Pod Insights Decoder The Supreme Court ruling that could kill net neutrality About this episode The Supreme Court has just taken on the entire idea of the US administrative state — and the Court is winning. Earlier this month, a conservative majority overturned a longstanding legal principle called Chevron deference. The implications are enormous for every possible kind of regulation — and net neutrality looks poised to be the first victim. Verge editor Sarah Jeong joins me to explain why.
Links:
Supreme Court overrules Chevron, kneecapping federal regulators | The Verge
What SCOTUS just did to broadband, the right to repair, the environment, and more | The Verge
FCC votes to restore net neutrality | The Verge
Reinstatement of net neutrality rules temporarily halted by appeals court | The Verge
Clarence Thomas' 38 Vacations: The Other Billionaires Who Have Treated the Supreme Court Justice to Luxury Travel | ProPublica
The Supreme Court's coming war with Joe Biden | Vox
Transcript:
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Our producers are Kate Cox and Nick Statt. Our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 7,392 words · 11 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
1:06 Speaker 02 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. I've been covering the fight over net neutrality for almost my entire career as a tech reporter, over 15 years now. The idea is that your internet provider shouldn't be able to discriminate between what services you access on the internet. AT&T shouldn't be able to slow down Twitter and speed up Threads, and Verizon shouldn't be able to block Zoom because it owns BlueJeans. It's pretty basic stuff, and after all this time, the Biden FCC has once again made it the law. The big telecom companies truly hate the idea that anyone can regulate their networks, and they've once again filed a lawsuit over it. And until very recently, everyone sort of understood what the arguments in a case like that would be and how they would go.
1:50 Speaker 02 Like I said, I've been covering this for 15 years now. It's pretty familiar. But then, everything changed. In late June, the Supreme Court issued a bombshell opinion in a case called Loperbright v. Raimondo, which overturned something called Chevron deference, the idea that courts should generally defer to agencies like the FCC when it comes to interpreting ambiguous parts of the law. That means that net neutrality lawsuit is suddenly on very different ground. Now it's about whether the court thinks the internet should be neutral or not, not the FCC. And wouldn't you know it, the Sixth Circuit immediately halted the FCC's net neutrality order and asked for briefs on how the Loperbright ruling would change the case. I invited Verge editor Sarah John on the show to talk about all this with me, and you'll hear us really
2:32 Speaker 02 get into it. For the last 40 years, judges have basically deferred to federal agencies when it comes to the details of interpreting the law, because the agencies employ experts and we expect them to have really deep knowledge in their subject areas. But now, judges will be empowered to ignore that expertise and make their own decisions. And with a dysfunctional Congress that can barely pass any laws as it is, the Supreme Court's decision in Loperbright is a major power for the judiciary over the other two branches of government. It's a very big deal, with some far-reaching consequences for basically everything in the policy world, from the environment, to labor law, to all manner of regulation. Here at The Verge, our policy team has been tracking this outcome for a very long time. So I wanted
3:14 Speaker 02 Sarah to come on the show to break down how we got here and what it means for the future. If it all sounds pretty chaotic and unstable, you're not wrong. You'll hear us discuss that towards the end. Okay, Chevron deference and the future of net neutrality. Here we go.
3:39 Speaker 02 Sarah John, welcome.
3:40 Speaker 03 Nice to be on here again.
3:42 Speaker 02 I feel like every time you and I talk, we invalidate a different part of our law school curriculum. Theoretically, the law is built on a series of precedents, and this version of the Supreme Court doesn't seem to care about that at all. And they keep throwing out these foundational precedents. The Supreme Court just threw out a huge precedent. Called Chevron deference. It's from the 80s, but it is foundational to how our government works. It's shocking, but not surprising that they threw it out. Let's start at the beginning. What is Chevron deference? Where'd it come from?
4:13 Speaker 03 So Chevron deference comes from a case Chevron v NRDC. Essentially Chevron deference is a two-step test, and it's extremely favorable to agencies. It's a very simple test, so courts usually just uphold an agency's interpretation of a statute. What you're looking at is agencies have power because of statutes that are passed by Congress, right? And they're enforcing those statutes. They're creating agency rules that elaborate on those statutes and apply those statutes to various more granular situations.
4:53 Speaker 03 The two-step Chevron test starts with, is the statute ambiguous? So if it's unambiguous and the agency has just messed it up, then the court steps in and goes, no, you did a bad job, and they go somewhere else. The second one is, so if it's ambiguous, is the agency's interpretation rational? That is generally the laugh test. Is this interpretation anywhere in the ballpark of what a thinking, reasonable human being would say? And it's like, you don't have to agree with interpretation. You just go, oh, I guess I could see how a person would think that. And then the court moves on with their lives. The idea is that an agency is best suited
5:38 Speaker 03 to deal with whatever field they've been tasked with. They have experts to consult. They've gone through this rulemaking process where they've talked to all of the stakeholders, and they've come up with a rule that they think makes sense in the situation.
5:54 Speaker 02 One thing that strikes me about the Chevron case itself, where Chevron deference came from, is that the agency in question was rolling back a rule. It was a more conservative, more pro-business move, and they were getting sued. And the court was like, no, actually, we're going to let the agencies do whatever they want. And then they created this deference to agencies, and now the conservative court is saying, no, we've gone too far. We need to actually undo that.
6:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, it starts with the Reagan EPA and an environmental group challenged their interpretation of the statute. And the court said, no, we're going to defer to the EPA because the EPA knows what they're doing. The idea was that they were going to make it extremely easy for the executive to function and not allow it to get tied up in litigation. Scalia was kind of big on this idea that judges shouldn't wade into stuff that they don't understand or like, isn't their job. Because the positioning of the federal government has changed, conservative judges now take on this idea that they should meddle in the business of the executive. They've made more of a power grab instead of abdicating power in the way that Scalia liked.
7:06 Speaker 02 There's an idea here that you can identify ambiguous language and then you can decide whether the ambiguous language has been interpreted rationally. This comes from Scalia, right? Scalia wrote the Chevron decision. He was the textualist. This is his framework. He had one approach to it, which is, can any idiot read this and figure it out? We're going to move on. And that has been reinterpreted into the notion that all words are ambiguous.
7:34 Speaker 03 It's whack as hell, right? Like, he is really annoying to read about textualism. And it was already really annoying. Like, he'd pull out the dictionaries and be like, oh, yeah, this dictionary dates to X year. Ergo, it's the meaning of the word that's being used in the statute. It's absurd stuff. And what you have now is the heirs of textualism are out there using linguistics corpuses to like nail down what words mean, quote unquote. The actual linguists are like, they're using the corpuses wrong. They don't really know what they're doing. It's applying this tool in this like really unthinking way to press forward with what is frankly, kind of a bogus legal doctrine. It's so frustrating.
8:17 Speaker 02 Chevron deference created what you might call the administrative state. We have all these agencies doing all of these things. Explain what that is and why it is suddenly so controversial.
8:30 Speaker 03 Even before Chevron deference, we had a deferential standard towards agencies. What Chevron does is that it makes that test way easier, which means that courts just sort of get out of the way of agencies. And when you think about that in terms of administrative law, you realize that this standard has existed in one shape or another ever since the birth of the admin state, which is to say, after FDR and the New Deal, and ever since we've had the agencies pop up, we've had, and increasingly now for 40 years, we've had a standard where judges are supposed to let agencies do what they do and not question what they do.
9:14 Speaker 03 It's only more recently that that's been eroded.
9:17 Speaker 02 This raises what I think is sort of an important foundational question. The argument in favor of Chevron, and the reason people think it's cataclysmic, is that it is what allows the agencies to function, right? We give them a lot of leeway because we say, okay, Congress passed a law. The agencies are going to interpret the law and do some stuff and make sure the internet is free and equal or the fisheries are clean or whatever they're going to do. And if you take that away and you tie that all up in litigation, the government grounds to a halt. But there was a time before the 80s, before Chevron. How did the government function then?
9:50 Speaker 03 We had something for a really long time called Skidmore deference, and it's thought that we've fallen back on Skidmore now that Chevron has fallen.
9:57 Speaker 02 So Skidmore is another case.
9:58 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's another case. It's older. Don't ask me what it means. Like, I pulled out my old admin law reference books to try and figure out what that could possibly mean. And all it said was, "We don't care about Skidmore anymore because we have Chevron now." So I don't know. I don't freaking know. I had my writers go and reach out and ask about Skidmore. All the attorneys would talk about, "Yeah, it seems to be that we've fallen back on Skidmore, but I don't really want to tell you that on the record because I don't know what this decision actually means." We did have a deferential standard before, but before Chevron, the door was a little more open. To litigation and the idea was that Chevron was going to shut that down. Skidmore is really old. We're talking about the 40s. So we're talking about sort of
10:43 Speaker 03 the tail end of the New Deal era. And that's when the agencies came into being like, we don't have an administrative state like we do today before that. So we're talking about the lifespan of the administrative state. We've had a deferential standard. And for the last 40 years, we've had a standard that is very, very deferential.
11:06 Speaker 02 So that's what Chevron deference is. What did the Supreme Court do to it?
11:10 Speaker 03 It blew up Chevron deference. It overturned itself and we don't know what the rule is anymore.
11:16 Speaker 02 So the case that overturned Chevron is called Loper Bright Enterprises versus Raimondo, who's the Secretary of Commerce. What is this case about?
11:25 Speaker 03 The case is about fishing boats. Essentially, there was an agency rule that affected their boats. And they thought that this rule sucked. They didn't like it and they sued over it. At every stage of the litigation, the courts go Chevron deference. Your case has no value. We don't care. Maybe you have a point, but the agency made this rule and the agency in this case was the National Marine Fisheries Service, which is just an agency that I could not care even like less about. Right? So you get Chevron tossed and goes to Supreme Court and the Supreme Court goes, all right, we're going to take this case. And as soon as they said, we're going to take this case, everyone knew the writing was on the wall that the Supreme Court wanted
12:10 Speaker 03 to overturn Chevron. Why else would you take this case?
12:14 Speaker 02 I feel like everything I learned in law school is getting thrown out the window. You usually have a split in the circuits deciding differently and you got to resolve it. But this is deeply settled. Like Chevron is 40 years old. They took it because they wanted to. That's what you're saying. Like, there's only one reason inside of the usual framework for why the Supreme Court takes cases.
12:32 Speaker 03 They overruled Roe last year, which was even more settled. Right? Like, it's even, it's a much older case. It was way more settled and they overruled Roe. So why not overrule Chevron, which is a younger case? Why not? I think that that was the dominoes falling there. We've determined this is the period of time in which it is okay for us to overturn precedent. So why not do Chevron next?
13:02 Speaker 02 The ruling in Loper is we've overturned Chevron. We're sending this back down to the courts for you to determine if this fishing vessel has to pay this fee under the agency's interpretation. And the fee is like $710 a day, like it's nothing.
13:16 Speaker 03 I think that's what's so wild about the Chevron cases, right? Like Chevron is about a bunch of stuff that normal people simply do not care about, that should not affect our lives, that we should not think about. Frankly, most judges should not have to think about. And the fact that this fisheries case has suddenly like had this like blast effect, just to EMP going off across like the entire country. That's weird. That's super weird.
13:44 Speaker 02 We knew this case was coming. We knew that this was the likely outcome. You and the rest of our policy team started pre-reporting all of the ramifications of Chevron deference going away. There are environmental implications at the EPA, consumer protection, labor law, campaign finance. We're going to talk about neutrality in detail here. Basically, every agency of the government is affected by Chevron deference going away. What are the big fears?
14:05 Speaker 03 I think the really big fear is probably net neutrality. Like net neutrality relies on a Chevron deference case. On the environmental side and the consumer protection side, so we're talking EPA and FTC, there's a little bit less fear because their authority has been chipped away a lot over recent years. On the labor side, you have like workplace safety. Like if OSHA promulgates rules, how safe can workers be? It really cannot be emphasized enough how far reaching the influence of Chevron is.
14:36 Speaker 02 Do you think that the agencies will get more buttoned up in how they issue these rules if they know they're always going to face a court challenge?
14:44 Speaker 03 They already are. Like the EPA has been doing that. The sort of sad thing about it is that when an agency gets the hammer dropped on it a little too often, they just get kind of skittish about doing brave things. Whenever you think like, why isn't the government doing something about this? The answer is probably that the agency in charge has been disempowered in some way. Even before Chevron fell, these agencies were getting chipped away.
15:11 Speaker 02 We need to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
15:24 Speaker 01 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the say.
15:55 Speaker 04 When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed sponsored jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications, and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. That's indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
16:24 Speaker 05 Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.
16:29 Speaker 06 Botox, onabotulinum toxin A, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It prevents on average eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo.
16:42 Speaker 07 Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away. As difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS, Lou Gehrig's disease, myasthenia gravis, or Lambert-Eaton syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
17:18 Speaker 05 Why wait? Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
17:28 Speaker 02 Welcome back. I'm talking to The Verge editor Sarah Jeong about what the Supreme Court did with its ruling that unwound Chevron deference and what that means for some really key pieces of regulation like net neutrality. Net neutrality is a really simple idea. Your internet provider should not be able to pick and choose which content gets more priority. Your carrier shouldn't be able to accept money from Amazon to make Prime Video stream faster than Netflix. And you certainly don't want internet companies blocking access to websites entirely, which would create all kinds of censorship concerns. The FCC has been trying to get this done for basically the entire 21st century, and there have been a lot of arguments along the way. But the simplest and most important part of the net neutrality fight is a pair of definitions. The Telecommunications Act
18:10 Speaker 02 of 1996 has two sections called Title I and Title II. Title I loosely regulates "information services," where access to a network and the content on it are the same thing. Remember, this law was passed in 1996, so think old-school AOL, where you dialed into AOL servers to access AOL's content. That's an information service. Title II, on the other hand, regulates something called "telecommunication services," which are utilities, like old-school phone service, that are much more tightly regulated to keep them fair. So just close your eyes and think about it for a second. Is the internet service you pay for more like dial-up AOL or more like utility?
18:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's ridiculous that we've been arguing about this for so long. Anyhow, during President Obama's first term in 2010, the FCC classified the internet as a Title I information service and implemented a relatively industry-friendly net neutrality rule. The telecoms hate rules and Verizon sued. And in early 2014, a federal court ruled in Verizon's favor and sent the FCC back to the drawing board. So in 2015, during Obama's second term, the FCC reclassified the internet as a Title II telecommunications service and adopted a new net neutrality rule. The telecoms, of course, immediately sued again, but this time, the FCC won. But that victory was extremely short-lived. By early 2017, the Trump administration was in
19:36 Speaker 02 charge and new FCC chairman Ajit Pai immediately killed net neutrality yet again. And you can see where this is going. The Obama administration passes net neutrality, the Trump administration kills it, and the Biden administration tries to bring it back. The FCC actually passed a rule to restore net neutrality back in April. But as we've seen, it's never that simple. Just a couple of weeks ago, a federal appeals court, the Sixth Circuit, put the rule on short term hold while it tries to sort out if it needs to go on permanent hold. And that brings us back to Chevron. Why the presumption that net neutrality is doomed now that Chevron is gone?
20:12 Speaker 03 The Sixth Circuit has said, all right, we're going to put a freeze on the net neutrality rules while this case is pending. And meanwhile, parties, please brief us on what the fall of Chevron has done to this case. We're sort of seeing this thing where like, I mean, like, why would the Sixth Circuit ask for briefings on this thing? Why would they pick up the case? Why would they ask for briefings on this thing? Why would they freeze the net neutrality rules if they didn't want to chuck net neutrality out of the window? Right? Like, they could just not take the case. But they're taking it. That's sort of the assumption here. If it goes up to the Supreme Court, because the Supreme
20:54 Speaker 03 Court is aligned to the way that it is, right? Like, every time we have a Republican majority FCC, they're going to vote against net neutrality. Right now, we have 3-2 in favor of the Democratic commissioners. The two Republican commissioners voted against net neutrality. We have a Supreme Court that has a super majority of conservative justices. Of course, net neutrality is going to go away. I think that's what the assumption here is.
21:22 Speaker 02 That is very funny to me, only because those same six conservative justices on the Supreme Court are very worried about social networks censoring what Americans say on the internet. And all of net neutrality is your ISP should not be able to pick and choose winners and losers. Like, there's about to be a, it feels like an ideological car crash. If that actually hits the Supreme Court. Because it's very weird to say that the applications on the internet should not be able to censor anything, but the actual pipes should.
21:50 Speaker 03 It speaks to the politicization of the circuits too, right? Like, for a very long time, it's been known that the Supreme Court loves beating on the Ninth Circuit, and the Ninth Circuit leans more liberal than the rest of the circuits. Sixth Circuit is a conservative circuit. The judiciary is very politicized. They're not supposed to be politicized, but it's like, everyone knows this, and it's just this bizarre thing that's happened.
22:12 Speaker 02 But the other absolutely bizarre just coincidence here is that Clarence Thomas wrote the Brandeis decision in 2005. Clarence Thomas is out there, just in every other dissent, saying Facebook should be a common carrier, and like, shouldn't regulate anything. And you just get to this just weird, wacky, backwards place, where you're gonna roll up to the guy who wrote Brandeis, saying Chevron deference should be applied, the Ninth Circuit got it wrong, and the FCC should be allowed to let internet service providers discriminate traffic on their networks. In 2024, when he's like, no one should discriminate anything on any platform, and then ask him to say the Ninth Circuit was right? I, I, like, the mechanics of this are just bananas to me.
22:54 Speaker 03 I'm sure that if they weren't applying Chevron to the Ninth Circuit, they would have found some other reason to say that the Ninth Circuit was wrong. Like, the assumption here is that you're going to see conservative judges cherry picking what they think deserves deference versus not deference, because now that's kind of more of a loosey-goosey standard. Like, yeah, you can cherry pick. You can sort of go, yeah, you know what? I don't think this makes that much sense. Let's dig into this a little more. Versus, you go, I think this makes enough sense. I think this meets whatever standard it is that we've had after the fall of Chevron. You sort of see how that operates, where you have seen conservative jurisdictions freezing Biden administration rules left and right.
23:39 Speaker 02 When I said earlier that the Loper-Bright ruling was shocking, but not surprising, this is kind of what I meant. You hang out in DC and talk to a bunch of federal lawyers. They'll tell you that in many ways, they've already been treating Chevron as functionally dead for a long time. And they've been structuring their arguments in court using other principles. But that's not necessarily easy. If judges aren't going to defer to an agency's expert knowledge on the facts of a case, it takes a lot of the tools out of that agency's toolbox. And it means a lot more rulings about complicated, maybe even arcane bits of law and procedure. So when we sit down now to try to talk about something like net neutrality that seems like it should be straightforward, we actually just end up talking about the judiciary getting more political. Because if the Sixth Circuit examines the evidence on its own and makes its not so
24:24 Speaker 02 expert determination about how the internet works, the FCC would appeal that back to the Supreme Court. And it's pretty clear, based on a 6-3 conservative court, how that appeal would go. People saw this coming, that you would predict court rulings based on the political leanings of the judges in the buildup to getting rid of Chevron. You also see it in the dissent to the Loper Bright ruling from the liberal justices. Here's Judge Alana Kagan in the dissent. Quote, "It is impossible to pretend that today's decision is a one-off in either its treatment of agencies or its treatment of precedent." She goes on to say that Chevron is as embedded as embedded gets in the law. The majority says differently, because this court has ignored Chevron lately. She then straight up calls out the majority and what it's doing.
25:08 Speaker 02 Here's a quote, "The majority's argument is a bootstrap. The court has avoided deferring under Chevron since 2016 because it has been preparing to overrule Chevron since about that time. That kind of self-help on the way to reversing precedent has become almost routine at this court. Stop applying a decision where one should, throw some gratuitous criticism into a couple of opinions, issue a few separate writings, give the whole process a few years, and voila, you have a justification for overruling the decision." End quote. So where is this kind of circular logic going to take us? We'll discuss it after the break. We'll be right back.
25:49 Speaker 01 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the say.
26:20 Speaker 04 When you need to build up your team to handle the growing chaos at work, use Indeed sponsored jobs. It gives your job post the boost it needs to be seen and helps reach people with the right skills, certifications and more. Spend less time searching and more time actually interviewing candidates who check all your boxes. Listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com/podcast. That's indeed.com/podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Need a hiring hero? This is a job for Indeed sponsored jobs.
26:49 Speaker 05 Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.
26:54 Speaker 06 Botox, onabotulinum toxin A, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It prevents on average eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo.
27:07 Speaker 07 Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away. As difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS-LuGerg's Disease, myasthenia gravis or Lambert-Eaton Syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
27:44 Speaker 05 Why wait? Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
27:53 Speaker 02 Welcome back. I'm talking to The Verge editor Sarah Jeong about what overturning Chevron is going to mean for big regulations like net neutrality that get batted around in the political winds. I feel like most people who are listening to us talk about administrative law net neutrality might expect in 2024 for us to immediately talk about how the Supreme Court is doing a power grab over the legislature. But that is surprising in the structure of our government, right? Like, that's not the outcome that's supposed to happen. Is that just a judicial construct? Is that John Roberts and the conservative court finding an opening to take this power? Is that something there's a check and balance against? Is that just a pendulum swing? How should people evaluate that?
28:32 Speaker 03 Did you get this thing in law school where you get the sort of very existentialist evaluation of the judicial system? Did you get that? I got that in law school. We did this navel gazing thing where you went, "Our entire legal system is based on a power grab." That's Marbury versus Madison.
28:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, sure. Okay, we all did that. That's like, that's the first day of law school.
28:55 Speaker 03 And then you just sort of, you stare at your navel and you go, "So, we literally made this all up. We're the ones who made up the power and no one else, like, no one conceived of the Supreme Court actually having the power to set precedent and overturn statutes and overrule the other branches of government. And there was just a crass power grab and we've built an entire system around this power grab." We looked at that and we just had a spiraling moment because it was like, it was not necessarily a good thing. We visited older Supreme Court decisions and they were like, "Was this justified? Did the Supreme Court, like, actually have the power to do that?" And then we'd start spiraling again. We're like, "Oh, my God, they just made shit up!" And like, and you
29:40 Speaker 03 just start, you realize that there's been a power creep over the... Centuries and then you like try to justify that in your head and find some way to like calm yourself down so you can move on with your life and have a career after law school without losing your mind. How did we get here? I don't know. Is it inevitable? Is there something special about these justices or this judicial makeup or the conservative legal movement? Or is this simply a progression of the judicial power creep that has happened over history? I don't know. I'm not a constitutional law scholar. I don't have special insight into these people. Maybe this was inevitable. Maybe it's not. Kagan certainly doesn't think it's inevitable. She seems to think that it's highly irrational and that doesn't make any
30:23 Speaker 03 sense and that the Supreme Court is doing some whack shit.
30:27 Speaker 02 There's a part of me that finds it hard to get worked up about a precedent passed when I was four years old, under the Reagan administration, that in its effect at the time was to let the EPA allow people to pollute more. And it's like, have we built our entire country or our entire functional government on that idea? That's weird. That's the weird first brick to build the functioning of the administrative state on. And then there's a part of me that's like, well, that's just how it goes. You gotta, you have to move on. You have to operate the system. And the federal government right now, the way it operates is that we let Congress be a clown show. We elect a president and we assume the president
31:11 Speaker 02 is the king, more so than ever. And then the president is to do a bunch of stuff and that is affected through the agencies, which we grant wide deference to, because that is actually the only way anything gets done. And maybe that should change. Maybe the outcome here is that Congress should legislate with more intention and clarity. And I'm just not sure if that will, like, they're gonna react to that this way.
31:31 Speaker 03 Oh, it's not gonna happen. You're right that this is not necessarily, this is not how the founders, quote unquote, intended the Constitution to work. It's not how a rational human being would look at the US Constitution and go, if I wanted to patch the US Constitution to have a working democracy, they would not patch it to make the admin state stronger. What we have right now is the admin state exists because Congress is so dysfunctional. The admin state has been strengthened because Congress is so dysfunctional. It's been weakened because you have certain interests who want to curb the power of the admin state for political reasons. This idea of Making an admin state accountable by throwing like judges who are there for
32:16 Speaker 03 life at them, that's a stupid idea. That is nonsense. But yeah, like you have these power grabs and these weird contortions around the government because the legislature is so dysfunctional. And it's dysfunctional for so many reasons. We can't even get into why it's dysfunctional. We shouldn't do that on this podcast. Like, also, people kind of all know, right?
32:41 Speaker 02 Decoder has an audience of business people, people who want to be business people. If you're trying to build a business, you're kind of looking for some amount of stability, right? You want some things to be stable. And the administrative state, for whatever its flaws, was at least predictable, right? You're, for the most part, dealing with subject matter experts. They're mostly hamstrung by miserable bureaucracy. You can pay a bunch of lobbyists to get what you want out of most of these agencies. Fine. The courts, in particular, the Supreme Court, is anything but predictable. Pure coin flips, all the way down, especially at the Supreme Court level, with this composition of the Supreme Court right now. For example, just this Supreme Court, the highly conservative Supreme Court,
33:24 Speaker 02 while gutting Chevron, ruled that the Consumer Financial Production Bureau gets to keep existing. You would just not predict that set of outcomes. Clarence Thomas continues to exist. And I don't know what he is going to do at any given moment. If you're a business person, and you're looking at Chevron going away, and the administrative state being beset by lawsuits, and a dysfunctional Congress, where do you find the stability? Is there any stability left?
33:50 Speaker 03 Yikes. Um, I mean, if I were a business person, and I had infinite money, I would just, I would start putting together more yacht vacations for Clarence Thomas. If you're a business person who does not have infinite money, you're screwed. You don't know what agency rules are going to stand and which aren't. You don't have that stability. Even if an agency rule isn't favorable to you, There's something valuable in knowing that that's not going to change for another four years or whatever. There is that stability that's really just useful to have in the background, whether or not a rule is favorable to you. And now you just like left sort of weirdly reading the tea leaves. You talk a little bit about the Supreme Court being
34:35 Speaker 03 a coin flip. There is the coin flip aspect, but there's almost like a worse thing going on where you have lawyers who are like out there trying to divine from oracle bones, like how any composition on a three judge panel in a certain circuit is going to rule based on how they know the personalities of the judges are, right? You get to other lawyers who do appellate practice, or even worse, Supreme Court practice. A lot of it is them figuring things out based on a judge's personality, and they know that because they know a guy, or because they clerked for this judge, or like their friend clerked for that judge. And it's so insular. And I think that it's presented to those lawyers
35:17 Speaker 03 as this beautiful thing about their profession, right? But anyone on the outside who isn't a part of this tradition or whatever, sees it as corruption. I think I've been away from law long enough that I'm on the side of that's corruption. You've made that inaccessible to the people in a way that sucks.
35:38 Speaker 02 One of the things that comes up on Decoder over and over again is the idea that the law is not deterministic. We do have an audience full of product managers and engineers and business people who think it's a system where some set of inputs leads inexorably to some set of predictable outputs. And I've never really made the connection to, well, if you make it not deterministic, if you describe it as it is, you get very close to corruption very fast, right? The judge is having a bad day, but they got an RV from a buddy, so that the ruling's going to go against you. But that's like the heart of it. Like, it's always been that way because it is just a bunch of people making decisions. Are you saying you think Chevron is going to make those decisions even less predictable in a way that edges towards corruption?
36:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. That is the main problem with Chevron. Because you made things less easy to determine, you have sort of the what did the judge eat for breakfast? You're getting closer to that sort of place.
36:36 Speaker 02 There's a lot in the tech world right now that feels like it's headed towards the courts. Copyright and AI, you and I have talked about on the show, but just a coin flip, that a bunch of courts are going to have to make it as a bunch of decisions. A bunch of the crypto bros are openly supporting Trump now. All of those regulations are going to head towards the court. Even if Trump wins and his SEC decides not to regulate crypto in any way, they will get sued because they have to make the affirmative rule that they're not going to regulate. And that's a lawsuit. So all this stuff is going to head back towards the courts in a world without Chevron. Do you think all these lower courts are going to say, look at this lot of garbage. We actually need something else like Chevron, which is more or less how you got there in the first place. Right? You swing the pendulum one way
37:20 Speaker 02 and you're like, well, here's a rule to make it simple. And then you swing it all the other way. You're like, oh, we made this complicated and messy and I fear it has to work a little too hard. Can we get a rule back? That'll take some time. But do you see that pendulum just swinging back?
37:31 Speaker 03 I think what's going to happen is that because you have so much of a loosey goosey role, like what you're going to do is be like, the standard that is higher than Chevron, when you get a case that you don't want to deal with, you go, yeah, I don't want to deal with this. It meets the standard. Let's get out of here. Get out of my court. Get out of my court. I'm done. I ate this thing for breakfast and I don't want to deal with this. And then you get a different case and you go, oh, I saw this on Fox News. I definitely want to take this case. Right? Like, it's and then they take it. I think that you're just getting more of a choice to intervene. And I think that's the part that's pretty scary.
38:10 Speaker 02 What do you think happens next here? Is there something you're looking for, a case you're looking at that will help us understand how courts will interpret the Loper Bright rule?
38:20 Speaker 03 It does seem like net neutrality is going to be the first Chevron victim. That one, I think, is moving fastest, at least that I know of. I'm sure there's other smaller cases that are probably getting processed, but I don't know what the timeline is on that. The thing about the net neutrality case is that it is a politicized issue. It shouldn't be. Like, why should telecom law ever be politicized? It is so boring. The fact that it's a political issue blows my mind. Because it's a politicized issue, I think that we're going to see what happens. Because it doesn't seem like the fall of Chevron is a politicization of the law. But frankly, it is. Like, that's how it's going to shake out.
39:05 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Sarah Jeong for joining me on Decoder. I gotta say, I didn't think we would enjoy doing this episode. We had fun. I hope you enjoyed it, too. If you have thoughts about this episode or what you'd like to hear more of, you can email us at decoder@theverge.com. We really do read all the emails. You can also hit me up directly on Threads on MattReckless1280. And we have a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really love the show, hit us with a five-star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Our producers are Kate Cox, Nick Statt, and our editor is Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
39:46 Speaker 08 Looking for a simple way to thank your clients or recognize employees for a job well done? A Starbucks card is more than a gift. It's a pick-me-up, a break in their day, and a reminder that you appreciate them. Whether you're shopping for digital or physical cards in bulk, Starbucks cards are the perfect gift to brighten anyone's day. Share the joy of coffee and connection when you give the gift of Starbucks. Shop Starbucks cards in bulk now at starbuckscardb2b.com.
40:13 Speaker 09 Mr. Monopoly here. Miss me? Monopoly is back at McDonald's with millions of prizes, a 2027 Jeep Cherokee, a Carnival Cruise vacation, gift cards from Tordash, and Best Buy. Fuel and play in the McDonald's app. Get your bag.
40:31 Speaker 10 No purchase necessary. 50 U.S. and D.C. age 18-plus. See playatmcd.com for rules and playatmcd.com/amoe for info and playing without purchase by mail by November 2nd. Chess card game ends November 8th. Game ends November 22, 2026. See rules for prize details. Monopoly is a registered trademark of Hasbro.
Previous Rivian CEO RJ Scaringe says too many carmakers are copying Tesla Next Logitech CEO Hanneke Faber wants your next mouse to last forever Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated