Pod Insights Decoder Getty Images CEO Craig Peters has a plan to defend photography from AI About this episode Last week, when I was co-hosting the Code Conference, I got to talk with Getty Images CEO Craig Peters. The generative AI boom is a direct threat to Getty in many ways. For example, the company is suing Stability AI for training the Stable Diffusion model on Getty content — sometimes clearly including AI-generated copies of the Getty watermark — without permission.
Getty's answer? Its own proprietary, in-house AI tool, trained — with permission — on its own content, using a model where the original creators can get paid. Getty's put some pretty strict guardrails around it for now, but, as even Craig told us, there's still a lot of work to do.
Links:
https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/21/23364696/getty-images-ai-ban-generated-artwork-illustration-copyright
https://www.theverge.com/2023/2/6/23587393/ai-art-copyright-lawsuit-getty-images-stable-diffusion
https://www.theverge.com/2023/9/25/23884679/getty-ai-generative-image-platform-launch
https://www.theverge.com/23900198/microsoft-kevin-scott-ai-art-bing-google-nvidia-decoder-interview
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2020/06/section-230-the-internet-law-politicians-love-to-hate-explained/
https://www.npr.org/2023/05/18/1176881182/supreme-court-sides-against-andy-warhol-foundation-in-copyright-infringement-cas
https://www.theverge.com/2023/7/26/23808184/big-ai-really-wants-to-convince-us-that-theyre-cautious
https://journal.everypixel.com/ai-image-statistics
https://www.npr.org/2023/05/22/1177590231/fake-viral-images-of-an-explosion-at-the-pentagon-were-probably-created-by-ai
Transcript: https://www.theverge.com/e/23667741
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Amanda Rose Smith.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our Editorial Director is Brooke Minters and our Executive Producer is Eleanor Donovan.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 6,462 words · 11 speakers
0:00 Speaker 00 You're busy. We know that, so we'll keep this quick. Introducing AMEX Corporate, now featuring the Corporate Cash Back Card. For one annual flat fee, get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, plus intelligent expense management with the unmatched expertise and backing of American Express. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
0:40 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:47 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:03 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. We've had another great conversation from a Code conference in the feed today. This time, it's my chat with Getty Images CEO Craig Peters. Getty is one of the most important photography services in the world. And as you might imagine, Craig and I talked quite a bit about the promise and peril of generative AI when it comes to photography. Craig was great onstage at Code. He is direct and no-nonsense about what AI can and can't do. And I gotta say, we got right into it. About a year ago, Getty banned users from uploading or selling AI-generated content. At the same time, the company said it was concerned about copyright issues in AI, and eventually, the company sued Stability AI
1:49 Speaker 03 for training the Stable Diffusion tool on Getty's photos. At times, Stable Diffusion was even generating Getty watermarks on its images. But Craig doesn't want to completely stop AI from happening. Just before Code, the company announced Generative AI by Getty Images, a tool which generates pretty solid AI photography of its own. Getty trained the tool itself using images it already had the rights to. And it's put up some pretty strict guardrails about what it can do. It certainly cannot generate any images of non-celebrities. What's more, Getty's come up with a way to compensate photographers whose images are being used to generate photos, which is pretty interesting and pretty complicated. I had early access to this new Getty tool and we had some fun coming up with prompts
2:32 Speaker 03 to show the code audience. I encourage you to watch the video of this episode, which is available on the Verge YouTube channel, so you can take a look at some of these images we're talking about. They're pretty fun. You'll hear Craig talk a lot, not just about copyright issues, but about what people are really talking about when they talk about intellectual property: money. What does compensation for being part of an AI training set look like? How can you distribute that money fairly? We also talked about the other elephant in the room when it comes to AI: deepfakes and disinformation. Getty has a long history as a repository of significant, important, and most importantly, real photos of people and events. The 2024 US election is barreling towards us quickly, and Craig told us that while Getty doesn't yet have a perfect solution
3:15 Speaker 03 for disinformation in the election, the date isn't moving, and he's working with both partners and competitors to race against the clock to make sure authentic images are the ones people see. Okay, Craig Peters, CEO of Getty Images. Here we go.
3:41 Speaker 03 You and I have been chatting since we first started talking about doing code. There's a lot to talk about. We should start with the news, though, because I think a lot of people expected you to show up, rail against the taking of content by AI. But you actually announced an AI tool this week.
3:56 Speaker 04 We did. We did. We launched it on Monday. After coming out of alpha, we launched that in partnership with Nvidia. So we partnered up with them and their capabilities to launch what we think is a pretty unique tool. A tool that, first off, respects the IP that it was trained upon. So it's permissioned, it's trained only off of Getty Images creative content. We are providing rewards back to the creators of that content. So as we grow revenues from this service, those creators are rewarded for their contributions to the tool. It's entirely commercially safe, so it cannot produce third-party intellectual
4:36 Speaker 04 property. It cannot produce deepfakes, so it doesn't know what the Pope is, it doesn't know what Balenci is, and can't produce a merging of the two. And we think for version one, the quality is quite remarkable, because obviously, we're a big believer that quality in gives you a, you know, better outcome.
4:58 Speaker 03 Craig very boldly allowed me access to this tool. I told him a prompt I was gonna use, but I didn't show him the results. So here's the first one I put up. This is a tool. It is fun to use. The well-dressed influential attendees enjoying the code conference. Fancy hotel ballroom. I will say I said in the Ritz Carlton and it wouldn't let me do it because I think it thinks Ritz Carlton is a very fussy name for stuff you're doing. Wide-angle shank out. So here's the result. Here's all of you. You look great. Very excited. I asked it to do it again and I think next year we're gonna have you all sit on the floor in the round. Pretty good. So then I thought I should do something on the news cycle. Famous pop star, a Super Bowl winning tight end, holding hands in a convertible. I think you all know where this is going.
5:42 Speaker 03 It's obviously Zac Efron having a time in his life. Now, to be fair, I did not specify gender, sexuality, ethnicity, anything. This is a reasonable result for this query, in my opinion. And again, Zac in Mercedes Lewis look great. And then here I asked it to do it again. This is great. This is more or less what Travis and Taylor look like. I don't know why she's wearing pads, but it's good. And then lastly, there's the image that I personally really wanted, which is the CEO of a major car company running away from our conference. Here's Mary, your security guard. Looking good. These are remarkable results, right? There's the sort of AI problems. You pay too much attention to the hands or whatever, but the hardest problems have been solved. And I can see how if I was actually writing the story, just being a little bit meaner to GM than I might otherwise, I might use a photo like this.
6:27 Speaker 03 Is that you think that that's what people want in the markets that you're in?
6:31 Speaker 04 Definitively. So we started, first of all, I mean, generative AI did not just burst onto the scene. It's been something that has been around for years. Nvidia, our partner, actually launched the first GANs model from text to image. And so we knew it was coming. And our question to our customers was, you know, how are you gonna use it? What do you need? And we create services for our customers that really allow them to create at a higher level, that save them time, save them money, and eliminate their IP risk.
7:04 Speaker 03 Yeah.
7:05 Speaker 04 And that last piece is critical within AI. Everything that we heard from our customers was, we want to use this technology. And that could vary from media customers to agency customers to corporate customers. They want to unlock some of their creativity through these tools. But they need to make sure that they aren't in violation of of third-party intellectual property, and that can vary around the globe. I mean, if you have an image and it produces an image of a third-party brand or somebody of name and likeness like Kelsey or Swift, you know, that's a problem. But there's much more nuanced problems in in intellectual property, like showing an image of the Empire State Building. You could actually get sued
7:46 Speaker 04 for that. Tattoos are copyrighted. So fireworks can actually be copyrighted. That smiley firework that shows up, Gucci Brothers actually own that that copyright. So there's a lot of things that we baked in here to make sure that our customers could use this and be absolutely safe. And then we actually put our indemnification around that so that if there are any issues, which we're confident there won't be, we'll stand behind that.
8:11 Speaker 03 There's a flip side to that, right? So you know, all the training data is yours. We had asked a bunch of providence questions of Kevin earlier. You know the providence, right? And that the next thing that enables you to do is say, okay, we're going to go pay our creators. How does that work? What's the actual formula for saying, we generated this image, someone paid us for it, and now upstream of that, we're going to pay you however many cents?
8:30 Speaker 04 Right. I think I think Kevin talked a little bit. I was getting mic'd up in the back, but I think he talked a little bit about attribution and whether the technologies exist in order to do that. In our case, at a pixel level, I think the question was earlier around audio. The answer is, right now, those those models don't exist. We tested out a bunch and didn't find them to to be, you know, sufficient in order to do that attribution. So the way we're doing it is we're doing it off of two things. What proportion of the training set does your content represent? And then how has that content performed in our licensing world over time? It's kind of a proxy for quality and quantity. So it's kind of a blend of the two.
9:08 Speaker 03 Yeah. So you're just doing sort of a fixed model?
9:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, and we'll evaluate that over time. If we find fairer ways of doing this, we'll certainly embrace it. We looked for for technology that might might do that. But at this point in time, I think it falls short of the goal.
9:21 Speaker 03 The dynamic here is really interesting, right? So your customers want this. I need to generate a stock photo or something for an ad campaign. Instead of hiring a photographer, I might go to the Getty tool. Will the Getty tool be cheaper? Will it undercut the hiring of the real photographer?
9:34 Speaker 04 I think that's yet to play out. I think, I mean, it's an entirely different model. It's a cost per call type model, generative model. And, you know, you played with the tool. I think this is a very good tool in terms of how it walks you through the prompts and what you can get out of it. Quality from the start, gives you high res from the start. So But it's work. And I think comparing and contrasting that to licensing pre-shot is something that, you know, we've done some time studies with customers and things along those lines. And I think it varies. Ultimately, again, we try to save our customers' time because that is the most expensive thing that they're applying. And I think in some cases, this can be very creative, but not necessarily the most time efficient.
10:15 Speaker 04 And I think our pre-shot, in many cases, can be much more authentic and much more efficient because, you know, you're searching, you're not paying for that search. You're getting a wide variety of content back with real people, real locations. And in many cases, brands care about that, but that can be a much more efficient process. So I think it really, we're going to find out over time.
10:36 Speaker 03 Getty's unique company in space, you actually employ a bunch of photographers, you send them to dangerous places, you create a bunch of news photos. Are you hearing from your own creatives that this is a problem?
10:45 Speaker 04 I wouldn't say that we're hearing from our own creatives that, you know, AI is a problem. I think we represent over half a million photographers worldwide. So within that, you can imagine, within this audience, there's a lot of different, you know, perspectives and points of view. And take that and multiply it times, you know, a thousand and you're going to get even more. So what we hear is a lot of concern about intellectual property. We hear concerns that ultimately, things are being trained on their intellectual property and there's value being created for that, right? Either through subscription services or through other, you know, models. And ultimately, people want that to be solved for.
11:28 Speaker 04 But what we hear from our customers is, again, they want to create and they want to use these tools. And so our point of view from the get-go has always been, we believe AI can have a constructive benefit for the society as a whole, but it needs to account for certain things. And so we've always looked for transparency in trading data. We believe, you know, creators and IP owners have the right to decide whether their material is trained on. We believe the creators of these models shouldn't be covered by something like Section 230, that you should have some skin in the game and take on some liability if you're creating these things and putting them out there. Again, our tool is one that, you know, we were very conscious as a member of the media. The last thing we wanted to do was produce a tool that actually could produce defects.
12:12 Speaker 03 Yeah.
12:12 Speaker 04 And so your Taylor Swift and Kelsey example is one you're gonna have struggle because it doesn't know who Taylor Swift is and it doesn't know who Kelsey is.
12:20 Speaker 03 It's the only, only thing in the world that doesn't know who Taylor Swift is.
12:23 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's exactly right. And that's intentional. And I'd like to think that, you know, Taylor Swift will appreciate that.
12:31 Speaker 03 What are we all working for? It's for Taylor Swift.
12:32 Speaker 04 Exactly.
12:33 Speaker 03 Inside of that, right? There's some big ideas there. So in my brief career as a copyright lawyer and my longer career as a journalist, I find that no one actually cares about copyright law. They don't care about the IP. They care about the money. Right? But the money right now is downstream of some very thorny copyright issues. You heard Kevin say, you know, he thinks, Microsoft thinks, that all this is built on a fair use argument that will eventually succeed or be modified in some way. You are in many ways on the other side of this. You're suing stability for having trained on a bunch of Getty Images. If that, if you win, like, maybe this whole ad of his falls down. Have you thought about the stakes of that lawsuit?
13:11 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think there are high stakes around that lawsuit. We brought it for a reason. We fundamentally believe that IP owners should have a right to have their content, whether it's used in training sets or not. And they should have the right to be compensated if that's their choice. And I don't, I don't buy the argument that Kevin put out there that, you know, I read Moby Dick and therefore, first of all, these computers are not humans. Secondly, they're actually corporate entities that are making money to your point. And in many cases, they're targeting existing markets with these technologies. I think the Warhol case, I mean, not to again, we're maybe a little more,
13:49 Speaker 03 This is why we're here.
13:49 Speaker 04 We're a little bit more IP geeks than than others, but I think the Warhol case.
13:53 Speaker 03 Why do you think we played Prince in front of Kevin?
13:54 Speaker 04 Yeah, I was wondering, what did I get to? It was supposed to be the Bengals, I think. Interesting. I think that's gonna play out. I think we're on the right. I think a world that doesn't reward investment intellectual property is a pretty sad world.
14:08 Speaker 03 Yeah.
14:08 Speaker 04 Whether that's music, whether that's editorial journalism, whether that's imagery, I believe we want to see more creators, not less. And I think it's actually interesting. Chris was on the stage last night from runway doing some demos. And I think Chris's point of view is one that we share. We want more creators because of this technology, not less. And I think that's a great world.
14:30 Speaker 05 Yeah.
14:31 Speaker 04 Right? So how do we enable? And that's what we put this tool out there. We put this tool out not to disintermediate creators. We put this tool out there to enable creators. So the users of our tool are creators. And I think it's going to allow them to create more insightful and innovative ways. But I think others are in some cases pointing these technologies directly at the creators themselves, or in some cases coders, or and I don't think that is the society that I want necessarily pushed towards.
15:02 Speaker 06 We have to take a quick break. We'll be back in a minute.
15:13 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bullspend, and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
15:22 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
15:30 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
15:44 Speaker 07 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
16:12 Speaker 06 Welcome back. We're talking to Getty Images CEO Craig Peters about AI.
16:16 Speaker 03 So obviously, you're in litigation and stability. There are lots of other companies that are potentially training on Getty Images, lots of other companies that are just out there crawling the web and training on that. Yep. Are you in productive conversations with the Microsofts, the Googles, the OpenAIs?
16:29 Speaker 04 We are in productive conversations. You know, whether they result in something productive, I don't know. You know, I think there's a lot of, first, I think there's a PR bullshit layer of like, all right, I'm going to join like this group and I'm going to try to cleanse my reputation because I'm a member of that. Of course, I don't implement anything around it. I don't do anything. I just, you know, cite the fact that my corporate name is on that website. I think
16:57 Speaker 04 That's not real engagement. I think we can have different points of view on law, but I think one of the things that I hope our model proves is that good quality ingredients in creates a better output. It creates a more socially responsible output and it creates one that I think businesses will adopt. So yeah, we're in conversations there, but we aren't going to move off of the fundamental point, which is we believe if you're an IP owner, you should have the right to decide whether your content's used in training and you should be compensated for that, right? And that doesn't mean at the minimus, Jack. Like it's not just a, you know, it's fundamental to these tools.
17:36 Speaker 03 I look at other, we've talked about a lot about music at the conference generally. Again, I'm a nerd for this stuff, but broadly, the music industry has developed its own private copyright law because the courts are a coin flip in fair use arguments, like crazy coin flips in fair use arguments. And so the music industry is just like, we're going to make our own deals on the side. We'll have our own norms. My favorite example of this, by the way, is the publishing rights for the thong song by Cisco are owned by Ricky Martin songwriter because Cisco just whispers the words "live in the vito oka." Like that's not, that's, if you apply that standard to AI, like none of these companies are making money, right? But the music industry has developed that set of norms. Do you see that happening here where you're going to need the courts to figure it out for you? Or that there will be an industry set of norms around licensing and deal making because the courts are unreliable?
18:21 Speaker 04 My hope is that we will not need to rely on the courts.
18:25 Speaker 03 Yeah.
18:26 Speaker 04 Unfortunately, I can't say that's the case across the board. I think there are some very responsible technology organizations that are having dialogue, that are willing to figure out solutions. They understand the stakes at play and I think you can have those conversations. I think there are others that are, you know, just kind of off doing, you know, what they want to do and damn the consequences. Damn the consequences for IP ownership. Damn the consequences for, you know, for deep fakes and what that means to, you know, press and facts and, uh, and democracy. So I, I hope for the solution that we can all agree on it. I don't know that that's necessarily going to be the case, which is why we not only invested a ton of time and resources to launch a, a product
19:11 Speaker 04 that we think actually proves that you can do this responsibly, um, which one of, by the way, a lot of those actors said, well, you could never do this. You could never get. Access to licensed data. So we didn't even try because it's an impossible thing, which again I call bullshit on. And I think this tool is a big bullshit on that statement. But you know, we launched, you know, we're spending millions of dollars to go on the other route because we don't have 100% confidence that we're going to be able to get there. We hope and we'll engage with anybody that wants to. But similarly, we needed to have that other track.
19:47 Speaker 03 Two more themes I want to touch on, where you can make questions to if you want to start lining up. You and I have talked a lot about authenticity. You mentioned deep fakes. Getty does generate some of the most important photographs of our time. Historically, this is the role that Getty plays in our culture. You've said to me that just marking that stuff as authentic is not good enough, right? That there's another problem here. Describe what you think that other problem is.
20:11 Speaker 04 Well, I think there's a problem where you can't discern what is authentic. And in a world where generative AI can produce content at scale, right? And you can disseminate that content on a breadth and reach and on time scale that is immense. You know, there's that potential that ultimately authenticity gets crowded out. Now, I think our brand helps cut through. I think our reputation helps cut through. I do think ultimately that has value. But I do worry about a world where, you know, I think this past year, I heard this stat, that there were more AI images produced than were shot on a camera. That's a staggering thing about where we are in the adoption curve of AI. And so you
20:56 Speaker 04 just play that out on an exponential basis. And then you again, you think about a world where there are nefarious, you know, individuals and organizations and institutions. And that worries me. Like, you know, our newsroom lit up when the Pentagon image was put out there. Is it real? You know, and we're getting calls, you know, asking for, you know, us to validate that. Now let's put that into an election in 2024.
21:25 Speaker 03 Do you think that just marketing cryptographically, you're in the Content Authenticity Initiative group, right?
21:30 Speaker 04 We're in the discussion. We haven't adopted it, to be quite frank. We're not sure that that is the right solution. Right now, it first of all, it puts the onus and the investment on the people creating original content, authentic content, rather than on the platforms and the generative tools that are producing generative content. And we fundamentally think that's a little bit backwards. The generative tools should be investing in order to create the right solutions around that. And in the current view, it's larger in the metadata, which is easily stripped. So you guys are a customer of ours, you use our imagery, you strip our metadata immediately when you put it in your CMS. Because it's lighter and page loads and everything else, so, which makes sense because you're competing for SEO
22:14 Speaker 04 and everything else that you need to do. So you strip it. And so I think what we need to look, and this is where, you know, engaging with Kevin and Microsoft and their team, you know, we're really encouraged by the pledges that they made to the White House in order to identify generative content, because we want to do the exact same thing, but we want to do it in a way that really gets at the core.
22:35 Speaker 03 Are you taking any particular steps ahead of the 2024 election, knowing that you're going to compete for real photographs, real images in a world of generative AI?
22:42 Speaker 04 We are, I would say, but it's one, and we're talking with the Associated Press, we're talking with A. John Friends Press, we're talking, you know, we're talking with our partners and our competitors about how do we go about doing this? And I wouldn't say that while we're taking steps, we don't have perfect solutions. And again, that date isn't moving, and we're getting closer and closer to it.
23:04 Speaker 03 I think one side.
23:07 Speaker 04 I don't think the elections are going to change, but it's one, I mean, I think this is one of those things where, you know, putting technology out into the world under the, you know, let's just, you know, move fast and break things.
23:19 Speaker 03 Yeah.
23:20 Speaker 04 You know, we're playing with bigger stakes here.
23:22 Speaker 03 Last big thing question and we'll go to the audience here. When Craig and I first started talking, one of the things you and I discussed was the market for photography changed inevitably forever when the internet arrived, right? And more people could create and our distribution platforms changed, but pricing collapsed. I know a lot of professional photographers who their careers evaporated with the advent of the internet effectively. Does this feel like that? And you built a business, right? In response to that, that you changed the business. Is this that same moment, do you think? Is it same level of change?
23:49 Speaker 04 I think it's clearly a lot of change. I think what we do has value. And I think, you know, whether that's a tool that can enable creativity or that's content that is highly authentic, that can engage an end audience in a meaningful way and move them, if you're a media company, move them to understand an issue. Or, you know, if you're a corporation, move them to actually engage with your brand or your products. I don't think that goes away. I think this puts different challenges in that is actually fun to navigate and figure out. I think the most important thing that will allow photographers, videographers, writers
24:33 Speaker 04 is that we enable more creators. Like, that's the end goal. And if we do that, then I think the world's a great place. And I think companies like Getty Images will thrive in that and those that work with us will thrive within that. I think if we try to eliminate creators, I think it's a sad world and I think it'll be challenging for our business and for those that try to make a living.
24:57 Speaker 03 We have to take a quick break. We'll be right back with some great questions from our Code audience, Getty Images CEO, Craig Peters.
25:09 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
25:19 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
25:26 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
25:40 Speaker 07 This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up require compatibility and availability varies 18 plus.
26:08 Speaker 03 We're back with some great questions from the Code Conference audience for Craig Peters. Actually, let's start over here. Introduce yourself, please.
26:15 Speaker 06 Andrew Sussman. So with copyright and patents, both stemming from the same part of the Constitution, Congress shall promote the useful arts and sciences, dot, dot, dot. Yet patents over the years have seen a narrowing, a constriction in the exclusive rights that are being granted. Yet copyright has seen largely only an expansion, whether it be how long they last, whether it's what do they cover? And in this case, it seems like some of the creative expression aspects are being wrapped into what are more procedural or data elements. Like if you were to take a text or an image and convert it into a series of numbers,
27:00 Speaker 06 where is the creative expression in that? So just curious as to if in connection with Congress revisiting, what the scope of copyright includes, should they also be looking at how broad copyright is as a general nature?
27:16 Speaker 03 My man, that's my own heart.
27:19 Speaker 04 Well, first off, I think the Copyright Office right now is in an act of open submission for input on AI and the degree to which copyright is or is not applied. And obviously, we have a point of view on that and we'll put a brief in and give input into that. But I think copyright needs to be something that constantly evolves. The world constantly evolves. And I think that's ultimately something that I think regulatory institutions.
27:49 Speaker 04 Governments, legislative, I think evolve at a slower pace than technology. So they tend to lag, but I do think they are doing their best to go through and be contemplative about, you know, how does this move the needle or not on copyright? And I think they're bringing all the voices in together in order to do that. And I think they'll come out and what is a reasonable space, I think. But my point is, is that copyright needs to evolve. And if we want it just to stay stagnant, it's going to ultimately not match up to the world that we're living in. So I don't know if that answers your question, but that evolution is critical.
28:27 Speaker 05 Jay Peters with The Verge, I know the new AI tool is designed not to create images of real people. But what if it does? What if it makes a Joe Biden? What if it makes a Donald Trump? What if it makes a Pope? What does Getty do in that situation?
28:41 Speaker 04 It can't. It doesn't know who they are.
28:44 Speaker 05 Is there any way for somebody to engineer a prompt, though, that gets like a pretty close approximation?
28:49 Speaker 04 Because it doesn't know who they are. It really doesn't. So if you go on Bing and you do Travis Kelsey and Taylor Swift, it will give you somebody wearing a Chiefs uniform that kind of looks like Kelsey. And you won't be able to type Taylor Swift and Travis Kelsey, but just do Swift and Kelsey. And you'll get an output. That's because it was trained on the internet. It was trained on our content and others that sit out on that internet. Therefore, it knows who they are. This content was trained in the universe where that doesn't exist. So it really does not know. Now, we put in prompt engineering, we put things in there that can inform you that that's not something that this tool will respond to. But even if we miss that prompt, because we didn't think of that in terms of the architecture,
29:35 Speaker 04 it won't produce that output. And unless we open up it to train on other content, it cannot produce those outcomes. And I think that's, again, thinking about how you build these tools so that they can really be beneficial into businesses and corporations. And at the same time, be responsible to society. I think it's a really important element. Now, I think what we can do is we can take third Intellectual property where they actually have the ownership rights. And then we can do custom fitting or what is custom training of that along with Nvidia to produce a model that's bespoke to that IP. But that's a case again where that IP will be owned or have the necessary permissions in order to bring that to the table.
30:20 Speaker 04 So we'll, we'll be doing that with brands and companies over the coming months and years in order to produce some of those. But the fundamental piece here is most large language models, you know, generative models, because they're trained on open data sets under the notion that that is fair use. They know a lot and they have to now do prompt engineering in order to restrict it. And, you know, that's like whack a mole.
30:43 Speaker 05 Yeah.
30:43 Speaker 04 Right?
30:44 Speaker 05 Yeah.
30:45 Speaker 08 Miles Fisher, appreciate your candid responses. You talk about big picture, enabling more creators. And that's for the greater good. So agree with that. At the advent now of deep fakes, you know, a lot of the academic think pieces have compared the criticism to the advent of the camera. In the mid 1800s, creators are left with nothing. The artistry of painting, all of that rendered mute. I'd just like to know personally, what do you think makes an exceptional photograph?
31:12 Speaker 04 It's a good question. It's, to me, it's the one that moves you. All right. So there is, there's a level of photography that I think, you know, whether it's computer generated or otherwise, it's the one that makes you stop, think, react, have emotion, engage. That's, that's a great photo. Whether that's in news, whether that's in sport, entertainment, or in a creative moment with a brand, like I think those are the things that talent truly can express. And that's why I believe in creative talent, because I don't think the expertise that goes into, you know, just let's, let's take what people might call stock for a second.
31:53 Speaker 04 If you knew what went into producing a great piece of imagery that actually got your attention. These are people that are, that are understanding how to bring empathy, trust, integrity into photos in a new way that you haven't thought about before and they can. Grab that attention that on an audience, that's tough to do. It's easy. I kind of sometimes equate our business to kind of like fast fashion in the creative sense. Like, because we're constantly having to do something new because somebody else is going to knock off what we just did yesterday. So, but that's what makes photography great at its core. It's something that makes you stop, think, emote, engage.
32:34 Speaker 03 Well, that's a great place to end it. That was a great question. Thank you so much, Mick.
32:37 Speaker 04 My pleasure.
32:37 Speaker 03 It's great to have you.
32:38 Speaker 04 Thank you.
32:46 Speaker 03 I'd like to thank Craig Peters for talking to me at Code. Thank the audience at Code for coming and asking really great questions. And of course, thank you all for listening to Decoder. I hope you enjoyed it. As always, I'd love to hear what you think of the show. You can email us at decoder@theverge.com. I do read all the emails. Or you can hit me up directly on Threads, I'm at reckless1280. We also have a TikTok. Check it out, it's at DecoderPod, it's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. If you really love the show, hit us with that five star review. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Stat. It was edited by Amanda Rose Smith. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. Our editorial director is Brooke Minter, and our executive producer is Eleanor Donovan. We'll see you next time.
33:32 Speaker 09 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing and wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on an Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
34:03 Speaker 10 This week, it pays extra to be a MyLowe's Rewards member. Through October 14, members get $10 MyLowe's money when you spend $200 or more on an eligible purchase during MyLowe's Money Days. Also, using your MyLowe's Rewards credit card? Even better, that's an additional $20 MyLowe's money. Use it to save on your next Lowe's haul. Exclusions, restrictions, and more terms apply. See Lowe's.com slash MyLowe's Money Days for details. MyLowe's money expires 30 days after issuance. Subject to change. Credit offer subject to credit approval.
Previous Microsoft CTO Kevin Scott on how AI and art will coexist in the future Next Rivian CEO RJ Scaringe on ramping up R1T production and competing with the Cybertruck Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated