Pod Insights Equity Podcast Why build a tech mafia when you can just build each other? About this episode Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast about the business of startups, where we unpack the numbers and nuance behind the headlines.
This is our Wednesday show, where we niche down to a single topic, think about a question and unpack the rest. This week, Natasha and Alex asked: Why is tech full of copycats, and what’s the next full circle moment we can expect?
The question was inspired by Natasha's recent Startups Weekly column: "YC makes a Product Hunt, Product Hunt makes an a16z, a16z makes a YC." As you can tell by that headline and this week's episode title, we're talking about how tech is full of copycats and what that means for the bar of innovation.
Expect to learn about the overlap in mission between three of tech's most well-known institutions, what Prologue means for Future (literally and figuratively), and how a rising tide can both confuse and complement the founder fundraising journey.
Also it was a good excuse to chat through some of the competitive dynamics that we see play out across the startup landscape. We had a great time, and hope you like the show. We're back Friday with our regular news roundup!
Equity drops every Monday at 7 a.m. PDT and Wednesday and Friday at 6 a.m. PDT, so subscribe to us on Apple Podcasts, Overcast, Spotify and all the casts.
Credits: Equity is produced by Theresa Loconsolo with editing by Kell. Bryce Durbin is our Illustrator. We'd also like to thank the audience development team and Henry Pickavet, who manages TechCrunch audio products.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Transcript 0:11 Speaker 00 Hello and welcome back to Equity, a podcast about the business of startups, where we unpack the numbers and nuance behind the headlines. I'm Natasha Mascheranos and this is our Wednesday show, where we niche down to a single topic, think about a question and unpack the rest. Today, we're asking, why is tech full of copycats? And what's the next full circle moment we can expect? As always, I am joined by the inimitable editor in chief of TechCrunch Plus and my friend, Alex Wilhelm. Alex, how are you?
0:37 Speaker 01 I'm doing great. I just want to say, like, the headline for the story at the root of this show was so much better than the way we phrased it as a question. I'm now thinking we should, like, go back in time, just take your headline, slap a question mark at the end of it and say, huh? Because that would rule.
0:51 Speaker 00 I mean, I'm kind of down. And we'll, we'll give you background on what Alex is alluding to, because it actually started within slacks between both of us. Last week, Y Combinator announced that it was launching LaunchYC, which is kind of this platform where people can sort through accelerator startups by industry batch and vote up and down. And if it sounds familiar, it is because it sounded very much like Product Hunt. And so your Slack to me, Alex, when you sent me the link, was YC launches Product Hunt, question mark?
1:16 Speaker 01 Right. Well, I mean, that was my first thought. I looked at this and I was like, wait a minute. YC is already an accelerator, a global, you know, like, remote accelerator. It's got a continuity fund. There's YC School.
1:28 Speaker 00 Startup School, yeah.
1:29 Speaker 01 Startup School. They have BookLife or Bookface, their social network for founders. I don't know. You know what I mean? And so, like, they're coming increasingly productified. And so I was surprised to see them come up with something new again, and also something that isn't actually new to the market.
1:41 Speaker 00 Right. And of course, like, that naturally made me think about this idea of, like, everyone building each other at a certain point. So you said YC makes a Product Hunt. I was like, okay, but Product Hunt made an Andreessen Horowitz, and then Andreessen Horowitz made a Y Combinator. And so that's really the story that we're going to be talking about today, which is the fact that everyone is making each other in a weird, full circle, copycat and kind of like competitive way, it seems like, these days.
2:06 Speaker 01 This undergirds my firm belief that actually the center of the technology world is not Silicon Valley. It's not, you know, Shanghai. It's not New York City. It's actually the Xerox Corporation, creator of all the copy machines out there that are run in full time.
2:18 Speaker 00 Oh, my God. Yeah, totally. I remember when I was like first learning about the world of tech and I got really excited about people trying to build, I think it was another Foursquare and you and Holden saw my pitch. This was when we were Crunchbase News and you guys were kind of like, okay, this is not the first time it's happened. And that was the time where my bubble kind of broke of like, everyone has tried to build the same companies so many times. This is a little different than that, though.
2:42 Speaker 01 It's a little different than that, but it shares a key point because when you brought up that point about Foursquare, you know, historically I recalled Goala, which was a competitor with Foursquare back when South by Southwest was a culturally relevant event and apps would compete there for kind of ascendancy and therefore, you know, minded market share. That was all well and good, but sometimes things are just too early. Like Foursquare was too early, pretty much. I think it's why the business ended up kind of where it is today. And when we think about technology products that did break through, often they're not the first time. Like, do you remember the HP iPAC?
3:09 Speaker 00 Oh, my God. Not even a little.
3:11 Speaker 01 Came out before the iPhone, part of the Pocket PC line of Windows-based devices in the smartphone category that no one remembers because only people who bought them were like HP execs. But Apple got the timing right when the technology was actually sufficiently ready to go. And so I'm curious if that plays into this because Andreessen Horowitz went early first, which meant that they went YC and then Product Hunt put together a fund. So they went Andreessen. And then last, YC launched, launched YC to the public. And so they went Product Hunt at the end, I think.
3:41 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah. I mostly agree with that timeline. I mean, that's correct. And the addition is like, they share investors. There's overlap in a lot of subtle ways. And so maybe it makes sense to like kind of handhold everyone into how these companies are all starting to look like each other.
3:55 Speaker 01 Yes.
3:55 Speaker 00 So starting with, I guess, the news of YC launching LaunchYC. Thank you for that, by the way, Y Combinator, that naming choice. But the reason it looked so much like Product Hunt, like we were saying in the beginning of this episode, is like, it's one way that we're going to see a institution try and make the navigation of new products and new startups easier. And so similar to Product Hunt, Launch is pitching itself as a way where people can kind of detect the next big startup, whether they're an investor, a hopeful employee, or a founder themselves. And the biggest difference between Product Hunt and Launch at this point is that only startups that have gone through YC's accelerator can launch on launch. And so it's competitive, but only to a
4:34 Speaker 01 Right. So what they've done is they've created a new outlet for portfolio companies to strut their stuff. Actually, that's probably an old sexist phrase. They've created a place for Y Combinator-backed companies to show off.
4:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
4:46 Speaker 01 And essentially allow people to participate in that very smart. And the thing is, Product Hunt has been very successful at this. I mean, like, it's been a surprise. I think dig.com used to be the place where people would want to get to the top of the front page to get all the traffic. But now Product Hunt has the mindshare.
4:58 Speaker 00 Oh, my God. Yeah, it is really synonymous with launching even earlier than, you know, it comes on TechCrunch sometimes. People will send me their Product Hunt profiles and be like, we launched last week and here's what we've heard so far. And so Product Hunt has really become this institution for the earliest innovators, which is such a special thing to build. And I get why an accelerator would want some of that attention as well.
5:17 Speaker 01 Okay, but flip it around because it's obvious why YC wants more marketing for its portfolio companies. It helps them hire and raise money. But why does Product Hunt need a fund? Going back in time, kind of one step, why did the glorious little PH end up wandering around with a new checkbook?
5:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, so this is a little bit of like mechanics, and so I'm going to keep it hopefully a little broad so I don't mess up. But a while ago, it was announced that Product Hunt is part of Prolog, which is a holding company that owns both Product Hunt and Hyper, which is a 60 million early-stage venture firm. And so at that time, the takeaway was that Product Hunt is getting in cahoots with a VC fund. And they're both being led by that same CEO, new-ish CEO, Josh Buckley. The reason I think it made a lot of sense was, you know, if you have that sort of deal flow and honestly, like, name brand and belief that people come to you, you probably have a great chance of winning cap table spots. It's a marketing agent and a lot of firms and startups need marketing help. And so in a lot of ways, it was kind of a boring addition because it was like, of course, you guys have a fund.
6:16 Speaker 00 Who doesn't have a fund? Prolog was announced before the downturn, mind you. So.
6:21 Speaker 01 I mean, I don't think it would be announced now.
6:23 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:23 Speaker 01 In fact, it was a prologue to the downturn.
6:26 Speaker 00 There we go. Da-da-dah.
6:28 Speaker 01 Da-da-dah.
6:30 Speaker 00 But I mean,
6:30 Speaker 01 We drank, we drank coffee today.
6:33 Speaker 00 It's weird because that's not where the overlap really stops. So Prolog, like I said, owns both Hyper and Product Hunt, and it has an investor that kind of makes it all more complicated. One of its investors is Andreessen Horowitz. Andreessen Horowitz has actually made its own Y Combinator recently. Do you remember when Andreessen just launched their early-stage accelerator?
6:51 Speaker 01 Oh, wait, before, pause. So, okay, Prolog is now the owner of both Product Hunt and Hyper.
6:57 Speaker 00 Yes.
6:58 Speaker 01 Andreessen is an investor in Prolog. Okay, so, sorry. Are they an investor in the holding company? Or do they provide capital to the venture fund itself?
7:08 Speaker 00 I'm sure it's both, but all we know is that they are the co-lead in Prolog, the holding company alongside Sequoia.
7:15 Speaker 01 Okay, now let's go to Andreessen making Y Combinator, because that's the last bit of this puzzle. And so Andreessen, earlier in the timeline, started to do more early-stage investing.
7:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, they announced recently the launch of Start, which is a program that's all about backing founders at the earliest stage. Andreessen had been doing this informally, but this was the most kind of official, professional way that we saw it be shared to the public. I think they're investing up to 1 million, which is almost double the check size of Y Combinator's recently expanded check size, which is around 500K. So, I mean, that was, I think we talked about that on the podcast two months ago. And so it's kind of like, we're here again. And the reason it took us so long to get through this is like, this stuff is messy. There's a web of all these companies that are starting to kind of build things that look like each other. And now, fast forward, we have these three institutions, Andreessen, Y Combinator, and Product Hunt. You know, a founder can go to any of these three or all three for their first check.
8:06 Speaker 01 Yeah. Okay, can I tell you what I think we're seeing here?
8:08 Speaker 00 Please.
8:09 Speaker 01 Is the greener grass effect and also a desire to both control destinies and make more money. So Andreessen was probably annoyed that they were taking Y Combinator-backed companies and paying 15X what YC just paid for them back when the check size was smaller and essentially contributing to a ton of upside for the backers of YC. And of course, Andreessen did rather well with much of its money. So it's a good return here and there, so shout out. But like, they wanted more. In the case of Product Hunt, I bet they got annoyed that they were doing so much work for VCs by promoting cool projects without getting any of the upside, so they made a fund. And then in the case of YC and Product Hunt, I think essentially they felt out-marketed. And so they were like, well, this, we'll do our own marketing. A bit like how Andreessen launched Future. So essentially, it's a combination of like,
8:53 Speaker 01 everyone thinks that the thing they're not doing is easier than it is. And so they expand into it. And I think that's a combination of arrogance to a degree. And the problem that humans have is we get good at something and then we think that means we're good at everything. And that's usually not the case. And then, you know, on a positive side, I kind of think offering a more cohesive product, Natasha, it makes sense to founders who want more handholding, perhaps?
9:14 Speaker 00 This is why I love podcasting with you, because that summary is like, kind of what we should have led with. It makes a ton of sense. Like, all these companies have watched their loudest critiques over the years. In Y Combinator's case, their loudest critique has been, your bachelors are getting so big, not all your startups can raise because they're not that easy to either stand out. Or, I mean, we joke at Disrupt, like, it's no longer how do you get into YC? It's how do you stand out at YC? And so-
9:38 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah. Good point. That is a change.
9:40 Speaker 00 Yeah, I feel like they're all kind of trying to respond to some of those critiques. And add in the fact that 2021 was the year where it felt like anyone could launch a fund if they had a opinion, or a market, or an audience. And it's not surprising that we saw the bar raise, which I guess is kind of like the next topic I wanted to talk about, which is like, where are the benefits of all these companies starting to look more like each other and offer the same products? We'll get to negatives next, don't worry.
10:04 Speaker 01 Okay, well, I mean, I can, do you mind if I take first?
10:06 Speaker 00 Please, please.
10:07 Speaker 01 Okay, so for Andreessen, the advantages are pretty clear. Wait, do you want advantages for the institutions in question? The startups that might be impacted, or both?
10:17 Speaker 00 I would do both, but let's start with the institutions. Like, why is it good for these institutions to start to look like each other?
10:22 Speaker 01 I'll do institutions, you do founders.
10:24 Speaker 00 Perfect.
10:24 Speaker 01 So, in the case of Andreessen, I think institutionally, the advantages are it will have an earlier bite, add more apples, and presuming that it can bring their talent engine to bear on those companies, they will have a better chance of success and they will essentially be able to drive more operating returns. That's my thesis there. Regarding Product Hunt, essentially, this is turning what was a niche social media product into a financial entity. And so for them, the upside goes from ad revenue to tens of billions of dollars. So that's nice.
10:51 Speaker 00 Yeah, talk about maturing.
10:52 Speaker 01 Yeah, they matured from zero to a lot really quick. And we'll see how it plays out. And in the case of YC, you know, Natasha, the last Y Combinator cycle, they didn't talk to us much, if I recall correctly. And so I think they're probably running the Andreessen playbook, trying to more control the narrative-
11:09 Speaker 00 Yeah.
11:09 Speaker 01 And be able to generate more of their own magic. And so I think that that is a component of both their growing financial clout and the fact that there are so many companies. It's not like in the old days and there was like 50 and you could kind of go talk to them, you know, and glad hand with the founders. Now there's 400 or whatever, or 1,000, I don't know. And so I think they have to do something to respond to that issue they've created for themselves. That's my take. So founders, take it away.
11:30 Speaker 00 I think for founders, a lot of it's similar, right? Like you can go to one institution and get the benefits that a lot of others have promised over the years. So now if you're a Andreessen Horowitz company, or you know, you pay attention to the firm, you have connections, you can actually go to them for formal starter capital. And obviously having them on your cap table at this point in tech history makes probably such a difference in an environment where investors are being risk averse. And they do need that stamp of approval early on. So I think it's smart for Andreessen Horowitz to go early stage and not in a quiet scout-like way, but in a loud, here's a program, here's up to a million dollars way. When we talk about YC making a product hunt, I'm sure its accelerator founders are excited to no longer be defined by the all elusive demo day.
12:15 Speaker 00 I think the tech press has contributed to that, us included. I think YC for so long has kind of, it's aged out. People don't really raise on two days and the demo day is really, is for show. It's still something interesting, but we see time and time again that even though there's interest in covering that and people reading it, it's not the most natural way to launch your company anymore. Like you can kind of launch on an ongoing basis.
12:34 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, we've seen tech stars move to more, I think, flexible onboarding and offboarding schedules for this. I mean, Natasha, we have spilled enough ink over the years about demo days and the positives and negatives thereof to be quasi experts at this point in time. I think if you don't go curated, you have to find some other method to move forward. And so YC is doing that. I don't know if YC launch is the, I mean, it's simple, but I mean, it's not particularly compelling. Product hunt, cool, got it. You know what I mean? Like that's one of the better brand names, I think, out there in the tech world in the last 10 years.
13:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, people don't really talk about that, but you're so right. Like that's a great name. Launch YC, it used to be internal to YC, they're saying, and they just made it public. And while I completely understand why it's just for accelerator companies, I think it is a lot of eggs in your own basket. And so I do wonder if at some point they'll find it important to expand to other companies. And when I asked Lindsay, their head of comms over email about them making a not so subtle split at product hunt, she basically said like she encourages founders to launch everywhere they can, including product hunt. And so of course that's like the political and probably correct answer. If you're a founder listening right now is not just picking one platform, the same way you wouldn't just send one email out.
13:40 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, I mean, if Y C told founders that they were not allowed to go on product time, one, it would be self defeating and silly, which is why they're not doing it. And they're not, to be clear, that we're aware of because what does Y C want? It wants lots of noise about its portfolio companies. So everyone can't avoid noticing the cool new thing they've backed.
13:55 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly.
13:56 Speaker 01 Solar powered ice cream drones, whatever. And so, yeah, that makes good sense to me. And I'm not, the thing that I'm curious about, and we can't answer this question, is that what's the impact of this? Like, we talk about it because we see interesting parallels to other activities by related entities that kind of bring them all together in this goulash of capital and publicity. Fair enough, fine, but what does it actually do for founders? How much traffic does it really bring in? Do they find that employee they needed? And so we're talking about this from a very meta level, and it's the grander level that we can't see because we don't have the data.
14:24 Speaker 00 It's such a good question to like, say anyways, though, because it's so clear that like, this is Y C answering a question that they've gotten a lot, but it's not clear if it's going to help founders with the pain points that they are experiencing. And in a way, to me, this just seems like Y C is being more competitive and more greedy in a good way. Investors, are they already going to be going to this website and looking for dealful this way? Or would they rather go to a platform that has companies beyond Y C? I mean, that seems like an inherent, like, why just focus on this one cohort? When you can do everything at the same time.
14:56 Speaker 01 Well, from a Y C perspective, I get why launch Y C fits because they only care about their portfolio companies. But if you're an investor, why not go to the broader mix? And so if Y C companies do still end up on P H, well, then I wonder how much of an impact launch Y C, which has been launched by Y C, will have.
15:11 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
15:13 Speaker 01 So let's, sorry, there's just a lot of similar words in this one. Let's talk about negatives, though. And we just mentioned that Y C will not mind if companies make noise elsewhere because they care about the overall health of portfolio. But that's not the same case as we see with investors. They do usually want to either lead the deals they want and then collect as many shares as they can. So I think that the biggest possible tension in this Venn diagram slash flow chart we've put together is Andreessen Horowitz and Hyper. Because if Andreessen is a backer of Prolog?
15:42 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
15:43 Speaker 01 Prolog, nailed it. Then they could eventually end up competing for deals or for allocation inside of deals, for follow on deals. And there's the potential for a lot of overlap and hurt feelings there.
15:53 Speaker 00 Yes, it is very easy to be externally inclusive, but internally exclusive. I don't think that people are as amicable here as we, you know, think. I just, I feel like a lot of these firms at some point are going to have to pick a side, or founders at least will have to pick a side as well. At this point, yes, you can still have Sequoia and Andreessen Horowitz on your cap table. But I do think like as you scale as a founder, those decisions get harder and harder to make. And if I was a founder, like I would want to pick the institution that has all the things. It seems like the biggest negative is founder confusion that's being masked as founder friendliness in a way.
16:29 Speaker 01 Yeah. And like also, like, this isn't just a question of like, you know, I'm raising my series D, who should I raise from? This is only early stage money. Hyper only raised 60 million for its fund. That tells you a ton about where it will write checks, what size of checks, how frequently, and how much money they're going to have for follow-ons. Call it 50/50, so they got 30 million to put in upfront, 30 million for, you know, reserves. I mean, that is for Andreessen Horowitz, like the lunch tab, I think, on their current AUM. And so, you know, if you're making a choice between them, how does Hyper possibly beat out Andreessen? In terms of like raising capital from an entity? And if that's the case, then is Hyper just kind of like the crappy B team for Andreessen?
17:06 Speaker 00 Yeah, I mean, that is totally, I'm sure, a worry on their end. And on anyone's end that's trying to compete with an Andreessen and vice versa. I feel like Andreessen launching an accelerator was not just them playing offense for fun, but it was them responding to, like you said, losing deals to YC and playing those high markups. And so I think a lot of these moves have been made out of like an insecurity or a competition element that wasn't there a few years ago.
17:29 Speaker 01 You know, I just, I fall back to this saying a lot the last couple of years, but pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered. It's an old timey farmer phrase, and it resonates with me a lot in this world. Because before Andreessen made a move into even earlier stage investing on a more systemic basis, it was doing great. And Product Hunt had a really cool niche before they added in a venture element. And YC is good at doing YC things, and now it's doing much, much more. And I wonder how much of the stuff is essentially feature bloat of the venture world? And I wonder if they're going to acquire the venture equivalent of technical debt.
18:01 Speaker 00 It's kind of like launching a column because you think you can and should. And then every week it just gets harder and harder to do because you don't really want to do it anymore in our world.
18:10 Speaker 01 Are you talking about one of us?
18:13 Speaker 00 Me, me uncovering layoffs every week.
18:16 Speaker 01 Oh, that's right. That is a weekly feature now.
18:19 Speaker 00 Yeah. And I mean, that's obviously like a sadder one, but it feature bloat is such a real threat because being a tourist in a venture setting and getting portfolio companies and stakes of equity in these companies and these people, not to be too dramatic, but like it's a lot of responsibility. And the downturn, I think, has only emphasized and then reemphasized a million times over how important your early stage investors are. So I think a little bit of like the muddling between everyone does make it harder for founders to figure out who's really in it for the long term, who has like something for optics and who actually is making a difference here.
18:52 Speaker 01 Yes.
18:53 Speaker 00 And so, I mean, it's a cynical take a little bit, but I don't think one that like is too unfair, considering YC can tell as much as they want that they're okay having competitive startups internally. But when it comes to externally, they clearly don't care about competing directly with Product Hunt, which to be clear, used to be a YC portfolio company. Product Hunt went through YC in 2014, I believe.
19:12 Speaker 01 Of course it did.
19:13 Speaker 00 I mean, that's so confusing.
19:15 Speaker 01 The headline, I'm sorry, going back to the very top of the show, the headline should have been, YC eats young.
19:21 Speaker 00 Maybe that can be our, our podcast headline. I'm sure they would love that.
19:25 Speaker 01 I don't think it actually will look great on the page now that I've said it out loud.
19:28 Speaker 00 Okay, fine.
19:28 Speaker 01 It made a lot of sense in my head as a quip. And then you ever just like get halfway through a sentence and you're like, this isn't going to land right.
19:34 Speaker 00 Like I just don't want it anymore.
19:35 Speaker 01 YC eats children. Not good, you know, like it just doesn't, yeah. So founders dealing with this complicated landscape have one more thing to deal with because we're also seeing funds that are fake existing, but don't have more capital. We're seeing some VCs pull term sheets. We're seeing founders pull job offerings. It's a market of banana peels on the floor, it seems. And now there's even more complexity to it. So Natasha, if you were a founder, how would you navigate not getting too distracted by all the noise?
20:01 Speaker 00 I think the advice that has resonated with me the most is if you're coming to a investor for capital, capital does feel like the most important product to be signing up for. The fundamental deal is money in exchange for equity. If you're happy with that, consider everything else as icing on the cake, but don't go to a Product Hunt hyper prologue collapse. Just because you hope to become viral on tech Twitter one day. I think that it's like getting your hopes up for a lot of the promises should not be something that you necessarily blindly believe, the same way that you shouldn't believe that going through Y C means that you're going to be a success. And that's not a knock on any of the institutions. They've clearly seeded and helped launch the biggest companies that define tech.
20:42 Speaker 00 But I just think like a little bit of like that, it's that easy conversation of like, we just offered these services. You can't offer someone success. So I think that I would, I would hope to have that kind of soul searching conversation with one of these people and whoever responds the best to it, I would accept their money.
20:57 Speaker 01 And we're going to make an analogy here to fine arts degrees, not to diss the literary arts, not to mock our friends who do creative writing for a living. As someone who consumes quite a lot of fiction, keep at it, everybody. But if you go to like Columbia for your NFA, some of your classmates will become New York Times list bestsellers.
21:13 Speaker 00 Right.
21:14 Speaker 01 Those are the startup unicorns equivalent from the Y C batch. And it's important to keep in mind that that's never going to be the majority case. So if you're a founder, Y C will not save you. It may help you, but that's going to be the case with all of these individual entities. I think it's fun to watch everyone try to figure out how to do the same things in different formats. And I'll just say that TechCrunch has survived a great many of these product cycles, you might say, and we're still here. So at least I have that to lean back on as everyone else tries to mimic everyone else.
21:42 Speaker 00 Oh, my God, yeah. It's also like we're poking a lot of fun and I think rightfully being critical of some of the decisions that are being made and what it means for founders. But like, it is a very cool universe to be in when it gets this, I guess, messy and like ambitious in a way. I mean, we haven't even talked about Andreessen launching Future almost a year ago as part of this episode, but like that again, was like this kind of new wave of conversation on V C firms doing content marketing and believing that tech optimism needed to be a bigger focus in, quote, "the media." I think it holds all of us to like a very different standard than, at least even when I first started out a few years ago, it feels like a completely different time to be a tech journalist because so many of these firms are trying to do so many things and it makes the startups that we cover and the V C's that we cover have a lot more, I don't know, they have a lot more stuff they have to prove now.
22:25 Speaker 00 It's harder to kind of do a medium job at this job.
22:28 Speaker 01 Well, I mean, anything that has outlier results as the main driver of economic return is going to be something that disparages and despises fine.
22:35 Speaker 00 Yeah.
22:36 Speaker 01 Right?
22:36 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, totally. Like fine does not work at all. And I think that's what all these firms are trying to do in a way. They're trying to like be more than just what they were, which I mean, good for you. Do that, do more of that. I guess like I would love to end a little bit on what we're going to see happen in the future. Who's going to try building what?
22:53 Speaker 00 And is there like a YC mafia that we should soon expect? I feel like we're overdue to see like former head of YC launches X, Y, and Z.
23:00 Speaker 01 No, I think, I think you're asking the exactly perfect question for 12 months ago. And I don't mean this at all in a mean way, I'm just thinking this through because last year, we would have gone through a list of companies that might have been good incubation points for startups. And we would have said, these companies might raise funds. What's the chance that people are going to do that this year? It's very low, right? And so suddenly the silly season is off. And so the tap has been turned down and the capital has turned to a dribble, which is why I think we should flip the question around. Not who's going to build what next, but whom who has already built something will be the first to kill it because they no longer want to support it. It's too expensive and not really core. It's like a startup cutting their burn by removing extraneous bits of their operating profile.
23:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, I'll take a guess.
23:40 Speaker 01 Please.
23:40 Speaker 00 I don't think Future, which is Andreessen Horowitz's media arm. I think I just explained that, but in case you don't know, I'm listening. So Andreessen launched Future almost a year ago. I don't think they're going to shut it down. And I, like a lot of people that work on that product, I think that Andreessen Horowitz is definitely going to, this is kind of a political answer, but I think they're going to expand how they're defining media and what their media ambition is. I don't think it's going to be as simple as launching Future. Clearly it's not because there are co-investors in Prolog. And Prolog's whole thing is that they're going to help companies get attention in this economy where attention is so low. And so I don't know, in my head, I'm like, okay, I don't think that these products are singularly the future for any of them. And so we're going to see a lot more where they come from because they have to. Does that feel like that is a fair answer? Was that too nice?
24:22 Speaker 01 Natasha, you always find a way of ending shows on a very positive note. And I mean that as an actual compliment because I think it does actually add a lot of, a little bit of nuance because we can get a little snarky and so I appreciate that. The question of, you know, what happens to these projects? I, ah, man, I almost want to say, how fast do interest rates rise? And the faster they rise, the more of this we're going to see kind of like shaved off. I still read Future occasionally, mostly out of just macabre curiosity about what the Andreessen version of my job looks like, if that makes sense. And yeah, I don't want to comment on it too much, but I want to end with something that you mentioned because you're, you're tying Andreessen again to Prolog. And you know, I'm more kind of just surprised that the great Andreessen media push crested when it did, because if you think back to Clubhouse and Substack and Future, there was a moment where it did seem that Andreessen was trying to, as an organization,
25:07 Speaker 01 Rewrite what it means to write and future is trucking along, just doing its thing. I'm sure it's a medium success so far, internally, I don't know. But Substack just had to do layoffs and isn't raising.
25:18 Speaker 00 Yeah.
25:18 Speaker 01 And Clubhouse.
25:19 Speaker 00 Had to do layoffs as well.
25:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, and is not any danger of raising capital that I've heard of anywhere. So Andreessen Horowitz could swoop in, but you know, I've been chewing a lot on that lately. So that's kind of my concluding mark here. For founders, though, you know, all this stuff, I guess, just means more avenues, more opportunities.
25:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. I kind of think that in a weird way, like having VCs and startup accelerators and something like a product hunt. I don't even know how to describe that place, but a startup platform all get into the media world and the investment world. I think we'll add empathy to our universe a little bit, like to each other's universes. But beyond empathy, a lot of learnings are going to come out of them doing these experiments. And I hope that changes the way that they build, right? Like there is a world where YC does this, they learn what's working and what's not. When it comes to how people sort through their companies on an evergreen basis. And that can be filtered back into the way that they conduct accelerators. And maybe it's asking for a lot, but past four or five years, it would be really cool to see, I guess, expansion change the way these products look. We don't know at the time if they're the future, right?
26:19 Speaker 00 Which is kind of weird.
26:20 Speaker 01 Oh, I thought you were going to add dot com to that.
26:22 Speaker 00 Oh, God, I should have.
26:23 Speaker 01 You should have. I think it's a great point. If these products don't end up being enormous moneymakers, but instead end up being information sources that are then kind of sorted by the corporate algorithm, which is just the collection of human minds at a business to make for a better operating profit for the company itself, then huzzah, I'm here for that. That's going to take a lot of work and also it would require people that are currently doing business in motion to pause and listen to new input sources, which is always tough if you're in a hurry. But I think we should stop there. There's a lot more in this area to talk about. We're not going to let this stuff go away. We have an eye on the pulse of the early stage community as always, because well, everything's in flux yet again.
26:56 Speaker 00 Right, I mean, I was just going to say, like, if there's any time to unlearn and to rethink about why things are becoming full circle, now is the time. So it's kind of our time to shine because we love doing this. And Alex, it is always lovely to talk to you about these really niche things that you make not feel too niche at all.
27:11 Speaker 01 The same back at you. I always love kind of leaving my late-stage pre-IPO world and coming into the early-stage area because it's so much more about people and personalities and so much less about spreadsheets. And so it's way more fun.
27:21 Speaker 00 I know, drama, competition, conflict. We love it here.
27:24 Speaker 01 I know.
27:25 Speaker 00 Everyone else, we will chat with you on Friday.
27:28 Speaker 01 See you then.
27:28 Speaker 00 Bye.
Previous Contrarian bets in a downturn Next Cauldrons, Bolts and sour markets: Welcome to Halloween in July Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated