Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Tristan Harris About this episode Tristan Harris, the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about the latest problem he and his peers are trying to solve: "Human downgrading."
In this episode: Harris’ background as a design ethicist Google; how his previous movement, Time Well Spent, was co-opted by the tech industry; how are Apple and Google's "digital well-being" features doing?; the utopian promise of tech; why Harris shifted to focus on “downgrading”; what the Center for Humane Technology does; has Harris gotten through to tech's leaders?; why Facebook and YouTube are worse than Shell and Exxon; digital platforms as cities; what we need to do now; techlash; the (sort of) good news; are CEOs just hoping this goes away on its own?; and why removing Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act is "critical."
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 13,867 words · 9 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 You're busy. We know that, so we'll keep this quick. Introducing AMEX Corporate, now featuring the Corporate Cash Back Card. For one annual flat fee, get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, plus intelligent expense management with the unmatched expertise and backing of American Express. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:33 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio, or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-Cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:50 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:56 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who can quit using my phone anytime I want. Hang on, I have to get this. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Tristan Harris, the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology. He was formerly a design ethicist at Google and started a movement combating tech addiction called "time well spent." Now he's back with a new problem he wants to solve, which he calls "human downgrading." One example of human downgrading is the way social media amplifies grievances in our society and makes the world a less decent, less democratic place.
1:34 Speaker 03 For each word of moral outrage that you add to a tweet, it increases your retweet rate by 17%. So if you say, "It's abominable, it's a disgrace, oh, these assholes that..." You just get attention. And I almost want to sort of snap my fingers and tell everybody, "You can wake up now."
1:50 Speaker 02 Although his previous movement, "Time Well Spent," was seemingly embraced by many tech leaders, Harris said he's been disappointed by the responses from leaders like YouTube CEO Susan Wojcicki.
2:01 Speaker 03 I mean, I'm sorry for calling her out, but a platform that is steering 2 billion people's thoughts in a known, documented radicalization way that we know is causing people to believe conspiracy theories, we know it's doing this, and they're not solving the problem.
2:17 Speaker 02 Tristan, welcome back to Recode Decode.
2:18 Speaker 03 So good to be back here with you.
2:19 Speaker 02 So we were in this same tiny little room talking about this, and it was way before people were thinking about it, this idea of "time well spent." And I was just riveted to the idea of someone who is within one of these companies. Started to discuss these issues that were important. And now it seems to have intersected not just with all the other problems, but that it's it's an integral part of the social unrest problems and everything else, depression, addiction.
2:42 Speaker 03 Yep.
2:43 Speaker 02 The way people behave online, fake news, it's all part of the same thing.
2:47 Speaker 03 Exactly.
2:48 Speaker 02 So give people just a very quick how you started it and then what we previously talked about and where we're going now.
2:54 Speaker 03 Great, yeah. So many people, I think, are aware of the work, know vaguely of the story that back in 2013, I was a design, sorry, I was a product manager at Google. And I made this presentation about how we have a moral responsibility to get the attention economy right, that we, in our hands, in Google's hands, were holding in our hands 2 billion people's attention. And we were shaping the flows that guided what 2 billion people were thinking about. And because thoughts precede action, that means you're controlling and shaping culture, relationships, politics, elections. Somehow people latched on to the addiction thing. That's how the common public heard it. But it was always about what happens when you shape 2 billion people's attention.
3:34 Speaker 02 Right. The moral, what's your moral responsibility?
3:36 Speaker 03 And what's your moral responsibility?
3:37 Speaker 02 Which is something I talk about a lot. This idea of what are you doing?
3:39 Speaker 03 Yep.
3:39 Speaker 02 It's actually basically a simple question. Why are you behaving this way? And do you understand your power?
3:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, absolutely. And I think that, you know, the tech industry, it's very hard to understand your power. Because there you are, you're a Gmail engineer, or you're a Facebook News Feed engineer, and you're just writing some lines of code every day. You don't think that's going to influence a genocide happening in the Myanmar, or, you know, influence the politics of France, or populism around the world. And the whole point of this big new agenda that we're launching, the Humane Agenda, is to say that we need to move from this disconnected set of grievances and scandals, like that these problems are seemingly separate.
4:12 Speaker 02 They are not.
4:13 Speaker 03 Tech addiction, polarization, outrage-ification of culture, the rise in vanity, micro-celebrity culture, everyone has to be famous. These are not separate problems. They're actually all coming from one thing, which is the race to capture human attention by tech giants.
4:27 Speaker 02 Right.
4:28 Speaker 03 With increasingly powerful AIs pointed at your brain to reverse engineer, what can I throw in front of your nervous system to crawl down your brainstem and get something out of you?
4:38 Speaker 02 Right, exactly.
4:39 Speaker 03 Whether that's an ad Click or an addiction or a political, you know, conversion or whatever. This is all part of one connected system like human. We call it human downgrading, which is the social climate change of culture. And it's important to have that because otherwise it's almost like before there was climate change, there was just some one group of people working on coral reefs, another group of people working on hurricanes.
4:59 Speaker 02 I know, these polar ice caps.
5:00 Speaker 03 And then these ice caps and it's like, oh, these are disconnected. It's like, no, they're not disconnected.
5:04 Speaker 02 Right.
5:04 Speaker 03 These are all connected issues. And so we have to have a unified agenda and we have, because that's the only way it's going to change. Because it's an urgent problem. So that's why we hosted this big event.
5:13 Speaker 02 Right.
5:13 Speaker 03 In San Francisco last week.
5:14 Speaker 02 I'm going to go back just slightly to time well spent because it got co-opted too. I mean, Mark Zuckerberg co-opted a little bit. Why did people pick on addiction first? Because you were talking about, I remember you talking about the slot machine of attention, the idea that people are using all these tricks and tools. Tell me how you think that went, that part of it. And I agree with you, the interconnectedness is critical to understand.
5:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, so going back in time, I mean, first of all, going back to two years ago when we were in this room. This is two months after the election. We're trying to say, hey, social media and technology has a huge invisible impact on the way the world is playing out. That was a bold claim back then. Not that many people were talking about that, even though researchers, to give them credit, had been studying this for a long time. But that was not the popular media understanding.
5:57 Speaker 02 And Mark was saying it's crazy to think.
5:58 Speaker 03 Mark was saying it's crazy to think that fake news impacted the election, Russia, no, that's nothing going on there. And so, you know, in terms of what happened with time well spent, and the important thing to say about that, which relates to the work we're doing now too, is that I saw how powerful, simple language of a common understanding could create change. So it's sort of hard to remember this, but before two years ago, people weren't using phrases like, "Technology has hijacked our minds. It's this race to the bottom of the brainstem for attention and, you know, we need time well spent." Those three phrases, you know, we came up with some ways to talk about something that a lot of people were feeling, but they didn't have a simple description for.
6:39 Speaker 02 Right.
6:40 Speaker 03 And I'm not trying to say this with any ego. I just mean that until there's good language to describe a problem, it's just in the invisible felt sense layer.
6:47 Speaker 02 Sure.
6:47 Speaker 03 And no one knows what to do about it. And so. As soon as this language is out there, and this is behind our theory of change now, when you have common understanding and it gets repeated three times in one day, what happens when you're, you know, three times in one day, someone repeats a book to you?
7:00 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. You think about the book.
7:01 Speaker 03 You have to buy the book, or you have to address that problem. And so, part of this is how do we create a lever that's big enough now to address the problem of human downgrading? Which is that while we've been upgrading the machines, we've been downgrading humans.
7:14 Speaker 02 Right.
7:15 Speaker 03 Downgrading our attention spans, downgrading our civility and our decency, downgrading democracy, downgrading mental health. And not intentionally, but that the race to upgrade the machines.
7:25 Speaker 02 Well, sometimes intentionally. You're being lovely. You're being nice. What do you think the...
7:29 Speaker 03 With time will spend.
7:30 Speaker 02 With time will spend. All of a sudden, Apple did its screen time.
7:34 Speaker 03 Yep.
7:34 Speaker 02 Google talked about it. Everyone talked about it. How do you assess what's happened? Because some people think it's not nearly far enough, but they began to discuss the idea of it.
7:43 Speaker 03 Right.
7:44 Speaker 02 Grayscale, everything else.
7:45 Speaker 03 Totally. So, I mean, so again, going back to culture change, you could say, and let me take you back to February 2013. I sat in Google for two years, trying to see, could we change things from the inside? Could we change how Android worked to reduce the addiction problem?
7:58 Speaker 02 Right.
7:59 Speaker 03 Could we change how some of these products worked? And I didn't get very far.
8:01 Speaker 02 Right.
8:02 Speaker 03 And...
8:02 Speaker 02 Because why do we want to do that?
8:03 Speaker 03 Why do we want to do that? The culture hadn't caught up. There wasn't, you know, it wasn't like, hey, we're motivated by profit and you're going to take away our money.
8:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's what people miss. It's not that.
8:11 Speaker 03 It's not that, exactly. People think, oh, it's just these greedy corporations. It wasn't that. I can tell you, I was in the room with the Android product managers.
8:16 Speaker 02 Yep, I would agree.
8:17 Speaker 03 It was just that it wasn't a priority. And so, what I saw, which is what's really powerful to see, is what happens when you create shared language? You go out there, you create public awareness, and a lot of people speak out. Roger McNamee, Jaron Lanier, Guillaume Chaslot, René Di Resta. People start speaking in this shared language, and it starts to create change. So now, what happens? So as you said, Apple and Google, both at the same time, May of last year, launched these digital wellbeing features. It's the reason why everyone has these charts and graphs of where their time is going on phones. This is definitely a direct, you know...
8:48 Speaker 02 A hundred percent.
8:49 Speaker 03 Consequence of this awareness raising.
8:50 Speaker 02 They never would have done it otherwise.
8:52 Speaker 03 Right. And so, that's a really powerful lesson for me, because it shows you that if a lot of people say there's a problem here, and they understand that the responsibility really is on the side of technology, then that can cause change to happen. And the most important thing about it is that all these companies did it at the same time. So, Apple and Google both launched these things in May of 2018. So now, it's like we flipped from a race to the bottom. So now, it's a race to the top for who cares more about people's well-being. Now, to your question of, is that enough? No, no, no, absolutely not. It's like .01 .
9:23 Speaker 02 How do you assess what they've done so far? Let's just where we are right now.
9:25 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, if you just take the, first of all-
9:28 Speaker 02 You want to say thank you, but at the same time, it's like, it's like, I don't know. It just reminds me of when you, when someone does something that they should have done anyway.
9:36 Speaker 03 Right.
9:37 Speaker 02 Like, thank you for not hitting me.
9:38 Speaker 03 Right, right. Or it's like when someone apologizes a little bit, but not enough. I mean, also, different companies bear different levels of responsibility. By the way, Apple's in one of the best positions to do so much more on this topic because their business model isn't about attention at all.
9:50 Speaker 02 Right.
9:51 Speaker 03 And they're kind of like the Federal Reserve or the central bank of attention. People forget that. People think, how are we going to regulate the attention economy? They go to governments, but let's go to Apple. Apple can change the incentives really quickly. In a year from now, we could have iOS 13 or 14 suddenly flipping the incentives around. But, you know, in terms of what you're saying, it's really important to celebrate when things do move in the right direction. But like you said, it's, we want to celebrate it just a tiny little bit, like a little golf clap.
10:14 Speaker 02 Right.
10:15 Speaker 03 Because it's like, when you really examine the full surface area of harms, polarization, radicalization, outrage-ification culture, call-out culture, groups being marginalized, people feeling threatened and trolled, these are all direct consequences of a race to get attention. Because the stuff that's best to getting attention, it turns out, let me give you an example with outrage. For each word of moral outrage that you add to a tweet, it increases your retweet rate by 17%. So if you say, "It's abominable, it's a disgrace, oh, these assholes that..." You just get attention.
10:45 Speaker 02 Yes, I've noticed that.
10:46 Speaker 03 You've noticed.
10:47 Speaker 02 Yeah.
10:47 Speaker 03 And it's, and the thing is, because attention is finite, and Twitter's looking at, you know, whatever gets the most attention, that stuff starts filling up a greater and greater percentage of the channel.
10:57 Speaker 02 Right.
10:57 Speaker 03 And then, it makes culture seem like everyone is outraged all the time. And I almost, you know, I studied a little bit of magic and hypnosis when I was, last few years. I almost want to sort of snap my fingers and tell everybody, you can wake up now. Like, there's a bit of artificial polarization that we've all gone, like, you know, society's been thrown into the outrage washer machine and we've been like spinning around in there for a couple of years. And, you know, yes, there's deep grievances and deep problems in society, but they've been so amplified.
11:27 Speaker 02 Really, truly.
11:28 Speaker 03 By social media.
11:29 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:29 Speaker 03 And if we can, you know, and there was some criticism of this in our, in our presentation last week about, you know, saying, take a breath, it's like, it's more like just to notice.
11:37 Speaker 02 Right.
11:37 Speaker 03 First of all, that this isn't all real. The grievances are real, but the amplification of polarization is artificial.
11:43 Speaker 02 Well, it was interesting, there was this interesting story in the New York Times where it was about, there's Twitter, there's Twitter Democrats and real Democrats, which was, they're not quite as mad, they're not quite as angry, they're not quite as
11:52 Speaker 03 Right.
11:53 Speaker 02 incensed, because it does, it creates this outrage culture, although it does filter down, it filters everywhere, all over the place.
11:59 Speaker 03 Well, that's the thing people miss, actually, because people say, oh, well, you know, I don't use these products, so I'm fine and I'm not outraged, but you live in a society that's affected by these dynamics, meaning the outrage spills out of the screen into the social fabric.
12:11 Speaker 02 Right.
12:11 Speaker 03 So, for example, you know, maybe you say, I don't use YouTube and I don't believe conspiracies. Well, guess what? You live in a culture where you maybe send your kids to a school where other people do, and they stop vaccinating their kids because they've been surrounded by social media saying, don't vaccinate your kids. The WHO says that the anti-vaccination or vaccine hesitancy is now a top 10 global health threat. And in part, I know you've interviewed Renee DiResta, who's one of my heroes, you know, about how this is spread on social media, the point is that even if you don't use these products, it's actually holding the pen of history. It's shaping the outcomes of every major election around the world. It's shaping the politics of outrage, it's shaping populism. You know, in Brazil, I don't think you would have gotten a Bolsonaro without WhatsApp and Facebook.
12:53 Speaker 02 Right.
12:53 Speaker 03 You have videos of all of the supporters shouting, Facebook, Facebook, WhatsApp, WhatsApp, like proudly saying, this is what, you know, won the election.
13:00 Speaker 02 Trump?
13:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, Trump. I mean, I think that this stuff is really shaping everything. And even, you know, I was just with Frank Luntz down in the Milken Conference, and even he's saying, you know, This is not good. We have to have a reconciliation. We have to realize that we can't keep going this direction. We have to reverse the polarization.
13:16 Speaker 02 So Apple's one of them. What about Google? And then I want to get to what's your solution?
13:21 Speaker 03 Yeah. So Google also launched these digital wellbeing features. So again, without us writing a single line of code to be able to say, if you change culture, billions of dollars of where companies are directing their resources and their design can change. And that's really important because with this podcast, with other people who are speaking, if we have a surround sound where everyone's saying the same problem of human downgrading, then they can start to reverse it. And so, Apple and Google, both collectively, that's going to reach more than a billion phones this year. So people's phones go grayscale at the end of the night. That helps reduce the effects of blue light and some of the addictive qualities. But again, these are baby steps. Facebook last year embraced time well spent. In Zuckerberg's January 2018 letter, he said, "Our new goal for the company is
14:04 Speaker 03 to make sure the time people spend is time well spent." However, as you may know, he followed that up in the shareholder call with, "That means people spending more time watching videos together online."
14:14 Speaker 02 Right. Yeah. The answer to Facebook is Facebook.
14:16 Speaker 03 Facebook is Facebook.
14:17 Speaker 02 That's my favorite.
14:17 Speaker 03 Yeah. So that's not enough. And we have to see, what is the price tag of human downgrading? Is it just that, oh, like, we have a lot less attention spans, or addicted, or more polarized? It's like, if you add up this balance sheet, free is the most expensive business model we've ever created. Because if people can't agree on shared facts and truth, that's it.
14:39 Speaker 02 Right.
14:39 Speaker 03 That's it.
14:40 Speaker 02 When truth becomes political.
14:41 Speaker 03 When truth becomes political. Because we have such enormous problems with inequality and climate change especially, that are increasing. And the quality of our sense-making is going down, while our problems are going up. We can't even construct a shared agenda of what we want to do about it. It's harder than ever. And so if we don't have technology that -- I mean, I'm not saying that technology solves the problem, but obviously, it's pointing us the wrong way right now. So if we reverse it, and imagine we have superhuman powers to find common ground. I'm not trying to speak like a techno-utopia. I'm not saying text and a solve the answer. I'm saying, we have to go from technology amplifying the polarization, to at least, in its qualities--
15:18 Speaker 02 That was the idea from the beginning, right? That was what attracted me to it 25 years ago, was the idea that this was commonality, that we had commonality, and that these tools could bring commonality.
15:30 Speaker 03 Right. They could create a global commonality, in a way.
15:32 Speaker 02 Right, exactly.
15:32 Speaker 03 Yeah. You know, we used to have things like the fairness doctrine, you know, in television that we'd have equal sides. We have some, you know, in Europe, I think during the soccer breaks, they have like, you know, 10 minutes of a common news thing during the period where everyone's paying attention to soccer games, football games. You know, we don't have that with social media. It has completely fragmented our truth. And more importantly, the scale of the disinformation and misinformation, people tend to underestimate. I don't think you've had Guillaume Chazlo on the program.
15:57 Speaker 02 No, I haven't.
15:58 Speaker 03 But he's the ex YouTube recommendations engineer. He works with us. And his research showed that Alex Jones was recommended 15 billion times.
16:06 Speaker 02 Right. Well, you know how I feel about the recommendation systems of YouTube.
16:09 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. I mean, we said in our presentation last week, you know, the whole thing is imagine a spectrum. You've got the calm Walter Cronkite, you know, David Attenborough side of YouTube. And then on the other side of the spectrum, you have crazy town, UFOs, Bigfoot, et cetera.
16:22 Speaker 02 Right.
16:23 Speaker 03 No matter where you start, you could start in calm town, or you could start in crazy town. But if I'm YouTube, which direction on those two poles am I going to send you? I'm always going to tilt the playing field towards crazy town, because that's where I get more, more time spent. And so YouTube is recommending Teen Girl watches a dieting video. This is a year ago. It recommended anorexia videos. You start with NASA moon landing, you get flat earth. And once people go to these, these more extreme beliefs, or these more conspiracy beliefs, there's a study showing the best predictor about believing in conspiracy theories is whether you already believe one. So if you believe one, it kind of ratchets you up into this different.
16:58 Speaker 02 To the next one.
16:59 Speaker 03 To the next one.
17:00 Speaker 02 Moon landing, I think, yes, definitely.
17:02 Speaker 03 Right.
17:02 Speaker 02 Vaccines.
17:03 Speaker 03 Because it, it, it changes, like, speaking as like a kind of magician hypnotist person, like, when you flip people's mind into that kind of questioning paranoid mindset. I had a, a birthday present about two years ago, where a friend had me walk down to these docks in Brooklyn. And she, she said, just like, sit there. And this is like an assignment, kind of. And I was just like, looking out at the ocean. And someone came by, they're flipping, they're taking Polaroid photos. And they thought they were just taking Polaroid like a tourist. And then suddenly, she handed the Polaroid to me and said, you know, go to this address in this dock. And she wrote this little letter on the Polaroid and handed it to me. And the point of saying this is, it flipped my whole perception around, because suddenly I was wondering who's in on this.
17:42 Speaker 02 Right, right.
17:43 Speaker 03 Everyone around me could have been in on it.
17:44 Speaker 02 I think that was a Michael Douglas movie.
17:45 Speaker 03 Exactly, The Game. And so suddenly, you know, conspiracy theories on these, you know, magnified by these platforms, times of billions of people, by the way.
17:53 Speaker 02 Right.
17:55 Speaker 03 You know, it flips everyone's mind into this kind of questioning mindset that questions institutions and trust, and people don't believe in media, they don't believe in government anymore. And if you look at the disinformation actors, what Russia's trying to do as well, the whole point is to get people to distrust their institutions.
18:09 Speaker 02 Right, that's all you have to do.
18:10 Speaker 03 That's all you have to do.
18:11 Speaker 02 That's all you have to do. So that's why you called it, going from Time Well Spent, which is talking about the addiction issues, which are actually physical issues.
18:18 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:18 Speaker 02 It actually is addictive.
18:20 Speaker 03 It absolutely is, yeah.
18:21 Speaker 02 To the idea of downgrading.
18:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:23 Speaker 02 So what shifted you? Like, you got a ton of attention for Time Well Spent.
18:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:27 Speaker 02 And addiction, again, addiction was the biggest part of it. What shifted you to it? I mean, obviously, you spent a lot of time with Roger, who's talking about this in Facebook.
18:33 Speaker 03 Yep.
18:34 Speaker 02 What made you go that way?
18:36 Speaker 03 Well, so, as you mentioned, Roger, who's fantastic, you know, we ended up, you know, pairing up as a team and going into Congress, and we were at these conferences talking to all the developing countries groups where you have genocides being amplified, but the ethnic tensions from social media amplifying the fake news about minority groups, whether it's the Rohingya in Myanmar or Sri Lanka. There's so many examples, Cameroon, Nigeria. So when you get a deeper and fuller accounting of the harms, it wasn't that I was unaware of those things before, by the way.
19:08 Speaker 02 Right, no, we talked about them.
19:09 Speaker 03 Part of this is just getting, yeah, it's just getting, you know, we can't, if you think about how fast the harms are accruing, and you think about what is it going to take to fix these problems? We need language that when you say the phrase "human downgrading," it should speak to the full climate change set of harms. Otherwise, if you pull on a lever, and it's only on the other side of the lever, it's only fixing the addiction problem, or you're only trying to fix the polarization problem, we're not going to get change fast enough.
19:35 Speaker 02 Right.
19:36 Speaker 03 And we actually need to move market forces in the direction of reversing human downgrading. So I think of this almost like moving from an era of an extractive attention economy that's the race to the bottom to strip mine, frac, human attention out of human beings, to see human beings.
19:50 Speaker 02 Frac is a very good word.
19:50 Speaker 03 To see human beings as resources, to a regenerative attention economy that says, almost like the birth of solar panels and wind or whatever, we still need attention from people. But what if we're living in a world where we're competing to minimize that attentional footprint and most create leverage for people to get what they want?
20:06 Speaker 02 What they want, with the useful parts of what it is, that where you get utility.
20:10 Speaker 03 Right, and let's also speak to this because we often get criticized as this sort of anti-tech group or something like that.
20:15 Speaker 02 Yes, you do.
20:15 Speaker 03 And it's really-
20:16 Speaker 02 Welcome to my section of town, too.
20:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's funny how these things-
20:20 Speaker 02 We love tech. We love tech.
20:21 Speaker 03 It's funny how these things, how these things happen. So, let me give you examples, like YouTube is fantastic.
20:26 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:27 Speaker 03 Like, it has never been easier to learn a musical instrument.
20:30 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
20:30 Speaker 03 It has never been easier to do-it-yourself fix any item in your home. It has never been easier to get health advice. My, our co-founder Azar Raskin, you know, had this leg injury and he looked up on YouTube, "How do you massage your leg to heal faster?" And it helped him more than any doctor he had seen.
20:44 Speaker 02 Doctor Google.
20:44 Speaker 03 Doctor Google. So, there's certain benefits that are amazing. It's never been easier to laugh with friends with YouTube. Like, that's a perfect example.
20:50 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:51 Speaker 03 The problem is that that's not what these products are about.
20:54 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
20:54 Speaker 03 These are great examples, but if you look at the surface area of what's actually happening, what are most people experiencing most, most of the time? And like climate change, all I have to do is tilt the playing field just two degrees on the polarization, or on the outrage, or on the conspiracy-
21:09 Speaker 02 Use plastic bags, use plastic bottles, yeah.
21:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, and suddenly the whole thing can tilt and go crazy so fast. And if you look at the solutions that the companies are offering, like, "Let's hire 10,000 content moderators."
21:21 Speaker 02 Right.
21:21 Speaker 03 Like-
21:22 Speaker 02 Impossible.
21:22 Speaker 03 It's impossible. They can't, and I'm not saying this to complain, I just mean, this is a very delicate, dangerous, complex situation. When you hire 10,000 content moderators, I would just ask, "How many Facebook or YouTube engineers speak the 22 languages of India?"
21:37 Speaker 02 Right.
21:37 Speaker 03 Where there's an election coming up next month. There is four fact-checkers in Nigeria for a country of 24 million people.
21:43 Speaker 02 They can't do it. They can't, I know that. I always say that, then, that's ridiculous.
21:46 Speaker 03 Right.
21:46 Speaker 02 What you're doing is ridiculous, because they don't know what to do.
21:49 Speaker 03 Right.
21:49 Speaker 02 Right? We're going to talk about that and what we're going to do about this.
21:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
21:52 Speaker 02 We're here with Tristan Harris. He's the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology. We're going to take a quick break now, and we'll be back after this.
21:59 Speaker 04 It's me, the
22:04 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice.
22:07 Speaker 04 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
22:16 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
22:22 Speaker 04 Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop.
22:27 Speaker 04 Touche. Priceline.
22:30 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
22:31 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
22:32 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
22:32 Speaker 01 Caramel?
22:33 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
22:34 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
22:46 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling.
22:51 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
22:56 Speaker 02 Okay, we're here with Tristan Harris. He's the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology. Explain what that is now. What are you doing? Where is it at? What's the... And then we'll get into these solutions and this new focus on downgrading humanity.
23:09 Speaker 03 Great. So yeah, we're a nonprofit. We have seven people in San Francisco. We need to grow to about 20. We have about every major world government knocking on our door. You know, we're trying to help the tech companies navigate these issues. But we're a nonprofit based in San Francisco. A lot of the former technology insiders who built some of these things, Aza Raskin, who's one of my best friends and is a co-founder of Center for Humane Technology. His father, Jeff, invented the Macintosh project at Apple, who actually wrote a book called The Humane Interface. And that's actually where the phrase humane came from, because Jeff's work, his dad Jeff, you know, said that the purpose of being humane is to be considerate of human needs and responsive to human frailties. You start by understanding the frailties of human nature, and you're designed to protect those things.
23:53 Speaker 03 That's what it is to be humane in terms of designing technology. And what we think is that technology right now is fitting society like a glove, but it's fitting our reptilian brain like a glove. And so we need to fit our social fabric like a glove. We have to ask what strengthens? What are we fitting it to? That's why you often invoke this metaphor of ergonomics. So just like an ergonomic chair, if you don't know anything about the geometry of your back, then everyone's sitting in these chairs that are just misaligned because no one's ever looked at what is the geometry of backs. So it's almost like society has a geometry of what makes for civility, decency, trust, open-mindedness, et cetera. And broadcasting to 50,000 people and having call-out culture at scale is not very good.
24:33 Speaker 02 Right.
24:34 Speaker 03 Ergonomically fit for that.
24:35 Speaker 02 So this is a group that you're dedicated to doing what?
24:39 Speaker 03 We are dedicated to reversing human downgrade.
24:41 Speaker 02 By how?
24:42 Speaker 03 By advocacy, research. We're trying to educate designers to basically change how they're designing these products. Because the point is, per your point, that AI is not going to solve the problem. Content moderators aren't going to solve the problem. It's actually a sophistication about human nature and social dynamics that's going to fix the problem. So what are the kinds of spaces where people are open-minded and civil? Let's just take this common ground example. So it turns out like groups, like for example, take something like your feeling about whether you can participate in a group. Have you ever been at a dinner where it's like 20 people? Do you feel like it's easy to participate?
25:15 Speaker 02 I do, but go ahead.
25:16 Speaker 03 I bet you do. But you know, for most people, 20 feels like too big. So that's like un-ergonomic to participation. So let's take that value of participation. Let's say, well, what tends to work ergonomically? What fits that value? Oh, a group of about six people. And that's where an example like Living Room Conversations is an organization, nonprofit and a project, that basically facilitates six-person conversations, equal political sides, about a shared topic of interest with real passion, with good facilitation, and generates common ground. And they get real people and they feel like you have a meaningful conversation.
25:50 Speaker 02 Right.
25:50 Speaker 03 Because you can actually talk to each other and respond to the last point that was made as opposed to, oh, they keep going around the table because there's 20 people and you can't actually respond. So that's an example of how we apply a lesson like that to how Twitter is designed, or how Facebook is designed, or how Reddit is designed. Because another example with Reddit is there is a project called Change My View, where it's a whole channel that was dedicated to people saying, "I invite you to change my mind about X." So for example, "I think climate change isn't real because of X, Y, and Z. Please change my mind." That's an invitation that says, "Let's have a dialogue about that." And they successfully created this whole community where people gain, they're called delta points. So the more you change people's minds, the more points you get.
26:32 Speaker 03 And so it creates this community of trust and thoughtfulness and rewarding expertise as opposed to rewarding outrage and winning based on who's better at punning or shaming the other side.
26:41 Speaker 02 Right.
26:42 Speaker 03 And so those are the lessons that we need. Not better AI, not more data, not just the blockchain, not just more Jeremy Bentham, ethics, Kantian, Amartya Sen. People often have this thing, we're here at Stanford and we have to train the engineers in ethics. Believe me, as a former design ethicist, I embrace that. I think that's great, but that's actually still not enough. What we really need is this subtle sophistication about how do you design social systems to bring out the best in human nature. And so what we try to do at the Center for Humane Technology is provide frameworks and help educate those design teams to do that.
27:12 Speaker 02 And also point out when people are not doing that.
27:14 Speaker 03 Correct. And do that peacefully or with pointed critiques, but that are not directed at the individuals and saying, look, this is a system that produces these harms and we have to have an honest balance sheet of those harms.
27:27 Speaker 02 Do you feel like you've gotten through to the leaders? Because these are still the founders. These are still the original people, which I think, I find them, I hate to use a religious term, but I find them religious. They're religious about what they've done.
27:38 Speaker 03 Say more about that.
27:39 Speaker 02 Well, I think when you're someone who's running a TV network now is very different than the founders of the TV network. They pushed forward in ways that they don't do now. They just run it like a business, essentially. And I think the founders believe in their mission in a way that's very hard to get them off of it.
27:56 Speaker 03 Right.
27:57 Speaker 02 For them to develop in any way.
27:58 Speaker 03 I mean, I think a good example of this is Susan Wojcicki, who's running YouTube now, says, "My job is not to fix these things. My job is to run the business."
28:05 Speaker 02 Right.
28:06 Speaker 03 And I have to say, I mean, I'm sorry for calling her out, but a platform that is steering 2 billion people's thoughts in a known documented radicalization way that we know is causing people to believe conspiracy theories and to increase hatred and 50% of, I think, white nationalists in this Bellingcat study said YouTube is what red-pilled them into white nationalism. Like- We know it's doing this and they're not solving the problem.
28:33 Speaker 02 Right. I think she's not, I think she is concerned. I was just with her and she looked beside herself. I think, I would say-
28:39 Speaker 03 I mean, it's great that, as if there was an interview in Bloomberg where she said, "It's my job to run the business." I know that quotes get taken out of context, which is part of the problem.
28:45 Speaker 02 I can see her saying that because she's a business person, but I think the, we were talking about some, there was an issue which was really interesting. Someone who was anti-gay and lesbian-
28:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:56 Speaker 02 -put a bunch of biblical quotes on YouTube and did a video, and it was just biblical quotes essentially, right? And so, they did those and then sold them as ads. They put them as, it wasn't a YouTube channel, it was an ad, and they bought an ad of the biblical quotes.
29:12 Speaker 03 Right.
29:13 Speaker 02 Then those ads got put into gay and lesbian videos. And so, all these gay and lesbian video sites were like, "What are you doing putting an anti-gay ad into our thing?" And then they pulled it-
29:22 Speaker 03 It's a digital, Frank, they can't control it.
29:24 Speaker 02 Well, then they pulled it and then the guy who made it is like, "This is, I'm not violating, this is from the Bible." And so, and she was like, "I just don't even know what to do." Like, I had to say, "I don't know what you should do." I said, "I think you should shut the whole thing down." That was, I was like, I don't, shutting down is my only-
29:38 Speaker 03 This, I, I tend to agree. I mean, not like, listen, the problem isn't just, um, let's just shut down technology.
29:47 Speaker 02 No, I mean, I wrote that at times. It's like Sri Lanka. I was sort of like, "Good, shut it down, just for now." Just to calm everything down.
29:53 Speaker 03 I mean, it's just like what Roger, Roger and I had this thing we were saying about a year and a half ago. It was this Tylenol example, you know, when it was found there was poison in Tylenol. You know, Johnson and Johnson took it off the shelf-
30:03 Speaker 02 Mr. Baker, yeah.
30:03 Speaker 03 -until it was safe. And their stock price tanked, but then it went up even higher because people trusted them.
30:08 Speaker 02 Right.
30:09 Speaker 03 Now, the problem is that the harms now are not as simple as whether or not we're all just getting poison from Tylenol. It's this diffuse climate change like harm. Maybe it doesn't affect you, but it's causing genocides around the world, or it's causing millions of people to believe conspiracy theories and debasing our, our social fabric. But because that doesn't affect you, people don't- Have that same level of urgency of we have to shut it down. But they really need to see, it's not like the world was broken before 10 years ago, when you could watch a video and nothing autoplay. I mean, because the important thing to say here in terms of who's the responsible party, 70% of YouTube's traffic, this is actually a year ago, so it's even higher now, I'm sure, 70% of YouTube's traffic is driven by what the algorithm is recommending. And the example of this is people think, oh, that's not true. Like, I'm the one choosing my way through YouTube.
30:55 Speaker 03 Let me debase that, that is not true.
30:56 Speaker 02 Even my 13-year-old knows that.
30:58 Speaker 03 Right. Well, I mean, the simplest example is you're sitting there, you're about to hit play in a YouTube video, and you're like, I know there's other times that get sucked in, but this time is going to be different. And then, of course, you hit play, and two hours later, you wake up from a trance, you're like, what the hell just happened to me?
31:09 Speaker 02 Right.
31:10 Speaker 03 Because what happened in that moment, people don't see, is that somewhere in a Google server, is it wakes up this avatar model voodoo doll version of you. And based on all your clicks and likes, that's, those are like your hair filings and nail clippings, it makes this model behave more and more like you. And then what they do is they print that little avatar model with 100 million videos, and they say, well, which one, if I were to test this video, this video, this video, this video, would keep you there the longest? And so it's like playing chess against your mind.
31:36 Speaker 02 Right, yourself.
31:37 Speaker 03 Yeah. And it's going to win, because, I mean, if you think about, why does Garry Kasparov beat you and I at chess? Like, why?
31:42 Speaker 02 I can't play chess, but.
31:44 Speaker 03 Well, he sees, for to the extent that we play chess, he sees more moves ahead on the chessboard. So you're seeing, so when you're playing it out, you're playing out simulated versions of, well, if I did this, he would do this. But he's just playing out more simulations, so he wins. But when Garry loses against the best supercomputer in 2004, Garry doesn't just lose chess in that match, it's like, he was the best human chess player we had. So from that moment onward, all of humanity has now worse at chess than computers. They've overtaken humans at chess.
32:13 Speaker 02 Right. It's a better Garry Kasparov.
32:15 Speaker 03 Better Garry Kasparov. So now, here we are, 2 billion human social animals with the best hardware we've got. It's like bringing a knife to a space laser fight. We're bringing our tiny little prefrontal cortex, which is amazing, but also very limited, they have paleolithic emotions, and we're bringing that to bear when we're about to hit play in a YouTube video. And YouTube has now overrun, and Facebook, by the way, anyone with a supercomputer, Google, YouTube, Facebook, can simulate the perfect things to show us.
32:40 Speaker 02 Yep.
32:40 Speaker 03 Now, this is actually a deep point that people, I think, really underestimate, because it's sort of a civilizational moment when, when an intelligent species, us, We produce a technology where that technology can simulate the weaknesses of the creator.
32:54 Speaker 02 Right.
32:54 Speaker 03 So it's almost like the puppet that we've created can actually simulate a version of its creator and know exactly what puppet strings to pull on the creator. So now we're all outraged. You know, take the kids example. You have kids who are now addicted to what they look like on social media because Snapchat promotes this beautification filter, basically rewarding you whenever you look different the way than you actually do. Like, it's never been easier to see that people only like you if you look different than you actually look.
33:23 Speaker 02 Right.
33:24 Speaker 03 Right? Fifty-five percent of plastic surgeons reported seeing someone who wants to get plastic surgery to look like their Snapchat beautification filter. This is for teen girls. So if you don't know this, the beautification filters in Snapchat, you know, they plump your eyes, your cheeks, your lips.
33:38 Speaker 02 Yep.
33:39 Speaker 03 And so we're distorting people's identity. And when you realize that this is having a control over our social fabric, it's having a control over children's mental health, it's having control over our politics, it's having control over our elections, and people really haven't realized that technology is holding the pen of history right now. Like, we're not in control.
33:56 Speaker 02 When you think about all the different things, one of the things you do get is that they're all working together but not thinking of it at all together, that they don't think that each individual, they're making a problem. It is like everyone getting a plastic bottle, everybody buying like.
34:13 Speaker 03 It's like climate change. I mean, they're each, it's like, you know, Facebook and YouTube are kind of Shell and Exxon. And, you know, but it's worse, though, because they also own the satellites about, that can detect how much pollution is being created. There's a really important point. How much human downgrading is in polarization or, you know, anger is happening in each of these countries, like from Facebook? We don't know.
34:37 Speaker 02 Right.
34:37 Speaker 03 Because guess who has the data? Well, you and I don't.
34:39 Speaker 02 Right.
34:39 Speaker 03 Who has the data?
34:40 Speaker 02 They do.
34:41 Speaker 03 They do. So this is why, you know, we had this line of it's a living, breathing crime scene in each of these elections. They are the only ones who have the data. So it's like Shell and Exxon, where you create the pollution, but you privately profit, the harm shows up on the balance sheet of the society, and the only way that we're going to know what those harms are accurately is if we have access to the data. So it's as if Shell and Exxon own the observatory satellites.
35:03 Speaker 02 Right, right, right.
35:04 Speaker 03 So clearly, from a regulatory perspective, this has to change. The easiest thing, though, to change, I mean, not that it's easy, but the thing that fundamentally has to change. Is that we're moving from an extractive attention economy that treats human beings as resources.
35:17 Speaker 02 As fuel.
35:18 Speaker 03 As fuel, right, for our data, for our attention, to a regenerative attention economy where we just don't drill. I mean, why in the world would we say, let's profit off of the self-esteem of children? Like, this, this is so wrong.
35:33 Speaker 02 Right.
35:33 Speaker 03 And we used to protect this.
35:34 Speaker 02 So, we're gonna, in the next section, we're gonna how we're gonna do that.
35:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:37 Speaker 02 But one of the things that is fascinating to me is, one is, these companies now do feel victimized. You've picked that up, haven't you, from them?
35:45 Speaker 03 Yes, very much so. Because they're trying hard, they're doing lots of good, and they're gonna be victimized from their past behavior, and I totally get it.
35:51 Speaker 02 Right.
35:51 Speaker 03 I totally get why they feel that way.
35:52 Speaker 02 I had someone saying, like, oh, we're still paying for 2016. I'm like, yeah, you are. You haven't paid it off yet.
35:56 Speaker 03 Right.
35:57 Speaker 02 Sorry. Sorry, you're gonna have to keep paying. And in fact, again, you may have to shut it down, you may not have to do that. And one of the things that's really interesting is when I talk to a lot of these people is, you know, they're like, well, this is the way it works. I'm like, maybe you don't get to grow. Maybe you don't get to do this. Maybe you don't, like, that's what you were just talking about. Why would you wanna benefit off of the self-esteem of children?
36:16 Speaker 03 Right.
36:16 Speaker 02 Maybe you don't get to do that. And we're gonna talk about it in the next section. But one of the things I try to, I use the example, and I've used it many times, is of a, and I use it again and again, because, again, I wanna repeat it over so people get it.
36:26 Speaker 03 Right.
36:26 Speaker 02 There's two things I say all the time, or three things. One is, everything that can be digitized will be digitized, so be mindful of what that means. The second one is that, you know, the Russians didn't hack Facebook, they used it as a customer.
36:39 Speaker 03 Right.
36:39 Speaker 02 Which I think I like to say over and again. The third thing, which I think is actually most accurate, because everyone's trying to look for metaphors of what is happening here. And I like to think of these platforms as cities that own everything, and you pay the rent for being there.
36:51 Speaker 03 Right.
36:51 Speaker 02 Even if it's free, it's not free in any way whatsoever.
36:54 Speaker 03 Yep.
36:54 Speaker 02 And they decide not to provide police, and garbage, and signs.
36:58 Speaker 03 Right.
36:59 Speaker 02 Anything. And they still get the rent.
37:02 Speaker 03 Yeah.
37:02 Speaker 02 And that's, and you, then that's the society you get.
37:05 Speaker 03 Right.
37:05 Speaker 02 And they don't like to see themselves that way.
37:08 Speaker 03 Right. So the urban planning metaphor is the best one. I totally agree. We've been saying similar things for years. Marc Andreessen obviously has this quote that software is eating the world.
37:19 Speaker 02 Eating the world, right.
37:20 Speaker 03 But if you think about what that means in the context of, well, who's running the software? Well, these billion-dollar corporations. So what that really means is that private incentives are eating the world, meaning private companies are eating the world.
37:32 Speaker 02 Right, right.
37:33 Speaker 03 And also, we don't regulate those private companies, so it means that deregulation is eating the world. So take an example. So Saturday morning was a protected area of the attention economy for children. We say, we have these rules that govern what you can and can't do.
37:47 Speaker 02 Right.
37:47 Speaker 03 What you can advertise, et cetera. But then YouTube for Kids gobbles up that area of the attention economy. So now you have a private company governing a public part of life of children's mental health on a Saturday morning. And whatever protections we had there, guess what? They're gone.
38:03 Speaker 02 They're not there. They never were there.
38:04 Speaker 03 Right. So from a regulatory standpoint, just a framework to use, is a very simple way of thinking about this is, what were protections on these different areas that we had that we simply lost because we let private incentives eat it up? And let's ask, what were the principles behind those protections?
38:20 Speaker 02 Initially.
38:20 Speaker 03 Initially. And let's bring those protections back, like the way that they make sense. That's just an easy one. So another example is elections. We used to regulate that if Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump want to put an ad at 7:00 PM on a Tuesday, it should be at equal price. And we can see that, you know, who did it. And there's a certain rules about, you know, the equal price, et cetera. Then you let Facebook gobble up election advertising, that area of the attention economy.
38:42 Speaker 02 Without any regulation.
38:43 Speaker 03 Without any regulation. And suddenly, it's an auction. And suddenly, it's like, wait, who decided that? Why are they the government of how now 2 billion people's elections are governed? And moreover, even if they have good intentions or they hire ethicists, it'd be like, do you want Coca-Cola governing, you know, the public square? But then they hire some ethicists to be better. It's like, no, you don't want Coca-Cola governing the public square.
39:02 Speaker 02 I think that's the interesting part, is that they become the de facto public squares without being public.
39:06 Speaker 03 Right.
39:06 Speaker 02 They're private.
39:07 Speaker 03 Exactly.
39:08 Speaker 02 They're the private public squares. And then they get to hide behind First Amendment.
39:11 Speaker 03 That's right.
39:11 Speaker 02 If it's First Amendment, I'm like, you're not public.
39:13 Speaker 03 Right.
39:13 Speaker 02 You're not a government.
39:14 Speaker 03 Well, this is where the metaphor of urban planning is so important because it shows that they are environments that we inhabit.
39:19 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
39:20 Speaker 03 They're environments. They're not products we use. This is the thing we were trying to say years ago was people say, oh, it's just a tool. It's just this neutral thing. I can use it to post stuff to my friends. It's like, no, when you're creating the habitat that 2 billion people live by, we spend about a fourth of our days, a fourth of our lives now in artificial social systems, meaning in these digital environments. And that's just on screen. I mean, when you're off screen, you're still thinking thoughts that came from that artificial social environment. So we have to govern them as public spaces. They, they're taking over public--
39:47 Speaker 02 Or they have to be governed.
39:48 Speaker 03 Or they have to be governed, exactly. And this is a challenge and there's no, just to be clear here, I mean, it's not like there's these easy answers of like, well, it's easy. You just have to do X, Y, and Z. I mean, there's different governments and there's authoritarian governments, developing countries and different languages, and we've never had a problem like this before. But that's the conversation we need to have is how do we govern globally?
40:05 Speaker 02 Well, we're going to talk about that next. I have to say, authoritarians love social media. They don't want to shut them down. Democracies want to shut them down, which is kind of, it's a fascinating time. Anyway, when we get back, we're going to talk about that and what the solutions are. We're going to take another break now. We're back with Tristan Harris, the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology.
41:20 Speaker 02 We're here with Tristan Harris. He's the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology and he's gotten very well-known for putting technology companies to the task of things, the impact they were having on society. We've been talking, fantastic discussion about what has happened. So let's talk about what we need to do. Because like you talked about, everything has been so disparate, whether it's technology addiction, or AI, or political unrest, or hate speech, they don't get linked together.
41:48 Speaker 03 Right.
41:49 Speaker 02 Linking them together is critical. I just wrote an essay talking about that. They're all linked together. It's not one problem.
41:54 Speaker 03 Exactly.
41:55 Speaker 02 And they all inform each other.
41:56 Speaker 03 Right. And they're all part of self-reinforcing feedback loops, much like climate change. Like, carbon has a self-reinforcing feedback loop with methane in oceans, et cetera. So similarly, in the attention economy, is it easier to say short, brief, sound-body things, or long, complex, nuanced things? No, short, sound-body things. When you say short things, what tends to work better is outrage. Outrage gets 17% higher retreat weights. So then if outrage gets said more often, then we polarize people more often. More polarization means we're more isolated, living in our own chambers. When we're more isolated, we're more vulnerable to conspiracy theorizing thinking. And so these things sort of self-reinforce.
42:31 Speaker 02 Yeah, absolutely.
42:32 Speaker 03 So we need a name for this connected system. We just use this phrase "human downgrading" because it gets at the heart, which is that while our data and our attention are used to upgrade the machines, to build better and better avatar models of us, it's downgrading humans. It's downgrading our mental health, children, attention spans.
42:50 Speaker 02 What needs to be done in the immediate term first? What needs to be done? Obviously, the realization is happening. I think the tech clash is here and going strong.
42:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:59 Speaker 02 What has to happen?
43:00 Speaker 03 Well, on the tech clash thing, first, I would like to see us get calmer and more nuanced about, let's just solve the problem. I mean, there's clearly, as you said, there's a lot of rage and frustration about the past. I agree with a lot of that. These issues were not hidden. It was not impossible to foresee some of these consequences. But now we are where we are, and we have to talk about how we can fix it. So the thing that we're most trying to say is, we have to have a common language and framework for addressing these problems. So "human downgrading," we said, comes from three things. One is unergonomic or artificial social environments. That's what I mean by we're like contorting ourselves to fit.
43:36 Speaker 02 Right.
43:36 Speaker 03 Into this, into this, fit to the product. As opposed to the product wanting to fit around our friendships, fit around our society, our public square, our civility. It should be asking, how do I fit and strengthen those things? Not how do I debase them and replace it with my synthetic version? That's the first diagnosis. The second one is from these overpowering AIs where they have a voodoo doll avatar version of each of us. That's more powerful and they can use that to manipulate us.
44:00 Speaker 02 By the way, that's a Will Smith movie about to come out, Gemini Man, but go ahead.
44:03 Speaker 03 Oh, interesting.
44:04 Speaker 02 They build a clone of himself and then he goes back to try to kill. They're both assassins and so he can't really kill himself because he knows all his moves.
44:10 Speaker 03 Right, interesting. I'm very excited to see this. I mean, this, this gets really dangerous when you realize that, again, everyone is looking out. This is a big point we made at the beginning of our new agenda last week in this big presentation. We think of it as like the inconvenient truth for tech. And the point we made is up until now, the biggest sort of milestone point that people talk about in the future of tech is when does it get better than human intelligence? When does it get better than human?
44:35 Speaker 02 When are they at dolphins, right?
44:37 Speaker 03 Right, exactly. So when, when are they, you know, taking our jobs because they can do everything we can do better than us? But there's a much earlier point. Imagine there's that timeline. Here's the graph of technological progress going up, up, up, up. And there's an earlier point before it crosses human strengths. All it has to do is cross human weaknesses. And from that, it's like a magician. If you're a PhD, as a magician, I don't care. I don't need to know that. I just need to know your weaknesses, not your strengths.
45:02 Speaker 02 Right.
45:02 Speaker 03 And when technology exploits our weaknesses, it gains control. So the point of this second diagnosis of going from these overpowering AIs avatar voodoo dolls of each of us, those have to be a fiduciary to our interests because that's a dangerous kind of asymmetric power. We have a model for this in every other form of asymmetric power. Lawyers who you hand all of your personal information over to so they can best represent you.
45:25 Speaker 02 Right.
45:26 Speaker 03 Doctors, you hand, you want to hand them as much information about you so they have more to do.
45:30 Speaker 02 To diagnose you.
45:31 Speaker 03 To diagnose you. So it's fine to have asymmetric power insofar as it is in our interest. It represents our interest. And you know, the joke about this is. That Facebook is like a priest in a confession booth whose business model is to sell access to the confession booth to anybody who wants to pay them.
45:50 Speaker 02 Right.
45:50 Speaker 03 But it's worse than that because they listen to 2 billion people's confessions. And they have a supercomputer. And they have a supercomputer next to them that's calculating 2 billion people's confessions. So that as you're walking in, it can predict the confessions you're going to make before you make them.
46:04 Speaker 02 Right.
46:05 Speaker 03 And then it actually sells access to the prediction about you to an advertiser.
46:10 Speaker 02 Right.
46:10 Speaker 03 And so that is a dangerous kind of power where it's like, you know, we can have priests in confession booths, although the joke is, maybe we shouldn't have those.
46:18 Speaker 02 Yeah.
46:20 Speaker 03 But you don't want. Let's not go into that. But you don't want priests whose business model is to sell access to someone else.
46:27 Speaker 02 Right.
46:28 Speaker 03 So the fiduciary thing is critical because it immediately says, you cannot have a business model based on exploiting the psychology of the person that you're seeing when you have asymmetric knowledge about them.
46:38 Speaker 02 So what do we do?
46:40 Speaker 03 Well, that's a whole area for legal scholars and policymakers to think about. We want to assist that conversation. Again, we're.
46:46 Speaker 02 What are some of the good ideas? What are some of the bad ideas in this?
46:49 Speaker 03 Good ideas about what?
46:50 Speaker 02 What to do about this bad priest?
46:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, that's. So Jack Balkin at, I think, at Harvard Law School has written this paper about information fiduciaries. But I think that's a, that was written in 2004 and it's more outdated. I think we need a newer model that represents the power of AI and prediction. As a computer scientist, I know where this is going. Like, take Cambridge Analytica. They needed to get access to your data to predict your big five personality traits. Once they know your big five personality traits, they can tune political messages to you. Okay. But they had to get those 150 Facebook likes from you.
47:22 Speaker 02 Right.
47:22 Speaker 03 Right? And so that was that whole scandal. There's a paper out by Gloria Mark at UC Irvine that based on your click patterns and how you click around on a screen. With 80% accuracy, I can get the same big five personality traits.
47:35 Speaker 02 So you don't even need to do that.
47:36 Speaker 03 I don't need your data. I can predict everything about you. And guess what? The more I downgrade you to acting into dopamine and fear, the more predictable you become. Because there's two ways to make you predictable. One is I build a bigger supercomputer and I can predict a fuller and fuller space of things that you might do next. The second way to make you more predictable is to simplify you, is to make you outraged. Because when you're outraged, how does that feel? You act in a more predictable, reactive way. Technology is doing both those right now. That's why we say human downgrading is an existential threat. Because it's downgrading our choice-making capacity to not fall into...
48:08 Speaker 02 And not even know that it's happening.
48:10 Speaker 03 And not even know that it's happening. And we have to fix this.
48:12 Speaker 02 I want to go to the solution. What is that? Who fixes it? Is it regulators that say, "You cannot do this anymore"? Because it's so complex, what they're doing.
48:20 Speaker 03 Correct.
48:20 Speaker 02 So who is responsible? Besides, what they seem to have done is, hey, you can turn it off. You can't turn it off.
48:27 Speaker 03 No, you can't turn... It's like saying you can turn off the environment you live in. You can't turn off your public square, your electricity, or your water. Like, you need it. We live in these environments now. So we have to make them habitable to us, and they have to be governed in public interest.
48:41 Speaker 02 The government.
48:41 Speaker 03 The government has a role.
48:42 Speaker 02 Which has done it before with chemicals, banks, cars.
48:45 Speaker 03 And Roger makes this metaphor all the time. You know, we used to have the chemical industry, they just do whatever they want. Once we realized there were some bad externalities, we got to regulate it. Cars, same thing, seat belts, et cetera. Airplanes, FAA. At the very least, if you consider that we're at the beginning of an accelerating trend, not at the beginning, we're at the tip of the exponential curve as it's starting to go up, where these issues are only going to get crazier. Technology's going to go faster. So at the very least, we used to have something called the Office of Technology Assessment, which basically was a nonpartisan group in government to do at least an analysis and generate quick policy proposals, consult with the experts. You know, right now, we're a nonprofit civil society group. A lot of this work is being done by people like Rene or Guillaume, people who stay up till 3:00 in the morning, independently scraping data sets
49:29 Speaker 03 because they get Mozilla fellowships and can barely scrape by. And they're the ones providing the accountability structure right now. This is not an effective system. We need to have well-funded observations of all these harms and then generating policy proposals much faster.
49:42 Speaker 02 Just the way the government does weather or...
49:44 Speaker 03 Yeah. And this is, you know, E. Wilson, who's sort of the father of sociobiology, has this quote that says, "The fundamental problem of humanity is that we have these ancient paleolithic instincts." We have medieval institutions and we have godlike technology.
49:59 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
50:00 Speaker 03 So Paleolithic instincts, medieval institutions and godlike technology. The point is, you can't have chimps with nukes and not regula- and regulate it with medieval 17th century, 18th century institutions. So the, at the very least, we need to bootstrap the institutions to have faster Oodalooops, faster.
50:17 Speaker 02 To keep up with it.
50:17 Speaker 03 To keep up with it.
50:18 Speaker 02 Which is hard.
50:19 Speaker 03 Which is hard. And I'm not saying that's easy. I'm just saying, we gotta do that.
50:21 Speaker 02 Because these companies are nation states.
50:24 Speaker 03 Yeah.
50:24 Speaker 02 They just don't have anyone.
50:25 Speaker 03 They don't have any, exactly.
50:26 Speaker 02 Anybody being able to vote them out.
50:28 Speaker 03 Right, but they could also, I mean, for all the harms, they could be the thing that makes, that gives us exponential common ground, exponential ability to solve climate change.
50:36 Speaker 02 So why don't they?
50:37 Speaker 03 They could be the things that help.
50:37 Speaker 02 Why don't they?
50:38 Speaker 03 Their business models and the fact that they're competing against one another and the fact that they don't even see the issues as we've described them. I don't think that even the framing that we've laid out today is the common understanding.
50:49 Speaker 02 There's just three of them. Let's be honest, maybe four.
50:51 Speaker 03 There's not that many, that's, so this is.
50:53 Speaker 02 Amazon, Facebook.
50:54 Speaker 03 Exactly.
50:55 Speaker 02 Google and maybe Alibaba and WeChat.
50:57 Speaker 03 This is the, the thing, so the, the negative side of.
50:59 Speaker 02 Is that all of them, that's the?
51:01 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's, I mean, there's only like five.
51:02 Speaker 02 Apple, Apple is not, not in there quite the same way.
51:06 Speaker 03 But Apple has a huge role, role to play, yes. But they're not, but they're not creating the problem. They have a role to play in the solution.
51:11 Speaker 02 Solution, right, right.
51:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, but the, but this is the good news. So this is what we said in our presentation. Look, like, human downgrading is the climate change of culture. Like climate change, it can be catastrophic. Unlike climate change, only about a thousand people among like five companies need to change what they're doing. Now, in saying that, I'm not trying to disempower the thousands and millions of us outside of these systems that are like, well, then I guess I'm not included. That's not it at all. This is going to take everyone, the policymakers, the shareholder activists, to put board resolutions on these companies' board, you know, board meetings, then the media guiding the conversation. Policymakers and government's job is to protect citizens from all these things. Everyone has a role. We are trying to simply facilitate and accelerate that work by providing that common language and understanding.
51:56 Speaker 03 We asked about policy, one simple thing.
51:58 Speaker 02 Okay.
51:58 Speaker 03 You know, the best ethics is the ethics of symmetry. Do unto others as you would do unto yourself. For the kid stuff, imagine a world where you designed. Products in such a way that you happily endorse and have your own children use those products for hours a day. That neutralizes about half the harms immediately because notice that none of the Silicon Valley executives have their own children use these products. The CEO of Lunchables.
52:20 Speaker 02 I've seen they use them. I've been around a lot of these children.
52:24 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, it's by the way, you say that when I say that it's not like Google Search Box or YouTube at all. I mean, more like social media, like a lot of them do not use social media at all. And, you know, it's just such a simple shift to make. And the CEO of Lunchables, you know, food, did not let his own children eat Lunchables.
52:42 Speaker 02 Right.
52:42 Speaker 03 So you know, you have a problem when you are not eating your own dog food. There needs to be skin in the game. Another principle is that the people closest to the pain should be closest to the power. There are groups that are trying to bring these ethnic minorities in these developing countries, most affected by these things with no public representation. Here we are in the free world where, you know, Renee and Guillaume and others do this hard to do research and they publish it in Washington Post, the New York Times, you know, in Nigeria and Cameroon and, you know, Sri Lanka, they don't have that same level of accountability. And so we need those groups to have a seat at the table. They should be included. There needs to be much more diversity, obviously, in these conversations, but especially where we know sorted by the harms by the tensions that are being produced.
53:23 Speaker 02 But there doesn't seem to be any movement that way. They're hoping it goes away.
53:26 Speaker 03 They're hoping it goes away because they created a Frankenstein. It's very hard.
53:29 Speaker 02 From yesterday's F8 is Mark's now trying to create the greatest encrypted privacy organization on the planet. Now he's just trying to encrypt it and hide it.
53:37 Speaker 03 Right. And obviously, you know.
53:38 Speaker 02 I mean, by missing something like he's like, oh, no, the jig's up over here. I'm going over.
53:43 Speaker 03 Right. Well, and a lot of that, I'm assuming, and I always want to be, you know, as charitable as possible and give the benefit the doubt. I'm sure there are some good reasons for doing that. Based on, you know, again, they're the only, they're the only ones who have access to know. So whatever decision making they're doing, they're the only ones deciding. That's a huge problem. Let's assume there's some good reasons for doing that. Besides that fact, there's still also the fact that this is the best way in the world to escape liability.
54:10 Speaker 02 Right.
54:10 Speaker 03 Because one of the things that happened with the Russia investigation is they don't want to look, you know, with with children's mental, they don't, as soon as they look, they're responsible. So, you know, when it's all private and these decentralized channels, suddenly it's all happening in the dark. And there are many of us who are concerned about what that means for disinformation when there's no way to track what's happening.
54:29 Speaker 03 So these are thorny problems. There's no easy solutions. We need complexity and nuance more than ever. We need thoughtfulness, not just naive tech clash. But I do believe that through seeing what's happened with Time Well Spent, with the Race to Hijack Our Minds, with the power of shared understanding, if people can see these the same way, if they can see the problem the same way, that the race to capture attention combines addiction, teen isolation, mental health, polarization, outrage-ification, the vanity-ification of our culture, that these are all connected issues and we can call that human downgrading. The question is, how do we harness all the market forces, all the policymaking forces, to as rapidly as possible reverse human downgrading?
55:09 Speaker 02 So who are the key players? The companies?
55:12 Speaker 03 The companies. And by the way, again, mentioning Apple. Apple can play such a huge role because they can incentivize that race. They're not incentivized to maximize attention on device. And as people wake up to these issues, as they started to with the addiction things, they're rewarded by consumers to say, who's going to better protect my kids? Should I buy an Android phone? Should I buy an iPhone?
55:30 Speaker 02 Right.
55:31 Speaker 03 So we just got to elevate the race to the top from the first one, which is who can show me a better chart and graph for where I'm spending my time, to a higher bar, which is who can reverse human downgrading?
55:41 Speaker 02 Alright, so Apple.
55:43 Speaker 03 So Apple, yep. That's design changes, that's App Store economic changes. There's some deeper conversations to have there. Policymakers, there's a whole slew of policy. You know, we have a new person.
55:53 Speaker 02 I think they should have an API for mental health at Apple. That's what I, you know.
55:57 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, well, they need to be, they need to enable access for these researchers because, you know, that's the other thing I said in my presentation, like, we don't have time for a decade of research on this. Like, it's very clear when you understand the mechanics of a developing mind. I mean, I was just with Jonathan Haidt, who wrote The Righteous Mind. You know, he did this huge literature review. You can look it up online. It's like 50 pages. It is so clear that for teen girls between 10 to 14 years old, that social media is toxic. Self-harm, depression,
56:24 Speaker 02 Yep.
56:24 Speaker 03 suicides have all shot up in the last, basically, five years.
56:29 Speaker 02 Oh, you don't even have to do research.
56:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, you don't have to do it. It's common. First of all, it's common sense. Second of all, the research does confirm it. We don't have time to wait.
56:35 Speaker 02 Right.
56:36 Speaker 03 And so the thing is, just like climate change, you can Have people throwing doubt and dismissing all this stuff and saying, well, it'll take a long time. It's really complicated. Who's to say if it's really polarizing people? Is it issue polarization or relationship polarization or affective polarization? And then they'll use sort of academic status games to disinclude you from the conversation. It's like, no, we know it's causing polarization. Obviously, there's lots of polarization that's already existed, the birth of cable news and Fox News and these kinds of things that are magnifying it. But it's clear that technology has amplified it. And at the very least, how can they all be in a race to create what Jack, you know, Twitter says like healthy conversations, civility, open mindedness.
57:15 Speaker 02 How do you assess that with him? I'm sorry.
57:18 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's, you know.
57:20 Speaker 02 He doesn't care. I'm sorry.
57:21 Speaker 03 You don't think he cares?
57:22 Speaker 02 No, I don't. I do not.
57:24 Speaker 03 Yes.
57:25 Speaker 02 I do not. I don't think he thinks it's a problem. I think he thinks it's an irritant sometimes, but I don't think he thinks it's a problem.
57:31 Speaker 03 You know, I don't know. I think.
57:33 Speaker 02 I like him personally, but honestly, I gotta say, this is too long, too long now.
57:38 Speaker 03 I think that for all these companies.
57:40 Speaker 02 And they're doing well, by the way.
57:42 Speaker 03 I know, they're doing really well. That's the thing. It's like they could hire so many more people, anthropologists, social scientists, a lot of people who are, you know, doing the hard work and the research now, by the way, who've thought about this, who are not inside the companies. They could do so much more on this. Obviously, it eats into their bottom line, but you know, let's take the example of Twitter. Back when you and I spoke in.
58:01 Speaker 02 2017.
58:02 Speaker 03 2017, early, like January, February 2017.
58:04 Speaker 02 Right after the election.
58:05 Speaker 03 Okay, there was a study out then that 17% of Twitter's users, estimated, were bots. 17%. Okay, what happens when you've been telling Wall Street, I've got 200x million users? And they're anchoring your stock price on that number. This is how many users we have because that's what makes you that valuable. You can't just shut down 17% of your accounts. And also just to make sure I'm speaking to all the audiences, some of those bots are fine. They're just telling you the weather. It's not that they're all Russian or whatever. But still, they're a problem and they're not going to go shut them down. Now, what happened exactly about a half a year ago at August 2018? Twitter shut down 70 million accounts, finally.
58:45 Speaker 03 And that's a great move. Exactly, finally, it took a long time. But when they did, Wall Street punished them as opposed to rewarding them for actually doing the long-term regenerative.
58:53 Speaker 02 Which would make it a better.
58:55 Speaker 03 Which would make it a better system. So, I agree with you. In each of the company's cases, they've acted too little, too late. Zuckerberg saying it's a crazy idea that fake news impacted the election. It's ridiculous.
59:05 Speaker 02 Or YouTube. We're gonna stop children's comments. I'm like, did pedophile just pedophilia just occur to you?
59:10 Speaker 03 That just happened like two, three months ago that the advertisers. And by the way, YouTube only tends to respond when, not just public pressure and media, but when their advertisers say, we're gonna pull the money out. That's when they really respond. These are not effective accountability systems. We need democratic accountability systems. We can't just wait for whether we can wake the advertisers up.
59:26 Speaker 02 So what would be a shock to their system? The removal of the immunity clause from the Communications Decency Act?
59:32 Speaker 03 I think CDA 230 is critical.
59:34 Speaker 02 Just remove it. Say, good luck with the lawyers.
59:38 Speaker 03 Well, we need to create.
59:39 Speaker 02 Cause I know, when I say it to them, they're like, we'll be finished. I'm like, I'm good with that.
59:42 Speaker 03 Right.
59:43 Speaker 02 I'm teasing them, but I'm kind of like.
59:44 Speaker 03 I think this is where the debate has to center. I think there needs to be a massive review of CDA 230. For those who don't know, the Communications Decency Act, Section 230, is basically what birthed the internet, because it says that platforms aren't responsible for the content that appears on there. But, you know, as Renee and I both have said, you know, freedom of speech is not the same thing as freedom of reach.
1:00:03 Speaker 02 Right.
1:00:04 Speaker 03 And that these platforms, when you're recommending Alex Jones 15 billion times, it's not that people type in Alex Jones 15 billion times with their keys, with their hands. It recommends them. If it's recommending them, think about, like, how big is the New York Times and the Guardian and all these people combined? It's nowhere close to 15 billion. And they're governed by this, these laws. So, they have to be responsible for recommendations of, especially what we know to be hate speech or inciting violence, or these things that are causing people to take up arms around the world. So, we need a really deep review of Section 230, and that's something that's a bigger conversation, but we need to engage with policymakers on that.
1:00:41 Speaker 02 All right. So Tristan, where do we go from here? What do you need? I'm with you. I'm in the Tristan Army. Someone asked me if I thought I was on your side or not. I'm like, I think there's not a side.
1:00:53 Speaker 03 There's no side here. First of all, this is also not like our side.
1:00:56 Speaker 02 Yes, please, I'd like my children addicted.
1:00:57 Speaker 03 Exactly, right.
1:00:58 Speaker 02 This country ripped apart at the seams. That's my goal.
1:01:01 Speaker 03 Exactly. So this is just team humanity and we're not at the center of it. We're simply trying to articulate a shared frame. We want to help all the actors in the space. Because if you look at how big this is, every country, every election, hundreds of languages, hundreds of countries, for issues ranging from mental health to polarization. So we have to solve it at such a huge scale. Every government is involved, every shareholder activist is involved. We're trying to help the researchers accrue their research and show it to policymakers. We need policymakers engaged. You know, we have this new head of mobilization, David Jay, who's working on coordinating working groups on these topics. Some of the work is in public, in public events. We're going to do a conference next year. But a lot of the work's behind the scenes.
1:01:40 Speaker 02 Podcast, you're going to start buying it.
1:01:41 Speaker 03 We're launching a podcast called Your Undivided Attention, where we're ironically, we're not, I mean, the whole point is...
1:01:47 Speaker 02 How about I leave you to your own devices now?
1:01:49 Speaker 03 Yeah, exactly. That's another good pun. But you know, we're going to be interviewing magicians.
1:01:55 Speaker 02 Magicians are a good idea.
1:01:57 Speaker 03 Well, just people who understand there's a subtlety to the human nervous system that tech designers are not the most in touch with. They're just writing the code. They're not thinking about their own nervous system. So especially the social nervous system, like how do these things connect together? So those are the expertise that we need to rapidly accelerate that and hand it to the companies to be, I mean, we need to help them. I mean, as much as they're also the problem.
1:02:18 Speaker 02 I don't want to help Mark Zuckerberg. Really?
1:02:20 Speaker 03 I hear you on that.
1:02:22 Speaker 02 Does he listen to you? Do you talk to him a lot?
1:02:24 Speaker 03 You know, we ran into each other at the Macron Summit last year, but we haven't, we haven't really sat down and chatted. We'd love to chat.
1:02:30 Speaker 02 Yeah, he doesn't like to see me. I was over there and he wouldn't let me. I brought some people over there and he'd let me in.
1:02:36 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah. Well, it's, you know, it's hard, you know, I can't say how many times I've gone back to the Upton Sinclair line, which is you can't get someone to question something that their salary depends on them not seeing.
1:02:48 Speaker 02 Right.
1:02:49 Speaker 03 Or another way of saying it is you can only have the ethics that you can afford to have. And right now, the price for many of these companies is too high. That's why we need policy to make it more affordable.
1:02:59 Speaker 02 Right. But you know the other saying? They're so poor, all they have is money.
1:03:03 Speaker 03 Right.
1:03:04 Speaker 02 Anyway, Tristan, your work is amazing. I think it's great. I think there should be more research out and policymakers.
1:03:10 Speaker 03 We need everyone's help, too.
1:03:11 Speaker 02 Policymakers really need to step in here, really smart, across the country and across the world. I think it's really important. And I think we've cut, it's come to that, I guess. That's how it's.
1:03:19 Speaker 03 Well, I will say there's been more interest than ever from world governments from who are affected by these issues, radicalization. I mean, this has to get stopped right now.
1:03:25 Speaker 02 Well, good. In two years, I hope we will have better answers.
1:03:29 Speaker 03 Exactly. Let's do this again.
1:03:30 Speaker 02 All right. Absolutely. 100%. Again, this is Tristan Harris. He's the co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology. Thank you for coming on the show.
1:03:37 Speaker 03 Thank you so much for having me.
1:03:38 Speaker 02 And thank you for listening. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Eric Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. How can people find you, Tristan?
1:03:49 Speaker 03 Go to our website, HumaneTech.com, check out our podcast, or I'm on Twitter at Tristan Harris.
1:03:53 Speaker 02 Okay, great. If you liked this episode, we really appreciate if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media and Pivot. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks to our editor, Joel Robbie. Special thanks to Anne Grimes and Ryan Roberts. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
1:04:19 Speaker 06 In this life, you can't win.
1:04:21 Speaker 07 When the world gets you down.
1:04:22 Speaker 06 No!
1:04:23 Speaker 07 Escape to Pluto TV.
1:04:24 Speaker 06 This is objectively fantastic.
1:04:26 Speaker 07 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free.
1:04:30 Speaker 06 Shwing!
1:04:31 Speaker 07 Even our news is uplifting.
1:04:32 Speaker 04 You stay classy, San Diego.
1:04:34 Speaker 07 Watch School of Rock, Crazy Ex Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
1:04:39 Speaker 06 We're not worthy!
1:04:41 Speaker 07 The best things on TV really are free.
1:04:44 Speaker 06 You just have to know where to look.
1:04:45 Speaker 07 Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
1:04:52 Speaker 08 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall, the most incredible survival thriller of the year. I need the whale! Help me! In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home! Josh Drogba. Survivor, Survivor. Whale Fall, rated PG-13, maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Scott Galloway Next Recode Decode: Sam Harris Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated