Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Susan Rice About this episode Susan Rice, the former US ambassador to the United Nations and National Security Advisor under President Obama, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about the "ass backwards" way President Trump has approached foreign policy and her new book, Tough Love: My Story of the Things Worth Fighting For. Rice explains the problem with isolationism and selfishness as policies, and says the current administration rolled back many of her achievements "out of spite," without a plan to replace them. She also discusses how Russia and other adversaries have wielded social media to sow division, why she will not abide the normalization of Trump's presidential tweets, and why the tech industry is "five minutes from midnight" with the US Congress.
Read a full transcript of this interview here.
Featuring:
Susan Rice (@AmbassadorRice), former US ambassador to the United Nations and National Security Advisor; author of Tough Love: My Story of the Things Worth Fighting For
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Reset, Recode's new podcast that explores why — and how — tech is changing everything.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,426 words · 11 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 You're busy. We know that, so we'll keep this quick. Introducing AMEX Corporate, now featuring the Corporate Cash Back Card. For one annual flat fee, get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, plus intelligent expense management with the unmatched expertise and backing of American Express. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:33 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio, or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-Cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:50 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:56 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who is jumping into the Democratic primary because apparently anyone can do it. But in my spare time, I'm just a reporter, and you're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about power, change, and the people you need to know around the tech industry who are part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play a live interview I recently recorded with Susan Rice, the former U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations and National Security Advisor under President Obama. She's also the author of the book Tough Love: My Story of Things Worth Fighting For. I spoke to Ambassador Rice at an event celebrating the 100th anniversary of Georgetown University's School of Foreign Service, where I also went to school. So let's go to the campus of Georgetown University to hear my conversation with Susan Rice.
1:47 Speaker 02 This is good. Okay. I usually interview tech people, but I've been interviewing a ton of political people lately, including Speaker Pelosi, a number of senators, actually on both sides of the aisle, and many, many others, talking about sort of global issues because I talk about tech and tech packs everything. But first, I want to...
2:10 Speaker 03 Talk a little bit about your background so people can get a sense. Because it was a really, the book, you sort of, I didn't know this about you. I had an idea that you were a super high achievement person, one of those people.
2:20 Speaker 04 Except I didn't go to Georgetown, so that was my first mistake.
2:23 Speaker 03 Wait, what was it Harvard?
2:25 Speaker 04 Stanford.
2:26 Speaker 03 Stanford, right, oh yeah, which I couldn't get into. So Georgetown people couldn't get into Stanford. Anyway, so it's fair. It's a fair assessment. So let's talk a little bit about your background. So people get a sense of how you came up to start focusing on foreign policy. And obviously, we really do have to get to the issues of just even yesterday and what's going on. There's so many issues. Oh God, what happened?
2:54 Speaker 03 I feel now like I can't take a shower.
2:56 Speaker 04 You can't.
2:57 Speaker 03 You know, like, I go in the shower and then I'm like, what? We're at war with who? Like, huh? Who was arrested? Anyway, so let's start with your background, which is really interesting. Your whole family's background, which is sort of the American story. Talk a little bit about, going back to your, I guess, great grandparents.
3:14 Speaker 04 Okay. Well, good morning, everyone, and thank you so much for coming out. And Kara, thank you so much for having me on your podcast and doing this. Madam Speaker, it's an honor to be in your presence again.
3:27 Speaker 04 My parents come from very different backgrounds, but each shared a deep commitment to education, to advancement, to excellence. On my father's side of the family, my dad was born in segregated South Carolina around 1920. And he was the grandson of a slave. My great grandfather, Walter Rice, was a soldier in the Union Army after emancipation. And he fought in the Civil War in South Carolina. And a white officer took him to Massachusetts after the end of the Civil War and gave him the opportunity to get a basic education. He translated that basic education into becoming a teacher.
4:10 Speaker 04 And then ultimately, he was driven out of South Carolina by the Klan and moved to New Jersey, where he then went on to get his divinity degree at Lincoln University in Pennsylvania.
4:24 Speaker 04 Back in those days, a slave getting a college education was quite an unusual thing. Right, but he didn't just do that. He went on to found-- Started a school. He founded a school in New Jersey called the Borden Town School, which for 70 years educated generations of African-Americans in vocational and technical skills, and thus it was known as the Tuskegee of the North. But it also had a very robust college preparatory track. And so from the late 1880s until Brown versus the Board of Education, made a state-funded school that was effectively segregated because it couldn't attract white students. Mm-hmm. Illegal. Right. This school had really an extraordinary record of achievement,
5:08 Speaker 04 and it brought to campus people like Albert Einstein, Eleanor Roosevelt, Mary McLeod Bethune. So that was my great-grandfather. My grandfather also was a minister and college-educated. And along came my father, Emmett Rice, who really was born in the heart of the harshest period of segregation in the Deep South. Jim Crow, lynchings, all these things, quite prolific. And he then went on to get his college degree, his MBA, and then he was drafted into World War II. And he served in the Air Force with the Tuskegee Airmen.
5:49 Speaker 04 And unlike a lot of people, his view of the Tuskegee Airmen wasn't this, you know, glorious history, although he was very proud to be part of them. He was extremely resentful of the notion that African-Americans had to prove to white people that they could fly and fight as well as anybody else. Right. And he resented also the fact that, you know, he would go off the base and was refused service in restaurants, and yet see German POWs being served. And so this was the environment in which he was raised, and yet he came from a tradition of education, and he had ambition and talent. After the war, he went out to Berkeley and got his PhD in economics at Berkeley.
6:30 Speaker 04 And he went on to become a professor at Cornell, serve in the Treasury Department at the World Bank, and ultimately as a governor of the Federal Reserve. Right. My mother's family, completely different.
6:42 Speaker 03 So a slacker, really?
6:43 Speaker 04 He was a slacker.
6:44 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay.
6:44 Speaker 04 So was my mom.
6:45 Speaker 03 Yeah.
6:48 Speaker 04 She was born in Portland, Maine, in the early 30s. She was the daughter of immigrants from Jamaica that had come to Maine in 1912. Whereas you can imagine, there were not a lot of people who looked like me. And my grandparents had nothing. They were menial workers, a janitor and a maid. And yet, like so many immigrants, they came to this country in search of the American dream. And they scraped and saved and sent all five of their kids to college. My four uncles, two became doctors, one became an optometrist, one a university president. My grandfather was the first man to have four sons attend Bowdoin College in Maine.
7:33 Speaker 04 And then along came my mother, the youngest, who couldn't go to Bowdoin because she was a girl when she graduated from college, or high school, rather, in 1950, as valedictorian of her high school class in Portland, Maine. So she had to go to this other place nobody in her family had heard of called Radcliffe. And so she managed to go to Radcliffe despite the fact that she was denied a scholarship by the Maine State Committee for Radcliffe because she was black. The rules were that the recipients of the scholarship were, it was supposed to be automatic if you were the valedictorian of your high school class.
8:15 Speaker 04 But in her case, because she couldn't move in the proper circles when she returned to raise money for Radcliffe because she was black, she was denied the scholarship. So she almost didn't get to go, but her high school principal and debate coach lobbied Radcliffe directly and got her the money. So she went on to have a very successful career. She was Phi Beta Kappa and magna cum laude and the president of the student body in her senior year. But she really... Appreciated immeasurably the support she got to go to college. And she devoted the bulk of her career to making higher education accessible to low-income Americans.
8:57 Speaker 04 And she was eulogized when she passed as the mother of the Pell Grant program because she worked for years with Senator Pell and others to establish the program and sustain it.
9:11 Speaker 03 Probably one of the most important programs.
9:12 Speaker 04 Yeah. I learned in the course of researching this book, Madam Speaker, you'd be interested to know this, that the Department of Education did not keep records on the number of individuals who had received Pell Grants. They knew how many grants they'd made, but not how many people had benefited. And so with Claiborne Pell's grandson, we pushed the Department of Education to actually figure this out. And it turns out 80 million Americans have benefited from the Pell Grant program.
9:42 Speaker 03 So, yes. So, the reason I wanted to talk about your background, because I think it's a unique combination, and now I kind of get it with you, but it's a unique combination of immigration issues, racism, obstacles, and achievement, overcoming achievement, and unnecessarily having to overcome obstacles that are there. You yourself excelled at school. Talk a little bit about that, not how good you were at school, but necessarily, because that's kind of braggy.
10:15 Speaker 04 And boring.
10:16 Speaker 03 But you went through, how did you get into foreign service? Because your family was oriented towards education.
10:21 Speaker 04 Right. So, my mom, you know, focused on higher education access and later went into the corporate world. My dad, obviously, more in the public service. But I was born and raised here in Washington, DC. This is my home. And my parents came here for the business of government. And I was born in 1964, and I was steeped in...
10:43 Speaker 04 The issues of the day. When I was four years old, my parents took me and my baby brother, who was in a stroller, down to the 14th Street corridor, which was burnt up after the assassination of Dr. King. And they took me to the mall to, you know, to see the Poor People's Campaign. And they sat me in front of the television to see Robert Kennedy's coffin come down from New York. And so, you know, I write in the book that Walter Cronkite literally narrated my childhood. And I, you know, Vietnam and Watergate and all these were the issues in which I was raised and around a dinner table where we were expected to debate and hold strong views.
11:27 Speaker 04 And so, I also was very fortunate because my parents, at that point, had put away enough resources to enable me to go to the National Cathedral School here in Washington, DC, which is a very elite private school for girls. And my classmates were substantially the sons and daughters of members of Congress and ambassadors. And so, growing up, that was the environment in which I was raised. And I spent, my first job in life, Madam Speaker, was as a page in the House of Representatives, which I wrote about. It wasn't a pretty story back then, the lifestyle of the page. We got into a little bit of trouble.
12:11 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:12 Speaker 04 But in any case. And then I spent all four of my summers during high school, after working as a page, then subsequently as an intern in the House, for the House Education and Labor Committee, under the patronage of Gus Hawkins. And so, this was my upbringing. I knew I cared about policy. I knew I cared about government. But I didn't know that I was going to go into foreign policy.
12:37 Speaker 03 Foreign policy, right. What was the shift? I mean, I went to the Foreign Service School. I had wanted to be a CIA agent. I might be still, and it's the longest con in history. Right in the middle of those.
12:49 Speaker 04 That's actually would be really a good story.
12:51 Speaker 03 Maybe it is.
12:52 Speaker 04 Maybe it is. Who's to say? There's a novel in there.
12:56 Speaker 03 Ambassador Raya, who's to say? But I wanted to do foreign service for a long time, like the idea of it. And I couldn't because I was gay. There was a lot of issues about going into the military. I wanted to go in the military and stuff like that. But that's, I was always oriented towards it. What shifted you to the foreign service idea of it?
13:15 Speaker 04 Well, it was really ironic. I mean, I went to Stanford, I did my history degree. I went to Oxford. And when I went to Oxford, my expectation was that I would then just do a master's degree for a couple of years and go on to law school. And my plan at, you know, age 21 or 22 was get a law degree, do public interest or public service law focused on domestic concerns, and perhaps one day run for Congress or for the United States Senate. Of course, being from Washington DC, that was, you know, a particular challenge, but...
13:54 Speaker 03 Yeah. Plus, you got to hip check Eleanor Holmes Norton, who's a mentor of yours.
14:00 Speaker 04 But she, yeah, but, you know, if I serve in Congress, she's been very effective, but I'd like to have a vote.
14:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
14:06 Speaker 04 That would be, you know, that would be kind of the minimum.
14:08 Speaker 03 Right, right. So you, so you were, so moved into foreign service?
14:11 Speaker 04 So, all right, so anyway, I do two years in Oxford and I study international relations. And I do it because I think, you know, if I'm going to go into, you know, public service and be an elected official, I should know something about the world. And the bottom line is, I fell in love with it. And I decided to stay on and do my doctorate. I never went to law school. It was Eleanor Holmes Norton who advised me that since I loved what I was studying to stick with it. She actually said to me, "How many black, how many African-American PhDs in international relations do you know?" And I said... None that I can think of. And she said, "How many black lawyers do you know?" I said, "More than I can count." And she said, "Well, if you love it, do it, and you'll be 25 when you're done. And if you still want to get a law degree, it's not too late."
14:56 Speaker 04 So that set me on a course of being very interested in the substance of foreign policy and international relations.
15:02 Speaker 03 What particularly stuck with you? What was the area that you... Was there an incident?
15:06 Speaker 04 No, it wasn't an incident. It was just a...
15:08 Speaker 03 Because I remember the Iran thing with Jimmy Carter being incredibly formative for me, watching that.
15:14 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, that was formative for me as well. But that preceded my interest. I guess if anything, honestly, it was the anti-apartheid movement, which was so, you know, hot when I was in college. And that got me interested in Africa. That got me interested in my dissertation topic, which was the transition of Rhodesia to Zimbabwe, which I was trying to study for potential lessons as to how South Africa could affect a peaceful transition. And then one thing led to another. I took a bit of a diversion. I worked at McKinsey & Company for a couple of years.
15:49 Speaker 03 Well, everybody has to. Go ahead.
15:51 Speaker 04 It was good training, actually. It really was. After I got my PhD, and then after McKinsey, I joined the Clinton administration. At age 28, I was a junior staffer at the National Security Council. And I worked on the UN portfolio and peacekeeping. And then one thing led to another. Then I ran the Africa office at the NSC. Then I went to the State Department in President Clinton's second term and served as Assistant Secretary of State for African affairs.
16:21 Speaker 03 So talk about your interest in African affairs, because it's been an area of focus for you.
16:26 Speaker 04 Well, it goes back, really, to my parents, actually. I was conceived in Nigeria. And that was because my dad, early in his career, was sent over to Nigeria by USAID to help establish the Central Bank of Nigeria in the early 1960s. And my mother worked for the Ford Foundation in West Africa. And they spent two years over there and came back just in time for me to be born on American soil. And I grew up with their fascination with West Africa, with all kinds of really beautiful and valuable Yoruba art.
17:06 Speaker 04 And somehow, that was early in my life infused in my system. And then, you know, the opportunity to study Africa from Oxford and to be able to travel there and do my dissertation research in a sustained way. So I really, early in my, in my career, got a physical feel for it.
17:29 Speaker 03 One of the most vexing foreign policy issues. One of the most vexing foreign policy issues.
17:33 Speaker 04 Well, it's not an issue, right? It's a whole, it's 54 countries now with all kinds of issues and challenges. But with extraordinary potential and promise, too. And so, I don't know, almost anybody who's spent any time in Africa, Madam Speaker spent a lot of time there, and not gotten a bit of that bug. It's just fascinating and stimulating and challenging and promising all at once. And so, I spent six of my eight years in the Clinton administration, focused primarily on Africa.
18:05 Speaker 02 We're here with Susan Rice, the former U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations and National Security Advisor under President Obama. We're going to take a quick break now. We'll be back after this.
19:12 Speaker 03 One of the things that I'll never forget was when Google first started, when I went to visit them, they had a display of where information was coming around the world. And they had a globe, they had a 3D globe. Have you seen this globe with them?
19:23 Speaker 04 No, but I can imagine where it's going.
19:25 Speaker 03 Yeah, of course they do. It's next to the kombucha stand. So, it's a 3D globe that lights up where information is being asked, and the colors are the different languages being asked.
19:35 Speaker 04 Oh, interesting.
19:36 Speaker 03 And so you spin around to China, it's red, they think they're so funny. You know, but there's tons of people asking questions. And so you can see when they're asking questions and the...
19:45 Speaker 04 Of the search engine.
19:46 Speaker 03 Of the search engine. And then what the amount of light coming off of things is the amount of questions, and when they're being asked. And of course, there's when people are up and are not up. But most of the world was...
19:59 Speaker 03 Europe was full of colors, the United States, mostly the big cities, but still, you know, there was color and light everywhere. And when it flipped around to Africa, it was... I hate to say this, but it was dark, there was not questions being asked. And so I remember saying to one of the founders, I can't ever keep them apart, saying, "Why is that?" And they said, "Well, they are... Of course, they have questions." Like, everybody has a question. Because I think questions are the foundation of knowledge. It's like, what is your question? And so asking questions means you're looking for answers. And it's a critical part of humanity is asking questions. And I said, "They've got to be asking questions." And he said, "There's a trunk line that doesn't reach, the Internet doesn't reach there." And Google was trying to figure out a way to wire Africa.
20:44 Speaker 03 But at the time when these trunk lines were created, they didn't get it. They didn't get one, just like everybody else didn't. It was really fascinating to me to think about the access to information and the lack of it. And the hope that it would jump, that technology would jump over those problems of having phones and signals and things like that. But I remember being struck by the ideas, they had a lot of questions, but they couldn't get answers.
21:07 Speaker 04 They don't have a lot of connectivity.
21:08 Speaker 03 Right, exactly.
21:09 Speaker 04 That's changing.
21:10 Speaker 03 Yes, 100%. But it was part of the heart of the problem, is that if you don't get to ask questions, you have a harder time.
21:16 Speaker 04 Yeah, if you don't have access to electricity, you also have a harder time.
21:19 Speaker 03 That's exactly, exactly. The whole concept of it. But when you were focused on that, what do you think your greatest achievements were?
21:26 Speaker 04 Well, I think that they were in various categories. With respect to the U.S. economic relationship to Africa, during the Clinton years, we transformed it quite dramatically from one that was focused almost exclusively on providing development assistance in a one-way fashion, which we substantially increased in that era, but to a more complex and comprehensive economic engagement where we had real vehicles to promote trade and investment. And as a speaker, we'll recall, that was the era in which Congress passed the African Growth and Opportunity Act, which was a big initiative of the Clinton administration and members of Congress.
22:11 Speaker 04 And it was designed to increase duty-free access for goods from Africa to the United States, in effect, giving them opportunities similar to the Caribbean Basin Initiative and elements of the GSP system.
22:27 Speaker 03 That's free trade. I've forgotten about that, but go ahead.
22:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's a good thing.
22:33 Speaker 03 I know that. I'm aware.
22:35 Speaker 04 Some people get confused about that.
22:36 Speaker 03 Oh, I got that part, too. But go ahead.
22:38 Speaker 04 But we also, through Exim Bank and OPEC and TDA and the work of the Commerce Department under the late Secretary Ron Brown, really pushed on the investment agenda as well. And so, in that era, the economic relationship between the United States and Africa really went to a new level. And I think that's something to look back on with pride. Debt forgiveness. And debt forgiveness, absolutely. That's exactly, good addendum. And debt forgiveness, under the HIPIC initiative, was really controversial. In fact, I write in the book about a fight I got into with Secretary of Treasury Robert
23:17 Speaker 04 Rubin and then another one with Larry Summers, who really didn't think at that time that it was wise to provide debt relief, particularly to countries like Nigeria because of the moral hazard. And we were pushing for, we, the policy people, were pushing for that because we felt that it was unsustainable otherwise.
23:36 Speaker 03 Right.
23:37 Speaker 04 So, anyway, there's the economic agenda. Then, there was also a security agenda, because in the wake of the Rwandan genocide, which I write about as well. And I had sort of a, as a junior staffer, a front row seat on the decision-making or lack of decision-making on Rwanda. We recognized that, you know, we were going to continue to be faced with these binary choices of does the United States intervene or does nobody intervene unless we help build African capacity
24:06 Speaker 03 Right.
24:07 Speaker 04 to participate in peacekeeping and conflict resolution operations. And so we established something called the African Crisis Response Initiative, which substantially increased the US investment in building peacekeeping capacity.
24:20 Speaker 03 Right.
24:21 Speaker 04 And so when war broke out for the umpteenth time in Sierra Leone and the West African troops decided to intervene under Nigerian leadership, they had US training and support
24:32 Speaker 03 Right.
24:33 Speaker 04 and equipment to do it and actually accomplished it much more effectively.
24:36 Speaker 03 We're going to talk about multilateralism and all kinds of things, but I want to talk about the Rwandan crisis. Talk a little bit about that because that's probably one of the most devastating events.
24:46 Speaker 04 Right. I write about, this is now early in my career. This is when I'm at the NSC staff as a 28-year-old staffer responsible for UN issues and peacekeeping. This was actually before I had the Africa portfolio. Remember 1993, October, which is when we had Black Hawk down in Somalia. And we lost 18 American servicemen in a horrible, you know, atrocity as their bodies were dragged through the streets of Mogadishu. And that had been a US-initiated intervention for humanitarian purposes, then handed off to the UN with US forces there as backup.
25:29 Speaker 04 And the mission morphed in from a simple humanitarian one into basically a combat mission. And when we lost our 18 service members, President Clinton faced a real crisis with Congress who wanted to order the American forces out. And so, you know, to Try to effect an orderly departure. President Clinton agreed that within six months of the downing of the helicopters, all US forces would withdraw from Somalia. And that's what happened. It was a bit of a humiliating retreat nonetheless, and we left without the mission accomplished.
26:11 Speaker 04 But the last American forces withdrew from Somalia on March 31st of 1994. On April 7th, 1994, the plane carrying the presidents of Rwanda and Burundi were shot down, which initiated the Rwandan genocide, which, as you'll recall, was about 90 days of extraordinarily intensive killing with machetes and leaving up to perhaps a million people dead. The United States, my big takeaway from watching how we made decisions on Rwanda was that we made a series of incremental decisions. First thing, to get American personnel out of harms way, which is always what we do
26:56 Speaker 04 in a crisis like that. And then we confronted decisions about, you know, do we shut down hate radio, et cetera. But we never entertained the policy question of should the United States intervene to try to halt the killing? Because politically, it was untenable. No, it wasn't even that. I mean, it was worse than that. Yes, it was not untenable, it was unthinkable. So we actually never called the question at a deputy's committee meeting or principal's committee meeting. President Clinton didn't say, "Give me options." And it wasn't just the United States.
27:37 Speaker 04 You know, we could have also mobilized others to intervene with us or with our support. But because of Somalia, in my judgment, it really didn't actually occur to people to contemplate in that time. redeploying US forces into an even more remote and unknown part of Africa for a humanitarian mission.
27:58 Speaker 03 Talk about that push.
27:59 Speaker 04 And so, we didn't have that discussion. We didn't have that debate. And, you know, later on, as the scope of the killing became clear and the consequences of collective global inaction, because it wasn't just the United States, it was the entirety of the international community, we then intervened to provide assistance to refugees in the neighboring countries, in Zaire in particular, but that was, you know, too late.
28:27 Speaker 03 Talk about that idea of the push-pull, because that's a constant, the constant political push-pull here of whether we should intervene, and we're going to get to America first and what's happening now, but it's not something fresh and new from Donald Trump, this instinct.
28:40 Speaker 04 But that wasn't, I think it was a different mindset at the time. We had done Somalia. George Bush had, the first, 41, had made the decision to intervene in Somalia.
28:51 Speaker 03 But he was an internationally focused president.
28:53 Speaker 04 Well, I think Clinton was an internationally focused president. And I think most of our presidents, until recently, were internationally focused, until very recently. But the Rwanda thing, I think, was unique. I mean, and Speaker will recall the same, like, not only did the administration not actually call the question, nobody was standing up in the wells of the Congress saying, you know, we've got to intervene, and nobody on the editorial boards of our major newspapers were recommending it. It just wasn't, in that moment, conceivable. And that was a very important lesson I took away.
29:30 Speaker 03 Which was?
29:31 Speaker 04 Which is, you've got to ask the question. You've got to confront it. The answer may be no, it may be yes, it may be do it a different way, but to not ask the question is, you know, I think, a real failure.
29:43 Speaker 03 Is that a fault of how we think about foreign policy, or used to? I'm going to, we're going to get to the current administration, but the way American foreign policy has been done, is that been the fault of?
29:52 Speaker 04 No, I think that was just a particularly unique moment.
29:59 Speaker 04 And, you know, later on, you know, the Clinton administration got very much involved in Kosovo and was very activist. And so I think, and perhaps in reaction to that failure in Rwanda. And of course, you know, you can't accuse President George Bush, 43, of not being activist.
30:19 Speaker 03 No.
30:20 Speaker 04 And, you know, and President Obama confronted these dilemmas repeatedly. You know, we decided to intervene in Libya. We decided not to intervene, you know, in the civil conflict in Syria. Obviously, we went in to fight ISIS, but that was a different question. And so, you know, as National Security Advisor, fast-forwarding.
30:43 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:44 Speaker 04 Many years, you know, my responsibility, I felt, was in these very complex questions of humanitarian intervention, to insist that we confront it on a regular basis. And in the case of Libya and Syria, obviously, that was also President Obama's instinct. And we met repeatedly on all these topics and revisited the questions at different stages. And again, as I said, came to different answers. And so my fundamental long-term takeaway about how we approach the question and the challenge of humanitarian intervention is that there is really no one-size-fits-all. You know, we've got to look at each case in its context on the merits.
31:27 Speaker 03 Although, in your case, you talked about how they're affecting each other, how they make one.
31:30 Speaker 04 They do affect each other, and, you know, hopefully, we're learning human beings as policymakers. But my fundamental conclusion is, just because we can't intervene everywhere, doesn't mean we shouldn't intervene anywhere. But we have to look at the risks and the benefits in each case and make decisions to our best of our ability.
31:49 Speaker 03 So let's fast-forward to your time on the Obama administration, because after the Clinton administration, you went to do other things.
31:54 Speaker 04 During the Bush administration, yes.
31:56 Speaker 03 Yeah, you weren't hired.
31:57 Speaker 04 I wasn't looking to be hired.
31:59 Speaker 03 I know, got that.
32:00 Speaker 04 Okay.
32:01 Speaker 03 All right. So what was your thinking when you were coming back into policy? The hopes that you had to change what had happened in the interim period between Clinton and President Obama?
32:13 Speaker 04 Well, I, first of all, it was a... A very early supporter of President Obama and worked on the campaign and worked on the transition. And when I came in, I came back as National, as, excuse me, as UN ambassador, which obviously was at a different level with more of a global perspective and span of responsibility. And I sat at the National Security Council Principals Committee Decision Table and in the Cabinet. And, you know, we had so many objectives coming in. We had the global financial crisis that we had to recover from. We had the challenge of the hangover from the Iraq War and the damage done to our alliances
32:54 Speaker 04 and partnerships as a result, and the need still to manage and calibrate the extent of our involvement in Afghanistan and Iraq. And so we had a number of carryover challenges to confront. But President Obama also had, you know, what we called inside the, an affirmative agenda, things that he wanted to get done over the course of his tenure that would leave the world, in our view, better than we found it, not just manage the inbox or the inheritance. And that's, you know, that's how come the president, you know, in his first year, pulled out his laptop and, you know, walked into a meeting with Xi Jinping in Copenhagen to try to, you know, save the climate talks.
33:39 Speaker 04 And that later evolved into the US-China Agreement on Climate. And sorry, it wasn't Xi Jinping, it was Hu Jintao at the time. And then it led to the Paris Climate Agreement. And, you know, he decided that we wanted to try to reduce the threat of nuclear weapons. And that led to the Nuclear Security Summit Agenda, and it led to ultimately the Iran Nuclear Deal. He was interested in, you know, enhancing and promoting our trading relationships. And so we had a number of bilateral agreements and ultimately tried to negotiate the Trans-Pacific Partnership, which we did negotiate, but then didn't join. And so on a whole range, the opening to Cuba, you name it.
34:20 Speaker 04 These were among the affirmative choices that we made even as we were wrestling with the things that we couldn't have predicted, like the Ebola epidemic, or the Russian invasion of Ukraine, or Russian interference in the election.
34:36 Speaker 03 Which we'll get to. But in terms of what you were mostly focused on, what you thought was the most important achievement during that time, and I do want to talk about the mistakes that you feel, upon reflection, happened during this period. What do you think the most important achievements were?
34:53 Speaker 04 I just listed a number.
34:54 Speaker 03 I know that. Of those, because many of them have been rolled back, and we'll get to that, but when you were thinking about it in a larger sense, what was the key attribute of what you were trying to do as a theory, I guess your theory?
35:07 Speaker 04 The theory of the Obama administration on national security and foreign policy is that the nature of the challenges we face are such that they can best be addressed in conjunction with allies and partners.
35:23 Speaker 03 Right.
35:24 Speaker 04 Very hard to think of a challenge, whether it's a rising China, or an aggressive Russia, or a pandemic disease, or climate change, or proliferation, or counterterrorism, that we can address in isolation more effectively than we can with allies and partners. And so the hallmark, in my estimation, of the Obama administration's foreign policy was to nurture and bolster those alliances and partnerships such that, you know, when we needed them, they were there. And that's how we accomplished the Paris Agreement. That's how we snuffed out the Ebola epidemic. That's how we rallied pressure on Russia following the invasion of Ukraine. It's how we got 65-plus countries to join with us in the fight against ISIS.
36:09 Speaker 04 It's how we maintained the coalition in Afghanistan.
36:12 Speaker 03 I wonder if it's specifically Ebola, because I think that's an excellent example of that, but this has been a sort of a concept for a long time. You know, this is all leading into now it's not that, but do you feel like that this idea of multilateralism, of cooperation, of allies, has been an important part of, one, keeping the peace, two, protecting national security, and, three, keeping a safe world to respond to whatever happens to come up? I want you to talk about the importance of that, of multilateral, and the ability to do that, because I think it's something that gets lost in what's happening now.
36:46 Speaker 04 Well, I think that one of the differences between the Obama administration and, say, the immediately prior administration was not that, you know, we didn't all agree on the importance of our alliances, but it was often a question of how we utilize those alliances and how deferential we were to those alliances and how much we cared about international law and multilateralism. So as UN ambassador, I was in the thick of our multilateral diplomacy. And, you know, as challenging and frustrating as the UN can sometimes be, our strong preference was to bring other countries along with us.
37:25 Speaker 03 Right.
37:25 Speaker 04 And to try to legitimize and strengthen the effectiveness of our actions by having that backing. So for Libya, for example, you know, I was tasked to go get a Security Council resolution that authorized our NATO's, the Arab League's intervention in Libya. And it was a heavy lift, but we got it. Whereas if you contrast it with Iraq, 2003, you know, the Bush administration decided, you know, forget the UN. We don't have the time or the patience for it, and went on. And that broke a lot of crockery, including with our traditional allies in Europe.
38:02 Speaker 03 Right.
38:03 Speaker 04 That felt that, you know, that was not only a mistake, but an unnecessary mistake. So that's just in a compare and contrast to give you a sense of the difference. You know, we worked hard to bolster these international institutions and their legitimacy, rather than tear them down. And we were fortunate to have, from Congress, in contrast to the Clinton years, the support to pay our dues and debts to the UN and to stay current and to remain an effective player.
38:33 Speaker 03 We're going to take another break now. We'll be back after this with Susan Rice.
38:46 Speaker 05 Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
38:55 Speaker 05 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
39:01 Speaker 05 Fine. No one deals more deals than... Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
39:09 Speaker 06 How about a latte?
39:10 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
39:11 Speaker 06 Vanilla?
39:12 Speaker 01 Caramel?
39:12 Speaker 06 Blueberry?
39:13 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want.
39:19 Speaker 01 With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling.
39:30 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
39:35 Speaker 03 I do want to move into current events right now because it's really important. We have a short time, we have questions from people here. But in terms of what you felt was your most difficult period, or the things that you yourself did wrong, this book has one page on Benghazi, which I think was, or a couple of pages on Benghazi.
39:52 Speaker 04 It's got a whole chapter.
39:55 Speaker 03 Yeah. Okay. All right. I'm sorry.
39:59 Speaker 03 Good. I point taken. Talk a little bit about that and, okay, all right, I got it.
40:03 Speaker 04 Okay. Sit, I promise you, so hold, it might even be the longest chapter.
40:07 Speaker 03 So talk about that, about what happened there from your perspective, because I think it was probably the most difficult period, and the things that then moved into the right wing attacking you so heavily and everything else. Talk a little bit about that.
40:22 Speaker 04 Well, most of you will recall, but I was at an event the other night where, with Richard Haas at the Council on Foreign Relations, and he said, how many people understand what happened in Benghazi? And a lot of hands didn't go up.
40:36 Speaker 03 Right.
40:36 Speaker 04 So, quickly.
40:39 Speaker 04 It's September 2012. We're in the middle of the president's reelection campaign. And we tragically, on September 11th, had an attack, a terrorist attack, on our diplomatic compound in Benghazi, Libya. We lost four Americans, including our ambassador. And it was, you know, it was a horrific loss. The administration immediately, the president the next day, condemned the act of terror. And yet, the Republicans pounced and suggested that he and the administration were downplaying the nature of the attack.
41:23 Speaker 04 On that Sunday, following the Tuesday of the attack, I was asked to go out on the, all five of the Sunday shows, and represent the administration, to talk about not only what had happened in Benghazi, but what had happened around the world, as many of our facilities in the Arab and Muslim world had faced demonstrations, many of them that had turned violent. And also to preview the upcoming United Nations General Assembly. That Friday night, just as an aside, well, it's not really an aside, it's kind of central. I went to stop by my mother's house. My mom, who I've described to you at this age, is, she's probably about, just about 80, she'd had, just recovered from her fourth or fifth cancer surgery, and had a post-operative
42:08 Speaker 04 stroke. And I was living in New York and coming home on the weekends, and so I really wanted to check in on her and spend some time. So I go by her house on my way home, and she says to me, "So what are your plans for the weekend?" And I said, "Well, I'm taking the kids tomorrow to Ohio State for their first Big Ten football game. And then the White House has asked me to go on the Sunday shows." And she said, "What? Why?" And I said, "Because, you know, they need somebody to go out." She said, "Where's Hillary?" And I said, "Mom, you know, she's had a week from hell." They asked her, and she said, "No." And she said, "My mom said, 'I smell a rat."
42:54 Speaker 04 You should not do this. I said, "Mom, don't be ridiculous. I've done this plenty of times. It'll be fine." And of course, it wasn't. Yeah. Listen to your mom. Yeah, so that's the biggest lesson in my book is listen to your mother. Right. That's number one. And it applies not just in the case of Benghazi, by the way. But it's useful to remind my kids as well.
43:19 Speaker 04 So what she perceived was that in the hothouse of a political Campaign. Campaign with partisan spears flying. Right. That whoever went out and delivered this message was going to be attacked as much or more as the message itself. And I wasn't thinking about myself. She was being my mom and looking out for my best interests. I was thinking about being part of a team that had just suffered an extraordinary loss. I'd been asked to do something. It wasn't how I planned to spend my weekend, but as a team player, I said yes. Oh, by the way, and then I went on the shows
44:04 Speaker 04 and what I shared as our best current assessment of what had happened were based on talking points that had been drafted and approved by the intelligence community. And I knew them to be accurate because I was a recipient every day of the President's Daily Briefing and all of our intelligence. And I knew that the talking points reflected what we had in classified sources as well. But it turned out some days after I went on the shows, about seven to 10 days later, the intelligence community got additional information, as we expected it would through the investigations, and updated their assessment of what had happened and acknowledged that what they had shared with me and members of Congress on that weekend
44:48 Speaker 04 was actually inaccurate in some respects. But here's the latest current assessment. But by that point, I'd become roundly branded a liar, incompetent, untrustworthy. Republican members of Congress were all over the television set. Peter King called for my resignation. And Lindsey Graham and
45:15 Speaker 04 John McCain were particularly virulent. And thus began months and months of denigrating my integrity and intelligence.
45:28 Speaker 03 The reason I wanted to talk about it was largely because what you also got caught in is the first instance of internet attacks and right-wing.
45:36 Speaker 04 I don't know if it was the first, but it was...
45:38 Speaker 03 Well, it was one of the first times that I thought it was... I paid attention to it. It was really interesting to me. It's not the first, but it was the beginning of that idea of how ideas are pushed down and spread, especially like yesterday, there was one, they showed, "We hired Donald Trump to fire..."
45:57 Speaker 04 That was Donald Trump Jr.
45:58 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's true, that's true. But there was also bots that went crazy and stuff like that. So it was the first beginning of what I think is Russian intervention using social means. But it was, whether you made a mistake or not, or were using inaccurate assessments, it took it to a new level that I thought was riveting and also horrifying at the same time.
46:19 Speaker 04 So, yes, is the short answer. But I had the attacks with the named faces...
46:25 Speaker 03 From real people, right.
46:26 Speaker 04 From real people, from real members of Congress and real right-wing commentators. And by the way, I had extraordinarily generous and robust defense from members of Congress on the other side, who, led by Speaker Pelosi and Harry Reid and others, who came to my early and sustained defense. But, you know, it was a thing. And it was amplified by the dispersion of political television, but also, I think, by social media. I don't have a clear, concrete understanding of quite how involved the bots were in that case, but I think they were, in retrospect. I didn't realize it at the time. But in any event...
47:09 Speaker 04 You know, I talk about the effects that it had on my daughter, who is nine years old, who really suffered for a period of time. I talk about how it affected my mother. And I do that with pretty raw frankness, because I want people to understand that, you know, the politics of personal destruction in this town don't come for free. That they impact the lives of people who didn't sign up for this. And now what we're seeing with the attacks on civil servants is just unbelievably offensive.
47:43 Speaker 03 Let's switch to the Trump administration and we'll get to questions. But right now, how do you perceive it? You are watching this from the sidelines. A lot of these achievements that you talked about have been rolled back, whether it's the Paris Accords, trade agreements, an attitude about multilateralism. It's all swept away. Talk how you feel. What is that like? As some, I mean, it sucks, I'm guessing is your answer.
48:12 Speaker 04 Yes, it sucks.
48:13 Speaker 03 But talk about where we are then. This America First idea, the shithole countries, the whole.
48:19 Speaker 04 I mean, I really don't, it sucks personally, but I don't really care. What I care about is that all of these undoings, reversals, are being done out of spite, without an alternative strategy to achieve a better outcome. And what are we doing to deal with climate? What are we doing to enhance our, you know, our trade relationships in the Pacific? What are we doing to improve the, or reduce the threat from Iran? We've lost the threat on the nuclear challenge now. That's had been under control. It's now out of the box. And all of their other malign behavior in the region is exacerbated. So we've just undone without replace.
49:04 Speaker 04 It's like repeal and replace. There's no replace, right? They just want to repeal. And so that's what we are seeing.
49:11 Speaker 03 There is an underlying mentality behind repeal.
49:14 Speaker 04 Well, the mentality is, actually, I'm going to be blunt here. I have come to the conclusion that we don't have an America First foreign policy, as misguided as that is. And it's misguided because, as I said earlier, so many of the challenges we face require the support and the collective action of allies and partners. So, you know, if you want to put America first, which I think every president has always done, the way to do it is to bring others to join with us in our objectives. So, Trump has the rhetoric of America first, but his actions belie that. And what it actually is, I think we've come to see, is it's a me first.
49:54 Speaker 04 It's what can I get personally for my political benefit or my financial benefit at the expense of US interests? And that's what we've seen in Ukraine, that's what we've seen in Syria, and we still need to figure out, you know, what the quid pro quo was in that case.
50:11 Speaker 03 Yeah.
50:12 Speaker 04 It's, you know, it's underlying everything.
50:15 Speaker 03 Yeah. Well, actually, it's an interesting thing. You're right, there's the politics of personal interest, I think, here, which is very clear from these phone, these perfect phone calls and such. But there is something behind it, this concept, which I think has been around in this country for a much longer time, and I think that's...
50:32 Speaker 04 Which is a retrenchment and isolationism.
50:34 Speaker 03 It's the idea that, what have they done for us? Why do we need to, like, there is actually, it's not even a theory, it's a mentality, like, what do we need to pay taxes for? What do we need, it goes back to the whiskey rebellion, like, what do we need? A joint continental congress? What do we need this? A continental army, excuse me. When you hear the rhetoric, it has that same string, is they're not paying their fair share, we're paying for everything. We're, like, what are we getting at? What are we getting out of it? And I think it's not just him, I think there is a larger...
51:03 Speaker 04 There is, but it's being stoked by so much misinformation and non-history. I mean, what do we get from Afghanistan to Vietnam to every major conflict we have had to be in? We have had the support of allies and partners. You know, would we want to have done any of— just take—go back to 9/11, since that's the most proximate. That was the only time that NATO has invoked Article 5, the self-defense provision. The allies came to our defense and joined with us to fight al-Qaeda and the Taliban in Afghanistan. Would we have wanted to do that alone? That's what we get. We get—you know, when ISIS reemerges
51:48 Speaker 04 or emerges in Iraq and Syria, we get allies and partners to join with us in that effort. And the notion that we entered into NATO or any other alliance relationship on the basis of a dollar transaction—
52:02 Speaker 03 Right.
52:02 Speaker 04 —is just antithetical to who we are as a nation. And, you know, now we're extorting the Japanese and the South Koreans to pay outrageous sums for our bases there, which serve our interests. We're not doing the South Koreans and the Japanese a favor by being there. It has mutual benefit, but we want that forward presence. That's part of how we project influence and power. So the whole notion that we are somehow doing these poor, mooching countries a favor is asked backwards.
52:39 Speaker 03 That's a nice way of putting it. So I'm going to— When you get the Q and answer, a couple more questions about the impact, because I—this is a tech—I'm a tech-oriented person. How do you look at—when you see— everywhere in each of these stories, there's an element of the damage that tech has done, whether it's tweeting, whether it's— like, yesterday, you saw it with the ambassador. She was testifying, even as he was using Twitter as a medium to threaten her. When you think about policy—the policy— foreign leaders are tweeting at each other. There's all kinds of things going on. When you look at a world like that, that it's opened up— and then there, of course, is the Russian interference in elections and the use of social media platforms. Whatever happens in the next election,
53:24 Speaker 03 there's a lot we have to figure out of how to deal with this new information environment with foreign policy and domestic policy, but especially around foreign policy.
53:36 Speaker 04 Well, I think there are different things going on here. I mean, obviously, the use of social media as a vehicle to exacerbate our domestic political divisions by our adversaries, principally Russia, as they, you know, play on both sides of every divisive issue: race, immigration, guns, gay rights. And they are working to weaken us as a rival power by causing us to basically eat ourselves up from within, pit ourselves against one another. And if they can continue to succeed in that, they can supersede us, defeat us, without ever firing a bullet. It's sort of like thinking they lost the Cold War, but they're winning this one, the digital war. So far. Yeah.
54:21 Speaker 04 But we've given them the opening with which to do it, which are our domestic political divisions. We also gave them the tools, the technical tools. Well, that's true, too, yeah. I write in the book, in the last chapter called "Bridging the Divide," my strong conviction that our domestic political divisions are, in fact, our greatest national security vulnerability. And talk about a number of the steps that I hope we can consider to address it. But, you know, but then you get into how foreign policy is conducted. And, you know, foreign policy by tweet is not an appropriate approach. Right. And... But it is happening. It's happening, I hope.
55:05 Speaker 04 I really do hope that when we have a new president, with hopefully some experienced and sober advisers around him or her, that we will go back to the era where you actually issue proper statements and you actually have considered rollout strategies when you make, hopefully, well-
55:27 Speaker 04 Conceive decisions through an actual national security decision-making process. Because you don't just wake up and tweet out whatever thing floats through your brain.
55:40 Speaker 03 Well, yes, you do, but go ahead.
55:42 Speaker 04 No, no, no. That's... He does, we don't. And that's a really important distinction.
55:48 Speaker 03 Are you sure?
55:48 Speaker 04 Yes.
55:49 Speaker 03 I mean, do you think it... When you say "go back," I'm always...
55:51 Speaker 04 Damn it, no. Look, this is really important. The notion that this can become the new normal is something we absolutely have to reject. We need to make considered thoughtful decisions through a rational process.
56:04 Speaker 03 Absolutely.
56:05 Speaker 04 We need to consult Congress and our allies before we announce these crazy-ass decisions. And when they do come out, they need to come with a thoughtful statement, not a tweet.
56:17 Speaker 03 So, last question. What is the one thing you would say to the tech companies, for example, to do then? To turn off Twitter?
56:29 Speaker 04 Well, the tech companies, like, you know...
56:30 Speaker 03 Doesn't matter.
56:30 Speaker 04 I don't blame Twitter for the fact that we've got a president who doesn't know how to use it.
56:34 Speaker 03 Well, actually, he's quite good at it, but...
56:36 Speaker 04 No, I mean, what I mean is use it in a responsible fashion that's befitting a president of the United States. I mean, Twitter existed in the last administration. You didn't see, you know, the withdrawal of our forces from Syria announced by President Obama on Twitter.
56:50 Speaker 03 Right.
56:51 Speaker 04 Anyway. So, I mean, what do the tech companies need to do? First of all, I think the tech companies need to really embrace their role and responsibility. And it goes back to the prior thing. It's not about who tweets on what. It's about how and whether they're allowed to be used by adversaries, foreign and domestic, to play the adversary's game, which is to exacerbate these divisions and to, you know, propagate false information. And this whole question of, you know, whether, you know, Facebook needs to police political advertising, I mean, is a huge question.
57:35 Speaker 04 And I think, frankly, I don't know what you think, but my view is...
57:40 Speaker 04 Why should Facebook abide by different standards than any other traditional form of media? Because that's in fact what they are. I know they like to say they're not a media company.
57:48 Speaker 03 Or just turn it off, like Twitter did.
57:53 Speaker 04 Or turn it off. But, you know. Yes.
57:58 Speaker 03 So would you like to be Secretary of State in another administration?
58:04 Speaker 04 That depends on a lot of things. Like, where am I in my life? Where are my kids? Who's the president?
58:15 Speaker 03 Are you backing anyone?
58:18 Speaker 04 Who's the team? No, I haven't endorsed anybody yet. You know, I think we have a strong field and I'm very much looking forward to fully supporting our nominee, but I haven't done that. And I realized in the last three years, there's a whole world out there.
58:36 Speaker 03 Yeah.
58:37 Speaker 04 You know, that you don't have to be in government
58:40 Speaker 03 What?
58:41 Speaker 04 To have fun and to serve.
58:42 Speaker 03 You can't say it to these people?
58:43 Speaker 04 No, I'm serious. I strongly encourage people to serve. The best, you know, the best professional experiences of my life have been to have the privilege to serve. And for all the knives in my back and my front, I wouldn't trade it for anything.
59:00 Speaker 03 All right. Well, on that note, let's get some questions from the audience. We have a few minutes. Questions? Go ahead. Come down to the thing.
59:08 Speaker 07 Thank you so much. My name's Elijah. I'm a first-year Masters of Science in Foreign Service. And I'm also from San Francisco and was actually honored to be a page in one of the last classes in 2011 with Speaker Pelosi. So it's great to have another page over here. And I also was one of the students in Ambassador Jovanovic's classes earlier this semester that she referenced. And was inspired, like so many people here, by her words yesterday. So kind of with that context, I'm wondering if you could talk about how you see the role of Congress in kind of upholding our alliance structures, traditional commitments to human
59:51 Speaker 07 rights, and kind of continuing the role the US should be playing in foreign policy.
59:58 Speaker 04 There's a number of deals on the table right now that they're working on. Well, I think Congress is a very important player. And, you know, it's difficult when we have a divided Congress and one party who seems to care only to rubber stamp and protect the actions of a president that's acting outside of the boundaries of arguably the law, at least the norm. But, you know, in normal times, Congress, you know, would be advocating for and standing up for critical principles. So, you know, the House has led on, you know, issues like Yemen, where, as I have acknowledged,
1:00:39 Speaker 04 I think, you know, we made a mistake in the Obama administration in backing the Saudi-led intervention to, you know, that has gone way off the rails. And we tried to roll it back towards the end of the administration. The Trump administration doubled down and, you know, we've... Well, the Saudis have gone way off the rails on a lot of things. On a lot of things. Well, not about gone, but they are off. They may have gone off earlier. Anyway, so I do think that Congress has a really important role. You know, I don't know if you all noticed, but in that off-the-record speech that John Bolton recently gave that got reported by NBC News... Yeah, off the record.
1:01:22 Speaker 04 The most frightening thing I heard him say is that he thought if President Trump got reelected, that he would pull out of NATO.
1:01:35 Speaker 04 Think about that. And that's from his national security advisor until two months ago. So what can Congress do if the president were to try to pull out of NATO? I mean, that may be the last break. And I know Congress is sort of, you know... Could that be accomplished? Well... You had Macron talking about the hollowing out. It can only be accomplished if we withdraw. And I don't think that's a likely outcome. But that's a place where Congress can, you know, can put on some real meaningful breaks. So anyway, that's a long way of saying that I think there are many important ways that Congress plays a critical role. And, you know, sometimes it's positive.
1:02:17 Speaker 04 In the case I described with respect to Somalia, for example, I think it was actually negative. They tied the hands of a president to an extent that I think was unwise. Okay. Two more quick questions.
1:02:30 Speaker 08 Michael Ortiz asked me to ask a question. He told me I had to. Thank you for your career of service ambassador and for your candor. And thank you, Kara, for holding tech to account. Do you lament, it seemed to be that there was sort of reduced policy options because of congressional Republican control in the run-up to the 2016 election? The lack of consensus, if you will. Is there more that could be done prophylactically in the run-up to the 2020, thanks to Democratic-controlled House?
1:03:05 Speaker 04 Yes, and it's been done, and it's sitting on Mitch McConnell's desk. Right? There's a whole election security agenda... There's a lot sitting on that desk. Yeah, there's a whole lot sitting on that desk. But there's additional funding, there's, you know, legislation that would require paper ballots, there's legislation that would automatically penalize foreign actors that are found to have interfered. I mean, this is all wrapped up in a bill that Mitch McConnell won't move.
1:03:32 Speaker 08 What about in terms of oversight of tech?
1:03:36 Speaker 04 That, you know, that hasn't happened yet, to my knowledge. You know, there's been a lot of hearings, there's been a lot of consideration of it. There's current investigations. I think it's... There's investigations. I think that's complicated, but I think that, you know... I think the tech companies need to understand that they're about five minutes from midnight on this, that they're either gonna assume their responsibilities without a lot of throwing sand in the gears, or they're gonna get legislated into some, a different kind of regulatory environment, which I think is probably not optimal.
1:04:14 Speaker 03 Well, investigation is gonna take seven years, and by then, we will have the Terminator has arrived. So I think the issue is legislative, there has to be a legislative solution, and quick, because the Justice Department actually is doing some really important investigations, so is the FTC, but they're underfunded, both of them, both of those, and they are overcommitted to a lot of other things. And so legislative solution, whether it's the state's attorney generals, or the Congress, is really the only place this is gonna get.
1:04:42 Speaker 04 I'd like to see more self-policing.
1:04:44 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:04:44 Speaker 04 I'd rather not have to rely on them.
1:04:46 Speaker 03 Sure, sure. No.
1:04:46 Speaker 04 I know, yeah.
1:04:47 Speaker 03 No. They're not the most self-regulating people.
1:04:50 Speaker 04 I got you.
1:04:50 Speaker 09 I'm R. Q. M. A. 2017. Thank you, Kara. Thank you, Ambassador Rice. In your view, how can we leverage technology as a force for good in foreign policy and foreign service moving forward?
1:05:03 Speaker 03 Better cell phones for Mr. Sonnen, but go ahead. What an, what an oaf. My teenager could hack his phone doing that, but anyway, nonetheless.
1:05:18 Speaker 04 I mean, I think in many of the ways that technology has the potential to benefit society more broadly, it has the potential to augment our execution of foreign policy. But it also has a downside to it, that I think we haven't fully, and I'm talking about technology broadly, artificial intelligence, biotech, I mean, these are all things that can make us better and more effective, but they also can be used as weapons of war, completely unregulated, and...
1:05:53 Speaker 03 I'm leaking. We didn't even talk about Edward Snowden.
1:05:56 Speaker 04 We didn't talk about Snowden. I do in the book.
1:05:58 Speaker 03 Yeah. I just chatted with him. He's good.
1:06:00 Speaker 04 Tell him I said...
1:06:03 Speaker 03 Drone strike? Yeah, okay, I got that. No, were you drone strike? That was Hillary.
1:06:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, let's not talk about Snowden.
1:06:13 Speaker 03 Okay.
1:06:18 Speaker 04 So I do worry about the various ways in which we're not sufficiently focused on how the downsides of technology can affect the conduct of not just diplomacy, but of war fighting. So I do think there are pluses and minuses, but I worry, quite honestly, that as we compete more and more intensively with China, that we've lost the very useful triumvirate that we had, frankly, during the Cold War between government, the private sector, and academia to coordinate and concert our capacities, you know, towards a common aim right now.
1:07:01 Speaker 04 You know, in Silicon Valley, the US government, and this is frankly well before the current administration, is viewed as the enemy, or at least with great suspicion. And that's not healthy, and now it's become a two-way street. I don't think about the CEOs, but about the workers. Right, exactly. Exactly. And it's constraining the ability of the CEOs to do what they may be inclined, I mean, Project Maven is...
1:07:28 Speaker 03 From Google.
1:07:29 Speaker 04 The classic example, and that was a...
1:07:31 Speaker 03 Though...
1:07:32 Speaker 04 That was an immodest, I mean, a modest effort.
1:07:35 Speaker 03 Right. Although, on the other side, there's a lot of feeling among the tech companies, CEOs will say, "We have to be this big in order to fight China." It's the she-or-me argument that Mark Zuckerberg tends to make. We have a choice between the two of them. And I think the question is, is our innovation is what keeps us fresh, or is it bigness? And so I think that's a real problem. But China's our absolute dangerous, faux technology.
1:08:01 Speaker 04 And meanwhile, some of these companies are making accommodations with China...
1:08:05 Speaker 03 Right.
1:08:06 Speaker 04 That, you know, they would never think to make with the United States.
1:08:09 Speaker 03 Right. But militarily, technologically, in technology militarily, China is really quite impressive in what they've been doing, and that's frightening. A Chinese internet, controlled internet, would be... Dangerous for everybody. Last question.
1:08:26 Speaker 10 Not a question. I've been asked to, first of all, thank you both for your participation. It's been wonderful. I've been asked to announce that for those of you who are looking for a lunch, there are boxed lunches in the ICC Galleria and at the Healy Family Student Center.
1:08:40 Speaker 03 Okay, great.
1:08:41 Speaker 04 All right.
1:08:41 Speaker 03 All right. I'm going to wrap up. My very last question. One, what do you think the most dangerous foreign policy, I mean, very short answer, of the Trump administration is? And is there one you agree with them on? Well, Edwards, you can end on that. What's the most dangerous pressing foreign policy issue right now?
1:09:00 Speaker 04 Well, that's not a short answer, but my answer to that, we have a number of constants, right? You know, we've got a rising China, we've got an aggressive Russia, we've got North Korea that still has nuclear weapons and missile capacity that's actually perfecting as we send love letters back and forth. We have the risk of conflict, I think, in the Persian Gulf. But I say this with no satisfaction and a lot of sadness. I think, frankly, the biggest threat we face right now is in 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. Now, I'm not being facetious.
1:09:37 Speaker 04 The unpredictability, the lack of actions commensurate with our interests and values, the denigration of our allies, the elevation of our adversaries, foreign policy being conducted for personal, political, and financial gain. The United States, under every prior president in my lifetime, has tried to do whatever that administration thought was the right thing for the United States of America. You can argue about whether it was, or whether you agree or disagree. I don't think you can say that any prior president in our lifetime set out to conduct
1:10:18 Speaker 04 foreign policy for something other than what he understood to be the national interest. And the United States tried very hard to be a stabilizing influence in the world, or at least what we perceived to be a force for good, even if others would argue that we were not. Now we are a net exporter of instability and unpredictability. And that's when it's the United States of America with all of our weight and all of our influence and all of our power being the greatest source of unpredictability. That's a dangerous thing. And it makes it really hard to deal with all these other constant challenges effectively.
1:11:01 Speaker 02 Well, on that note.
1:11:03 Speaker 04 Happy note.
1:11:04 Speaker 02 Exporter of instability. Thank you so much. Thank you again to Susan Rice for coming on the show and thank you to Georgetown University School of Foreign Service. You can follow me on Twitter @KaraSwisher. My executive producer Erica Anderson is at EricaAmerica. My producer Eric Johnson is at HeyHeyESJ. If you like this episode, please share it with a friend and make sure to check out our newest podcast, Reset. Just search for it in your podcasting app of choice or tap the link in the show notes. Thanks also to our editor Joel Roby. Special thanks to Andrew Logan for recording this interview. And thanks again to Georgetown University for hosting us. Thank you for listening to this episode of Rico Decode. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: SEC Commissioner Robert Jackson Next Recode Decode: Jana Messerschmidt Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated