Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Luther Lowe, Yelp; Beth Wilkinson, Wilkinson Walsh Eskovitz About this episode Recode's Kara Swisher and SKDK's Hilary Rosen talk about tech, regulation and politics with two special guests: Luther Lowe, the vice president of public policy at Yelp, and Beth Wilkinson, the co-founder of trial law firm Wilkinson Walsh Eskovitz. The group explains how lawyers from Twitter, Facebook and Google found themselves testifying in front of Congress this week and why the politics of the hearings around the 2016 election are so messy and different from what has come before. Lowe and Wilkinson also talk about the other political issues facing Silicon Valley, including antitrust regulation, consumer data privacy and the future of jobs.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 13,623 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Recode Radio presents Recode Decode, coming to you from the Vox Media Podcast Network.
0:08 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode, and you're listening to Recode Decode, a podcast about tech and media's key players, big ideas, and how they're changing the world we live in. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to your podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcasts for more. Today, I'm in Washington DC with my friend Hillary Rosen. She's a political strategist for SKDK, Knickerbocker. Hey Hillary, you're also a CNN analyst.
0:38 Speaker 01 Hey Kara, happy to be here.
0:39 Speaker 00 How are you doing? Great. So I'm going to explain Hillary's presence. She doesn't just follow me around. This month, we're trying to do something-
0:44 Speaker 01 I do follow you around.
0:45 Speaker 00 Yes, you do. We're going to do something a little different here on Recode Decode. Every Wednesday for the next four weeks, Hillary and I will be tag teaming an interview with a really interesting person in the political world. Could be media, could be anything, but related to politics, as Hillary is a longtime political pro here in Washington. And every month, we're going to have a different, for our extra Recode Decodes, we're going to have a different co-host with me on different topics, which brings us to today. So, welcome, Hillary.
1:11 Speaker 01 Thanks Kara.
1:12 Speaker 00 Do you have anything to say to the listeners?
1:13 Speaker 01 Washington is a very exciting place right now.
1:15 Speaker 00 It is.
1:16 Speaker 01 Scary and swampy.
1:17 Speaker 00 Swampy. It's super swampy.
1:18 Speaker 01 Very, super swampy.
1:19 Speaker 00 100% more swampy. And obviously, a lot of the stuff in the news has to do with the tech world, its involvement in Washington, which it hoped never to happen, and now it's full-scale tech this week.
1:31 Speaker 01 I think we've never seen this kind of scrutiny on the tech industry, certainly, but probably not since post-2008, the scrutiny on the banking industry.
1:41 Speaker 00 Right, right.
1:42 Speaker 01 Have we seen this kind of anxiety around the impact of a particular industry-
1:47 Speaker 00 So, go through for listeners who don't, maybe, are paying that much, what's the stuff that tech is really focused, right now, there's been a bill, so go through the couple of things that have been going on.
1:55 Speaker 01 So, there are multiple areas, and we've got great guests here today to talk about them, but if you go down the list of sort of what people are looking at, it's the role that the social media companies played in the election, both on the paid advertising side, as well as the social media-
2:13 Speaker 00 Content.
2:14 Speaker 01 Content side, the so-called fake news, but not just fake news, but also trading information and using false identities for content.
2:23 Speaker 01 Then there is the
2:24 Speaker 00 The Russian problem.
2:25 Speaker 01 The Russian problem. Then there is the actual investigation of the Trump administration officials and what role they may have played in colluding with Russia or anyone else in
2:40 Speaker 00 Using the internets.
2:41 Speaker 01 Using the internets.
2:42 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:42 Speaker 01 The worldwide webs.
2:44 Speaker 00 Invented here and used against them.
2:46 Speaker 01 In this election. And then there's the antitrust issues and consumer problems that people are talking about, whether some of these companies have gotten too big to regulate. The so-called, is Amazon creating jobs or killing jobs? Question. And Luther is gonna
3:05 Speaker 00 Oh, we're in a minute.
3:07 Speaker 01 Help us on some of those questions. And then there is the, can you regulate tech at all? Or is it too big to regulate?
3:13 Speaker 00 And should you, because of innovation?
3:14 Speaker 01 And should you regulate? You know, for years, the tech industry has said, if you regulate us, you're going to kill innovation, we're too complicated, we're based on algorithms, we're based on engineering. This is not an area where Washington has traditionally had any expertise. And that line has worked for a long time.
3:31 Speaker 00 And the bill?
3:32 Speaker 01 And people are wondering whether or not that will still work. The most recent legislation got a lot of play just this week, introduced by Senator Warner and Senator Klobuchar, which would essentially create transparency in advertising, the way that they have in broadcast television. You have to disclose who you are advertising for when you involve yourself in a political campaign. That's never happened online.
3:55 Speaker 00 And this is gonna air last thing on November 1st, so what, and there's gonna be a hearing, where?
4:01 Speaker 01 So, there are a series of hearings that are probably gonna take place. The first one is November 1st in the Intelligence Committee, where Facebook, Google, and Twitter are being called to testify on this social media component, both the paid and content side of it that we discussed. I think you're gonna start to see some hearings on some of the antitrust issues raised by Amazon and others in terms of size and impact on consumers. And I expect that over the course of the next two years, we're gonna see a lot more hearings and a lot more investigations.
4:37 Speaker 00 Depends on who's in office. We're gonna talk all about that and more. We have great people to talk about. Hillary, thank you for that primer. So it's trouble for tech right now.
4:44 Speaker 01 A little bit of trouble for tech.
4:45 Speaker 00 Trouble for tech. They feel so badly. They're like delicate flowers, so we'll see what happens to them. All right, today in the red chair, we have two great guests to talk about this. First up is Luther Lowe, the Vice President of Public Policy at Yelp, and you have been very active in it for years now, and we'll talk about your background and the like. He's been at Yelp since 2008, so a longtime Yelper. Also joining us in the studio is Beth Wilkinson, the co-founder of, apparently, the hottest Washington, D.C. boutique law firm in the country. It actually is Wilkinson Walsh and Eskivitz. Beth recently worked for Facebook on the Oculus case and a whole bunch of others. She's a prosecutor. Was a prosecutor. Was a prosecutor, has, but so knows a lot about this. And so we're going to talk
5:27 Speaker 00 about all these things. Luther and Beth, welcome to Recode Decode.
5:31 Speaker 02 Thanks, Karen.
5:32 Speaker 00 All right, so I'm going to go with your backgrounds first, and then we'll get into it. Hillary will have a whole bunch of questions of where we're going, because there's so many topics here to go into, and I want to focus mostly on that, but I want listeners to get a sense of who you are. So Beth, why don't you start, give us a brief sort of bio, and especially around the prosecutorial stuff, but people you deal with now on all kinds of cases.
5:53 Speaker 02 Sure. Like most women, I started my career as an Army lawyer.
5:56 Speaker 00 Uh-huh.
5:57 Speaker 02 I was in ROTC in college and worked here at the Pentagon on national security and special operations law, which one would think really has no applicability in the real world, but turned out to be very useful. And I prosecuted cases up in New York, Eastern District of New York, and probably the biggest case was the Oklahoma City bombing case involving Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols. And now I've been in private practice for almost 20 years, try all kinds of cases for all kinds of clients, pet the company cases, and white-collar investigations. And I would say the topics we're going to talk about today cover all of those.
6:32 Speaker 00 So you're getting a lot of attention in that area. And you represented Facebook publicly in the Oculus trial around, you do all kinds of different litigation.
6:39 Speaker 02 Yes, anything that goes to trial, we will take.
6:41 Speaker 00 Anything goes to trial. Okay. Luther.
6:44 Speaker 03 Thanks for having me on, Kara. So I've been at Yelp, I'm a dinosaur at Yelp, been there for nine years, but prior to that I worked in Democratic politics and I guess most notably with General Wesley Clark, helping him with the memoir and really had a lot of friends in the Democratic political scene. And so as Yelp was growing and as we became more active in Washington, they sort of looked around and said, hey, you're the political guy at the office, why don't you sort of take some of this on? And so I think now as the zeitgeist around big tech and antitrust have gotten a lot bigger, you know, work's gotten a lot busier.
7:20 Speaker 00 Yeah, and you're very known for your very pushing, not the agenda of Yelp so much, but sort of attacks, I don't want to say attacks, it's not fair. You're really well-known for not giving up on this issue around Google especially and other companies that have gotten too big.
7:35 Speaker 03 Well, I hope that's the case. We try to really advocate on behalf of the consumer, we really tried to reframe the argument not around sort of company A versus company B, but really articulate this in the terms of how are consumers being harmed?
7:48 Speaker 00 All right, so let's get started on some of the issues. So there's so much here happening. Why don't, give us a little background, because most tech has not been really attacked in a long time. Like, I think Microsoft, I think people are using that term. So if you could just give a little background, everyone knows that Microsoft monopoly trial, but why don't you talk about it and then sort of give us the scene and Luther, I'd love to hear your thoughts on that, too.
8:10 Speaker 02 Sure. I mean, I think it goes back to what Hillary's saying, when a company or an industry gets so big and so powerful, it's just a knee-jerk reaction of the government to start investigating in any way they can, and sometimes their competitors come in to help, which is often true in the antitrust context. But, you know, the Department of Justice can come in, in the criminal area, US attorneys around the country, it can, you know, interact these days with tech all the time in requesting information, which I think is a huge
8:37 Speaker 00 We'll talk about that, too.
8:38 Speaker 02 ...issue for tech and problem. And we've seen that controversy with Apple and the government and many other players in tech. You know, I think there's a focus in the government on sadly what's on the front page when they use their investigative research. Sources and that's the same for the FBI. And there can be that perfect storm and I think that's where tech is right now. I mean, they are in the crosshairs of the government. You have Congress adding to that. And you have testimony which is being requested, as we just heard from Hillary. And that puts kind of these companies in a very difficult place where they want to cooperate publicly and they're being investigated privately.
9:15 Speaker 00 So why now? What has happened? Is it just the power of tech or is it the mood? Because most Democratic and Republican sides have been pro-tech, very pro-tech. And this has been the biggest area of innovation in the country, I think we can pretty much say.
9:29 Speaker 02 Well, I think it's both. I think people are scared of the companies being so big. And I think, you know, we saw this with the Google investigation by the FTC, which I will disclose, I was brought in by the government to work on that. And there was a lot of animosity, even in the tech's own community, about the power of some of the companies. And so I think that's just grown over time and with the new administration. I think there's a new focus. There was a sense that the Democrats, President Obama and his team were very sophisticated in tech and had a relationship with some of the companies.
10:03 Speaker 00 Friendly with tech.
10:04 Speaker 02 Friendly, might be a way to describe it.
10:05 Speaker 00 I'll say it.
10:06 Speaker 02 Somebody might call it cozy, I don't know. And I don't think they have that same relationship with our current administration. So I think it's all those kind of factors coming together.
10:16 Speaker 00 All right, Luther, your thoughts on how this, we got here? Because you've been banging away at this drum for a long time.
10:21 Speaker 03 Sure, I agree with Beth as well. I think that, what I would add is maybe just the levels of concentration, particularly by Google and Facebook, have increased. You know, last year, 99 cents of every new dollar in online advertising went to Google or Facebook. The year before that, it was 85 cents. And so we just see, you know, going back to the last sort of attempt at an investigation five years ago with the FTC, all of these sort of assumptions that went into both opening and closing that investigation have not really aged well. You know, if you're an antitrust enforcer and you're deciding whether or not to shut something down, you shut it down after you've been adequately convinced, hey, you know, the market's competitive and, you know, things are going to be okay, there's going to be new...
11:07 Speaker 03 You know, two guys in a garage starting some disruptor and everything's gonna, you know, the market's gonna take care of itself, but that's clearly not the case. Things are getting more concentrated and that's very interconnected with these issues around sort of Russia. I think some, so that, you know, I think that is emerging as a major issue about just concentration generally. And then you had this issue with the New America Foundation.
11:32 Speaker 00 Explain that.
11:33 Speaker 03 So, there was a team of folks that worked on antitrust and concentration issues at the sort of left-leaning New America Foundation, which happened to receive over $20 million from Google, Eric Schmidt and his family.
11:49 Speaker 00 Who's the chairman of Google.
11:50 Speaker 03 And so, we had a, we, what we learned is that after they put out a 150-word statement praising the European Commission's enforcement action against Google, there was a phone call apparently made between Eric Schmidt and Anne-Marie Slaughter, the head of the foundation, and then subsequently, the 10-person team was spun off. They were effectively fired. And so, a lot of gray area around was this sort of a, you know, did Schmidt call him this hit of this team? I don't know.
12:22 Speaker 00 Yeah. Did he get what he paid for?
12:24 Speaker 03 Exactly. And so, so that, I think, raised a lot of awareness on the left, where Google, at least, has traditionally had a lot of fans. And then, like, within three weeks of that, you had this James DeMour anti-diversity memo come out of Google. And I think that's kind of, like, erupted the Bannonite crew, where you have folks who are just saying, oh, all these Silicon Valley tech firms wanna shut down right-wing views. And so, it's sort of this perfect storm, this convergence around on both poles.
12:54 Speaker 00 Would you kind of start off with the Facebook, Hillary?
12:55 Speaker 01 Yeah, let's go there, this perfect storm around tech, because I'm wondering whether either of you think that if Hillary Clinton had won the election, whether we would still be in this situation. So, in other words, is this organic due to size and dominance and consumer impact? Or is this... Really an outgrowth of people's frustration at the outcome of the election.
13:19 Speaker 02 I think it's the former. I don't think, I think it could have easily happened if Hillary Clinton were the president. I think the sexual-
13:25 Speaker 00 She was not as friendly to tech. She was-
13:27 Speaker 02 She wasn't, but I-
13:28 Speaker 00 She got money from them, but didn't get a lot, and it wasn't the same kind of love affair.
13:31 Speaker 01 A lot of people in her team, though, were former.
13:34 Speaker 02 I don't think it, what I think the problem is, Luther alluded to this, is the Democrats were friendly with tech and they thought they were politically aligned in terms of gender issues. And Carrie, you've always talked about tech and how they can seem to solve every problem except for gender parity. And so I think stripping away and showing all the true gender problems they have, from just pay equity to sexual harassment, it's disarmed the Democrats. And they can't really come to the defense of tech anymore. So I do think that is a perfect storm, along with the concentration issues. And I don't think it really does matter. People want to blame this current administration. I think they are always looking for high-profile cases, but prosecutors don't really care about the
14:17 Speaker 02 politics. They care about the high-profile nature of the case and whether it's interesting. So I think it would have happened either way.
14:23 Speaker 03 I, it's a great question. I think about this a lot. I was, you know, very personally involved in the Clinton campaign, raising a lot of money and trying to internally make sure that they were strong on antitrust. I think there were some sort of folks that were trying to ride from the Obama administration into a future Clinton administration and have that chummy relationship with Silicon Valley that I think would have resisted calls for at least antitrust enforcement. But I do think there were signals from the cam, from her campaign that showed that she was, would have taken it seriously. I know there are folks like Senator Warren that were kind of holding, you know, the campaign's feet to the fire and saying these issues are important.
15:05 Speaker 03 I mean, it's really hard to say, but you can't help but think that the Trump election has really kind of poured gasoline on everything and created this.
15:14 Speaker 00 That's a really good way of putting it. Yeah, I mean, there wouldn't have been a Russian investigation, right? Because she would have won, but it wouldn't have been.
15:20 Speaker 01 Unlikely, although somebody might have discovered it at some point, and it would have raised just as many issues. Maybe the Republicans would have raised it.
15:28 Speaker 02 Well, it was out there. I mean, the Obama administration knew it. They just didn't talk about it. So I think it would have been discovered, and Clinton would have had to discuss it if she became president. I mean, it's a fundamental violation of our electoral process, and I don't think it's that he got elected, it's that there was interference, period, in the election.
15:48 Speaker 01 And let's go to some of the impact of the Russia investigation. I think that antitrust issues, you raised, Luther, are really, really important, and I do think that there's a huge amount of consumer pressure on that, so I definitely want to get to that. But when you think about an investigation, and this isn't just one investigation, this is multiple investigations, and Beth, if you are in these companies and you're trying to be transparent, because that's sort of the buzzword of the day, we ought to be, you know, we saw Sheryl Sandberg in town last week, and we've seen Jack Dorsey out there.
16:23 Speaker 00 Facebook and Twitter.
16:24 Speaker 01 Facebook and Twitter. We've seen, you know, Sundar talk about transparency. Everybody is talking about these companies needing to be more transparent, which means the public and the press want to see the ads, they want to know about the fake identities, they want to know where the money transfers are, they want to know who's buying and circulating among all of these networks. But if you're inside these companies, and you've got Bob Mueller, the special investigator, looking at this, you have Congress looking at this, what do you do? How do you balance the public's desire to know everything versus what they're really worried about, which is the bottom line and protecting themselves legally?
17:07 Speaker 02 Well, first, I think we should be careful not to always call it Silicon Valley or tech because some of these companies handle it quite differently and have different issues.
17:14 Speaker 00 And also, they're not involved. I mean, I was just talking to people, both Apple and Microsoft, and they're like, "We don't got nothing to do with this, but we're getting," you know, it's the, they call it the viral contagion, like, it does, over all of tech. I mean, Apple might have a problem later if there's some encryption issue, but...
17:28 Speaker 02 Right, and even the ones that are involved have different, different ways of handling it. The other thing I'd like to say, these aren't, this isn't new, this is a tech problem. I'll go back to, you know, putting them all in the same category. This happens to industries all the time where there's multiple investigations. I mean, this is what we do in other lawyers, where the government's investigating you, there's private plaintiffs who want to sue you, there's different government investigators and Congress. Think back to the financial crisis, the banks were all dragged down here, put in front of Congress, they were investigated by prosecutors. So, tech thinks when it's happening to them, it's, you know, biggest outrage, "Oh, my gosh."
18:05 Speaker 00 Of course.
18:05 Speaker 02 You know, they're just too young to know that it's, "I'm old, so I know that it's happened to all these industries."
18:10 Speaker 00 Really good point.
18:11 Speaker 02 And so, there are people out there that know how to counsel people, like Hillary and others, that know that what you need to do is, first of all, you need to figure out what's really going on in your own company. I think people sometimes talk too quickly, and then they are correcting themselves, and that's a huge problem in front of the public, it's a huge problem in front of prosecutors who look for consistency. So, you need to figure out what's really going on in your company, come up with what, you know, I don't even want to call it a message, because it has to be what's really happening. And then you do have to be transparent, because you're, you're a public company, the public will not tolerate it. So, you have to testify in front of Congress. I think the companies that are involved are smart, they have their general counsels, who are some extraordinary
18:53 Speaker 02 people. And then you have to go into the government and cooperate, but how you do that, you need good advice from seasoned professionals, because you don't just go in and start talking, because often, you will go in and say things. That are wrong because you haven't done your homework, you haven't been tested, you haven't gone through a murder.
19:12 Speaker 00 You saw it with Twitter just recently, the short beginning part, they didn't, it looked like they hadn't done their homework in any way whatsoever.
19:20 Speaker 02 And so people start to think that you're not being truthful when you haven't been careful and thorough and you shoot first and aim later, as they say, and I think that's a huge mistake for companies that haven't interacted in DC with the political arm and with prosecutors.
19:34 Speaker 00 Luther, they've been raising a lot of lobbying money, the numbers have been going up rather precipitously for all these companies.
19:42 Speaker 03 Certainly, and I think I would even go back to the 2010 was when the FEC was originally looking at a lot of these questions around how is and how should a platform like Facebook or Google disclose political advertising, disclose who the purchaser of that political ad is along the lines of what we see in sort of a television ad. And the written submissions of these companies was kind of laughable, it was saying, well, we should be treated like the buttons and the pencils because, you know, the ads are so small that we can't put a disclosure there, but of course, these are technologists that could easily create sort of mouse overs or interstitials or ways to get that information there.
20:25 Speaker 03 And so I think that you sort of have to go back seven years to those discussions with the FEC to see where this problem began.
20:33 Speaker 00 That's the Federal Election Commission, which is pretty toothless.
20:38 Speaker 03 It is pretty toothless, you're right, that's also part of the problem, but then you sort of couple that with the amount of concentration, there's a reason that this type of problem didn't happen in 2012, 2008, there's just been so much more concentration within these industries and we are sort of, as a society, two fish sitting in kind of these two information barrels and it just makes the target a lot easier.
21:04 Speaker 00 All right, when we get back, we'll talk more about that, the growth of power and also. How little Washington really does know about what's happening in tech. And in the last part, I do want to talk about where it's coming, AI, self-driving and stuff like that, because that's hits, I mean, Steve Case wrote a book on this, talking about that soon, there's going to be some real problems, and now there are. But first, if you're enjoying this interview, then you should check out one of our other podcasts, Recode Media with Peter Kafka. Peter, who did you talk to this week?
21:29 Speaker 04 Kara, first of all, I just want to say hello. It's nice to be in the same room with you.
21:32 Speaker 00 Thank you.
21:32 Speaker 04 It's very exciting. Kara, this Thursday in New York City, I'll be talking to Joe Hagan.
21:36 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
21:36 Speaker 04 Wrote Sticky Fingers. It's a new biography of Rolling Stones, Jan Wenner.
21:40 Speaker 00 I don't like that title, but okay.
21:42 Speaker 04 Jan Wenner doesn't like anything about the book. He pitched the book to Joe and then has disowned him, so it's very controversial and much more exciting to talk about.
21:48 Speaker 00 And then also, what else?
21:50 Speaker 04 Oh, man, we have so much good content.
21:51 Speaker 00 So much good content.
21:52 Speaker 04 On the Recode Media feed. We just talked to Jimmy Kimmel recently. We also talked to Michael Barbaro, the host of the New York Times fantastically successful daily podcast.
22:01 Speaker 00 Big, big, huge numbers.
22:02 Speaker 04 Huge numbers, 100 million downloads, and he came to talk to us.
22:05 Speaker 00 Explain what that is. They have the reporters come in and talk.
22:07 Speaker 04 It is a thing that I thought would never work, which is the New York Times reporters talking about their stuff every day. It turns out, it's fantastically successful, as it should be. It's great.
22:14 Speaker 00 It's well-produced. It's really interesting, actually. You don't have to read the paper, but I do, anyway.
22:18 Speaker 04 No, it adds to the paper.
22:19 Speaker 00 It does.
22:20 Speaker 04 Makes you want to read the paper more.
22:21 Speaker 00 Yes, I love it.
22:22 Speaker 04 This has been an ad for the New York Times.
22:23 Speaker 00 This has been an ad for the New York Times. Sounds great. Peter, you can find Recode Media on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. We're here with my special co-host, Hillary Rosen, who's going to be here for four weeks in the month of November. November is an election month, so it's also a political month, and Hillary is an expert on politics, and she's going to be co-hosting a whole series of shows we're doing. Our guests today are Luther Lowe from Yelp. He runs their public policy arm. Yelp has been a very active and vocal, one of the few companies in Silicon Valley that's been vocal, talking about the growing power of companies like Google and Facebook. And Beth Wilkinson, who is a hotshot lawyer who's represented some of these companies,
23:06 Speaker 00 also prosecuted, been involved in various things on both sides of this. And we're talking about the problems that tech is facing. I think it's been in the news a lot lately. We talked a little bit, Hillary, yesterday, about the Clinton administration. Who in the Trump administration is leading this? Now, I know Donald Trump made a lot of anti-tech remarks on the campaign trail, and I don't think he knows almost anything about tech or science or things like that, but I think he has a lizard brain for understanding. Trouble, you know what I mean? Like, I think he has identifying something that people feel about tech, or is a good target. Can you each talk about that, sort of this administration and their thoughts about this? And is there any organization to going against big tech?
23:46 Speaker 02 Well, I think you're right. The president realizes, the same way he touched on his base, that there are people out there that are afraid of tech. Whether they're taking the jobs, or they don't know how to use tech. And there's a huge divide between Silicon Valley and DC and how people understand it. You know, it starts at the Justice Department. Jeff Sessions, who I think the Attorney General wants to do what the president wants him to do, because they've been in this odd fight over other issues. Rod Rosenstein, who's the Deputy Attorney General, is a career prosecutor with a lot of respect in the community. So there's a whole group of people out there who will take their cues from more the media, I would say, than even the president, in terms of investigating these issues.
24:30 Speaker 02 And then there are the Antitrust Division, which looks at the issues, and the FTC. They just announced, my former partner, Joe Simons, from Paul Weiss, is going to be the head of the FTC. I think you're going to get a very different set of concerns or investigations there, though, because you have a Republican-libertarian view towards mergers and acquisitions. So I think it'll come down more to the criminal prosecutors who will be investigating this. Of course, you have Mueller, who is an extraordinary lifetime prosecutor, and he's hired kind of the dream team of people who will do everything they can to make sure that they've investigated, you know, their charge.
25:07 Speaker 00 So it won't be the White House? Do they have any points of view? Because he attacked almost every tech company at some point.
25:13 Speaker 02 Well, in a normal administration, the White House would have no contact whatsoever with the Department over investigations. That is verboten. And he seems to have tried that early on with the whole firing of Jim Comey. And I think they've... Roll them back a bit. I can't say that I think that that wouldn't happen again. I'm sure that people at the Justice Department don't want his interference, but I don't know that that will stop him.
25:39 Speaker 00 What about public attacks? Does that create?
25:40 Speaker 02 He can do that. I mean, and I don't, we all see it on Twitter.
25:43 Speaker 00 But he doesn't affect Congress or things like that?
25:45 Speaker 02 I don't, what do you think, Luther? I think he does.
25:47 Speaker 03 Politically, I think this whole issue, the Russia stuff puts them in a, the Republicans in an interesting place because, you know, whereas their president was, you know, bashing Amazon because he doesn't like Jeff Bezos and the Washington Post writing some expose about his administration.
26:02 Speaker 00 Which he links together almost continually.
26:04 Speaker 03 It just conflates it all. And then, one interesting thing that I think was underreported was the fact that on the day of the European Commission's record fine against Google, I mean, this is the guy who's sort of gone around the world branding himself as Mr. Pro-America and, you know, not afraid of finger wagging at any other country or foreign company. And they get asked on the, on this record fine day, you know, Sarah Huckabee Sanders, hey, what does this sort of America-first president think about this giant, these Eurocrats cracking down on this popular US company? And her response was, we're not going to get into this private company matter. And you imagine that happening last year, you know, the Obama administration.
26:49 Speaker 00 He did, yeah.
26:50 Speaker 03 The Obama, you interviewed him. He said this to you. He made the news with you, exactly.
26:54 Speaker 00 He was very America-first on that issue.
26:55 Speaker 03 They would have had the, they would have had John Kerry, the OSTP, they would have had everybody lined up, ready to finger wag and call it protectionism. And here you had the White House just clearly making a conscientious effort to sort of stay silent and let that speak volumes. And then you've got, you know, this Russia stuff. There's clearly among that kind of Bannon-like crew, a resentment and paranoia around Silicon Valley, its employees, the political leanings of its employees, who say they can't be trusted, they need to be regulated and broken up. You're reading these sort of accounts of Bannon saying this stuff.
27:29 Speaker 00 Utilities is the word he used.
27:30 Speaker 03 Exactly. And then you have...
27:34 Speaker 03 You know, in doing that, in sort of making those claims, in some ways, you're adding fodder to the Russia meme. You're saying, you're implicitly admitting that Russia maybe have used these tools in a way to help Trump. So...
27:49 Speaker 01 That is the catch 22 that I think members of Congress are facing right now, Republican members of Congress, because even though it is Democrats that have been traditionally cozier with Silicon Valley, as Beth alluded to earlier, because of the perception of sort of social and progressive values being more aligned, the Republicans now are caught between if they start to attack these companies and if they start to attack social media, are they in and of itself admitting that the election is not legitimate? And so, there is this kind of back and forth. We'll see at these intelligence hearings that we referenced
28:31 Speaker 01 earlier on November 1st, Chairman Burr, Richard Burr, Senator from North Carolina, who's actually the Chair of the Committee. We've seen Mark Warner be a lot more vocal about this issue, but he's actually not the Chair of the Committee. And we'll see how these Republican Senators deal with what is very obvious in terms of evidence of Russian interference, but they've all been fairly quiet about it.
28:56 Speaker 02 I just think we want to also focus on what the government can do that's scary that has nothing to do with investigations and using tech.
29:03 Speaker 01 Right.
29:03 Speaker 02 I mean, there are statistics out there, articles by other journalists, that the government is using its powers to request information that could seem like political intervention.
29:13 Speaker 01 So, talk about that.
29:14 Speaker 02 So, there's a company called Dream Host, and the government has demanded 1.3 million IP addresses of people who are involved with the protests at the inauguration, which I just find chilling, the fact that people who are exercising, again, their First Amendment right, now you're getting a government request to this company. They are using federal requests to find out about immigrants and data that the tech company have on immigrants. You have this whole issue of search warrants with phones. You know, Microsoft did an extraordinary job in the Second Circuit, the court that oversees the New York Federal Courts, saying the government shouldn't be allowed to get a warrant to take data that was stored over in Ireland. And they won that case and the warrant was not allowed to be issued or executed.
29:57 Speaker 02 And then the Supreme Court just accepted the government's request to have that her case reheard. That's a big issue. The Supreme Court doesn't normally ask to hear a case if they agree with it. So I think Microsoft and the tech world is concerned about that. The number of requests to the companies, I think there's an article that 26 of the biggest tech companies have had more than twice the requests for data in this year alone than they had the last year. So I think those requests are talked about now more by the government. And I think that's, that's
30:29 Speaker 01 And those are FBI requests.
30:30 Speaker 02 Right. That's what I, when I say government, I mean subpoenas, you know, things that the government thinks they're allowed to
30:37 Speaker 01 And why is that?
30:38 Speaker 02 Well, because tech is taking over like in the old days, you know, when I was a prosecutor, you could get phone records very easily.
30:44 Speaker 01 Right.
30:45 Speaker 02 Just the, like, I called you, the
30:46 Speaker 01 AT&T.
30:47 Speaker 02 Right? That, they don't really need those from phone companies anymore. Now they want all your data that tech has, and tech has a lot more data about us than a phone company ever had.
30:55 Speaker 01 So is that a function of this administration or just government in general saying what a cornucopia of information we have available here?
31:01 Speaker 02 I think it's both. I mean, I can't imagine a democratic administration asking for the IP addresses of protesters, but I could be wrong. That, to me, sounds more like an administration focus, and that should cause everybody some real grave concern. In terms of requesting, you know, more data, I think that is just how the world has evolved. And that's why I think Microsoft and other companies came in and filed a brief supporting them, fought hard on the search warrant, that, you know, how would you feel if Ireland or Russia came over and, and asked for our data?
31:35 Speaker 01 Mm-hmm.
31:36 Speaker 02 I mean, would we want to give it? That's what the, you know, that's what the government is saying, that even though you have your data stored in Ireland, we should have to cough it up here.
31:44 Speaker 01 Right.
31:45 Speaker 02 Well, I don't, I don't want my data given to the Russians if they come over and make a request.
31:49 Speaker 01 So can the tech companies successfully conflate those issues to get the public on their side? Whereas there may be legitimate reasons to want and be able to identify, for instance, Russian identities and, you know, fake identities on Twitter or on, on Facebook.
32:08 Speaker 01 And secured that.
32:11 Speaker 02 They have a long way to go to explaining what they do. And that is their fault. You know, I do that as a trial lawyer. My job is to translate complex concepts to jurors so they understand. I don't really know how to do anything else. They need to do that. People don't understand and what tech says is what Washington doesn't understand. That's true, but it's your job to teach them.
32:30 Speaker 00 Right.
32:30 Speaker 02 And if they don't, and Microsoft had that problem many years ago. And it was very costly. That idea of like, well, you don't understand, so we don't need to talk to you.
32:39 Speaker 00 Luther, you had a, about this issue.
32:41 Speaker 03 Oh, I was, excuse me, I was just gonna jump on Hillary's point earlier about the, the political dynamics between the Rs and the Ds on this, that the one, the sole sort of Republican cosponsor at this point on the Honest Ad Act, that, that Klobuchar and Senator Ornour are advancing is McCain, who's not exactly beloved by the, the White House right now. So that may also underscore the fact that this, this is an awkward issue for Republicans to, to really rally behind.
33:12 Speaker 00 So where do you go? Because what's interesting is everyone's everywhere on everything. Like, it depends on the topic. You used to sort of know where people were on topics, but you have an administration that's Peter Thiel, as an influencer on the president. They tried to bring a lot of these tech people onto these commissions and they all went off of them. And at the same time, we had an interview with Cory Booker, which was quite hostile to tech. So it just depends on the issue. How do you navigate that as a lobbyist? Like, because you don't know where, you used to know, it seems like, which side was on which side.
33:44 Speaker 03 You know, I am happy to sort of explain and sit down with anyone who I think could, could help sort of move the chains on, on the issue of sort of addressing the problems of concentration in, in the technology world. And so we have to sort of talk to folks on, on both sides. And yeah, what's, what's sort of weird about the job these days is that you have things that you can almost sort of put quotes and say, was this Elizabeth Warren or Steve Bannon that said this?
34:13 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
34:13 Speaker 03 And that's, that's made the year a bit interesting. I'm not sure that sort of Congress at large, I don't know if, I mean, we, we are kind of reading this about, reading about this in the New York Times every day and we're seeing this, it feels like tech's really under the gun, but... You know, it's not, I don't know if that's getting down to every single member of Congress. Like if you, we had a letter that Keith Ellison told us about after the fact, being sent to the FTC, asking them to open up all the Google files. And I thought it was kind of surprising. It was just sort of one, a single congressman on that letter that, you know, presumably they circulated it and couldn't get more signatures.
34:55 Speaker 03 So I don't know how, I think that there's a lot of goodwill and durability by these individual companies that they built up by providing kind of white glove support. So here's, you know, Congressman, is how you manage your Facebook page, or here's, here's how you run your Google Ads for your campaign. And, but the, ultimately, I think this is sort of a, they're, particularly on this upcoming hearing where they're, they're sort of having to ask tough, answer tough questions about the ads, it is sort of a product of their own creation because they are the ones who in 2010 were saying, oh, treat our ads like buttons and pencils.
35:34 Speaker 01 Luther just referenced something that I think listeners may not understand that is really, really important, which is that for the last 10 years or so, each of the major tech companies have had an entire, essentially-
35:48 Speaker 00 Apparatus.
35:49 Speaker 01 A global assist team for politicians-
35:53 Speaker 00 Right.
35:54 Speaker 01 -to help them use-
35:55 Speaker 00 You mean the embedded ones that Facebook did?
35:56 Speaker 01 Yes, to help them use their systems more effectively.
36:01 Speaker 00 Right.
36:02 Speaker 01 And oftentimes, that was to help them pay for advertising more efficiently, and other times it was just, how do you use our free tools better?
36:10 Speaker 00 Right.
36:11 Speaker 01 So that was, you know, tech help that campaigns didn't have to pay for, that members of Congress didn't have to pay for, but that they, you know, effectively used to reach their constituents.
36:23 Speaker 00 Sort of like free cars for the auto industry.
36:25 Speaker 01 It would be, it would be just like that, as if Detroit said, you need to get from campaign stop to campaign stop, so we're going to give you cars. We're going to lend you cars to do it.
36:35 Speaker 00 And show you how to drive them.
36:37 Speaker 02 But I think that's demonizing, I'll defend the tech companies.
36:40 Speaker 01 I, I.
36:40 Speaker 02 People know what tech does for them.
36:42 Speaker 01 Yeah, no.
36:42 Speaker 02 I mean, it does outside of that.
36:44 Speaker 01 And I'm saying this without, actually without value judgment. It's just that it is a way that they have embedded themselves into the fabric
36:51 Speaker 03 It's an exertion of soft power.
36:52 Speaker 01 of politics.
36:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
36:53 Speaker 01 That is quite important.
36:55 Speaker 00 So, Beth, talk about that, that idea. Because the word embedded, when Brad Parcells from the, from the Trump campaign talked about Facebook, that word was so loaded. I mean, it was wrong. It was wrong because they do provide everybody. They provide the Democrats, the Republicans.
37:09 Speaker 01 Yes, they do it across the board politically.
37:11 Speaker 00 But the word embedded, and it looked like they were helping the Trump administration was sort of, I'm, I'm assuming.
37:16 Speaker 02 They're trying to make it sound devious.
37:17 Speaker 00 Right. I think Brad Parcells just wants more business. That's what I read. But it definitely had resonance because I had a lot of readers write me because I said, that's ridiculous. They weren't embedded. They were there the whole time.
37:27 Speaker 02 And the, the point is, the company's job, it is their job to teach the people here in Washington how tech works. But I think tech has a good residue, a residual of goodwill because we all know what tech has done for our lives.
37:41 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
37:42 Speaker 02 So you don't have to come in and teach me how to, you know, pay for my political ads. That's helpful. But, you know, I read my iPad. I can go on my Facebook page and talk to my family and friends. I mean, it has transformed life, even for those of us that aren't as sophisticated as the people out in Silicon Valley. So I think Congress is treading lightly too because these aren't all one issue. And tech companies have different issues within their own companies. And they come out in different positions depending on, you know, what the particular issue is. Like you were saying at the beginning, you know, Apple and Microsoft aren't really involved with this Russia stuff. And they're like, why are you, you know, hammering me for this?
38:19 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
38:19 Speaker 02 So I, I think there's a lot of, there's just a level of sophistication that people may not have, but they realize that this isn't just one big issue. And they need to be very careful in regulating or legislating.
38:31 Speaker 01 And, and there's one more point to that, which I, I think you mentioned at the outset. Tony Rome of Recode had a good story about this this week, which is that those very same members of Congress who are essentially responsible for oversight and regulation of tech, as they are in every other business, are also now, for instance, Soliciting Amazon to put their new headquarters in their state.
38:53 Speaker 00 Genius by Amazon.
38:55 Speaker 01 So, you know, virtually all of the large tech companies have made a significant effort in trying to spread out the jobs across the country to move them away from just Silicon Valley. And so, there is this kind of hope. I think of it sometimes as a faint hope, but there's a hope that the innovation will create jobs in their districts regardless of whether that actually has come to pass and the skewing of wealth.
39:23 Speaker 00 Two stories we just did. Microsoft yesterday announced a fund with the Green Bay Packers to locate jobs in Wisconsin. Google a billion dollars, I'm sure you saw that Luther, to create jobs.
39:35 Speaker 02 Kara, don't you take credit for that for your Kentucky tour? I heard you down there. I know you think that...
39:40 Speaker 00 I do.
39:41 Speaker 02 It is a great thing to be moving those jobs.
39:42 Speaker 00 I think it's a lot of press right now, honestly. I'll be honest with you. I don't think they really mean it. But that's okay. If it works, it works. But I do think it's PR, it's on their part, you know? And I think the Mark Zuckerberg's livestock tour of the United States is another part of that.
39:57 Speaker 02 I beg to differ.
39:58 Speaker 00 Okay.
39:59 Speaker 02 I saw him down in Dallas do it.
40:00 Speaker 00 Okay, all right.
40:01 Speaker 02 And I think, you know, you see him put on his Facebook page every year what he wants to learn.
40:06 Speaker 00 I get it.
40:07 Speaker 02 He's an incredibly curious guy and I think it's, you know, it's a bit cynical and I know you're good at that and there's a good reason for it because a lot of times these guys tell you things that are just not true.
40:15 Speaker 00 Right.
40:16 Speaker 02 But I think he realizes that tech is in a bit of a bubble and they need to just like...
40:21 Speaker 00 I get it. I think he's very earnest. I think his essay was very earnest, his 9,000-word essay was very earnest about the issue, about community. But it's sort of like saying, it's someone who caused the problem saying, "We should do something about the problem." That, to me, is like a little...
40:33 Speaker 02 At least he's doing something.
40:34 Speaker 00 I get that, but, and I don't think he's, he's not a particularly PR savvy person as you can see by some of his videos where he should have lighting or something like that, like who's not. I don't think that's the case with him, but I do think it is a, to me, it's more pandering to people, like, "We'll come and visit you and look at you." Like, you're, you know, do you know what I mean? Like, nobody comes out to Silicon...
40:53 Speaker 01 I think it's sort of less personal and more of a big public policy issue, which is how... What, where are the jobs in the next, you know,
41:02 Speaker 00 Right.
41:02 Speaker 01 20 years? What does grow them? When Amazon, you know, slaughters retail, are they creating more jobs by providing more distribution for small businesses? Or are they really just slaughtering retail? I think that these are the questions that policymakers and a more thoughtful president would really be asking and delving into. And I think because they're so loaded right now with all of these other issues and the impact on the public, they're not getting that kind of scrutiny.
41:32 Speaker 00 Before we finish this section, that's what I want to talk about in the next section, what's coming up around AI, around automation, robotics, and things like that, because that's all going to be legally, attract a lot of legal attention and regulatory.
41:43 Speaker 01 Yes, very complicated.
41:44 Speaker 00 But first, before, let's, each of you talk about what's coming up this next week with, for tech. What are the key things that are in the hearings and what you think are going to happen there in the short term? And then the next section, we'll talk a lot about where it's going.
41:58 Speaker 01 And can I just amend Kara's question, Beth, for you in particular? If these social media companies are, do they have legal liability for having sold ads and engaged with these Russian? Now, I know you don't want to like prejudge it, but is it just a terrible thing? Or is it really illegal for them to have had false identities and advertising from outside? And should people really be worried about prosecution? Or is this just a good government investigation issue?
42:31 Speaker 02 Well, I hope they shouldn't have to worry about prosecution. But of course, you know, we always prepare for the worst and hope for the best. So I don't think it is illegal. And I think, you know, there's a, it would be very difficult to make out a criminal case. But unfortunately, sometimes when the government isn't motivated to do its highest and best work, people bring cases where they shouldn't. So I think you have to have it in the back of your mind. You have to be prepared. And again, this is why you have to do your homework before you go into those hearings. I do think, I sound like a Facebook commercial, but Colin Strachey, the general counsel, is an extraordinary lawyer in person.
43:05 Speaker 01 Although people are calling that it should have been faced, Mark or Sherrod.
43:09 Speaker 00 Cheryl at these hearings.
43:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, I don't get that.
43:11 Speaker 00 I saw it yesterday.
43:11 Speaker 02 He's a lawyer and, you know, Mark Zuckerberg is a visionary and Cheryl is an extraordinary person, but I think these are complicated legal questions. I certainly don't know the answers. And I know that the Facebook folks, and I'm sure the other companies, have thought long and hard about these issues. And I think most people don't have the answers. That's why they're having the hearings. But I think they, I think the criminal liability is not at the top of their list. But regulatory issues are, and I think that's as scary for these companies as criminal.
43:40 Speaker 00 So what happens next week?
43:42 Speaker 02 Preparing for the hearings, I think. I don't know. Probably Luther, you're better.
43:45 Speaker 03 I mean, frankly, I don't think these hearings, I think these hearings are inadequate reactions to sort of the symptoms of the same problem. The problem is the failure to enforce antitrust laws and that of concentration. That, you know, there's a reason that we didn't have these hearings for eight years ago is because the internet was more open, it was more pluralistic, and that's just simply not the case today. And so I'm looking forward to them in that sense. But I don't think, you know, I actually don't know. I hope that they're asked, Google at least is asked about not money only being paid out, but also paid to Google, but also sort of the two-way street where broadcasts like RT, the Russia Today, you know, was
44:28 Speaker 03 one of their premium content providers. So they're doing a rev share. They're getting payouts on that. And so what, for those sort of content creators, was there, were they using that effectively as an ATM to help fund other operations? The other issue is, you know, how did these, the organic kind of content creation, that seems to be the real problem. You know, I think there was a really good, Mark Penn had an op-ed, I think, this week in the
44:59 Speaker 00 He used to work for Microsoft.
45:00 Speaker 03 Wall Street Journal about how you can't win an election with $100,000. And I totally agree with that. I don't think that they're, that, you know, these amounts are really substantial. It's this kind of astroturfing that was being done, the creation of these groups and fake accounts and building kind of whole social ecosystems to ... other kind of real human beings into believing certain things and voting certain ways.
45:24 Speaker 01 And very smartly, there was a really interesting story that got pretty overlooked yesterday in ABC News from Brian Ross, who's an investigative reporter there, where a group that was traced to Russia called Black Lives came out and essentially have been organizing across the country, they were doing this all through the election, sowing discord with the status quo, discord with President Obama, discord with Hillary Clinton, discord with so-called all the politicians, essentially depressing the vote. And they were not paid advertising, it was all social media content and offline organizing based on social media organizing.
46:07 Speaker 01 And it's fascinating how disruptive things like that can actually be.
46:12 Speaker 00 So what do you, each of you, very briefly, and then we'll get to our next section, our next part, think is going to happen with these hearings, just they're going to what, Beth?
46:21 Speaker 02 I don't think much. I mean, I think they're going to have this dialogue, and I think after that, Congress doesn't really know what to do because they're not educated enough, and I don't blame them. I mean, I don't understand, but isn't there Tor browsing and other things people can do all the time to hide their identity? So the fact that somehow people use fake identities with Facebook or Google.
46:39 Speaker 00 Right.
46:40 Speaker 02 I just, I think it's the nature of the beast that you can hide and do things that are disruptive.
46:46 Speaker 00 Nothing goes, just a lot of.
46:47 Speaker 02 Well, I mean, there may be a way to regulate that, but I don't, I don't think anyone knows exactly how to do that, and you really have to understand the technology.
46:55 Speaker 00 Right.
46:56 Speaker 02 And that's the problem. I don't think the average congressperson, and I'm sure Luther's spent years trying to educate them, understands it. I'm pretty smart and I don't understand it. So I, I think that's, that's probably where, you know, more firepower has to be used.
47:11 Speaker 00 And Luther, the legislation.
47:12 Speaker 03 I agree. I think it'll, I think it'll be pretty anticlimactic, the hearing itself, because, you know, it's just going to be sort of general councils saying, oh, we're, we're looking hard into this and we're going to be transparent in the future, and yes, sir, no, sir. But the, you know, from a legislative standpoint, this Honest Ads Act, I, you know, I hope it does spur a broad bipartisan discussion, because there's far more that these platforms can be doing beyond adhering to this.
47:41 Speaker 03 ...button and pencil baseline that they're currently held to in terms of disclosure on their political ads.
47:47 Speaker 00 Well, you know Luther, they're not very powerful. That's what they tell me every day. Sorry, Beth, but they do. It's really exhausting.
47:52 Speaker 01 Right. Well, and the other issue is-
47:54 Speaker 00 Billionaires tell you they're not powerful.
47:55 Speaker 01 Congress may not know how to regulate them, but are they smart enough to identify enough incentives for them to self-regulate?
48:02 Speaker 00 Right. And that's the big issue. So, we're going to talk about that going forward because there's a lot of stuff that's going to need a lot of government involvement and probably a lot of problems going forward and solutions that are needed to figure it out. We're here with Luther Lo from Yelp, who does their lobbying for them, and Beth Wilkinson, who is a trial lawyer, who's represented companies, who have been against companies, and who's a lot about what's coming down the pike for tech companies in Washington. And we're here with my co-host, Hilary Rosen, who we're going to talk about what's coming next. I'd also like to tell you about my other podcast, Too Embarrassed to Ask, which I host with Lauren Good of The Verge.
48:38 Speaker 05 Hi, it's me, and I'm not a bot.
48:41 Speaker 00 You are a bot.
48:42 Speaker 05 I'm real. I'm not a lizard person.
48:44 Speaker 00 You know, I question that on a daily basis. Every Friday, we answer all of your questions about consumer tech. Lauren, what did we talk about this week?
48:52 Speaker 05 I'm going to turn it over to Recode's politics editor, Tony Rom. Is that, are you a politics editor?
48:58 Speaker 00 Yeah.
48:59 Speaker 05 Yes, why not? What did we talk about this week?
49:01 Speaker 00 Politics guru.
49:02 Speaker 06 Well, other than talking about lizard people, we talked about Russian interference in the 2016 election and how Facebook, Google, and Twitter are set to testify about it on Capitol Hill on November 1st.
49:14 Speaker 00 Right. And that's going to be what? A watershed? What?
49:18 Speaker 06 It's either going to be really boring or kind of a mess for these companies. Either way, they don't want to be there. So, it's going to be a bit of a showdown.
49:23 Speaker 00 Tech companies have a history of, like Jerry Yang on that China committee, you don't remember that, but I do. It's not good. It did not turn out well. For most companies, they go to Capitol Hill, their tech companies don't do well.
49:33 Speaker 06 Yeah. Yeah, I would say that they were going to be heavily lawyered up, but the people who are testifying are the general counsels of Facebook, Google, and Twitter, so the lawyers are there.
49:41 Speaker 00 The lawyers are there. It's a very legal discussion.
49:43 Speaker 06 Very legal.
49:44 Speaker 00 It was a really great discussion with Tony, if you want to hear about all, what's going on, not just about that, but other things around these social media companies and politics. And we hope you'll go listen to it. You can find Too Embarrassed to Ask on Apple Podcasts, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. That's Too Embarrassed to Ask. See you there. We're here with Rico Decode. We're talking to Luther Lowe from Yelp and Beth Wilkinson, who is a well-known trial lawyer in Washington who deals with a lot of tech companies and issues around what is coming up for them going forward. And one of the issues, we've talked a lot about issues that are happening now around Russia, around legislation around ads, around, you mentioned James Demore and diversity and other kinds of issues. But let's talk about what's coming next, because I think what Hillary referenced a
50:26 Speaker 00 little bit was the idea around automation, around robotics, around self-driving cars, around artificial intelligence. These are all things that the government is going to have to be necessarily involved in for many things. Can you each sort of talk about what you think the most important issues going forward are for tech to think about from a legal and regulatory point of view? Beth, why don't you start?
50:51 Speaker 02 Well, I had one that you didn't list. It's not as sexy, but I think it'll be a huge issue, which is online gambling.
50:57 Speaker 00 Ah, okay, yes, of course.
50:58 Speaker 02 There's a sports case in front of the Supreme Court where New Jersey Governor Christie was trying to do sports gambling. And, you know, the repercussions, if that is allowed, will have a huge impact.
51:10 Speaker 00 Explain what they would be.
51:11 Speaker 02 So it would allow people to bet online, and we know what that does because we see it overseas. I'm working on an investigation. It's public where I'm one of the judges for professional tennis. They're looking into corruption there, and there's online and legal betting all around the world. And so, you know, places like Russia come in and put big bets down on everything from, you know, do you win the match to do you go deuce two times? And there's a lot of pressure on these individual players because there's a lot of money at stake. And, you know, it's facilitated really by the internet, and that's not allowed here in the U.S. And if it is, I think it'll transform all of these companies. It'll be, you know, and there'll be a lot of interest because there'll be a lot of money,
51:54 Speaker 02 and you're tying sports, the internet, and money together, which is, in the U.S., a huge combination. And I'm not sure, you know, then you have a real profit motive that is going to make people want to hold on to this. I think that's going to be an issue. We saw it with FanDuel's, remember, a couple of years ago? The Attorney General of New York investigated, kind of petered out, they cooperated. But depending on how this case goes, I think that could be a huge issue for the companies.
52:19 Speaker 00 And what's against the idea of doing that here legislatively?
52:23 Speaker 02 I think the potential corruption, and we've always had, you know, sports gambling in Las Vegas, so it's a little difficult to say, why do they get in another's, but there's more regulation there. And I think people are worried about all the different states doing it, you know, and you're going to have this corruption. I mean, with gambling comes corruption.
52:39 Speaker 00 Right, okay. And what else? But that's a really excellent point.
52:42 Speaker 02 I think cryptocurrency and Bitcoin, another, you know, where the money is, and are those securities? Those are big issues for these companies. And then I think what you're talking about, VR, AR, those things are, I think, we don't understand them back here in Washington, but we at least have an idea. And I think people understand driverless cars are like cars, so we need regulation. I think it's going to be the same challenge, though. How do we figure out how to regulate? That tech is usually far ahead of the government, so...
53:15 Speaker 00 Especially if it's on a state level versus a federal level, because there's certain laws that have to be in, say, self-driving. And they're also linked with jobs, as Hillary was pointing out.
53:23 Speaker 02 Right. You might have a regulatory scheme like you do in, you know, the FDA, where you have a federal scheme. Or you may go state by state, and if you have state by state, like you normally do for driving, you can have some real difficulties for the companies.
53:36 Speaker 00 Especially because it's more complicated.
53:37 Speaker 02 Lobby 50 states and, right, come out with different rules, and how do they make the cars, you know, kind of meet the regulations? If you have 50 sets of regulations, most companies want a federal scheme. It's easier for them.
53:49 Speaker 00 Sure. Luther?
53:50 Speaker 03 I would go back to the last major disruption, I would argue, was DOJ versus Microsoft, when you had effectively, even though people sort of remember that as this sort of stalemate, where the government came in too little, too late, and, oh, you know, we stopped using Microsoft anyway, you sometimes hear, that oxygenated the market, because suddenly Microsoft's product managers couldn't just say, huh, I'm going to bulldoze into this adjacent business vertical today. And so, you know, coincidentally, you have, six months after that case is launched, you have Google is born, 1998. And I think Microsoft could have very easily strangled
54:33 Speaker 03 Google in the crib in 98, because it had dominance at over 90% share in Internet Explorer. And so, antitrust enforcement, if, I think, is desperately needed, because the dynamics today are that these firms are really sitting on massive data modes. And so, if you think about... The next wave for AI and form factor shifting to kind of voice-based technology. If you don't have the
54:59 Speaker 00 Which they dominate.
55:00 Speaker 03 Exactly.
55:01 Speaker 00 Which Google and Facebook and Amazon dominate.
55:03 Speaker 03 If you don't have that kind of oxygenating enforcement happening, then you could easily see these firms just get more consolidated, get more dominant, more deeply entrenched. And so I think that that is a major test. You know, Microsoft was almost 20 years ago before that.
55:24 Speaker 00 AT&T.
55:25 Speaker 03 Was IBM and then, yeah, before that was AT&T. And each, it's like this 20-year cycle where government action or threat of action can create this oxidating effect. And we're at one of these inflection points, I'd argue. And if we're not, if we don't enforce the antitrust laws, then that could lead to just more deeply entrenched dominance. I am excited about cryptocurrency and Coinbase, just because it seems like if that kind of takes off in the way that sort of the people have said it sort of is almost like TCP IP was, it could create sort of a new medium for value exchange, which really could fundamentally disrupt and change how we consume content and how we are doing this.
56:09 Speaker 03 But it's in such early stages and it's very speculative now, so it's hard to say, you know, where that goes. But I'm genuinely fearful that this is just going to get kind of darker and more dystopian and tech becomes more ever-present if we're not willing to kind of, you know, use our antitrust laws.
56:29 Speaker 00 Have you seen Blaine Runner 2049? I just interviewed Jared Leto.
56:32 Speaker 01 Well, and are we at a point where government is still capable of regulating? So regardless of your political views, there are
56:43 Speaker 01 Literally hundreds of thousands of civil servants in this country who work at the Department of Justice on the civil side and the criminal side, at the Consumer Product Safety Commission, at the Securities and Exchange Commission, at the Consumer Financial Protection Board, at the Civil Rights Commission, at the Federal Trade Commission, you think about all at the, you know, the National Highway and Transportation Safety Board for self-driving cars.
57:11 Speaker 02 Securities and Exchange Commission.
57:12 Speaker 01 You think of, you know, 20 or more federal agencies with thousands and thousands and thousands of, quote, "regulators" looking at various businesses, all of which are being disrupted now by tech and innovation. And do they have the capacity to keep up?
57:32 Speaker 02 Well, I think they're trying, and Luther thinks the big thoughts, I think the small thoughts. I think some of these investigations come together in the regulatory, when there's a front-page issue, so opiates, right, is a huge issue. So who transports those now? They get translated.
57:46 Speaker 01 Online.
57:47 Speaker 02 Pharmacies online and Amazon. So if you're upset about Amazon and you don't know how to regulate Amazon otherwise, but you're mad about opiates, you could drag Amazon into that.
57:57 Speaker 01 Yep.
57:58 Speaker 02 You know, you think of...
57:59 Speaker 01 That's a really good point.
58:00 Speaker 02 And so I think those investigations and those regulations are going to come in that way. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, you know, Senator Warren's favorite little bureau, has been trying to regulate, kind of, you know, online lending. And now they're going after the Indian tribes. So, you know, that's because they want to go after online lending, and that's their way of getting at the Internet. So all these things, I don't know that they're going to know how to regulate the big issues, but I think they will go after them on these issues that are kind of more conventional that they understand.
58:33 Speaker 01 And there's plenty of those.
58:34 Speaker 02 And there's plenty of those.
58:35 Speaker 01 There's lots of them.
58:36 Speaker 02 Now, because these companies are in the middle of all our commerce, you can drag these, just like you're dragging in Google and Facebook on the ads, you know, they're not really the source of the problem, but because they're, excuse me, the conveyor, I think they're going to get dragged in. So that's how I think a lot of these issues are going to come in the future, just because they are so big and they are in the middle of every issue.
58:55 Speaker 01 Sue, before we finish up, I want to talk about a couple more things, very briefly. One is Europe. Marguerite Vestager is certainly not.
59:03 Speaker 00 Backing down and she's
59:04 Speaker 02 She's not shy.
59:04 Speaker 00 She's not shy and she's on, she's, turns out the world is turning towards her when she was saying. What do you imagine happens in Europe, each of you really briefly, and then I want to go through each of the companies and what you think their biggest challenge from a legislative or regulatory point of view is, and then Hillary might have a final question, but, so just very briefly, Europe.
59:22 Speaker 02 I really don't know. I don't think I'm the one that's qualified. I think you're right that their regulators are, have been more persistent and I think they will be compared to the US.
59:32 Speaker 00 Privacy, everything.
59:33 Speaker 02 Because of the administration. And privacy is such a huge issue in Europe, but also our administration is, you know, Luther's going to be disappointed because there's not going to be a lot of antitrust enforcement in this administration, I don't think.
59:44 Speaker 03 I, so, I think what Commissioner Vestager in Brussels is doing is really exciting. You know, I, I think that the day before she announced her big record fight against Google, there was a slew of US companies that basically sent her a love letter saying, gosh, thank you for doing this, we sure wish our FTC would do this, and we don't consider this protectionism. And every time I go to Brussels and I sit down with her team, there's like another US, somebody representing a US tech firm walking out of the conference room. And, and that's the little secret about Brussels is it's, US firms are having to go to Europe to seek relief, that this is not protectionism, this is a venue where they enforce their antitrust laws.
1:00:27 Speaker 03 And I would also make a distinction between enforcing antitrust and, and regulation on the point earlier. Antitrust is the antidote regulation. If you enforce antitrust, you don't have to regulate. And I, and so I think that the taxes is a separate issue, like the, the tax stuff, but on antitrust, I think you now have a situation where European consumers are poised to enjoy better protections than US consumers, and that's going to create a political forcing mechanism for state AGs for
1:00:55 Speaker 00 Which you're going to see a lot of in states.
1:00:57 Speaker 03 I'm cautiously optimistic. I mean, at least happy that we have a blank slate at the FTC, although you're right, it is a sort of kind of traditional Republican mold, so. You know, time will tell in the US FTC.
1:01:06 Speaker 01 On the regulation front, the state attorneys general around the country have increasing resources in some of these big states, and you're right, we haven't talked about them as either enforcers or prosecutors yet, but they'll be very active.
1:01:20 Speaker 00 Absolutely. Which one, do you think?
1:01:22 Speaker 01 I think you look at New York, and Eric Schneiderman, you look at Illinois, you look at California.
1:01:27 Speaker 02 They're all in the opiate crisis. If you look at that, they're the ones bringing the cases.
1:01:30 Speaker 01 Pennsylvania, they have resources, they have big offices, and...
1:01:34 Speaker 02 They're Democrats.
1:01:35 Speaker 01 And they're Democrats.
1:01:36 Speaker 00 All right, last question, and then Hillary might have a last question, but Mike, just each of the companies, their biggest issue they face, so let's go through them, and each of you, and either both can answer, or individually, whoever doesn't have an answer, Apple.
1:01:47 Speaker 02 I think they're in a good place.
1:01:49 Speaker 00 Unless there's some encryption thing that pops in.
1:01:52 Speaker 02 Right. I mean, that's always going to be an issue for them, and they've taken a principled stand, I think, because they're a hardware provider, basically, and they've kind of stayed above the fray, they're in a very good place. I think it's their competitors who've gotten so big. I mean, Amazon's biggest problem is that it's so big and so good.
1:02:10 Speaker 00 All right, Microsoft.
1:02:12 Speaker 03 Doesn't register. I think they're, I mean, they're not as...
1:02:15 Speaker 00 It's so funny. They used to be so evil.
1:02:16 Speaker 03 Yeah, they're not.
1:02:17 Speaker 02 Their stock price is doing great.
1:02:18 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
1:02:19 Speaker 03 I think Sundar and the CEOs of Google and Microsoft sort of buried the hatchet, and so that famous beef has kind of gone by the wayside, yeah.
1:02:30 Speaker 01 You've got to go back to Apple on two issues, though. One is just the issue with jobs, and whether they really can
1:02:35 Speaker 00 Right.
1:02:36 Speaker 01 sustain their overseas manufacturing relative to domestic, and the other are potential antitrust issues, complaints from the other companies around their dominance on the App Store, and whether they can continue to keep such a tight hold on that.
1:02:54 Speaker 00 Although that seems rather quaint now, doesn't it, considering all the other issues? Google, I'm not going to give you Google, but, okay, you can have, you can, go ahead.
1:03:02 Speaker 02 I mean, Google are their ads. I mean, their best revenue is going to be their biggest problem, and it's what they're facing with Congress right now. And I don't think that's going to go away either.
1:03:11 Speaker 00 All right. Luther, go ahead.
1:03:13 Speaker 03 Well, today, when a mom does a search for a pediatrician in Washington DC, she's seeing this sort of Google plus box at the top. And I think that is a way where Google is directly harming consumers. And that's really the smoking gun that the FTC missed. And I think when Vestager looked at the same set of evidence, they decided to move forward. And so that's where I think they're potentially exposed is on these antitrust issues, because you can show direct consumer harm.
1:03:39 Speaker 00 All right. Facebook.
1:03:41 Speaker 02 I think I'm too biased.
1:03:43 Speaker 00 All right. And Mark's a nice guy. Go ahead.
1:03:46 Speaker 03 You know, Facebook-
1:03:47 Speaker 00 Yes. I agree with you on that one.
1:03:49 Speaker 03 I think the thing that's a little bit concerning about Facebook to me is you've read these stories about they just acquired TBH. And, you know, they sort of cloned all of Snapchat's features-
1:04:01 Speaker 00 And they admitted quite publicly about it.
1:04:03 Speaker 03 Yeah. And so, again, I think that these are just-
1:04:06 Speaker 02 Google copied everyone, too. I mean, you know, it's good old fashioned American competition.
1:04:10 Speaker 00 Yeah.
1:04:11 Speaker 01 I think Facebook has a content problem.
1:04:13 Speaker 00 Let's have you do it.
1:04:14 Speaker 01 I think Facebook has a content problem that will stretch their credibility over time. Who is posting and what can we trust about what they say? And I think their risk is that it becomes so polluted, that the system becomes so polluted with content that people don't trust or don't know where it comes from. They seem to be focused on trying to deal with that.
1:04:35 Speaker 02 Don't you think that's because people are treating them like they're more like a conventional media source?
1:04:40 Speaker 01 They are a media company.
1:04:42 Speaker 02 But they are and they aren't.
1:04:44 Speaker 01 They say they're a tech company, but they are a media company.
1:04:46 Speaker 02 But I don't get to go to, you know, ABC News and put up what I think.
1:04:49 Speaker 01 Right.
1:04:50 Speaker 02 So it isn't the same as a-
1:04:51 Speaker 00 It's a different kind of media company, but it's a media company. They do try to- Hillary said, they try to pretend they're a benign platform. This is a word I use all the time.
1:04:59 Speaker 02 I don't know that they're benign, but my point is-
1:05:01 Speaker 00 Oh, I don't think they're benign at all.
1:05:02 Speaker 02 It's much more- I know you don't. You don't think anyone's benign.
1:05:04 Speaker 00 No, I don't.
1:05:05 Speaker 02 That's good.
1:05:06 Speaker 00 I think you're not benign at all.
1:05:07 Speaker 02 I'm not benign. You are so right.
1:05:09 Speaker 00 But then neither are you.
1:05:11 Speaker 02 I don't pretend to be.
1:05:12 Speaker 00 That's true.
1:05:13 Speaker 02 But I think that it's different when everyone's putting their own content, or what they would call their own content up, because then you get into First Amendment issues very quickly. Into the implicit promise of the business.
1:05:23 Speaker 01 Well, and again, I think all of these issues are, is there a legal issue, or is there a moral responsibility, or is there a public policy issue? And the intersection of those three issues going forward, I think, are what's going to be our most challenged.
1:05:36 Speaker 00 Last one for me, Twitter. We didn't talk about them at all, but the president's favorite.
1:05:40 Speaker 02 He's saved that company. Single-handedly has saved Twitter.
1:05:44 Speaker 01 Saved and ruined it.
1:05:45 Speaker 00 Yeah. So, any issues there, besides viability as a business?
1:05:49 Speaker 02 Right. Well, I think that's a pretty big issue. You know, regulatory issues are kind of a luxury, if you don't think you're going to stay in business.
1:05:56 Speaker 03 I'm eager to see what their kind of plan of self-governance, attacking these fake accounts and trolling, will be, because that's clearly just dogged them forever. I think just, I mean, their market cap's, what, something like 30 billion? I mean, they're like a 10th or a 20th of the size of these companies, and not a lot of people, I mean...
1:06:15 Speaker 00 But they get a lot of attention because of the president.
1:06:16 Speaker 03 They do, because all the media, well...
1:06:17 Speaker 00 And the media, and the people.
1:06:19 Speaker 03 People in the media use it, and I think that's the reason we even include them in the same breath. But really, there's just not as much data, there's not as much influence, and so I think that gives them some inoculation from this.
1:06:30 Speaker 01 I think that's probably the most important thing about Twitter, and the least-used thing about Twitter, is that it is essentially, of all of them, the most used by elites than any other communications mechanism. Elites don't communicate with each other on Facebook in the same way.
1:06:49 Speaker 00 No, not at all. Hillary, last question, to wrap it up.
1:06:52 Speaker 01 Well, I'm curious whether you think this is, you know, in a year, our dinner table, is dinner table talk in Washington still going to be about the tech industry, or is this going to fade?
1:07:02 Speaker 02 I don't think it'll fade. It may not be these same issues we've been talking about, but again, they've transformed the economy, and, you know, Washington follows the money, and they're going to talk about the companies that are really affecting, you know, their constituents' lives, and that's these companies.
1:07:17 Speaker 03 I totally agree with that.
1:07:19 Speaker 00 All right. Thank you so much. I love that. Let's end on that. Let's end on that. But there'll be plenty of business for you both, I think, I suspect, including you, Hilary Rosen. Hillary, thank you so much for co-hosting. Thanks for having me, Kara. We have many to go. Looking forward to it. Very exciting. And you could take my job at any time. I can see that, obviously. All right, Luther and Beth, it was great also talking to you and thanks for coming on the show. Thanks, Kara. We appreciate it. These are big issues. We're going to bring you guys back and figure it out in a little bit after things, see what happens. If you enjoyed the interview as much as we did, be sure to subscribe to the show. Be the first to listen to future episodes or catch up on previous episodes, including some really fantastic interviews I've done with people like Leonardo da Vinci author Walter Isaacson and Yelp CEO Jeremy Stoppelman, who's your boss.
1:08:02 Speaker 00 And in last November, I interviewed Hillary as well as the Republican political consultant Juliana Glover on this show, so you can go and look at that. You can find all those episodes and more wherever you found this one or on our website, recode.net/podcast. Now that you're done with this, check out some of our other shows on Recode Media with Peter Kafka. You'll hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment. I host Too Embarrassed to Ask along with Lauren Good of The Verge, where we answer all of your questions about consumer tech. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from all of Recode's live events, including the Code Conference. Thanks for listening to this bonus episode of Recode Decode. Thanks also to Cadence 13, the company that distributes the show, including Beth O'Connell and our editor, Chris Basil, and thank you to our producer, Eric Johnson.
1:08:44 Speaker 00 I'll be back here at my usual time on Monday, and then Hillary and I will be back next Wednesday with another great guest. Tune in then.
1:08:53 Speaker 07 Hey, Recode Decode fans. This is Sarah Cliffe with a new podcast suggestion for you. It's called The Impact, and every week, we have stories about real people. I got pregnant two months after I graduated high school. It was not planned. We look at the policies that shape those people's lives. Too often here in DC, we stop talking about laws after they pass. But on The Impact, we will follow those policies out into the real world where all of us live. It's just fantastic. It's just great. Subscribe on Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, or whatever podcast app you like the most.
Previous Recode Decode: David Rosenblatt, CEO, 1stdibs Next Recode Decode: Ray Dalio, author, 'Principles: Life and Work' Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated