Pod Insights Decoder Recode Decode: Craigslist founder Craig Newmark About this episode Craig Newmark, the founder of Craigslist and Craig Newmark Philanthropies, talks with Recode's Kara Swisher about his foundation's recent donation of $20 million to the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism. Newmark says the school is advancing good journalism by providing opportunities to people who might not otherwise get them. He also talks about his other philanthropic work, helping veterans and women in tech as well as working with voting rights organizations, calling the 2018 midterms "critical for American democracy." Plus: Why Newmark is optimistic about the future of media in the age of Facebook and Twitter, how Craigslist evolved from an email list into the powerhouse it is today and why he's not interested in selling it or going public.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 Thanks to ZipRecruiter, which is the presenting sponsor of Recode Decode and the smartest way to hire. Staffing tech companies is tricky. From high turnover to rapidly changing skill sets, you really have to stay on your toes. ZipRecruiter knows because they're a tech company, too. So it's no surprise they built a product that uses powerful machine learning algorithms that make finding qualified candidates simple, efficient, and intuitive. If you're hiring, it's time to get smart. Try ZipRecruiter for free right now at ziprecruiter.com/decode. That's ziprecruiter.com/decode.
0:35 Speaker 00 Hi, I'm Kara Swisher, editor-at-large at Recode. You may know me as the subject of countless missed connections on Craigslist, but in my spare time, I talk tech, and you're listening to Recode Decode from the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today in the red chair is Craig Newmark, who I've known for a very long time. He's the founder of Craigslist. He's also the founder of Craig Newmark Philanthropies, which supports a range of causes, including voter protection, veterans, women in tech, and journalism. I wanted to have him on the show this week when I saw that he had just donated $20 million to the SUNY Graduate School of Journalism. Craig, welcome to Recode Decode.
1:08 Speaker 01 Hey, it's a pleasure to be here.
1:09 Speaker 00 And you've never been here. We've got so much to talk about. There's so many issues to talk about with you, and you have such a fascinating career. But this donation is really quite something, and I want to get into it a little later. But first, let's give people who don't know you. I mean, your name is well-known, Craigslist is. Let's talk a little bit about your background, how you got to where you are, so people will get some sense of your entrepreneurship.
1:28 Speaker 01 Well, I've been thinking a lot recently about what happened, what's made me whatever I am. Part of that is just being a nerd in the classic Dr. Seuss sense. Thick, black glasses taped together. Oh, a plastic pocket protector.
1:46 Speaker 00 You actually had one?
1:47 Speaker 01 I really did. This is all literal. Nerds are literal. And no social skills to speak of. And even now, I'm simulating social skills.
1:57 Speaker 00 OK, good job. You're doing a good job.
1:59 Speaker 01 Back in our version of Sunday School, way back, Mr. and Mrs. Levin, who are my teachers, they taught me the stuff which mattered in a big way as I went through life.
2:12 Speaker 00 Where'd you grow up?
2:13 Speaker 01 This is Morristown, New Jersey. And the deal there at the Jewish Community Center. They helped me understand that I should treat people like I want to be treated.
2:24 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
2:25 Speaker 01 And they also, I think, taught me that I should know when enough is enough.
2:29 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
2:30 Speaker 01 Particularly considering material positions or money.
2:32 Speaker 00 Right.
2:34 Speaker 01 Now, the next big effect in my life, high school history, US history with Mr. Shulsky.
2:41 Speaker 00 Okay.
2:42 Speaker 01 And...
2:43 Speaker 00 Your homage to the teachers.
2:44 Speaker 01 Uh, yeah.
2:45 Speaker 00 Yeah.
2:46 Speaker 01 He bridged, he bridged me into US history and American values. Because another way of saying what the Levens taught me was that, well, our country, you know, is about fairness, opportunity, and respect, or should be.
3:02 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
3:03 Speaker 01 And in history, I learned about that kind of American value.
3:08 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
3:09 Speaker 01 Something we aspire to. I also learned that a trustworthy press is the immune system of democracy, as I like to put it. And I got pretty committed to the Bill of Rights, due process, the Declaration of Independence, and the Constitution. This guy was serious about getting that across to us, and it stuck pretty thoroughly to me.
3:31 Speaker 00 It stuck thoroughly. So you went to school, where did you, you studied computer science, correct?
3:35 Speaker 01 Yeah. In high school, there was, there was an old IBM 1620. It actually did have blinking lights. It, we used punch cards, which, a phrase which may frighten many, but I learned four tran two. Went to school, though, college, Case Tech in Cleveland, got a couple of degrees in computer sciences. That worked out fairly well. I learned a lot. And then from there, I spent 17 years at IBM, to my surprise.
4:02 Speaker 00 Right, right up there, in, up in New York, above New York.
4:05 Speaker 01 Oh, uh, that's, you're thinking of the big machine nation.
4:08 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah.
4:09 Speaker 01 I spent six years first in Boca Raton.
4:11 Speaker 00 Right, oh, on the, on the, on the, Sun Quirk.
4:14 Speaker 01 On the, well, it was on the Series One.
4:16 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
4:17 Speaker 01 But at the end of my time there, I was working with the first PC.
4:20 Speaker 00 Right.
4:21 Speaker 01 IBM PC.
4:22 Speaker 00 Right, which was... From there, they did it, they did it down in Florida, away from the ma- from the main headquarters.
4:26 Speaker 01 Yeah, my former roommate, office roommate, was the guy who wrote the bios.
4:31 Speaker 00 Wow, that's amazing.
4:33 Speaker 01 I, but since I didn't get along with people very well as a nerd, they didn't invite me to join the project.
4:40 Speaker 00 Right, so you worked for IBM, but still continued to sort of slave away there as many, many, that's, that's a normal career for a lot of people.
4:47 Speaker 01 Yeah, like after that, 11 years in the field, Detroit, then Pittsburgh, and then I decided I needed a change. Charles Schwab got me a good job and I moved out here.
4:59 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:00 Speaker 01 And about two years into my tenure there, that's when the dot com thing hit San Francisco in a big way. I had acquired a number of the necessary skills, did some web work, wound up doing software contracting, most notably for Bank of America, where I helped develop home banking.
5:19 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:21 Speaker 01 And around that time, I realized that a lot of people had helped me in the San Francisco Bay area.
5:27 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:28 Speaker 01 I should give back.
5:28 Speaker 00 Right.
5:29 Speaker 01 And that, well, that was the start of Craigslist.
5:32 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm. What was the idea for it? Because, and I do want to get into it, because it damaged newspapers too, the, the, the creation of Craigslist. But talk about the concept of it, that, that, I assume it's that classifieds were static, expensive, non-effective, all kinds of things.
5:48 Speaker 01 Well, Craigslist just started as a simple mailing list, which developed categories relatively, oh, relatively quickly.
5:58 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
5:59 Speaker 01 I figured I had started something, I'd committed to it, I needed to continue with it.
6:03 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:04 Speaker 01 Fortunately, I could write my own code to automate whatever procedure took time.
6:10 Speaker 00 Right.
6:11 Speaker 01 Just kept growing, grew word of mouth. And at some point, I had to make some decisions like, well, if it's going to continue to exist, I needed to make it into a real company.
6:23 Speaker 00 Right.
6:23 Speaker 01 Now bankers and VCs around here told me I should do the usual thing.
6:29 Speaker 00 Which is collect money.
6:30 Speaker 01 Yes, it would be an awful lot of money.
6:32 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:33 Speaker 01 But from Mr. and Mrs. Levin, I remembered, no one enough is enough.
6:38 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:39 Speaker 01 So I decided to not monetize the site in the usual way.
6:43 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:44 Speaker 01 Nothing altruistic about it, just what I thought were actual values.
6:49 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
6:50 Speaker 01 And proceeded on that basis. And not altruistic, just basic values. A year in, I realized that as a manager, I kind of suck.
7:00 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
7:01 Speaker 01 That's why Jim Buckmaster runs things.
7:03 Speaker 00 Right, right. And so he came in.
7:05 Speaker 01 Yeah.
7:06 Speaker 00 So with the concept of it, the idea was to just make classifieds easier? Was it, were you attacking classifieds? Or you just thought it would be a place where people would trade knowledge, information, and things they wanted?
7:16 Speaker 01 All that is much fancier thinking.
7:18 Speaker 00 Okay.
7:19 Speaker 01 Than I'm capable of.
7:20 Speaker 00 What were you thinking?
7:21 Speaker 01 I'm thinking that people in my community need something to help get them through the day. The deal is that what Craigslist became at that point is a place to help you put food on the table, then to help you find a table.
7:36 Speaker 00 Right.
7:36 Speaker 01 And then to help you get a roof under which to put the table.
7:39 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
7:40 Speaker 01 And that's, that's really how I think about it. It's pretty basic because in our lives, sometimes it's just enough to help someone else get through the day. That ain't bad.
7:53 Speaker 00 Yeah, what was the get through the day part? Reading class, or just meeting people, or?
7:56 Speaker 01 Well, getting through the day, I mean, again, getting enough money or whatever to get food on the table.
8:02 Speaker 00 For whatever services, or to find your services. But you weren't thinking of classifieds are terrible, I'm gonna fix them.
8:07 Speaker 01 No, I had no thinking really about classifieds. At some point, years in, it dawned on me that I had a... Done classifieds.
8:18 Speaker 00 Right.
8:18 Speaker 01 In a good way.
8:19 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
8:20 Speaker 01 Like, once you put a classified ad up, it was easy to remove.
8:25 Speaker 00 Right.
8:25 Speaker 01 Which meant, no one was calling you after it's removed.
8:29 Speaker 00 Right, right, exactly, right. They waited in the newspapers. And so, as it grew, you, i- i- it became quite a business, though, once you started to monetize it. You charged for a variety of things, which, and some of the stuff you didn't charge for.
8:41 Speaker 01 Yeah. The deal is, the site should be monetized as little as possible. And even when we're charging, oh, Craigslist is providing, uh, providing ads that are much more effective, we feel, for, uh, less money.
8:56 Speaker 00 Right, right. And so, as it developed, you became, you weren't running it, Corey, but you were guiding it. It went back and forth in ownership, or there were, you always owned it.
9:06 Speaker 01 Well, at that, at the beginning, I did give away equity to a couple other folks. And I figure, maybe I have some moral responsibility in the background. But when I turned over management to Jim, I relinquished all management control. I relinquished all management involvement.
9:25 Speaker 00 Right.
9:25 Speaker 01 I was in cus-, I was a customer service rep.
9:27 Speaker 00 Right, right.
9:28 Speaker 01 Because, when you make someone CEO.
9:31 Speaker 00 Right.
9:32 Speaker 01 You gotta get out of the way.
9:33 Speaker 00 Right, right. Well, most people don't, Corey. Let's be honest.
9:37 Speaker 01 There's something called, uh, founder syndrome. Somebody who's good at starting something is terrible at continuing it. I had read about it. And sometimes, I'm smart enough to learn from other people's, uh, unpleasant experiences.
9:52 Speaker 00 So what did you do after that, after you, because you were still attached to it, because your name was on the product and...
9:58 Speaker 01 Well, I was emotionally attached to it, but I figured, I've also stopped coding. Because we, you know, Craigslist had hired, uh, a lot of programmers who were better than me. But I was a really, really good customer service rep. I find, uh, even nobility in service. And that turned out to be a pretty hard job.
10:21 Speaker 00 Right.
10:22 Speaker 01 In customer service, you do see things you wish you could unsee. But I kept on with that. The last five years, though, I focused on philanthropy.
10:31 Speaker 00 Right.
10:32 Speaker 01 And, well, in part because my, the Craigslist team doesn't really need me anymore.
10:37 Speaker 00 Right, right. Talk about the philanthropies. You made a lot of money from this. It's still, it's still private, is that correct? I don't want to get this wrong.
10:44 Speaker 01 It is strictly private.
10:46 Speaker 00 And you want to keep it that way?
10:48 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:48 Speaker 00 Are you still a major shareholder?
10:51 Speaker 01 Yes.
10:52 Speaker 00 So you can control that?
10:54 Speaker 01 We run differently than people think we do.
10:57 Speaker 00 Meaning?
10:59 Speaker 01 Jim runs the company. I don't interfere.
11:01 Speaker 00 Right. And, but you're a major shareholder?
11:03 Speaker 01 Yes.
11:04 Speaker 00 But the decision not to go private, not to go public because?
11:09 Speaker 00 Or sell?
11:09 Speaker 01 What's the point?
11:10 Speaker 00 Okay. Not a lot of people say that. I want to hear you say that.
11:13 Speaker 01 Going private, what's the point? Selling, people keep telling me again now that they see I'm doing philanthropy, people say, I could have a huge amount of money to give away. And that's an apt observation these days. I do feel the nation is in crisis.
11:32 Speaker 00 Right.
11:33 Speaker 01 And that people of goodwill need to stand up and do something.
11:38 Speaker 01 Money talks.
11:39 Speaker 00 Right.
11:40 Speaker 01 And money talks in a way that I never really understood until recently.
11:44 Speaker 00 Okay.
11:44 Speaker 01 I would characterize that as nerdly naivete.
11:47 Speaker 00 Okay. And, but you, but it remains private and not sold and not?
11:50 Speaker 01 Correct.
11:51 Speaker 00 Right. There was a period where, I guess eBay was, a lot of people were looking at it. Is that correct?
11:56 Speaker 01 There was. And there was a situation too where a former employee who I had given stock to, I granted it to him.
12:03 Speaker 00 I wrote about it, yeah.
12:04 Speaker 01 Yeah. We got through that. And now Craigslist owns that equity, which would have otherwise been in other hands.
12:14 Speaker 00 So what kind of company would you characterize it as?
12:16 Speaker 01 I don't know if there is a term.
12:19 Speaker 00 Yeah, I know. It's really, it's...
12:21 Speaker 01 We may be unique in American or even world business because, you know, we are serious business people. Craigslist consists entirely of serious business people. And yet, we just remember the values that we learned in Sunday School.
12:37 Speaker 00 Right.
12:37 Speaker 01 That pretty much everyone does.
12:38 Speaker 00 So you moved to the philanthropy. Talk a little bit about that.
12:41 Speaker 01 Well, over the years, over the 10-plus years, people from nonprofits were asking me, you know, how can you grow a community online? What can you do? And they also didn't mind if I made a contribution.
12:57 Speaker 00 Right.
12:58 Speaker 01 So I got involved in the nonprofit world in different areas. Then I got more involved in it. Sometimes I stumbled onto things. Like, I was at a PBS NewsHour thing. Luncheon, and sitting next to me was a volunteer from the Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America. Well, having come of age during Vietnam, I saw that there was a problem with the war, but that vets coming back from the war shouldn't be treated badly.
13:30 Speaker 00 Right.
13:31 Speaker 01 And that kind of stuck with me for, let's say, forty years or so. Well, maybe thirty years. But the idea is that, I figure vets give away, they give up. They sacrifice a lot to protect us.
13:47 Speaker 00 Right.
13:47 Speaker 01 They risk taking a bullet to protect me. More recently, I've learned that their families sacrifice a great deal. Because living without their fighter can be really rough.
14:01 Speaker 00 Absolutely.
14:02 Speaker 01 There's problems like payday lenders and used car salesmen really actively try to rip off families around bases.
14:10 Speaker 00 Right.
14:11 Speaker 01 Not good.
14:11 Speaker 00 No, so?
14:13 Speaker 01 Well, what I've done is worked with CFPB and Consumer Reports on that subject. Also on other subjects relating to that, and part of philanthropy. I'm thinking, if you want to thank a vet, you help them get their kids a good education.
14:31 Speaker 00 Right.
14:32 Speaker 01 So donors choose for military families.
14:34 Speaker 00 Right.
14:35 Speaker 01 We're just concluding that now. I don't think the final numbers have come out, but we've helped out at least a hundred thousand military kids.
14:43 Speaker 00 Right, right. So you, so how big is your philanthropy? What's the, I mean, there's obviously the big ones like the Gates and the Zuckerbergs. Are you, how big is it?
14:52 Speaker 01 Mine is small.
14:55 Speaker 00 Okay.
14:55 Speaker 01 And right now, the only person full-time on it is me.
14:58 Speaker 00 Right.
14:59 Speaker 01 You know, I get help from comms people and lawyer and a controller. And I'm trying to design it, so I have a narrow focus of specialty areas, priorities.
15:11 Speaker 00 Right.
15:12 Speaker 01 And the idea is to be able to turn around a grant proposal fast.
15:16 Speaker 00 Right, that you get.
15:17 Speaker 01 And we've managed to do that. Some things are tough and require a lot of thinking.
15:22 Speaker 00 Right, but you focus on just a couple of topics. So there are military, veterans, women.
15:30 Speaker 01 Voter protection.
15:32 Speaker 00 Voter protection.
15:32 Speaker 01 And trustworthy journalism.
15:34 Speaker 00 Trustworthy journalism. So talk about the, I'm gonna get to the trustworthy journalism in the next section, but when you focus on women's issues and voter protection, what is that about?
15:42 Speaker 01 Well.
15:43 Speaker 00 What do you give to?
15:43 Speaker 01 I'm interested in helping out in women in tech, because I remind myself that our country is supposed to be about fairness, opportunity, and respect.
15:52 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
15:53 Speaker 01 And I should practice what I preach.
15:55 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
15:55 Speaker 01 And like in Jersey, we say, "I should put my money where my mouth is."
15:59 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
16:01 Speaker 01 So what I'm doing, in my ignorance, is finding groups that do really good for women in tech, supporting them, getting educated by them, because I'd like to avoid mansplaining.
16:15 Speaker 00 Right, right. Well, that would be nice.
16:17 Speaker 01 Well, so, for example, I support Girls Who Code.
16:20 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
16:20 Speaker 01 And I'll talk to Reshma Sojani about how I can help, without being stupid about it.
16:26 Speaker 00 Right.
16:27 Speaker 01 I prefer to limit my stupidity to other areas, and I succeed.
16:32 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
16:33 Speaker 01 And I work with Women Who Tech, that's Alison Capen.
16:37 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
16:38 Speaker 01 And I just talk to, let's say, there is women's hacker groups at the University of San Francisco, and my alma mater, Case Tech. So I've provided support to them for things, including scholarships for the Grace Murray Hopper conferences.
16:56 Speaker 00 All right, and then voter protection?
16:58 Speaker 01 Voter protection. Our deal is that...
17:03 Speaker 01 Well, everyone in our country whose eligible vote should have the, well, they should be able to vote without much hassle. And yet, a lot of bad actors in politics have said that part of their strategy is to stop people from voting that they don't like. That means, I gotta stand up and help the groups who are doing a good job fighting those bad actors. That includes the Brennan Center for Law, Voto Latino, Demos. The deal is that even the Russians have gotten in on the game. When Mueller indicted those Russian groups, he specifically said they were trying to suppress the vote.
17:48 Speaker 01 So to have a fair election, or a not very unfair election, people of goodwill need to help out the people who know what they're doing.
17:57 Speaker 00 Right, there's been some setbacks recently in the Supreme Court that they didn't hear.
18:01 Speaker 01 There was one, I think, in Wisconsin. And there's a number of places where voters really are at risk. There are states where, oh, the Secretary of State will just decide to arbitrarily un-register someone, or if a registration-
18:18 Speaker 00 Because they didn't vote.
18:20 Speaker 01 Well, just, no, it's much worse than that. They may just receive voter registrations, and they may just forget to process them if they're there for the wrong party. And, for example, I'm funding one effort, the point of which is to figure out who's registered at one point in time, then take a look at, take a look later, and to see if anyone has mysteriously dropped out, particularly without notice.
18:48 Speaker 00 Right, right, and they're doing this to suppress, just to suppress the vote? How successful do you think they've been?
18:53 Speaker 01 I don't know, because we know that, I was involved in these efforts in 2016, and I have no idea, really, how successful things were. I do know that this election is mission-critical for American democracy.
19:11 Speaker 00 For people to vote. All right, when we get back, we're gonna talk about your $20 million you gave to SUNY, and I want to know why you picked that, and also, more about what you think about where, you said it's the immune system of American democracy. When we get back, we're gonna talk about that, and more with Craig Newmark. He is the founder of Craigslist, but now he is a philanthropist.
19:31 Speaker 00 Today's show is brought to you by ZipRecruiter, which is the presenting sponsor of Recode Decode and the smartest way to hire. If you run a tech company, then you're probably very used to, well, running, sprinting through dev and testing cycles, scrambling to find investors, hurtling through regulatory reviews. So when you're hiring, you don't want to waste time interviewing people who don't have all the skills and experience you need. You need a way to quickly identify the strongest, most qualified candidates. You need ZipRecruiter. Their powerful matching technology scans thousands of resumes across the network to actively find people with the right experience and invites them to apply to your job so you get qualified candidates fast. It's so effective that 80% of employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate through the site within the first day. So if you're hiring, it's time to get smart.
20:16 Speaker 00 Go to ziprecruiter.com/decode right now where you can try ZipRecruiter for free, the lowest price there is. Don't waste another second. Go to ziprecruiter.com/decode and start putting that technology to work for you. That's ziprecruiter.com/decode.
20:35 Speaker 00 I'd also like to tell you about one of our other podcasts, Recode Media with Peter Kafka. Peter, who'd you talk to this week?
20:41 Speaker 02 Kara, you're going to love this conversation. You know why? Because you are a smart person with an avid interest in technology and media. That's why you're doing this podcast. I talked to someone who's exactly like you, Eugene Wei, early Amazon employee, product guy, flipboard product guy, Hulu product guy, Oculus, really big brain, wrote an essay that went viral a little while ago explaining the sort of limits and challenges that Snapchat and Twitter and Facebook all face. He's a really smart dude and he spent an hour talking with me and you can listen to it for free.
21:12 Speaker 00 Sounds great, Peter. You can find Recode Media on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
21:20 Speaker 00 We're here with Craig Newmark. He is well-known as an entrepreneur who created Craigslist, but right now we're talking about his philanthropy, in specific, right now about the $20 million he has just given to the Journalism School at SUNY in New York. Can you talk a little bit about what prompted that? Why? That's a lot of money for a journalism program and obviously an important one to teach people how to do journalism in this day and age.
21:44 Speaker 01 Well, what I'm trying to do in the here and now is support a lot of people doing mission-critical work.
21:52 Speaker 01 In journalism. For example, there's ProPublica. Right. Which is a great example of trustworthy journalism. Right. I'm also supporting a whole bunch of groups who are focusing on analyzing disinformation in order to counter it. Mm-hmm. Like Dana Boyd's group, Data in Society. Right. A whole bunch of things. There's a Tao Center. Oh, there's folks even in Indiana that I'm talking to. There's the folks at First Draft at Shorenstein Center. So the idea is that I've contributed over 20 million to a collection of groups looking at defending journalism and defending the country against bad actors, whether foreign
22:36 Speaker 01 or domestic. But I think we not only need to work in the here and now, but we need to work in the, oh, in the near term. Right. Hence, we need a lot of good, well-educated journalists. And given my, well, given the way I believe in things of sharing, well, fairness, opportunity, and respect for all, the City University of New York, CUNY Graduate Journalism School is a great place to do that. Jeff Jarvis, Sarah Bartlett have great track records in journalism, great track records for integrity. I mean, I've done my due diligence.
23:20 Speaker 01 And what the CUNY Graduate Journalism School is about, it's about diversity, it's about giving people the opportunity to get a really quality education, quality journalism, at a much lower price than they would get everywhere. Right. The idea, fairness, opportunity, and respect, this is a way of putting it into practice.
23:44 Speaker 01 And that's something I believe in in a big way.
23:46 Speaker 00 So, so why, I'm just curious, why, did you, you looked around at a lot of journalism schools? Do you feel that there's not enough journalists being trained? Or what, what was the thinking? And I know you're giving money to other journalism organizations.
23:57 Speaker 01 It's kind of all the above. I see CUNY as being the figurative and literal epicenter of a lot of these activities. Some of the best work is being done, again, in Manhattan, at Columbia, in Dana's team, NYU, you go north, and again, Shorenstein Center. South, there's Pointer. In our area, there's.
24:21 Speaker 00 Berkeley.
24:22 Speaker 01 Berkeley. And things are happening there. So the idea is that I can learn enough, I can get help from folks at Ford Foundation, at, oh, Jennifer Preston, at the Knight Foundation. I can get the help I need. And then it becomes time, having identified good organizations, to put my money where my mouth is. CUNY, again, the CUNY Graduate School of Journalism, is a great place to do that because they provide a good opportunity for people who might never get.
24:59 Speaker 00 Never get it. So what do you expect the $20 million to be used for? Did you direct it in any way?
25:05 Speaker 01 I have not. It goes, basically, into what I think of as an endowment, providing funding in an environment where funding is shrinking, and it's all pretty scary. And that's scary in a number of ways, because across America, people who might need opportunity are being denied that.
25:25 Speaker 00 And you, so it can go to anything? Creates an endowment to do shares, or tuition, or?
25:31 Speaker 01 I think it provides operational funding for that. For detail, you can ask Sarah.
25:37 Speaker 00 Right, but they get to do it. And, and what was the pitch by them to you? What was it? Sarah and Joe.
25:43 Speaker 01 Basically, they explained how they work, how their funding works. They showed me something, I guess I already knew, that they're providing good education in journalism to people who might never otherwise get a break.
25:58 Speaker 00 Right.
25:59 Speaker 01 And also, they, again, they're at that epicenter of restoring a lot of trust to journalism everywhere.
26:09 Speaker 00 So, talk about that issue, because right now, it's never, I think there's never been so much of a siege on journalism. Every day, one of the members of the Trump administration, or someone affiliated with them, is attacking the press. Yesterday, it was Corey Lewandowski, after his appalling behavior on television. But, just every day.
26:25 Speaker 01 Well, I start, in a way, trying to figure out what I, as a news consumer, I want to find news I can trust. And what does that mean? And that's been helped by the folks at the Trust Project, at the Markela Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara. And in my simplified, not-a-journalist perspective, I want news organizations to listen to different kinds of people, regardless of politics, or ethnicity, or whatever. I want, you know, news outlets to have codes of ethics, which say things like, "Don't make stuff up." And I want news outlets, when they do make a mistake, because, you know, that's going
27:09 Speaker 01 to happen, that they fix it in a serious way. Now, Sally Lehrman, who runs this, has more trust indicators, but I'm somewhat simple-minded, and I'm very aware that I'm not a news professional, and I'm not telling anyone how to do their job.
27:25 Speaker 00 Right.
27:26 Speaker 01 So, if a news outlet wants me to trust it and maybe pay for it, I, they have to behave in a trustworthy way.
27:33 Speaker 00 Right.
27:34 Speaker 01 That's the start of things there. Then, the idea is to fund a lot of operational work. Fact-checking is a big part of this. And a lot of it goes around the International Fact-Checking Network, which is a network of networks with a common code, meaning that if you're going to do a fact-check, you have to publish...
27:55 Speaker 01 Oh, your material's showing how you got there.
27:58 Speaker 00 Right.
27:58 Speaker 01 So if you don't trust their fact checks, you have the raw material sources to look at.
28:03 Speaker 00 To look at it yourself.
28:04 Speaker 01 And they're having a big meeting in Rome right now. And it looks like lots of progress is being made in fact checking. Bill O'Dea, helping fund out in Duke University, they're trying to build the means for fact checkers to work together.
28:19 Speaker 00 Right.
28:19 Speaker 01 First draft.
28:20 Speaker 00 First, I want to talk to you about what you think the landscape is right now for the press. What's happening?
28:25 Speaker 01 Um, there's a whole bunch of things happening at once. On the optimistic side, I keep getting approached quietly by people at a whole range of news outlets, even unexpected ones, people who want to do straight ethical reporting, even if their boss won't want them to do that. And so I see a lot of hope for things. People are seeing these mechanisms, this ecosystem of trustworthy journalism, and people are pretty optimistic about it. The deal is just to, oh, one part of the problem is to get everyone to work together
29:08 Speaker 01 and then to find those organizations which might not have enough funding.
29:13 Speaker 00 Right, I got that part. I want to talk about the landscape right now, which is not positive.
29:17 Speaker 01 Okay.
29:17 Speaker 00 Is not optimistic.
29:20 Speaker 01 Then, can you help me understand that?
29:22 Speaker 00 Well, with Trump discussing the press every day, attacking it, then saying, "I'm attacking it on purpose to weaken it," using it, you're just creating distrust. And I'll get to internet companies next, but how do you look at that landscape?
29:35 Speaker 01 Well, I draw some hope from those services like PolitiFact or the guy at The Post, I think it's Eric Wemple, who are just carefully documenting lies. And doing that, just getting some recognition of it, helps people. But I'm more interested in dealing with that landscape. And an idea I've heard from Dana Boyd is that of strategic silence. And then I've read in the last week or two, how
30:06 Speaker 01 How a number of reporters, Brian Stelter and others, they're just saying that they're tired of all the lying. And they've started to challenge people in the White House press room.
30:20 Speaker 00 Right, right.
30:21 Speaker 01 And then getting tired of all the lying may get them, I'm hoping, to apply this idea of strategic silence, which means that, well, as Dan Gillmor says, "You don't give a loudspeaker for liars." And if that starts happening, I think that would dramatically clear up the landscape.
30:44 Speaker 00 You do. I don't. I think lies work beautifully.
30:49 Speaker 01 But if people don't hear them, and if the networks of disinformation are disrupted, if the bad stuff cannot crowd out honest reporting, there's hope. And I have chosen to be hopeful, to put my money where my mouth is.
31:07 Speaker 00 Right. I get you've chosen to be hopeful, but I think the landscape is more dangerous than most people recognize.
31:13 Speaker 01 You may be right, but we can't let fear paralyze us. This year is pivotal for the country. It could be pivotal for the world and the species. And it's time for people of goodwill to stand up, maybe make some mistakes, but to do this. I mean, remember, I talked to a lot of vets. And they stood up to defend the country in the way they knew. I came of age during Vietnam. Vietnam vets tell me, "That wasn't my fight." They tell me, "This is my fight."
31:51 Speaker 00 It's to stand up to it. What do you, when you talk about what needs to be done to get press more credible, I'd love to know what you think the press has done wrong by just allowing the equalization of the lies or not attacking them, or what?
32:06 Speaker 01 Well, in a lot of cases, they would amplify a lie because when you give uncritical airtime to a lie, the lie gets reinforced. If you, yeah, if you give airtime or perhaps space and print.
32:28 Speaker 01 It reinforces the lie. Now, some people are good at debunking it in real time. Not many.
32:35 Speaker 00 Right.
32:36 Speaker 01 So this idea of strategic silence, just not going along, that might be the answer. I think it's Jay Rosen, who says, "Replace the White House press corps with interns if, oh, if something important happens, but otherwise, take those highly professional journalists and get them to report real news."
32:59 Speaker 00 Real news. Which is?
33:01 Speaker 01 Whatever is happening anyplace else.
33:04 Speaker 00 Right, right, absolutely.
33:05 Speaker 01 Yeah. Like, this is a, would be an extreme case, but if you were to take one of those reporters to report regularly on the Washington School Board, you might actually do more good that way.
33:18 Speaker 00 Right, right.
33:19 Speaker 01 Local news matters.
33:20 Speaker 00 Right. Well, we'll get to that in a minute. We're here with Craig Newmark. He has just given $20 million to the SUNY Journalism School because he believes in journalism. We're going to talk about sort of the changes that the information society has created. We're going to take another break now. We'll be back after this with Craig Newmark. Today's show is brought to you by TransferWise. Do you ever need to send money internationally? Sure. Your bank or PayPal can get your money from A to B, but that transfer will cost you more than it should, a lot more. That's the old way of doing things. Let me tell you about the new, smarter, and cheaper way to send money internationally: TransferWise. TransferWise was founded by two friends, Tavitt and Cristo, who were frustrated by their bank's bad exchange rates and high fees. They wondered, what if we could bypass the banks entirely?
34:04 Speaker 00 So they built TransferWise. That was seven years ago. Today, more than 2 million people use TransferWise. People sending money home, businesses paying suppliers, freelancers getting paid, the list goes on. TransferWise's clever new technology gives you a great exchange rate and a low fee. So it'll put some extra money in your pocket for more important things. No one has ever said, "It's important that my bank gets some extra money." Test it out for free at transferwise.com/podcast or download the app. Once again, that's transferwise.com/podcast. It's the wise way to send money.
34:40 Speaker 00 I'd also like to tell you about my other podcast, Too Embarrassed to Ask. Every week, we answer your questions about consumer tech and the week's news. This week, I talked to Renee Duresta, an expert on disinformation and so much more about our horrible digital life right now. Renee, what did we talk about? I was real happy.
34:55 Speaker 03 I was happy.
34:56 Speaker 00 Talked about disinformation and its impact.
34:59 Speaker 03 Disinformation, its impacts, misinformation, how we talk to each other, how our leaders communicate with us, how to restore civility to the dialogue in an age of algorithmic conversations.
35:14 Speaker 00 I just say, put your Twitter down. Put it down right now. That's what I say to a lot of people that are on Twitter sometimes, that I know, I text them, I'm like, put it down.
35:20 Speaker 03 It's great advice. Everybody needs that.
35:23 Speaker 00 Yeah, I have a very well-known friend who was arguing, was arguing, in fact, with a bot, and I'm like, you're arguing with a bot? Stop. Anyway, you can find Too Embarrassed to Ask on Apple Podcasts, Google Play Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts. That's Too Embarrassed to Ask. See you there. We're here with Craig Newmark, the founder of Craigslist. We've just been talking about a donation he made to SUNY Journalism School of $20 million. But I do want to get to Silicon Valley, because one of the things about, we talked about the amplification of lies and how easy it is, is by using social media that was created right here. Some people might think creation of Craigslist hurt newspapers, for example, by killing off classifieds. Classifieds went digital. It's not your fault particularly, but the digitization of everything has weakened media.
36:08 Speaker 00 No? Yes?
36:10 Speaker 01 I have to challenge the premise there.
36:11 Speaker 00 Tell me. Please do.
36:13 Speaker 01 I've looked at the last 60 years of newspaper circulation and revenues.
36:18 Speaker 00 Right.
36:19 Speaker 01 Down, down, down. Down, down, down due to TV news, as people say.
36:22 Speaker 00 Right.
36:23 Speaker 01 Around 2008, got hammered even worse by the big dot-coms.
36:27 Speaker 00 Right.
36:28 Speaker 01 I think Craigslist played a small role in that, one so small that I don't know if anyone has been able to measure it.
36:36 Speaker 00 Right.
36:37 Speaker 01 With all the effects that the big guys had.
36:39 Speaker 00 Right.
36:40 Speaker 01 So I don't really know if Craigslist had that substantial effect. And at this point, my focus is on doing what I can to restore trust for these stuff.
36:51 Speaker 00 Right, absolutely, I got that. So talk about the big guys, what social, we all know the impact of television, but let's talk about the impact of internet companies. I'd love to get your thoughts on Facebook and how it distributes information. But talk about that from when you watched it happen, when these big guys came in and started really impacting journalism's business model, the advertising model, which is now the digital advertising model is pretty much dominated by Facebook and Google at this point.
37:17 Speaker 01 I can only address something from the perspective of a technology founder.
37:22 Speaker 00 Okay.
37:23 Speaker 01 That is, you know, you produce a really good
37:27 Speaker 00 Product.
37:28 Speaker 01 Product, you give it away mostly free, you're hoping to make a comfortable living. And something engineers are not prepared for are how people can abuse the system.
37:39 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
37:40 Speaker 01 And we, it takes a while for us to really realize it, for it to grow out of denial, you know, that's basically human.
37:48 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
37:49 Speaker 01 And naturally, we try to handle it ourselves. We try two or three times, and if we're paying attention, we may realize that our first attempts at dealing with problems didn't work.
38:02 Speaker 00 Right.
38:03 Speaker 01 And then we get help, and then we wind up on the road to a solution.
38:09 Speaker 00 Right.
38:10 Speaker 01 So I think that Facebook, Google, and Twitter are moving ahead pretty well in that regards. And I'm impressed with the turnaround that I've seen looking through side channels.
38:23 Speaker 00 Mm-hmm.
38:24 Speaker 01 Yeah, I'm not good at side channels, frankly. I'm a nerd. I've seen Jeff Jarvis do a great deal of good. Through these and I'm doing whatever I can to give them that credit.
38:35 Speaker 00 All right, so you don't feel that you think they've, I think they've broken things almost irreparably. I, I do, and, and are not taking responsibility for fixing it at all. I don't know if it's, I actually don't know if it's fixable in terms of how it's changed, how people take in information. I look at Twitter every day and see it not cleaned up in the way that you're talking about. I see Facebook continuing to drag its feet on very important things. Now, I'm hoping a lot for the next election, but you can't say you broke something and, oh, well, it's not, you know, you get my point.
39:07 Speaker 01 I do see things being fixed. I also know how difficult these problems are because sometimes if a bad actor is running a long con, it takes, you know, serious law enforcement skills sometimes to understand when a long con is in place. And I don't know if AI will be smart enough to do that in our lifetimes. If it does become that smart, I for one welcome our machine overlords. But the idea is that people are working on a limited AI to try to detect problems. The companies are hiring people to try to detect problems. They're
39:50 Speaker 01 serious, but these are really, really hard problems. And people are thinking about it. Me, I have a feeling that verified identities will help with some of this because a verified identity can hold a bad actor or can help to hold a bad actor accountable for something. The problem is that we always need anonymity for people like dissidents or, well, people who've just escaped to a shelter, that kind of thing. This is ramifications that I need to know more about. I talked to Dana Boyd. And often I do that in the context of the CUNY, you know, graduate journalism school.
40:33 Speaker 00 Right.
40:34 Speaker 01 Because that's, that's a big convening place for all this happening.
40:37 Speaker 00 All right. So, but they have, do you imagine, as a tech founder, that you did think of the repercussions of your inventions? I think they didn't think of them at all and were slow to understand them. Rather, slow, I'm being polite when I say slow.
40:52 Speaker 01 Slow is sometimes accurate. I could only speak for myself and reflect that in some respects I was kind of a dumbass about it. I got an education quickly and I am one of those humans who will ask for a direction. But in my specific case also, remember that in 2000, I gave up all management involvement in Craigslist. The idea, again, is that tech founders, just like ordinary humans, sometimes there's a problem and humans are good at being in denial about something.
41:35 Speaker 01 And then sometimes humans are remiss in asking for directions.
41:40 Speaker 00 Do you think the personality has changed, has things have changed? I mean, I literally, when I did my interview with Tim Cook recently, he talked about it quite cogently and the reaction was, how dare he say such things? That you need to have responsibility, that you need to have, you know, they attacked him rather than listen to the message he was putting forth.
41:58 Speaker 01 Well, what I'm doing, again, is quietly going through back channels, trying to nudge ahead progress. I don't have the eloquence or persuasive abilities to make things happen with any speed. I just nudge and then I keep nudging and nudging further. Hopefully that provides some atmosphere.
42:19 Speaker 00 So what has to happen among these tech companies? I mean, for example, just recently, I was arguing with someone at one of the big tech companies around these kids in Texas and they're like, what do you want us to do? Wade in every time? I'm like, I kind of do. I think your employees, I want you to do it. I think you shouldn't be doing business when this is happening with them. You know, I mean, I'm like, I have an opinion about this. You may not want to do that, but...
42:42 Speaker 01 I don't want any of them to become an arbiter of truth. I want them to use professionals to try to figure out what might be trustworthy and what's not. For example, I'd like a news outlet to, oh, to subscribe to the Trust Project principles, maybe to the work being done by the Credibility Coalition. I'd like them to work with the investigators who are tracking patterns of both disinformation and harassment. They're usually the same. And I want to, I want to get summary fact check records.
43:26 Speaker 01 That is, if a news feed encounters an incoming chunk of news. And it can't really do fact checking in real time. But if it knows that that news outlet has a track record for generally being right, and then fixing what got wrong, then I might want to see that one. I might choose to see items like that. I might choose to say, hey, if something comes in from a news outlet which gets it wrong a lot, I want to choose not to see that.
44:00 Speaker 00 Right, but that puts a lot of onus on the reader, and it puts a lot of onus on the news organizations and not these distributors.
44:06 Speaker 01 I disagree with that.
44:07 Speaker 00 Okay.
44:08 Speaker 01 The idea is that the news reader chooses only, do I want to see stuff which is probably trustworthy? Do I want to see stuff that's probably not trustworthy? Oversimplifying for discussion. But the idea is that, oh, the user chooses what kinds of stuff they see. The platform relies on other parties to work on this, like the International Fact Checking Network.
44:36 Speaker 00 Right.
44:37 Speaker 01 Like first draft out of the Schor and Seen Center. Like the tech and check people out of Duke University. They also may involve some AI stuff, like the work being done at FactMata. And there, I got to disclose, I'm a token investor.
44:55 Speaker 00 Okay. So you don't want them to be arbiters of truth of platforms they build?
45:01 Speaker 01 Correct.
45:02 Speaker 00 Why?
45:04 Speaker 01 Because I think it's unfair to concentrate that much power in one place. An arbiter of truth gets to shape the reality that its users perceive.
45:15 Speaker 00 Yes, I've met Rupert Murdoch.
45:19 Speaker 01 I almost met him, but I was frightened of him.
45:22 Speaker 00 Oh, don't worry about it.
45:23 Speaker 01 But the deal is that we don't want informational power to be concentrated too much in any particular place. And the way to do that is to create networks of networks of people who know what they're doing and who show you how they do it. So if you want to challenge it, then you can challenge it. I want big networks of networks with some redundancy because even in the US, journalists are under siege to some extent. There are big problems with harassment, death threats are worse, that kind of thing. And I'm talking with parties, including Wikipedia, as to how do journalists protect themselves
46:06 Speaker 01 here, both informationally, reputationally, and in other countries, how journalists protect themselves physically. Because journalists are getting killed, that's not right.
46:19 Speaker 00 Right, right. So not letting, you know, I did an interview with Mark Zuckerberg, and I'm going to be talking to him more in the future, but one of the things he really does want to shy away, he said, "I don't want to sit at my desk in California and make decisions about these things." And one of their solutions was to crowdsource what's good, which I find disturbing on every level. I know the New York Times is good. I don't need a crowd, you don't want a crowd to be voting up and down and likes and dislikes. It seems so open to gaming.
46:48 Speaker 01 I used to think that crowdsourcing of trustworthiness could be a thing. I have backed off from that. The deal is trustworthiness. Well, you start with commitment, at least verbal commitment, that's the Trust Project stuff. A news outlet, if you want to think of it as trustworthy, they should start by saying, "We're trustworthy." And then you do the Reagan-esque thing, "Trust but verify." That's what the International Fact-Checking Network is about. There's other people who are taking a look. First Draft is providing the means where people can help each other do some of these fact checks. So we have an ecosystem emerging.
47:34 Speaker 01 Now, I'm not a journalism professional. I don't want to tell anyone how to do their business because I think that a reporter has to do something like writing a news story every day to deadline. I can barely write 500 words to deadline. So what I've done is found professionals, a lot of them centered at the City University of New York Journalism School, and I can rely on people who know what they're talking about. Because, you know, I have a feeling unless you've written the deadline for like 10 years or something, you just don't know.
48:13 Speaker 00 Yeah, yeah. So I want to finish up. You seem optimistic about journalism. I've never been more pessimistic, I have to say.
48:21 Speaker 01 Well, I see this ecosystem developing. I see people getting more optimistic and feistier. Like I read, oh, the newsletters that come out of Politico and Axios and Brian Stelter's out of CNN, and I do see indications of things getting better.
48:42 Speaker 00 Right. Because they're mad as hell and they're not going to take it anymore?
48:45 Speaker 01 Well...
48:46 Speaker 00 We know how that ended.
48:47 Speaker 01 They focus on real stuff happening to make things better. We do need more people mad as hell, and I've seen some signs that Anderson Cooper is getting tired of the lying. The break, I think, will come when more and more people read some of the best writing of the last week or so on this, like that Dan Gillmor piece saying, you know, "Don't provide loudspeakers for liars, whoever they are. You know, somebody's lying to, just don't repeat the lies. Don't give them airtime."
49:21 Speaker 00 All right. So what is next for you? Twenty million dollars is a lot of money. More $20 million donations all around the world. How do you get others in Silicon Valley? I think Facebook could just pay for all of local news. That's what I think. I think they've ruined local news and should now pay for it.
49:36 Speaker 01 Twenty for Cooney Journalism School.
49:38 Speaker 00 Right.
49:38 Speaker 01 Twenty for a bunch of other...
49:40 Speaker 00 Right.
49:40 Speaker 01 Another twenty for a bunch of other people.
49:42 Speaker 00 Right.
49:42 Speaker 01 And I gotta do more.
49:45 Speaker 00 How are you gonna get Silicon Valley people to do more?
49:47 Speaker 01 Well, the deal is, I talk with them. I work quietly with the big dot-coms. Although, again, Jeff is the guy to really make things happen. And I feel that they're consistently moving in a better direction. It's kind of like they're asking for directions, which is sometimes hard to get a human to do. And I see that happening. And, you know, before the events of November 2016, journalism and democracy were slowly drifting into a bad place, kind of like the frogs slowly boiling in water. Well, we got a wake-up call.
50:29 Speaker 00 Right.
50:29 Speaker 01 And I think people across the world, particularly Americans in journalism, are standing up and are doing remarkable things. And I'm sure that I see that. I mean, like any human, I might be fooling myself. We like to fool ourselves. We're good at it.
50:48 Speaker 00 Right.
50:49 Speaker 01 But I'll put my money where my mouth is and see what happens.
50:53 Speaker 00 Well, good for you, Craig. I have to say, kudos to you. I wish more people would do the same, not just for journalism, but issues that you're talking about. And it was great talking to you. Thanks for coming on the show. If you enjoyed the interview as much as I did, be sure to subscribe to the show. You can find more episodes of Recode Decode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts, or just visit recode.net/podcast for more. If you have a minute, please leave us a review on Apple Podcasts and tell other people about the show. That helps them discover great interviews like this one. Now that you're done with this, you should check out our other podcasts, Too Embarrassed to Ask and Recode Media with Peter Kafka. You can find those shows wherever you found this one. Thanks for listening to this episode of Recode Decode. Thanks to our editor Joel Robby and our producer Eric Johnson. I'll be back here on Wednesday. Tune in then.
Previous Recode Decode: Box CEO Aaron Levie Next Recode Decode: Why do some in the tech community support universal basic income? Page updated October 15, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated