Pod Insights Decoder Rewind: Can Mastodon seize the moment from Twitter? About this episode ActivityPub is back in the news, thanks to Meta’s Threads launch and Elon’s continued immolation of Twitter — now X. That makes this the perfect time to dig into the Decoder archives to hear what Mastodon CEO Eugen Rochko thinks about the future of social media. Mastodon got a head start as the most well-known of the rising decentralized social networks, but that’s changing fast. Bluesky, on a competing protocol, is picking up steam and Threads promises to decentralize in the future, using the same ActivityPub protocol as Mastodon. That’s a big deal, with big potential.
Verge Editor-at-Large David Pierce has been covering all this very closely. Before we jump into the interview with Rochko, I spoke with David to help update everyone on what ActivityPub even is, and what it could mean for the future of social media.
Links:
More than two million users have flocked to Mastodon since Elon Musk took over Twitter - The Verge
A beginner’s guide to Mastodon, the hot new open-source Twitter clone - The Verge
Elon Musk - The Verge
Benevolent dictator for life - Wikipedia
Mastodon Social
Eugen Rochko (@Gargron@mastodon.social)
Erase browser history: can AI reset the browser battle? - The Verge
Twitter alternatives for the Musk-averse - The Verge
We tried to run a social media site and it was awful | Financial Times
Denial-of-service attack - Wikipedia
Can ActivityPub save the internet? - The Verge
Five reasons Threads could still go the distance - The Verge
What's next for Threads - The Verge
Transcript:
https://www.theverge.com/e/23422689
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
It was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott and it was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Editorial Director is Brooke Minters and our Executive Director is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 14,119 words · 9 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control, set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs, and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards, all backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:26 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them, that's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
0:36 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:44 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:58 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. We are technically off this week on Decoder, but I wanted to bring back an interview from earlier this year because it's so relevant right now. It's my conversation with Mastodon CEO Eugen Rocha. Mastodon is probably the most famous decentralized social network, but that's going to change fast. Meta's new Instagram Threads platform is due to be decentralized in the future, using the same Activity Pub protocol as Mastodon. That's a big deal. David Pierce is here. He's been covering this all very closely, and he's here to help us catch up. David, welcome.
1:38 Speaker 04 Thank you. It's my first time on Decoder. First time, long time.
1:41 Speaker 03 That's why David and I are co-hosts on The Verge chat, so it's crazy that you have not been on the show. Really quickly, what is Activity Pub for people coming into this conversation with Eugen?
1:50 Speaker 04 Sure. The true answer is there is no really quickly, what is Activity Pub? But I'll do it as fast as I can. Basically, it's the underlying protocol for how social things move around the internet. Basically, the same way that email works, which is instead of being run entirely within a platform, it's structured in a set of standards that exist across the internet that different things can send and receive as long as they exist in this simple structure. So it takes that idea and applies it essentially to social posts, videos, texts, images, anything. It's a read and write system that anything can tap into.
2:25 Speaker 03 So I'm on Instagram Threads, you are on Mastodon, I can follow you on Mastodon, and when I hit like on your post, it shows up on Mastodon.
2:33 Speaker 04 Exactly. All this stuff is sort of understood by these different platforms to be these universal ideas of this is a post, this is a like, this is a follow, this is a follower, and anything can understand what that is and actually write into that system.
2:47 Speaker 03 So this is a gigantic idea in social networking. It's especially gigantic if a company like Meta embraces it with something like Threads. Eugen and Mastodon have been at the forefront of this movement. We talked about it a lot in this conversation. What should people be listening for in this conversation with Eugen Rochko?
3:05 Speaker 04 Yeah, in listening back to it, two things really jumped out to me. One is that Eugen spends a lot of time reckoning with kind of how big he wants Mastodon to be, both as a company and as a service. And I think you guys had this conversation in the wake of all the stuff that was going on at Twitter, right? Twitter's changing a lot. There was this big influx of people into Mastodon, and he was already trying to decide, how big and important do I want this to be? And obviously, now we have Threads, which just became the fastest growing app of all time, and the scale of the potential for this thing has completely changed. And so his idea of what he wants Mastodon to be in this space, I think is really interesting. And he seems very conflicted, and it really
3:49 Speaker 04 jumped out to me, listening to it again. The other thing, and this is related, is money, right? I think the big question we've been asking about the Fediverse this whole time is, how is it going to monetize? Is this going to be a creator business? Are you going to find a way to pay money for content moderation? And he has essentially run this thing on a Patreon. Like, he's not making a lot of money, he's not interested in making a lot of money. He invokes Linux a bunch of times, which I thought was really interesting. But this question of, especially again, as Meta comes in, which is very, very, very good at making a lot of money on social networks, what happens if Meta is the company best at making money on the Fediverse? I think is a question that sort of lingers over a lot of this conversation. And it's really interesting to hear him kind of reckon with that in your conversation.
4:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, and I will specifically call out Meta's numbers. Mark Zuckerberg has said, "We'll wait till we see a pathway to 1 billion users, and then we'll turn on the monetization."
4:46 Speaker 03 That is an incredible scale to even be thinking about. It's far beyond what anyone on Mastodon or other Fediverse sites have even considered before. And so if Meta brings a billion people into this and lights up the money spigot, the whole, the nature of this whole project will change. I think it's fascinating. That brings us to, I think, the biggest open question of all, which is Meta has said they're going to decentralize and work with Activity Pub and Mastodon and others. Do you think they're actually going to do it?
5:13 Speaker 04 I don't know. There's a lot of debate about this, and I think a lot of correctly founded conspiracy theories about Meta's intentions and just about everything that it does. But I will say Meta has, over and over, said it wants to do it. It just reaffirmed again, there were Meta people all over threads posting about how they want to integrate with Activity Pub, and the work has already started to decentralize. So the, all the noise is happening very much in the right direction.
5:39 Speaker 03 I've actually seen some emails on the various Activity Pub mailing lists, where the engineers are actually building this standard, where Meta engineers are now engaging in the engineering part of it.
5:50 Speaker 04 Oh, nice.
5:51 Speaker 03 Which I think is as much evidence as we can get right now, but I think they're actually going to do it. And I think they need to do it for antitrust reasons. I think they need to do it for content moderation, regulation reasons. I think there's a lot of good reasons for them to say, "Look, it's decentralized. If you want to leave, you can leave."
6:07 Speaker 04 Right.
6:08 Speaker 03 Which none of the major social networks have ever been able to say before, and I think they're kind of excited about it. The flip side of that is the Mastodon community is having its own very conflicted conversation about Meta joining decentralized social. What's going on over there?
6:22 Speaker 04 Yeah, so Eugene posted this very funny blog post right over the July 4th holiday. I think the title is just "What to Know About Threads", and it basically goes through everyone's deepest fears and sort of tells them not to worry. One of the headings in this blog post says, "Will Meta embrace, extend, extinguish the Activity Pub protocol?", which is the big worry, right? That Meta comes in, drops this huge set of users in, kind of takes over the Fediverse, and then slowly removes all of the openness and goodness in it. Destroying it in its wake. There's a version of this, Eugen even hedges a little saying, you know, Threads could abandon Activity Pub, but his point is, we'll be exactly where we are now.
7:05 Speaker 04 They can't kill us. And that is kind of the point. He also says in general that he thinks Meta's work here is good for Mastodon, it's good for the whole ecosystem. He seems very bullish, which I think is what you would say in this situation. There's no real upside to running around saying, this is bad news. I'm scared, I'm scared, I'm scared. But I do think, and this comes up a bunch in our conversation, like, I think he's a true believer. It's very clear the guy is not in this to make a fortune. It seems like he has turned down several fortunes in this process. But he is in on this thing as a protocol, as a future of the internet, and I think seems to see Meta as a net good, at least for now.
7:44 Speaker 03 Yeah. And that's the thing I would point people to as they listen to this conversation. There's a lot of idealism here. And Decoder is often very practical, very tactical. This one is very idealistic. It's just a guy who built a project with some friends and some Patreon money. And now the project that he's pushing forward might be the foundation of the next new largest social network, what is already the fastest growing app ever. Pretty amazing. So here's Eugen Rochko, CEO of Mastodon.
8:25 Speaker 03 Eugen Rochko, you are the founder and CEO of Mastodon. Welcome to Decoder.
8:30 Speaker 05 Hi, hello.
8:31 Speaker 03 It's very nice to have you here. Mastodon is having quite a moment, but I know you've been working on this project for a long time. So I think there's actually quite a lot to talk about.
8:39 Speaker 05 Yes, indeed.
8:40 Speaker 03 Let's start at the very beginning. Mastodon right now in the popular conversation as a competitor to Twitter, but that's not really what it is. It's not really where it started. What is Mastodon?
8:53 Speaker 05 I mean, it's not that far off from where it started. I started working on it in 2016 because I thought that something as important as Twitter should not be in the hands of a single company. I was a pretty heavy Twitter user back then. I started using it, I think, in 2000. Eight or so when I was a teenager. Uh, and it quickly became a very important part of my life in, in the sense of talking to friends, finding out about things that happen in the world and so on. Around 2016, I, I felt fed up with how Twitter was being run as a company, where it was heading, the community that was on there, the harassment and so on. And so I started looking into alternatives and after viewing the landscape,
9:38 Speaker 05 I decided to build a product of my own and try to make it good.
9:45 Speaker 03 I appreciate that. What, what I mean specifically by it, it's not exactly like Twitter. Twitter is a company. Up until recently, it was a publicly traded company. It had investor reports, it had to make a profit. It had employees, it controlled the entire product. Mastodon is not that in almost any way.
10:04 Speaker 05 Indeed, indeed. Mastodon is free and open source software that allows you to create a social media server or platform that connects to a decentralized network of similar servers, all talking the same protocol, allowing not only different Mastodon servers to exchange information, but also other software that speaks the same protocol. It's, it's a very powerful ecosystem with a lot of potential.
10:33 Speaker 03 When you say you're the CEO of Mastodon, but the product itself is open source software that anybody can run. How does that work? What are you actually the CEO of?
10:43 Speaker 05 I am the CEO of the company Mastodon that works on the software Mastodon. It's just, it's slightly confusing perhaps, but it's also fairly straightforward that somebody is making the software and it's us and we have the same name. For the longest time, it was just me. I started working on this in 2016 when I was still in uni. And I just, after graduating, I started a Patreon page for it. And it was, you know, at $5 per month for a while. And then It gradually increased until I was able to work on it full time.
11:23 Speaker 05 And back then it was like, I don't know, $200 per month or $600 per month. And it was enough for me to live off of because of my situation back then. I started working at full time and I was technically a sole proprietor. It's a type of way to do business in Germany. You're basically just represent yourself as a company sort of thing. And yeah, that went on for a long time, actually until 2021, when we finally incorporated a separate legal entity for Mastodon. Over time, we got more people contributing to the code. Some on a voluntary basis. There were a lot of drive-by contributors on GitHub.
12:08 Speaker 05 You know, over 700 people have contributed lines of code to the software, but also just people that we work with regularly, contractors that I hired. Right now, it's quite a sizable, well, not quite a sizable, but it is compared to where it started, it's quite a sizable company. There's me, full-time employee, developer, CEO, whatever you want to call it. There's another developer, Claire. We have a CFO on a contract basis. We have a talent manager. We're hiring for three positions full-time. We have two developers working on our iOS app as contractors.
12:51 Speaker 05 We have one developer working on the Android app as a contractor. There is a user experience design agency that works with us on a contract basis. And yeah, that's about it, but it's quite a lot of people to manage.
13:08 Speaker 03 Well, so the company itself, it sounds, I'm just keeping a rough count there. You have four full-time people and then a handful of contractors and an outside agency.
13:18 Speaker 05 Well, currently two full-time people, but hiring for three more. So in the end, it would be five.
13:23 Speaker 03 Okay, so the talent manager is also on a contract basis?
13:26 Speaker 05 Yes, yes.
13:27 Speaker 03 Okay, I'm just, the decoder for me is all about structure, right? How do these things happen? How do we put these companies together? Mastodon, there's a lot of pressure on the protocol, right? There's a lot of interest in it. There's a lot of new servers being spun up. Then there's having to develop and manage the development of a large open source project like Mastodon itself. How do you split the time, right, between all the things people want Mastodon to do, all the features people might wish to add to it, and then you actually running your company?
13:59 Speaker 05 I mean, I'm not gonna lie, it's quite tough, and it's been quite tough since November. For a long time during Mastodon's lifetime, it wasn't as difficult because, well, the pressure on the project was much lower, even during busy times. I mean, Mastodon didn't just pop out of nowhere in November 2022. We had our run-ins with Global Fame, even going as far back as 2017. That's when it went viral for the first time, and magazines like Mashable and The Verge have covered us back then for the first time. But in hindsight, it was much lower pressure back then. I was able to manage on my own, but now clearly the pressure is much, much larger,
14:43 Speaker 05 and it's not enough for just me to be involved in the project. Like, it needs to expand, there needs to be more people working on different areas, there needs to be more delegation. And since November, it's been basically a whole ongoing project within our company to, like, figure out the hiring process, because we're basically hiring for the first time. This you can tell from like the story that I told about the development of the company. Like, that's basically the first step that it makes from being like just me to like having more people and like more full-time employees. And it's just, it's a huge step, and it's a new process for us.
15:24 Speaker 05 So we spent a lot of time like figuring out, okay, so these are the key roles that we need to fill as soon as possible, because again, we're also dealing with a limited budget, right? Even though a lot more people donated through our Patreon in November, and it's like huge explosion of funds really, going from $7,000 per month to $30,000 per month. Like, it's a big budget increase, which is what allowed us to look into hiring more people. But it's still a constrained budget, right? So you need to figure out, okay, so these are the key positions that will have the maximum impact on what Mastodon is doing as a company. And so we decided, you know, we need a DevOps person, because I can't be running the company and solving technical issues 24/7.
16:11 Speaker 05 We need another developer so that it's not just me and Claire. So somebody else can work with Claire when I'm not around, right? And we need a product designer because we got this far by me doing like the design, figuring out usability, user experience and so on. But I'm not actually qualified to do that. And I want Mastodon to be the best product that it can be. I want it to be polished. I want it to be on par with any commercial alternative you you might throw at it. So it's really important for me to find, you know, the right designed person that would also be able to take ownership and initiative at this stage.
16:55 Speaker 05 Because, you know, basically, a lot of larger companies, they have whole teams working on this stuff. And and a lot of these tasks are delegated. But in our case, it's kind of like, we have to find somebody who's um, who's able to like multitask a little bit and then just like fill in the role that until now I have to basically do.
17:15 Speaker 03 I want to come to all of that. I think that's very interesting. I think just being on this podcast, a lot of people are gonna come talk to you, uh, which I'm very curious to see how that goes. But I want to just sit for one second in what I think of as the middle stage that very few people pay attention to, right? And I always think about it when you listen to like the story of a band or something. The band forms, they play one show in the garage and then everyone skips the middle part to their playing in stadiums. And you're kind of on the, oh, boy, we better staff up so we can like play in stadiums part of the journey. But that middle part between us covering you in 2016 and 17 as Mastodon launches in November, when Elon buys Twitter and all the attention.
17:58 Speaker 03 What made you stay convicted in Mastodon? That this was a thing without the big spikes of growth or attention? And whatever challenges and whatever financial limits that were placed on you, why did you stay focused on it? Because you were ready in November of 2022 for the moment, right? The product was there, the servers were there, the ecosystem, the community was there, which is very important to be ready for the moment. But you could not possibly know the moment was coming. So what made you stay focused?
18:29 Speaker 05 Well, I would argue that I couldn't possibly know the moment was coming then. But the writing was on the wall for me back in 2016 that something was going to happen sooner or later.
18:43 Speaker 03 So Something with the big social networks, you mean? Or something with Twitter specifically?
18:47 Speaker 05 Yeah, just a shift. You know, because social media websites, they come and go, they die. Even if they stay around like MySpace, nobody's talking about MySpace like it's a relevant thing anymore. And there's plenty more that have literally disappeared, like app.net, Google Plus, Friendster, whatever.
19:07 Speaker 03 It is a graveyard.
19:08 Speaker 05 Friendfeed, you know? Yeah, it is a graveyard. And, you know, I never believed that Twitter would be, you know, completely immune to that sort of thing happening. So you could see like all the seven years that I've worked on this is kind of like a preparation for this sort of thing, just without, you know, knowing when exactly it would happen and, you know, like exactly what to do. It's been a long process of figuring out what are the right features? What are the right designs? What's the right messaging? How do you do this? How do you do that? So I will not claim that, you know, I had all the details figured out from the start. It was a long process of figuring stuff out.
19:50 Speaker 03 So you've described the sort of financial journey here as $600 a month in Patreon to $7,000 a month to $30,000 a month in Patreon. Is there another source of revenue? Is there a potential another source of revenue?
20:04 Speaker 05 No, that's pretty much it. One thing that we've done over the years is that we just sort of created an additional like platform for the higher tier Patreon sponsors to give money to us as a sponsorship that would just allow us to give them invoices back, like that's, that's the only thing and save on Patreon fees a little bit. But for the most part, Mastodon is financed through Patreon and like that, that platform that we built for the higher tiers and that's it. Last year, we received a grant from NLNet, which was something that came from the European Commission, which is a grant for open source projects that work on decentralized social networks.
20:49 Speaker 05 That was a little bit of side funding, but it was a one-time thing. And, you know, in the past, there was another one, it was a prototype fund project, but that was more like a personal grant kind of thing. Like sometimes you find these grants that sponsor people who work on open source projects and it can help continue working on this. But to answer your original question on why I stuck around, I mean, I believe in the vision. I believe that Mastodon is the better way to do social media and I've stuck around because I am, well, I am dog fooding it, you know, I am using it. It's my daily driver, you know, I have a home feed that I look at every day.
21:28 Speaker 05 I share what's happening in my life, the music that I listen to on my Mastodon profile. I most enjoy Cat Day and looking through cat pictures and sharing cat pictures every Saturday. So, you know, that's why I've stuck around. And of course, there is a personal element to this as well in that it's kind of a cool job to have. You're doing something unique, you're getting paid to work for yourself in a way, at your own pace. Which can mean sometimes, you know, the times are quiet and there's not much to do. Unfortunately, sometimes it means that you have to work like pretty much nonstop and it's extremely stressful and extremely draining.
22:12 Speaker 05 Like it's been for the past like three months. So that's the downside.
22:17 Speaker 03 Usually people go through that experience at a startup because they have equity and they might go public or they might sell the Facebook or something for a huge amount of return. Do you see that outcome for yourself, that there will be some kind of exit for Mastodon where you'll reap some sort of massive financial reward? Or is it, this is the vision, it's an open source project and we need to stay focused and idealistic?
22:41 Speaker 05 It's not really why I went into this and I, no, I don't see that. It is an open source project. It is free software and there is, you know, there's nothing to be reaped from it. But I think I see a good future for Mastodon. I see it growing both as a network and as a project. And, you know, my wage right now is really rather low. And for the most part, it's because, you know, when new funds come into the project, there are important things that I think need doing more than, you know, paying myself more.
23:20 Speaker 05 But I'm hoping that at some point there will be a break even point where I'll be able to just have a dignified wage as well.
23:30 Speaker 03 That's fair enough. This is the classic decoder question. It, just listening to you, it, it sounds like you've had to make an escalating set of ever more complicated decisions since you started this project and it was just you. You're now at what might be the most fun part, right? Which is staffing up, figuring out who to hire, how to hire. How do you make decisions? What's your framework to make decisions?
23:51 Speaker 05 Framework to make decisions sounds very serious indeed. And it makes me wish that I had a more elaborate answer to that. But sometimes my decision making is led by what the community is asking for. But of course, it's all comes down to my vision for the project.
24:15 Speaker 05 And what I think is right. That is my framework for considering community suggestions or community demands and figuring out what the project needs and what it should avoid. In the future, I am really looking forward to having a more organized model for this kind of decision making. Keyword that has been thrown around is participatory governance. Now, I'm not going to promise anything specific, but that is something that I'm talking to a couple of people about. One thing that I would want to get out of something like that is just a more organized way of inferring
25:00 Speaker 05 community opinion about specific features or directions. Because at the moment, it is quite chaotic. The main way that people can voice their opinion about what should be Mastodon or what shouldn't be Mastodon is issues on GitHub, which is, you know, basically, you know, feature requests, bug reports on our source code repository. And, you know, it's just, you know, somebody submits a feature request. How do you know if that's something that a lot of people want and would benefit from? Or something that only one person would benefit from? Or if it's something that one person would benefit from and then a whole bunch of people will hate it, you know? Right now, it's very chaotic. And, you know, my wish is to find a way
25:44 Speaker 05 to have some kind of vehicle where people would feel like they're represented. And I would get a way to know, okay, so they've made their decision. So now I can either go along with it or not, but then I know there's just some kind of backing to that, you know? Not just like trying to figure out, okay, 40 people on GitHub have given a thumbs up to this feature request. What does that mean for the, you know, 2 million people using Mastodon today?
26:12 Speaker 03 How do you build a social network using the tools of social networking? Seems like a recursive problem. We could do the entire podcast on open source governance models. We could probably do an entire conference on. Open source governance models. There have been a lot of them over time. Each of them has trade offs. I'll just use Linux as an example because I'm confident the audience is familiar with Linux. At the top of Linux is Linus Torvalds and he like literally has the title benevolent dictator for life of Linux.
26:42 Speaker 05 Yeah.
26:43 Speaker 03 And that is the governance model that flows down from that title. Is that what you're thinking of? I gotta pick one of these sort of well worn.
26:50 Speaker 05 That is how it is right now. And honestly, I subscribe to that model. I think it's effective. I think that it leads to a better product because a good product needs long term vision and it needs cohesive vision. And that's something that like a committee cannot give. When you have a lot of people who just have pet issues, one thing that they care about, it it kind of ends up being a patchwork and it loses some of its focus. And it can end up in a situation where it just stops being a good product, it becomes too confusing. And sometimes, you know, you need to make executive decisions about changing
27:30 Speaker 05 stuff in a serious way, which might not be popular with what most people in a committee would want. And so I don't look down on the BDFL model. I think that it's it has its place in open source, at least. I would not make any comments or claims about other areas of life, but in open source, I think it makes sense. And that's what I would prefer to stick with. But that doesn't mean that I don't think there's better ways to to involve other people and and have better communication.
28:04 Speaker 03 What you're describing now is familiar in shape, if not in the specifics, right? It's an open source product that has found product market fit, or at least the opportunity for product market fit. It's going to grow really fast. You need some help scaling. This is when venture capital firms show up at your door and say, look, we know how to do DevOps. We can install a bunch of lawyers to help you figure out open source governance. Look at all these tools. Here's a whole army of people that have done this before. Let us give you the money and the help and we'll scale it as fast as we can. Has that been happening to you?
28:38 Speaker 05 We've definitely had a lot of people from venture capital firms reach out to us. And we've even tried having a few conversations just to see where they were at, what they wanted. We've obviously had considered ways to have a more sustainable funding model for the open source project that would not rely on Patreon. We've explored if maybe there would be a way to find funding for that.
29:04 Speaker 03 Uh oh.
29:05 Speaker 05 I cannot say that anything productive has come out of it. And we've rejected every venture capital firm that has reached out to us so far. Now, when I say a more sustainable funding model for the project, I obviously mean software as a service because it's the most natural way for an open source project to basically find a business model for itself. You have a product that you have the most familiarity with. You can offer it to other people in a way that they don't have to find out how to install it, how to manage it, and so on. So it is quite natural and it's been on my mind for quite a few years as a sort of backup
29:48 Speaker 05 plan for, you know, in case for some reason people stop donating to the Patreon, you know. But there's a lot of activity in that space right now. A lot of these hosting firms are jumping up, starting up. I think we could have an edge in that space, but it also doesn't seem like a priority right now, if I'm honest.
30:13 Speaker 03 So. Yeah. Are you rejecting all the VC firms because the pitch is basically the same for all of them? We'll give you a bunch of money and resources, but we're looking for 30x revenue growth or whatever?
30:24 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's basically, it's somewhere between a hosting business is not really venture capital scale, right? It doesn't promise the same returns. What they seem to be interested in is more of a, you know, we'll give you money now and you don't have to think about monetizing, but in two years, let's figure out how we could turn your open source project around. And, you know, that's kind of a no-go zone for me, you know? It's a trap, you know? It's clearly against our project's ideals.
30:59 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
31:09 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard, confessions.
31:19 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
31:27 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
31:41 Speaker 06 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini in Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini in Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
32:09 Speaker 03 We're back. I want to dive deeper into how Mastodon works. Let's talk about Mastodon, the community, the product, right? So I kind of understand the company now. And I understand very clearly that you have a specific set of ideals about how you want to run the company, about the nature of decentralized social networks, about moderation. I want to talk about all those things. But right now, the basics of the community are you download the Mastodon software from Mastodon, the company. You can spin up your own server. You can go try to get your own users for it. And then you can, in a federated way, send messages back and forth across these servers. How many users does Mastodon have now across instances?
32:48 Speaker 05 I am unprepared for this question. I am actually unprepared for this question because the statistics API on our official website has not been functional for a couple of days because I need to change the code a little bit to make it more efficient. So I actually have not kept up with it. But I would say.
33:08 Speaker 05 At least one and a half million monthly active users.
33:13 Speaker 03 Okay. And then in November, when Elon took over Twitter, you saw a huge spike. What does that spike look like?
33:19 Speaker 05 That spike was 2.5 million monthly active users.
33:24 Speaker 03 So it's gone down since then?
33:25 Speaker 05 Yeah, but there's a caveat to that spike, and that is the way that active users are counted on Mastodon in the software is if you log in, right? And every person who signs up, logins. So it's kind of inflated through people who sign up and then bounce. So it's natural for it to go back down, back to more natural levels. And it's just in fact unfortunate side effect of how the statistics were implemented in it. So it's both impressive because, you know, the, you know, the, the big number highlights how many people checked out Mastodon. But it's also normal for the number to go back down to a more level area again.
34:04 Speaker 03 Are you still growing?
34:05 Speaker 05 Yeah, it's still growing. In fact, it's growing faster now than it was before because of some changes that we did to our official apps, as well as the changes we did to the official join Mastodon.org website. I adjusted the sorting to highlight bigger servers first. It's a big change from what it used to be, where we tried to highlight smaller servers. And a lot of them at the top were the ones where you can't create an account straight away, but you have to wait for approval. And that was just not very user friendly. So now the ones with open registrations and larger ones are at the top. And of course, that has had a very quick effect on the growth and increasing it.
34:46 Speaker 05 And similar changes have been made in the official apps, as well as the onboarding improvements in general that we've been working on since November. They've finally been released on both iOS and Android. They include both a better explanation of what the hell decentralization is, what the servers are before you get thrown into the server list, but also changes to the server list that allow a bit more sorting, a little bit just displayed information in a better way, but also provide a pick for me option, where if you don't make a selection, it gives you a random option.
35:18 Speaker 03 So I have an account on Mastodon.social, which is the one that you run. By the way, I follow Eugen. He's not kidding with the cats thing, in case you're listening. That was 100% true. But there's all sorts of other servers. What are the economics of running one of those servers? Because that's, to me, is one of the... The most difficult things to understand. I spin up a Mastodon server on Squarespace or whatever it is, one of these hosting companies that wants to let me do this very easily. I run it, I get users. I've got to pay Squarespace. Do I, the administrator of the server, make any money? Is there anything built into the platform that lets me make any money doing this?
35:53 Speaker 05 No, not really. It's not really about making money off of hosting Mastodon. It's more about when you host Mastodon for yourself, you're in control. You own it. It's your megaphone and nobody can say you're kicked out, or you can say this, you can't say that, or, you know, take your data and sell it to a third party. It's your complete ownership over your own social media platform, right? But without losing global reach because people can follow you from other servers. And so hosting a Mastodon server for yourself or for your
36:31 Speaker 05 family, for a small private group of people that you know, it is really relatively simple and it's not too expensive. You do need either a hosting provider, somebody who will offer Mastodon as a service, or you need like a small virtual private server from Digital Ocean or similar hosting company where you can, if you have the know-how on how to install programs on Linux and how to run them, where you can install Mastodon and, you know, you just need your own domain name and there you go. When you run the server for yourself, you don't really need to think about things like moderation because, you know, you're just responding for yourself. And obviously you'll need to block bad actors and stuff,
37:16 Speaker 05 but, you know, you're just doing it for yourself. You don't have to worry about, you know, community management. Then completely different side from this is when you want to run a server for a community or for the public. It's a whole different level of responsibility and obviously involves, you know, moderation burdens, like.
37:36 Speaker 05 You need to moderate, you need to find people who will moderate for you. Sometimes for for smaller communities, people just do it out of their pocket because, you know, the community matters to them, or it's like an offshoot of their like main community website. You know, if they have like a forum and, you know, they get a Mastodon server like as a bonus value add to that. Like, we could actually talk about Medium as an example of that because Medium have spun up their own Mastodon server.
38:02 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
38:02 Speaker 05 Now, they're a publishing platform for long form articles for writers, right? And what do writers do? They usually announce what they've written on social media in in short form content. And so Mastodon is a perfect fit for them to basically offer it as a value add. You have your Medium account, you can sign into Mastodon and post about what you've just written on Medium and drive traffic to your writings that way. So that's one example of how it fits with something that already exists. And of course, for other cases, the Mastodon service that aren't monetized, if that's the right word, is through Patreon.
38:43 Speaker 05 Basically by, you know, people are providing a service and then some people who value that service donate back to keep it afloat.
38:52 Speaker 03 So Mastodon that social is the one that Mastodon, the company, runs?
38:56 Speaker 05 Correct.
38:57 Speaker 03 That is, I would say, the most famous one, for lack of a better word. You open signups, you close signups. Why do you sometimes close signups?
39:05 Speaker 05 In the past, it's been a huge burden, especially when I was working alone, to wrestle with the scaling problems, with the technical issues of running a large scale server at the same time as running a company and writing code. That's just one side of it. The other side is ideological. Ideologically speaking, Mastodon is a decentralized social network, right? So we don't want to
39:31 Speaker 05 Promote a single node more than other ones. The ideal system is one where there's a whole bunch of different servers and they're roughly the same size and it doesn't matter which one you use, they're all interconnected, right? Because when you get to a situation where one single node is much, much bigger than all the other ones, the problem is that it gets disproportionate power to change things, to enforce its own whims. And an example of that is email and the situation with Gmail. Gmail is huge and they have very good spam filters, but unfortunately those good spam
40:10 Speaker 05 filters sometimes catch people who try to self-host email and it creates a situation where it's so difficult to self-host email, you're basically forced to just go use Gmail or one of the other large providers instead. And that's the kind of situation we ideally want to avoid in Mastodon and in the Fediverse, which is the name for the network that Mastodon is basically part of based on this Activity Pop Protocol. So to avoid that, and so for that reason, you know, historically, we've been trying to promote a healthy distribution of people across these different servers. Now, what I've learned however, over the years, is that there is no replacement for having
40:55 Speaker 05 a default, right? I'm sure you realize, like, when people are used to just going on a website and creating an account, presenting them with a choice of hundreds of different servers, all provided by different people and organizations, that they don't know, it's quite a paradigm shift. It's quite difficult for people to grasp on first sight. And I think it's something, really it is a strength of the platform, that there is such a diversity of offerings. Instead of, on Twitter, you just have Elon Musk and, you know, if he decides to do X, there's nothing you can do about it. On Mastodon, in some ways, you still have the potential for like a mini Elon, right?
41:40 Speaker 05 But unlike with Twitter, you have the option to just take your account and go somewhere else. Or start your own and still participate in the network. So the power of of somebody like Elon in in the fativerse is greatly diminished. So that's the the strength of it. But to realize the strength, you need to be basically into the idea already. And for that, we need like a simple conversion, you know, a a simple signup that people can go through without too much hassle, without being presented with a, you know, a completely different way to do things where they, you know, they go and they say, oh, it's too complicated. I can't choose.
42:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:24 Speaker 05 So that's what I've realized over the years. And the idea right now is to keep registrations open and continue having them open to the best of our ability. The only situation where I think we we would maybe in the future close signups temporarily is if there is technical issues that affect quality of service. Because priority for us has always been if if lots of new people are joining and that, you know, the servers are melting down, is ensure that the people who are using our server now can continue to do so and have good quality of service. If that means closing signups and directing people elsewhere, then so be it.
43:06 Speaker 05 But with the way that we're expanding the company, getting dedicated DevOps person and so on, and with the, you know, the new funds that we got, I think we will be able to keep registrations open going forward.
43:18 Speaker 03 So the Gmail comparison is really interesting here. I cannot believe I'm about to explain Gmail to the Decoder audience, but I'm gonna I'm gonna do it, just so I have said it out loud. Email is an open protocol that is run by a standards organization. Gmail runs on those protocols, SMTP and IMAP and the rest, and so does Outlook or whatever. The reality for most people is that there's a collapse between the protocol and the application on their phone. Right? So if you have Outlook, you are almost certainly not using the Gmail app. If you have Gmail, you're almost certainly not using the Outlook app. You're going to the service and putting that app on your phone. The only real exception to this rule is like the Apple Mail app on the iPhone.
44:01 Speaker 03 Where everything else is kind of, there's a collapse between the protocol and how it's expressed to the user. Mastodon.social, that's the one you run. You download the official Mastodon app. It's going to default you into it because defaults are important. I mean, literally, the number one criticism I hear from people is, well, you have to pick a server and it'll never work because no one wants to pick a server. Okay, you're going to solve that problem. But now, aren't you getting closer to that collapse between the open protocol and the user experience? Where people think Mastodon, they download the Mastodon app and they end up on the Mastodon server?
44:32 Speaker 05 Well, for reference, right now Mastodon Social isn't actually the default in our app. It's just one of the top ones that shows up. However, I think that possibly going forward, we might rework the onboarding user experience into presenting a default option as well as an advanced option where all of that stuff with choosing a server would be basically hidden away from those people who get scared by choice, right? Who get intimidated by choice. But yes, you are correct in that it gets us closer to the Gmail situation, but it's kind of unavoidable with the constraints of the problem that I've described where, you
45:14 Speaker 05 know, the choice is too complicated and you need to convince people that this is better and it is something they should invest some time into. And then they'll realize both how it works and what they can do with it. That is the idea. The idea is the funnel, right? They get started on Mastodon Social, but afterwards they can move to an account on their own server that they create or on a different server provided by a different company or a different person, right? And historically, it has been the case. A lot of people who are currently running their own servers or even have started their own public servers that they offer, they had their first account on Mastodon Social.
45:58 Speaker 05 So it is working and it does make Mastodon Social somewhat disproportionately large, I imagine, in the future, but... That's just part of making it work, I think.
46:10 Speaker 03 Is there a point at which the cost of Mastodon Social will be too much? Where you'll have to actually monetize it directly?
46:17 Speaker 05 It's hard to say if the cost will be too much. And it's equally hard to say if there will ever be a point where some kind of monetization is absolutely necessary. One thing that I've looked into as part of our software offering, as part of the Mastodon software, somewhere down the line, is a way for admins to basically monetize account creation. Basically to offer paid accounts, like a premium email service would do. I think that's a very fair way to monetize. What right now people manage to do with Patreon and basically an honor system, you just codify it into the software.
46:56 Speaker 05 You say, okay, I pay you this amount per month and for that I receive an account and good quality of service. And that makes sense to me. I can't say for sure if we ourselves will ever make use of something like that. And, you know, it's hard to predict so long in advance and with unknown growth as well. But it's something that I want to make available for other admins so that there can be more sustainable business models in the Fediverse.
47:26 Speaker 03 I realize I keep asking about money, but one of the reasons I keep asking about money is that if you want this to be a success, on the scale of success you're talking about, it actually needs to become an ecosystem, right? There needs to be multiple kinds of business models and businesses using the protocol, using Mastodon, inventing new ways of going. That's what makes it resilient to change in a way that, you know, MySpace's business was not resilient to change. Are you open to that, to saying, okay, some people are going to monetize this thing in a way that maybe I personally don't like or that I'm ideologically opposed to, but in order for the ecosystem to thrive, lots of people have to be trying lots of different things?
48:04 Speaker 05 Well, I don't know about, I don't, something that I would be ideologically opposed to, but I think that-
48:11 Speaker 03 You're one of the few CEOs I talk to that will state their values as clearly as you have, so that's why I asked it that way.
48:15 Speaker 05 I think, I think- A diversity of of business models in the Fediverse would be a good thing. I I think different people exploring different ways to do stuff on this in this ecosystem would benefit everyone because the good business models would fail and the good ones would thrive, hopefully. At the end of the day, I think it's good to be able to to support these different business models. And I think companies are eager to start building on top of the Fediverse because for the first time in history, it's an ecosystem where one company cannot just pull the rug from under them, right? By closing the APIs because it's open source, it's built on open protocols.
49:00 Speaker 05 So the API literally cannot be locked down in in the way that Twitter is doing right now or has promised to do, you know? So, you know, when the developers from Tabbots built their Ivory app, the premium paid iOS app for Mastodon, they know for sure that I am not going to pull the rug from under them and they will not lose their existence. And I I welcome apps like that. I I welcome apps being built on top of the Mastodon API. I welcome other software being built on top of the Activity Pub protocol that integrates with Mastodon. I I think it's very exciting that Tumblr has announced Activity Pub support, that Flickr has expressed interest in it.
49:45 Speaker 05 I was very happy when Vivaldi, the the browser, announced their own Mastodon server and Mozilla has announced the same and Medium and it's extremely exciting.
49:56 Speaker 03 So those companies that are announcing support for Activity Pub, which is the underlying protocol for Mastodon. So we had Automattic CEO Matt Mullenweg come on. He said Activity Pub is great. Fundamentally, this is all blogging. My whole company is blogging, whether it's Tumblr or WordPress.com or whatever. We're going to support this and and be in full support of blogging. We talked to Mitchell Baker from Mozilla. She said Mastodon is really interesting. This is where I'm pointed. First, we're just going to set up an instance and see how it works. But you can see the turn there for her is building some Activity Pub support directly into the browser itself. Do you worry that, okay, here's a lot of attention from big companies,
50:35 Speaker 03 they're just going to spin up their own massive instances, or Tumblr will become a sort of strange new default Activity Pub source, and we'll just kind of end up back at Twitter but with an underlying open source protocol? Because that is the Gmail problem, right?
50:52 Speaker 05 I think that Twitter with an underlying open source protocol, and, okay, open source doesn't really play, doesn't factor into the protocol bit. Twitter based on an open protocol would be a good thing, even in its current state, because you would be able to follow the people that you care about and be followed back by them without engaging with the actual platform, right? Instead of being locked in into one commercial service, you would be allowed to leave and to build your own platforms and do something better without fighting against the network effects of a locked-in commercial platform. So I see it
51:34 Speaker 05 as a good development, no matter what, when more platforms are announcing support, because it means that the network, the platform, becomes more useful for everybody. And if we create a future where a whole bunch of social networks are interoperable based on Activity Pub, it's a great future, even if, you know, ideally also, you know, open source and everything, but even without that, it would still be a better situation for the web than is right now.
52:06 Speaker 03 One of the things about Activity Pub that is interesting is that it is closer to format-agnostic than sort of the other-
52:14 Speaker 05 Very versatile.
52:15 Speaker 03 Right, versatile, that's a good, that's a good word for it. In the way that, you know, Instagram is sort of incompatible with a tweet from the, from the jump, like they're just not the same thing, or TikTok is not compatible with a Facebook post from the jump. And you can see how much work Facebook internally has had to do to retrofit something that looks like TikTok onto Facebook. Activity Pub is just more versatile than that. The posts can be long, they can contain multimode media, pictures and text, whatever it is. Do you think that someone might fork it and make it more specific? Because those are the social platforms that tend to win, right? The ones that kind of funnel everybody towards a particular format that captures the zeitgeist.
52:57 Speaker 03 And I'm specifically thinking of, if you talk about Friendster to MySpace to Facebook to Instagram to TikTok, the funnel has been now just point a camera at your face and go. And you're kind of back at, well, actually, writing is the A-plus ultra of the internet. We should just do a good job at it.
53:13 Speaker 05 I would argue that this has already happened, but not in quite the way that you've described it.
53:18 Speaker 03 Okay.
53:18 Speaker 05 Because Activity Pub is the protocol for exchanging information in, like, in the programmatic way, right? And in a programmatic way, an Instagram photo maps onto the same structures as a video on YouTube or a post on Twitter, right? You can map these concepts onto very generic concepts and add all the, you know, necessary metadata as extra on top. Now Mastodon is a product built on top of this protocol that focuses on short microblogs, on short posts with videos or images attached or polls where people follow each other.
54:02 Speaker 05 But there already are other Fediverse projects that focus on different aspects of the social experience, like Pixelfed, which is focused entirely on photos, right? It's a photo app. It isn't not really concerned with short-form blogging. It's just concerned with photos. But you can follow a Pixelfed user from your Mastodon account and vice versa. And then, you know, in your home feed on Mastodon, you get all these photos that people on Pixelfed post. And on Pixelfed, you get all the photos that a Mastodon user posts. It maps back onto each other. Not always 100%, and it doesn't have to. Because as you say, it's so versatile. It doesn't always make sense.
54:46 Speaker 05 If there is a new platform that does something very, very unique that would have no way of mapping onto what Mastodon is doing today. They would not have to share any space. But there might be another platform that is kind of similar to that one. And they would be able to interoperate using that same, those same semantics, right? There's a variety of these platforms on the Fediverse. And Pixelfed and Mastodon are just some of them. There's another one called PeerTube, which is one where you have channels and you publish long-form videos on them. And again, you can just follow a channel on PeerTube from your Mastodon account and get those videos in your home feed.
55:29 Speaker 05 And you can leave comments and then those comments appear on the videos. Because a reply on something like Mastodon, which could be compared to Twitter, really maps well onto a comment on a video like on YouTube, you know?
55:44 Speaker 03 Do you think there's any danger of one of those platforms saying, "Ah, we've hit the limit here. We're just going to fork the Mastodon code and build our own version of this thing and build a separate network that might have its own network effects." And that becomes the challenge to Mastodon?
56:02 Speaker 05 Of course, something like that could happen with the protocol. There is an XKCD comic for that. And you know, the punchline is now you have one more standard to care about.
56:14 Speaker 03 It's a very famous comic, yes. I kind of walked into this answer.
56:19 Speaker 05 I think what speaks in favor of Activity Pub and Mastodon is that we have built up this network. We have built up some momentum and some network effects for this protocol. Which means that it's not really in anybody's interest to start completely from scratch. Of course, it doesn't stop everyone. There's that Jack Dorsey's pet project, Blue Sky, which, you know, they have analyzed all the different decentralized social media projects and then decided to come up with their own, completely separate from everything that came before, again, you know, so, you know, that stuff happens all the time.
56:59 Speaker 03 They've succeeded in hiring like one person after this lengthy project.
57:02 Speaker 05 Yeah, after two years of deliberations, they've published something and now it's quiet again, you know.
57:09 Speaker 03 There's Noster, which is, I think Dorsey's also very much into that.
57:13 Speaker 05 And there's that, yes, there's that. And as far as I know, it's just full of, you know, spam and people talking about cryptocurrencies. The stuff like that pops up. But Activity Pub is a very promising technology. No protocol is perfect and can never be perfect. That is important to be acknowledged because you will never be able to make Activity Pub 2 that will not have some issue that somebody will find and be like, okay, we need Activity Pub 3, right? So acknowledging that, you might come around to the conclusion that, okay, Activity Pub is here, a bunch of people are using it, a lot of people are using it, we'll stick to it and we'll make it better. And you can make it better because you can extend
57:57 Speaker 05 it. It's a technology that can be extended. There are these basic concepts, basic semantics, but if there's something that doesn't map onto those semantics, you can add them progressively on top of it for new features, for new concepts. And then other people that that interoperate with you can decide, okay, well, we want to display that information in our app as well, so we'll start supporting that.
58:24 Speaker 03 We have to take one more quick break. When we come back, ask Eugen about Mastodon's big selling point: governance. I mean it. It's the selling point. Stick around.
58:35 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
58:44 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
58:52 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
59:06 Speaker 06 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
59:34 Speaker 03 We're back with Eugene Rocha.
59:38 Speaker 03 I've wanted to ask this set of questions because I'm very curious how it works and how you think about making it work. The technology and how you personally think about who might use it and why? All that is based on the central notion that one company should not be in charge of social networking, right? That you should not have a Twitter or you should not have a Facebook or even a YouTube or whatever that is just sort of in control of how we express ourselves online. I ask those questions because I never really hear people ask you the questions. I hear people ask about the next set of things, which is content moderation. But I feel like you can't quite understand the content moderation aspect of Mastodon without understanding the governance of the protocol. But now I have to talk about content moderation.
1:00:23 Speaker 03 The point of this, as far as I can tell, is that you don't think one person should be in charge of content moderation. Yes. So anybody can start a server. They can impose any rules they want. Some of those rules can be very strict. Some of them can be very permissive. There's no central place to impose rules from your perspective.
1:00:43 Speaker 05 Yes, exactly.
1:00:44 Speaker 03 As you come to a place where Mastodon socially comes to the default, do you feel any burden to change the content moderation rules for the default server?
1:00:52 Speaker 05 I wouldn't say that there are any issues with the rules that we have right now that we have identified. For the most part, our users are happy and our moderation load is bearable. We have a bunch of paid moderators working on our server and, you know, as it grows, it will expand further and further, obviously. I mean, the moderation team. But in the sense of rules, I think it's quite fair to keep them as they are. They are on the safe side of the gradient between, you know, permissive and safe, but not too restrictive.
1:01:34 Speaker 05 And I think it's a good balance that we've stricken over the experience of, well, seven years of running that server.
1:01:42 Speaker 03 As you grow, this is the challenge, though. Small communities are relatively self-sustaining, self-moderating to extent. As they scale, things get out of control very quickly, right? And people start doing very bad things very quickly. We have written about the challenges that moderators face on scaled social platforms for years now. Is that a set of challenges that you're facing where people are doing the worst possible things with your service? Are you, do you have automated tools? How does that work for you?
1:02:12 Speaker 05 I would say that we were lucky enough that due to our smaller size, we haven't had to deal with the kind of horribleness that, let's say, Facebook moderators have to deal with.
1:02:26 Speaker 05 It's honestly, most of our reports are either just, you know, generic spam or people being mean to each other. It's not the horrible stuff that Facebook moderators need therapy for. So in that sense, we've been lucky. To answer your question on automation, we...
1:02:45 Speaker 05 Have avoided automation so far because we believe in the personal approach. And what allows this personal approach is the decentralization and the different size constraints. Right. First of all, back in regards to the rules, right? It is actually quite liberating in a sense to have this decentralized network. Because you can say, okay, these are the rules of the service that we offer. And if you're not okay with it.
1:03:14 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:03:14 Speaker 05 That's fine, because you can go somewhere else where what you want is allowed. Or you can just run it your own. We don't have any obligation to, you know, allow you to post this or that. If you can just do it yourself on your own money, right?
1:03:28 Speaker 03 And I just want to point out that this is a hypothesis that has never been tested. Right. That if you give people a choice of moderation regimes, that they will pick one that offers the most safety and they won't pick one that has the horribleness. Because right now, everything is so centralized. So this is like a large scale test to see if that the sort of market based version of content moderation actually succeeds the way people have always said it would.
1:03:54 Speaker 05 Yeah. So going from that point to back to moderation. This decentralized system also allows to share some of the load of the moderation burden between completely different systems and completely different organizations. Right. If you count a person running a server as basically moderator, then the lower bound of the number of moderators and the federators is something like over nine thousand or 10,000, because that's the number of servers that there are. And of course, you know, for the single person servers out there, it doesn't really matter because they're just, you know, as I said, they're not really moderating. They're just running their own personal platform. But for all these communities.
1:04:39 Speaker 05 You know, if you have 20 people and one moderator, that's a much higher ratio of users to moderators than on any other commercial social media platform. Right? And this decreases the moderation burden for everybody because for the most part, people take care of, you know, the rule breakers on their own servers. And then, you know, the other moderator doesn't have to deal with it.
1:05:06 Speaker 03 But this leads to challenges, right? Because what you want is a megaphone, right? You, you, when you're a writer on Medium and you write the thing and you post it to the Medium Mastodon instance, you're not trying to get to 20 other Medium writers, right? You're hopefully trying to address millions of people who follow you across Mastodon instances. And they all might have different rules. And if you write about some hot button issue that breaks a bunch of rules, right? You won't actually reach all those people. But those communities also have to moderate themselves. And so you kind of end up at a place where it, the, it's harder to know what is going to happen because there are so many fragmented rules as opposed to I'm just mad at YouTube all the time
1:05:50 Speaker 03 because YouTube is too opaque. Like, I'm wondering if you see a balance there that actually results in something different. Right? Because right now, I think the frustration most people have is they don't know what's going to happen.
1:06:03 Speaker 05 I would say that content moderation is one of the hardest problems in social media. There is no denying that. You know, we can, we can add features, we can remove features, we can improve, you know, how a button looks or whatever. Content moderation is always going to be at the core and center of, you know, what, what makes a social media platform work. So, yeah, it is complicated. But to counter your point, if you publish something about some hot button issue that a lot of people will disagree with, They might not see it, even if you, you know, have a centralized service where, you know, everything is allowed, because they'll block you, because they'll filter out the word, because
1:06:45 Speaker 05 they'll, they'll use a blacklist that they've made themselves and share around. That sort of thing is not unique to the federers and to the decentralized system of moderation. If, for whatever reason, you get blocked by a server of like 20 people, right? Well, that's part of it. Just imagine you were blocked by 20 people for, you know, writing that issue. Now, I'm not saying that everything is perfect, because, for example, I think that there needs to be more transparency for users about what is happening with moderation on their servers, you know? I don't think it's great that your admin can make a decision
1:07:28 Speaker 05 to block another server and then suddenly you lose a bunch of followers without knowing about it. I, I, I think that we need to build, you know, some kind of notification system into it that will tell you, okay, your admin has made the decision to block the server, you've lost this amount of followers. If you disagree with this, here's what you can do, right? As long as you have that, then people can, again, move to a better server, start their own. Nobody really suffers, right?
1:07:56 Speaker 03 So I, I agree with you. I think content moderation is the most complicated part of operating a social network. My thesis is that it is fundamentally the product, right? In a way that any Mastodon instance with its different set of content moderation rules is only distinguished from the next Mastodon server because it has slightly different rules or a slightly different community, right? And that community might self-enforce those rules. What I'm curious about is moderation is the cost, right? Even beyond server costs or whatever, moderation and legal compliance, as your community scales, becomes a cost that is almost unbearable, except for the largest companies in the world. So Facebook has to run moderation services across the world. They have to be in legal compliance across the world.
1:08:41 Speaker 03 Right now, as we speak, there is a Supreme Court case being heard about Section 230 and Google's recommendation algorithm on YouTube. I don't know how that's going to go. I can point to two specific Mastodon examples, right? The Financial Times, I think, started a Mastodon instance and shut it down within days, saying, "Okay, just the legal compliance costs of running this server are too high for us." And the other one that was much funnier than that, I think it was a Harry Potter server shut itself down because there was an argument about Harry Potter and the community got out of control. And there's like, there's like a lot of arguments about Harry Potter. That community is just like fully out of control right now. But you can see, okay, I start a server, it gets moderately popular.
1:09:25 Speaker 03 And suddenly, as an administrator, my costs, both in money, in time, in legal fees, whatever it is, just start to skyrocket in a nonlinear way to my user base or my activity or my financial return. Is there a way for you at the protocol level, at the governance level, to bring that back in line? Or is that, well, someone's going to have to figure out how to monetize this to make those costs work out?
1:09:49 Speaker 05 Well, first, to address the Financial Times. I think they made the fundamental mistake of trying to run a public server instead of just running a server for their own journalists and people who work for the Financial Times. Because the moderation load, even the technical investment required is completely different for these models. And I'm not going to recommend everyone to start a public Mastodon server and just start, you know, accepting registrations from the public and get like thousands and thousands of users, because it is a huge responsibility. It is a responsibility. It comes with a cost. It comes with potential liabilities. It's not easy. But is it easy to start a social network from scratch? No, it is not. It is absolutely not. Imagine starting something like Twitter completely from scratch.
1:10:34 Speaker 05 Mastodon is what allows you to do that, if you want to do it. It's a shortcut to starting your own Twitter. For the public, if you want, but you know, it comes with all of the costs and problems and risks of running a public service like that. Now, if you run it just for yourself, because you're an author, you're a blogger, you're a publisher, if you just wanna, you know, if you're just an enthusiast and you wanna consume content from other people on your own terms, you know, it's a completely different model, because no, you're not really liable for anything, it's just for yourself, you're not really risking much, and it doesn't cost a lot, and you don't need to think about moderating or hiring moderators or whatever.
1:11:16 Speaker 05 For the servers that do run publicly and then accept registrations from the public, yes, moderation comes at a cost. Now, of course, as I mentioned before, the cost of moderation and the burden of moderation is shared across the entire network, and it is a lot lower than if a single company was doing it for millions and billions of users, right? If all you have to manage is a community of, let's say, even 5,000 people, unless you have a lot of churn, which means if you have a lot of new people joining all the time, for the most part, the people that you have on your server will be well behaved, because
1:11:58 Speaker 05 the bad ones will already have broken the rules and be suspended, you know?
1:12:02 Speaker 03 Can I push you on this?
1:12:03 Speaker 05 Yeah.
1:12:04 Speaker 03 This is what I believe the same thing that you believe, but I'm not the CEO of Mastodon. Do you have data that says that is actually true? Because I feel like that is the lived experience of being on the internet, that if your community is small, it will self-regulate, and then it gets big and it goes nuts. But if I'm making this bet, I would want to know that that's true. And I could provide you anecdotal counterfactuals, right? I could say, you look at Reddit, Reddit is a history of small communities fracturing into rival subreddits, and that will go on for infinity. So is this something that you believe? Is this something that you know? Is this something that you can measure?
1:12:41 Speaker 05 Well, it's based on my experience running Mastodon Social and the moderation loads that we get. I mean, most of the reports that come to us are usually about people who have just signed up, and they're people that don't belong here, like the people who don't... Actually agree with our rules and who who break them straight away. And during times when we had closed registrations, the load on our moderation team was a lot, a lot lower. Because for the most part, you know, it's quite straightforward, really. You know, the the people who break rules, they show themselves like very quickly. They get banned. And then there's nobody left to break the rules. Right?
1:13:23 Speaker 05 So I I feel like people overestimate sometimes the burden, the the amount of reports, the amount of of moderation necessary that comes with a specific server size, the specific amount of users. Because most people don't regularly break the rules. It is still a minority of of of people who do that, a minority of cases where it happens. And it only increases when you have lots of new people coming in and possibly, you know, if if you have like, you know, a troll army that decided to make a bunch of accounts, you know, that can make the numbers go up. But otherwise, it's been quite manageable so far, really.
1:14:03 Speaker 03 As you look across the spectrum of Mastodon instances, do you actually see a a diversity of rules? Do you see that, OK, there are, there's a spectrum and we have the most permissive sites and the least permissive sites?
1:14:16 Speaker 05 There is a spectrum, but I think for the most part, the majority of the servers that run Mastodon today have agreed on a certain set of of rules. Probably because a lot of them have been inspired by Mastodon Social and our rules originally. So there is a lot of overlap. Some are a bit more restrictive about specific things, like, for example, content warnings or um the kind of self-promotion that you can do, whether you can run an account as a company, as a brand versus as a natural person. That sort of thing, sometimes people get restricted with it.
1:14:57 Speaker 05 You know, obviously, there is a side to the Fediverse that is completely on the opposite side towards permissive and, you know, everything goes, free speech, everything. And for the most part, it is, you know, ostracized and and and distanced from from the the previous side. So there's a lot of different approaches exist out there.
1:15:20 Speaker 03 And do you see that? Are they growing in parallel? Is one growing faster than the other? How is that playing out?
1:15:27 Speaker 05 I believe that our part grows faster because they get traffic from joinmasteron.org, right, our official website and our official apps. So that helps.
1:15:38 Speaker 03 Do you worry that the sort of other side, the most permissive libertarian side is going to say, this is unfair. You need to list our servers as a default as well?
1:15:47 Speaker 05 Well, there is no real obligation for us to link to anybody really. So it's, you know, it's just sometimes, yeah, I get people very upset with me for not giving them a free link from our official website. But we're not really obligated to provide a link to anyone. And we just do it to make the signing up process easier for end users. And we're only going to link to a place if we think that people are going to be safe there and they're going to have a good time. And if your server is allowing everything and all types of, you know, language that is completely inappropriate, then, you know, they're not going to be safe there and we're not going to send them there. So there's that.
1:16:30 Speaker 03 Eugene, you've given us a ton of extra time. I want to say thank you. I'm very excited to see where Mastodon goes. I did sign up over the weekend. Decoder listeners know I took a break from Twitter-like networks to heal my brain after 10 years. But I signed up for Mastodon social, so I'm excited to use the product. I have two feature requests for you. One, it's slow. Can you make it faster?
1:16:50 Speaker 05 Yes, I think so. That would normally be not a software problem, but an infrastructure problem, something specific to Mastodon social. And honestly, depending on when you access it, it could have been a DDoS attack because, you know, that that happened. And just last night, I was looking into a traffic spike, seven times higher traffic than usual that was causing a lot of errors to appear. So, you know, if you're complaining about slowness, it could be that. And I would be happy to report that we are upgrading our infrastructure completely from what we were using before. And, you know, our infrastructure for Mastodon
1:17:33 Speaker 05 social, it basically grew out from a single box originally in, you know, in 2016. We moved providers, I say we, back then it was just me. I moved providers quite a few times during seven years, you know, from Trying to remember where our original box was, probably Digital Auction, actually. Um, we've tried using Scaleway, then eventually moved to Hetzner, the German hosting company where we are right now. But basically, it grew out of a single box into basically a cluster of fifteen or twenty different machines, manually managed by me. And right now, we're upgrading to using Kubernetes.
1:18:14 Speaker 05 And, you know, that simplifies a lot of the scaling significantly from, you know, where it would take half a day to set up a new machine. It's like, okay, it's a couple clicks, a couple of keyboard button presses, and, you know, you have the capacity for a lot more traffic than you had before. So, in that sense, and plus having, you know, a DevOps person on the case, it will hopefully improve the speed by a lot.
1:18:43 Speaker 03 Second feature request, and I'm actually curious if you feel the pressure to look and feel more like Twitter now than before. My second feature request is just to quote tweets. I often want to just like quote tweet someone from the verge and say, "This is great. Look at this." And I know that you're opposed to it, but is it...
1:18:59 Speaker 05 We could do a whole episode about quote tweets. Yeah, I can just, you know, if I start talking about it now, if I start describing, like, the history of the, you know, and the positions that people have on this feature. But I'll keep myself short, and I'll say, "We have a public roadmap on our website, and quote posts are under the exploring section of that roadmap."
1:19:24 Speaker 03 The most complicated section of all.
1:19:27 Speaker 05 It means that we're looking into it, and, you know, hopefully we'll bring you quote posts.
1:19:32 Speaker 03 I like it. What's next for Mastodon? What should people be on the lookout for next?
1:19:36 Speaker 05 Groups, probably. That's a big one, big feature coming. It's, well, it's what you would expect. Facebook has groups, Twitter has communities, and Mastodon will have groups as well, so.
1:19:47 Speaker 03 Very good. Yuzen, thank you so much for being on Decoder. We'll have to have you back soon.
1:19:50 Speaker 05 Thank you, and have a good day.
1:19:55 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Eugene Rochko for taking the time to talk today, and thank you for listening to Decoder. I hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of the show. You can email us at decoder@theverge.com, or hit us up directly on Twitter or TikTok, we're at DecoderPod. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like that show, hit us with that five-star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. It was produced by Creighton DeSimone and Jackie McDermott. It was edited by Kelly Wright. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our editorial director is Brooke Minters, and our executive director is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
1:20:35 Speaker 07 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple Conducted Study of Heart Rate Accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
1:21:05 Speaker 08 I work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know. I've made things a little difficult in the past. Okay, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG, and finally, I understand. Now I'm making work work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, Pay, and Workforce Management.
Previous Why would anyone make a website in 2023? Squarespace CEO Anthony Casalena has some ideas Next There's no AI without the cloud, says AWS CEO Adam Selipsky Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated