Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Mark Suster, managing partner, Upfront Ventures About this episode Upfront Ventures Managing Partner Mark Suster talks with Recode’s Kara Swisher about leading the oldest and largest venture capital firm in Los Angeles. He explains why he rejects the term “Silicon Beach,” preferring “LA Tech,” and what people miss when they think of Southern California as a less-techie place than Silicon Valley. Suster says the increasingly common overfunding of tech companies and overpaying of tech workers in the San Francisco area are discouraging innovation. He also discusses how the geography of entrepreneurship in SoCal is changing, why Upfront-backed smart doorbell maker Ring sold to Amazon, and what people get wrong about one of LA's sexiest tech companies, Snap.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 14,197 words · 2 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by Namely. When was the last time you checked your pay stub or picked benefits at work? Chances are, it wasn't easy. HR software has been clunky and hard to use ever since HR has been a thing. One technology company takes a different approach. Namely is the only all-in-one HR, payroll, and benefits software employees love to use. Ready to clock in? No problem. Need to write a performance review? You can do that. Want to schedule some vacation time? Namely makes it easy to do, even from your phone. Namely also uses social news feeds like Facebook where employees can share updates, celebrate birthdays, and give shout-outs for a job well done. Namely doesn't just make work easier, it actually makes it a little more fun, too. Over 1,000 companies use Namely every day.
0:43 Speaker 00 If you're in HR or run your business, it's time to see Namely in action. Get a free demo by visiting namely.com/decode. One more time, that's namely.com/decode. See how you can build a better workplace with Namely. Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You may know me as the new CEO of Cambridge Analytica, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Mark Suster, a managing partner at Upfront Ventures. He joined the venture capital firm in 2007, but before then founded two companies, Build Online and then Coral, which was acquired by Salesforce. Mark, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:25 Speaker 01 Thank you for having me, but the red chair looks black.
1:28 Speaker 00 I know, we have a red chair. We could bring it in for you.
1:30 Speaker 01 I would feel more comfortable if you had a red chair.
1:32 Speaker 00 Well, we'll try. Well, you can go sit in it later after we're done with the interview. He's here at our offices in San Francisco, but Mark is from Los Angeles where Upfront Ventures is. So, we want to talk about a wide range of things, including LA and everything else, and also your recent sale of Ring, which was one of your companies, to Amazon, which was a big deal. I have Ring at my house. Now, Amazon runs everything.
1:52 Speaker 01 Do you like it?
1:53 Speaker 00 I love it, but now I don't want to. I was trying to get Amazon and Google out of my house because they do everything, and now Amazon's.
1:59 Speaker 01 Well, the nice thing about Ring is that it is outside your house. The camera's facing out rather than in.
2:03 Speaker 00 I know.
2:04 Speaker 01 Well, it's an important point because it was important to Jamie that the camera was facing out.
2:08 Speaker 00 You know what? I love Ring. So, they've been a sponsor on this podcast, but I actually used the product before that. It's a great product. We'll talk about that in a little bit. But I want to talk about a whole bunch of things, including being in LA and things like that. So why don't we go over your history? I like to go through people's resume, essentially. So why don't you tell me a little bit about how you got started in the business? And then we'll get into LA and investing and where you think trends are going. Because you're pretty much the leading LA venture capitalist, right?
2:34 Speaker 01 Let me say this. You worded it that I'm from LA. I'm actually not from LA. I grew up in Northern California and I grew up a software developer. I started my career as a programmer.
2:44 Speaker 00 Yeah, so talk about that.
2:46 Speaker 01 I point that out because having a perspective of Silicon Valley, where I built one of my startups, sold one of my startups. My wife used to work at Google. Like, we really understand, I think, the culture here.
2:58 Speaker 00 Right.
2:58 Speaker 01 I've been in LA for 10 years.
3:00 Speaker 00 I don't mean to diminish LA.
3:01 Speaker 01 Oh, I know. I just, I want to, anyone listening, I want them to understand that I really, I view the lens of the world through having grown up in Northern California. I lived abroad for 11 years. I've worked in nine countries. I came back to the US, settled into Silicon Valley, and assumed that I was going to raise a family here and live here.
3:20 Speaker 00 And be a software developer or entrepreneur.
3:22 Speaker 01 Yeah, and in 2007, I moved to LA for two years.
3:25 Speaker 00 Why did you move? What was the thing? So wait, you were, let, talk about your software development first.
3:29 Speaker 01 Okay.
3:30 Speaker 00 So you were doing software development.
3:32 Speaker 01 So I started my career as not packaged software, as custom software. So I worked for what's now Accenture. It was called Anderson Consulting. As a programmer, working on large corporate billing systems and security systems and stuff like that. I left in 1999 to build a startup. I raised capital. I built that company in London. We were in five countries. We sold software. Back then, it was called ASP. I don't know if you remember when it was called Application Service Providers. And then we called it On Demand, and then SaaS, and then Cloud. It's all the same shit. You know, we were building centralized services for large European companies back in the late 90s.
4:14 Speaker 01 And I sold that company to a French publicly traded company called the Sword Group, and I moved back home. And when I moved here, I moved to Palo Alto and I started building my second company. The timing for talking about this is interesting because we were building what Dropbox built before Dropbox existed. And I sold that company to Salesforce and we became Salesforce Content Management System.
4:35 Speaker 00 Okay. And you didn't stay at Salesforce?
4:38 Speaker 01 I decided not to stay at Salesforce.
4:39 Speaker 00 You still want to be part of a big company?
4:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, I think at that point, I was 39 and I had been running companies for 10 years. And I think I always felt like I was my own boss. And Salesforce is a wonderful company. I have very close friends who are still there and have been there through all the years. But it's very much Mark's company, Mark and Parker. And I was looking to do my own thing again.
5:02 Speaker 00 Right. And so, talk about moving to LA. So you thought you'd have this sort of serial entrepreneur kind of?
5:07 Speaker 01 So, the fund that I'm with, it's Upfront Ventures, actually run the fund. I've been running it since 2011. The founder, Yves Systaron, was on my board. So they had invested in me. And so Yves said to me, why don't you come to LA, learn the business, stay for two years, and then go open our Silicon Valley office?
5:24 Speaker 00 Why did you want to go into venture from doing?
5:26 Speaker 01 I wasn't sure if I wanted to go into venture. I actually called him and said I wanted to do another startup. I thought I was going to do my third. And he was looking for an operator because I think he recognized that increasingly capital was just capital.
5:38 Speaker 00 Right. Anybody has money, right?
5:40 Speaker 01 And entrepreneurs were looking for people who had actually walked in their footsteps and done their job before. Honestly, my thought at the time was, it's worth a try. I was 39. If this works, this could be my career. And if it doesn't work, I could always go back to being an entrepreneur.
5:55 Speaker 00 Right. And so you moved to LA. And had you spent time down there? Did you know much about the tech?
6:00 Speaker 01 I had lived in LA from 91 to 94. So I did my undergraduate at UC San Diego. There were no jobs when I graduated college in 91. It was a recession. I really wanted-
6:11 Speaker 00 Also, LA wasn't a tech center-
6:13 Speaker 01 Well, I wanted to live in San Francisco.
6:14 Speaker 00 Aerospace.
6:14 Speaker 01 That was my goal, was to live in San Francisco because I wanted to work in the tech sector. But there were no jobs in 1991, so I took the job I could get because I really wanted to be a programmer. And I got a job in LA and my first client was JPL. Jet Propulsion Laboratory-
6:28 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's all aerospace, right.
6:29 Speaker 01 They designed rockets that put a man on the moon. And I traveled all over the country working for large corporate clients. So I worked in LA for Southern California Gas Company. I went out to Miami and worked for Florida Power and Light. My area of specialty was distributed computing. This is pre-World Wide Web.
6:46 Speaker 00 Yeah.
6:47 Speaker 01 And we were working on how to take servers and connect them with clients and dealing with the network in between. It's called middleware. And what happens when a transaction doesn't complete and you have to roll it back and so on and so forth. And so I moved with Anderson at the end of 94, early 95, to set up an internet practice in Europe.
7:06 Speaker 00 Right.
7:06 Speaker 01 And I spent all my time with telcos, helping them figure out how to launch internet offerings.
7:11 Speaker 00 So when you got back to LA, were you worried about that idea? Because, I mean, let's talk, we're going to talk more about the LA market, but it hadn't been the center. They had all these sort of flameouts, essentially. They had MySpace and then Demand Media.
7:23 Speaker 01 So this is, if I take you back even further, in the emergence of the internet, what LA was really good at was monetization.
7:32 Speaker 00 Right.
7:33 Speaker 01 And you know the saying that necessity is the mother of all invention. Because they couldn't raise capital, they couldn't, they didn't have big funds.
7:39 Speaker 00 Right.
7:40 Speaker 01 So they had to find a way to monetize. So Google's model was actually borrowed from Overture, which built GoTo.com. You probably remember that, Bill Gross. And when Bill Gross went to TED and talked about a pay-per-click model, he stood on stage at TED and was booed. He was booed for talking about pay-per-click.
8:00 Speaker 00 Right, I remember that.
8:01 Speaker 01 He was walking to the elevator and a gentleman came up behind him and tapped him on the shoulder and introduced himself and said, "I think that's a really amazing model. Could I be your first customer?" It's a true story, Bill will tell you if you ask him. And his name was Jeff Bezos.
8:14 Speaker 00 Right.
8:14 Speaker 01 And he became the first big client of GoTo.com. And he was doing pay-per-click and driving people to buy books. And it turned out that model worked so well that-
8:22 Speaker 00 Yeah, I was at that Ted Cal.
8:24 Speaker 01 Oh, you were?
8:24 Speaker 00 Richard Saul Warman was running it.
8:26 Speaker 01 He got, he got-
8:27 Speaker 00 Jeff used to show up on his, whatever the heck badge that he had, but he was little.
8:31 Speaker 01 Yeah.
8:31 Speaker 00 Jeff was little then.
8:32 Speaker 01 And it was like the company, people didn't really know it.
8:36 Speaker 00 Yeah.
8:36 Speaker 01 This is, you know, mid to late 90s and our firm was an investor in Overture. So that's how I know a lot of the story.
8:41 Speaker 00 Which then sold to Google.
8:42 Speaker 01 Yeah. No, we sold to Yahoo.
8:44 Speaker 00 Yahoo, that's right. That's right. I'm sorry. Overture went to Yahoo. That was their big, and then-
8:47 Speaker 01 1.6 billion.
8:49 Speaker 00 Bought the technology. It was-
8:50 Speaker 01 So what Google bought is another LA company. So I want to point this out. So first of all, we created the category. Google won and they won for reasons where I could tell you if you're interested, but Google won. And we still built a company that sold for 1.6 billion dollars. Then another, so Bill Gross graduated from Caltech. Another Caltech alumni was named-
9:10 Speaker 00 And he's in Pasadena, started his group in Pasadena.
9:12 Speaker 01 Idea Lab, started in Pasadena as a result. Another Caltech graduate named Gil Elbaz created a company called Applied Semantics. And what Applied Semantics did is they didn't do search the way that Overture was doing. They would read what was on your webpage. They would look at semantic analysis and they would serve ads based on what, you know, keyword density and also based on click stream of what clicks you took before you got to the page. Well, that became Google AdSense. So both Google AdWords and Google AdSense, the two most profitable businesses ever created, were initiated in Los Angeles.
9:47 Speaker 00 Right, absolutely.
9:48 Speaker 01 We didn't win.
9:48 Speaker 00 No. So when you're saying it was a place where people thought about monetization, was that a problem? They didn't, they didn't think about just spending whatever to get to?
9:56 Speaker 01 Because- Necessity is the mother of all invention.
9:58 Speaker 00 But all the companies that succeeded were like the Amaz, which didn't think of that at all. They were initially.
10:03 Speaker 01 When you think about Silicon Valley, where people will hand you $30 million and tell you to go generate the next amazing internet service and try not to monetize because let's try to build really big and capture the market. You have the luxury of not monetizing. When someone says, I'll give you $3 million and that's all you're getting, you got to make money. So let's look at who came out of-
10:24 Speaker 00 It's only 400 miles. It's not even like, or whatever, 300 miles.
10:27 Speaker 01 But you know, especially back then, Silicon Valley VCs, most of the funds were like $150 million. They weren't like $10 billion that they are today. They were $150 million and they literally didn't want to travel more than 25 miles.
10:41 Speaker 00 Right. Because the idea was- Mark Andreessen wouldn't go past Hobie's, I remember.
10:43 Speaker 01 I had to meet, I have to meet you at Buck's. I'm not going to go past Buck's, right?
10:47 Speaker 00 Yeah.
10:47 Speaker 01 So those were the days. And if you look at Commission Junction and you look at Price Grabber and Shopzilla and a whole bunch of these lower my bills, they were all finding ways to arbitrage money and to drive eyeballs to websites and they were all monetization techniques.
11:07 Speaker 00 Right, monet techniques. And why was that? Why?
11:10 Speaker 01 Again, I think LA is a place where people have to make money.
11:13 Speaker 00 Make money, right.
11:13 Speaker 01 So, look at MySpace, okay? So, MySpace actually came out of a direct marketing initiative. They started by direct marketing face creams and stuff like that.
11:22 Speaker 00 Right.
11:23 Speaker 01 And it wasn't working and the internet had crashed and they realized that they could go buy a bunch of email lists from all these VC-backed companies that didn't succeed. So, they bought all the email lists and they started emailing everybody and driving them to a social network called MySpace. That's how MySpace was born. A lot of people don't know that either, but it was born-
11:42 Speaker 00 Data portability.
11:43 Speaker 01 It was born out of selling face creams initially.
11:46 Speaker 00 Yeah, there were some controversial face creams in there, by the way.
11:48 Speaker 01 Yes, I agree with you.
11:50 Speaker 00 They burned people's face off. As I recall, it was a sketchy group of people.
11:55 Speaker 01 I was not an investor. I was not around.
11:56 Speaker 00 It made the Bitcoin people seem ethical.
11:59 Speaker 01 There were some good people. There were some less good people, as is always the case. I know some of the good people. So, in any event, if you look at, we had a failed start with Overture. We didn't become Google. We had a failed start with MySpace. It didn't become Facebook, but it was inevitable that it would start to happen. And what I think is unique about LA, at least in consumer web, we can talk about hard tech in a minute, but in consumer web, we really understand the sensibility of brands, of consumers, of marketing, of how they make decisions, but also of design. So, look at Gen Z. Two of the leading products created in the last five years in the consumer space, Snapchat, LA-based, and Tinder, LA-based.
12:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
12:42 Speaker 01 And I don't think that's by accident. And you look at other companies, people tend not to associate with LA, but Riot Games, League of Legends, bought for $10 billion, ultimately created in LA.
12:52 Speaker 00 Right. We'll get to that, like, why that is, what's different. So, when you went down there, you went there to, did you consider yourself an LA venture capitalist or was that going to be your focus? Because you are, you do, you are kind of the center of- LA tech.
13:05 Speaker 01 I went for two years and my wife worked at Google.
13:09 Speaker 00 Right.
13:09 Speaker 01 And I promised her we would come back.
13:11 Speaker 00 Right.
13:11 Speaker 01 She did not want to live in LA.
13:13 Speaker 00 Uh huh.
13:14 Speaker 01 I actually promised her we would never live in LA, so I broke that promise.
13:17 Speaker 00 Right.
13:17 Speaker 01 She saw the film Training Day, Ethan Hawke in the bathtub with a gun in his mouth. And she's like, I'm not living there. And after nine months, no joke, she said, I'm not leaving.
13:26 Speaker 00 Oh, wow.
13:26 Speaker 01 So LA is a wonderful place. It's 19 million people. It's very diverse. There's, it's not monocultural. So anyway, so I was there. And what I said to her, aside from the fact that she fell in love with it, what I said to her is, there's very few VCs here that have any amount of software skills, technology background, operating experience. And I think, okay, it's a smaller pond, but I could be a much bigger fish.
13:48 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, no, there's an expert. What was the guy who was talking, a very famous film writer? And he said, wrote, I think he telegrammed his brother, millions to be made out here and everyone's an idiot. Like, you know what I mean? Like, something like that. It was a very famous Hollywood telegram.
14:03 Speaker 01 So all of, all of the VCs that existed in the eighties and nineties, like, they all went away.
14:09 Speaker 00 Right.
14:09 Speaker 01 From LA down to San Diego. And the emergence of like Dana Settle with Greatcroft.
14:15 Speaker 00 Right.
14:16 Speaker 01 What's now Upfront Ventures. Yeah, there's a small number of us, but they, like Dana was new.
14:21 Speaker 00 Right.
14:22 Speaker 01 To LA back then.
14:22 Speaker 00 Right, right.
14:23 Speaker 01 So there were a number of these newer funds that have been created in the last 10 years.
14:26 Speaker 00 But, but do you consider yourself an LA venture capitalist then? Or how do you, explain Upfront, how, so it started?
14:33 Speaker 01 Upfront is a national firm.
14:34 Speaker 00 Right.
14:35 Speaker 01 We've been around for 21 years. So we're the oldest VC in LA. We're also the largest.
14:39 Speaker 00 You do have the coolest offices.
14:41 Speaker 01 We have a pretty cool offices, you know?
14:42 Speaker 00 VC offices in LA are better than here.
14:45 Speaker 01 But the idea for us is we're not a regional fund. We do 40% of our investments in LA, 60% are outside of LA.
14:54 Speaker 00 That's a lot, 40%.
14:56 Speaker 01 40% is a lot, but like, think of it this way. A city of 19 million people, it is obviously the second largest city in the United States. And it is the third largest venture market. It's the fastest growing. Why wouldn't we use our advantage to look at the top end of the funnel of every deal created locally and then just be more selective? But what I don't want to do is have concentration risk where every deal we have is in Southern California. So we do 25% Bay Area, about 15% New York City. But we have deals internationally, so two of us are dual citizens. I'm a dual citizen of the US and UK, so I've done two deals there. My partner Eve, who founded the fund, he's got, I think, three deals based out of France. So we're not afraid to get on airplanes and go do deals elsewhere.
15:40 Speaker 00 And talk very in this section about the LA scene. How do you look at it though? Because you are the most prominent venture capitalist in Los Angeles, probably.
15:47 Speaker 01 The way that I look at Los Angeles is this. First of all, we have incredible tech talent. So we have more top 25 engineering universities in greater Los Angeles than anywhere else in the country. And again, that shouldn't be a surprise because we're the second largest city behind New York. There's 19 million people in greater LA. There's seven to seven and a half million people in greater Bay Area. So we have this incredible pool of talent. And you mentioned it before, like if you're a talented engineer, you either went into aerospace and defense, you went into Hollywood, or you moved up north to join a startup. But they didn't want to move up here.
16:23 Speaker 00 Right.
16:24 Speaker 01 You know, there's better weather, better lifestyle, more diversity, lower cost of living, a lot more going on. And especially when you think about so many of these people being like 23 to 35, they prefer to be in LA, but the jobs weren't there. And that's something that changed. And because that's changed, it's not just that those people, if you go to UCLA or USC or Caltech or Harvey Mudd or Cal Poly Pomona or any of these colleges.
16:49 Speaker 00 All of which are there.
16:50 Speaker 01 You want to stay, but now we're getting people moving down from the Bay Area. And it's not just entrepreneurs. A lot of VCs are moving down. You have David Lee, you have Chris Sacca, Fred Wilson spends every winter there now. So you have a lot more people who are coming to LA.
17:03 Speaker 00 So do you, when you create that cohesion of a group of people, because one of the things that is, has been powerful about Silicon Valley has been you have the VCs, the schools, Stanford especially, and then you have the entrepreneurs and sort of iron triangle of a situation. And talk about what the atmosphere in LA is then for that. Because you have, you know, Harvey Mudd, you've got a lot of schools, but it's still not quite the same thing. It doesn't feel quite as tight when I'm down there.
17:29 Speaker 01 It definitely.
17:30 Speaker 00 You guys have tried.
17:31 Speaker 01 Well, listen, let me say this is we're not going to replace Silicon Valley, and that's not even the objective. I think we can build a dynamic valuable ecosystem without. It's like, you know, would Chicago really replace New York as the financial capital? Would Seattle replace LA as the creative video capital of the world? It's just not going to happen. There's just 40 years of developing those communities in the Bay Area. So we're not trying to do that. But I would tell you that what I used to complain about was what I call the invisible startup. And the invisible startup is someone really talented. There was a team out of USC that were security experts and they created a company. They raised $5 million from Coastal Ventures. This is right when I arrived.
18:15 Speaker 01 And then Coastal Ventures moved them up north, which I don't blame Coastal Ventures, and I don't blame this company, but that company is called Lookout. And it's now north of a billion dollar valuation. It's a very prominent mobile security. But they were Angelinos, like they should have stayed. And so I think there's a million invisible deaths that we died of people who relocated. And I think those, the reason I'm so passionate about more capital being in LA is I think those people didn't want to leave LA and I think we can retain them now.
18:42 Speaker 00 With the capital there that they don't have to, or they aren't forced to move, like come up here so we can be close to you.
18:47 Speaker 01 If people write the first check, the first three to $5 million in LA, and you establish your team, you're not likely to move.
18:54 Speaker 00 Yeah. Before we move on, because I do want to talk about some of the companies there and why they went up and down. You hate the term Silicon Beach.
19:00 Speaker 01 I do.
19:01 Speaker 00 To explain, you and I had a terrible Twitter fight over.
19:04 Speaker 01 You know, I try not to get in too many Twitter fights these days.
19:07 Speaker 00 Yeah, don't get one with me.
19:09 Speaker 01 That I know for sure. Listen, so first of all, I think beach emphasizes the worst perception that people have of Los Angeles that we're not serious.
19:19 Speaker 00 Right.
19:20 Speaker 01 The vast majority of high quality companies are east of the 405, anywhere but the beach. And I don't want to, first of all, be derivative to Silicon Valley.
19:29 Speaker 00 Can you explain east of 405 to people?
19:30 Speaker 01 Oh, yeah, sorry. So from the beach until the 405, which is the north-south freeway.
19:36 Speaker 00 Santa Monica.
19:37 Speaker 01 You just have to watch the Californians on Saturday Night Live. You know, you take the 405 to the one time. But it's about four miles from the beach to the 405 and that's called the West Side. And the West Side of LA, it's very expensive.
19:49 Speaker 00 Yeah, Bel Air.
19:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, no, Bel Air is actually east of the 405. So you've got Brentwood, Santa Monica and Venice and Malibu.
19:57 Speaker 00 Right.
19:57 Speaker 01 And that's what, and those are all beach communities and they're beautiful. That's where I live.
20:01 Speaker 00 And there's a lot of startups there too.
20:01 Speaker 01 There's a lot of startups. So you tend to see a lot of people starting there and then you migrate elsewhere because it's just too expensive. Like you wouldn't build a startup on Fisherman's Wharf in San Francisco, right? It's not the right environment for it.
20:13 Speaker 00 I might, I might, Mark.
20:14 Speaker 01 You might, you might. Actually, it's probably these days.
20:17 Speaker 00 Delicious crab and...
20:18 Speaker 01 Yeah, and the Clem Chatterballs.
20:20 Speaker 00 Sea lions, things like that.
20:22 Speaker 01 There you go, it smells, it smells there. And so what I don't want to do is emphasize the beach. And I don't want to be derivative to Silicon Valley because I don't think we need to. I think we can be proud of what we have. So I like to call it LA Tech.
20:35 Speaker 00 LA Tech, yeah.
20:36 Speaker 01 Yeah, just emphasize, I mean, I know it's not like some glamorous name, but neither is Silicon Beach, it's just derivative.
20:41 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, okay, all right. Do you like the beach, Mark?
20:44 Speaker 01 I do like the beach.
20:45 Speaker 00 All right, okay.
20:45 Speaker 01 I do, I mean, I'm not a surfer, I'm not a quintessential, I'm not 6'3" blonde, six-pack. I'm a nebbish Jewish like computer programmer.
20:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, you don't look like you'd be on Laguna Beach.
20:56 Speaker 01 No.
20:56 Speaker 00 Neither could I, but in any case, all right, when we get back, we're going to talk more about some of the investments Mark has done at Upfront and about some of the big LA companies because even though, you know, it isn't regional, kind of it, like there is, there is a region-ness about things like that. We're here with Mark Suster. He is a partner, managing partner at Upfront Ventures and we're going to talk more about Los Angeles and some trends. Today's show is brought to you by Freshly. Meal kits are so last year. Freshly is the new way to get dinner on the table in no time. Their chefs send you delicious, freshly prepared meals so you can eat better without any of the work. No cooking or cleanup required. Their meals are delivered to your door fresh and ready whenever you are. Just heat them up when you're hungry.
21:39 Speaker 00 My sons ate everything freshly sent to our house and they loved it. I did not actually get a bite because they ate it all. Freshly chefs and nutritionists make sure that every meal is all natural, nutritious, and made with high-quality ingredients. So now you can come home late and still have a delicious chef-cooked meal waiting for you. Just choose from the rotating menu of 30 options. Try Freshly and you'll see what it's like to put zero effort into making dinner. Go to freshly.com/decode and get $25 off your first order of six meals. That's $25 off plus free shipping at freshly.com/decode. We're back with Mark Suster from Upfront Ventures in Los Angeles. And we've been talking about sort of the LA tech scene, which Mark refuses to call it Silicon Beach.
22:21 Speaker 00 I agree with him, actually, but he wants to call it LA Tech. Let's talk a little bit about LA Tech. Is it, again, you're not, you have investments all over the world, but you have 40% of them in Los Angeles. Talk to me a little bit about the LA scene, because what seems to have happened, there's been, one of the things that helps Silicon Valley is there's so many successes in one place. There's more than one, essentially. And LA, the experience has been one at a time, and then many of them have flamed out. MySpace, big and hot, then not. Demand Media was the next one, and now Snapchat is struggling, even though I think the world of Snap, I think it's a really cool company. But it's never had that, do you need to have that big group of companies there, or is that not necessary?
23:02 Speaker 01 Well, I'll say a couple of things. When a company succeeds, you end up with a lot of important things. One is what we call recycled capital. So people who make a lot of money and reinvest it in younger entrepreneurs. You end up with mentors, but you end up, so what Silicon Valley has an advantage of is people who have seen scale.
23:20 Speaker 00 Right.
23:21 Speaker 01 Because you could have a great engineer from Indiana, or St. Louis, or Florida, and that engineer is no less qualified than someone who's from Silicon Valley, but if they worked at LinkedIn and saw scale, or Salesforce, or Facebook, they have an advantage. They understand both, not only how to scale, but they understand consumer behavior in a way you don't if you haven't seen scale. So Example, when I moved to LA, I funded a company I know you're aware of called Maker Studios. And the first thing I did.
23:49 Speaker 00 Sold to Disney.
23:50 Speaker 01 We sold to Disney. And the first thing I did is I recruited a former colleague of mine from Salesforce to move down to LA to be the CTO. He had seen scale at Salesforce. He stayed for five years after we were acquired. And I really wanted to build a company that could scale. So he hired 55 engineers. So we built a real engineering team at Maker Studios. And so we ended up selling. He stayed for his lockup period and he's got another startup now. And so that repeat, rinse and repeat process is happening more in LA than it ever has in the past.
24:24 Speaker 00 There has to be a few companies like Google.
24:26 Speaker 01 But now people have seen scale at Tinder. They've seen scale at Right Games. They've seen scale at Snapchat. And actually, you're seeing people break out of SpaceX. People forget that SpaceX is an LA-based company. They forget that Elon lives in Bel Air. He lives in LA.
24:41 Speaker 00 Nobody forgets that. But Elon's his own little planet over there. He's not, I don't think he mixes a whole lot.
24:46 Speaker 01 I think he's not even on the planet. He's stratospheric. I think he's the greatest entrepreneur of our times. But I have seen him out at dinner. I've sat next to him at a dinner party and it does happen because he lives in LA.
24:56 Speaker 00 Yeah, absolutely. He used to live up here, actually, if I recall. I remember him at X.com.
25:01 Speaker 01 Yes, which became PayPal.
25:03 Speaker 00 Well, no, he merged with them.
25:04 Speaker 01 He merged with them and a combined company.
25:06 Speaker 00 But when you have one, it does create, if there's problems like Snapchat right now, for example, let's actually go back. What happened from your perspective to the MySpace and demand? And those are all individual problems that they each had.
25:19 Speaker 01 So MySpace in particular, I think, didn't architect its technology right for scale. So I think that was one of the problems. Number two is, I think they made a mistake, which is Rupert Murdoch, when it was YouTube was bought by Google. And it really pissed them off because they wanted to buy YouTube because YouTube became successful on MySpace. And so video became popular in the era of social media, photos became popular. So what he didn't have was he didn't have the currency, the way that Google did because it had this stratospheric public market valuation that it could pay 1.65 billion to buy YouTube. And he was really pissed off. He went out and bought the trophy prize, which was PhotoBucket.
26:03 Speaker 00 Right.
26:04 Speaker 01 Because he thought, oh, I'll buy the photo one. And then he shut down the API. So he didn't allow developers to build on MySpace.
26:11 Speaker 00 No, that's the thinking.
26:11 Speaker 01 And that's right when Facebook opened up. So you had Zynga and you had Slide and you had Rockyou.
26:16 Speaker 00 It was a mentality.
26:17 Speaker 01 They had opened up and they opened up the platform community at exactly the time MySpace shut it down. So I think that's really what happened and Rupert just thought he could innovate internally. Facebook eventually, as you know, kind of shut down their platform as well, but they were open at the right time.
26:31 Speaker 00 Well, not right now. It's coming home to roost at this very moment.
26:34 Speaker 01 It was architected better and that's a story I'm happy to take on if you'd like to, but I will tell you, the example is Amit Kapoor, who is the COO, Stanford graduate COO of MySpace, then went and created Gravity, another LA-based company which we backed and we sold that to AOL. And Amit now has a venture fund and is funding companies based in LA.
26:52 Speaker 00 So there creates that, the seed.
26:53 Speaker 01 Yeah, they're kind of rinse and repeat. I've got capital to spend, I've seen scale, I'm going to create my next generation startup.
27:00 Speaker 00 Is geography an issue? Because it's so spread out. That's another, the concentration. I mean, I always think of Los Angeles as New York. If you squeezed, if you slapped everything down, it just spreads out.
27:09 Speaker 01 I know you'll think that I'm spinning this, but I'm trying not to. I think that's mythology, I really do. Because if you look at the Bay Area, you've got the crowd who lives north of the bridge and they'll never go to San Jose, they'll never go to Palo Alto, they only will take the boat over to San Francisco. So you have the San Francisco community, you have the East Bay community, you have the Palo Alto Menlo Park community, you have the San Jose community. Like, people don't do that in the Bay Area. You'd sooner get on a plane and fly to LA than you would be to go to San Jose.
27:38 Speaker 00 Right.
27:39 Speaker 01 The same is true in LA. You have pockets. So our main pockets now are Santa Monica Venice, which is the West Side.
27:45 Speaker 00 Where Google has a big Snapchat and they're moving.
27:47 Speaker 01 Well, so they've all moved down to the second pocket, which is going to be 20 years from now, the big thing in LA, which is Playa. But I think-
27:54 Speaker 00 Explain where that is, that's near the airport.
27:56 Speaker 01 That's down just north of the airport. So it's about 20 minutes south of Santa Monica. But the important thing is it draws from Redondo Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Hermosa Beach, south of the airport. And the reason that's important is you can draw all the young people because the young people want to live down there and it's more affordable. But it's also by freeways, so you can take the 405, which we talked about earlier, you can easily get in there. And so it was undeveloped land and you'll see a lot of development down there.
28:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, it was a controversial development initially.
28:26 Speaker 01 It was. And what I think you'll see over time is actually the growth of downtown Los Angeles. Because there's tons of industrial space. It's much cheaper and you can actually get there from north LA, from over in the valley, but you can also get there from east. And it's a lot more affordable and it draws from many more parts of Los Angeles. And you probably know this, we actually have public transportation now. You can take a train, a light rail, from Santa Monica to downtown. You can go from north Hollywood to downtown. So as the rail system has been built up, I think it becomes a lot more commutable.
29:01 Speaker 00 Right. And then, so you have that area as the downtown part. You know, Nasty Gal, it's down there, there's a whole bunch that were down there.
29:06 Speaker 01 So a lot of people that are in e-commerce are downtown LA. So media and e-commerce has really been downtown.
29:12 Speaker 00 Been in downtown LA. And then not much in Beverly Hills in that area, right?
29:16 Speaker 01 No, because Beverly Hills is too expensive. It's like building a startup in Atherton.
29:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, Tinder, where Tinder's around there, right?
29:21 Speaker 01 So Tinder-
29:23 Speaker 00 It was in Beverly Hills.
29:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, but that's because IAC. It was started at IAC. But you have West Hollywood, that's a lot of stuff. So you have West Hollywood, you have North Hollywood, you have downtown LA, you have the west side, but there's-
29:36 Speaker 00 And then the types of companies. You're saying there's a lot of creative stuff? Because I considered Snapchat a creative company more than an emotional company. I don't know how else to put, you know, like it has more creativity.
29:47 Speaker 01 I'm going to give you a metaphor for how I think about consumer businesses. We'll talk about B2B in a minute. But consumer businesses, you have infrastructure. So in order to build, let's say in the era of shipping, in the era of airplanes, you needed airports, you needed deepwater ports for shipping. And then, once you did, valuable stuff happened on top of that infrastructure. The infrastructure of the internet had to be built first. So it was routers and switches and databases and browsers and caching software. And all of that happened in Silicon Valley, or most of that happened in Silicon Valley. But, once that was built, I would argue that everything you do as a consumer on the internet falls into three categories. I call them the three Cs.
30:30 Speaker 01 Content, commerce, and communications. So, when you think of it, you are spending time because you want to buy shit, right? So, those are done from e-commerce companies. You want to communicate with other people. You're lonely or bored. And you want to consume media and information. And I think, not just LA, but LA and New York are really well-positioned for the three Cs. Because they're media-oriented. And, and we also understand consumer brands. And we understand how to create products. And we understand international trade. I mean, 43% of all products that come into America come through LA. It comes through either Long Beach or the LA port. So, we're a great import-export. I think we're really the entry point for Asia into the United States. Really, you are, yeah.
31:14 Speaker 01 But, we also are like the northern capital of South America. I mean, there's 5 million Mexican people in Los Angeles. And unlike what Trump would try to get you to believe, the vast majority of them are hard-working, they're not first-generation immigrants, they're professional, they're not all-educated, a lot of them are educated, and they're productive. But, we have a large population of South Koreans, the largest population outside of South Korea. We have the largest population of Persians outside of Iran. And so, it's this great melange of people that are building those three Cs. And we also have the celebrities that can endorse products. So, back to Ring, you may know that Shaquille O'Neal was our spokesperson. Right, right. So, if you go into a Best Buy and you look at 12 products, and they're all announcing
31:59 Speaker 01 their different video specs, and this has this much storage, and this much RAM, and this Wi-Fi... Consumers don't want to buy products like that.
32:07 Speaker 00 To the mentalities, marketing, media.
32:10 Speaker 01 So we have the ability to brand, market, have endorsements, have consumers be able to figure out how to buy products. So I think we do well in the three Cs. And then you look at the hard sciences. I mean, there's a reason SpaceX is there. It's because we have JPL and Northrop Grumman. And we're the place where there was the birth of the aerospace industry, Howard Hughes. And so all of that talent is still in LA. It's just never been in the startup community.
32:36 Speaker 00 Right, right. And what's the negatives? Is it just the hard computing or the geekishness? Because I find most, I think of it in a similar way. I find LA companies more emotional. I don't mean that in a negative term. And the ones in Silicon Valley are very cold. Like, it's a very different, there's not a lot of storytelling, there's not, except for Apple, obviously.
32:56 Speaker 01 Yeah, Apple's certainly an exception. I will tell you this, is that there are categories I don't think LA will be good at. And one of them is SaaS.
33:05 Speaker 00 Right.
33:06 Speaker 01 Software as a Service. Because to be a product manager, to be a sales rep, to be pre-sales or post-sales support, there's just such a concentration of those people because of, historically, Oracle, PeopleSoft, Siebel, Salesforce Now, Workday. And all those people are aggregated here. It's really hard to find experienced people in LA who have done that. And I think we'll create some of those, but I don't think we do as well on that. But we do really well on trade, transportation, logistics. We do really well, I think, on hard sciences. There's a great robotics program at USC. So we're starting to see a lot more robotics come from LA.
33:49 Speaker 00 Is there more cooperation from the universities there, too? Because you've got USC, UCLA, Harvey Mudd.
33:54 Speaker 01 Caltech.
33:55 Speaker 00 You know, just...
33:56 Speaker 01 I don't think so. I mean, I would love to tell you that there is, but I don't think so.
34:00 Speaker 00 Why is that? Because Stanford's been such a critical element to Silicon Valley.
34:03 Speaker 01 I think Stanford is really unique. I think even the UC system overall hasn't done a great job at trying to figure out how to support entrepreneurs or how to spin out companies because they had a royalty system and they didn't think about the equity culture. I think Stanford's really led the country in that.
34:20 Speaker 00 But why not? I mean, Harvey Mudd, come on, or Caltech.
34:23 Speaker 01 I don't know why it is. I can tell you at Caltech, my perception, even though we have incredibly successful alumni from there, is that it's more theoretical school. It's less practical application. So MIT, I think, has done a better job in the startup world at creating startups and breeding that culture. Like, the places I love, I love Carnegie Mellon, I love for startups.
34:46 Speaker 00 Cars, yeah.
34:47 Speaker 01 I like, actually, Wharton is doing a fantastic job of creating startups. They have these combined programs that are management and computer science together. I don't think we've done a tremendous job in L.A.
34:58 Speaker 00 What could happen? How could that be done?
35:01 Speaker 01 People have been trying ever since I've been there. I don't, I wish I had a good answer. They set up tech transfer offices. We went and spent a bunch of time on universities. I think there's a lot that could happen. I don't know what the winning formula is.
35:12 Speaker 00 Do you know why? You know why?
35:14 Speaker 01 No, but like, outside of Stanford, where else does it happen?
35:17 Speaker 00 You're right. MIT doesn't translate it as well.
35:19 Speaker 01 Cal, I don't, I mean, Cal's a wonderful place. I haven't seen the same level of startups come out of Cal. It's right, right across the bay.
35:25 Speaker 00 Right, exactly. You're right. So, when you're thinking about those companies, obviously, Snapchat's been the latest big name. And seeing, can you diagnose, were you an investor in Snapchat?
35:38 Speaker 01 I was not.
35:38 Speaker 00 Yeah. Why? Were you offered it? You had to have been.
35:41 Speaker 01 Listen, here's what I tell people about Snapchat, and I authentically believe this, even though it sounds like post hoc rationalization. When they went out to raise, there were a million photo-sharing companies.
35:52 Speaker 00 There were.
35:52 Speaker 01 I didn't think that it would be exceptional relative to all the other ones I was seeing. I was looking at a company called Scout. And Scout was like, location-based networking, and you know, a lot of young kids. And I was really nervous, honestly, as a parent, about protecting children and what would happen if children were groomed on a website like that. I was super close investing and the founder is a wonderful guy. He's out of, I think he's Finnish, if I remember correctly, maybe Swedish. And he spent so much time, energy and effort in building systems to protect the children, but still, three children were raped through
36:36 Speaker 01 this system that were groomed. And you can't control everything, right? But I just had so much nervousness over investing in something. And at the time Snapchat was inappropriate pictures being shared. And I just, I felt like that was, they hadn't built stories. It hadn't been a mess, you know, the same kind of app that it's become. So that was that. And then all of a sudden, it took off and it became massive. And Mark famously tried to create an app to compete with, buy it and then create an app called, was it Poke or something to compete with it? And that actually just gave it, gave it more oxygen. And by the time it just really had taken off, I don't think I could have competed in one because Benchmark came in and they offered them, I think, I don't know the exact
37:20 Speaker 01 numbers, but I think order of magnitude like 12 million at a 60 pre. And back then, you know, we were a smaller fund. And I'm not saying we would have won it if we would have competed. But Benchmark had the success across their portfolio to take a bet like that. And again, this is many years ago. These days, a lot bigger checks are being written. I just think, even if I wanted to compete, I don't think I would have won it by then. So it's a rare exception of one that went from super early stage Jeremy Lu giving him 500K because he was spreading around a lot of bets on talented teams and he got a few of them very right. And then just immediately stratospheric success where I couldn't have won it.
38:00 Speaker 00 What about now? What did they do? Because it was, you know, an IPO. You take them or you get them. And now it's a big IPO. Tinder was owned by someone else, so I wasn't.
38:09 Speaker 01 And I'm sorry, what's the question you're asking?
38:11 Speaker 00 What do you imagine's happened now with them? Obviously, Facebook came right back and managed to do Instagram stories.
38:17 Speaker 01 There's a few things that I think Silicon Valley reporting gets wrong about Snapchat, and there's a few things that maybe I could elaborate on.
38:23 Speaker 00 Sure, please.
38:24 Speaker 01 So I think the narrative in Silicon Valley, because so many of the people that comment on Snapchat are not avid, young users of the product, and they compare it to Instagram. I think Snapchat really is more like WhatsApp than Instagram.
38:37 Speaker 00 I agree.
38:38 Speaker 01 And it has a network effect, where, once people are communicating with all their friends on it, it's very hard to disrupt. And I'm not saying it can't happen, but it's very hard to disrupt. So I think it's a lot more sustainable than people think. Number two is, they went from brand advertising, which helped them grow very fast, because you didn't have to prove it to go sell a $2 million campaign, you didn't have to prove efficacy, and they shifted it towards a direct marketing or a CPA model, where people now are doing a lot more DR. And that's more sustainable, because it's direct bidding, and they have a bidding platform. And they've shifted all that revenue without falling off a cliff, which I think is a monumental achievement that people don't talk about.
39:21 Speaker 01 The things that I think they didn't get right were twofold. Number one is, I don't think they understood the world of influencers well enough. And I think Evan really was reluctant to serve them.
39:33 Speaker 00 It's surprising from LA.
39:34 Speaker 01 Yeah.
39:34 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's his personality.
39:35 Speaker 01 It's his personality.
39:36 Speaker 00 And we did marry a supermodel, too.
39:38 Speaker 01 And they chose not to lean into that. And a lot of those people ended up at Instagram. And I think you could have sucked the oxygen out of the room and enabled them to stay on Snapchat, and would have been harder to get Instagram to bring them over. Number two is, I believe that you had to build a management infrastructure that, over time, learns how to decentralize power, and to hand off power, and build a hierarchy, and a campus, and a company culture that can withstand the trauma and the changes. And I don't think they've done that. And that'll be their big challenge going forward.
40:15 Speaker 00 Yeah, do you think they can do it? I mean, look at Facebook with Mark.
40:18 Speaker 01 I don't know.
40:19 Speaker 00 It's hard.
40:19 Speaker 01 I don't know. Okay, but at least Facebook has a campus and a culture.
40:23 Speaker 00 Yes, yeah, yeah.
40:24 Speaker 01 And you have Cheryl, that, you know, at least has had enough power to build organizational structure that I don't think Snapchat really invested in.
40:32 Speaker 00 Right, and they need to do that. Are you worried about their, what do you imagine they need to those two things? And I agree with you on the communications part. I think they're much more robust. They're also much more innovative. Facebook just borrows and borrows and it doesn't come up.
40:45 Speaker 01 It's the funniest thing to me because if the situations were reversed and Snapchat was a Northern California company and Instagram was an LA based company, everybody up here would be screaming bloody murder about how we're stealing IP. Nobody seems to care. I asked someone about this recently. He said, I asked a VC. He said, well, honestly, people do care, but no one wants to complain about Facebook because they still buy all our companies.
41:10 Speaker 00 That's interesting. You know, actually, I did an interview, a podcast with Kevin Systrom. He just, he just flat out said, yeah, we're still it. That's what we did. They, he said, they built a radio. Well, he just said it like he didn't even bother. And I appreciated that, actually. He said, you know, they built a radio and we built a better radio. So what? Do they have the things on radios? And I was like, hmm, okay. All right. You're going to defend your behavior? That's fine.
41:32 Speaker 01 They have, Instagram has reached a point where some of the product is better than Snapchat. Some of the product is better. And I think Snapchat's paying attention. But I think Snapchat also has an innovation engine of things that are in the pipeline that are coming.
41:46 Speaker 00 They're 100% more creative. It's not innovative. They're more creative. And that's the difference.
41:50 Speaker 01 Look at even like Bitmoji and look at the success of Bitmoji and bringing in characters into your stories. You know, what we talk about augmented reality, but really they kind of led in augmented reality.
42:03 Speaker 00 They did.
42:04 Speaker 01 And so the question is, can they keep that innovation engine coming? I don't know.
42:08 Speaker 00 That's hard. All right, we're here with Mark Suster. He is a venture capitalist upfront ventures in Los Angeles, talking about LA. We're going to talk about the broader stories, but I do want to get to Ring in our next section and more about where he thinks venture capital is going, especially with the huge amounts of money from SoftBank and others and how it's changing. Today's show is brought to you by TransferWise. Do you ever need to send money internationally? Sure, your bank or PayPal can get you money from A to B, but that transfer will cost you more than it should, a lot more. That's the old way of doing things. Let me tell you about the new, smarter and cheaper way to send money internationally: TransferWise. TransferWise was founded by two friends who were frustrated by their bank's bad exchange rates and high fees. They wondered, what if we could bypass the banks entirely? So they built TransferWise.
42:53 Speaker 00 That was seven years ago. Today, more than 2 million people use TransferWise. People sending money home. Businesses paying suppliers. Freelancers getting paid. The list goes on. TransferWise's clever new technology gives you a great exchange rate and a low fee, so it'll put some extra money in your pocket for more important things. No one has ever said, "It's important that my bank gets some extra money." Test it out for free at transferwise.com/podcast or download the app. Once again, that's transferwise.com/podcast. It's a wise way to send money.
43:26 Speaker 00 We're here with Mark Suster. He is a venture capitalist in Los Angeles at Upfront Ventures. He runs the firm, which is a really cool firm down there. You just recently had a big hit with Ring. Explain how that happened. You sold it to Amazon, but pre that.
43:39 Speaker 01 Jamie Simonoff is a longtime entrepreneur in L.A. I try to explain this to people who invest in venture funds because they all say, "Well, can't the Silicon Valley funds just fly down and do all the best deals?" The reality is, a lot of the people we're backing, we've known for 10 years. Jamie created a company called PhoneTag. I don't know if you ever used that, but it was a great product.
44:00 Speaker 00 I did.
44:00 Speaker 01 In the early days of voicemail, where most of us didn't want to sit and listen to voicemail all day, it created transcriptions for you. I think the company name was SimulScribe. The product was PhoneTag. So I knew Jamie through that. He then created a second company. It was called Unsubscribe. It wasn't for me, but he was creating products, innovating. Then he created something called Edison Labs, and Edison Labs was going to start spinning out a lot of companies. And they came up with this idea they called Doorbot. And I was hanging out with Jamie at a local conference and he was telling me about Doorbot and he said it was security doorbells. And I thought, that's a clever idea. You know, I've got ADT as an alarm system, but it's kind of a crappy system.
44:44 Speaker 01 They kind of provide crappy service. There's no video and I believe in computer vision and I think there's a huge trend towards not just video, but video and laser and infrared and other ways to interpret the physical world with computing devices. And that's what Jamie was building and I didn't know would people care or not, but I knew he was a great entrepreneur, so we brought him in. And my partner Greg Bettinelli was new to the fund. It was, I think, his first deal. The first deal he took over became Goat, which is another company we haven't talked about doing hundreds of millions of sales, LA-based. And Greg really was a large part of the reason why Goat was created. But this was his first de novo deal was Ring and, you know, we knew Jamie and we just wanted to back his vision.
45:29 Speaker 00 And he struggled for a little bit too, with computer complaints and...
45:32 Speaker 01 So we co-led the seed round and they launched the product.
45:36 Speaker 00 Which was how much, what did you put in there?
45:37 Speaker 01 I think in total, the round was like a million and a half dollars, something like that. And he sold $3.1 million of product like that. It was amazing and they sent him out and this is the thing about hardware. If you have problems in hardware, you can't just do an update. So, yeah, we struggled somewhat with product quality early days, but for a company that was so new, so innovative, so ahead of its market, I think they did a fantastic job. And Jamie's the consummate service professional. So we raised the next round with True Ventures. We participated also in the A round. And then he had enough capital where he replaced a lot of the malfunctioning products and he built a better version and then a better version and then a better version.
46:18 Speaker 01 Well, Shaq came in later, but where we really struggled was the next round of capital. Because there was a Silicon Valley narrative.
46:26 Speaker 00 That hardware didn't, they were, well, they had spent a lot of money on hardware.
46:28 Speaker 01 The narrative was Nest would beat us.
46:31 Speaker 00 Oh, Nest, yeah.
46:31 Speaker 01 Yeah, and they just kept saying, well, Nest is eventually going to do this and Dropcam's going to do this, and they never did, like, they never.
46:37 Speaker 00 Well, they did, they just did.
46:39 Speaker 01 Look at their product, they basically copied Ring.
46:41 Speaker 00 They did, and they have very nice commercials, I'll have to say.
46:44 Speaker 01 For years, though, they really struggled to innovate, where Ring has outpaced them at every step. And so, actually, it was a venture fund set up by a home builder who understood the market, which was Shea Ventures, now, I think they're called Calibrate now, that stepped in and led that round, and then Kleiner Perkins came in, and Richard Branson came in, and then Shaq.
47:06 Speaker 00 Right, right. And you, but the idea was that you couldn't do it, and also hardware was hard. They had struggled here with, oh, God, not Fitbit, a bunch of them like that. They had, they, there was sort of an anti-hardware thing after they poured lots of money into it.
47:20 Speaker 01 Who's they?
47:20 Speaker 00 Venture capitalists here had the narrative that hardware was too hard, essentially.
47:24 Speaker 01 So, the difference, like, I'm not a Fitbit negative person, so I'm not trying to say negative things about them, but here's the difference with Ring. With Ring, if you buy a security doorbell, you use it every month and you get utility out of it every single day. With Fitbit, a certain number of people get huge value out of it forever, and a certain number of people, it goes on the desk, right?
47:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, absolutely.
47:48 Speaker 01 And with Ring, that doesn't happen. And so, we have a huge, huge attach rate of people who not just buy the Ring, but they buy the subscription product.
47:56 Speaker 00 Subscription, yeah, which I did.
47:57 Speaker 01 And so, you, he started with the doorbell, and then he did a flood lamp, which you can just literally unscrew your flood lamp and screw it in. And then he had a stick-up cam, and then he sold like a solar charging unit, and then he sold a sign that went outside your house. And because he delighted customers, they kept coming back and buying more products.
48:16 Speaker 00 Sure, absolutely. And so, why sell to Amazon? This is a huge market.
48:19 Speaker 01 You know, listen, I think-
48:20 Speaker 00 Nest was coming.
48:21 Speaker 01 I think it's not just Nest coming. It's also Amazon wanted to be serious in the category. And I think Jamie took a view that here's a chance for me to not only get a great financial return for investors and employees and himself as founder, but to join arguably the best-run company maybe in the world now and to be a large, important part of that. And I think Jamie found that attractive.
48:46 Speaker 00 Right, right. And you didn't want to hinder him from that. Did you see a bigger market for that? It is tough. Nest was coming at you.
48:51 Speaker 01 Our job is to support founders. And when they decide they want to sell, we never fight against them. If I had my choice, I would have rather taken more risk and tried to go long. But I'm a VC, and that's what my job is to go long.
49:04 Speaker 00 Yeah, exactly. It's kind of hard to turn down.
49:06 Speaker 01 I didn't want to sell Maker Studios to Disney either, right? My goal is to build long-term, lasting, successful companies that can IPO and create communities around them.
49:17 Speaker 00 Well, not selling does have its appeal. Like, that's, you know, Mark Zuckerberg didn't sell, Google didn't sell, but MySpace sold.
49:24 Speaker 01 But the road is lined with people who didn't sell and eventually didn't succeed also. Those stories just don't get told. We have collective amnesia and memory. And honestly, I'm super proud of Jamie for getting to the finish line. I think it's the largest tech acquisition Amazon ever made. I know they paid more for Whole Foods, but the largest tech acquisition. And I'm super proud of him. And he's staying in LA, the team's staying in LA, Amazon's investing in LA.
49:51 Speaker 00 Smart to do that. It was, I was sort of like, oh, the one thing that Amazon doesn't own are Googles.
49:57 Speaker 01 Now they do.
49:58 Speaker 00 Now they do. I can't resist Jeff Bezos, apparently. So talk about, I mean, he also has created a sort of a juggernaut in Seattle in that regard. Well, they have Microsoft, and they had a bunch of companies. Talk about where you think trends are going. SoftBank has all this enormous amounts of money. I just interviewed the DoorDash CEO last night in Las Vegas at Shop Talk at our Code Commerce event. And it was $535 million, and half of that was from SoftBank. They're handing out checks of hundreds of millions of dollars. How are you all being impacted by them and what's happened? Because at first, it was Marc Andreessen doing that, handing out giant sums of money. But now, he's been... Mark Andreessen, essentially.
50:39 Speaker 01 Well, let me say it this way. One thing I'm sure you're aware of is the trend that companies are staying private longer.
50:45 Speaker 00 Yes.
50:46 Speaker 01 And there's a certain attractiveness to entrepreneurs to staying private and not being conditioned to the public markets. And because of that, capital is actually chasing the opportunity to still get investments because they can't wait until it goes public. And I think there's an appeal also for entrepreneurs. So I would also say with this large pool of capital, not just SoftBank, but Tamasik, and there's a lot more sovereign wealth funds out of Middle East doing direct investing. LPs are investing, hedge funds are investing, mutual funds are investing. Two things are happening. One is founders are able to sell stock into secondary so they can get some monetization and so they don't feel the pressure to go public. And some of the seed and early funds are actually
51:31 Speaker 01 selling their stock in those transactions. And actually, some VCs are. So it's actually being seen as a potential exit.
51:38 Speaker 00 Sure.
51:38 Speaker 01 For some people. But when large pools of capital come into companies at early stages, it distorts markets. And so there's going to be some positive stories and there's going to be a lot of negative stories, too.
51:50 Speaker 00 Godfather, like, take this money or else, kind of thing. I've heard a couple where they're saying, take our money or we'll take it to your, we'll walk over to your competitor.
51:57 Speaker 01 Look, that's life. I mean...
51:58 Speaker 00 Does that matter, all the money? Or does it, really?
52:01 Speaker 01 You remember the famous story, which is Steve Case running this little tiny company called AOL. And he goes to see, I probably, you know, read it. He went to see Bill Gates and, you know, we can buy you or bury you, which is it going to be?
52:16 Speaker 00 That was the first line of my book.
52:17 Speaker 01 There you go. So I must remember that line. And you think that's like, that's such common behavior. And I had that in my two startups. I had people saying, I can buy you, I can buy your competitor. And the first time, I didn't listen to them and I just kept building. And the second time, I thought, I'll have what's behind door number two. Those are very personal decisions. But of course, people feel that pressure. But then you look at companies like, I'm not so sure. Again, I hate saying negative things because I don't really know the company. But... Let's just take as an example magically. The enormous amount of money going into a company pre-product launch. I think it just distorts so many things.
52:54 Speaker 00 It distorts. What does it do? What is it?
52:56 Speaker 01 Well, first of all, you take the pressure off of founders from launching products. Because if you can...
53:01 Speaker 00 If they're not desperate, they...
53:03 Speaker 01 You know, I always said necessity is the mother of all invention. Like, if you give someone $2 million and they have to launch on $2 million and they have to wake up a little bit earlier and not have as big a team and not waste money on parties and all this other stuff, sometimes it produces more innovation. Like, the scene I have in my head is Apollo 13, you know, when they're trying to get the spaceship back.
53:24 Speaker 00 Yeah, and they have this.
53:25 Speaker 01 And they have these 11 materials and you gotta sit around and come up with some way to get the spaceship back. Like, that's the mentality I have, is I think the creative pressure of not being over-capitalized actually helps with innovation.
53:37 Speaker 00 But here they are. So what's gonna happen with this? Is it just gonna be a lot of failures? A lot of money?
53:42 Speaker 01 I think that...I mean, look at the dot-com era.
53:44 Speaker 00 There's not enough rat holes to shove all the money down.
53:46 Speaker 01 Well, look at the dot-com era. We over-capitalize all the companies. It distorts markets because if you can create a company that doesn't have to monetize and you have eight companies that don't have to monetize, the three that try to build successful business models can't. Because why would you pay for product if I can get everything for free?
54:04 Speaker 00 Right, yeah.
54:05 Speaker 01 And so, it does distort markets in the short term. I think when the markets eventually crash, I don't know when that's gonna come, I've thought it was gonna be three years ago, so don't listen to me, but eventually markets go through cycles and that capital, some of it will be pulled back out and to put into other uses.
54:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, I love it's the guy from LA that's prudent and non-spending. Then, what about the big companies that are doing... There's, you know, one of the things a lot of startups here are saying, like, it's not the era of the startup, it's the era of the big companies now.
54:32 Speaker 01 Well, I think most of the innovation is still coming from startups. So if you look at the success of Facebook and Google and even Salesforce, a lot of their innovation now is coming through acquisitions. Salesforce just bought Mulesoft, it was $6 billion plus dollars. And they had bought two or three companies before that. They bought Quip, they bought a number of companies. If you look at... Facebook buying WhatsApp, buying Instagram, buying Oculus. I think they're buying innovation and I think Google has done it too. And I don't think anything's wrong with that. I think that's going to continue to happen. It's just so hard to create the environment. When you're at Google and you're paid, I'm going to make it up $300,000 a year plus half a million dollar a year in stock grants and you can turn up when you want.
55:16 Speaker 01 And it doesn't really matter if you don't win in your market. It just, it produces a certain conservatism.
55:22 Speaker 00 They don't think, they don't think.
55:23 Speaker 01 I think it creates the wrong environment for it. And then there are the rare, unique breed of people who are just built to take the risk on, to, you know, create next generation products, to go out there every day against all the odds. Like Jamie Simonoff with Ring, when everyone said he couldn't do it.
55:40 Speaker 00 Amazon too, you'd have to call them pretty innovative. Like it's for a big company, they've.
55:44 Speaker 01 I think Amazon is really an outlier. I don't understand why they're freaks of nature. They're so good.
55:49 Speaker 00 He's so hungry, he's always been like that.
55:51 Speaker 01 It's unbelievable to me because he could just sit the rest of his life on a beach and so could his great, great grandchildren.
55:56 Speaker 00 I was, we had the head of Nordstrom at our Co-Commerce thing yesterday. And I told a story of going to, I did a story, I worked for the Washington Post. Nordstrom was invading all the cities with their innovative stores. And I was out there in Seattle to meet the Nordstroms and I had extra time. So I went to see this little startup, Amazon. You know, he wasn't little, little, but he was little and had five people. And it was, it was like it was an afterthought.
56:22 Speaker 01 You may not know this, but our firm was created by, so Eve Systeron was the head of North American Investments for a retail company called Carrefour.
56:32 Speaker 00 Yes, of course, French company.
56:34 Speaker 01 French company, so.
56:35 Speaker 00 Which was very innovative.
56:36 Speaker 01 Very innovative. And Denis Defare, the co-founder, decided he didn't want to come to the US because he didn't want to compete with Walmart. So, but he wanted to learn from US consumers who are leading consumers. So Carrefour ended up not just staying in Southern Europe, they were created in France, but they went to Eastern Europe, China, South America.
56:53 Speaker 00 Essentially the Costco for people who don't know.
56:54 Speaker 01 Well before Walmart did.
56:57 Speaker 00 Yeah.
56:57 Speaker 01 So he said, Eve, why don't you go invest in these companies in the US? So he invested in a small company with three warehouses called Costco.
57:05 Speaker 00 Costco, yeah.
57:06 Speaker 01 They took 20% of Costco, 8% of Starbucks. They were investors in.
57:10 Speaker 00 Very innovative.
57:10 Speaker 01 Dick's Sporting Goods, PetSmart, Jamba Juice, PF Chang's, Ulta Beauty and Cosmetics. And they basically dominated the category. But. Eve met Amazon in the early days because all of the Costco team had seen their retail sales and the numbers were just up and to the right.
57:29 Speaker 00 Right.
57:29 Speaker 01 And I think Jeff had like this outrageous price in mind, which was like $60 million valuation. And companies back then were funded at like five or 10 million dollars valuation.
57:39 Speaker 00 He had a lot of ambition.
57:40 Speaker 01 Yeah.
57:41 Speaker 00 So I finish up talking about where we are. Right now, we're in sort of a crisis around Facebook. Tech is disliked. There's all these massive technologies coming, automation, robotics, that could be problematic for society. It's not a good time for tech. Tell me where you think things are going from a venture perspective.
57:58 Speaker 01 I would say it's not a good time for democracies.
58:01 Speaker 00 No.
58:02 Speaker 01 You know, it's like the, we all thought that all the trends were heading in positive directions and you know, you could very easily talk yourself into dystopian future. But in general, I think technologies have been more good than bad. I just shared this on Twitter yesterday, like in all the dystopia that we see every day, I saw a tweet from a guy, I think he was in India, who was teaching poor inner city people, homeless people, how to do design work using a product called Canva.
58:37 Speaker 00 Canva, from Australia.
58:38 Speaker 01 Yeah, C-A-N-V-A. And I don't know the company all that well, led by a woman. They just raised earlier this year 40 million from Sequoia.
58:47 Speaker 00 Melanie, Melanie.
58:48 Speaker 01 Melanie. At a billion dollar valuation. I don't know her, but I was reading a lot about.
58:52 Speaker 00 Listen to my podcast with her.
58:53 Speaker 01 I will. I was trying to learn more about the company and the space and just interested in it. And I see this tweet from this gentleman and he's using their product in a remote village in India to teach homeless people how to be better designers to improve their lives. And there's a lot of that in the world and we can focus on our own little dramas.
59:15 Speaker 00 Right, but it's pretty serious.
59:17 Speaker 01 I'm not saying it's not serious.
59:18 Speaker 00 Robotics is serious.
59:19 Speaker 01 There's, there's both. There's like the positive consequences of everything that's happening and there's the negative.
59:26 Speaker 00 So where are you looking? Are you looking at cryptocurrency? Are you looking at, what is your, what is, you are like, mmm hmm.
59:31 Speaker 01 So. I'll tell you, so cryptocurrency, I'm not as big a believer in cryptocurrency, but the underlying technology, which you hear a lot, this blockchain, I think is transformative. And so I'm spending a lot of time trying to understand that. I just released a primer video on YouTube. If you search on YouTube for upfront ventures, you can find my primer video and I release slides. And I'm trying to educate myself and a lot of times by educating other people, it forces you to learn.
59:58 Speaker 00 Yeah, then you can have discussions.
59:59 Speaker 01 But I'll tell you what I spend my time on is computer vision. And I'm a really big believer in computing, being able to interpret the physical world in better ways than we as humans can. I'll just give you some examples. So I invested in a baby monitor. It's called Nanit. And what we do is we help monitor the well being of your child when they're sleeping. So the idea is monitor less, sleep more, or sleep more, monitor less. It's most of the people had baby monitors. It was like, oh, my God, is my baby dead? Are they alive? Or whatever. So our goal is to give you stats every day to help you be a better parent and not feel like you need to rush in all the time. But a byproduct of that is we believe
1:00:41 Speaker 01 we can predict autism younger than anyone else can, because we believe from about six months on, we can start to see signs that doctors yet can't diagnose. And I won't bore the podcast with why, but we have a bunch of data out of Israel to suggest that. But I believe cameras can also be used to predict Parkinson's, because you develop a twitch in your finger and a shuffle in your walk. Alzheimer's, you develop both a change in your voice pattern and a shuffle in your feet. And these things that observationally a doctor can't pick up because they see you once or twice a year, a computer can pick up the changes.
1:01:16 Speaker 00 Monitoring, you know, there's cardio here, there's a whole bunch of things.
1:01:18 Speaker 01 So we also invested in a company here in the Bay Area called Density. And what they do is they hang a little device above doors that uses lasers to track the patterns of how people move around spaces.
1:01:29 Speaker 00 Yeah. Mark Cuban was talking about a different one.
1:01:32 Speaker 01 Oh, did he?
1:01:33 Speaker 00 Near shopping malls and said to watch people's traffic patterns.
1:01:36 Speaker 01 Yeah. And so part of what we're doing, we're not in shopping malls. We're used a lot in space planning. So working With large people who have real estate, like you take a meeting room like this, is it used 80% of the time or 20% of the time? And of the 80% of the time it's used, does it have six people in it or two people in it?
1:01:54 Speaker 00 Right.
1:01:54 Speaker 01 And it doesn't matter if you're a small building, but if you're in a
1:01:58 Speaker 00 See, you bring a fresh idea, computer, but it's sensors. I'm obsessed with sensors.
1:02:01 Speaker 01 It's sensors.
1:02:02 Speaker 00 Sensors. I talk about sensors a lot. There's gonna be sensors everywhere.
1:02:04 Speaker 01 And industrial scale sensors. And I've invested in six companies in the category and across all different applications. But other examples, insurance policies, like if you can't have too many people in a room, we're doing line busting. So you can actually see how many people are on the line at certain places that you want to go. We're helping businesses with things that sound mundane like HVAC, like when do you turn on your heating and electricity based on when employees come in?
1:02:29 Speaker 00 I think line mechanics are fascinating. I spent an hour talking to the Disney expert on this.
1:02:33 Speaker 01 If you're ever interested, I will show you a demo from Density that we have a real time monitor that shows you line patterns going into queuing up at restaurants.
1:02:43 Speaker 00 Ugh, I love that. Literally, I spent an hour with the Disney person in charge. Like, that person's a genius because they know how to move people around and
1:02:49 Speaker 01 It's important.
1:02:49 Speaker 00 Things they say and signage and how you signal crowds and it was riveting.
1:02:54 Speaker 01 The other thing that businesses don't know a lot about is something called tailgating. So when you go into a building and someone swipes their card, people follow them in even though they're not supposed to, right? And so with Density, we can track tailgating and we can help you know when there's a problem. But we do it with lasers, not cameras. So the important thing about that is we're building an anonymous service. In a world where people increasingly don't want to be monitored with cameras, we made a conscious choice to make it anonymous.
1:03:20 Speaker 00 Except we're always monitored.
1:03:22 Speaker 01 You may be monitored by other people, but we've made a conscious choice for people to not be monitored.
1:03:26 Speaker 00 That's fascinating. It's interesting because right now this Facebook thing's about that. What are you following you around?
1:03:31 Speaker 01 Yes.
1:03:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's a really interesting, you know, it's computer vision. I like that, Mark. That is, I really, you've made me think there for a second. I'm gonna come see all these companies. I want to finish up. You've run a big conference there too, where you have everybody in. You had the mayor, mayor of
1:03:47 Speaker 00 Los Angeles, who may be running for president, apparently.
1:03:49 Speaker 01 He said onstage with us that he is.
1:03:51 Speaker 00 That he is, okay. Is he going to have a good chance?
1:03:55 Speaker 01 I think he's probably one of six or eight people who could really do it.
1:03:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:03:58 Speaker 01 And I think he would make a great candidate.
1:04:00 Speaker 00 Yeah, it's interesting. I just did an interview with Anthony Scaramucci, and he thinks Trump will win if the Democrats put up a communist, essentially. He thinks they're going to put up a communist, and that's why he's going to win. Instead of some... Garcetti's sort of in the middle, isn't he? Sort of more...
1:04:12 Speaker 01 I mean, he's definitely a Democrat.
1:04:13 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:04:14 Speaker 01 I think he's done a great job at protecting immigrants. He's done a great job at, you know, running the second-largest city in the country. I think he's right on a lot of positions, but he's very pro-tech. He's pro-innovation, he's pro-trade.
1:04:28 Speaker 00 But you do that in LA, you just sort of...
1:04:31 Speaker 01 I'm a big believer that international trade is a net positive for everybody. I don't think our ailment as a country is the fact that we're trading with Asia. I think we get a lot more benefit from cheap products provided to everyone that give them more disposable income. But I believe that we need to take the gains that we have from being in a world economy and invest them in education and infrastructure for people affected. And so I'm a Democrat, and I believe in taking those gains and reinvesting them. I'm not to the far left, so I don't believe in, like, Elizabeth Warren's view that we should not be part of TPP, because I believe that China will just dominate trade in Asia, and that's a lost opportunity for us.
1:05:13 Speaker 00 So, lastly, tell me one thing that people don't... Again, I don't want to regionalize you, but you are the most prominent venture capitalist in Los Angeles now. What is something that you think people should not... is wrong that people get up here and elsewhere about LA tech?
1:05:28 Speaker 01 The number-one narrative that people have about LA tech is they perceive it as just the place where you're building video and advertising and kind of lightweight tech.
1:05:39 Speaker 00 Right.
1:05:39 Speaker 01 And I think they misunderstand that we have phenomenal engineering talent that's... we're really building some big, ambitious projects. Some of them are going to be very successful. Maybe not at SpaceX level, but that's a phenomenal success. But I'll just give you a couple of examples, and I will mention that they are up-front coming. Companies so that I'm not sounding like I'm talking my playbook without disclosing that but Ubeam which is a wireless energy company that there's you know they've had some positive press and some skeptical press but they really are innovative and they've really pushed the boundaries. We have gotten direct feedback from the market that nobody has done the kind of wireless energy transfer that we've done.
1:06:16 Speaker 00 Great idea. We debrief them at all things.
1:06:17 Speaker 01 And Meredith, in fact, you're right. I remember that. And Meredith is just fantastic. And she's really truly an entrepreneur and innovator. And I think she's going to build something very successful. You never know. These are always risks. Another is Rebecca Kantar who has created a way to do cognitive assessment using computer games. So you run simulations where you have, I'll give you an example, a virtual world of fish, of coral, and plant types. And you have to assemble the right fish, coral, and plant types in an ocean environment with the right level of salinity and sunlight and depth to create a self-sustaining ecosystem. How you make the decisions tells something about how your
1:06:59 Speaker 01 brain processes information. And she built that because she wants the SAT to go away because she wants to teach children differently.
1:07:06 Speaker 00 The kids are about to take it. Very nervous.
1:07:09 Speaker 01 We're teaching rote memorization to children where rote memorization isn't what's required.
1:07:13 Speaker 00 No, she's thinking.
1:07:13 Speaker 01 So her first client is McKinsey. And they have used it to start to enhance their recruiting process. So they had, I don't know, 1,000 people go through it and compared it against their own recruiting process. And they like it so much that they're now embracing it as a technology. But that's being built in Los Angeles. It's real, true breakthrough technology.
1:07:34 Speaker 00 So the concept is, so it's the idea that it's not this like some latest
1:07:38 Speaker 01 We're building real technology.
1:07:39 Speaker 00 The latest Matt Damon startup, essentially. Although, does he have one?
1:07:42 Speaker 01 No, but like the Kardashians deserve a lot of credit.
1:07:46 Speaker 00 You know, I'm a big fan. You can't insult a Kardashian to me.
1:07:49 Speaker 01 They deserve a lot of credit.
1:07:51 Speaker 00 I had her on stage at Code Media. Everyone was shocked by it. I think they've done a lot of really interesting things, whether you like them or not, or like their messaging. It's still, they're very fascinating.
1:08:00 Speaker 01 They're amazing business people.
1:08:02 Speaker 00 Innovative people. They're amazing. Anyway, Mark Suster, thank you so much for being here.
1:08:07 Speaker 01 Thank you for having me. I appreciate it.
1:08:08 Speaker 00 I'm sorry I fluff your name all the time. But it was great talking to you. Thanks for coming on the show. You're one of my favorite VCs to talk to because you're so smart. And I don't know if you know this, not all of them are. But thanks again for coming. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcast for more. If you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about the show. That helps other people discover great interviews like this one. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other Recode Radio podcasts on Recode Media with Peter Kafka. You'll hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment, some of whom apparently live in Los Angeles. I also host Too Embarrassed to Ask, where we answer all of your questions about consumer tech. And on Recode Replay,
1:08:52 Speaker 00 you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including the Code Conference and Code Media, and our recent Code Commerce, which took place in Las Vegas last night. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode, and thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
1:09:12 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by IBM. By 2050, the world population will reach nearly 10 billion, and food production will need to grow by 70%. Farmers are working with IBM and Watson to help increase their crop yields. Let's put smart to work. Find out how at ibm.com/smart.
Previous Recode Decode: BlackBerry CEO John Chen Next Recode Decode: Joanna Coles, author, 'Love Rules' Page updated October 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated