Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Microsoft President Brad Smith About this episode Microsoft President Brad Smith talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher about his new book, co-authored with Carol Ann Browne, Tools and Weapons: The Promise and the Peril of the Digital Age. They discuss what Microsoft learned from United States v. Microsoft Corp. in 2001 and how that antitrust investigation compares to today’s techlash; the culture of disruption and “move fast and break things” in Silicon Valley; and why every tech company, even those not responsible for problems, should be part of the solutions. Smith also talks about the impact of Edward Snowden’s NSA leak and the Cambridge Analytica scandal, how the government can expand the opportunities enjoyed by the tech world with more of America, and tech regulation around the world — including why Smith believes the US will have a national privacy bill by 2024. Plus: Is it inevitable that big tech companies will be broken up?
Featuring:
Brad Smith (@bradsmi), president of Microsoft and co-author of Tools and Weapons: The Promise and the Peril of the Digital Age.
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Pivot, Kara’s podcast with NYU Professor Scott Galloway that offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 11,648 words · 6 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 When it comes to your business, you want cards and tools you can trust. Amex Corporate helps put you in control. Set custom spend parameters to help fit your business needs and quickly issue unlimited corporate cash back cards. All backed by best-in-class fraud protection and the powerful backing of American Express. Get started at go.amex slash Amex Corporate. Terms apply.
0:29 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:53 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone who is bracing for Russia to weaponize Snapchat filters in 2020, but in my spare time, I talk tech and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is someone I've known a very long time, Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft. He's been at the company for almost 26 years and has been president for the past four. Brad has also co-authored a new book with Carol Anne Brown called Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of the Digital Age. Brad, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:24 Speaker 03 Thank you, Kara. Great to be here.
1:25 Speaker 02 So I'm excited about this book because it's a lot of stuff you've been talking about for a long time, which is something I've obviously been interested in. And so I want to talk about the book and what you've been doing at Microsoft and sort of the state of play between tech companies and government. Steve Case many years ago wrote The Third Wave, where he's talking about government regulation coming to tech, the new tech. And this kind of is what has happened since, I think, is what sort of the result of it. So this is my take. So I wanted to sort of, let's get people to know who you are, your background. So you've been at Microsoft since you were born?
1:58 Speaker 03 Just even earlier than that.
2:00 Speaker 02 Right, okay, right.
2:01 Speaker 03 No, but I've been at Microsoft since 1993, as you said, 26 years. I was a lawyer with a law firm. I worked in London and DC before that. Really started my career representing the PC software industry as it was expanding into Europe in the late eighties and early nineties and then made the jump across the English Channel.
2:22 Speaker 02 So why did you want to work for Microsoft? So this was the time, I guess it was still small, smallish.
2:28 Speaker 03 It was definitely-
2:29 Speaker 02 The most dominant software player.
2:31 Speaker 03 To put it in perspective, when I joined Microsoft, the company had about 4,000 employees. Today it has 140,000 employees. I wanted to work for Microsoft in part because I was an avid user and fan of the company's products. I bought Microsoft Word version 1.0 the day it came out and I've been using versions of Word ever since. I could see what the operating system business was doing in terms of how it was changing the face of computing. I was impressed at the time because I felt Microsoft was a company with a long-term vision. And indeed, if you compare the Microsoft at the time to the other companies in the industry,
3:13 Speaker 03 Lotus, WordPerfect, Novell, there's a common theme. Microsoft is still here. Those were great companies as well, but it turned out Microsoft did have the right long-term plan.
3:24 Speaker 02 But you got there right during its sort of start to be in trouble days, the sort of the era of the monopoly lawsuits and the struggles that it had.
3:34 Speaker 03 There's some truth to that. I had done work as a lawyer, including in the antitrust field, and the company's first antitrust investigation actually started in 1990. And the first really big negotiation with governments was in 1994. So I'd only been at the company several months. And it was a joint negotiation between Microsoft and the Department of Justice and the European Commission. I was part of that process.
4:01 Speaker 02 And the reason I want to stress it is because what's happening today, Microsoft was the first there to deal with government interest in technology because there hadn't per se been much regulation of technology in any way whatsoever.
4:14 Speaker 03 I think that actually is a fair characterization. When I look back- It really was almost what I would describe the first collision between information technology and the world.
4:25 Speaker 02 Right.
4:25 Speaker 03 It was a big international set of issues. Of course, it ended up exploding.
4:30 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
4:31 Speaker 03 It ended up with the Department of Justice and 20 states seeking and initially obtaining in order to break up the company from a district court. It led to antitrust cases in 26 other countries. We had to adjust, we had to learn, we had to go through a lot of what I think the tech sector as a whole is increasingly confronting today.
4:52 Speaker 02 So let people know what happened in the end of that, because a lot of people don't. Microsoft did not get broken up. It didn't turn out quite the way as the headlines were at the time, but explain what happened.
5:03 Speaker 03 I think that there was an evolution.
5:07 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
5:08 Speaker 03 A court of appeals decided that the company wouldn't necessarily be broken up, but the company was found to be liable.
5:15 Speaker 02 Yep.
5:15 Speaker 03 There was a consent decree that was issued. There were further cases in Europe. There were a number of regulatory rules, in effect, imposed on Microsoft. And the whole decade of the 2000s was really, in many ways, spent adjusting to all of that and then seeking to emerge with what I'll say is a sense of responsibility.
5:38 Speaker 02 Right.
5:39 Speaker 03 Perhaps more maturity, but also the kind of innovative spirit that I think we really feel you can see at Microsoft today.
5:46 Speaker 02 Absolutely, it has changed. But what I want to get to is that what did you learn from that period? See, most of it was Microsoft versus all of tech. That was sort of the, Microsoft was this big, powerful company, attacking Netscape, attacking various companies. And what happened in the wake of that was all the creation of all these companies, Googles, the Ubers, everybody came. And it wasn't necessarily a direct line. You couldn't draw a direct line. But tech underwent another period of renovation, essentially, during that time. And Microsoft was seen as a very powerful player, very frightened, people were very frightened of it, and then it wasn't. Tell me, what did you all learn there to how to behave? Because a lot of people are worried about this current period of regulation, which we'll get into in a second.
6:29 Speaker 03 We learned a lot of things, but there's one in particular that always stands out to me. We had to look at ourselves in the mirror and see not what we wanted to see, but what other people saw in us. We had to accept a higher level of responsibility. We had to appreciate the concerns that other people had. I think we had to instill in ourselves a commitment, as we say in this book, look, when you create technology that changes the world, you have to accept some responsibility to address the world you have created.
7:03 Speaker 02 Right.
7:04 Speaker 03 That is what we learned in part.
7:07 Speaker 02 And how did the culture change then? How did you, because you were then becoming part of the leadership. How do you shift a culture like that? Because it was still run by Steve Ballmer, who was not, I would say, a shrinking violet of non-aggression.
7:18 Speaker 03 I think we've gone, I think every company goes through a series of cultural stages. You don't have one cultural evolution and then stop. There was first a definite cultural evolution in the 2000s, when Steve was the CEO, Bill Gates was the chairman, and it was called, "We have to learn to get along. We have to, you know, build some bridges. We have to make peace with governments. We're going to have to agree to some restraints, and that's going to require processes and controls." Then, in some ways, that set the foundation for what I think of as the cultural evolution of this decade, led by Satya.
7:55 Speaker 02 This is Satya Nadella, is where people, he's the new CEO. He's been there forever also.
7:59 Speaker 03 Yeah, and Satya became CEO in 2014. And in a very interesting way, I think Satya took the cultural evolution of the 2000s and said, "Let's sustain this level of responsibility. Let's be committed to trust with customers as a core principle for the company, but let's add to this what he describes as a growth mindset, you know, a real focus on A learn it all rather than know it all culture at Microsoft. And let's use that to unleash innovation, especially with more employees and perhaps most importantly, younger employees.
8:36 Speaker 02 And most people can agree, you kind of became what you were. Like you kind of defined what the company was rather than everything. Because you all were in everything. You were in MSN, you were in cable at one point. It was sort of a, just sort of aggression everywhere rather than, not sticking to your knitting particularly, but like doing what you guys do best. Microsoft does best.
8:54 Speaker 03 I think that's a really interesting point. There absolutely was a time in the late 90s when, as you point out, people looked at Microsoft. Is Microsoft going to be a bank? Is Microsoft going to be a cable company? And you could just go on and on and on. And we did eventually learn that it's really hard to do the big things well if you're trying to do everything at the same time. We're still a diversified tech company, I would hasten to point out. But I think people rightly think of us as being more enterprise focused as well as consumer, but more enterprise.
9:25 Speaker 02 Well, everything is adjacent to everything else. It feels more adjacent.
9:28 Speaker 03 Fair, a fair point. But I do think we do focus more on trying to do well a certain number of things.
9:34 Speaker 02 Absolutely. So when you're, the reason I want to go into this is because what, I want to sort of, you give sort of, as you look at the landscape, you're one of the leaders in policy and regulation. And certainly, Microsoft's been the company's subject to the most regulation so far. There hasn't, except for fines, which we'll get into in a second. Most tech companies had almost no regulation what to speak of, what, at all, I think. If at all, except in Europe and other places.
9:58 Speaker 03 I was going to say, Europe, Europe is the place where we've all been regulated.
10:01 Speaker 02 Right.
10:02 Speaker 03 And the United States is in some ways the country where we've been least regulated.
10:06 Speaker 02 Or at all. I can't even think of a regulation at this point. Just regular laws, just.
10:10 Speaker 03 Regular laws. I mean, you certainly have issues of spectrum and the like that impact our industry, but they. One of the interesting things about digital technology is it is arguably the technology that has gone the longest period of time without regulation in the history of almost any technology that has truly changed the world.
10:30 Speaker 02 Powerful and being a powerful industry because if you think about it, Wall Street, everything has a regulation, almost every manufacturing, they all have like some level of regulation. So let's set the table right now for where we are from your perspective. What prompted you to write the book itself? It's called Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of a Digital Age. Explain that headline for people who have not read it yet.
10:52 Speaker 03 The, any tool can be a weapon. As we point out in the book, a broom can be used to sweep a floor or hit somebody over the head.
10:58 Speaker 02 Do you often hit people on the head with a broom?
11:00 Speaker 03 I don't, but hopefully most people don't.
11:03 Speaker 02 Fire, let's go for fire.
11:04 Speaker 03 But it can be.
11:05 Speaker 02 Fire, you warm the house or burn it down.
11:07 Speaker 03 Yeah, basically you name it. Tools can be used as weapons.
11:11 Speaker 02 Knives.
11:12 Speaker 03 Think about digital technology, it's an incredible tool. I mean, I like to say it will, it will help the world cure cancer. We need it to help address our environmental challenges. But it has been weaponized. It has been weaponized by other governments. We see cyber attacks, we see disinformation campaigns, we see issues around privacy, we see the potentially unintended consequences as we move quickly to artificial intelligence. Think about technologies like facial recognition. Think about just the gaps that are created when some people have access to broadband and skills and other people do not. So in short, we're at a critical inflection point, as we argue in the book, where technology
11:54 Speaker 03 is creating both opportunity and huge challenges. And as an industry, we need to acknowledge these challenges, we need to help address them, just as Microsoft had to go through a cultural change as a company 20 years ago. We believe the tech sector needs to go through a cultural change over the next decade to find a way to keep moving fast, to innovate, but to do it with guardrails that will protect the public interest.
12:21 Speaker 02 Right. So let's talk about these tools and weapons. When it was created, most people had this hopeful idea around technology, that it would be the panacea for all, our problems would bring us together and things like that. Sort of do a landscape of where the years have gone from your perspective.
12:39 Speaker 03 Well, I think of the 2000s as sort of this transition to the internet era. That's when we saw search explode. It's when we saw the advent of touch-based computing and mobile explode. That is what further enabled social media to explode. And I think especially mobile basically was a huge step in making computing ubiquitous in all of our lives. Now, let's look at this decade. I think the first transition point this decade was 2013 because that's the year when Edward Snowden shared a number of secrets with the world. And it did a number of things.
13:22 Speaker 03 First, it opened people's eyes to how much data there was about themselves and how that could be accessed and used by governments. It created a bit of a split between the tech sector and the government, including the Obama White House, with whom the tech sector had a very friendly relationship. But interestingly enough, what we also saw was this continuing collection of more and more data. And then I think we hit the next real inflection point in 2018, and it was Cambridge Analytica. And in effect, the questions that had been asked about the government five years earlier were now being put forward against tech companies themselves.
14:03 Speaker 03 And we're now grappling with this wide array of issues, and the halo is gone.
14:09 Speaker 02 Right. So I think I'm glad you mentioned Snowden because a lot of people forget that because I think that's where the relationship between tech and government, which had been cooperative, you know, you all have a certain level of cooperation, really fell apart because of revelations, the amount of spying, the backdoors and everything else. What should have happened then? Because it seems as if it was handled badly in terms of, or was there going to be an irreparable damage to the relationship once tech understood how much the government was spying on tech?
14:40 Speaker 03 Well, the first thing I would say is... It is actually unnatural to have an extraordinarily close relationship that is entirely friendly.
14:52 Speaker 02 Right.
14:53 Speaker 03 Between any, yeah, yeah, but between any major industry and a government in a democratic country. There is usually a healthy tension that involves the government's interest in wanting the industry to succeed.
15:07 Speaker 02 Right.
15:07 Speaker 03 But also wanting the industry to succeed in a way that ensures that, in effect, no industry or technology is above the law. Just as no person is supposed to be above the law. So I don't necessarily look at what happened in the years that followed 2013 as necessarily the wrong path. I actually think a different question is more interesting. Why did it take so long for regulators, leaders, the public, to start asking questions about things like privacy?
15:39 Speaker 02 Right.
15:39 Speaker 03 Because I think those were predictable.
15:41 Speaker 02 Well, Scott McNally said it. I just interviewed him about that because it was the anniversary of that saying, you have no privacy, get used to it.
15:48 Speaker 03 Yeah, and that was a prevailing view in the industry, that privacy was dead, get over it. But to me, one of the interesting stories we share in the book is the White House meeting in December of 2013. Number of tech leaders were there. We were pushing the Obama White House, we were pushing President Obama to do more, to put checks and balances on the NSA. And there was a point in this meeting when he looked at us and said, I have a suspicion the guns will turn. Your companies collectively have far more information about people than the government itself.
16:23 Speaker 02 Right.
16:23 Speaker 03 And I always thought that privacy would be quiet until the day it became loud. That there would become a day when, in effect, we might face what I've referred to, what we talk about in the book, as the equivalent of Three Mile Island.
16:40 Speaker 02 Right.
16:40 Speaker 03 Three Mile Island changed the face of the nuclear power sector in a day, in 1979. And I think Cambridge Analytica did the same thing. It took until 2018. But I frankly always thought that day was going to come.
16:55 Speaker 02 There had been a number of incursions. The Sony, I would think the Sony, the New North Korea hacking into Sony. There was all kinds of different things. Well, that brought into mind hacking versus privacy. But the fact that so much data was available, people's emails, things like that. And then the same was the case of the hacking of Hillary Clinton's emails.
17:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, interestingly, you have this confluence of events between 2015 and 2018. In 2015, the Sony hack showed that a foreign government could bring-
17:25 Speaker 02 Or was doing it.
17:26 Speaker 03 Yeah, it could bring a company to its knees through a cyber attack. 2017 showed that wannacry and not petya, that foreign governments could attack the world, could attack a country like Ukraine. We had these mounting concerns around issues like privacy. We saw it flaring up between the European Union and the United States. And ultimately, we reached, I think, a tipping point where the concerns that people are asking finally reached a point where somebody gave it a name. The Economist called it techlash.
17:58 Speaker 02 Techlash, right.
17:59 Speaker 03 And that's what we've been talking about ever since.
18:01 Speaker 02 Why do you imagine it took so long? Why do you think these incidents, because these are all major incidents. I mean, I wrote about all of them. And people seem concerned, but also that's the price of technology. And the tech industry seemed relatively unconcerned, I would say.
18:15 Speaker 03 I think one of the lessons that one learns, we learned it at Microsoft, I think perhaps we're learning it as an industry, whenever things are going well, it's pretty easy to think that they will always keep going well. And let's face it, our industry prospered and did great things for the world, often with the explicit slogan that the best way to develop technology was to move fast and break things.
18:44 Speaker 02 Break things.
18:45 Speaker 03 Well, once-
18:46 Speaker 02 Facebook, that's just Facebook.
18:48 Speaker 03 I think that as an entire industry-
18:50 Speaker 02 That's how they think.
18:51 Speaker 03 Well, we all-
18:52 Speaker 02 Well, they made posters.
18:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, well, some people are better at posters than others.
18:56 Speaker 02 You have posters at Microsoft, too.
18:58 Speaker 03 They're not, they're not as good.
19:00 Speaker 02 Yeah.
19:01 Speaker 03 But- Yeah, the reality is it's been important to move fast. And we should celebrate the spirit of innovation that enabled the industry to move fast. But there comes a time when you realize, you know what? We shouldn't go faster than the speed of thought.
19:17 Speaker 02 Right, right.
19:18 Speaker 03 We need to think about what is happening. And that's part of the message in this book. Let's look around and see what's happening.
19:23 Speaker 02 Right, I think it's an important one. And you're one of the few people saying that, which is kind of interesting. We'll get into that in the next section. But one of the things to finish up this one is that idea of move fast and break things. When you heard it for the, when I saw it for the first time, I'm like, break? Is that the word you, I said it to, I was at Facebook and I said, is that the word you, I got the move fast part, but is break what you actually want to say? Not disrupt or change or whatever?
19:48 Speaker 03 Well, I think if you want to broaden it a little bit, I do think it's fair to say that there have been many times in many parts of our industry where disruption has been considered an end in and of itself. And I personally think that one should step back and even think about that a little more broadly. Certainly if there is a single vision or principle that Satya has articulated at Microsoft since, you know, his first year as CEO, it's that there are certain values that are timeless. There are actually certain values that are more important than the development of technology. And we need technology to serve these values.
20:27 Speaker 03 We shouldn't think that disrupting everything is actually a good goal in and of itself.
20:34 Speaker 02 Unless you understand the consequences. And we'll talk about that when we get back. We're here with Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft and co-author of Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of the Digital Age. We're going to take a quick break now, and we'll be back after this.
21:15 Speaker 04 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
21:19 Speaker 04 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
21:45 Speaker 02 We're here with Brad Smith. He's the president of Microsoft and he's a co-author of a book called Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of the Digital Age. This is something Brad has been talking about a lot. This has been a topic which not many people were listening to early on, for sure. I have been banging at the drum, you have some others. So Cambridge Analytica, why do you think Cambridge Analytica did that? Why do you think that was the moment? Because people at Facebook still to this day, I was there the other day, and they're like, it wasn't that big a deal. And I'm like, oh, God.
22:14 Speaker 03 I think it's a great, I think it's a great question, Kara. When I try to think about it, everything in life is a big deal and not a big deal at some, at the same time. And certain things take off.
22:27 Speaker 02 Right.
22:27 Speaker 03 And when they do, you look back and you ask, why is that the thing that took off? I think the reason that Cambridge Analytica took off is because fundamentally it was about the use of people's data in a political campaign to support a candidate for president, Donald Trump, who many people were not prepared to support.
22:48 Speaker 02 Right.
22:48 Speaker 03 And so when they learned that information that they were sharing, including about their friends and the like, was being used for a political campaign in this way, they got upset. And because it was about politics, Congress got upset.
23:05 Speaker 02 Right.
23:06 Speaker 03 And so you had this making for a bit of a tinderbox on a particular privacy issue that was different from what we'd seen in the past.
23:15 Speaker 02 Privacy with politics, with the Russians, with...
23:19 Speaker 02 All kinds of things.
23:20 Speaker 03 It's a pretty.
23:21 Speaker 02 A lot of scandal.
23:22 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, it's a pretty powerful stew if you think about it that way. And so at one level, you know, one can debate forever. What impact did it actually have on anything? The reality is it doesn't necessarily matter because what does matter is how people thought about it. It was as if a light bulb had been turned on and people looked around and they saw the room and they said, wow, look at all this data. Look at how it can be used. We should be paying more attention to what this means for our privacy.
23:54 Speaker 02 So one of the things that I think a lot of people have been talking about is the focus had been on Facebook and Google essentially, which are two companies that have most of the data. You know, Microsoft doesn't traffic in as much data for sure and neither does Apple and neither do lots of companies. I mean, they had, they use data and it's certainly important, but it was focused on just two companies who did this. When you're thinking about these things, what do you think, because you're all up in Seattle, Amazon's in Seattle, see, Amazon has a lot of information on people, has yet to have a very big privacy scandal yet, but you know, pending, like as with all of them. People think when you think of the tech launch that it's one tech industry, but it's just not. And there's different levels of tech, like and who's involved and who's responsible, but you all get glommed together.
24:37 Speaker 02 So how do you organize an industry where certain players are causing most of the mess and the others have to live with it?
24:44 Speaker 03 I really think about two things. The first is there's definitely differences between companies. Some have more data and some have more consumer data than others. Some have business models that really encourage more use of that data for monetization and advertising and others less so. But there's a big but. I like to remind people, when the United States Congress passed banking laws in the 1930s to regulate the nation's banks, they did not create an exception for the banks they liked.
25:17 Speaker 02 Right.
25:18 Speaker 03 They applied to all the banks.
25:20 Speaker 02 Right.
25:20 Speaker 03 And I think that we across the tech sector actually would serve ourselves well.
25:28 Speaker 03 To focus on how we can solve problems, even if we don't feel we helped cause them. And I worry that across the industry, there are too many days when people say, this is somebody else's problem, I didn't create it, I don't have any responsibility to help solve it.
25:47 Speaker 02 That said, I mean, I can't imagine if a newspaper was doing a crappy job, I wouldn't be like, those people are ruining it for the rest of us, kind of thing. Is that an attitude that you think is pervasive around tech?
25:58 Speaker 03 I think that there is an attitude in tech sometimes that people say, you know what, I don't want to go work on that because I don't want to stand next to that other company, they're in the firing line, they've got a virus, so to speak, politically. If I stand next to them, I'm going to do something worse than catch a cold.
26:19 Speaker 02 Right.
26:20 Speaker 03 I think that's a mistake. I think one of the most interesting examples of, in my view, a company doing the right thing, as we describe in this book, was in the wake of the Christchurch terrorist attack. Jacinda Ardern, the Prime Minister of New Zealand, got on the phone, made calls. I had had one of the first, well, actually the first meeting with her because I coincidentally was in New Zealand's capital shortly after the attack. But she asked people to help. Google, Facebook, Twitter, all said yes. I think they felt, understandably, logically, that they needed to be involved, given that their platforms were used by the Christchurch terrorists.
27:01 Speaker 02 This is to broadcast for people, and they broadcast a lot of the attack on these, and these platforms are very slow to get them down. They say fast, but I, most people think it was slow.
27:10 Speaker 03 Yeah. The company we should applaud is Amazon. Because Jeff Bezos took the call, Amazon decided to get involved. They could have said, you know what, we didn't solve, we didn't contribute to this problem, our services weren't used, we're not going to show up, we're not going to help. We at Microsoft, obviously, were involved from the very first day, but we need a bit more of that kind of civic spirit, and I'd love to see more companies doing that.
27:36 Speaker 02 So why isn't it there? And then I want to get into the individual problems, from inequality to social media to disinformation in a second, but how do you get that to happen? How do you get, because my experience with tech is they can't decide on lunch, essentially. Like, there's a lot of issues that they come together every now and again, but it's rather rare, and I know it's onerous, from what I can hear, you know, from people dealing with it, like, having agreement on anything.
28:01 Speaker 03 I think that's a fair comment, it's an accurate observation, and I think it is a reflection of our need to build a more civic spirit across the industry. It's also a reflection of the need for companies, perhaps especially large companies, to develop the capacity to make decisions. Because whenever you get into these questions of, you know, should we or should we not do this, you really set the stage for what can be endless debates. And unless you have the capacity to be decisive, you just have endless debates, which results in inaction, and, in effect, the answer is no, whether people intended it to be or not.
28:42 Speaker 03 And I, I think there's a muscle that the industry needs to develop, as well as a culture.
28:48 Speaker 02 And is it because it's young, or because it's...
28:51 Speaker 03 I think it is a reflection of the industry's youth, which is sort of an interesting thing to say in and of itself.
28:58 Speaker 02 You're not so young anymore, though, right?
29:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah, I mean, you know, Microsoft's looking to our 50th anniversary in just a few years, but you have other companies, obviously, that are both extremely successful and much younger. I think the real message for all of us is, you know what, you have to grow up faster than maybe you used to.
29:19 Speaker 02 All right, so let's talk about, because I think the main problem coming is regulation, and how it's going to be written, and how it's going, how the industry's going, would you... Is that wrong?
29:30 Speaker 03 I think one should hesitate to use the word problem. I would wholeheartedly agree that it is going to be a principal phenomenon. And I think this is a challenge for the industry. It is an opportunity. And the real question we should ask is, what are the problems that laws and regulations need to help us solve? It won't be, in my view, one regulation that is so sweeping that it covers every issue. So, you know, what we really strive to do in the book, you see it in the table of contents, is let's look at the different problems and let's talk about some potential solutions.
30:07 Speaker 02 So, let's go through some. One that I obviously have spent a lot of time on recently is surveillance, facial recognition. I'll put facial recognition, sensors, cameras, everything else. Where are we on that right now, from your perspective?
30:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, having been in this industry for a quarter of a century, I think the facial recognition issue is one of the most unusual issues we have ever seen. We at Microsoft, literally just 16 months ago, put out a blog that said, "This is technology that is subject to abuse. It's going to need to be regulated." And there were people in Silicon Valley who looked at us and said, "What are you talking about? Why are you saying this?" And here we are, and it is exploding around the world. We're sitting here today in a city, San Francisco, that has banned its use for the public. And the issue is changing on almost a monthly basis.
31:04 Speaker 02 So, what do you imagine the regulation needs to be? Because I'm interviewing the guy, the people who do police cameras. They don't think it's ready for primetime. The only people who think it's ready for primetime are some of the creators of it. I had Andy Jassy from Microsoft, which makes recognition.
31:17 Speaker 03 From Amazon, but yes.
31:19 Speaker 02 Yes, Amazon, right. And he was talking about, like, "We don't have responsibility for if people misuse it." And I was like, "Well, you do. But, okay, sure. That's an interesting attitude, but it's not going to hold for very long." Where do you imagine that regulation is going here in the United States and globally?
31:36 Speaker 03 I think we are going to need and we are going to see new laws that will address the risk of bias and discrimination.
31:45 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
31:45 Speaker 03 And I think there's particular steps that a good regulation can take to do that. I think we are going to see laws that address commercial privacy. In other words, if we go into a shopping mall and our face is being identified and our images are being captured, I think we're going to see laws that give us as consumers some control over that kind of data. And I think perhaps most importantly, we need and will see laws that address the use of facial recognition by public authorities, especially law enforcement.
32:18 Speaker 02 Police.
32:19 Speaker 03 Yes. So as to ensure that we don't have people arrested or taken downtown in the back of a police car for an incorrect identification, or worse, ongoing or even mass surveillance. So I think we're going to see all of these things addressed, and I think we need governments to step forward. But I actually wholeheartedly agree with what you also said. This is not an issue where a tech company should be permitted to say, we may create this technology, but we only have one responsibility, and that's to follow some law when some government passes it somewhere. If we want to be an industry that is respected by the public for doing more than selling
33:03 Speaker 03 whatever we can create to anybody who is prepared to buy it, then we darn well better say, we have some principles we're going to apply to ourselves, even when the law is not yet in place.
33:15 Speaker 02 Which doesn't seem to be the case. Is there a country that's more stringent on these laws than others? Or is it state by state here in the United States?
33:24 Speaker 03 Well, interestingly, yeah, we're seeing two phenomenons. I mean, one is we're seeing at the national level, some governments start to move faster. And I don't think people will be surprised to hear that that is likely to be in Europe, where already they have more privacy protections because of the nature of European law. But the other phenomenon that is interesting, that should actually speak to any company that wants to be in the facial recognition business, is we're starting to see court decisions here in the United States. Facebook... Lost at least a preliminary decision based on Illinois law that could go quite far in actually making it difficult to develop and use facial recognition even for very beneficial
34:07 Speaker 03 purposes. I think it's the classic case of if you want good things to prosper, you better be thoughtful and responsible because if you're not, you're going to find that people are going to end up throwing out the baby and the bathwater.
34:20 Speaker 02 The whole thing. Where are the beneficial uses of facial recognition?
34:23 Speaker 03 Well, let me share with you one thing that I was very-
34:26 Speaker 02 Getting on a plane faster, I'm not sure.
34:28 Speaker 03 No, well, I was fascinated. I was in Brazil three months ago. And there is a nonprofit organization that works to find missing children and missing adults who are family members. And in some cases, they are missing adults that have mental health issues. They might be separated from their families. They're homeless. The family, in a lawful way, can provide photographs of their loved one.
34:58 Speaker 02 Right.
34:59 Speaker 03 And then if somebody ends up in a hospital emergency room or arrested by the police, they can take a photo in real time and run it against the database. And a probability appears of whether this is the person.
35:14 Speaker 02 Okay, there's one.
35:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, there's one. And I'll say it is one that has reunited missing people. Now, I'll give you another one. There is an effort in Washington DC under the auspices of the National Institutes of Health that has realized that there is a certain genetic syndrome that tends to manifest itself more among people from Asia, Latin America, and Africa, where there are certain facial characteristics-
35:43 Speaker 02 Ticks.
35:43 Speaker 03 Yeah, that then are related to more serious health hazards, including kidney damage and the like. And by using this kind of technology physicians are able to augment their natural abilities with this kind of technology tool.
36:01 Speaker 02 For that limited use.
36:02 Speaker 03 Yes, for that limited use.
36:04 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think the problem is it won't be for that limited use. It'll be for, you know, you'll sit, you'll do it forgetting, I mean, years ago I did Clear and I regret it, but it's too late, right? What can I do? It's out of the bag essentially.
36:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:16 Speaker 02 I like Clear too, by the way. This is the way to get on planes faster.
36:20 Speaker 03 But if we step back and just think about the evolution of technology, I think facial recognition is an incredible illustration of the degree to which we should want people to have the opportunity to be creative, to be innovative, to, you know, if, if you asked about any technology two years into its development, is that the only thing it will ever do? You would have, you know, killed the smartphone five years before the iPhone was invented.
36:48 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
36:49 Speaker 03 You know, so we, we don't want to stifle technology, at least in my view, but we've got to have strong guardrails, especially for this technology. And we should be prepared to say that there are some uses that we should never permit and there are some uses that we should not allow until the technology is more mature than it is today.
37:08 Speaker 02 All right. Related to surveillance is privacy, the idea of privacy. I mean, because that's one, a part of privacy. It seems as if it's all over the map across the world, but Europe is obviously more stringent. The United States has privacy bills all over the place. There's one coming online in California. Where do you imagine that ending up? Is whoever has the strongest global one will be the winner here?
37:33 Speaker 03 Well, I think there's an interesting aspect of the story around privacy, which we really sought to bring to life in our book. And in a sense, the chapter on privacy is the story of, as we describe it, the two unlikely individuals who have most influenced privacy protection in the United States. One, an Austrian student named Max Schrems, who persuaded the European Court of Justice to strike down a safe harbor and push the US government to strengthen privacy protection. And the other, a San Francisco-based real estate developer, Alastair McTaggart. And there's an interesting lesson in both of their stories.
38:14 Speaker 03 One is the opportunity for the European Union to use its influence, as it did with the United States, to strengthen privacy around the world. And then the other, and I think it's the really interesting lesson from Alistair McTaggart's experience, is to use-
38:33 Speaker 02 Explain what-
38:34 Speaker 03 Basically, what Alistair did, and I just, you know, you won't find perhaps everybody in the tech sector applauding what he did, but I think it is absolutely worthy of applause. He said, "We need some laws in this country that better protect privacy. We have gridlock at the national level." He looked at the situation in Sacramento. He said, "We're going to have gridlock there, but California, as some other Western states, has this thing called a ballot initiative." So he used his own money to collect more than twice the number of signatures needed to put a strong privacy initiative on the ballot. It was going to go before the public.
39:16 Speaker 03 Once it was on the ballot, it brought people to the negotiating table, and we saw California adopt a privacy law.
39:23 Speaker 02 That goes into force in 2020.
39:25 Speaker 03 Exactly.
39:26 Speaker 02 Will that be the de facto national privacy standard?
39:29 Speaker 03 Because one in every eight Americans lives in California. If California is the only state that enacts a privacy law, I do believe it will be-
39:40 Speaker 02 There's about 12 others, right?
39:42 Speaker 03 There are some others. I think ultimately, we are a country that needs a national privacy law. I gave a speech in 2005-
39:50 Speaker 02 You did.
39:51 Speaker 03 -in Washington, DC, calling for a national privacy law, and everybody-
39:54 Speaker 02 They're moving fast, Brad.
39:55 Speaker 03 Yeah, they, I was clearly-
39:56 Speaker 02 There's nothing.
39:57 Speaker 03 I was very influential, Kara, can't you tell?
39:59 Speaker 02 They have some congressperson who doesn't know anything about it. It's like, she's getting to it, like-
40:04 Speaker 03 It will come, but I do, but I do-
40:06 Speaker 02 Really?
40:07 Speaker 03 I think in the 2020s.
40:07 Speaker 02 When?
40:09 Speaker 02 Okay.
40:10 Speaker 03 It's not going to come this year.
40:12 Speaker 02 No.
40:12 Speaker 03 But I think that your point is nonetheless on the mark. California is large enough to create a national standard in the United States.
40:21 Speaker 02 It seems like it could do on a lot of like emissions and everything else. All right, let's get to one more thing in this section. So privacy and consumer protection of their data. That will be in the same privacy bill, correct?
40:34 Speaker 03 Absolutely.
40:35 Speaker 02 Like hacking of their data and things like that.
40:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, the interesting thing about privacy is it's actually a two-sided issue, so to speak. One side of it is the protection of consumer data. That's what people like Alistair McTaggart have focused on. The other is the protection of what you would call citizen data. That's the government surveillance side of the coin. And that is this issue that keeps evolving. We share some of the big decisions that have been made, not just by governments, but in the tech sector over the last five years, the debates between government and tech. But these two things are going to continue to evolve, I think, in a very robust and at times even dramatic way over the next five years.
41:20 Speaker 02 So do you predict a national privacy bill in the next five years? I'll hold you to it.
41:24 Speaker 03 I will predict a national privacy bill in the next five years. And I'll be back here in four years and 364 days.
41:32 Speaker 02 We'll see, we'll see. If Mitch McConnell's still there, I wouldn't bank on it. Anyway, we're here with Brad Smith, the president of Microsoft and the co-author of Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of a Digital Age. We're going to take a quick break now, but when we're back, we'll talk more about this book, which he co-wrote with Carol Ann Brown.
42:16 Speaker 04 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
42:20 Speaker 04 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
42:46 Speaker 02 We're here with Brad Smith. He's the president of Microsoft and also a big thinker on regulatory and other public policy issues for the tech industry. His new book is called Tools and Weapons: The Promise and Peril of a Digital Age. He co-wrote it with Carol Ann Brown. Let's move on to social media and protections of democracy. They all sort of fall into the same thing. Obviously, the big bit of information has been about what social media does. One, disinformation. Two, addiction. Three, fake news and things like that. They're all sort of wrapped up into one unpleasant pile of crap. So that's how I put it in my legal point of view. How do you look at what's going to happen in this area?
43:30 Speaker 02 Because we just did a big, long thing on Section 230 and protections, and that's probably not going to, this gives immunity, broad immunity to lots of publishers. Talk a little bit about where we are right now.
43:43 Speaker 03 I think 2019 has been an inflection point year for this issue. As you point out, you know, Section 230 was created in the 1990s. The idea was to give broad immunity to interactive computer services. The notion was the Internet was young, it needed to grow up.
44:02 Speaker 02 Couldn't be sued out of existence.
44:03 Speaker 03 Exactly, yeah. And what we've seen in 2019 is two factors or forces really come together. One is concern about nation-state disinformation campaigns, principally Russian campaigns, now well documented, starting in 2016 in the United States. But then we saw a second development emerge as well. It was the Christchurch terrorist attack. And the use of, in that case, a terrorist Use social media and the internet as a stage. And these are two very different things, but they've reinforced concerns among governments
44:44 Speaker 03 to impose more responsibilities on tech companies. And I should hasten to add, it's easy to think about YouTube and Facebook and Twitter, but a company like Microsoft has LinkedIn, we have services like Xbox Live. This is broader than those.
45:00 Speaker 02 Yes, they're more minor.
45:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, clearly.
45:03 Speaker 02 I don't think a terrorist is going to be doing a LinkedIn broadcast for some reason.
45:07 Speaker 03 We would clearly hope not.
45:09 Speaker 02 No.
45:10 Speaker 03 But what we saw, and this is the really interesting and important point, is all of a sudden, things changed. The Christchurch attack was on March 15th. Jacinda Ardern, the Prime Minister of New Zealand, within 10 days said, "We need tech companies to take a different approach." Within three weeks after that, the Australian government passed a new law that imposes criminal penalties, not just fines, but prison sentences on tech executives if they don't expeditiously remove violent terrorist or extremist content. Two weeks after that, we saw the British government introduce a new proposal.
45:52 Speaker 03 We've seen the French and German governments use this as an opportunity to advance their proposals as well. If you almost envision a map of the world, it's easy in the United States to think that the United States itself is the center of the world, we have this statute. It hasn't changed yet. Yeah, it hasn't changed yet. But if you envision the world that starts with New Zealand to Australia, up to the United Kingdom, France and Germany, you fill in Canada, where Prime Minister Trudeau has raised more issues. I would say the law is changing very quickly. And even if Section 230 itself does not change, all of us in the tech sector are going to
46:37 Speaker 03 need to because of these other countries. I actually believe that we are seeing a wave, and the wave is going to come back to the shores of the United States. We actually probably will see some change in this country as well, but the US is-
46:51 Speaker 02 It's been chipped away with around sex trafficking, but it still hasn't had a full frontal attack. I mean, Josh Hawley is the first one that's, but that's over conservative speech, too.
47:01 Speaker 03 It's, the US will be a late mover, not a first mover, which is actually, I think, unfortunate because it means that people in the US government are less influential in the global conversation.
47:15 Speaker 02 Will be acted upon.
47:16 Speaker 03 And the real question that we should be asking ourselves, in my view, in the tech sector, the question that we address in this book, is not whether we want to continue to live in the past because I think the past is now over. The real question we should be asking ourselves is, what is the right future? And I would argue, it needs to be a future that preserves fundamental benefits in Section 230. It's what makes the social media model possible, but there are some new responsibilities, and we need to take them on, and we would be better served to develop and advance our own ideas.
47:54 Speaker 02 So how do we do that? Because I think whenever I mention it to people, YouTube, they just turn white because they feel like their businesses would be sued out of existence, and they're probably right in many ways.
48:05 Speaker 03 I think that if-
48:06 Speaker 02 It can't be touched, is their feeling. And I'm like, it's gonna be touched. There's a lot of touching about to happen.
48:11 Speaker 03 Yeah, looking at the world globally, it's being touched all over the place. I think what one has to move towards is a conversation that says, look, no one should want this abolished. If it were abolished tomorrow, then there are just fundamental technological services that would be put at great risk.
48:33 Speaker 02 Right.
48:34 Speaker 03 So if you want to avoid that result, put a little bit of thought into what's the right way to touch it in a balanced and thoughtful way. What is a good model for the next 20 years?
48:47 Speaker 02 What are you, from your perspective, what is that?
48:49 Speaker 03 I think it is to identify certain areas where certain responsibilities can be assumed. And indeed, because of the events in Christchurch and what's called the Christchurch Call, you know, there are certain responsibilities that tech companies are stepping up to. I do think was, as we think about all these issues around fake news and the like, we should all rec-
49:12 Speaker 02 Which is related.
49:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, they are. But we should recognize, you can't impose on a tech company, because you can't impose on anybody, the responsibility to be the ultimate arbiter of what news is true and what news is false. But you can start to impose some responsibilities to identify who is speaking. You know, if content is being posted, what country is it coming from?
49:36 Speaker 02 Yeah.
49:37 Speaker 03 If content is spreading, is it a human who is doing the speaking, or is it a bot? If you think about the nature of political advertising in the United States, there's a really interesting analogy, in my view. We point to it in the book. We don't try to say, oh, this politician can say this in an ad or not. But you always do know, at the end of the day-
49:59 Speaker 02 Where it's coming from.
50:00 Speaker 03 Yeah, who is speaking. Let the public know who is speaking.
50:02 Speaker 02 So you don't feel like tech companies should have any role in monitoring hate speech or getting rid of people? Because it's a, it make, it goes down, or the health of the conversation. Right now, they're all talking about these healthy conversations, which I think it's impossible. It's an imposs- you can't have healthy, you can have some healthy conversations on it, but it tends towards an unhealthy conversation.
50:23 Speaker 03 I think that we live in a world where the American conception of the First Amendment and free expression is actually at one end of the political spectrum. And, you know, we are having to adapt and adjust.
50:40 Speaker 03 To certain standards from other countries that address certain aspects of hate speech. But I also agree, it's a very delicate balance. It is a balance where there are human rights interests that are important to advance free expression. But, you know, it's a big world. And, you know, we do have to work, especially with other democratic governments across Europe and elsewhere, about how to address this.
51:04 Speaker 02 Is it an impossible thing? I was just, you know, there was, there's always, every week, there's something else. And recently, there was one where a lot of people who push free speech then don't like it when they're insulted. And it's like, oh, you can't call a manager to fix it. Like, you can't, there's no fixing any of it. Like, people can say what they want. And then people become indignant when they themselves are subject to being attacked.
51:25 Speaker 03 I think we need to move from a situation where we say we can't do anything because it's so difficult to figure out what to do.
51:34 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
51:35 Speaker 03 To a conversation where we identify at least some smart things that can be done, but recognize the limits on them, and recognize the importance of this balance. There've been columnists at the New York Times that I think have said pretty persuasively, "A world where tech companies absolve themselves of all responsibility in the name of free expression is not actually creating the world, at least the world of technology, we want."
52:04 Speaker 02 That's me, but go ahead.
52:05 Speaker 03 Yeah, and others, yeah.
52:08 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah, at the same time. Do we want them making decisions?
52:11 Speaker 03 Exactly.
52:12 Speaker 02 Right.
52:13 Speaker 03 Exactly.
52:14 Speaker 02 Well, maybe the, my feeling is the architecture is thus, that it will only degenerate into crappy discussions.
52:20 Speaker 03 Well, that's one of the reasons, I think, we're starting to see governments seeking to understand better.
52:26 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
52:27 Speaker 03 How algorithms work.
52:29 Speaker 02 Right.
52:30 Speaker 03 In promoting certain kinds of conversations.
52:32 Speaker 02 And related to hate speech and others is the press from conservative side, you know, like Senator Hawley and others, that there needs to be, and President Trump, that we're looking into this, we're looking, I mean, he's not looking into anything, but that's besides the point, but the idea that it has to be even-handed, like a fairness doctrine.
52:52 Speaker 03 I think it's difficult to imagine how you import a fairness doctrine.
52:58 Speaker 02 Right.
52:59 Speaker 03 And at the same time, I think most of the people in the tech sector, at least at the leadership level, do strive for something that is not putting a thumb on the scale for one party or the other.
53:11 Speaker 02 Yeah. And I think- Nobody believes them. I agree with you. I think they are, but I think nobody believes them. And then, related to that, is the concept of whether these companies should be broken up. Now, all the Democratic candidates, I've noticed lately, suddenly Pete Buttigieg is saying things. Elizabeth Warren, obviously, is the best-known one of breaking them up for regulation. But all the Democrats have jumped on that particular bandwagon. Do you see breakup as, or will it be a combination of fines, which many people find inadequate? I find the recent YouTube one to be inadequate, the recent Facebook one to be inadequate. Is it a combination of things like fines and certain regulations, or is breakup inevitable?
53:50 Speaker 03 Well, I'm not one who believes that breakup is inevitable, nor am I an advocate for breaking up companies. And in fact, if you are forced to spend as much time studying the history of antitrust law as I was 20 years ago, what you really see is that breakups are talked about all the time and are almost never imposed. I think the real question should be, what problem do people want to solve? What is the best way to solve that problem? If one thinks it's an antitrust problem, there are a variety of antitrust solutions. Not potentially fines, for all the reasons you mentioned, but more other
54:31 Speaker 03 kinds of constraints that are imposed. But I think some of the problems that people worry about the most, in fact, may be problems that call for action outside the antitrust sphere. Or, we may see a third development, and in fact, I think it's fair to say, it is a development that is emerging. Historically, antitrust law was used to go after solely economic issues and economic harms. And now we're seeing a new school of antitrust thinking, which has no, let's look at the harms to democracy, let's look at the harms to privacy, let's think about the impact of data.
55:13 Speaker 02 Consumer harm.
55:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, and the current head of the antitrust division in the Justice Department has endorsed this view.
55:19 Speaker 02 Make and Delheim has said this.
55:20 Speaker 03 Exactly.
55:21 Speaker 02 Which I think is the direction a lot of people are going.
55:22 Speaker 03 I think that is probably an accurate observation and prediction.
55:26 Speaker 02 All right, so when you think of it that way, do you imagine that these companies will be broken up? You just don't know. Because like, here you have, you haven't had a new social media company since 2011, you haven't had a search engine since the beginning of time, beginning of search, there's one, there's just simply, I mean, I know you guys are trying real hard over Bing, but, sorry, they seem to have been, they seem to dominate. Is that the only, because a lot of people feel that there can't be innovation without, why bother going into several different sectors? E-commerce, another one.
56:00 Speaker 03 I'll again say, I just don't think it's likely that breakup is the remedy.
56:08 Speaker 02 That occurs.
56:09 Speaker 03 That typically is pursued, but we'll see antitrust cases move forward, we'll see sectoral regulations that are aimed at addressing specific parts of technology, I think we may see more of a focus on particular business models. Certainly, the advertising-based business model is increasingly in the crosshairs of regulators.
56:32 Speaker 02 There's two of those.
56:34 Speaker 03 Yeah, and we'll see more of that. Again, that's not a statement of advocacy, that's just the observation of somebody who's lived with these issues for a quarter of a century.
56:45 Speaker 02 Okay, let's finish up talking about rural broadband and sort of the talent gap of where people are, because I think those are together, is that there's talent everywhere, and I think it's just a question of opportunity, not a question of talent. But we remain stubbornly non-diverse as a tech community.
57:02 Speaker 02 Only because it's a question of opportunity, it seems like. There was a really good tweet yesterday of people jumping from jump to jump and it was and someone called it white guys funding each other, you know what I mean, like because it was like all like and then they patted themselves on the back. Talk about what we need to do to bring in rural broadband, take advantage of the talent across the country. Microsoft has been doing some of this, making some investments in this area. Finish up talking about where that's headed. And whether we need a government program to do this.
57:33 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, these are issues about which we have a lot of passion. I would say there are some big technology gaps in this country today, as well as in the world. The first gap is the rural gap. And we share the story of going to a particular county in eastern Washington state, the county that has the highest unemployment rate. And what you find is they're still living in the 1990s when it comes to the dial-up era. You see how difficult it is to attract jobs. You see the impact on culture. You actually see this interesting phenomenon where almost so much of the government data about rural communities is just inaccurate.
58:15 Speaker 03 And one argument we make in this book is that we need a national cause to bring broadband to every part of the country. We've done this, we did it with the telephone. Franklin Roosevelt did it with electricity. We need to do it in some ways with new technology. That's what we're focused on at Microsoft. We do need government funding for the right kind of targeted, public matching investments. And we should do it and say, we're going to close and eliminate this gap over the next five years. It can be done. And we highlight in the book the connection between that issue, which is a technology issue, and the politics of our day.
58:59 Speaker 03 We have a populist in the White House, in part because rural America feels that the government doesn't understand it. And we point out that in important respects, people in these communities are right. The government doesn't understand it. Then we have another gap. It's the skills gap.
59:17 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
59:17 Speaker 03 And it is, I think, very disconcerting, as we point out, that if you look at who has access, say, in high school to a computer science class, the people who have access to these new skills are more male, more white, more affluent, and more urban than the United States as a whole.
59:38 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
59:39 Speaker 03 So here is this fantastic skill that can propel people into greater prosperity, a brighter future, and, you know, it is not being made available equally. And that is a critical public policy issue. Let's face it, if the government does one thing almost entirely as a public matter, it's education.
1:00:03 Speaker 02 Right.
1:00:03 Speaker 03 And it is letting us down. So we need more there. So when you look at these two gaps and you see them together and then you connect it with all the issues that we...
1:00:13 Speaker 02 Opies, everything, yeah.
1:00:15 Speaker 03 Yeah, every single aspect of American society, you realize there, this is in part is a technology issue and a technology skills issue. And we in the tech sector and across the country more broadly, need to peel the layers of the onion and think about this technology dimension and think about, in part, what we as an industry can do to help solve it.
1:00:37 Speaker 02 Well, what are this, just finish up, what would be the biggest solution to do that? Because a lot have been tried, this whole Silicon Hall or I just think it's just, look, the good jobs are, they're not gonna, coal miners not gonna, most of them are not gonna become coders. They're just not. And some of these programs aren't very good. You know, a lot of it is locationally based. But what do you think the most important thing to do of all the things to try here?
1:01:00 Speaker 03 Well, I'll at least start with, let's eliminate the broadband gap.
1:01:04 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. Yes.
1:01:06 Speaker 03 You know, we've met young, promising African-American high school students in rural Virginia.
1:01:14 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
1:01:15 Speaker 03 But they can't excel in computer science because they can't access the Internet from home. And, you know, what we've pointed out is anytime you can move from a wired to a wireless technology, you just look at the history of technology, it spreads into rural areas much more rapidly. And yet, even here in 2019, we're seeing most of the presidential candidates that have broadband plans talking about only one thing, fiber optic cables.
1:01:45 Speaker 02 Right.
1:01:46 Speaker 03 The hardest and most expensive solution to a problem that can be solved much faster if we think about it with the benefit of some additional technology and, we would argue, a smarter way to spend public money and to think about what companies, it's what we're doing. I mean, we have this airband initiative. You know, we're now, we're committed to working with telecommunications partners to bring broadband to 3 million people by the year 2022. But even more than that, what we're really trying to do is build a market. So the market can take off and help close this gap.
1:02:21 Speaker 02 So broadband access.
1:02:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
1:02:24 Speaker 02 Training skills. How useful are those programs?
1:02:26 Speaker 03 I think, oh, I, I am a big believer in training skills. One of the stories we share is something that we've championed, Microsoft and Boeing in Washington State, together with the state government, the Opportunity Scholarship Program. And, you know, it's now enabling thousands of low-income, often minority, typically first-generation-to-go-to-college students to get a college degree in a high-demand STEM field. And the thing that gives me the most enthusiasm about it, I've chaired the board for this since it was created in 2011, is that our studies are showing that five years after
1:03:08 Speaker 03 graduation, the average income of the students who have gone through this program is 50% higher than their entire family's income was when they started going to college. And, you know, just think about our country. We so often worry with great justification, in my view, that
1:03:29 Speaker 03 Economic mobility is dead.
1:03:31 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
1:03:31 Speaker 03 People can't rise up.
1:03:33 Speaker 02 Right.
1:03:33 Speaker 03 The way other generations did before. Here is an example, in my view, with the right investment, public-private partnership, business leadership, you can make a difference.
1:03:43 Speaker 02 I want to finish on, how much should the government be involved? In other countries, it's certainly, there's policy, like China, like, moving ahead of us because we don't have that anymore, that idea that the government is responsible for this.
1:03:56 Speaker 03 Well, that is the other equation, other part of the equation, that we describe in the book. The tech sector needs to do more, but we need governments to do more. We need governments to move faster, we need government to catch up with technology. We need not just government acting by itself, but we need a new era of multi-stakeholder efforts, where governments and businesses, tech companies and nonprofits, work together. And if you look at a problem like broadband, or you look at a problem like the skills gap, I think those are readily identifiable as issues where this is the right formula. But even when it comes to something like cybersecurity, when, if you want to protect
1:04:41 Speaker 03 cyberspace, which is often owned and operated by private companies, we need a new era where we're working together in new ways.
1:04:50 Speaker 02 Do you see that coming?
1:04:51 Speaker 03 I do.
1:04:52 Speaker 02 You do?
1:04:53 Speaker 03 I do. I'm realistic enough, as we say in the book, to recognize, we have huge headwinds. Starts with gridlock at home and nationalism around the world. But every day, we have opportunities to build coalitions of the willing. And that is what we're doing. You know, we've done it to address some of the cybersecurity threats. You know, we've done it to start to address, you know, some of these skills gap issues. You look at the different nonprofits that are playing such an important role in this space. We've done it now to start to make some progress around rural broadband. If we could just take the great energy and enthusiasm that is so clearly evident across the tech sector.
1:05:38 Speaker 03 And instead of saying, we're going to move fast and break things, we're going to work together and fix some things.
1:05:44 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
1:05:44 Speaker 03 We're not going to solve every problem in the world. You know, that would be naive. But there's a lot more good that we can do than what we're doing right now.
1:05:52 Speaker 02 I actually have one more quick question. What if all the upcoming technologies, which one are you most nervous about in terms of weapons? And which one are you most positive about will be a tool?
1:06:02 Speaker 03 I'm probably the most nervous about facial recognition.
1:06:05 Speaker 02 Okay.
1:06:06 Speaker 03 Because of its potential for abuse. And I'm probably the most optimistic about artificial intelligence more broadly, simply because of the impact it actually is starting to have in helping us solve some of the most fundamental societal challenges of our time.
1:06:23 Speaker 02 Clothing and health and disease and everywhere.
1:06:25 Speaker 03 Yes. Medicine, disaster relief, protection of human rights. I think about something like Microsoft seeing AI. My gosh. Give a person who is blind the ability to use the camera in their phone to identify what is in the world around them, you change a person's life.
1:06:47 Speaker 02 All right. Brad Smith, thank you so much for coming. We really appreciate it.
1:06:51 Speaker 03 Good. Thank you.
1:06:52 Speaker 02 Can't believe I'm saying Microsoft's good for the world. It's been a long journey for us, hasn't it been? But that's Frank Shaw laughing in the back. Anyway, thank you for coming on the show. You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Eric Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. Brad, where can people find you online?
1:07:11 Speaker 03 They can find me on Twitter at BradSMI, and they can find me at LinkedIn under the same name.
1:07:18 Speaker 02 Link it in. That's what my mother calls it. Link it in. I was like, it's not link it in.
1:07:22 Speaker 03 It's not the way we pronounce it, but if that helps people find it, that's okay.
1:07:25 Speaker 02 She's never having a job again in her life. Anyway, if you like this episode, we really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Brandon McFarland. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
1:07:58 Speaker 05 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall, the most incredible survival thriller of the year.
1:08:07 Speaker 05 In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home. Josh Drogba. Survivor, Survivor. Whale Fall, rated PG-13, maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Why workers need to be part of the conversation about UBI and artificial intelligence Next Recode Decode: The Wing CEO Audrey Gelman Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated