Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki (Live at Code Media 2018) About this episode YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki talks with Recode's Kara Swisher at the 2018 Code Media conference in Huntington Beach, Calif. She explains why YouTube opted not to ban one of its stars, Logan Paul, despite a recent string of controviersies including a video he filmed of a dead body in Japan. She also talks about how the site has dealt with revelations of Russian political meddling, why it still doesn't see itself as a media company and what she thinks of rivals like Facebook that are pushing more and more into video: "They should get back to baby pictures."
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 7,878 words · 12 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by Qualcomm. At Qualcomm, inventing comes first. The rest of the world innovates on top of Qualcomm's foundational inventions. To learn more, visit qualcomm.com/WeInvent. Today's show is brought to you by IARPA's Hybrid Forecasting Competition. Sometimes, ordinary people can predict the future better than the experts. Now is your chance to find out if you can superforecast. In this competition, thousands of participants will produce geopolitical forecasts with help from cutting-edge artificial intelligence, algorithms, and crowdsourcing. Registration is open for a limited time. Learn more at hybridforecasting.com.
0:44 Speaker 00 That's hybridforecasting.com. Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, coming to you from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcasts for more. Today, we're going to play an interview I conducted at the 2018 Code Media Conference. Let's take a listen. So, we've had a lot of interviews lately. In the past month, I came to YouTube.
1:27 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:28 Speaker 00 You interviewed me.
1:29 Speaker 01 Yes, that was a lot of fun.
1:30 Speaker 00 That was a lot of fun, and we're going to talk about that a little bit. And then I interviewed you on the TV show, and now we're here. So, let's just go right into it.
1:37 Speaker 01 Sure.
1:38 Speaker 00 I'm going to start. One thing we didn't talk about on the TV thing, and we did talk a little bit at YouTube, was Logan Paul. And I'm using him as an example of just awfulness on your platform. So, why don't you just... You have... Explain what you've done, and I'd really like to understand why you haven't absolutely kicked him off your platform.
2:00 Speaker 01 Yeah.
2:05 Speaker 02 Well, to start, our platform is, has three main constituents. It has our users, our creators, and our advertisers. And what we've seen is that if there is someone on our platform, our creator, who does something really awful, or any kind of egregious behavior, that affects everybody. And so with Logan Paul, we've actually taken two actions. The first was a removal from our premium monetization, and then a hold of all of the original shows.
2:40 Speaker 01 Right.
2:41 Speaker 02 And then, due to more, a pattern of really egregious behavior, we decided to suspend monetization of his.
2:52 Speaker 01 Right.
2:53 Speaker 02 Now, we think that's actually a pretty strong statement in itself. And then, more, like, just to get away from him as an individual, and talk about the platform as a whole, we actually, on Friday, announced the fact that we were going to have a new set of, kind of a code, for our creators who do egregious actions, in terms of removal of premium monetization, that they could be removed from services, they could even be removed from trending, and watch next, and other areas. And we felt like that was really important, to be able to maintain the responsibility on our platform of...
3:32 Speaker 01 But again, why not just throw them off? Like, what is, where is the, like, you have, how many children? Eighty-three children, right, at this point? You have a lot of kids. If, once they do things, you, you...
3:44 Speaker 02 I'm not sure children is the best analogy. Because like, you do want to keep your children.
3:49 Speaker 01 Yes.
3:49 Speaker 02 But, but, right? Like, I wouldn't want to throw them out if they do something bad. But, I hear you on this point. And, I mean, look, we do terminate accounts all the time.
3:58 Speaker 01 Right.
3:58 Speaker 02 So we do have a three-strikes rule. And if somebody violates three times, then we actually, we terminate those accounts. And we do that all the time. And we always try, when we think about our actions, to make sure that we're being consistent. And, but whatever we're doing, we're applying...
4:12 Speaker 01 I think a lot of people complain that you're not consistent.
4:13 Speaker 02 No, we, well, we, they might complain about that, but we try our very best to be consistent across everybody.
4:20 Speaker 01 Okay.
4:21 Speaker 02 And when someone does violate our strike, if they have three strikes, then yes, we terminate that.
4:27 Speaker 01 Right.
4:28 Speaker 02 The problem is when someone will do something that is egregious, but it doesn't fully violate the policy, or they get, you know, one strike, but not three strikes. And so that was actually why this announcement that we had on Friday, we thought was really important, is it does give us a lot more levers and opportunities to be able to implement and pull back any kind of services for creators if they are violating or doing something egregious on our platform. But basically, to answer your question, he hasn't done anything that would cause those three strikes. And so we can't just be pulling people off of our platform. If we did just pull people off of our platform, because...
5:09 Speaker 01 They're tasteless and vile.
5:12 Speaker 02 Well, they need to violate a policy, and we need to have consistent behavior. I mean, this is like a code of law.
5:20 Speaker 01 Let's get to that. Why don't you... You can always... You're Google, you can change the rules, right? Like, you can just say, "Now we're doing this."
5:29 Speaker 02 Yes, but like, what you think is tasteless is not necessarily what someone else would see as tasteless. And so I'm just saying, we need to have consistent laws, codify that in our policies, so that that can be trained and we comply consistently to millions of videos and millions of creators.
5:45 Speaker 01 That gets the idea, and you and I talked about this. I'm not trying to give you a hard time. It's just like, you're running, what is essentially... Do you think you're running a media company?
5:56 Speaker 02 Well, we are a technology platform, but the output of our product is media.
6:02 Speaker 01 But are you a new kind of media company? Would you even accept that? Because I think it's not just you, and I think Facebook is even worse. They run away from the idea of themselves as a media company. And I think I know why. Because then you have to impose values, right? We talked about this when we were at YouTube. And I think my argument to you was, at some point, you have to have a set of values. And that's it? Like you, and you don't, people don't want to pick values because then you have to make choices, really hard choices.
6:27 Speaker 02 Well, so we do want to have, we do have values. And we always have had community guidelines. And we've always said, these are the behavior that we think is not appropriate.
6:36 Speaker 01 Right.
6:36 Speaker 02 And so, we look at what people do. And if they, again, if they violate those policies three times, we kick them off the platform. We terminate accounts all the time. And there are many people who think they should not have been terminated.
6:48 Speaker 01 Give me an example of someone, three, what have they done?
6:51 Speaker 02 Oh, there are a lot, I mean, there are lots of things. So, you know, promoting, promotion of drugs, promotion of hate, violent activities, releasing people's private information, adult content. I mean, there are a million way, and we outline this on our site. These are all of the different guidelines, both to be part of our community. And we outline very clearly the strikes. So, you know, if someone does something that is really distasteful, we look and say, is this distasteful or did it violate a policy?
7:32 Speaker 01 Right.
7:32 Speaker 02 And we can change the policy. And we constantly are changing and we constantly are updating these policies.
7:38 Speaker 01 Do you ever imagine that distasteful is enough? Because here you are, I think you're building a media company, I think you have a media company. And so, it seems to me that every week, you're just going to have, you're going to open a drawer and there's going to be another horror show for you, like no matter what. Because you can't, you must be like, oh, Jesus. I think one of your employees actually came up to me and said, it used to be all squirrels and cats. And now it's a college ethics debate every week at YouTube. Like, it's like, should we do this, should we do that? What do you do when you have this much power over people's communications? And yet...
8:13 Speaker 01 Well, you don't want to kick people off. We want to be a platform or a benign platform is how I think you all look at it.
8:20 Speaker 02 So first of all, we want to be fair, right? So you're saying like, this is distasteful, this is horrible. And you know what? The thing is, we need to codify what we see as distasteful in our policies. And then we need to have that be very clear for, so that we're not just saying, oh, look, this is distasteful and kicking it off of the platform. And then I think the other thing we need to do is consult also with experts, too. So we're starting to do a lot more of understanding, you know, sort of where do we draw these lines? And also remember, we're a global platform. And so we might have different values here in the US, but then you go to India or Thailand or Vietnam, and they have a different set of values. And so we also have to be sensitive to those areas.
9:02 Speaker 02 So we think that having those values is very important. And that's actually why we felt like on Friday, when we announced the fact that now we had a new set of services and benefits and privileges that we could tell creators ahead of time, look, if you do something egregious on our platform, these are the things that can be removed. And they always knew that they could have their account terminated.
9:26 Speaker 01 Right, right. But essentially, what you're doing is slowly suffocating them. I mean, that's, you know, yes.
9:31 Speaker 02 No, we're not, no, we're not so, no.
9:33 Speaker 01 Quickly suffocating them. No, what? Well, you take away the monetization.
9:38 Speaker 02 Taking away the monetization is really powerful in itself. Because, look, that's, it's a business. And so, but, and if some, there are, you know, content that we will remove if it violates our policies, and again, if they're through strikes, we'll...
9:54 Speaker 01 So how you do this? One of the things, you guys just hired 10,000, is that 10,000 people?
9:59 Speaker 02 Right, so we're in the process of having 10,000 people that will be looking at controversial content at Google.
10:09 Speaker 01 To get faster. Now, as I said to you when I was interviewing you recently, like, you need a million people for the, how many trillions of videos are every five seconds? Or it's some enormous number.
10:19 Speaker 02 We have 400 hours uploaded every minute.
10:21 Speaker 01 Every minute, which is a lot.
10:23 Speaker 02 Yes, it's a lot.
10:24 Speaker 01 That's a lot of work for 10,000 people.
10:26 Speaker 02 Yes. Luckily, it's not all being done by people.
10:29 Speaker 01 So you're going to do some with computers and AI and...
10:32 Speaker 02 Yes.
10:33 Speaker 01 So where is that in the, how do you feel about that? Because again, that's, the combination is still probably not enough, correct, or not?
10:42 Speaker 02 Well, we think that that the combination of that many people and the machines will really help us to be able to manage a content on our platform. And if it's not, then we will add more people and we'll also add more machines. Okay. And it's really important to have both because the people train the machines, the machines do that work at scale, and then the machine and then the humans double check the work of the machines.
11:08 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by Qualcomm. At Qualcomm, inventing comes first. When they connected the phone to the internet, Qualcomm's foundational inventions created the mobile revolution. And now, as Qualcomm leads the world to 5G, their inventions will enable new industries and the next great product the world can't live without. Qualcomm is inventing the tech the world loves. To learn more, visit qualcomm.com/WeInvent.
11:38 Speaker 00 I also want to tell you about Too Embarrassed to Ask, my other podcast, which I host with Lauren Good from The Verge.
11:43 Speaker 03 That's me.
11:44 Speaker 00 Every Friday, we answer your questions about consumer tech. Lauren, what did we talk about last week?
11:49 Speaker 03 We talked about how it's impossible for you to put down your phone during the duration of our podcast thing.
11:54 Speaker 00 You know what? I am an important person.
11:56 Speaker 03 Because you are addicted to tech, just like everybody else we know these days. We talked about tech addiction, compulsion, obsession, lots of different terms for it. But this idea that we, as human beings, are getting very, very, very attached to our devices, but also some of the companies that make the devices and applications we use are designing them in such a way that we can't put them down.
12:16 Speaker 00 We can't. Slot machine of attention. It's like being at a, you know, you just want to click on the buttons constantly.
12:22 Speaker 03 You want to just click on the buttons. So we talked to a lot of really smart people at this week's Code Media Conference. We asked them about their tech obsessions and their tips and tricks for how to break those habits.
12:32 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's really important. It's going to be a big topic over the next year, and it's something tech companies really are going to need to face. All joking aside, it's important for our society of how we handle this amazing group of innovations and how we use them responsibly. It was a great discussion, and we hope you go listen to it. You can find Too Embarrassed to Ask on Apple Podcasts, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. That's Too Embarrassed to Ask. See you there.
12:54 Speaker 01 All right, so the other controversy obviously you got into, and then we'll move on to your other businesses, but controversies are so much fun, and you're very good support for it, Russia stuff. What have you been doing to ensure, obviously Facebook has gotten into more trouble for this, and Twitter, but what have you guys doing to ensure that this doesn't happen again? Again, is this a machine thing, a people thing? What happened there from your perspective?
13:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, well, we're, we've looked really carefully at this, and we talked about this before, but we, from our analysis of YouTube, what we've seen is there was a small set of ads, less than 5,000, and about 1,000 videos that all had relatively low view counts. So, you know, first of all, we are, you know, once we're aware of something, we can certainly look for that, identify that content, and remove that content. But the other thing that we have made as a change is requiring anything, any kind of news that is state-sponsored to be labeled.
14:02 Speaker 02 This is who is funding this content, and we're actually doing this across all state-sponsored news globally. So whoever is providing the funding for it, it will now be labeled that way.
14:14 Speaker 01 Right, and then, and are you worried about these next elections, or how are you, what are you doing specifically for the midterm elections, or even the next presidential election here in this country?
14:25 Speaker 02 Well, we think we're, I mean, we think it's something really serious and important to be focused on and understanding, and so, you know, I think from our, our systems of detection and looking at abuse, you know, these are all areas where we're certainly looking for that type of content, and we're focused on the transparency component, and then I'm sure we're taking a number of steps too, from an advertising perspective, to make sure that we have the right set of rules and regulations around that.
14:54 Speaker 01 So getting into advertising, just yesterday, Keith Weed, is that from Unilever, was talking about that idea of not wanting to advertise, and you have gotten a lot of, not you in particular, but YouTube and other companies, of not wanting to be adjacent to What has been problematic for a lot of these advertisers. How do you address that idea? They really, and I know you all got attacked at Davos by George Soros, et cetera. Like, sort of, tech has been the punching bag for everyone now. How do you look at that? And do you differentiate yourself from Facebook and Twitter? Or are you all on the same troublesome boat?
15:32 Speaker 02 Well, we see a lot of value. I mean, I think there's some, there's some issues that we all are looking at and we're thinking about how can we do better? And we're taking them seriously, like news, for example. But I also think YouTube is different in the sense that it is a, first of all, it's a video platform. And it's got a lot of really incredible information that people use all over the world from an entertainment perspective to an education perspective. And actually, I was surprised to see that we do a billion views a day of just educational material. And so the how-to content is really an important area. And, but back to Keith Weed and to advertisers. I mean, we take their feedback very seriously.
16:17 Speaker 02 We're an advertising-supported platform. We want to do the right set of things to build their trust. They're building brands on YouTube. We want to make sure that our brand is a place where they want to build their brand. And we've made a number of changes based on the feedback that we have with them. For example, our Google Preferred lineup is going to be all curated now by, and reviewed by humans. The second thing that we're doing is we made changes to how our partner program works. So at the beginning of last year, actually, anyone could be in the partner program. Then we made a change to 10,000 lifetime views last year. And then most recently, we changed it to having to have 1,000 subscribers
16:59 Speaker 02 and 4,000 watch hours within a 12-month period. And so those are all examples of where we're making really significant changes because we want to be able to work with advertisers and make sure that they can come back to our platform and feel comfortable. And also provide the right set of tools and options for them to be able to be on the type of content they want. Because not all advertisers are the same. Some are like, we're very brand-sensitive. And some are saying, you know what? We're more focused on direct response. And we're OK with content being a little edgier.
17:27 Speaker 01 But do you worry about that? And what is it within the ethos? You've been in Silicon Valley forever.
17:33 Speaker 02 Sure.
17:33 Speaker 01 Is there an ethos in Silicon Valley where they've let this go? I mean, I think, you know, I've called, I love Twitter, but it's a cesspool. Let's be, you know, you're swimming in a cesspool essentially. And that's just my tweets. But it seems like Silicon Valley is, very much doesn't want to address that idea of growing up. Do you think that's fair or not, some of the recent criticism?
17:57 Speaker 02 I mean, I feel like this year, we've been really focused on growing up. And we have, I mean, Google is, how old is it? 19 years old? 18, 19 years old? And, you know, it's been an evolution, but I think the issues that we're seeing this year are very, are significant, and we take them seriously, and we feel we have responsibility. And we are working really hard to figure out, how do we address them? How do we build better solutions for, you know, all the different issues?
18:29 Speaker 01 Why has that taken so long? Because I often find, I deal with people, and they don't understand their power, nor do they want to take the responsibility. That seems to be a persistent issue for a long time now. Or do you not agree with that? You may not agree with that.
18:44 Speaker 02 I mean, we're a platform, and when you're a platform, you, and one of the great things that we've done is we've enabled so much new types of content. We've enabled all these voices that before never had an audience. We talk about the diversity of audience, the diversity of content, all these wonderful benefits that have come out of having an open platform. And so, yes, we take the responsibility really seriously, but if you're gonna say, we're gonna go above and beyond the law, and we're actually gonna say, here are these guidelines, and we're gonna outline all of these guidelines, like, you know, it's really important to figure out, where are you drawing that line?
19:23 Speaker 01 Right.
19:24 Speaker 02 And you can imagine, like, you know, there is this continuum, right? On one side is censorship, and on the other side is too much freedom of speech. And so, you want to draw the line in a place that is the right place, where you're enabling the, you know, great discussion, healthy discussion, healthy points of view. But you can also go too far and censor content that really is important for the world to see. And it's a complicated and very nuanced place where that line is drawn. And I think that's one of the reasons has platforms that have really encouraged freedom of speech and encouraged openness and open source and all these, you know, all the amazing things that the web has done, figuring out, oh, we're going to draw the line here. It's a complicated, and so it has to be done really delicately.
20:09 Speaker 01 Yes, I get that. I get that. But sometimes they really don't want to draw the line at all, that they don't want, and have done very well financially not doing that.
20:16 Speaker 02 Well, we've always had community guidelines. We've always drawn that line somewhere because we have hosted content. And as a result, I think that actually has got, that served us relatively well. You know, and we had a period of flags and users reviewed the, you know, any user can flag a content and then it's reviewed by a set of our reviewers. But I think what has happened is in the last year, the world has gotten more complicated, has gotten more divisive.
20:43 Speaker 01 Yes.
20:44 Speaker 02 Also, like, we have gotten bigger and the combination of all of these things coming together have meant that we need to go back, we need to look at our policies, we need to revise them. And look, it's really complicated. Like, where do you draw the line? How do you define, you know, what types of, what types of, you know, certain type of product, like harmful, like, you know, guns, for example? Like, where do you draw those lines?
21:10 Speaker 01 You know, if you hired me, I could draw the lines. But, okay.
21:13 Speaker 02 No, I'm sure, I'm sure if we hired you, you couldn't draw the line.
21:16 Speaker 01 Oh, I could.
21:17 Speaker 02 No.
21:18 Speaker 01 Oh, I draw lines.
21:19 Speaker 02 You do draw lines. But I think the thing that we've learned is one person alone is not enough to draw a line. What you really need is you need to go to the experts, you need to talk to the experts, you need to understand, you know, how to do this delicately. And then every country, remember, like, we're global. And so we have to do this in all of these different countries.
21:37 Speaker 01 All right, I'm going to move on to other things. You're professional, I'm sorry to harangue you about this, but I'm not, I'm sorry.
21:41 Speaker 02 But we do take it very seriously, and I just wanted to make sure we communicate.
21:45 Speaker 01 I do get that. Your other content, professional content, you have a lot of different services. Can you sort them out for me? Because you have the live, you've got Red, you've got... Where do you... How are you looking at the professional content you're creating? Do you see yourself getting into a business? Like, I think Apple just paid an enormous amount of money for the Reese Witherspoon Nicole Kidman show. Are you gonna wade into that? You guys have been a little... With your originals, a little smaller? You hired an MTV executive. How do you look at that as a CEO?
22:17 Speaker 02 So, we have two different services. We have YouTube Red.
22:22 Speaker 01 Right.
22:22 Speaker 02 And then, we have YouTube TV. And YouTube Red is a service that is really a music service. We have an amazing collection of music. We have all these music videos. And then, on top of that, it has the ability to watch all of YouTube ads-free with the background and offline services. And then, on top of that, we've actually been doing a number of YouTube originals. So, we've done about 50 YouTube originals.
22:48 Speaker 01 Fifty?
22:48 Speaker 02 Yes. In the last... In the last two years. And we started out doing shows mostly with YouTube personalities. And we've expanded above and beyond that to doing more with music. For example, we did Demi Lovato, Simply Complicated, and we did this four-day live with Katy Perry. And then, we've actually also been doing more drama and other shows. So, for example, just last week, we announced that we were doing Step Up with Step Up High Water. So, we're doing something with Karate Kid. We're doing a number of different shows. And so, all of these shows are something that we're adding on top of this music service with Red.
23:33 Speaker 02 Then, we have YouTube TV, which is really a more... I'd say is the broadcasters with the YouTube and the online features, so that you can search everything. You can get the recommendations. You can store anything in our cloud DVR. And so, those are the two services that we have.
23:53 Speaker 01 So, what do you... How do you imagine spending the Netflix-level money? The billions and billions? Do you need to buy a Netflix? Or buy a Spotify or something like that? How do you look at that?
24:05 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, they're spending lots of billions of dollars.
24:07 Speaker 01 Yes.
24:08 Speaker 02 And, um...
24:09 Speaker 01 Lots. And you have a few yourself. You all have some billions available.
24:15 Speaker 02 Well, I think our goal is to continue to increase what we're doing. So as we are building that muscle of creating content, we'll continue to do more and more. And we'll see what's successful. We'll see what our users respond to, what's driving subscriptions, what's being watched. And I think one of the really amazing things about YouTube is the platform and the data that we have. So we can actually understand like how many shows went to completion, how many drove subscription, how many drove engagement. We can look on our platform and put out content for free, for the pilot, and see how people engaged in that. So we see that we have a billion and a half people coming to our site every month, and we can use that as a way to drive our users to our subscription products.
24:59 Speaker 01 But again, you all would have been in the position to do it Netflix or in Amazon. Amazon went deep, has gone deep into it. How do you, you imagine that a place where you've gotta go? Do you have to, you have to purchase that or just spend that in those billions of dollars? Do you see yourselves, is that in your plan to do that? I know you're testing it, but it's small for, especially for a company your size.
25:24 Speaker 02 Well, we're growing. And so far, we've been really pleased with that growth. And so, I mean, you need to start somewhere. And I think if you look at both Amazon and Netflix that are spending billions of dollars, you can't, you don't just start the ground running by spending billions of dollars. You have to start with a subscription, a number of users, and from there, you can build it up. The other thing, though, I would say is that, if you look at different content types, they have done, they being Amazon and Netflix, have done a really good job in the category of shows and movies. And if you look at content overall, there are many other areas of content. And YouTube has, and online, have brought new types of content that we just didn't have before on TV.
26:08 Speaker 02 So like I just talked about, educational content. A billion views a day of educational content. Music content. Content, vlogging content, gaming content. These are all health and beauty, wellness, like yoga.
26:22 Speaker 01 So you don't see yourself having like a giant show?
26:25 Speaker 02 Well, so.
26:26 Speaker 01 Maybe.
26:26 Speaker 02 Well, a giant, I mean, depends what you mean by a giant show, but like we see.
26:31 Speaker 01 I'd say House of Cards, we're not supposed to anymore, but House of Cards.
26:33 Speaker 02 Sure.
26:33 Speaker 01 For example.
26:35 Speaker 02 I mean, I mean, we could, but I'm not sure that would further necessarily what we're trying to do at YouTube. Where as like our goal is to be, you know, a large, you know, a leading video platform and have a large diverse set of content. And we feel like there are all these categories that no one else is really providing a solution to. And we can be best of breed there. The shows and movies is a very competitive space. It needs to be paid for economically with a subscription service. You can't just do the subscription service starting from zero. So we've been in red for about two years. We've been ramping up and I think you'll see us continue to ramp up and continue to do more content and continue to add content that appeals to our, our audiences.
27:14 Speaker 01 So what would a hit on YouTube look like to you then?
27:20 Speaker 02 Well, you know, I think a hit would be that we would see, um, you know, a lot of the critical acclaim that you see with a hit, we would see high engagement. Um, we would see, you know, millions of people watching it. So I think all of the traditional criteria.
27:38 Speaker 01 But not necessarily in shows and drama, that kind of thing?
27:41 Speaker 02 No, I was talking about with a show or drama. I mean, we have lots of shows today that have millions of subscribers and millions of views and hundreds of millions of views. So we have that all happening today. We just have that in the different categories. We have that in the categories I mentioned as opposed to a drama.
27:57 Speaker 01 Like a big hit, like Handmaid's Tale.
27:59 Speaker 02 To use your example.
28:00 Speaker 01 Something like that. Would you like to have had like a Handmaid's Tale on your service? Do you ever see doing something like that?
28:05 Speaker 02 Well, yeah, I think, I, sure, I mean, that would be great.
28:09 Speaker 01 Well, all it takes is money and giving it to Hollywood.
28:12 Speaker 02 Well, I, no, I, I, it does.
28:17 Speaker 02 I think you have to figure out like, well, what are you doing that's unique in that area? And what, how can you use the YouTube audience in a way that Netflix or Amazon are not using? And I think we tend to trend as a younger audience, we tend to trend music, for example. That's why something like Step Up was very popular on our platform. And, you know, also, we're global. So this year, you'll also see Red expand into many more countries. We're only in five countries right now. Now that we've finished all of our music deals, we're gonna actually be expanding to a large number of countries.
28:51 Speaker 01 How many countries?
28:53 Speaker 02 Many, like, I don't know, 100.
28:55 Speaker 01 100 countries. All right, last question, and then we'll get to some audience questions. Facebook.
29:02 Speaker 02 Yes.
29:02 Speaker 01 You and I have had this discussion for years. Facebook's coming for you, you're like, mm. You know, you always, and then you hang up on me. But they've been like, right.
29:10 Speaker 02 Do I do that now?
29:10 Speaker 01 No, no, no.
29:14 Speaker 01 Oh, Susan, you're gonna be talking to me for years to come. But we talk about that. I've called you a million times. Now, Facebook's gonna do it now. And Yahoo tried it for 14 seconds. Are you worried about them as a video platform in a competitive way?
29:33 Speaker 02 I mean, you always have to take your competitors seriously.
29:36 Speaker 01 Right.
29:36 Speaker 02 But you don't win by looking backwards and looking around. You win by looking forward and looking at your customers and figuring out, what do they want? How can I be better at what we do? And I look at YouTube and I look at the opportunity. And we have a really wonderful ecosystem. And so, you know, the priorities that we have for this year are some of the things that we talked about, like building trust among our advertisers and our creators, tightening our policies, building more engagement, increasing the creator, the ecosystem that we have with educational content. And so, we just see, we have this amazing platform, we wanna invest in that. And so, I don't know what Facebook is gonna do.
30:21 Speaker 01 What do you think they're doing?
30:22 Speaker 02 I don't know.
30:23 Speaker 01 Oh, come on, come on.
30:24 Speaker 02 I don't know what they're doing. I mean, you read the press and you, I read your articles about what they're doing. And I read their analyst reports and...
30:33 Speaker 01 What would you be worried about if they did?
30:36 Speaker 02 Well, I'm not sure I would tell you because then they would read it and then maybe do it. But, I mean, I-
30:43 Speaker 01 Make something up.
30:46 Speaker 02 No, I think they should focus on what they're focused on. I think they should get back to baby pictures and sharing.
30:54 Speaker 01 And the quote of the night. Thank you.
30:58 Speaker 02 No, I mean, look, I'm not an expert about Facebook and so, like, there are experts in it. And they should do what's best for their business. And, look, we should all compete for content. And I'm, I just don't, I build our business, I focus on what we need to do. I know we have a lot of things to do. And, I mean, you gave me, you can always remind me of all the things that we need to do.
31:28 Speaker 02 We're gonna keep doing them because that's the way we're gonna get stronger.
31:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, you're the CEO, that's why I remind you, just so you know.
31:34 Speaker 02 Yes.
31:34 Speaker 01 And I'm thrilled you are, by the way, the CEO of YouTube. Questions from the audience? Go ahead.
31:40 Speaker 04 Hi.
31:41 Speaker 02 Hi.
31:41 Speaker 04 My name is Roly Wynnlock, I'm from Webster.io. And we're a video platform for business. Tons of videos being produced on the platform. And they want these videos, from a business perspective, to be out there on multiple platforms doing great work. When I tell them that I had this one-on-one conversation with you, what can you, as the CEO of YouTube, tell me that I can tell all these companies? That is the future vision of YouTube for business? Not so much bloggers, entertainment, all those things?
32:10 Speaker 01 Yeah, that's a good question.
32:11 Speaker 02 Well, I'm really glad to hear you talk about that because I always feel this is a huge opportunity for businesses to have, in fact, I really think every business should have a YouTube page. Because they can talk about their products, they can talk about their services, and that's incredibly valuable. There's a lot of, anyone who's producing the brochure, anyone who's producing a how-to manual, anyone who has customer support, which is basically all companies in the world, could really benefit on having a YouTube channel and then pointing their users there. So, you know, our goal is to make it easier for businesses to be able to have pages, have YouTube channels, to create content, to connect with their users, and-
32:56 Speaker 02 You know, I would just encourage them to keep giving us the feedback that they need to do that job effectively.
33:01 Speaker 01 Right. We got only a few minutes, going to ask everybody. OK, go. OK, great. Quick, quick, quick.
33:07 Speaker 02 But great idea. I'm glad you're working on it.
33:10 Speaker 05 Hi, Susan. You're an inspiration to me as a business role model, but you're also an inspiration to my daughters. I have three of them. The nine-year-old, she uses YouTube as essentially her search engine. And obviously, the parent company, Google, is incredible at search. And the search always comes up good, even though there's a lot of crappy webpages on Google. When it comes to YouTube, and she watches kids-oriented videos, and then the recommended list comes up, there's some really disgusting stuff in there.
33:39 Speaker 01 Yeah, she and I have talked about this, this issue, the search problem.
33:43 Speaker 05 Yeah, it seems really bad, especially when it comes to kids. And my kid is well under 13. She's not supposed to be able to see this stuff, and she sees it all with her elementary school login, which is a Google-enabled login.
33:58 Speaker 01 So how can you make search better, Susan? You're owned by a company that's good at search.
34:03 Speaker 02 Yeah. Well, first of all, just for background, we have a YouTube Kids product. And so for everyone who's a parent in the room who's looking for YouTube or has questions about YouTube, I'd first point them to YouTube Kids. But then, to address the question about search and how to make that more, you know, to remove the recommendations that are inappropriate for your daughter, a couple of things. First of all, with search, we're working really hard to, depending upon the topic, to be able to default to whatever are the authoritative sources. That's especially important in a topic like news, to make sure that they're getting sources
34:45 Speaker 02 from whoever is authoritative in that space. And then, you know, we talked about the policies here, like also making sure that, you know, as we go through and figure out, like, what's the content that needs to be removed. So, you know, we're working through this content overall to make sure that we are making the right recommendations to users related to, you know, what their search is too. It's hard, without actually seeing it, it's hard for me to comment on any specific area. Like, we're working to make-
35:16 Speaker 05 It's within every kid's category. Kuya's George, Elsa, type it in.
35:20 Speaker 02 Yeah, you should.
35:20 Speaker 05 And you'll see some really gross stuff.
35:22 Speaker 02 Yeah.
35:22 Speaker 05 Peppa Pig.
35:23 Speaker 02 I agree with you. It's a problem. So, okay, well, so I'd ask when you've done that, because we've been very focused in that area, and actually removing that content or age-gating it. And so, if you have, I don't know if, like, if, when you looked at it last, but we have been very, very active in removing the content or age-gating it. So, and then when it's age-gated, it, like, shouldn't be recommended in that way. All right. Very quick, we've just got a few more.
35:46 Speaker 06 Hi, Dan Unger with Surfer. Susan, what are your thoughts about OTT in the next few years and where you-
35:52 Speaker 02 Yeah, big time.
35:52 Speaker 06 -as YouTube focusing?
35:54 Speaker 02 Well, I think OTT is a big area, and that's why we've been investing with the YouTube TV. I think the next generation of viewers is going to want to have the features of the search, the on-demand, mobile, cross-device, all of those, that functionality. And so, I would just encourage most content providers to invest in an OTT strategy. So, I see it as a huge area of growth for the long term. All right.
36:22 Speaker 06 Thanks.
36:23 Speaker 07 All right, I'll try and make this super quick. First of all-
36:24 Speaker 02 Sure.
36:25 Speaker 07 It's the first time I've ever heard you characterize YouTube Red as a music service first.
36:28 Speaker 02 Yes.
36:29 Speaker 07 Great start. I have a real problem understanding the YouTube original strategy. When you've articulated very clearly about the unique content offering that exists on YouTube and having these attributes that are rewarded, like, personality and authenticity and all these wonderful, great things. To what end is it to put YouTube originals of big budget, you know, high things on that? I know it's behind a paywall, but it's still on YouTube proper. And I just don't get to what end?
36:58 Speaker 02 Well, the Red originals are, will only have the first episode or the pilot on the free service, and-
37:06 Speaker 07 But you're still on a YouTube channel? Right?
37:09 Speaker 02 Well, actually, so in YouTube, on the main page, you can go and you can actually see all of the originals in one location and browse them that way. So they are available in one consistent way to be able to search and to find within the product.
37:25 Speaker 07 It just seems like interspersing premium content there versus, for example, YouTube TV, which totally rewards premium content. Seems, I don't know, strange.
37:37 Speaker 02 Well, so I think the goal, you know, when we first started this, we didn't have really any content, right? When you first start out. So having one page where you would have like 10 shows doesn't really make sense. And so it could have been that that original strategy, as you saw it, which was more to intersperse it, made sense then. But we have built a dedicated area just for the originals for our users to find, so that the red users can go and see like, these are all the originals that we have.
38:04 Speaker 01 OK, very quick, Peter's gonna kill me, go ahead.
38:07 Speaker 08 A quick question on community. So YouTube talks about community a whole bunch. And I'm wondering, Susan, could you help crystallize it by telling us how you define and think about community for YouTube?
38:19 Speaker 02 So what we see is the advantage of a digital platform is that you can have this two-way communication. And whereas TV was really about a one-way broadcast, you can have two-way communication with online video. And our goal is to encourage that as much as possible between the creators and the fans. And so that could be the comments, live. That could be even monetization, like sponsorships or buying their merchandise. You know, we built this community tab where they can communicate with texts, photos, polls, et cetera, so that if you're a fan and a creator and they want to ask like, well, what video should we do next? There's a mechanism for them to do that.
39:01 Speaker 08 So would you say in the future, the ideal state is just more and more two-way communication between creators and fans?
39:07 Speaker 02 That's the opportunity that we see with online, is to really build that two-way communication. And we believe that in the end, that actually makes a creator be able to do a better job and be more in touch with what their audience wants. And if you're, look, if you're a fan and your creator hurts your comment or responds back to you, like, I mean, that's incredible. And so we want to give more of those types of moments.
39:29 Speaker 01 All right, I'm gonna let these last two, Peter, I'm sorry, but go ahead.
39:32 Speaker 02 I'll answer them really fast.
39:34 Speaker 01 Hey.
39:34 Speaker 02 Hi.
39:35 Speaker 01 So...
39:37 Speaker 09 What kind of person would you groom to run YouTube after you?
39:42 Speaker 01 Are you leaving?
39:44 Speaker 02 Well, I'm planning to be there for a while.
39:49 Speaker 09 Besides Kara.
39:52 Speaker 02 Someone who, you know, I think it's actually been more complicated than I thought. I came from the ads background, and so having that ads background has been really valuable. But then also understanding the consumer component of it, and then also the media. So I think someone who has experience in all three of those areas is really valuable. And then lastly, someone who's just, you know, willing to always, you know, be flexible and aware of what's, you know, a changing, dynamic environment.
40:27 Speaker 01 My Curtis, last question.
40:28 Speaker 02 Okay, next one.
40:29 Speaker 10 Hi, Kurt with Recode. It's my understanding you guys have been in the running for NFL digital rights for the last couple of years?
40:36 Speaker 01 Sorry, Kurt. Go ahead, go, good.
40:38 Speaker 10 Am I allowed to ask?
40:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
40:40 Speaker 10 Great, thanks. Kara's my boss, so I can ask her if I have to.
40:44 Speaker 10 Question is, what is your, like, why is YouTube, what's your pitch? Why is YouTube a great place for NFL streams? And what opportunity do you see for more live sports moving forward for you guys?
40:54 Speaker 02 Well, I can't comment on any specific deal, but I will tell you why YouTube is a great place for live sports. We have a billion and a half users who come to our site every single month, and those are just the logged-in users. And when we have any kind of live streaming event, it goes very, we have large number of viewers, there's an opportunity as we build out more of these engagement metrics. I mean, we just had the Tesla go to Mars. I think we had a couple million viewers. It was our second largest viewing that we had seen. We, all the inauguration, I mean, all of these have been large live stream events.
41:37 Speaker 02 And I think we could reach a lot of users with any kind of live sports events, and also enable additional features for selling merchandise and also for enhanced viewing experiences.
41:53 Speaker 10 Do you want to stream the NFL?
41:55 Speaker 02 Sure, I mean, I would love to stream the NFL, but I can't comment on any kind of business relationships.
42:01 Speaker 01 Fantastic. Susan, I really appreciate it. I'm gonna come on YouTube now. I'm gonna create my own channel.
42:06 Speaker 02 Yeah, actually, so while we're here, we're waiting for you. I hope next time I get to interview you on YouTube, or you can interview me on YouTube. If you come and you start a channel on YouTube, I will come as a guest if you invite me.
42:19 Speaker 01 Oh, it's gonna happen. Thank you so much, Susan.
42:23 Speaker 00 Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. For full coverage of the Code Media Conference, visit recode.net. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other Recode Radio podcasts. On Recode Media with Peter Kafka, you'll hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment. I also host Too Embarrassed to Ask along with Lauren Good of The Verge, where we answer all of your questions about consumer tech. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including the Code Conference and Code Media. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode, and thanks to our editor Joel Robby and our producer Eric Johnson. We'll be posting more interviews from Code Media this week, so stay tuned.
43:05 Speaker 11 I'm Sean Ramisverm. I'm the host of Today Explained, a new show from Vox. It's an all-killer, no-filler daily news explainer that'll drop every afternoon. Our show's gonna explain the news every way we know how: clips, radio drama, maybe even a song.
43:28 Speaker 11 Subscribe now in Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen.
Previous Recode Decode: Jeremy Bailenson, author, 'Experience on Demand' Next Recode Decode: HuffPost editor in chief Lydia Polgreen (Live at Code Media 2018) Page updated October 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated