Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Margrethe Vestager About this episode Margrethe Vestager, Europe's commissioner for competition, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher in front of a live audience at Web Summit 2017 in Lisbon, Portugal. Vestager explains how the E. U. is trying to make tech companies more transparent and accountable for their dealings and why a "free" market needs government intervention to function. She says the algorithms that control what content gets surfaced on social media may "have to go to law school" before we can trust them again, and that Facebook or Snapchat's priorities cannot be allowed to supersede democracy's.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, coming to you from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You may know me as a supporter of the right to be forgotten, although personally, I know I am unforgettable. But in my spare time, I talk tech and you're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. You'll find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to your podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcast. Today, we're going to play an interview I conducted at the 2017 Web Summit in Lisbon, Portugal. I talked to European Commissioner for Competition Marguerite Vestager, who you may have heard of on a previous episode of Recode Decode.
0:44 Speaker 00 Though the last time we talked was before the 2016 US presidential election, and a lot has changed since then. Let's take a listen. All right, let's get started because we have a very short time. So, Marguerite, how fucked is Silicon Valley?
1:00 Speaker 01 Well, I don't like to generalize, because everyone should have a fair chance of making it.
1:07 Speaker 00 Right.
1:08 Speaker 01 Also in Silicon Valley.
1:09 Speaker 00 Okay.
1:10 Speaker 01 But at least serious enough so that we found that a fine of 2.4 billion euros was the fine in the Google case that we just decided.
1:21 Speaker 00 So, talk about where it is now, because you've been out on the forefront of talking to these companies about their power, about their influence, and right now, in the United States, finally, in Congress, which has acted not at all, and our government has not acted very much against these companies, they're under a lot of, they're under siege, they're under pressure, especially about Russia investigations. Can you talk a little bit about why you first went for them? Because I think they don't have a sense of their power, and now people are recognizing the potential impact of what they've done.
1:53 Speaker 01 Well, all values are very simple. If you're successful in the market, it should be because you have the best product, that your customers like you, not because that you cut corners, or you get a tax break, or you don't inform authorities about how things actually are. And this is, this is the case of the Apple case of unpaid taxes, and the Google case of misusing a dominant position, or the Facebook fine of not giving sufficient information to authorities when assessing a case. And on top of sort of my day job as a commissioner of competition, I have this worry about what happens with our democracy.
2:37 Speaker 01 What happens with our way of being together, being social? And I think maybe sometimes the platform businesses, they underestimate the powers that they hold.
2:49 Speaker 00 All right, let's talk about that because right now, these investigations are, it's pretty clear these platforms were used and abused by others, in this case, Russia. And a lot of the indications point that it had an impact on the election. And of course, it's not just a US issue, it's a global issue, that these platforms have enormous influence over politics, society, culture, all kinds of things, including the coarsening of society. One of the things I've always talked about is the fact that they're not benign platforms and they see themselves that way. They often do. Can you talk about the challenge of dealing with these big companies? Because largely, they've been protected by the government in the US.
3:28 Speaker 01 Well, for us, the challenge is to develop the right tools. Because I find that sort of the founders of the European Union, they saw rightly that we need fair competition to have a fair market.
3:43 Speaker 00 Right.
3:43 Speaker 01 And I think the motives of breaching competition law, they are as old as Adam and Eve. It's about greed and fear. And when you combine that with power, you have a very, very poisoned cocktail. So the motives, well, they go way back. But our challenge is to stay fast enough and to have the right tools. Because this is fast-moving areas in our economy. And we really need to make sure that all the businesses, all the coming-ups, all the entrepreneurs have a fair chance of making it in this market to serve citizens in the role of customers.
4:22 Speaker 00 Do you imagine, though, that the damage is done? Because so many of these companies, right now, there's consolidation in the United States. There's, these companies are getting more powerful. One of the things that you'd been accused of by these companies is you're trying to stifle innovation, when in fact, they're getting more powerful than ever. So can you talk about that accusation that you're trying to do protectionist? Stifle innovation, not let them do what they do best.
4:48 Speaker 01 But on the contrary, because I think everyone here would like to be the next Google.
4:53 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
4:54 Speaker 01 Who doesn't want to build a success?
4:56 Speaker 00 Well, I don't, but go ahead.
4:57 Speaker 01 Well, you are a success already, so no need.
5:00 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:00 Speaker 01 No, but the thing is that, one thing is that when you grow.
5:04 Speaker 00 Yeah.
5:04 Speaker 01 You shouldn't deny others the chance to challenge you. And you should never yourself say, "No one will challenge me, so I don't need to innovate anymore."
5:14 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:15 Speaker 01 Competition is one of the most important drivers of innovation. Because you have to stay in the race, you have to think of something new. And if you don't, well, of course, you should leave the market. And this is again where competition law enforcement comes in, to make sure that it actually happens.
5:33 Speaker 00 So let's talk about the state of play with these fines that you've put in. You've levied these fines, the one, right now in the United States, there's tax reform going on to bring back some of these, such as the Apple taxes and the billions that are here. Can you talk about where they are at this point, what happens now?
5:52 Speaker 01 Well, the thing is that even if you repeal a case after a commission decision, you still have to pay the fine. Of course, if you win, then you get your money back. If you don't, well, we redistribute the fine to member states of the European Union. So the fines of the Google case, the guarantees has been made. The fines of the Facebook case has been paid. And now we're in the process of Ireland to recover the unpaid taxes of Apple.
6:20 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:21 Speaker 01 But the commission as such is also working on digitalized taxation as a matter of principle.
6:28 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:28 Speaker 01 Because corporate taxation was maybe invented in a time where you had a physical footprint. You were present in the country. Now you can be present in the country by buying more server space back home. So we need to reinvent corporate taxation to make sure that every company pays their fair share of taxes.
6:49 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by HP, which has a new podcast they'd like to tell you about.
6:53 Speaker 02 What does machine learning have to do with autonomous driving? How do you build a powerful, open-source community? Will the cloud really consume the world? Tune in to Stack That, a new podcast from Hewlett-Packard Enterprise to dive into the world of emerging trends and learn how you can leverage this tech for the benefit of your business. Each week, our hosts Byron Reese of GigaOm and Florian Leibert of Mesosphere will tackle a new topic with the help of guests from Airbnb, Google, Confluent, and other industry experts. Check out Stack That on iTunes, Google Play, SoundCloud, Stitcher, and news.hpe.com. And make sure to subscribe so you don't miss the latest episodes.
7:35 Speaker 03 Today's show is brought to you by Airtable. Spreadsheets were built for crunching numbers. Airtable is built for collaboration, and it's flexible enough to keep up with even the fastest-moving teams. Whether you're organizing clients and inventory for a boutique skiing agency, or the editorial calendar for a Fortune 500 company, see why more than 30,000 organizations trust Airtable to let them work the way they want. Visit airtable.com/recodecode to get $50 in free credits today.
8:07 Speaker 00 Well, talk a little bit about today's news, about the International Committee Investigative Journalists uncovered the Paradise Papers, which was essentially a scheme, it seems like a scheme, I'm trying to bring it down to a very simple level. It's rich people trying to hide their wealth, essentially, ultra-rich people. Can you talk a little bit about how you look at something like this? Because there were several tech companies involved, there were investments, there were hidden-in-shell companies, all kinds of things. So what was your thoughts today? Because it's a very complex and robust system to protect these companies and the people involved.
8:45 Speaker 01 Yeah, but that has to change.
8:47 Speaker 00 So how does that happen? Well, talk about what you thought today when you saw those.
8:51 Speaker 01 Well, I think, thanks to citizens, there's been an enormous pressure because of the Lux Leaks first and the Panama Papers, and now with the Paradise Papers, for legislation to change, for transparency. We would like to have also public, country-by-country reporting. Just report simple things. Do you have activities? Do you have employees? Do you make a profit? Do you pay your taxes? So that we know. And second, we would like also all the tax intermediaries, those who make this happen, to feel responsibility of enabling some businesses not to pay their taxes, where the many, many, many, many businesses,
9:35 Speaker 01 they do pay their taxes.
9:37 Speaker 00 Well, how do you do that? Because this scope of what's going on here, I mean, I'm assuming it's just the tip of an iceberg here of how they do protect their monies going forward. And one of the things, for example, with Facebook, I think all of us understood that there was Russian government money invested in Twitter and Facebook and other places. But, you know, now it's very clearly outlined of how that works. How do you, with your powers, begin to change that? And you, I mean, you're a very hopeful person, but I'm not. And I'm assuming they'll figure out ways to subvert all these things.
10:16 Speaker 01 Oh, yes, but people like me never get unemployed, unfortunately. But I think we can take steps forward to improve things. I have a very strong tool in competition law enforcement to do merger control, to look into cartels, misuse of dominant position, when member states hand out favors, for instance, in terms of tax breaks. But even though that's a strong tool, it cannot solve everything. We need regulation as well. To say, well, these are sort of the basic rules of how the market should work. And that, in particular, within taxation, to make sure that our tax authorities have
10:57 Speaker 01 the right tools and they know the full history of a company. And that has actually been passed as legislation in the European Union within the last couple of years.
11:08 Speaker 00 Right. That is counter to what's going on in the United States, which obviously has an impact. We have tax reform going on that's essentially give backs to wealthy people. That's what seems to be going on. We've got a president who, I'm not going to go on about other things, but wants to, and by the way, I'm still sorry, Europe, I apologize, for the United States of America. So, but here's, he wants to remove regulation. That's one of his most popular stances, is the idea of removing regulation, removing oversight, removing any kind of strictures against these companies and their growth. How do you battle that when these companies are in the United States, they're not being
11:51 Speaker 00 pulled back by the authorities in the United States?
11:54 Speaker 01 But the thing is, I never feel more European than when I'm in the States. Because we're different.
12:01 Speaker 00 Right.
12:02 Speaker 01 We have built up a market, a single market, where you have a potential of 500 million customers. But it's a market where you care. You care about environment, working conditions, human rights, taxes being paid. Because we want a free market, but we know that the paradoxes of a free market is that sometimes you have to intervene. You have to make sure that it's not the law of the jungle, but the laws of democracy that works.
12:29 Speaker 00 Right. So, talk a little bit about where it's going to, because one of the issues I've been writing about a lot, or talking about a lot in podcasts and various things, are what's coming next. In a lot of ways, a lot of the things you're talking about are technologies, not of the past, but of the previous behaviors. Coming up, AI. Robotics, automation, self-transportation, self-driving cars, but the whole change of the transportation system, infrastructure, new cities. Is that an area that you think you have to begin to look at strongly?
13:11 Speaker 00 Because I literally was just in an Amazon warehouse in Kent, Washington, where there are people there and they're working there, but the robotics is both breathtaking and disturbing to see at the same time. How do you look at those? And do you think, because they're real advantages when you can, when you have a robot to boss around versus a person. So how do you look at that?
13:31 Speaker 01 Two points. First of all, we take an interest in data. Because sometimes it's nothing, but sometimes it's a real barrier to entry. It makes it very, very difficult for others to come into this market. So we take care and look into mergers if the amount of data will disable competition.
13:52 Speaker 00 Yep.
13:53 Speaker 01 And the second point is that I think some of these algorithms, they will have to go to law school before they let out.
14:01 Speaker 00 Okay, all right. Meaning, what does that mean?
14:03 Speaker 01 Well, the thing is that...
14:05 Speaker 00 Because I don't recommend anybody go to law school, but go ahead.
14:07 Speaker 01 Well, I have a thing with lawyers as well, but...
14:09 Speaker 00 Yeah, I get that.
14:10 Speaker 01 Yes. But that being said, well, you cannot just say what happens in the black box stays in the black box.
14:17 Speaker 00 Well, they like it that way.
14:18 Speaker 01 I know, but that's not how things are.
14:20 Speaker 00 They don't know what's going on in the black box, as it turns out, but...
14:23 Speaker 01 And this is why you have to teach your algorithm what it can do and what it cannot do. Because otherwise, there is a risk that the algorithms will learn the tricks of like the old cartels. We just had a really old-school truck cartel of six companies colluding on prices and on environmental benefits on trucks. And we had to fine them almost four billion euros for their behavior. And we don't want algorithms to learn the tricks of the old cartelists. We want them to play by the book, also when they start playing by themselves.
15:00 Speaker 00 So last, I want to finish up very quickly and talk about where it goes from here and what are your biggest concerns? We were talking backstage, we both have teenagers. You're not very, surprisingly, I'm like a European regulator with strictness on my kids, and you're not. You like them, let them do what they want, or what?
15:19 Speaker 01 Well, I don't, I don't think that parents should be friends with their, with their children on Facebook or Snapchat or, or whatever.
15:26 Speaker 00 Really, how can you make them miserable then? How does that work?
15:29 Speaker 01 Well, that's a real life competence and I, I tell you, I master it.
15:33 Speaker 00 Yeah. So, so you, when, when you're thinking about your kids and the impact on what they're having, one of the things that's being discussed in Silicon Valley and Hollywood and everyone else is around sexual harassment, around all kinds of issues, but it really boils down to an idea of diversity. And that's another, do you feel like that's your purview? That, we were talking about this, that when you're thinking about AI and various things, it seems like crap in, crap out. And if you have the same people designing these systems all the time, the same kind of people, do you think that's something you, that's part of your purview or you, as a, as a regulator?
16:07 Speaker 01 Well, two things. First of all, I see my, my oldest daughter, she puts down her phone and she uses it less and less.
16:15 Speaker 00 Yeah.
16:15 Speaker 01 Because she has a real life, in a real life. And that, I think, is a very good thing. The new generation is doing all kinds of things also when it comes to the sustainability goals. They're engaged differently in their society. They are not just all in, on their screen. And that's, I think, is a very, very good thing. But, but we have to take our democracy back. We cannot leave it, neither to Facebook or Snapchat or, or anyone else. We have to take democracy back and renew it. Because society is about people and not about technology.
16:52 Speaker 00 And going forward, what do you think your biggest focus is gonna? The last question, what do you think your biggest focus for the next year is going to be on? In a very short.
17:03 Speaker 01 Well, the next focus is going to be on whether we think that we can trust technology or not.
17:08 Speaker 00 No.
17:08 Speaker 01 Because this is the biggest wake-up call we've ever had. We've seen the potential, now we get the fear of what it will bring us. If we don't relearn to trust technology, then we'll never make any good of the potential.
17:23 Speaker 00 Marguerite Vestager, everybody.
17:25 Speaker 01 Thank you.
17:28 Speaker 00 Thanks again to Marguerite Vestager for joining me onstage and to the organizers of Web Summit for hosting us. If you enjoyed this interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode wherever you found this one or on our website, recode.net/podcasts. We also have several other podcasts you should check out. Peter Kafka hosts Recode Media. Lauren Gooden and I host Too Embarrassed to Ask. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including the Code Conference. Thanks for listening. Thanks also to Cadence13, the company that distributes the show, including Beth O'Connell and our editor, Chris Basil. And thanks to our producer, Eric Johnson. This has been another episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Monday with another great guest. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: How Reid Hoffman would fix social media (Live) Next Recode Decode: Leslie Berlin, historian, Stanford University Page updated October 17, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated