Pod Insights Dear Hank & John 421: Sonic’s Butt Game About this episode Is it easier to push or pull? What is the difference between bandicoots and bilbies? Any advice on coping with a changing mental worldview? Who are your favorite family-friendly stand-up comedians? Will dinosaurs evolve again? …Hank and John Green have answers!
If you're in need of dubious advice, email us at hankandjohn@gmail.com.
Join us for monthly livestreams at patreon.com/dearhankandjohn.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:01 Hank Green? You're listening to a Complexly podcast.
0:09 Hank Green? Hello and welcome to Dear Hank and John.
0:12 John Green? Or as I prefer to think of it, Dear John and Hank.
0:14 Hank Green? It's a podcast where two brothers answer your questions, give you the best advice and bring you all the week's news from both Mars and AFC Wimbledon. John?
0:19 John Green? Yep.
0:20 Hank Green? What kind of tea is the hardest to fit into a cup?
0:23 John Green? I don't know, Hank. What kind of tea is the hardest to fit into a cup?
0:26 Hank Green? Manatee.
0:27 John Green? Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha.
0:30 Hank Green? Actually, my tea's right over there. Can you wrap it for me?
0:31 John Green? No.
0:32 Hank Green? Oh, come on. It's right there.
0:33 John Green? You go get it.
0:34 Hank Green? It's so... You're closer.
0:36 John Green? I'm six inches closer.
0:38 Hank Green? You're in the way. I can't... I'd have to go around?
0:40 John Green? We're in the same place at the same time. Hank wants... Hank wants his tea. He's gonna get up and get it.
0:44 Hank Green? I'm gonna go get my tea.
0:44 John Green? Okay. He's gonna put down his microphone. This is the kind of high drama that people come to Dear Hank and John for. Their sort of thrilling, audio-based content that people love.
0:53 Hank Green? I tell you what, the little ASMR tea.
0:56 John Green? Little ASMR.
0:56 Hank Green? Iced tea.
0:57 John Green? Yeah, good for you.
0:58 Hank Green? I almost tried to drink out of my microphone, John. I got confused.
1:02 John Green? So, that reminds me of the time that I ate a memory card, thinking it was a pretzel chip. And horror ensued. And then I eventually had somebody...
1:11 Hank Green? Did you need the contents of the card?
1:13 John Green? Oh, yeah. I had already filmed my Vlogbrothers video for the day and I ate my micro... my, my, my SD card. And I had somebody come and say, "Oh, I can fix any broken SD card." And they did like a CT scan of it.
1:25 Hank Green? Whoa.
1:25 John Green? And they were like, "I can't fix your SD card. You bit right through it."
1:31 Hank Green? I tried to figure out exactly what the problem was, and it turns out the problem was, "You really treated that like a chip."
1:37 John Green? You got a hell of a bite on you, green.
1:39 Hank Green? You didn't half-ass that. I like... John likes a crunchy chip.
1:42 John Green? I do. I do have a crunch.
1:43 Hank Green? A full, satisfying crunch.
1:44 John Green? Now, Hank, we're in the same place at the same time, which is unusual for Dear Hank and John. Usually Hank is in Montana and I am in Indianapolis, but I have come to Montana.
1:53 Hank Green? Yeah.
1:53 John Green? For the purposes of doing a bunch of work stuff.
1:55 Hank Green? Do you know what?
1:56 John Green? And also hanging out with my brother.
1:57 Hank Green? We should release this on Hank's channel as like a video.
1:59 John Green? Okay, but we usually release the video on Patreon.
2:03 Hank Green? It's true.
2:03 John Green? Patreon.com/DeerHankAndJohn.
2:05 Hank Green? One, yeah.
2:06 John Green? Okay, do we have anything to advertise if we're gonna be getting all these new, new watchers and listeners?
2:10 Hank Green? Wine is over.
2:12 John Green? Wine is over.
2:13 Hank Green? Iced tea is the way.
2:14 John Green? Iced tea is the future.
2:16 Hank Green? You make your own special iced tea?
2:18 John Green? Catherine just closed our door.
2:20 Hank Green? Iced tea is the future and you can get it at Keats and Co.
2:23 John Green? Keats and Co. Go to goodstore.
2:24 Hank Green? Goodstore.
2:25 John Green? And not only can you get iced tea, but starting now, you can also get underwear.
2:30 Hank Green? It's true.
2:31 John Green? Now Hank, correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't everyone go to their local underwear company and think, "God, I wish this place had tea?" And go to their local tea company and think, "God, I wish this place had underwear."
2:41 Hank Green? I had a billionaire say this to me and they were like, "There's no way you can do this." Who would trust their tea people with their socks? And I was like, "I don't care, man. I think you don't see the vision."
2:53 John Green? And he didn't see the vision, or she. But the truth is, you can trust both our underwear and our socks and our coffee and our tea because Hank and I are not... And our soap.
3:03 Hank Green? And our eco-friendly cleaning supplies.
3:05 John Green? And our eco-friendly cleaning supplies because Hank and I are not paid to say any of this because all the profit goes to charity.
3:10 Hank Green? That's right.
3:11 John Green? Goodstore, it really is a better way to buy stuff you need anyway, from underwear to cleaning supplies.
3:19 Hank Green? What were we thinking? That's what I liked to...
3:22 John Green? What were we thinking?
3:23 Hank Green? Yeah, I was like the...
3:23 John Green? By giving it all away?
3:24 Hank Green? Crazy Johnny with his crazy warehouse.
3:26 John Green? Oh, yeah.
3:27 Hank Green? Our prices are so low that we gave away all the profit.
3:33 John Green? Our prices are reasonable, but our profit goes to better places like tuberculosis care and preventing maternal mortality and stuff like that.
3:42 Hank Green? The prices are crazy to me because we price based on margin and like thing to thing. I'm like, "Oh, well, some things are cheap and some things are expensive because that's how they actually should be."
3:54 John Green? Right.
3:55 Hank Green? Coffee's just really hard.
3:56 John Green? Yeah, coffee should cost about 95 cents per cup and that's what ours costs. And if you get it for less than that, you don't want to know the labor conditions that were involved in its farming.
4:05 Hank Green? Yes. So that's part of what's going on. I like to have you here in my office. This is nice.
4:10 John Green? It's a beautiful office. It's very visually stimulating.
4:14 Hank Green? Yeah.
4:14 John Green? There's no shortage of visual stimulus in your office.
4:17 Hank Green? I had the thought, if I can make it so that I can see everything, I'll never lose anything.
4:23 John Green? Yeah, and?
4:24 Hank Green? That was wrong.
4:25 John Green? Yeah.
4:25 Hank Green? I lose things all the time.
4:26 John Green? I do prefer for things to be out... Though, this is something that that my wife and I have a fundamental disagreement about.
4:31 Hank Green? Yeah.
4:32 John Green? I would prefer that the cabinets, because as you know, I I don't see anything in my mind when I close my eyes. I have the aphantasia.
4:38 Hank Green? Mm hmm.
4:38 John Green? And uh, this extends because I have a pretty severe version of this. It extends to not having any kind of map in my head, not not being able to know directions or like. Like today I got lost getting to your house, even though I've been to your house a million times. And uh, I don't know what's behind the kitchen cabinets. This drives Sarah crazy. She's like, we lived in the same house for 15 years. The the cabinets have not changed. The wine glasses are where the wine glasses always were. And my position is, who knows what's behind a cabinet that you can't see behind? Okay?
5:09 Hank Green? That's crazy. That is wild. I once saw a comment on an Instagram reel. That was about a related phenomena and it said, oh, didn't you know? Men don't see with their eyes. They see with their hearts.
5:21 John Green? I don't know what I see with. And people are always like, how do you write books with this with this uh affliction? And I'm like, it's not an affliction. It's the only way I've ever been. And I am also not convinced that you actually see things in your mind when you close your eyes. But I am impressed by everybody else's ability to like get around and like know what's behind uh, closed.
5:40 Hank Green? But I, yeah, I don't have any closed things in here.
5:43 John Green? Yeah, which I really like because from my perspective. It's almost more terrifying to know that there's so many items and artifacts. Behind.
5:52 Hank Green? Yeah.
5:53 John Green? A closed door.
5:54 Hank Green? Yeah, I actually want to put more shelves in here, but there is one closed door over there.
5:58 John Green? Difficult.
5:58 Hank Green? And that has the router and stuff in it. And so you open it and wires just pile out, which I love having that behind a closed door.
6:05 John Green? Yeah, that is a little stressful, but there is a lot of visual information in here, but it's not an unpleasant experience. However, this is an audio based podcast, so I don't know.
6:14 Hank Green? Well, some people are seeing it.
6:15 John Green? I don't know why we've gone quite so video centric for our podcast.
6:19 Hank Green? Can I, you said that you you have this thing aphantasia, but it's the only way you've ever been.
6:25 John Green? Yeah.
6:25 Hank Green? And I would I say, people ask me like, Hank, or you do have ADD, ADHD?
6:30 John Green? Yeah.
6:31 Hank Green? And I say, I don't know what I have, but whatever it is, I like it.
6:33 John Green? Hmm.
6:34 Hank Green? That's that's what I've gone with, but it turns out.
6:36 John Green? You do have ADHD.
6:37 Hank Green? I recently found.
6:38 John Green? Yeah.
6:38 Hank Green? My assessment from when I was a child.
6:40 John Green? Yeah.
6:41 Hank Green? Where I was diagnosed with ADD or whatever it was called back then.
6:45 John Green? Yeah.
6:45 Hank Green? In nineteen ninety eight, nineteen eighty eight, I think like nineteen eighty eight. And uh. And, and mom and dad were just like, "Yeah, that's fine. He's got bigger problems."
6:55 John Green? You did have bigger problems because you had the sensory integration disorder.
6:58 Hank Green? Yeah, I had all kinds of learning dysfunctions.
7:01 John Green? Learning challenges.
7:02 Hank Green? Yes.
7:02 John Green? Yeah, but the point is, you are where you are and you're doing great and we're proud of you. And you're now going to answer this question from Zach, who writes, "Dear Hank and John, John and Hank. Dear John and Hank, is it easier to push or pull?"
7:15 Hank Green? Oh, it's-
7:15 John Green? "Concisely yours, Zach." Now, do not tell me the scientific answer to this. I am not interested in your science.
7:21 Hank Green? Well, there is a scientific answer to it. Well, there's a, there's like an engineering answer to it.
7:25 John Green? Okay, my, my scientific answer is that it's easier to pull.
7:29 Hank Green? That's right.
7:30 John Green? My heart answer is that this, this like answer pretends that all the human muscles are the same everywhere. That is true. Yes. So you are exerting less force when you pull. Exactly. It's easier to pull, but that, what if you have tiny little back muscles in huge pecs? Yeah. Well, it's really- Then it might be easier to push.
7:52 Hank Green? I think that it's largely that it is, it is the legs that you want to have involved. So the legs, did you, I don't know off the top of my head this stat, but somebody once asked me,
8:02 John Green? Yeah.
8:02 Hank Green? Uh, uh, if, if you had to eat a part of the body to survive for a long time, what would it be?
8:09 John Green? The butt.
8:09 Hank Green? It would be a leg.
8:10 John Green? Not the butt?
8:11 Hank Green? Well, the butt is, as you might have heard.
8:13 John Green? Oh my God. Do not give me butt as legs in this context.
8:18 Hank Green? Yeah, but regardless, that, that area, so like the quads, this is the, the far, by far the most calories of the body are in the legs.
8:25 John Green? Sure.
8:26 Hank Green? And, uh, and, and that's because those are by far the strongest muscles in the body. And also there's a lot of fat storage down there.
8:32 John Green? Sure.
8:33 Hank Green? So-
8:33 John Green? Okay.
8:34 Hank Green? Those are the big muscles. You want to be using those. And oftentimes when you imagine pulling, you're imagining just sort of like leaning back and pulling with your arms.
8:41 John Green? But you're actually pulling a lot with your legs.
8:43 Hank Green? But when you're pushing, you usually are pushing all with your legs. So what you have to do is pull by turning your whole body around so that like if you're, if I'm pulling you.
8:53 John Green? Oh, you pull like the way those strong men pull semi trucks.
8:57 Hank Green? Yeah. That's how you pull.
8:58 John Green? Semi trucks?
8:59 Hank Green? Semi trucks?
9:00 John Green? Semi trucks.
9:00 Hank Green? Semi trucks. There's a lot of words for that thing.
9:04 John Green? An 18 wheeler.
9:05 Hank Green? Tractor trailers.
9:06 John Green? A big rig.
9:07 Hank Green? A Randy Jackson.
9:09 John Green? I've never heard that one, but I believe you.
9:12 Hank Green? A lorry is what they call it in the United Kingdom.
9:14 John Green? Yes.
9:15 Hank Green? And in America, they call it a Larry Whitaker.
9:20 John Green? A stoops McGee.
9:22 Hank Green? They call it a highway bigman.
9:23 John Green? All right, I think we're good there, Hank. The point is that when you're a strong person and you're pulling a semi truck, or an 18 wheeler, or a big rig, or a stoops McGee, you are, you're pulling, but you're pulling in the opposite direction. You're pulling with your legs, which you're often not doing when you're pulling, although I guess you're still pulling with your leg. The point being, pulling is easier.
9:46 Hank Green? Yeah. There's something physically that where like if you're turned around, but like this, you know, that kind of pushing is like, it's different.
9:53 John Green? Yeah. Also, doesn't it a little bit depend on the object?
9:56 Hank Green? I think that it does. Like, I think that a semi might not matter that much, but I know that there's, like, I did this physics, uh, like, literally, I did a physics problem in high school or college. It was like, is it more efficient to pull or push a lawnmower? And it was way more efficient to pull it, but you don't pull lawnmowers, because if you fall forward, it goes on top of the lower part of your body.
10:20 John Green? It's going to get ya.
10:21 Hank Green? Yeah.
10:21 John Green? Reminds me of that horrifying and lovely poem by Philip Larkin about the hedgehog, groundhog. I don't remember what kind of animal it is. You want me to read it to you?
10:32 Hank Green? Not usually, but one never knows. I have aphantasia for poetry. Once people start talking weird, I can't hear them anymore.
10:38 John Green? I'm not gonna talk weird. I'm gonna, I'm gonna read it to you, I'm gonna read it to you the way that I would read it to you if it were a paragraph.
10:44 Hank Green? Okay.
10:45 John Green? So that you don't have aphantasia for poetry.
10:46 Hank Green? I hope that that works.
10:47 John Green? And by the way.
10:48 Hank Green? It's so hard to do with poems. You, like, immediately you drop into, not you, but one drops into poetry cadence.
10:54 John Green? If you're not moved by this poem, I don't know what I can do for you.
10:58 Hank Green? Okay.
10:59 John Green? "The mower stalled twice. Kneeling, I found a..."
11:01 Hank Green? Immediately went into the poetry voice.
11:03 John Green? All right, I'll try it without the poetry voice and see if that helps. "The mower stalled twice. Kneeling, I found a hedgehog jammed up against the blades. Killed. It had been in the long grass. I'd seen it before, and even fed it once. Now, I had mauled its unobtrusive world un mendably. Buryal was no help."
11:22 Hank Green? I liked it. I liked it.
11:24 John Green? It's not over.
11:24 Hank Green? Okay.
11:25 John Green? "Next morning, I got up, and it did not. The first day after a death, the new absence is always the same. We should be careful of each other. We should be kind, while there is still time."
11:38 Hank Green? I think that there's something wrong with my brain.
11:41 John Green? Yeah, I mean, if you're not moved by, we should be careful of each other, we should be kind while there is still time. I don't know what to tell you.
11:47 Hank Green? Can you unlock your phone? Can I try and read it?
11:49 John Green? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, this is gold. People are gonna love this.
11:53 Hank Green? I just, you, like, the poetry voice. I don't know how to not do it in the poetry voice, but.
11:57 John Green? Try it.
11:57 Hank Green? The mower stalled twice, kneeling down. Well, I wanna, I wanna add words because this isn't how people talk. The mower stalled twice, kneeling. I found a hedgehog jammed up against the blades, killed. It had been in the long grass. I'd seen it before, even fed it once. Now I had mauled its unobtrusive world unminedably. Burial was no help. Next morning I got up and it did not. Did not what?
12:18 John Green? Get up, buddy. It's dead.
12:20 Hank Green? It did not, okay.
12:21 John Green? It's a dead, dead hedgehog.
12:23 Hank Green? That's how this, a person would say this. Next morning I got up and it did not. The first day after a death, the absence is always the same. We should be careful of each other. We should be kind while there's still time. I don't know, I just like.
12:35 John Green? My way was better.
12:36 Hank Green? You're, that's, but.
12:37 John Green? Let's let the people vote.
12:38 Hank Green? But not for a brain that can't hear when people start talking weird. Like, I feel like I had to do so much work.
12:44 John Green? Well, okay.
12:45 Hank Green? To learn how communication works.
12:47 John Green? I hear you and I believe you, like, you believe me that I have a fantasia, even though I struggle to imagine what that would be like.
12:53 Hank Green? And I also struggle.
12:54 John Green? But, yeah, let me tell you that you already do this very well, and you do it with songs.
13:02 Hank Green? Yeah, I don't know. I think, like, I'm sure if I spent a lot of time with poetry, I would totally get it.
13:06 John Green? That's what I think.
13:07 Hank Green? Yeah, absolutely.
13:08 John Green? I think it's.
13:08 Hank Green? I don't think it's, I don't think it's like a fundamental way that I'm broken. I, but like, I have it with comic books, too. I can't read comic books well.
13:14 John Green? Really?
13:15 Hank Green? Because they're not set up the way that I.
13:17 John Green? Your brain works.
13:18 Hank Green? Learns how, learns how to do stories.
13:20 John Green? Yeah, it's just like a big leap to try and start, uh, understanding a new medium. My only point is that we should be careful of each other and we should be kind while there is still time.
13:30 Hank Green? Yeah, yeah, especially in the long grass.
13:32 John Green? Especially in the long grass. And let me tell you, we are in the long grass. All right, this next question comes from Doozy, who asks, hi from Melbourne, Australia. My name is Doozy, rhymes with bluesy. Bandicoots are bilbies, or bilbies are bandicoots, question mark. It's very confusing and unclear. They are endangered in Australia and super cute. Now, Hank, if you had told me.
13:51 Hank Green? Yeah.
13:52 John Green? That a bandicoot.
13:53 Hank Green? Uh huh.
13:53 John Green? Is an actual animal. I would have bet my life savings against you.
13:58 Hank Green? I think I knew that, but I don't, I didn't know about bilbies. Bilbies also, I would, I would, I would have bet it, bet it against.
14:05 John Green? Anyway, Doozy says, uh, they're super cute and so it would be great to, for you to promote them and talk about them. Thank you, Doozy. I'm happy to promote them and talk about them. I just don't know what they are.
14:15 Hank Green? I also don't.
14:16 John Green? I know what Crash Bandicoot is. Is that a Bandicoot?
14:18 Hank Green? Yeah, that's, that's what he's named after.
14:20 John Green? Are they, are they orange?
14:21 Hank Green? Let's find out. What's a bilby?
14:23 John Green? That's, now that looks like a bunny.
14:25 Hank Green? Well, it's not, cause I'm sure that it convergently evolved to a bunny and it is in fact a marsupial.
14:29 John Green? Oh.
14:30 Hank Green? Because it's from.
14:31 John Green? Cause it's from Oceania.
14:33 Hank Green? And then a Bandicoot, it appears to be the same thing?
14:36 John Green? No.
14:36 Hank Green? It looks a little different.
14:37 John Green? They both have huge ears.
14:39 Hank Green? Doesn't look like Crash Bandicoot. Crash Bandicoot looks like.
14:42 John Green? Crash Bandicoot looks almost nothing like the Bandicoots that I've been exposed to in the last 30 seconds.
14:48 Hank Green? Yeah, I'm looking at Bandicoots and none of them have jeans.
14:50 John Green? None of them are wearing jeans, none of them are wearing shoes, and is, does Crash Bandicoot have gloves on?
14:56 Hank Green? I guess that's how he goes fast.
14:57 John Green? Yeah.
14:58 Hank Green? That's what helps him go.
14:59 John Green? He's got like driving gloves.
15:00 Hank Green? Now, can you remind me, is Crash Bandicoot a good guy or a bad guy?
15:03 John Green? He's a good guy. I'm not entirely sure, actually. Like, when I think about what actually happens in the game.
15:08 Hank Green? Yeah.
15:09 John Green? I don't know if he's like trying to make a good outcome occur, or if he's.
15:12 Hank Green? Is he like the Luigi to Sonic's Mario?
15:15 John Green? No, I think he is his own, I think that, I think that people saw Sonic and they were like, I, we don't have Sonic, we need to make Crash Bandicoot.
15:23 Hank Green? Oh, Crash Bandicoot is like the Sonic for Sega.
15:26 John Green? Yeah, he's like, oh, we have Sonic at home.
15:28 Hank Green? Uh, he's like the Kirkland brand. He's the John Green to Hank Green, if you will.
15:34 John Green? Well, yeah, it was like they, somebody, I think Sega had Sonic.
15:37 Hank Green? Sega had Sonic.
15:38 John Green? And then somebody, but I don't know that for sure. That's just like the vibe I get. Cause it feels like he kept it after.
15:44 Hank Green? History of Crash Bandicoot. Okay.
15:51 John Green? I guess Sega, Sega was, uh, right.
15:53 Hank Green? That's confusing for me.
15:55 John Green? Now, can you, can you search for Sonic?
15:57 Hank Green? They, they took inspiration from other games such as Donkey Kong Country, Mario, and Sonic.
16:04 John Green? Not only that, they jokingly codenamed it Sonic's Ass Game.
16:09 John Green? It's a direct quote from Wikipedia. I'll remind you, it's not cursing if you're referring to Wikipedia. What is, what is, what does that mean? It's Sonic's ass game, Hank. What's? You know. Is it Crash Bandicoot is like Sonic but an ass? But he's not an ass, he's a bilby, as we just established. In fact, right there in the name is Bandicoot. It's true. Wait, is Sonic, is, wait, is Crash Bandicoot in fact a Bandicoot? We should answer that question next, or is that just his name? The way some people are named Rabbit. Yes, Crash Bandicoot is a Bandicoot. Specifically, he is depicted as a genetically enhanced anthropomorphic eastern bard Bandicoot. Uh, in the video game of his same name.
16:51 John Green? His ears look nothing like the adorable Bandicoot ears. He was genetically engineered. But he was genetically engineered to make his ears less cute? Yeah, no, so that he could be more powerful. Uh, sometimes cuteness is a diminisher. It can be a drawback. It can be a drawback. Yeah. Is this what the Australian wanted us to promote, is Crash Bandicoot? I think the Australian wanted us- 1990s video game character? I think the Australian wanted us to promote the actual endangered animals, which we are promoting while also saying that Crash Bandicoot is not doing a good job, in our opinion, of depicting a Bandicoot, and is in fact mostly Sonic's ass game. Right, but Sonic's ass game continues. There was just a Crash Bandicoot property released in 2023, Crash Team Rumble.
17:34 John Green? Do you think Sonic's ass game is a better title for an album or a song? Sonic's ass game to me, I'll be honest with you, I'm having a hard time parsing it in a way that isn't about- Yeah, I hear you. How good Sonic is- Is at that. Yeah. Yeah, like how well he fills out his genes.
17:55 John Green? That is, that is how I parse it. Yeah.
17:59 John Green? Sorry for all our five-year-old listeners, but I just don't know how to get around it. We're just quoting Wikipedia. Sonic's butt game. He's got a good butt game. It could be a donkey thing. Could be a donkey thing. He could be playing Pin the Tail on the Donkey. Sonic's Donkey Game. Yeah. Yeah. That's an ass game. That's an ass game. That's a, in fact, I would argue the single most famous ass game is Pin the Tail on the Donkey. Uh huh, I don't, I couldn't come up with another one. No. I guess donkey riding, like donkey racing is probably a game.
18:27 Hank Green? Donkey Kong.
18:28 John Green? Donkey Kong.
18:29 Hank Green? But he's not an ass. He's just named Donkey Kong.
18:33 John Green? Dude, I just realized that Donkey Kong is not a donkey. He's a monkey.
18:39 Hank Green? Oh, yeah.
18:40 John Green? That's like Crash Bandicoot not being a Bandicoot.
18:43 Hank Green? It's like Sonic the Hedgehog being a Bandicoot.
18:46 John Green? Or Sonic the Hedgehog indeed being a monkey.
18:48 Hank Green? Was Sonic the Hedgehog genetically engineered to be like him?
18:52 John Green? No, he came from space, bro.
18:54 Hank Green? Oh, do you know this because you watched the movie?
18:57 John Green? Yeah. Seventeen times.
19:00 Hank Green? He came from somewhere. I'm not sure if it's space, but I think it is.
19:03 John Green? Right.
19:04 Hank Green? Yeah. You haven't seen the movie?
19:05 John Green? No, but that would, I mean, I am excited to have the Fermi paradox well and truly solved.
19:10 Hank Green? By the Sonic the Hedgehog film.
19:12 John Green? Sonic the Hedgehog film.
19:13 Hank Green? Did you know Jim Carrey said that he was retired from acting unless there was an extraordinary role that came along? And then immediately after that, took the role of the bad guy in Sonic the Hedgehog 3?
19:22 John Green? You know, I think by extraordinary, he meant real fun.
19:27 Hank Green? Or lucrative.
19:28 John Green? I don't know.
19:29 Hank Green? Extraordinary could be lucrative. But I bet, I bet that, I bet that role is really fun.
19:33 John Green? That's the thing. I wonder how fun it all is. Especially once you're good at it, you know?
19:38 Hank Green? That's what I've been writing.
19:38 John Green? You know what you're doing?
19:39 Hank Green? That's what I've been writing a novel about for the last several years.
19:41 John Green? What?
19:42 Hank Green? Whether or not, uh, acting in Hollywood and being a, uh,
19:46 John Green? Yeah.
19:46 Hank Green? movie star is fun.
19:48 John Green? Oh.
19:49 Hank Green? Or whether in fact it is a trap from which it is difficult to escape.
19:53 John Green? Yeah.
19:54 Hank Green? Anyway, let's answer another question from our listeners.
19:56 John Green? That's probably also a, a, an important question for us to ask and for other reasons.
20:00 Hank Green? No joke. This question is from McKenna who asks, hello Hank and John. My name is McKenna and I had cancer three years ago, leukemia. I made it out fine. But my mental worldview shifted dramatically. I grew up going to Protestant Christian churches and consider myself to have faith in the Bible. My hospital stay drastically changed me into an atheist, or if I do believe in God, I don't like the guy very much. Believing in humanity is hard and I've had a hard time coping with that transition. Any advice?
20:28 John Green? I think we should turn to the cancer survivor on this one.
20:31 Hank Green? I guess, but I haven't had any crises of faith in my life.
20:36 John Green? That's true, I have. So you answer from the cancer survivor perspective and I'll answer from the constant crisis of faith perspective.
20:43 Hank Green? Sure, I mean, one thing about that that is uh that is changing about cancer is that it's usually, not always, but usually you come out with a bunch of friends from that community and those people don't all make it. Um, and that was the case for me. That for me isn't that hard to sort of place into the history of humanity.
21:06 John Green? Right.
21:07 Hank Green? Or, you know, sort of like my understanding of how physics and biology and chemistry work. I honestly feel, in terms of humanity, I don't feel like I lost any appreciation for humanity because I saw a lot of humanity. I saw a lot of humanity in the people who love me and the people who love the, the, my, my friends who died. I saw a lot of humanity in the healthcare system, um, that obviously can be inhumane, but like in terms of the actual people in it are just a bunch of people trying to do their best, given the systems that we have. And I, and I learned a lot about sort of myself and what I wanted and was a bit surprised and, and honestly, um, pleased, pleased to find
21:50 Hank Green? that I wasn't worried about like missing the future. I wasn't worried about, you know, lost income. Uh, though I of course had the, the privilege of not having to worry about that too much in terms of like practical considerations. I was just worried about like not being there for the people who I love and, and what they would carry forward if I wasn't here. Um, and so I, that made me like kind of feel good about myself. And it was like lessons that I feel like I don't want to lose a hold of.
22:20 John Green? Mm-hmm. I think part of what a lot of people struggle with in the wake of life-threatening illness and, you know, I've had little glimpses of this. I recovered from a pretty serious, somewhat life-threatening bout of meningitis, for instance. Uh, but I haven't had the kind of glimpse of it that you've had or McKenna's had. But I think a lot of what people struggle with is on the other side of that, like, a lot of your preconceived notions are challenged. Now, a lot of your preconceived notions weren't challenged, which is interesting, but I think McKenna's were, you know? Especially if you grow up hearing, "Everything happens for a reason," or you grow up hearing, like, "God has some kind of master plan for us."
22:58 John Green? And then you see up close that that master plan, if it exists, as McKenna says, is the kind of thing that... Where I don't like the guy very much.
23:08 Hank Green? Right.
23:08 John Green? I'm not... I don't love the master plan.
23:09 Hank Green? Yeah. I mean, could we have a just like a... Like, you're a pretty clever guy up there.
23:14 John Green? Yeah, couldn't you have had a better master plan?
23:17 Hank Green? Yeah.
23:17 John Green? Um, or indeed, like, if the master plan is so far beyond my understanding, why was I given this ability to grieve so deeply and to hurt so much?
23:25 Hank Green? Yeah, which we don't need to have.
23:28 John Green? We don't.
23:28 Hank Green? Well, I mean, we may, we may, in order to...
23:31 John Green? Well, we don't...
23:32 Hank Green? Be ourselves, but...
23:33 John Green? Maybe. But almost all the... In my experience, almost all the lessons I learned from my friends dying, or from serious illness, or whatever, are lessons that I could have learned elsewhere cheap... more cheaply.
23:42 Hank Green? Mm-hmm.
23:43 John Green? Um, that I didn't have to... In my opinion, anyway. But part of what's happening for McKenna, maybe, is when they say, "I have a hard time believing in humanity," is that they are struggling to see what you have seen, which is that people are capable of astonishing sacrifice and compassion and kindness and generosity. Uh, and instead is seeing a lot of what is also true of humanity, right? Which is that humanity is monstrous and a catastrophe.
24:10 Hank Green? Mm-hmm.
24:11 John Green? And how do you hold those competing ideas in your mind at the same time? I don't have an easy answer for that, but I think you have to.
24:16 Hank Green? Yeah. I also, like, I don't... I just do, you know?
24:21 John Green? I know.
24:21 Hank Green? Yeah.
24:22 John Green? You are able to, but a lot of us struggle to.
24:25 Hank Green? Mm.
24:25 John Green? Uh, we want a simple, straightforward answer to, "Is humanity good or bad? Is humanity good news or bad news? Is humanity a gift or a curse? Like, is consciousness itself something to be reveled in or something to be despised?"
24:38 Hank Green? I do have a hard one with that. Like, here's... Here's the thing.
24:40 John Green? Yeah.
24:41 Hank Green? I... Because I'm... I'm... Like sort of it and also outside of it. I feel very strongly that life is a good thing.
24:50 John Green? Mm hmm.
24:51 Hank Green? And so obviously, like, I'm part of life. But also, there is a way in which humans are sort of, you know, not just biological, but also cultural and technological. And so when I'm like, from that perspective, I'm like, boy, it's good that life exists, but but there is no suffering in a world without life.
25:10 John Green? Yeah.
25:11 Hank Green? So so the fact that the only world without suffering is a world without life.
25:15 John Green? No suffering on Mars.
25:16 Hank Green? To completely destroy all suffering, we could just imagine a world with no living things, and it would contain no suffering. And would that be a better world? And I I have, I don't have like a philosophical reason why, but I just believe that it is better to have life.
25:31 John Green? Yeah.
25:32 Hank Green? And so in the same way, I believe that it is better to have culture, and it is better to have consciousness.
25:38 John Green? But it's but it's hard to make sense of some of the ways that humans hurt each other.
25:44 Hank Green? Oh, yeah.
25:45 John Green? And and and I I don't think that ignoring or minimizing or diminishing the horrors we visit upon each other is the right solution.
25:55 Hank Green? Right. I and I think that I do think that there is space for curiosity about that.
26:01 John Green? Yeah.
26:01 Hank Green? Which isn't a sort of like a first instinct that one has when it comes to horrors. And there's space for eventual compassion, if not forgiveness, where there's just like a, you know, not like a requirement. But it is a thing that can happen and can be positive.
26:21 John Green? Right. But I understand having a hard time having faith in humanity. And part of how I'm able to have faith in humanity is to believe that, you know, I am walking alongside forces of love that are greater than myself.
26:34 Hank Green? Right.
26:35 John Green? And that's part of how I do it. Hank does it a different way. The last thing I'll say about it, McKenna, is that you're on a journey of meaning, to quote the great Hank Green. You are.
26:46 Hank Green? That was you.
26:47 John Green? But, OK. Well, to quote even greater John Green then. But you are, you're on a journey of meaning that lasts a lifetime. Like, that's what, that's, that's what we do here, is we try to make things easier for each other and try to understand as best as we can.
27:03 Hank Green? This next question comes from Sheera, who asks, "Dear Mr. and Mr. Greens, who is your favorite stand-up comedian or your favorite stand-up comedians that are mostly family-friendly? Thanks for your dubiosity, Sheera."
27:15 John Green? I enjoy Pete Holmes.
27:16 Hank Green? He's mostly family-friendly.
27:17 John Green? Pete Holmes is mostly family-friendly. I'm actually not positive.
27:19 Hank Green? I think, yeah.
27:20 John Green? But vibe-wise, he is.
27:21 Hank Green? Yeah, yeah.
27:22 John Green? He might curse now and again.
27:23 Hank Green? Yeah.
27:24 John Green? But vibe-wise, he's family-friendly, and I find him very funny.
27:28 Hank Green? He's very funny.
27:29 John Green? And he's also, uh, he, he, he sends up some of my other favorite comedians, like Mike Birbiglia, who is also my friend. He sends up Mike Birbiglia in ways that are like, simultaneously like generous and knowing.
27:43 Hank Green? Yeah.
27:43 John Green? There's something about...
27:45 Hank Green? I've seen that clip.
27:46 John Green? My son, my son calls this bullying, but he's wrong, he's 15 now, and he calls, he, he refers to like, when he and his friends bully each other, but he means it in a kind way.
27:56 Hank Green? Right, they spar.
27:57 John Green? They spar. There's something about being knowingly and lovingly
28:02 Hank Green? Yeah.
28:03 John Green? made fun of, that is better than being knowingly and lovingly complimented.
28:07 Hank Green? Oh, yeah, I mean, I think that it goes, comes down to individual people. I, like, I know people who do not like this kind of communication.
28:13 John Green? Hmm, I do.
28:15 Hank Green? Yeah, me too.
28:15 John Green? I love being teased, if it's, if it's from someone I truly love, in a way that truly knows me.
28:23 Hank Green? They're getting, like, it's very diff, it's hard to do well.
28:25 John Green? Yeah.
28:26 Hank Green? So when someone does it well, it's like, "Ah, it's because you get me, you know me, you know how to like, you know how to hit me in that spot," that's like, uh, that's strengthening that spot instead of weakening it.
28:35 John Green? I remember once I asked my friend Maureen Johnson if my eye looked weird. I said, "Does my eye look weird?" And she said, "I think we've found the name of your memoir."
28:48 Hank Green? Which reminds me that this podcast is brought to you by Does My Eye Look Weird? The new memoir from John Green.
28:55 John Green? Oh, yes. Today's podcast is also, of course, brought to you by Crash Bandicoot. Crash Bandicoot, this is really the only podcast where you can get a little bit of post-cancer life modeling and Crash Bandicoot content in the same 60 seconds.
29:09 Hank Green? This podcast is also brought to you by the human leg. The human leg, the most calorie-dense part of the body.
29:16 John Green? And today's podcast is brought to you by the long grass. The long grass, how do we get out of it?
29:21 Hank Green? We're here.
29:22 John Green? We're here.
29:23 Hank Green? We're here. We're in the long grass because we're in the long grass.
29:26 John Green? That's right. All right, Hank, before we get to all the important news from Mars and AFC Wimbledon, I have to mention a couple of things. First off, a lot of people have written us about Beef Days. Now Beef Days is a concept that you and I have embraced wholeheartedly, where instead of having beef whenever we feel like it, we have beef on a few certain days throughout the year wherein we celebrate Beef Days. This has cut my personal beef consumption by like 90%, and you said you felt like it was a terrible failure because lots of people didn't get involved in Beef Days and it didn't really change the culture. And the hardest thing in the world to change is
29:57 Hank Green? Yeah.
29:57 John Green? social norms.
29:58 Hank Green? Yep.
29:59 John Green? Hundreds, I'm not exaggerating, of people have written in to say that they also celebrate Beef Days. So if we find ourselves at the end of our lives in front of St. Peter's Gate and he lets us in,
30:09 Hank Green? Mm-hmm.
30:10 John Green? just know.
30:11 Hank Green? Beef Days was part of it.
30:12 John Green? Beef Days was part of it. Now, I'm not going to get into heaven. In this hypothetical world where St. Peter exists and you go up to the gates, everyone knows that I'm going to get up there and immediately St. Peter's going to stare me dead in the eyes and say, "I think we both know." And I'm going to say, "Yes, indeed, I know." And he's going to say, "It was the La Croix."
30:26 Hank Green? Yeah. I mean, it's a whole household problem, it seems to me, having had your children in my home.
30:33 John Green? My children love La Croix. They're also not going to go to heaven because of the La Croix. They're going to be like, "You, even though you, even though you quote-unquote recycled all this aluminum, the aluminum came from somewhere, buddy, and you knew. You knew."
30:45 Hank Green? There is a, there is a solution to this problem.
30:47 John Green? I, you're going to say a SodaStream, but I love my La Croix's.
30:50 Hank Green? No, no, there's a solution to this problem that has not yet been invented.
30:53 John Green? Okay.
30:54 Hank Green? Which is whatever soda carbonator does as good a job as La Croix.
30:59 John Green? La Croix on tap.
31:01 Hank Green? La Croix, a keg of La Croix.
31:03 John Green? Oh, you're speaking my language.
31:07 John Green? This midwesterner, this midwesterner just got a shiver that went all through his body.
31:13 Hank Green? You gotta go to like a, like a dram shop and just bring your crowlers to fill it up with La Croix.
31:20 John Green? That sounds so good to me.
31:21 Hank Green? I mean, I've always thought that there must be a way to make La Croix at home. It's not complicated.
31:27 John Green? All right.
31:27 Hank Green? But what are you, what's your concern? What's, why is it not as good to have a home? Cause you have a home carbonator.
31:32 John Green? I do, and I use it sometimes, but it's just not as good as La Croix.
31:35 Hank Green? Is it the flavor or is it the bubbles?
31:37 John Green? It's both the flavor and the bubbles.
31:38 Hank Green? It has worse bubbles?
31:39 John Green? The best tweet of all time was when somebody said a La Croix flavor is like you're drinking a plain soda water and somebody in the next room shouts grapefruit.
31:48 Hank Green? Yeah.
31:49 John Green? That's, that's, that's the exact amount of fruit I want and that's the exact amount of fruit they give me.
31:54 Hank Green? Yeah.
31:55 John Green? I just had one of your spend, spend drifts.
31:57 Hank Green? Yeah.
31:58 John Green? Whatever it's called.
31:59 Hank Green? Mm hmm. Spend, spend drift is a great actual, uh, modification of this name because you spend.
32:05 John Green? You do. It ain't free. Um, and it's like, instead of having an artifact, whatever La Croix has, they have, uh,
32:12 Hank Green? Actual fruit juice.
32:13 John Green? It's terrible.
32:16 John Green? I'm not interested in it at all.
32:18 Hank Green? I love them. They're so good. So good. It's like on the package. It's like this, this, every one of these contains 17 cherries.
32:27 John Green? All right, Hank, we got one last question before we get to the all important news from Mars and AFC Wimbledon.
32:31 Hank Green? It comes from Rihanna who asks, dear Hank and John, trying to get my five year old to sleep the other night, I somehow wound up explaining to her how eventually there will come a time when there won't be any people left alive on earth.
32:45 John Green? Oh, this really helps five year olds go to sleep in my experience.
32:47 Hank Green? But that earth will probably still be here.
32:50 John Green? Yeah.
32:50 Hank Green? I was of course, having feelings of extreme panic inside at saying this out loud. I think I did a pretty good job of keeping it together and not letting the dread show. Anyway, my five year old didn't seem panicked because she got excited and asked, when that happens, will dinosaurs evolve again?
33:06 John Green? Well, will they Hank?
33:08 Hank Green? That's not a bad hypothesis, Rihanna says. Yeah. I, look, we don't, what I can say for sure is that the earth has a while.
33:16 John Green? Yeah.
33:16 Hank Green? And also, so, so in both ways.
33:21 Hank Green? There's less time than you think.
33:23 John Green? Right.
33:23 Hank Green? For the Earth, because everybody says, oh, the sun's gonna explode in five billion years.
33:26 John Green? Right.
33:27 Hank Green? But in a billion years, the sun's gonna be so hot that it's gonna bake off the oceans.
33:31 John Green? Which is gonna be a real problem.
33:32 Hank Green? So, that, that's...
33:34 John Green? Because we, I'll remind you, we're mostly a water planet and we're mostly water life.
33:38 Hank Green? We're just fish on land.
33:39 John Green? We're just fish on land, and so boiling oceans will be a big issue for us.
33:42 Hank Green? Yeah.
33:43 John Green? Lack of fresh water will be a big issue for us.
33:45 Hank Green? Right. So, we've got, we've got about a billion years.
33:48 John Green? Which is important to note, because that means we're in the second half of life on Earth.
33:53 Hank Green? Oh, yeah. But, we are not in the second half of complex multicellular life.
34:00 John Green? Right.
34:01 Hank Green? So, so for so much of the Earth.
34:03 John Green? Yeah.
34:04 Hank Green? It was just single-celled organisms or really simple multicellular organisms.
34:08 John Green? Right.
34:09 Hank Green? As far as like vertebrates go, we are, we are probably at, at about the halfway point.
34:13 John Green? Wow.
34:14 Hank Green? Which is really interesting, and not at all how I had been pitched to the situation.
34:18 John Green? No, no. If you think about vertebrates, we're, we're 50% in.
34:23 Hank Green? Yeah.
34:24 John Green? To life being manageable. Now, that tells me, I think vertebrates are gonna be super sticky, for lack of a better term. I think vertebrates are gonna hang around as long as possible.
34:36 Hank Green? Yeah.
34:36 John Green? Do I have a ton of confidence in humanity being there at the end of the vertebrate age? I do not.
34:42 Hank Green? Right. But I think that it is both, it is possible that a very sort of, uh, different-looking vertebrates could evolve in the future.
34:50 John Green? Yeah.
34:50 Hank Green? It's gonna be very dependent on a lot of different things, on the level of heat and the, the sort of composition of the atmosphere, et cetera. Uh, and I think it's entirely possible that another intelligent species could evolve, if we totally obliterated ourselves, that like, you know, primates could do it again, or...
35:05 John Green? Primates could do it.
35:06 Hank Green? Yeah.
35:07 John Green? Maybe, I'd be really interested to see what the birds could get up to, but they have like a, they have like a problem with the wings.
35:13 Hank Green? Yeah.
35:14 John Green? They don't, can't like do stuff with their wings, except fly.
35:16 Hank Green? Flying birds have had a long, long time to get smart.
35:21 John Green? Yeah.
35:22 Hank Green? And they haven't gotten all the way there.
35:24 John Green? They've gotten, they've gotten interesting. They've gotten really interesting, pretty smart, but they haven't gotten all the way there. I worry that they will struggle to get all the way there. I think primates have a really good chance. I think sometimes we underestimate the chance that raccoons have.
35:36 Hank Green? Raccoons have a, have a pretty high chance, actually.
35:38 John Green? Because they've got the hands.
35:39 Hank Green? They got hands. They got hands. And they're already quite smart. And also, they have evolutionary pressure toward getting smarter.
35:46 John Green? Do you think Jewel wrote the song, "My hands are small, I know, but they're not mine, they're not yours, they are my own," about raccoons?
35:53 Hank Green? Yeah, definitely.
35:54 John Green? I think so, too. I just wanted to double check.
35:55 Hank Green? She follows me on Instagram if you want me to ask her.
35:57 John Green? Don't. That's a weird first question.
36:01 Hank Green? She's a, she's a, I followed her back. She's a weird follow.
36:04 John Green? Is she?
36:05 Hank Green? Yeah. Yeah.
36:10 John Green? You just followed her back in case you ever had the occasion to DM Jewel?
36:13 Hank Green? Totally, yes.
36:15 John Green? Just to be like, "Hey Jewel, it's me, Hank Green."
36:17 Hank Green? Well, maybe she could be on Ask Anything.
36:19 John Green? From the internet?
36:20 Hank Green? I had a huge crush on you when I was in high school.
36:22 John Green? You want to be on my show?
36:23 Hank Green? It's not weird at all.
36:24 John Green? Yeah, yeah, it's not weird. Uh, for me, it was Natalie Imbruglia.
36:27 Hank Green? Really?
36:28 John Green? Yeah, and that was my big crush.
36:29 Hank Green? I feel like I came out on, on top on that one.
36:31 John Green? No, I don't know. They're both really talented people. Point being, dinosaurs could evolve again, in the sense, here's how I think dinosaurs could evolve again, and correct me if I'm wrong, because I'm not a scientist, and this isn't science, this is guesswork anyway.
36:43 Hank Green? Yeah.
36:44 John Green? But what if you sort of get smarter, larger birds, like, like ostriches, that become less and less mobile, and less and less feathered?
36:53 Hank Green? Yeah.
36:53 John Green? And, and have a evolutionary reason to get larger and larger. You're getting toward a dinosaur-like thing again. And we've seen convergent, we've, we've seen-
37:03 Hank Green? I thought you were, I thought you were asking how birds could get smart. But yeah, totally. Well, absolutely.
37:08 John Green? And we've seen convergent evolution, like recreate things that we thought were gone.
37:14 Hank Green? Yeah. I mean, I think the hard part would be the arms. So it's not really a T-Rex unless it's got arms with little claws on it.
37:21 John Green? Yep.
37:22 Hank Green? But that has not, never happened. There's a bird called the Watson. When they're babies, they have a little, uh, claws on their elbows, which is weird, uh, that, that they use to like climb in trees. Um, so I guess, what, in terms of intelligence, can I hit you with a weird idea?
37:39 John Green? Yeah, please.
37:39 Hank Green? So- Birds can do a lot of manual dexterity.
37:44 John Green? Sure.
37:45 Hank Green? They don't use their forelimbs, of course.
37:47 John Green? Right.
37:47 Hank Green? They use their feet, but also they use their tongue. I think it's totally possible that they could end up with a tongue hand in the same way.
37:55 John Green? A tongue hand.
37:56 Hank Green? Uh, that giraffes kind of have like a nose hand.
37:59 John Green? Yeah, or um, I would argue many monkeys have a tail hand.
38:03 Hank Green? They do have a tail hand. They do, they do, they do. And I don't know what would prevent, honestly, the growing of a hand on the tail. Now, I have some ideas about why this would be complicated, but I, I, I don't know that it's, I don't know that it's impossible.
38:21 John Green? Five limbed creatures.
38:23 Hank Green? I, I'd love to talk to an evolutionary biologist who, who's like deep into like body planning parts of the genome.
38:30 John Green? Yeah.
38:31 Hank Green? About and, and how that all works about whether or not the body could sort of just like, be like, oh, I'm gonna take the hand uh, system and just put that on the end of the tail.
38:40 John Green? That seems hard, but I'm not an expert.
38:42 Hank Green? Exactly.
38:43 John Green? I, so I think we agree that raccoons are likely, if we, if we boom snuffed out tomorrow, mammals would start to get bigger.
38:51 Hank Green? Yeah.
38:51 John Green? There would be evolutionary pressure for mammals to get bigger and their brains would get bigger. I think that number one, probably, maybe not, number one would be primates. Number two, I'm standing by raccoons because of their hands. I think their hands are incredible.
39:05 Hank Green? People are gonna be thinking about ocean life and I think that there are problems there.
39:10 John Green? I think there's reasons why ocean life never did civilization, even though it's been around way longer than us.
39:15 Hank Green? I agree, and I also think there are problems. I think language, as you know, is a really important part of.
39:21 John Green? Yeah.
39:22 Hank Green? Of.
39:22 John Green? But you could do language underwater.
39:23 Hank Green? Civilizational intelligence. You could do language with hand signals and stuff underwater.
39:27 John Green? No, no.
39:27 Hank Green? And you could do, yeah, whales do it. Whales and dolphins do it. I, I, I think whales and dolphins have had a fairly long time to create really complex language and probably have done it and we just don't understand it. But anyway.
39:38 John Green? That is true.
39:39 Hank Green? So, point being whales and dolphins are possible, but you think it's hard.
39:42 John Green? I think there's other problems. I think that like.
39:45 Hank Green? You think it's hard to build temples?
39:46 John Green? Yeah, it's hard to build at all when you are an ocean animal.
39:49 Hank Green? Yeah, fair enough.
39:50 John Green? Because you're optimized for moving through water, which is not, does not help you optimize toward being able to build stuff.
39:56 Hank Green? I don't know how much you need to build to have a civilization. I think you need specialization of labor.
40:03 John Green? Yeah.
40:03 Hank Green? But for all we know, dolphins already have that. Yeah, well, you need, but you, what, well, what is labor? What, like, what does that come down to? You actually have to be doing stuff together.
40:12 John Green? Right. Which is building.
40:15 Hank Green? Yeah.
40:16 John Green? Even if you're not building buildings, you're building some, you're building stories, you're building something.
40:20 Hank Green? It's also extremely hard to do chemistry underwater.
40:22 John Green? Okay, good to know.
40:23 Hank Green? Chemistry is, it, you know.
40:25 John Green? Was born underwater.
40:26 Hank Green? So like chemistry happens underwater, but if you want to do chemistry, you have to control the chemistry.
40:31 John Green? Mm-hmm.
40:31 Hank Green? To control the chemistry in this pot and in this pot, and then mix those two pots together.
40:34 John Green? Mm-hmm.
40:35 Hank Green? That's very hard underwater.
40:36 John Green? Okay, all right. So these are some of the reasons why Hank thinks that water animals are unlikely.
40:40 Hank Green? Yeah.
40:41 John Green? I think it's primates number one by a mile.
40:43 Hank Green? Yeah, for sure.
40:44 John Green? Raccoon-like creatures number two.
40:46 Hank Green? And I would prefer that.
40:47 John Green? I would prefer raccoons.
40:48 Hank Green? Yeah.
40:49 John Green? We had a chance as primates.
40:51 Hank Green? Yeah, give them a crack at it.
40:52 John Green? Let's give them a crack.
40:53 Hank Green? Oh, and I think, just for clarity, they will do worse than us.
40:56 John Green? Hundred percent. This is something that people don't understand about people, which is that we are incredibly powerful, and as a result, we cause a lot of harm. But if you made another animal incredibly powerful, it would also cause a lot of harm and maybe more harm.
41:11 Hank Green? Yeah.
41:11 John Green? I don't know if you've hung out with a raccoon, but it might be worse.
41:14 Hank Green? They're super cute. But, man, ah, the, the drive is in all kinds of fermentic directions.
41:22 John Green? Yeah, I mean, so is ours, to be fair, yes.
41:25 Hank Green? But if you think a bunch of, I mean, if you think ADHD is good for civilization, then raccoons seem to have it in spades.
41:33 John Green? Yeah, I mean, I, I think, I think we should give raccoons a chance. I just think that they might be monstrous to each other, the way like chimpanzees rip off each other's faces and stuff.
41:41 Hank Green? Chimpanzees are also not nice to each other.
41:43 John Green? Um, but nor are we.
41:45 Hank Green? No, and bonobos are.
41:48 John Green? Maybe it'll be bonobos.
41:49 Hank Green? That's fingers crossed, man.
41:50 John Green? Oh, that'd be great.
41:51 Hank Green? That to chimps, for you guys.
41:53 John Green? I might say, I might, I might be able to, to hand it off if it was gonna be bonobos.
41:58 Hank Green? Yeah.
41:58 John Green? Lots of pleasure-seeking.
42:00 Hank Green? Yeah, good, like, social bonding.
42:02 John Green? Deep social bonds, not a lot of outcasts within the community.
42:06 Hank Green? Yeah.
42:07 John Green? That would be better.
42:08 Hank Green? Less, but still.
42:09 John Green? Still, of course, it's always gonna happen. Now, let me throw out one final one that I think you're gonna love.
42:14 Hank Green? Okay.
42:15 John Green? Dogs.
42:17 John Green? Hmm.
42:18 Hank Green? Dogs.
42:18 John Green? Yeah, sometimes they walk around on two legs. Not that that's a necessity.
42:21 Hank Green? I don't think that's a necessity.
42:22 John Green? Absolutely not, but I think they do it sometimes, just because it's cute.
42:26 Hank Green? They're very, it's interesting, uh, it would be interesting what, to see what dogs did without us, because we have already selectively bred them to have a bunch of more social things going on.
42:38 John Green? Exactly. That's why I think there's a possibility.
42:40 Hank Green? Stuff before, but now there's a lot of like, love.
42:43 John Green? Yeah, they got a lot of love. They got the big eyes.
42:45 Hank Green? Uh huh.
42:46 John Green? I will say, if dogs don't make it as an, a kind of apex civilizational species, I can see them being the raccoons pets.
42:54 Hank Green? No.
42:55 John Green? Hmm.
42:55 Hank Green? They'd be that they, because raccoons are so small.
42:57 John Green? Oh, they would be the like pack animals.
42:59 Hank Green? They'd be the pack animals.
43:00 John Green? They would be the horses of raccoons.
43:02 Hank Green? And then raccoons, if they could make it, would be a way better size for a civilizational species.
43:08 John Green? This is a big issue for Hank. He thinks that we're too big.
43:10 Hank Green? Too big. Raccoons way easier to get to space.
43:13 John Green? Way easier.
43:14 Hank Green? They're so small. They eat less.
43:16 John Green? Now, that is the truth, Hank. When we are visited by aliens, they will not look like us. They will be tiny.
43:21 Hank Green? They will, they, absolutely, like, if actually they get to us.
43:26 John Green? Yeah.
43:26 Hank Green? There is a far greater than 50% chance that they will be smaller than us. I think we're big. I don't think that we understand how big we are.
43:35 John Green? Yeah, it's possible. Cause we're looking at elephants all day, thinking about how big they are.
43:39 Hank Green? But they, yeah. I mean, we're all, I think we're like fairly average when it comes to mammal size. No, no, we're big.
43:44 John Green? We're big for mammals. Think about all the chipmunks out there.
43:47 Hank Green? Oh, the rodents.
43:48 John Green? Yeah, tons of rodents.
43:50 Hank Green? We're so big. That's my, man, if I get to do Smarty Pants again, we're too big. We're too big.
43:56 John Green? If I get to do Smarty Pants, I'm gonna steal that.
43:58 Hank Green? Okay, you should.
43:59 John Green? I would like to. It's a fun one.
44:01 Hank Green? Yeah.
44:01 John Green? All right. It's time to get to the all-important news from Mars and AFC Wimbledon. All start, AFC Wimbledon played their first game against promotion favorites Luton Town, and we lost, which is not a surprise. Uh, we expected to lose, but the manner in which we lost was truly heartbreaking.
44:16 Hank Green? Ooh.
44:16 John Green? We lost on like a bad luck 85th minute, uh, own goal.
44:20 Hank Green? Well, that's a good sign, though.
44:22 John Green? It's a pretty good sign that our defense might be ready for League One, or else Luton Town hasn't fully. Into gear, but it did make me think like, okay, we can, uh, we can maybe survive. We can maybe make it. Uh, we've also signed some new players and, uh, everybody looks, everybody looked congealed. I would say at no point did I watched, I watched the game at no point did it look like we were going to score a goal. Like we did not, we had zero goal mouth threats, but we looked very good defensively. And Luton Town also did not look like they would score a goal, except for this random ridiculous thing that happened. Where it was just like stupid, bad luck.
44:59 Hank Green? Yeah.
45:00 John Green? So on the whole, I emerged, and I'm going to be saying this a lot this season because we're not going to win a lot of games. I emerged hopeful from this loss, which is all you can hope for.
45:10 Hank Green? Nice, nice.
45:11 John Green? What's the news from Mars?
45:12 Hank Green? Well, the news from Mars is kind of the news from Jupiter. And look, maybe we're just going to mix it up.
45:16 John Green? Yeah.
45:17 Hank Green? And, and do news from other planets.
45:18 John Green? Cause it's news from non-Earth.
45:20 Hank Green? Messy up, but this is also news from Mars. So the Europa Clipper is a mission that is going to Europa.
45:26 John Green? Yeah.
45:27 Hank Green? Very exciting. Europa is a very exciting place.
45:29 John Green? Now, we think that life could be on Europa.
45:30 Hank Green? We think that life could be in Europa for sure.
45:33 John Green? Okay.
45:33 Hank Green? Probably not on, be a little tricky to be on, but, but maybe in, there's a lot of water in the moons of Jupiter. It's liquid water.
45:40 John Green? Okay.
45:41 Hank Green? Um, so, uh,
45:42 John Green? On the surface?
45:43 Hank Green? No.
45:44 John Green? Okay.
45:44 Hank Green? On the inside. So Europa Clipper is heading out to, to Jupiter where it lives and, uh, where Europa lives. And it, uh, and it has this, uh, this tool on it called Reason, which is a radar tool. They want to calibrate this radar tool. They want to like test how it works and they could only do that so much here on Earth.
46:03 John Green? Sure.
46:03 Hank Green? But in order to get to Jupiter, uh, the Clipper is doing a gravity assist with Mars.
46:09 John Green? So it's going up to, to gravity. Mars news.
46:11 Hank Green? Yeah.
46:11 John Green? Oh, yeah. The Europa Clipper just went right past Mars.
46:14 Hank Green? So it's going right past Mars.
46:15 John Green? Slingshot.
46:16 Hank Green? Getting a slingshot, getting pulled along a little bit to speed it up, get it out, all the way out to Jupiter, which is hard. And you don't want to carry fuel around that you don't have to, because that's mass and you want to use that mass for science. So it's headed out, uh, to Jupiter, and as it does its flyby, they also got within like 500 miles of Mars. And they tested out this, uh, thing. They did some tests to see how it was working. It's working. They do some calibrations, and now they have that all ready, so they don't have to do it when they get to Europa.
46:44 John Green? You're just looking for good news, Hank, and this is a little bit of good news in the world of space exploration.
46:50 Hank Green? Yeah, means that this tool is working.
46:52 John Green? Okay, and we are gonna go to Europa, not, I mean, not personally, but, but with our...
46:57 Hank Green? No, and I love that.
46:58 John Green? With our hand satellites. Our satellites are almost like extensions of our hands.
47:02 Hank Green? Yeah.
47:03 John Green? That reach out deeply into space.
47:05 Hank Green? Yeah, and they can, they can see in wavelengths we can't see, and they can hear in frequencies we can't hear.
47:10 John Green? So, it's true, the monkeys have tailhands, but we have satellite hands.
47:14 Hank Green? That's right.
47:15 John Green? Which are, I think sometimes we underappreciate how beautiful it is that we have learned so much about what it means to be here, despite each of us only being here for a little while.
47:27 Hank Green? It's wild. It's wild. And see, like, I, I understand why we focus on the problems, because they need to be solved.
47:32 John Green? Yep.
47:33 Hank Green? But, if we only focus on the problems, then it's like, why would we solve all these problems? Everything is terrible.
47:39 John Green? Right.
47:40 Hank Green? Why would we even bother?
47:41 John Green? You can't fall into despair, because despair doesn't tell the whole story.
47:46 Hank Green? Yes. We, and the reason the problems matter is because we care. And care is also something that would not exist without life.
47:54 John Green? All right, we're off to film our Patreon-only, uh, podcast that we do once a month, where we catch patrons up on what we've been up to and how we're doing.
48:03 Hank Green? It's a livestream, so it's weird just to film it, but yes.
48:06 John Green? It will be filmed, in the sense that it's a livestream.
48:09 Hank Green? Yeah, I don't really think about the fact that, you can watch it afterward, and people do do that.
48:13 John Green? But it won't be filmed in the sense that there will be no tape.
48:15 Hank Green? Yeah.
48:16 John Green? So, I probably could have used a better word for that.
48:19 Hank Green? Yeah. We're about to do our Patreon-only livestream.
48:22 John Green? There you go, Hank, and, uh...
48:23 Hank Green? You can find out about that at patreon.com/dearhankajohn.
48:26 John Green? That's what I was gonna say. Thank you for podding with me. It is always a pleasure, especially when we get to be together in real life.
48:30 Hank Green? It's nice. We should do it all the time, but I would have to live...
48:34 John Green? In Indianapolis, because I'm not moving to Missoula. It's very expensive here.
48:38 Hank Green? This podcast is edited by Ben Swardout. It's mixed by Joseph Tuna. Our marketing specialist is Brooke Shotwell. It's produced by Rosiana Hals, Rojas, and Hannah West. Our executive producer is Seth Radley. Our editorial assistant is Deboki Trukravarti. The music you're hearing now and at the beginning of the podcast is by the great Gonerola. And as they say in our hometown, don't forget to be awesome.
Previous 420: The Plant Episode Next 422: We Got Another Brother (w/ Travis McElroy!) Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated