Finshots Daily
Original podcast
Where to listenCopy share link
In today’s episode on 17th October 2025, we take a look at active versus passive investing. That’s it.
2,000 words · 1 speaker
Hello folks, you're tuned into Finshots Daily. In today's episode, we take a look at active versus passive investing. That's it. Before we begin, here's a quick word from team Ditto. Life has a way of surprising us and not always in a good way. Sometimes it's a sudden illness or an unexpected hospital visit that can shake up everything. In India, families still pay about thirty-nine percent of medical expenses directly from their own pockets and just one hospital stay can wipe out years of savings. The easiest way to protect yourself is by getting a good health insurance plan. It's way cheaper than footing one huge bill. And if you're unaware where to start, book a free call with Ditto. No spam, just honest, jargon-free guidance.
Trusted by over eight lakh people for their health and term insurance needs. The link is in the description. Now, back to the story. You've probably heard the fable. A blindfolded monkey throws darts at a newspaper stock listings and somehow beats professional fund managers in stock picking. It's the kind of story investors love because it makes the stock market sound like a glorified casino where luck and not skill separates winners from the rest. Over time, it's become gospel for passive investing. The idea that instead of chasing alpha that returns above the market, you should just buy the index and, well, go play cricket. But markets are rarely that simple. And to explain why, let's whip that story on its head.
Okay, imagine a thousand monkeys each flipping coins ten times. A few of them will inevitably call heads ten times in a row, right? Now, that's luck with, say, a smugly. But then you notice something odd. All the winning monkeys come from the same village and flip coins in the exact same peculiar way. Would you still call it luck? Now, that's the point Warren Buffett wanted to deliver in nineteen eighty-four. While finance professors at the time sang praises of the efficient market hypothesis, the idea that no one can consistently beat the market because all known information is already priced in, Buffett pointed to a ragtag group of investors who had done precisely that year after year by a wide mile, all using the same philosophy. But let's
That story for a bit. Why am I talking about monkeys and misfits now? Because passive funds are booming in India. From just one percent mutual fund assets in 2016 to 16% today or a 16-fold leap. And somewhere between the blindfolded dart thrower and buffet's coin flipping village lies the real investing debate. Is passive investing truly better than active? So let's try to understand. We'll start with passive investing because it's beautifully counterintuitive. You do nothing and somehow end up doing better than most people doing everything in the market. And why is that? Well, if you've got three minutes, you can read the story that we wrote a while back. I'll link it in the description for you to check out.
But the short answer is that passive funds simply mirror the market and let it do its thing. And weirdly enough, that's why they work. By doing nothing, they eliminate the biggest destroyers of wealth: human psychology. In other words, are it to act or to tinker the process that's better left untouched? Take a Sensex fund. It's designed to do what Sensex does, that is drop laggards and add top performing businesses to the list. So over time, the index quietly upgrades itself. It owns more of what's working and less of what's not. In that sense, it's a built-in momentum investing machine. But that also creates its own feedback loop. As the biggest stocks get the biggest flows, they keep getting pricier.
That's what happened in the US during the tech boom. As trillions flooded into the index funds, the S and P 500 got concentrated in big tech. It worked brilliantly until those very names stumbled. You could still argue, so what? Even then, drawdowns weren't catastrophic. Passive funds save me fees unless an active manager beats the index by three to five percent net-net. It's not worth the headaches. And you'd be right. So with that outperformance benchmark in mind, let's see whether active investing still has a leg to stand on. First, it's important to understand that passive investing shines in efficient markets like the US, where information spreads fast and prices adjust instantly. But India.
Well, that's a little different. Our markets are still evolving and inefficiencies exist like a small cap no one tracks, sectors the herd ignores, or the disclosures that take time to penetrate. In other words, there are pockets where skill can still shine. And that's what most active strategies bet on. They're not trying to beat the market every single month, but trying to spot these misprisings before others do. Like playing long-term themes like India's manufacturing push or financial inclusion before they become index darlings. And sometimes, they went big. Especially in small and mid-cap segments, the parts of the market that are least efficient, least researched, and most chaotic. And there's actually data to back this.
As one study notes, over the past five years, both the Nifty Small Cap Hundred and active small cap funds delivered about thirty-three percent CAGR. But over ten years, small cap funds pulled ahead by eighteen percent CAGR versus fourteen percent for the fund. And even if you look at rolling returns to smooth one-off bull runs, between September twenty twenty and September twenty twenty-five, the Nifty two fifty small cap returned eighteen percent annually on a five-year rolling basis. Twelve out of thirteen small cap active funds beat that, and ten of them returned over twenty percent. That's real outperformance, pure impressive alpha. And also consider this, when you buy an index, it's not all that diversified.
Take Nifty fifty, it's top-heavy, dominated by banks, IT, and airlines. So buying the index could often mean doubling down on a handful of giants not exactly owning the market, is it? And passive isn't as passive as it sounds. You're still constantly choosing which index to buy, Nifty fifty versus Nifty Next fifty versus ESG. Now, that's decision-making in disguise. Then there's behavior. Many passive investors did panic sell in recent crashes when they should have been adding or, well, doing nothing. So the label didn't save them from themselves. Meanwhile, even a modest active strategy outperformance can compound brutally over time.
Ten lakh rupees at ten percent for ten years becomes twenty-five point nine lakh rupees. At four percent alpha, that is fourteen percent, it becomes thirty-seven lakh rupees. That's eleven lakh rupees more in the same market but with a different process. Of course, that's the theory. In practice, only a handful of active fund managers beat the market consistently, and even fewer do so after accounting for fees and taxes. The rest lose to passive funds because the odds are simply stacked against them. As markets evolve, cycles change and styles go in and out of fashion. So, an active fund that thrives in one decade can struggle in the next. And if investors can't stomach short-term underperformance, they often abandon ship right before things turn.
That's why investor returns often trail fund returns, which again brings us back to the important question. Which strategy can prove better? Active or passive? Well, neither, or rather, both. Because you see, the smartest investors treat the debate not as a binary but as a balance. They build a core satellite portfolio, a passive core that compounds steadily, surrounded by smaller active or factor-based satellites that chase alpha. The passive core provides stability, risk mitigation and discipline, while the active satellites allow conviction and flexibility. And how much you allocate to each depends on your risk appetite, belief and temperament.
For instance, for someone starting out in the markets, index investing could prove to be a great teacher with low cost, low fuss and one that lets you live through market cycles without panic. And for someone who knows their investing style or has a manager whose process they can explain to a ten-year-old, it would make sense to slowly explore active exposure in staggered phases. And the real secret to good active investing may not be picking right funds or stock ones. It's rather about following the right process repeatedly. Which brings us back to Buffet's Park story. In 1984, Buffet wrote an essay titled "The Superinvestors of Graham and Dodd's World." It was his tribute to the fifteenth anniversary of Graham and Dodd's Security Analysis,
the book that shaped his philosophy and fortune. The coin-flipping monkeys were his metaphor for a very real tribe who beat the market year after year across decades. Share hometown or fancy degrees, but an unusual philosophy from Graham and Dodd's book, which boils down to three deceptively simple ideas. Number one, treat a stock like business, not a ticker symbol, not a trend, not a bet. A business with revenues, costs, risks and a future you can value. Number two, let the market be your servant, not your guide. Graham called it Mr. Market and emphasized imagining it as your erratic business partner. Some days his euphoric and offers to buy your shares at crazy prices.
Other days his gloomy and offers to sell at a steep discount. Your job isn't to match his mood, but to make the most of his mood swings.
Number three, always demand a margin of safety. In other words, leave room for error in the price by paying say sixty cents for a dollar worth of business. All the investors in that pack from Walter Schloss, Bill Ruane and Tom Knapp followed the same philosophy. And to see how powerful it proved to be, look no further than Tom Knapp and his firm Tweedy Brown Partners. Knapp wasn't some Wall Street rock star. He studied liberal arts, got into investing through a summer job and eventually stumbled upon Graham's work and went to open his little firm called Tweedy Brown. And all he did was scout balance sheets, bought stock sellings at throwaway prices, ignored Mr. Market's noise and insisted on a margin of safety every single time.
And by how much did he outperform the passive index doing so? Between sixty-eight and eighty-three, his funds delivered a staggering one thousand six hundred sixty-one percent return versus two hundred and thirty-eight percent for the S and P five hundred. Now, that's the part of active investing. People underappreciate. It's boring, methodical, relentless, yes. But that same process takes out human intervention out of play, just like passive investing. Tom followed through it and by the time most investors were still chasing hot tips, he had already packed his bags and bought a beach house. So yes, if you've got the temperament to stomach volatility, the curiosity to dig deep and the discipline to follow through,
active investing can earn its place in your portfolio just as passive investing. One last thing, whether you lean active or passive, your allocation towards them is an important part of the puzzle. Because even the best active strategy or the cheapest passive one can't fix a badly balanced portfolio. Your allocation decides your risk, protects your round sides and whether you'll stay the course when the market slaps you in the face. Because the market will always have its monkeys and its misfits, its flukes and its fundamentals. You'll meet both in your portfolio someday. And the trick isn't to outsmart either, but build a process that survives both. Anyways, that's all we got about active versus passive investing debate.
And whether you agree or disagree, let us know your thoughts. I'll see you in the next one.
Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to hi@friendshots.com. Until next time.
Page updated November 10, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated