Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Hermitage Capital CEO Bill Browder About this episode Recode's Kara Swisher talks with Hermitage Capital CEO Bill Browder, a hedge fund manager turned human rights activist and his son, Josh Browder, whose company DoNotPay helps consumers fight everything from parking tickets to the Equifax leaks. They talk about the different ways they have pursued justice for relatively powerless people, their entrepreneurial journeys, and how both the Putin regime and mega-corporations have taken advantage of the internet.
Featuring:
Bill Browder (@BillBrowder), Hermitage Capital CEO
Josh Browder (@JBrowder1), DoNotPay CEO
Hosts:
Kara Swisher (@karaswisher), Recode co-founder and editor-at-large
More to explore:
Subscribe for free to Pivot, Kara’s podcast with NYU Professor Scott Galloway that offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics.
About Recode by Vox:
Recode by Vox helps you understand how tech is changing the world — and changing us.
Follow Us:
Newsletter: Recode Daily
Twitter: @Recode and @voxdotcom
... But enough about us
We are conducting an audience survey to better serve you. It takes no more than five minutes, and it really helps out the show. Please take our survey here.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift. Support around the clock. All backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:37 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required.
0:54 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
1:00 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as someone whose best friends are Russian bots. But in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chairs are Bill Browder and Josh Browder, an entrepreneurial father-and-son duo. Bill is a hedge fund manager, the CEO of Hermitage Capital Management, and the author of the bestselling nonfiction book, Red Notice. And his son Josh is the CEO of a company called Do Not Pay, which describes itself as the world's first robot lawyer. Bill and Josh, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:35 Speaker 03 We're great to be here. Thank you for having me.
1:36 Speaker 02 So I met Bill at a party in an Aspen Security Summit, where we were talking about lots of important security issues, which Bill is rather familiar. He told me about Josh's company, which is a startup in San Francisco, correct?
1:47 Speaker 03 That's right.
1:48 Speaker 02 And I wanted to sort of get them together to talk about this, not just a father and son, but like where entrepreneurism right now, where investing is, what's important thing. So let's start first with you, Josh. Explain your company, Do Not Pay.
2:00 Speaker 04 What we do is we help consumers fight for their rights.
2:02 Speaker 02 Right, okay.
2:03 Speaker 04 So Facebook has a team of lawyers figuring out how to... Mess with and screw the consumer, but the average person has no one. So we help you get out of your parking tickets, fight when there's a data breach, do all government paperwork, all the things that is really expensive, but technology is very good at automating.
2:21 Speaker 02 So explain how you do that. Explain how you automate that.
2:24 Speaker 04 So for example, you get a parking ticket. You go on to do not pay and it asks you questions about your ticket. Based on your answers, it generates all the documents like and finds a loophole to get you out of your parking fine. For example, problems with the signage, things like that.
2:39 Speaker 02 So you have to sort of document that with them.
2:41 Speaker 04 That's right.
2:42 Speaker 02 And so how did you come up with this concept?
2:44 Speaker 04 So I was in, I'm from the UK and when I turned 18, I started driving and I got about 30 parking tickets and I couldn't afford to pay these really expensive tickets. And so I was writing the same letter. I wasn't going to pay them for him.
2:55 Speaker 02 Right, okay, good, good parenting right there.
2:57 Speaker 04 And I was writing the same appeal letter over and over again. And I've always loved software and I thought this can so easily be automated. So it started with parking tickets and then morphed into everything else. And now it works in 150 different areas of the law.
3:08 Speaker 02 So the concept of robot lawyer, I mean, I welcome it. I have to say, I welcome our robot overlords in general. But talk about the concept because a lot of legal stuff is, you know, a lot of people talk about AI replacing this and that and everything else. But legal stuff seems perfect in that regard.
3:24 Speaker 04 It's really perfect. I don't think bots are going to be arguing in the Supreme Court anytime soon. But for something like consumer rights or a parking ticket, it's really perfect and can give people a lot of leverage.
3:34 Speaker 02 So parking tickets are one thing, but when you're talking about more complex legal issues, it's different.
3:39 Speaker 04 So we have this product, it's called Ode $500 Plus. And you can sue anyone in small claims court for under $10,000. So if your landlord is not returning your security deposit, you can now fight back. Most people have no idea what to do in that situation.
3:52 Speaker 02 So they have to go to the small claims court. How different is from Nolo or some of the other sites that provide forms and things like that?
3:59 Speaker 04 Well, this actually walks you through from start to finish. Everything from the demand letter to forms to a script to even read in court.
4:07 Speaker 02 To read in court.
4:07 Speaker 04 So you're almost a bot yourself, following the instructions.
4:10 Speaker 02 Following the instructions. And so it's a pay thing. So these are relatively small legal issues.
4:15 Speaker 04 Yeah, but sometimes it can be even like $5,000 for a security deposit.
4:20 Speaker 02 So, but can it morph out into a bigger kind of thing?
4:24 Speaker 04 One of the biggest things that we did is we helped people sue Equifax after the data breach.
4:28 Speaker 02 Well, go through that. So, explain what Equifax did.
4:32 Speaker 04 So, Equifax leaked the credentials of hundreds of millions of Americans and as a result, they got hacked, they had credit card fraud. And so, everyone was waiting for this class action settlement years later where everyone, it now appears people won't even get like dozens of dollars. And so, what we said is why not take Equifax to small claims court using technology? And when we did it, lots of lawyers said this will never work.
4:57 Speaker 02 Why?
4:58 Speaker 04 Because you can't, it's very difficult for an average person to just read a script and prove negligence against a large corporation. So, it was really an experiment, but it was actually successful. We had hundreds of people win thousands of dollars against Equifax.
5:12 Speaker 02 Meaning saying that they, in a small claims point of view, you have to show harm, correct?
5:17 Speaker 04 That's right. And so, people were showing that they were hacked and terrible things that happened in their lives as a result.
5:24 Speaker 02 And so, what's the big picture of doing this besides you getting parking tickets? What's the, which often entrepreneurial idea comes from stuff like this. But what's the bigger, how can you carry it out to a larger idea of certain acts that we think of as sort of artisanal almost, that we have to hire lawyers? I've interviewed a divorce lawyer who said a lot of this can be automated, for example.
5:45 Speaker 04 I see Do Not Pay as a sort of consumer union. We have workers' unions, so why not have a consumer union? If we have millions of people using our service, one day we can go to a Comcast and say, "You have to treat all of our customers better," or "You'll face havoc."
5:59 Speaker 02 You will do that?
6:00 Speaker 04 Yes.
6:01 Speaker 02 You will do that, or else you'll just say, "We're going to unleash legal documentation on you," because everybody shares the same gripes.
6:07 Speaker 04 That's right.
6:07 Speaker 02 Right. And so, when you, this idea of people joining online has been lost over the years. There used to be a lot of stuff early on in the internet time when there was going to be a lot of buying together, there was going to be a lot of joining together. It's sort of shattered into a million ugly little pieces for a lot of people.
6:25 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think that's lost. Everyone is too separated, but if you get people back together, then the big corporations will have to behave.
6:32 Speaker 02 So Bill, so you have, you're a hedge fund manager. You make investments and things like that. You have a little more of a reputation for other things, but...
6:38 Speaker 03 Well, I used to be a hedge fund manager. I guess now I would probably characterize myself as Putin's number one enemy.
6:45 Speaker 02 Yes, that's right. Yeah.
6:46 Speaker 03 I was a hedge fund manager in Russia. I ended up exposing corruption. I was expelled from the country by Putin, declared a threat to national security. My offices were raided. I hired a young lawyer named Sergey Magnitsky to help me defend myself. He uncovered a $230 million Russian government corruption scheme. And he exposed it and he was subsequently arrested in Russia, put in pretrial detention, tortured for 358 days, and killed 10 years ago at the age of 37. And so I put aside my hedge fund business entirely and now am a human rights activist focusing on justice for Sergey Magnitsky and justice for other victims of
7:31 Speaker 03 the Putin regime.
7:32 Speaker 02 And in terms of what you've done with that, as the Magnitsky asked, would you explain that?
7:36 Speaker 03 So we couldn't get justice in Russia because the people who killed Sergey were protected by Putin explicitly. He actually openly exonerated them. And so we said, we need to get justice in the West. And how do we get justice in the West? Well, the answer is that the Russians who commit these crimes, who killed Sergey and do other similar things, they do it for money. They don't keep that money in Russia. They keep that money in the West. And so we said to ourselves, if they value money so much that they're going to kill people, and then they want to keep it safe in the West by making it, putting their money at risk, that may not be real justice in terms of prosecution for murder, but it certainly puts them in a very weak and vulnerable position. And so we came up
8:21 Speaker 03 with this idea of freezing their assets and banning their visas. And I first brought this idea to Washington in 2010 with a Democratic senator named Benjamin Cardin and Republican Senator John McCain. And of all the things that people don't agree on in Washington, the one thing they could agree on was that Russian tortures and murders shouldn't come to America and shouldn't be able to spend their money here. And in 2012, the Magnitsky Act was up for vote. It passed 92 to 4 in the Senate, 89% of the House of Representatives, and it became a federal law on December 14, 2012. And this became probably the single biggest irritant for Vladimir Putin because he's
9:04 Speaker 03 a human rights violator and he's got a lot of assets, and this puts his money at risk.
9:07 Speaker 02 So, in terms of moving to do something like that, because a lot of it, you know, a lot of, there's a lot of Russian players in tech and all kinds of stuff, and obviously the Russian interference in the elections has been in the news, but this is sort of more at the heart of their issues, right? The money.
9:24 Speaker 03 So after the Magnitsky Act was passed, Putin said it was his number one foreign policy priority to repeal the Magnitsky Act. And if you remember, there's a very famous meeting in which a Russian lawyer went to Trump Tower on June 9, 2016. Her name was Natalia Veselnitskaya. She represented the Putin regime, and she was there specifically to ask Donald Trump Jr., Paul Manafort, and Jared Kushner if Donald Trump is elected. This is before he was elected. If he's elected, would he repeal the Magnitsky Act? And it was on that basis, and on the basis of Putin's general predisposition towards Donald Trump and away from Hillary Clinton, that he pushed for Donald Trump to become the President of the United States because at the top of his list was repealing the Magnitsky Act.
10:08 Speaker 03 And so, in a very weird and strange way, this one murder over my lawyer has led to the motivation for Russia to interfere in the US elections.
10:17 Speaker 02 Wow. Thanks, Bill. Appreciate it.
10:20 Speaker 03 Unexpected consequences.
10:22 Speaker 02 Unexpected consequences. So, you were doing your own thing, you were investing and things like that. Moving away into this area, when you wrote about and read notice...
10:33 Speaker 02 What does that do? What does that do to a person? I mean, it's interesting to be able to move away and create that. And then I want to talk about how you, you know, you have a son who's entrepreneurial.
10:41 Speaker 03 Well, he's also a justice activist.
10:42 Speaker 02 Right.
10:43 Speaker 03 And so, well, so what I discovered, I mean, I loved being a, an investment guy. I loved the intellectual challenge and, you know, being right was measured by investment returns. And that was all very wonderful and very satisfying and I wouldn't, and nothing wrong with it. But, but I have to say that fighting for justice is literally a thousand times more satisfying than fighting for money.
11:06 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
11:07 Speaker 03 And one of the things that I'm most proud of with Josh was that he's found a way to combine the two in his life and his career. He's one of the most successful young people I know. He started a company, he raised venture capital to fight for consumer rights, to fight big corporations and to sort of level the playing field. And so I'd like to think that, that maybe their little bit of parenting had something to do with that.
11:31 Speaker 02 Right. So the concept, Josh, is that you've been, he's been doing it on a macro level. This is a major macro level, an international, global, macro level, and you're doing it on the micro level. How do they fit together? Was that, was that being a justice entrepreneur?
11:44 Speaker 04 Well, I think it's very different to fighting Russian tortures and murders.
11:48 Speaker 02 Yes, of course. Yes, it is.
11:49 Speaker 04 Parking ticket bureaucrats.
11:50 Speaker 02 Although some parking ticket people are really awful.
11:52 Speaker 04 But one thing I would say that I've learned from my father is that I'm never phased by anything. I've, I remember waking up when he was stuck in Russia, they were detaining him at the airport. I've seen really terrible things. And so when some lawyer or someone is after me, something that would scare the average person, really, I don't care that much.
12:12 Speaker 02 Right. So talk about the idea of people's rights on the internet, because I think you're at the heart, the reason I did want to talk to you is because you're at the heart of, I think, a growing feeling that the internet is controlling you. Vice versa, and you could do this on privacy, you could do this all kinds of ways. Is that you're just an object to be acted upon and you don't, you haven't been able to use the powers of these amazing technologies for yourself, except for maybe finding a date or getting your car delivered to you at the right time.
12:40 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think that as we speak, people are brainstorming in every big corporation, how can you get the most money, how can you get the most data. Meanwhile, as a person, you're just feeling incredibly exploited and you need a way to fight back.
12:53 Speaker 02 So in terms of creating a company, right, how much money did you raise?
12:57 Speaker 04 We raised 4.6 million in total.
12:59 Speaker 02 In total, and is your company profitable yet?
13:02 Speaker 04 No.
13:03 Speaker 02 How do people get paid? What do they pay you for what?
13:05 Speaker 04 So, most of it is free, but if you're successful in some areas, there's a subscription of $3 a month. So we have a direct relationship with our customers.
13:13 Speaker 02 Meaning, what are they paying for?
13:15 Speaker 04 Paying for like, some services. For example, we have this one service that automatically cancels all your free trials, just like that.
13:22 Speaker 02 Oh, explain that, please. Please, please explain that.
13:25 Speaker 04 So, big companies use deceptive practices to get your credit card.
13:28 Speaker 02 Yes, I understand that.
13:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, and lots of people set calendar reminders, but they ultimately forget to cancel. And so what we've done is we created this free trial credit card that you can use on all your subscription free trials, and you never have to worry because when you use it, it will just cancel the free trial for you.
13:44 Speaker 02 For you?
13:45 Speaker 04 Yes.
13:45 Speaker 02 So after a month?
13:46 Speaker 04 And it's not linked to your payment service or bank account, and so it's just there that you can use on the internet, your personal free trial credit card.
13:53 Speaker 02 Which doesn't have any money on it, right? You pay because it's a free thing.
13:57 Speaker 04 So we figured out a way to trick all the big companies into getting past the payment screen.
14:02 Speaker 02 That's a brilliant idea. I just had a fight with someone over this, this they kept going.
14:05 Speaker 03 So, first of all, you don't remember to cancel after a month.
14:08 Speaker 02 Oh, I know.
14:09 Speaker 03 And if you do, these guys are, they make it difficult for you. You can't cancel online, you've got to like, call up something and they put you on hold.
14:15 Speaker 02 I've been paying for AOL since 1996.
14:17 Speaker 03 Right, well, if you had subscribed to Do Not Pay.
14:20 Speaker 02 I'm going to. No, not now. I'm too late, too late, too late.
14:23 Speaker 03 No, no, you can subscribe now. It's open for subscription.
14:26 Speaker 04 It's free for you.
14:27 Speaker 02 No, I understand. Thank you so much, but I've already had a problem that, oh, I could switch the credit card. No, I'm not on a free. Anyway, let's not go into my ridiculous problems with America Online that continue to this day, 30, 20 years later. So, sorry. Go ahead. So, the idea is the idea of doing things that are not necessarily in the interest of taking advantage of people.
14:45 Speaker 04 We're looking at all the loopholes that exist in the world and trying to make it pro-consumer rather than pro-corporation.
14:51 Speaker 02 Why do you imagine the Internet has gotten so far away from that idea of consumers being the focus versus these corporations?
14:58 Speaker 04 I think it's all down to the budget. I'm not sure how big Facebook's budget is this year, but if you compare that to what the average American's budget is with a negative bank account, it can explain why they can afford to hire so many people to figure this out.
15:13 Speaker 02 So, these are all just different things, any kind of loophole you're trying to find?
15:16 Speaker 04 Yeah. Another one is we're very pro-pet owner, so we have this thing coming out.
15:20 Speaker 02 Pro what?
15:20 Speaker 04 Pet owner.
15:21 Speaker 02 Pet owner, okay.
15:22 Speaker 04 So, if you have-
15:23 Speaker 02 Who's not?
15:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, everyone loves dogs and cats. And so, if you have a pet, you get charged airline fees, housing fees, so we figured out a way to get you out of all of that.
15:31 Speaker 02 What?
15:32 Speaker 04 And that's coming out soon as well.
15:33 Speaker 02 What do you mean?
15:34 Speaker 04 So, we have the pet emotional support animal classification, things like that.
15:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, of course. That's a scam, right? Come on, Josh. That's a scam.
15:43 Speaker 04 I think that-
15:45 Speaker 02 I have a friend who, like, wants to bring an octopus on board, but go ahead, move on.
15:48 Speaker 04 I mean, maybe an octopus, but 80% of America have anxiety.
15:52 Speaker 02 Yes.
15:52 Speaker 04 And pets can be really comforting for that, and so, we just want to make, and this thing already exists. You have to pay, like, $500, so it's available to the rich. What we want to do is make these tools available to everyone.
16:02 Speaker 02 I see. So, I want to talk a minute about entrepreneurs when we get back, like, what the entrepreneurial mentality is among young people now. And then, Bill, I'd like to talk to you, like, the same thing sort of happens with services we use, and the Russians taking advantage of those things. When we get back, we're here with Bill and Josh Browder. They're father and son, and they have some very different and interesting things they're doing, both related to the Internet.
16:40 Speaker 05 Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Fine. No one deals more deals than. Please stop. Touche.
16:53 Speaker 05 Priceline.
16:54 Speaker 06 How about a latte?
16:55 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
16:56 Speaker 06 Vanilla?
16:57 Speaker 01 Caramel?
16:57 Speaker 06 Blueberry?
16:58 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
17:11 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
17:21 Speaker 02 We're back with Bill and Josh Browder. Bill is the CEO of The Hermitage Capital Management, and Josh, his son, is the CEO of Do Not Pay. We've just been talking about his business. I want to get into like what it's like to be an entrepreneur today. But one of the things that you've zeroed on, even though you're dealing with sort of high-level international finance stakes, is the Russian continued abuse, use and abuse of platforms for their benefit and against the benefit of consumers, voters, and different, and to manipulate people. Can you talk a little bit about that? Because I think it does, like, the ability of them to do it so easily had a lot to do with how they're.
18:00 Speaker 03 So if you look at Russia right now, Russia has got an economy the size of the state of New York. And the military budget is 90% less than the US military budget. And it's such a corrupt country that 80% of the military budget gets stolen. So it's really 2% of the US military budget. But at the same time, they're sort of, Vladimir Putin wants to be a proud, muscular, aggressive country, but they can't do it on a symmetric basis. And so what they do is they go out and they try to find places where they can be asymmetric. In other words, where they can sort of hide in the shadows and cause trouble. And one of the best places to do that these days is the internet. And the internet is all sort of plausibly deniable. It's all diffuse. Nobody knows who doing what to whom.
18:43 Speaker 03 And the Russians are good technologically. And when I say Russians, I should say certain people in the Russian. Part of the Russian government, not all Russians are bad, but the Putin regime is bad. And they're out there, you know, on a very, very, what I would call, low-cost, high-impact basis, they've got this troll farm in St. Petersburg where-
19:01 Speaker 02 The Internet Research Agency?
19:03 Speaker 03 And I know all about that because I'm one of their targets constantly. If you ever want to tweet something nice about me, you'll have like 50 tweets underneath you from the troll farm, from all these supposed Americans saying terrible things.
19:15 Speaker 02 Try tweeting Anthony Scaramucci, see what happens. But go ahead.
19:18 Speaker 03 It's the same thing. It's the technology which they've mastered. And they've mastered it on Twitter, they've mastered it on Facebook. And it's very, very difficult. It's difficult for two reasons to stop. One is there's no rules, the legislation to say that people can't do it. And it doesn't appear as if these companies, these major social media companies, have any proper barriers in place to stop it.
19:42 Speaker 02 Right.
19:43 Speaker 03 And they don't seem to feel responsible. I mean, it's interesting, you know, if BP does an oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, they get sued for billions and billions of dollars for the damage they caused. Facebook and Twitter have caused a lot of damage, there's no question. It's acknowledged, it's been proven. But they're not taking any responsibility. And so until there is-
20:00 Speaker 02 Well, they don't have to.
20:01 Speaker 03 Until there is, this stuff is going to go on. And I'm sure the Russians are all licking their chops right now, gearing up for 2020.
20:08 Speaker 02 Well, what's interesting is, I call it the new Cold War. Like, they've won, they lost the Cold War, and they certainly were inadequate to the task of winning it, by the way. I mean, I think we overstated their abilities.
20:18 Speaker 03 On a symmetric basis, they lost it. But now they're playing plausibly deniable asymmetry. And they're winning it right now. Vladimir Putin is just laughing at the chaos that he's created, and all the anger, the sort of intellectual and cultural civil war that's been created with all of this stuff, which costs him nothing. You know, 100 million bucks, 200 million bucks is the cost of the budget of the Internet Research Agency and the other people that are doing this stuff. I mean, compare that to the military budget that they can't compete with.
20:43 Speaker 02 Right, which they never could, which they actually never could. All you had to do is visit there to understand the difference.
20:48 Speaker 03 It's rotting at the seams.
20:50 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm. Well, it's been rotting for a long time.
20:51 Speaker 03 It has been.
20:52 Speaker 02 Let's be clear. So when you're thinking about these things, Josh, when you're, as an entrepreneur now, one of the things that your dad's talking about is people that have created the Internet that have gotten- I wouldn't say cynical that don't care about consequences. Talk about being a young entrepreneur now. Do you think people, how old are you?
21:08 Speaker 04 I'm 22.
21:09 Speaker 02 Right, so you're a different class than the Zuckerbergs and then even before that, the Google guys and stuff like that. But there seems to be a change, it seems to be in Silicon Valley, coming among entrepreneurs, that they're thinking about the impact of what they do. Is that, am I wrong about that? I just seem to be talking to a lot more entrepreneurs that have a sense of social commitment, that have a sense of their impact, that have a sense of what they're inventing matters, like how they are inventing it matters.
21:40 Speaker 04 I think among the entrepreneurs, definitely. However, so I went to Stanford and still the majority of students.
21:45 Speaker 02 So you're like the actual ad for an entrepreneur, right? You went to Stanford.
21:49 Speaker 04 I'm not sure about that.
21:50 Speaker 02 Sandhill, who's your VC?
21:52 Speaker 04 We have a lot of VCs.
21:53 Speaker 02 But probably all the Sandhill boys, right? Correct?
21:56 Speaker 04 Straight out of Silicon Valley.
21:57 Speaker 02 Yeah, straight out of Silicon Valley.
21:59 Speaker 04 So everyone at Stanford still wants to go work for Facebook or sometimes even Palantir, things like that. But the entrepreneurs, definitely.
22:05 Speaker 02 Palantir does defense.
22:06 Speaker 04 I would say that there's a lot of bad stuff being created as well, so you have to fight against that.
22:11 Speaker 02 So how do you think about that as an entrepreneur? Like, how can we create a class of entrepreneurs? That's why I wanted to talk to you, is that young entrepreneurs that have a sense, like, one of the things I always say when I give speeches to young entrepreneurs, I said, imagine, and I've done this, it's not a joke, but it's a pretty good joke. I said, imagine that your invention is an episode of Black Mirror and then don't make it. Like, you know, if you can think of like the most terrible thing, but they never think about that. I want to get into the mentality of creators. Like, how do you change that? You were trained at Stanford, where a lot of entrepreneurs are trained. You're right in the heart of Silicon Valley. How do you change that dynamic among engineers to understand that one thing they could do could have an effect in Myanmar or blank, you know, whatever it is?
22:53 Speaker 04 So Stanford recently introduced mandatory ethics classes. I support that. And I think that entrepreneurs should always, what we try and think of at Do Not Pay is what's the worst thing that can happen with every one of the products we make? So with the free trials thing, what if like everyone starts using it? No more free trials. That's kind of a bad situation. But similarly with the pets thing, everyone has their pets. It's not the worst thing in the world. And so I think just taking it to that next level is really important.
23:21 Speaker 02 And when you're thinking of ethics, did you end up taking an ethics course? Do you think they care?
23:25 Speaker 04 I did, yeah. I took multiple ethics and philosophy.
23:29 Speaker 02 But do you think that as a entrepreneur, like right now, the entrepreneur is, and you can't put everyone in a lump, but you really can. This is a very homogeneous group of people, like type of, type of person, not necessarily, but it's certainly not as diverse as it needs to be. It's certainly not as thoughtful as it needs to be. How do you change that as a young entrepreneur?
23:47 Speaker 04 I think that the good news is the market is changing it for a lot of these entrepreneurs. In the past, like the fashionable thing could have been like ad tracking technology to work on or things like that. These days, unless you're, if you do the slightest thing wrong, Apple will remove you from the App Store and things like that. So there's a strong incentive to do the right thing as well.
24:05 Speaker 02 Right, but that's a financial incentive. What about getting through to entrepreneurs? Their social impact?
24:10 Speaker 04 I think a lot of, as a young person, a lot of ethics are formed in college and so just drumming it into the students during college, wherever they are, if they go to college.
24:19 Speaker 02 Right. And do you imagine there should be other people making decisions at these companies, like that aren't necessarily, one of my things was you've got to have more different, it can't be all run by engineers necessarily.
24:30 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think lawyers are actually, although I think they're overpriced, they're surprisingly ethical people. So we need more lawyers in Silicon Valley.
24:38 Speaker 03 You've met a different kind of lawyer than I have.
24:39 Speaker 02 Yeah, I know, me too. I don't know about that.
24:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
24:43 Speaker 02 So they're going to be all replaced by AI, just in case you're interested.
24:46 Speaker 04 They can move to ethics.
24:47 Speaker 02 They can, yeah, right, exactly. But, you know, Bill, when you're talking about this, this idea of letting this stuff go, like, you know, and you could have let it go, you could have, yeah, corruption is kind of like Putin and corruption and goes together like, you know, chocolate and peanut butter, essentially.
25:01 Speaker 03 You know, a lot of people told me when all this stuff was happening, you know, I should just, you know, let it go, go to ground, disappear, forget about it. And for me, I just wasn't able to do that. And I think that there is something, you know, we come from a long line of justice people. My grandfather, Josh's great grandfather, his political philosophy I don't agree with, but he was the head of the American Communist Party during the Great Depression. And he-
25:28 Speaker 02 That's a spot to be in.
25:30 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, and he actually had it properly, that was probably the high moment of the American Communist Party.
25:34 Speaker 02 It was, indeed.
25:35 Speaker 03 Because there was, because there was just such injustice where everybody was, you know, starving and a few people had everything. And so there's been this-
25:45 Speaker 03 You know, I don't know whether it's genetic or cultural that runs through our family where everybody, including Josh's little brothers and sisters, everybody just feels like an immense sense of anger and injustice. And I don't know how you teach that. I don't know how it comes around.
26:04 Speaker 02 What's been the repercussions for you, besides danger presumably?
26:08 Speaker 03 Well, for me-
26:09 Speaker 02 You're just like avoiding umbrellas at all costs.
26:11 Speaker 03 Well, the repercussions have been absolutely dramatic. The Russians have threatened to kill me.
26:16 Speaker 02 They wanted you back there, I remember.
26:18 Speaker 03 They threatened to kidnap me. They've gone after me using Interpol arrest warrants eight times. I was arrested in Madrid last summer on a Russian Interpol arrest warrant. They've, I live in London, they've applied to the British government 12 times for mutual legal assistance and extradition.
26:34 Speaker 02 And their allegations are?
26:36 Speaker 03 Well, I've been convicted twice in Russian court and sentenced to 18 years in prison. They've accused me of murdering Sergey Magnitsky and murdering four other individuals. They accused me of being a spy, all sorts of stuff. I mean, it's basically, I know that I've gotten right to, right under Vladimir Putin's skin by the amount of crazy allegations they've made against me. And in a certain way, I almost wear it as a badge of honor because if I wasn't being effective and they weren't feeling it, they would, you know, they probably wouldn't be doing all this crazy stuff.
27:08 Speaker 02 Is there a chance that the Magnitsky Act, I mean, Trump is his pal, does that worry you, the closeness of the Trump administration to Putin?
27:15 Speaker 03 Well, there's two things. There's Donald Trump himself and the Trump administration. And Donald Trump himself is completely, he's off his head. And probably the most crazy thing that happened was last summer, there was the first summit between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. And it took place a couple of days after the indictment. Robert Mueller indicted 12 Russian military intelligence officers. And at the press conference after the summit, which was, by the way, held in secret without any-
27:46 Speaker 02 Right.
27:46 Speaker 03 -any people there.
27:47 Speaker 02 I recall. No one had a pen.
27:49 Speaker 03 There was no witnesses from the US side. And the journalist from Reuters raises his hand and said, President Putin, are you going to hand over the 12 Russian GRU agents? And Putin, who obviously had been thinking about this all throughout the weekend, what his response was going to be, said, "Well, it's not so simple as that. Yes, we will, provided that President Trump hands over Bill Browder."
28:13 Speaker 02 Yeah, I remember.
28:14 Speaker 03 And 11 of his, members of his criminal organization, which turned out to be Mike McFaul, the US Ambassador to Russia, Kyle Parker, the Chief of Staff of the US Helsinki Commission that drafted the Magnitsky Act, Todd Hyman, who is an agent at the Department of Homeland Security that was prosecuting money launderers connected to the Magnitsky case, and a bunch of other people all somehow connected. And Donald Trump said, "I think that's a brilliant idea." And it took him about four days to walk that back, and it was only one hour before the Senate voted 98 to 0 that none of us should be handed over. And so Donald Trump, I don't know what's going through his mind. His administration is not like that. I mean, at the same time as he was considering it, the spokesperson
28:59 Speaker 03 from the State Department said it was absurd. The head of the FBI said, "That's not going to happen," et cetera, et cetera. But I don't know what he's going to do. But I'm not as concerned about the Magnitsky Act being repealed for one simple reason, is that it requires an act of Congress. And I've met many members of both sides of the aisle, and whether people, you know, criticize Donald Trump or not on the Republican side, they're not going to hand over, they're not going to allow Russian tortures and murders to come back into America. So I think the Magnitsky--
29:25 Speaker 02 Just Saudi ones, but go ahead.
29:26 Speaker 03 Well, actually, interestingly, on Saudi, it's other story. So the Magnitsky Act has now been expanded to global, to go after bad guys globally. And after the Jamal Khashoggi murder, Lindsey Graham and many other Republicans were pounding the table, saying that these people should be sanctioned, going right up to Mohammed bin Salman. And in the end, the US administration sanctioned 17 Saudis on the Magnitsky Act. The one that Donald Trump wouldn't allow to be sanctioned is Mohammed bin Salman. But that doesn't mean that a future government won't. And in fact, I think MBS should be happy Trump is in place because any president, Democrat or Republican in the future will hand that man over.
30:03 Speaker 02 Yeah. Then he could just play video games all day like he does, apparently, allegedly. That's what I understand. Anyway, when we get back, we're going to talk with Bill and Josh Browder. They are respectively the CEO of the Hermitschitz Capital Management and the CEO of Do Not Pay. They are also father and son. We're going to talk about sort of where entrepreneurism is going, and also where some things we need to do to protect our elections going forward.
30:24 Speaker 05 Priceline Negotiator. It's me, the. Priceline Negotiator. We don't need the jingle twice. What about a third time? Stop it. This is about vacation inflation and how Priceline negotiates amazing deals on hotels, flights, and rental cars. Seems like they just said it. Yeah, but I didn't mention that you can save up to 60% off hotels in the Priceline app. Time to read the tagline. Fine. No one deals more deals than. Priceline. Please stop. Priceline. Touche. Priceline. Priceline.
30:55 Speaker 06 How about a latte?
30:56 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
30:57 Speaker 06 Vanilla?
30:58 Speaker 01 Caramel?
30:59 Speaker 06 Blueberry?
30:59 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup pie varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
31:22 Speaker 02 We're here with Bill and Josh Browder. Bill is the co-founder and CEO of the Hermitage Capital Management, and his son Josh is the CEO of Do Not Pay. Josh, where do you see like, so you could endlessly do this, right? You could endlessly do all kinds of loopholes, like moving on, like from one to the next, correct?
31:39 Speaker 04 That's right. What we want to do is rope people in with one and then get them with all the loopholes.
31:42 Speaker 02 Right. And so the concept is sort of the way modern society is now, as we become more digitized, we've been sort of attached to everything we do is digital. Who are the worst offenders in this area? Is it just every part of it? Or is it just analog things? You were talking about attacking online services or offline services, really?
32:04 Speaker 04 I think everyone is very upset about privacy and rightly so, but the biggest problem in the world is just incompetence. The Equifax data breach happened because they didn't use basic encryption. And we have that. There was Capital One, hundreds and hundreds of millions of people.
32:19 Speaker 02 Explain what happened there so people don't, most people do know, but not everybody knows.
32:22 Speaker 04 Millions and millions of accounts, and then hundreds of thousands of social security numbers just released because they didn't encrypt it properly. And as like, it takes like one Stanford computer science class to learn how to do that. And it's amazing that these corporations with billions of. Like, assets can't even do it properly. And so I think every week, there's going to be another data breach. And things like that is the real concern for consumers.
32:48 Speaker 02 So what do you, when you think about that, I mean, obviously, you're using it as a business opportunity, as an entrepreneur, to do that. At the same time, it's protecting people. How do you change the mentality of Silicon Valley to think like that? Because these are, like, there's not that many companies like yours. There aren't. There's some that, you know, where you can, I suppose the closest analogy would be to VPNs, where you're going to be protected when you're surfing the internet to protect your privacy, or what you're searching on, so you don't get marketed to endlessly. Which is another big problem, being marketed to endlessly.
33:18 Speaker 04 Yeah. I see it all as incentives. And so if you can just punish the bad actors with maximum pain, which is what Do Not Pay is trying to do, then eventually, hopefully, we'll live in a world where they hire competent people and encrypt people's data, and also don't spam them with ads endlessly.
33:34 Speaker 02 Do you think that will change? I just interviewed Gabe Weinberg, who's the head of DuckDuckGo. He's the founder of DuckDuckGo. And, you know, he's talking about why not, why are we doing behavioral ads at all, for example? You know, when contextual ads are just as lucrative, in some ways.
33:47 Speaker 04 I think it's got a long way to go to change. I mean, the Facebook FTC fine was not really a disincentive to anyone.
33:55 Speaker 02 No, not really. You're so kind, Josh. It was a parking ticket.
33:58 Speaker 04 Yeah, exactly.
33:59 Speaker 02 I hope they don't use your service to try to get back their money.
34:01 Speaker 04 Yeah, slap on the wrist. I think we have a long way to go.
34:04 Speaker 02 Yeah. So what does that say, as an entrepreneur, when that happens? When a company like Facebook pays a small amount of money to have, and then, of course, which they made up in seconds?
34:13 Speaker 04 I'm a big believer in bottom-up change. That's obviously a top-down change, is big government coming in. The government is not going to do anything. It takes consumers coming together to make a real change, in my opinion.
34:24 Speaker 02 What regulation from the government would you like to see?
34:27 Speaker 04 I think you should have, like, massive fines, like, $10,000 per consumer for data breaches, automatically applied, things like that.
34:35 Speaker 02 Right. I wanted $50 billion in the FTC. What do you think? I think that was just like...
34:39 Speaker 04 I think that's a discount.
34:40 Speaker 02 Don't you think? You think that's not enough?
34:42 Speaker 04 That's, yeah, I mean...
34:43 Speaker 02 $50 billion? They'd be like, what? Wait a minute.
34:46 Speaker 04 I think it has to truly ruin these companies, yeah.
34:49 Speaker 02 Yeah, yeah. It's a lot of money. So one is disincentives to do the things.
34:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
34:53 Speaker 02 What about the, an idea of people investing in things that do? Because there is a point where I think consumers are going to control, take back... As they did with entertainment in a lot of ways. Entertainment held people hostage. You had to buy 12 songs on an album. You had to see this movie when. You had to sit down at this point. And they had total control over your entertainment watching. And I think people seized, first illegally and then quite legally.
35:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, in the UK, we have this new laws coming out. I think throughout Europe called PSD2, which means that all your financial data is yours and every company holding it has to create APIs. I think we need similar stuff in the US, data portability.
35:30 Speaker 02 And what about the idea, not just data portability, but the idea that your data is yours?
35:36 Speaker 04 I think so. I think if someone is making money off of it, then they should give you a royalty at least.
35:41 Speaker 02 I agree, a vig, right?
35:42 Speaker 04 Yeah.
35:42 Speaker 02 Or something like that. And why doesn't that take hold? Because they want all the money for themselves. Besides, they're greedy.
35:47 Speaker 04 Yeah, there's a whole black market where you can just buy email addresses and things. It's really terrible.
35:53 Speaker 02 So when you're thinking about, you know, doing these kind of things, you're exactly, the reason I did want to talk to you is because one of the things we're talking about, I kind of want to appeal to these companies to do it for the right reason. And then I'm like, one of the reasons for the breakup, for example, if you break up YouTube or Google, or if you break up into three people, whatever you do, whatever you take off of Facebook. The next morning, YouTube's got to be saying, you know what, maybe, or there's room for someone else to say, I'm going to create a video service that actually protects kids. I'm going to create a video, a search service that doesn't track you as much. I'm going to create, like, you get in the mentality of choice so that you appeal to something that people want that they didn't know they wanted.
36:33 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think that for the big corporations, it will take them competing with each other to make this happen. So with the new iPhone update, the sign in with Apple.
36:43 Speaker 02 Yeah, what do you think of that?
36:44 Speaker 04 I think I'm split. On the one hand, it's very anti-competitive. On the other hand-
36:48 Speaker 02 Because why, why?
36:49 Speaker 04 Because you're locking people into the Apple ecosystem. And Android is a great system as well. But on the other hand, forcing developers to implement privacy changes is great. And Google and Facebook, I'm sure they really hate the whole policy.
37:03 Speaker 02 Oh, yeah, they hate it. Which is, I mean, I think it's good.
37:06 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's great.
37:07 Speaker 02 When they start complaining to me, the billionaires start kvetching about their poor lives. It's always a plus for me. But in terms of entrepreneurs, and I'm not saying for good, because it should be a financially lucrative thing. How do you look at this as a business? You're not doing this just because you're a nice guy and want to get people out of- Parking tickets.
37:25 Speaker 04 I think that creating an amazing service will ultimately be a great business opportunity. And if your incentives are aligned with your customers, I think that's the most important thing. For us, our subscription only starts if people save money.
37:37 Speaker 02 Right.
37:37 Speaker 04 So our thing is, how can we save the money or get them success as quickly as possible? That's how businesses should be thinking. With Facebook, the customer of Facebook is the advertiser, not the user.
37:46 Speaker 02 Yes, yes, we realize that. But, and lastly, for you, when you're thinking about being an entrepreneur and raising money, it's quite a frothy environment right now. Capital is everywhere.
37:56 Speaker 04 Yeah.
37:57 Speaker 02 I always use the expression, there's not enough rat holes to shove the money down. What is that like as an entrepreneur right now? There's a lot of entrepreneurs are getting too many rights, for example, complete control over the company, stock. Like, you look at the WeWork IPO and you say, oh, my God. Like, that's sort of the ultimate in like, complete investor abuse in some ways.
38:17 Speaker 04 I think they'll all come back to bite them ultimately when the market crashes. So that is, one of the benefits of having like a financial family is that I don't buy into any of this bubble stuff. So I believe in like, long-term success.
38:29 Speaker 02 And so when you're going out as an entrepreneur right now, what is the feeling in the market that you, that you think is a problem? And what do you think would be a good thing?
38:37 Speaker 04 There's way too much competition between the firms, and I think you should just focus on the best partner, rather than just getting as much money as possible.
38:45 Speaker 02 Right. And you think about that, oh, you're so normal. It's so lovely to talk to you. Anyway, and lastly, let's finish up with you talking about the concept of where we go from here with the elections. What do we, how do we, like, there's all this stuff stuffed up in the Senate right now, Moscow Mitch, apparently, that's his nickname on Twitter, so I've read, is stopping that. How do you look at those things? What do you, is this is something that you're pushing to change?
39:10 Speaker 03 Well, I'm not directly involved in the legislation. I'm interested in sanctions legislation, freezing their assets. However, I'm interested in everything to do with Russia. And the, and the Russians have not been penalized properly. They have not been punished. And, you know, sort of like that $5 billion FTC fine for Facebook, they will be back. The Russians will be back. And they will be back in any way they can to try to achieve their objectives, which will be very inexpensive for them to do. And I mean, it's remarkable. If you think, I mean, so in, in, in Holland, for example, they were worried about Russian interference in their elections. And they had started to automate their ballots. And what did they do? They went back to paper ballots.
39:51 Speaker 02 Right.
39:51 Speaker 03 And it's been determined, whatever, whether you're Democrat or Republican, it's been determined that Russia interfered with the US election. They interfered with, with social media. And they actually tried to get access to the voting machines.
40:06 Speaker 02 Yes.
40:06 Speaker 03 And so it's illogical and inconceivable that there is not a consensus, 100% consensus, that we need to tighten that up. And the fact that we haven't is, is absolutely shameful. And there will be more interference in the future. And, and the trouble with that is that it could cut any different way.
40:26 Speaker 02 Right.
40:26 Speaker 03 And
40:26 Speaker 02 Yeah, the Russians could decide one week.
40:28 Speaker 03 So let's just say that Trump loses the next election. He'll then say, oh, it was Russian interference and he's not going to accept the result. And so it's an absolutely, you know, the moment that people lose confidence in the democratic system, that's the, the truly terrible third world situation that we'll have to deal with. And that's something that, that will be just inconceivably bad for the future of this country.
40:52 Speaker 02 So what has to happen to sort of block the Russians?
40:54 Speaker 03 Well, I mean, it's, it's pretty straightforward that on the social media side, if someone were to change the rules and say that, you know, you can't have a Twitter account unless you're a person. You don't have to have like, say, who you are. You just have, somebody has to have a, a record that you're like a real person. And then real people can say whatever they want, but like fake people, bots can't. And I would argue that Facebook shouldn't sell political advertising.
41:18 Speaker 02 I would argue the same.
41:19 Speaker 03 I mean, I mean, it's, it's, how much money is enough?
41:23 Speaker 02 Mm hmm.
41:24 Speaker 03 Well, just stop it, you know? And so because anyone can do political advertising.
41:29 Speaker 02 Right.
41:29 Speaker 03 And, and they have, and they do. And then I think that unless there's confidence that in these electronic ballots, just go back to paper ballots. Be done with it.
41:38 Speaker 02 Both, both. Microsoft is proposing both, an encrypted. Digital ballot and which is has a accompanying paper ballot that you have to match up.
41:47 Speaker 03 This is this is not rocket science, but the indigestion of the legislative system and the fact that there like no one's even willing to consider this is in Congress is well, I should say in the Senate, the House actually passed the bill, the Senate didn't.
42:02 Speaker 02 Right, hence Moscow Mitch, but move along.
42:05 Speaker 03 Moscow Mitch, I mean, even some of my young children are like chanting Moscow Mitch. I mean.
42:11 Speaker 02 Do you do that with them? No, kidding.
42:14 Speaker 03 So all that stuff needs to be fixed and it's not being fixed and we're going to all be wondering what what these guys were up to when the results come in in 2020.
42:24 Speaker 02 So what is your what are you focusing in on now?
42:26 Speaker 03 Well, from from my perspective.
42:28 Speaker 02 Protecting the Magnitsky.
42:29 Speaker 03 Well, the Magnitsky Act is protected. From my perspective, there's two things I'm doing. One is to get other countries to pass the Magnitsky Act. We've got the Magnitsky Act passing by the United States. We succeeded in getting a Canadian Magnitsky Act, a British Magnitsky Act, an Estonian, Latvian, and Lithuanian Magnitsky Act. The island of Gibraltar and Jersey have Magnitsky Acts, but the big prize is Europe, the EU. The Russians all travel to south of France, to Sardinia and Italy.
42:56 Speaker 02 They do like those those villas there.
42:58 Speaker 03 The Marbella in Spain, and and they love that stuff. And if we can get an EU Magnitsky Act and those villas will get seized, they won't be able to travel, they'll be stuck, sentenced to life in Russia. And and that will be a huge, huge thing. It's sort of halfway there. The European, some of the good European countries are are pushing it forward. Hungary, which is led by a man named Viktor Orban, who's a buddy of Putin, is trying to stop it. You've got other countries like Italy, where you have Salvini, who is the best friend of Putin, who's also trying to stop it. And so it's.
43:33 Speaker 02 You just sit down, though.
43:34 Speaker 03 It's a struggle. It's a struggle in the EU, but that's our big thing. The other thing which we're trying to do is we figure out who got the money, who got the $230 million from the corruption scheme that my lawyer, Sergey Magnitsky, exposed and was killed over. And we found that money and in going through a lot of different countries, through a lot of different banks. And we are working with law enforcement in 16 different countries to have the bankers prosecuted and the money frozen. For the guys who value money more than human life, those people, when their assets get frozen, get very upset, and that's a good thing.
44:07 Speaker 02 Well, good. All right. Thank you so much, both of you. I love when a son and father do social justice and use the Internet for profit and fun. I really appreciate it. Again, Josh Browder, his company is called Do Not Pay, and I'm going to use it for a couple of things now that I realize I can do that. And Bill is still working on these issues around Russia and their complete abuse of financial systems, the Internet, et cetera. Thank you so much for coming on the show.
44:31 Speaker 03 Thank you.
44:32 Speaker 02 You can follow me on Twitter at Kara Swisher. My executive producer, Erica Anderson, is at Erica America. My producer, Eric Johnson, is at HeyHeyESJ. Bill and Josh, where can people find you online?
44:42 Speaker 03 On Twitter, at Bill Browder.
44:44 Speaker 04 And Twitter, at J Browder1.
44:46 Speaker 02 Okay, great. And I'm going to praise you to see what happens. And then I'll say Strauss VTA to all of them, and, you know, that's what I do.
44:53 Speaker 03 There you go.
44:54 Speaker 02 I was talking to a reporter who was responding to Russian bots, and I actually texted him, like, "Those are Russian bots. Stop talking to them, because they won't respond properly." Or sometimes they do.
45:04 Speaker 03 Oh, they go into long conversations.
45:05 Speaker 02 They can, yeah.
45:06 Speaker 03 They're up all night in St. Petersburg.
45:07 Speaker 02 I know, literally. You can catch them. There's ways to catch them with certain words you can use. Anyway, if you liked this episode, we really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media, Pivot, and Land of the Giants. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor, Joel Robby. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: "She Said" authors Jodi Kantor and Megan Twohey Next Recode Decode: Whistleblower Aid CEO John Tye Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated