like prime.
1:29:03 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. So scalability in terms of that is going to be huge.
1:29:06 Lester Nare? That makes sense.
1:29:06 Krishna Choudhary? Right.
1:29:06 Lester Nare? Makes sense.
1:29:08 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, we can piggyback on this trillion dollar semiconductor fabrication process.
1:29:14 Lester Nare? This is crazy.
1:29:15 Krishna Choudhary? Right. Yeah. And that's, that's a photo of one of the grad students probably posing with it.
1:29:20 Lester Nare? Yeah, they're like, we don't need your face. We just need your beautiful hands.
1:29:22 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, yeah, yeah. You're a hand model.
1:29:24 Lester Nare? Yeah, put the gloves on them. This is expensive.
1:29:28 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, exactly. Um, so yeah, very, very, very cool. I think, I think it primes the new chips for industrial scaling. We could be, we could be getting, we could be getting ever closer to that dream.
1:29:41 Lester Nare? This, so now I can read the title, the millisecond. Five X, three to five X longer amount of time you can actually run and keep things in memory, for lack of a better term. Transmon the platform that is already industry standard that's used. And so it's not like net new and everyone has to change everything.
1:30:01 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:30:02 Lester Nare? Qubit breakthrough, the, the type of thing we do, the tantalum silicon qubit out of Princeton in nature.
1:30:10 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:30:10 Lester Nare? We're still number one. I don't care what nobody says.
1:30:12 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. Actually, the, we, we are though, because there was a, there was a thing that, um, it took the US news rankings and all of these other rankings and then averaged it out.
1:30:23 Lester Nare? Oh, yeah.
1:30:24 Krishna Choudhary? And we were number one.
1:30:24 Lester Nare? Yeah, I'm just, we talked about our leaderboard that's coming in our last episode, that leaderboard, we're going to create our own metric.
1:30:32 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. And make sure.
1:30:34 Lester Nare? You know, it, it'll be, the methodology will be public. It won't be a black box like all these other AI models.
1:30:46 Lester Nare? And we'll just rank based on the facts, you know, as we like them.
1:30:50 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:30:53 Lester Nare? Three super, super sick stories this week. We talked about hypersonic aerodynamics.
1:30:57 Krishna Choudhary? Yep.
1:30:57 Lester Nare? Above Mach five. Very interesting. Stevens, Stevens Institute of Technology in New Jersey. That was in nature communications. We followed that up with some microbial life in the deep sea. Not near hyperthermal vents or anything. This is in a different.
1:31:13 Krishna Choudhary? This is cold.
1:31:14 Lester Nare? This is cold. Scientists, the title was life found in place scientists thought impossible. Out of University of Bremen. There are biomarker evidence for serpentite, serpentite chemo.
1:31:27 Krishna Choudhary? Synthesis.
1:31:28 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:31:29 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah.
1:31:29 Lester Nare? In the Mariana's four arc communications, nature communications, earth and environment. And we ended with an incredible quantum breakthrough, millisecond transwond qubits. Out of Princeton in nature. I, I just, I mean, the stories we've covered this year have just been. And again, it's tough because we weren't doing this in previous years. So it's like.
1:31:49 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, we don't know.
1:31:50 Lester Nare? We have no baseline.
1:31:51 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. I mean, I'm learning a lot doing this show. It's, it's pretty, it's pretty cool.
1:31:55 Lester Nare? It's incredible. I just hope people recognize and understand how incredible some of the stuff we're doing. All the time is.
1:32:02 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah. And I just, I mean, as humans, we're.
1:32:04 Lester Nare? We're so sick. We're sued. We're so sick. We have problems. Okay. We get it.
1:32:10 Krishna Choudhary? Yeah, we get it.
1:32:10 Lester Nare? Those are like individuals and like groups that identify with problematic stuff. But when we, when it comes to like science and resilience and like, just like our ability to.
1:32:23 Krishna Choudhary? Like chipping away at that cave of the unknown.
1:32:25 Lester Nare? Yes.
1:32:26 Krishna Choudhary? You know, it's just, just amazing.
1:32:27 Lester Nare? It's incredible. I'm Lester Nare as always joined by my co-host and our resident PhD Krishna Choudhary. With another incredible episode. We will see you all next week. This is from First Principles.
Previous Octopus Camouflage, Orcas vs. Sharks, Civet Coffee & Sub-Diffraction Telescope Tech (EP. 16) Next 3I/ATLAS Explained, Forensic Fingerprints & Alzheimer’s Breakthrough (EP. 18) Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated