Pod Insights Decoder Land of the Giants: Tesla vs. The Competition About this episode We have a little surprise in the feed today: An episode of "Land of the Giants," which is all about Tesla this season. Former Verge transportation reporter Tamara Warren and former Jalopnik EIC Patrick George, who are both deeply sourced in the world of cars, host, and every episode has reporting and insight about Tesla that really hasn’t been shared before. It was ahead of the EV competition in basically every way for a long time. But the question Tamara and Patrick want to answer is: Is Tesla still winning by default? And where is the competition pulling ahead now that every carmaker is doing EVs? I joined them in this episode to discuss how modern cars, especially EVs, are being totally rethought as rolling computers.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 6,888 words · 29 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 Real innovation is powered by real people. This is AMEX Corporate. Trusted experts, smarter technology, 24/7 dedicated support from day one to answer questions, help set up policies and approvals, and consult on spend capacity as your business needs evolve. Plus, on-demand resources help level up operations at every stage. That's the trusted service you've come to expect. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate.
0:31 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:41 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
0:49 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:03 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. We have a little surprise in the feed today. It's an episode of The Land of the Giants, which is all about Tesla this season. And this is a really great season. The hosts are former Verge transportation reporter Tamara Warren and former Jalopnik editor in chief Patrick George, who are both deeply sourced in the world of cars. Every episode has reporting and insight about Tesla that really hasn't been shared before. I cannot recommend this season enough. We're running this episode in the Decoder feed today because, well, I'm in it. Tamara and Patrick talked to a lot of people to figure out where Tesla ranks against its competition on a few key fronts.
1:47 Speaker 03 Tesla was obviously first to really create the mainstream electric vehicle industry in the United States. It was ahead of the EV competition in basically every way for a long time. But Tamara and Patrick wanted to dive into the question of whether Tesla is still winning by default. And where is the competition pulling ahead now that every carmaker is seriously doing EVs? I joined Tamara and Patrick to discuss how modern cars, especially EVs, are being totally rethought as rolling computers. See, normal cars have dozens of computers from dozens of suppliers in them. And most of those computers don't talk to each other very well, which makes things like software updates incredibly hard. A Tesla, on the other hand, is a fully integrated computer. The company designs their cars
2:32 Speaker 03 from the ground up as a single computing environment. That allows Tesla to push frequent over-the-air updates to control everything from the air conditioner to autonomous driving, and do things with those computers regular carmakers just can't. That control has given Tesla a serious edge, until perhaps recently. The competition hasn't fully caught up, but everyone else can see what Tesla is doing and is heading that way. If you're a Decoder listener, you know we've had a lot of car CEOs on the show talking about this idea. And next month at the Code Conference, I'll be talking to GM CEO Mary Barra about it as well. You can apply to attend at voxmedia.comcode. Tamara and Patrick also talked to other experts
3:13 Speaker 03 in the industry about other key elements of car competition, and where Tesla stacks up. Some of them, like speed, are pretty straightforward. Others are more nuanced, like reliability. What parts break down or fall off, and how often? How do people feel about it when things do go wrong? It's a complicated question and a complicated moment for Tesla and the car industry. Like I said, the season is great. Okay, land of the giants. Here we go.
3:51 Speaker 04 In 2019, Tesla was lapping the competition. It owned roughly 80% of the EV market. America was making a gradual shift toward electric cars. Tesla was on a roll, and then it announced its next big thing.
4:06 Speaker 05 Los Angeles, November 2019. The skies are polluted. The world is addicted to oil. But we're here to offer a solution: the Cybertruck.
4:21 Speaker 04 The Cybertruck, a stainless steel pickup that looked like a cyberpunk military fever dream. Sharp angles everywhere.
4:29 Speaker 06 There's nothing even historically that really looks like the Cybertruck. And it was kind of like, okay, what if DeLorean made a pickup truck was maybe part of the inspiration?
4:38 Speaker 04 Johnny Lieberman is an automotive journalist.
4:41 Speaker 06 It's wacky. I mean, it's very cool looking to me. You know, when I saw it and kind of knew what it was, I put a deposit down on one.
4:47 Speaker 04 And so did nearly 2 million others, all to reserve their spot in line, even if no one knew when the truck would actually be available. It wasn't out yet, but it started popping up in videos with style icons like Pharrell and Travis Scott.
5:04 Speaker 04 People were buying and selling their spots in line. The Cybertruck waiting list was reaching hype beast levels of anticipation.
5:11 Speaker 06 I got caught up in the buzz and I, I just thought it was such a cool looking vehicle. Like, you know, polarizing, of course, but like, wow, I like things that don't look like anything else. Some people just absolutely hate it.
5:24 Speaker 04 Love it or hate it, the Cybertruck was a complete design departure from the rest of Tesla's models. It represented a new and exciting direction for the company. Tesla had popular cars. The Model Y launched in 2020 and was a hit, but it looked just like every other Tesla since the Model S. The lineup was starting to feel a little stale. So people couldn't wait to get their hands on this truck. But now, nearly four years after the unveiling, they're still waiting to get their hands on this truck. At the time of this recording, Tesla hasn't shipped any. In fact, the first one just rolled off the production line in July. So one down, 999,999 more to go. And when the
6:05 Speaker 04 Cybertruck finally does arrive, it will enter an increasingly crowded EV truck market that didn't really exist four years ago. There are Hummers, Ford F-150s, Rams, there's even a buzzy California startup called Rivian that exclusively makes EV trucks and SUVs.
6:20 Speaker 06 I've never put a deposit down on a vehicle before. Well, I did for the Tesla. They never made it. So then I did it again for the Rivian and then I bought it.
6:29 Speaker 04 For Lieberman and other EV buyers, the excitement around the Cybertruck and Tesla has waned. It's no longer the only game in town. And now Tesla's 80% domination of the market has been whittled down to 60%. And some projections have it plummeting to 18% market share by 2026. The competition is here.
6:52 Speaker 04 This is Land of the Giants. I'm Tamara Warren.
6:56 Speaker 07 And I'm Patrick George. Tesla is the company that made EVs cool. It sold a vision where the future was luxurious and sustainable. But now, the rest of the industry is selling a similar vision.
7:07 Speaker 04 So today, we're going to see how Tesla stacks up against the competition and how the competition stacks up against Tesla. To do so, we're going to play a little game.
7:18 Speaker 07 Here's how it works. We've split the experience of owning a new EV into seven different categories, seven ways that customers commonly evaluate their EV purchases, things like price, performance, quality, ease of charging, the vibe of the brand, and so on. For each of these categories, we spoke to experts as well as people who have recently purchased EVs. Some of them bought Teslas and some of them bought other brands. At the end of each category, we'll award a point to either Tesla or the competition, depending on who's doing better.
7:46 Speaker 04 Simple, one point per category. Whoever has the most points at the end wins.
7:53 Speaker 04 All right, Patrick, let's play. Starting with one of the primary concerns new EV buyers shared with us. How am I going to charge this thing?
8:01 Speaker 08 There was like a nervousness of getting a vehicle that you're just not sure what the charging experience is actually like.
8:10 Speaker 07 If you're used to driving a gas car, the oil industry's got you covered. Gas stations are everywhere. But for EV owners, a little more planning is required.
8:18 Speaker 09 The range is a priority factor and how far I can go without being inconvenienced.
8:26 Speaker 07 And range anxiety has long been a factor that held people back from buying electric cars. But as batteries have gotten better, range anxiety isn't as bad as it used to be. In fact, most EVs these days are getting around 200 to 300 miles to a charge. That's a lot more than what the average American drives every day, around 40 miles.
8:44 Speaker 10 That was just a huge wake-up call and a game changer because it really kind of obliterated this sort of fundamental concern that most auto companies thought, what was the reason why there was no demand for electric cars?
8:58 Speaker 07 Andrew Hawkins is transportation editor at The Verge and our authority on all things charging.
9:02 Speaker 10 Now, I would say it's charging anxiety is the thing that most people will say is preventing them from making the switch.
9:09 Speaker 07 And honestly, figuring this part out can be a pain in the ass.
9:12 Speaker 11 I've not successfully charged my car in public.
9:15 Speaker 08 Charging this car currently for me is a total bitch. My parking garage does not allow me to charge. They won't even set it up for me.
9:23 Speaker 11 It takes a while to charge your car. Like, I pulled into a parking lot that has these, that like says there's one available. Somebody pulls in right in front of me, but they're going to be there for half an hour to an hour. So it's not like a gas station where I could just wait.
9:37 Speaker 12 It's a lot easier to fill up at a gas station for 10 minutes than to wait a couple of hours in the middle of a drive.
9:43 Speaker 11 So I put in a home charger and that's kind of the only way that you can have this car is like having a charger at home.
9:52 Speaker 07 Figuring out how to charge your EV depends on a few factors. If you own your own home and have a parking spot, you could install your own charging station. It's a bit pricey, though, like a couple grand. Obviously, a lot of people rent or don't have a dedicated parking spot. So that means filling up at a public charging station run by a company like Electrify America. It's kind of like a gas station, but there are far fewer.
10:13 Speaker 08 BMW offers free charging with Electrify America, which is nowhere in Manhattan or Brooklyn. So you have to drive to a Queens mall and walk around for like 30 minutes.
10:23 Speaker 07 That does not sound convenient, but if you own a Tesla, it's different.
10:27 Speaker 13 I've had no issues. They're everywhere. Every five, 10 minutes, there's a Tesla charger, it feels like.
10:34 Speaker 08 They do have an incredible charging network.
10:37 Speaker 07 Tesla's Supercharger network is the largest in America. It's generally regarded as the easiest and is often the fastest to use, but it only works for Teslas.
10:45 Speaker 10 It's a huge advantage for the company.
10:47 Speaker 07 The Verge's Andrew Hawkins again.
10:49 Speaker 10 It's been something that customers have cited over the years as being one of the primary reasons why they've decided to buy a Tesla.
10:56 Speaker 07 For years, Tesla was the only car company that spent real money, billions of dollars in this case, to build out a charging infrastructure.
11:03 Speaker 10 It was mainly an afterthought for the entire industry. And I think Elon Musk and Tesla made the very smart realization that if they wanted people to be driving electric vehicles in all the states and then maybe all the countries in the world, they were going to have to make an equal, if not greater, investment in charging infrastructure. So they decided to do it themselves.
11:24 Speaker 07 So great if you own a Tesla, less great if you don't, but help is on the way.
11:30 Speaker 14 Plugging in is about to become faster and easier for thousands of American drivers. GM joining Ford in a landmark agreement to allow their vehicles to use all Tesla chargers.
11:40 Speaker 07 Andrew Hawkins says this move is great for Tesla.
11:43 Speaker 10 Tesla gets a unlimited supply of new customers to its supercharger network, which is really, I don't even know how to quantify that revenue quite yet. I don't think anybody really quite does because it's, it's just, we're sort of now still just kind of coming to terms with the whole thing. That's money in the bank for them.
12:01 Speaker 07 But if other car companies have access to Tesla's superior charging network, Tesla's advantage in this category kind of evaporates, right? As far as the customer experience, yeah, but we're not quite there yet. These changes will be rolling out over the next year or two. It's also a great additional revenue stream for Tesla, the company. Now the other major EV makers will be reliant on Tesla for a key part of its business.
12:25 Speaker 07 So we're going to give this point to Tesla.
12:30 Speaker 07 It's still way ahead of the competition when it comes to charging. Next up, let's talk about design. Take it away, Tamara.
12:38 Speaker 04 Car design is a complex execution of engineering and creativity. It's form and function. Form speaks to our aesthetic tastes. It's what makes a car attractive or unattractive. Function is how the driver interacts with the car, that intuitive understanding of how to operate it.
12:55 Speaker 15 When the vision of the company and the vision of the designers meet in the same place that these things actually hit the road. It's a very awesome time to be a car designer, I think.
13:06 Speaker 04 Paul Snyder is our design expert today. He's the chairperson of Transportation Design at the College for Creative Studies in Detroit, one of the top car design programs in the world. He says when Tesla introduced the Model S over a decade ago, it accomplished a fresh perspective on minimalist design.
13:22 Speaker 15 When Tesla first came out, it was pretty astounding, I think, in the industry. The interior is especially fresh, and that mainly has to do with its simplicity and the care that was taken in the few details. Model S really cracked it open in that regard because it did have a very fresh proportion because there is no engine in the front. And it's done really well.
13:50 Speaker 04 But the Model S was a long time ago, and Tesla hasn't played with proportion much since then. And some of the EV buyers we spoke to are over it.
13:58 Speaker 11 You can see that they are running the same cars that they've been running for a while. I don't think they've like modernized the look. But then you see the truck and you're like, oh damn, if that's their vision of the future, I choose something else.
14:12 Speaker 08 Teslas used to look cool, and now they don't. They've become the Uber car of the city. Before we had this car, we were releasing a RAV4. We would always be like, oh my God, someone's going to accidentally get into our car because it's the Uber car.
14:30 Speaker 08 And now that's Tesla.
14:33 Speaker 04 When our design expert, Paul Snyder, looks around, he really likes what some of Tesla's competitors are doing right now.
14:40 Speaker 15 I think freshest things on the road, I saw one just the other day, is the Lucid Air. Driving down the road, the thing looks like a spaceship, but it still looks like a car. It's just really something.
14:51 Speaker 04 Other car companies are now taking EV design seriously. The Germans have finally shown up. Luxury brands like BMW have long set the standard for beauty in automotive design. But that company's early EV entry, the i3, looked more like a toy car than a luxury ride. BMW's new i7 hits a very different mark. It's stately and telegraphs wealth and exclusivity. At a much more affordable price point, Tesla's competition is coming from a somewhat surprising place. It's Hyundai, a brand associated with econo car design. It's like the car you buy when you get your first real job. But the company has positioned itself as a leader in EV design. The Hyundai Ioniq 6 is a sculpted sedan with a luxe look that's won multiple design awards.
15:36 Speaker 04 As for what Tesla has cooking, there have been rumors about a new roadster and a small econo car, but as of this summer, we haven't seen them yet.
15:43 Speaker 15 So they're good, but I wouldn't say I would give them an award. I'll reconsider Tesla when they redo the Model S. I mean, how long are they going to keep selling that Model S?
15:55 Speaker 04 For the design category, we are awarding this point to the competition, at least until Tesla shows us something new.
16:06 Speaker 04 That puts the score at a dead even 1 to 1. But car design overlaps with a key area of innovation that Tesla has pioneered, and that's the user experience of driving and controlling the car through tech. So our next category, we're calling tech features.
16:23 Speaker 13 The user experience of the car was really important to me. I'm tech background. I cared about that kind of stuff. I wanted to be on the forefront of what was happening.
16:34 Speaker 07 Tesla's biggest impact on the industry, next to popularizing EVs, may have been reimagining the driving experience through technology.
16:42 Speaker 16 Everything from the experience, just unlocking it, getting it on the road. The best analogy I could feel like, it felt more like driving an iPad than driving a car.
16:51 Speaker 07 It feels like driving an iPad because Tesla basically put a big ass iPad, a tablet-like touchscreen, in all of its cars. Instead of 1,000 tiny knobs and buttons, Tesla put nearly all its controls on that one touchscreen. Because we're a smartphone-obsessed society, that experience ends up feeling pretty natural to a lot of buyers. The screen controls just about everything, basic stuff like navigation and music, but also surprising stuff, air conditioning, the windshield wipers, locking and unlocking the car. You could even access Netflix or play video games on the screen. Tesla had a few reasons for doing all this. Sure, it's a cool user experience, but getting rid of all those buttons and knobs also saved it a ton of money. Another way Tesla does tech differently,
17:34 Speaker 07 it's constantly tweaking the way its cars work through over-the-air updates.
17:38 Speaker 17 So I love that they have over-the-air updates that just you get in in the morning and you can see what's been updated over time.
17:44 Speaker 07 Like iPhones, Tesla's connect to Wi-Fi so that when the company pushes out software updates, the cars get upgraded with bug fixes and new features, just like when you wake up to a new version of iOS. And there's a reason all this is possible.
17:57 Speaker 03 Tesla's big innovation was re-architecting how all the computers in a car work together.
18:02 Speaker 07 Neelai Patel is editor in chief at The Verge.
18:05 Speaker 03 If you think about your average mass-market car, a Ford or a Chevy, what those companies fundamentally do is they assemble components from lots and lots of different suppliers. So the computer that runs the windshield wipers is totally different than the computer that runs the radio, is totally different than the computer that runs the brake lights or the cruise control. Tesla integrated all those computers. They designed their car from the ground up as a single computing environment, and they're able to ship software to that computer over the air very fast. A company like Ford or Chevy or Volvo or whoever is at the mercy of suppliers who actually write all the code for those modules in the car. And they have no unified way of updating their car's software because it's actually lots of different computers.
18:50 Speaker 07 Tesla's approach has been revolutionary, and Patel says the industry is now racing to catch up.
18:56 Speaker 03 Every carmaker has decided that Tesla's way is the right way to do it. And they are all moving towards integrating those computers as fast as they can.
19:04 Speaker 07 But surprise, surprise, the traditional automakers aren't great at tech and software. So they've outsourced parts of that experience to big tech companies. Does your car have Apple CarPlay? Do you like it better than your native system? What's that? Yes? That's just one example of many. Ultimately, this means, just as before, traditional carmakers still don't have as much control over the car as Tesla or the seamless integration.
19:28 Speaker 03 Without question, Tesla is in front in terms of what automaker at scale has the most control of the software in its cars. Tesla's miles ahead of everyone else. I think that that gap will close pretty rapidly. This is an existential problem for these companies, but Tesla's going to be in front for a while to come.
19:48 Speaker 07 No surprise here, we're giving this point to Tesla.
19:55 Speaker 07 All right, that's two points for Tesla and one for the competition. When we come back, we've got four more categories to settle who wins this battle for EV supremacy.
20:11 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
20:21 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
20:29 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
20:43 Speaker 18 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
21:08 Speaker 19 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
21:38 Speaker 20 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
22:01 Speaker 04 Okay, this is a fun one. Let's talk performance. So for years Tesla had the fastest car in the market.
22:07 Speaker 21 Ha, that is the Lucid Air Sapphire, and it's the triple motor nightmare for Elon Musk. And the one question that everyone wants answered is, will it finally unseat that fucking Tesla Model S Plaid as the quickest accelerating production car of all time?
22:24 Speaker 04 Last year, Jason Camisa hosted a definitive drag race on YouTube for Hagerty Insurance between the three fastest production cars on the planet: a Tesla, a Lucid, and a Bugatti.
22:40 Speaker 21 Oh, we're gonna have a winner.
22:43 Speaker 22 The biggest advantage that Tesla's had in terms of performance is on acceleration, right? So 0 to 60 is the common measurement of a car's acceleration capabilities, and that's where electric cars shine so well.
22:54 Speaker 04 Doug Demiro is our performance expert. He reviews cars on YouTube and started a car auction website called Cars and Bids.
23:01 Speaker 22 I think that most people, when they think of performance, they think of a car that goes fast. I think automakers in the past were hesitant to put so much performance in relatively modestly priced cars because they were afraid that people then wouldn't buy the expensive cars. And Tesla was like, forget that.
23:17 Speaker 04 Tesla started putting that speedy 0 to 60 acceleration in all of its cars, not just the high-end models, and that kicked off a trend.
23:25 Speaker 22 And so suddenly, these other automakers were like, oh crap, we can't hide our good performance behind these high price tags. We have to make them more affordable because Tesla's already done that.
23:34 Speaker 04 Now, because of Tesla, nearly all EVs are speedy, which is great for us drivers. But unless you're living like Dominic Toretto in The Fast and the Furious, speed isn't everything.
23:44 Speaker 23 I live my life a quarter mile at a time.
23:47 Speaker 22 For car enthusiasts, they also would consider performance to be things like the steering feel and the way that a car handles. Like, how does it handle through a corner? How well does it stay planted in a corner? How stable does it feel in a hard corner at high speed? And in that sense, actually, Tesla is not a particular standout and never really has been.
24:05 Speaker 04 When Demiro surveys the competition, he thinks that Ford, Hyundai, and Kia are giving Tesla a run for its money. They're all making EVs that have nailed overall great performance.
24:15 Speaker 22 But I think Tesla correctly identified that most people don't really care about that. They never really have. They just want to slam on the accelerator pedal and show their friends how fast it goes down the on-ramp. And so from a performance perspective, looking at it from the world of the car enthusiast, Teslas are fast, but not much more than that.
24:32 Speaker 04 Okay, back to Tesla's speed advantage. Remember that drag race between the Tesla, Bugatti and the Lucid?
24:38 Speaker 21 This is going to be a production car world record. The last time we raced a Lucid versus a Tesla, the Lucid was eight car lengths behind. Now it's three in front.
24:51 Speaker 04 That's right. The Lucid won and Tesla lost. By a lot. Meaning it's no longer the fastest EV. So while Tesla has moved the industry to make faster cars widely available, it appears the competition has caught up. Literally. And in other areas of performance, Tesla was already behind. So we're awarding this point to the competition.
25:17 Speaker 04 Which brings us to a dead heat at two apiece. All right, now for the slightly less fun, but super important part of owning a car. Patrick, let's talk about quality.
25:26 Speaker 07 Okay, so when it comes to quality, buyers we talked to had some strong opinions about Teslas.
25:31 Speaker 11 It just doesn't feel luxury to me.
25:34 Speaker 24 If I'm going to spend $70,000, the drive needs to feel nicer. And if it's a luxury brand, then I, as an owner, expect better.
25:43 Speaker 11 They're dumpy cars. Like, I don't know, you go inside of a Tesla and they're like, the handles are crap. It feels plastic and junk in a way that I ended up with a BMW and it's like, oh, this is an actual luxury car.
25:57 Speaker 25 Tesla is kind of considered a luxury vehicle just because of the price point. But if you actually get inside a BMW of that price range or Mercedes-Benz, it's a whole nother level. The interior materials of Tesla really aren't that different from, you know, a Hyundai or Toyota.
26:14 Speaker 07 That last voice was Jake Fisher. He's the Senior Director of Auto Testing at Consumer Reports. His publications surveys thousands of car owners closely on how much they like their cars. He says the thing about measuring quality, though, is that it can be pretty subjective.
26:27 Speaker 25 Do the cup holders fit my beverage? What about the quality of the interior fabrics? Is the ride nice?
26:36 Speaker 07 Fisher says there's a more useful way to look at all this. Instead of quality, which is vague, he directed us to a more specific metric.
26:42 Speaker 25 We're talking about reliability. We're talking about things that have gone wrong. So things that broke, things that require you to take the car to the dealership to get resolved.
26:52 Speaker 07 Essentially, how does the car hold up over time?
26:55 Speaker 25 Reliability problems or those problems are not created equal. For instance, you might be in your car and it doesn't start and you can't go anywhere. Well, that's a severe problem. You could also have a problem where a piece of trim has broken off and has landed in your lap. Well, that's a less severe problem. It doesn't stop you from driving your vehicle. However, you do have to get it fixed and you are not very happy. And you may wind up having to have someone do service on the vehicle. So we actually weight all those when we're talking about true reliability. And we predict the reliability of the new vehicles based on the history.
27:31 Speaker 07 And when he looks at Tesla and weighs in all those factors, he says Tesla's reliability record isn't stellar, but it could be worse.
27:38 Speaker 25 We don't see a lot of powertrain problems. We don't see a lot of major mechanical problems. But we see a lot of the types of issues that I would say that most of the industry has resolved 50 years ago. Like an issue where the hatch does not close or the door doesn't close or the paint isn't, you know, is scraping off because of really poor fitment.
27:59 Speaker 07 Problems like this would kill the reputation of a car from a traditional company. But Fisher says Tesla owners often react a bit more like gadget buyers than car buyers. That early adopters typically expect their product to be a little buggy.
28:11 Speaker 25 The same people who have the problems are telling us they're happy. So is it possible that the manufacturer, that Tesla's saying, wow, if we want to make our customers happy, maybe I should worry less about making that door close and more about giving them the latest feature. They didn't choose to buy a boring Toyota, for instance, you know, that's going to be reliable and run for 300,000 miles or whatever. Their priority is getting the latest and greatest. And they probably understand that there's going to be growing pains with that latest technology.
28:40 Speaker 07 But what about other EVs?
28:42 Speaker 25 What's interesting is what we find in our data is that the manufacturers that have been building internal combustion engine vehicles for 100 years are struggling more than Tesla when it comes to electric vehicle stuff. We're talking power converters and batteries and charging and motors and all those. They're struggling more. And the reason is that Tesla actually has been doing it for a lot longer than they have.
29:08 Speaker 07 But now, Fisher says some of Tesla's competitors are figuring it out.
29:12 Speaker 25 The Korean triplets, I would call them, the Kia EV6, the Hyundai IONIQ 5 and the Hyundai IONIQ 6, the Genesis GV60. These are vehicles that really are, they feel really well-built. The reliability that we've seen is just top-notch. They're very solid vehicles. You look at BMW, for instance, with the i4 and the iX. I mean, these are just exceptionally solid vehicles.
29:36 Speaker 07 So some good cars from the competition, but it's not all bad news for Tesla. Fisher says the older, less popular cars like the Model X have more issues, but the newer, simpler, more popular cars like the Model 3, they actually do all right.
29:49 Speaker 25 The Tesla Model 3 has been consistently average. I'm not saying that it's bad. I'm not saying it's the best car in the world, but we do recommend the Tesla Model 3. In fact, it is overall, while they may have a fair amount of problems, they aren't major problems. So it is a bit of a push.
30:06 Speaker 07 Okay, we gotta go with our expert on this one. If he says it's a push, I guess we have to award this point to no one.
30:14 Speaker 07 Meaning we're still all tied up. So let's talk about everyone's least favorite part of owning a car: the buying it part.
30:23 Speaker 04 Okay, so say you want to buy a new car. Cars are a huge, important purchase, typically the biggest or second biggest a person might make next to a house. And for most shoppers, buying a new car means going inside a dealership, test-driving a couple, haggling over price, and eventually signing on the dotted line. A lot of people hate this experience.
30:44 Speaker 12 The dealership model is extremely unattractive. There is nothing attractive about the dealership model.
30:52 Speaker 16 You're trying to get out of there and they bring their sales manager in to try and do another negotiation. It's always a very disappointing experience.
31:00 Speaker 13 They were trying to hard-sell me. They're trying to negotiate me and trying to make a lot of money on me at the dealerships. It was like a horrible experience.
31:09 Speaker 04 Meanwhile, Tesla offers a very different experience.
31:13 Speaker 16 With Tesla, it just felt completely the opposite.
31:16 Speaker 04 Tesla's approach is very elegant and simplifies things. If you want to buy a Tesla, you can just order one online, or you can visit a physical Tesla store and order one there. The options are intentionally limited. Just a few colors, just a few models, no special Eddie Bauer additions here. And there's no haggling. The price is the price. Simple, right? Except Tesla recently complicated things by upending its own way of doing business. It started cutting prices by a lot.
31:44 Speaker 10 We never really saw such a drastic reduction in their prices on their model lineup in the company's history before. So that was a pretty clear indication that they were worried about the competition.
31:57 Speaker 04 Here's The Verge's Andrew Hawkins again.
31:59 Speaker 10 They were seeing all of these other EVs coming down the market, and they were concerned that they weren't going to be the first choice for most of these customers, that if a customer was out shopping for an EV, that maybe they'd buy a Ford before they'd buy a Tesla, because Ford was a trusted brand, a recognizable logo. It didn't maybe have as much baggage attached to it as Tesla seems to have. So I think those price reductions were a pretty big red flag in terms of the thought processes that are going on at Tesla HQ.
32:28 Speaker 04 And these price fluctuations can be frustrating.
32:31 Speaker 06 You know, annoys certain existing customers, because if you paid $60,000 for a Model Y yesterday, and today it's $52,000, and they're not giving you a rebate, boy, that sucks. And then it's also confusing for customers, I think. You know, and like, well, I'm gonna buy it, but maybe if I wait a week, it'll go down in price.
32:49 Speaker 04 Or, as noted scholar Fat Joe would say, Yesterday's price is not today's price. No one likes price volatility. That's part of the whole reason people hate going to a dealership to buy a car.
33:03 Speaker 04 We're still going to give a slight edge to Tesla in this category. Sure, the price changes are annoying, but the experience of buying the car is still generally easier. So, point to Tesla.
33:16 Speaker 04 Which means Tesla has regained the lead 3-2 going into our seventh and final category, brand.
33:23 Speaker 07 Okay, let's talk brands because what we buy often comes down to how we perceive a brand.
33:28 Speaker 26 Can you really tell the difference in Coke versus Pepsi?
33:31 Speaker 07 Scott Galloway is our brand expert. He's a professor of marketing at NYU School of Business and co-host of Vox Media's tech podcast Pivot.
33:38 Speaker 26 I do a test taste with my students. They love Grey Goose vodka. 90% of them can't tell the difference between that and Smirnoff, which is a vodka at a fraction of the price.
33:49 Speaker 07 Galloway says when it comes to brand identity, Tesla has always excelled.
33:53 Speaker 26 It's an unbelievable brand. Huge depth of associations, personification through Elon Musk, his mastery of new mediums to get attention without paying for traditional branding. He's put on a masterclass on how to build a global brand of that depth in less than a decade.
34:11 Speaker 07 He says that when you choose a brand, it says something about you, especially when you buy a Tesla.
34:16 Speaker 26 It not only says that you like innovative products and you care about the environment and you're wealthy, which are all wonderful things, it also says that you're an Elon fan.
34:25 Speaker 07 And that last part is starting to become an issue for Tesla.
34:28 Speaker 26 There's a lot of people who are no longer Elon fans.
34:31 Speaker 17 The image that I had of it was sort of like, kind of like a tech jerk.
34:35 Speaker 11 There's still the libertarian D-bag Tesla drivers.
34:39 Speaker 08 Anti-trans, misogynistic.
34:42 Speaker 11 I'm Jewish and I chose a BMW, a German car, over a Tesla for like, partially because of moral reasons.
34:53 Speaker 07 A lot of people are sick of Elon Musk. That's not news, but it is a reality for this brand and our association with it. And all of this is happening at a time when the competition is gaining and in some cases surpassing Tesla in key categories. And a lot of those companies are legacy brands that buyers have a long history with.
35:10 Speaker 26 Some of the best brands in the world are in this sector. I think Hyundai surprisingly has been one of the more innovative automobile companies. I don't think anyone was expecting it. But companies like BMW and Mercedes, they have such a depth of brand equity.
35:28 Speaker 26 And they kind of go after, I think, the similar luxury buyer. I think those brands just continue to resonate with people.
35:34 Speaker 07 As more people switch to EVs and more EV options become available, customers will have to increasingly ask themselves, which brand is right for me? But here's the thing, for now, despite all the baggage, Galloway says you just can't count Tesla or Elon Musk out.
35:50 Speaker 26 Everyone's coming for his launch, and you know what? He keeps figuring out a way to outrun them.
35:54 Speaker 07 Just look at the Model Y. It's the best-selling car in the world so far this year.
35:58 Speaker 26 As it relates to EVs, they're the original gangster.
36:03 Speaker 07 Like it or not, the point goes to Tesla.
36:07 Speaker 07 Which means Tesla wins 4 to 2. It was close, but as our expert pointed out, Tesla is the OG. It's the Kleenex of EVs, the Coca-Cola, the brand that defined the category. That's powerful stuff. Tesla created a market for EVs and over the last 20 years has pushed the rest of the industry to follow in its own image. The industry has followed. Now, in a lot of ways, it's actually ahead of Tesla in categories like performance and design, for instance. But it's not quite enough to win. Tesla is still very much the king of EVs in America with a bigger slice of the market than all other EV makers combined. For now, anyway.
36:52 Speaker 07 Next time on Land of the Giants. After Elon Musk bought Twitter, you probably saw a lot of the headlines about how intense it was to work under him. But Musk's hardcore management style was old news for a lot of folks who have worked for Tesla. And if you didn't want to work six days a week, if you didn't want to, like, you know, work extra hours, if you didn't want that, what happened to you?
37:11 Speaker 23 You didn't want.
37:16 Speaker 23 Won't, no. You gon' work six days or you gon' find you another job. This is how this company was.
37:24 Speaker 07 That's next time on the Tesla Shock Wave. Musk wants to change the world, but at what cost?
37:32 Speaker 04 Land of the Giants, the Tesla Shockwave is produced by the Vox Media Podcast Network in partnership with our colleagues at The Verge.
37:39 Speaker 07 Our producer is Charlotte Silver. Zach Mack is our showrunner and senior producer. Jolie Myers is our editor.
37:45 Speaker 04 Clara Cronin is our fact checker. Adrian Lilly mixed and scored this episode. Andrew Hawkins is transportation editor at The Verge.
37:53 Speaker 07 Nishat Kurwa is our executive producer. My co-host is Tamara Warren. And I'm Patrick George. Follow us to hear our next episode when it drops.
38:17 Speaker 27 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
38:48 Speaker 28 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous There's no AI without the cloud, says AWS CEO Adam Selipsky Next Fandom runs some of the biggest communities on the web. Can CEO Perkins Miller keep them happy? Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated