Pod Insights Decoder Harvard professor Lawrence Lessig on why AI and social media are causing a free speech crisis for the internet About this episode Today, I’m talking to internet policy legend Lawrence Lessig. He's been teaching law for more than 30 years, and is a defining expert on free speech and the internet — and something of a hero of mine, whose works I've been reading since college.
You’ll hear us agree that the internet at this moment in time is absolutely flooded with disinformation, misinformation, and other really toxic stuff that’s harmful to us as individuals and, frankly, to our future as a functioning democracy. But you’ll also hear us disagree a fair amount about what to do about it. The First Amendment, AI, copyright law — there's a lot to unpack here.
Links:
https://asml.cyber.harvard.edu/
https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/10/17/1081194/how-to-fix-the-internet-online-discourse/
https://www.protocol.com/facebook-papers
https://www.tiktok.com/@aocinthehouse/video/7214318917135830318?lang=en
https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/sensitive-claims-bias-facebook-relaxed-misinformation-rules-conservative-pages-n1236182
https://bigthink.com/neuropsych/repetition-lie-truth-propaganda/
https://www.theverge.com/23883027/alvarez-stolen-valor-first-amendment-kosseff-liar-crowded-theater
https://fortune.com/2023/05/30/sam-altman-ai-risk-of-extinction-pandemics-nuclear-warfare/
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/intellectual_property_law/publications/landslide/2019-20/september-october/into-fandomverse/
Transcript: https://www.theverge.com/e/23693274
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 10,516 words · 8 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Harvard law professor and internet policy legend Lawrence Lessig. Larry is a defining expert when it comes to free speech and the internet. He's taught law for more than 30 years at the University of Chicago, Stanford, and Harvard. He co-founded the Creative Commons in 2001, and he's published a dozen books since 1999, delving into the intersection of communications, money, the media, the internet, and democracy itself. Larry is a hero of mine. I have been reading him since I was in college, and so much of his work has directly shaped so much of my thinking. It was an honor to spend some time with him.
1:50 Speaker 03 But I gotta tell you, this episode is a little looser than usual. See, the Decoder crew was in Boston last week for the launch of Harvard's new applied social media lab, which Larry is a part of. The launch event for the lab was a glitzy affair, featuring a number of guest speakers, including former President Barack Obama, who was set to join Decoder and talk about how social media can actually benefit democracy and how we might build towards that goal. Unfortunately, President Obama had to drop out of the event due to an illness. We are working with his team on rescheduling that conversation, which we're excited to have for you in the future. Happily, Larry was available to fill in, and he was more than prepared to dive deep on the big issues that the lab was designed to address and that I've been thinking
2:34 Speaker 03 about quite a bit lately. As you'll hear us say, there's a lot to unpack here. You'll hear us agree that the internet at this moment in time is absolutely flooded with misinformation, disinformation, and other really toxic stuff. It's harmful to us as individuals and frankly, to our future as a functioning democracy. But you'll hear us disagree a fair amount about what to do about it. Here in the United States, the First Amendment puts really strong protections around speech and heavily limits what the government can do to regulate any of it, even outright lies, as we saw with both COVID and the 2020 election. But because there's so much stuff on the internet that people do want taken down, a number of strategies to get around the First Amendment have cropped up. For example, there is one law that is
3:19 Speaker 03 really effective at regulating speech on the internet: copyright law. Filing a DMCA claim on something is one of the fastest ways to get it removed from the internet. And there's a whole folk understanding of copyright law, which is often wrong, that has sprung up in the creator economy. For example, Larry and I talked about the current and recurring controversies around React videos on YouTube. Not what they are, but what that controversy represents. The users of a platform trying to establish their own culture around what people can and cannot remix and reuse. Their own speech regulations based in copyright law. That is a fascinating cultural development. There's a lot of approaches to create these kinds of speech regulations that get around the First Amendment. And
4:01 Speaker 03 I wanted to know how Larry felt about that as someone who has been writing about speech on the internet for so long. His answers really surprised me. Of course, we also had to talk about AI. You'll hear us pull apart two different kinds of AI that are really shaping our cultural experiences right now. There's algorithmic AI, which runs the recommendation engines on social platforms and tries to keep you engaged. And then there's the new world of generative AI, which everyone agrees is a huge risk for the spread of misinformation, both today and in the future, but which no two people quite seem to agree on how to tackle. Larry's thoughts here were surprising. Maybe, he says, we just need to get all of politics offline if we're going to solve this problem. This conversation is full of twists and turns. I came away with so much to think about. And like I said, it's pretty loose.
4:46 Speaker 03 Professor Lessig just agreed to come hang out with me at the last minute and we just talked about it. Maybe we should do all of our decoders like this. Okay, Professor Lawrence Lessig, here we go.
5:08 Speaker 03 Lawrence Lessig, you are a professor of law at Harvard Law School. You've written a lot about copyright law, a lot of which I read when I was a young law student. Welcome to Decoder.
5:19 Speaker 04 Thank you for having me.
5:20 Speaker 03 I am really excited to talk to you. We are here at Harvard, which just launched the Applied Social Media Lab, which is intended to study the future of social media and its interaction with democracy. There's a lot of ideas to unpack there. Really quickly, tell us what the lab is meant to do and your involvement in it.
5:38 Speaker 04 I think what's important is how it wants to do it. So what the lab is going to do is bring people from industry, not loaned from industry, but people who have kind of left industry, who have decided they want to try to do good in the world, into the context of Harvard Law School, where we'll have policy people engaging with technology people, architecting how we could build a better social media. And of course, social media means media generally. So how we can take what has turned into a really poisonous soup and filter it into something that might actually be helpful for democracy.
6:13 Speaker 03 There's a few things happening right now in that soup that are new, one of which is AI, which I want to talk about. Another is two different wars and two different fronts that are defined by miss and disinformation at scale. And a third is what feels to me like a generational reset of how we think about social media at large. We came through the Facebook era, we went through what you might call the Twitter era. The Twitter era is definitively over. It is now a different company with a different name. And it feels like a younger generation is looking at social media differently. They've been raised with different expectations. All of that feels like... Well, we've been at this for over a decade. Should we try something new or something meaningful finally going to change? Do you feel that as well?
6:58 Speaker 04 Absolutely. I think that the worst part of social media's place in society is people not understanding, in fact, what it is. Like, people have a naive view. They open up their X feed or their Facebook feed, and they're just getting stuff that's given to them in some kind of neutral way, not recognizing that behind what's given to them is the most extraordinary intelligence that we have ever created, AI, that is extremely good at figuring out how to tweak the attitudes or emotions of the people they're engaging with to drive them down rabbit holes of engagement. The only thing they care about is engagement.
7:43 Speaker 04 And so, you know, the Facebook files, which two years ago were released by Frances Haugen, I was honored to be able to represent her at the first stages of that. If you look at the Facebook files, they are filled with engineers, really good engineers, trying to do the right thing, trying to talk about how to make the platform safer so it doesn't, like, lead young girls to commit suicide or doesn't lead to radicalism in politics. And again and again, they were overruled by people who were focused on the business model of engagement to drive profits. And I think once you step back and you realize, wow, all of this is being fed to me for a reason, and the reason really has nothing to do with making democracy work better or helping me understand the world better.
8:27 Speaker 04 It's all about using me for an end that is not my own end. And the AIs that are doing it are the most powerful intelligence that has ever tried to do this. And it's terrifying when you realize it because not clear what we do about it.
8:44 Speaker 03 So there's a lot to unpack there, right? There's the commercial incentives of the social media platforms. There is the notion that we should regulate them in some way. There's the emergence of new technology, which... Might be hard to understand for even the technologists, let alone the average person. Let's start with that middle bit, how we might regulate it. In countries around the world, in Europe in particular, in China most particularly, the governments just go ahead and regulate the social media networks, right? They do not have the restrictions on speech regulations that we have in this country with the First Amendment. We keep trying to get around it, right? There's like a number of ways our government tries to get around it. Lately, it seems like you can just be Republican and pass some speech regulations
9:26 Speaker 03 in Texas and Florida, and we'll just see how that goes. You can ban some books. You might do what's called jawboning, where the Biden administration put a lot of forceful pressure on Facebook and other platforms. They got themselves in trouble, but they did it. Or you could use other laws, right? You could use copyright law, which is a frequent stand-in for speech regulations because everyone kind of accepts it. Is that an appropriate approach? Like, we can't just do it straight up because of the First Amendment, so we'll find other ways to do it.
9:57 Speaker 04 So it's first important to be clear about the first part of what you said, which I think is really important, and that is the way other countries are actually doing it. You know, so in China, which obviously is not a political system to be recommended, but we can observe that there's a Chinese version of TikTok and there's an American version of TikTok. And the American version of TikTok is completely uncontrolled. It runs all the time. It feeds the worst possible content to especially young people to drive them to engage. The Chinese version of TikTok is blocked during certain hours. It limits the total amount of time you're allowed to be on it. The substance of what it provides
10:38 Speaker 04 is like aiming to like lead people to want to be astronauts. You know, if you ask our kids what their number one dream job is, it's being a social influencer. If you ask the Chinese kids, it's being an astronaut. That's not an accident. That's not like the free market working. That is an intentional design decision that they're making towards helping their kids and we're making towards giving up.
11:03 Speaker 03 But I would say if you went and asked A bunch of parents in America, should the government pass some speech regulations? That makes our TikTok look more like Chinese TikTok? And then you describe those outcomes, they would say yes. And then you would have to say, well, we can't because of the First Amendment. And that seems like a really important tension that we are facing.
11:19 Speaker 04 Right, even like among my own colleagues, you know, we have this conversation about how should the First Amendment be applied in this context? I mean, let's, let's take a very precise example. Imagine China invaded Taiwan tomorrow and immediately started amplifying all the American voices on TikTok that were saying that Taiwan had it coming, China's the natural leader for this area. It's ridiculous that we've been resisting one China for so many years. And suppressed all the American voices on that platform that were saying, um, this is outrageous. This is a free people, blah, blah, blah. That decision to suppress and amplify is what we call editorial judgment. It is the core of First Amendment protection.
12:03 Speaker 04 So when you say, could we do anything about it? The standard First Amendment answer is no, there's nothing you could do about that. That's absolutely the most protected thing you could have. And, you know, it's amazing to see how we slid to this position of being vulnerable in this way. If in 1960, the Soviet Union had come to the FCC and said, we'd like to open up a news station in the United States for Americans to consume in the United States. The FCC, of course, would have blocked it, but we've moved to a place where we have no capacity, no legal capacity to do anything about this kind of influence, with the consequence being that we are so incredibly vulnerable. And the First Amendment, you know, is basically going to knock down most of these experiments that are happening within the States.
12:49 Speaker 04 What saddened me the most about this, you know, when Francis Haugen originally testified in the fall of 2021, there was a wide range of agreement among Republicans and Democrats. This was a huge problem. We needed to do something about it. And then AOC did her first TikTok. And her first TikTok was rejecting the idea that the United States government should do something to respond to TikTok. And her basic argument was, it's unfair to do something to TikTok when we still have not passed any privacy legislation in the United States. Which first of all demonstrated she didn't understand anything about the nature of the problem. And number two demonstrated that money has gone into the Democratic Party in a way to
13:32 Speaker 04 divide the two parties when it comes to social media and what we do about social media. So the First Amendment, of course, is an important barrier, but even more important than the First Amendment is the fact that the economy of influence that's governing in this space is an economy of influence of money.
13:49 Speaker 03 So I'm more cynical about this than you are, maybe even more cynical than you are.
13:52 Speaker 04 Wow, that's kind of hard to believe.
13:53 Speaker 03 I am pretty cynical about the bipartisan nature, or the supposed bipartisan nature of wanting to regulate Facebook. What I see is a bunch of politicians on both sides who know the First Amendment exists, who can't just go ask the platforms for content moderation that would favor their party. So whenever they see a weapon, like the Haugen papers, the Facebook files, they say, oh, we can just threaten you with legislation that may or may not pass, but we'll threaten you with it, and that'll be a lawsuit, and that'll be a long process for you to go fight it, and the public opinion will be against you. Or you can just change your rules. You can just moderate content to favor Republicans or favor the Democrats. I see that cycle play out over and over and over again. And to me, it appears to be wholly in bad faith.
14:38 Speaker 04 Yeah.
14:39 Speaker 03 Right? The First Amendment exists, no one wants to go litigate whether the government should make speech regulations. But can we go threaten a bunch of these companies with pretend legislation or manufactured outrage because of what has been leaked? Sure, we can. And then maybe they'll turn the knobs and amplify our content more. That cycle seems to be more dangerous than almost anything, right? Because it is effectively speech regulation and practical impact on these companies without any sort of oversight or any check on how much it might be imposed.
15:07 Speaker 04 Yeah, absolutely. And that's exactly what happened in 2016 and in 2020. Indeed, the Facebook files demonstrated that though, you know, for example, conservatives said that they were being discriminated against by these platforms. In fact, the interventions from the political department of Facebook overwhelmingly were interventions to bend the rules in favor of allowing conservatives to do whatever they wanted on the platform. So you're right, that dynamic was certainly what happened in that election. 2024.
15:34 Speaker 04 It will be that plus, order of magnitude greater danger, produced by foreign governments that have targeted the United States in this election. Like, you know, there are all sorts of stories of the Russians in 2016 and 2020, the Chinese in 2024 have all, it's already revealed this is what they're doing. The first round will be the Taiwanese elections in January of 24, where they have already begun to figure out how they can flood that space to create disinformation to tilt the election in the way that they want to tilt it. But that's just a dry run. In fact, the technology they're using will work better in America than it does in Taiwan, because it turns out the AI is better tuned to English than it is to the Taiwanese version of Chinese.
16:18 Speaker 04 And so we will be completely vulnerable to something that has as its purpose screwing up our election. Look, you know, Mark Zuckerberg doesn't hate America. Facebook wasn't trying to destroy American democracy. He was just trying to make money. But now you'll have even more sophisticated AI focused like a laser on blowing up the basic institutions.
16:40 Speaker 03 And the mechanism of this AI, or the expression of this AI in your mind is specifically TikTok?
16:45 Speaker 04 It's the algorithms behind things like TikTok, but it's also, more importantly, the content generation capabilities that LLMs will give them. So, you know, the LLM capability to mislead people into believing that they are engaging with certain people about certain things, that they've seen a certain speech by Obama, or a speech by Biden, or a speech by Trump. All of these things that we don't have any defense mechanism for right now will just flood into the system. You know, think of it like pathogens, like they will just spread pathogens throughout the system, and we have no antibodies for them. And we, as you're pointing out, because you're obviously legally educated, we also have a constitutional barrier to building those antibodies,
17:28 Speaker 04 or at least the government taking steps to build those antibodies, and the most dominant platforms for facilitating the spread of information have basically given up. You know, I'm not sure what Facebook will actually do in 2024. They're back and forth about it, but Elon Musk. Musk has fired the election team. I mean, you know, that platform alone is like terrifying from its effect of what it's going to do for misunderstanding in this context.
17:54 Speaker 03 Just assuming it's still there by the time.
17:56 Speaker 04 Assuming, right, something like that. But you know, you know, this war in Israel right now, I think, is like a perfect example of this, like the level of misinformation on both sides is astonishing. And yet you don't see people reacting in a healthy way. It's not like you see them like shifting to sources that will help them understand. Instead, they're doubling down on the sources that help them to misunderstand. I think one of the most startling facts that of the past, you know, three years, after January 6th, a bunch of polling reported in January of 2021, found that 70% of Republicans believed Donald Trump that the election was stolen.
18:40 Speaker 04 And when that number came out, everybody was saying, well, you know, that's, that's just temporary. They'll, they'll, they'll get it. Like eventually they'll just kind of relax.
18:48 Speaker 03 That was always wishful thinking in my mind.
18:50 Speaker 04 And it went down a little bit, but it's now come back up. And you know, if we were like talking about the Soviet Union and you said, well, you know, in the Soviet Union, they believe that America caused the war in whatever, and they still believe that completely false fact, we'd say, yeah, well, that's because you've got state run media. Well, we don't have state run media here, but you can still perpetrate an obvious lie. And that stays and that's not just stays, it gets embedded into the identity of the people who consume that media. And not accidentally, both because the business model of social media is engagement and it turns out the politics of hate is the most effective way to get people to follow.
19:34 Speaker 04 And also because they're strategic bad actors who are very good at leveraging and using the platform.
19:41 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
19:52 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
20:01 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
20:09 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
20:23 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration blog, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18+.
20:51 Speaker 03 We're back with Professor Lawrence Lessig, talking about the algorithms that power social media and how they're used to spread lies and misinformation. There's the AI-powered recommendation algorithms that a normal consumer encounters when they use a platform. So there, I think you have a TikTok problem. Right? The Chinese government is entangled with TikTok in some way, is meaningful or not. It's actually very hard to know. But they are definitely entangled with ByteDance, which owns TikTok. And people might encounter those recommendation algorithms. Those are obviously opaque. Everyone's pages are similarly opaque, so there's not even a shared cultural context behind the algorithms everyone is experiencing there. That's one bit of regulation. And you can see that the government might be able
21:34 Speaker 03 to fumble its way towards a theory of banning or restricting TikTok, or forcing a sale to Oracle, all these ideas that they've tried. Right? This is a foreign actor. They have built a distribution channel to millions upon millions of young Americans. We should probably take a look at that. You can see how the government could wind its way to the Supreme Court and potentially win on some theory of restricting that platform. The other part of it, oh, there's a bunch of LLMs in the world that can be used to make misinformation. And we should impose some sort of regulatory structure such that you can't just lie to people at scale. That runs headfirst into the First Amendment. Even if you're a foreign national in this country and you decide to use Google Bard to tell you a lie, that's fine. I can't figure out how to make that illegal.
22:18 Speaker 03 Can you figure out how to make that illegal?
22:21 Speaker 04 So let's talk about both. Yeah, I think it's nice that you unpack them that way. The TikTok issue is, I think, extremely hard. You know, Montana has basically passed a law to ban TikTok. Immediately TikTok filed a suit challenging it, bringing a whole bunch of artists forward who said that their whole livelihood was TikTok, so therefore it's the core of First Amendment protection. And I think it's going to be hard under the First Amendment. I mean, I actually volunteered to help Montana defend their law, but I think it's going to be hard. But even if you solve the foreign influence problem, you still haven't solved the business model problem. Because even if you know that China is not intentionally trying to screw with the elections,
23:05 Speaker 04 you still have a platform that's trying to figure out how do you make people spend more time on the platform? And it just is our psychology that the best way to do that is to turn us into conspiracy theorists who are crazy about all sorts of.
23:19 Speaker 03 I think, I just want to, I agree with you in that that is effective. I don't think it's the best way. And I would actually offer you one very meaningful counter example, which is I think Taylor Swift is a much more powerful figure in American culture and politics right now, and she's done the exact opposite, which is harder.
23:36 Speaker 04 Yeah.
23:37 Speaker 03 I mean, I think it's cheaper and easier to make people angry, but it's more effective and more durable.
23:40 Speaker 04 Absolutely, absolutely. But you know, the question is, if you are sitting there watching week by week engagement numbers.
23:49 Speaker 03 Sure.
23:50 Speaker 04 Taylor Swift invested a long time in building the brand that would make it so that she could be an oracle of something good and true.
23:58 Speaker 03 But I'm saying most durable art makes people feel good, not bad, right?
24:03 Speaker 04 So I love what she's doing. She's a hero.
24:05 Speaker 03 I'm not asking you to criticize Taylor Swift. I'm just challenging your premise that the single most effective way to build engagement is anger.
24:12 Speaker 04 Yeah, but I would just say that, you know, the fact that you can point to Taylor Swift, and I can point to everything in social media, doesn't mean that I've lost the argument. I mean, you're right. Taylor Swift is a good example.
24:24 Speaker 03 Marvel movies. You can pick any number of things that make people generally feel good.
24:27 Speaker 04 Okay, so let's just recognize that's going to be a hard problem. And people feeling good doesn't mean that they know the truth. You know, there are a lot of people who believe the big lie, who feel good about what they're doing, like they're defending the truth, defending America against, and they're told that in a very positive way. So I'm not, I'm not saying that-
24:48 Speaker 03 Would you make that illegal? The thing that I'm stuck on here is, again, I came up reading your work, which was very much in favor of loosened speech regulations. And in particular, I think the stuff that you have published that has been most meaningful to me is the idea that the more we tend towards copyright maximalism, the more we sort of backdoor our way into speech regulations. So that Disney is now in control of art, because Disney has overwhelming copyright protection. It feels like you're arguing the flip now, that we actually need some more speech regulations, that we should find a way to regulate what is allowed on these platforms, or what people are allowed to make with technology. That feels like a really big shift for you.
25:28 Speaker 04 I don't think it's a flip, but I wouldn't admit it's a flip, right? But I don't feel like it's a flip. It feels like it's a different problem. Right? So I don't favor the idea of speech regulations in the sense of the government deciding which speech is allowed and which it isn't. I think it's important, though, that government's allowed to address a new kind of problem. Algorithms are a new kind of problem. You know, some people say, "When the algorithm decides to feed me stuff that makes me believe that vaccines don't work, that's just like the New York Times editors choosing to put certain things on the op-ed page or not." It's not. It's not at all like that. Like, when the New York Times humans make that judgment, they make a judgment that's reflecting values and understanding of the world and what they think they're trying to produce.
26:13 Speaker 04 When the algorithm, like, figures out what to feed you so that you engage more because you believe vaccines don't work, that is not those humans. And indeed, like, the best example of this is in 2017, in the fall of 2017, ProPublica published an article- About how Facebook had a ad category called Jew haters. You could buy Jew haters as a category and advertise to Jew haters. And when ProPublica published this, Facebook was like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. We didn't do that. We didn't, there was no human that wrote that category. And that was true. It was the AI that generated the category. So the point is, we've got to break the tyranny of analogical reasoning here. Yeah, it's like the editor at the New York Times, but it is not the editor at the New York Times.
26:57 Speaker 04 And if you do that, then you can begin to see that we need to have a capacity to respond to this new kind of threat, which is different from, I think, the traditional issues that we were talking about in the context of, in the context of copyright. That was the TikTok issue. The second, remind me about the second one, because I thought that was really interesting.
27:14 Speaker 03 That we should be, a foreign national in this country uses ChatGPT to tell a lie. And that should be somehow restricted.
27:21 Speaker 04 Yeah. The challenge there is, you're right, the foreign national.
27:26 Speaker 03 Let's go, we'll just make the foreign national Vladimir Putin. Vladimir Putin shows up, probably in Florida, and he opens up ChatGPT and says, tell some lies about the election.
27:34 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah.
27:35 Speaker 03 That is almost certainly protected speech.
27:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, certainly protected speech. Although, remember that the DC Circuit, Brett Kavanaugh, writing the opinion, affirmed without dissent by the United States Supreme Court, upheld the idea that you could limit the ability of legal immigrants to spend money independently of a political campaign because we're trying to protect the American democracy to be a democracy that Americans choose. So there's a tension in the jurisprudence. On the one hand, you speak like Citizens United does, says that the question is just the speech. And does the government have the right to regulate, quote, speech? Doesn't matter who's speaking. Scalia, when he wrote his concurrence in Citizens United, said, everybody's making a big deal about the fact that we're giving rights to corporations.
28:22 Speaker 04 Has nothing to do with it. The question is whether the government has a right to regulate the speech. Who cares who's uttering it? It could be a robot uttering the speech, you know, a replicant uttering the speech. It could be you uttering the speech.
28:34 Speaker 03 I don't think that was in Citizens United, replicants.
28:36 Speaker 04 It should have been. That is a really important point. But like, if you adopt that position, then you're right. There's nothing you can do about Vladimir Putin. But I don't think we're going to settle on that position. I think we're going to settle on a position that begins to recognize, we have a lot to do to protect. Democratic processes. And that's actually, you know, related to the work that we're doing at this new lab.
28:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:57 Speaker 04 Because, you know, there are a bunch of people out there like, how do we reform the media to make it so it's like our ideal of what the media should be? I think that's hopeless. I mean, God bless them and good luck. I think we instead need to recognize that we need to protect democracy from the radiation of these AIs. Like, you know, think of it as if it's like, all of a sudden, you know, we can't.
29:25 Speaker 03 And just to be clear, this is the generative AIs, not the recommendation algorithm AIs.
29:29 Speaker 04 I think they're, they're the same thing right now. I mean, they will be deployed hand in glove in order to achieve the objective of the person deploying.
29:38 Speaker 03 Walk me through that specifically, because I'm still stuck on the idea that if we're going to write some regulation, it should be, especially in the context of speech, it ought to be like strict scrutiny from the beginning, right? Very narrowly tailored. And that means you have to define the problem.
29:52 Speaker 04 Yeah.
29:52 Speaker 03 And so when you say hand in glove, it's, there's going to be a bunch of weird generative AI created content about our election that gets fed through an AI.
30:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
30:00 Speaker 03 Recommendation algorithm.
30:01 Speaker 04 But let's be clear about what I'm trying to say. What I'm trying to say is that enterprise of like figuring out how to regulate media to solve that problem, I think is hopeless.
30:11 Speaker 03 Okay.
30:11 Speaker 04 We're not going to regulate media to solve that problem.
30:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:13 Speaker 04 That problem's going to be there in some form, some metastasized, dangerous form, regardless of what regulation there is, even if we have creative ways of thinking about how to get around the First Amendment. But these two things work together because the, the recommendation engine is just very good at figuring out what people are open to.
30:31 Speaker 03 So you have a fire hose of AI generated content and the recommendation algorithm.
30:35 Speaker 04 Just figuring out where to aim it, right? And so my point is like, okay, that's going to happen. We should recognize we can't do democracy in that space.
30:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
30:43 Speaker 04 It's not going to work. And then we got to think about where can we rebuild democracy or what could it look like that was protected from that sort of thing? So one of the things that is happening around the world, completely invisible in American media, but one of the most interesting democratic innovations happening around the world is the explosion of things called citizen assemblies. France did one, a huge one around climate change. Ireland has done a whole bunch of them, including two that proposed ending regulations on abortion and endorsing same-sex marriage. The citizen assembly. Came up with those solutions, overwhelmingly supported them, then it went out to referendum, the public overwhelmingly supported them. We know that the politicians in Ireland could
31:24 Speaker 04 never have supported those two things, but these citizen assemblies could do it. There are hundreds in Japan, they're all through Europe right now. There have been some tiny experiments in the United States, but not much. But the point about these citizen assemblies is that these are places where citizens confront each other, they're representative, like they're large and representative. They confront each other, they hear the other side, they see that the other side is not a bunch of reptiles, they're like ordinary humans with the same issues, like how do I make sure my kid has a job after high school? And when they experience that, and they deliberate, and they come up with some resolution of some issue, whatever it is that's being presented to them, it has been
32:05 Speaker 04 protected, it's almost like in a shelter, from these corrupt, you know, the corrupting influences of AI, whether foreign-dominated influences, or even just commercial engagement influences. And what I think is that, you know, the more people see this, the more they'll be like, well, let's see more of this. Let's figure out how we can make this more of our democratic process. So, at the lab, we just are closing a deal to acquire a really powerful virtual deliberation platform, that has been a proprietary platform, and charges a bunch of money for people to use it. We're going to open source it, and we're going to make it available in every single context. So, churches could use it, schools
32:47 Speaker 04 could use it, local communities could use it, a DAO could use it, a game could use it. You could be in the middle of organizing your friends at a game in a clan, and then you push the deliberation button, it will be an API, it opens into a healthy deliberation context. We're doing this because we believe, first, we don't know how best to enable deliberation.
33:08 Speaker 04 Secondly, we think people out there do. And third, we think that when they do, they'll begin to think about this as another way to do democracy. And it would exercise a muscle of a kind of democratic relation to other people that we don't have right now. Like, our democratic relation to other people is to hate the other side. Politics of hate is not just that we're polarized, it's that we have to turn into villains, people who are not the same political view as we are. So what I believe is that we're going to have to find a way to begin to build something different while, at the same time, we're going to fight the war to make sure the media doesn't poison us too much. So, again, the radiation metaphor, I think, is really powerful here.
33:51 Speaker 04 Like, you know, the skies open up and we're not protected from the UVs in the way we were before. We're going to have to go underground, we're going to have to have shades on, and we're going to have to protect as much as we can. And not clear we're going to succeed. You know, it's hard to acknowledge exactly how terrifying these threats are. You know, the politics threat is one thing. A friend reported a conversation with one of the big AI companies, one of the senior developers at one of the big AI companies, who said, "My kids are not going to see high school." And what that statement was, is that he thinks we're not going to be able to control what happens with AI. Like, it is an existential threat that we will not meet.
34:35 Speaker 04 And like, when you realize exactly how dangerous these things are, and exactly how weak our capacity to do something collectively about it is, there's a lot of reason to be terrified about it. And that leads a bunch of people to, like, say, "Well, whatever, I'll just spend my time watching, you know, Netflix."
34:54 Speaker 03 It is interesting how much the AI doomers are also the people building the systems.
34:57 Speaker 04 Yes.
34:58 Speaker 03 Fascinating relationship.
35:01 Speaker 03 We'll be right back with more about one of the biggest challenges to come: generative AI.
35:11 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
35:21 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
35:28 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
35:43 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18+.
36:11 Speaker 03 We're back, asking Professor Larry Lussig what he thinks about the wave of copyright lawsuits being filed against generative AI companies. There is one way that the current moment in AI could come to an end, and I would be remiss if I didn't ask you specifically about it, which is all of these LMS are built on vast amounts of training data scraped from the open internet. Who knows if that was appropriate, or legal, or authorized? There are a number of fair use cases pointed at these LM systems now. There's one against OpenAI. There's, I believe, one coming against Google. If there isn't, there will be. I make that prediction, even if I don't know. They've got the most money. My colleague Sarah Jeong says, "It feels like this industry is built on a time bomb."
36:55 Speaker 03 This is a house of cards, because no one knows the answer whether this copying was fair use or not. You're a copyright law professor.
37:02 Speaker 04 Yeah.
37:02 Speaker 03 Do you think it's fair use or not?
37:03 Speaker 04 So I have two strong views, and one is very surprising. So the not surprising view I have is that whether you call it fair use or not, using creative work to learn something, whether you're a machine or not, should not be a copyright event. Now, maybe we should regulate in another way. Maybe we should have like a compulsory license like structure or some structure for compensation. I'm all for that. But the idea that we try to regulate AI through copyright law is crazy talk.
37:33 Speaker 03 But I mean, that's where we are right now.
37:35 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's what they're trying to do.
37:35 Speaker 03 It's always the first and fastest regulatory method.
37:38 Speaker 04 And it's got the most vigorous remedies.
37:41 Speaker 03 It's got the most money on the other side of it, too.
37:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, most money, yeah. So I think all of this in the American context should be considered fair use.
37:47 Speaker 03 Is that a policy conclusion or a legal conclusion?
37:49 Speaker 04 It's a legal conclusion. I think that the run the fair use analysis, that's what you get. And I
37:54 Speaker 03 Even if what you've done, and I'll just like the Sarah Silverman case, I'll take it for example. They clearly took her entire book and they can clearly spit out excerpts of her entire book. And somehow in that you run that analysis, I think that's a coin flip. And I look at sort of all their fair use of the courts right now. It feels like maybe more of a coin flip than ever before.
38:15 Speaker 04 There's a recent case that might make it more of a coin flip than I would have thought. Kagan wrote a very strong dissent in the case. And so maybe that signals that copyright law is shifting in a new way. The question of like legal access to the underlying material is always there. So I'm saying if you have access to the underlying material
38:36 Speaker 03 And that's where your licensing scheme would come in.
38:37 Speaker 04 Yeah, and I'm not even sure it's a licensing point. And my point is if it's out there in the world and somebody has legal access to it and they use it to learn, that's not a copyright event. Reading a book is not a copyrighting event, even though when you do it online, it technically copies. The whole point is it shouldn't be a copyright event because the equivalent, reading, is the sort of thing that was free. It was protected as free. Copyright was a narrow range of controls that we had to impose to create incentives for authors. And I don't think any of those controls are relevant to the context of the training. So I'm a very strong, "training is free." The view I have, which is surprising to people, is that, or people who know anything, you know, 10 people in the world who know anything about my views on copyright. No, no, no, I have to make sure I'm one of those people.
39:22 Speaker 04 Is that I absolutely think that when you use AI to create work, there ought to be a copyright that comes out of that. And the Copyright Office has just sort of said, "No." Yeah, they've said, "No." What they've said is, "Maybe if you have a complicated enough prompt, then you can get a copyright." Which, you know, we used to say fair use was the right to hire a lawyer. Now copyright is the right to hire a lawyer. Because you're like, "Here's my prompt, is that a copyright or not?" When what we need is an efficient system to basically just allocate the rights. Now, the tweak I would make, which I think is really critical, is, I would say you get a copyright with these AI systems if and only if the AI system itself registers the work
40:06 Speaker 04 and includes in the registration provenance. So that I know exactly who created it and when. And it's registered, so it's easy for me to identify it. Because the biggest hole in copyright law, a so-called property system, is that it's the most inefficient property system known to man. We have no way to know who owns what. We have no way to know who to negotiate, with whom to negotiate. Certain entities love that, like the collecting rights societies. You know, they love the fact that it's impossible to know because then you've got to have these huge collective rights societies. But the reality is, we could have a much more efficient system for identifying, quote, "ownership." And I think AI could help us to get there. So I would say, "Let's have a system where you get a copyright immediately." So I push generative fill in Photoshop? Yeah.
40:51 Speaker 03 It immediately goes to the copyright office, says in some database, here's my picture I made in Photoshop.
40:56 Speaker 04 And here's how it was made and when it was made and what fed into it. Like whatever the provenance has to be to make it useful. I'm not sure of that exactly. But if you began to do that, you begin to build infrastructure of registries that would make it easier for us to begin to navigate in this context. The other reason to push for this is that, you know, artists in the next 10 years are going to increasingly move to AI generation for their art. Okay. If you don't get copyright from that, then basically these people have almost no way to make any living. You'll remember this, I hope, from copyright law. At the birth of America, foreign authors got no American copyright.
41:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
41:37 Speaker 04 And all the Americans thought, this is great. We're protecting the Americans against the foreigners. But of course, what that meant is that all the English books were much cheaper than the American books. So the American authors were the disadvantage because the English authors weren't getting copyright. And the American authors began to push, give everybody copyright so that there's no unlevel playing field. Well, that's the same with this generative AI. If when I sit down and I make a creative work, I get a copyright. And you push a button on Mid Journey and there's no copyright there. The people consuming that work, like businesses trying to build advertising, are going to stop dealing with the artists, they're going to just deal with the Mid Journey, and they're going to get all this stuff for free that they can use in a commercial way that the artist before would have been compensated for.
42:22 Speaker 03 The basic laws of supply and demand kind of get in the way well before the sort of copyright licensing cost. If I'm using Mid Journey, I can make 10,000 images in the time it takes an artist to make their first cup of coffee.
42:34 Speaker 04 Right.
42:34 Speaker 03 And this is what I hear from artists and musicians, right? Our markets are about to get flooded with C+ work, because the most would C+ work.
42:42 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
42:43 Speaker 03 And like, most people don't care enough. But if you have enough supply of C+ work, the price of that will fall to zero.
42:49 Speaker 04 Yeah, I mean.
42:50 Speaker 03 And no one will ever pay us for A+ work. And like, whether or not, you know, paying me for A+ work comes with an appropriate copyright license or not seems pretty secondary to that basic economic problem.
43:00 Speaker 04 Well, I mean, think about photographs. The same dynamic happened with photography, right? In the old days, when the only people who had cameras were professionals, quality of photographs was very good. Then all this. Consumer cameras and then digital cameras came along. So the number of pictures in the world went up dramatically. And the quality of the average quality of them went down. Now, you would say, did that mean that there wasn't a demand for professional photographers? Well, a lot of them went away. But, you know, there are still pretty good professional photographers who are hired for substantial amounts for their particular professional work. But my, my point, I think, is slightly different. All I'm saying is, we need to have a world where everybody's on the level playing field. Every creative work is protected in some sense. And I just want to radically lower the cost of negotiating that protection.
43:45 Speaker 04 And if we radically lower the cost of negotiating that protection, then the best work would rise to the surface more easily. And, you know, people would be rewarded for having figured out how to produce that best work.
43:56 Speaker 03 I would say that, knowing what I know of you, that is a surprising viewpoint. Do you feel like you'll end up in a place where copyright steps in, as it so often does, as another solution to other problems, right? Providence, I want to know this is made by a person. Now there's a federal database that would tell me if it's a person or an AI. And copyright will be the vehicle by which this information is disseminated.
44:19 Speaker 04 It could be copyright. This actually relates to another part of a really great question you asked before that I think it's important to be clear about. You know, so when you were asking about AI in the context of elections, and how are you ever going to control that stuff? Because there are all sorts of, you know, right now proprietary AI, like OpenAI, has said you can't use this content for political speech. But we have all sorts of open source models out there that can use the content for political speech. And so one question is, can you do anything about that? And the answer is, absolutely, you could control American campaigns. And people are not creative enough about how to control it. But if, for example, you made every treasurer of every campaign swear on the penalty of perjury
45:04 Speaker 04 that no money was spent for any AI-generated content in that campaign, you could shut it down right away. But that still would leave you vulnerable to the foreign influence. Now, that's not to say that there shouldn't be something we do about it. That we should do that. But the point is, it will never be complete. And I think it's the same point with the Providence issue. There are so many fantastic databases out there that are being developed, blockchain databases, that would allow us to do much more in identifying. Like providence and ownership of content. And I think that they are set up so that the Copyright Office could recognize them. That would be the best of both worlds. And we don't want the Copyright Office doing it because no government agency is going
45:46 Speaker 04 to have the capacity to do it in the creative ways that it's being done right now. But we need to get to a place where that is easier. And I think the market could drive us there more effectively than the copyright lawsuits because copyright applied to providence claims is going to be a really hard thing to enforce.
46:01 Speaker 03 I think the blockchain people are desperate for a use case that looks like this. Anything, anything other than what they got now. I want to end kind of more in the weeds on something. I started by saying it feels like a reset moment on the internet. Like the platforms are shifting, user behavior is shifting. A thing that has jumped out to me, maybe more than anything, is that younger people on the internet are so deeply aware of copyright law in a way that my generation wasn't beyond getting sued for using Napster. That was basically our interaction with copyright law. Right now on YouTube, there is a controversy over so-called react videos where one creator makes a video, a bigger creator reacts to that video, adds nothing other than some faces
46:44 Speaker 03 potentially, and then they get all the views, right? And this is fine or not fine, but actually within the creator sphere on YouTube, the notion that this is a copyright violation and something should be done and this is wrong and they're going to reach to copyright law is very strong, right? There's actually a copyright maximalism amongst younger creators that is shocking to me. Do you see that there's like a new kind of folk private copyright law where because speech regulations are definitely against sort of the American idea, we're going to substitute in our folk wisdom about what copyright can or should be, we're going to say fair use like a magical incantation to claim moral superiority and have a fight?
47:27 Speaker 03 That seems all very like wrong to me, like something bad is about to happen here. Because we're, again, we're once again training people to talk about regulating speech without actually talking about regulating speech.
47:40 Speaker 04 I think it's actually a reaction to a very bad implementation that YouTube made of the original effort to protect copyright owners from piracy on YouTube. So YouTube set up this very complicated, I mean, not complicated, but it's a very sophisticated content identification system to be able to identify content. And then if your content is identified, then you can either demonetize the site that's doing it or order the site to take it down. And that created both a war for legitimate uses. So, for example, I gave a bunch of speeches that included music and the label did a takedown.
48:22 Speaker 04 And my speeches were speeches about copyright law, using these as examples that I wanted to demonstrate what the law was. And they issued a takedown to me and YouTube was very automatic about it. I fought back and they eventually threatened me and then I sued them and got them to Liberation Music to agree that they weren't going to play this game anymore. But of course, everybody plays that game where they're issuing takedowns to everybody. But that created this really perverse incentive for people to basically create complete ripoffs of other people's work and then just use the same mechanism to go after them. And these were all complete fraudsters. I mean, there are people who take public domain work. They put it up and then they use this registration system to say, these other people producing
49:05 Speaker 04 the public domain work are violating my copyright and the machine's not smart enough to be able to do anything about it. And so this, I think, has created an economy of what feels to me like real piracy, because these are not creators who are trying to do something creative, remixing in some interesting way. They're just trying to exploit the system to steal from others. And that reaction creates a counter reaction, which is, I think, the culture you've identified. I'm not sure how we get beyond it, other than a more sophisticated, our commitment by platforms like YouTube to be more sophisticated in this policing about what's actually going to be allowed as a remix and protected as a remix and what isn't. And if they were actually aggressively policing that in the way that's consistent with the values of copyright, I don't think it would be triggering the kind of
49:51 Speaker 04 Anger that's being triggered on the other side. I'm just as angry if I see somebody like take creative work and just put like a smiley face on it and then sell that or try to monetize that. That's totally wrong. But I think everybody should be able to agree that we should be allowed to take creative work and comment on it or critique it or use it to like, I love the people who try to teach guitar and they find that they have a certain, you know, two or three notes that then triggers this reaction and their whole site gets demonetized because it's
50:21 Speaker 03 It's particularly bad at music. I know a lot of music podcasters, for example, who just like won't put their work on YouTube.
50:26 Speaker 04 And music is quite frankly, one of the worst areas for fair use.
50:31 Speaker 03 This is what radicalized me, by the way.
50:32 Speaker 04 Yeah, yeah. I mean, you know, if you try to get the equivalent of like text and music and film is the same. You know, the freedoms that we take for granted in the context of text just don't exist in the context of music and don't exist in the context of, in the same way in the context of film. They could, what's necessary is the courts or maybe Congress to kind of tilt it in a direction to try to achieve a kind of common recognition of fair use across these platforms. But instead, there's been conventions set by industries that were long before the internet that creates these expectations that
51:07 Speaker 03 So this is happening right now. YouTube is entering into deals, particularly Universal Music, where they're going to invent some private copyright law on the platform to deal with AI. So there is an AI artist on YouTube that sounded like Drake. It's a big scandal. Universal got very mad about it. YouTube has basically said, we're going to invent some stuff for you. So if there's AI that sounds like Drake, we'll let you take it down. That's not in any federal law that I can find or any decision that I can find yet. It hasn't been litigated. It's not really in any state law outside of likeness. So you basically have a private copyright law to one platform for the benefits of the music label. You could argue that that is an appropriate sort of market solution to this problem, but it feels like we should probably actually have a law.
51:51 Speaker 03 Where do you think that lands?
51:53 Speaker 04 It could be a market solution, assuming we're not having an antitrust issue involved. And I'm not sure I would assume that right now.
52:01 Speaker 03 With YouTube specifically?
52:03 Speaker 04 Yeah, with YouTube and some of these labels, right? So, you know, I have a lot of sympathy for the artists who are anxious about the fact that their style is taken and used in a particular way and AI is Obviously making this easy, trivial. And that's why I said at the beginning, I think there might be sui generis ways to compensate for the content, for that sort of consequence. But I think what we need is a vigorous debate on both sides of it. And what we saw in the early internet was that, you know, most of the loudest, most important forces were coming from the maximalist control perspective. And that was a mistake. It was a mistake for artists. You know, I remember like 20 years ago, artists were convinced that this campaign
52:44 Speaker 04 of copyright extremism would produce an internet that would be profitable for artists. Well, you know, ask artists how much they get from Spotify today. So it's actually worked against the interests of artists. And I think that if we had had a healthier debate back then, more open, less kind of moralistic, like there were criminals on one side, pirates on one side, and believers in property on the other, we could have come up with a better solution. And I hope that we have, well, I don't actually hope, I don't think there's any hope for this at all, but what we ought to be having is a more healthy debate about that today.
53:18 Speaker 03 I think that's all we can hope for. Professor Lessig, thank you so much for being on Decoder. I really appreciate it.
53:22 Speaker 04 Thank you.
53:27 Speaker 03 I'd like to thank Professor Lawrence Lessig for taking the time to join me on Decoder. Like I said, last minute, but he killed it. I'd also like to thank Harvard for hosting us, and thank you for tuning in. I hope you enjoyed the show. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of Decoder. You can email us at decoder@theverge.com. I read all the emails. You can hit me up directly on Threads, I'm at reckless1280, and we have a TikTok. You can check it out, it's at DecoderPod, it's a lot of fun. Now, this week, the TikToks are all at Harvard, so the video looks really good. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really like the show, hit us with that five-star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt, it was edited by Callie Wright. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
54:12 Speaker 03 Our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
54:17 Speaker 06 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
54:48 Speaker 07 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous Clearview AI and the end of privacy, with author Kashmir Hill Next AI is on a collision course with the music industry. Reservoir's Golnar Khosrowshahi thinks there’s a way through it Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated