Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Facebook’s former security boss Alex Stamos and Twitter co-founder Ev Williams (Live) About this episode Alex Stamos, the former Chief Security Officer at Facebook, and Ev Williams, the co-founder of Twitter and CEO of Medium, talk with Recode's Kara Swisher in these live interviews from the 2019 Collision conference in Toronto, Canada.
In the Stamos interview: Is Facebook misunderstood?; Stamos’ proposed solutions; legitimate candidates vs. the Russians; how to protect ourselves from all election attackers; the weaponization of Facebook’s products; America’s reluctance to regulate; breaking up Facebook and Google; why big companies need to stop rewarding employees with stock; Stamos’ recommendations for Mark Zuckerberg; and is Facebook actually committed to change?
And in the Williams interview: Why he left the board of Twitter; where social media is right now; why his venture firm Obvious Ventures doesn’t invest in social; its investment in Beyond Meat; Williams’ theories of venture investing; the lack of diversity in what companies get venture funding; how techlash has changed Silicon Valley; the many iterations of Medium; would Williams buy established media companies?; and is he worried about the media?
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Give you and your team more time to focus on the work that matters. This is AMEX Corporate, one intelligent platform for company spending. With smart expense management to help capture details, categorize spend, and streamline expense submission and approval, there's less manual work for your team and greater visibility and control for you. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:27 Speaker 01 You could try to find the perfect coffee to water ratio. Or you could press a button. With Keurig, each K-cup pod is precision-measured for a perfectly delicious cup. No effort, no grind, no math required. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
0:53 Speaker 02 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, the editor-at-large of Recode. You may know me as the CIO of Facebook, which stands for Chief Irritating Officer, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today, we're going to play two live interviews I just conducted in Toronto, Canada. I spoke with Facebook's former chief security officer, Alex Stamos, who left the company last year and was deeply involved in the Cambridge Analytica scandal. I also spoke with Twitter co-founder Ev Williams, who's now the CEO of the blogging platform Medium and a partner at Obvious Ventures. These interviews were recorded live onstage at the Collision Conference in Toronto, so let's go there now to hear both of them, starting with Facebook's former chief security officer, Alex Stamos.
1:37 Speaker 02 Hi, everybody. I'm back. So Alex and I know each other really well, and we like to argue with each other about a lot of things. And we were most recently up in Napa Valley at this stunning resort, and all we did, we were in a wine cellar, and we started screaming at each other, essentially. So we're hoping to replicate that here a little bit. So let's talk about some of the...
2:02 Speaker 03 There's a lot less wine, I don't think that's...
2:04 Speaker 02 I'm going to go off from our discussion. One of Alex's contentions, even though he talked a lot, and he's been one of the more forthright people in tech about what happened at Facebook and other places, is that it's misunderstood. So one of your arguments is that Facebook is misunderstood. Is that correct?
2:23 Speaker 03 What I think is, I think there's a lot of directionally correct criticism where the details are wrong.
2:29 Speaker 02 Alright, so directionally correct, they ruined democracy and...
2:33 Speaker 03 No, well, so, no, I don't think Facebook has ruined democracy. So I think there's a couple of things going on here. One, there's a whole class of tech criticism that is actually criticism of other people, right? Like, yo, the saying, "Hell is other people." Facebook is other people, right? And when you talk about anti-vaxxers and crazy parents today recommending bleach, this is the collective decisions of millions or billions of people when you give them a freedom they never had before. Now, that doesn't mean the company doesn't have responsibility, but you, I think one of the problems is we're not teasing apart what the companies are doing actively and what kind of societal issues have been unleashed by the fact that we have gone rid of the information gatekeepers.
3:17 Speaker 03 And I think that's one of the core disagreements between the valley overall and the media, is sometimes for those of us in tech, it feels a little bit like there's a lot of media people who want to go back to the world where 38 middle-aged white guys decide what is the political...
3:32 Speaker 02 No, come on, that's bullshit. That's not true. That's not the case. What you're essentially arguing is, Facebook doesn't kill people, people kill people, right? Or not? It's humanity, essentially.
3:44 Speaker 03 What I'm saying is that people will utilize speech sometimes to do really good things and a lot of times to do bad things. And we've got to think about what responsibility we want the companies to have, because when we give them responsibility, we also give them power. And that's the other thing that I think I disagree, actually, with some of my friends at Facebook, because I think in a lot of ways, Facebook is too powerful. And I'm very afraid of this moment when we are assigning responsibility to half-trillion to trillion-dollar companies with no democratic accountability and no limits to that power, and then asking them to fix societal-wide issues.
4:18 Speaker 02 Let's get first to the beginning of this. I want to talk about some of your fixes, because I think some of them are, we do agree on some of them. So the misunderstood part is, directionally, it was correct. So what direction was it correct and what has been incorrect?
4:29 Speaker 03 Okay, so a great example of something that I'm still really active on, so a little pitch, my colleagues and I at Stanford are releasing a report on June 6 about what to do after the Mueller report on election security. And one of our big recommendations is both for regulation from Congress and self-regulation from the tech companies to really expand the definition of political advertising and to reduce the ability to use targeted ads against individuals. So, the direction of allowing people to use hyper-targeting to manipulate societies, absolutely a correct
5:01 Speaker 02 Criticism.
5:02 Speaker 03 Criticism, issue with tech, something that needs to be fixed.
5:04 Speaker 02 Direct targeting of people, this ability to target people in unprecedented ways and presumably manipulate them.
5:11 Speaker 03 Right, right. Whether or not it's Russians or not, it's just a bad thing. It is a bad thing that we are now, the truth is that this has been a problem for a while. The 2012 election where Obama's team totally kicked the butt of the Republicans online, that is probably the first US election that was quote-unquote "thrown by Facebook," that was at least significantly affected by online advertising. But, most people in the media were okay with the outcome, so they didn't get pissed about
5:35 Speaker 02 it. Or didn't know it.
5:37 Speaker 03 Or they didn't know about it. I don't know. It was pretty well-covered. I saw the Obama tech team give a big interview at an Amazon Web Services conference where they talked about how much data they were pulling from Facebook and how finely they were targeting the ads. And so, they did nothing, everything that is complained about in Cambridge Analytica really happened in 2012.
5:53 Speaker 02 There's a difference when you have Obama team and a group of Russians in St. Petersburg manipulating an election, I think
6:00 Speaker 03 Right. Well, yes and no, I mean, I would say
6:02 Speaker 02 Yes and no?
6:03 Speaker 03 There's a difference there, but the problem is that the actual most effective use of Facebook to manipulate people in 2016 was almost certainly the core Trump campaign and a variety of RNC-related groups. It wasn't the Russians themselves. The biggest thing the Russians did was the hacking leak campaign, for which the actual conduit of that was the mass media. The fact that the media covered the Podesta leaks and the DNC leaks and changed the way it covered Hillary around her emails based upon the Russian hacking. If you look at just from a size perspective, both from an organic and an advertised content, the Internet Research Agency output pales in comparison to the amount of money spent. And the quality of the targeted ...by the Trump campaign itself and by a variety of Republican groups.
6:42 Speaker 02 All right, so targeted advertising is directionally a problem. What about the involvement of the Russians? Because I've just been spending a lot of time in Washington. Most intelligence people feel like it's increased exponentially.
6:53 Speaker 03 Oh, yeah.
6:54 Speaker 02 Not just at Facebook, but on our electric grids, telephone systems, all kinds of things.
6:58 Speaker 03 Right, I mean, we are entering a very, very scary period, right? For a couple of reasons. One, the Russian playbook for 2016 is out there. It is not that technically difficult to hack the email of a couple of grandfathers and release the contents, nor is it that difficult to build a team of people that basically are, you know, edgelords, pushing memes all day and then doing a little bit of targeted advertising.
7:22 Speaker 02 Right.
7:22 Speaker 03 So what I expect is that the Russian playbook is going to be executed inside the United States by domestic groups, in which case, some of it, other than the hacking, is not illegal. All the Russian internet agency stuff, if done by a group hired by an American billionaire and they're careful around existing--
7:38 Speaker 02 A Russian billionaire.
7:39 Speaker 03 --law. No, an American. Like, if you had an American, you know, the Koch brothers, or Sheldon Adelson, or George Soros, or, you know, pick your billionaire. You know, Reid Hoffman got kind of caught paying for a company to do some of this stuff on the Democratic side. My real fear is in 2020, it is going to be the battle of the billionaires, of secret groups working for people aligned on both sides, who are trying to manipulate us at scale online. And one of the hard parts is, there's a difficult-- it's very difficult to draw the line about what's acceptable political speech, especially in the United States where Citizens United gives these guys almost no legal barriers at all. And then how do we tell the companies we want them to stop it? Because it's easy to say we want to stop Russians, right? Like, that's an easy rule to write.
8:20 Speaker 03 It's a lot harder to say we want to stop some kind of super PAC that is secretly manipulating people at scale, especially if what they're doing might violate some of Facebook's Terms of Service, but don't violate federal law.
8:32 Speaker 02 Because of Citizens United.
8:33 Speaker 03 Because they're citizens, yeah.
8:34 Speaker 02 So what would be the solution? So you have the billionaires, the attack of the billionaires on the election. You have influence by the Russians, who will continue to do it because it works, presumably. Other countries-- China, Iran, others.
8:49 Speaker 03 Right. I think we'll see less China in the West. The Taiwanese election in January of 2020, the PRC is going to be all over that.
8:57 Speaker 02 Right, and in India, which is happening now.
8:58 Speaker 03 India, so India, the election's over, the counting is happening right now. India is a fascinating issue because most of the disinformation is driven by domestic actors. And they don't, and they're doing it on WhatsApp. It's actually the interesting, WhatsApp is the exception that proves that some of the kind of dumb criticism about Facebook and algorithms is poorly built because WhatsApp has no algorithmic ranking, it has a huge amount of privacy for people, and yet there's a disinformation problem because the problem is people. And in this case, in India, you have the ability to enlist hundreds of thousands of people to push propaganda on behalf of your political party.
9:31 Speaker 02 All right, so the problem is people, which you said again, but they've been armed with tools that are unprecedented and possibly not controlled, so would you, would you argue with me and say that, I have said this, I think you know this, that I felt like these companies have weaponized everything and amplified it at the same time? It's sort of like going from a gun that shoots six bullets to a machine, you know, a semi-automatic machine gun. How do you look at, that's how I look at it.
9:59 Speaker 03 Well, I like your use of the term amplification, because I think one of the things we start to forget is that these companies are actually many products at once. If you take just the Facebook product, the big blue app, you could decompose it into 10 or 12 different applications that have different levels of amplification. And at the top of, I use on a chart, an inverted pyramid for this, the top of that inverted pyramid is advertising and recommendation engines. And so I think that's where you start, because that's where the most risk is. And there's also, I think, the less, the least amount of free expression concern when you block somebody's access to advertising. And so if we're going to start from a regulatory, both self-regulatory and industrial, and you know, federal regulatory perspective, you start at the top there of regulating political
10:42 Speaker 03 ads, we have a bunch of detailed recommendations in this report that's coming out, but we're going to talk about how we would expand the Honest Ads Act, the kind of transparency requirements. There's been a bunch of transparency changes, but they're totally voluntary, so these companies can just drop them at any moment.
10:55 Speaker 02 So a bill, I mean, this is Amy Klobuchar's bill.
10:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:01 Speaker 02 Both here and elsewhere in the globe, not just in the United States.
11:05 Speaker 03 Yes, and well, and actually, I mean, the real game in town seems to be other countries. It seems to be post, after the Christchurch shooting, the most interesting regulatory moves have all been in the non-US Anglophone countries.
11:17 Speaker 02 Right.
11:17 Speaker 03 Australia, New Zealand, Canada. Here in Canada, there's lots of discussion about regulation. And because of the lack of a First Amendment parliamentary systems where you have kind of an implied constitution, but no constitutional right to free speech, these countries can move much more quickly than the United States can. And so my proposal would be, I think the US should lead on this. And so we should have a US, the US should lead on regulating ads. We should have a US federal privacy law. Our reluctance to play in this space has opened the door for other countries to regulate in a way that is, in some cases, not helpful. And in this case, maybe we could set a standard that becomes international standard.
11:53 Speaker 02 Would it? Would it? Because they don't have the same.
11:57 Speaker 03 I think so. I mean, I think what would happen if the US came up with a broader definition of political ads, and then came up with requirements around who you have to be to run them, what kind of transparency is provided, and how much microtargeting can happen, I do think that would encourage a number of other countries to adopt the same standards, if only because it is much more likely they will be enforced.
12:19 Speaker 02 But the US just decided not to join the online extremism proposal from Jacinda Ardern.
12:25 Speaker 03 Yes, that's a problem. And so I think that's a different issue than online ads. I think on the content moderation extremism, the United States is out of the game, partially because of the First Amendment, partially because of the Trump administration is never going to do anything that undercuts their, you know, it's pretty clear that one of their 2020 strategies is to build a huge amount of kind of cultural dislocation among their supporters based upon saying that internet companies are suppressing them, right?
12:51 Speaker 02 Right.
12:52 Speaker 03 Conservatives control Fox News, they have a huge online ecosystem.
12:55 Speaker 02 So the Russian strategy, I like to call it.
12:57 Speaker 03 I'm not sure that's the Russian strategy, but they, I mean.
13:00 Speaker 02 Well, creating discord, dislocation, feelings.
13:02 Speaker 03 Yeah, and creating the idea that you're a suppressed minority, right?
13:06 Speaker 02 Right.
13:06 Speaker 03 Even if you control two branches of government and a huge media ecosystem. And so there's no way they're going to sign up for Christchurch or anything else that could possibly undercut the argument that Trump supporters are the suppressed group, that there's any kind of moderation that means anything.
13:21 Speaker 02 We're here with Facebook's former chief security officer, Alex Stamos. We're going to take a quick break now, but we'll be back after this.
13:29 Speaker 04 How about a latte?
13:30 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
13:31 Speaker 04 Vanilla?
13:32 Speaker 01 Caramel?
13:32 Speaker 04 Blueberry?
13:33 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor, or give everyone what they want.
13:39 Speaker 01 With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee. No effort, no grind, no settling. Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
13:55 Speaker 05 Bonjour, compadre. It's the...
13:59 Speaker 05 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities, like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
14:26 Speaker 02 All right, so privacy bills...
14:28 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:28 Speaker 02 Something with fines. What about fines?
14:32 Speaker 03 On privacy bills?
14:34 Speaker 02 No, not fines. So with fines by government agencies all around the world.
14:38 Speaker 03 Yeah, I mean, one of the interesting problems we have in the US is we don't have a competent privacy regulator that translates rules into... So, one, we don't really have privacy laws, right? So the FTC kind of comes up with... They move the goalposts, and they say you have to follow these goalposts, and then there's not a lot of interpretation of what that actually means technically. And this is a problem you see a lot in Europe because European GDPR is being interpreted by 28 different data protection authorities, so you have 28 goalposts you're trying to shoot through. I think in the US, we can do a better job on if we had an organization that could fine without going to court, right? And that's what some of these other countries do have, like the Irish, is they have organizations that can that can do things before they go nuclear. Right now, the FTC's options are
15:22 Speaker 03 they threaten to go nuclear, and then that allows them to have a negotiation. And if that doesn't work out, they have to go to court and it's a five-year fight.
15:30 Speaker 02 And then antitrust.
15:32 Speaker 03 Antitrust. So I think there are legitimate antitrust arguments for breaking up Facebook and breaking YouTube up from Google. Those arguments, legitimate arguments, are the ones on competition policy, right? If you want to argue that these companies have reduced competition through their incredible ability to predict the future, to use their cash reserves to buy companies and to take out competition, I think that's a legitimate argument. Breaking up the companies does not solve the fundamental issues. You can't solve climate change by breaking up ExxonMobil and making 10 ExxonMobil's, right? You have to address the underlying issues. And so, I think there's a lot of excitement for antitrust because it kind of feels good to be like, "Oh, I hate this company, so let's break it up." Having three companies that have the same fundamental problems doesn't make anything better.
16:15 Speaker 02 So what is the, what is the solution? You've had a couple that are interesting.
16:19 Speaker 03 Right, so, I mean, so if Mark Zuckerberg called me, which he doesn't, and asked my advice on this, I would say a couple of things. I think Facebook needs to have an internal revolution on the culture of how products are built. And there's actually a model for this, which was Microsoft 2002, in which Microsoft was facing kind of the same level of pushback on core information security issues, and they completely changed how the product works. So he directionally has some ideas on that, but I think it's hard without making significant leadership changes to do that. And so, if I was Mark, my suggestion would be, especially because there's all this, the antitrust stuff is a lot very personalized on him. He should hire himself-
17:00 Speaker 02 Well, it's personalized on him because he controls the company completely.
17:02 Speaker 03 Because he controls the company, right. Because there is a legitimate argument that he has too much power. He needs to give up some of that power. And if I was him, I would go hire a new CEO for the company. He's already acting as the chief product officer with Chris Cox gone. That's where his passion is. He should hire a CEO that can help signal both internally and externally that the culture has to change. And, I mean, my recommendation, I'm not a recruiter, but if I can get 20% of this guy's salary in the first year, that would be fantastic. My recommendation would be Brad Smith from Microsoft, but some adult who has gone through this before at another company. And then the second, I think, big thing I would do-
17:37 Speaker 02 Change the management structure.
17:39 Speaker 03 Change the management structure, yeah. To have not the technologist who owns product be at the top. I think it is important to have a manager at the top.
17:46 Speaker 02 Should you go a step further and not allow these tech companies to have this kind of stock where they have complete kingship over it?
17:54 Speaker 03 So this is where I disagree, because I worked for a tech company that had an activist investor that cared mostly about what Wall Street thinks.
18:01 Speaker 02 Well, Yahoo, yes.
18:02 Speaker 03 At Yahoo.
18:02 Speaker 02 But that came at the end.
18:04 Speaker 03 Right, well, yeah, so Yahoo was dying for 10 years. I mean, there was, there was a lot of problems at Yahoo, but- I actually think the companies are too beholden to Wall Street. And so the second big thing I would change is they need to get rid of stock compensation at big public companies.
18:17 Speaker 02 Okay.
18:18 Speaker 03 So like 80 something percent of my compensation at Facebook was set by Wall Street. And so this is a crazy world. If the CEO comes to you and says, "You've done a really poor job of making our products good for the world. I am very upset with you. Congratulations, you got a raise because our stock went up." Right? Allowing, using RSU's as the main form of compensation for executives takes away any kind of discretion from, from the CEO to motivate people with money. And I think that's a fundamental issue in Silicon Valley. It's for startups, stock makes sense because people are taking a risk. If you work for a huge profitable company, they already have to fully expense it. Both, there's no tax benefit. You're paying full marginal tax rates on, on stock compensation. You should be bonusing people.
19:03 Speaker 03 You can pay them as much, but the bonuses should be based upon a basket of metrics that measure whether you're doing good long-term things for the world, not based upon whether Wall Street liked your recent numbers. Because Wall Street doesn't give a crap of whether tax good.
19:15 Speaker 02 Because it would give you incentives to do the worst thing, presumably.
19:17 Speaker 03 Right. And because, what kind of mixed message is it to say we're pivoting the company to care about long-term issues, yet most of your compensation is based upon what happens right after the quarterly numbers are released? I mean, Facebook's stock is way back up.
19:31 Speaker 02 It is.
19:32 Speaker 03 And it's not because any fundamental things were fixed, it's because they're making more money than ever. And so like, how do you manage a team when, when you can't control what you're paying people?
19:39 Speaker 02 Do you think, we just have a few more minutes. Do you think they actually are committed to fixing things at Facebook? Or is it just a lot of talk?
19:47 Speaker 03 I mean, I, I do think Mark is serious that he really cares about what people remember him for and what this company does. I think that one of the fundamental issues is that the metrics the company has been measuring to manage tens of thousands of people that make decisions have been the wrong ones. And that is a hard thing to change. And that's why I'm saying like, changing out leadership on the product side might be necessary to help also signal that like, the things we used to measure around engagement, around time used, time spent, all that kind of stuff, that's not what we care about anymore.
20:17 Speaker 02 All right, last question. If you were running Facebook, do they call you? Do they talk to you?
20:22 Speaker 03 Um, I talk to lower down people who are actually working on these problems.
20:25 Speaker 02 Okay, but they don't like...
20:26 Speaker 03 At the top?
20:27 Speaker 02 Yeah.
20:28 Speaker 03 We're not close.
20:29 Speaker 02 They're not close. If you were running Facebook right now in the product area, give me, we've got only two seconds to do this, give me three or four things you think have to be done to make the product healthier for humanity.
20:44 Speaker 03 So I agree with some of the directional stuff of moving the company towards smaller groups, moving it towards ephemerality, moving it towards encryption. Encryption, end-to-end encryption, gives you ability to mathematically guarantee people's privacy that allows you to put data out of your reach and out of the reach of your advertising team and anybody who wants to use it. The thing that has to happen with that is they have to do some fundamental rethinking of how they do safety in this situation, which, the problem is, there's a future in which Facebook encrypts everything, everything moves to small groups. A lot of these problems go away from the press because the press doesn't see it anymore, but they actually exist and the societal impact is still bad. And I think that is, that is a very seductive future for the company and the company has to resist that and they have to work on...
21:29 Speaker 03 Well, I think, I believe in encryption and privacy, but we have to balance the privacy responsibility with the safety responsibility and there is lots of good technical work we can do to do better on both of those. I would like to see them spend the next year doing that.
21:41 Speaker 02 Anything else?
21:43 Speaker 03 Uh, no. Great to be here. Thanks for...
21:44 Speaker 02 No more "I'm sorry, Torres," right? You wouldn't stop saying...
21:48 Speaker 03 Oh, well, I mean, the other big thing is I think they just need to be honest about what they can and can't do. One of the, the big problems with the company is they, they make these content decisions based upon external pressure and trying to react to immediate issues and they don't base it upon kind of a constitution of why does Facebook do certain things? And the truth is, there should be limits to the company's power. And I think it would be better for the company to say, "There are certain things we are not going to do, even if we get yelled at a lot by the New York Times," and explain to the media...
22:17 Speaker 02 Or Ted Cruz, or...
22:18 Speaker 03 Or Ted Cruz, right, exactly.
22:20 Speaker 02 Or Donald Trump.
22:20 Speaker 03 Because, because what's happened is they've vacillated back and forth. And so, it's, um, to use a recent metaphor, there's a little bit of a James Harden action going on here of working the refs, right? Of, they have indicated as the refs that they can be worked, that they will give you the call if you flop, and so everybody's flopping now. And that's, that's not good. For democracy, for these decisions to be made in a secret conference room based upon external pressure. It needs to be made with a public discussion based upon really core fundamental values of what they want to do. And I don't understand what those are. I mean, I worked there. I don't understand what is the goal of Facebook's content moderation. Is it to keep people safe? Is it to help make the product better for society? Is it to help the community? They haven't explained like what is the fundamental goal?
23:05 Speaker 03 And they haven't said this is the limit that we will not go past. And that is a critical thing they need.
23:08 Speaker 02 I'm going to give you a pro tip. Maybe they haven't thought about it.
23:12 Speaker 03 Yeah, it's possible.
23:13 Speaker 02 Anyway, thank you, Alex Stamos.
23:14 Speaker 03 Thanks, sir.
23:17 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Alex Stamos for joining me on stage. We're going to take another break now, but we'll be back after this with Medium CEO Ev Williams.
23:25 Speaker 04 How about a latte?
23:26 Speaker 01 Maybe dark roast?
23:28 Speaker 04 Vanilla?
23:28 Speaker 01 Caramel?
23:29 Speaker 04 Blueberry?
23:30 Speaker 01 You could get them to agree on one flavor or give everyone what they want. With Keurig, there's over 500 K-Cup Pod varieties of fresh, flavorful coffee.
23:42 Speaker 01 No effort, no grind, no settling.
23:47 Speaker 01 Great coffee without the grind. Keurig.
23:52 Speaker 05 Bonjour, compadre. It's the
23:56 Speaker 05 How do I negotiate so many great travel deals? My greatest gadget, the Priceline app. It's got hotel deals, flight deals, rental car deals, all of those deals in a bundle. Deals, game day deals, concert trip deals. No one deals more deals than Priceline. Hold your horses, there's more. The app lets you filter hotels by neighborhood, vibe, star level, and amenities like pools and spas and beachfronts. Wait, I'm not done. Stop cutting me off.
24:22 Speaker 02 We're here with Ev, who I've known for forever.
24:25 Speaker 06 Seems like it.
24:25 Speaker 02 Seems like it. And I want to talk about a lot of things. But let's start, first of all, it's called life after Twitter, which you've had quite a life after Twitter. You left the board this year.
24:37 Speaker 06 Yeah, a couple of months ago.
24:38 Speaker 02 Can you talk about a little bit why you did that?
24:42 Speaker 06 Yeah, it's not very dramatic. I've been on the board since there was a board, so approximately 12, 13 years. And
24:51 Speaker 06 And only on the board for the last 10 or so, so it's, or however, nine.
24:56 Speaker 02 Mm-hmm.
24:56 Speaker 06 So, I stayed on the board as long as I thought I could be helpful, mostly. And the company is a really good place now compared to some of the time it's been before. And I just felt like I want to spend my time on energy, on other things.
25:14 Speaker 02 Was it overwhelming for you, like, the issues you all faced there around hate, around President Trump, around, mostly President Trump, really?
25:22 Speaker 06 Well, being on the board is not being at the company.
25:26 Speaker 02 Right.
25:27 Speaker 06 And so, while it's called life after Twitter, I kind of laugh because it's kind of been life after Twitter for me for a long time.
25:34 Speaker 02 Yes.
25:34 Speaker 06 And I'll always be associated with the company, always be rooting for it. Still a shareholder of the company. So there's, certain part of my, my year is no longer spent in Twitter board meetings, but I've been focusing my time on other things for a long time.
25:49 Speaker 02 All right, I want to get to the things you're doing, but what do you, where do you think it is right now as, as a medium, the whole social media space? It's obviously been under attack quite heavily. I don't assume you're going to write a Chris Hughes-like document for the New York Times, correct?
26:03 Speaker 06 No.
26:04 Speaker 02 Calling Jack Un-American or anything like that?
26:06 Speaker 06 No. Sorry, I didn't hear the question.
26:08 Speaker 02 Where do you think social media is right now?
26:10 Speaker 06 Where do I think it is?
26:11 Speaker 02 And what it needs to do to fix itself?
26:12 Speaker 06 I mean, it's, it's in the, you know, the bleakness of, of figuring out what, where, where it needs to go. I think with the, I don't have any answers as to how we get out of the current situation, but I think we, there's a tendency to say, oh, social media is terrible and forget all the great things about it, which I still believe are true. And I believe the terrible things are true because social media is humanity. And it amplifies, unfortunately, amplifies a lot of bad aspects of humanity. It's very powerful at that, and very powerful at connecting people with terrible ideas
26:54 Speaker 06 and amplifying those and making them seem like they're good ideas. On the other hand, it does the opposite. And I think there is a better version of social media to be invented, and I don't know if that will happen. Incrementally, because there's lots of smart people trying to evolve these systems at these massive companies, or if it will happen with just completely new paradigms and new ideas that come along. I'm confident it will remain around, but I think also people's relationship and sort of the novelty and some of the excitement that brought us to is wearing off. It's like a sugar high. And now we're like, oh, do we need this in our life in the same way?
27:36 Speaker 02 Right. And do you imagine, let's get to new companies, because you're an investor with Obvious Ventures. You're not really investing in that space.
27:44 Speaker 06 We don't really, no.
27:45 Speaker 02 Why is that?
27:46 Speaker 06 It's not that we wouldn't, but at Obvious Ventures, we focus on what we call world positive investing, which is things that we think address big systemic problems we face as a society. We haven't seen something come along, and we don't do actually very many internet or media things. We do a little bit, but we do things more in health and wellness and sustainability.
28:07 Speaker 02 World positive, that's a very techie word. What does that mean?
28:11 Speaker 06 Well, it's just our term before things like, we have a lens. We're not an impact investor, we're a for-profit investor because that doesn't compromise on financial returns, because, but we're very genuinely focused on things that we think are big ideas and big solutions.
28:30 Speaker 02 Why don't you want to call it impact investing? Because that's what it's called, I mean.
28:34 Speaker 06 Impact investing can be great, but impact investing historically is a view that we will take a lesser financial return in order to have some sort of other impact. And which, there's investments that make sense for that. Our view is that the biggest companies that scale the most are not going to have, they're going to have big returns. And so rather than say, we're going to compromise in returns, we feel like that can be a failure mode and say like, actually, it's not that healthy of a company or it doesn't have great product-market fit. We're saying, no, it has to be, it has to be great. So an example. Well, one of our companies is Beyond Meat.
29:11 Speaker 02 Which you've done really well on.
29:12 Speaker 06 Which has done phenomenal. And it's not an impact investment. It's a phenomenally lucrative, profitable investment that addresses this massive need of lowering our carbon footprint when it comes to the meat.
29:27 Speaker 02 What's really interesting is that Beyond Meat is doing great in the stock market. And Uber is tanking and Lyft is tanking.
29:33 Speaker 06 I wouldn't have predicted that necessarily a few years ago.
29:35 Speaker 02 So talk about how you got into this, the Beyond Meat. Because there's also Impossible Foods. There's a lot of food tech investing, I guess, if you want.
29:44 Speaker 06 Beyond Meat was one of the first investments we did. We actually rolled it into Obvious Ventures. Biz and I, you know, my longtime partner Biz was a vegan for a long time. Kleiner Perkins did the Series A in Beyond Meat. I think because they knew he's a vegan. And they're like, hey, are you interested in this company? And so he brought it to us. And we were very excited about it. We love the products. I've been vegan and pescatarian for a long time.
30:11 Speaker 02 Wait, which one are you?
30:12 Speaker 06 I was vegan, now I'm pescatarian.
30:14 Speaker 02 Okay.
30:15 Speaker 06 I haven't eaten a land animal for a very long time. So I enjoyed the products. Biz enjoyed the products.
30:21 Speaker 02 You just draw the line at fish?
30:22 Speaker 06 I draw the line at fish.
30:24 Speaker 02 All right, okay.
30:24 Speaker 06 Yeah. And Ethan Brown, the CEO and founder of Beyond Meat, is just an incredible human. And so we backed him fairly early on.
30:32 Speaker 02 And at the time you did it, there wasn't a lot of people interested in that sector. And there was investments, but it was more on the research side. A lot of the research stuff. And this is a small market. What did you hope? I'll get to the stock market thing. Why did you go public with it? And what did you hope for? That it would be in every supermarket? Or you're aiming at people who eat meat?
30:52 Speaker 06 Yeah, I mean, the goal with it, and the company's been around for a few years. And the goal with it was always to penetrate the meat market. And I mean that in the actual, the grocery store sense. And to really, that's a massive trillion dollar market that we thought there's a better alternative to. So we didn't have the plan for that. Ethan and his team had the plan. But it's going well so far.
31:17 Speaker 02 So where do you imagine? Like, there's a world, I guess it would be world positive. How much pushback have you had from? Meat companies, I know they don't want you to call it meat, because just the way the milk distributors don't want oat milk to be called oat milk, or cashew milk, or...
31:33 Speaker 06 I think some of them see it as an opportunity, and some of them see it as a threat, I would imagine.
31:37 Speaker 02 Tyson is in it, right?
31:38 Speaker 06 Tyson was actually a big investor and shareholder, and they got out just before the IPO.
31:42 Speaker 02 Because they're making their own version.
31:43 Speaker 06 Yeah, I would assume any meat company, I mean, the response to the Beyond Meat IPO, which has been so gratifying, is that people are paying attention to this plant protein company that most people wouldn't have predicted would make such a big blip, and I think it's a lot of people seeing the potential.
32:00 Speaker 02 And in terms of when you think about these world positing, talk about what your theories are of venture investing, because that's changed a lot. You know, you have the advent of giant investors like SoftBank, which of course has gotten a bath in the Uber investment. How do you look at investing then as a venture? How do you distinguish yourself?
32:19 Speaker 06 So ours, we kind of play a different game, I think, than most Silicon Valley investors. And first of all, it's our lens of filtering out a lot of things that could be great investments, but if we don't think they really are going to address some need for society, we'll say, that's okay, there's lots of others we'll focus on, which eliminates most of enterprise software. And then also, the message that entrepreneurs really appreciate is that we are mission-aligned, and we will support an entrepreneur who is mission-focused, which people come to us because they really like hearing that, because as an entrepreneur, you can be, and I've been in this position, where you're aligned with your investors in terms of wanting to build
33:03 Speaker 06 something really big, but you can get misaligned in terms of really the purpose of that thing.
33:09 Speaker 02 So what does that bring you to? What areas are you excited about in that regard?
33:12 Speaker 06 So we do a lot of stuff in sustainability, from solar and solar software. We have, we're investors in Proterra, the electric bus company. There's some other, another exit we just had was Ollie, which was a supplement company. And so we tend to do things that are outside of the traditional Silicon Valley world that I know, which of course Silicon Valley is expanding greatly in terms of what they invest in, but it's not a lot of software or media.
33:46 Speaker 02 All right, I'm gonna get to medium in a second, but when you think about venture, I just interviewed Mark Cuban and Steve Case, and they were talking about the efforts they're making to get all around the world, to try to get more talent from elsewhere. Right now, 80% of venture capital goes to three states, and most of it to California, and most of it to Silicon Valley, continues to be all white, all male, not very geographically diverse, not very globally diverse. Why does that continue, from your perspective?
34:19 Speaker 06 I think it's habit. It's definitely not the lack of viable investments that are outside the geography or demographics of that traditional set. And so, we aren't internationally focused, and one thing is that so much of the money is in Silicon Valley, and the firms are there because they come out of, you know, it's historic. And it is hard to invest in other places where you're not, there's just a time and the day problem. We have a couple of investments in Europe, but not a lot, and we have some in New York and throughout the country. But part of that, I certainly celebrate expanding the ethos and the formula of Silicon
35:04 Speaker 06 Valley to other places, but it's pretty massive and there's this perpetuating cycle. People come out of companies and they go back in and they invest in their friends.
35:13 Speaker 02 I get that, but why doesn't it happen? You're a very well-meaning person, you have a broad attitude toward diversity, but most people just talk about it and nothing happens in that regard. It seems like you're, one, missing the boat, meaning there's lots of investments you're missing, and, two, perpetuating something like this is not an excuse for doing that.
35:34 Speaker 06 Yeah, I agree. I don't see any excuse for doing it. We try very hard to... Invest, I don't have the data off the top of my head about our portfolio. I know it is something that comes up in every partner meeting and every conversation I'm in about how we both hiring the firm, both women and people from underrepresented backgrounds, and how we get that into our portfolio. And we work on it daily, and my partners are very focused on that.
36:04 Speaker 02 Do you think Silicon Valley has changed in attitude, given this tech clash that's happening?
36:09 Speaker 06 I think it has dramatically. I mean, in my 20 years of building companies in Silicon Valley, the intensity of focus on diversity and inclusion in the last five years is dramatically higher. It's an order of magnitude higher, and it's changing definitely how we invest, how we run companies, how we hire. It's changed all those things, in my experience, and we have a long way to go.
36:32 Speaker 02 Yeah, the numbers still don't bear it out.
36:34 Speaker 06 I totally agree.
36:35 Speaker 02 It's the strangest thing. So, when you think about where the biggest, most interesting innovations are happening, where do you tend towards right now? You're obviously in food tech. There's a lot of mobility stuff going on, and that's not mobile phones. Where do you think the hottest place to look at is? And where do you think the hype, the worst place right now is?
36:57 Speaker 06 Well, I don't spend that much time looking at investments, to tell you the truth. I spend more of my time on Medium, which maybe we should talk about that.
37:04 Speaker 02 Yes, I'm going to talk about that. I'm going to get that right now.
37:06 Speaker 06 But, I mean, I think obviously AI is infiltrating everything we do, and there's some very interesting things. Actually, there's an overlap of AI and material and molecule discovery.
37:20 Speaker 02 Right.
37:20 Speaker 06 Which I'll probably butcher this if I try to even explain it. One of our companies is Zymogen, which is just doing mind-blowing things and inventing new, discovering new materials and new chemicals through AI. And so, that's a field that I barely understand. And I think every time I learn more about it is doing incredible things. There's a number of companies like that.
37:43 Speaker 02 Medium?
37:43 Speaker 06 Yes.
37:44 Speaker 02 What's happening with Medium now? When last we talked, you changed it about 63 times, like, in the way you're looking about it. How do you look at it right now? What do you think of it as?
37:57 Speaker 06 I would argue I have not changed it 63 times, although I do defend my need to change my mind.
38:04 Speaker 02 I don't mind it. I don't care if you change it.
38:06 Speaker 06 We haven't changed that many things about Medium. Medium's been around for about seven years. The entire time it's been an open publishing platform that has grown that entire time. So more people write, more people read. Two years ago, we started building a subscription business on top of that. That's been going very well. And so over the last two years, the main thing we've done is built this premium consumer subscription business on top of the open publishing platform. So it's really a mesh of those two things that allows anyone to publish, have a voice, potentially get paid. We pay thousands of writers from all over the world every week, and that's a growing amount.
38:48 Speaker 06 And then we have a professional editorial team, and then we also work with third-party publishers. So we do all that.
38:55 Speaker 02 Would it be right to say that you've pushed off of the professional stuff more and tended more towards different writers? Has that not worked as well, or what part has worked the best?
39:07 Speaker 06 Everything's growing. The bulk of Medium is still self-published authors.
39:12 Speaker 02 Right.
39:13 Speaker 06 And that's what... And we have our partner program where we pay them through... Most people write on Medium. We don't opt in to get paid. They're looking to find audience. We also have a very growing editorial team that is publishing. The latest thing we've been doing is starting these little publications or mini magazines around a variety of topics. We've been doing that both in-house and through partners like Mark Bittman and Roxane Gay. We just launched something with a couple of weeks ago. And so all of that is working. And it's really the combination of things that are working because it's very clear to me that advertising isn't working, pure advertising for publishing, for quality information.
39:57 Speaker 06 People still want good things to read and to inform their view of the world. And so every publisher that, as you know, is putting up paywalls and subscriptions, and it seems very clear that people aren't going to subscribe to dozens of sites. Just like they don't subscribe to every TV show they watch or every musician. They're going to look for a lot of value under one subscription that's personalized, that's high-quality, that's, I think, ad-free is tremendously.
40:26 Speaker 02 Well, they're doing that in podcasts. They're trying to bring together podcast.
40:30 Speaker 06 They are, and we're much farther along than anyone doing that in podcasts.
40:33 Speaker 02 Do you consider yourself a network, then? And how would you describe yourself as a media company?
40:38 Speaker 06 You could call it a network, and Medium's always been a network. It's really a platform, and the subscription part is a bundle. It's a bundle of thousands of writers, of dozens of publications for one price. Some of that is licensed, by the way, from third-party publishers. So we include New York Times, Financial Times, Bloomberg. A lot of these, just a few stories from them are in there. And so, really, our goal is to build the best content-subscription product that there is.
41:09 Speaker 02 Do you think yourself of buying big media companies? All the others, a lot of Lorraine Powell Jobs, Marc Benioff, obviously Jeff Bezos and others with some money have been purchasing things. There was a rumor you were looking at New York Magazine. Is that true?
41:28 Speaker 06 It's true. There was a rumor about that.
41:30 Speaker 02 Yeah.
41:33 Speaker 06 And I love New York Magazine. I think they do a great job. And, look, I think it is something I've thought about because I think there's a lot of those organizations that do great work, and they need a new model, frankly. And a lot of them are, I think, will be fine, but a lot of them are going through more difficult times. The difference between myself and most of the people you mentioned is if we were to do that, it would plug into the business and build them.
42:03 Speaker 02 So what do you imagine, finishing up, what the modern media company looks like? What's been the thing that you've done and you've thought, ah, that's not the way it should go? What do you think a modern media company looks like? Because you could go and buy old media companies and try to...
42:19 Speaker 06 Yeah, I don't think that's, I think a modern media company, we think, I think the idea of being open to some degree is important, and this is where we're really trying to capture the best of what you get from the internet and from being, from social media in many ways, which is giving a lot of people the chance to be heard, but it's not guaranteed, it's not, it's not just let the machines and, and algorithms and people fight it out for attention, it's really blending openness.
42:49 Speaker 02 So not Twitter, right?
42:50 Speaker 06 Not, not Twitter, and, but it's, it's, we just serve a very different purpose. So the modern media company, if you're, if you're building a publisher today, given the internet, I think it'd be crazy to limit yourself to the people in the building or the people who you, who you know. And so we have the good fortune of getting tens of thousands of people every single day saying, here's my story, here's my idea, here's my perspective, and we curate that, and, and sometimes we, we edit it and we put it in front of more people, and then we also get the benefit of working with people who are well-established. And so a modern media company, I think, taps the world's brains and, and really builds the best.
43:33 Speaker 06 And a big part of what we do in our philosophy is blending humans and, and machines. So we've seen, we've seen the pure open platform, what that gives us in terms of content, and we've seen that the, the traditional world and how that can be limited in terms of scale and efficiency. And so I think the, the next version's gonna blend those things, that's what we're trying to do.
43:56 Speaker 02 And are you positive about media? Because it's still in its long death swoon, which still, they still haven't killed off media, and it's been more popu, reading is more popular, television's more popular.
44:04 Speaker 06 Yeah.
44:05 Speaker 02 Do you, are you worried about media?
44:07 Speaker 06 About media?
44:09 Speaker 02 In general, do you think the changes that are being made, or?
44:11 Speaker 06 I'm very optimistic. I think, I think it's interesting that the written word and publishing, which we're currently focused on, though not limited to, is kind of the last to be, you know, there's, there's time when it was gonna be the death of the music industry. And there's a time, it was never, as I recall, the death of the TV industry, but there's a time when the, when reality TV dominated and that's what we kind of thought the future was. And both those are tremendously better, both as, as businesses and as consumer products. And I think the same thing, for the same reason, can happen with the information we read and nonfiction educational content as well.
44:49 Speaker 02 So you imagine that there will be great media brands not, like, you know, you have Game of Thrones, for example, which just finished, which we're not sure we're going to do after that. But you still are positive that media can morph into this in this noisy, angry...
45:07 Speaker 06 Absolutely. The reason it sucks is because of advertising, full stop. That is the game that we've been playing for 20 years, and it wasn't so bad at first. And now, attention wins, period. The cheapest way you can generate attention, which is the same reason that reality TV dominated. Change the business model, you change the content. To me, people talk about saving publishing or saving news. How about we create something way better? And I think we can do that in the same way other industries do, by changing the incentive structure.
45:36 Speaker 02 So that would make kind of Twitter and Facebook reality television in a weird way, because that's where a lot of people get their news.
45:42 Speaker 06 The reality TV version of the internet will exist in, you know, for a long time, just the reality TV version. I think Facebook and Twitter are distribution systems for content, more than they are content themselves, and social media is a whole nother thing, but I'm talking about publishing and, and even, even when, when people are talking about where they get their news and information, if, most things people read are on other sites that are commercially published and driven by advertising.
46:08 Speaker 02 All right, last question. Do you think you'll go public with Medium?
46:12 Speaker 06 It's too soon to say, but if we do, I would like to go on the long-term stock exchange, another obvious investment.
46:20 Speaker 02 All right. We'll talk about that later. Thank you, Evan.
46:23 Speaker 06 All right. Thanks, Carol.
46:25 Speaker 02 Thanks again to Alex and Ev for joining me onstage, and thanks to you all for listening. You can follow me on Twitter @KaraSwisher. My executive producer Eric Anderson is @EricAmerica. My producer Eric Johnson is at HeyHeyESJ. If you liked this episode, we'd really appreciate it if you shared it with a friend. And make sure to check out our other podcasts, Recode Media and Pivot. Just search for them in your podcasting app of choice. Thanks also to our editor Joel Robbie. Special thanks to Donald Donovan, Zara McGrath, Hugh Gallagher, Eamon Defredes, and Clarissa Shirose. Thank you for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. I'll be back here on Monday. Tune in then.
47:13 Speaker 07 20th Century Studios presents Whale Fall, the most incredible survival thriller of the year.
47:21 Speaker 07 In theaters Friday. To survive the unthinkable, do the impossible. You're gonna become so dangerous that the predators can't help but let you go. Austin Abrams. I'm going home. Josh Brogram. Survivor, survivor. Whale Fall, rated PG-13, maybe inappropriate for children under 13. In theaters Friday. Get tickets now.
Previous Recode Decode: Anand Giridharadas Next Recode Decode: DuckDuckGo CEO Gabe Weinberg Page updated October 13, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated