Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Rep. Adam Schiff About this episode Congressman Adam Schiff, who represents California’s 28th district and chairs the House Intelligence Committee, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about the 2020 election, the Russia investigation, and more.
In this episode:
Schiff’s letters putting Facebook, Google and Twitter “on notice” for deepfakes in the 2020 campaign; the lack of tech regulation to date; Edward Snowden and the encryption fight; how things have changed since the Democrats gained a majority in the House of Representatives; partisan differences in the Russia investigation; Robert Mueller’s upcoming testimony; Trump, the new “Teflon president”; how Trump and Schiff use Twitter; “how do we get back to normal?”; Nancy Pelosi vs. the “squad”; replacing Mitch McConnell and defeating Trump; the greatest intelligence threats to the US; and what worries Schiff the most.
Vote for us
Recode Decode has been nominated for best technology podcast in this year’s People’s Choice Podcast Awards! Cast your vote for Recode Decode at https://www.podcastawards.com/app/signup before July 31st. One vote per category.
Follow us
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), host
Adam Schiff (@RepAdamSchiff), guest
Erica Anderson (@EricaAmerica), executive producer
Eric Johnson (@HeyHeyESJ), producer
More to explore
If you haven't already, subscribe to Recode Decode
Subscribe to Recode's other podcasts: Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 9,608 words · 10 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift. Support around the clock. All backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:37 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:54 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
1:00 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who thinks Megan Rapinoe should be in the line of succession to the presidency, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play an interview I just conducted with United States Congressman Adam Schiff, who represents California's 28th district. He's the chair of the House Intelligence Committee and has also been a leading voice on tech policy in Congress, including issues like deep fakes, disinformation on social media, and Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. We recorded this interview in his office in Washington, DC, so let's go there now to hear my conversation with Congressman Adam Schiff.
1:42 Speaker 02 So, thank you for coming, Congressman Schiff.
1:44 Speaker 03 My pleasure.
1:45 Speaker 02 We're in your office here during a rainstorm on the House side in the Rayburn House Office Building. Let's talk a little bit about a letter you have just sent to Facebook, Twitter, and Google. So, it's to Mark Sundar Pichai, Mark Zuckerberg, and Jack Dorsey.
2:02 Speaker 04 Yes, we've written to them to essentially try to put them on notice about the problem of deep fakes, so it asks what they're going to do about it, what they've done already, what their policies are. Back in 2016, my paramount concern as we were watching in real time what the Russians were doing was that they were going to start dumping forgeries among the real documents. Now, by and large, they dumped authentic but stolen Clinton emails. But of course, there would have been nothing that would prevent them from dumping forgeries, and they could have inserted additional paragraphs suggesting illegality, things that would have been impossible to disprove in the weeks leading up to the election.
2:44 Speaker 04 Now with deep fake technology, it would be very easy, in a way that would be difficult to ultimately attribute to the Russians or anybody else, insert into the social media ecosystem completely fraudulent video of Joe Biden, or Elizabeth Warren, or Donald Trump, or anybody else in the weeks leading up to an election that would be almost impossible to disprove. That worries me more, frankly, than other things that also concern me.
3:10 Speaker 05 Because it goes so quickly. Let me quote from this letter, "The consequences for our democracy could be devastating. A timely, convincing, deep fake video of a candidate going viral on a platform like Facebook, Twitter, Google, YouTube could hijack a race or even alter the course of history." You refer to the video of Nancy Pelosi, which I've written about, lots of people, YouTube took it down, Facebook did not, everybody made a different decision. But what happened is it went viral on all these platforms, and it was hard to take it down. Once it did, it was not a deep fake, it was just an altered video. So talk about the impact of that video here. Is that what prompted this?
3:46 Speaker 04 It's not what prompted it. In fact, I think we had done a hearing in the intel committee even before that Pelosi cheap fake was released. But it was a great trial run to see, are the tech companies ready to handle this? What's the response going to be? How do we deal with an environment in which... Lies travel far faster than truths. In the last election, the Trump campaign made an effort to portray Hillary Clinton as ill, as in poor health. They could have easily pushed out a video like that of Nancy Pelosi, where it looks like Hillary Clinton was slurring her speech, and 20 million people might see that, 5 million people might learn that it was a doctored video.
4:29 Speaker 04 But even those who see it and learn that it's doctored still don't shake completely the impression that it leaves. So it was a good trial run to see, are we ready? And the answer was no, we're not ready. The tech companies aren't ready. They don't have, I think their policies fully thought out yet. The government isn't ready. We don't have the technologies yet to be able to detect more sophisticated fakes. And the public is not ready. The public, by and large, when you bring up deep fake, they don't know what you're referring to. And so we don't have much time. It's eight months until the primaries begin to try to prepare the public, prepare ourselves, determine what other steps need be taken to protect ourselves from this kind of disinformation.
5:13 Speaker 05 Let's talk about those steps. And I want to talk, we'll talk about the broader issues around tech in a second. But you asked for some things. You want to know how many views did the manually altered video of Speaker Pelosi? This is this test run you're talking about. How long did it take to initiate a complete review? How many views the video has received for being marked false? You were talking about how Mark had talked about that deep fake were a completely different category than overall fakes. So you're asking them to look at things. When you get these answers, that's just the beginning. You've got to do something about it.
5:41 Speaker 04 Well, it is the beginning, but forcing the companies to go through the discipline of analyzing the question, developing policies, and being able to publicly justify their policies is part of what we can do. This is a difficult space for the government to operate in, because we're not going to censor people. But we can use the bully pulpit to try to encourage good behavior. We can also share information when we learn through the intelligence community that Russia is pushing out a deep fake. We can alert the companies to it. You know, there needed to be better cooperation, coordination. In the last election, we need to make sure that that's, those problems are ironed out before the next one. But, you know, that, it's not ineffective merely to ask the questions.
6:26 Speaker 04 You know, I wrote a similar series of letters. To the tech companies, asking them to deprioritize this anti-vaccination misinformation. And they did so with great speed. I don't know that I've ever gotten a result that quickly from a simple letter. So it can be powerful, but you're right, it's not the end by any means. We're trying in the Intelligence Authorization Bill to create a reward program through DARPA to those who develop technologies to detect doctored content. But how we use that technology, what kind of obligation we impose on the tech companies. I do think that, you know, the congressional scrutiny of how these tech companies are operating,
7:09 Speaker 04 whether they're using best practices, whether they've been good corporate citizens, whether they still deserve that immunity provision.
7:16 Speaker 05 We'll get to that.
7:17 Speaker 04 I think all of that is salutary, because I think they understand if they can't demonstrate good corporate citizenship, that they may prompt a lot of response from Congress they don't want to see.
7:29 Speaker 05 One of the things, I think it's sort of pattern matching, but nobody's done anything ever to them. They've never been legislated against, they've never had any guidelines in place, they've never had any rules.
7:38 Speaker 04 You know, I think up until 2016, most Americans and most members of Congress viewed them as a benign force for good. You know, it certainly had long been past the point where they were nascent companies struggling to get a foothold and where the argument that we need no regulation to make sure we don't stifle innovation. We'd already been long past that point, but nonetheless, they seem like a force for good. You know, we had the...
8:09 Speaker 05 Celebrities, you know, look up to, these are the heroes of our day, that kind of thing.
8:14 Speaker 04 You know, some of that, yes, but also the fact that people in Egypt and elsewhere could communicate out of the watchful eye of their government, they could organize. We were seeing so many benefits. Now, ultimately, the Arab Spring didn't pan out to be the great benefit we thought.
8:29 Speaker 05 Sure. What's interesting is Hong Kong, they didn't use any. They used paper and they used, you know, masks and they didn't use the social media as much.
8:38 Speaker 04 Well, and this is the thing, you know, I would say that 2016 was a turning point in the public view of technology as a benign force for good. Now, we are gravely concerned about other uses of technology, not just the social media platforms, but China, for example. One of the hearings we had in the Intel Committee was how they are exporting their digital form of totalitarianism, the euphemistic Orwellian safe cities model, where they have ubiquitous CCTV cameras tied into big data and facial recognition, social media scores. So we are definitely--
9:15 Speaker 05 It's a surveillance economy, is what it is. And they have to, they spend more on internal surveillance than almost anything to keep people in line. I think, you know, they have to do that, especially with facial recognition and everything. I'm going to get to that in a second.
9:27 Speaker 04 But I would imagine that is why you see what you do in Hong Kong, where people are going old school. They're realizing that, yes, technology is great in terms of communicating, but it's also a great tool for the government to keep track of what you're doing.
9:42 Speaker 05 Right. So let's go back a little bit, because you've been, how many terms have you been?
9:46 Speaker 04 This is my 10th term.
9:47 Speaker 05 From California, from California. So you're very aware, tech companies, you're very aware of the importance of innovation in tech in California. Let's go back a little bit in terms of the relationship between government and tech, because it was good, and then it wasn't. Where do you imagine things went off the rails?
10:07 Speaker 04 Well, I think that these companies grew so far, so fast, that their growth really outpaced their ability to analyze the impact on the public good. And I think part of it was there was such a cultural bedrock view that what they were doing was unmitigated good, that, you know, the kind of libertarian ideal, that it took time even for them to realize how their technologies were used for ill. And then, of course, that came into great competition with the economic motives. And so, you know, I think for Congress and for much of the public, that turning point came in 2016.
10:51 Speaker 05 What about Edward Snowden before that? Because I think a lot of the non-communication started there. There was a real break, and then the encryption fight during the Obama administration.
11:01 Speaker 04 Well, you know, that, I think, certainly had the effect of creating antagonisms between the government and the tech sector.
11:12 Speaker 04 I don't think it altered the public attitudes, though.
11:14 Speaker 05 Right.
11:15 Speaker 04 In terms of the public attitudes, they looked at Snowden, they looked at the encryption debate, and they saw, really, these things as flip sides of the same coin, that government was being intrusive in terms of the surveillance power, the technology companies were providing the answer. That's not how I think the public views the issue writ large anymore. I mean, they may still feel that way about encryption, but they also now realize that it's not good versus evil, tech versus government. It's now, technology is a force for good and ill. And I think there's a growing public recognition that the kind of laissez-faire attitude government has had towards the tech community is, has passed its point of utility.
11:57 Speaker 05 But do you think the Snowden revelations, when they should have been cooperating on things like Russia, impacted? You're in the midst of the Russia, the Russian investigations. Do you think it impacted the ability of those companies to work here at a critical time? Because that was right around when a lot of this, it was 2012 is when the Russians really started, like, they started moving around. And the theory I have is like, look, they lost the Cold War, but this is the new version of that.
12:23 Speaker 04 Well, I do think that the technology companies felt post Snowden, and maybe even pre Snowden, that getting too close to the US government, particularly getting too close to the US intelligence community, was antithetical to their philosophy, but was also bad for business. In a global environment in which people around the world were very protective of their privacy, as they are here at home, being as seen as too, you know, too much in bed with the US government was not a good thing. So I think that was the environment we went into the 2016 election in. And that probably spilled over in terms of the degree to which we could get cooperation from the tech sector.
13:07 Speaker 04 It was, you know, very difficult. We were pulling teeth, for example, to get them to provide us with all of the social media ads. It was then pulling more teeth to get them to excise the personally identifiable information so that we could release them publicly. They did not seem to want us to release them publicly.
13:26 Speaker 05 Right.
13:27 Speaker 04 Ultimately, we did, and I think it was very beneficial because researchers could use that.
13:31 Speaker 05 Right.
13:32 Speaker 04 And indeed, the companies themselves could hold them up as examples of what people need to be looking out for. But... We had to overcome a lot of opposition to do that. I don't think that opposition is completely gone by any means. But I do think.
13:46 Speaker 05 What do you mean by that? That they're not?
13:48 Speaker 04 Well, I mean, they're not. First of all, it's not a monolithic agent.
13:52 Speaker 05 Right, of course.
13:53 Speaker 04 Sector. I mean, some companies are more willing.
13:55 Speaker 05 Oh, no. I think the two that if you if you want to put it down to plague on politics, most tech companies like, you know, Facebook and Google, those jackasses, like, they're ruining it for the rest of us. I think Facebook and Google are the ones, they feel, are the ones who are more violative of these kind of things.
14:11 Speaker 04 You know, I don't know if that's correct about the public perception. You know, I can say in terms of our own interactions, it was often more difficult to get information from Twitter than some of the other companies in terms of the Russian manipulation of their platforms.
14:25 Speaker 05 Right.
14:26 Speaker 04 We often got better data from the Hamilton Project about what they were seeing about Russian use of bots on on these platforms than we could get from the platforms themselves. So.
14:37 Speaker 05 Why? Why was that?
14:39 Speaker 04 Well, that's a good question.
14:40 Speaker 05 Twitter's case, it could be a goat rodeo way they manage things. In other cases, they did they deny it? Do you feel like it was a denial of wanting to give it to you?
14:48 Speaker 04 Well, we would get.
14:49 Speaker 05 Or not knowing.
14:50 Speaker 04 We would get answers back that were written by the lawyers. And as a lawyer, I could appreciate good lawyerly writing, answers that didn't necessarily answer the question or answer the question in such a way as to avoid telling us something they didn't want to share. And so we would have to go back to them multiple times to make sure that we had this ability on on the issue. You know, I do think the companies, either because they recognize the problems that have been created or because they fear losing their immunity or being broken up, I think they are less reticent to share with us now when we do our oversight. But it's still not easy.
15:31 Speaker 05 How does it change since you've you're in the majority now? You were sort of, you were on a lot of cable television. They weren't, this committee was, where is this committee now? Because it seemed like it went off the rails pretty quickly. The Senate, not as much. But how does it change with you being in charge?
15:47 Speaker 04 Well, you know, the good news, bad news of our committee is that even through the worst of our differences on Russia, we continue to do all the rest of the business of the committee in a nonpartisan, bipartisan way. So, on the floor next week is the Intelligence Authorization Act. That passed out of our committee on a unanimous bipartisan voice vote. We passed that bill last year. We passed it the year before. Whether we are the minority, majority, we've been able to do it. And that's the bread and butter of our work. It reflects funding levels for the agencies, privacy protections, changes in how much we're going to devote to human intelligence versus signals intelligence, a whole host of issues, and we come to agreement on it.
16:31 Speaker 04 And frankly, we get those bills passed even when the Senate Intel Committee, which has done better on Russia, can't get that work done. So, that's been the good news. The bad news is that our differences on Russia have been profound, and that continues. That's made life very difficult. You know, we, you know, adhere to the mission we took on in the beginning, and that was determine what the Russians did, how they did it, the connections they had with the Trump campaign. And we were fighting them to get those answers when we were in the minority. We are now fighting the Justice Department to get those answers in the majority, and fighting the administration. So, we continue that effort, and certainly much easier with the gavel, but it is difficult
17:16 Speaker 04 now because we have a president obstructing everything.
17:18 Speaker 05 So, you have to sue it, sue it out, get them to?
17:21 Speaker 04 We do. And now, we are getting information. We are bringing in witnesses. We are getting documents, but it is a hard slog. And they are raising, the administration is raising, nonexistent privileges and using every delay tactic they can. Nonetheless, we are gaining information and gaining ground in our understanding of what took place, and we're going to continue to press until we get the information out to the public.
17:48 Speaker 05 So, overall now, where do you feel you are with what took place? Because what you need to do is look about what they're doing today.
17:53 Speaker 04 Yes.
17:54 Speaker 05 Which the FBI does, I'm assuming, CIA in certain parts of the world do.
17:58 Speaker 04 Yes. You know, I think we have a good appreciation of what the Russians did. What we are looking at on our committee is what are the counterintelligence risks that have been created as a result of what they did in 2016 and 2018? What are the risks going forward? What Mueller and his team did was basically a criminal investigation into who should go to jail. The Mueller report itself is a prosecutor's report on why he charged certain people and didn't charge others. It doesn't address at all the other half of the investigation, which is the counterintelligence investigation. Who was operating as agents of a foreign power? What were those agents doing in this country?
18:42 Speaker 04 What risks have been posed to American national security by virtue of contacts between the Trump people and the Russians? Those risks continue even as to things that were not charged. And so we are trying to get an understanding of those and what we need to do to protect ourselves, as well as analyze what Mueller wasn't allowed to look at, including the issue of money laundering. So there are still a great many things we don't have answers to, but at the end of the day, the most important thing for us is to make sure that the country is protected, that there's no vulnerability compromise that is impacting U.S. policy that goes undisclosed.
19:23 Speaker 02 We're here with Congressman Adam Schiff. We're going to take a quick break now, but we'll be back after this.
20:26 Speaker 05 What are you most worried about right now? It's interesting because sometimes you and Senator Warner often say, "Well, if you knew what really went on." What is the big worry from your perspective right now?
20:36 Speaker 04 You know, what I've been saying really for most of the last year and a half is really quite the contrary, which is, everything in the public view is already damning enough. I mean, just look at what's in the public view. And, you know, what's in the public view is a massive Russian intervention in our election, a Trump campaign that not only was aware of it, but was encouraging it, made full use of it, didn't report it, and then tried to cover it up. And to this date, a president who, through his word and deed, seemed to encourage the Russians to do it again.
21:18 Speaker 04 Every time he speaks with Putin, and he mocks the idea that the Russians intervened in our affairs, as he did in his last meeting, or, as in his phone conversation just prior to that, once again called this all a hoax, or that debacle in Helsinki where he took the side of Putin over his own intelligence agencies, he is communicating to the Russians. He is too weak to call them out if they intervene again, and what's more, if they intervene on his side, he may very well even be grateful. That's the message he's delivering. And, you know, the Russians, just like us, they do psychological profiles of their adversaries. They know exactly what buttons to push to get what they want out of the President of the United States.
22:00 Speaker 05 So, Robert Mueller is coming next week to talk. Were you... There was no collusion proven. It was possible cooperation on this. Was that a blow to the efforts you were making to try to... Because what happens here is it gets confused. I think getting it confused is damage, is the way to really damage it, is if you say the Russians did this incredibly... The most intelligence agencies agree. All the intelligence agencies agree that this is what happened, and one person in the room says, "Well, maybe."
22:29 Speaker 04 Well, you know, just the way you phrase the question shows the success that
22:34 Speaker 05 That's what I'm trying to...
22:35 Speaker 04 That Trump and Barr have had in misrepresenting Mueller's work.
22:39 Speaker 05 Right.
22:40 Speaker 04 Because, of course, there's no part of the report that says there was no collusion. Quite the contrary. What Mueller says is... We don't analyze the question of collusion.
22:48 Speaker 05 Right.
22:48 Speaker 04 That can be criminal and it can be noncriminal. What we look at is, was there evidence beyond a reasonable doubt of criminal conspiracy? And while we do find evidence, we don't find that we can prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt. Now, that's very different than a conclusion that there is no collusion. In fact, there is lots of evidence of collusion. There's a Russian offer of help communicated to the top levels of the Trump campaign. There is the president's own son saying he would love to have that help. There's the president's son, the campaign chairman, and son-in-law taking a secret meeting to receive that help. There are lies that the president and his son engage in to cover up that meeting.
23:30 Speaker 04 There are the Russians telling the campaign through an intermediary named Mifsud that they can help the campaign through the anonymous release of stolen emails of Hillary Clinton, which is what exactly they would go on to do. There's the president making multiple requests to find out what the Russians have given WikiLeaks that can be released.
23:51 Speaker 05 Sean Ridge, just this week.
23:53 Speaker 04 All of these things, the provision of polling data to someone linked to Russian intelligence by the campaign chairman involving multiple states. So, all of that is evidence of collusion. And, you know, what we hope to do in the hearing is bring that out. Because, you know, what Bill Barr did as essentially the agent of the president was misrepresent what was in the Mueller report and delay the release of the Mueller report as long as he could. So that he would have a month and the president would have a month using his bully pulpit to mislead the country into thinking the report says no collusion, no obstruction.
24:31 Speaker 05 So, what do you do now? Because most intelligence agents, all intelligence agents agree this happened, but there's confusion on it. Confusion has been created. Is that over? Can this, does this testimony matter at all?
24:44 Speaker 04 It matters a great deal. Bill Barr would like nothing better than his misleading word to be the last word. It's why he is affirmatively now trying to discourage Mueller, why the Justice Department is trying to interfere with the hearing next week. And...
25:01 Speaker 04 It's because Mueller will contradict in word, if not explicitly taking on Barr, what Barr misrepresented, what the president is misrepresenting. And the American people need to hear that from Mueller. It's one thing when they hear it from me, it's another when they hear it from the president, it's another when they hear it from the Attorney General. This is the guy who did the investigation. And what Bob Mueller is going to say next week is he's going to say, "The Russians intervened in a systemic way, that was no hoax. They did so to help one of the candidates, and it wasn't Hillary Clinton. The Trump campaign was not only aware of it, they were eager to get that help.
25:44 Speaker 04 They not only were eager to get that help, they made use of that help. They not only made use of that help, they then lied to cover it up. Those cover-ups may be a crime, I can't say, but I can't exonerate him either." That is a powerful rebuttal to the falsehoods being put up by the White House.
26:01 Speaker 05 One of the things, sort of the idea around it is that he's reticent, that he doesn't want to come. He said all he said. He did that press conference, which I found unusual, the idea that "I said all I've said." How do you get him to say more?
26:14 Speaker 04 Well, the press conference, I think, was an effort to say, "I really don't want to testify, but I know that I can't completely disappear, so how about 10 minutes?" That, of course, didn't satisfy anyone.
26:26 Speaker 05 Why doesn't he want to say just what you were saying?
26:30 Speaker 04 Well, you know, I think it's a combination of things. I think that he's been kicked around for two years. He realizes no matter what he says during the hearing, he's going to be kicked around more. No one looks forward to that. I think he also views his role as a prosecutor, and prosecutors don't normally talk outside of their indictments. But as he acknowledged in his own report, he is not operating in a traditional prosecutorial role. And while I understand why he is reluctant, that came with the job. And if you're not willing to do what is required of the job, then don't take the job.
27:05 Speaker 05 What if he is reticent in the media? Because, you know, the report's going to come out now, we'll see what really happened. Kind of didn't, because they were able to talk about it in the way they wanted to. He gave a press conference where he didn't really, it didn't, people are waiting for this to nail. This administration, and it never does.
27:25 Speaker 04 Well, it's certainly true that what was said of Reagan is far more true of Donald Trump. When they called Reagan the Teflon president, he was a piker compared to Donald Trump. I mean, the things that are provable about Donald Trump on a daily basis would have resulted in Ronald Reagan's removal, or anyone else for that matter. So he brings a new level of Teflon we've never seen. Nonetheless, you know, I think it will be powerful to hear from Mueller. I think it's important the country hear from Mueller. Whether it changes attitudes appreciably, I don't know. I come into this with very circumspect expectations
28:08 Speaker 04 about what will happen. There are a lot of hardened attitudes about the president, about Russia. But I do think that we have an obligation to get the facts out to the public, and the public will make the judgment about what weight to give them and how to use them in their decision making. But it isn't sufficient to do an investigation like this, like Watergate, to hand off the report and then say, we don't really want anyone to pay attention to this in Congress or the public. If the Republicans had been in this same posture after Watergate, there would have been no Watergate hearings. They would have gotten the report from Jaworski, and they would have said, okay, anything else is a do-over. It wasn't true then, it's
28:50 Speaker 04 not true now, and so we'll discharge our responsibility, and we'll leave it to the public to decide what the consequence should be.
28:59 Speaker 05 But no definitive blow. It's a slow-moving thing, or what is the...
29:04 Speaker 04 Well, I don't know what the impact will be of his testimony, whether it will be catalytic, whether it will change attitudes on impeachment, or whether it will really not move the needle very much. I think it's impossible to say. I do think that we need to be realistic. I don't imagine there are going to be any dramatic new facts that come out in his testimony.
29:25 Speaker 05 Right, all of a sudden, what I really meant to say is...
29:27 Speaker 04 If there are dramatic new facts...
29:28 Speaker 05 He's a Russian agent.
29:29 Speaker 04 Yes. I don't think we can expect that. But nonetheless... Because most people have not had the opportunity in their busy lives to read this report, it's the first time they're really going to hear about it from an impartial source.
29:42 Speaker 05 So when you talk about the Teflon president, when you're dealing with this kind of thing, he's a very heavy user of social media in the same way, using it to do a lot of falsehoods, actually, using these platforms. How do you look at that? What do you think? Do you sometimes go, oh, wow, he's good at that? Or you're like, I'm appalled by the use of the platforms like this?
30:04 Speaker 04 Well.
30:05 Speaker 05 Or both?
30:06 Speaker 04 I guess both. Yesterday, he tweeted out something patently false about Iran's compliance with the nuclear deal.
30:14 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
30:15 Speaker 04 You know, I have to say.
30:16 Speaker 05 It's like Wednesday at 2 o'clock.
30:17 Speaker 04 Although I keep saying, you know, I've lost my capacity to be surprised, I am still surprised.
30:22 Speaker 05 Really? What do you do?
30:24 Speaker 04 Yes, I'm still surprised.
30:25 Speaker 05 Do you sit there and just go, what the heck?
30:26 Speaker 04 Yes, I do.
30:27 Speaker 05 Get your fingers out.
30:28 Speaker 04 I read the president saying that Iran was cheating on the nuclear deal when there's no evidence to support that and a lot of intelligence that they were living up to the deal before we got out of it. And it still takes my breath away that a president of the United States will just baldly lie about something of such significance. That ought to take our breath away.
30:49 Speaker 05 And he has a vehicle to do it in a different way.
30:52 Speaker 04 He has a vehicle, yes, he does.
30:53 Speaker 05 How do you look at his use of Twitter?
30:55 Speaker 04 Well, you know, for someone who loves to criticize these companies, no one has derived more benefit from Twitter than Donald Trump.
31:00 Speaker 05 Well, I say that, you should send them flowers every day.
31:02 Speaker 04 Yeah, no.
31:03 Speaker 05 There should be a new bouquet.
31:04 Speaker 04 Without a doubt, without a doubt, because traditionally, if he were relying on reputable newspapers or broadcasts, to the degree they would discuss a statement of the president's like that, they would examine it and they would expose it. And he knows he can communicate directly without the filter of good journalism. And so it is what it is. You know, I think.
31:32 Speaker 05 Does that change politics forever? Or is it just that he's an aberration who happens to be very good at Twitter?
31:38 Speaker 04 Both. I don't think that when he's gone, uh, someone is going to be able to carry on the cult of his personality. There are certain parts of this that are unique to him.
31:50 Speaker 05 Yeah.
31:51 Speaker 04 Uh, the kind of reality TV, I can't turn my eyes away from this disaster quality.
31:56 Speaker 05 Yeah, Mike Pence is less than compelling.
31:59 Speaker 04 That is true. That is true. There will be someone running in the Trump lane.
32:04 Speaker 05 Right.
32:04 Speaker 04 For some time, that will try to do what he does probably without the same, you know, native ability.
32:09 Speaker 05 Yeah.
32:10 Speaker 04 But in terms of using social media as a end run around any journalistic filter.
32:16 Speaker 05 You use it a lot. Why, what are you trying to do there?
32:18 Speaker 04 Well, I, I've always believed.
32:20 Speaker 05 You're rather sassy on social media.
32:22 Speaker 04 You need to communicate in every media that your opposition is.
32:25 Speaker 05 Uh huh.
32:26 Speaker 04 And you don't.
32:27 Speaker 05 What are you going for? Sometimes you do indignant, sometimes you do funny, you do.
32:31 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, you know.
32:33 Speaker 05 You do these yourself?
32:34 Speaker 04 I have to say, in the beginning.
32:35 Speaker 05 You do these yourself?
32:36 Speaker 04 I was a rela-, yes. Um, and now I, I have my staff review them and my staff will propose tweets to me.
32:43 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
32:44 Speaker 04 In the beginning, I have to say, I, I was kind of a late user compared to other members. I bridled at the idea of having to put a complex thought in, in a few characters. But then I, I grew to think it was kind of a fun challenge in a way, to say something unique, or witty, or ironic, or whatnot. Uh, and yes, our Twitter feed is a little eccentric. Um, I did a, and, and I caught my censors, my staff censors, I think late in the evening when their, their guard was down, with a tweet that was just straight out of King Lear.
33:15 Speaker 05 Mm-hmm.
33:16 Speaker 04 And it did very well. Um, I think the people that follow our Twitter feed follow it because it's a little unusual, but we use it for a variety of purposes. Sometimes we use it to rebut the president, sometimes we use it to. Alert people of new things that have happened either in the Russian investigation or other things. Sometimes we use it to call attention to things that are positive and it's a nice break from the sort of monotony of what Trump is doing wrong today.
33:44 Speaker 05 May I ask a question then? Is this any way to run a government? Because this week, he did a tweet that was a order that the Justice Department lawyers didn't understand. And the lawyer, if you saw the lawyer, I think I wrote about it this week, the lawyer was like, he tweeted, "I don't know what it means yet. I'm going to need to find out." But it's government by tweet. It's not just campaigning or "I'm the best president ever and people love me." That's fine. But this is government by tweet.
34:07 Speaker 04 Oh, it's just awful. I mean, there is no—
34:11 Speaker 05 Where do we go?
34:12 Speaker 04 The interagency is what's between his hand and the screen on his phone. There is no interagency. I mean, he will announce sanctions. He will do away with sanctions. He will accuse countries of violating treaties. He will undercut his own staff. He will make an overture to a North Korean dictator for an unplanned meeting. I mean, all of that is just on the impulse.
34:41 Speaker 05 How, like, from an intelligence point of view, how does it—how do we get back from that?
34:47 Speaker 04 We're not going to as long as he's president. When he leaves office, the question is, how do we get back to some norm of office again? We are already writing the post-Watergate reforms of this generation. Reforms of the pardon process, reforms of the ability of the president to intervene in—
35:11 Speaker 05 Executive action.
35:12 Speaker 04 —specific cases in the Justice Department. We're going to have to have a much speedier mechanism for the enforcement of congressional subpoenas and process.
35:20 Speaker 05 Yeah, he might work on that.
35:21 Speaker 04 We're already writing the reforms. And, you know, frankly, they'll be bipartisan when he's gone. The Republicans won't support them now because they're—they run scared to death of being on the receiving end of a presidential tweet. There's been, I think, the most profound display of collective cowardice that I've ever seen in terms of a legislative body. But we'll pass these reforms when he's gone because they will feel—well, they'll recognize they do already the need for it. And there won't be the same political peril of being perceived as slating the president.
35:52 Speaker 05 So, why don't you all do something about that? Were we in impeachment? Just today, just yesterday, there was this odd fight between Nancy Pelosi and the Squad over tweeting, over disagreeing with each other. It's a new day in politics, or not? I mean, it's a different kind of mentality in politics. Do you feel that way, or is there any way to go back? There isn't, as far as I can tell.
36:15 Speaker 04 Well, you know, I do think that one huge impact of Donald Trump has been to change the tone of politics. And it is no exaggeration to say that the president sets the tone for a lot of things. I remember early in the administration feeling that his character flaw was infecting the whole of government. And then I remember after Dr. Ford testified and Trump went to that rally and was mocking her. And I was watching the people standing behind him on the stage, and they were laughing at Dr. Ford.
36:58 Speaker 04 And I thought to myself, okay, now it's gone well beyond infecting the character of the government and affected the whole country.
37:06 Speaker 05 100%.
37:07 Speaker 04 And, you know, I think we see that in a debasing of the political process and the dialogue. I mean, if you answered the phones in our office for a while, particularly when I go on Fox, and compared it to what it was like answering the phones in a congressional office 10 years ago, or 20 years ago, or 30 years ago, I mean, it has been a complete debasing of the political dialogue.
37:33 Speaker 05 You need to get rid of phones. That's my feeling. I just don't have them called, because you know who's on the phones. So, but within your own party...
37:39 Speaker 04 Well, people are more polite on the phones compared to how they are on social media.
37:43 Speaker 05 Well, true, but many of them are bots. I had a reporter, a very well-known reporter, was arguing with someone, and I texted them and said, "You're arguing with a bot. Like, stop. Like, you don't understand. Like, I just traced it for you." Which was funny, but she had gotten in and stayed over it, which was really interesting. What about within your own party? Here are a bunch of really young, fresh congresspeople who are using the mediums in a similar, in a way that's... Not unsimilar, factual, but not unsimilar in terms of of creating opinions and disagreements out in public. What does that do for?
38:19 Speaker 04 Well, I wouldn't compare anybody, I guess, to Donald Trump.
38:22 Speaker 05 No, but it's using the platform in this way that's very different. And so Speaker Pelosi said, oh, it's whatever these online thing isn't what really is politics. Is it or not?
38:33 Speaker 04 Well, I think social media has really transformed the political process. You know, we've seen a lot of systemic changes over the last decade, changes in how campaigns are financed that have empowered private interests outside of the Capitol at the expense of the political parties, at the expense of the leadership. Social media is also, I think, really changing the nature of the institution, the nature of the political debate, and the nature of how campaigns are run. I mean, if you look at what the president was able to do on social media. I think we are really witnessing two revolutions taking place at the same time that are hugely disruptive.
39:12 Speaker 04 There's a revolution in the economy through globalization and AI that is producing massive migration flows, that is producing
39:21 Speaker 05 Job disruption eventually.
39:23 Speaker 04 Enormous disruption in the marketplace, in people's jobs, and all the economic anxiety that goes with that. At the same time, there's a revolution in how we communicate through social media, which is equivalent to the invention of the printing press, except there we had hundreds of years to get used to it, and here we have weeks sometimes, or a year, or years. Either one of those things would be hugely disruptive. Both put together, I think, are resulting in a conflagration. And so we are, I think, just figuring it out now. What does this mean and how is it going to change the nature of Congress, the nature of our economy, our lives, our retirement system?
40:02 Speaker 05 Where do you come down on the controversy this week? Should they be able to tweet what they want?
40:07 Speaker 04 Absolutely. I mean, they they have a first amendment right to say or tweet whatever they want. Whether it makes sense to be attacking each other when the real opposition, at least to what we're trying to accomplish in terms of these families who are suffering, is the President and Mitch McConnell, I don't think it helps advance the cause for us to be going after each other. There is a world, a universe of difference between what we think ought to be done for these children and what Mitch McConnell does or Donald Trump does. I mean, as we speak, they are potentially engaging in raids around the country. Already immigrant communities are in great fear about what's going to happen to their
40:52 Speaker 04 friends, their neighbors, their children, their parents. I remember the day after the election, going to the Boys and Girls Club in Hollywood, and people think of Hollywood as being very wealthy, but there are parts of Hollywood that are very poor. And there were, the director told me that the kids at the club the night before were in tears because they felt their parents were going to be deported. And so, this is what we're up against. And I think when the House is burning down around us as it is, we can't afford to fight with each other. We need to keep our focus on protecting these kids, these families, protecting people's access to health care, making sure that this guy is a one-term disaster only, making sure
41:36 Speaker 04 that Mitch McConnell is replaced, and we have a Senate that will protect people from gun violence and is working to preserve their access to health care rather than do away with it.
41:46 Speaker 05 How do you put your chances at?
41:49 Speaker 04 Well, you know, I think that prudently, in terms of the presidential race, we have to expect it's going to be hard. It's, I think it's a 50-50 race. We underestimated him in the primary and the general. We're not going to underestimate him again. It will all come down to whether we can turn our people out. The good news for Democrats and progressives is that we significantly outnumber those that think Donald Trump is doing a good job. If we turn out our people, we win. So it is within our own power to control our destiny. You know, and that's empowering. We can do this. We just need to make sure that we turn our people out and that we're not a House Divided. And so, I would much rather be in a position where we're in control of our own destiny
42:34 Speaker 04 than we're at someone else's whim and we have to count on them to fail. So...
42:41 Speaker 04 This is, you know, incumbent president, always tough thing to beat. But if there was ever an incumbent president who could be beaten, it's this one. And I'm optimistic we will beat him. I'd like to make sure that we take the Senate at the same time.
42:55 Speaker 02 We're going to take another break now. We'll be back after this with Congressman Adam Schiff.
43:00 Speaker 06 It's me, the. We don't need the jingle twice. Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars. Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than. Please stop. Touche. Priceline.
43:29 Speaker 03 How about a latte?
43:32 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
43:33 Speaker 03 Vanilla?
43:33 Speaker 01 Caramel?
43:34 Speaker 03 Blueberry?
43:35 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
43:55 Speaker 05 Two things I want to talk about before we're finished. One is what, getting back to innovation, the idea of where innovation is going. But before that, I want to ask you about where you think the threats are now from a digital point of view in the cyber wars. Is it from China, from Russia, from where are you worried the most? Many people, you know, we talk about artificial intelligence, facial recognition, robotics, automation, and things like that. China's really moving far ahead in many of these things. You're from a state that has been at the leader of tech around the whole globe. What is your biggest worry among those? And what do you think we have to do as a country to keep that innovation or keep that particular?
44:39 Speaker 05 Engine going.
44:40 Speaker 04 Well, I would distinguish between worries over how foreign powers might intervene in 2020 and then the broader challenge that we face from other countries. In terms of 2020.
44:53 Speaker 05 Is it deep fakes?
44:54 Speaker 04 Well, in terms of a foreign adversary, it's Russia. In terms of what tactics they may use, I would put deep fakes or something similar at the top of the list. I still have profound concerns about the security of our elections infrastructure. And frankly, they don't have to change the vote, they just have to create enough doubt where we can't rely on the outcome. If we have a situation like that, can you imagine a Bush v. Gore, electronic dangling Chad situation?
45:24 Speaker 05 Yeah.
45:25 Speaker 04 How that would work in a Trump era? I shudder to think about.
45:30 Speaker 05 And then if he's lost, will he go away quietly? No.
45:33 Speaker 04 Well, particularly if they can raise a question about the legitimacy of the vote tally. There is an effort to conflate by the president and sometimes by people around him the threat to 2020 posed by Russia and China. Chinese intervention is of a very different character. Yes, China lobbies the United States, and yes, China writes op-eds, and yes, China uses its trade policy where they know it will hurt as a way of exerting pressure on the president. That's pretty much out in the open. What Russia does is very different, so I don't think there's any comparing those two. Over the long term, though, China is the much more worthy rival, much more powerful
46:15 Speaker 04 rival with a much more worrisome and powerful future across every domain, whether it's R and D and technology, whether it's in space, whether it's in the military front, whether it's in their Belt and Road Initiative, the development assistance. In every sphere, China is advancing while the Trump administration is self-immolating. And most worrying to me is
46:42 Speaker 04 That they're exporting this digital autocracy. And so they're not only using technology to keep their own population more firmly constrained, but they're helping other autocratic regimes around the country, around the world, do the same thing. And this, you know, points out frankly, the broadest concern I have, which is the rise of authoritarianism. At a time when our president is making common cause with the autocrats. We always thought, I think, that the idea that more people every year, year after year, would be living in greater freedom with more representative government was somehow inexorable. It's not. We're at an inflection point. And this, I think, is one of the real ideological challenges of our time.
47:24 Speaker 05 I always do say autocrats love the internet. Why wouldn't they? It's a way to track faces, track data, track everything. So I want to finish up on that.
47:31 Speaker 04 They love it, and I think they fear it.
47:32 Speaker 05 I think they love it. I think it's a great medium for them. I think it works really well in a lot of ways. So getting to whether these companies should be broken up, we should, the way you beat this to me is competition and innovation. And even if you have a China that's funding all its companies, you can't be innovative except with lots of new companies, lots of new ideas, in fact, which is the way we got ahead in the first place. Are tech companies too big, from your perspective? Is it, does it pose a danger from an intelligence point of view and everything else? If all this power is in the hands of a few companies, AI or whatever, or data or probably everything related to that?
48:09 Speaker 04 I think we have probably the greatest concentration of market power in our history. And we ought to be looking at the question of, should any of these companies be broken up? And what would that look like? And what's the cost of that transition? I think those are questions that are very much before Congress. I don't know the answer at this point. I also think we need to look at that profound question over whether they should still have the immunity that they do.
48:34 Speaker 05 Yeah, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
48:37 Speaker 04 So I think that-
48:39 Speaker 05 Nothing makes Silicon Valley sweat more.
48:42 Speaker 04 Well, nothing may make them more highly motivated to do the right thing than the fear of losing that, or losing it. But I do think it's time for us to do that vigorous oversight and make those judgments. It's ironic that the intel committee was the first to do oversight of Silicon Valley in a meaningful way. And it's only because of how that issue came to us through Russian manipulation. But those kind of hearings should have been going on now for years. But they are starting now in the Congress and the Judiciary Committee, the...
49:17 Speaker 05 There's a lot of hearings. What's the law that will be passed first?
49:22 Speaker 04 Well, I would think that if there's major action to be had here, it will more likely come on the immunity provision before a breakup.
49:34 Speaker 05 Wow.
49:35 Speaker 04 But, you know, that's just a hunch.
49:37 Speaker 05 And that's something you agree with the Republicans on, interestingly. That's what the... You're not at the antisocial social media summit right now in the White House, are you?
49:45 Speaker 04 No.
49:46 Speaker 05 You weren't invited?
49:47 Speaker 04 No. The last time I went to the White House, which was about a week ago, when we were almost at war with Iran, the President looked quite surprised to see me.
49:55 Speaker 05 Oh, really?
49:56 Speaker 04 Yes.
49:57 Speaker 05 You're allowed in there, right?
49:58 Speaker 04 I was invited.
49:59 Speaker 05 Right, right. But you weren't invited to this summit?
50:01 Speaker 04 I don't think so.
50:03 Speaker 05 Yeah. You're not really a conspiracy theorist. But sometimes conspiracy theories are true, in lots of ways. What is the thing that you worry the most about?
50:12 Speaker 04 Well, what I worry the most about is what I was mentioning, that authoritarianism is gaining ground. And if we don't figure out these big economic challenges, we have seen really bad things happen when people are under enormous economic strife. Already, we're seeing that manifest in this really ugly form of xenophobic populism. If the economic situation gets worse around the world, and we've been in a boom for a long time, then there's no telling where that goes. And I think... Figuring out those big economic questions is imperative for our economic
50:50 Speaker 04 future, but it's also imperative for dealing with these forces that are propelling this angry populism. But I also fear that as we cozy up to the Kim Jong Un's and have our love affair with these dictators, that the rest of the world is not standing still. And yes, the new president can begin quickly to repair some of the damage, but some of the damage is not going to be easily undone. And so that global picture is what concerns me the most.
51:27 Speaker 05 And lastly, you know, you deal with a lot of intelligence with a lot of new technologies that are coming. Is there one that worries you the most? Is it facial recognition? Is it AI? Is it which one of them done in the wrong way from an intelligence point of view?
51:43 Speaker 04 I guess what I would say, and this is a very inadequate shorthand, but 5G may tie this all together and make it much more efficient to pull in the CCTV and the social media scores and the facial recognition software. It begins to look very Orwellian. And I guess that technological autocracy is what I worry about in the tech sphere that China is just blazing the trail for. Once that's gotten hold, it's very hard to take apart. And so we've got more than our share of challenges.
52:26 Speaker 05 Yeah, I'll leave you with a happy one. What do you like about technology? When you think about it from the, not for any point of view, the intelligence point of view, your personal point of view, what do you like about it?
52:35 Speaker 04 Oh, I, you know, I also represent the entertainment industry.
52:39 Speaker 05 You do.
52:40 Speaker 04 And so I, you know.
52:41 Speaker 05 They got the crap kicked out of them by technology.
52:43 Speaker 04 I'm an avid consumer of film and music. I love the ease with which I can watch things and share things and find my way around. And so I make ample use of technology. You know, I will say one thing, the big fallacy of technology, which it took me a long time to realize. In the beginning, you know, smart technology gave you the illusion that you could get more free time because you could be much more efficient. But no, it's completely the opposite.
53:17 Speaker 02 No, Adam Schiff. You have to stare at it all the time.
53:20 Speaker 04 Which is one of the reasons why I like scuba diving because apart from the technology that keeps you alive and figures out-
53:26 Speaker 02 You can put a screen in your mask and it'll tell you what the fish are. It'll be AR. Do you know that?
53:31 Speaker 04 What's that?
53:31 Speaker 02 There's screens on masks like that where you will wear them down.
53:35 Speaker 04 Oh, and will help you identify the fish?
53:37 Speaker 02 The fish and it'll tell you about them.
53:39 Speaker 04 As long as I don't get Donald Trump's text messages when I'm 50 feet below because I would quickly run out of oxygen.
53:46 Speaker 02 All right. I'll leave it on that. Congressman Schiff, thank you so much. And we're looking forward to the hearings next week and we'll see what comes of it. Thank you.
53:52 Speaker 04 Thank you.
53:54 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Congressman Schiff for coming on the show. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Erica Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. If you liked this episode, we really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media and Pivot. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robby. Special thanks to Emily Simons and Reen Barger. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
54:34 Speaker 07 In this life, you can't win.
54:36 Speaker 08 When the world gets you down.
54:37 Speaker 07 No!
54:38 Speaker 08 Escape to Pluto TV.
54:40 Speaker 07 This is objectively fantastic.
54:41 Speaker 08 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free.
54:45 Speaker 07 Schwing!
54:46 Speaker 08 Even our news is uplifting.
54:47 Speaker 06 You stay classy, San Diego.
54:49 Speaker 08 Watch School of Rock, Crazy Ex Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
54:55 Speaker 09 We're not worthy!
54:57 Speaker 08 The best things on TV really are free.
54:59 Speaker 07 You just have to know where to look.
55:00 Speaker 08 Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
55:07 Speaker 09 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall, the most incredible survival thriller of the year. I need the whale! Help me! In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home! Josh Fulgham. Survivor, survivor. Whale Fall, rated PG-13, maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Andrew Yang Next Recode Decode: Stitch Fix CEO Katrina Lake Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated