Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: John Hennessy and Dave Patterson, winners, 2017 Turing Award About this episode Alphabet chairman John Hennessy and Google distinguished engineer Dave Patterson talk with Recode’s Kara Swisher about winning the 2017 Turing Award, a prestigious achievement in computer science. In the 1980s, Hennessy and Patterson developed a revolutionary new type of computer processor called RISC, which allowed computers to run faster and more efficiently — a breakthrough that became especially important in the era of mobile devices and the internet of things. They talk about the intense pushback they received from the computing industry at the time and why we're now in a "new golden age of computer architecture," filled with difficult problems that businesses have thus far been unable to crack. The upshot: Another RISC-like revolution needs to happen.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,801 words · 4 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by IBM. By the end of this podcast, nearly 10,000 new malware variants will have launched. Now AI can help protect your data from threats wherever it lives with IBM Security. Let's put smart to work. Learn more at ibm.com/smart. Today's show is brought to you by HBO. HBO's Silicon Valley is as timely as ever as Pied Piper founder Richard Hendricks pivots to build a decentralized internet free of ads and data tracking. But as the saying goes, new internet, new problems. Watch new episodes of Silicon Valley Sundays at 10:00 PM on HBO. I watch it every week.
0:41 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, Executive Editor of Recode. You may know me as the winner of the Swisher Award for Excellence in Podcasting, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode for the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, in the red chair, we've got some very big brains. I'm a little bit nervous. John Hennessy and Dave Patterson, the winners of the 2017 Turing Award, which is essentially the Nobel Prize for Computer Science. They can tell me if that's different. They won the award for developing RISC, a technology that revolutionized computer processing. John is also the former president of Stanford University. He's been on the stage at All Things D many years ago.
1:22 Speaker 00 And the new chairman of Google's parent company, Alphabet, which is a big job. We have lots to talk about there, I guess. And Dave is a former professor of computer science at the University of California at Berkeley, and today is a distinguished engineer at Google also. John and Dave, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:38 Speaker 01 Thanks, Kara.
1:39 Speaker 00 So I do, I am nervous about interviewing you because usually I can make jokes and I do know more than many of the people.
1:44 Speaker 01 We will make jokes if you do.
1:45 Speaker 00 All right, okay. So why don't we start by talking about your backgrounds? Because you asked when you got here if we have a really geek audience. We do, but we try to be discernible to lots of bigger, we're trying to go for a bigger audience. And I was joking with these two that I had Anthony Scaramucci recently, which I can't believe they're in the same association with him, and neither can I, but here we are. So let's talk a little bit about your backgrounds. Why don't we start with you, Dave? And then we'll talk about the book, the groundbreaking book you wrote. I've run into, today I was at a cybersecurity thing, and everybody talked about your book from, what, 20 some years ago? But start with you, your background.
2:18 Speaker 01 I'm the first in my family to graduate from college. Got all my degrees at UCLA and spent all of my life at UC Berkeley. So all I know is giant public universities.
2:31 Speaker 00 And?
2:32 Speaker 01 And?
2:33 Speaker 00 And I know you have more of a bio than that.
2:35 Speaker 01 Okay, I ended up in working in computer hardware. Berkeley wanted to expand in computer hardware and so they hired me and some other guys forty years ago.
2:44 Speaker 00 And why was that? Why did you decide to do that?
2:46 Speaker 01 Well, Berkeley was trying to, you know, growing its computer science department. They're really great in what's called computer science theory and programming languages and they went to branch out into other areas. And the first one was hardware and then later they branched out into AI.
3:00 Speaker 00 And why did you, why were you interested in that? What was some?
3:03 Speaker 01 Well, why was I, you know, Berkeley's a great place. I wanted to try being a professor. I wanted to see, I was the oldest of my family. I have three younger brothers and sisters and kind of we'd sit around the dining room table doing homework and I'd end up teaching the material. So I enjoyed teaching and so I wanted to see if I could both do teaching and research at a place like Berkeley.
3:26 Speaker 00 And why computer hardware?
3:28 Speaker 01 Well, that's actually interesting question. Kind of what I did for my dissertation was kind of half software and half hardware. So when I went on the interview market, there were places that considered me as a software person and places a hardware person. Berkeley wanted to get into hardware, so I said, okay, I'll work on that.
3:44 Speaker 00 And what, tell me what that was at the time when you were starting there?
3:47 Speaker 01 Well, as John and I will probably say, you know, the center of the computing universe for hardware was the East Coast.
3:53 Speaker 00 Yes, it was.
3:55 Speaker 01 The two main places were IBM in New York and Digital Equipment Corporation.
4:01 Speaker 00 DEC.
4:01 Speaker 01 DEC in Boston. And so when John and I wanted to go try and influence the computer industry, we had to get an airplane fly.
4:08 Speaker 00 Right, yeah.
4:09 Speaker 01 To go there.
4:09 Speaker 00 I covered the decline of DEC just as it was declining, but it was still at force for a long time when I first started.
4:14 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'd say the most shocking thing in my technical career was when this tremendous engineering organization got bought by a third rate PC clone company.
4:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, what was it?
4:24 Speaker 02 Compaq.
4:24 Speaker 00 Compaq, that's right.
4:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, and I was just like, that's not the way the world's supposed to work.
4:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, a lot of things got bought like that. John, talk about your background.
4:32 Speaker 02 So I grew up on the East Coast, got my college degrees there, had the good fortune to stumble on my PhD thesis, which involved programming microprocessors. In those days, people can't think back that far, but microprocessors were used for laboratory control.
4:46 Speaker 00 Right.
4:47 Speaker 02 There were no personal computers, nothing like that. So I got involved in building a programming language to program microprocessors for real-time control applications. Turned into an interesting area, started interviewing. Stanford was the 14th school I interviewed.
5:03 Speaker 00 Wow.
5:04 Speaker 02 And so I interviewed everywhere from Wisconsin and Iowa and Illinois, all the way out.
5:11 Speaker 01 Did you interview at Colorado State?
5:12 Speaker 02 I did, because Colorado State had a big group working on real-time control. And so it happened to be a hot area. So they were one of the first places I interviewed.
5:20 Speaker 01 I went there and Janie Irwin, all of us interviewed at the same time.
5:23 Speaker 02 So the good news is, I interviewed at Stanford in March, and we were having a drought. So the weather was beautiful, it was sunny. I flew back to the East Coast, it was sleeting at JFK when we landed. I looked at my wife and said, if I get that job in California, and she said, we're going.
5:39 Speaker 00 We're going, right, right, right.
5:40 Speaker 02 And so I came. So I came and...
5:42 Speaker 01 Well, I could tell you, I should tell you my Berkeley story. I'm there because of my wife. She grew up in Northern California, and as a kid, and I met her in high school. And I interviewed at a bunch of places, but hadn't heard from Berkeley. And she said, you've got to call Berkeley to find out. So she made me call as a graduate student, the chair of the department at Berkeley.
6:02 Speaker 00 Right, good for your wife.
6:03 Speaker 01 Yeah, you know, and as a grad student, it was just humiliating. And he said, okay, Dave, I got your thing here. Well, you're in the top 10, but not the top 5, he said.
6:12 Speaker 00 Oh, wow.
6:13 Speaker 01 So as a grad student, I thought, that wasn't as bad as I thought. But it turns out, he said that to anybody who called.
6:18 Speaker 00 Oh, perfect. So you...
6:20 Speaker 01 And but he took up my resume and said, huh, you know, I think they made an offer to somebody else who turned them down. And he said, huh, this guy? And then he handed it to somebody who was coming to Southern California, and we hit it off, and so I got a job there.
6:32 Speaker 00 See, that's how life goes.
6:33 Speaker 01 But if my wife hadn't forced me to call, I wouldn't be there.
6:37 Speaker 02 You wouldn't be there.
6:38 Speaker 00 Colorado State.
6:39 Speaker 01 Yeah.
6:40 Speaker 00 You would have been at Colorado State, you would have stopped at Colorado. So you decided to come out to Stanford?
6:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, so I came out to Stanford. I mean, people...
6:45 Speaker 00 Was it a big place to come at the time? Because now, obviously.
6:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, it was very strong. It was a top computer science department. But again, like Dave mentioned...
6:52 Speaker 00 It was on the East Coast.
6:53 Speaker 02 It was kind of more theory-oriented and a strong AI group as well. The Valley was almost nothing. I mean, there was very... Intel was there, '77.
7:03 Speaker 00 Yep.
7:03 Speaker 02 Intel was there, but they primarily made memory chips. That was their big business. It wasn't yet the microprocessor boom that would occur later. HP made laboratory computers, but there were essentially no major computer companies in the Valley at that time.
7:18 Speaker 00 Right.
7:18 Speaker 02 There were still lots of farms. Where the Google Plex is today
7:21 Speaker 00 Right.
7:22 Speaker 02 was a family farm.
7:22 Speaker 00 Yes, I remember. That was a long time ago. But then there were all kinds of groves and fruits and...
7:27 Speaker 02 Groves, there were, there were, there was an orchard still on El Camino in Sunnyvale.
7:31 Speaker 00 Right, exactly. So coming here was, was a risk for both of you, correct? Speaking of risk.
7:36 Speaker 01 We, uh, yeah, you know, my, my wife made this decision too, because we had two kids and our siblings had houses and we didn't. And she said, "Well, look, if you go to Berkeley, can you change your mind and go to industry?" And I said, "Yes." And she said, "Well, if we go to industry, can you go to Berkeley?" And I said, "No." And she said, "Okay, we'll be poor but proud."
7:55 Speaker 00 So you, so you come here and you were both going into, since you were saying there was an industry here, there was Intel, there was a couple of companies, but nothing substantive?
8:05 Speaker 02 Nothing substantive. And, you know, it was the early day, microprocessors were just growing up. They were just beginning to be thought of as computers. And there were these development systems you could buy to, to develop hard, to develop microprocessors primarily for laboratory control still.
8:22 Speaker 00 Right, right.
8:23 Speaker 02 But the field was changing and it was clear, I think, if you looked at it, that within a few years, you were going to be able to build a real computer on a single chip.
8:31 Speaker 00 Sure, yeah.
8:32 Speaker 02 And that was an interesting question, because I think it was the question that Dave and I both asked, which is, how should these computers be designed?
8:38 Speaker 00 Right.
8:39 Speaker 02 Should we keep copying mini-computers, which is what they had been doing? Or should we rethink how the computers should be designed, given this fairly dramatic change in the underlying implementation technology?
8:49 Speaker 00 Right, absolutely. And explain mini-computers. I, I get it. There was the large systems...
8:53 Speaker 02 Big, big, big, basically racks of hardware, designed, using a technique called bitslice. So you'd have, one chip might implement four bits of an adder, another four bits of an adder. And they were, you know, they sold for a hundred thousand to a million dollars, basically.
9:09 Speaker 00 Dex's business.
9:10 Speaker 02 Dex's key space, right? The Vax 11780, their big machine that was a big success. You know, it sold for 250,000 to 500,000 dollars. Today... Maybe one tenth as fast as the slowest laptop you would buy.
9:25 Speaker 00 Right, right. So the concept was around this and not anything else. So where did you two meet then? You were here at competing universities?
9:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, we were both, in fact, people ask where the story risk came from is once we hit upon the ideas of this different way to design computers, which is explainable, but
9:43 Speaker 00 Go right ahead.
9:44 Speaker 01 Okay, well, let's do that. So when software talks to hardware, there's a vocabulary, you talk to it. And the mini-computer and mainframe eras, the prevailing wisdom was that you want these very rich vocabularies, you know, five-dollar words, polysyllabic words, and that's how, the right way to do it. And John and I's idea was, well, in this fast-changing microprocessors, let's do the opposite. Let's have a very small, very simple vocabulary, monosyllabic words. And then the question was going to be, how fast could we execute those words? How fast, you can think of as reading the words. How fast could computers read those words? Well, they have to read more words if they're simple. But the question was, how many more words would they have to read?
10:28 Speaker 01 And how fast could you read them? And it turned out, the risk, which was the reduced vocabulary, is we had to read about 20% more words, but we could read them four times faster.
10:41 Speaker 00 Right.
10:41 Speaker 01 So it was like a factor of three win.
10:45 Speaker 00 So now, talk about the implication of this. You got together and you wrote a book together. First, you were making these innovations. So talk about that process of how you worked together.
10:54 Speaker 02 Well, we started, we were running research groups, which people think, okay, Berkeley and Stanford are competing.
11:00 Speaker 00 Competing, right.
11:00 Speaker 02 But the truth is, we were both on the same side of the line.
11:03 Speaker 00 Right.
11:03 Speaker 02 And there were a lot of people who were naysayers.
11:05 Speaker 00 Right.
11:06 Speaker 02 Who didn't believe our technology.
11:07 Speaker 00 And what was the naysayer argument?
11:08 Speaker 02 The naysayer argument varied from academic, I think the one that was repeated most often was, these are academic projects. When you scale them up to be real computers,
11:20 Speaker 00 Right.
11:20 Speaker 02 all the advantages that these papers have written about will go away.
11:23 Speaker 00 Right.
11:24 Speaker 01 We were cherry picking. We were just taking the easy part of the problem and exaggerating the benefits.
11:30 Speaker 00 And it couldn't be...
11:31 Speaker 02 It couldn't be transferred to industry and scaled up to be a real computer. When you put in virtual memory or you put in floating point, all the advantages.
11:38 Speaker 01 There's also a philosophical argument that led to a lot of anger, which was the belief of these bigger, richer vocabularies is the hardware would be quote-unquote closer to the software. So maybe all the problems we were having with software with projects failing and filled with bugs was because the hardware wasn't very good. And if we just had a richer vocabulary, a bigger, richer vocabulary, its software would be easier. And then these two idiots come along and say the opposite of that. And not only is that not going to help, you're going the wrong way. You should go backwards. So this got people angry. They thought these were dangerous, dangerous ideas that were going to destroy the computing industry.
12:18 Speaker 00 Why would it destroy them? Explain.
12:20 Speaker 02 Well, there was everything, there was everything varying from you guys are just crazy, you're just academics, you don't know what you're doing, to if you start a company and develop this technology, you're going to undermine the large computer companies.
12:32 Speaker 00 Which were selling these big systems.
12:34 Speaker 02 Big systems, right? And one of the reasons, I think, in the end, that the technology was not adopted quickly was that it did pose a real threat to their existing product line.
12:46 Speaker 00 That's exactly what it did.
12:47 Speaker 02 And we see this all the time, Kara. Companies, rather than kind of endanger their own product line, will let a startup come along and wipe them out because they're just too nervous about the established product line.
13:00 Speaker 00 That's the expression someone, I think it was Disney, when they were getting into online stuff, he said, the CEO at the time, I think it was Bob Iger, said, "We might as well eat our lunch ourselves. We're going to have our lunch eaten, we might as well eat it ourselves." Which was an unusual attitude.
13:13 Speaker 02 I say, "Shoot yourself in the foot rather than have somebody shoot you in the gut."
13:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, that's a fair point. I don't like any shooting.
13:20 Speaker 02 More graphic. Yeah, I don't like the shooting.
13:22 Speaker 00 So when you were doing, so you got together, so you were not competing, even though people think of these...
13:26 Speaker 02 No, we were kind of competing. We were competing in some ways.
13:28 Speaker 00 You were the Californians, though. You were essentially Californians where this was going.
13:32 Speaker 01 Yeah, but we, you know, John and I, I think, are both kind of natural collaborators. And we could have, we could have decided my was the right way, his is the wrong way. But fortunately, we were... We were young but wise enough that's like, we need many more people on our side.
13:44 Speaker 00 Right.
13:45 Speaker 01 There's a lot of people out there who don't think this is a good thing to do. We, you know, we're, let's, let's take the, we'll be on the same team, so.
13:52 Speaker 02 There was another issue involved in selling our story about this technology. And that was, we didn't really have a firm scientific quantitative explanation of why we could run programs so much faster. And that made it harder to convince people. We had data, but we couldn't, we couldn't give the scientific explanation of why this is true. And getting that, figuring out that explanation and getting that right, that was the beginning of really our book effort. Because we thought, wow, there's a much better way to design computers based on principles rather than on what Dave and I would call the supermarket textbook of computer architecture.
14:30 Speaker 00 Right.
14:30 Speaker 02 Here's one from the, here's one from column A, here's one from column B, here's one from column C. No attempt to compare them or see how they, see how the trade-offs, what the trade-offs were.
14:41 Speaker 00 So you write this book together, is that right? And what was that you were trying to change the idea of computer architecture, of how you would do it?
14:47 Speaker 01 Well, we, we were following, the ideas in the book, we followed in our work. And, and we, you know, so we were taking, you know, and we put in the title of the book, "Quantitative Approach." We thought you should be able to run experiments before you build anything and compare two different ways to do it and get a number to say which one's better. And, and that's how we were doing it. And we just got increasingly frustrated with the textbooks, which were still from like the supermarket catalog era of describing architecture. So the actual triggering event was I could see that I was probably going to become Chair of Computer Science in Berkeley. And we were both so naive about administration that I thought my life would be over. So, oh my God, my life is going to end. We have to write the book right now.
15:29 Speaker 00 Why was your, because you had to run this big department?
15:32 Speaker 01 Yeah. And we thought our research careers are over, all our time would go away. You know, you know, kind of, this is a classic kind of faculty attitude, right?
15:40 Speaker 02 Is, is your use of...
15:41 Speaker 01 A chance to get something done before you condemn yourself.
15:43 Speaker 00 Right, exactly, I wanted to. So, talk about the impact of it, because it was an enormously impactful book for, I've talked to so many people, they, they talk, it's, it's like, I'm trying to think of the equivalent in... Journalism would be this drunken whites elements of style.
15:58 Speaker 02 Elements of style. That's very generous.
16:01 Speaker 01 I would settle for that.
16:03 Speaker 02 So I think we tried to capture this approach. I think what probably one of the things that surprised us is in the first year, we sold as many copies to practicing engineers as we did to classroom settings.
16:16 Speaker 00 Sure.
16:17 Speaker 02 And that was a real change. In fact, Microsoft.
16:18 Speaker 00 They're trying to change their attitude.
16:19 Speaker 02 Yeah, change their attitude. Microsoft actually put it in their company store. So you could get a copy at the same time you ordered a pen or a pad of paper. You could get a copy of our book. And that showed that there was really a different way of thinking about it. I think and over the years, the book's been translated into more than a dozen languages and used around the world. And it's been for us, it's been a remarkable opportunity to teach students all around the world.
16:46 Speaker 01 And fortunately for me, John, despite having this little teeny job as president, would every five years or so work on the next edition? So I think he did three editions of the six editions while he was president. And had he said the entirely reasonable thing is, I've got a day job. I can't do this anymore.
17:05 Speaker 00 Running Stanford. Oh, that, oh, that.
17:07 Speaker 01 That would have been the end of the book.
17:08 Speaker 00 All right, we're going to talk when we get back about developing risk, this technology that revolutionized computer processing and still continues to. We're here with John Hennessy and Dave Patterson at the winners of the 2017 Turing Award. We'll also explain what that is. We know who Alan Turing is. Well, we'll explain that anyway when we get back. Today's show is brought to you by European Wax Center. They want to tell you about Pink Tax, an unfair tax on goods and services that are marketed to women. As a result, every year, women pay more than $1,300 more than men for the exact same things. Women's basic clothing, like white t-shirts and jeans, cost more 40% of the time. Women's personal items, like deodorants and razors, cost more 56% of the time. European Wax Center wants all women to feel that they can be confident in their own
17:53 Speaker 00 skin and confident in demanding a level playing field. Go to axthepinktax.com. That's A-X with just an A-X and not an E at the end. One more time, that's axthepinktax.com to learn more and see how you can help raise awareness about this important issue that affects all women.
18:12 Speaker 00 I'd also like to tell you about one of our other podcasts, Recode Media with Peter Kafka. Peter, who'd you talk to this week?
18:18 Speaker 03 I talked to Emily Steele. She won a Pulitzer Prize, or a Pulitzer Prize, depending on how you say it, for her great work she did last year on sexual harassment at Fox News, and then later at Vice Media. She's great. We had a great conversation about how to report really difficult stories like this. And also, this will blow your mind, why she doesn't do that much reporting on Twitter. It's amazing. That's a really good conversation. You will like it a lot.
18:41 Speaker 00 Sounds great, Peter. You can find Recode Media on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. We're back with John Hennessy and Dave Patterson, the winners of the 2017 Turing Award. They're also some pretty smart professors, from what I can understand. And actually, I've been talking about their background in the book they wrote that was very impactful to how people rethought computer architecture, which was how old, 19?
19:07 Speaker 01 90.
19:07 Speaker 00 1990. So, talk about developing RISC, the technology that sort of revolutionized computer processing, and then we'll go where it is today.
19:14 Speaker 01 Well, it got started at Berkeley, actually, in a series of graduate courses. I had done a sabbatical at DEC, where they were doing this conventional wisdom, as I mentioned earlier, about the really rich vocabularies. And it led to a bunch of bugs.
19:29 Speaker 01 My sabbatical, I was trying to help them with the bugs that they had in their equipment. And so, when I got back, you know, the microprocessor guys, as we said earlier, weren't really experts in computers. So, they were just going to imitate what the big guys did. And so, I wrote this paper that said, okay, if the microprocessor people imitate the big guys, there's going to be a lot of bugs, and we're going to have to figure out how to repair it. And the paper was rejected. And the rejection was, this is a stupid way to design microprocessors. Well, that kind of, if you're going to do it, it's going to have bugs, and it is stupid. So, there must be, there's-
20:00 Speaker 00 A better way.
20:01 Speaker 01 There must be a better way. So, we started it out with a series of four graduate courses, where we kind of investigated the ideas, and eventually built chips out of it, remarkably enough.
20:12 Speaker 00 So, the graduate course, in order to- Figure out what to do.
20:14 Speaker 01 Well, one of the things, yeah, one of the things I did when I, it's unusual for an assistant professor to take a sabbatical. It was fortunate, but unusual. And so it gave me a chance to think about what can you do well in the university and what not so well. And academics don't have real deadlines, except for courses.
20:31 Speaker 00 Right.
20:31 Speaker 01 Courses are absolutely going to start and stop. So I thought, well, why don't I tie the research to the courses? And then we'd have deadlines and be able to make steady progress. And so that's why, that was the trick, or that was the idea that we were trying to do. And then in, I think in the first quarter, or second quarter, John, we were both funded by DARPA. And that's where the risk name comes from. DARPA at that time funded high-risk, high-reward research. So we thought if we called it risk, they had to fund it.
21:02 Speaker 00 Yeah. Explain what it actually stands for, John. And then, so this is how you named it?
21:08 Speaker 01 That's where the name came from.
21:09 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. Reduced Instruction Set Computer. I think the notion of trying to target the instruction set for fast implementation, for efficient implementation really is probably the right word, Kara, because I think today we care as much about energy as we care about, about execution speed. And I think that was the key thing. Lots of things were changing. It was a time when a lot of the computer industry was changing. We were moving from writing in assembly language. Remember, Unix was just coming of age, the first operating system written in a high level language as opposed to in assembly language. And of course, that influenced our, our thinking as well. And I began the same way Dave did, with a brainstorming class of graduate students, just to say...
21:53 Speaker 00 What should we do if we...
21:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, exactly. Clean slate, clean slate.
21:57 Speaker 00 How hard is that, though? When you, when you, you know, you're taught in a certain, in any discipline, in any academic, you have a, you have a class...
22:02 Speaker 01 I don't know, we were young.
22:03 Speaker 02 Graduate students are completely open.
22:06 Speaker 01 Yeah.
22:07 Speaker 02 They don't have all the inhibitions we might have.
22:09 Speaker 01 They don't have a history of failures, right? They don't know all the times it didn't work. And we were young and optimistic. You know, we thought if our ideas were solid, why, why not, right?
22:19 Speaker 00 And so what happened with this? So you did these graduate programs, coming up with greenfield approach, or clean state, however you want to phrase it. What were you, what were you going to, what did you think it would lead to as a new processing?
22:32 Speaker 02 I actually thought we would publish our papers, people would read them. The data was pretty good, they'd say, ah, we should do this.
22:40 Speaker 02 And that didn't happen.
22:41 Speaker 01 That didn't happen. Well, one of the things that happened is because it was so controversial, there were a series of debates that John and I participated, from coast to coast. And I think, I think, I remember John saying at the time, by the third debate, I think people thought, okay, there's some ideas here. Maybe because we, John actually wrote the paper that had the scientific explanation. I think maybe by then we had it, maybe not.
23:02 Speaker 02 No, I think even later.
23:03 Speaker 01 It was even later than that. Okay.
23:05 Speaker 02 So I think one of the, one of the things that happened, for example, is
23:08 Speaker 00 So you started a debate.
23:09 Speaker 02 Digital Equipment Corporation actually had a west coast lab at that. Some of those people had worked on our project and picked up the ideas, but they, in turn, couldn't get the east coast guys to accept the ideas. So in the end, what happened was a famous computer pioneer came to see me and said, you have to start a company. Gordon Bell.
23:29 Speaker 00 Yeah, okay.
23:30 Speaker 02 One of the early guys at DEP.
23:31 Speaker 00 I know.
23:32 Speaker 02 Came to me and said, you've got to start a company because otherwise these ideas are not going to get out there.
23:37 Speaker 00 Yeah.
23:38 Speaker 02 And, and I talked to a couple colleagues and we decided to do it, somewhat reluctantly, of course. It wasn't, it wasn't something I had.
23:44 Speaker 00 Why reluctantly? You forget that everybody wasn't doing that.
23:47 Speaker 02 Everybody wasn't doing it. That's the primary reason. And, you know, I knew that it was going to take a lot of time. I wasn't, you know, would I go back to the university? Would I stay at the company? I mean, I wasn't exactly clear. So that's how we got started.
24:02 Speaker 00 And talk about the impact then, because it was
24:05 Speaker 02 You know, people didn't believe it at the beginning. I mean, just building on what Dave said about this contrarian viewpoint, I was on one panel and it was my, an antagonist on the panel, an opposing viewpoint. And somebody said, well, you know, Hennessy just got a million dollars from the venture capitalist to go build this company. What should he do? And without blinking an eye, he says, take the money and go to South America.
24:27 Speaker 00 Oh, my God.
24:28 Speaker 02 So, it turns out, I didn't, I didn't do that.
24:32 Speaker 00 Oddly enough.
24:32 Speaker 02 It just worked out.
24:33 Speaker 00 We had Michael Dell on the stage and he said that about, I think, Apple, many years ago, like, they should take the money and give it back to shareholders.
24:41 Speaker 02 Oh.
24:42 Speaker 00 Something.
24:43 Speaker 01 That's one of those quotes you
24:44 Speaker 00 You never take that. I think Bill Gates had one, like, 64K is enough for anybody.
24:48 Speaker 02 Yeah, that's right.
24:49 Speaker 00 Everybody's got one of those. There's a funny, funny, talk about the implications of once it became clear that this was the way things were going.
24:57 Speaker 01 It has kind of an interesting trajectory. For maybe 15 years, anybody who's risked
25:05 Speaker 01 Had the fastest computer in the world.
25:06 Speaker 00 Right.
25:07 Speaker 01 But then, you know, the really good engineers at Intel figured out that they could actually translate their rich vocabulary into the simpler vocabulary in hardware.
25:16 Speaker 00 Right.
25:16 Speaker 01 And then, any of the risk ideas they could use.
25:20 Speaker 00 Right.
25:20 Speaker 01 And then, they had a lot more money, so they have bigger engineering teams and really good technology. So eventually, Intel kind of used the risk ideas against the rest of the risk companies and took over the marketplace in the PC era.
25:33 Speaker 00 Right.
25:33 Speaker 01 And, you know, and PCs did really well, but starting in 2007 with the iPhone, which I guess is the beginning of the post-PC era, well, suddenly, there's this place, as John said earlier, where they cared about efficiency.
25:45 Speaker 00 Right.
25:47 Speaker 01 And which is kind of similar to what we cared about early on.
25:50 Speaker 00 Which is the true life, the true concept you were talking about.
25:52 Speaker 02 Right.
25:53 Speaker 00 Yeah.
25:53 Speaker 02 Right. And the early days, it was transistors and silicon area. Today, it's still silicon area, because if you look at Internet of Things, you've got computers all over the place that have to sell for a dollar or two.
26:03 Speaker 00 Right, right.
26:04 Speaker 02 So it really does matter how big the chip is in that.
26:07 Speaker 00 Right. And so, talk about the shift when mobile came, because I would say the iPhone really...
26:11 Speaker 02 Mobile made it. Mobile made it.
26:13 Speaker 01 Because then, the ARM processor that you've heard of, well, the R in ARM stands for RISC, so it's Advanced Risk Machines. So that got increasingly popular and is part of my retirement. I went around and gave a lot of talks, and so I collected a bunch of data. But basically, there's probably this year, there'll be 20 billion microprocessors sold, and 99% of those will be...
26:34 Speaker 00 99% are RISC, yeah.
26:35 Speaker 01 Yeah, be RISC. So, yeah, it's everywhere.
26:39 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. I want to hear from you about the mobile, what it...
26:43 Speaker 02 Well, I think the mobile, the mobile really drove it, because all of a sudden, you cared both about what the processor cost, but you also cared a lot about energy efficiency. And that's one thing, the so-called CISC approach, right, that was the traditional approach, has never been able to close the gap. So it consumed more energy. Didn't matter so much on a desktop machine.
27:04 Speaker 00 Right.
27:04 Speaker 02 Maybe you need a fan, you know, instead of not having one. But it wasn't a big differentiator. But in the mobile space, power's everything. You really do have to worry about energy. And as we move into this next generation...
27:15 Speaker 00 It forces it.
27:16 Speaker 02 Yeah. Forces efficiency. Forces it. You know, and I think as we move into this next era, where we're talking about... Devices that may have processes in them that may last for 10 years with a single battery. Power is going to matter a lot.
27:31 Speaker 00 Yeah, I want to get into that in our next section. But so you two created this and are you billionaires?
27:37 Speaker 01 I have a salary.
27:40 Speaker 01 John's invested better than I have.
27:44 Speaker 00 Well, one of your ex-students who has a lot of money has wondered why that you did you take advantage of that, do you think, of these?
27:52 Speaker 01 Me? This is Dave. I pretty much stayed a professor.
27:57 Speaker 00 Why didn't you move into industry?
27:59 Speaker 01 I had, you know, I think when I was young, I had this strong belief in the public university teaching, you know, we were fulfilling the American dream. And I just had this little speech I gave when somebody asked about a startup is I'm going to be a professor. You know, it wouldn't have been that bad if I'd taken a couple of years off and done a company. But when I was young, I was kind of like, strong willed and I'm an academic and that's what I'm going to do.
28:21 Speaker 02 Yeah, I'm several companies in. I mean, I starting with Jim Clark with Silicon Graphics that I was a consultant to and then MIPS. Then I started a company, Atheros, that built the early Wi-Fi chips.
28:33 Speaker 00 Which one was it?
28:34 Speaker 02 Atheros.
28:35 Speaker 00 Oh, yeah, yeah.
28:36 Speaker 02 So they built Wi-Fi chips early on. So I've done the entrepreneurship thing a few times. And then I joined the Google Board in 2004.
28:46 Speaker 01 I understand that's not a voluntary position.
28:47 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah, that was a good move. Although that was later, that was later.
28:52 Speaker 02 Yes, just before they went public, about six months.
28:54 Speaker 00 Right, that's right, that's right. I met them in 98.
28:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, I met them at Stanford.
28:59 Speaker 00 Yeah. Oh, that's right, they were there, of course. So talk a little bit about that, where you, these companies, but since you both are academics, because you did stay in academia, really, than than anything else.
29:09 Speaker 02 Came back to what I loved.
29:10 Speaker 00 When we're thinking about students, one of the people that was taught by you, when you think about how you train these students today, because one of your things was to get these, you know, you did risk based on a class, essentially. Talking about how students should be trained today. And when we, our next section, I want to get on where things are going and how, who's designing these systems and how they should be designed. Talk about training of the students.
29:33 Speaker 01 Well, it's a fantastic time to be a student in computer science. You have amazing computers at your fingertips. On the particular things that John and I do, it's much easier to build hardware than it was earlier. There's these things called field programmable gateways, which are kind of programmable hardware. So you can prototype your ideas and change them every day and connect them to the Internet, and it's kind of, it's a real computer, but modifiable. So it's, so I think students getting their hands dirty. Well, you know, I got into computer science because I was a math major at UCLA, and a math class was canceled, and I took this software class, and I was hooked, right?
30:14 Speaker 00 Math class was just canceled?
30:16 Speaker 01 Yeah, it was, the class I needed was canceled, and there was this two-unit computer class. I hadn't thought about computers at all.
30:22 Speaker 00 You hadn't done computers before?
30:23 Speaker 01 No, never thought about it, don't know why. But I took it, and I loved it. You know, the, the, your, the ideas in your mind come alive in that screen, and that was just exciting. And so I think we want to give students that opportunity. You know, programming can do that, building hardware can do that, but building things and see your ideas come alive is something, you know, in cyberspace we can do in the curriculum, that's, you know, you can't, can't do that in civil engineering, probably.
30:50 Speaker 00 No, no, you can't just build bridges a lot of places. Well, you can, but it's hard.
30:54 Speaker 01 So it's this incredibly exciting, stimulating opportunity that we can do as educators.
31:00 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think Dave's right. I mean, computing is about building things. I think we teach principles, right? We teach students how to use abstraction, so that we can build really complex software systems. And the scale of the software systems we build now is phenomenal. If you tried to do that 30 years ago, we didn't have the tools to do it. So we try to teach them principles of abstraction, organization, so that they can do that. How to test a large piece of software? Because certainly a lot of software that gets released is buggy. We teach some principles of security, so that they understand issues of security and privacy, which has become certainly vastly more important in the last few years.
31:38 Speaker 00 And what are the challenges now facing teaching from your perspective?
31:41 Speaker 01 The number, the popularity, the popularity. It's, well, at Stanford now, it's the number one major, right?
31:47 Speaker 02 It's the number one major for women even, right now, which just happened this past year, which is amazing, amazing.
31:54 Speaker 01 Yeah, so in Berkeley, the classes, you know, we have, I didn't know we could handle four-digit class sizes. I didn't know the system would work, but we have introductory courses in computer science with more than 1,000 students. So students are voting with their feet. And this is happening at campuses across the country. It's not just, not just.
32:11 Speaker 00 But not enough, but there's not enough.
32:12 Speaker 01 Well, we're, universities are trying to figure out how to scale to everybody, right?
32:17 Speaker 02 We've got to scale, we've got to figure out how to hire faculty. You know, and it's not just at the big-name places. It's the entire hierarchy that's got to figure out how to build people.
32:25 Speaker 00 Right. When we get back, we're going to talk about that more, especially about diversity and trying to figure out who's going to be designing the future, because I don't know if you're going to continue, but maybe you will, and where it's going. When we get back from a word from our sponsors, and then we'll be back with Alphabet Chairman John Hennessy and Google Distinguished Engineer, or your distinguished engineer, Dave Patterson, after this. Today's show is brought to you by HBO. Silicon Valley is back for another season and another pivot. This time, founder Richard Hendricks turns his sights on launching a decentralized internet. With so much focus on data tracking and privacy on the web, this latest turn of events feels eerily relevant. But this should come as no surprise. The comedy has made a name for itself with two real jokes about startup culture. It's the show's attention to detail that feeds the comedy.
33:10 Speaker 00 Every reference is on point, not to mention the fantastic Emmy Award-winning cameos from people like me. I'm still waiting for that Emmy, but I really enjoyed being on it, including giving Gavin Bellson advice on how to run Hulu. Get new episodes of Silicon Valley Sundays at 10:00 PM on HBO.
33:30 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by Betterment. It's tax season, which means it's a great time to think about your finances as a whole. Are you ready for the deadlines coming your way? Are you saving as much on taxes as possible? And are there any accounts that could be working harder for you? Maybe you have an old 401K sitting around. High fees on that account can drain your savings. According to an independent study, rolling over to a Betterment IRA could mean 60% lower fees. Betterment is a modern solution to an age-old problem: how to save for a better retirement. Investing involves risk, but licensed experts at Betterment will help you develop a personalized plan to make sure you have the retirement you deserve. Find out today if you're on track to hit your savings and investing goals.
34:12 Speaker 00 And when you need it, Betterment has the tools and guidance to help you get on track. Recode Decode listeners can get up to one year managed free. For more information, visit betterment.com/decode. That's betterment.com/decode.
34:28 Speaker 00 We're back with Alphabet Chairman John Hennese, who's also kind of a good academic, apparently, and Google Distinguished Engineer Dave Patterson, who apparently teaches people some things. They won the Turing Prize. What is the winning of the Turing Prize? You've had massive, is it just a banquet? What happens?
34:43 Speaker 01 You mean what happens?
34:43 Speaker 00 Yeah, what is it? Explain what it is.
34:45 Speaker 01 Well, right here in San Francisco, I think at the Palace Hotel, on June 23rd, there'll be a ceremony where they'll have us come on the stage, show a video, and hand us a check.
34:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, good, good.
34:55 Speaker 02 Yeah, and we, it's tradition that the Turing Award winner's per peral lecture, talking about the state of the field, where it's going, what's happening.
35:03 Speaker 00 All right, give me a little preview, both of you. What's the state of the field, Dave and John?
35:06 Speaker 01 Well, okay. Well, we've collaborated on, we're going to share the talk, since we co-author things. The title is "A New Golden Age for Computer Architecture." And I think the four things that we think in the part of this golden age are what is called today's domain-specific architectures, which are like Google's TPU. You know what that is? The hardware for deep learning, hard-raw machine learning. Security, you know, security is embarrassing. You know, we think hardware people need to rise to the challenge and do something about it. There's this idea of an open, and I talked about these vocabularies being, this idea of an open vocabulary. There's something called RISC-V, which is an attempt to, it's to be like the Linux
35:49 Speaker 01 of microprocessors, is an open thing that anyone can build. And finally, there's a thing called Agile hardware development, making it a lot easier to build. So those, we think those four things are going to lead to another golden age in computer architecture.
36:02 Speaker 00 And when you say golden age, John, what does that mean? What do you?
36:05 Speaker 01 Well, I think.
36:06 Speaker 00 It's been kind of golden. It's been kind of golden over the past 20 years.
36:08 Speaker 02 It was, it was for quite some time. The last few years, there's been a slowdown. I mean, we talk about the end of Moore's law, right? Really, the slowdown of Moore's law.
36:17 Speaker 00 Right.
36:18 Speaker 02 We also talk about another technology problem. Yeah, there's a doubling every few years, and that's kind of leveled off.
36:24 Speaker 01 Now it's doubling, doubling every.
36:25 Speaker 02 Seven years, or eight years, or 10 years.
36:28 Speaker 00 So too long, not enough.
36:29 Speaker 02 Yeah. And then there's another, another problem that we call the failure of Dennard scaling. So Dennard was the guy who invented DRAMs, the one transistor DRAM. He made an observation that as, as you got more transistors, the power didn't go up. So you could actually do more computing for the same amount of energy. And that actually broke down. And so now, the problem is, I mean, you look at a modern microprocessor from Intel, it slows this clock right down, it shuts itself off, because otherwise, it's going to burn up.
37:00 Speaker 00 Right.
37:01 Speaker 02 So that's a challenge that we have to face as well. And I think the way to solve these problems is to rethink the way you design computers, which is why Dave and I think, once again, it's a new golden age.
37:11 Speaker 00 So where do you imagine that rethinking happening? Are there any directions that you're?
37:15 Speaker 01 You mean, where in the world?
37:17 Speaker 00 Yeah, how does it happen? How does it occur? And where in the world? Because it may not be here.
37:21 Speaker 01 Well, that's why, I mean, we're researchers, right? And we think when it's unclear what to do, those are great times for researchers. When there's new challenges, and, you know, Intel doesn't know what to do, ARM doesn't know what to do, that's a fantastic time to be a researcher in computer architecture, because good ideas can win, right? When it's pretty, I think.
37:44 Speaker 01 Maybe 10 or 20 years ago, it got kind of dull because didn't any idea you had Intel would still go ahead and they knew how to make a lot of money, just it'd be faster this year. Now it's really unclear, so.
37:56 Speaker 02 Rise of AI, I mean, that's the rise of machine learning.
37:59 Speaker 00 We'll talk about that a little bit.
38:00 Speaker 02 That's a big piece of it because they're incredibly computationally intensive tasks, right? And that was one of the stumbling blocks we had to overcome. In order to get machine learning to work, we had to throw a thousand times more hardware power than we thought we had to throw at the problem. And all of a sudden, you've got these machines doing these comparatively special purpose tasks, but very different than traditional general purpose computers. So you can rethink, how do you design a machine to do that function very fast? Virtual reality, augmented reality, you can think about all these.
38:31 Speaker 00 All the different things that hang off of it. Do you imagine that we need a breakthrough to get to that, correct? From what I understand, and especially with the massive amounts of data that is that are pouring in.
38:41 Speaker 01 Yeah, well, we need to, we need to do things differently. And I think researchers love it when we have to do things differently. Yes, we need as innovative ideas as, you know, maybe the risk ideas were.
38:54 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's a discontinuity.
38:56 Speaker 00 So is there something you've heard recently that's been like, well, I've heard all kinds, like, living computers?
39:02 Speaker 01 Oh, no, I don't know. It needs to be that exotic. It's, you know, transistors are pretty, silicon transistors are pretty amazing technologies, even if it's slowing down. And they are going to get a little better, but we've been like, it's like building, we want to build a building in a different way. We don't necessarily have to get rid of bricks.
39:19 Speaker 00 I see. Good point. That's a fair point.
39:21 Speaker 01 So, but we've, in the past, it's always been a bad idea to do special purpose architectures. That was like, you know, the kiss of death. Because, you know, you do all that energy, and then how many are going to sell? How many people? But now, we have no choice. With this ending of Moore's Law and the art scaling, there's no other choice. We have to do special purpose architectures. And so the excitement of machine learning is it's kind of a narrow, but general purpose a technology. And we have to figure out how to build, you know, machines for those.
39:51 Speaker 00 And the companies critical to this are Go, well.
39:55 Speaker 01 Nvidia is the reigning champion. That's where people go. Google, you know, I helped write papers about the TPU. The TPU, that first generation, I think, pretty successful. It was, you know, at a time in normal computing, if you're like twice as fast, you know, you kill everybody in the marketplace. We said that the TPU was like 30 to 80 times better, right? So that's kind of amazing numbers. But because it's a new area and it does that one thing well, you can get these fantastic advantages.
40:29 Speaker 02 But I think you'll see all the, I think, Apple, Amazon, Facebook, will all, Microsoft are all investing in this technology because it appears the range of applicability for deep learning is quite broad on very complex tasks that traditionally computers have not been able to do well.
40:48 Speaker 00 That they're able to do. Well, explain one of those to, give an example for regular.
40:51 Speaker 02 Image recognition is probably the best one. It's the one we can, now we can have a program which is better at classifying breeds of dogs and cats than anybody but an AKC certified master.
41:03 Speaker 00 Right.
41:04 Speaker 02 Which is absolutely amazing. And self-driving cars, I mean, they really depend on this.
41:08 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
41:09 Speaker 02 Ability to interpret scenes which are not easy to interpret for computers.
41:14 Speaker 00 And then learn it again and again.
41:15 Speaker 02 And learn it again and again.
41:16 Speaker 00 Right. How do you make, you know, I don't want to dumb down this because you're both so highly intelligent, but the idea that it's dangerous, that these new types of computing.
41:26 Speaker 01 You mean?
41:27 Speaker 00 The Elon argument, the Stephen Hawking.
41:28 Speaker 01 The AI itself. Yeah, it's not so much the hardware we're building, but you know, the technology itself. Yeah, I think there's this argument that other fields have done a better job of when we get to these cultural issues like physicists and atomic energy and biology and, you know, dangerous bugs.
41:45 Speaker 00 That's what I'm thinking.
41:46 Speaker 01 Yeah, I would say, I hang out with a lot of machine learning people. I know they care desperately about fairness, which is one of the criticisms that you hear about machine learning.
41:55 Speaker 00 Sure. Because they all tend to look the same, sorry, like you guys.
41:58 Speaker 01 Well.
41:59 Speaker 00 Younger versions of you guys.
42:00 Speaker 01 Yeah. At least at Google, there's women.
42:05 Speaker 01 And so I, you know, one of my colleagues at Berkeley is writing a book about fairness. So they seem to be taking these issues on. But right now, you know, there's big holes in the technology or and if we don't work on them, you know, bad things could happen.
42:21 Speaker 00 Yeah.
42:21 Speaker 02 Well, and I think there's a concern that humans will be removed from the loop in all these cases.
42:26 Speaker 00 Sure.
42:26 Speaker 02 And particularly if the technology were to be used for offensive warfighting or something like that. I mean, I think there is, there are real dangers that we need to worry about. You have a technology, I mean, think about medical technology. It has both good uses and dangers uses as well. It's the same thing here. Appropriately used, the technology will be fine. Maliciously used, it'll be dangerous.
42:52 Speaker 00 Right. Do they just look at Valley, understand the malicious uses as well? I mean, just, we just got off a week of hearings of Facebook where Mark Zuckerberg was essentially lauded because he was able to wear a suit and not sweat, you know, pretty much. But he didn't say much and there's some a lot of questions about the responsibility of tech companies. I'm not using just Mark because it's a general attitude in Silicon Valley.
43:12 Speaker 01 Well, if I can speak as a professor, as opposed, you know, I just, the fact that they let somebody doing an app access to all tens of millions of people's data, that's kind of irresponsible.
43:23 Speaker 00 That's bad management. That's what I called it.
43:25 Speaker 01 Yeah, I mean, I, did they not realize that?
43:28 Speaker 00 Well, that's what I'm talking about.
43:29 Speaker 01 You know, were they, is the reason they didn't realize that they're making, yeah, it just, it's some, there was just a real failure there and it's a, it's a black mark for everybody.
43:38 Speaker 02 Well, I think the real danger here is a breakdown in trust. Because we, we trust companies. We give them our data. We give them, they have our email.
43:47 Speaker 00 Sure.
43:47 Speaker 02 You know, we trust them. They, we trust Google to do a search properly. If we lose that trust element, then the tech sector will be abandoned by people.
43:56 Speaker 00 Right.
43:56 Speaker 02 And it's whether it's information security, it's accuracy of data, it's accuracy of news feeds, all those things.
44:02 Speaker 00 It's use of data.
44:03 Speaker 02 Use of data.
44:03 Speaker 00 Especially with these new computer architectures, which will be. Much more embedded and much smarter, correct?
44:08 Speaker 02 Correct.
44:09 Speaker 00 I mean, do you think the government understands that correctly? I mean, you got your first funding from DARPA. I mean, is there still that commitment from government to really understand and discern it? Or are you worried about?
44:20 Speaker 02 I think certainly government wants to understand the technology and how to use it. I think the problem becomes when they want to legislate, they have a hard time writing legislation that keeps up with technology. Look at our copyright law. It's stuck in the 1700s and we haven't been able to make the vital changes. And I think that's what we have to worry about. How do we craft regulations? If we're going to have regulations, how do we craft regulations that don't inhibit innovation?
44:51 Speaker 00 So as we move into this new era of architecture, which I think is very clear, as you're saying, it seems as if we're on the cusp of another innovation in computer architecture. Who should be responsible for that? Is it should be the industry? It should be who? Is it academia? Is it government? What was interesting struck me last week from the hearings is the congressmen or the senators kept asking Mark what regulation he'd like, which I thought was fascinating. But again, of course, why would they know what to do at all? Because they hardly understood Terms of Service.
45:26 Speaker 02 Well, I suppose, given the importance of technology to society, it's going to have to be all three parties coming together, right? That's probably a very difficult proposition to get government to work with.
45:40 Speaker 00 And citizens, right?
45:42 Speaker 02 And academia can play a part of bringing in knowledge and expertise without necessarily a bias of one form or another and help chart that. But it's not going to be easy to chart, Carol. I think it's going to be hard. I think most Americans probably haven't thought about, okay. How much privacy am I willing to give up in exchange for what?
46:02 Speaker 00 Right.
46:03 Speaker 02 They really haven't thought about the boundaries. Of course, they all use credit cards.
46:06 Speaker 00 Right.
46:06 Speaker 02 And if you don't think everybody who touches that credit card is collecting information, you're being naive.
46:11 Speaker 00 No, not at all. But I think some of the technologies that are showing up now are quite different from the last 10 years. I mean, some of them, a cellphone is one thing, but self-driving cars, automation, AI, robotics, for example.
46:25 Speaker 01 Well, yeah, but I mean, I think self-driving cars is something that computer scientists have been talking about for a while.
46:29 Speaker 00 Yes, they have.
46:30 Speaker 01 We think this is, I mean, this will be, if it really works, this will be something we'll brag about forever. I mean, 1.2 million people die every year.
46:39 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
46:39 Speaker 01 There's incredible billions of damages. If we could-
46:42 Speaker 00 Energy and efficiency. It goes on, obviously.
46:44 Speaker 01 If we could cut back, could we save a million lives a year with, you know, with the advance of technology? We could, right? And anybody who knows somebody who's been one of these terrible accidents changes their lives forever. We could, we could make this, you know, over time, much rarer event. And that would be one of the things we'd brag about like the internet, right?
47:07 Speaker 00 Right. So, but in that vein, and again, I'm not trying to be a leotard in this area, do you think they think enough about jobs, the impact of jobs, the impact of, do you think Silicon Valley, to me, has matured enough where they, there is this, when you interview certain people, like I had Sundar and Shrep from, from Facebook and others, and it was the same year we had Elon, he was talking about Terminator-like kind of outcomes, essentially. And they were talking about sort of the happy, shiny future. But what I do get a sense of is that nobody really does under, I think I did an interview with Marc Andreessen last year where he talked about that it was the farming to manufacturing shift. It was a similar thing. And I kept saying, well, there was a lot of social unrest,
47:49 Speaker 00 there was a lot of populism, there was, and that took 70 years. This is a very compressed time period. Who has the ethical underpinnings when, because some of these technologies are quite culturally changing, social changing, political, all this stuff. And I think a lot of these past elections have been about that, about fear of the future.
48:07 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think you're right, Karen. I think you're going to see disruption to white collar jobs, not just blue collar jobs.
48:13 Speaker 00 Yes, that's what I mean, yeah, high paying jobs.
48:15 Speaker 02 And I think the data that's out there shows that in the end, it'll lead to economic growth and new opportunities, but there'll be a disruption, just as there was during the Industrial Revolution. And you're right, that it's going to happen much faster. So we're going to have to adjust. Many jobs are going to be what they call de-skilled. So in other words, part of the skill set of the job will be taken over by the computer.
48:37 Speaker 00 And why shouldn't it be?
48:38 Speaker 02 Why shouldn't it be, right?
48:39 Speaker 00 Like you're saying with the cars, why shouldn't it be safer?
48:41 Speaker 02 Why shouldn't it be, right?
48:42 Speaker 00 Right.
48:42 Speaker 02 So, but then, obviously, drivers are out of jobs then, in that setting. And how do we, how do we recover that? How do we restructure? How do we re-educate people into new job settings?
48:52 Speaker 01 You should probably interview Sundar again, because that's...
48:54 Speaker 00 Yeah, I am. I'm going to be.
48:55 Speaker 01 This is one of his hobbies, hobby horses, right? Is, is helping with technology and jobs. And there's...
49:01 Speaker 00 Yeah, I had him on an MSNBC show talking about it. I'm going to bring it back.
49:05 Speaker 01 Yeah, he's, there's a bunch of programs that I read about. So fortunately, you know, I'm glad I'm working at a place that seems to be taken seriously. I worry about for my grandchildren, you know, about the jobs and stuff like that.
49:14 Speaker 00 So I'm going to finish up asking, what would you guys do now if you were, I mean, you can do whatever you want. I don't think age is a hindrance in any way. But if you were starting out right now...
49:23 Speaker 01 If we were young again?
49:24 Speaker 00 No, I'm old too. So, I mean, if you would pick anything and go anywhere right now, change everything, is there one area of computing that you would focus on?
49:34 Speaker 01 I think...
49:35 Speaker 00 Or would you go to a restaurant?
49:36 Speaker 01 No, no, we're both optimists. I mean, if I was younger and had more energy, I would, this golden age sounds pretty good to me.
49:44 Speaker 00 Right.
49:44 Speaker 01 I think computer architects haven't been asked enough, to do enough about security.
49:48 Speaker 00 Yeah.
49:49 Speaker 01 And it's, you know, for those of us in the industry, it's humiliating how bad security is.
49:53 Speaker 00 It is.
49:53 Speaker 01 It's, you know, it's not, I don't think it's necessary. And I think hardware, which does things, you know, every nanosecond... We should try to see if hardware can really make a difference.
50:04 Speaker 00 Right.
50:05 Speaker 01 So, yeah, that's the one I...
50:06 Speaker 00 I agree.
50:07 Speaker 01 That's the one that I'm particularly interested in. And this, I think I talked about with RIS5, this open source instruction set. In the past, you know, we've had to wait for Intel. We have to beg Intel to make a change before we can do anything. Now, we don't have to beg anybody. We could jump in there, come up, try ideas, put them online through these field programmable gate arrays, and see if they work. And not only that, you don't have to work for Intel or ARM. Anybody in the world can do this. So, we could see this potentially rapid acceleration of innovation around security with architecture and software systems. And, you know, we, I sure, we need to get better at this. And I can imagine this path working. And so, yeah, I, that's what, I think that's a really exciting thing to work on.
50:51 Speaker 02 Yeah, I think it's an interesting time. Here's this whole new set of applications which consume enormous amounts of computer power and produce incredible results. We have to rethink both the hardware and the software systems that we used to build them, because they're both changing. We need to respond to these new kinds of applications, and we need to change the way we design the machines. So, that opens up opportunities for both software and hardware people. It's really a focus on co-design. So, you've got to bring these people together-
51:20 Speaker 00 You do.
51:21 Speaker 02 ... and get them to work together to do something innovative. And that, that's always an exciting time when that happens in a field.
51:26 Speaker 00 So, John, you don't want to bring back Google Glass?
51:28 Speaker 02 Uh-huh, try again.
51:29 Speaker 00 You know what? It's still a great concept.
51:32 Speaker 02 It's a great concept.
51:33 Speaker 00 It's exactly the right concept.
51:34 Speaker 02 Yeah, it's a great concept. We need, we need more killer apps besides face recognition.
51:39 Speaker 00 You know what? Do you remember General Magic? There's a new movie coming out about General Magic.
51:43 Speaker 02 Yeah.
51:43 Speaker 00 You know, it had, it had an iPhone back then.
51:46 Speaker 02 Remember, there were a couple tries at PDAs before the iPhone broke through?
51:50 Speaker 00 Well, General Magic was, and they were all, they all worked there, all the people that later went on.
51:53 Speaker 02 Yeah.
51:53 Speaker 00 I think Google Glass is going to make a comeback.
51:55 Speaker 02 Yeah.
51:56 Speaker 00 I've decided it's like the right concept, with the idea of something around your face and, and computing, and so it's just interesting to me. I would like you to invent that, please, if you don't mind.
52:04 Speaker 02 Okay, I'll work on it.
52:05 Speaker 00 Anyway-
52:05 Speaker 01 He's chair, so.
52:08 Speaker 00 Anyway, thank you so much for coming and congratulations on your award, named for Alan Turing, who is another great engineer, and visionary, actually, about where computing was going. We've had a great interview with John Hennessy and Dave Patterson. They are really legends in the business, and I hope you'll come back again and tell me where things are going in the future. Thanks for coming on the show. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes on Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to your podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcast for more. If you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about this show. This helps them discover great interviews like this one. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other Recode Radio podcasts. On Recode Media with
52:52 Speaker 00 Peter Kafka, you hear no-nonsense interviews with some of the smartest people in media and entertainment. I host Too Embarrassed to Ask, where we answer all of the questions about consumer tech and the week's news. And on Recode Replay, you can find audio from all our live events by Recode, including the Code Conference, which is coming up, and Code Media, we've got an amazing lineup for that, so be sure to tune in. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. Thanks to our editor Joel Robbie and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back with a bonus episode on Saturday. Tune in then.
53:24 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by HBO. In a world of incessant data tracking, one tech startup is working to create a brand-new internet, and that startup is Pied Piper. It's a totally decentralized, totally awesome, and too-good-to-be-true network, only on HBO's Silicon Valley. This tech could make the world a better place. Catch new episodes of Silicon Valley Sundays at 10 PM on HBO.
Previous Recode Decode: Joanna Coles, author, 'Love Rules' Next Recode Decode: New York Times tech columnist Farhad Manjoo explains the 'Frightful Five' Page updated October 16, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated