Pod Insights Finshots Daily Reliance, ONGC, and the missing unitisation agreement About this episode In today's episode on 24th February 2025, we examine the decade-long gas migration dispute between Reliance and ONGC and if a unitisation agreement could have prevented this mess. Speak to Ditto's advisors now, by clicking the link here - https://ditto.sh/9zoz41
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Hello folks, you're listening to Finshots Daily. And in today's episode, we examine the decade-long gas migration dispute between Reliance and ONGC, and if a unitization agreement could have prevented this mess.
0:14 Speaker 00 Before we start today's episode, here's a quick announcement from Team Ditto. Did you know that eighty-three percent of Indian households are put in grave financial danger if the breadwinner passes away? This is why it's important to be financially prudent and buy a term insurance. If you're young, you can secure your family with a cover of over one crore at nominal premiums of just ten to fifteen K a year. At Ditto Insurance, a product by Finshots, we've helped thousands of people select a term plan with the help of certified advisors. We promise a spam-free experience, no pressure to buy, and a claim support team always by your side. Head over to the link in the description or Google Ditto Insurance to speak to an expert now.
0:59 Speaker 00 Now, on to today's episode. The government warns Reliance Industries Limited or RIL and its partners BP and Niko to pay 1.5 billion dollars in compensation. And if you've been following the news, you've probably seen how the Delhi High Court recently overturned an international tribunal's ruling that had earlier cleared RIL of the burden of paying this hefty amount. And this legal battle has been years in the making. And how did it all start? Well, it goes back to the NELP, that is New Exploration Licensing Policy, which opened up oil and gas exploration to private and foreign companies. These companies could now bid for oil and gas blocks in a competitive auction,
1:40 Speaker 00 which was, until then, the domain of state-run giants like ONGC and oil. The first NELP bidding round in the year 2000 opened up a jackpot for Reliance Industries as it got its hands on one of the gas exploration blocks. And coincidentally, Reliance Industries' block sat right next to the block awarded to the cane in the Krishna Godavari basin, which was later taken over by the ONGC. A little side note, these gas fields lie deep under the sea in the Bay of Bengal. Of the Andhra coast. By two thousand nine, R I L had begun digging wells and pumping gas from its awarded block, while O N G C had yet to start exploration.
2:21 Speaker 00 However, the real twist came in when in two thousand thirteen, O N G C observed something anomalous. It suspected that the underground gas reservoirs in both blocks were connected, allowing gas to flow from O N G C's block into Reliance Industries Limited's. And since Reliance had begun production first, it might have inadvertently extracted O N G C's gas as well. Sensing a major issue, O N G C took the matter to Directorate General of Hydrocarbons. After this, the dispute landed in the court, which eventually in two thousand fifteen ordered a probe by Digoyler and McNaughton, or D N M. Their report confirmed that gas had indeed migrated from O N G C's block into Reliance Industry Fields, and that Reliance had extracted and sold it.
3:06 Speaker 00 Following this, the government set up the Shah Committee, which gave its verdict in two thousand sixteen. While there was no criminal intent, it concluded that Reliance had unfairly benefited. Since Reliance Industries had gained one point seven billion dollars from gas extracted from its K G basin block, the government felt it should pay back at least one point five five billion dollars in compensation. Now, Reliance wasn't going down without a fight. It challenged the compensation demand in international arbitration and won. And for a moment, R I L might have breathed a sign of relief, thinking that the matter was settled. But the saga wasn't over, and just days ago, the Delhi High Court turned the tribunal's ruling upside down,
3:49 Speaker 00 this time in the favor of the Indian government. So, that's the backstory. Now, all of this led us to wonder, could this entire mess have been avoided in the first place? And that's when we came across the concept of unitization agreement, the main talking point of today's story. Let's understand this with a climactic scene from the two thousand seven film, There Will Be Blood. In the film, Eli, who's desperate for money, approaches Daniel, a ruthless oilman, to sell a piece of his land that's sitting atop vast oil reserves. In response, Daniel exclaims, "If you have a milkshake, and if I have a milkshake, and if I have a straw that reaches across the room, I drink your milkshake." I drank it up.
4:32 Speaker 00 Simply put, Daniel mocks Eli, revealing to him that he has already drained all the oil beneath Eli's land, without actually needing to buy it. And this perfectly illustrates what was called the rule of capture, which was prevalent in the United States in the 20th century. It stated that whoever extracts the oil first owns it, regardless of whether it migrated from another property. This means oil from one property can be extracted using wells on a neighboring property and be owned. You just have to be quick. Naturally, this led to some serious disputes as companies rushed to drill and extract the oil as fast and as much as possible before their neighboring landowners did.
5:12 Speaker 00 And the result was overdrilling, poor planning, massive wastage, and inefficient oil recovery. And at its core, the reliance ONGC dispute also boils down to the same issue: gas migration. If an underground reservoir is shared across two blocks and one company starts extracting first, does that mean they own everything that flows into their well? Well, this is where the unitization agreement comes into play. Look, oil and gas fields often transcend land and water boundaries, sometimes even creating conflicts between nations. And history is full of such cases. And unitization helps solve this problem by treating shared reservoirs as a single entity. So, instead of competing,
5:55 Speaker 00 companies or nations holding rights to different parts of the field combine their interests into a unit. Production is then decided and shared based on a pre-agreed formula called track participation. That is, how much oil or revenue each party gets after selling it.
6:13 Speaker 00 The UK and Norway were among the first to embrace unitization. In 1976, they signed the unitization agreement for the Frig gas field, which sprawled the maritime boundary between these two nations. They agreed to jointly develop and operate this field as a single unit, essentially setting a precedent of sorts for the world for handling such disputes. And they didn't stop there. In 2005, they signed another agreement which outlined how they would collaborate and operate. Under supervision of both nations regulatory authorities. Now, coming back to the Indian case of Reliance Industries versus ONGC. Could India have avoided this mess? Maybe. The government or the Directorate General of Hydrocarbons could have forced in this possibility
6:56 Speaker 00 of gas migration and implemented a unitization agreement in place before allocating the blocks to different parties. If that had happened, Reliance Industries and the government might have avoided this elaborate legal dispute, which is still sub judice and saved involved parties from years of legal trouble. Anyways, what's our take? Should Reliance pay the government 1.5 billion dollars? Well, that's where things get tricky. As we saw on one hand, the finders keepers rule suggests that whoever extracts the gas first owns it, just like in the old oil rush days. Reliance Industries started drilling before ONGC and there was no unitization agreement in place to dictate otherwise. By that logic, Reliance could argue that it did nothing wrong.
7:42 Speaker 00 On the other hand, without a unitization agreement, ONGC never had a fair shot at extracting gas from its own block. And expert committees have already proved that Reliance Industries extracted more than 11.2 billion cubic meters of gas from ONGC's block, sold it and profited from it. Then, it's only fair that Reliance Industries compensates the government or ONGC. Yes, ethically and economically, ONGC had a claim to a share of that wealth. So, maybe a fair resolution might not mean Reliance Industries paying the full 1.5 billion dollars, but some compensation? And that again raises questions about regulatory oversight and whether clear rules should have been in place from the start.
8:28 Speaker 00 What do you think?
8:30 Speaker 00 Thank you for listening to today's episode. And if you want to share your feedback or suggestions, do drop us an email to hi@friendshotstarted. Until next time.
Previous Finshots Cracks Crypto #6: A simple guide to crypto trading, investing and taxes in India Next Bill Ackman wants to be Warren Buffett Page updated November 11, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated