Skip to content

How Utah locals fought Kevin O'Leary's AI data center

Decoder

44m
Transcript

Original podcast

Where to listen

Summary

Written by a model from the transcript; not yet reviewed.

In this episode of Decoder, host Nilay Patel speaks with Verge features writer Josh Jezza about the political firestorm surrounding Kevin O'Leary's proposed Wonder Valley data center project in Utah, also known as Stratos. The project aimed to build a massive 40,000-acre AI campus requiring over nine gigawatts of power, but it was approved through an obscure military development agency without the knowledge of local county officials or residents. The guest and host explain how a diverse coalition of local activists mounted a fierce backlash against the secrecy, environmental risks, and lack of tangible community benefits, ultimately stalling the development and triggering political casualties.

The discussion explores the broader dynamics of the tech industry's frantic AI infrastructure boom, where speculative developers race to assemble powered land and flip it to hyperscalers for massive markups. The conversation highlights how tech companies run into local democracy as an insurmountable obstacle when communities reject projects that offer all costs and no upsides. Through specific examples like O'Leary's public confrontations and subsequent defamation lawsuit, the episode illustrates the growing friction between the hyperscalers' quest for speed and the stark economic and political realities of local opposition.

  • Data center developers often rely on state-level development agencies to bypass local zoning and land-use regulations before residents even know a project exists. 7:50
  • Local communities are mobilizing against massive AI data centers because the projects offer high environmental costs with zero tangible local benefits. 13:29
  • Speculative developers use powered land assembly to promise giant facilities to hyperscalers, selling packages for up to twenty times the raw land cost. 28:40
  • Widespread grassroots pushback and political accountability can successfully stall billion-dollar data center projects despite extreme industry momentum. 39:05

Chapters

  1. 0:00
    Show Introduction and Sponsorship

    The episode opens with sponsor messages and a brief host introduction.

  2. 1:40
    Host and Guest Introduction

    Neil Appetel introduces Josh Jezza and outlines the Utah data center story.

  3. 2:15
    Political Fallout and Local Opposition

    The project sparked a political firestorm, halting progress and igniting protests.

  4. 6:28
    Approval Process and Secretive Planning

    O'Leary leveraged a military agency to secure approvals before local governments were informed.

  5. 12:00
    Community Response and NIMBYism

    Residents united across political lines to oppose the project, citing environmental and local concerns.

  6. 25:56
    Financial Dynamics of Data Center Builds

    Investors and credit institutions drive the rapid pace of data center development, often ignoring local impact.

  7. 33:09
    Broader Implications for AI Infrastructure

    The Utah case illustrates the tension between AI infrastructure expansion and local democracy.

  8. 38:16
    Takeaways for Other Communities

    Listeners learn how grassroots opposition can influence large tech projects nationwide.

  9. 46:56
    Closing Remarks and Episode Wrap‑Up

    The host thanks the guest, summarizes key points, and invites listeners to follow the show.

Highlights

  • 6:35

    Secret State Approvalsstory

    The guest explains how Kevin O'Leary's project gained approval through an obscure state agency called MITDA without the county government even knowing about it until a month before the public announcement.

  • 13:50

    Zero Local Upsideinsight

    The guest points out that unlike historical manufacturing projects, data centers fail to excite local communities because they do not create meaningful local jobs or economic upside.

  • 21:27

    Political Casualties in Utahdata

    The guest details the political fallout in Utah, where two local commissioners and Senate President Stuart Adams lost their seats over their association with the controversial project.

  • 23:59

    Backfiring Partisan Tacticsstory

    The guest describes how Kevin O'Leary's strategy of attacking protesters and accusing them of being Chinese agents on Fox News completely backfired and mobilized more opposition.

  • 26:31

    The Speed of Speculationstrategy

    The guest breaks down how the data center boom is driven by hyperscalers racing toward AGI, causing developers to rush powered land assemblies and jam up utility queues.

  • 28:19

    The Rise of Powered Landinsight

    The guest explains how developers assemble land and power capacity to flip packages to hyperscalers for twenty times the cost of raw land.

Quotes

  • “The project is technically called Stratos, but it's more prominently known as Wonder Valley, a reference to O'Leary's nickname on Shark Tank.”
    Unnamed speaker · 2:02
  • “The data center race is all about speed, and now this is looking like it doesn't have that momentum it had earlier.”
    Unnamed speaker · 22:10
  • “There would be 13,000 jobs, and none of that happened.”
    Unnamed speaker · 4:22
  • “The sheer volume of outrage, kind of the response from the state and local government.”
    Unnamed speaker · 38:33
  • CrowdStrike 0:00–0:28
  • Doppel 0:42–1:08
  • CrowdStrike 15:59–16:15
  • T-Mobile 16:58–17:34
  • Pipedrive 18:04–18:57
  • American Express 36:24–36:43
  • Upwork 36:51–37:42
  • Apple 47:34–47:59
  • 20th Century Studios 48:04–48:12

About this episode

Today I’m talking with Josh Dzieza, a longtime features writer here at The Verge, about a massive data center in Utah that does not exist, might never exist, and yet has already completely reshaped the politics of the entire state. Josh just published a major feature this week on the struggling Stratos data center project in Utah backed by Shark Tank star Kevin O’Leary. So I invited Josh on the show to discuss what’s happening inside the AI industry’s infrastructure boom, inside the bipartisan backlash to data centers, and how the tech industry is running into the one obstacle it can’t seem to spend its way out of: local democracy. Read the ⁠full interview transcript on The Verge⁠. Links: The People of Utah vs. Kevin O'Leary | The Verge Adams — burdened by data center fallout — ousted by voters | Salt Lake Tribune ‘Shark Tank’ star sued by opponents he claimed were foreign agents| NYT Fox News apologizes for airing O’Leary claims about data centers | The Hill Kevin O’Leary agrees to downsize massive Utah data center | The Verge The biggest data center ever is becoming a huge problem in Utah | The Verge America's data center future is Loudoun County's past | The Verge The left and right agree on one thing: no data centers | Decoder Decoder is a Signal Awards finalist in the Business category! You can vote to help us win ⁠here⁠. Subscribe to The Verge to access the ad-free version of Decoder! Credits: Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Decoder’s producers are Greg Ott, Kate Cox, and Nick Statt. This episode was edited by Ursa Wright. Our editorial director is Kevin McShane. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript

0:00
44:44

8,203 words · 17 speakers

Topics

  • Stratos
  • Meta
  • The Verge
  • Wonder Valley
  • MITDA
  • AMX Corporate
  • Fox News
  • Box Elder County
  • Anthropic
  • Great Salt Lake

Page updated · transcript and summary are machine-generated