Pod Insights Decoder Why The Atlantic signed a deal with OpenAI About this episode Today I’m talking to Nicholas Thompson, the CEO of The Atlantic. I was really excited to talk to Nick. Like so many media CEOs, including Vox Media’s, he just signed a deal allowing OpenAI to use The Atlantic’s vast archives as training data, but he also has a rich background in tech. Before he was the CEO of The Atlantic, Nick was the editor-in-chief of Wired, where he set his sights on AI reporting well before anyone else.
I was also really interested in asking Nick about the general sense that the AI companies are getting vastly more than they’re giving with these sorts of deals — yes, they’re paying some money, but I’ve heard from so many of you that the money might now be the point — that there’s something else going on here – that maybe allowing creativity to get commodified this way will come with a price tag so big money can never pay it back. If there is anyone who could get into it with me on that question, it’s Nick.
Links:
Vox Media and The Atlantic sign content deals with OpenAI | The Verge
Journalists “deeply troubled” by OpenAI’s content deals with Vox, The Atlantic | Ars Technica
What the RIAA lawsuits mean for AI and copyright | The Verge
Perplexity plagiarized our story about how Perplexity Is a bullshit machine | Wired
How to stop Perplexity and save the web from bad AI | Platformer
The text file that runs the internet | The Verge
OpenAI, WSJ owner News Corp strike content deal valued at over $250 Million | WSJ
The media bosses fighting back against AI — and the ones cutting deals — WashPo
The New York Times spent $1 million so far in its OpenAI lawsuit | The Verge
AI companies have all kinds of arguments against paying for copyrighted content | The Verge
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. Our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,432 words · 9 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. AMX Corporate connects cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:24 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Subaru. You know that place your mind always wanders to? The lake, the mountains, the homes of the people you love most? The completely redesigned 2026 Subaru Outback is built to help you get there. With legendary capabilities, standard symmetrical all wheel drive, and the confidence to go further. The 2026 Subaru Outback. Love never looked so good. Visit Subaru.com/Outback to learn more.
0:51 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Nick Thompson, the CEO of The Atlantic, one of the oldest magazines in the United States. Like, really old. It was founded in 1857, and it's now owned by Laureen Powell Jobs, whose last name I am certain that Decoder listeners will recognize. I was really excited to talk to Nick. Like so many media CEOs, he just signed a deal allowing OpenAI to use The Atlantic's vast archives as training data. But Nick also has a rich background in tech. Before he was the CEO of The Atlantic, Nick was the editor in chief of Wired, where he set his sights on AI reporting well before anyone else, including me. So he's been paying attention to this for a long time. Now, I feel like I should disclose right away
1:37 Speaker 02 that Vox Media, The Verge's parent company where I work, has a deal with OpenAI, which was announced on the same day as The Atlantic's deal. I actually don't know very much about the terms of our deal, since I'm on the editorial side of the house, and there's a strict firewall between the business side and the editorial side. I suspect all of these deals are pretty similar, but I actually asked Nick about that. And there's a pretty funny reason that he doesn't know either. You'll hear us talk about it. Of course, I also asked Nick why he was willing to sign a deal with OpenAI in the first place, and why now? When there's so much general unhappiness about AI companies using other people's work without permission, and specific unhappiness with OpenAI. You'll hear Nick explain that what he really wanted to get back was a sense of control. Control over how much data was being used,
2:21 Speaker 02 how results were being displayed, and of course, how much money The Atlantic was being paid. You'll hear Nick say this all sounds like OpenAI is gearing up to build a next generation search product, which of course led us to talking about Google and whether getting Google to pay for search in AI is a realistic goal. I was also really interested in talking to Nick about the general sense that AI companies are getting much more than they're giving with these sorts of deals. Yeah, they're paying some money, but I've heard from so many of you that the money might not be the point, that there's something else going on here that maybe allowing creativity to be commodified in this way will come with a price tag so big, money can never pay it back. There's anyone who could just get into it with me on that question? It's Nick. This one went long. It's a good one. Nick Thompson,
3:06 Speaker 02 CEO of The Atlantic. Here we go.
3:21 Speaker 02 Nick Thompson, you are the CEO of The Atlantic, who are also notably for this conversation, the former editor in chief of Wired. Welcome to Decoder.
3:27 Speaker 03 Thank you so much, Neela. I'm delighted to be here.
3:29 Speaker 02 I am really excited to talk to you. I bring up the Wired thing because I want to talk to you about AI and the deals media companies like The Atlantic and notably Vox Media, the company that I work for, are making with companies like OpenAI. It feels like you have to understand the media business, the tech business, and where the tech business might be going in relationship to the media. Let's start at the very beginning. Why make a deal like this with OpenAI? What is your deal with OpenAI?
3:52 Speaker 03 The exact interest of the deal with OpenAI? We can go through it in a complex way or the simple way? The simple way is we believe it provides revenue, but more importantly, provides a potential traffic source, provides an avenue for a product partnership that could be very beneficial, and that provides a way for us to help shape the future of AI. AI is coming. It is coming quickly. We want to be part of whatever transition happens. Transition might be bad, the transition might be good, but we believe the odds of it being good for journalism and the kind of work we do at The Atlantic are higher if we participate in it. So we took that approach. We started talking to all the AI companies, all the large language model companies. We had parameters that we would accept for a deal, parameters we would not accept for a deal, and we reached a deal with OpenAI. So that's the basic framework.
4:37 Speaker 02 What were the parameters?
4:39 Speaker 03 The deal really has three parts, four parts, depending on how you look at it. Part one is for a limited period of time, two years in our case, they are allowed to train on our data, right? So they can read Atlantic stories and they can incorporate that into their base large language model. We have some controls over the kind of outputs they're allowed to give to people, but they are allowed to train on our data for two years. Second part of the deal is the product partnership. So they give us credits. So we were building tools on the business side with the engineering team that are using OpenAI. So we don't have to rely on Llama. We're not, you know, we are just using OpenAI credits. We are working with them. At some point, there may be engineering support, there may not be engineering support. Who knows exactly how that is going to work, but that is a potentially valuable part.
5:23 Speaker 03 And we are launching a lab site soon where we'll have a whole bunch of experimental tools to help readers. First one we created was a Chrome extension that will, as people are reading other places on the web, will show them stories the Atlantic has written that are related to, like just stuff like that. So we'll have a labs experimental site. So that's the second part of the deal. Third part is this very interesting search element where right now in OpenAI, they have browse mode and they can link out to Atlantic stories. They have said that they're going to build a search product. They have not launched a search product, but they have said they would build it. We have allowed them to include the Atlantic in their search product. Our view is that if this becomes an important way that people navigate the internet, that it will be better for us to be in it than to not be in it. And also to help shape it and not help shape it.
6:08 Speaker 03 So that's the third part. And then the fourth part is that there is a line back and forth. So when we see something like in browse mode, we notice something interesting about the URLs and the way they're linking out to media websites. You know, you go back and forth and those things get fixed. So our sense is that we are helping the product evolve in a way that is good for serious journalism and good for the Atlantic. So those are the key components of the deal. Underlying it is a view that journalists and media companies should be paid for their work. Obviously, the large language models scraped without permission, did not pay us. We think we should be paid for that. And there are a whole bunch of ways you can get paid for that. You can sue, you can do deals, you can shake your fists, you figure out whatever the best approach is to get paid, but there should be a fair exchange in value. So that is a key part of it.
6:52 Speaker 03 But we also believe that the world will be a better place for serious journalism if content like that created in The Atlantic and that created in The Verge is part of these models. If the search results return Verge stories, that is better for the readers and it is better for the world than if they do not, right? There are all kinds of trade-offs, but that is another element in it.
7:12 Speaker 02 There's a lot there. I want to take one piece of it and just focus on it for one second. You mentioned revenue.
7:17 Speaker 03 I did.
7:18 Speaker 02 How much money is it over two years?
7:20 Speaker 03 Well, so some of the terms of the deal are non-disclosure agreements. Obviously, I can't disclose that particular term, but it is a fair exchange in value.
7:26 Speaker 02 Do you think it's material or meaningful to The Atlantic's revenue as a whole?
7:29 Speaker 03 So it's short-term revenue. Is it material in 2024? Is it material in 2025, the two years of the deal? Of course. Would you want to extrapolate out to 2026? Of course not. Like, one of the things that you should, that we all know from deals with tech companies is they care about their interests, not your interests. They do deals that end. You don't expect it to continue forever.
7:52 Speaker 02 I feel like the industry learned that lesson in the hardest possible way. The rug pull of Facebook's various news initiatives or Google's various news initiatives and that money going away. Basically, everyone depended on those companies and then that dependency was revealed to be in error. Do you feel that? Was that skepticism present when you were talking to OpenAI?
8:12 Speaker 03 Yes and no. So I think there was a different mistake. My view, my philosophy, and this is not a perfect metaphor, is that basically the editorial work sits upstream and then everything else is downstream. That's the way you run a business. So you decide what stories you're going to run. The editors choose them, they write them to the best way they can, and then you fight like hell to get as much traffic as you can from Google, from Facebook, on Instagram, TikTok, whatever you're doing, right, to get them on to Reddit in the right way. You do all those things, but you do those things after you've written exactly the story you want. And where the companies made mistakes is that they moved the Google and the Facebook stuff upstream, right? And so they signed these deals and they didn't just expect that the revenue would continue forever, which is mistake one, but the much more serious mistake is if you start to assign stories or edit stories
8:56 Speaker 03 or change even a word in the stories because you want to have it go viral on Facebook, then you've started to sacrifice the thing that you do that matters, right? You know, I've spent most of my life working only at three places. I worked at Wired, then I went to New York, and then I went back to Wired, and I'm at The Atlantic. All of those places are kind of different dynamics. And at The New Yorker, what you're doing is you're fighting really hard to make sure everyone pays attention to fighting for Facebook and Google. There is no risk that this will be moved to the wrong place in the river. You know, at other magazines, and certainly you saw it in a lot of media. So that's mistake number one. Mistake number one, and that is the crucial mistake, is making the business deal upstream of the editorial. Mistake number one is assuming that these companies will partner with you forever. And if they say, we're going to give you X money this year, you'll also have that X money in three years, which is after the contract. And that is a mistake.
9:41 Speaker 03 But the much more important mistake is if you start to change the sacred thing you do, which is the creation of stories for the platforms. Okay, so now back to the AI deal. Is there any way in which we will change the way we do our stories because of this deal? Absolutely not. This will have no effect. We will do the exact same stories in 2024 and 2025 than we would have if we didn't have this deal.
10:05 Speaker 02 One of the big criticisms here is, okay, you sold this stuff for two years. They're going to train their model. It's going to get better. Then the deal will end. They won't pay you again, but they will have already trained the model. And that value will remain forever. And then they will just continue doing whatever they want to do.
10:21 Speaker 03 There are about 20 different terms that are important when you're negotiating a deal like this. That is one of the important terms. And so it has been publicly stated, and so I can say this, they are destroying our data. They will use our data to train any model that they build in the next two years, two years after we sign that deal. They train each new model on entirely new data. And so they will have our data for the next two years, but when it gets to GPT-6, they won't unless they have another deal. That clause is important, both for the reason you said, and also so we have more leverage when there's another moment of negotiation.
10:51 Speaker 02 It feels like OpenAI is the challenger. They obviously, the upstart, they're chaotic in the ways that startups can be chaotic, in a fun way and also in a compromised way. The real target here, it feels like, is Google, which has had a very extractive relationship with the media for a long time. Now is keeping more of that traffic for itself, is also building AI search products, delivering AI results, and is paying no one. Do you think a deal like this helps you get leverage against Google?
11:19 Speaker 03 I think so. Google has a different situation where they have so much more leverage on us because you can't block.
11:25 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:25 Speaker 03 I mean, there are ways you can partially block Google, right? You can block this Google bot and not that Google bot. But they have a lot more leverage on us at OpenAI. So the negotiations are different. I also would imagine that they are waiting. There are a lot of things that are happening with OpenAI, including the New York Times lawsuit. I think they're waiting to see how that shakes out. I haven't talked to Google directly about this, but if they pay for content, do they have to pay for all the links? And they have to pay back for 25 years' worth of it? Like, so I don't know what their calculations are, but I think they're watching what's happening. And my hope will be that there's a fair value exchange with Google as they build AI search.
11:58 Speaker 02 That part where you said OpenAI has already taken it, right? They've already scraped on what they refer to as publicly available information, which might include all the way up to YouTube, right? These are the reports that we've heard. Do you feel like you're taking the payment now in recompense for what they've already taken? Or is this for the future?
12:14 Speaker 03 Well, so that's a hard question to answer. This is not like you committed a sin and you're paying us for the sin. We don't view it that way. We view as you created. I was trying to do a calculation the other day. It was like, how much does the high-quality journalistic content? How much value did it create for OpenAI? And you can actually kind of do a back-of-the-envelope calculation. And you can see how much money, based on that calculation, a rough back-of-the-envelope, what they owe the journalism industry. So, or what the journalism industry contributed. And you can think about of what the journalism industry contributed, what percent should go to us and what percent should they keep, right? And that's sort of one way where you came up with a number. I don't view of it as like paying for a sin. I view it as like, okay, they've built this thing. It has this value. We're part of it. We'd like to be paid for it.
12:57 Speaker 02 That calculation, when you went to OpenAI with it, did that match what they wanted to pay you? Or were you higher or lower?
13:04 Speaker 03 I mean, that particular calculation has so much variation in it because how much do you weigh each of the factors is roughly where we ended up.
13:12 Speaker 02 The reason I ask it that way is the notion that this is a pre-settlement for a lawsuit that you might have filed the way that the New York Times filed a lawsuit, or you're setting a price floor for a further negotiation with Google, really changes the way you think about the deal itself, right? So if you're saying, you already took it, just pay us to catch us up and then in two years we'll start over from scratch, that changes versus you're building GPT-5 and a search product, we want to be on the ground floor to the challenger to Google. You might accept a discount in that case because you think the upside is higher. What was the balance there?
13:45 Speaker 03 We want to maximize several things, right? We want to maximize the amount of money that comes to serious journalism companies. We want to shape the industry in the best possible direction based on our values and we think the values that are important. We want to bring in as many readers as we possibly can. And so as we think through the deal, we're weighing all of those things. Now, the question of how you maximize money for the Atlantic Guardian publication is interesting because you do have an option. You can take the New York Times route, right? Or the Alden Capital route and you can sue. We looked at that calculation in the case of OpenAI and chose not to sue. That doesn't mean we're not going to sue every other large language model company out there. You weigh what they're offering you and on all those fronts, all the benefits they're offering, again, the product partnerships, search, et cetera.
14:28 Speaker 03 You weigh all those things versus, you know, what it would cost to sue and how much you would get from it and then you make a choice.
14:32 Speaker 02 It's been reported that the Times is a million dollars deep into its legal fees.
14:37 Speaker 03 I can see that.
14:38 Speaker 02 Against OpenAI.
14:39 Speaker 03 Suggesting they expect to get more than a million dollars for their content.
14:42 Speaker 02 Why? Hopes they assume they will want, they'll get more than a million dollars. The Atlantic is owned by a billionaire, it's owned by Lauren Powell Jobs. Would she have fronted a million dollars in legal fees or is that off the table for you?
14:52 Speaker 03 That's a complicated question. I mean, the answer, of course, yes, right? If we made an argument to her that this is what is best for the future of serious journalism, then she would certainly have supported it.
15:00 Speaker 02 The reason I ask that question that way is there's a lot of risk there, right? And when you have a rich owner, you can accept maybe more risk than if you are a publicly traded company or you have a bunch of VC money like Fox does.
15:12 Speaker 02 But the risk there is almost impossible to ascertain because the copyright law argument is like a total coin flip at this moment in time.
15:21 Speaker 03 Do you think it's a coin flip? Or do you think it's a like 60 40, 40 60, 70 30, 30 70?
15:25 Speaker 02 I think it's a pure coin flip.
15:27 Speaker 03 You think it's 50 50? Former copyright lawyer Patel here.
15:29 Speaker 02 And that is a pure lawyer answer. I think you can run through the argument and on a good day, a judge that has just used Dolly to make a storybook for their grandchild is on your side.
15:41 Speaker 03 Yep.
15:41 Speaker 02 And on a bad day, they've just seen the two startups that ripped off Johnny B. Good and the RIA is suing them and they lose. And I could not, I think that is as emotional decision as almost anything right now.
15:52 Speaker 03 But do you actually think the Times is going to reach an outcome? Or do you think they're going to settle it? Partly you settle based on where you think the case is going, right? And you do the arguments and you're like, oh my God, it's now 70 30. So we should settle on different terms.
16:04 Speaker 02 Right. I think there's that and we haven't gotten through any of that. And we really haven't seen anything substantive from OpenAI in terms of how they've trained. Most of these companies, it's really under lock and key. What they've trained on, what their approach to training was, what their approach to copyright law and training was. So sure, maybe as time goes on, that will change. But just on a straight, let's go through the argument. You ingest a bunch of data, you train a model on it, which means you set some weights and you throw the data out and I can do this generation. Who knows?
16:32 Speaker 02 If the Times wins, for example, and your two years is up and it turns out it wasn't very used to train these, do you think you'll be able to get more money? Are you just waiting at the clock on these losses?
16:40 Speaker 03 Oh, if the Times wins.
16:41 Speaker 02 Yeah.
16:42 Speaker 03 We will get more money from everybody. Every journalistic organization will get much more money from everybody, right?
16:46 Speaker 02 If the Times loses.
16:48 Speaker 03 We will all get much less.
16:49 Speaker 02 I'm just asking, like, how are you factoring that risk?
16:51 Speaker 03 Basically, you have a conversation with your lawyer and your lawyers and you talk, I talked to lots of copyright lawyers to decide whether, if I thought the Times had a 99% chance of winning, I would have a very different perspective going into these negotiations. If I thought the Times had a 1% chance of winning, a different perspective, right? So that does, you make your decisions based on that. You also weigh other things, right? Will text be important to training large language models two years in the future? Or will it all be multimodal data? Will synthetic data be so good, right? I've had people making large language models basically say, we don't need you because we can do it all through synthetic data in the future, right? And maybe the synthetic data is derivative of the organic data. But you have to weigh, what will your data be worth tomorrow? And therefore are you getting a better deal now or you get a better deal tomorrow? Do you think your data is going to be worth more tomorrow? Because text will still be valuable.
17:36 Speaker 03 And in fact, that organic human certified data that we created at the Atlantic and have been doing forever. If you think that is going to be more and more valuable and think the Times is going to win, well, then you would be more cautious. You would demand more in the deals. Not saying you wouldn't do any deals, but you just have a different framework.
17:50 Speaker 02 Do you think that the decision to take the deal now is rooted in, well, we can get some revenue now and hopefully all of these copyright lawsuits, because there's a lot of them. The industry really just has to lose one to get to where you're saying, right? The record labels have to win, or the Times has to win, or Sarah Silverman has to win, and then the dominoes start falling in your favor.
18:11 Speaker 03 But it is also, here's one more factor which I think is interesting. I believe that us doing this deal and the Wall Street Journal doing their deal helps the Times because it shows that there is a market for this stuff. There's a criticism, like, why is there not this collective action, right? And the reasons why there isn't collective action are hard, including antitrust law, which means that I can't, like, talk to Bankoff and negotiate with him.
18:32 Speaker 02 Bankoff is the CEO of Vox Media.
18:33 Speaker 03 Right. So Jim and I can't talk and, like, negotiate together and get better terms for both of us. There's another collective action problem where if you join a group, a consortium, the money presumably is spread based on the word contribution. But some people, like the Times, presumably think that their brand value and their words are more valuable on a per-word basis. At the top of the food chain, they have an incentive not to join a consortium. So you have a whole bunch of reasons why you can't do collective bargaining together as an industry to get better terms, right? Which would probably be better all overall for media. While that is true, one of the ways that we can help the industry is by making deals and setting a market. So that then, I believe that us doing a deal with OpenAI makes it easier for us to make deals with the other large
19:17 Speaker 03 language model companies, if those come about. I think it makes it easier for other journalistic companies to make deals with OpenAI and others. And I think it makes it more likely that the Times wins their lawsuit.
19:25 Speaker 02 The fourth factor in the fair use analysis that a court would do is the effect of the new use on the market for the old work.
19:33 Speaker 03 Correct.
19:33 Speaker 02 And you're saying, well, you have to have a market. You have to set some prices for this kind of use.
19:38 Speaker 03 And we are setting the market.
19:39 Speaker 02 And you think, and you think that that over time will strategically help the Times?
19:42 Speaker 03 I mean, look, the Times case is going to depend on a thousand things that are more important. But I do think that as a general principle, setting a market and getting a fair exchange of value is good precedent for our industry.
19:57 Speaker 02 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
20:08 Speaker 01 This episode is brought to you by Subaru. You know that place your mind always wanders to? The lake, the mountains, the homes of the people you love most? The completely redesigned 2026 Subaru Outback is built to help you get there. With legendary capabilities, standard symmetrical all wheel drive, and the confidence to go further. The 2026 Subaru Outback. Love never looked so good. Visit Subaru.com slash Outback to learn more.
20:34 Speaker 04 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
20:43 Speaker 05 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
20:51 Speaker 04 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com slash campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
21:05 Speaker 06 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration blog, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
21:34 Speaker 02 Welcome back. I'm talking with Nick Thompson, CEO of The Atlantic, about why he signed a licensing deal with OpenAI. He's just explained why it makes a lot of financial sense to ask for compensation and insists your content has value. But there's another layer of implications to taking this kind of deal. And it comes from the people who are making all of the content, who are making the work, who are writing the stories and making all the podcasts. And the thing that really strikes me about it is that The Atlantic's union is mad. The Vox Media Union, which The Verge team that I manage is in, is mad. The Union for New York Magazine, another Vox Media imprint, is mad. They've all written letters and circulated statements saying they're outraged about this. And I've been thinking a lot about that outrage and what it means. No one seems mad when a media organization licenses their content to Apple News or we publish on YouTube,
22:19 Speaker 02 even if the terms from YouTube or any of these other platforms are worse or feel even more exploitative. And I've been trying to pull this apart. And what I've kind of landed on is the copyright part of this is just an economic argument. You took our stuff, you didn't pay for it, now you gotta pay for it. You want to use it in some new way, we'll come to some agreement on some parameters, we'll pay for it. And the money on the economic side does not cure the moral problem that people see, which is partially a labor issue. This technology might displace all of us on some timeline. And partially just that, hey, you just took this stuff. And now your CTO, Mira Maroti, is running around saying, maybe some creative job shouldn't exist. Right? Like, there's a blitheness to this industry, particularly from OpenAI.
23:04 Speaker 02 And that disconnect between the economic problem that copyright law might help you solve, or the Times case might help you extract more money from, and the moral dilemma seems like it's wider than ever.
23:17 Speaker 03 Oh, I totally agree. I wrote a book on the history of the Cold War that was published in 2009. And when I learned that that was in the training set of Lama, I was like, you know, the sort of the emotional...
23:28 Speaker 02 Yeah.
23:28 Speaker 03 Or wait, so the book was pirated. And not only that, it was like chopped up into the wrong order. Like, it was like this violation, right? And so I think there's two, at least two things that are super important here. There's that, one, that feeling, right? Like, wait a second, they just took this, they didn't pay for it. And then secondly, there's this fear, which is, AI could do terrible things to our industry. Absolutely. So you have those two very emotional factors coming together, and this is a deal with an AI company. So my view, or my role as CEO, is to try to put that aside and to say, what I'm trying to optimize for is the future health of the Atlantic, the future economics of the Atlantic, the future of this industry.
24:11 Speaker 03 I'm weighing all these different factors together, and I think the deal, net-net, is very good for us in all these ways. AI is this rainstorm, right? Or it's this hurricane, and it's coming towards our industry, right? It's tempting to just go out and be like, oh, my God, there's a hurricane, it's coming, right? And I'm angry about that. But what you really want to do is, you want to, like, for the rainstorm, you want to put on a raincoat and put on an umbrella, right? If you're a farmer, you want to figure out what new crops to plant. You want to, like, prepare and deal with it. And so my job is to try to separate...
24:43 Speaker 03 The fear of what might happen and work as hard as I can for the best possible outcome. Knowing that because I have done a deal with an AI company, people will be angry because AI could be a very bad thing. And so there's this association. But regardless, I have to try to do what is best for the Atlantic and for the industry.
24:57 Speaker 02 All right. That was the CEO answer.
24:59 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:59 Speaker 02 There's a reason I introduced you as the former editor and chief of Wired because I want that answer too, which is you ran a industry leading publication during the social media era. A lot of what I've heard from people who wish to regulate AI or slow it down or anything is we failed to learn anything from the social media era. We failed to learn how to regulate these companies. We failed to learn how to hold them in check. We all certainly failed to learn how to get paid for how much they use our content. Facebook made a bunch of money distributing our content and media companies made none. YouTube, I think, still doesn't pay high enough rates to support a news organization on YouTube. And it's just a moral failure on YouTube's part. From that perspective, as you watch
25:40 Speaker 02 the social media era unfold, what mistakes from that era are you trying to avoid making? Because the idea that the tech companies are just the weather is like very tempting. They're just going to do this and we can't stop. The social media is just going to happen to us. And it did. But I think a lot of people are looking back on that and saying, boy, did we make a bunch of assumptions about their motivations or how people would communicate using these tools. It turned out to be utterly wrong and we should have actually stopped it earlier or changed it earlier.
26:08 Speaker 03 Answering as a CEO, that is what we were trying to do. We are trying to figure out a way that these tools evolve in such a way that they are best for us. Maybe it's just the weather is the wrong example because we do have some control in the very early stages in making these things better. Just like if there had been a way early in Facebook to shift the way that News Feed worked so that established brands weren't given the same weight as non-established brands. Like one of the sort of, there were like 20 fundamental sins at the beginning of News Feed, which ended up being hugely damaging to both journalism and like American democracy. But one of the tweaks would have been, can you sort of change the weight in the way the design and the way the fonts work or whatever so that somebody
26:49 Speaker 03 in Macedonia can't start a publication called The Verge with another Z at the end that looks just like you and has the exact same weight. Right? I think that one of the lessons is to like pay a lot of attention, right? So the AI search products have not been built and have not been launched. As they are built and as they are launched, what are the values we want embedded in them? Like, how much text do we want them to show? How do we want the external links to work? How do we want the level of summarization? Like, those are really crucial questions to get right at the beginning. And I think we are more likely to get them right as we do these kind of deals. The other thing I'll say, though, as the former editor of Wired, like, oh, my God! Some days I wake up and I'm like, I wish I was a reporter again, right? It's like so amazing, like, the stories that, I mean, you guys are telling a lot of them,
27:30 Speaker 03 but like, the opportunity to report, because it is total madness.
27:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
27:36 Speaker 03 Right now, it's like the best story to report on in years. It's incredible. And so, you know, I can't do any of that because I'm a businessman now and I don't even talk to the editors, right? I just, I like, I don't even know, I don't even know what we're going to run in the Atlantic today. But I would love, like, I spent a lot of my time writing those stories on Facebook back when I was there and at Wired. I love that. I love, like, writing on these crazy people in this world of churn, making these massive decisions. It's so much fun.
28:04 Speaker 02 When you say it's all crazy out there, the thing that really strikes me is, I would say, even two years ago, people thought the internet sort of calcified into a series of platforms and this is what it's going to look like. And then Elon bought Twitter and then ChatGPT showed up. And now it feels like everything's breaking apart.
28:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:19 Speaker 02 And the thing that feels most like it's breaking apart to me is the assumption that the big platforms have our best interests in heart or can be trusted or trusted with our children. You see the spate of legislation that's out there that would regulate how kids use platforms. You see all the reporting that is out there about Facebook willfully ignoring some of the problems it causes with teenagers. The other side of it is a lot of the underlying assumptions about the value that is being exchanged are kind of like Google's assumptions, right? Google does image search, they get sued, they win because they're a bunch of kids. Google indexes all of our sites, but they send us traffic and we sort of agreed with that approach for a long time. They keep winning because they're innocents, or they at least hold themselves out to be
29:03 Speaker 02 innocents and they deliver a lot of value in a new way. That part feels like it has definitely changed to me, right? This assumption that it's just a bunch of kids trying to change the world. And of course, we should, like, let them skate by and ask for forgiveness, not permission. Do you think as from the business point of view that that is actually going to create opportunities to bring value back to the people who make the work? Because that's the real problem.
29:26 Speaker 03 I don't think that's changed. I think that changed in 2016 or that changed in like late 2016, early 2017, and then by Cambridge Analytica, which was 2018. I think that's when, I mean, that is all changing now. You are exactly, you are very right that that is changing.
29:40 Speaker 02 But the specific similarity that I'm drawing is not, I can't trust them because of Cambridge Analytica. I'm pointing right at perplexity is scraping a bunch of paywalled websites and showing the results, or OpenAI trained on YouTube to make Sora.
29:55 Speaker 03 Right.
29:55 Speaker 02 Or Suno, the company, the R A double A just is making music trained up. And the the underlying piece of it is, well, it's just out, like, it's just ours to take and we'll pay you some money to cure it at the end. And that's just the cost of doing business.
30:07 Speaker 03 Right. So this is so at stake and it's at stake today, this very moment while we're doing this, and it's at stake in the case of perplexity, I think. Right? So Google got away with stuff because, hey, we're like cool kids and we're wearing like five fingered lizard shoes to meetings with senators and it's all cool. And they get away for a while and then eventually regulations catch up. They have to balance. It's complicated. You know, the dynamic changes. Facebook, the dynamic changes after the election of Trump and then even more so with Cambridge Analytica. Uber comes along and has a totally different strategy, which is we're going to get away by like just ignoring everything and then making so much money that we're huge and then we'll follow along. Right? Which is a very different, a different approach. I think that perplexity is trying to decide, are we going to be Uber? And we're just going to ignore robots.txt, right? You've read all these stories.
30:51 Speaker 03 Or are we going to try to do kind of the Google thing and just be like, we're, we're an AI company. We're interesting. We're going to get big and see what happens. Or are we going to change and like cooperate with the publishers? And I think that is at stake right now. And my sense is that there are probably ways that we as an industry can push perplexity into that third path that I'm talking about, where they are a responsible player that doesn't do 900 word summaries of a 900 one word story. Right? And that actually does sort of a fair use summary and a proper link out. Right? Will that happen? If that happens, that is so much better for us than if it does not. And so what is the role that I can play in making that happen? What is the role that you can play in making that happen? And that is very important for the future of media.
31:35 Speaker 03 And I think it's particularly important because I think the biggest thing happening to media right now are the most. When you talked about this in the amazing conversation with Ezra Klein, you guys talked about the insidification of the web. That is the thing that is most at stake right now, right? AI content right now is bad. What if AI content becomes good? What if the web, it becomes sort of indistinguishable and you can't find yourself around? How do you navigate through that, right? And building search engines that are still able to direct you to legitimate, real content, not the billions of spinoffs? That is like the, one of the most existential problems that exist. And if that problem is not solved, we're in a world of hurt. So that's the thing that is happening right now that I am most worried, intrigued, interested
32:20 Speaker 03 in for the next couple of years.
32:22 Speaker 02 Well, because Google's entire business model depends on
32:24 Speaker 03 Right, okay.
32:24 Speaker 02 crawling the open web, right? I mean, like, if that, the thing you're talking about breaking is Google search broadly. If the web becomes so insidified that Google cannot sort the wheat from the chaff, that version of the web comes to an end. And maybe we've all paid enough attention to perplexity and they have a deal or OpenAI's search product has better sources from the Atlantic and whoever else. And that will become the winner because people seek out quality. It's a big bet, but it kind of relies on the web becoming so polluted that Google can't sort it out.
32:55 Speaker 03 When I think about what is the Atlantic's future, right? So you have to decide, okay, what happens if the web becomes super polluted? Okay, if it does become super polluted, will Google, Perplexity, OpenAI, whatever the next Bing, whatever search startup there is?
33:07 Speaker 02 Dear sweet Bing.
33:09 Speaker 03 Though, will they be able to navigate it? Okay, if they don't, how then do we have a successful business model? Do you rely only on direct? Like, basically if the web is gone as a distribution mechanism for the Atlantic, how do we reach readers? Well, thank God we have a print magazine, right? Like, it's kind of the most hilarious thing, like the revenge of print, right? There's print, but there's also, of course, there's your apps. There's direct relationships you have with people in your newsletters. And then the interesting question is, what about the Wall Gardens? What about Apple News? What about all the, do they become more important? If the web becomes so polluted, you can't really have a functional website there, do you rely more on those places? Now, my hope is that the web doesn't get so polluted, right? And I think one of the key tasks of the tech industry and everybody else is to try to make sure it doesn't get that way. But who knows, right?
33:54 Speaker 03 The finances incentivizing pollution are high. Maybe it gets so polluted that the polluters no longer have an incentive to be out there? Who knows what's going to happen? Anyway, figuring out a strategy for a world of maximum pollution is a fun part of my job.
34:08 Speaker 02 I have this concept that I call Google Zero, which is the notion that basically every publisher is 30% of traffic comes from Google, give or take. Over time, that number is going down, or it's moving in the ecosystem away from some publishers and more towards other publishers. And so eventually you have to just look in the mirror and say, okay, if my Google traffic goes to zero, what am I?
34:27 Speaker 03 Right.
34:27 Speaker 02 Is there still a business here? What does the Atlantic's business look like if Google goes to zero?
34:31 Speaker 03 We're fine, I think. I mean, we have a very strong subscription business and those people renew. And so you can imagine a situation where our subscription business becomes a higher percentage of revenue, which is already the majority of our revenue. It becomes just a higher part and we are figuring out like, some of those people find us from Google, right? The question is, in your Google Zero, like as long as there's still a few thousand queries a month that are subscribed to the Atlantic, like we can lose the like, what is the meaning of life queries?
34:57 Speaker 02 Oh, I see. Right, Super Bowl queries are gone.
35:00 Speaker 03 Super Bowl queries are gone.
35:00 Speaker 02 But as long as people are Googling, how do I subscribe to the Atlantic? And then subscribing to Atlantic, that's fine.
35:04 Speaker 03 So as long as it's Google One, not Google Zero, we're in a decent spot, right? So.
35:10 Speaker 02 Do you sort your Google queries right now based on the value of like, which queries convert and which queries don't?
35:15 Speaker 03 No, but we have a, we go into Google Search Console and like, the top 10 queries are the Atlantic, Atlantic, subscribe. And that subscribe is not in there, but like, people who are searching for the Atlantic probably have a high subscription intent.
35:26 Speaker 02 Sure.
35:27 Speaker 03 So we actually, when we, when ChatGPT came out, we did a fun analysis. We went through Google Search Console and we went through each of the top 100 queries and then a random sample up to like, you know, the 100,000th query. And then analyzed, would that query go away with a perfect chatbot, right? And the, the Atlantic queries aren't going to go away. The what is the meaning of life, which actually does or used to direct you to an Atlantic article by Arthur Brooks, those queries go away, right? And so then we were like, okay, how much of our traffic will disappear? And then how much of our subscriptions will disappear? And the traffic decline is much steeper than the subscription decline. So in a world of Google One, let's call it, we take a real hit in traffic and readership. And that has knock on effects. It does have some knock on effects on our subscription business. It has knock on effects on our advertising business.
36:12 Speaker 03 It has knock on effects on the number of people who read a story, which maybe makes a journalist less likely to write, all those different things. But it's not crippling, right? We are less dependent on Google in a deep way, I think, than most publishers. But still, we're profitable, but we're not massively profitable. And a hit is a hit, so we'd have to figure that out.
36:32 Speaker 02 We've talked a lot about the web being so polluted, it might just be too polluted to operate on. Do you think there's another referer? Out there, do you think it's like OpenAI's search product might become a reliable referrer of traffic to you?
36:43 Speaker 03 That's the bet, right? There are a lot of people out there who are like, well, OpenAI is like, search doesn't work. It's like, yeah, AI search doesn't work right now. Like, it doesn't work very well. Like, AI is good for a lot of things, it's not good for search. That means that Google search traffic is not going to go away for a while, right? Once AI is good at search, that's when Google regular 10 blue link search traffic goes away. There's a hedge built into this. I do think that AI search will start to work, right? It's a, it's a hard problem because the logic of the vector model that makes the base training models is not good for search. Then you have to build another model on top of it, which is your RAG model. But your RAG model isn't just going to do a basic search, it has to do like a whole bunch of other complex things. So we're building internal Atlantic search and super complicated.
37:25 Speaker 03 Like, we do, somebody puts in a query and we do A, B, and C with AI in order to get the best results. That's us with, you know, one engineer working on this problem. Over time, the AI companies will put many engineers on this problem and they will, I think, figure out how to solve search. So when that happens, it will be a partial replacement for Google and God willing, there will be norms within the AI search industry where, again, you won't be giving a 900-word search result about a 901-word article, you will be linking out in a way that gets people to that article. So God willing, that happens. Do I think that three years from now, we will have as much search traffic from Perplexity, OpenAI, all of their competitors, as we do right now from Google? Absolutely not. But will we have some? I sure hope so.
38:11 Speaker 02 We have to take another quick break. We'll be back in a minute.
38:47 Speaker 04 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
38:56 Speaker 05 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
39:04 Speaker 04 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
39:18 Speaker 06 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
39:46 Speaker 02 Welcome back. I'm talking with Atlantic CEO Nick Thompson about what traffic and revenue even look like for a media company and how AI fits into that puzzle. If you have a paywall and that's the main revenue stream, what's the value in letting OpenAI synthesize any of your work in a search product? Is it sending you traffic? Are you guaranteed any traffic from them?
40:08 Speaker 03 We're not guaranteed traffic, but send us traffic. Every visitor who comes to the site, A, as long as they like what they see, it increases the brand value, and B, there's some chance they end up subscribing. And we don't have a hard paywall. We have a paywall with adjustable rules. Many people hit the gate, some people don't hit the gate. So some people won't hit the gate and they'll read an article and they'll see our ads, or maybe even they'll see an ad on the gated article. So there's lots of revenue we make off of every person who comes to The Atlantic.
40:34 Speaker 02 One of the things that has really struck me in conversations with various social media executives is the belief, it is a rock-solid belief, that what social media products have revealed is that people don't care about brands, they care about people, and that all media will be individuals and not brands. I don't believe them. I think that is a very self-serving approach from the social media companies because they have an infinite supply of teenage creators that they can just replace at will. But you run one of the most storied brands in media. When you hear an Adam Mosseri just post that, he posts things like that all the time. What's your reaction? Is it, this is correct? Is it, I need to just walk away from platforms like this? Or is it more mercenary? Like, we need to find some customers on Instagram
41:17 Speaker 02 and show them the brand there, but we can't depend on them?
41:20 Speaker 03 I mean, we've been through this in the last five years in our business where if brands didn't matter, and all that mattered were individuals, everybody would be on Substack, right? And that's not how the way it shook out. And the way it shook out is that there are some individuals who've made amazing brands and are on Substack. And there's some people who are at The Atlantic or at The Verge. The incentives are different for every writer, they're different for every individual, they're different for every editor. And so I think the way it's shaken out is that what social media did, and what Mosseri, you know, Mosseri has been talking about this for 15 years. He is right that social media did help individual brands. I remember the first time I heard Mosseri make this argument, I'm pretty sure he was talking about the NBA, right? And he's like, it
42:03 Speaker 03 used to be, it was the east versus the west in the All-Star, now it's team Giannis versus team LeBron, right? I think, I think that's the metaphor he used the first time I heard him talk about that. And it's true. It did make LeBron's individual brand more valuable. But LeBron still plays for the Lakers, right? Giannis still plays for the Bucks. The brands, the teams, the structures still exist in this world. I think you've seen like a little bit of a barbell, right? In our industry, in a lot of industries, where power, wealth, and influence have accumulated people at the far end, right? Like, The New York Times, and they've accumulated just, you know, individuals, right? And then it's like local news in the middle that's been crushed. I think you may see more of that in the future. And so my hope would be that The Verge and The Atlantic are on the far side of the barbell.
42:46 Speaker 02 Yeah, I mean, also my hope. I look at the far side of the barbell, and I look at The New York Times, which is undoubtedly one of the winners in all of this. They can fund the million dollars in legal fees to no result. On the back of a video game subscription service, like that is the revenue. That's what makes the product sticky is connections and Wordle and like
43:06 Speaker 03 It's remarkable.
43:07 Speaker 02 It's very smart. They were very clever. They realized that word games are going to fund the word games of the front page.
43:15 Speaker 03 Or the other way around, right? You feel better about playing Wordle because it's part of the New York Times because you associate the New York Times with the Ukraine coverage, right? I don't know exactly how the virtuous circle works, but they figured out a good way of doing it.
43:25 Speaker 02 The thing that scares me about that is that's what I hope, right? Is that that is all just one synthesis of brand value and just value values, right? But then I hear people say the content is not actually valuable. People are paying for the games. They come back every day for the games and the content is just there. And if they weren't paying for the games, they would just find the content elsewhere because it's free. And we're getting to a place where the high quality work is behind the paywall and low quality pollution is freely available to everyone else. And the information environment has been destroyed. And if you say the content isn't valuable, and I've heard so many people say the content itself is not valuable. The work is not valuable. It's the services that are valuable or the distribution that's valuable or whatever. The ad targeting is valuable.
44:09 Speaker 02 Then at some point, none of us can pay anyone, right? Like at some point, we're just saying the content isn't valuable. We might as well let teenagers read our stories on TikTok for free.
44:19 Speaker 03 Well, I have a good counterpoint to that. So there's this magazine I'm very familiar with and they've been entirely unsuccessful at launching games, products and crossword products and derivative products. And, you know, their CEO even tried to spin up an AI based social media platform, which ended up getting sold. And yet it is still making lots of money and it's still profitable. It is called the Atlantic. I mean, a hundred percent the content is valuable. The people are paying us like we're the experiment proving that the New York Times content is valuable. We have, you know, well over a million people. We just announced that they're paying us ever more money for our content, right? They're not. Paying for anything else.
44:56 Speaker 02 Do you think that that is extensible? I mean, The Atlantic is singular, is an institution in America. Do you think that's extensible to local news? Do you think this is extensible to some of these small communities or effectively news deserts where there's nothing?
45:10 Speaker 03 One of the hard things is that if you look at the brands that have been most successful with paywalls, they tend, not completely, The Information is a good counter example, they tend to be brands that have existed for a long time and have built up a lot of brand value. And so, could you create a new local newspaper and even with fantastic reporting, create a paid model for it? That is a hard problem. I have not seen great evidence that that can be done in the long run. Maybe it can be. But I have no doubt that there is really good content, can be extremely valuable. And if you create something with extreme value, you can get people to pay for it. Now, you have to run your business efficiently, and you have to be lean about it, and you have to figure out all the smart ways to get people to read it. It is definitely doable, and I 100% completely, totally, fundamentally disagree with all those people who've been saying to you that the content is not valuable. They're just wrong.
45:55 Speaker 02 All right, I want to end here. You've given me so much time. You said something to me as you were on your way to The Atlantic that has stuck with me
46:01 Speaker 03 Oh, no.
46:02 Speaker 02 ever since. I asked you why you were leaving your post as editor in chief for Wired to go be the CEO of The Atlantic. And you said this thing to me that I've never stopped thinking about. You said, "I can't wait to run the product team." You were so excited about it. It was the thing. And I, as an editor in chief, I was like, "Yep, that's it. That's why you would go. I want to run the product team. That's the thing I want." You've been there for a minute. You are making deals with another giant product organization. You're getting some credits to use OpenAI's systems. What are the products you want to build?
46:29 Speaker 03 It's funny you mention that today. Probably two hours ago, I was talking to the guy who's building internal AI search at The Atlantic. It's just a demo model, and like, who knows if it'll go out on our website if it won't go out. But the question is, how do you basically build an AI-based search engine internally to The Atlantic? And it's an amazing problem, because you could just say, "Well, just send the query out to OpenAI and search the database they have." But that's not the right way to do it. Some of the way people do search is they'll take a query, and then they'll run a next query on it to turn it into like a 500-word query, right? And then they'll take that 500-word query, and then they'll compare that to the database. Is that the way to do it? Well, that's the way to data, but okay, then how do you write the query for how you want to compare? It's an amazing problem, right?
47:12 Speaker 03 And when I was the editor, I wouldn't get to deal with that, right? Jeff Goldberg does not get to be in these conversations. Jeff Goldberg gets to decide how we're going to cover the industry, but I get to decide how we're going to run our AI search product. I love getting to help run the product and engineering team and helping hire those people. And like, one of the most fun things that I've gotten to do the last three years is we've run hundreds of experiments on how our paywall works, how our pricing works, how our checkout page works, right? Like, we're getting to run this operation as machine like a tech team, right? We get to say, well, okay, let's run this price test and let's change this color and let's have the paywall rules be A and B
47:54 Speaker 03 unless the sell-through rate crosses X and unless the subscription propensity in a particular store. Like, I just love that stuff, right? I was, you know, part of the reason I love being a writer is I'm a nerd. And the opportunity to be in those conversations, help shape those conversations, and then to see that it's working, right? That the data science team, the product team, the engineering team, the consumer team have built this thing that like, took us from losing a lot of money to making money in a short period of time. That's great. That's really fun. Now, the next evolution will be, can we at The Atlantic help build the next set of products that'll help this industry survive in the era of crazy AI? Like, maybe we can, maybe we can't. But the fact that I have an opportunity to help try to do that is, um, is great.
48:38 Speaker 03 So I stand by that. We have a great product and engineering team.
48:42 Speaker 02 I think in the social media era, a lot of media companies thought they were suppliers of content to other distribution. You're talking about owning the product, right? You want an app on the home screen next to Instagram. Do you think about that as a competitive field you're in now?
48:54 Speaker 03 You mean, like, the Atlantic app or a separate thing that we built?
48:57 Speaker 02 Just your product experience. Again, in the social media era, the BuzzFeeds of the world were like, our business is going viral better than anyone else can go viral on someone else's platform. That feels over in a million ways. And now you're saying, I'm going to build a national, I'm going to run a product team to build a product. That product is competing for attention with everything else.
49:17 Speaker 03 So as we've sort of mapped out, how does The Atlantic thrive in a world where the web goes away? Redoing your app has been one of the major initiatives that we didn't even have an Android app, right? So building an Android app, getting it to parity, right? Getting the feature sets, you could build a feature on one, on iOS and have it launch on both, figuring out what it is that the readers want. It's not the most glamorous stuff, but it's really important and really cool. And so now absolutely figuring out how to build that product and how to compete. In my ideal version, three years from now, we'll, at The Atlantic, we'll have figured out something amazing and launched it into the world that is really good for long form journalism. You know, I took one crack at this. I, through Emerson, which is the parent company of The Atlantic, I built this social media platform. I worked with, you know, my partner, Raffi Kocorian, to build a platform
50:02 Speaker 03 called Speakeasy. And the idea was to create conversations that are positive and fulfilling online. And we ended up, you know, we, you know, twists and turns of a startup and all this and that. And we ended up selling the technology into McCourt and Project Liberty, which is a good outcome. But we didn't end up, as you may have noticed, we didn't end up supplanting Twitter. But like, the opportunity to do that kind of thing is wonderful. And I hope that there's a moment to do that at The Atlantic again, whether it's something that's related to The Atlantic and its mission, whether it's something that's directly part of The Atlantic, like, that is 100% something I hope we can do in the next two, three years.
50:36 Speaker 02 All right. Well, you're gonna have to come back.
50:38 Speaker 03 Yeah.
50:38 Speaker 02 And show me that product when we launch this.
50:39 Speaker 03 Ideally, ideally, you'll see it and you'll be like, oh, that's cool. You know, it first came up when we were talking on Decoder.
50:45 Speaker 02 Yeah. I'm excited for it. Nick, thank you so much for joining the show.
50:48 Speaker 03 Thank you so much. It was great to talk with you.
50:53 Speaker 02 I'd like to thank Nick Thompson for taking the time to join Decoder, and thank you for listening. I hope you enjoyed it. If you'd like to let us know what you thought about this episode, or really, anything else, drop us a line. You can email us at decoder@theverge.com. We really do read all the emails, as many of you have discovered. You can also hit me up directly on Threads. I'm at Reckless1280. And we have a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Stat. Our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
51:33 Speaker 07 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com/MyLowe'sMoneyDays for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
52:02 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on an Apple-conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
Previous Canva CEO Melanie Perkins is happy to provide designers alternatives to Adobe Next Biden’s top tech advisor on why AI safety is a “today problem” Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated