Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Margrethe Vestager, Commissioner for Competition, European Commission About this episode In this special bonus episode, Margrethe Vestager, Europe's Commissioner for Competition, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about the high-profile cases she has brought against Apple and Google for alleged unfair tax breaks and antitrust violations, respectively. Vestager says "there is a limit to everything," including the assistance successful companies should get from the government, and their access to consumers' data. She rejects President Obama's past allegation of European regulators singling out American companies, and explains why Silicon Valley should be put under the microscope.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, hosted by Kara Swisher, powered by digital media.
0:07 Speaker 01 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You may know me as Silicon Valley's least diplomatic person, but in my spare time, I talk tech and you're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. You can subscribe to Recode Decode at iTunes.com/RecodeDecode, and while you're there, leave us a review. This week, we're running a bonus episode of Recode Decode because we have a very special guest. Today in the red chair is Margrethe Vestager, the Commissioner for Competition for the European Commission, which is the executive arm of the EU. Commissioner Vestager was formerly a member of the Danish Parliament from 2001 to 2014. Commissioner Vestager has been somewhat of a thorn in the side of US tech companies,
0:52 Speaker 01 which are used to getting exactly what they want from US regulators, not from Commissioner Vestager. She brought formal antitrust charges against Google three times in 2015, something her predecessor had been exploring for several years prior. And most recently, she brought a case against Apple for paying low, low taxes in Ireland and is looking to recover almost $15 billion in past taxes. Welcome to the show.
1:17 Speaker 02 Well, it's a pleasure to be here, and obviously an honor too.
1:20 Speaker 01 Yeah, exactly. You're here in Washington, correct? What are you doing here now? And I want to get into your background, because I think people don't know, everyone in Silicon Valley is aware of you.
1:28 Speaker 02 Well, basically, I come to Washington a couple of times a year, sort of on a strictly business basis, talk to my counterparts of the Federal Trade Commission or the DOJ, give an occasional talk, very often in a lawyer or academic environment. And when I'm here, of course, take the opportunity to talk to people.
1:48 Speaker 01 Right, exactly. Regulators, other regulators like you.
1:51 Speaker 02 That'd be other regulators, that would be media, that would be people like you, because I think that... Any start of uh of finding out new things and try to breach uh differences is of course that we talk.
2:04 Speaker 01 Right. How do you find Washington?
2:06 Speaker 02 Oh, I'm loving it.
2:06 Speaker 01 Do you? Why is that? No one says that.
2:08 Speaker 02 Well, because I have a a trail that I jog while I'm here and I think that the reflecting pond and the Washington uh Memorial and and and the Lincoln Memorial is uh some of the most beautiful sort of
2:21 Speaker 01 Very moving.
2:22 Speaker 02 man-made places.
2:23 Speaker 01 It's surprising, doesn't it? Doesn't it surprise you how much it moves you when you see them?
2:27 Speaker 02 And the thing is, I think it was uh not last time, but the previous time I was here, it has been snowing.
2:32 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
2:33 Speaker 02 And you know, I was running in the morning, there was no one there and there was just this new snow that had fallen. It was still dark.
2:39 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
2:40 Speaker 02 And the Lincoln Memorial, it just, you know, it took me, you know, so I got goosebump and and I felt, you know, this very strong presence of US history and American culture.
2:50 Speaker 01 Yeah, absolutely. Well, that's very nice. It's interesting. It's interesting you say that. Um I have a lot. I when I told tech people I was interviewing you, they had a lot of questions.
2:56 Speaker 02 Okay.
2:57 Speaker 01 So they're very interested in what you do think of American, American, American companies. But let's talk a little bit about your background. I think people don't realize you you entered politics very young, at a very young age, at twenty-nine, is that correct?
3:08 Speaker 02 Well, actually, even even before that, but uh I when I was very young, I took no interest in party politics.
3:14 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
3:15 Speaker 02 Uh my sort of uh line of interest was how can you be part of and influence the society that you live in?
3:22 Speaker 01 Right. You were an economics major, correct?
3:24 Speaker 02 Yes, I was. And and then I got sort of drawn into sort of some more conventional politics in the Socialist Party in Denmark. But uh but my background, my both my father and my mother being uh ministers in the Danish People's Church.
3:38 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
3:39 Speaker 02 Sort of, you know, it gave this very fundamental value that you should take part in your community.
3:45 Speaker 01 Right, right. And I I did you always want to do that? Did you want to be?
3:48 Speaker 02 Oh, no, no, no, no. It's just a matter of me not being able to say no.
3:52 Speaker 01 So what did that give you? Your parents both being Lutheran ministers, is that correct?
3:56 Speaker 02 Yes.
3:56 Speaker 01 What did that what did that instill in you in terms of just being part of a a larger community or doing, you know, Denmark is a very different country than the US and there's a great social contract going on there with people?
4:07 Speaker 02 Yes, and it's a society with a very short distance between people in power and the electorate.
4:15 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
4:16 Speaker 02 So you you feel very strongly that you represent something who have a real interest in in what you're doing.
4:22 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
4:23 Speaker 02 And uh where I grew up. Um, it was a very open home.
4:28 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
4:28 Speaker 02 You would find anyone who would come there, people who needed marriage counselling, people who wanted to get married. Uh, if there's been a sudden death, people who were very poor, people who were very well off. They would all come and be part of a very sort of lively uh home, where you found a lot of discussions uh. But also a lot of engagement.
4:50 Speaker 01 Right. And then you moved quickly after college into or university.
4:54 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
4:55 Speaker 01 Um, into the party that you were part of. And you did a variety of jobs when you were there, correct?
5:00 Speaker 02 Yes.
5:00 Speaker 01 You did.
5:01 Speaker 02 I was both.
5:01 Speaker 01 Go into that a little bit?
5:02 Speaker 02 Well, I was both the sort of the organizational uh head of uh of the party. Uh, I did a number of of different things in in that uh doing that. And then I became. In ninety-eight, the Minister of Education and Ecclesiastical Affairs.
5:20 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
5:21 Speaker 02 Then we lost the election in two thousand and one and became part of the opposition. Then two thousand and seven, I became also the political head of our party.
5:30 Speaker 01 Very powerful.
5:31 Speaker 02 Well, it very much depends. Danish politics is very, very different from US politics.
5:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. I was trying to watch Borgon last night, which is supposedly partially based on you a little bit.
5:40 Speaker 02 Yes, and the thing is that actually it's quite a a nice and accurate portrait of uh. Of Danish politics and I think also sort of the Scandinavian atmosphere when it comes to politics. And I know that a lot of people appreciate it because it's another look upon politics than what you get from House of Cards.
5:57 Speaker 01 Right, yeah. Well, that's how our politics works. We're always murdering people right and left. That must be a horrible show to see from somewhere else, imagining it, watching it.
6:05 Speaker 02 But it was a little too dark for me anyway.
6:07 Speaker 01 Yeah, yeah, you haven't pushed anyone in front of a train lately.
6:09 Speaker 02 No.
6:09 Speaker 01 Okay. Um, so when you were in government, you you did a lot of economic policy. And one of them was, at one point you were cutting benefits at one point, which was quite controversial in Denmark. Can you talk a little bit about that? Because people sort of see, in Silicon Valley at least, see you as not that, like the idea of. You know, you were more tough than most Danish politicians.
6:30 Speaker 02 Well, what was important for us was to make sure that the Danish economy was sustainable.
6:34 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
6:35 Speaker 02 That we could sort of stay in charge of our our spending and our debts. In order not to run into a situation where, you know, other people would would want to take over.
6:46 Speaker 01 Sure.
6:47 Speaker 02 So we did away on a very, very long transition period with sort of a a pre-retirement scheme, not for people who were, you know, run down by the job they were doing, but people who could work but who were able to retire quite early around the the age of, I think, sixty or something like that. So gradually we did away with that. And now we have one of the lowest unemployment rates among senior members of the working community. I think the most controversial thing was that we shortened the the period where you can get unemployment benefit from four years to to two.
7:25 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
7:26 Speaker 02 In order to sort of challenge the labour market to be more open.
7:30 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
7:31 Speaker 02 Uh, because one of the worst thing that can happen, at least in the Danish society, is the long-term unemployment.
7:36 Speaker 01 Right.
7:37 Speaker 02 It gets more and more difficult to get back.
7:39 Speaker 01 To create jobs.
7:40 Speaker 02 In a job situation. And what we see is that also on your self-esteem, your look upon yourself, your skills, your competences, actually the damaging effects begin to take place already after six months.
7:54 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
7:55 Speaker 02 We thought, or from our part, it was of the best of intentions, but for quite obvious reasons by some.
8:02 Speaker 01 It's expensive.
8:03 Speaker 02 It was seen as a very hostile act towards people who who were unemployed for a period of time.
8:09 Speaker 01 Right. So let's fast forward to going on to the European Commission. Obviously, you could have been Prime Minister, you could have been anything. And and why did you want to take this job? And you started off in a different job there?
8:18 Speaker 02 Well, the thing was that I had been a a legislator in in different positions for more than twenty years. And I found that it would be, you know, an amazing privilege to work more with enforcement.
8:34 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
8:35 Speaker 02 Because I, to still a larger degree, I had this. Feeling that we put a lot of effort into uh creating new legislation. But too little effort into implementation.
8:47 Speaker 01 Um hum.
8:48 Speaker 02 And too little effort into enforcing.
8:50 Speaker 01 Right.
8:51 Speaker 02 And I think it takes, you know, it takes a lot of political leadership actually to implement.
8:57 Speaker 01 Um hum.
8:58 Speaker 02 And to enforce new legislation because this is when we change.
9:01 Speaker 01 Right, right. When you haven't been shy about that at all, you jumped right in when you had the competition job. It's called the commissioner of competition. What does that mean to you? What does that mean? Because other people feel that it means different things from your point of view.
9:14 Speaker 02 Well, to me, it means uh making sure that everyone has a fair chance of making it.
9:18 Speaker 01 Um hum.
9:19 Speaker 02 To keep a level playing field. To make sure that you are challenged by quality, new products, prices, the services that you can provide.
9:30 Speaker 01 Um hum.
9:31 Speaker 02 So that you have a fair chance of making it. No guarantees, of course, but that you have a fair chance of making it. Even if you're a small company, big company, European, national, foreign, publicly owned, privately owned. Uh so that citizen experience that the market is fair and open.
9:47 Speaker 01 Um hum. Now, you have taken, let's go to the topics that you've been enforcing, because you have been. You could call yourself the enforcer, which is, which is something that's irked Silicon Valley a lot. And even in an interview I did with President Obama, he talked about protectionism and things like that. We'll get to that in a second. But I'd like to sort of go through some of the actions you've taken, because there's been a lot. And a lot of them are aimed at Silicon Valley tech companies and they're sort of, they've hit back pretty hard at you at the same time. I guess let's go backwards, I guess. Apple. Tell me about Apple.
10:19 Speaker 02 Well, in Europe, we have um three tools when it comes to to fair competition.
10:25 Speaker 01 Um hum.
10:25 Speaker 02 One is antitrust.
10:26 Speaker 01 Um hum.
10:27 Speaker 02 One is merger control, and the third is state aid control.
10:30 Speaker 01 Um hum.
10:30 Speaker 02 And the third you don't have in the States. In the very beginning of the European Community, our founding fathers found that no specific company should be able to outcompete other companies with taxpayers' money
10:44 Speaker 01 Right.
10:45 Speaker 02 in their bank.
10:46 Speaker 01 So these are special tax breaks.
10:47 Speaker 02 These are special tax breaks, they are selective, they give you an advantage which is not open to other companies.
10:54 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
10:55 Speaker 02 And, and this is the case in, in the Apple case.
10:58 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
10:58 Speaker 02 That we find that through two tax rulings, Ireland has enabled Apple to be taxed very, very lightly on the profits, uh, that they themselves.
11:10 Speaker 01 And it's fifty euros in every million dollars in profit.
11:13 Speaker 02 Made in Europe and booked in, in Ireland.
11:15 Speaker 01 Booked in Ireland. So one of the, you said if taxes are not being paid by some, then they have to be paid by others, and that is why it is not fair competition when some member states hand out selective tax benefits. Now, Ireland has a reason for doing this, they want to attract Apple and, and they have a number of US companies, it's actually well-known for it. They look at these, and I know Ireland is, is opposing what you're doing.
11:36 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
11:37 Speaker 01 They look at these as ways to attract investment and jobs and things like that. How do you, what do you say when they say that to you?
11:44 Speaker 02 Well, I say, well, you do that already.
11:46 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
11:46 Speaker 02 Uh, I think Ireland has the most attractive corporate tax level in Europe, it's twelve and a half percent.
11:51 Speaker 01 Twelve and a half percent, mm-hmm.
11:52 Speaker 02 And, uh, that in combination with having access to a single market of five hundred million potential customers.
11:59 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
12:00 Speaker 02 Uh, very good infrastructure, also digital infrastructure, very skilled population, both in Ireland but also in general in Europe.
12:07 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
12:08 Speaker 02 Very high quality of R and D. So the reasons to do business in Europe is piling up, but tax avoidance should not be one of those reasons.
12:16 Speaker 01 It shouldn't be a tool.
12:17 Speaker 02 No.
12:17 Speaker 01 Because tax breaks have been going on forever, for lots and lots of companies, here in the United States and different states when they move there and things like that.
12:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, but I think you also have sort of a different culture.
12:28 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
12:28 Speaker 02 Uh, I think it's, or at least I've been told that it's much more common that you negotiate your tax arrangements in the state where you have your
12:38 Speaker 01 Sure.
12:38 Speaker 02 headquarter or your activities.
12:40 Speaker 01 Or you want to move it to.
12:41 Speaker 02 And it's not the same thing in Europe.
12:43 Speaker 01 Because?
12:45 Speaker 02 I think, well, we have another tradition and another culture, maybe also a slightly higher level of transparency.
12:52 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
12:53 Speaker 02 And as I said, we have a very longstanding tradition for looking into whether some companies are getting selective advantages, not open to the rest of the business community.
13:04 Speaker 01 Would you be surprised that they would give Apple, a company like Apple, better advantages, or do you feel like everyone should get the same? Because Apple's obviously a high-profile company, products are well-known across the world, and they tend to go in places and get better deals than other people.
13:17 Speaker 02 Well, I think that any company should compete on the quality of their products, the prices, the novelties that they can produce, the services, and I do hope that companies grow on that basis, because that would be fair competition.
13:34 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
13:35 Speaker 02 If you're in a situation where your pay or your effective tax rate is so much lower
13:41 Speaker 01 Almost zero.
13:42 Speaker 02 than any other company, well, then obviously you have a much better position when it comes to compete with
13:51 Speaker 01 With prices.
13:52 Speaker 02 With prices and everything else.
13:53 Speaker 01 Right. So, you know, it was interesting, because Tim Cook is not really known for being outspoken or very difficult, I'm sure he's difficult to you, but he said, "It's total political crap." You saw this quote, "They just picked a number from I don't know where." Were you expecting that response from Apple?
14:09 Speaker 02 Well, I don't do that kind of predictions. It was
14:13 Speaker 01 What you're thinking about, if you're gonna, I think it was fourteen billion dollars?
14:16 Speaker 02 Yeah, but the thing is that, well, it is obvious when you do casework like this that both the country in question and the company in question, they disagree.
14:26 Speaker 01 Right. The US Treasury did the same, because they want the money also, correct?
14:31 Speaker 02 Yes, but we can come back to that.
14:33 Speaker 01 Yeah, okay.
14:34 Speaker 02 But the thing is that any decision that we take in the commission can be appealed to the European courts.
14:39 Speaker 01 Sure.
14:40 Speaker 02 And that is an obvious reason for doing sort of the casework based on facts and the evidence of the case. But also in itself I think to do a a robust investigation based on the fact of the case. Well, that is the value that what has been going on for for decades by now. Uh, and I think it is very important that you do not let the politics of the day or party politics or affiliation. Influence that. Because uh, when you want competition on the marriage, then you have to base your casework on facts.
15:13 Speaker 01 Right. So what can you walk us through how you decided to aim at Apple? Was it just an egregious example from your opinion or what was the?
15:20 Speaker 02 Well, actually, it was my predecessor.
15:21 Speaker 01 Yes.
15:22 Speaker 02 Uh, who opened the case.
15:24 Speaker 01 Several of them were like that.
15:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, and he was able to do that because of information that came out. Through hearings in the US Senate.
15:31 Speaker 01 The US Senate, right.
15:32 Speaker 02 Because it is no secret that we've been doing state aid control for decades. What was secret was the tax rulings and the Apple numbers. Because back then, there was very little transparency. As to uh, how the company was organized, what they generated of profits and how they were booked and taxed. So I don't think it was possible to do the case. Before the the US Senate hearings started, because that sort of. Gave the concerns that my predecessor then acted upon to open the case.
16:06 Speaker 01 To open the case and you've been carrying them out, which is really interesting. So the US Treasury also opposed. What you're doing largely because they want the money, they want the money repatriated to the United States. How do you look at that, their objections?
16:19 Speaker 02 Well, we have two different tax system, um, not that I in any detail know the US uh, tax system, but you have a more sort of a global approach. Where in Europe, we would think that uh, profits are to be taxed where profits are generated.
16:33 Speaker 01 Right, in Europe.
16:34 Speaker 02 Uh, and here you talk about profits being generated in Europe and booked by Apple themselves in Europe. Uh, which is why we think they should also be taxed uh, in Europe. Then very often you would have tax treaties to make sure that you do not have double taxation.
16:50 Speaker 01 Sure.
16:51 Speaker 02 That you get a tax credit when you pay taxes in in other countries. But then again, it is important to make sure that those tax treaties do not then enable double non-taxation.
17:02 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
17:03 Speaker 02 Uh, because they actually have the opposite aim.
17:05 Speaker 01 Mm hmm. So where does it go next from here with Apple? Are you in negotiations with them, the US Treasury Department?
17:10 Speaker 02 No, the next thing to happen is for for Ireland to themselves to calculate the unpaid taxes.
17:16 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
17:17 Speaker 02 For the unpaid taxes to be recovered, put in an ISCO account, closed account. Uh, and then the Irish have said that they will appeal the case and then, of course, the court will start its proceedings.
17:27 Speaker 01 And where is Apple in this? What do they need to do?
17:30 Speaker 02 Well, they that depends very much on themselves, but for us, since what we do in this third tool of of competition law enforcement, we deal with the government. It's it's the government. It is the state to whom we direct the decision.
17:44 Speaker 01 What did you, when you were doing this, obviously, this is the most famous company in the world, one of them, one of the most famous companies in the world. Some people called you a superhero for doing it, others not so much. It's sort of the opposite. What kind of political pressure are you under when you pull out the big names like this, where you go after these companies?
18:01 Speaker 02 Well, the thing is that we try to, you know, stay sort of clear of the politics.
18:07 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
18:07 Speaker 02 Uh, because we cannot allow that to interfere with the casework.
18:11 Speaker 01 Mm hmm. But you didn't pick just any company, Apple. You must be aware.
18:15 Speaker 02 But the thing is that also we have taken decisions on Fiat, the European car company, and Starbucks, and the Belgian scheme where a number of European multinationals were involved. And to me, the important thing is that citizens find that someone is looking after that. Not only most companies, but all companies do pay their taxes.
18:39 Speaker 01 Have you met with Apple?
18:40 Speaker 02 Not after the decision.
18:41 Speaker 01 Not after the decision, no. All right, we're here with Commissioner Margrethe Vestager
18:46 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
18:46 Speaker 01 of the European Commission. She is the Competition Commissioner. We're going to take a quick break for a word from our sponsor. When we get back, we're going to talk about data, which is the big issue that Silicon Valley has with the European Commission, and there's been a lot of wrangling over it. Today's show is sponsored by Casper, which has made a perfect mattress and sells it directly to consumers to save you money. The Casper is an obsessively engineered mattress at a shockingly fair price. It combines springy latex and supportive memory foams to create an award-winning sleep surface with just the right sink and just the right bounce. Time Magazine named it one of the best inventions of 2015. Shipping to both the US and Canada is completely free, and there's a 100-day, risk-free trial and return policy. If you don't love your Casper mattress, they'll pick it up and refund everything. These mattresses
19:31 Speaker 01 are made in America. Get $50 towards any mattress purchase by visiting casper.com/recode and using the promo code RECODE. Stop paying for the mattress industry's inflated prices. Go to casper.com/recode and use the promo code RECODE. Terms and conditions apply.
19:50 Speaker 03 Hello, I'm Peter Kafka, and I am the host of Recode Media. Every week, I sit down with some of the smartest and most interesting people in media, people like daring fireballs John Gruber, New York columnist Malcolm Gladwell, full frontal host Samantha Bee. These are smart, fun, unscripted interviews, because they're interviews, that's the whole point, with people who make stuff that you see, hear, and read every day. Probably want to know more about them, right? No problem. Listen to Recode Media on iTunes, Google Play Music, anywhere you listen to podcasts. We will see you there.
20:17 Speaker 01 We're back with Margareta Vestager, Europe's Commissioner for Competition, who has become a controversial figure in Silicon Valley for a bunch of things, including putting, declaring that Apple owed $15 billion, $14 billion in back taxes and possible interest, and some other things. But one of the areas that she's really been tough on with Silicon Valley, with Google, Facebook, and others, is data. Data is a big issue all over the world. Privacy is also a big issue. You brought formal antitrust charges against Google on a number of issues around Android, around its services, antitrust issues around its services, and then most recently about its advertising practices. Talk a little bit about going after Google in Europe.
20:58 Speaker 02 Well, actually, the thing is that what we are aiming at is a certain behavior. And the case has started a long time ago with my predecessor.
21:09 Speaker 01 Again, are the only one enforcing it.
21:11 Speaker 02 Yes, again. It takes some time. The case worked now. But the thing is that... What the commission acted upon then was complaints from a number of both European and US companies.
21:21 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
21:22 Speaker 02 Who found that uh Google practices were harmful uh for them.
21:27 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
21:28 Speaker 02 So now we have uh three different cases and we have sent what we call a statement of objection in in all three cases. First one is a case where we found that Google used their dominance in general search to promote themselves in a neighboring market.
21:42 Speaker 01 In their services.
21:43 Speaker 02 In uh.
21:44 Speaker 01 Shopping services.
21:45 Speaker 02 Shopping comparison.
21:46 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
21:47 Speaker 02 I think that triggered a number of the complaints that they found that it was very difficult to compete in a market where Google was so dominant. Second case is a case about um advertising. How can hand can sort of intermediaries be in this ve- very valuable market uh where Google put a a number of restrictions as to where should our ads be put, uh what number of them.
22:10 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
22:11 Speaker 02 And then we have the third case, which is a case where we have found that Android uh is being used as a tool to enable Google to stay dominant also when our search becomes mobile.
22:23 Speaker 01 Mobile search.
22:24 Speaker 02 Because uh Android is, in in my view, a very, very interesting operating system. It's open source, a lot of good things can be said about it. So it's not the Android system as such, it is the way that it is used with manufacturers of original equipment in order seemingly to make sure that when you open the box and you get the first-hand experience, it's a Google experience, and then why look for something else?
22:50 Speaker 01 Right, right. Well, I think that was the point of them inventing Android, I believe, for to keep search going in the mobile environment. I think they don't really not say that, because I think they had issues around the desktop search dying.
22:59 Speaker 02 Oh, yes, but I think everyone has an issue with dex- desktop uh research.
23:03 Speaker 01 Well, Google would have most of the issue, because it's the se- the core of their business is that.
23:07 Speaker 02 But I think everyone is thinking about it, and I think a lot of uh citizens very much appreciate it.
23:12 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
23:13 Speaker 02 That now you can be on the go.
23:14 Speaker 01 Sure, absolutely, absolutely. But I think that they, so you're saying they're enabling it so that they get the advantage again. It's all about advantage.
23:21 Speaker 02 It's a great thing, but but the thing is that if you then adopt a behavior. Where you you do something which is not by the book in Europe. In order to stay dominant. And not, you know, let your sort of your competitive edge. Make you stay dominant, but your behavior, that's that are two different things.
23:40 Speaker 01 Are they doing precisely from your point of view that that they're doing that they feel that they're innovative and they're the best. They have ninety percent of the market in Europe now, I think, something like that.
23:48 Speaker 02 Oh, but obviously they are innovating, you know, I am so old that I can remember the internet before Google search, so. Obviously, for for a number of reasons, they have, it's an amazing company that has produced amazing products that have enabled. A number of amazing and very good things. But what we have found in in the Android case is that for, since it's it's open source, you can do an Android fork. But it seems to be very, very difficult to find a manufacturer that would actually produce a phone for you to put your Android Android fork. And we have found that it was very difficult to get, for instance, the Google search without also taking more. Uh, Google services on board to have a full Google suite.
24:33 Speaker 02 So that when you open your box and you have the out of the box experience, it is a Google experience and then it's a one way Google street. And it's very difficult to find a a turn to go somewhere else.
24:45 Speaker 01 Do you consider them to be like Microsoft back in the operating system days where Microsoft had dominance on the desktop?
24:51 Speaker 02 Uh, no, actually not. Of course, you can find similarities between the cases, but since so many things have changed before then. I think there are a number of differences as well.
25:02 Speaker 01 Such as?
25:04 Speaker 02 Also, to the environment where they work, uh, it's two different companies with different behavior, different corporate cultures. And also the way we behave as customers and the competitive landscape is very different from what it was.
25:18 Speaker 01 Did you find, the US had looked into these issues, similar issues and passed. What did you think of that when they did that with the FTC, all kinds of government agencies and then they, to me, they rolled over quite a bit on a lot of these issues. And said they couldn't find proof, they couldn't.
25:34 Speaker 02 But, but it is not for, for me or, or my services to redo, uh, what they do. And actually, a number of things are, are different. Uh, also in the Google market share in the U S compared to, to Europe.
25:46 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
25:47 Speaker 02 So even though we work together very, very closely on a number of cases, of course, we completely accept if we do things and they don't.
25:55 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. Do you, um, when we get into this idea of data, I think a lot of it is, would they paid for their services? What if people paid for services from these people? Um, would that assuage the problem if you got the Google service and then you got to pick what you wanted and paid for it?
26:10 Speaker 02 Oh, but you do pay.
26:11 Speaker 01 Yes, you do. Yeah, usually through advertising and other ways.
26:13 Speaker 02 Yes, you do pay, uh, you do pay either by looking at, at ads or by, by giving up your data.
26:20 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
26:20 Speaker 02 I'm an economist so much that I know that there's no such thing as a free lunch.
26:24 Speaker 01 No, absolutely not.
26:24 Speaker 02 Uh, so you pay with one currency or another.
26:28 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
26:28 Speaker 02 Either Sense, EuroSense or, or Yousense, or you pay with your data, or you pay with the advertisement that you accept.
26:36 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
26:37 Speaker 02 So, of course, you pay.
26:39 Speaker 01 Right.
26:39 Speaker 02 And I think people become more and more aware of the fact that their personal data actually do, uh, have a value.
26:46 Speaker 01 It's being used by Facebook and Google and Apple and Snapchat now and others.
26:50 Speaker 02 So people realize this to completely different level. And what we see in Europe is that a huge proportion of citizens find that they're not in control.
27:00 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
27:01 Speaker 02 They distrust the companies to protect their data. And I think that is very bad.
27:06 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
27:07 Speaker 02 Because then, then there is a risk of, uh, of withdrawing from all the benefits of our digital economy.
27:16 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
27:17 Speaker 02 Uh, and in order to build up trust, I think it is very, very important that we enforce privacy rules, that we get privacy by design.
27:26 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
27:26 Speaker 02 Uh, in new services, so that privacy is not just an add-on, but it is the very basic in, in the way you do the services.
27:34 Speaker 01 Why do you not believe individuals can make these decisions themselves, for themselves? I mean, that's the, our, U S argument is that, or the U S companies' argument is that individuals should be able to make these decisions for themselves and regulators in Europe should not be the ones making that for them, mouthing their.
27:48 Speaker 02 Yes, but I, I think then we have different traditions because in, in Europe, we have had a... A single market, which has been sort of framed with democratic decision making from the very beginning. Democratic decision making on safety standard, environmental standards, um, consumer protection, privacy protection, et cetera, et cetera. So for us, it's a very strong tradition to say, well, as a small individual in this gigantic market, uh, you don't have to know everything yourself because there are laws to protect you. So that you can trust, uh, the market and the services that you use to be there for
28:33 Speaker 02 you. Uh, so for us, it's part of the trust in the market that we have this regulation. And the European Parliament and our council passed the legislation some month ago, which will be in, in place by two thousand eighteen, which will be simpler, but also stronger in order to, to enable citizens to feel that they're in control.
28:55 Speaker 01 Do you imagine there's ever not a gulf existing because the, the privacy issues in Europe are much, they have much stronger protections, there's much different cultural attitudes towards protections, and yet they've all embraced these digital technologies largely right now from the US. Is there, is there a place of, is there a, a center place or not, or just that they have to live by your rules when they're operating in Europe?
29:18 Speaker 02 Well, I think you have more, more things that, uh, play at the same time. Uh, because you'd find that some US companies are doing better in Europe than they do here. A lot of Europeans embrace these companies and find that they're great. Uh, I come from Denmark and, and there you find it, I think, more than anywhere else. Highly digital, the community, old as well as young people, uh, on Facebook, uh, WhatsApp, Snapchat, whatever.
29:43 Speaker 01 Another company you're looking into, the data or on WhatsApp?
29:45 Speaker 02 Anyone, you know, excited about the new opportunities. At the same time, well, then you find that there must be, you know, reasonable protection that I, I own my pictures, my data, that I can control them. Who are they given to and what are they used for? And I think that comes from a very strong European culture of wanting to know that, well, I know who I am and I know my relationship with the people who sell me things and I would like to be in control.
30:17 Speaker 01 Why do you think these companies are doing things? Some, are they malevolent or do they just, they just want to grab every piece of data possible in order to facilitate their businesses? How do you look at them as a regulator?
30:28 Speaker 02 Well, I think it's a completely honest thing to want to do business.
30:31 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
30:32 Speaker 02 It's a good thing to wanting to make it, both to make money and to be a success in the marketplace, to get the attention of customers. That's the very sort of basics, otherwise no jobs would be created.
30:45 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
30:46 Speaker 02 And I think that, I don't sort of, I'm not in the business of pointing fingers or blaming companies because I think for most companies it's completely open and honest thing that they want to do business and they want to do great.
30:59 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
31:00 Speaker 02 But there is a limit to everything and even though-
31:03 Speaker 01 Oh, not for them. Have you met them?
31:05 Speaker 02 Well, you know, in Europe, we would congratulate anyone who's successful.
31:08 Speaker 01 Yeah.
31:09 Speaker 02 And you can grow and you can be dominant and we have done that, but congratulation stops if we find that you start to misuse a dominant position.
31:18 Speaker 01 Why do you think they're misusing it?
31:20 Speaker 02 Well, first of all, we got complaints about it and then we found evidence, which makes us think that they actually did it.
31:27 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
31:28 Speaker 02 And some of the consequences may of course be that smaller companies may find that it's not any more worthwhile to try to do something new because they will never be able to show it to the customer, the potential customer.
31:41 Speaker 01 Because Google and others are in the way. When we get back, we're going to talk a little bit about that idea because in an interview with President Obama, he accused the European Union of protectionism and other things. So let's get to that because I think a lot of companies in Silicon Valley also say that and that most of the companies in the US are the most innovative ones and they're being stopped dead in Europe. We're here with Commissioner Margrethe Vestager of the European Commission. She's head of the Competition Commission. We're going to take a quick break and we'll get back and talk about that. We'd like to thank Qualcomm for sponsoring today's episode. We're currently reviewing submissions to the Why Wait Lunch Contest that I've been telling you about. But in the meantime, if you listen to this podcast, you love innovation. You're also going to love the Why Wait Invent Off by Qualcomm.
32:26 Speaker 01 It's an online documentary series in which two teams are challenged to invent something that uses the Internet of Things to save a life. The teams are given a Qualcomm Snapdragon-powered device and a DragonBoard 410C loaded with advanced processing power, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and GPS. And that DragonBoard is the size of a credit card. Check out qualcomm.com/inventoff to see what they invented. Thanks, Qualcomm. We're back with Margrethe Vestager, Europe's Commissioner for Competition, who has been aiming, I hate to use words like that, but at Google, Facebook, Apple. Who haven't you? I'm just trying to think of, you've been doing some tough actions against them, with
33:06 Speaker 01 Google especially, but also with Facebook and WhatsApp after you all approved the merger that happened, the use of data and things like that. When I was interviewing President Obama, I asked him about these different actions, and he said that it smacks a little bit of protectionism. How do you answer that? Because all the Silicon Valley companies say the same things, that Europe's being too protective of its own companies, and that most of the tech companies that are competitive these days are US companies. So it's an attempt to slow down inevitably more innovative US companies. How do you react to that? It's not me saying this.
33:40 Speaker 02 No, I, of course, but I think that kind of accusation quite seriously.
33:46 Speaker 01 Of bias.
33:47 Speaker 02 Of bias. Because one of our fundamental values is that we enforce competition law no matter the size of the company, if you're publicly or privately owned, if you are a EU national or you're owned by someone else in the global marketplace. And when I look into merger control, antitrust, state aid control, I find no US bias. That, of course, do not take feelings away, I realize that completely. But if you look at, for instance, in state aid cases over the last 15 years, from 2000 to 2015, well, we've done 150 cases with negative decisions where recovery has been ordered. And I think only
34:32 Speaker 02 A handful, two percent or something like that, ever involved US businesses.
34:37 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. Which European businesses that are digital have you gone after, though? Or are these just the big names?
34:42 Speaker 02 Oh, well, you find any kind of business, uh, because, uh...
34:46 Speaker 01 I'm talking about tech businesses.
34:47 Speaker 02 Yeah, but when you find state aid, uh, I think there is no sort of preferred taste.
34:52 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
34:52 Speaker 02 Uh, you would both find sort of traditional manufacturing businesses just as well as, uh, as tech businesses.
34:58 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
34:59 Speaker 02 But no, I don't think so. And I think if, if it was sort of the era where chemical businesses was those who sort of set the agenda, who was the driving forces in the economy, well, then you would find a lot of German cases, uh, uh, on our, our table because a lot of our chemical industry is, is German.
35:18 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
35:18 Speaker 02 I think it is much more because that it is the, the new industry, it is where you, you find sort of the driving forces in our economy.
35:26 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
35:26 Speaker 02 And that would also traditionally be where you find most antitrust cases.
35:30 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
35:31 Speaker 02 Not because they are, are US companies, but because that is where they are.
35:35 Speaker 01 So you don't feel like you have a bias toward US companies? When they shoot back at you saying that?
35:40 Speaker 02 Oh, no, no, not at all. And I don't, I don't find, what motive would I have?
35:43 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. Well, very, you know, recently in Britain, the Brexit, you know, too much regulation, that right now in this election here in the US, it's all about too much regulation, too much government, too much telling people what to do. And you can see those forces at work throughout the US economy.
35:58 Speaker 02 Yeah, but you know, when, when I was a child, there was no Harry Potter and the magic of, uh, of Hogwarts. It was Laura Ingalls, which was the series I read over and over and over again. And the magic back then...
36:12 Speaker 01 Commissioner Vesey loves America.
36:13 Speaker 02 It was, no, but it was the magic back then. It was hard work. It was engaging your community. It was, it was fairness.
36:20 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
36:21 Speaker 02 And, uh, and you know, I think these are very strong values.
36:24 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
36:25 Speaker 02 For everyone to contribute and for everyone to do their, uh, what they should in, uh, in the marketplace, in the community.
36:32 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm. So what do US companies have to do to change? Because they seem to be just opposing you rather strongly, which I think is the first move of any company when they feel themselves under legal attack.
36:42 Speaker 02 Well, you see, you find in, in the accounts of Apple Sales International already back then, I think in 2003, a statement saying that they realize that they pay, uh, low tax compared to, to the Irish tax code as such. And obviously, I think on on that realization, it is completely uh, on a thing to to place yourself where the tax code is favorable to any company in Ireland. It is twelve and a half percent.
37:09 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
37:10 Speaker 02 I'm the one promoting it the most in in these days.
37:12 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
37:13 Speaker 02 And that, of course, you you can have the the advantages of a of a favorable tax code. But that is another thing that uh you as a specific company getting a specific advantage, not open to your competitors, to other businesses uh, looking for funding or employees or whatever. And I I think as as part of the corporate responsibility is to make sure that not only most companies pay their taxes, but that all companies pay their taxes for reasons of fair competition.
37:43 Speaker 01 Same thing around data.
37:44 Speaker 02 Yes.
37:45 Speaker 01 Now, uh, we've got to finish up because I know you have places to go to important meetings in Washington. But do you agree with the idea that Europe is hostile to US companies? Or how do you put that back? Because I asked that question to President Obama. How do you answer that? You're not hostile, you don't?
38:01 Speaker 02 Well, I think it's very difficult to talk about Europe as one thing.
38:04 Speaker 01 Right.
38:04 Speaker 02 Uh, because you find different sentiments in in different parts of of Europe. I come from a country, it is small, I realize that, of course, but where you find that almost everything uh American is being embraced.
38:16 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
38:17 Speaker 02 And in in other countries, you find a different level of skepticism.
38:20 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
38:20 Speaker 02 Uh, so that would be quite diverse. Uh, what member states, you go to what would be sort of the approach and the appearance. But I think in general, if you boil it down, there is a great appreciation of shared values
38:35 Speaker 01 Mm hmm.
38:36 Speaker 02 and a transatlantic uh partnership.
38:38 Speaker 01 Are you technical? Do you find yourself, do you use technology? What do you use yourself? iPhone or?
38:43 Speaker 02 Yes, I use iPhone. I have uh two, one for work and one for private things and uh. And I try to, you know, stay on top of things, but having young daughters, I realize that it may be out of reach to be as, what is it that they call it?
39:00 Speaker 01 Tech savvy.
39:01 Speaker 02 Native in our digital world.
39:05 Speaker 01 Do you use Facebook and WhatsApp and other things like that?
39:07 Speaker 02 I use Facebook, but not at all as much as I use Twitter. Twitter is my favorite media.
39:13 Speaker 01 Uh oh, are you worried about what's gonna happen to it?
39:15 Speaker 02 No, not really.
39:17 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, we'll see. Wait, what if they get bought by Google or something like that? Perhaps you might have something to say about it. And your daughters, same thing? They use?
39:24 Speaker 02 Oh, yes, they do. Sometimes I think, you know, they're breathing through their phones, but it's, I think to a large degree, all the bad things being said, it's a great enabler because it allows you to stay in touch and to have sometimes very different relationship than we used to have back then when I was their age.
39:49 Speaker 01 All right. And last question, when do these actions end? They just continue through until there's either a settlement or a legal case?
39:57 Speaker 02 Well, it depends very much on the instrument. If it's an antitrust case, we can do basically two kinds of decisions, either prohibition with a fine, or we can do binding commitments, and as long as the company then honor those commitments, there will be no fine. If it's a merger issue, well, we always, of course, try to clear a merger because we want to enable business community to move on. If that's, if the merger is threatening sort of the competitive environment, they may offer divestments to facilitate competition. And when it comes to state aid, well, then unfortunately, sometimes we have these negative
40:38 Speaker 02 decisions where the state then have to recover unpaid taxes or grants or interest if it's a very favorable loan. So the instruments vary, and they're very different. They all have the same purpose, to enable fair competition.
40:55 Speaker 01 All right. Thank you so much, Commissioner Vestager, for coming in today. I know you're really busy.
40:59 Speaker 02 It was a pleasure being with you.
41:01 Speaker 01 Thanks so much. Thanks to Commissioner Vestager. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. Be the first to listen to future episodes or catch up on previous episodes, including some really fantastic interviews I've done with U.S. Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, AOL co-founder Steve Case, and the geography of Genius author Eric Weiner, just to name a few. Don't miss this week's first episode with John Hanke, which came out on Monday. We talked about Google, Pokemon Go, and the future of augmented reality. All those interviews and more are at recode.net/decode. Now that you're done with this, why not try one of our other podcasts? Recode Media with Peter Kafka comes out every Thursday. On Fridays, I host Too Embarrassed to Ask along with Lauren Good of The Verge. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from our events
41:46 Speaker 01 like the Code Conference, Peter Kafka's Code Media, and Jason Del Rey's Code Commerce. Thanks for listening. Thanks also to Digital Media, which distributes this show. This has been another episode of Recode Decode. Remember to subscribe to the show and leave us a review at iTunes.com/RecodeDecode. I'll be back here on Monday with another great guest. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: John Hanke, CEO, Niantic Next Recode Decode: Bradley Tusk, CEO, Tusk Holdings Page updated October 25, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated