Pod Insights Decoder Can you patent a pizza? About this episode Hey everyone it’s Nilay – I’m on vacation this week, so the Decoder team is taking a short break. We’ll be back next week with both the interview and the new explainer episodes. To tide you over until Monday, we have a bonus episode from our friends at Vox Media and Eater’s Gastropod about an incredible patent battle in the world of pizza.
I’m serious: One of the biggest fights in the pizza industry took place in US court in the ‘90s — an intellectual property dispute about stuffed crust pizza between Pizza Hut and patent holder Anthony “The Big Cheese” Mongiello.
So much of what we talk about on Decoder comes down to IP lawsuits like copyright or patent disputes, and how judges decide those cases and where the law ends up can steer the course of history. And that’s true whether we’re talking about a line of code, the distribution method of an MP3, or, yes, even stuffed crust pizza.
Links:
Can You Patent a Pizza? — Gastropod
Ivana and Donald Trump Pizza Hut Commercial — YouTube
The Next Big Thing in Pizza? Try 'Stuffed Crust' — NYT
Who Created the Stuffed Crust Pizza? It's Complicated. — Eater
Method of making a pizza — Google Patents
Credits:
Decoder is a production of The Verge, and part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Today’s episode was produced by Kate Cox and Nick Statt and was edited by Callie Wright. Our supervising producer is Liam James.
The Decoder music is by Breakmaster Cylinder.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript 9,541 words · 22 speakers
0:01 Speaker 00 What if managing company spend took less managing? Introducing Amex Corporate, one intelligent platform connecting cards, expenses, and payments so you can keep work moving. Built to simplify, designed to scale. This is Amex Corporate. Get started at go.amex/ammexcorporate. Terms apply.
0:27 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard, but not the pipeline? That's bull spend, and marketers are calling it out in. Dashboard Confessions.
0:36 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had: impressions.
0:43 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
0:58 Speaker 03 Hey everybody, it's Neela. I'm on vacation this week, so the Decoder team is taking a short break. We'll be back next week with both the interview and our new Explainer episodes. We have an incredible schedule coming up. I am very excited to share all this with you. To tide you over until Monday, though, we have a bonus episode from our friends at Vox Media and Eater's Gastropod about an incredible patent battle in the world of pizza. I'm serious. One of the biggest fights in the pizza industry took place in court in the 90s, an intellectual property dispute about stuffed crust pizza. This is so very Decoder, I love it the most. As you'll hear how Cynthia Graber and Nicolaj Willey describe it, stuffed crust pizza is a multimillion-dollar idea, most notably for Pizza Hut, which launched it in 1995 with
1:41 Speaker 03 a commercial featuring none other than Donald Trump. But did Pizza Hut steal this idea? And what does it even mean to own the idea for stuffed crust pizza? At the heart of this dispute is cheesemaker named Anthony Mangello, who spent years obtaining a patent for stuffed crust pizza. Mangello, whose nickname is "The Big Cheese," was convinced he was the first person to do it, and he pitched the big pizza chains like Pizza Hut. So when Pizza Hut rolled out stuffed crust pizza years later, Mangello wasn't happy, and he took the company to court for $1 billion. That's a great story, and in this episode Cynthia and Nicolaj do an excellent job of breaking down the legal framework under which ideas can be protected under US law. From copyright to trademark to trade dress and patents.
2:23 Speaker 03 So much of what we talk about in Decoder comes down to IP lawsuits, like copyright lawsuits or patent lawsuits. And how judges decide those cases and where the law ends up can sear the course of history. And that's true whether we're talking about lines of code, music distribution, AI, or yes, even stuffed crust pizza. All right, here's Gastropod. Can you patent a pizza? Here we go.
2:46 Speaker 04 All right. So my name is Anthony and my last name is Mangiello, AKA the Big Cheese, because I've been in the cheese business for 32 years of my adult life. But the truth is, I am and always will be the creator and originator of stuffed crust pizza.
3:05 Speaker 05 Listen, kids, stuffed crust pizza may seem like it's always been around, but I am old enough to remember a world without it. A world before the stuffed crust pizza was invented.
3:16 Speaker 06 And inventing food, that's what we're all about this episode. We, of course, are Gastropod, the podcast that looks at food through the lens of science and history. I'm Cynthia Graber.
3:25 Speaker 05 And I'm Nicola Twilley. And this episode, we've got the shocking true story of how Pizza Hut stole the stuffed crust idea from the guy who invented it. Or did they?
3:36 Speaker 06 Because, wait, can you actually own the idea of something like stuffed crust pizza? And like, if you say you invented it, as Anthony claims, how can you prove it?
3:44 Speaker 05 If you're a scientist who comes up with a new drug, there are laws to allow you and only you to make it. If you're a singer who writes a new song, there are laws to make sure no one else can release that song without your permission. But if you're a chef, or even just a humble home cook who comes up with the next great thing in food, what do you do?
4:04 Speaker 06 We've got the stories of stuffed crust pizza, Fudgy the Whale, KFC's secret recipe, and more to help get to the bottom of this. This episode was funded in part by the Sloan Foundation for the Public Understanding of Science, Technology, and Economics, and by our fantastic supporters. Thanks to you all. Gastropod is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network in partnership with Eater.
4:23 Speaker 05 Speaking of Eater, you love them and we love them for their restaurant recommendations, but you should know that they're just as passionate about dining in as they are about dining out. That's why we're excited to dive into the relaunch of their Eater at Home section. It features a mix of new and existing columns, deeply reported stories, and brand new video series, all focused on cooking, feasting, and celebrating from home. Think expert hacks and how tos, kitchen upgrade advice and entertaining etiquette. It all kicks off with a guide to throwing the ultimate fondue party, and who doesn't want an excuse to melt some cheese? Find more at eater.com.
5:08 Speaker 06 Anthony Mongiello comes from a multi-generational cheese family.
5:12 Speaker 04 My grandfather came from Italy in the early 1900s. While he was in Italy, he was a tinsmith. So when he came to the US, he brought his trade with him. And he made what we called metal ricotta cans.
5:29 Speaker 06 Anthony's granddad's ricotta cans had special holes for the way to drain out of, which was super nifty. But Italian cheesemakers still had to mold their mozzarella by hand, until Anthony's dad came to the rescue.
5:41 Speaker 04 So my dad is actually noted in the history books for creating the very first automated molding machine for the Italian cheese industry.
5:50 Speaker 06 Anthony was surrounded by both cheese and by cheese innovations. So it's no surprise that when he was only 18 years old, he was already following in the family footsteps.
5:59 Speaker 05 It all began when his friend's mom asked him to make pizza.
6:03 Speaker 04 So I said, sure, of course I can. So I brought home some cheese from work to the house, and I stopped at a bakery, and I bought the dough balls from the bakery.
6:14 Speaker 06 And then Anthony kind of made a mistake. He thought the balls of dough looked small, so he stuck two of them together. And then he stretched out the crust. He knew how thin the pizza itself underneath the sauce and cheese should be.
6:25 Speaker 04 So I pushed all the excess dough to the crust. So if you could envision a cooked crust, I had a raw crust as big as a cooked crust. So I put the sauce, I put the cheese, I thought everything was fine.
6:39 Speaker 06 Listeners, it was not fine.
6:41 Speaker 04 And as I'm looking through the glass door of the oven, I can see the pizza cooking. And then the dough that I had in the crust area started to grow and grow and grow. I couldn't believe how big it was growing. It was like a giant ring of a zeppeli or a calzone around the crust of the pizza. I was embarrassed now. I says, oh, my gosh, what did I do? Well, I took it out of the oven. And needless to say, this big crust made the pie look very funny.
7:12 Speaker 06 They all ate it, of course. The part with the sauce and the cheese was standard pizza. But then everyone got to that huge ring of puffy crust around the edges of the pizza, where all that extra dough had gone.
7:21 Speaker 04 And you bite it and it sort of collapses when you bite it and then it opens. And I was like, wow, if there was something inside here, that would be great. And that is truly how stuffed crust pizza was born.
7:34 Speaker 05 And the angels sang. But I mean, really, had no one stuffed a crust before?
7:40 Speaker 04 There were so many people that said, Anthony, this is too simple. Anthony, I'm sure somebody's already created this. I have never seen anything like it. I never knew of any crust that was ever stuffed before in my lifetime.
7:53 Speaker 06 Anthony even did some research and he didn't find any example of anyone stuffing pizza crust. So he told his dad, the cheese molding machine inventor. He said, Dad, I have what I think is an amazing new idea.
8:04 Speaker 04 When I told him about stuffed crust pizza, he was really impressed. And he told me, you have to protect it the best you can.
8:12 Speaker 05 So how exactly does one protect a stroke of genius like the stuffed crust pizza?
8:17 Speaker 06 Well, there are in fact, legal tools to protect inventions and innovation. And there have been these types of protections for a long time.
8:23 Speaker 07 The earliest evidence we have for something like a copyright or a patent system comes from a Greek, I think you could call him a gossip columnist, a guy named Athenaeus.
8:34 Speaker 05 This is Chris Bregman. He's a professor of law at NYU and he writes a lot about what lawyers call intellectual property, or IP, which is the thing you're trying to protect with a copyright or patent system, such as the one described by our ancient Greek gossip columnist, Athenaeus.
8:51 Speaker 07 And he was writing about the Greek city-state of Ciberus, which is in Italy, in Calabria. But that it was a Greek city-state at the time. And he says, you know, these people were so addicted to luxury that what they really wanted was new dishes all the time because they had such jaded palettes. And so if someone came up with a new recipe, they they would prepare it for a jury. And if the jury liked it, they would award them a one-year exclusive right to make the recipe within the city walls. And you know, Athenaeus was like, can you believe these softies? You know, these luxury lovers? So that's a very early intellectual property system. If Athenaeus can be believed.
9:30 Speaker 06 Chris says Athenaeus's writings might not be true, but it is still a good story. In any case, aside from those luxury lovers, most people who wrote things like books or recipes didn't really worry about how to protect their creative output until the 1400s because it was unlikely anyone would steal what they'd written. And then a new technology appeared on the scene.
9:49 Speaker 07 So we never really thought about it too much until the printing press got invented in about 1450 AD. And suddenly it was reasonably cheap to copy. So in the years before the printing press, copying was expensive. You had to copy things by hand. There was no real economic advantage to copying. But suddenly you could take a book and you could run off 1,000 copies relatively inexpensively. And people started thinking after that about whether that was going to prevent authors from engaging in new creative labor, making new books.
10:23 Speaker 06 The concern was, well, maybe authors wouldn't bother because it'd be too easy to rip them off. So why create in the first place?
10:29 Speaker 05 Interestingly, at about the same time, there was a burst of creativity in what's now Italy, in places like Venice and Florence. It was the start of the Italian Renaissance with people like Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo coming up with all sorts of groovy new inventions.
10:46 Speaker 06 And local rulers granted them exclusive rights to those inventions for a number of years. It was basically the intellectual dawn of the patent system.
10:53 Speaker 05 Which continued to develop and was increasingly formalized in Britain as the agricultural and industrial revolutions got going. And then the first modern copyright laws protecting authors, they emerged in England in the early 1700s.
11:06 Speaker 06 And then the idea of protecting intellectual property was adopted by the new leaders of the United States just a few years after the Constitution was written. One of the first things the new government did was enact the Copyright Act of 1790.
11:19 Speaker 08 And our founders decided that in order to encourage and reward creativity and innovation, they would provide certain protections.
11:29 Speaker 08 That would reward innovation, creativity for a certain period of time and then allow those innovations and creativity to go into the public domain so that other people could benefit from them as well.
11:42 Speaker 05 Valerie Flugge is an assistant professor of business law at California State University Northridge. She's written about food and IP law.
11:49 Speaker 06 Anthony wanted to benefit from the protections laid out by our founding fathers, but it turns out there are a bunch of different ways to protect IP.
11:56 Speaker 08 So there are basically five different types of intellectual property that can be used to protect not only food, but any kind of innovation or creativity. They're not all five available. It depends on the circumstances.
12:09 Speaker 06 We've mentioned a couple of these already. There's copyright, then there's patents.
12:13 Speaker 08 There are two different types of patents. There are utility patents and design patents.
12:17 Speaker 06 And then there are two we haven't mentioned yet. There are trade secrets, which is like Coke's secret formula. That's still a secret today. And trademarks. The name Coca-Cola is trademarked.
12:27 Speaker 05 So which from this morgue of IP protections should Anthony pick to make sure he reaps the maximum benefit from his stuff cross-invention?
12:36 Speaker 06 Now Anthony came up with a new recipe. Maybe he should copyright it, just like Athenaeus said that people were doing in ancient Greece.
12:42 Speaker 07 So copyright, the idea is that we're going to give authors and artists some period of exclusivity during which they can use the law to prevent others from copying their work. And this will give them enough time to make back the money they've invested in creating in the first place. And this will prevent copies from depressing incentives to create.
13:07 Speaker 05 Lots of creative things can be protected by copyright. This episode of Gastropod is copyrighted. So is Taylor Swift's new song. So is Disney's latest movie.
13:15 Speaker 06 Copyright is a really important form of protection. It's super strong and it lasts for at least 70 years after the creator's death. Things stay pretty locked up. For instance, nobody could do anything at all with Mickey Mouse without Disney's permission until literally this year, 2024, when the copyright protection ended.
13:32 Speaker 08 So it's a long-term protection if you can get copyright. The problem when it comes to recipe and food design is that neither one really qualifies and meets what is necessary to get copyright protection.
13:45 Speaker 05 That's because copyright is designed to protect creative expression. To qualify your creative expression, whatever it is, it has to be original and it has to be fixed in something that lawyers call a tangible medium, something more or less permanent.
14:00 Speaker 08 And the courts have held with respect to recipes that recipes are not creative expression. Recipes are really facts, a method and a procedure.
14:11 Speaker 07 So copyright doesn't cover facts. And copyright also doesn't cover ideas or methods or processes. These are outside the scope of copyright. So if you think of recipes at their essence, they're facts and processes. It's an instruction, right? For taking a bunch of stuff, flour, water, yeast, bit of salt, right? These are the facts of what's in bread. And then running them through a bunch of processes, you know, mixing them, kneading them, shaping them, baking them, that's at its core what a recipe is and none of that stuff can be protected by copyright.
14:52 Speaker 05 This seems kind of bananas. I mean, I think of coming up with a new recipe as super creative and I am not alone. Lots of recipe creators agree with me and have tried their case, but Chris says no dice.
15:04 Speaker 07 They have a moral argument. They don't have a great legal argument.
15:08 Speaker 05 The law is firm on this one. Copyright doesn't cover facts and it doesn't cover processes. And judges have said multiple times, that's what recipes are.
15:16 Speaker 07 It's just outside the domain of copyright.
15:18 Speaker 05 There is one way that recipe writers can get a copyright and that's if they have stuff around the recipe that isn't the actual recipe itself.
15:25 Speaker 08 So if you use artwork or you have some creative commentary along with your recipes. Or you arrange them in a particularly creative order, you may get copyright protection to extent to that.
15:39 Speaker 07 So, you know, Nigella Lawson writes a book, and there are recipes in the book, but there's also all kinds of stuff about her, her life, her wardrobe, you know, her, her house. And that stuff, that kind of, you know, descriptive stuff that isn't really at the core of the recipe, but is more about expressing some other thing, that's, of course, copyrightable. The recipe isn't.
15:58 Speaker 05 OK, so even if I disagree with the legal philosophy here, the long and short is that Anthony is not going to be able to copyright the recipe for his pizza invention.
16:07 Speaker 06 But what about protecting it as a trade secret? His secret method for stuffing a crust? That seems like it could make sense.
16:14 Speaker 08 Trade secrets protect information that a business keeps private and has some potential economic value. And the business develops it, takes reasonable steps to keep it secret. And if they do that, the business owner is protected to a certain extent from other people being able to access that information.
16:34 Speaker 05 The weird thing about trade secrets is it's not something you apply for, like copyright or a patent.
16:40 Speaker 07 And in fact, applying for it would cancel the protection because you would have to tell the US government what it was you were protecting. And if those records became available to other people, they'd disclose the information.
16:50 Speaker 06 In our Coca-Cola episode, we described all the things the company does to keep their secret formula a secret, like keep it in a vault and only a couple of people know it at a time. And in fact, Coke stopped selling their soda in India in the 1970s because the Indian government required foreign companies to share all their trade secrets with the government in order to do business there.
17:10 Speaker 05 And Coke wouldn't share because if they told their secret to the Indian government, then people everywhere else, including in the US, could argue that it wasn't really a secret anymore. And Coke would lose their trade secret protection everywhere. Even though India is one of the biggest markets in the world, Coke didn't go back on sale there until the 1990s, after a new government changed the rules.
17:33 Speaker 06 Coke, of course, isn't the only company that's taken extraordinary means to protect what they market as the secrets of their success.
17:39 Speaker 08 So as some examples, Kentucky Fried Chicken, the way that they make their coating on their chicken, is protected by trade secrets.
17:54 Speaker 08 They've created whatever it is they've created. They've kept it confidential. They've kept it away from the public. And so that is protected for them.
18:02 Speaker 05 Basically, what happens when you have trade secret protection is if someone tries to take your secret to a competitor, you can sue. And if you can prove that you did your best to keep it a secret, you'll likely win. But if the judge decides you didn't keep it a secret, you can lose trade secret protection.
18:19 Speaker 08 McDonald's used to have trade secret protection for its Big Mac sauce. But that was arguably lost a few years back when one of their chefs did a video telling people how they could make the secret sauce at home.
18:32 Speaker 06 This happened in 2012. McDonald's at the time was trying to be more transparent about what was in their food.
18:38 Speaker 08 For years, that special sauce was a big secret, guarded closely inside McDonald's headquarters in Oak Brook, Illinois. That is until now.
18:48 Speaker 09 We're going to make a version of the Big Mac with ingredients that are similar that you could buy at your local grocery store.
18:55 Speaker 08 In a video posted on YouTube, McDonald's executive chef Dan Coudreau takes to the kitchen and finally reveals the makings of one of the fast food industry's best kept secrets.
19:05 Speaker 05 What this means is that McDonald's can no longer sue if BK decides to serve a burger with special sauce.
19:12 Speaker 06 Even before the video came out and McDonald's lost its trade secret protection, Burger King could have decided to make that special sauce if they really wanted to. They just have to buy a McDonald's burger with special sauce and try to reverse engineer it.
19:24 Speaker 08 Trade secrets do not protect somebody from somebody buying their food product, their recipe. As I assume many of your listeners are, they're really good at tasting something and trying to figure out what's inside it. So if somebody buys a Coke, tastes it and says, hmm, I think I know what's in this and in what proportion, and makes it on their own, they can do that.
19:49 Speaker 05 This loophole is a bit of a deal breaker for the big cheese. After all, once you've seen a stuffed crust pizza, you can probably figure out how to make it. So actually, trying to protect stuffed crust pizza as a trade secret wouldn't offer much protection at all.
20:05 Speaker 06 Another problem for Anthony is that he wasn't running a pizza empire and he didn't want to. But for stuffed crust to become a reality, he would have to tell someone else how to make it. Trade secret really couldn't be the way for him to go.
20:16 Speaker 05 Which of the other three IP options would protect his invention? We'll find out after the break.
20:24 Speaker 01 Are your ad campaigns lighting up the dashboard? But not the pipeline? That's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in dashboard confessions.
20:33 Speaker 02 My boss asked for results, so I opened my dashboard for the only positive sounding metric I had. Impressions.
20:40 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. See revenue, not just reach. LinkedIn delivers the highest return on ad spend of major ad networks. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
20:54 Speaker 10 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 in 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
21:23 Speaker 11 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
21:39 Speaker 05 OK, so copyright and trade secret are a bust, but what about IP protection option number three? What about trademark and its subcategory, trade dress?
21:50 Speaker 06 Trademark and trade dress are for something that is uniquely associated with your product. Trademarks are for the product name, like, say, Campbell's Soup or Baked Lays. And trade dress is the signature way a food looks, like if your cheese cracker is in the shape of a goldfish.
22:03 Speaker 08 The question would be, when you see that orange fish cracker, do you think to yourself, oh, this is an orange fish cracker? Or do you think, is this the Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Cracker?
22:17 Speaker 12 Goldfish.
22:18 Speaker 08 So if you think this is a Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Cracker, then you're thinking about the manufacturer of the product. And the trademark protection is so that somebody else can't come out and produce a similar-looking cracker that may not have the same quality or maybe playing off of your goodwill. And let's say you eat one of those other crackers and you say, oh, this is terrible. I will never eat a Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Cracker again when it wasn't a Pepperidge Farm Goldfish Cracker to begin with.
22:52 Speaker 06 Companies have challenged Pepperidge Farm on their trade dress. In the 90s, Nabisco decided to make a cheesy cracker mix connected to a Nickelodeon kids cartoon called CatDog.
23:15 Speaker 06 The character in the cartoon was half cat and half dog, and so Nabisco made a cracker mix that had three shapes. One was half cat, half dog, another was a bone, and a third was a fish.
23:24 Speaker 05 And Pepperidge Farm was not having any of it. They took Nabisco to court and they argued that consumers might eat this Nickelodeon-inspired snack mix with its fish-shaped crackers and be confused because people clearly believe that all cheesy fish crackers are Pepperidge Farm crackers.
23:41 Speaker 07 Now, OK, so if enough consumers are confused, and you know, what the threshold is has always been a bit of a mystery, but some courts would say 15% is enough. OK, so 15% of consumers of these kinds of snacks are confused, then that's a trademark violation. The senior user of that shape essentially gets to bar other companies from using something like it, not just fish, but whales, or maybe even rockets. So I got to express some skepticism, and that is that trademark law, as it's evolved in the United States, basically thinks of consumers as morons in a hurry. And, you know, whether that's actually what consumers are, how they act, is largely unexplored.
24:26 Speaker 07 But some of the things that are found to be trademark infringements, you would think if anyone's paying any attention whatsoever. This would not be confusing. But, you know, anyway, I'm reporting, you decide, I guess.
24:39 Speaker 06 Chris may think that other companies should be able to make vaguely fish-shaped crackers and that consumers are smart enough to know the difference. But Pepperidge Farm won the case. And lots of companies have trademarks that allow them to protect their names and designs. Magnolia Cupcake's frosting swirl, Hershey's Kisses, that unmistakable shape. And one of my childhood favorite ice cream cakes, Carvel's Fudgy the Whale.
25:00 Speaker 13 Fudgy the Whale is back. That's a whale of a cake for a whale of a name.
25:04 Speaker 06 Bingo. I would assume that a stuffed crust pizza is surely as iconic as Fudgy the Whale or a fish-shaped cracker. But Valerie said not so fast.
25:13 Speaker 08 The legal concept is when it comes to a product design, you can't get trademark protection until it's acquired something that's called secondary meaning.
25:23 Speaker 06 Secondary meaning is when the thing is so famous that it's associated with your company. Like, if you see the red and white design of a can, you know it's Campbell's. Same with Goldfish, those are Pepperidge Farms. But stuffed crust, nobody would look at that and think, that's the big cheese himself.
25:38 Speaker 05 Because nobody knew what stuffed crust pizza even was. It wasn't a thing yet. And you can't get trade dress protection until your product is a thing.
25:46 Speaker 06 And there's another problem Anthony would face. If he wanted to get trade dress protection, the thing he would want protection for would have to be purely ornamental. It couldn't be functional at all. This limitation came up when the Japanese company Pocky tried to sue another company that made a similar-looking coated cookie treat.
26:02 Speaker 07 The court in the Pocky case, and this is the Third Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia, the judge is a guy named Stefanos Bebas. He wrote an incredibly thoughtful opinion, I thought, about whether Pocky could be protected by, basically, trade dress. And he said, well, this can't be because it functions. It all functions. So how does it function?
26:26 Speaker 06 If you haven't had a Pocky, it's just a long, skinny, cylindrical cookie stick with a coating over, say, four fifths of it.
26:33 Speaker 07 And Judge Bebas said, well, you know, the shape of the Pocky, it has this handle, and the handle is there so you can eat the Pocky without getting chocolate in your hands.
26:42 Speaker 06 Denied. And the same thing happened to Dippin' Dots, which are these weird little multicolored ice cream balls that neither Cynthia nor I have ever tried. They apparently had a bit of a moment in the 90s in mall food courts and places like that.
26:56 Speaker 05 And Dippin' Dots brought a case against a rival called Mini Melt's, who had started making a copycat little ice cream ball snack.
27:04 Speaker 08 And it was denied because they found that those small beads were necessary to make the product creamy. So again, it was functional. It was a way to make a creamier product. It wasn't just an ornamental look.
27:18 Speaker 06 Judges don't grant trademark protection easily because if you get a trademark, then nobody else can ever make something that looks like your trademarked thing.
27:26 Speaker 07 As long as you're using it to indicate the source of products, that that right can last, at least notionally, until the end of time. And so to withdraw a functional thing from common use and to give a monopoly in it to one company forever and ever and ever is a serious thing to do.
27:42 Speaker 05 I mean, imagine if only one company could make a chocolate-coated cookie stick or a tiny ice cream ball for the rest of eternity.
27:51 Speaker 06 Or if Anthony was the only person who would ever be able to stuff the crust of a pizza.
27:55 Speaker 05 Humanity as a whole would lose.
27:58 Speaker 06 So all we have left on our list of IP protections is patents. That's it. Now Anthony had designed a new pizza crust. Maybe a design patent would do the trick.
28:06 Speaker 07 So design patents don't protect the way things work. They protect the way an article of manufacture looks, the ornamental appearance. And you could apply design patents, for example, to the shape of a breakfast cereal.
28:17 Speaker 05 Basically, if you've made a breakfast cereal that has a new and original look or design, you can apply to the US government and get a design patent, and no one else can make a breakfast cereal that looks like your product for 15 years.
28:30 Speaker 07 So let's say we have a particular shape for breakfast cereal. It's just ornamental. It's not meant to do something like hold the milk better, or, you know, feel better in your mouth. It doesn't have a useful feature. It's really just, you know, decorative. That can be covered by a design patent.
28:46 Speaker 05 You might be thinking, what up, lawyers? Isn't that the same thing as trade dress? But Valerie told us that though they are similar, they are also slightly different in ways that companies often take sneaky advantage of.
28:59 Speaker 06 Remember, you can't get trade dress protection till your product is recognizable as your unique product by consumers, till it has secondary meaning. Well, if you get a design patent first, then you get 15 years of exclusivity to build up your rep in the marketplace.
29:13 Speaker 05 And then when the design patent expires, you're more likely to qualify for trade dress protection.
29:18 Speaker 06 And Valerie told us that plenty of foods have been protected by design patents.
29:22 Speaker 08 Lots and lots of Kraft pasta products. So I don't know if you ate these growing up, but I certainly did. You would get Kraft mac and cheese that the pasta would be shaped like a dinosaur, a map of the United States. More recently, I think because of Harry Potter, a magic wand. And all of those are protected by a design patent.
29:43 Speaker 06 Anthony's new pizza would look a little different from regular pizza because its crust would be so huge. But there's a problem. A product can't get a design patent if the function of the new invention causes the design. A stuffed crust pizza only looks the way it does because there's stuff in the crust that makes the crust bigger. The function causes the design, so we couldn't get a design patent. Which only leaves one option for our hero, a utility patent. And the criteria for a utility patent are strict.
30:11 Speaker 08 First of all, it's got to be useful. Secondly, it has to be what they call novel, which means it's got to be new. It can't be something that's already been out there. And then in addition to that, it has to be what they call non-obvious. So it has to be something that wouldn't, if somebody's in your same situation, wouldn't say, oh, that's really clear. That's easy. That doesn't take a lot of thought to get to that next step.
30:36 Speaker 06 Valerie told us that despite these strict criteria, there are quite a few foods that have utility patents that were able to prove to the US Patent Office that the food, or maybe the technique to make it, was novel and useful. There's microwavable sponge cake and an instant stuffing mix, and probably my favorite, SpaghettiOs. Putting saucy pasta in a can was a real step forward for children everywhere.
31:05 Speaker 07 The real problem was if you cooked the spaghetti first and then put it in the sauce in the can, it would get very mushy. So Campbell's came up with a way of actually putting essentially raw spaghetti in the can along with sauce. And they came up with a way of both cooking and agitating the can so that the spaghetti cooked in the can. So this was a pretty famous patent back in the mid 20s. Long ago expired. But that wasn't terribly silly. If you like spaghetti in a can, this was a slightly better spaghetti in a can. As an Italian American, I find this horrible to contemplate, but nonetheless, there you have it.
31:41 Speaker 06 Like Chris says, SpaghettiOs may not be the most authentic pasta dish, at least according to anyone of Italian heritage, but the patent itself, that was legit.
31:52 Speaker 06 Not so much for another iconic food that Smuckers tried to patent, the PB and J.
31:57 Speaker 14 With a name like Smuckers, it has to be good.
32:01 Speaker 15 And for moms in a hurry, Smuckers makes Uncrustables PB and J sandwiches. Smucker starts with delicious peanut butter and jelly, takes off the crusts, and seals in all the goodness of homemade.
32:13 Speaker 08 So they claimed that their patent, their food item, was a innovative way to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, which involved putting the peanut butter on the bread and then putting the jelly in between the peanut butter and then crimping the bread. And this way, the jelly wouldn't leak out and it wouldn't get the bread soggy because the peanut butter would prevent it from spreading to the bread.
32:37 Speaker 06 But the Patent Office did some research themselves and they said, nope, Smuckers, you didn't invent anything new.
32:42 Speaker 08 There were articles on how to make a good peanut butter and jelly sandwich that said, if you don't want the jelly to leak or if you don't want it to go and make the bread soggy, put the peanut butter on first and put the jelly in the middle. So this was a product that the Patent Office found was not novel and it was not non-obvious.
33:03 Speaker 06 So this was what Anthony had to prove to the US Patent Office, that his invention of stuffed crust pizza was new and non-obvious and useful. Would it work? Would stuffed crust pizza be seen as SpaghettiOs or Uncrustables? That decision after the break.
33:19 Speaker 01 Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great. Till the CFO sees them, that's bull spend. And marketers are calling it out in Dashboard Confessions.
33:29 Speaker 02 I remember telling my boss, "It'll be good for the brand," when leads were slow. Yeah, it wasn't.
33:36 Speaker 01 Cut the bull spend. LinkedIn lets you target by company, job title, and more. Advertise on LinkedIn. Spend $250 on your first campaign and get a $250 credit. Go to LinkedIn.com/campaign. Terms and conditions apply.
33:50 Speaker 10 College football is back. So Hilton called to me, the superstition concierge, to make your fan rituals a reality. Need a room to match your lucky number? We got you. Want to make sure our team doesn't wash your lucky jersey? Oh, that smells lucky. Hilton's unmatched hospitality can keep up with any superstition. Even a marching band wake-up call at 5:55 and 55 seconds. Hit it! When you need a team that will do whatever it takes on game day, it matters where you stay. Hilton, for the stay.
34:19 Speaker 11 Propel Fitness Water. With Gatorade Electrolytes, zero sugar and vitamins. Propel hydrates better than water to help you get the most out of your workout and get back to your best self. What propels you? Propel with Gatorade Electrolytes.
34:35 Speaker 04 So at the time, I was working construction in Manhattan, and I was running a big job.
34:41 Speaker 06 Anthony may have been working construction, but his mind was still focused on stuffed crust pizza. He knew that, as we said, he had to prove to the Patent Office that his invention was new and non-obvious and useful. And so he started to go through the checklist. Would it be useful?
34:54 Speaker 04 So I would go walking around the construction floor after they had their lunch, and I'd see pizza boxes. And I would open them. And what did I see? Four, six crusts just sitting there. Ah, okay. If you stuff this crust, people will not throw it away. They're gonna eat it. There's the beneficial aspect of it.
35:17 Speaker 06 Done. Clearly a useful invention. For the other criteria, that it was new and non-obvious, Anthony hit the books. As far as he could see, no one had done this before. So far, so good. He put together the application.
35:31 Speaker 04 And I did it. It took me over three years to achieve my patent. The examiner in the Patent Trademark Office was having a hard time conceptually understanding what this product was. He told my attorney that, "Oh, I can't get a patent because it sort of infringes an apple turnover or a ravioli." And I had to fly my attorney to the Patent Trademark Office for him to sit down face-to-face with the examiner to explain to him this all is about a pizza. And after he came back, I was awarded my patent in 1987, patent number 4661361.
36:14 Speaker 05 Amazing, but that still wasn't enough for Anthony. He wanted to make extra sure that he had solid protection on all sides. So he went ahead and applied for a trademark to protect the name of his pizza, too.
36:24 Speaker 04 So, common sense, I called it stuffed crust pizza. But when I applied for the trademark, the trademark office says, look, that's too descriptive of a sentence. And you cannot trademark something that describes something. So I changed it to stuff in the crust with a hyphen after the N and a dash. And lo and behold, I got my trademark, stuff in the crust.
36:50 Speaker 05 And then with all that IP protection locked down, Anthony started cold calling the big dogs, Domino's, Little Caesar's, and of course, Pizza Hut.
36:59 Speaker 04 And the only people that entertained the thought of talking with me and wanting to see my concept, guess who that was? Pizza Hut.
37:08 Speaker 05 The company wanted more information. They asked him to send his designs.
37:11 Speaker 04 This was the only open door I had, so I stuck my foot in it. And I sent them the patent, I sent them the trademark, I sent them the process, I sent them everything, and they sent me back a letter saying, thank you, but we are not interested in this product.
37:25 Speaker 05 Anthony was understandably a bit discouraged at this point, but he didn't give up. A few years later, he tried again, and this time Pizza Hut suggested he should send his patent and the process description to their R and D department. So he did, but then they still said they weren't interested.
37:41 Speaker 04 So in 1991, I started my business, my formaggio cheese business. And then in 1994, I have, uh, sitting at my desk and I get a phone call from a friend of mine. And he says to me, Anthony, congratulations. I says, what are you congratulating me for? He said, you sold your pizza idea to Pizza Hut? I said, I don't understand what you're talking about. He says, Anthony, look in the newspaper. So I go and get the newspaper and it was the centerfold of a newspaper. And it's said Pizza Hut is launching in 1995, a $45 million advertising campaign for their new product they call stuffed crust pizza.
38:25 Speaker 16 What's better than a cheesy bite? Cheese in every bite. That's why we invented stuffed crust pizza topped and stuffed with almost a pound of cheese. There's only one original, the original stuffed crust pizza from Pizza Hut. No one else pizzas the Hut.
38:40 Speaker 04 I nearly fell off my chair. I couldn't believe it.
38:43 Speaker 06 Pizza Hut said their brand new creation was the brainchild of a woman in their R and D department. She said she was inspired by a guy in a focus group who said he'd feed his crusts to his dog.
38:53 Speaker 05 The stuffed crust pizza was an instant sensation. I remember my brother begging my mom to take us to Pizza Hut so we could try it. And clearly we were not alone because it sold like hotcakes, hot cheese stuff cakes.
39:07 Speaker 04 The statistics that I looked up in 1994, Pizza Hut had 8,200 outlets. They were doing $4.6 billion in sales. In 1995, after the launch of stuffed crust pizza, their sales grew to $5.2 billion. Now, here we are in 2024. Three of the largest pizza companies in the world, and that's gonna be Pizza Hut, Little Caesar's, and Papa John's.
39:50 Speaker 04 All three of them are making stuffed crust pizza. Never mind all the different varieties you're gonna find of brands in a supermarket. It's a multi-billion dollar concept.
40:05 Speaker 06 But back in 1995, Anthony had no idea how big a deal this new pizza was going to be. He just knew something was wrong. He had the patent for stuffed crust pizza.
40:14 Speaker 05 After he nearly fell off his chair, Anthony picked up the phone. He called Pizza Hut, told them who he was, and he was immediately passed along up the chain.
40:23 Speaker 04 Third person answers the phone. I says to the gentleman, hi, my name is Anthony Mongello. And he says, we know who you are. And there was silence.
40:35 Speaker 04 He says to me, we'll offer you $50,000 for your patent and your trademark.
40:41 Speaker 06 Anthony briefly considered it, but instead, again, he thought, no, I have the patent. You, Pizza Hut, you're infringing, and I want both recognition and a piece of the pie. He reached out to his lawyer, and his lawyer said he had a case.
40:53 Speaker 05 But he needed evidence to prove that Pizza Hut was infringing on his patent. He needed to figure out whether they were making their stuffed crust the same way he specified in his patent.
41:03 Speaker 04 I used to go to the stores and buy stuffed crust pizza. And I'd, my brother would stand there with a video camera, trying to film the people in the back. So we could try and see how they were making this. But my brother would be there with a camera. I'd order a stuffed crust pizza. I had a razor knife in my pocket. As soon as they handed me the pie, I would run to a table or a countertop. And I'd take the razor out and I would cut the thing open. And I'd look from inside and I could see the string cheese. And I could see the spaces in between the string cheese of just the dough.
41:40 Speaker 05 Which was exactly the method Anthony had specified in his patent. Time to see Pizza Hut in court.
41:47 Speaker 06 Anthony thought it'd be quick, but the case dragged on. There was plenty of evidence given on both sides. Pizza Hut's argument was that they invented it in-house and that they were making it a different way than was in his patent. Anthony obviously argued the opposite, that they were doing just what was in his patent.
42:01 Speaker 05 The case was tried by a judge, as patent cases usually are, rather than by a jury. And in the end, the judge ruled against Anthony. He based his decision on two things. One, he said that Pizza Hut hadn't infringed the method because Anthony had described crimping the edges of his pizza innovation to create individual slices. And Pizza Hut didn't do that. Anthony says, that's not the point. They basically used the same method.
42:26 Speaker 04 The way they put these cheese sticks on the dough base, separate, individual food portions, equally spaced is exactly what they did. They copied my patent verbatim.
42:39 Speaker 06 But the judge had another comment when he ruled against Anthony. He said that the patent was not valid because there had been prior publication of a similar technique in a Women's Day magazine cookbook called Encyclopedia of Cookery. Basically, the judge invalidated the patent.
42:53 Speaker 08 That can happen. A judge can say, nah, the US Patent Office should not have granted that patent in the first place. The difference being is that when it goes to trial, the judge is hearing more evidence than the Patent Office Examiner does when they decide whether or not to deny or grant the patent.
43:12 Speaker 07 And that sounds to me roughly like a good result. Because stuffed crust pizzas as a genus, I think that's probably too broad to be owned.
43:21 Speaker 05 Sorry, Anthony. Chris is not on Team Big Cheese.
43:25 Speaker 06 Anthony didn't appeal, but of course, he has always and always will consider this something he contributed to the world of culinary delights.
43:32 Speaker 04 I'm really sorry that things went down the way they did. But the truth is, I am and always will be the creator and originator of stuffed crust pizza. And I have a United States patent issued to me in 1987 to prove it. Now Pizza Hut never invented this. They never got a patent. No one could ever get a patent because I have one.
43:56 Speaker 05 In other words, Anthony feels like, sure, Pizza Hut may have made the stuffed crust into a hit, but you can't take the glory away from him. And he's still innovating in cheese products today.
44:07 Speaker 04 Every product I make is a Mangello original creation. We were the first company to marinate a little selling genie ball and put it in a cup with all the herbs and spices that a consumer can go grab and go and pick up. We were the first to make a bruschetta and mozzarella roll with the meat wrapped around the outside of the cheese. I am an artist and my cheese is my canvas.
44:34 Speaker 06 Anthony says he was the first to create these types of snacks. And the big thing he took away from his past experience is that he also has to be the first one to sell them.
44:41 Speaker 04 So what I've learned from that, and I'd like to teach everyone, is if you have a concept, first of all, run to market as soon as you can. So in my world and in my business, all I do is I'm there first.
44:55 Speaker 05 This tactic, it's called first mover advantage in the business world. And it's one of a range of ways that people who invent something but can't protect it very well under the existing IP laws can still reap the benefit of their inventions.
45:08 Speaker 06 Chris studies the world of inventions that aren't necessarily protected by IP and the fields that it applies to, things like fashion, tattoo art, and yes, food.
45:17 Speaker 07 If you want to know how IP works. One way of doing that is looking at places where there's lots of creativity, but there's not a lot of IP. And then try to explain, well, how does that work? And what difference does it make that IP is at least partially absent?
45:30 Speaker 05 Chris says that in the world of food, where, as we've seen, it can be kind of hard to protect new inventions using IP law, being first to market is a popular strategy.
45:40 Speaker 06 Take the case of a surprisingly viral pastry sensation, the cronut.
45:44 Speaker 17 One of the hottest things in New York City right now is a pastry called the cronut. It's so popular, the inventor is now fighting other bakers who want to copy the cronut.
45:53 Speaker 07 So the cronut's an interesting example of an early mover, an innovator, who had a period of exclusivity before others figured out how to produce the cronut well, right? And reliably.
46:06 Speaker 06 Dominique Ansel is a famous baker in New York. And in 2013, he started selling a hybrid croissant and donut that he brilliantly called the cronut. It was an immediate hit, so much so that people were lined up outside the door within days. And he trademarked the name just a week later.
46:20 Speaker 18 When Tony Tang of Tony's Donut House in Los Angeles started making his version of the cronut, he was promptly served a cease and desist letter for using the trademarked cronut name.
46:32 Speaker 19 I'm reading this letter and I'm like, loving him, then I'm hating him, then I'm loving him, and then I'm hating him. But then when it was all done, I still loved him, because he's the man.
46:42 Speaker 18 Tony's pastry is now the cravenut. Other bakeries around the country are going with the desant.
46:48 Speaker 05 Other aspiring cronut bakers came up with copycat croulants and croniers. It was a phenomenon. And even though Dominique Ansel didn't have a patent and couldn't stop others from making the same pastry, he still benefited from getting there first and trademarking the name.
47:06 Speaker 07 During that period, there was a ton of news coverage. People associated the cronut with that innovator. And that, of course, burnishes the innovator's reputation. So the fact that, you know, that notable invention's associated with you provides some returns. In some instances, that may be enough.
47:21 Speaker 06 That's one method to profit off an invention without having a lot of legal protection. Chris says there's another way people can reap those rewards. It's what he calls attribution.
47:29 Speaker 05 Attribution is particularly common in the world of high-end cuisine with chefs at fancy restaurants.
47:35 Speaker 07 So chefs may cook someone else's recipe, sometimes with some modifications. And they'll say, you know, inspired by, right, on the menu. This, this comes from a place. And sometimes when chefs fail to do that, you know, there's complaining. There's not lawsuits, but there's complaining within the community. And that complaining within the community may be enough over time to encourage people to provide that kind of attribution, which builds the reputation of the chef that originated the recipe, that reputation contributes to the success of the chef's restaurant. It's a complex ecosystem. It's, it's not simple like IP, but it's effective.
48:12 Speaker 05 The other thing Chris has noticed is that sometimes the lack of IP protections, it doesn't reduce creativity, but it does change what form that creativity takes. He gives the example of bartenders. You can't patent or copyright a new cocktail recipe, but if it takes some flair to make it, then it's harder for other people to copy. So the lack of IP law favors cocktail innovation that requires some performance art, too. Same applies in restaurants.
48:40 Speaker 07 So a restaurant with great service, with beautiful decor, great ambiance, that, that is a performance. That's a performance of the food. And that performance is also very difficult often to copy, right? High quality, great ambiance in a restaurant is something that isn't cheap to just replicate. So again, it's like, you know, the, the lack of IP protections, either formally, like in recipes, or really de facto on the street, like in music after Napster, this contributes to the encouragement of some forms of consumption and the discouragement of other forms of consumption. The encouragement of some forms of creativity and the discouragement of other forms of creativity.
49:17 Speaker 06 Like today, musicians make most of their music from tours, not from selling albums, because it's so easy to stream and even to pirate music, but you can't copy the experience of a live show.
49:27 Speaker 07 So, you know, again, it's like, the world changes, but it's, it changes and complex in interesting ways. That might be good, might be bad, we could debate that, but it's, it's very interesting.
49:37 Speaker 06 Neither Chris nor Valerie thinks our IP system is perfect. One issue is that these types of legal protections mostly help out people and companies with deep pockets because they're the ones who can afford to sue for any kind of infringement and they have the resources to keep a lawsuit going.
49:50 Speaker 05 There's a cynical saying that's often credited to Thomas Edison, who ended up with more than 1,000 patents. A patent is merely a title to a lawsuit. And it's kind of true. Like we saw in the tale of Anthony Mongiello and the stuffed crust pizza, a patent doesn't do anything unless you have the money to take advantage of that period of exclusivity and the cash to hire lawyers to defend it in court. Rarely do you see the little guy coming out on top.
50:17 Speaker 06 Which is too bad because at the end of the day, the point of these protections isn't to increase the number of cases that lawyers can argue or to ensure that only rich companies are protected. In theory, it's really to make sure that the people who are inventing things can benefit from that invention and so will want to keep inventing.
50:32 Speaker 05 But there's an important nuance in there. The point of IP is not just about what's fair for the individual inventor, it's about what's good for society as a whole.
50:41 Speaker 07 The logic is to give people enough of an incentive that they will create, not to give people complete property rights forever and ever and ever over the creation.
50:52 Speaker 05 Chris says that in the end, whether you can patent a pizza or not, that's not the right question. What matters most is, are we getting enough creativity in the realm of pizza or food in general? Are there new dishes and new recipes? And there are.
51:07 Speaker 07 If recipes are underproduced, so if the freedom to copy recipes means that we don't get a lot of recipes, then maybe we should be worried. I think the fact is, we get a lot of recipes. We get a ton of culinary creativity. And this, I think, proceeds from something we really haven't referred to, which is cuisine is a much more open art form, one in which there's a lot more sharing of information, one in which also builds on very deeply rooted traditions, culinary traditions, that reinvents these traditions, that reworks them. And, you know, this is a way, this is an environment in which creativity can also happen without much intervention from intellectual property.
51:49 Speaker 05 To be fair, all creativity builds on other creativity. Artists look at other art, writers read other writing, podcasters listen to other podcasts. But perhaps it's even more so in something like food, which is so central to our survival and our identity.
52:06 Speaker 06 And our daily enjoyment. The Patent Examiner pointed out that raviolis and apple turnovers already existed. So did empanadas and calzones. They're stuffed crusts all around us. So maybe stuffed crust pizza was just waiting to happen.
52:22 Speaker 06 Thanks so much to Chris Bregman, Valerie Flugge, and Anthony Mangiello. We have links to their research and their food innovations at gastropod.com. Plus, we have a link to a new short movie that tells the story of Anthony's case from his perspective. It's called Stolen Dough.
52:35 Speaker 05 And of course, thanks to our amazing producer, Claudia Geib. We'll be back in two weeks with a brand new episode.
52:43 Speaker 20 Your heart can tell you a lot about your health. Apple Watch Series 12 measures your heart rate every five seconds with the most accurate heart rate sensing in wearable. So your vitals app, now with heart rate variability, can tell you when something is off. And your readiness score can let you know when to rest and when to push. Hear the story in every heartbeat with Apple Watch Series 12. The features described are for wellness purposes only and not for medical use. iPhone 11 or later required. Based on Apple conducted study of heart rate accuracy, August 2026. Visit apple.com slash Apple Watch Series 12.
53:13 Speaker 21 I work here. You know, that thing you have to wake up for every day? I know. I've made things a little difficult in the past. OK, a lot difficult. But I got some help from UKG. And finally, I understand. Now I'm making work work better. I've even got AI agents helping me find new ways to help you, your people, and your business. Because when work works, everything works. UKG, HR, Pay, and Workforce Management.
Previous Federation is the future of social media, says Bluesky CEO Jay Graber Next Mailchimp CEO Rania Succar on culture, acquisitions, and how big 'small business' really is Page updated October 12, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated