Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Therapist Esther Perel About this episode Sex and relationship therapist Esther Perel, the host of the podcast "Where Should We Begin?", talks with Recode's Kara Swisher at South by Southwest 2018 in Austin, Texas. Perel's new book "The State of Affairs" sets out to change the popular conversation about sexual infidelity, but she says many partners are cheating on each other with their phones. She says dating apps, such as Tinder, wind up discouraging their users from pursuing committed relationships, and also explains the psychology of the sexual harassers and abusers who have been exposed by the #MeToo movement.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by IBM. By 2050, the world population will reach nearly 10 billion, and food production will need to grow by 70%. Farmers are working with IBM and Watson to help increase their crop yields. Let's put smart to work. Find out how at ibm.com/smart. Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. Today, we're going to play an interview I conducted at South by Southwest in Austin, Texas, at BOKS Media's The Deep End. I talked to psychotherapist and bestselling author Esther Perel. She wrote The State of Affairs: Rethinking Infidelity
0:42 Speaker 00 and is the host of the popular podcast, Where Should We Begin? Let's take a listen.
0:49 Speaker 00 All right, Esther. I pronounced it correctly, right? You're married to a southern man? And they call it, what do they call it in the South? Do your American voice for us, please.
0:58 Speaker 01 Esther.
0:59 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:01 Speaker 00 Fantastic. I like it that way. I was telling her she's lucky we don't call her Essie, which is really a horrible name. Sorry to all the Essies in the house, but it is. So we're going to talk about a lot of things. We're going to focus, obviously, on tech because Esther has a lot of thoughts about this. But we're going to have a wide-ranging interview. And I just literally got off the stage with Christiane Amanpour, where she has a new series called, on the main stage, called Sex and Love Across the World, or something like that. And literally, all we talked about were orgasms. And so I'm ready for this discussion. So, and she complimented Esther onstage quite a bit about the work you've done. So let's start just in general. Everyone knows who you are, but talk about what your focus is now. And then we'll get into tech and all, and questions from the audience
1:46 Speaker 00 and things like that.
1:49 Speaker 01 So there's different focus. I just finished a book called The State of Affairs.
1:54 Speaker 00 Right.
1:55 Speaker 01 I just, yesterday, launched the new second season of my podcast, Where Should We Begin?
2:01 Speaker 00 Right.
2:02 Speaker 01 Which is... Unscripted anonymous couples' therapy sessions. So it was the first attempt to bring a therapist's work into a digital form. I said three years ago that my next subject would be men.
2:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
2:18 Speaker 01 And people didn't find it very interesting.
2:21 Speaker 00 Okay.
2:21 Speaker 01 And now they do.
2:23 Speaker 00 Right.
2:25 Speaker 01 So that's where I'm beginning to, I'm creating conversations. Much of my work is about creating conversations about the stuff that we don't talk about.
2:34 Speaker 00 Right.
2:35 Speaker 01 And one of the conversations that needs to happen is a conversation about power and sex and the oldest power exchange structure that has existed between men and women, but together.
2:49 Speaker 00 So let's talk first about, we're gonna get to me too, for sure. But let's talk about this idea of you first doing digital conversations. Tell me how that came about, because people have been, we've had Dr. Ruth, we've got all kinds of sex therapists around, around the globe.
3:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
3:07 Speaker 00 How did you think about doing that and why that, in that format?
3:13 Speaker 01 So my transition from the work of a couples' therapist, working in my practice and working primarily in the clinical world, to entering this digital world is literally three years. It's actually very short. But I had done teleclasses. I used to teach therapists all over the world. I've trained therapists for something years. And then at one point, I met with my co-founder, with Lindsay Rotowski, and I said, "Why don't we once do something like that for the general audience?" I can't see all the people who wanna meet. I know that from the TED Talk, people are writing to me from all over the world, in places where there is no information, and that all over the world is inside the United States too.
3:56 Speaker 01 And I think I can offer something. How do I do it without losing my soul?
4:03 Speaker 00 Right.
4:03 Speaker 01 Like, how do you trade scale and maintain the integrity? And so we launched the first webinar. From the webinar, we began to develop online courses. And in those courses, these are the conversations that people are not having.
4:19 Speaker 00 Right.
4:20 Speaker 01 Around love and sex, in its multiple nuances.
4:25 Speaker 00 And bringing them on was innovative, bringing the couples on. Was that difficult to get people to do that? Or what was?
4:33 Speaker 01 So, the Rekindling Desire course doesn't have live couples. The podcast, we partnered with Audible. And the first time, we just posted on social. And we had maybe a hundred-something people, or maybe more. But they hadn't heard it.
4:52 Speaker 00 Right.
4:52 Speaker 01 These are not my patients, so that I'm not beholden by the confidentiality. They know exactly what they sign up for. And they often wanted the opportunity to work with me. And it was a way to work with me for free and to be brought to New York. And for me, you have the opportunity to work with people from all over the US, not just urban Americans as well. And really cover a diversity of backgrounds in every aspect. Straight couples, trans couples, gay couples, every color and every class, which you don't always get to do that much. I used to have it at NYU, and I missed that.
5:27 Speaker 00 Right.
5:27 Speaker 01 Now, we have...
5:29 Speaker 00 It was just like, overbred New Yorkers you were helping, right?
5:32 Speaker 01 Yes, yes, yes. Yeah. And then, now, it's in the thousands.
5:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:38 Speaker 01 It's thousands of people who want to participate. And now, they've heard it. So, the second season, it's people who heard it. And then, they said, "I want something like that. I want to experience this."
5:49 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:50 Speaker 01 So, it's a very different experience. The ones who applied without having known what this was gonna become. And the ones who applied because they had been immersed in the experience. And they said, "Maybe this could help us."
6:03 Speaker 00 Right. So, let's talk about that. Because, you know... I want to get into the online space, the idea, because we're going to talk about tech bros and relationships. I got a great question online about why maybe there's a lot of sexism because they can't have relationships, which I think is a bit of a canard. I'm not, I'm not clear, but talk about the commonalities of what you've found, because you're getting a wider audience and, and this, we'll get to your new book about, it's about infidelity, correct? Right?
6:27 Speaker 01 It's about relationships through the lens of infidelity.
6:30 Speaker 00 Okay.
6:31 Speaker 01 It's really the broader.
6:32 Speaker 00 Okay. So, talk a little bit about the commonalities that you've found getting to this broader audience. And I hate to use the term scalable, but you've made yourself scalable.
6:40 Speaker 01 It's millions of people.
6:42 Speaker 00 Right.
6:43 Speaker 01 In a hundred and eighty something countries and territories. It's very interesting to know that almost more than forty percent of listeners are men. And they're in every remote country, from Chad to, it's just like, that is incredible. Because it is a public health campaign on relationships. It started out as a creative project, but it actually became something way, way, way bigger.
7:13 Speaker 00 Right.
7:14 Speaker 01 That and the TED Talks.
7:15 Speaker 00 Right.
7:16 Speaker 01 I was to say, I've kind of, you know, it's thousands of letters as well, so I hear it, I see. And I work internationally. I work in seven languages. I don't need translation, so I actually have access to diversity. It's everything. It's a, the commonalities, the human experiences, the major dramas of our life are not different. But what changes are the way we narrate our pain, the interpretation we give to it, what gets weight and what doesn't, the extent to which we think we should suffer, or the extent to which we think we're entitled to be happy. The larger values that predominant, that are dominant within the West, individualistic
8:01 Speaker 01 cultures and the more collective cultures is what really translates all the way straight into your sheets.
8:09 Speaker 00 So, talk about those relationships. Talk about those relationships. What do you, what do you think the predominant thing you're dealing with now? And we'll get to online, because I think online has sort of messed up everything. Or maybe it hasn't. Maybe from your perspective, it hasn't. How do you look at the way relationships changed in the past few years?
8:28 Speaker 01 Okay. By the way, my keynote yesterday was on that and it's up on YouTuber. It's incredible, in a very short amount of time, massive changes have taken place. People marry for love.
8:44 Speaker 01 People tie sexual satisfaction with marital happiness. We have contraception. We can separate sex from reproduction for the first time. We root sexuality in desire within long-term relationships. Male privilege and double standards by which they have always had a license to cheat and nine countries still will kill women just for strength. For the first time, actually, infidelity rates have changed primarily because the rate of women has gone up by 40% because we have divorce laws, because we have economic independence on women. Monogamy used to mean one person for life. Today, monogamy is one person at a time.
9:23 Speaker 00 Okay.
9:24 Speaker 01 I mean, it just is...
9:25 Speaker 00 That's how I look at it.
9:28 Speaker 01 And if you travel the world, you literally see the changes, you know, along every one of these dimensions of relationships. The place of children, the number of children, the meaning of sex as it associates to children. It's not the same when you have eight kids and when you have one or two. There is just about no unit that has transformed more in 100 years than the couple.
9:53 Speaker 00 So, talk about that. Where are we now? And I want to get to the online part of it because I think it has all the Grinders, the Tinders, the... All the various things that have happened, the way people meet and communicate online.
10:05 Speaker 00 Talk a little bit about that, how that has transformed. Because maybe you don't think that's the case, that relationships remain the same
10:11 Speaker 01 No, no, no, no. I mean, you know, there is a conversation about that. Is the dating different but the mating is the same?
10:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
10:18 Speaker 01 Or when the dating changes, does it also change the mating?
10:22 Speaker 00 Right.
10:23 Speaker 01 And I don't think that we know all these answers at this moment. But what we do know is, if I have a choice between two people, it's rather limiting. In the village, I had a choice between two people. Later, I had a choice between six or 10 or 15 people, and that was a lot better. When I have a choice between 1,000 people, it's crippling.
10:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
10:43 Speaker 01 So, I'm on the one hand, looking for the soulmate. We're looking today for the one and only. That one and only is supposed to be the one that's gonna cure you of your case of FOMO. You know, with whom, you have never called anybody soulmate besides God. Now it's become your partner, that is going to fulfill you. It's not just a person with whom you're gonna have the basic needs of Maslow, not even the belonging needs of Maslow. It's the self-fulfillment needs that are gonna come on. And you're doing it with a romantic consumerism whereby, you know, you're constantly doing this, checking if there is nothing better there. And basically, the ritual of commitment becomes deleting the apps.
11:24 Speaker 00 Ritual of commitment, meaning?
11:25 Speaker 01 Meaning, I found the one. I can stop searching. I can delete my app.
11:30 Speaker 00 Right. Does that happen?
11:34 Speaker 01 Ask them.
11:35 Speaker 00 No, it does not. It does not, it does not, because it creates... So what does that change in the, in the way people relate to each other then? In that environment? With endless choice, essentially?
11:47 Speaker 01 So I think that it has created one, it does a lot of things. But one of the phenomenons that it has created that is very, very interesting, which is what I've come to call stable ambiguity. So I meet you, I date you, I like you. I can kind of simmer you, you know? So we can meet on occasion, but I'm simmering a few others as well.
12:14 Speaker 00 Simmering?
12:14 Speaker 01 Yes, simmering. It's like cooking a petit food.
12:16 Speaker 00 No, I know what simmering is.
12:20 Speaker 00 I can simmer. I can simmer cooking, the other one I can't do.
12:24 Speaker 01 And I am with you just enough so I don't have to feel lonely. I've got this relationship in New York, but it isn't really going anywhere. And I have another one in L.A. And it's nice when I'm in L.A., but it isn't also going... This stable ambiguity is just enough constancy and just enough involvement so that I don't have to feel the loneliness that pervades my life. And not too much so that I don't feel that I have made a commitment by which I have forgone my freedom. And that stable ambiguity becomes one very common dating pattern in the moment.
12:59 Speaker 00 Is this a good thing? Or you don't have judgment?
13:02 Speaker 01 I think that...
13:05 Speaker 01 I mean...
13:06 Speaker 00 I can see you go...
13:07 Speaker 01 No, no, no. It's because the world isn't dividing good and bad. I think... I can say that I have rarely heard people tell me it's phenomenal. It feels great. I don't.
13:20 Speaker 00 Right.
13:20 Speaker 01 But they can't really say it's degrading. It actually is half-full. It's fast food. And fast food feeds you, but afterwards leaves you with a bad taste. Because it's not okay to say these things today. You know, you have to be able to pretend that you can be a happy consumer.
13:40 Speaker 00 Right, with that. So what has to change in them? I mean, what do you think when you look at the Tinders, which becomes gamification of dating essentially, or gamification of relationships?
13:50 Speaker 01 But look, it's been a long time since we shifted from procreative to recreative. So I think there's always been a moratorium period. The moratorium period today has extended from, you know, about 15 years of sexual nomadism. If you do it with apps, or if you do it in bars, or it does make a difference. But the fundamental is experimentation without outcome.
14:15 Speaker 00 Right.
14:16 Speaker 01 After that, you still, most people still at some point, want to build a story with a person.
14:24 Speaker 00 Right.
14:24 Speaker 01 You know, and love stories are one thing, and life stories are something else.
14:29 Speaker 00 All right.
14:30 Speaker 01 And at that moment, the question is to what extent has the 15 years of nomadism helped me in creating a more committed relationship with whom I'm going to build something versus it actually has on some small level fucked me up?
14:47 Speaker 00 Right, right. Yeah, yeah, I'd say that.
14:51 Speaker 01 And I think that it varies by the people.
14:53 Speaker 00 By the people.
14:53 Speaker 01 I think it varies by the people.
14:55 Speaker 00 So how do people look at relationship with couples now once they get past the nomad period of their life?
15:01 Speaker 01 They have unrealistic expectations. It goes from a period of such disaffiliated relationships in which you are meant to have, it's like a race to the bottom. How can I have connections with people with whom I feel the least?
15:15 Speaker 00 Okay, yeah.
15:17 Speaker 01 And then go to the finding of the soulmate and the one.
15:20 Speaker 00 Right.
15:20 Speaker 01 And this is the two extremes, I think, in which a lot of people live. Do you relate to these people?
15:25 Speaker 00 Yeah, oh yeah.
15:26 Speaker 01 Oh, just wanna make sense.
15:28 Speaker 00 Yeah. No, they're all totally happy in their relationships.
15:31 Speaker 01 I can't see them, I don't have my glasses.
15:33 Speaker 00 No, we're gonna ask them questions in a minute. We're gonna ask in groups of questions, because Esther wants to see a theme. But when you're, but so, do you blame technology for this? Or do you think it's just humanity, as they just get more tools to find more? Or should something be fixed about it in order to get people?
15:50 Speaker 01 I think technology is a manifestation of the world of options.
15:55 Speaker 00 Right.
15:55 Speaker 01 Our world of relationships has shifted from a model that was organized around duty and obligation to a model that is around freedom and choice. And the choice just keeps getting bigger. None of us seem to wanna go back to the previous era.
16:11 Speaker 00 No.
16:12 Speaker 01 But we all understand that the massive amounts of choices that we have have left us with a tremendous sense of uncertainty, a chronic ailment of self-doubt, and constantly is, how do I know? How do I know it is the person? You know, because now I only have myself to rely upon. I have to make all the big decisions that used to be made for me. And this is actually a psychological shift. It's not for nothing that people feel exhausted. It's just not because they've been swiping, swiping.
16:46 Speaker 00 Right.
16:47 Speaker 01 You know, that doesn't tire you. It's the, it's the knowing. It's the figuring out, who am I? What do I want? What do I need? Is it really what I need? Is what I need what I think I need? How happy am I when I need this thing? And when I find it, how do I know it is the thing that I was looking for?
17:02 Speaker 00 That was just one of Esther's sessions, just as I can see, I can mind.
17:08 Speaker 00 Okay, I'm exhausted by that.
17:12 Speaker 00 So what do you, how do you get to that successful? And then I wanna talk about the mistakes we've made. And I do wanna talk about me too, also. Even though we've talked about it a lot, I think we need to talk about it all the time until everyone's completely exhausted by it. But talk about what then make, how do you move into a successful relationship?
17:31 Speaker 01 I think that the first thing is, there is no perfection. There is no the one. There is a one that you meet at some point with whom you're gonna write a story and you could have written another one. And the beauty is that today we can actually write two or three stories in the course of our life, and many for that matter. And sometimes with more than one person at a time as well. So that's the first thing. And then you understand that optimization is not the only model. Contentment goes a long way. What they call satisfizers, as my friend Logan Newery just said. You know, there is something about, let me see where this takes me, rather than, is this it? And then go with it and explore yourself.
18:15 Speaker 01 And don't think that you know it all immediately just because of the picture or just because of the first date. Relationships take time. They are experiences that are iterative processes. I say, you respond, I check your response, I gauge you, I bring in something else. It's iterative and reiterative. And this is the thing that we have really lost with the digital. The digital is flat. It's two dimensional. You don't have to see, you don't have to sense. So, and we know that people's communication online is massively distorted. They think, they are sure they understood what the other person said. And all the sociolinguistic studies tell you they don't. So this is part of what you lose.
18:59 Speaker 01 So once you get off the app, you meet a person. And then the rest is your experience with the person. But more and more, we have lost skills. We lose skills.
19:11 Speaker 00 It's an interesting thing. My son met his first girlfriend on Snapchat, which I found disturbing in every single fashion. And then they met in person and it was a disaster. I mean, you know, now he has, although now he refuses to call anyone a girlfriend, but that's another, I'll bring him in.
19:26 Speaker 01 I have two.
19:29 Speaker 00 But no one's a girlfriend. Like it's, I don't even understand it anymore. But it was interesting because I was like, you can't really get to know someone on Snapchat. But he did feel like he had a connection. It was an interesting, because there are connections. There are connections you make online with people that are very rich, can be very rich. We're gonna take a quick break now for a word from our sponsors. We'll return to this live interview from South by Southwest 2018 in a minute. Today's show is brought to you by Brooklinen. They want to upgrade your nightly routine and help you feel more well-rested every day. You spend a third of your life in your sheets. Better sheets means better sleep. Brooklinen sells the high-quality sheets without the crazy markup you might get in stores. It's the fastest-growing bedding brand in the world. The sheets come in a variety of colors and patterns,
20:14 Speaker 00 and you can mix and match to complement any decor. My Brooklinen sheets are very comfortable and some of the best that I've slept on. Brooklinen.com has an exclusive offer just for my listeners. Get $20 off and free shipping when you use the promo code RECODE at Brooklinen.com. Brooklinen is so confident that they offer a risk-free 60-night satisfaction guarantee and a lifetime warranty on all their sheets and comforters. The only way to get $20 off and free shipping is to use the promo code RECODE at Brooklinen.com. That's B-R-O-O-K-L-I-N-E-N dot com, promo code RECODE. So let's talk about, also, not just that you, that this is a flat communications tool,
20:59 Speaker 00 but it also gets in the way of relationships now. I have, I have an issue with my phone. I admit it. I use it all the time. I like it near me. I've had it a lot. It's, it's not the best relationship I've ever had, but it is. So people are, this gets in the way, this idea, and you see it around South by Southwest.
21:19 Speaker 01 Yes, it's technology in the bedroom. The amount of people, the last thing they stroke before they go to bed is their phone, and the first thing they stroke before they go, when they wake up, is their phone. So it's a really, it's a, it's a choreography. I mean, basically, I'm here, you know, I take the phone.
21:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
21:38 Speaker 01 And when I wake up in the morning, I do this instead of actually spooning you.
21:42 Speaker 00 Right.
21:43 Speaker 01 And... Or as one of my patients recently said, you know, it's like every night I go to bed and she's on Instagram in the bed. And it's like, I'm lonely. I just want to talk, to chat, to connect. And she's just like getting lost and zoned. And it creates a new definition of loneliness. You know, they talk about loneliness all the time at this moment. It is the public health crisis number one. But what they really are distinguishing is that it no longer has to do with being socially isolated. It has to do with experiencing kind of a loss of trust and a loss of capital while you are next to the person with whom you're supposed to not be lonely with.
22:24 Speaker 01 And so you're lying there, you know, when your partner went to work and stayed at work till midnight, you knew that they were not there. Now they're home, but they're not really present. And what we, and we call this, in psychology, we call it ambiguous loss. Ambiguous loss is what you feel when a person is physically present, but psychologically gone, like Alzheimer. But the same thing happens when your person is lost. Looking at Instagram. They're lost. You can't, you talk to them and they don't hear you and they don't answer you. And they're physically present. And that is a very confusing experience. Ambiguous loss is also the reverse, is when somebody is psychologically gone, psychologically present, but physically gone, like when they're kidnapped. Right.
23:09 Speaker 01 Okay, so. Like when they're kidnapped. Yes, like when they're, when you're in situations. Right. But the point is, you don't know if you need to let go or if you have to hold on. Right. That's why it is such a stressing thing. Should I call for attention while you're in your Insta, lost? Or should I actually just accept that I'm on my own? And you stay and you wait for them to end, to close it, to turn around, to turn off the light, to connect with you, and they don't. And when that happens, night after night.
23:40 Speaker 00 What do you advise then? What do you do? Do you grab the phone and run? What do you do? That's a psychological tool.
23:46 Speaker 01 In this case, I basically said, the first thing I think I said, which wasn't so clear, because he didn't say it like that either. He just says, "It annoys me." And I just said, "You're lonely." "You're lonely." You know, to sit there next to someone because it's gone on. Then I said to her, "Do you know he's lonely? Does it matter to you?"
24:08 Speaker 00 Right.
24:08 Speaker 01 Because I can't imagine that that's actually what you intend to do. You know, and what would happen if instead of watching what everybody else is posting, you actually checked in with him for a moment? You know, do you think you... Do you worry that you're gonna lose yourself or anything? You just engage in a conversation that is not about blame, that allows people to reflect, that allows people to take responsibility, that banks on their good intention. And then you say, "You're gonna try three things differently and let's see which one of them works." Because I don't know what will work better, but I can tell you that if you continue this, I can tell you where you're gonna end up.
24:46 Speaker 00 And what was the response from your perspective? It's so common. This is such a common issue now.
24:52 Speaker 01 You know, you... Look, the greatest invention that was ever made in Western civilization was the invention of the Sabbath. Somebody understood in one of the oldest creation stories that you needed a day off. Because when you stop, it's not just that you take a break, it's that you recharge. You, you know, you restore. It's like, and you build back. And when you never stop, something begins to happen to your brain. That is not... This is like couch neuroscience, but it's kind of out there at this point. And you basically explain the same way, how do you tell people that it's not healthy to eat McDonald's every day? It's a whole education.
25:35 Speaker 00 Right.
25:36 Speaker 01 And you basically say, "It's gonna destroy your relationship."
25:39 Speaker 00 Right.
25:40 Speaker 01 Do you want that? If you don't, I can actually give you a few ideas. Get an alarm clock. When you go for dinner with him, leave your phone in your bag, don't put it on the table, and certainly don't take it with you when you go to the bathroom, because you end up staying there 20 minutes.
25:55 Speaker 00 Right, yeah.
25:56 Speaker 01 You know, while he's sitting.
25:57 Speaker 00 That is the national emergency bathroom lines. Because of Instagram.
26:01 Speaker 01 And instead of texting back and forth 50 times, the amount of time that takes, just pick up the phone and talk for three minutes and arrange it. It actually, you know, the voice, the loss of the voice, the voice is really the first thing that a baby hears in neutral. We need the voice. It's the most soothing thing. People don't hear the voice. Call, call, you know. And you basically say, would you do that with me for a week? I am trying to write an article and I would like to see if it would make a difference. Would you like to be a participant in my study? And then after a week, they come back and you say, did it make a difference? And then you say, what will it take for you to continue and do that?
26:40 Speaker 00 Right.
26:41 Speaker 01 And then you, you know.
26:42 Speaker 00 Now, do most people say, I'm excited, does anyone come saying, no, I really do like my phone better?
26:46 Speaker 01 No.
26:46 Speaker 00 No.
26:47 Speaker 01 No, the, the, it actually, you know, the majority of people feel calmer. The first thing is they feel calmer. They're not constantly thinking that there's something important that they need to be in touch with. It allows them to be more present. It allows them to learn to self-soothe. It does a lot of things. There's nothing wrong with it. I love my phone too, you know, so. But there is something about, basically, at this point, people are primarily in triangular situations. They are rarely just with the person that they're with.
27:18 Speaker 00 Right, so they're cheating on their partner with their phone.
27:21 Speaker 01 All the time, all the time.
27:22 Speaker 00 So talk about the infidelity book. What were you trying to get to? I don't recall. You said it's beyond that. Can you talk about what you were trying? Because your last book was Mating in Captivity.
27:31 Speaker 01 Mating in, I've written Mating in Captivity. I've written The State of Affairs. And primarily what I do is I study modern relationships. I study also what are the expectations that we bring to relationships? How have our mentalities changed? And what is the, in the dance between love and desire in relationships? And particularly, I study desire because it is one of the most organizing principles of our Western societies. So too in everything that technology does. The "Mating in Captivity" was about the dilemmas of desire inside the relationship, and the state of affairs looked at what happens when desire goes looking elsewhere. Here is this subject called infidelity.
28:13 Speaker 01 It has existed since marriage was invented, so too the taboo against it. And it is treated in the most reductionistic, you know, black and white victim perpetrator model, something that affects almost half the population worldwide, in every model of marriage.
28:33 Speaker 00 Probably more than half of them.
28:34 Speaker 01 You know, we will never know because men lie up and women lie down. Men exaggerate in their lying and women diminish in their lying. So we will actually never really know, and the questions that are asked are very misleading. So I wanted the stories behind, and I wanted to create a new conversation for the oldest sin that embraces the complexities of infidelity and does justice to the millions of people who are in the throes of it and in the pains of it.
29:02 Speaker 00 So what is the most difficult part of that? Because a lot of it has to do, not just with the infidelity, but it's the lying and the hurt and the cruelty a lot of the time that can go with it.
29:13 Speaker 01 Yes, I mean, what is so difficult around infidelity, like in many other aspects of relationships, is that it's two people experiencing one event in completely differentiated ways. There's nothing that they can share about it. So, you know, sometimes I am lying to you, but I have the experience that maybe for the first time I've stopped lying to myself.
29:37 Speaker 00 Right.
29:38 Speaker 01 And how do I tell you that? So the difficulty around the subject is how do you create a dual perspective? What it did to you and what it meant for me. And at the heart of affairs, there is lying and deception and gaslighting and a breach of trust and a violation and all of that. But at the heart of affairs is also often yearning and longing and loss for the person that I once was and have not met in so many decades, for reconnecting with a sense of aliveness, for vitality, for intensity.
30:13 Speaker 00 Right, in a good way, in a, in a, in a good way. So we should give Donald Trump a break on the porn star. I think we should. No, don't laugh at me, Esther. No, we should not, we should not give him a break on the porn star. No, okay.
30:29 Speaker 01 Infidelity is one thing.
30:31 Speaker 00 Right.
30:31 Speaker 01 And this is a different thing, which I will let you name.
30:34 Speaker 00 Okay, I don't know. I want you to name it. You're the relationship expert.
30:37 Speaker 01 Crass.
30:38 Speaker 00 Crass, okay.
30:39 Speaker 01 Crass.
30:39 Speaker 00 Crass, okay. All right, okay, that's a good word. So when that happens, when you have that, what are some of the...
30:45 Speaker 01 Exploitation, manipulation.
30:47 Speaker 00 Right, yeah.
30:47 Speaker 01 Power trips.
30:48 Speaker 00 Power trips, so let's get to that.
30:50 Speaker 01 Misogyny. I mean, it has names, it's not new.
30:52 Speaker 00 So talk about that, what's happening now, with the people talking out. I mean, it was... This, what happened with Donald Trump happened millions of times, and people paid off and kept people quiet. And same thing with Me Too. When you look at what's happening now, is that very different? The voices of Me Too, the voices of Time's Up? What do you imagine is occurring now? Because it feels like an earthquake in male-female relationships.
31:18 Speaker 01 I, you know, it's interesting, because when you write about infidelity, you write about consensual relationships.
31:24 Speaker 00 Right.
31:25 Speaker 01 It is really not a situation of harassment. That's kind of... Seduction is one thing.
31:30 Speaker 00 They're often conflated, though.
31:32 Speaker 01 Yes, mistakenly. Mistakenly. I mean, infidelity are generally consensual experiences. And they are experiences of seduction. They're not experiences of harassment. You know, that is where they part. Now, I think that there's something very beautiful, as in powerful and important, happening in us challenging or taking on or taking, putting under intense scrutiny the oldest power exchange system, which was that forever men traded social power...
32:05 Speaker 00 For sex.
32:06 Speaker 01 For sex. Often sex that they would not have been able to have if they could not compensate. Which is why I think there's something, and I'll finish my thought first, and women traded the power that was available to them, which often was youth and beauty and sex, for access to the social status and power that was denied to them. This has been an old economy. And what's important about that to understand is that sexually powerful men don't harass, they seduce. It's the insecure men who need to use power
32:49 Speaker 01 in order to leverage the insecurity and the inaccessibility or the unavailability of the woman.
32:57 Speaker 01 Women may fear rape and men fear humiliation.
33:01 Speaker 00 So you're saying these people are insecure, the ones that the stories that is based in...
33:08 Speaker 01 Yes, that underneath the use of power lies a deep sense of powerlessness. And then you manipulate and you exploit the power that you have in order to cover that. It's, you know, it's like, the way I look at power dynamics is the way that you play pool. If you want one ball to hit the hole, it is never that one that you need to kick. Things are not pushed by the stuff that is linear. It's something else that needs to push this thing. This is the way power dynamics work. What you see on the surface is a powerful man. What is in reality is a man that is suffering from, suffering is maybe a nice word, but, you know,
33:50 Speaker 01 from lack of, and then uses the power available in, basically harassment is a form of erotic sadism.
33:57 Speaker 00 That's a great way of putting it.
33:58 Speaker 01 That is what it is, because it's the difference from rape.
34:01 Speaker 00 It's interesting that, but you're not casting as a victim, because I think most people just want to kick them.
34:06 Speaker 01 Why, that doesn't victimize the person at all, it just gives a more accurate description.
34:10 Speaker 00 Description of what's going on.
34:11 Speaker 01 Of where you, you know, of what may be activating this. Why would a person, you know, put you in a situation in which every day when you come to work, you don't really know what you're gonna expect?
34:23 Speaker 00 Right.
34:24 Speaker 01 Will this be a normal day? Or will this be one of these complete slimy, icky days in which the entire time you want to take a shower?
34:31 Speaker 00 Right, right.
34:33 Speaker 01 I think you understand the difference.
34:34 Speaker 00 Right.
34:34 Speaker 01 And the whole sadism is that you don't know.
34:37 Speaker 00 Right, right. So what's gonna happen next? And then we'll get to questions from the audience. What do you imagine happening next with this? Where does it go? Is it unprecedented, or has it happened before and then it dies down? Because you're talking about it as an economy, and you're absolutely right, that this is a power economy. How does the economy shift? Because economies have shifted many times.
34:56 Speaker 01 Always. I mean, for me, when I try to understand it, and I look at other norms that have changed. You know, powerful social norms that shifted, corporal punishment.
35:08 Speaker 01 Many people, maybe even in this room, may still have been part of a system that believed that if you get your butt kicked, it builds character. That is no longer the norm. How do we shift a norm like this? And you watch norms.
35:23 Speaker 00 Okay, marriage, all kinds.
35:24 Speaker 01 You took, literally took it out of my mouth. You know, for me, those are two very powerful examples. Because it's multifactorial. You don't change it from one place. You know, for me, it is about two things. We have done a lot of work for the past forty years, helping women, girls, find their voice and their power. But it needs to be matched with helping boys, not helping. It is our responsibility as a society to stop stripping boys of their emotionality, starting at age four. Mothers first. We touch our boys less than we touch our girls. We strip them, literally, of their connectivity, of their need for others, so that we can instead put in there
36:09 Speaker 01 a making of a performance-based masculinity about fearlessness, competitiveness, self-reliance, and all the stuff that we then know has all kinds of deleterious effects just on themselves, regardless of harassment. And if we, if we, the lives of women will not change until the lives of men changes too.
36:29 Speaker 00 Right, I agree.
36:30 Speaker 01 These things are interdependent. And so the notion for me, that is maybe a little different, where we say, "They need to be quiet now." They, they, this is their time to listen and to shut up. No, this is their time to finally have the right to have conversations about themselves and about masculinity, and the making of manhood, and the definitional voids that is pervasive around manhood, so that we can create a more true equality.
36:56 Speaker 00 No, you're a hundred percent correct. I think it's really, it's hard to get, because right now in Silicon Valley, it's like I can't say anything. I have so many men saying that to me. I'm like, "Stop it, you certainly can't."
37:05 Speaker 01 So I've done conversations like that. I've led a bunch of these conversations, from eighty to a thousand people, where I literally create fishbowls and have the conversations about the stuff. Listen, often when men end up talking like this... It's not just that they've never said it to anybody else. In the majority of cases, they've never even uttered it out loud to themselves. And it is powerful. And that is, for me, where the intersection is to take place.
37:34 Speaker 00 And with each other, and talking about it with each other, which is interesting. Yeah, I just had an instance with my son. I was just talking to him, walking over here, and one of his friends did something to a girl that wasn't welcome. And his first thing, his friend's first thing was like, "I didn't do it that way." And my son, which, I mean, honestly, I think all, as I've said before, all men should be raised by lesbians, but it's true. He said, "Well, you really have to stop treating women badly, and here's why." And he had a discussion with his friend, and I thought that was much more powerful than the woman who we bothered. I thought it was a really interesting...
38:07 Speaker 01 So I go into companies, and I work on relationships, and I work on relational intelligence, and I do it with co-founders. And, I mean, my way is through conversation. Because if you no longer have rules and set up structures of power and social hierarchies, the only thing you have to deal with relationships is conversations, negotiations. And that needs to be learned. Those things are not innate.
38:32 Speaker 00 Some things are, though. Talking and the way people communicate, the way the companies are set up. We're much more aggressive. I mean, they just are.
38:41 Speaker 01 It's innate that we learn vocabulary. It's not innate that we learn to express a vocabulary to someone who, in your presence, is having another experience than you.
38:50 Speaker 00 We're going to take another break for a word from our sponsors. We'll return to this live interview from South by Southwest after this. Today's show is brought to you by Freshly. Meal kits are so last year. Freshly is the new way to get dinner on the table in no time. Their chefs send you delicious, freshly-prepared meals so you can eat better without any of the work. No cooking or cleanup required. Their meals are delivered to your door fresh and ready whenever you are. Just heat them up when you're hungry. My sons ate everything Freshly sent to our house and they loved it. I did not actually get a bite because they ate it all. Freshly chefs and nutritionists make sure that every meal is all-natural, nutritious, and made with high-quality ingredients. So now you can come home late and still have a delicious chef-cooked meal waiting for you.
39:33 Speaker 00 Just choose from the rotating menu of 30 options. Try Freshly and you'll see what it's like to put zero effort into making dinner. Go to freshly.com/decode and get $25 off your first order of six meals. That's $25 off plus free shipping at freshly.com/decode. All right, let's get questions from the audience. Let's get three or four questions quickly. Hands up, come on, I know you have questions right here.
40:00 Speaker 02 Hey there. Just starting from where we are, you speak a lot in both of your books about the effects of feminism, I think, on intimate relationships. And I don't want to misparaphrase you, but...
40:13 Speaker 00 Can I make a little personal?
40:14 Speaker 02 Yeah. Just that you talk about the way that, I think, that feminism in society has possibly affects relationships between men and women and that equality or equanimity is not necessarily the thing that makes for good sex. Is that fair to say? That you, in your books, that's something you... So then, looking at where society is going now, I mean, this kind of amazing moment, do you currently see, in your practice, the way that the either Me Too movements or the sort of the C-chains that's going on, do you see that trickle down into practice yet?
40:57 Speaker 02 Or do you have anticipation about how that might either positively or negatively affect intimate relationships?
41:06 Speaker 00 Okay, just a second, is there another question? So we can see if there's another. Right there, behind you.
41:11 Speaker 03 Hi. I have a question. I'm a chef and I usually work in an environment with a lot of men that behave with this macho culture that you're describing. How do you go to talk about these men and how you feel without them feeling that you're attacking in any way? That you just wanna create a better environment for, you know, for the future generations? How do you go and express yourself in a way that is not, that they don't perceive that you're a threat?
41:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, the attack thing.
41:48 Speaker 03 Great question.
41:49 Speaker 00 Alright, let's do those two.
41:50 Speaker 01 Okay.
41:53 Speaker 01 So, what I have said is not at all something that links feminism to desire. What I have said is that sexual desire is not always politically correct. And it doesn't always abide by the rules of good citizenship. Meaning that, but it is, but, but when you're playing, when you're talking about desire and when you're talking about sexuality, you can't strip power from sex. But it is a play on power. That is the complete difference. You know, everybody's wondering, why is it that some people would demonstrate during the day against certain things that they would totally delight at night? Because that is the difference between reality and play.
42:38 Speaker 01 You know, we do, in our fantasies, sometimes want to experiment with the very same things that for the life of us we wouldn't want to experience in, in reality. And that juxtaposition is very important to keep in mind. You know, I want equality in my salaries, in my, in the responsibilities that I get, in what people think I'm capable of, etc., etc. And when I am in a sexual interaction, I want to be able to experience a different hierarchy in which there is no more powerful position than voluntary surrender. But the key word is voluntary. Giving yourself to somebody is an absolute experience
43:23 Speaker 01 of sovereignty and autonomy and freedom. That's the interplay between, you know, feminism in itself is, you know, is only an issue when people wonder, "How can I say this and want that?" Because every child that plays being a prisoner and a guard, for example, knows the difference between when they're playing. Nobody would want to be a prisoner. But there is something fun about playing the prisoner, for example. You know, the fireman, the teacher, all of that.
43:57 Speaker 00 Or whatever you like.
43:58 Speaker 01 Whatever you...
44:00 Speaker 00 We don't judge. We judge a little bit, but we're not gonna say.
44:03 Speaker 01 And then, the question about how you talk to men. I think that, for me, when I begin to think about that question, it's really this. We are born women, and we become men, from chromosome on. Masculinity is a fragile identity. It constantly has to prove itself. It has to test itself. It has to go out into the woods in every culture. There's not a single culture where women have to go prove that they have now become women. And that makes the issue of being the threat so important. Why is it such a vernacular to say, "How do I talk to them without them feeling that it's a threat?" Because there is a fragility underneath. Otherwise, you wouldn't be threatening.
44:47 Speaker 01 So you are not the issue. The threat is not the issue. It's the fragility that is the issue. And that's why I said, probably the deepest ache is humiliation. It's the humiliation. The word "emasculation" does not exist in the feminine, and neither does the word "loser." And so, how do you talk? You talk in a way that doesn't put people down, the same way that we want to be talked to. You talk in a way that lets the other person maintain a sense of dignity, that they can still have their... You can say "no" in a way that doesn't make them feel that small. "No" to anything. "You know, I don't want to do this or that." Doesn't matter. But a certain way that leaves people not instantly diminished.
45:32 Speaker 01 And neither women nor men want to feel diminished or degraded by the aggression of somebody else.
45:40 Speaker 00 But you've got to naturally assume there's some moment where you don't... Sometimes, I feel, as gay person, you're always... Allowing for that, making sure that they feel comfortable and it's not returned in the same way. In that if they can feel badly for a minute, maybe it's okay because of...
45:56 Speaker 01 Oh, feeling bad is fine.
45:58 Speaker 00 What I mean is, you make them feel under attack. Is that a problem? You just can't, it just won't work.
46:03 Speaker 01 No, but I also want to protect myself. I'm not interested in creating the wrath of somebody else.
46:09 Speaker 00 Right.
46:10 Speaker 01 So there's a way in which you set a limit that doesn't create an escalation. I don't want it.
46:15 Speaker 00 Sure, sure, but my point being is that right now with all the, the backlash happened rather quickly, like two minutes into it.
46:21 Speaker 01 But she's not talking about it.
46:22 Speaker 00 Right, but she should, she has to worry about how she talks versus how they receive. And why in the world do we have to be so fucking polite to people all the time? That's all, you know what I mean? Like, so what if they feel...
46:33 Speaker 01 I don't think you have to be polite to people. I think that you want to do something that actually serves you well.
46:39 Speaker 00 Okay, all right, to get to what you want. But it often seems like women and people of color always have to say, be forgiving, but that's a different issue.
46:46 Speaker 01 Oh, see, I know that can be taken this way, but that's not, that...
46:50 Speaker 00 All right, we're gonna disagree on that one. I used to have to apologize for people being gay and I'm fucking sick of it. All right, so, um, two more questions.
46:59 Speaker 01 I accept.
47:00 Speaker 00 Two more quick questions.
47:02 Speaker 04 I don't have a question, I just want to thank you because I've listened to both seasons of, of your audible podcast and your insight is so beautiful and, um, and your common sense is just right there. And I think really there are two crises going on. One is raising young men and boys with a feminine side, which is so, so crucial. Um, and, and the whole social media. I have two young adult children and the things you were saying about, you know, turning the phone off and don't let that be the last thing you stroke is, you know, I raise my kids day after day after day that, you know, relationships are the most important things in our lives.
47:44 Speaker 04 And, um, I wish you could be in all of our schools teasing our children. To get off their phones. I mean, they are wonderful tools, but they don't, they don't build relationships.
47:55 Speaker 00 But it is hard, it's irresistible. They're irresistible.
47:58 Speaker 04 Absolutely.
47:59 Speaker 00 All right.
47:59 Speaker 04 But we need to teach it.
48:01 Speaker 00 Thank you. One back there. Right, oh, back, another question.
48:06 Speaker 05 Hello, Esther. Just wanted to thank you so much for your work. And my question relates to, there can be people who, particularly men, maybe they're, they're male allies, so they, they understand what you're talking about. But what do you, how do you deal with, you know, that hyper masculine, people who are going to see this as weakness and who are going to be dismissive of it? How do you reach them and not kind of create a gulf between the male allies and men who are just going to see them as, as cowards and it's going to create an even bigger barrier?
48:36 Speaker 01 Numbers. It used to be that there was one divorced child, one child of a divorced family in a classroom, and so they felt very, very different. But once it was more than half the classroom, it became actually much more normative. I used to work for many, many years with interracial, intercultural, interreligious couples. That was my specialty. You know, and every, and they were the only ones often, the only ones in their whole neighborhood. Well, then you feel like you are the, the other. But once it becomes the number, then it, then the, the balance shifts. And if for that, you need to build the capital of people who gradually begin to stand up
49:17 Speaker 01 to the other men, and you first do it quietly, then you bring it into the public sphere, and gradually, it, the, the volume rises on your side and diminishes on the other side. But that takes a decade.
49:31 Speaker 00 For this to, for what, it takes a decade to get that?
49:35 Speaker 01 But once it gets going, it can't be stopped. That's the important thing. Every one of those changes that took place, you know, it's what become, what, what, what was the norm now becomes the stigma.
49:49 Speaker 00 No, absolutely. So I want to finish up. No more time left. But when you talk about that idea of how you do make changes and shifts, you said you're optimistic. Are you hopeful that this is a moment held by... Whatever, everybody's talking about it, for sure. And social media helps that, technology helps that and hurts it. Do you think it's one of these great moments?
50:15 Speaker 01 You know why I'm optimistic? In an interesting way, if I make it personal. I have been working on relationships for 35 years. I rarely went into companies before. Only if there was a crisis, and it usually was called "soft skills."
50:30 Speaker 00 The soft what?
50:31 Speaker 01 The soft skills.
50:32 Speaker 00 Right.
50:32 Speaker 01 And I thought, "What's soft about it?" But now, I'm constantly going to work on this subject. And in varieties of ways, the fact that relational intelligence, which implies power dynamics, implies trust, implies communication, implies listening, implies accountability, implies the whole relationship with the founders and all of that. That, for me, says something's shifting.
51:00 Speaker 00 That they're interested in.
51:01 Speaker 01 They're interested, they understand that, you know, product, performance, all of this matters. Data matters, but there is a whole other reality that has to do with relationships, and big data won't capture that.
51:14 Speaker 00 Right.
51:15 Speaker 01 And that's how I know something's happening, and I'm not the only one. There is something about psychologists or whatever, you know, people who have delved into this thing called relationships that has become essential to an economy of experience. And so people want to understand relationships. And I think that's what has happened that I see that makes me be positive. And I think anything that takes apart, that dismantles a system of oppression, which, this is a system of oppression, the harassment thing we talk about, I cannot think will not be good. You know?
51:52 Speaker 01 But that's it. Because I am a child of two Holocaust survivor parents, and I know oppression. It's like, when fascism sets in, that's why he can't be let off the hook.
52:04 Speaker 00 Right. No, I don't want to... I'm not... I don't know if you see my Twitter, but I'm not a pal.
52:12 Speaker 01 We do agree. You know, it's like, I, I, I, you know, it's like, there's certain things that when you've grown up with something, it's in your veins, it's in your blood. So that's why I am positive because, because I don't mind the roar. I think it's very good.
52:29 Speaker 00 I mean, I see the funniest question at the end, it is related to Trump. If you would advise him and Melania, what would you do? What would be your first move? Because she looks unhappy. I don't know if it's just me.
52:43 Speaker 00 Look, you'd be great.
52:44 Speaker 01 Nobody asked her for her opinion. I mean, she, you know, I, I, I don't know a clue about this woman, but I have a feeling from the little bit that I've listened to her in some of the interviews, that she actually, um, this is the way I sometimes say it. When you pick a person, you pick a story. And sometimes you are recruited for a play that you didn't audition for.
53:08 Speaker 00 Right, right.
53:09 Speaker 01 And I see this woman, like, she's in the wrong play every time. It's not the character she wants to be, like, how the hell did she find herself? She just wanted a green card. And I've been there.
53:26 Speaker 01 I also wanted a green card one day. And, and, you know, and then she maybe have wanted someone with whom she could have an arrangement. And everybody's entitled to their relational arrangement. But this, this is not a play that she didn't audition for.
53:42 Speaker 00 So what would you advise her? What would you say? Get out, get out.
53:47 Speaker 01 Look, this is, this would not happen. If she wants to get out, she wouldn't come to me.
53:51 Speaker 00 Yeah.
53:52 Speaker 01 And if she comes to me, she would be asking me, how do I tolerate this for another, I hope, not six years.
53:57 Speaker 00 Yeah, and what about to him? What would you say to him? Look, everyone needs redemption, presumably, not him, but okay.
54:05 Speaker 01 I would say to him, you know, I'm in a bit of a bind because when I work with men like you, I often feel that I overwork. You make me want to say all kinds of things while you're looking at me with contempt. And contempt is the number one killer of relationships. You have no intention to change because you have no incentive to change because that is what happens to men like you. So I'm not sure I'm going to be able to help you. But if one day you really want some help, just give me a call.
54:37 Speaker 00 All right, then. On that note, let's hit the road. Thanks for listening to this live interview from South by Southwest in Austin, Texas. Special thanks to Andrew Marino for recording it. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find all our past interviews in whatever app you use to listen to this or on our website, recode.net/podcast. And if you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts. That helps other people find the show. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other Recode Radio podcasts. On Recode Media with Peter Kafka, you'll hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment. I also host Too Embarrassed to Ask along with Lauren Good of The Verge, where I answer all of your questions about consumer tech. And on Recode Replay,
55:20 Speaker 00 you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including the Code Conference and Code Media. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. And thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then. 16 million new collar jobs will be created by 2024. To help fill them, IBM's new education model gives high school students workplace experience and an associate's degree. 90 P-TEC schools are already preparing graduates for tomorrow's STEM careers. Let's put smart to work. Find out how at ibm.com/petec.
Previous Recode Decode: Anthony 'The Mooch' Scaramucci Next Recode Decode: What men and women need to know about working together Page updated October 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated