Pod Insights Decoder Google's Sundar Pichai on AI-powered search and the future of the web About this episode Today, I’m talking to Google CEO Sundar Pichai, who joined the show the day after the big Google I/O developer conference. Google’s focus during the conference was on how it’s building AI into virtually all of its products. If you’re a Decoder listener, you’ve heard me talk about this idea a lot over the past year: I call it “Google Zero,” and I’ve been asking a lot of web and media CEOs what would happen to their businesses if their Google traffic were to go to zero. In a world where AI powers search with overviews and summaries, that’s a real possibility. What then happens to the web?
I’ve talked to Sundar quite a bit over the past few years, and this was the most fired up I’ve ever seen him. I think you can really tell that there is a deep tension between the vision Google has for the future — where AI magically makes us smarter, more productive, more artistic — and the very real fears and anxieties creators and website owners are feeling right now about how search has changed and how AI might swallow the internet forever, and that he’s wrestling with that tension.
Links:
Google and OpenAI are racing to rewire the internet — Command Line
Google I/O 2024: everything announced — The Verge
Google is redesigning its search engine, and it’s AI all the way down — The Verge
Project Astra is the future of AI at Google — The Verge
Did SEO experts ruin the internet or did Google? — The Verge
YouTube is going to start cracking down on AI clones of musicians — The Verge
AI is killing the old web, and the new web struggles to be born — The Verge
How Google is killing independent sites like ours — HouseFresh
Inside the First 'SEO Heist' of the AI Era — Business Insider
Google’s Sundar Pichai talks Search, AI, and dancing with Microsoft — Decoder
Transcript: https://www.theverge.com/e/23922415
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:01 Speaker 00 Company spending is complex. Managing it should be simple. This is AMEX Corporate, a single platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments to streamline the way you work. Flexible controls for when priorities shift, support around the clock, all backed by American Express, so you can stay focused on what matters most. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is AMEX Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:35 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
0:44 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:51 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:06 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, I'm talking to Alphabet and Google CEO Sundar Pichai, who joined the show the day after the big Google I/O developer conference. Google's focus during that conference was very much on AI and how the company is building AI into virtually all of its products. My personal favorite was the new AI search in Google Photos that lets you just ask things like, "What's my license plate number?", and get an answer back from your entire photo library. All in all, Google executives said "AI" more than 120 times during the keynote. We counted. But there is one particular announcement at I/O that's sending shockwaves around the web.
1:48 Speaker 03 Google is rolling out what it calls AI overviews in search to everyone in the United States by this week, and then around the world to more than a billion users by the end of the year. That means when you search for something on Google, you'll get AI-powered results at the top of the page for a number of queries. The company literally describes this as "Let Google do the Googling for you." A version of this, called the Search Generative Experience, has been in test For about a year now. So you might have seen riffs on this, but now AI previews are here and they will change the web as we know it. And I don't think that's just me reacting hyperbolically. A bunch of people who make websites feel the same way. As an example, the News Media Alliance, which represents a bunch of fancy publishers, put out a press release calling AI previews and search, quote, catastrophic to our traffic.
2:31 Speaker 03 If you're a Decoder listener, you've heard me talk about this idea a lot over the past year. I've been calling it Google Zero. And I've been asking a lot of web and media CEOs, what would happen to their businesses if their Google traffic goes to zero? And I mean that question sincerely. If AI chatbots and AI-powered search results do a good job of just delivering people answers to their questions, why would anyone go to a website? And if we all stop going to websites, what's the incentive to put new content on the web? And what's going to stop shady content farms from flooding the web with AI-generated spam to try and game these systems? And if the incentives to make good content on the web go down and the incentives to flood the web with AI spam go up, what are all these bots going to summarize when people ask them questions? AI is a big idea. It's going to cause some big problems.
3:17 Speaker 03 Sundar has some ideas about this, of course. For one, he's not convinced that the web, which he says he cares deeply about, is in all that much long-term danger. You'll hear him mention Wired's famous 2010 headline, "The Web Is Dead", and he makes the argument that new transformative technologies like AI always cause short-term disruption. Sundar also says that injecting AI into search is about creating value for Google's users. And those users are telling him that they find these new features to be helpful. And they even click on links in those AI previews at higher rates, potentially sending out more traffic than before. But he didn't say where that leaves the people who put the content on the internet in the first place. We really sat with that idea for a while. And we talked a lot about the anger that creative people feel towards AI systems training on their work.
4:01 Speaker 03 I've talked to Sundar quite a bit over the past few years, and this was the most fired up I think I've ever seen him. You can really tell there's a deep tension between the vision that Google and others have for the future, where AI makes us smarter and more productive and more artistic, and the very real fears and anxieties that creators and website owners feel right now about how search has changed and how AI might swallow the internet forever. And Sundar is really wrestling with that tension. It was a good conversation. Oh, one note before we start. You'll hear me say to Sundar that I think he keeps making oblique references to OpenAI, and he pushes back on me pretty strongly. I was thinking about it afterwards, and it's pretty clear he wasn't just talking about OpenAI, but also Meta, which has explicitly turned away from sending any traffic to any websites whatsoever, and has also been clear that it doesn't really want to support news on its platforms at all.
4:45 Speaker 03 I wish that had clicked for me during this conversation, because I would have asked about it way more directly. Okay, Alphabet and Google CEO Sundar Pichai. Here we go.
5:06 Speaker 03 Sundar Pichai, you are the CEO of both Alphabet and Google. Welcome to Decoder.
5:10 Speaker 04 Hello, good to be here.
5:12 Speaker 03 I am excited to talk to you. I feel like I talk to you every year at Google I/O, and we talk about all the things you've announced. There's a lot of things to talk about. There's a lot of AI news to talk about. As you know, I am particularly interested in the future of the web, so I really want to talk about that with you. But I figured I would start with an easy one. Do you think language is the same as intelligence?
5:31 Speaker 04 Wow, that's a... it's not an easy question. I don't think I'm the expert on it. I think language does encode a lot of intelligence, probably more than, you know, people thought, explains the successes of large language models to a great extent. But I think my intuition tells me, I mean, as humans, the way we consume information, I think there's a lot more to it than language alone. But I'd say language is a lot more than people think it is, yeah.
6:00 Speaker 03 The reason I ask that question to start is I look at the announcements at I/O with AI and what you're doing. I look at your competitors with AI and what they're doing, and everything is very language-heavy, right? It's LLMs that have really led to this explosion of interest and innovation and investment. And I wonder if the intelligence is increasing at the same rate as the facility with language. And I kind of don't see it. To be perfectly honest, I see computers getting much better at language and actually, in some cases, getting dumber. And I'm wondering if you see that same gap.
6:30 Speaker 04 It's a great question, though. Part of the reason we made Gemini natively multimodal is so that, you know, with audio, video, text, images and code, and you're beginning to see glimpses of it now, but it hasn't all actually made its way into products fully yet. So maybe the next cycle, when we have multimodality working on the input and output side, and we are training models using all that, I think that'll encapsulate a lot more than just today, which is primarily text-based. So I think that continuum will shift as we, you know, take in a lot more information that way. So maybe there's more to come.
7:06 Speaker 03 The reason I ask that is it feels like last year, you know, the tagline was bold but responsible. That's Google's approach. You said it again on stage this year. And then I look at our reactions to AI getting things wrong.
7:19 Speaker 04 Yeah.
7:19 Speaker 03 And it seems like they're getting more and more tempered over time. I'll give you an example. In the demos you had yesterday, you showed multimodal video search, someone trying to fix a broken film camera. And the answer was just wrong, right? Like, sort of straightforwardly, the answer that was highlighted in the video was just, just open the back of the film camera and jiggle it. And it's like, well, that would ruin all of your film. And no one who had an intelligent understanding of how that camera would just suggest that.
7:45 Speaker 04 You know, ironically, I was talking to the team, they, you know, the team as part of making the video.
7:51 Speaker 03 Mm hmm.
7:52 Speaker 04 They consulted with a bunch of subject matter experts.
7:55 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:55 Speaker 04 Who all reviewed the answer and thought it was okay. I understand the nuance. I agree with you. Obviously, you don't want to expose your film by taking it outside of a darkroom. There are certain contexts in which it makes sense to do that. You know, if you don't want to break the camera, and if what you've taken is not that valuable, all right, it makes sense to do that. You know, it's a good example of, you're right, there is a lot of nuance in it. And, you know, part of what I hope search serves to do is to gives you a lot more context around that answer and allows people to explore it deeply. But I think, you know, these are the kind of things for us to keep getting better at. But to your earlier question, look, I think.
8:40 Speaker 04 I do see the capability frontier continuing to move forward. I think we are a bit limited if we were just training on text data, but I think we are all making it more multimodal. So I see more opportunities there.
8:51 Speaker 03 Yeah. Let's talk about search. This is the thing that I I'm most interested in. I think this is the thing that is changing the most, sort of in an abstract way. It's the thing that's the most exciting.
9:00 Speaker 04 Yeah.
9:01 Speaker 03 Right, you can ask a computer a question and it will just like happily tell you an answer.
9:04 Speaker 04 Yeah.
9:05 Speaker 03 That feels new. I I see the excitement around it. Yesterday, you announced AI previews are coming to search. That's an extension of what was called the search generative experience, announcing a rollout to everyone in the United States. I would describe the reactions to that news from the people who make websites is fundamentally apocalyptic. The CEO of the News Media Alliance said to CNN, this will be catastrophic to our traffic. Another media CEO forwarded me a newsletter and the headline was, this is a death blow to publishers. Were you expecting that kind of response to rolling out AI previews in search?
9:39 Speaker 04 I definitely, you know, I recall in 2010, you know, the headlines of the web is dead, right? You know, I've long worked on the web, obviously. I deeply care about it. When the transition from desktop to mobile happened, there was a lot of concerns because people are like, oh, it's a small screen. How will people read content? Like, why would they look at content? We had started introducing what we internally called Web Answers in 2014, which are featured snippets outside. So you had questions like that. I remain optimistic empirically what we are seeing throughout these years. Human curiosity is boundless.
10:17 Speaker 03 Yeah.
10:18 Speaker 04 When people come, and it's something I think we have deeply understood in search, more than any other company. I think we will differentiate ourselves in our approach, even through this transition. I think as a company, we realize the value of this ecosystem and it's symbiotic. If there isn't a rich ecosystem making unique and useful content, what are you putting together and organizing? Right, and so we we feel it. I would say through all these transitions, things have played out a bit differently. I think high quality content, users are looking for it. The counterintuitive part, which I think almost always plays out is it's not a zero sum game in terms of AI overviews.
11:02 Speaker 04 People are responding very positively to it. It's one of the most positive changes I've seen in search based on metrics we see. But people do jump off on it. And when you give context around it, they actually jump off it. It actually helps them understand. And so they engage with content underneath too. In fact, if you put content and links within AI overviews, they get higher click through rates than if you put it outside of AI overviews.
11:26 Speaker 03 Yeah.
11:27 Speaker 04 But I understand the sentiment, right? You know, it's a big change. These are disruptive moments. AI is a big platform shift. And people are projecting out and, you know, this is people are putting a lot into creating content. It's their businesses. It's their. So I understand the perspective. So, you know, I'm not surprised. We are engaging with a lot of players, both directly and indirectly. But I remain optimistic how it'll actually play out. But it's a good question, but happy to talk about it more.
11:53 Speaker 03 I have this concept I call Google Zero, which is born of my own paranoia. Every refer that The Verge has ever had has gone up and then it's gone down. And Google is the last large scale referrer of traffic on the web for almost every website now. And I can see that for a lot of sites, Google Zero is playing out. Their Google traffic has gone to zero. Particularly independent sites that aren't part of some huge publishing conglomerate. So there's an air purifier blog that we cover called House Fresh. There's a gaming site we cover called Retro Dodo. Both of these sites have said, look, our Google traffic went to zero. Our businesses are doomed. Is that the right outcome here of all this? The people who care so much about video games or air purifiers that they actually started websites and made the content for the web are the ones getting hurt the most in the platform shift?
12:38 Speaker 04 I mean, it's always difficult to talk about individual cases, right? And like, you know, at the end of the day, we are trying to satisfy user expectations and users are wording with their feet and right? So and people are trying to figure out what's valuable to them. And we are doing it at scale and, you know, I can't answer on the particular side.
12:59 Speaker 03 But it's that thing where it's a bunch of small players are feeling the hurt loudly, like they're saying it, like our businesses are going away. And that's the thing you're saying, like, we're engaging, we're talking, but this thing that is happening very clearly.
13:13 Speaker 04 But it's not clear to me that's a uniform trend. Like I have to look at data on an aggregate, right? So anecdotally, when people give, there are always times when people have come in an area and said, Me as a specific site have done worse, but that may be a moment in which that's because it's like an individual restaurant coming and saying, I've started getting less customers this year.
13:33 Speaker 03 Yeah.
13:34 Speaker 04 People have stopped eating food or whatever it is, right? I mean, that's not true necessarily, right? Some other restaurant might have opened next door, which is doing very well, right? So it's tough to say anything from our standpoint, when I look at historically, even over the past decade, you know, we have provided more traffic to the ecosystem and we've driven that growth, right? So that, you know, and you may be making a secondary point around small sites versus more aggregating sites, you know, which is the second point you're talking about. You know, ironically, there are times when we have done changes to actually send more traffic to the smaller sites. Some of the sites which complain a lot are the aggregators in the middle.
14:14 Speaker 03 Yeah, yeah.
14:14 Speaker 04 So should the traffic go to the restaurant, which has created a website with their menus and stuff? Or, you know, or people writing about these restaurants? These are deep questions. I'm not saying there's a right answer.
14:25 Speaker 03 But you're about to flip over the whole apple car, right? You're about to start answering some of these questions very directly. And where that content comes from in the future, I think you want the people who care the most to publish that information directly to be the thing that you synthesize.
14:38 Speaker 04 Yeah, I, I.
14:39 Speaker 03 And the incentives for that seem to be getting lower and lower on the web, anyway.
14:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, I feel it's the opposite. And if anything, I feel like through AI overviews, when you give people context, yes, there are times people come and all they want is a quick answer and they bounce back. But overall, when we look at user journeys, when you give the context, it also exposes people's to various branching off, jumping off points. And so they engage more. So I actually, this is what drives growth over time. I look at like desktop to mobile, questions were similar. In fact, I think it was a cover almost tempted to pull out, saying the web is dead. And there was a Google zero argument.
15:18 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:18 Speaker 04 Ten years ago. It's not an accident. I think we are, we still remain as one of the largest referrers.
15:24 Speaker 03 Yeah.
15:24 Speaker 04 Because we've cared about it deeply. For a long, long time, I look at our journey even the last one year through search and rate of experience, I constantly, you know, founders prioritizing approaches, which would send more traffic while meeting user expectations. We think that through deeply and we actually change our approach. And if there are areas where we feel like we fully haven't gotten it right, we are careful about rolling it there. What's positively surprising us is that people engage more and that will lead to more growth over time, I think, for high quality content. There's a lot of debate about what's high quality content, you know,
16:04 Speaker 04 but I think, I would hope that, you know, at least in my experience, you know, I value independent sources, I value smaller things, I want more authentic voices. And I think those are important attributes we are trying to constantly improve.
16:20 Speaker 03 You mentioned that you think more people will click through links and AI previews. I think Liz, who runs search, had a blog post making the same claim. There's no public data that says that this is true yet. Are you going to release that data? Are you going to show people that this is actually happening?
16:35 Speaker 04 At an aggregate, I think people, I mean, we rely on this value of the ecosystem, right? If people over time on an aggregate don't see value, if the website owners don't see value coming back from Google, I think we'll pay a price. I think so we have the right incentive structure. But obviously, look, I think we are careful about, there are a lot of individual variations and some of it is users choosing which way to go. And so I think, I think, I think that part is hard to sort out. But I do think we are committed at an aggregate level to do the right thing.
17:07 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back.
17:18 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
17:27 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
17:35 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
17:49 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
18:14 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called and me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
18:47 Speaker 03 We're back. I'm talking with Google CEO Sundar Pichai about the difficulty that the shift to AI overviews and search results might cause for website owners and content creators.
18:57 Speaker 03 I was reading some SEO community trade publications this morning responding to the changes. And one of the things that was pointed out was that in Search Console, it doesn't show you if the clicks are coming from a featured snippet or an AI preview or just a regular Google 10 blue links. Would you break that out? Would you commit to breaking it out so people can actually audit and verify and measure that the AI previews are sending out as much traffic as you say they are?
19:22 Speaker 04 You know, I think it's a good question for the search team. They think about this, you know, at a deeper level than I do. I think we're constantly trying to give more visibility in a way. But we also don't want people to, we want people to create the content that's good. And like, we are trying to rank it and organize it. So I think there's a balance to be had. You know, the more we spec it out, then the more people design for that. So I think there's a trade off there. I think, so it's unclear to me what the right answer is.
19:51 Speaker 03 Yeah, that trade off between what you spec out and say and what people make.
19:55 Speaker 04 Yeah.
19:55 Speaker 03 I think that's been the story of the web for quite some time. And it had reached, I think, a steady state. Whether you think that steady state was good or bad, it was at least a steady state. Now that state is changing, right? It's like AI is obviously changing it. The ten blue links model, the old steady state, very much based on an exchange, right? We're gonna let you index our content, we're gonna featured snippets, we're gonna let you see all of our information. In return, you will send us traffic. That formed the basis of what you might call a fair use argument, right? Google's gonna index the stuff, there's not gonna be a lot of payments in the middle. In the AI era, no one knows how that's gonna go, right? There are some major lawsuits happening, there are deals being made by Google, OpenAI, for training data.
20:39 Speaker 03 Do you think it's appropriate for Google to start making more deals to pay for data to train on search results? Because those AI snippets are not really the same as the ten blue links or anything else you've done in the past.
20:51 Speaker 04 To be very clear, there's a myth that Google's search has been ten blue links for, you know, like, you know, I look at our mobile experience over many, many years, right? And we've had answers, we allow you to refine questions and so on, we've had featured snippets and so on. So the product has evolved significantly. But having said that, as a company, even as we look at AI, you know, we have done even, we've had showcase, we have done licensing deals. To the extent there is value, we obviously think there is a case for fair use in the context of beneficial transformative use.
21:33 Speaker 04 Not gonna argue that with you as given your background, but I think there are cases in which we will see dedicated incremental value to our models and, you know, we'll be looking at partnerships to get at that, yeah. So I do think we'll approach it that way.
21:48 Speaker 03 Let me ask this question in a different way, and I won't do too much fair use analysis with you, I promise, as much as I like doing it. You know, there are some news reports recently that OpenAI had trained its video generation product, Sora, on YouTube. How did you feel when you heard that, that news?
22:03 Speaker 04 Look, we don't know the details. Our YouTube team is following up and trying to understand. We have terms and conditions, right? And we would expect people to abide by those terms and conditions, right? And so I think when you build a product, and so that's, that's how I felt about it, right? I think.
22:20 Speaker 03 So you felt like they had broken your terms and conditions, or potentially, or if they had, that wouldn't have been appropriate?
22:24 Speaker 04 That's right. Yeah, that's right.
22:27 Speaker 03 So the reason I ask that question, which is a much more emotional question, is, okay, maybe that's not appropriate. And what OpenAI has said, whatever they've said, is essentially in the order of, we trained on publicly available information, which means we found it on the web. Most people don't get to make that deal, right? They don't have a YouTube team of licensing professionals who can say, we had terms and conditions. They don't even have terms and conditions. They're just putting their stuff on the internet. Do you understand why emotionally there's the reaction to AI from the creative community? That it feels the same way as you might have felt about opening a training on YouTube?
23:00 Speaker 04 Absolutely. Look, I think, be it website owners or content creators or artists, you know, I can understand how emotional a transformation this is. And I think part of the reason you saw even through Google I/O, when we are working on products like music generation, we have really taken an approach by which we are working first to make tools for artists. They even put a general purpose tool out there for anyone to create songs, right? So the way we have taken that approach in many of these cases is to put the creator community as much at the center of it as possible. We've long done that with YouTube. Through it all, I think we are trying to figure out what are the right ways to approach this.
23:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:43 Speaker 04 But it is a transformative moment as well. And, you know, there are other players in this. We are not the only player in the ecosystem. But to your earlier question, yes, I understand people's emotions through it. I definitely am very empathetic to how people are perceiving this moment.
23:58 Speaker 03 Because they feel like it's a taking, right? That they put work on the internet and the big companies are coming. They're taking it for free and then they're making products that you they are charging 20 bucks a month for. Or that will lift their creative work and remix it for other people. The thing that makes it feel like a taking is very little value accrues back to them. And that's really the thing I'm asking about is how do you bring the value back to them? How do you bring incentives back to the small creator, the independent business, and saying, look, this feels like a taking?
24:25 Speaker 04 The whole reason we have spent, I think we've been successful on platforms like YouTube is we've worked hard to answer this question well.
24:31 Speaker 03 Yeah.
24:32 Speaker 04 Right? And so you'll continue to see us dig deep about how to do this well. And I think the players who end up doing better here will have more winning strategies over time. I genuinely believe that. And, you know, I think. Across everything we do, we have to sort that out. Anytime you're running a platform, I think it's the basis on which you can build a sustainable, long-term platform. So I view that, you know, through this AI moment, over time, there'll be players who will do better by the content creators, which which support their platforms. And whoever does it better will emerge as the winners. I think that, you know, I believe that to be a tenant, right? In these things over time.
25:12 Speaker 03 One thing that I think is really interesting about the YouTube comparison in particular, it's been described to me many times that YouTube is a licensing business, right? You license a lot of content from the creators. You obviously pay them back in terms of the advertising model there. The music industry has a huge licensing business with YouTube. It is an existential relationship, I think, for both sides. Susan Wojcicki used to describe YouTube as a music service, which I think confused everyone until you looked at the data. Universal Music is mad about AI on YouTube. YouTube reacts, right? They like build a bunch of tools. They write a constitution on what AI will do and will not do. People are mad about search generative experience or AI previews on the web. Google doesn't react the same way. And I'm wondering if you can swear that. You think so?
25:55 Speaker 04 That's so far from reality, right? I mean, it's, we have taken, I look at other players and how they've approached.
26:01 Speaker 03 You mean, you're talking about OpenAI, which is just out there taking stuff, right?
26:03 Speaker 04 Look, in general, when you look at how we have approached search generative experience, even through a moment like this, the time we have taken to test, iterate, prioritize approaches.
26:15 Speaker 03 Yeah.
26:16 Speaker 04 And the way we've done it over the years, I, you know, would say, I definitely disagree with the notion we don't listen, right? So we deeply care, we listen. Not everything we do may, you know, people may agree. When you're running an ecosystem, you are balancing across different needs. But I would definitely think, and I hope we always do, because I think that's the essence of what makes a product successful.
26:39 Speaker 03 Let me talk about the other side of this. So there's search and people are going to game search and that's always going to happen. And that's a chicken and egg problem. The other thing that I see is happening is the web is being flooded with AI content. There was an example the other, a few months ago, some unsavory SEO character said, here's this thing I just did. I stole a bunch of traffic from a competitor. I copied their site map. I fed it into an AI and had it generate me copy for a website that matched their sitemap. I put up this website. I stole a bunch of traffic from that website, my competitor. I think that's a bad act. I don't think we want to incentivize that in any way, shape or form. That's going to happen at scale, right? And more and more of the internet that we experience will be synthetic in some important way.
27:20 Speaker 03 How do you, on the one hand, build the systems that create the synthetic content for people? And on the other hand, rank it so that you're only getting the best stuff? Because at some point, the defining line for a lot of people is, I want stuff made by a human and not stuff made by an AI.
27:35 Speaker 04 I think there are multiple parts to your question, right? So, one, how do we sift through
27:40 Speaker 03 Yeah.
27:41 Speaker 04 high quality from low quality? I'm like, I literally view that as our mission statement. It is what has defined search over many, many years. I actually think people underestimate. Anytime you have these disruptive platform shifts, you know, you're going to go through a phase like this. I have seen that teams invest so much, or entire search quality teams, you know, been spending the last year, right? Gearing up our ranking systems, et cetera, to better get at what is high-quality content. I think, if I think the next decade, people who can do that better, who can sift through that, I think will win out. I think you're right in your assessment that, you know, people will value human-created experiences.
28:24 Speaker 04 I hope the data bears that out and, you know. We have to be careful every time there's a new technology. There are old filmmakers, if you go and talk about CGI in films, they're going to react very emotionally.
28:37 Speaker 03 Yeah.
28:37 Speaker 04 Right? And there are still esteemed filmmakers who never use CGI in films. But then there are people who use it and produce great films, right? And so you can't just say anything with AI. You know, you may be using AI to layout, enhance video effects in your video, et cetera. But I agree with you. I think using AI to produce on mass content without adding any value, et cetera, I don't think is what users are looking for.
29:07 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:08 Speaker 04 But there is a big continuum and, you know, over time, users are adapting. We are trying hard to make sure we do it in a responsible way, but also listening to what users actually find as high quality versus not.
29:23 Speaker 03 Yeah.
29:23 Speaker 04 And trying to get that balance right, right? And that continuum will look different a few years out than it is today. But I think it's, I viewed as the essence of what search quality is. Do I feel confident we will be able to approach it better than others? Yes. Right. And I think that's what defines the work we do.
29:44 Speaker 03 We have to take another short break. We'll be back in just a few minutes.
29:54 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them, that's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
30:04 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow.
30:10 Speaker 02 Yeah, it, it wasn't.
30:12 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
30:26 Speaker 05 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required. Compatibility and availability varies. 18 plus.
30:51 Speaker 06 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition, even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
31:24 Speaker 03 Welcome back. I'm talking with Google CEO Sundar Pichai about where all this generative AI is leading us and ultimately where it might lead the web. For the listener, these have been a lot of subtle shots at OpenAI today. Can I put this into practice by showing you a search? I actually just did the search. It is a search for best Chromebook. As you know, I once bought my mother a Chromebook Pixel. It's one of my favorite tech purchases of all time. So this is a search for best Chromebook. I'm going to hit generate at the top. It's going to generate the answer. And then I'm going to use something terrifying, which is I'm going to hand my phone to the CEO of Google. This is my personal phone. Don't dig through it. So you look at that and you know, it's the same generation that I've seen earlier. I asked for best Chromebook and it says, here's some stuff you might think of. And then you scroll and it's some Chromebooks. It doesn't say whether they're best Chromebooks. And then it's a bunch
32:08 Speaker 03 of headlines. Some of it's like virghe headlines. It's like, here are some best Chromebooks. That feels like the exact kind of thing that an AI-generated search could answer in a better way. Like, do you think that's a good experience today? Is that a waypoint or is that the destination?
32:23 Speaker 04 I think, look, you're showing me a query in which we didn't automatically generate the AI.
32:27 Speaker 03 Well, there was a button that said, do you want to do that?
32:29 Speaker 04 But that's, let me, let me push back, right? There's an important differentiation, right? There's a reason we are giving a view without the generated AI overview. And as a user, you're initiating an action, right? So we are respecting the user intent there. And when I scroll it, I see Chromebooks. I also see a whole set of links which I can go, which, which tell me all the ways you can think about Chromebooks. I see a lot of links. So we both didn't show an AI overview in this case. As a user, you're generating, generating the follow-up question. I think it's right that we respect the user intent. If you don't do that, right, people will go somewhere else too, right? I think so. You know, so.
33:12 Speaker 03 I'm saying, the answer to the question, I did not write, what is the best Chromebook? I just wrote best Chromebook. The answer, the thing that identifies itself as an answer is not on that page. And the leap to, I had to push the button to Google pushes the button for me, and then says what it believes to be the answer is very small. And I'm wondering if you think a page like that today is, that is the destination of the search experience? Or if this is a waypoint and you can see a future, better version of that experience?
33:39 Speaker 04 I'll give you my, your phone back. I'm tempted to check email right now, out of, out of habit. Look, but you know, I. I think the direction of how these things will go, you know, it's fully tough to predict. You know, we, we are, you know, users keep evolving. It's a more dynamic moment than ever. We are testing all of this. This is a case where we didn't trigger the AI overview because we felt like our AI overview is not necessarily the first experience we want to provide for that query because what's underlying is maybe a better first look at the user.
34:13 Speaker 03 Yeah.
34:14 Speaker 04 Right. And, and those are all quality trade offs we are making. But if the user is asking for a summary, right, we are summarizing and giving links. I think that seems like a reasonable direction to me.
34:24 Speaker 03 I'll show you another one where it did expand automatically. This one I only have screenshots for. So this is Dave Lee from Bloomberg did a search. He got an AI overview and he just searched for JetBlue Mint Lounge SFO. And it just says the answer, which I think is fine. And that's the answer. If you swipe one over, I cannot believe I'm letting the CEO of Google swipe on my camera roll. But if you swipe one over, you see where it pulled from. You see the site it pulled from. It is a word for word rewrite of that site. Is that, I mean, this is the thing I'm getting at, right? Like the AI generated preview of that answer. If you just look at where it came from, it is almost the same sentence that exists on the source of it. And that to me, that's what I mean. It's at some point that the better experience is the AI preview.
35:08 Speaker 03 And it's just the thing that exists on all the sites underneath it. It's the same information.
35:12 Speaker 04 Look, the thing with search, we handle billions of queries. You can absolutely find a query and hand it to me and say, could we have done better on that query?
35:22 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:22 Speaker 04 Yes, you know, for sure. But when I look across, in many cases, part of what is making people respond positively to AI overviews is the summary we are providing clearly adds value, helps them look at things they may not have otherwise thought about. If you aren't adding value at that level.
35:42 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:43 Speaker 04 I think people notice it over time, right? And, and I think that's the bar you're trying to meet. And our data would show over 25 years, if you aren't doing something which users find valuable or enjoyable, they let us know right away.
35:57 Speaker 03 Yeah.
35:57 Speaker 04 Over and over again, we see that. And through this transition, everything is the opposite.
36:03 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:03 Speaker 04 It's one of the biggest quality improvements we are driving in our product. People are valuing this experience. So there's a general presumption that people don't know what they are doing.
36:12 Speaker 03 Yeah.
36:13 Speaker 04 Which I disagree with strongly. Like, you know, people who use Google are savvy. They understand. And I can give plenty of examples where I've used AI overviews as a user. I'm like, oh, this is giving context. Or maybe there are these dimensions I didn't even think in my original query. Right? How do I expand upon it and look at it? Yeah.
36:33 Speaker 03 You've made oblique mention to OpenAI a few times, I think.
36:37 Speaker 04 I actually haven't. Like, I think.
36:39 Speaker 03 You see, saying others, there's one other big competitor that is, I think, a little more.
36:45 Speaker 04 I mean, you're putting words in my mouth, but that's okay.
36:47 Speaker 03 Yeah, okay. Well, I would say, I saw OpenAI's demo the other day of GPT-4O Omni. It looked a lot like the demos you gave at I O, right? This idea of multimodal search, the idea that you have this like character you can talk to, you had gems, which was the same kind of idea. It feels like there's a race to get to kind of the same outcome for a search-like experience or an agent-like experience. Do you feel the pressure from that competition?
37:13 Speaker 04 Well, I mean, this is no different from Siri and Alexa. And like, you know, we worked in the industry. I think when you're working in the technology industry, I think that is relentless innovation, right? You know, we felt a few years ago, all of us building voice assistants, you could have asked the same version of this question, right? And what was Alexa trying to do? And what was Siri trying to do? So I think it's a natural extension of that. I think you have a new technology now, and it's evolving rapidly. I felt like it was a good week for technology. There was a lot of innovation, I felt, on Monday and Tuesday and so on. That's how I feel. And I think it's going to be that way for a while. I'd rather have it that way. You know, you'd rather be in a place where
37:55 Speaker 04 the underlying technology is evolving, which means you can radically improve your experiences which you're putting out. I'd rather have that anytime than a static phase in which you feel like, you know, you're not able to move forward fast. I think a lot of us have had this vision for what a powerful assistant can be. But we were held back by the underlying technology not being able to, you know, serve that goal.
38:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
38:20 Speaker 04 I think we have a technology which is better able to serve that. That's why you're seeing the progress again. So I think that's exciting to me. I look at it and say, we can actually make Google Assistant a whole lot better. You're seeing visions of that with Project Astra, right? It's, you know, it's incredibly magical to me when I use it. I'm very excited by it.
38:38 Speaker 03 It just brings me back to the first question I asked, right? Language versus intelligence.
38:41 Speaker 04 Yeah.
38:43 Speaker 03 To make these products, I think you need a core level of intelligence. Do you have in your head a measure of this is when it's going to be good enough? Well, I can trust this. On all of your demo slides and all of OpenAI's demo slides, there's a disclaimer that says, check this info. And to me, it's ready when you don't need that anymore. Right? You didn't have check this info at the bottom of the 10 blue links. You don't have check this info at the bottom of featured snippets necessarily.
39:10 Speaker 04 Mate, you're getting at a deeper point where hallucination is still an unsolved problem.
39:16 Speaker 03 Yep.
39:16 Speaker 04 In some ways, it's an inherent feature. It's what makes these models very creative. You know, it's why it can immediately write a poem about Thomas Jefferson in the style of Nilay. It can do that, right? It's incredibly creative. But LLMs aren't necessarily the best approach to always
39:34 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:34 Speaker 04 get a factuality, which is part of why I feel excited about search. Because in search, we are bringing LLMs in a way, but we are grounding it with all the work we do in search and laying it with enough context. I think we can deliver a better experience from that perspective. But I think the reason you're seeing those disclaimers is because of the inherent nature. Right? There are still times it's going to get it wrong.
39:58 Speaker 03 Yeah.
39:58 Speaker 04 But I don't think I would look at that and underestimate how useful it can be at the same time. I think that would be a wrong way to think about it. Google Lens is a good example, right? When we did Google Lens first, when we put it out, it would get, you know, it didn't recognize all objects well. But the curve year on year has been pretty dramatic and users are using it more and more. We get billions of queries now. We've had billions of queries now with Google Lens. It's because the underlying image recognition paired with our knowledge entity understanding has dramatically expanded over time.
40:33 Speaker 04 So I would view it as a continuum. And I think, again, I go back to this saying, users vote with their feet, right? Fewer people use Lens in the first year. We also didn't put it everywhere because we realized the limitations of the product.
40:48 Speaker 03 When you talk to the DeepMind, Google Brain team, is there on the roadmap a solution to the hallucination problem?
40:55 Speaker 04 It's Google DeepMind.
40:59 Speaker 04 Are we making progress? Yes, we are. We have definitely made progress. You know, when we look at metrics on factuality year on year. So we're all making it better, but it's not solved. Are there interesting ideas and approaches which they are working on? Yes, but time will tell, right? And but, you know, but I would view it as L L M's are an aspect of A I, right? You know, we're working on A I in a much broader way. But it's an area where I think we're all working definitely to drive more progress.
41:31 Speaker 03 All right, last question. I think it's the theme of this conversation. Five years from now, this technology, the paradigm shift will be, we'll be through it. It feels like. What does the best version of the web look like for you five years from now?
41:43 Speaker 04 I hope the web is much richer in terms of morality today. I feel like the way humans consume information, you know, still not fully encapsulated in the web. Today, things exist in very different ways, right? Your webpages, your YouTube, et cetera. But over time, I hope the web is much more multimodal. It's much more richer, much more interactive. It is a lot more stateful, which it's not today. So I view it as, while fully acknowledging the point, people may use A I to generate a lot of spam. I also feel every time there's a new wave of technology, people quite don't know how to use it.
42:20 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:20 Speaker 04 When mobile came, everyone took webpages and like shrouded into mobile applications. Then later, people evolved really native mobile applications. So the way people use A I to actually solve new things, new use cases, et cetera, is yet to come. So when that happens, I think the web will be much, much richer too. Dynamically composing a U I in a way that makes sense for you, right? Different people have different needs, right? But today, you know, you're not dynamically composing that U I.
42:52 Speaker 03 Yeah.
42:53 Speaker 04 A I can help you do that over time. You can also do it badly and wrongly, and people can use it shallowly. But there will be entrepreneurs who figured out a extraordinarily good way to do it. And out of it, there'll be great new things to come.
43:08 Speaker 03 Google creates a lot of incentives for development on the web through search, through Chrome, through everything that you do.
43:13 Speaker 04 Yeah.
43:13 Speaker 03 How do you make sure those incentives are aligned toward those goals? Because I think maybe the biggest thing here is that the web ecosystem is in a moment of change and Google has a lot of trust to build and rebuild. How do you think about making sure those incentives point into Reckless?
43:29 Speaker 04 Not everything is in Google's control. I wish I could influence how, what is the single toughest experience when I go to websites today? As a user, you have a lot of cookie dialogues to accept, et cetera. Right? So I would argue there are many things outside. You can go poll 100 users, right? And like, you know? So, but you know, the incentives we would like to create, there's a complex question, which is how do you reward originality, creativity, independent voice at whatever scale at which you're able to do and give a chance for that to thrive in this content ecosystem we create? Right? And that's what I think about. That's what the search team thinks about.
44:10 Speaker 03 Yeah.
44:10 Speaker 04 But I think it's an important principle and I think it'll be important for the web and important for us as a company.
44:16 Speaker 03 That's great. Well, Sudhar, thank you so much for the time. Thank you for being on Decoder.
44:18 Speaker 04 Thanks, thanks, Neelak. Greatly enjoyed it.
44:24 Speaker 03 I'd like to thank Sudhar for taking the time to join Decoder today and thank you for listening. I really hope you enjoyed it. If you'd like to let us know what you thought about this episode, or really anything else, drop us a line. You can email us at decoder@theverge.com. We read all the emails. It's a lot of fun. You can also hit me up directly on threads, I'm at reckless1280. We have a TikTok for as long as there's going to be a TikTok. Check it out. It's at DecoderPod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. And if you really like it, hit us with that five star review. Boy, do we love getting those reviews. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode is produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was recorded by Varan Pavak and Brett Putman and it was edited by Kelly Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
45:07 Speaker 07 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant-quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher, featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Off the valve through October 21st, US and East. See store online for details.
45:38 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
Previous TikTok's big bet to fight the ban bill Next How the FBI built its own smartphone company to hack the criminal underworld Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated