Pod Insights Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe Space Debris (featuring Dr. Jonathan McDowell) About this episode Daniel and Kelly talk to Dr. Jonathan McDowell about the kinds of junk you find in space, the problems it causes, and what we can do about it.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 10,806 words · 8 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Daniel Whiteson? This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
0:05 Speaker 01 This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Granger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Granger to keep products moving and trucks rolling. So his operation runs smoothly, no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click Granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.
0:35 Speaker 02 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
1:08 Kelly Weinersmith? In 1962, the United States detonated a 1.4-megaton hydrogen bomb 400 kilometers above the surface of the Earth. This was part of a project called Operation Fishbowl. Not surprisingly, it created a huge explosion, which lit up the sky and disrupted radio transmissions. It also knocked out streetlights in Hawaii, which may have worried partygoers who, according to Smithsonian Magazine, were gathering on hotel rooftops for H-bomb explosion viewing parties. It also messed up six different satellites. Four belonged to Americans, one was Russian, and it also messed up the very first British satellite. The Soviet Union was conducting similar tests of nuclear weapons in space at the same time.
1:53 Kelly Weinersmith? This didn't bode well for the future of satellites in space. This amazing new technology of satellites held a lot of promise, but who would want to invest in it if the United States and the Soviet Union kept making satellites inoperable with nuclear weapons tests in space? Well, lucky for all of us, in 1963, both nations agreed to stop screwing up space for the rest of us and signed the Partial Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, which banned the test of nuclear weapons in some places, including space. And this year, you also get a UN resolution saying weapons of mass destruction can't be orbited in space. And you get a United Nations Outer Space Treaty, which comes into force in 1967, which reiterated all of these points for other nations as well.
2:37 Kelly Weinersmith? Phew, now satellites are safe, right? Well, probably. While space is really vast, we've put a lot of stuff in orbit around Earth, and the pace at which we're sending stuff up is ever increasing as the cost of sending that stuff up drops. Could it get too crowded up there? Could some of the space litter we've left behind smash into the stuff we're still trying to use? I'd be really bummed out if I couldn't watch cat videos using my Starlink satellite-provided internet. To answer some of these questions about the risks of stuff bumping into each other in space, we're interviewing Dr. Jonathan McDowell, who has been tracking objects sent to space since 1961, when the Soviet Union sent up Sputnik,
3:20 Kelly Weinersmith? the first-ever satellite in space. Welcome to Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe.
3:39 Daniel Whiteson? Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist, and I feel like my house is constantly filling up with junk.
3:46 Kelly Weinersmith? I'm Kelly Wiener-Smith. I'm a parasitologist, and I have felt that way since I married Zach. And the rate at which the junk has been increasing has exponentially since we had children. So we might have a Kessler syndrome situation happening in our house in the near future.
4:03 Daniel Whiteson? That's only if your children collide with each other and make more children or something.
4:08 Kelly Weinersmith? The biologist in me is not okay with that metaphor.
4:11 Daniel Whiteson? No, that was bad. So which of you is the cleaner upper? Or are you both contributing to the junk?
4:16 Kelly Weinersmith? I am the cleaner upper. I am also the less bringer stuffer into the houser. I don't like to buy a lot of new stuff, but that's not my husband's attitude about stuff. What about newer family?
4:30 Daniel Whiteson? I'm the thrower awayer. I'm the person constantly carting out bags of junk into the house. Whereas my wife and daughter like going thrift store shopping. And so they're bringing stuff in and then I'm like taking trips to the thrift store. When I take a trip to the thrift store, for example, it's a negative impact on our house. And they have the opposite effect. So we have like a thrift circuit going.
4:52 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, man. So I've gotten myself in trouble for being the person who throws stuff out in the house. Because my daughter will not let go of things and Zach doesn't want to let go of things either. And I got in trouble because once I was like, well, if I just throw it out, they won't notice, but then they notice. And so for a while I moved everything to a storage unit. You might be noticing it's a whole thing.
5:11 Daniel Whiteson? Yes.
5:12 Kelly Weinersmith? It's a whole thing.
5:13 Daniel Whiteson? I see. So you've moved to the multi-stage throw out technique. Like I'm gonna put it over here. And then when nobody notices, I'll move it over there. And then eventually I get to throw it away.
5:20 Kelly Weinersmith? And that's why I have a whole farm. Lots of spots to squirrel their junk away. Oh, and I just remembered that Zach has been listening to the podcast, which is so nice of him.
5:33 Kelly Weinersmith? Don't check the tenant house.
5:36 Daniel Whiteson? Well, the danger of moving onto a farm in a big house is the more space you have, the more junk you get. I feel like we have a constant density of junk. And if we lived in a smaller space, we would have less stuff.
5:46 Kelly Weinersmith? The belief has been that because we have all of this space, we can get more stuff. But I don't want the junk outside. I don't want more stuff. I don't want more stuff.
5:55 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah. Space is more valuable than almost any stuff. Whenever we throw something away, I'm like, ah, look at all that empty space. It's wonderful.
6:02 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes. Right? Isn't it nice? So when you, when you come home with like a bag in your hand and to just be able to like put it on the counter? Cause there's clear space on the counter and not like have to elbow cups out of the way.
6:14 Daniel Whiteson? Hundred percent agree with you. All right.
6:18 Kelly Weinersmith? All right. Team clean over here.
6:19 Daniel Whiteson? And if we were in charge of the atmosphere around Earth, maybe you and I, we'd keep it pretty clean.
6:23 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, but the people that we keep interacting with would be like, well, there's a lot of space. So we're just gonna move it somewhere else, you know, and then the graveyard orbit would get all crowded. And I don't know, I'm a pessimist, Daniel.
6:35 Daniel Whiteson? Zach and Katrina would fill the universe with junk.
6:39 Daniel Whiteson? So big.
6:40 Kelly Weinersmith? There's room, there's room. Don't worry. Buy more books, buy more books. Well, we don't have to keep them. We're not going to read them again. No, I can't let go of a book. Books gotta stay forever.
6:50 Daniel Whiteson? Zach, you can keep all your books in orbit near Pluto.
6:53 Kelly Weinersmith? I love you.
6:56 Daniel Whiteson? And today on the podcast, we're going to be talking about junk and space junk with somebody who has spent their whole career thinking and tracking bits of garbage in space.
7:05 Kelly Weinersmith? I have loved interacting with Jonathan McDowell on Twitter. When we were writing A City on Mars, he was my go to person where I was like, the needles from Project West Ford, are they still in space, Jonathan? The glove that got lost during the EVA number 543, is that still in space? He knows the answer to all of these questions. He is the guy. We're excited to have him on the show today. So let's jump right in.
7:32 Kelly Weinersmith? On today's show, we have Dr. Jonathan McDowell. He's an astrophysicist at the Harvard Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He's also the editor of Jonathan's Space Report, a free internet newsletter founded in 1989, which provides technical details of satellite launches. His website provides the most comprehensive historical list of satellite launch information, starting with Sputnik. And he's a fellow of the Royal Astronomical Society, an American Astronomical Society Fellow, and he has an asteroid named after him, 4589 McDowell. So he's now officially the second person on the show who has an asteroid named after him. Martin Elvis, uh, beat you by a few months there.
8:12 Speaker 04 My old boss, yes.
8:14 Kelly Weinersmith? He was your old boss?
8:15 Speaker 04 He's the one who conned me into crossing the pond and coming to work at Harvard instead of staying in England, which I'm now sort of regretting. But yes, now Martin and I go back a ways.
8:28 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, wonderful. Well, he's absolutely lovely. And he talked to us about asteroids. We're talking to you about stuff that's floating around in space. So we had a listener who asked a question, and we're going to play the question a little bit later. But that got us interested in space debris. So I think for starters, let's just talk about what kind of stuff we have up there, debris or otherwise, that's orbiting the Earth right now.
8:48 Speaker 04 So there are about 25,000 objects that the Space Force radars are tracking every day.
8:55 Kelly Weinersmith? It's a lot.
8:56 Daniel Whiteson? 25,000. Wow, that's incredible number.
8:59 Speaker 04 That's just the ones big enough to see, right? They go from the 450-ton International Space Station down to little shards of debris that are only about five or 10 centimeters across. I'll talk a bit about where they come from, but below that, between like, say, one centimeter and 10 centimeters, we think there might be as many as a million pieces of debris that we don't even know about because they're too small for the radars to see. So now, space is big, but everything in space, because of Kepler's laws, is traveling at like 17,000 miles an hour. And so, you know, it's pretty crazy up there. And we
9:38 Speaker 04 have now 10,000 working satellites. Just five years ago, it was only 1,000. Now it's gone up to 10,000.
9:47 Daniel Whiteson? Is that all Starlink?
9:48 Speaker 04 Well, about half of them are Starlink, yeah. And so there's internet relay, there's internet of things relay, there's ship and airplane tracking, there's weather satellites, there's spy satellites, resource monitoring satellites, signals intelligence, which is like intercepting communications and radio signals for the military, and of course, a few science satellites. People often think that space is like, oh, that's science. But science is a pretty small fraction of what's going on. And what can happen is every time you launch a satellite, you use a rocket to do it. And to put it in orbit, the upper rocket stage has to get into orbit along with the satellite. So now you've launched
10:29 Speaker 04 your satellite, but you've also made a piece of space junk, the rocket stage. And nowadays, if you're like prudent, you have a restartable engine, you can bring the rocket stage down in the ocean afterwards. But we didn't used to even bother to do that. So if you look in the catalog of, there's now over 60,000 objects in the space object catalog, including all the re-entered ones. The second entry in the catalog is Sputnik, Russia's first satellite. But the first entry, satellite number one, is actually the rocket stage that puts Sputnik in orbit. And so the very first entry in the catalog is a piece of space junk.
11:06 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, that's interesting and depressing.
11:09 Speaker 04 Yeah. What's worse, if you leave a little extra fuel in the tank of your rocket stage, which you can tend to do because you don't want to arrive at your destination running on empty. Rocket stages have, you know, fuel and oxidizer that combine to burn to make the flame. But they're in separate tanks, separated by often like a rubber gasket or something like that, which over years can erode. The two can get together and depending on your mix of propellant, 10 years after you abandon your rocket stage in Earth orbit, the fuel and oxidizer can have a party and suddenly you don't have a rocket stage, you have 300 pieces of space debris.
11:46 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, my God. So you're saying they explode?
11:48 Speaker 04 And that would be the technical term, yes. Or as the space guys like to say, an RUD, a rapid unplanned disassembly. We have all kinds of euphemisms, right? For the bad things that can go wrong in space. Another one of my favorites is, you know, ICBM, a continental ballistic missile, but do you know IOBM? Which is in ocean by mistake.
12:11 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, no. Love it.
12:15 Daniel Whiteson? So what's the sort of natural context? Like, we are creating these little bits of space junk, but was the near Earth atmosphere sort of empty before that? Or are there like a lot of natural things floating out there?
12:26 Speaker 04 So within the orbit of the moon, we do have like meteors coming in on escape trajectories, right? They're not orbiting the Earth. They have escape velocity with respect to the Earth. They're going much, much faster than satellites. And so they come in, they burn up, they're gone. They don't hang out in Earth orbit. The only piece of natural space junk we have orbiting the Earth is the moon.
12:50 Daniel Whiteson? You can't call the moon junk.
12:52 Speaker 04 Well, you know, it's a big lump of stone, you know. We added to that with Sputnik and we've added ever since. Again, not just rocket stages blowing up, but also satellites hitting each other. So in 2009, an iridium communication satellite hit an old Soviet dead communication satellite at, you know, about 20,000 miles an hour in orbit. And to give you an idea of the kinetic energy involved in that, right? I mean, it's like some number of gigajoules and I don't have a feel for that. So I calculated in terms of my unit of how hard something hurts is imagine being hit by a one ton truck. You can kind of sense how much that would hurt.
13:37 Speaker 04 The energy involved in one of these orbital collisions is about 50,000 times that.
13:43 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow.
13:44 Daniel Whiteson? Wow.
13:45 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, my gosh.
13:46 Speaker 04 And so what happens is a hypersonic shockwave goes through both spacecraft, reducing them to shrapnel. The clouds of shrapnel pass through each other largely unchanged and you end up with them in the original orbit, but many, many little pieces instead of one big one. So we don't like that. That's bad. It can cause, ultimately, if you have enough of those, you can get a chain reaction called the Kessler syndrome that could make space unusable. And then, you know, some people think it's fun to fire a missile at one of their own satellites and blow it up just to show how powerful they are, anti-satellite weapons. And that causes, yep, there's more debris due to that. There's been a move in recent years to go, you know, guys, that's probably not a good idea.
14:30 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, let's dig into that a little bit more. So I know that the Soviet Union, the United States, India, China, right? They've all blown their own satellites up in space. Is that right?
14:39 Speaker 04 That is correct. Fortunately, so far, they've only been tests on their own satellites and not attacking somebody else's.
14:46 Kelly Weinersmith? So for our audience who's maybe not familiar with this, why are countries blowing up their own satellites?
14:51 Speaker 04 Right. It's to prove that they could blow up your satellites if they wanted. And so the idea, you know, what people may not appreciate is so much of our lives today actually invisibly depends on space technology. I mean, the most obvious case, of course, is GPS. I actually know how to read a map, but the younger generation are going to be really hosed if GPS ever goes down, they're not going to be able to get home. I'd be hosed. And that was originally a military system to target cruise missiles. And so that's in a war, taking out the GPS satellites would be something that an attacker might want to do. Similarly, military around space communications, there are missile warning satellites that spot when a missile is launched and that's how you get that warning.
15:35 Speaker 04 And there are these sort of very spy satellites, right? And so the military, even more than normal people are so very invested in space. Their systems are integrated with space systems. And so in a war, those space systems are obvious targets. And so the idea of anti-satellite weapons has been around for a long time. The first attempt that I'm aware of was in 1959, when they fired a test missile against the Explorer Six satellite and missed it. But it's not a new idea, is what I'm saying. So all of these things, you know, very early, the 50s were a crazy time, man. They tried all kinds of stuff very early.
16:15 Daniel Whiteson? And so every time we blow up a satellite, you go from one object in space to like a million objects in space. Do we then track all of those individual components?
16:24 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, the ones above 10 centimeters, we track. And so sometimes people talk about shooting down a satellite, but I hate that phrase because you don't actually shoot it down. You add energy, you special into pieces, but those pieces still have orbital velocity and they stay in orbit. And so if you have a satellite that's say in a 500 kilometer circular orbit, the pieces are in elliptical orbits that are one end is 500 and then the other end might be lower or it might be higher, as much as 1,000 kilometers or 2,000 kilometers coming down to the ones that go downward, you know, will re-enter quickly. The ones that go up will stay up for a long time. And so the worst one was a Chinese anti-satellite test in 2007. And that created 3,000 pieces of tracked debris.
17:09 Speaker 04 And so in my catalog that I have on my website, each one of those 3,000 pieces has a catalog number from the Space Force. It has orbital parameters that are updated every day. It's quite a task keeping track of these things.
17:23 Daniel Whiteson? So there's some random chunk of a satellite that has like a name and this place in your database and you're tracking it and it's just like a hunk of metal floating through space?
17:30 Speaker 04 That's exactly right. And, you know, every now and again, for example, the International Space Station. Has to dodge one of these things. So the Space Force tracks and goes, oh, hey, guys, about 24 hours from now, this chunk of metal is going to go within a few hundred meters of the space station.
17:47 Daniel Whiteson? Wait, before we get to the ISS, how do we track all these things? Like, who is tracking this random chunk of a Chinese satellite? How do we monitor these things?
17:55 Speaker 04 So mostly, it's the US Space Force, which for low orbit satellites, they use radars. So you bounce radar radio energy off the satellite and the echo gives you its position and velocity. But it's a problem because if you have like, say, 100 new pieces that you're tracking, so you see them come over, okay, you get measurements of 100 pieces. An hour and a half later, they've orbited the earth. You look again, you've got another 100 pieces, but matching up which one goes with which one is very non-trivial.
18:26 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
18:27 Speaker 04 And so it takes a long time to catalog the debris and that's a period you're not getting warnings from those new objects. So that's why new debris is very bad. Radars are great up to about 1,000 kilometers, a few thousand kilometers. They're a one over R to the fourth law. If the thing is 10 times further away, it's 10,000 times weaker reflected single. So for high orbit satellites, radars really aren't the way to go. And we've been using regular optical telescopes to observe the objects. And now we're actually starting to deploy satellites in high orbit, whose job is to catalog all the other satellites and keep track of them.
19:05 Daniel Whiteson? Why is it one over R to the fourth? Is it because you get one over R squared from your signal and then one over R squared from the bounce?
19:11 Speaker 04 Exactly right. It's one over R squared each way.
19:14 Daniel Whiteson? Wow, I see. So that's difficult. It seems to me like a really hard problem, even if you know where everything is, even if there's nothing new, because radar is just giving you locations, right? It doesn't measure velocities.
19:25 Speaker 04 Yes, there's a Doppler, but it's only one component.
19:27 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, right. Okay.
19:29 Speaker 04 Right. You have a range and a range rate. And then you only have a very approximate angular position on the sky because the radar is very sharp. And so you need multiple observations to kind of resolve that and do it. So again, this is something they've been doing since the 1950s and it was manageable back then when there weren't that many satellites. And now it's getting a really tough problem and you can see them struggling. There was a recent Chinese satellite launch, 18 satellites went up about a month ago. And it was only yesterday that Space Force started issuing orbital data for them because it took them that long to sort it out. It's a fascinating problem and really technically challenging. And in the circumstances, they do a pretty good job,
20:11 Speaker 04 but it's not really good enough for what we need today.
20:15 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, it seems like a lot of compute is required. You have to know all these trajectories, predict where they are, get the new data, update the trajectories if they are deviate from your prediction. I'm wondering about the security here. Like, there must be things in space that are like secret spy satellites. Are those parts of your database? Is the NSA watching you to see if you're tracking that stuff?
20:34 Speaker 04 If they're not, they're not doing their job.
20:38 Kelly Weinersmith? You've really acclimated to life in the United States, Jonathan.
20:41 Speaker 04 Yeah, right. Exactly. The secret satellites are tracked by the Space Force. The US secret satellites, they don't release the orbital data for that publicly. The Russian and Chinese secret satellites, they do. The Israeli and French ones, they sometimes just sometimes don't. So our friends, they keep the secret one secret, but for people we don't like, we just publish them. Until very recently, there was maybe 100 or so secret US and allied satellites. And most of them were pretty big. Some of the old big bird spy satellites are like 10 tons, right, in low orbit. And so they're as bright as the brightest stars in the sky. And so in order to get their orbits, all you really need are binoculars and a stopwatch.
21:25 Speaker 04 Sometimes not even binoculars.
21:27 Daniel Whiteson? So it's in this category of like officially secret, but totally obvious.
21:31 Speaker 04 Exactly. So, you know, we figure that there's a bunch of amateurs whose hobby is to fill in the holes and get the orbits of the satellites that aren't meant to be public. And we feel fine about that because we figure that if a bunch of amateur astronomers with binoculars can figure out these orbits, the North Koreans can too. And so I think for a long time, the Space Force were a bit of denial, or the Air Forces, it was, they were a bit of denial. That's good. They would ask us, what sensors are you using to detect our satellites? My eyes. We look up, it's coming overhead, there it is. And so I think now there's more of a realization that actually pretty fruitless trying to keep these orbits secret. And I
22:15 Speaker 04 think in the long run, for safety of space operations, so that other people know not to bump into them, that era of making the orbit data secret has got to end, I think. And that's an active discussion.
22:27 Daniel Whiteson? Have we ever had a secret satellite blow up or turn into secret space debris?
22:31 Speaker 04 Absolutely, absolutely.
22:33 Daniel Whiteson? Secret space junk? Never heard of that before.
22:35 Speaker 04 I think the most common case is the upper stage from one of these satellites blew up and created a lot of debris. And so for a long time, those orbital data were secret, classified, but they kind of wised up eventually and released that. So that's good. There've been some improvements lately in the transparency of the system, which I'm pleased to see. There's slowly, you know, there was a lot of like Cold War mentality. And now it's sort of, even though we may be going to another Cold War or whatever. But see, one of the big things that's changed in the past 10 years is it used to be, I would give talks, I would say, space is about one third civilian government, one third military, and one third commercial.
23:14 Speaker 04 Those days are gone. Now, space is overwhelmingly commercial. And that means that the incentives at the government level, right, are to support the commercial industry. And that means more transparency in terms of not having to worry about being hit by a secret satellite. There's other transparency issues because companies want to keep their plans secret and things like that for commercial reasons. So that's a whole other issue. So times have really changed. The last five, 10 years has been a dramatic shift towards this new era of commercial space.
23:47 Daniel Whiteson? And what's your interest in it? I mean, you're an astrophysicist. Are you curious about this because you're just curious about anything in space? Or is this like political advocacy where you feel like, hey, space is for everyone and we should all know what's up there?
23:59 Speaker 04 You know, it's changed recently. So yeah, I've had this separate life since I was a kid of wanting to know what was going on in space. And, you know, I found this list of the year's satellite launches when I was about 12. And I very quickly realized after copying it down that it wasn't really that great a list. They could do better. And so 50 years later, I have the best list. Because I'm obsessive like that. And so that was sort of my original impetus. And I've got more and more dragged into the policy side. And then as space has started to become so busy that we, humans are starting to have an impact on the space
24:39 Speaker 04 environment. And part of that is an impact on astronomy. My two lives of astronomer and space pundit have kind of merged and very much now are becoming advocacy and becoming the Cassandra saying, hey, guys, we got a problem here with the overwhelming effect that we are now having on the space environment in a lot of different ways, and the need for new regulation to adapt to the new environment that we're in.
25:10 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, let's take a quick break. And when we get back, we'll talk about policy and impacts.
25:22 Speaker 05 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds up to $200,000 right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
25:53 Speaker 06 This is Stugatz from Stugatz and Company Live. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it all starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla sedan with the latest features and tech or Tesla. Drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you can get more at trade-in. Get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
26:40 Kelly Weinersmith? And we're back. So there's all this junk floating around in space. And I'm under the impression that part of why it's hard to remove the junk from space is because there's policies that make it difficult to take someone else's junk out of space without like getting their permission first. Is that correct? And what's holding us back from removing all of that junk from space?
27:00 Speaker 04 Right, that is part of it. And so, yes, the Outer Space Treaty says that unlike, say, stuff abandoned in the ocean, stuff in space, you can't abandon it. It's still your problem. And the Outer Space Treaty didn't have an idea of companies or anything like that. And so if you want to put something in space, you're like SpaceX, for example, you've got to get a license from your government, in this case, the US. And part of that license is then the US as a country takes on the duty of jurisdiction and control of that satellite. And so that means if there's an old Russian rocket stage orbiting that's been abandoned for 30 years, I can't go up and take it without getting Russian permission because it still airs.
27:45 Speaker 04 And so that is seen by the space lawyers, particularly in the US, as a big, big problem that they don't want to, they kind of run and hide whenever you bring it up. I do feel this is a solvable problem, that no one wants the space junk. One thing I'm encouraged by, so there's a company called Astroscale, which is based in Tokyo and in the UK. And they've been recently flew a satellite around a big old Japanese rocket stage, observing it as sort of a preparatory mission to having the technology to remove it from orbit. And I think companies like that, that are sort of have an international basis. If you can do sort of a bilateral thing where, say, a European mission takes out a Japanese
28:31 Speaker 04 piece of space junk with both countries agreement, you can sort of set a tone that you can then grow later to go, okay, so we've done this. You see, we're not doing anything nefarious. We're cleaning up the orbit. Hey, Russian guys, can you join us and help us get rid of your junk too? And I think that's the way forward. But, you know, obviously in the world political situation as it is, it's not trivial.
28:55 Kelly Weinersmith? And I was talking to someone the other day who was saying that one of the problems with these technologies for clearing out space junk is that you can say like, oh, I'm going out there for space junk. And that's why I've got the laser. And that's why I've got this arm so that I can grab your space junk and throw it down. So it'll burn up in the atmosphere. But that's all dual use. That laser can be used to destroy someone else's satellite. That grappling arm can throw someone else. And that, is that actually holding anything back? Or are people just willing to accept that when you develop the technology to remove stuff from space, maybe you're also developing some dual use stuff to get used down the road?
29:25 Speaker 04 I think it's an issue that people bring up. I mean, personally, I think that's, I hate the term dual use. It's like everything is dual use, you know? I can stab you with my pen. I mean, yes, of course, any satellite that's maneuverable can be maneuvered to kind of, you know, smash into your satellite, right?
29:43 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah.
29:43 Speaker 04 In principle. And so I think that's just an excuse for not doing anything.
29:48 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
29:49 Speaker 04 Or just an expression of mistrust, you know, that is gettable over, in my opinion. But it's going to take a while. So I think, you know, the last 10 years, we've seen a bunch of experiments. The British in particular did a fun set of experiments where they sent a harpoon at a target to try and catch it. They threw a net around the satellite to reel it in and catch it. And so people are trying crazy stuff. And we're sort of starting to settle on, okay, what are the approaches that will actually work? And I think then the next step is to go and actually do it for real. And so the first people to do this were actually, surprisingly, the Chinese. The Chinese, a couple of years ago, they had this navigation satellite in geostationary
30:32 Speaker 04 orbit that had died and was just drifting in the traffic lane, you know? And so they sent up another satellite that went and locked onto it, probably with a robot arm or something, and brought it up 300 kilometers into what we call the graveyard, a sort of a space junkyard, and released it there. And then went back down to go look for other target. And that was the first time that anyone had actually done a kind of garbage truck space debris removal for real with a real piece of space debris. And so, you know, the fact that the US hasn't done that yet is frankly, a little bit embarrassing.
31:11 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, it would be nice for leading the cleanup.
31:14 Daniel Whiteson? I have a sort of naive question as a physicist. Like if the natural environment is just the moon, that suggests that there's some process of clearing near earth orbit of bits. Like if you had rocks coming in, they would naturally gravitate together or something. What is the sort of time scale for nature to take care of this itself? For it to like form a ring or to pull together into a new moon made of space junk?
31:37 Speaker 04 If you just leave the satellite population as it is.
31:40 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
31:41 Speaker 04 What happens? And yeah, let's say if the earth were a perfectly round, you know, point source and the moon and the sun didn't exist, then things would just orbit forever without changing their orbital parameters. The earth has an atmosphere. And so below about 1,000 kilometers, there's just enough atmosphere to have a headwind at orbital velocities that will eventually bring stuff back down into the atmosphere. And that time scale is every 11 years, we have the famous solar cycle, the solar maximum, that makes the atmosphere more dense. And that basically clears out everything below 500 kilometers in one or two cycles. So if you're below 500 or 600 kilometers, you're going to re-enter the earth's atmosphere within 20 something years.
32:24 Speaker 04 But if you're between like 600 kilometers and 10,000 kilometers, you're going to stay orbiting for centuries to millennia.
32:34 Speaker 04 There really isn't that much affecting you. The moon's far enough out that it's not really bothering you. Once you get beyond like a hundred thousand kilometers, now you have to start worrying about the gravity of the moon and the sun. And that will squeeze and turn your orbit. And it's fun, actually, there are weird things like the Cozai effect that exoplanet astronomers are really into, but also apply in Earth satellite stuff. There's a lot of parallels in the math.
33:01 Kelly Weinersmith? The bail just wants to know what's the Cozai effect?
33:03 Speaker 04 So what it is, is if you have an elliptical orbit and there's another body like the moon tugging on you, what it does is it squeezes and stretches the orbit. So it becomes more and less elliptical in a periodic way. And at the same time, tilts the orbit relative to the equator. And so the satellite I work on, Chander, is in an orbit like that. And over a decade or so, it goes from almost equatorial to almost polar and back again. And the low point of the orbit started off at 10,000 kilometers. It goes up to like 15,000, comes down to 5,000 and back up again. And if you get the sun and moon aligned, you could even have the low point go negative, which would be the end of the mission. Because then you try to orbit through the surface of the earth. Doesn't work very well.
33:48 Speaker 04 And so that's just one example of all the funky stuff that can happen. The flattening of the earth can be important.
33:55 Daniel Whiteson? What about the gravitation between the objects? Like, I understood that if you have some huge set of debris in orbit around a planet, if it's close below the Roche limit, the tidal forces will keep it from coalescing. For listeners who aren't familiar, the Roche limit is how close you can get to a planet before its tidal forces will pull you apart. We have tidal forces from planets because the planet's gravity pulls on the closer bit harder than on the further bit. But if you're far enough away from the planet, your internal structure can still hold you together. But if a moon, for example, gets too close to a planet, those tidal forces will pull it apart, shred it and turn it into a ring. But if it's far enough away, the self-gravity will eventually pull it together into a new moon. Could that happen eventually with all of our space junk?
34:39 Speaker 04 I haven't done that math. I doubt it. I think the total mass isn't enough to get you self-gravitating. We've launched maybe 20,000 tons of stuff.
34:50 Daniel Whiteson? That sounds like a lot, but I guess it's not compared to an astronomical object.
34:53 Speaker 04 Yeah, not compared to even a fairly small moon. My guess is that that would not happen.
35:00 Daniel Whiteson? Maybe we should use a moon as a unit of measuring how much space junk we put into this out there because it would make us feel better about it.
35:07 Speaker 04 The international standard moon. Yeah, okay, I'll take that under consideration, Daniel.
35:13 Kelly Weinersmith? All right. So when you were describing Chandra's orbit, it's becoming even more clear to me how hard it must be to track all of these objects because they're all doing their own sort of things while they're out there. So we've got all of this junk that's sort of hard to track. You had sort of touched on the Kessler syndrome. Let's dive into that a little bit more. So space is huge. How big of a risk is it that we're going to start getting these feedbacks where everything runs into each other? Let's talk about that.
35:35 Speaker 04 So space is huge, but low Earth orbit isn't that huge, right? So if we focus on the busiest part of space right now, from the human point of view, which is all the satellites between the bottom of the Earth's atmosphere and about 2,000 kilometers, there's a lot of stuff there. The average distance between any two objects is about 100 kilometers, but you're going at 25,000 kilometers an hour. So the analogy I always use is, you know, if you're driving on the highway, we're always reminded, the faster you go, the further you have to leave the distance from the car in front of you, right? So when you're traveling
36:16 Speaker 04 at 25,000 kilometers an hour, you don't have a lot of dodge time in 100 kilometers, right? And so we do get collisions and we're seeing them. We're seeing small collisions that are maybe not destroying a satellite entirely, but kind of breaking stuff off it. And the trouble is that the collision rate goes to the square of the number of satellites. So if you have 10 times as many satellites, you have 100 times as many collisions. So right now, the collision rate is not that bad. Even so, if you stop launching everything today, the collision rate is high enough that eventually on time scales of a century, you would start to get this runaway chain reaction.
36:55 Daniel Whiteson? What's the collision rate like now? How many collisions do we see per day or per year?
36:59 Speaker 04 I think we see two or three small ones per year.
37:02 Daniel Whiteson? Okay.
37:02 Speaker 04 Maybe one big one a decade of order. And so that is amplified by
37:09 Speaker 04 What we call breakup events. There's not one satellite dumping another, but when the rocket stage blows up, for example, and things like that. And we have several of those a year, adding hundreds of objects to the catalog each year from that kind of source. The number of debris objects is increasing. It's not like in the movie Gravity, right? Where everything goes to hell in about half an hour. Right? This is something that plays out. As with most environmental things, right? You slowly drown in your own waste. Right? Every year, it's a little bit worse and a little worse.
37:46 Daniel Whiteson? But it accelerates, right? You were saying that the collision rate depends on the number of objects squared. So every time you have an object that breaks into two, you've increased the number, which now increases the rate of collisions. And that's the feedback loop, right?
37:58 Speaker 04 That's exactly correct. Yes.
38:00 Kelly Weinersmith? And is this all going to be exacerbated even more by additional constellations of satellites? So SpaceX has their Starlink, but I think China is planning something similar?
38:10 Speaker 04 Yeah, China's made the first two launches of its Qianfan, thousand sails satellites. And, you know, people have seen the success of Starlink in providing communications in Ukraine. And so all the militaries in all the countries want their own, we must have control over it ourselves, Starlink constellation. And so I think in addition to the commercial interests, there's military interests. And so, yeah, we're going to see more and more of these constellations come along. Amazon have started deploying theirs. There's a company called Espace that wants to launch hundreds of thousands of satellites. So this is really happening. You know, what SpaceX will tell you is they have this Wizzo algorithm
38:55 Speaker 04 that will fix it in software, basically, that the satellites have these argon electric thrusters. They accelerate argon atoms with electric potential from solar panels to provide low thrust, but very many miles per gallon rocket engines that can do slow dodges, not fast dodges. And so they're always calculating, you know, they're doing thousands and thousands of small maneuvers to avoid each other and other people's satellites.
39:26 Speaker 04 And they're like, we got this, you know, we, we know how to do this. I think their math works out if you assume that the, you know, errors are always bell curve. And, you know, but that's not reality. The reality is that, as we say in the trade, errors are non-Gaussian. They're not like random, that someone screws up and something goes very wrong. And it only takes two people and two different constellations to screw up in the right way. As it were for your algorithms to just totally fail and you have a collision. And so we've been lucky so far. But I think if you up the number of satellites by another factor of 10 or so, the chances are
40:10 Speaker 04 that we're going to start seeing collisions. SpaceX has been quite careful. They're actually retiring now about 300 of their satellites that have components that they feel are dodgy and might cause a failure. And so they're bringing them down under control while they're still working and incinerating them in the atmosphere, which is a whole other environmental problem that's just emerging. Cause you know, messing with the chemistry of the upper atmosphere, what could possibly go wrong?
40:34 Kelly Weinersmith? That's worked fine for us so far.
40:36 Speaker 04 Yeah, right. But putting that aside for a second, you know, they're trying to be what they feel is responsible, bringing these satellites down, but not all companies maybe are going to do that. And for example, of the first batch of Canfan satellites, 17 of the 18 have started raising the orbits. One of them looks like it may have failed in a Saturn column, which will leave it up there for a century. If you're launching 10,000 satellites and you have a 1% failure rate, say that's 100 failed satellites added to the mix. And, you know, so it doesn't take too many of those to kind of exacerbate the problem.
41:14 Daniel Whiteson? But these companies must be incentivized to solve this problem, right? They don't want to invest billions in their network and then have them all be destroyed. They must be clear eyed about it.
41:22 Speaker 04 If anything will save us, that's it. It's the bottom line. And it's the usual environmental story that they will do not enough about the problem until it starts getting bad enough that they actually see economic losses due to the problem. And then they will scramble to self-regulate and do something that will improve it.
41:43 Kelly Weinersmith? And on that positive note, let's take a break. And when we come back, we'll talk about implications for astronomy.
41:56 Speaker 02 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
42:24 Speaker 07 This is Shirley Strawberry from the Steve Harvey Morning Show. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features and tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at trade-in, get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
43:14 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, so you mentioned a little bit earlier in the show that all of these Starlink satellites, for example, are making astronomy difficult. What is the magnitude of this problem?
43:24 Speaker 04 Right. Right now, it's an annoying nuisance, but again, up things by another factor of 10, and it becomes really difficult to do certain kinds of science. And so the problem is this, there are two problems. They're different for low-orbit satellites and high-orbit satellites. For low-orbit satellites, they're so low that in the middle of the night, they can't see the sun. They shine by reflected light, and so they're dark. And so they're not really a problem for astronomers in the middle of the night. They are, however, if you have enough of them, for example, if this e-space company I mentioned really launches like 100,000 satellites, you could get to a situation where there are more visible satellites in the sky than visible stars.
44:03 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, my gosh.
44:04 Speaker 04 Especially like just at the limit of visibility, the sky, instead of being nice and dark, will be kind of seething in this nauseous way. And then the brighter ones will make it very hard to kind of recognize the constellations because there's going to be so much traffic. It's going to be like in the flight pattern at Logan Airport or whatever.
44:22 Daniel Whiteson? But why are these things bright? I mean, they don't have lights on them, right? Are they just reflecting the sun?
44:26 Speaker 04 They reflect sunlight and they're big. They're big and low and they reflect sunlight. The current Starlink satellites are thirty meter span.
44:35 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, my gosh.
44:36 Speaker 04 Solar panels, they're not small. These are not tiny CubeSats, they're one ton ish satellites. So it's really a change in the environment for everyone in the world, right? Even if you're not a spacefaring country, but you like looking up at the sky. You maybe have cultural connections to the sky. And now suddenly you're seeing the sky changing. And one of my colleagues was just out hiking in the wilds of Canada. Said, you know, they saw like so many satellites now that they would never have seen a few years ago.
45:03 Daniel Whiteson? Can they do something on the satellites to reduce the reflectivity? Like have an anti-reflective coating or a sunshade?
45:09 Speaker 04 To SpaceX's credit, they are doing a number of things that have reduced the brightness of the satellite. But then they came out with this new model of the satellite where they had these fancy new mitigations. But they were also twice as big. So it kind of canceled out. To their credit, they've done a lot of work, but there's still more that needs to be done. So then the second problem is the high orbit satellites. They are too faint because they're high up. They're too faint to be seen by the average person looking up in the evening at the constellations. But they leave trails on astronomical images. And they're way, way brighter than the distant galaxies that we're looking at. And so you take this picture of some, you know, distant galaxy and you've got a big streak going across the image. And, you know, we're not just trying to take pretty pictures.
45:53 Speaker 04 We're trying to measure brightnesses of stars to like one or two percent accuracy. And so just photoshopping out the trail doesn't entirely solve the problem. And even if that works, if you have one trail every five images, you do what we call median filtering. Basically you throw away the bad ones and you just have to observe for longer than you otherwise would have. So it's a tax, but it's workable. But then, you know, if you up the number right, so that it's like ten streaks on every image going crisscrossing, going every way. That becomes pretty impossible to analyze in an automated way. If you have like, you know, 10,000 images of galaxies and you're trying to analyze them. Remote with an algorithm and trying to distinguish between the crisscrossing satellite streaks
46:37 Speaker 04 and actual astronomical phenomena is going to get pretty impossible. You know, there are some sciences going to be affected worse than others. The Magellanic Clouds, our nearest galaxies, are visible high in the southern sky in southern midsummer. Southern midsummer is the worst for this because that's when the sun isn't that far below the horizon. The satellites get illuminated all night long. And in plausible scenarios, five or 10 years from now, there are several thousand illuminated satellites all the time in the sky throughout the night in midsummer. We may be able to work around it with new kinds of cameras that can turn their shutters off
47:20 Speaker 04 for brief moments of time while the satellite is passing, triggered maybe by a finder camera that spots the satellite coming over. It's not trivial. That's money, right? That's money that we don't have to re-equip the observatories.
47:33 Daniel Whiteson? So Musk said, quote, "I am confident that we will not cause any impact whatsoever in astronomical discoveries, zero." How confident are you that that's the case?
47:43 Speaker 04 I am 100% confident that he is wrong about that.
47:48 Speaker 04 There are subtleties, right? And so, for example, there was a report of a flare in a redshift 11 galaxy that was super scientifically exciting until it turned out to be actually a satellite passing through the field of view of the telescope at the time. If you've just got like an optical fiber on the sky that you're taking a spectrum, right? You don't have an image of the sky. It's hard to figure out that that was a satellite. So there's all kinds of ways in which this is like a new kind of contamination factor that ranges from mild annoying to, oh, we accidentally published a wrong exciting result because there was no way to tell that it was caused by satellite contamination.
48:30 Daniel Whiteson? So if you were a dictator of the earth and you were in charge of this and everybody had to follow your instructions, what would you do to allow us to have this amazing space technology and worldwide network and also do astronomy?
48:43 Speaker 04 Yeah, that's the challenge. I think we just need a cap on the number of active satellites of a given brightness at a given altitude. You know, we have caps already, like in geostationary orbit, there's orbital slots that get assigned by the International Telecommunications Union. You can't just launch as many geostationary satellites as you like. I think we're going to have to go to that in low Earth orbit. We're going to have to have some kind of orbital slot thing, and that will then change the design trade so that instead of launching 10,000 small satellites, maybe you launch 1,000 bigger satellites, and that helps with not bumping into each other as well. So I think it's a matter of finding
49:24 Speaker 04 regulation that will, yes, absolutely let the space technology develop, but not in a complete free-for-all way, and manage the resources that we have in a sustainable way, and in a way that doesn't impact the environment and the astronomy more than a certain amount. And we're, I mean, absolutely, it's going to be worse for us than it used to be. But I do believe there's a happy medium where the astronomers could just about kind of survive, and the satellites can still make bunches of money.
49:57 Kelly Weinersmith? So let's wrap up the show by asking the two questioners that we got from a listener. So Josh sent us two questions. Here we go.
50:05 Speaker 07 Besides the stuff that just orbits the Earth, what happens to all the other stuff? Does it just go off into space, run into planets, moons, and stars? And parenthetically, I'm thinking that if they do hit planets and moons, they just sit there forever. And if they hit stars, I'm assuming they melt away.
50:28 Speaker 04 Right. Well, even if they hit a planet, you know, the typical planet hitting speed is going to be more than enough to pulverize you. We have, in addition to the 25-something-thousand objects currently in orbit, the 60,000 objects that have been in orbit since Sputnik, there's about One to 2,000 objects that we have sent beyond Earth orbit, either to the moon or into orbit around the Sun. And they're poorly documented. I've been trying to make a catalog of them, figure out where they all are. Most of them will just orbit the Sun forever. I say forever. After a million years, there are various effects that will cause them probably to spiral into the Sun or to hit a planet. But, you know, we're talking million year timescales. These things are going to be out there for a while unless, you know,
51:13 Speaker 04 the Smithsonian goes and collects them or something.
51:16 Kelly Weinersmith? With their gigantic budget.
51:17 Speaker 04 Yeah, well, you know, a thousand years from now, hopefully it will have a gigantic or 100,000 years from now, whatever. We do have stuff in orbit around Mars. We have stuff in orbit around Jupiter and we have stuff on the surface of the planets.
51:30 Daniel Whiteson? Stuff you mean on purpose or space junk or both?
51:33 Speaker 04 Well, both, right? So we try not to have the space junk hit Mars because, and so what we do is when we send stuff out in the direction of Mars, we actually sterilize the probe, sort of bake it so that there's hopefully no bacteria on it so that we won't contaminate the search for Martian life with bugs from Florida. And then when we launch it, we actually deliberately aim it away from Mars a little bit. We deliberately miss a bit, separate from the rocket stage. So now the rocket stage is in an orbit that doesn't go close to Mars. And then we make a course correction to put the probe on course from Mars. And so that way we avoid having the big sort of space junk pieces that we launch in orbit
52:17 Speaker 04 around the Sun hit Mars at least on the first time around. You can't sort of predict far enough in advance to guarantee it'll never hit, but hopefully the bugs will be dead by then. So that is, you know, this whole issue of, you know, protecting the environment of the other planets is certainly something that people give a lot of thought to. But there is, yeah, there's a bunch of junk orbiting the Sun. One of the things that I've been involved in is movement to try and regulate this better and at least get people to say what orbit they put their junk in so that we can find it later. Occasionally we've accidentally catalogued space junk as, oh, we discovered an asteroid. Whoops, never mind that asteroid is on an asteroid. It's a rocket stage. We would like you, please, if you launch something in the orbit around the sun,
53:02 Speaker 04 give us the orbital elements so that we can disambiguate it from asteroids. There's an asteroid mining company that's explicitly said it wants to launch this survey probe next year, and they're not going to tell us which asteroid it's going to because that's proprietary information.
53:17 Daniel Whiteson? Right.
53:18 Speaker 04 I think that's just not okay. If you're flying a light plane in the US, you have to file a flight plan. You should have to file a flight plan if you go to the asteroids. That's public interest information. And so the American National Economic Society has issued a statement saying that we think that interplanetary orbits, like we're like, the solar system's our area. And if you're going to be in it, we think you should publish your orbital data and not keep it secret. So we'll see if we can make that stick. But that's going to be an area of discussion in the years to come as more and more activity. You know, used to be that the deep space arena was just NASA, JPL, and the Soviets, right? And now it's all kinds of developing countries.
54:02 Speaker 04 The UAE has a Mars orbiter. India has moon landers and private companies like SpaceX are launching stuff to the moon and Mars. And so we really need to do a better job of keeping track of what's out there.
54:17 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah. And speaking of keeping track of what's out there, Josh's second question is right on point there.
54:22 Speaker 02 This is probably more speculative and harder to answer, but in the event of the existence of advanced extraterrestrial beings, what might they intuit about us if or when they do find the random fastener or rocket booster or humanoid poop? Would they be curious? Would they be bored? Would they be disappointed? We were so wasteful with the stuff we ejected into the space trashcan?
54:52 Speaker 04 Yeah, I think their attitude is going to be, well, glad those guys went extinct. They were really.
55:03 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, I'm hoping our cleanup methods really get much better in the coming decades.
55:07 Speaker 04 Yep, you and me both.
55:08 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, fingers crossed.
55:10 Daniel Whiteson? Have we had elements of space junk that we think have gone interstellar that have left the solar system, you know, basically the inverse version of Obilob's Omuamua?
55:19 Speaker 04 Yep, absolutely. There are a couple of pieces of the New Horizons probe, one of the rocket stages and a couple of, there are things called D-spin weights that are like, you have a spinning rocket stage, you want to slow it down, you unspool two weights on a wire, kind of like a yo-yo kind of thing, and then they float off and take the angular momentum with them. And so that's like another class of space junk. It's like little pieces of space junk that are just, okay, they're on their way out of the solar system.
55:50 Kelly Weinersmith? All right. So to wrap up, are you feeling optimistic about the future? Are we going to get those caps on satellites? What do you think?
55:56 Daniel Whiteson? Before we go extinct.
55:58 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah.
55:58 Speaker 04 I don't know, Kelly. I think that there is, you know, even in the companies, right? I don't want to paint them as unfeeling corporate, you know, money is a whole thing. They, they do care about space. And so I think there is interest in being responsible space citizens. And that, you know, gets balanced against all the pressures that are pushing them to be careless. And so I think it could go either way. It's the usual environmental thing. It will get bad enough that something will have to be done and then there'll be a scramble to try and fix it.
56:28 Kelly Weinersmith? I think that's a very realistic take on things. All right. Thank you so much for being here today, Jonathan. We had a lot of fun.
56:34 Speaker 04 Hi guys. Thank you for having me.
56:36 Kelly Weinersmith? Good luck tracking everything.
56:37 Speaker 04 Thank you.
56:39 Daniel Whiteson? And listeners, if you're planning to launch anything into orbit, please, please let Jonathan know.
56:51 Kelly Weinersmith? Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is produced by iHeartRadio. We would love to hear from you.
56:56 Daniel Whiteson? We really would. We want to know what questions you have about this extraordinary universe.
57:02 Kelly Weinersmith? We want to know your thoughts on recent shows, suggestions for future shows. If you contact us, we will get back to you.
57:09 Daniel Whiteson? We really mean it. We answer every message. Email us at questions@danielandkelly.org.
57:15 Kelly Weinersmith? Or you can find us on social media. We have accounts on X, Instagram, Blue Sky, and on all of those platforms, you can find us at D and K Universe.
57:24 Daniel Whiteson? Don't be shy. Write to us.
57:30 Daniel Whiteson? Wait.
57:31 Speaker 07 I came in for two things. How is this $47? All right, we're gonna need a plan here. Just start simple with Bank of America Advantage Safe Balance Banking. No overdraft item fees, no monthly maintenance fee if you're under 25. Oh, that's actually really simple. Safe Balance Banking, one less thing to figure out. Learn more at B of A dot com slash simple banking. Terms and conditions apply. Bank of America and a member FDIC.
57:59 Speaker 06 This is Stugatz from Stugatz and Company Live. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it all starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features NTEC. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you can get more at trade-in. Get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
58:37 Speaker 05 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A plus by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval. Morning, Carmen.
59:07 Daniel Whiteson? Hey, Carmen.
59:07 Speaker 05 Morning.
59:08 Daniel Whiteson? Quick question.
59:08 Speaker 05 Just one second.
59:09 Daniel Whiteson? Sorry. Carmen's worked at this office for 20 years. She knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with, well, everything.
59:16 Speaker 02 Hey, Carmen, what did Faye pitch in 2023? Who owns the Nordic account?
59:20 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, uh, where's the printer? But Carmen's revenue report is due in five minutes, so she shows them work IQ.
59:26 Speaker 05 Hey, co-pilot, who owns the Nordic account? And what did we pitch them in 2023?
59:32 Daniel Whiteson? Get the context you need with Microsoft. Work lives on.
59:37 Daniel Whiteson? Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:00:08 Daniel Whiteson? This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
Previous Who really wrote Maxwell's equations? Next Time travel fiction Page updated November 5, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated