Finshots Daily
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
In today’s episode on 24th September 2025, we try to understand the new H1-B debate that Trump’s sparked. That’s it!
1,880 words · 1 speaker
Hello folks, you're listening to Finchart's Daily. In today's episode, we try to understand the new H1B debate that Trump sparked. That's it.
Before we begin, here's a quick word from Team Ditto. Life has a way of surprising us and not always in a good way. Sometimes, it's a sudden illness or an unexpected hospital visit that can shake up everything. In India, families still pay about 39% of medical expenses directly from their own pockets and just one hospital stay can wipe out years of savings. The easiest way to protect yourself is by getting a good health insurance plan. It's way cheaper than footing one huge bill. And if you're unaware where to start, book a free call with Ditto. No spam, just honest, jargon-free guidance. Trusted by over 8 lakh people for their health and term insurance needs. The link is in the description. Now, back to the story. Donald Trump did it again. Just as the world was stepping into the weekend,
the US president signed a proclamation that slaps $100,000 fee on new H1B visas that was around $1,000 and chaos rolled in. Because H1Bs keep US tech running and nearly 70% go to Indians. Sensing the panic, the White House quickly clarified that the levy is a one-time fee, not annual. It hits only fresh petitions, not renewals, and there's a vague national interest clause tucked into the fine print. But if anything, the clarification has raised more questions than it answered. Even for us, as we were going through these changes. So, in an attempt to understand the fundamental issue better, I imagined a debate with Mr. Trump himself. Okay, this is how it goes. Me.
So, let's talk about this H1B business, Mr. Trump. You argue it's being abused. All right, you're not entirely wrong. There are consulting shops that gain assistance by filing multiple applications, benching workers or undercutting wages. But let's, for the sake of this debate, say that every single H1B issue this year was abused. That's still only 85,000 jobs, which is the cap for H1B visas, or 0.03% in a population of 330 million Americans. Trump. Or it's 85,000 American jobs given away. But it's not just numbers, it's a principle. You're inviting foreigners when Americans need work and during recessions, during layoffs, shouldn't citizens come first?
Me. Right, but H1Bs don't exist in a vacuum. Last year, 780,884 people applied for those 85,000 spots. So, less than 11% got through. Companies clearly see demand and look at who fills them. Highly skilled software engineers, doctors, biotech researchers. Now, these are in roles with a huge surplus of local candidates. Trump. We could train locals instead of leaning on foreigners. Me. That's a nice sentiment, but America itself was built on immigrants. Families that arrived with nothing were leading companies in two or three generations. Now, that's why 46% of Fortune 500 companies today were funded by immigrants or their kids.
Firms like Apple, Google and Tesla together, they generate trillions in revenue and employ millions of Americans. That's not cultural erosion by growth. Trump. But wages? Don't H1Bs depress local salaries? Me. No, Mr. Trump. We wrote something on this a little while ago and it proves that immigrants on H1B visas might actually be benefiting Americans. Well, more than people think. And immigrants also start companies, hire locals and pay taxes. And if the US doesn't keep them, they build giants elsewhere. Now, look at TSMC in Taiwan. It's founded, trained in America, but built the world's most critical chipmaker back home.
And today, the US debates going to war over Taiwan because of TSMC's strategic importance. Imagine if it had been built in Silicon Valley. Trump. Fine, but the system is unfair. Indians flood the pool and they clog up green cards. I've not been liking that of late. Me. That's an important nuance, sure, but H1Bs have no country quota. Everyone competes equally. The backlog comes later at the green card stage. Trump, my voters don't care about nuance. They see layoffs, then see foreigners with jobs. They conflate H1Bs with illegal immigration, they want the border shut. Me? Exactly, but the two are worlds apart, don't you think?
Illegal immigration can strain welfare and law enforcement. Legal immigration like H1Bs brings in skilled taxpayers. That distinction gets lost in the noise. Trump? I've said it before, I actually like H1Bs. I've used them at my properties. It's a great program when done right. I just want it tightened, not scrapped. Me? So, why the hundred thousand dollar fee? Trump? Because I can. Tremendous number, makes headlines. Yes, folks, so that was the conversation, but might not be the healthiest. But it makes a few things clear. Each side clings to its tooth. Abuse exists, but so does genuine demand.
Americans deserve protection, but immigrants add enormous value and they pay taxes. And instead of holding all those truths together, the debate gets flattened and that's what makes it so messy. Now, we know experts at this, and what we see today might look different a few years down the line in a different political or economic environment. But what we can do right now is come back to the hundred thousand dollar question. And try to separate the noise from what really matters. The fine print of Trump's order is telling. For starters, Homeland Security has been asked to refuse petitions unless the fee is paid upfront for any new H1B petition filed after September twenty one, twenty twenty five. So, admission itself now hinges on proof of payment.
And most crucially, agencies must rewrite how H1Bs are prioritized and how prevailing wages are calculated. In fact, the Department of Labor has been directed to raise prevailing wage levels, while DHS has been told to prioritize higher paid roles in the lottery. Now, in other words, even if the hundred thousand dollars stole vanishes next year, the structural changes may not. Today, the lottery treats all petitions equally. But under wage ranking, a two hundred thousand dollar AI engineer has a far better shot than a seventy thousand dollar coder. And that could squeeze out thousands of IT sourcing linked roles, which have averaged about sixty five percent over the past five years.
The report counters this by saying that several tech giants have laid off thousands of American workers while simultaneously securing large batches of H one B approvals. But the reality is more layered. Because many of those layoffs could be tied to global slowdowns, automation and shifts to cloud or AI, work that is increasingly outsourced regardless of visa policy. You can see this in the H one B approvals itself, where new applications have plateaued over recent years, while a big chunk of filings are simply renewals or extensions. In those cases, employers for the bill, but the trade offs is that workers often find it harder to switch jobs and can end up earning less compared to American counterparts doing the same job.
And then there's the ambiguity of national interest. The US issued around four hundred and seventy thousand H one B approvals over the past five years. If the government now starts reserving a chunk of those for sectors it deems strategic, like say AI, semiconductors or defense tech, it means fewer visas for everyone else. And a vague definition could also tell the game toward companies with lobbying power rather than genuine skill shortages. Now, funnily enough, this is where Trump's stance today looks very different from his fury promises of yesterday. He once threatened to shut the program down. Now he seems more interested in reshaping it. So it's neither extreme idealism nor protectionism. It comes out as a balanced attempt to look tough while quietly keeping that door open
for global talent and let the US get what it wants. Because as we saw, anti-immigration is, in many ways, anti-America itself, and to shut the door on scalable talent is to deny its own history. As Thomas Friedman explains in the book The World is Flat, Talent is the new oil and nations that harness it will thrive. Those that block it will eventually pay the price. In a flat world, there is no such thing as an American job. There is just a job and in more cases than ever before, it will go to the best, smartest, most productive or cheapest worker, wherever he or she resides. Which brings us to the last bit. Now, who pays the price here?
Well, there will surely be some winners and losers in the shorter run. For Indian IT giants, the calculus may shift. Why pay a hundred thousand dollars per entry level engineer onsite when you can expand delivery centers in India? And fresh Indian grads with US job offers could be the first casualties. The winners could be the US universities because scarcity of visas may drive more students to pay for a degree in hopes of improving their odds later. And offshore GCCs in India may benefit too. Over eighteen hundred multinationals already run GCCs here, many tied to US firms. If the US companies balk at a hundred thousand dollar fee, that number could climb rapidly. In the meantime, you need to keep an eye on three dials. One, how the entry levels by the US immigration gets defined.
Two, how wage ranking reshapes the lottery and three, whether courts ultimately uphold Washington's authority to prize gate a visa program at scale. In the long scheme of things though, top talent will make the cut. Marginal onsite roles in the US could quietly vanish. And that ironically could be a silver lining for India. If the pipeline of fresh grads heading west lows, more of it gets retained at home before it's lured away by offers somewhere else. That means deeper domestic markets, more Indian IT companies deploying capital onshore rather than relying on wage arbitrage, and a slowdown in the aspirational US shift.
For big Indian IT houses, the blow won't be crippling since they have already been investing heavily in US local hiring. And this simply accelerates that strategy and makes India's pitch to capture more of global R and D product engineering from home. There is also a legal and political undercurrent worth noting. Industry groups and law firms are already lining up challenges and litigation may come. If courts issue an injunction, the shock may be blunted. If not, the fee becomes a standing constraint. But here's the problem. Lawsuits take time, businesses don't. They'll budget for the worst case and adjust hiring today. And that timeline friction, when rules are uncertain but hiring decisions can't wait, often does more damage to the economy than the rule itself.
So, that's the real catch for the US. Push jobs offshore and it doesn't just protect local workers, but it risks losing tax dollars, startups and very breakthroughs that keep it ahead in the global race. So, tell us, which side are you on and where are your bets?
Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to hi@funshox.com. Until next time.
Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated