Pod Insights Decoder Disney just fought off a shareholder revolt — but the clock’s still ticking About this episode Today, we're talking about Disney, the massive activist investor revolt it just fought off, and what happens next in the world of streaming. Because what happens to Disney really tells us a lot about what's happening in the entire world of entertainment. Earlier this month, Disney survived an attempted board takeover from businessman Nelson Peltz. While investors ultimately sided with Disney and CEO Bob Iger, the boardroom showdown made something very clear: Disney needs to figure out streaming and get its creative direction back on track.
To help me figure all this out, I brought on my friend Julia Alexander, who is VP of Strategy at Parrot Analytics, a Puck News contributor, and most importantly, a former Verge reporter. She's a leading expert on all things Disney, and I always learn something important about the state of the entertainment business when I talk to her.
Links:
The Story of Disney+ — Puck News
Disney’s CEO drama explained, with Julia Alexander — Decoder
Is streaming just becoming cable again? Julia Alexander thinks so — Decoder
Disney Fends Off Activist Investor for Second Time in 2 Years — NYT
For Disney, streaming losses and TV’s decline are a one-two punch — NYT
Disney’s ABC, ESPN weakness adds pressure to make streaming profitable — WSJ
Disney reportedly wants to bring always-on channels to Disney Plus — The Verge
The Disney Plus-Hulu merger is way more than a streaming bundle — The Verge
Disney’s laying off 7,000 as streaming boom comes to an end — The Verge
The last few years really scared Disney — Screen Rant
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 0:00 Speaker 00 You're busy. We know that, so we'll keep this quick. Introducing AMEX Corporate, now featuring the Corporate Cash Back Card. For one annual flat fee, get 1.5% cash back on eligible business purchases, plus intelligent expense management with the unmatched expertise and backing of American Express. Built to simplify, designed to scale. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms and cap apply.
0:30 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
0:40 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:47 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
1:02 Speaker 03 Hello and welcome to Decoder. I'm Neelai Patel, editor in chief of The Verge, and Decoder is my show about big ideas and other problems. Today, we're talking about Disney, the massive activist investor revolt it just fought off, and what happens next in the world of streaming. Because what happens to Disney really tells us a lot about what's happening in the entire world of entertainment. And this is a crucial moment for the company and the industry as a whole. Disney is obviously a giant in the world of entertainment. There's Mickey Mouse and the theme parks, of course, but there's also Marvel, Star Wars, Pixar, ABC, and a whole lot more. Disney funded all that growth with huge fees it was collecting from cable companies that needed to distribute Disney-owned channels like ESPN and ABC. And it cemented its dominance with an incredible run of blockbuster movies,
1:46 Speaker 03 particularly from Marvel. But streaming has upended both the cable bundle and the traditional movie business, and the end of the ride appears to be clearly in sight. So Disney's made a huge bet on Disney Plus to take on Netflix, and it's now rolling Hulu and ESPN into that product in an effort to recreate some of the old cable magic. But the pressure isn't going away. Earlier this month, Disney survived an attempted board takeover from an activist investor named Nelson Peltz, his second attempt in two years. Peltz was upset with Disney's approach to Disney+ and he thought CEO Bob Iger could be doing a lot of things differently. And while investors ultimately sided with Disney and Iger, the boardroom showdown made something very clear.
2:28 Speaker 03 Disney needs to figure out streaming because it has spent more than $11 billion on Disney Plus so far without making a profit. And at the same time, it needs to fix what many critics consider to be a serious creative rut in its movies and TV shows. To help me figure all this out, I brought on my friend Julia Alexander, who is VP of Strategy at Parrot Analytics, a Puck News contributor, and most importantly, a former Verge reporter. She's a leading expert on all things Disney, and I always learn something important about the state of the entertainment business when I hang out with her. And there's a lot going on in the Disney story. It's about distribution. It's about old Hollywood versus new. It's about how our individual habits have been dramatically changed by technology in a way that some of the most powerful companies in the world are struggling to predict. What's going on at Disney really tells us so many stories about why
3:13 Speaker 03 the media business is the way it is, what the internet did to it, and why it's all now changing once again. All right, Disney and the state of entertainment. Here we go.
3:34 Speaker 03 Julia Alexander, welcome to Decoder.
3:36 Speaker 04 Thank you for having me again.
3:37 Speaker 03 I'm excited to talk to you because it feels like there are a tiny number of people in the world who understand what is happening inside Disney, and very few of them actually work at Disney. You've got a view on Disney. You have paid a lot of attention to Disney for a long time. That company just came through a massive shareholder battle with Nelson Peltz, who's an activist investor. They won. They seemed triumphant. But a phrase you keep using about Disney, even in their triumph, is that there is a hum of anxiety throughout the company. What is the hum of anxiety at Disney?
4:07 Speaker 04 If you look at Disney's finances, you can kind of see that hum of anxiety come to fruition even two years ago. First quarter fiscal year 2022, media networks and linear networks, which is typical cable and linear broadcast system, made up like 35% of their overall revenue, right? And that is continues to drop every single quarter since then. And if you look at streaming, although their revenue has increased, they're still not a profitable business by any stretch of the imagination. And so the Nelson Peltz fight really comes in at this moment of continuous hum of anxiety in the company, which is the runway that we're on, that we need to take off in order to kind of be this legacy media company of tomorrow, a phrase that I like to use to describe Disney, is quickly coming to an
4:50 Speaker 04 end. And there's no sign that Disney Plus is really going to replace the lost revenue from the linear division. There are signs that Disney Plus is very successful and that it will continue to be successful and will continue to grow. But is that enough to offset what is happening in the decline in the cable business, which is the greatest invention in capitalism history? Well, at least there's no signs right now that say yes. What happens with Disney, this very strong media brand company, if it can't figure out its streaming business before its linear business actually falls off a cliff?
5:23 Speaker 03 Do me a favor for the Decoder audience. You said the cable bundle is the greatest invention in the history of capitalism. I feel like a lot of Decoder listeners have never had cable. Explain what the cable bundle is very quickly and why you think it's the greatest invention in the history of capitalism.
5:36 Speaker 04 There's different forms of linear channels within a television ecosystem that we used to think of it. So you had your broadcast networks, which are still very strong. So you have ABC, CBS, NBC, those still bring in large audiences. Then you had basic cables. These were other channels that sat within this one unified ecosystem. So think of it kind of like the App Store of television, right? Like what it kind of used to be, instead of apps, you had channels. The basic networks, like AMC, basic cable networks, you paid a little bit extra for access to them. And then your the roster of channels that you would grew from channel one to channel like sixty. And then there were all these cable channels, so ESPN, HBO, Showtime, these are all premium cable channels.
6:19 Speaker 04 And you could add those on to your package, but they all sat within this ecosystem. So be just because you added HBO does not mean you got rid of ABC. And so the more that these cable channels came together and these these companies grew, the more they started selling their high interest cable channels ESPN within packages. So if I'm Disney, I want you Charter or you Comcast to carry ESPN and you want to carry ESPN. So in order to get ESPN, you're going to also have to buy the Disney Channel and ESPN two, ESPN three, ESPN four. And the more that this happened, the more affiliate revenue is coming into the companies and the more advertising revenue you could sell. So even if your channel was not getting as much viewership as ESPN, which was certainly the case for many networks,
7:04 Speaker 04 your network was still profiting off being within this ecosystem that ESPN was part of. That has gone away in the direct consumer era.
7:13 Speaker 03 So you've laid out how the cable bundle worked and why it was so hugely profitable for companies like Disney. But we are not seeing the same story play out for Disney Plus. Let's just go through it. Disney Plus launches in 2019 and it grows really fast to almost a hundred million subscribers in its first year. The following year, Bob Iger, who had been CEO for more than 15 years and oversaw the acquisition of Lucasfilm and Marvel, steps down and he hands the reins to Bob Chapek, the head of Parks and Resorts. Two Bobs. Then COVID happens in 2020 and streaming services all explode with growth. But it turns out not everyone was going to stay inside forever, that growth was not sustainable. And it cost these companies a lot. Disney has spent more than $11 billion in Disney Plus, hasn't turned a profit yet.
7:58 Speaker 03 This is the other side of the story, right? Is that just as cable starts unbundling and people start replacing it with streaming, the economics of the streaming services start to fall apart. And it doesn't feel like any of these companies were prepared for that.
8:12 Speaker 04 The ironic part of this part of Disney's history, which was a small chapter, but a very important chapter, Bob Chapek is the CEO at this point. He's the former head of Parks, right? Comes in and he's the CEO. He's tasked with kind of carrying through Bob Iger and Kevin Mayer, who was the former head of DTCI or streaming at Disney, who then became CEO of TikTok for a very short period of time.
8:31 Speaker 03 For two minutes.
8:32 Speaker 04 For two minutes. So Bob Chapek comes in. One of the things that they do, in part because of the pandemic, but then they carried it through to 2021 and early 2022, if I remember correctly, was they said, we're just going to take movies and send them to streaming. We're going to build up Disney Plus by bringing it to the streaming audience. And then we're going to go directly from theaters to Disney Plus. A quick explainer on how movie studios typically make money. They go to theaters where they earn anywhere between 60 to 70% of the revenue from the film. The rest of it goes to the exhibitors like AMC, Regal, Alamo, whatever it is. Then what happens is what many people listening to this podcast will remember. It would go to Blu-ray. It would go to DVD. Then you would remember
9:14 Speaker 04 that it would go to HBO, right? So there is pressure to perform at theaters. But if you didn't perform in theaters, you were also getting secure money coming in from HBO. So by the time the film actually made its way back to being fully owned by Disney, it had made a ton of money on the back end that they didn't even have to worry about because they had all these deals in place. We totally eliminated that. The industry just got rid of it. And they said, we're going to go directly from theaters to our owned and operated platforms. So we're basically paying ourselves. We Disney Plus are paying you, the Walt Disney Studio, to bring this film over here specifically. Not only does that cut down your audience in terms of who's getting access to the film and where you can really build that franchise, but it cuts out a ton of the profit that you're making off that film.
9:55 Speaker 03 So linear TV is declining because the cable bundle is going away. And you've just described why the economics of streaming are so much worse than the theater model. When Disney would sell a movie to the theater, to licensing, it would sell DVDs. I really want to stress this. Companies like Disney were making huge amounts of money with incredible margins before streaming took over. And now those revenue streams are drying up fast and that's a really big deal. I think many people pointed out the increased revenue from ESPN in particular is what allowed Disney to buy Marvel, to buy Lucasfilm. That's going away and the thing that's supposed to replace it is a similarly expensive bundle in Disney Plus. So you buy Disney Plus, you get Hulu, you get ESPN Plus, maybe over time Disney loads more and more things into that.
10:38 Speaker 03 Is Disney Plus ever meant to get as expensive as an old school cable subscription with all of the content in it?
10:44 Speaker 04 I think that's the million dollar question and underlining that question is something that is very prevalent in today's direct to consumer streaming market. That was not a concern almost at all within pay TV and that's churn, right? So that's cancellation. We've made it very cheap to get a lot of television, a lot of movies at once. Think about when Netflix launched and it was like 10 bucks, right? And so it hasn't actually increased that price, their prices that much even on their premium tier. But when you were within pay TV, for people who are listening who likely to Neelai's point did not have pay TV, if you went to cancel, you would be on the phone with Comcast for four hours. And by the end of it, you ended up buying more, like you didn't get rid of it. Somehow you got more out of them. And so you never canceled.
11:28 Speaker 04 So that service, you're able to have sustainable revenue that was increasing. And as your total addressable market, as your audience grew, you're able to sell advertising at a higher rate. Within direct to consumer, you have to price low in order for mass adoption to happen, right? People are going to come in, especially when there's free offerings. Look at how much attention YouTube commands as a free offering, right? Within Gen Z, Gen Alpha and millennials. Look at new services like Tubi. These are free ad-supported television services typically called fast platforms. Those are free and they have a lot of old television, old films, but they generate larger shares of attention from audiences every single month. So in order to be a premium subscription service that is, that is charging a fee, you have to start low and then build up high.
12:11 Speaker 04 But you can only build highs, anybody who's built a subscription business knows, if your churn rate is extremely low. So really hard if you're spending marketing money to effectively re-acquire the same customer. You're losing, but having to prove the value of your product again and again. If you look at Disney Plus, the goal is always to make the largest revenue you can off each customer. Typically, that comes from advertisement, which is why we're seeing that huge push. And that comes from higher prices. But you can only increase those prices if that churn rate's low. That's why you're seeing the Disney Plus Hulu integration really rolling out. You're seeing that internationally with the Star integration. If that gets churn rate low, then what that tells you is that value perception of the product is high. And so they can increase their prices and say, we might lose some customers, but it's okay.
12:56 Speaker 04 But price increases, again, as anyone who runs a subscription business knows, you have to handle them carefully. You typically do it when you've got an onslaught of really strong programming coming in. And I think Disney is sitting at a point where the programming isn't as strong as they'd like it to be on Disney Plus. The churn's a little bit higher than they like it to be. It does get to a point where it's a fifteen, twenty, thirty dollar product. I'm sure they might want it to eventually, potentially, you know, potentially one day. But they're simply not there yet.
13:21 Speaker 03 So this strikes, I think, at the heart of the issue. Disney needs to make a chunk of guaranteed money from every cable subscriber in America. I feel compelled to point out that people did not love their cable companies. In fact, they hated that, like openly hated them. I also feel compelled to disclose that Comcast is an investor in Vox Media, a parent company. They don't like me, and I made a Netflix show called The Future of. I also hosted the Mr. Robot After Show for USA. Great disclosures, all very relevant to this conversation. People didn't like their cable companies, but they were getting a lot of value. There was not a lot of choice. You couldn't really quit them easily. Fine, Disney makes a bunch of money that way. The idea now is all of that revenue has to come back from Disney Plus as the cable bundle goes away? Or is there somewhere else that Disney is going to make up the lost revenue from?
14:06 Speaker 04 There are a few pathways Disney specifically has in front of it. So Disney's biggest advantage is that maybe sitting alongside Nike and Apple. It is one of the most world renowned brands, right? So Disney has that in a way that Netflix doesn't. Disney, to me, equals love. Netflix equals convenience. And so you open Netflix because it's got most of what you want. This now includes licensed programming like Suits. We all saw everybody in America got Suits fever last summer. That happened on Netflix because of the size of that platform. Disney can do Star Wars, it can do Marvel, it can do Pixar, and that is its advantage. Those are very expensive and something to understand about Disney that gets lost in the conversation. Disney has always been a supplier. Disney supplied to theaters. Disney
14:50 Speaker 04 supplied to cable operators. So they were not the actual distributor. They did not have the operational spend of a direct to a consumer platform which they now have. And so their spending has increased on the same type of product, but they haven't brought down their spending on the content side. They're slowly starting to do that now. So what Disney likely has to do is twofold. One, determine how to better license its catalog to other players. So that way it can continue building sustainable revenue until its streaming division, which will include ESPN in 2025 as they launch their OTT service for that product that will be integrated into Disney Plus and Hulu. Part of it is figure out, okay, so we have all this programming we don't really need. People aren't necessarily watching it and we can license it out. This is a double edged sword, right? If you just
15:34 Speaker 04 license all your programming to Netflix and that programming finds a new audience on Netflix, you've just trained your audience to spend time on Netflix. And so they're not necessarily going to come back to you at this frequency that you need them to come back to you at. Instead, they grow a part of a churn and return audience, right? They cancel, they come back when they need to, and then they go back to Netflix. But the other key component that Disney has the advantage of is that as we are inundated in this era of abundance, finding scarcity is so much harder to do. And scarcity takes the form going forward, in my opinion, in physical events. So you can see this with Taylor Swift tickets. You can see this with Barbenheimer, which was Barbie and Oppenheimer at the movie theaters. And you can see this at Disney parks. We think of it in the media
16:19 Speaker 04 as a boring story because it's just so conventionally safe. But if we look at that company or that segment of the company, I think it did eight or nine billion in revenue in the last quarter and it did like 3.5 billion in operating income. To put that in perspective, that is more in operating income alone than I think linear television, which was one of its largest sectors, did in revenue. So it's a huge difference for Disney and streaming again, strong revenue coming in about 5.2 billion, but still at a loss in terms of operating income at the time that we're recording this. If you're Disney or thinking about what are we going to do? You lean into your two biggest strengths. One is being able to create event style content, go back to theaters. You use your ABC network to have your new Mandalorian show and bring it to Disney Plus.
17:02 Speaker 04 You really lean into that event and bring Hulu in to be this churn catcher. Two, you sell the content to other players that is not necessarily performing on your platform, so why hoard it? And three, you do what they are doing, which is invest $60 billion over the next 10 years in parks and say, we want eventually to get people over here because we can monetize somebody much higher rate than we're necessarily going to do on a pure entertainment side. Easier said than done, parks are expensive. There are not that many around the world, but that is where you can see Disney really leaning into and saying, how do we get that love back within this community and really monetize it? And it's parks.
17:36 Speaker 03 I just went to Disney World last year and I was ruthlessly monetized. So I can see the strategy working. Like every minute of my visit, I felt monetized. I felt the monetization running through me. We need to take a quick break. When we come back, Julie and I get into what went wrong with Disney Plus's content strategy over the past few years.
18:00 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
18:09 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
18:17 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
18:30 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
19:00 Speaker 06 Propel fitness water with Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you propel with Gatorade electrolytes?
19:19 Speaker 03 We're back with Parrot Analytics VP of Strategy, Julia Alexander, to talk about Disney Plus and how it started to go sideways. Here's a little context about Disney around this time. Julia just told us about the combination of three big trends, the decline of linear TV and the cable bundle, the big changes streaming had caused to traditional distribution, and then the pandemic powered illusion that the streaming audience would keep growing forever and magically turn into profits. All of that is really what's putting pressure on Disney. Julia also mentioned Bob Chapek, who took over as CEO for Bob Iger in 2021. If you're just catching up on the Disney saga, Julia and I have talked about the two Bobs quite a lot on this podcast over the years. We'll link to some of those conversations in the show notes.
20:02 Speaker 03 The short version is that Bob Iger appointed Bob Chapek as his successor and then ended up firing him and coming back to run the company in relatively short order. It was a mess, but none of it changed those three essential pressures on the business. So we're just going to spend some time here on concrete examples of what Disney got wrong in those first couple of years of Disney Plus. Because as you'll hear Julia explain, Disney was operating off some very skewed data because it launched Disney Plus right as the pandemic set in. Its expectations were out of sync with reality and you can see that as it experiments with what it thinks audiences want out of Disney Plus and what's really keeping them subscribed.
20:49 Speaker 04 You have to remember, and it's something that we don't talk enough about as analysts, but it's so important. These companies have not had a solid data set for customer activity until very recently. Most of these streaming services launched in November of 2019. So like a few months before the pandemic and the pandemic had a massive pull forward. Anyone who was going to get a Streaming service in the United States got it between 2020 and 2021 when the rest of these kind of services launched like Peacock and Max. So Disney Plus had a moment of saying, we need to increase adoption. Wall Street is rewarding scale that all they want is scale. So if we have a new Star Wars and Marvel show every two months, every three months, very HBO style, then every three months, we're going to see a huge increase in subscribers.
21:33 Speaker 04 That was not what happened. They were seeing big increases in subscribers because they were launching in new countries. And so you launch and now there's more opportunity to build subscribers. The other thing is that the Marvel and Star Wars fans were coming in from the get go. They were there and they were not leaving. So you didn't have to work as hard at that expense to keep that audience. So they're thinking, okay, our data set shows that these shows are performing well on the platform, which they would do because your platform is built up of families and then Marvel and Star Wars fans and your subscriber activity is increasing because you're launching globally, but you're not necessarily attracting a new audience. There was a very specific moment on Disney Plus that I think was a great lesson that had a bunch of wrong
22:13 Speaker 04 takeaways. And it was in July 2020 and they brought Hamilton to Disney Plus. And that movie did bonkers for Disney Plus, not only in terms of engagement as in viewership, but in terms of the amount of subscribers that brought into the platform and the type of subscribers. They were non Disney fans who came in for Hamilton. And everyone pointed to it and said, it's a really big moment. If we bring movies to Disney Plus, it will increase the amount of people who are going to come to Disney Plus. That's fantastic. What we didn't look at was again, that that term churn. Right after they left, I think we look at third party data from a firm called Antenna, I think it was like 70% of people who came in for Hamilton churn, like canceled. They got out of there compared to the benchmark was maybe 30% for those who came in who were not
22:56 Speaker 04 part of the Hamilton crowd, who were just average Disney fans. The reason why Disney kind of moved a bunch of things over was one, the pandemic meant that there weren't a lot of opportunities to go to theaters and they used it as a new platform. They used it to increase adoption, which I would not blame them for. I think that's smart. They were thinking about how do we get to mass adoption? And remember, Eli, this was the period where Wall Street was was valuing and rewarding growth over all anything else. It was grow, grow, grow, grow. It wasn't until the end of the Chapek era that Wall Street came in and said, oh, are we making money here? And if we're not making money, what are we doing? And then all of a sudden they had to totally change course on their strategy.
23:32 Speaker 03 You've described a lot of tensions here, right? We've got to move all the revenue from our decaying cable bundle to parks and Disney+ Plus. That's a really hard problem. We have to go back to windowing. There needs to actually be other places to sell things to. So if you were windowing to pay cable and the cable industry is dying, maybe your number of distributors is going down. You don't want to window to other streaming services because they're in direct competition with you. These are all very hard problems. I described the victory over Nelson Peltz as a triumph, right? They beat the activist shareholder who was a pain in Disney's side. But that victory didn't actually solve the problems, right? He's just the symbol of the problems, like waving a flag and saying, look at all these problems.
24:15 Speaker 03 Bob Iger isn't the person to fix it and the plan is bad. Defeating him isn't the solution to the problems, right? It's just saying the shareholders believe in me, Bob Iger, to fix it? Like, I don't know that Disney's actually fixed it. Is that the hum of anxiety?
24:30 Speaker 04 That's absolutely the hum of anxiety. And what's really funny, if you have an hour to kill and want to read through some PowerPoints, you can go read Nelson Peltz and Tryon's deck about what their issue is with Disney. There's like 160 slides. And then you can read Disney's deck, which is like 70 slides, is kind of a response. The funny thing about this whole situation is that Nelson keeps going, the streaming strategy is not working, we have to make changes. Disney has said the same thing. Disney's like, the things you're recommending, we are also aware of and we're working on those already. Disney's problem is not the Disney problem. It is the underlying problem facing legacy media companies. So that includes NBC Universal, thank you Eli for your disclosures, NBC Universal, Paramount Global, Warner Brothers Discovery.
25:13 Speaker 04 All of these companies who are trying to innovate for the future and invest in it, but are tied down by these legacy assets. This was why for so long they didn't get into streaming. Because they were like, we're not going to cannibalize our audience on linear. If you remember the Hulu launch, part of the reason that Hulu didn't take off the way Prime Video did and they launched around the same time was Prime Video invested in originals, Netflix invested in originals, Hulu, which was a... Kind of bundle offering between Fox and Disney and I think NBC Universal, they didn't know what to make of it, but they knew they had to be in streaming. And so they were like, okay, we'll do this thing and we'll put some of our shows here, but we won't agree on how we're going to do our shows or when they're going to come here. And so it confused consumers. It's really hard to train habit.
25:57 Speaker 04 It is even harder to train different habit. And so this is always my concern to your point about licensing to other players. If you license Netflix, again, again, you just train your audience to go to Netflix. Eventually they stop opening your app. I always like to say the hardest part is getting someone to download an app. The second hardest part is getting them to actually open it day after day. And so with Disney, the hum of anxiety they're feeling is this, is this hum of anxiety in Hollywood, which is how do we hold on to these legacy assets for as long as possible? Because they are still generating revenue in the billions. But how do we also price these products that way? We're generating a significant profit, so not just revenue, but significant profit that is going to allow us to continue paying for the investment in new titles, in new acquisitions, in new technology.
26:41 Speaker 04 And Disney is in the middle of figuring out, I think they're a very close number two, right? Netflix, Amazon kind of sitting at the top. Paramount Plus, Peacock, Max, all of those are still really struggling to figure out. And then the great tension hanging over all of this. The undisputed beast is YouTube. And that's something where they're very scared. Think about this from, from the Disney standpoint. I think of a lot about how they're, we call them a legacy media brand, right? I compared them to Nike and Apple. Great brand. There was a really worrisome moment for me during the Chapek era. He was, he had an earnings call and he said, "We are losing the preschool audience to YouTube and Netflix." And I remember thinking like, "You own Mickey Mouse." Like, "What are you talking about?"
27:26 Speaker 04 But kids are going to YouTube. And anyone who listens who's got kids knows this. And they're going to YouTube and they're playing Roblox and that's where they're spending their time. If kids grow up with something that's not necessarily Disney, they don't have the adoration that's going to compel them to go to parks. Now, they still watch Disney. This isn't being baby like Disney has totally lost the kid audience, but YouTube keeps eating away at it day after day. The other really concerning factor about YouTube is that Disney has to be premium. It has to be great. Netflix has to be premium. HBO Max has to be premium. YouTube just has to be good enough.
27:59 Speaker 03 Chapek saying, "We're losing the preschool audience to YouTube." He was talking about Cocamelon, like, straight up Cocamelon is a YouTube phenomenon. The thing is a rocket ship. It's not rolled up in a company that Kevin Mayer runs, which is kind of funny in its own way. They have a big Netflix deal. It's a franchise, but it started as a bunch of YouTube videos and anybody who has children is watching Wheels on the Bus from Cocamelon on YouTube 100 times a day. Then there's Bluey, uh, which is also phenomenon. That is on Disney Plus, but that is not a Disney property. They don't own it. Bluey might be going away. There's all these rumors and it's at the end of its run. I hope not, because my own child will be devastated if that happens.
28:39 Speaker 03 But the two biggest phenomenons in children's programming right now, one is straight user generated content that turned into an enormous franchise. And the other one is like a quirky Australian government funded program. Where is Disney in making the new franchise? Are they capable of doing it?
28:56 Speaker 04 This, I think, it really gets to the heart of a lot of the concern around Disney. And I do think they're best poised to combat it more so than any other company because they're not the only company dealing with this. If you ask people what the biggest issue with Netflix is, and I promise this gets to your Disney question, but the biggest problem with Netflix film, for example, is, is that it's totally forgettable, right? You, you can't name a Netflix franchise. They've spent more than a hundred billion dollars at this point on content and they maybe have like three or four franchises that you could point to and be like, this is something like, I can see a Stranger Things t-shirt in Walmart and I get it. As we look at Disney, Disney not only wants to build these amazing franchises and find new IP to acquire, they want to own the whole thing because they want to be able to put it into parks and do the merchandise and own the streaming rights and whatever it might be.
29:40 Speaker 04 And so I think that gets really complicated, especially if you're in the bit of a, of a creative dry route. They've made a few mistakes along the way that have hurt brand value. So a great example is Marvel and Star Wars on Disney Plus. And so when they were announcing that they were going to increase the amount of content they were putting on Disney Plus in order to meet fans, they said, we're going to do like five or six Star Wars shows a year, like five or six Marvel shows a year. At some point you can get the same level of audience attention and subscriber activity with two shows. You don't necessarily need the six shows, but you're also devaluing your brand because the more content you make, the like, the likelier chance that not all, that's going to be great. That's just how hit rates work. That's why Apple TV plus.
30:24 Speaker 04 It's a pretty strong hit rate because they've only done a handful of things compared to Netflix, which has a very low hit rate. And so when we look at Disney and its ability to create franchises, it creates them. And then with streaming, it leaned on them to a place where we then said, okay, this is now what we're supposed to expect out of Marvel. And I don't necessarily know if I need to return to this, if it's going to be at a level that I don't really care about anymore. And there's 10,000 other things fighting for my attention and I can just give it elsewhere. Marvel and Star Wars were devalued. It got complicated. It started feeling like homework and that was something they shouldn't have leaned on to as much. It's really hard for that company to understand how to be a steady heartbeat, how to have
31:05 Speaker 04 something that is there for different audiences at a broad level without relying too much on their four or five verticals that burn out the audience and force that audience to go find something else.
31:19 Speaker 03 We need to take another quick break. When we're back, Julie and I get into why the Marvel rocket ship came back down to Earth, what that means for Disney+.
31:29 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great till the CFO sees them? That's bullspend and marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
31:39 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, it'll be good for the brand when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
31:47 Speaker 01 Cut the bullspend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
32:00 Speaker 05 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
32:29 Speaker 06 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade electrolytes, zero sugar, and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
32:48 Speaker 03 We're back with Julia Alexander from Pair Analytics to discuss what really went wrong with Disney's Marvel strategy.
32:55 Speaker 03 Do you think they just got confused by the success of the Iron Man version of Marvel? Right? Like, everyone shows up to all those movies. They're, they were all, the stories were tight, they were well made, but they were phenomenons in their way. And then you have Avengers, Endgame, and you kill most of them. You kill most of the beloved characters. You got a whole bunch of new stories, maybe. All those movies seem extraordinarily messy. I think fans are very mixed on the newer Marvel movies. Is that just because they're making too many? Is it because they didn't have a good idea? Like, that seems like the heart. Like, if ESPN drove one version of Disney, Marvel definitely drove another version of Disney. But at least ESPN had sports. Like, there were always going to be more sports. There's not always going to be another Iron Man, right?
33:39 Speaker 04 Right. Well, you could argue that the first three to four phases of the MCU, so that Iron Man to Endgame kind of era, was like the greatest 22-episode television series, right? Like, that's what it was. It was, there was a new episode, and they just happened to be $250 million movies that brought in, you know, 800 million, 900 million, a billion dollars. Iron Man felt like an event. The way that The Dark Knight did, right? They came out the same year. Like, those two movies felt like very specific comic book events. One was a big Christopher Nolan movie, one's got, you know, this Robert Downey Jr.'s redemption arc. As they went through the period, Marvel definitely connected, right? The Captain America, Teen Up, that was the whole Avengers. But they did it at a rate that was understandable,
34:21 Speaker 04 and it was enjoyable. Guardians of the Galaxy was like C-list superheroes, but you had James Gunn come in with Chris Pratt and a very lovable cast, strong writing, good music, and all of a sudden, it was like their next big thing. Ant-Man had Paul Rudd and was relatively funny. And so you had these different styles of film, but they never lost that creative edge, and they were easy to follow, and you wanted to see where they were going because you weren't putting in homework. This is my point. Half of Netflix's consumption is licensed programs, which means it's older TV shows and older films. The other half is original programming. But Netflix, as we can see through their licensing strategy, really understands that people mainly just want something to throw on. This is not new. Our desire for television has not changed.
35:06 Speaker 04 Our desire for how we receive the television has shifted irrevocably. And so Disney approached streaming, which is inherently a television product, as a movie product. By that, I mean, they used a movie strategy. They said, we're going to have a ton of big events, and we're going to have this within the same three or four verticals. And at some point, people are like, this is boring. So now you're seeing that kind of happening on the Marvel and Star Wars side, Star Wars under Kathleen Kennedy over at Lucasfilm. And it just totally derailed the phenomenon of the brand. And so when you try to get that audience, who's now dissatisfied, to go pay $30 for a movie with a character they're not that really interested in, and the storytelling isn't that great, you've now made your huge event feel commonplace. And you can't do that in TV.
35:51 Speaker 04 And you especially can't do that if the TV function is to support your film function.
35:55 Speaker 03 Why didn't they just lean on ABC? Like, they have a huge archive of, like, hit sitcoms from ABC. They have a huge archive of ESPN documentaries or whatever. Why not lean on that expertise instead of pushing into these handful of franchises that couldn't take the weight?
36:12 Speaker 04 Disney Plus has always been, in my opinion, a scaled niche platform, which feels like an oxymoron, right? But compared to Hulu or Netflix, which are scaled for quadrant services. So they have programming for male, female, old, young. That is what they really focus on. That's what television is. That's what television's always consisted of. But I think they saw the launch of Disney Plus and its first few years as onboard at any cost. And so that was, we'll rely on our big tent poles, because that's what people really care about. They had this huge ABC library that was also helping Netflix retain a lot of their customers. They had free form for teenage girls. They had ESPN content, which they weren't going to touch at the time because they didn't want to cannibalize their audience.
36:55 Speaker 04 They didn't want to upset their partnerships with Comcast and Charter and bring that content elsewhere. And so they said, what do we have full control over? What do we know that audiences want? And what makes us special? What makes us differentiated? A significant misunderstanding that I think most of these companies understand now is that they thought their content was differentiated. The vast majority of it is not. And if you lean too much on your differentiated brands, it takes your event and turns it into ordinary. And if you have ordinary, good luck selling that again as extraordinary.
37:26 Speaker 03 Let's talk about what happens in extra Disney. They fended off Nelson Peltz, but the anxiety is still there. The problems are there. They are integrating Hulu, which does seem like a really big deal to just fill out the service, to say there's more stuff here that might put the Disney brand at risk because Hulu has a lot of stuff on it that isn't traditional Disney. But they're filling out the service with Hulu. They are going to integrate ESPN next year. They're doing the tie up with Fox Sports and others to make the ultra sports service, which will be really interesting. Bob Iger needs a successor. What does the next year or two look like for Disney?
38:04 Speaker 04 Lots of exciting times at the Walt Disney Corporation. So fundamentally, what I would expect to see, once the Comcast deal with Hulu closes, so once they pay Comcast, that whatever they decide the amount is to really just own Hulu, I would expect heavy investment in Hulu. There's no real reason for Disney to have done that beforehand because why pay Comcast more? But I think they understand. The way we view streaming services is the way we talk about them is how we used to talk about channels. Right? So you say, I watch something on Disney plus. I watch something on Netflix. We used to say, I watch something on ESPN. I watch something on Bravo. And so to say that we're treating each service as a channel means that you really have to find ways to make that channel as engaging as possible.
38:48 Speaker 04 To your point about the dilution of the brand, I think it's really important to acknowledge that Disney's brand has changed again and again over its 100 year history. When it launched, right, it was like an animation studio. Then it was a theme park company. By the time that they had the ABC merger, because they realized that they needed to be within cable because it seemed like a great business and to be within linear television and to further extend its distribution efforts globally, it became a TV company. By the time ESPN comes around, it's like the not a cable operator, but it is the cable company in many ways. Then it became the Marvel and Star Wars company. It was a big brand again, right? Went back to live action. So now it's a streaming company and a parks company. And so I think this idea of, well, does Hulu dilute the brand? Disney has to really.
39:33 Speaker 04 Reignite the idea of what the Disney brand is. And that's going to change. It's going to come back to it's no longer just Mickey Mouse and Captain America, but it's also going to include FX programming, right? So it's going to include Shogun, like it's going to include Abbott Elementary. Like there's just these elements that are going to feel very Disney in a way where they were segregated before, because now it all exists within one app. So it's like one channel. It is this idea that is Disney. So I think you'll see much more investment in Hulu. I think you will see them really iron out their international strategy. The vast majority of revenue for streaming companies will eventually be international. It will not be domestic. Netflix right now, I think the percentage is like 70% of its new net ads come in from international markets. And so they really like the US is a turn prevention market.
40:16 Speaker 04 Every growth opportunity, including opportunity to scale revenue is international. But that does not mean you have to be in every country. Disney can go to theaters with big movies. They can license their content to parties who are going to be there. They can even take potential minority stakes in direct to consumer platforms that come up. They do not need to be owned and operated. I think you'll see Disney really determine, okay, we want to be a platform here. We want to partner with a platform here, or we're just going to license here. Like, we're just going to have theatrical and licensing. So international will be a big deal, far more focus on parks. And then lastly is the succession. So a big part of the Nelson Peltz argument was not just streaming. It was the succession plan for Bob Iger. And the question was, who succeeds Bob Iger?
41:01 Speaker 04 There's no one who can really take over for him. This is a concern that has gone around Hollywood for years and it was made arguably worse by the Bob Chapek conundrum, where Bob Iger then came back. There's, there's four names who are rumored. The three top ones are really Jimmy Patel, who's head of ESPN, Dana Walden, who's head of kind of Disney content in general, and Josh Damaru, who's head of parks. If I was in charge, and I've been told I'm not, I would recommend that the Disney company going forward is not just a content company. It's not just a parks company. It's both, and you need both those things. And to have someone like Dana and Josh come in together and really operate as to create the future of Disney. That would be my recommendation. But as a company, much more Hulu, much more focus
41:45 Speaker 04 on international strategy, the succession thing happening for sure. And then also focus again on returning back to what Disney has done well, which is event programming at scale and then finding ways to monetize that throughout an entire pipeline as opposed to just moving it directly to their direct consumer services.
42:05 Speaker 03 Well, that is a good prescription. Hopefully you are actually put in charge. That would be great for me personally. I've always wanted to know the CEO of Disney. Julia, thanks so much for coming on.
42:14 Speaker 04 Thank you.
42:17 Speaker 03 Thanks again to Julia Alexander for joining us on the show. You can read her excellent analysis work over at Puck News, and I really recommend it if you want to understand Disney and the entertainment industry. If you have thoughts about this episode or what you'd like to hear more of, you can email us at decoder@theverge.com. We really do read all the emails. You can also hit me up directly on threads. I'm at reckless1280. We also have a TikTok. It's at decoderpod. It's a lot of fun. If you like Decoder, please share it with your friends. Subscribe wherever you get podcasts. Decoder is a production of The Verge and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt. It was edited by Kelly Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James. The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder. We'll see you next time.
42:58 Speaker 07 Fall savings are happening now at The Home Depot. Save up to $500 on select appliances. Plus, enjoy free delivery when you spend $998 or more. From prepping to cooking to cleaning up, Frigidaire has you covered. The custom Flex Temp drawer switches from fridge to freezer. With more than 15 cooking modes, including stone baked pizza mode, you can enjoy restaurant quality pizza in as little as two minutes. Then clean up with the Frigidaire dishwasher featuring the industry's fastest normal wash cycle. Shop fall savings now at The Home Depot. Off the ballot through October 21st. U.S. only. See store online for details.
43:29 Speaker 08 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in a wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash apple watch series 12.
Previous Dropbox CEO Drew Houston wants you to embrace AI and remote work Next Discord CEO Jason Citron makes the case for a smaller, more private internet Page updated October 26, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated