Pod Insights Empire: World History 213. How Three Wise Men Became Three Kings About this episode The story of the Three Wise Men has been reinterpreted since it was first written down. The gift-bearing visitors to the newborn Jesus were initially described as “Magi”, meaning Persians of a priestly caste, but by the 4th century they were given the individual names of Gaspar, Melchior and Balthazar. And in Medieval Europe they were described not as Three Wise Men, but as Three Kings. Yet there’s more to the evolution of the Magi than Western ideas, in Syriac Christian traditions there are up to 24 Magi, and in the Ethiopian church they are named Hor, Karsudan, and Basanater. So how have these ideas developed over time?
Listen as William and Anita are again joined by Professor Lloyd Lewellyn-Jones to discuss the evolution of the story of the Magi, and the influence of British imperialism on their symbolism…
Twitter: @Empirepoduk
Email: empirepoduk@gmail.com
Goalhangerpodcasts.com
Assistant Producers: Anouska Lewis
Producer: Callum Hill
Exec Producer: Neil Fearn
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 They're running a cover two defense. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go-to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats. Order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
0:30 Speaker 01 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot designed to keep you connected. Powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HACK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
1:00 Speaker 02 Reports due to, then meeting prep, then...
1:03 Speaker 03 Chronic migraine doesn't care about your to-do list. For people with chronic migraine, 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more, Botox, onabatilinumtoxin A prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine. It is not approved for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. Botox prevents, on average, eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo. Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions,
1:46 Speaker 03 including ALS, Lou Gehrig's Disease, myasthenia gravis, or Lambert-Eaton Syndrome, and medications including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
2:10 Speaker 04 Hello and welcome to Empire with me, Anita Arnon.
2:14 Speaker 05 And me, William Dribble.
2:16 Speaker 04 And we're doing some Christmasy specials because we love you and we love this subject. I mean, it's amazing. We're talking about the Magi, the three wise men, three kings. If you haven't heard the first episode, go back and listen to it because it's really outstanding with our outstanding guest, a professor of ancient history and now a proper man of the cloth, Lloyd Lewellyn Jones is with us again. Hello. Hello, hello. You took us on such a fabulous romp in the last episode. And you know, the reason, again, if you're just joining us, is why are these guys doing this story? I thought, I'm listening to Empire. Well, if you listened to the first one, and hopefully in this too, we always have this idea that the nativity story with the three wise men
2:59 Speaker 04 turning up with their gold frankincense and myrrh is a direct trajectory from the Gospel of Matthew coming straight down to us and nothing has been changed. And it is, you know, it's as pure as that. But what we're doing is we're talking about the influence of different empires at the time on this story. So we talked a lot about the Persians. We talked about the Romans, which was a fabulous introduction to, you know, the kind of geopolitics that was going on at the time. Why is he called the son of God so many times by Matthew? It's because Augustus was talking about himself as the son of God. So all of these things are a fantastic window into the times when these huge empires were clashing
3:41 Speaker 04 against each other. Lloyd, the last, we talked about the names because Matthew doesn't say the names. He doesn't even say how many.
3:49 Speaker 05 And he doesn't say also when. It doesn't say if it's kind of, you know, the week after, it could be years after. It's still a baby.
3:55 Speaker 04 Yeah. So let's first of all, just remind people the names that we have come to associate with the three wise men. Melchior, the wise man who supposedly brought gold. Casper, the man who supposedly brought frankincense. And Balthazar, the poor man who brought the myrrh that we often mock because, you know, myrrh, it's just, I just can't stop.
4:16 Speaker 05 It's a wild animal, isn't it?
4:17 Speaker 04 It's a dangerous beast.
4:19 Speaker 05 You've always liked it.
4:20 Speaker 04 It's a dangerous beast that can bite the baby. So where are we going to start? Where do you want to take us, William?
4:26 Speaker 05 We should say that those names, which we are so familiar with and which we've all grown up with. Are not the names that other churches give to the wise men.
4:36 Speaker 06 There are variations on the theme, essentially. And you know what? The process of transliteration, you know, is is a pretty much an open one anyway. So for some it's Kaspar, for others it's Gasper, for others it's Kastar, and so on and so forth.
4:55 Speaker 05 And just before we go any further with that one, it's linked, isn't it? I've always read to the name that we've talked about before on this pod for the acts of Thomas the King Gondofaris, who's meant to have invited Saint Thomas to India in that story.
5:10 Speaker 06 Exactly. So the tradition is that Kaspar is an indigenous Iranian. Okay, so he's from the Iranian plateau and he is some kind of member of a royal family, maybe a king himself. But he is the person who introduces the disciple Thomas to a later Parthian king. So that's the link in there.
5:32 Speaker 05 And to this day, I've literally just come back from Kerala in southwest India. There's a whole community of Christians there who believe that their church was started by Saint Thomas. And they tell you this with with great earnestness.
5:44 Speaker 06 It is incredible. There's also this tradition, Ernst Hönsfeld, the great archaeologist of the 1930s, believed that Kaspar gives his name to Kandahar.
5:54 Speaker 05 Oh, really?
5:54 Speaker 06 Yeah, yeah, yeah, which may be stretching it a bit, but but Ernst was, you know, Ernst Hönsfeld was was very serious in in making that connection. And maybe there's there's something in it, who knows? But basically, what we're dealing with is a string of legends, mythologies, which rise up about these names. And I think importantly, and this is something we touched on when we did the last programme. Matthew was very keen to show that Old Testament prophecies are being fulfilled in the Jesus narrative of his birth. So in the Book of Psalms, the great hymn book of the Hebrew faith, we have, for instance, one psalm which talks about, they will come to him from afar,
6:37 Speaker 06 from Arabia, from the east. And I think it even says, you know, from. Messiah and Sidon, they will come and they will lay homages before him, him being Messiah, the the anointed one of God. And so, of course, what later Christians after Matthew wants to do is to kind of pinpoint those points on the map to say, well, they came from all over the ancient world to the empire of King David itself, you know, so here's another empire being created with subjects showing homage to this newborn king.
7:09 Speaker 05 And and just to say clearly in one sentence, what is Matthew doing with these guys? Why does he have them turn up?
7:16 Speaker 06 Well, the most important thing is they are witnesses to the birth of Messiah. It's a revolution in the world where God, for the first time, enters the world fully formed, fully human and fully divine at one and the same time. Not an avatar of God, not not, you know, coming down in a human body, but actually being fully human. So the Magi are the witnesses. And of course, the great celebration in the Christian faith we have is on the sixth of January, the Feast of Epiphany. Epiphany, of course, being a Greek word, meaning to appear before. So this is when Jesus appears before witnesses for the first time. So that's their importance theologically.
7:59 Speaker 04 You know, it just struck me that there may be some people who are devout Christians who may find this all a bit too much, saying, hang on a minute, this is just the story. This is what happened. This actually did happen. And I don't know why you're talking about influences or Matthew trying to use analogies from different empires to prove a point or delving into apocrypha or even, you know, sort of old stories to to say these old predictions are coming true. I feel sort of secure asking you because you've devoted your life now to Christ, right? You're you're a priest now. So so how do you address this? To anybody who's nashing their teeth going, why are you doing this?
8:35 Speaker 06 It's a great question, and it's something I've had to deal with since I was essentially sixteen, seventeen, you know, doing A level biblical studies and all of this, starting to take the Bible apart and then retaining my faith. And the way it's worked out for me is the more I can tear into the Bible. Understand its creation and the history that underpins the whole thing. In fact, the stronger my faith gets because somehow I see a truth that is greater than the fallible way in which humans have to try to get their scriptures out. The scriptures are changeable, but God speaks through them and somehow to me. You know, there, there is a bigger picture of a narrative of salvation,
9:20 Speaker 06 which is a greater truth than anything we can find in the written word itself. So it's something I've really, really had to, to work on and some people struggle with. And I no longer struggle with it. I'm glad to say I've found my peace with being both a historian and a man of faith.
9:36 Speaker 04 But do you have lots of opposition? I mean, a- among clergy, because now you're a member of the clergy. Do, do some come and say to you, look, actually this is not helpful. This is confusing. And, you know, this is the story. This is just what happened. Stop muddling us all up with all of your Persian stuff.
9:52 Speaker 06 Very rarely, not amongst the clergy, sometimes amongst congregations, you can see the eyebrows raising in a sermon. Because they're unfamiliar, you know, we cannot get away from the fact that there are two nativity stories. There's Matthews, which is wise men. There's Luke's, which is shepherds and angels, and never the two will meet. Now, how do we deal with that? Well, we have to take them one at a time. We have to look for the, the message, the meaning that sits behind these stories. And then we can deal with them in our heads in how we want.
10:24 Speaker 05 But Lloyd, on this episode, we would like now to move on in a sense from the gospels, which we discussed in the last episode and, and these two very different versions of nativity. And look what Christian tradition adds to it, which is to completely scramble it in all sorts of ways. And take it in a whole variety of different directions, depending on whether you're in the Armenian church, the Ethiopian church, the church of North Africa, which doesn't exist anymore, Tatalian. Where would you like to start?
10:51 Speaker 06 I, I'd like to start a little bit closer to the, the period of the gospels themselves.
10:56 Speaker 05 Sure.
10:57 Speaker 06 Because what we have to realise is that there were lots of, lots of competing voices. In the early in Christian church, everybody wanted to get their truth out there. And I suppose at some point, you know, texts were either accepted into the canon of what we call the New Testament, or they were shoved into apocryphal books, which still had a kind of circulation, but weren't so well known, or there were real kind of miscreants who sat outside of the tradition, waiting for many thousands of years to be discovered again. And I think, Anita, you were absolutely right in saying, you know, we've got this idea that the tradition is passed down to us directly from Matthew, and we have it in our Bibles now, and that's all there is to it. But actually, there's a far more complex story that goes
11:42 Speaker 06 on here. And we could do this for any section of the Gospel, stories of Jesus's life. But let's see what they do then with Matthew's story of the wise men. Well, in the second century, so just 200 years after Jesus's death, we have a whole set of birth stories and stories of the youth of Jesus, which simply don't get into the New Testament at all. One of them is this incredible Gospel of Thomas, which is the sayings of Jesus. Another one, we call the Protoevangelium of James. So the like the Proto Gospel or birth story of James, in which we go through the nativity story. But interestingly, we also have the early years of Jesus growing up in Nazareth, where he's a bit of a mischievous
12:27 Speaker 06 boy, a bit of a rebel toddler. So for instance, because he's got all these superpowers, which he doesn't know how to control.
12:33 Speaker 05 Is that where the sparrows, he takes the, that comes from there?
12:36 Speaker 06 So he takes some mud, you know, and he says to his little friends, look, what I can do. Takes some mud and he spits on it and says a prayer and they suddenly turn into sparrows. And another point, you know, he quarrels with a boy in his school, and he strikes him dead. And the little boy's father runs to Joseph and says, look what your son has done. And Joseph almost takes Jesus by the ear and drags him back to the schoolyard and says, make this boy live again. And so he does, the first resurrection that we have. You know, I mean, they don't, do not make the final cut. So there are all these alternative stories coming out about the infant Jesus.
13:10 Speaker 05 And some of those end up in the Quran.
13:12 Speaker 04 Don't they?
13:12 Speaker 06 That's right. That's the incredible thing.
13:14 Speaker 04 So which ones end up in the Quran? Like which ones? Which ones are in the Quran?
13:18 Speaker 06 Some of these stories of the childhood of Jesus, the naughty childhood.
13:21 Speaker 04 Naughty Jesus, who who has to bring his friend back to life?
13:24 Speaker 06 Absolutely. And of course, Mary's story in the Quran is so much bigger than anything you get in the New Testament. A whole surah to herself, you know, the surah of Maryam is enormous, absolutely. But around the time that these stories are being told, there's also another tradition which we call pseudo Matthew. So we don't know who wrote it, but clearly he's riffing on Matthew. Okay, he's taken the Matthew's text and he goes with her a little bit. And in this particular gospel, the three wise men, they approach and they give homage to the infant Jesus and they give their gifts. And then Mary gives them a gift to go home and she gives them the swaddling bands that Jesus had worn. Okay?
14:05 Speaker 04 Wow.
14:05 Speaker 06 And they take these back. And where do they go? They go back to Persia. And this is specifically said in this text. And in Persia, they go to their temple, a Zoroastrian temple. And they burn the rags, the swaddling rags themselves, and this creates the sacred flame of Zoroastrianism.
14:23 Speaker 04 Blimey.
14:23 Speaker 06 So that that living flame begins with the cloth that has touched the body of Jesus. So there we have a complete riff.
14:32 Speaker 04 Hang on a minute. Swaddling bands. Are we talking about sort of the the the wrap around a baby or nappy? Are we talking nappy stuff?
14:38 Speaker 06 Not quite the nappy. No, not quite the nappy. In antiquity, people believed that there were lots of sort of things that could, demons and ghouls and things that could corrupt the body. So to keep it safe, you would wrap it very, very tightly. I mean, that was something that was done in Wales until the 1960s. I was swaddled.
14:54 Speaker 04 No, no, no, it's made a comeback. Well, it certainly did when my kids were babies because, yes, you sort of give them little tight things to wear so that they feel secure like they're back in the womb. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
15:03 Speaker 06 So it has a mental thing, but also it has this theological thing. So it's it's those cloths that have intimately touched the body of the of the Son of God that then gives life to the everlasting flame, which is incredible, isn't it? You know, which allegedly has never gone out. You know, if you go to Yazd in Iran today, that flame allegedly is still burning. Yeah. Yes, yes, yes. Then we have another version, another spin on that story, which was found in Egypt. It dates to the sixth century, the text that we have, but it's quite clear that it was a much, much earlier story. And in this one, the wise men go to Jerusalem.
15:43 Speaker 06 As Zarathustra has predicted, Zarathustra, the great prophet of Zoroastrianism. So he has already said that this child will be born. So there's a prophecy in Iran that these guys listen to. And so they go with their gifts and they adore him. And there it's proscunion out in. So they lay themselves on their stomachs before him in a good old Persian fashion. They do a complete salam.
16:09 Speaker 05 If he's the king of kings.
16:10 Speaker 06 Ah, king of kings, exactly. And then Mary gives them their cloth. And again, they take that back with them. And they bring with that cloth a light into their country. So the light that will lighten up the Gentiles, the cloth kind of has this aura, this far, as we would say in Persian. This kind of luminescence around it, the godliness that we have there. And they again, put fire to this and the fire burns. And thereon after, the wise men disseminate from Persia into India, Afghanistan, Pakistan into Gandara and so forth. Spreading the words of Christ.
16:51 Speaker 06 And this is where they are joined by Saint Thomas and therefore the the Indian tradition.
16:56 Speaker 05 Which text is that?
16:57 Speaker 06 So this is called the Arabic infancy gospel. It was originally written in Aramaic. We now have it in Arabic dating from the sixth century, so a very early Arabic text.
17:08 Speaker 05 That must be one of the very first texts in Arabic, yeah.
17:11 Speaker 06 And this is the incredible thing, you know, these stories have taken hold very, very early on indeed. But then we have the Syria version.
17:21 Speaker 05 This is an incredibly rich variety of stories. It's kind of selection box of all sorts of strange riffs.
17:27 Speaker 06 Let's not forget, you know, the Syriac church in many respects was more. Powerful than the church in Jerusalem for many centuries.
17:36 Speaker 04 When we say Syriac, we're talking about early Christians in Syria.
17:38 Speaker 06 Early Christians in Syria.
17:39 Speaker 04 Syria, right, okay.
17:40 Speaker 06 Syria had been a hub of Christianity from the offset. Antioch in particular had been, you know, a real site for Christian worship.
17:47 Speaker 05 The first place Gentiles get openly welcomed in.
17:50 Speaker 06 Precisely. And so, you know, it's just a matter of accident of history, really, that Christians among us are not worshiping the Syriac tradition, because it could have gone that way very easily, rather than the Western Roman tradition. I mean, that's the whole that the Syriac church had. And so you can imagine, therefore, that the amount of materials we have available to us, pretty much unknown in the Western tradition, unfortunately, is so rich. And a scholar from America called Richard Landau has done a fantastic job on unearthing some of these early texts. And he came across this text called The Revelation of the Magi. It dates to the fifth century, and again, no doubt with earlier sections to it.
18:31 Speaker 06 And in this one, we have, again, a group of Zoroastrian wise men, seers, who, again, are commanded through a prophecy of Zarathustra that they must go and follow a star to Jerusalem, and that's where they end up. And they each give their gifts. But these wise men, and they're numbered here as 12, all have fathers who are wise men as well, so there's 24. Because as we know in Zoroastrianism, these are a priestly caste, they are in the family. So we have actually a kind of a story of wise men waiting for centuries,
19:13 Speaker 06 generation after generation, for the prophecy of Zarathustra to come true. So it's being reclaimed in the Persian tradition, really. So they all bundle off and they give their gifts, all of them. And then afterwards they return, and once again, the Thomas tradition is inserted into that then as well.
19:34 Speaker 04 Just remind us, do they talk about gold, frankincense or myrrh? Or they don't, they just say gifts? Do they say gifts in the Syriac? So it could be anything at all.
19:41 Speaker 06 Anything at that point.
19:42 Speaker 04 So just, I mean, just to bring this a little bit into our reality right now. If the Syriac tradition was so very strong with what's going on in Syria at the moment, how much could we lose if there is a lot of instability and violence in Syria? I mean, we're hoping not. And at the time of recording, Assad has been ousted and we're not quite sure what is going to happen next. On, at the time of recording, Damascus seems to be in one piece. But just, I mean, from your, with your archaeological hat on, what in the ancient Christian Syriac religion, what are the artefacts that still exist in Syria today?
20:19 Speaker 05 Oh, so much.
20:20 Speaker 06 Honestly, there is so much there. I mean, so much that is known and has been studied in the archives and in the libraries. But the most remarkable thing is the amount of stuff that we haven't revealed yet. You know, there are libraries and archives in Syria that go back to the founding of the Christian church and we don't know the half of what's there yet.
20:40 Speaker 05 And tragically and even ironically, one of the greatest libraries and one of the most important monasteries is in Saeed Naya, immediately beside where this hideous prison full of political prisoners is. And on the rock immediately above it is this beautiful monastery.
20:55 Speaker 04 Describe it.
20:56 Speaker 05 It's a shrine to the Virgin Mary, who, as Lloyd said, is also very important in the Islamic tradition.
21:02 Speaker 04 Yeah.
21:03 Speaker 05 And when you go to Saeed Naya, you see on one side of the church, the Christians and often mixed in, but sometimes behind them or in the aisles, you see Muslims. And everyone comes there and prays side by side. And when I was there, there were these, these guys who came in and they were offering sheep to the monks. I said, you know, does everyone bring this? They said, well, it depends what they're doing. But we had two Syrian astronauts here, they said, who were going to the space station Mir, and they came and gave their helmets when they came back. So there's all sorts.
21:34 Speaker 06 Ah, amazing.
21:36 Speaker 05 But, I mean, the tragedy for Syria is that that is immediately next door to this horrible.
21:40 Speaker 06 Oh, you say terrible, but it's that kind of place, you know, these very old churches and monasteries that have libraries within libraries. And because they're so carefully guarded by The monks that and and sometimes nuns as well who who look after them. We don't really have open access to these things. So we don't know what we're going to find in in these kind of places.
22:03 Speaker 05 Lloyd, one of the, when I was reading up for this, I read a fantastic article called The Magi in Syriac Tradition. And the liveliest story I found in that essay was a text called The Cave of Treasures. And this one talks about the gifts of the Magi having originally been given to Adam. And he takes them out of the garden and even and he hides them in a cave. And the Magi bring them from the cave to Jesus. Isn't that a gorgeous story?
22:30 Speaker 06 Oh, isn't that fantastic? I mean, that makes so much sense, doesn't it? Because in that Christian tradition, of course, Jesus is the second Adam. And Mary is the second Eve, of course, as well, you know. And there's also this tradition, isn't there, in early Christianity of magical caves as well? Do you know the the story that is told around Ephesus in Turkey of the seven sleepers?
22:50 Speaker 05 Yeah.
22:51 Speaker 06 So these early Christians were being persecuted by the Romans and they go and sleep in this cave. And magically they're transported 400 years into the future when they wake up, when the persecutions are all over. So caves are always these these places in all kinds of ledges and myths, aren't they?
23:07 Speaker 05 And in the Arabian Nights.
23:08 Speaker 06 Exactly. I've got a little bit of a text from the revelation of the Magi. I think I'd like to read to you. Do you want to hear?
23:13 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
23:14 Speaker 06 This is essentially the kind of the the ending point of the whole thing. And it's Jesus who speaks to the Magi now that they've become evangelists in themselves. So Jesus says, I am everywhere because I am the ray of light. And where the light has shone, there I am. I shine this light in the world for the majesty of my father, who sent me to fulfill everything that was spoken about me in the entire world and in every land by unspeakable mysteries. Isn't that fantastic?
23:48 Speaker 04 Beautiful.
23:48 Speaker 06 This whole idea of the light of the world just emanating from him.
23:52 Speaker 04 We're going to go into a break very, very shortly, but just before we go to the break. Melchior, Gaspar and Balthazar, at what point are they lobbed on to the story then? And and were they? Real people. Do we know that they were real people? Because they even have sort of backstories, giving them where they've come from, what they did, how old they were, they had red beards, they had long hair. You know, there's an awful lot of detail that comes to it.
24:14 Speaker 06 Yeah, absolutely. No, there is no historical validity for any of this whatsoever. But what we can say is the tradition of the three names is certainly alive and well by the fourth century, because we see them in the churches of Ravenna in northern Italy, being named Balthazar, Gaspar, Melchior.
24:33 Speaker 05 I've always understood that the guy who comes up with them being kings, not magi, in other words, rulers, not priests, is Tertullian, who is intriguingly far away in Carthage in what's now Tunisia.
24:47 Speaker 06 That's right.
24:48 Speaker 05 And that makes perfect sense that if you're sitting in Tunisia, you wouldn't know what a magi was.
24:51 Speaker 06 What a magi was, precisely. So you make them a king.
24:53 Speaker 04 Well, I'll tell you what, that's what we're going to do in the next half. We're going to talk about how that transformation of magi, wise men to kings, we three kings of Orienta has a lot to answer for. And we're going to find out why and how that could have happened. Join us after the break.
25:10 Speaker 00 They're running a cover two defence. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favourite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats. Order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
25:40 Speaker 01 Visible puts the ultimate wireless hack in the palm of your hand. With unlimited 5G wireless data and hotspot, designed to keep you connected, powered by Verizon's 5G network. And no contract holding you back. Plans start at $25 a month. Or get the premium Visible Plus Pro Plan and save $10 on your first month when you use promo code HAK. Make the switch at visible.com. Terms apply. See visible.com for details.
26:10 Speaker 02 I hope I don't have to cancel again tonight.
26:12 Speaker 07 Chronic migraine means 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more. Botox, onabacholineum toxine, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine. It is not approved for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. Botox, the number one prescribed branded chronic migraine preventive treatment.
26:27 Speaker 01 On average, eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo. Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems or muscle weakness can be signs of a life threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS, Lou Gehrig's disease, myasthenia gravis or Lambert Eaton syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects. Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
27:14 Speaker 04 Welcome back. Now, we are going to start this half with a little reading from my dear friend William, who was your first book, earliest book?
27:22 Speaker 05 My first book.
27:23 Speaker 04 You were just a baby. You were a little embryo when you were embryonic William.
27:26 Speaker 05 I was 21.
27:28 Speaker 04 And the spitting image of your son, which is so, I mean, mini me, except he's huge. Adam looks just like you did at that age. Anyway, travelling through Iran to the town of Savi and you're following Marco Polo's trail. Take it away.
27:42 Speaker 05 So Marco Polo has one of these stories about the Magi and it's a gripping and strange story. And it's clearly related to the same sort of set of traditions that Lloyd is talking about in the first half. Stories about the beginning of Zoroastering and trying, in a sense, to link it to these Magi who appear in the gospel. So Marco Polo is heading to Mongolia to the court of the Great Khan and he's halfway through Iran when he comes to the town of Savi and he tells a story. "In Persia is the city of Savi from which the three Magi set out when they went to worship Jesus Christ. And in this city they are buried in three very large, beautiful monuments side by side.
28:25 Speaker 05 In one of them, there is a square building carefully kept. The bodies are still entire, with their hair and beards remaining. One of these was called Jasper, the second Melchior, and the third Balthazar." Mr. Marco Polo asked a great many questions of the people of that city as to these three magi, but never one could he find that new ought of the matter, except that these were three kings who were buried in days of old. However, at a place three days distant, he heard of what I'm going to tell you. He found a village there by the name Kala Atapristan, which is to say, the castle of the fire worshippers. And the name is rightly applied for the people there do worship fire, and I will tell you why. They relate that in old times, three kings
29:10 Speaker 05 of that country went away to worship a prophet that was born, and they carried with them three manner of offerings, gold, frankincense, and myrrh, in order to ascertain whether the prophet were a god, or an earthly king, or a physician. For they said if he takes gold, then he is an earthly king. If he takes incense, then he is a god. But if he takes myrrh, he is a physician. Polo went on to say how the three magi arrived there. They went in separately, and to their amazement, each saw the child of their own age. One found him young, the next in his prime, the third old and hoary. Then they all entered together. This time the
29:50 Speaker 05 child appeared his actual age, namely thirteen days old. No little impressed by this, the magi gave their child all three gifts, and in return, were presented with a small closed box. There follows the strangest part of the whole story, and the legend of the three magi is linked to the beginning of Zoroastrianism. And when they had ridden many days, they said that they would see what the child had given them. So they opened the little box, and inside, they found a stone. On seeing this, they began to wonder what this might be, that the child had given them, and what was the import thereof. Anyway, they throw the stone away into a well, and the flame wells up, and this is the beginning of Zoroastrianism.
30:32 Speaker 06 Oh, isn't it fantastic? That's wonderful. And you can, you can really see different strands of the earlier stories going into that, can't you? You really can.
30:40 Speaker 05 And he's told that live in, in Persia in 1271.
30:45 Speaker 06 Ah, that's just, that's wonderful. I love it. I really do. You know, there are Early Chinese stories of the Magi as well.
30:53 Speaker 04 Really?
30:53 Speaker 06 Not as not as early as this, but certainly 16th, 17th century ones too. And you know, today, the Christian church in China claim one of the wise men is Chinese.
31:04 Speaker 05 Really?
31:05 Speaker 06 Yes.
31:06 Speaker 04 I didn't, I did not know that. Marco Polo also famously wrote about seeing the tomb of the Magi, which was in Constantinople. So it was Helena, wasn't it, who, who was the mother of Constantine, who said, I have got the relics of the three wise men, the Magi, I've got them and keeps them there. And then they make their way, I mean, right now in Cologne, there is the shrine of the three kings in Cologne.
31:28 Speaker 06 That's where you can go and see them now, absolutely. And, and the shrine there was set up by the Holy Roman Emperor Frederick Barbarossa.
31:36 Speaker 04 Right.
31:37 Speaker 05 He brought them back from Crusades.
31:38 Speaker 06 From Crusades, yes, yes, yes. And I think this is where we get the new kind of use of, of the term kings for them. In the Middle Ages, it was very important for kings to be seen as representatives of Christ on earth. So I think what they did was in the kind of theology of Christology, they heightened Christ to this king of kings. And then essentially they call themselves, you know, kings underneath his kingship as well. So this is where the wise men become very important.
32:09 Speaker 04 They get crowns. I mean, it's in 1199 that King Otto decides to give them three golden crowns as well.
32:15 Speaker 06 That's right.
32:15 Speaker 04 The start of the transmutation into kings is earlier than that even, isn't it? I mean, you, you were talking about, yes, Totalian. So tell us about why that happens.
32:26 Speaker 06 Well, Totalian, Totalian is a very important Western Christian bishop and theologian. And he's basically on the coast of North Africa.
32:34 Speaker 04 What, what date are we talking about?
32:36 Speaker 06 Fourth century, late third, early fourth century CE. He is probably as far away from Persia as you could be at that date. And so therefore Magi would, I think, mean very little to him. And possibly, you know, studying the Gospel of Matthew as he did, that word in Greek had no resonance for him. Um, majai would have meant nothing at all.
32:56 Speaker 05 We've given him too late a date. It turns out he's actually born in one sixty A D. Oh, is he so early?
33:01 Speaker 04 Really? So it is early. And I thought it was really very, very early because, you know, the, the shrine itself and the otto giving crowns is really late.
33:09 Speaker 06 Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
33:09 Speaker 04 And I, I sort of, you know, he's, he's holding on to something and that is this idea of they are kings. So do you think it is just a lost in translation thing that no one will understand majai? So I'll put it in words that people will understand.
33:22 Speaker 06 I think initially that's what it is in the Western church. But then, as I say, by the Middle Ages, there's a theology of kingship that goes along with it, you know? Because like the wise men, like the kings from afar, all Christian European kings are paying homage to the king of kings. So I think that's what becomes of that in the end.
33:44 Speaker 05 And then at the Reformation, there's a swing back against kingship and Calvin doesn't like this.
33:51 Speaker 06 Calvin's expression, I've got it written here because I have to say I love this. I love Calvin. He talks about the majai as kings. "The most ridiculous contrivance of the pagan," that is to say, the Catholic, "on this subject is that these men were kings. Beyond all doubt, they have been stupefied by a righteous judgment of God that all might laugh at their gross ignorance."
34:18 Speaker 05 Doesn't hang back.
34:20 Speaker 04 When we're talking about Calvin, we're talking about slightly sneery John Calvin, who's writing in the fifteen hundreds.
34:24 Speaker 06 Fifteen hundreds, in the height of the European Reformation and basically, you know, negating anything of the theology of the Roman Catholic Church. So saying there swipingly, "Kings, pah, how could they be kings?"
34:37 Speaker 05 Bah humbug.
34:37 Speaker 04 So this is the question, is it bah humbug? Because, you know, we have to set ourselves in opposition to the Catholics and so every symbol requires challenge. Or he's read something somewhere that makes him think, you know what, these Catholics are crazy. They've just completely got it wrong. How does that happen?
34:54 Speaker 06 Oh, now Anita, now you're getting to the heart of the Reformation. So the Reformed Church is all about the word. It's going back to the word. And of course, it's having access to the word in your own language. So the Latin Vulgate Bible had dominated the church for six hundred years at this time. Nobody really able to access either the Hebrew or the Greek. And what the great reformist scholars were doing, like Martin Luther, Calvin, Zwingli and others, were going back to the original texts. So Calvin knew his Greek Testament inside out, and he knew the word was magi. He also knows, of course, his classics. He knows Herodotus and knows that magi means priest.
35:40 Speaker 06 So, you know, this is what he is, he's saying there.
35:42 Speaker 05 So he's not just saying Bahambug, he's saying actually, actually they're Persian priests, and he's right.
35:47 Speaker 06 And that's really what the Reformation is all about, interrogating the texts.
35:51 Speaker 05 And then we have, this, this is now the age of discoveries, whereas the Reformation, this is the period that Europeans are going out into the world. And we see in some of the Renaissance painting, ideas that these magi don't just come from far away, or they suddenly don't come specifically from Persia. In the Renaissance tradition, you suddenly find them coming from different continents. So Melchior is European.
36:19 Speaker 06 Yes.
36:19 Speaker 05 Gaspah becomes Asian and Balthazar is at this period shown black from Africa.
36:25 Speaker 06 Yes, and African, absolutely. And that's a, that's a tradition which hangs on in the European artistic tradition for the next two hundred years. It's really fascinating. So you can, you can virtually date all of these depictions of the magi by the appearance of a single black magi. From between about fourteen eighty to about seventeen eighty, this is what happens. Now, after seventeen eighty, though, the world expands even more, of course, during the Enlightenment. And now we have the appearance of American magi as well. So we have, you know, wearing Inca-like headdresses and this kind of stuff too. So basically, empire.
37:07 Speaker 06 Is being used here to inform, of course, the centrality of the Christian church at the beginning of the British Empire and the French Empire and the German Empire and so forth too. So that Matthew and text is now being utilized to see the centrality of the Western religious tradition.
37:26 Speaker 04 So so one of the things that really tickles me is in the 15th century, artists had not seen many black people. They didn't know what to do with them. So you've got the Adoration of the Magi by Hieronymus Bosch and and he he has to paint Balthazar at an angle. So he doesn't have to do all the features because lighting this man is very, very difficult.
37:44 Speaker 06 Don't know how to do it, absolutely.
37:45 Speaker 04 He doesn't know how to do it. He doesn't know how to paint it.
37:47 Speaker 06 That's exactly right. Absolutely. And more outlandish costumes as well for Balthazar, more than anyone else.
37:53 Speaker 04 He's definitely got the bling out of the three, for sure.
37:55 Speaker 06 And if you also notice in all of these earlier paintings, the Renaissance paintings in particular, camels, oh my goodness me, camels come in all shapes and forms. You know, most of these Western artists have never seen a camel, but they're told about some kind of humped beast from the east.
38:08 Speaker 05 Brilliant camels, exactly, yeah.
38:10 Speaker 06 Incredible things.
38:11 Speaker 04 I think there is something wonderful to be done about the history of the leopard in art because they are some funny looking things in some of the paintings I've seen.
38:17 Speaker 05 You've actually got a very good camel on one of those Welsh fonts, haven't you, in the border countries in that Hereford School of Art?
38:24 Speaker 06 Oh, have we really? I didn't. I didn't know that, really.
38:26 Speaker 05 There's a font near Haye on Y.
38:28 Speaker 06 Yeah.
38:29 Speaker 05 Uh, that's 12th century, I think. And there's a lovely attempt at a camel on that, which which looks like not quite, we're not quite clear what kind of animal it is.
38:39 Speaker 05 So Lloyd, today Christians still celebrate the epiphany, but they do so in very different ways in the very different churches. Do you want to take us on some of the different, different timings, isn't there? There's great confusion in Jerusalem because there's four, three or four different epiphanies.
38:52 Speaker 06 That's right. So depending on when you place Christmas Day, of course, that has a huge knock on effect for when you place Epiphany, which is supposed to be 12 days after. Remember, actually, the text that you you mentioned with Marco Polo, they said that on the 13th day, the epiphany took place, wasn't it? So it can it can oscillate quite quite remarkably. So in the Western tradition, it has settled down on the 6th of January.
39:18 Speaker 06 Whereas in the early Christian church, actually, it used to take place on the twenty fifth of December. So our Christmas Day was actually the Epiphany at one point, which was also the day when Christians celebrated the baptism of Jesus as well. So over time, these great religious feasts were separated and given their own standing points, probably really to relieve the tediousness of winter more than anything else, you know, to give an excuse for a celebration. In the Armenian church, in the Syriac church, as well as in actually many European, Central European churches, the Magi are given far greater prominence than in Northern European and North American churches.
40:02 Speaker 06 They they have far more spectacular feasts, but also, of course, gift giving for many Christians still occurs on January the sixth, on the on the day of Epiphany, as of course, a commemoration of the gifting of of the gold frankincense and myrrh by the Magi themselves. And the one I particularly love is in France, of course, where you also get this cake called the Galacte Rois, with this lovely, wonderful puff pastry with kind of almond inside it. And the lucky person gets a coin and a crown.
40:31 Speaker 04 The little coin in the middle. Yes, I know, I know. And and I mean, if you haven't had one of these things, there are bakeries that do it for that just period of time, that very short window.
40:39 Speaker 06 Exactly.
40:40 Speaker 04 Where you can have these amazing layered gorgeousnesses of marzipan and pastry. Delicious.
40:46 Speaker 05 I remember when I I had one Christmas and Epiphany in Egypt, and I remember being very sad for the the cops because they have to wait until the seventh of January, they celebrate Christmas.
40:57 Speaker 06 Yes, I think it's that late, isn't it?
40:59 Speaker 05 And then they don't get Epiphany until January the nineteenth, and that's when they get their presents. So if you're a Coptic child, it's a whole month after everyone else has opened them. It's very unfair.
41:09 Speaker 04 Lloyd, it's been absolutely gorgeous as always to have you on. Thank you so very much. And sort of in this run up to Christmas where everything really is about falling over yourselves and wrapping paper and getting hysterical in a shop. It is really lovely to be able to have this kind of view on a story that we think we know. And as always on Empire, we find out we really don't know it very well at all. Thank you very much.
41:31 Speaker 06 Oh, it's been a pleasure. Thank you.
41:32 Speaker 04 You're gorgeous and brilliant and wonderful. And you're going to be a very busy man, being a man of the cloth this Christmas, aren't you?
41:37 Speaker 06 Yes, yes, it all kicks off now. So as I put down my academic cloth next week and put down my pen, I've been finished my marking, then I put on the dog collar and it's all go. Basically until 6th January.
41:47 Speaker 05 You've got to write a book about this sometime though, Lloyd.
41:50 Speaker 06 I know, one day, absolutely.
41:52 Speaker 05 You're knocking them out about one a year at the moment. So I think you can polish it off in no time.
41:57 Speaker 04 Lloyd, do you have your fancy robes sorted out? Do you have a special design for fancy robes?
42:01 Speaker 06 Well, we have, of course, in the Anglican Church, we have a change of robes according to the season. So at the moment, we're plunged into purple, of course, because it's Advent. But come Christmas Day, I'll all be in silver and white. And that's what I'll be wearing right the way through to Epiphany then.
42:16 Speaker 04 Very, very nice. Look, one of the things that Lloyd mentioned, and we mentioned on this program, is about the Nabateans. And you might be wondering, hang on, you've done, you've done, you've done your wise men, stroke kings, but you haven't really, in sufficient detail, done your gold frankincense and myrrh. That's what we're going to be doing in the next episode. And we're going to be joined by that gift of a woman.
42:38 Speaker 05 Oh, favourite, favourite woman, exactly.
42:40 Speaker 04 Bethany Hughes is going to be, who's currently filming something about the Nabateans. So join us for that.
42:46 Speaker 05 We're actually getting her fresh from a Nabatean Christmas, exactly. She's going to be sitting in Oman doing that.
42:51 Speaker 04 So, I mean, don't say we don't spoil you, because we do. But it's Christmas. So that's what we want to do. Anyway, till the next time we meet, it's goodbye from me, Anita Aron.
42:59 Speaker 05 And goodbye from me, William Turimpo.
43:08 Speaker 00 They're running a Cover 2 defense. But you're running to get game day deals on Uber Eats. Keep everyone at tonight's watch party fed with deals from your go-to restaurants. Or stock up with deals on your favorite snacks and groceries. Whatever the occasion, get game day deals on Uber Eats all season long. It's not football without food. Uber Eats. Order now. Terms apply. Product availability varies by region. See app for details.
43:38 Speaker 00 Your sausage McMuffin with egg didn't change, your receipt did. The sausage McMuffin with egg extra value meal includes a hash brown and a small coffee for just $5. Only at McDonald's for a limited time. Price and participation may vary. Promotion pricing may be lower than meal pricing. Sam's Club is the club for every holiday club. Guess who's joining the club this season? Walmart Plus. Yep, Sam's Club Plus membership now comes with Walmart Plus at no extra cost. Two memberships, one great price. Just $120 a year can save you time and over $700. Want to get in on the membership duo of the century? Visit sam'sclub.com. Come join us. Sam's Club.
Previous 212. Who Were The Three Wise Men? Next 214. The Empire of Frankincense & Myrrh Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated