Pod Insights Decoder The rise and fall of Vice Media About this episode Today we’re talking about Vice, the media company: Where it came from, what it did, and, ultimately, why it collapsed into a much smaller, sadder version of itself.
This is a lousy time for digital media, and it’s hard to make a profit from putting words on the internet right now. So when Verge senior reporter Liz Lopatto went to go report on what happened, she and I both assumed Vice had been done in by the brutal economics of digital advertising on the web. But the Vice story is more than that — in the word of one executive that talked to Liz, it was a “fucking clown show.”
Links:
How Vice became 'a fucking clown show' — The Verge
Vice is abandoning Vice.com and laying off hundreds — The Verge
Vice, decayed digital colossus, files for bankruptcy — NYT
Vice Is Basically Dead — New York Magazine
Shane Smith and the Final Collapse of Vice News — The Hollywood Reporter
At Vice, cutting-edge media and allegations of old-school sexual harassment — NYT
HBO cancels ‘Vice News Tonight,’ severing relationship with Vice Media — CNN
Shane Smith has a secret multimillion-dollar Vice deal — New York Magazine
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 8,265 words · 11 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:34 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neil Anpatel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, we're going to talk about Vice, the media company, where it came from, what it did, and ultimately, why it recently collapsed into a much smaller, sadder version of itself. Vice is not a new company. It started in the 90s, but it grew into something massive with grand ambitions, enormous cultural influence, and a ludicrous amount of money behind it. The promise was that Vice could turn big investments into bigger profits and become a media behemoth for a new generation of internet natives. None of that happened. After a few very rocky years, Vice declared bankruptcy in 2023.
1:48 Speaker 03 And earlier this year, as part of the post-bankruptcy restructuring, the company abruptly shut down its Pulitzer-winning news division, laid off hundreds of people, and said it would stop publishing to its website entirely. Instead, Vice will become a production company focused on selling video to social platforms and other kinds of distributors. Now, this is a pretty lousy time for digital media. There are layoffs going on everywhere because it's hard to make a profit from putting words on the web right now. So when Verge senior reporter Liz Lepata went to go report on what had happened to Vice, she and I both assumed that the company had been undone by the brutal economics of digital advertising on the web. But the Vice story is much more than that. In the words of one executive that talked to Liz for her story, "It was a fucking clown
2:32 Speaker 03 show." It turns out that you really can fake it till you make it, all the way up to a $5.7 billion valuation in the case of Vice. But at some point, you have to start running a real company. And Vice just never did that.
2:49 Speaker 04 There's always this feeling you get when you've started reporting a story and it's not at all the story you think it is, where you're just like, "Oh, okay. I guess I'd better report the story that this actually is." I thought, "Oh, okay, this is a story about cookies on the internet. This is a story about advertising. This is a story about like how we built stuff that isn't sustainable." And it is a story about building stuff that isn't sustainable, but it is not a story about cookies and advertising, or at least not mostly a story about cookies and advertising.
3:20 Speaker 03 We built a lot of institutions a while ago on the internet. You might call them millennial media institutions. Pitchfork is one of those. BuzzFeed, notably, another one, maybe V1. Vice is definitely one of those, although it's a bit older than all the rest. To be fair, Vox Media and The Verge are one of those things. And I keep joking that we're the last website on earth, because it's not a great time in media on the internet right now. All the other ones are going away, including Vice News, including BuzzFeed News, including Pitchfork. Like, down the line, they're all going away. It feels tempting to say it's all for the same reasons. And that might be true in the case of Vice. But I think what you uncovered is that Vice, as a business, the phrase you used was "hall
4:05 Speaker 03 of mirrors" when you were describing the story to me. Like, no one actually knew what the business of Vice was.
4:11 Speaker 04 I heard a lot of theories about what the business of Vice was. And I have, like, watched a lot of videos of Shane Smith describing the business of Vice. I still don't have a super good handle on what was going on there. Why don't we back up and start at the very beginning? Vice began in Canada in the 90s.
4:32 Speaker 04 In this sense, it is a Gen X institution. This sort of, I guess punk zine is the best way of putting it. And there are sort of some early key players. You have Shane Smith, you have Gavin McInnes and Sarush Alvi, who are sort of the three big co-founders. Gavin McInnes, if that name is familiar to you, is also the founder of the Proud Boys.
4:55 Speaker 03 I'll be blunt about the Proud Boys. They're pretty racist. Gavin McInnes sports pretty heavily with white supremacy.
5:00 Speaker 04 That's been a recurring theme with Gavin McInnes, including in the early days of Vice. It's one of the reasons that he ultimately, I think, got fired is that he was bad for the brand. But he was like, sort of the original editorial voice. Shane Smith did a lot of the advertising stuff and Sarush was sort of the go-to adult, if you will, in that group. So they're, they're, you know, whatever, doing their punk zine. Like at the very beginning, I think there are stories about them lying to get on welfare roles in order to get money to operate Vice. They get an investment during the dot com boom, the first one in 1999.
5:37 Speaker 03 The stories about the early days of Vice are pretty chaotic. The investor who gave them that initial money has a pretty different version of events than the myths that Vice later spun up. But whatever actually happened, Vice was out there doing the kind of work that really resonated in the early blog era. Vice was pretty tied in with the New York indie rock and hipster scenes of the early 2000s. And it was known for things like its do's and don'ts column, where it published photos of people at parties and out in the street with extremely rude captions. Oftentimes, those people weren't aware that they were having their photos taken or having them published. That's all in the first decade of the 2000s. It was a very different time on the internet. But then things took a turn. Gavin McInnes leaves in 2008 and Shane Smith has very different ideas for the future of Vice.
6:20 Speaker 04 There's a very famous moment where David Carr, who was then the media columnist for the New York Times, interviews Shane Smith and writes about him. Shane Smith says something about how the New York Times isn't doing stuff that's as daring as what Vice is doing. David Carr sort of stops him and is like, Look, The New York Times has been reporting on genocide since before your publication existed. Like, don't. This is, you're not a real journalist. Don't do this. It is a pretty incredible watch. And I kind of wonder if that's maybe part of what motivated what happened next.
6:54 Speaker 03 That documentary came out in 2011. What happened next is that Vice did move into journalism. They had a deal with HBO to produce documentaries. They had another deal to do a nightly news show, which also initially was on HBO. And Vice's overall video style influenced the whole generation of video journalists online. And the news division, Vice News, did some incredible stories, both in video and on the website. Vice won Emmys, a Peabody Award, even a Pulitzer.
7:22 Speaker 03 So Vice's style goes from an affectation to a real thing. And we know a lot of those journalists. We know a lot of people who've made that work over time, who've worked in Vice's newsrooms. And it's actually really interesting to see how they sort of retroactively added an infrastructure of actual journalism to get to the thing that they were always supposed to be making. And that was very rigorous. And they were very daring in a lot of the work they did. They got into a lot of trouble, but I think Vice's management took it for granted in an almost like shocking and irresponsible way.
7:55 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean, they started essentially as a fashion magazine, right? Like, that was like, sort of the impetus behind like do's and don'ts. If you listen to one of Shane Smith's many Joe Rogan experience interviews, I think this one took place in 2011. He talks about Vice as essentially a fashion magazine. The movement into something that becomes bigger is really interesting. The pitch is essentially, we understand the kids and you do not. The children are not watching television. And we speak to the youth in a way that nobody else speaks to the youth. That's why you should give us money. In fairness, I say this as part of the, the group of the quote unquote youth that they were talking about. They were doing stuff that was really distinctly different from what
8:42 Speaker 04 Traditional media outlets were doing that did speak more to the concerns of younger people, and that was largely being produced by younger people.
8:50 Speaker 03 Yeah. Let's talk about the business. I think people understand what Vice is, but the business that they're building around this, that's the thing that ultimately fell apart so completely. And what's fascinating about that to me is the number of times Shane Smith was able to raise money at ever higher valuations did not appear to be linked to that business getting more sustainable, or more scalable, or even more predictable. It just seemed like he was able to raise a lot of money against this pitch of that we know what the kids are doing.
9:23 Speaker 04 That was a kind of frothy period because the interest rates were really low. And so there was a lot of money, like, in the VC world, but also just, you know, around that was looking for places to go where there would be a return on investment. So I think that was part of what fueled this, was this zero interest rate environment. But I think that that pitch at that time was really something, a lot of traditional media companies had been really frightened by the way that the internet had taken their business. There had been, you know, a slowness to adopt, you know, online journalism.
10:02 Speaker 03 So this was the Vice business model, right? Like fundamentally, they're putting content on the internet. They don't quite know how they're going to monetize it. They build some advertising infrastructure. They land a bunch of big sponsorships with big brands. But really, they're just sort of running from big investment to big investment.
10:20 Speaker 04 Kind of. They start putting together video. They start selling video to places like CNN with the idea that you can bring in a youth audience. From there, they cobble together all of these partnerships. And there's this idea that they have that if you shoot the same video and package it different ways, you know, for TV, for OTT, and for web, you can make a lot more profit off the same video because all you're doing is editing it. And you get to, you know, decide your own margins and that that's going to be the business. Which, at the time, was not a ridiculous thing to think. It turns out that you, like, need to handle things really differently for every single one of those markets. But that was not obvious at the moment. It was not a ridiculous bet to make. That was sort
11:05 Speaker 04 of like, kind of the business plan. But one of the things that I sort of Was discovering was that there just, there was never a moment where Vice went from being like a startup and everybody who has worked at a startup is kind of familiar with the shit show environment that a startup is to like installing like a serious business organization with serious accounting and all of these sorts of functions that you need in order to be a grown up business, basically.
11:39 Speaker 03 So that's the first phase of Vice. We have to take a quick break. When we come back, we'll get to the company's really big turn.
11:50 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bullspend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
11:59 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
12:07 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
12:20 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it. When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton for the stay.
12:50 Speaker 06 Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.
12:55 Speaker 07 Botox, onabotulinum toxin A prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It prevents on average eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo.
13:08 Speaker 08 Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS, Lou Gehrig's disease, Myasthenia gravis, or Lambert-Eaton syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
13:44 Speaker 06 Why wait? Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
13:53 Speaker 03 Welcome back. We're talking to Verge senior reporter Liz Lopatto about the downfall of Vice. This is the big turn, the height of the Shane Smith era. He was out there collecting huge investments all the time. $250 million from A and E Networks, a total of $400 million from Disney, and the valuations are just going up. It seems like Shane wants to sell the company at a huge number, and no one will give him that number, so instead of selling, he just keeps raising more money. But then, right at the end of 2017, The New York Times publishes a bombshell report about sexual harassment and misconduct inside Vice. The company was very much a boys' club environment, and that report, which landed right as the Me Too movement was gaining steam, was too much to ignore.
14:34 Speaker 03 So Shane Smith stays on as executive chairman, but he steps down as CEO and replaces himself with Nancy Dubuque, a vice board member and television executive from A and E Networks. That could have been the moment when Vice Media finally had an adult in the room and the organization grew up, but that is not what happened.
14:53 Speaker 04 The descriptions that I got of the people who were operating under Nancy were not
15:00 Speaker 04 Complimentary. I'm just gonna read a couple of them. One of them was a fucking clown show. Another one was comical. Another one was cartoonish. Screwball cast of suits.
15:09 Speaker 03 That's my favorite one.
15:11 Speaker 04 Yeah.
15:11 Speaker 03 I've been saying, I've been describing lots of things as a screwball cast of suits, because it's just such a good turn of phrase.
15:16 Speaker 04 I had someone tell me he'd learned valuable lessons from his coworkers about what never to do with a company. I had someone say that, you know, the people that had been brought in were essentially in Vice costumes. You know, they were people who didn't understand what Vice was or what Vice did, but they were trying to dress like hipsters. Part of what Shane did was he created essentially a taste business. Vice had a sensibility. You know, it was politically aware, it was politically engaged, it was culturally aware and culturally engaged. And there was just a sort of je ne sais quoi about that. And Nancy, who was an extremely successful executive at A and E, was responsible for shows like
16:00 Speaker 04 Duck Dynasty and Ice Road Truckers, which are not really like the Vice sensibility. That's, that's not what Vice is doing.
16:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
16:07 Speaker 04 And to some degree, if you are in the taste business, your job is to, you know, make hits that are recognizable as part of that taste. And so there was this sort of idea that you needed to know what a Vice story was, or what a Vice documentary was in order to really successfully run the business. And many people I spoke to said that Nancy never really got a handle on that part of it.
16:30 Speaker 03 So Nancy is now in charge. She's the CEO. There's the Vice newsroom in the website, the digital side. They have a cable channel called Vice Land. They are selling shows to HBO and CNN. Is she running all of that? Is she running part of it? Is she paying attention to some parts more or less than others?
16:48 Speaker 04 My understanding, based on the folks who spoke with me, is that she focused on the stuff that she understood, which was the cable channel. One of the problems that happened was that Vice lost its deal with HBO for Vice News Tonight. That was a really important deal for the company. It was, as I understand it, profitable. And it's always a problem when you lose a profitable part of your business, you know? So they made a deal with Showtime, and the guy who had been running the show exited, and they brought in someone else. But there were sort of a series of decisions or moments like this that were, that were happening where There was a kind of changing of talent. There was a kind of, I guess, maybe lowering
17:29 Speaker 04 of expectations, one might say, like going from HBO to Showtime is, I would argue, a downgrade. I think that was part of what was going on. One of the other things that I heard from folks who were working at the website was like, these verticals would be spun up as deals. So like broadly was one of the verticals that I heard had been spun up as part of a deal.
17:48 Speaker 03 The verticals are the sort of like branded topics.
17:51 Speaker 04 That's right. So you're thinking like broadly, noisy motherboard, like these sort of like blog within a blog moments. And what I had heard from some of the people who worked at them was that, you know, they'd get spun up in response to some deal and then essentially forgotten about until it was like time to cut costs and then things would be cut. You know, there wasn't necessarily a lot of active management of what was going on. It was sort of haphazard.
18:19 Speaker 03 One of the things that really strikes me about this period in particular is there's the sensibility required to run a cable channel, which maybe you need a cable executive to do that. You need it to be more mainstream and more Ice Road Truckers, whatever that thing is. There's Vice's sort of classic video sensibility. And then there's the sensibility that's happening on the website, which is, you know, at this point, like winning awards, right? Like a Pulitzer Prize, like Emmys, a Peabody, like they are becoming a very aggressive muscular news organization. They're out in the world causing trouble. And then like over here is we need to program a cable channel with a bunch of like shows about weed or whatever Nancy thinks Vice is. That seems like a real tension that I think your
19:04 Speaker 03 story got at more closely than anything else I've read about Vice before.
19:08 Speaker 04 It's the tension of having different audiences, right? The pitch of like dealing with young people. A lot of us just didn't come back to cable. I didn't come back to cable. The people who are going to be watching a cable channel are not necessarily the same people who are going to be interacting with the stuff online. It seemed like they got, you know, different audiences in cable versus, you know, YouTube, for instance. So there was, there was sort of a disconnect between these parts of the business. It wasn't working as smoothly as perhaps, you know, people had hoped when they had set it up in this way.
19:41 Speaker 03 The TV world is, as you've described, like a hits business. Like you need a hit show, you need a hit show on HBO, they're going to renew the deal. Your cable channel needs to be hit, something has to happen. The website is a much more plotting business, right? You like put up some stories every day, the audience comes back, you sell some ads. And those seem like they operate on different timeframes. And one of those things is a little more predictable, a little more consistent than the other. And then in your reporting, you find out that a bunch of expenses are being moved around these things to make them all look different or better at different times. That's the part that like really jumped out at me in this story is, is that normal? Is that like a particularly vice thing?
20:23 Speaker 03 Is that just a crazy chaotic company that no one's in charge of?
20:27 Speaker 04 To me, Occam's razor suggests just chaos and an overwhelmed accounting department. Like I had one division head tell me that they had essentially done their own shadow accounting in order to make sure that they were meeting their budget because they couldn't rely on the actual accounting department to tell them because the actual accounting department was so overwhelmed. This is where, you know, that moment of not really building out the business part of the business kind of came back to bite vice. One of the things that I heard from two executives was that there was a NetJets account on the digital budget. And NetJets, if you're not familiar, is a private jet service.
21:11 Speaker 04 I thought that that was, that was certainly strange. Two people took credit for canceling that. Two different people told me that they personally had done it. So there was just a level of organizational chaos there that in some ways made it incredibly difficult to run a real business. And, you know, the people I spoke to were kind of divided about Nancy Dubuque. Almost everybody agreed that she had done a wonderful job at A and E. There was no real disagreement on that point. But there were people who thought that she had personally run the business into the ground because she didn't understand what she was doing. And there were people who thought what Shane had created was unfixable and Nancy probably
21:56 Speaker 04 couldn't have saved it. And maybe nobody could have saved it.
22:01 Speaker 03 We have to take another quick break. We'll be right back.
22:12 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
22:21 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
22:29 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
22:42 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
23:12 Speaker 06 Chronic migraine is 15 or more headache days a month, each lasting four hours or more.
23:17 Speaker 07 Botox, onabotulinum toxin A, prevents headaches in adults with chronic migraine before they start. It's not for those with 14 or fewer headache days a month. It prevents, on average, eight to nine headache days a month versus six to seven for placebo.
23:30 Speaker 08 Prescription Botox is injected by your doctor. Effects of Botox may spread hours to weeks after injection, causing serious symptoms. Alert your doctor right away as difficulty swallowing, speaking, breathing, eye problems, or muscle weakness can be signs of a life-threatening condition. Patients with these conditions before injection are at highest risk. Side effects may include allergic reactions, neck and injection site pain, fatigue, and headache. Allergic reactions can include rash, welts, asthma symptoms, and dizziness. Don't receive Botox if there's a skin infection. Tell your doctor your medical history, muscle or nerve conditions, including ALS-Lou Gehrig's Disease, Myasthenia gravis or Lambert-Eaton Syndrome, and medications, including botulinum toxins, as these may increase the risk of serious side effects.
24:06 Speaker 06 Why wait? Ask your doctor. Visit botoxchronicmigraine.com or call 1-800-44-BOTOX to learn more.
24:15 Speaker 03 We're back, talking with Verge senior reporter Liz Lopatto about what really happened at Vice.
24:22 Speaker 03 So in 2021, the company tried to go public through a SPAC deal. It was very much the trend of the moment. Right now, the biggest SPAC in the news is Trump's Truth Social, which is a great example of how a SPAC deal can generate a lot of attention and a lot of money without anyone doing the kind of due diligence a more traditional IPO would require.
24:39 Speaker 04 There was this period where it was becoming clear that things were changing in the business. Some of that does have to do with the way that advertising is sold online. There is a kind of advertisement where there is essentially an automated bidding process and the lowest bidder wins. And so that just drives ad rates relentlessly down. And it's not just, you know, every media property that's involved in this. You're also essentially competing against a bunch of social networks, which have gotten very big and very powerful. So it's just a different period on the internet than 2014 was. And this is like a time when there needed to be an adjustment. And there were some adjustments, but it seems like it was not enough.
25:24 Speaker 04 It's not enough money for, you know, the number of executives that they have. It's not enough money for all of their ambitions. It's very clear that they're going to need to do some kind of turnaround. There is a sort of relentless contraction of the staff throughout all of this. A lot of the lower level folks I spoke to understood what was going on. And they were just like, okay, so when's my number coming up?
25:50 Speaker 03 It's so funny that in the grand scheme of shady Vice things, the SPAC deal doesn't even rank because it's just like a thing that happened and then didn't happen. And then the point of a SPAC deal is to be listed as a public company. It's just the mechanism by which you get listed is not subject to as much scrutiny as a traditional IPO process. But that scrutiny would have revealed that Vice didn't have a business. If they do the $3 billion SPAC deal and the company is listed publicly, then they're a public company and they have to reveal their finances and do quarterly reports and like all the stuff. And wouldn't that have immediately revealed that there was nothing there?
26:24 Speaker 04 It would have revealed whatever was there. Whatever it was that was happening there would have been public. And I am in many ways very sorry that this deal failed because I love a public company. I do. I love reading your financial reports, guys. I'm a sicko. What can I say? Part of that was that they had raised money from TPG. They had a preferred stock in Vice Media that meant that they got additional equity if the company didn't hit certain performance markers. This is reportedly, I think, I think that's the journal that had reported that out. The way that SPACs work is that there is just a company that is only money and hangs out on the market looking for an acquisition target.
27:07 Speaker 04 And then when it finds an acquisition target, the two merge and you have a publicly traded company that didn't exist before. What this does is it lets people in the company being acquired talk about what they plan for the future in a way that is not allowed in IPOs.
27:25 Speaker 03 It would have been fascinating to see Vice go public that way in 2021, but it didn't happen. Another thing that almost happened, but didn't, was an acquisition deal with Antenna Group, a European television broadcaster based in Greece.
27:36 Speaker 04 I am super curious about this. And if you are a person who is listening to this podcast and you know literally anything about this deal, let's say you're a lawyer somewhere or perhaps somebody who is a financial person, like, please let me know. I'm so curious. But what had happened was that Vice had a longstanding deal with Antenna. They had renewed the deal to make content for Antenna Group. And Antenna Group is like this Greek company that operates a bunch of over the air television stations. It was, I think, over 200 hours of TV a week that they were making for Antenna Group. There was an attempt at a sale process with Antenna Group and Group Black,
28:19 Speaker 04 which is another media owner, and nothing happened. The sale process failed. And after that sale process failed, Vice was in bad shape. So if you go and look at the bankruptcy filings, which I highly recommend, they're a very entertaining read. They had already taken three forbearances on their loans at that point. And the entity that was associated with this Antenna Group deal didn't pay them. And it triggered the end of that deal. Simultaneously, there was a IT group called YPRO that had won a judgment against Vice Media for not paying them that froze Vice's bank account.
29:04 Speaker 04 That was the sort of immediate circumstances that led to this bankruptcy.
29:09 Speaker 03 Those things combined, Vice has to go bankrupt because it doesn't have the revenue coming in and now its costs have skyrocketed. That seems like a very simple, like, you're the CEO of the company, you gotta see that train coming, right? Like, how were they not prepared for these eventualities?
29:25 Speaker 04 Well, Nancy Dubuque quit, was what happened.
29:28 Speaker 03 So she was prepared. In a different way, she was very prepared.
29:31 Speaker 04 In a different way, she was prepared. Yeah, no, she quit shortly after it was clear that Antenna Group had pulled the plug, shortly before the bankruptcy. You know, she had a note about being glad that she'd left the company better than she found it, which is confounding to me. Because if that is better than she found it, like, how did she find it? Again, feel free to contact me if you know. So Dubuque quits. There are these co-CEOs who are named, Bruce Dixon and Josefa Lacadewala, who are the two people who are CEO when Vice files for bankruptcy in May.
30:03 Speaker 03 May of 2023.
30:05 Speaker 04 That's right.
30:05 Speaker 03 There's another company that enters the picture here, right? Vice goes bankrupt, and then a huge, like, investment group called Fortress shows up and basically buys it? It feels like Fortress now just controls Vice.
30:17 Speaker 04 Vice owed them a lot of money. And so there was a bidding process to buy Vice's assets because they were in Chapter 11 bankruptcy, rather than Chapter 7, where the whole thing shuts down. They essentially did a credit bid, where they were like, we'll forgive some hundreds of millions of dollars of debt, and then we'll own the company. And they won. They own Vice now. There is a shell company that's left over that is, like, dealing with the bankruptcy, and those creditors from the bankruptcy can expect 1% to 2% of their money back.
30:51 Speaker 03 There's another through line here that we should just touch on briefly. One of the sources of revenue for Vice in this whole period of mess is money from the Saudis. The Saudis, I think somewhat famously, are trying to launder their image by doing media, by doing sports, because they have a pretty bad human rights record, famously murdered a journalist named Jamal Koshagi from the Washington Post. It's not great. And you see Vice needs money so desperately, it kind of runs towards Saudi money. And they do a bunch of things that, kind of in retrospect, seem like they weren't worth the money, right? Like, not from a... Actual dollars and cents perspective, but from a, if you want to run a newsroom with integrity,
31:34 Speaker 03 you should not do some of the things they did in response to the money.
31:37 Speaker 04 Vice had a relationship with the Saudis before Khashoggi was killed. That's true. After his murder, Vice said they were reviewing their contract with the Saudi publishing group SRMG. And then there were sort of these secret things that occurred. Vice secretly organized a music festival in 2020 for the Saudis. There was the ad agency, it's called Virtue, was pitching marketing campaigns to promote Riyadh. In 2022, there were talks with Saudi media conglomerate MBC Group, which had also taken a 30% stake in Antenna in 2022. And then Vice eventually did go through with that partnership directly, which was announced in January 2023.
32:19 Speaker 04 The Guardian started reporting stuff out of the London office, which was that Vice was, quote, "repeatedly blocking news stories that could offend the Saudi government." And also that employees who were working on the Saudi joint venture had replaced a photograph of a memorial protest with a giant map of Saudi Arabia. Not great, I would say, from, from a newsroom perspective. But the thing that I still am puzzled about when it comes to Antenna Group is that if you go into the bankruptcy filings, there is an entity called GMN Cayman. This is the entity that was paying Vice for the Antenna Group deal. There's a second one called GMN Cayman Hold Co.,
33:03 Speaker 04 which was the entity that agreed to make payments to terminate that deal. I didn't find either of those things on Google search, except for in the Vice bankruptcy documents. And so I went to the Cayman Islands Business Registry. And by the way, it is expensive to get these documents. The address is the same as a law firm there. And there are two directors who are named. Both of these men match with some LinkedIn profiles of guys who worked for S and B Capital, which is, quote, "the investment banking and asset management arm of the Saudi National Bank headquarters in Riyadh."
33:39 Speaker 03 If you're writing the story, my view of this was like, these are some dots. We invite the audience to connect these dots, right? Like, it's hard to know. And I think even as you were reporting the story, people were asking you to figure out this connection between Antenna and Vice and the Saudi money. There's something about how Vice was financed at the end, like the underlying foundation of its finances that suggests that, like, actually, its business was nothing, right? It was just like taking Saudi money in some way or another, or taking money from Antenna in some way or another to make stuff that had no relationship to the consumer brand that was being expressed in the United States.
34:19 Speaker 04 One of the things that was frustrating for me was like not being able to crack Antenna. Because I genuinely would love to know what happened there. Was there more than meets the eye? I mean, was there a real business at Vice that just didn't sell because Vice didn't know how to pitch itself? For instance, because that's a real possibility, too. It's possible that Vice just didn't understand in those acquisition talks, how to tell a coherent story about what it was. It's possible that Antenna looked at the books, realized that the deal was one of the things that was kind of holding the company together, and then pulled the plug to drive it into bankruptcy so they could buy it on the cheap. Like, there are lots of ways this story can go,
35:03 Speaker 04 and I just don't know what happens to be true here. I just know that there are these signatures, these directors for this company, that have nothing to do with Antenna that are tied to the Saudi National Bank.
35:16 Speaker 03 The rest of the timeline is fairly straightforward. In May 2023, Vice filed for bankruptcy. In August 2023, it sells itself to Fortress for $350 million. And in February 2024, the company stops publishing to the website, lays off hundreds of people, including huge numbers of journalists, and pivots to being a production studio.
35:36 Speaker 03 There's something inevitable about this. What if Vice always should have just been a production studio? It's hard to monetize websites and Vice was known for its video operation for like 20 years. It feels like a lot of people should be asking why it took Vice so long to get here.
35:52 Speaker 04 If I knew this kind of thing, I would be a media executive instead of a reporter, right? Maybe. Sure. Let's say sure. What was fascinating to me was that this reorg didn't happen right after bankruptcy. Because if it is the right answer, the time to do it is as quickly as possible because you want to cut as many costs as quickly as you possibly can, right? Like you're in bankruptcy. Like, the idea is to restructure the company in such a way that it becomes viable. And so, the faster you can figure out what to cut loose and what to sell and who to fire, you know, the faster you sort of get on the road to being profitable. So, from that perspective, the idea of Vice becoming a
36:33 Speaker 04 B2B studios business, that doesn't strike me as a bad idea. That seems like a perfectly viable thing. It's certainly an important part of what they were doing throughout all of these years. It's just befuddling to me that it took until January for them to do it. The thing I keep coming back to is the sort of the screwball cast of suits, where there was just a real, I think, reluctance to understand what business they were in and how to run it. That, more than anything, kind of made this a little bit inevitable. There was just a, not a clear picture of what Vice itself was, even in the minds of the people who were running it. While all of this was going on, the salaries, again,
37:15 Speaker 04 were quite high. There was a great deal of money that stayed on the balance sheet because those executives were not fired right away. There is an executive I spoke to who called the accounting there fanfiction finance. Basically, they believed the pitch so thoroughly that they hadn't actually sat down to look at what they had, you know? Like, it was like, you just, you were such a true believer in the, the thing that Vice could be. That you didn't really quite know what Vice was.
37:45 Speaker 03 That story is personified in Shane Smith, right? Like, that is Shane Smith selling people a tale. And then when he's no longer the face of the story, it gets quickly out of control and it spirals. But he's still in the mix, right? There's a report in the rap that he's trying to buy Vice again. What is his relationship to the company right now?
38:06 Speaker 04 Reportedly, he was involved in brokering the Fortress deal. This is according to the Hollywood Reporter. The idea that his sensibility is going to be really necessary, his deal making skills and his ability to, you know, sort of work things is going to be part of what leads Vice out of bankruptcy is a bet that's being made. It's maybe worth discussing how much money Shane Smith made here. There's reporting on his divorce filing, which showed that he made $1.6 million per year, plus 1,400 a month in whatever per quizzits are. And there was also an incentive for him to make deals. He got a 5% cut on his deals if a quarter of the revenue for the deal was profit.
38:52 Speaker 04 His contract, according to New York Magazine, had no ceiling on how much he could be paid and multiple sources of payment that funneled him millions of dollars in compensation. He got 100 million out in 2014. You know, he sold his shares. On an episode of Deezus and Marrow in 2017, he talks about buying a $25,000 Pablo Picasso plate. In 2021, he sold one of his homes in Los Angeles for 48.7 million, according to Mansion Global. There's an episode of the Joe Rogan podcast in 2014 where Smith calls himself post economic and brags that he's a billionaire. And, you know, I'm sure that some of that billionaire status had to do with the valuation of his shares at the time.
39:37 Speaker 04 A lot of the people who were lower down the company really resented that because Vice had a history of, you know, it was really difficult for freelancers to get paid. I spoke to one person who had their credit card cut off when they were on a reporting trip where they were reporting on a human rights violation and they were on the return trip. Just very, very recently out of the country they were in where they were undercover when the credit card stopped working. Who told me, you know, if it had happened 24 hours earlier, they would have been in a really dicey situation. This is in another New York Magazine piece about Vice. There was bragging about having, you know, young people at the company because you didn't have to pay them very much. There was a sentiment among some of the people I spoke to who are outside of the executive
40:22 Speaker 04 suite, who viewed this essentially as a way for people who were execs to be really well compensated, kind of at the expense of the actual workers. And one thing that people really particularly resented was, right before Vice filed for bankruptcy, they fired a bunch of people. And then because of the bankruptcy, those people did not get their full promised severance. And so you can go look at the GoFundMe for these fired people who were furious because, of course, the bankruptcy filing reveals all of the executive salaries and that a bunch of the people who had those salaries had gotten retention bonuses right before the bankruptcy.
41:06 Speaker 04 So that was, that was a real point of contention among people who worked there, was that, you know, there were people who did very, very well and they were all at the top of the company.
41:16 Speaker 03 Yeah. Let me ask you kind of the last big think question here. Shane Smith might want to swoop back in and fix Vice and he might want to bring that sensibility back and he actually knows how to pitch it. And maybe he's the thing that makes this all go. Shane Smith is also a 54-year-old, post-economic, potential billionaire who is buying Picasso China. He's living a very different life than the person who started the punk rock scene in Montreal and literally like faked the idea of big distribution forward and made deals and did all this stuff. He's a business person now. Like, I think most people think of him as a media executive, not this like punk rock entrepreneur guy.
41:57 Speaker 03 For a company that's built on sensibility, can Shane Smith, 54-year-old, "I sold my house for $48 million," can he go and connect with a bunch of teenagers and be a rebel again? It seems like the future of Vice depends on the answer potentially being yes.
42:14 Speaker 04 I mean... It's not impossible. There certainly have been 50-year-old media executives who have understood how to sell things to kids. There's not quite enough appreciation for how much Vice was at the right place at the right time. Like, when Vice moved into its Williamsburg space in 2015, it had displaced two indie rock venues. There was always like a sense of like the commoditization of the cool that Vice was. And I think now when we talk about kids these days, you know, we're talking about Gen Z. We're not talking
42:57 Speaker 04 about millennials because we're 40 and like a lot of us are parents and we have 401Ks if we're lucky and like, you know, all that stuff. We're boring. I am out of touch with the Gen Z sensibility, very blissfully so. I don't, I don't mind my quiet life as, as a middle-aged woman. But it is very, very different. For instance, there is less sex and fewer drugs.
43:19 Speaker 03 That's true. Statistically, that is true.
43:22 Speaker 04 Vice was very much a brand that was about sex and drugs. Like that, that was part of, that was part of the appeal. And so if we're thinking about what appeals to Gen Z, what appeals to young people, what, you know, what they're looking for, I don't know that it's Vice. It might very well be that Shane Smith still has a sensibility that is Vice's sensibility, but it may be that as a culture, we're not interested in that anymore. That's a possibility, too.
43:46 Speaker 03 It's amazing that a private equity company called Fortress is gonna have to figure that out. That's actually the least Vice thing that could possibly happen in this whole situation. Liz, thank you. This story has been so much fun to work on with you and to watch you go through the reporting process. I know it was emotionally harrowing at points, but it's a great story and thanks for coming on Decoder to talk about it.
44:03 Speaker 04 Yeah, my pleasure.
44:04 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Liz Lopatto for joining us on Decoder. You should go read her Vice story. It's incredible. If you have thoughts about this episode or what you'd like to hear more of, you can email us at decoder@theverge.com. We really do read all emails. You can also hit me up directly on Threads. I'm at reckless1280. We have a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. Decoder is a production The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
44:40 Speaker 09 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
45:09 Speaker 10 I work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know, I've made things a little difficult in the past. Okay, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG, and finally, I understand. Now I'm making work work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, pay, and workforce management.
Previous Why Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince is the internet’s unlikely defender Next Dropbox CEO Drew Houston wants you to embrace AI and remote work Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated