Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Journalist Julia Angwin About this episode Julia Angwin, the former editor-in-chief of The Markup, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher in this live podcast recorded in Washington, DC.
In this episode: How Angwin got into journalism; why weren’t people always angry about tech privacy?; ProPublica’s investigations into tech companies; the "ungovernable" tech giants; leaving ProPublica to co-found The Markup; Angwin’s co-founders, Jeff Larson and Sue Gardner; what the hell happened?; what part of it was Angwin’s fault?; the difference between being skeptical and negative; Larson’s Medium post and Craig Newmark’s reaction; is it easier to raise money for advocacy news?; media literacy for young people; "scientific journalism"; and what Angwin will do next.
This special episode of Recode Decode with Kara Swisher was taped in front of a live audience at The LINE DC to celebrate Vox’s fifth anniversary. If you enjoyed it, we think you’ll also enjoy this live taping of The Weeds, and this special episode of The Ezra Klein Show featuring Vox’s co-founders Ezra Klein, Matt Yglesias, and Vox Media’s Publisher Melissa Bell.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 8,772 words · 12 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Growing teams need a corporate card built for more, something that doesn't sacrifice speed for control. Introducing the American Express Corporate Cash Back Card. Get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, advanced spending controls, and real-time visibility, plus intelligent expense management. Get started at go.amex slash amexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:31 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio, or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:48 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:55 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as the Maria Keurig of tech journalism. Getting close to this stuff will probably kill me, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play a live interview I just did with investigative journalist Julia Angwin, who until very recently was the editor-in-chief of The Markup. We talked about why she was fired on Monday by her co-founders Jeff Larson and Sue Gardner.
1:21 Speaker 03 She took me aside in January with Jeff, the two of them, and they said, "You're not suited to be editor-in-chief." And the reasons were things like, "You don't like meetings."
1:32 Speaker 02 Yeah.
1:34 Speaker 03 That's true. But I did go to all of them.
1:38 Speaker 02 We'll also talk about Angwin's history of investigating tech companies like Facebook at The Wall Street Journal and ProPublica.
1:44 Speaker 03 These are companies that are almost ungovernable. They're bigger than any nation, and they regulate speech around the world. Like, their decisions about what people can say to each other is the decision in any country.
1:56 Speaker 02 This interview was recorded in front of a live audience at the Line Hotel in Washington, DC. We were there for a party celebrating the fifth anniversary of Vox.com, and we recorded on the rooftop, which is why you'll hear some street noise in the background. So let's go there now to hear my interview with journalist Julia Angwin.
2:15 Speaker 02 Hi, everybody. First of all, I want to know what the hell you're doing out here at this time of day. I don't know what I'm doing. I decided to drive my kids to work, to school, work, whatever. Anyway, I'm sorry I'm dressed like this. I'm freezing. So I'm going to stay dressed like Johnny Cash this morning. So you're going to have to deal with it. So I'm really excited to do this. I love Vox. Recode has recently been united with Vox, and we're doing all kinds of cool things together, and we're very excited, including these events. And it's their fifth anniversary of Vox itself. It's, I think, the 59th anniversary of what Recode has been over the years. But we've been going for a long, long time. But we've just started doing these amazing live podcasts. And so when they asked me to do
2:57 Speaker 02 this, I thought, who could we get where we could talk about journalism and where things are going, and perhaps there's a little bit of controversy we could talk about at the same time. And so I brought up someone I have worked with for many years, Julia Angwin, from the Mark-- well, not from the Markup. So she's going to come up. We're going to talk about a lot of things. We're going to talk about the Markup and a bunch of other things.
3:19 Speaker 02 Sit in my gold chair, my golden chair. So anyway, Julia and I worked at The Wall Street Journal together 20 years ago, 30? I don't know. All right, okay. So we worked in traditional journalism for a long time, and both of us left traditional journalism to do other things. Let's get Markup out of the way. Tell us what happened there. Explain what the Markup was supposed to be, what happened there, and any other incredibly awful details you could bring to mind.
3:53 Speaker 03 Well, it's great to be here, guys. I never knew being fired from the company I founded would be so good for my social media presence. And I left ProPublica a year ago to found the Markup. I have been a tech journalist along with Cara for 25 years, and I had built up a specialty in doing investigative journalism alongside and with computer programmers who would help me build big data sets and analyze data to do really deep investigative work.
4:25 Speaker 02 Let's just, before you get to that, how did you decide to do that? Because you were a traditional media-- you were in media. I was in the early internet, one of the few people who was covering tech long ago. Talk about how you got into that. Why did you-- you had covered-- Just companies, right?
4:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, actually, you know, I remember I covered Jim Bankoff when he ran AOL. And I covered AOL and you obviously were the original AOL person, but I wrote the book on it, literally. But I remember actually Jim Bankoff, I wrote a story. He's the first reference ever being quoted using the term "social media." It's in the OED in a story that I wrote about him.
5:01 Speaker 02 Okay, so he was, he was running the content stuff for AOL?
5:04 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. But the way, the way that I ended up in this weird sort of fusion of programming and journalism is that I grew up in Palo Alto and started programming in fifth grade. So my parents were the early, early-
5:15 Speaker 02 You went to Palo Alto High School?
5:16 Speaker 03 I did go to Palo Alto, also known as Paly. So I actually grew up in the personal computer revolution. So computers had gone from the size of the stage to the size of this. And everybody was super excited, including my parents, who drove out there in their VW in 1974 and said, "Look, let's join this." And so I never had a typewriter. I learned code in fifth grade, actually because of Steve Jobs. He had done a program in the Palo Alto School to have all the kids learn how to program in BASIC. And I actually thought there were only two life choices: hardware, software.
5:50 Speaker 02 Right, okay. So you were going to get into compute?
5:53 Speaker 03 Yeah, I worked in my, so I went to college. I studied math at University of Chicago. They didn't have a CS degree, so I took CS classes. And I spent my summers working at Hewlett-Packard. And there was no reason I wasn't going to go back, except that I fell in love with the college paper and started writing for it. And so I thought, "Well, I'll just do this for a couple of years, just as like a rebellion against tech." That worked out for a little while. I was here in DC after college. I covered The Hill. But eventually, in 1996, The San Francisco Chronicle hired me to cover tech because it became clear that there were no reporters who knew anything about it. And so they were like, "Oh, wait, you've used computers before. Like, please cover technology."
6:35 Speaker 02 Right, right, right. That's about it. Yeah, that's the qualification.
6:38 Speaker 03 That was it.
6:39 Speaker 02 So you had had this computer background. Had you, had you ever thought of moving into tech itself? Like, getting a job at Google or wherever?
6:45 Speaker 03 No, I mean, after my summers in Hewlett-Packard in college, I mean, to be completely candid with you, Cara, the, like- My boss there was sexually harassing me and so I was so young that I didn't know there were any options and I don't even know if there were options at that time. So, one of the main reasons I left tech is I was really early pushed out
7:05 Speaker 02 Right, right.
7:06 Speaker 03 by Me Too.
7:07 Speaker 02 Right.
7:07 Speaker 03 And so, when I had a job waiting for me after college, I thought, you know, I just can't go back to that dude, I'm gonna go into journalism and that was a good choice for me.
7:16 Speaker 02 Right.
7:16 Speaker 03 I think.
7:16 Speaker 02 And so, and at that time, tech had been just dominated by men, right, as it is today.
7:21 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:21 Speaker 02 So, you decided to get into journalism, you went to the Chronicle and then to the Journal.
7:26 Speaker 03 Yes.
7:27 Speaker 02 Right. So, how did you get into the idea of using computers to do this? Because this was, people had been doing it for crime statistics
7:33 Speaker 03 Yep.
7:34 Speaker 02 and everything else, but you shifted it in a different way.
7:37 Speaker 03 Yeah, so like most newsrooms had like a data desk, actually, I don't know if you all know, but it was called the Computer-Assisted Reporting Desk.
7:44 Speaker 02 Right.
7:44 Speaker 03 The Car Desk.
7:45 Speaker 02 Right.
7:46 Speaker 03 And that field is still called that, which is kind of terrifying. But, what happened was, I went on book leave to write a book about MySpace because I thought social networking was gonna be big.
7:57 Speaker 02 Right.
7:58 Speaker 03 I was right about that. I was wrong about which ones to write a book about.
8:02 Speaker 02 Yeah.
8:03 Speaker 03 And when I came back, I thought, you know, the thing I really was shocked about, one of the many things I was shocked about while writing that book was sort of the dawning of the realization that there was a market for personal data, because that's really what the social networks were doing, is monetizing your data. And so, I thought, I wanna start an investigative project on that topic. So, I started reading like the literature and I found that there was this programmer at Berkeley in graduate school, Ashkan Soltani, who had sort of done this scan of the web to see sort of how much tracking was going on. So, I convinced my boss to let me hire him as a, just to do that research again for me. And that's how it started. I was just like, oh, that seems cool, that seems like an investigative project, and I hired him. And then that spawned a whole series of articles called What They Know, where I continued
8:48 Speaker 03 to hire him, and I stole programmers off the graphics desk, and I stole them wherever I could to do all sorts of different types of analysis. And what I found was that that type of reporting It could lead to more concrete results because the fact that you diagnosed the problem so clearly and you released your data set meant that people could really clearly identify the problem and there was a way to solve it. I mean, obviously, we haven't solved any of those problems.
9:12 Speaker 02 But when you were writing those things, there was no being, people being upset about it that much. There was some, there was some, that they were doing this, they were doing this wholesale stealing, taking of data, not stealing, you gave it up. There wasn't that much anger over it. It was sort of, it was celebrated. It has been celebrated for a long time.
9:30 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, I was, I was too early, right, for the outrage. I mean, people were like, why are you writing about this? It's just creepy ads, you know? And I think it had to get to the point where the election was, where people realized, oh, this is affecting our common discourse in elections. That's why I feel like people woke up in 2016. But when I was writing in 2010, you know, Jeff Jarvis blogged, like, this is so dumb, you're taking down, you know, the innovation economy, like, what a stupid series of articles, right? And that was kind of the common tech view of it.
9:58 Speaker 02 This was a good thing and this was, you finally found a business plan.
10:01 Speaker 03 Yep.
10:02 Speaker 02 That works and that people don't care and they want to willingly give up their information.
10:06 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:07 Speaker 02 Right, that was the thought about it. So I'm going to fast forward to what happened at Markup. So you had moved, you had gone to ProPublica, which is the fantastic organization that does investigative, and had done this again, and come across a story around Facebook.
10:21 Speaker 03 Yeah, so basically, we were looking into Facebook and how, what Facebook knew about you. So we, we put, we offered readers a tool that let them sort of download all the things that Facebook said it knew about you. And what we noticed was that we didn't, we hadn't realized that they were profiling people by race. And so they would identify you as African-American affinity. So it wasn't quite, it was like you, their description was actually affinity, meaning like you liked black people.
10:48 Speaker 02 Right.
10:49 Speaker 03 Which was weird. And so somebody tipped me off the fact that that meant, if you, if advertisers could choose that category, they could probably discriminate in their ads by race. So we thought, oh, let's see if we can break the fair housing law and make a housing ad that's only targeted to white people. And we put it through the system and it went through. And so we wrote an article like, wow, didn't know you could break the fair housing law, that's cool. Then.
11:13 Speaker 02 Yeah.
11:14 Speaker 03 Facebook said, oh, we'll fix it. Like, we'll build an algorithm, whatever. They built the algorithm, released it. We tested it again, and we could still break the fair housing law. So then they were like, oh, we'll try it, fix it again. HUD began an investigation, and then we noticed other things, right? We felt we actually tested other things. We were able to buy ad. We didn't actually buy the ads. We, we noticed actually that employers were putting age categories in their ads. So their ads would only be targeted to people like 18 to 24, which also is a violation of age discrimination laws. So we started looking at more and more different aspects of the way that you could discriminate in advertising. And after about two and a half years, three years, actually, it was only about a few weeks ago.
11:58 Speaker 03 Facebook finally said it would stop offering those, what I call the dropdown racism menus that they were offering before.
12:05 Speaker 02 Right, right. They don't call it that. It's really helpful to people to target their ads properly.
12:12 Speaker 03 Right, it's a service.
12:13 Speaker 02 Yes. Were they very, very sorry?
12:15 Speaker 03 They were.
12:16 Speaker 02 They were very, very sorry.
12:17 Speaker 03 Incredibly sorry. And they actually, do you know what they were gonna try to do?
12:21 Speaker 02 Have an I'm sorry tour?
12:22 Speaker 03 They were gonna do better.
12:23 Speaker 02 Do better.
12:24 Speaker 03 They were gonna do better.
12:25 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's like this. We didn't mean to do this, and we're gonna do really, really better. They have hand signals when they do it. So, not Mark. So when you put into this, what was the attitude towards Facebook? Now, you had written about MySpace in your book. Had you seen the power of Facebook? Had you thought about what was happening there?
12:47 Speaker 03 You mean prior to the advertising? Yeah, no, actually, back at the Wall Street Journal, we had done a story, literally the same story as Cambridge Analytica, about a company that was taking your voting information, stealing data from Facebook and using it to target ads. It's just we were too early. It was, but it was literally the same thing. And Facebook, by the way, said they were sorry, and they were gonna change the third-party control so that people couldn't steal this data anymore. So, so, yeah, I'd been increasingly concerned about this data market for a long time.
13:21 Speaker 02 And why do you think they have that attitude? You've approached them from a computer point of view, which is something they understand. Why do you think they continue to do this? What do you, because today, there's news, they just announced they're going to pay a $3 to $5 billion fine, which is, they have it in their drawer. It is not a fine. It is not a fine. Let us just say, it's not even, it's not even a, it won't touch them in any way.
13:46 Speaker 03 Right.
13:47 Speaker 02 Why do you think they're like this?
13:50 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, it's always hard to prove intent, right? But I guess what I said-
13:54 Speaker 02 I know, we've noticed that, anyway.
13:57 Speaker 03 But I have to say that I feel like it's really, like, there's, there was a little bit of an engineering mindset. Like, I feel like whenever I would talk to the people at Facebook, they'd be like, "Well, if you choose to target ads, like, what is the difference between targeting towards a group versus having a dropdown menu to exclude a group?" Like, in the engineering mindset, they literally were like, "Well, if you could target ads to people with brown hair, like, why couldn't you have a dropdown menu to exclude your ads from ever being shown to a black person?"
14:24 Speaker 02 Right.
14:25 Speaker 03 And so, it was just like this, like, lack of sort of context, like, about humans and laws, that I feel like maybe there was just like a lack of education about it.
14:35 Speaker 02 And their response to you was what? That this was fine?
14:40 Speaker 03 It evolved over time. Like, the very initial response was, "I don't think you understand ad targeting."
14:44 Speaker 02 Right.
14:45 Speaker 03 And then it became, "Oh, this was a mistake, we're going to fix it," you know?
14:50 Speaker 02 And what do you imagine is going to happen today to Facebook and companies like this? Because I think a lot of people feel that people have outrage over privacy, but I don't think people do. I think there's, they're going to get fined and they're going to move on and find ever more nefarious ways to spy on you.
15:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, if you look at Google, they paid a almost $6 billion fine to the EU last year. It didn't, it literally didn't move the stock, make a blip in their earnings, you know? Didn't change any behavior. So, so we've seen that these companies can weather these kinds of fines. And so, I don't know, I mean-
15:23 Speaker 03 I try to be optimistic. Like, I do think that public, when they're embarrassed, they try to eventually sort of fix things, but it doesn't feel like, systemically, there's a fix that anyone is pursuing. And I don't know how that works, because these are companies that are almost ungovernable, right?
15:39 Speaker 02 No, they're absolutely ungovernable.
15:40 Speaker 03 Right. I mean, like, they're bigger than any nation. And they regulate speech around the world. Like, their decisions about what people can say to each other is the decision in any country. And every country is struggling with how can I, this is something bigger than me that I can't control. It's a force that I don't think we even know how to deal with in the world.
16:03 Speaker 02 Right. How would you deal with it?
16:04 Speaker 03 I'm not that great at solutions. I'm super good at problems, but I do feel like that there has to be, something structural has to change. And I don't know what it looks like, but I do feel like it has to be, governments have to have some control over how speech happens in their countries.
16:23 Speaker 02 Which happened in Sri Lanka. They just shut it down.
16:26 Speaker 03 Yep, that happens. And Germany's doing a pretty good job of keeping the Nazis off Facebook, so it's like weird, and Twitter. So, like, you can go there and have a Nazi-free experience on the internet. And so you realize there is a world where you could have a Nazi-free experience.
16:37 Speaker 02 Not in this country. They're trending. We're going to take a quick break now. After this, we'll talk more with investigative journalist Julia Angwin about why she was fired from the markup and what part of the turmoil there she believes was her fault.
16:51 Speaker 04 It's me, the
16:54 Speaker 04 We don't need the jingle twice. Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars.
17:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app.
17:12 Speaker 04 Fine. No one deals more deals than Please stop. Touche.
17:19 Speaker 04 Priceline.
17:20 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
17:21 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
17:22 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
17:23 Speaker 01 Caramel?
17:23 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
17:24 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want.
17:30 Speaker 01 With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling.
17:41 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
17:47 Speaker 02 Let's talk about journalism because one of the things that's being impacted by Facebook and Google and the changes they've made in targeting is to suck up all the digital advertising dollars.
17:55 Speaker 03 Correct.
17:55 Speaker 02 You decided to go off from ProPublica where you had the very traditional, even though ProPublica is more of an outlier than the Wall Street Journal than the San Francisco Chronicle, to start the markup.
18:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:05 Speaker 02 What was the concept?
18:07 Speaker 03 What I wanted to do was, I had a little team at ProPublica, two programmers and a researcher, and we were doing our investigations. And, you know, one year we did Facebook, one year we did software that was used to assess criminals and predict their future criminality, which we showed was biased against black defendants, big surprise. And we showed, one year we did car insurance, how breadlining worked. But each year we had to pick, and I felt like everything is happening all at once, and like, I want four teams like this. Because the technology is not just impacting like the companies that we think of as tech, Facebook and Google, but every bit of our lives is being algorithmically decided. And some of these decisions, like the criminal risk scores, have enormous consequences, incarceration or not.
18:52 Speaker 03 And so my idea was I wanted to scale up this work and sort of build a field around tech accountability journalism. You know, tech journalism had, its origins were really very much fanboy, right? And so the field is evolving, but I wanted to build that investigative wing and really make a model for the field of how this could be done using technology to investigate technology.
19:15 Speaker 02 So you went around, you went to raise money and got, how much money?
19:19 Speaker 03 Almost, more than 23 million.
19:21 Speaker 02 From?
19:22 Speaker 03 Mostly from Craig Newmark, who pledged 20 million.
19:25 Speaker 02 Right, who ruined classified advertising for most, for the San Francisco Chronicle, for example, Craigslist founder.
19:30 Speaker 03 Yeah.
19:31 Speaker 02 So he was taking his money, and he's talked about this, he was taking his money that wrecked newspapers to try to do something about it. He said that to me.
19:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, I'll let you put words in his mouth.
19:42 Speaker 02 I shall. And he said, so you, $23 million to form a team to look at just, instead of just what had been done, which is piecemeal, or else someone like me, which I just stand outside of tech companies and yell at them.
19:56 Speaker 03 Which, by the way, is very effective.
19:58 Speaker 02 I know it is. It's really effective. And I will continue to do so. So you decided to do this. You got two partners. One was someone you work with at ProPublica.
20:06 Speaker 03 Yeah, my colleague Jeff Larson, who he and I had been doing these investigations together for years. And then he and I recruited this woman, Sue Gardner, who'd run Wikimedia Foundation, to be our business partner. Because we knew that, we had heard that journalists were not good at running businesses. And so we thought we needed someone to help us with that.
20:25 Speaker 02 Right. And you'd seen people trying this stuff. I've tried, I did, there's lots of efforts in this area. What did you think was going to, Vox itself was within the Washington Post and then moved here. What did you think about going into business as a reporter? And the word is reportrepreneur, in case you're interested.
20:45 Speaker 03 Oh, geez, I didn't know that.
20:47 Speaker 02 Please don't use it ever again.
20:50 Speaker 03 I won't.
20:51 Speaker 02 So did you, did you worry about that part of it?
20:54 Speaker 03 I did worry about it, but I actually felt like the nonprofit model that we were pursuing had a little bit more hope. I feel like the for-profit model has led to, it's just been really hard, because it doesn't, it really, it trends towards clickbait, you know, and you have to really push against that, because the ad model is really this incredibly transactional model, and it's not based on the quality of your audience at all. So I was hopeful that we could sort of build a nonprofit model by getting our readers to understand that, like, we weren't going to have any tracking on the website. It was going to be very privacy protecting. It was going to feel like a service, you know, because a lot of places that charge subscriptions, but then they still track you and still advertise you. And it's like, come on, guys. You know, so we felt like, okay, maybe people would donate the amount
21:39 Speaker 03 that they would have subscribed somewhere, because they understood that we were on their side. We weren't selling their data, collecting it at all.
21:45 Speaker 02 So it was ProPublica, it was a nonprofit model, that you would have people who supported you, which is like a subscription, essentially, and then money from rich people.
21:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, right. Combination. You've got to always have a billionaire in journalism these days, apparently.
22:00 Speaker 02 So you did that, and then moved into this. So I guess the only question is, like, what the hell happened?
22:05 Speaker 03 Yes. So I did a kind of founder's mistake, which was when I recruited Sue to be the business partner. And I didn't really, we didn't talk about what our roles would be until we were a couple of weeks away from closing the gift from Craig. And then she said, she gave me an ultimatum that she would quit if I didn't make her CEO and my boss. And I was scared. I thought, oh my God, we're gonna lose this money. How do I go back to him and say like, we're starting again with a different team? And so I said, okay, well, I'll agree to that, because honestly, I didn't want to do the business side stuff. So I thought, most of that job is actually stuff I don't want to do, but I need an employment guarantee. I need a contract so that I can't be fired at will. And she said,
22:50 Speaker 03 sure, let's totally do that. But it's gonna take a couple of months. Let's just close this stuff and we'll get to it. We'll get to it. And we never got to it.
22:57 Speaker 02 Right.
22:58 Speaker 03 And so that's why I was fired by email on Monday.
23:02 Speaker 02 Right. So what was the problem? I know, starting things, like I started mine with Walt Mossberg. We had plenty of fights. We had plenty of issues. We had less fights than we had agreements, which was, that's the way it should work, essentially. But in starting these things, it's really, and we had a for-profit model, and we had events and complex things. What happened there? So you had, what was your, what was your fault? What did you do wrong? Like you said, first of all, you didn't get this guarantee.
23:28 Speaker 03 Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I think we weren't aligned on the vision as much as I thought, right? Because once we started getting into it, it just became clear that she was taking a much more anti-tech position than I. And I'm obviously known for being very skeptical about tech, but I'm, but I'm a reporter. I go in with the facts, right? And there were just, we had numbers of meetings where she was talking about how we should have a take, write a policy paper about a position on tech, how we should be a cause, not a publication. She built a spreadsheet ranking all of the employees that I was thinking about hiring by how skeptical they were on tech and how negative and wanted them to be more negative. And I felt like not only these were morally
24:12 Speaker 03 Questionable, but they were legally very risky. And so we had a lot of conflict about that. And I started to feel very nervous about where this was going. Was this going to be an advocacy organization? Because honestly, I could sort of see why, from a financial point of view, probably it's easier to raise money. If you're like, we're out there swinging, right? And so from a business side perspective, that may have been a better play.
24:34 Speaker 02 Well, talk about that, the difference between skepticism and being negative.
24:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:38 Speaker 02 Because I get accused of being super negative all the time.
24:41 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:41 Speaker 02 Constantly. And I think it's fair. It's a fair point of view. I think I've been with them long enough to be warning people about what's happening. Talk about that idea, because you want to, there are advocacy publications.
24:52 Speaker 03 Yes, right.
24:53 Speaker 02 I guess you might put Mother Jones in there. You might put some others, but you didn't think of yourself as that.
24:58 Speaker 03 No, because I actually had this other idea where, so I really felt like journalism is always put on the pedestal objectivity, which is this weird neutral tone and point of view. And it really has led basically to false equivalency, right? On the one hand, climate change is happening. On the other hand, some random person says it's not.
25:16 Speaker 02 Right.
25:16 Speaker 03 And the truth is, that's not a fair representation of what the reality is. The fair representation is that 99% of the science suggests that climate change is happening and 1% of people who don't have credentials say it's not. So I wanted to move a little bit more towards what I call the scientific method approach, which was you have a hypothesis. Hypothesis, Facebook allows dropdown menu for racism that allows advertisers to break the law. Test that hypothesis. Okay, how much data do we need to collect? We can, in that particular case, by one ad, you've basically proven it. Some hypotheses need thousands of data points, right? For criminal risk scores, we collected 18,000 scores of defendants. So, and then you basically say, here's our finding. Our finding is X, and here's our limitations.
26:01 Speaker 03 So the limitations of our finding is we couldn't test every ad on Facebook, right?
26:04 Speaker 02 Right.
26:05 Speaker 03 And so I felt like that was our approach. And that is different than Mother Jones and the nation. But it's also different than normal journalism. It's just, it was just an idea of could we bring more scientific approach? Because I feel right now, despite all the craziness in the world, I do feel data changes the narrative. When you bring data to the table, people are willing to take it onboard. And it does lead to change and impact and policy changes. And so I felt like that was our calling as a journalist, was to bring that data to the table so that we could make change.
26:37 Speaker 02 And what happened?
26:39 Speaker 03 Um, well, so I don't know why I was fired, right? She would never gave me a reason. The, the reason that's been out there is the management issues, leadership. That's what she said.
26:49 Speaker 02 You didn't hire fast enough?
26:50 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:51 Speaker 02 Did you not hire fast enough?
26:52 Speaker 03 We, uh, I wish we had been hiring faster, but we had a pretty aggressive hiring schedule. So I felt like we were definitely on track to launch in July. Um, we had our, we had some investigative stories that were coming down the closing finish line. I felt like excited about it. But she, um, she took me aside in January with, um, with Jeff, the two of them. And they said, uh, you're, you're not suited to be editor in chief. And the reasons were things like, you don't like meetings.
27:23 Speaker 02 Yeah.
27:24 Speaker 03 That's true.
27:25 Speaker 02 Okay.
27:25 Speaker 03 Um, but.
27:26 Speaker 02 Right.
27:26 Speaker 03 I did go to all of them. I went to all the meetings, but I just didn't like them. Another reason was I didn't, I wouldn't agree to take a personality test. Um, I don't believe they're based on evidence and, uh, she was really insistent that, um, she needed me to take.
27:38 Speaker 02 A personality test?
27:39 Speaker 03 A personality test.
27:40 Speaker 02 Like which one?
27:41 Speaker 03 There were a couple, Enneagram or something. I don't know. I don't know what these things are.
27:45 Speaker 02 Yeah.
27:45 Speaker 03 Um, and so there were a whole bunch of reasons like that, that I wasn't suited to leadership. But it wasn't a performance improvement plan. Like here's the ways you can grow as a leader or anything like that. It was just a negative.
27:57 Speaker 02 And this is someone who had not run a publication previously.
28:00 Speaker 03 I mean, I think she ran some, the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation internet.
28:04 Speaker 02 Right.
28:04 Speaker 03 Site. So she, she's been in journalism, uh, radio and TV.
28:09 Speaker 02 Right.
28:10 Speaker 03 So that was disturbing. That's when I sort of realized that, oh, we didn't even go in that well, right?
28:15 Speaker 02 Right, right.
28:16 Speaker 03 And then, uh, we continued to have conflicts about the mission and the advocacy. And then in the end of March, she and Jeff took me to dinner again and said, um, that was failing as editor in chief and bringing down the markup. And once again, there was no plan of how I could improve. It was just a declaration and then said, you know, you're probably better suited as a columnist. And I was like, oh, I mean, I'm not really a columnist, you know? I mean, every once in a while, I've written an op ed here or there about an investigation I did. So it wasn't, it didn't, I just said like, that doesn't make sense.
28:48 Speaker 02 So you would not step down in the way they wanted you to?
28:50 Speaker 03 Yeah, but they didn't offer, like, honestly, they didn't even offer me a job. It was just like, you might be suited as a columnist, but there was no job description of like, what that would look like and what were your roles be or anything?
29:00 Speaker 02 Right.
29:00 Speaker 03 So I wrote them a letter with my lawyer saying, look, it seems like you're reneging on your agreement to give me my employment contract. It's been sitting with you. My lawyer has given it to you, but I'm not going to step down as editor in chief because I have promised our donors and employees that it will pursue a particular vision and I don't have faith that you're going to carry that out.
29:17 Speaker 02 And you thought they were going to do much more advocacy?
29:20 Speaker 03 Yeah, that's what it seemed like. And I don't actually know what they're going to do because there's two journalists left in the newsroom and I don't know what that publication is at this moment. But that's where it looked like it was heading and I didn't feel like I could stay there and not be the person in charge of editorial. And so I wrote that letter and then, and then she fired me.
29:38 Speaker 02 And she fired you?
29:39 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:39 Speaker 02 So what happens now? Now, Jeff has written a very problematic memo, a very defensive memo, which I said on the internet yesterday, about what's going on and begging the people to come back, which is odd at the same time.
29:54 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's worth pointing out, so all, there were seven reporters, five of them resigned after I was forced out.
30:00 Speaker 02 Right, so five, most of the staff is gone. Craig has given this money. Now, he's written a note and tweeted that he's thinking of reconsidering it.
30:08 Speaker 03 Yep.
30:09 Speaker 02 So what happens?
30:10 Speaker 03 I don't know. I don't know how this plays out. I have to brush up on my like coup literature.
30:15 Speaker 02 Right.
30:18 Speaker 02 I can help you there.
30:21 Speaker 02 I can help you a lot, actually.
30:23 Speaker 03 Right, actually, somebody told me that the coup's already happened. I have to, this is the counter coup.
30:27 Speaker 02 The counter coup, yes, it's the counter coup. We've got to get some Mother of Dragons into you.
30:34 Speaker 02 I can help. So what, what do you want to do now then? And then we'll get some questions from the audience.
30:38 Speaker 03 I actually just, I just want to do the thing I was doing. I mean, it would be awesome if I could just do that. Like, we had some great investigations. I feel like we were going to launch. I had some great people who were going to come. The people who were there are great. If I could do this somehow, somewhere, that's what I would do. I want to build this field. This is too important an issue for there not to be a team like this doing this type of work. It doesn't have to be at the markup. It can be somewhere, but I'm going to try to figure out a way to make it happen.
31:07 Speaker 02 We're going to take another break now. After this, we'll talk more with investigative journalist Julia Angwin about how she defines scientific journalism and whether it's easier to raise money for a media startup when you have an ideological goal.
31:19 Speaker 04 Priceline Negotiator. It's me, the Priceline Negotiator. We don't need the jingle twice. What about a third time? Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars. Seems like they just started. Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Time to read the timeline. Fine. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Please stop. Priceline. Touche. Priceline. Priceline.
31:50 Speaker 05 How about a latte?
31:51 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
31:52 Speaker 05 Vanilla?
31:53 Speaker 01 Caramel?
31:53 Speaker 05 Blueberry?
31:54 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
32:17 Speaker 02 Questions from the audience right here?
32:19 Speaker 06 Hi, I'm really interested in what you said about it being easier to raise money for a journalism organization that's focused more on advocacy. Can you talk more about that and maybe suggest an alternative business model or model in general for journalism that can be more objective but also investigative?
32:39 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm actually not sure about that, but I do feel like I could imagine that like people donate to their favorite causes and I can understand why you might want to position your journalism as a cause. What I feel though about that is that From my experience doing this type of work, that it undermines your findings. When you go in with an agenda, you have to be willing to follow where the data leads you. And so I think it's a dangerous road. I can see it's tempting, but I think it's dangerous for for the pursuit of truth.
33:15 Speaker 02 Because in the end, Facebook sucks is your endpoint, for example, which it probably is true. It's probably accurate, but it's but you but you don't want to start with that. You want to give them the benefit of the doubt when you start something and you could go down another road, for example.
33:27 Speaker 03 Yeah, no, and many times our stories have taken many surprising turns, right? So we were looking at Amazon. I had been told that there was a if you shopped on your mobile phone versus desktop, you would get different prices. So we put all this testing software up in the Amazon cloud, of course, and ran tests on Amazon from Amazon cloud. And and we found no results. We were like, oh, there's nothing here. And I thought that was really disappointing, but happened. And then I went to drinks with Barry Lynn, the guy from Open Markets Institute. And I was like, yeah, we looked into Amazon, we couldn't find anything. And he said, oh, well, have you tested? The real question with Amazon is how do they treat themselves as a seller on their own platform that they control?
34:11 Speaker 03 So we tweaked our hypothesis. We said, OK, let's ask that question. We already had all the stuff running. And boom, we were like, oh, gosh, they give themselves a huge advantage when of this when they're the seller or one of their favorite sellers, what are they called? I've forgotten the name. But the ones who pay them fees to be in their warehouses fulfilled by Amazon. And so then we were like, oh, we had a huge finding. And that's and that's where you just let the facts lead you to where you want to go.
34:39 Speaker 02 Right. So they were up to something. You just didn't find the thing they were up to, right? One thing. And that would make more sense for them to advantage themselves. That's one of the big issues.
34:47 Speaker 03 And also, we would have been fine with no finding, right? Like, I mean, if there's nothing to find, then there's nothing to find.
34:52 Speaker 02 Right. But you keep looking and pushing at various parts. But advocacy is is fine, too. It's there's a lot of there's a lot of people of points of view who do reported analysis.
35:02 Speaker 03 There is like, I actually feel like we're not lacking right now for opinions about tech online, in my feeling. And so I felt like that space was fully owned. It was good. It was great. Everyone's doing it. We could bring just a different piece to the table.
35:16 Speaker 02 OK, over here.
35:17 Speaker 07 Thanks so much for coming out. I'm interested in your take on media literacy for youth and how we are educating like high schoolers in particular to like consume the news. So how do you and how does that relate to the work that you're doing with with data? Where a lot of people in general and young people don't really care about data. They just like want the the stories and they don't sometimes respond to data in the ways that we want them to. So how do we teach young people to be more, I care more about like what the data is saying rather than other frivolous things?
35:59 Speaker 02 I will push back on you. I have a son who literally is like, I call him Wikipedia, walking Wikipedia because he has so many, not those facts, but he's so factually oriented that he will not talk about anything else. So it's an interesting change. But how do you?
36:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, I'm not sure I believe, I'm not sure that hypothesis is true. I'd like to see the data for that. But I, but I do think that like media literacy in general is a, is a challenge. And I, and I actually just feel like that's a classic case of pushing the burden onto the user, right? Like, the fact is that if you're being completely spammed with lies all the time, like, is it actually your responsibility? Like, I feel like one thing that we kind of haven't paid attention to enough is the literature around persuasion and the fact that all of us are very persuadable. And we used to have information gatekeepers who had certain standards and they didn't publish things that were untrue. And the reason was they were at risk for a lawsuit, right?
36:57 Speaker 03 The Wall Street Journal, where Kara and I worked together for years, you know, every story in there, we could be sued for. We could be sued for the letters to the editor. Those were fact checked, right? The advertisements we were actually responsible for. The internet companies got a special exemption in the 1996 telecom act so that they're not liable for anything that anyone writes on their platforms.
37:19 Speaker 02 If you'd like to know, so I'm going to write about it in the New York Times next week and they're very nervous. Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. Gives internet companies broad immunity from anything that flows over it. It's sort of treating them like a phone company, essentially. And it was done at the time, and I was there and I wrote about it for the Washington Post, actually, in order to allow these companies to grow. They were small startups and they didn't want to be sued out of existence from the very get-go. And AOL was a big part of pushing for that and other, and other, other sites at the time were. And so what they did is got, got this broad, broad immunity. And I, it was, it was, I just interviewed Nancy Pelosi about it and she said it was a gift that they're abusing. And it certainly was a gift.
38:02 Speaker 02 And so the question is, do we want to allow people who are the richest people on earth now from using this, this gift to abuse it further? And I think it's, it's been chipped away over issues of FOSTA and. Yeah, but there's only one chipping, I think, so far. Yeah, so the question is, do you remove it for the large companies? Do, does the world's richest, do the world's richest people deserve immunity from behavior? Because what's resulted is, it's sort of like giving kids sugar all the time. And sure, you can have sugar, sugar, you can keep your room messy, you can do this. What do you imagine is going to result? And this is why we have what we, I, this is my belief, but it's, other people have different beliefs. So it's going to be a big question. But as to younger people, I do think they get inundated.
38:47 Speaker 02 It's like sludge, you can't be protected from it. The government really should be protecting people from this, or lawyers suing, you know. In the US, we usually choose lawyers. Lawyers, yeah, so question right here.
39:01 Speaker 08 Huge fan of your podcast.
39:02 Speaker 02 Thank you.
39:03 Speaker 08 My question is, if there's a politician that starts getting rhetorically and legislatively very tough on tech, do you believe that the tech companies will kind of resort and hunker down like the hydrocarbon companies did in the eighties and nineties?
39:16 Speaker 02 They've hired a lot of lobbyists. You might look at that, there's a lot of data on that, like in terms of, they didn't have lobbyists before and now they have a ton of lobbyists, first of all. I think their approach is a little different than, say, a big oil or big, you know, banking or stuff like that. They're very, they'll show up, they'll apologize, they'll have meetings, they'll have dinners, they'll have thought time. Mark is having a lot of dinners with smart people, like he's getting his Harvard education now, which is kind of fascinating.
39:47 Speaker 02 He's having these, and everyone will go, like you, you know, if you're, I don't know. The guy who wrote the Hamilton book, Ron Chernow, you'd go to dinner with Mark Zuckerberg, right? Why not? And so they're doing it that way. I think they're allowing the discussions to go on and then secretly, behind the scenes, sort of trashing people, like, correct? I mean, I don't know. I think they seem to be, it's a different way approach. But there's no question they're doing heavy duty lobbying on lots and lots of issues that affect them. I think the question is, who can they? They try to find people they can work with on their side. Like, you have someone like Senator Warner, who's very tough on them on some issues. Or Senator Klobuchar is tougher on them.
40:31 Speaker 02 Senator Bennett is moving into that direction. Senator Wyden is very interested in voting machines. That's more of his area. So that's, they tend to try to co-op them. When I wrote a column this week about Sri Lanka, the first call was a Facebook person saying, "Hey, girl, wanna chat?" And I'm like, "No." And I didn't. Call me Friday, and then Friday I'll not pick up the phone. So it's a much softer approach. I just, I don't, I can't explain it, but it's just as effective. And they certainly will. I think Mark's piece about his wanting legislation was fascinating. You should read between the lines of that particular thing, I think.
41:16 Speaker 02 Okay, quickly, here and here.
41:18 Speaker 09 I'm interested in the notion of scientific journalism in an era in which there's a lot of examining of science itself. There's between, you know, P-hacking and replication problems. Science, you know, academic science has started examining how rigor, how the apparent rigor isn't actually as real as we thought.
41:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's a great question. You know...
41:47 Speaker 03 I say scientific journalism and what I mean by that is it's better than the normal journalism, which is three anecdotes and you're out, right? So when we had our meeting with Craig, he was like, okay, let me just see I understand this. Basically, all you're talking about is increasing the sample size. I was like, yes, that's basically it. That's not entirely true, right? So we have a data ethics policy, or we had at the markup, which actually said we will not do P-hacking and also that we aim for replicable results. And we will publish our data and our code as often as possible, which is what I've done all my career. And so I do think journalism can aspire to the standards of science, but we are journalists, right?
42:32 Speaker 03 And so I think of us as the first people out of the trenches, right? We're doing the first draft. And then actually, science usually comes in and does a lot of follow-up work to validate and solidify the results. This happened with our work on criminal risk scores. We put out the dataset, there's been, I think I have more academic citations than my husband, who's a professor, because it's been replicated and written about so much. And it's really moved the field in terms of the field of computer science fairness and algorithms.
43:01 Speaker 02 We have to go, but the very last question. What would you investigate right now if you had a publication to work for? You will.
43:11 Speaker 03 Trying to break my heart over here? God, there's so much. But you know, one of the things I'm really upset about is the use of algorithms to score people in ways that actually aren't really seen as tech. Your resume is sent through an algorithm, right? People work for algorithms, fired by algorithms, people who work at a work. And so this idea that, and I do, I just think it's worth pointing out, the people who are scored and sifted by algorithms, strangely, are often people of color and poor people. And so we're getting into a world where actually some people get human judgment and some people are judged by machines. And that's a very upsetting thing.
43:56 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Julia Angwin for joining me onstage at Vox.com's fifth anniversary party. If you enjoyed it, we think you'll also enjoy our live taping of Vox's The Weeds and a special episode of The Ezra Klein Show featuring Vox.com's co-founders Ezra Klein, Matt Iglesias, and Vox Media's publisher, Melissa Bell. To listen to them, just search for Vox's The Weeds and The Ezra Klein Show in Apple Podcasts or in your favorite podcast app, or just tap the links in the show notes. Thanks to you all for listening. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. And please tell a friend about this show. You can follow me on Twitter, at Kara Swisher. Now that you're done with this, go check out our other podcasts,
44:39 Speaker 02 Recode Media and Pivot. You can find those shows wherever you found this one. Thanks to you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode, and thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
44:56 Speaker 10 In this life, you can't win.
44:58 Speaker 11 When the world gets you down.
44:59 Speaker 10 No!
45:00 Speaker 11 Escape to Pluto TV.
45:01 Speaker 10 This is objectively fantastic.
45:03 Speaker 11 Relax into the movies and shows you already know and love, all for free.
45:07 Speaker 10 Schwing!
45:08 Speaker 11 Even our news is uplifting.
45:09 Speaker 04 You stay classy, San Diego.
45:11 Speaker 11 Watch School of Rock, Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy, The X-Files, Wayne's World, and so much more.
45:16 Speaker 10 We're not worthy!
45:18 Speaker 11 The best things on TV really are free. You just have to know where to look. Escape to Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.
Previous Recode Decode: Why thinking about your death five times a day is good for you Next Recode Decode: Trash in space, diversity in STEM and artificial meat at TED 2019 Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated