Pod Insights Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe Listener Questions #17 About this episode Daniel and Kelly answer listener questions about screwworm at the southern border, life without the Moon, and the status of synthetic blood.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 12,362 words · 15 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Speaker 00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human. Running a small business takes everything you've got. But with Chase for Business, you're not alone. They bring together local support and a broad range of resources to more than 7 million customers. With a deep understanding of your day-to-day needs, they provide products and guidance built to help you thrive. Right now, earn $500 when you open a new Chase Business Complete Checking account for new business checking customers with qualifying activities. Offer expires January 21, 2027. Chase Business Complete Checking has the flexible tools you need to accept payments, make deposits, and manage your finances with confidence.
0:43 Speaker 00 Learn more at chase.com/podcastbizoffer. Chase: Make more of what's yours. Fees may apply to Chase Business Complete Checking accounts. The $500 offer is available for new business checking accounts with qualifying activities through January 21, 2027. Eligibility and qualification requirements must be met. Additional restrictions may apply. Please speak with a business banker for more information. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., Member FDIC.
1:20 Kelly Weinersmith? Screw worms have invaded beyond the Panama Canal. Will they infect Texas cows grazing amongst the chaparral?
1:28 Daniel Whiteson? How would life evolve without a moon? Would we have people, cats, and funky mushrooms?
1:34 Kelly Weinersmith? How long is the wait until synthetic blood goes on sale? I promise I'm not a vampire, I'm just a little pale.
1:41 Daniel Whiteson? Whatever question keeps you up at night, Daniel and Kelly's answer will make it all right.
1:46 Kelly Weinersmith? Welcome to another Listener Questions episode on Daniel and Kelly's extraordinary universe.
2:04 Daniel Whiteson? Hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist and I'm not a vegetarian, but I don't like to eat blood.
2:10 Kelly Weinersmith? Hello, I'm Kelly Weider-Smith. I study parasites and space. And I also am not a big fan of eating blood. What are those blood sausages or whatever that are popular in the UK?
2:20 Daniel Whiteson? No, thank you.
2:21 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, I can't do that. Or at least I've never tried. Maybe, maybe I'd like it, but I can't get myself to try it.
2:26 Daniel Whiteson? There is some line for me between like, normal muscle and like, the rest of the body and the blood and the brain and the guts and stuff. It just creeps me out. Though Katrina has a friend who's big into cooking organs, and she has a website, I think it's called Awful Recipes, O-F-F-A-L.
2:45 Kelly Weinersmith? I, you know, I feel like it's actually a deficit of my character that I'm not into eating more of the animal. Because I do feel like, yeah, that if you're going to take another animal's life, you really should make the most of it. But I just really have problems with the texture and stuff. So my solution has been to try to cut down on meat as much as I can.
3:05 Daniel Whiteson? No, I totally agree. It feels weird to just throw away parts of an animal because you're like, ew, icky. And when really, the whole thing is kind of icky if you think about it too much. Which we all should. We all should be thinking about it too much and feeling okay about our choices.
3:20 Kelly Weinersmith? That's right. Yes, we should think through our choices. It's so easy to be separated from the food that you eat and not think through the implications of what's happening there.
3:27 Daniel Whiteson? But nobody's gonna have an appetite after this episode anyway. Right, Kelly?
3:31 Kelly Weinersmith? I'm here to help. All right. So, let's jump right into question number one from John. This is a topic I've been wanting an excuse to dig into for a while. And so, let's hear what disgusting thing John wanted to know about. Well, friends, at this point in the episode, we thought we were going to drop an audio file where our friend John reads his questions. But sometimes, an audience member will send a question, and then they disappear. Maybe they've moved away, maybe they're busy. Hopefully they're well. We never got the audio file, so I'm gonna go ahead and read the question from John. Here we go. Please do a segment on the current situation at the south border concerning cattle and the reemergence of the parasitic fly and their
4:15 Kelly Weinersmith? maggot offspring known as screw worms. Is the current embargo something worth worrying about? Will it spread across the border regardless of what we do? Are there any human diseases related to the parasite? After eliminating them back 50, 60 years ago, how did it become a problem again catching us by surprise? Thanks.
4:38 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, man, Daniel. All right. Nobody.
4:43 Daniel Whiteson? Why were you so excited to get this question, Kelly?
4:46 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, because I had been hearing about screw worms for a while, but had never really dug in. And so they were on sort of like the periphery of my consciousness. And I was like, oh, great. Now there's a new parasite that I have an excuse to learn about. But I, what, how, what is a really good word for like, I'm begging? I beseech you? I beseech you do not look up pictures of screw worm or like what screw worm does to people. Because the photos.
5:14 Daniel Whiteson? Now I'm gonna have to.
5:14 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, God, it's really horrible. And if you do, we will go ahead and record some videos so that we can put your reaction up on Blue Sky and our Instagram accounts because it's really horrifying. So, so let me go into the life cycle before we do anything else. Okay.
5:30 Daniel Whiteson? Tell us what is this thing, basically? Because I know just because it's called a screw worm doesn't mean it's a worm.
5:35 Kelly Weinersmith? It's not a worm.
5:36 Daniel Whiteson? Because it's called a screw worm doesn't mean it screws anything. So what is it and, and how does it live?
5:40 Kelly Weinersmith? It is not a worm, but it does screw. So it is this, we're talking about the new world screw worm. There is another species in the quote unquote old world. And so the deal here is it's a fly. Mom lays her eggs around the edges of wounds or on mucus membranes. So like around your eyes or in your mouth and stuff.
6:02 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, no.
6:02 Kelly Weinersmith? I know. I know. Bad start, bad start. The eggs hatch and the larva, like the babies hatch out of the eggs and then they start screwing into the flesh to get into the flesh to eat it. And that's why they're called screw worms. I guess they sort of screw in the way a, a screw screws into wood.
6:19 Daniel Whiteson? Why do they screw? I mean, they can't just like chew their way in like any normal parasite?
6:23 Kelly Weinersmith? I mean, I guess they're doing both, but also a lot of parasites aren't like chewing their way through flesh. So for example, you know, hookworms have like hooked mouths and they sort of bite down, but they're not like kind of chewing their way through and migrating through the flesh. Whereas screw worms are migrating through the flesh, which is really truly horrible.
6:40 Daniel Whiteson? Why are they migrating through? Like, where is it they want to go? I happen to be between them and their destination.
6:45 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, no, they've consumed the flesh. They're done with it. They want more flesh. And so they're screwing in to get more of it. And so, you know, we talked in a previous episode about maggots that specifically ate dead tissue. And so they were useful for cleaning out wounds. But these flies are specifically eating the live tissue.
7:05 Daniel Whiteson? Wow.
7:05 Kelly Weinersmith? And they are not pleasant. So they screw in, they eat. When they're done eating, they fall out and off the host onto the ground.
7:14 Daniel Whiteson? All right.
7:15 Kelly Weinersmith? They do a stage called pupating. And then when they hatch, they emerge as adults who go off in search of more flesh to lay their, their eggs on.
7:26 Daniel Whiteson? How come nobody called these like zombie flies or something?
7:28 Kelly Weinersmith? Um, so we usually reserve the word zombie for instances where a host behavior is being sort of like manipulated in a way that benefits the parasite at the expense of the host.
7:42 Daniel Whiteson? I love this. They're like semi official rules in biology for what you can call a zombie?
7:47 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, no, no, there's a lot of fighting over this. There's, there are people who feel like you shouldn't be using the phrase zombie at all because you're just going to confuse the public. They're not coming back from the dead. I feel like the public gets that, like you need to give them a little bit more credit, but.
8:00 Daniel Whiteson? Are there similar rules for like werewolf or mummy?
8:03 Kelly Weinersmith? I don't think so. No.
8:06 Daniel Whiteson? No. All right. So it's a free for all, folks. If you discover something, feel free to call it a werewolf.
8:10 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, no, no, there are, there are aphid mummies. And so they essentially shells of their former self because parasites have like eaten their insides and stuff. And they're like pale relative to the others. I don't know too much about aphid mummies. Anyway, so to get back on track, I ended up watching a video lecture that veterans. Arenarians are supposed to watch to get like, you know, credit for the requirements for their field about screw worms. And they were like, sometimes it'll just be like a pinprick hole in an animal. Cause like, you know, dogs and stuff can get this too. And you just have to feel the hole and you feel the worms moving around inside. So it's not even that it's like a big, anyway, super gross.
8:50 Daniel Whiteson? So you can be walking around with like a sack of these worms inside you?
8:53 Kelly Weinersmith? You would know, but yes, the answer is yes. So females lay something like 200 to 300 eggs at a time and they can lay two to four batches in their lifetime. So you can pretty quickly, once you have an open wound, it attracts more screw flies or more screw worms. So if you're in an area where there's a lot of screw worms, you can pretty quickly build up a life threatening illness because they're just eating so much of you, or you can get secondary infections because now you have this growing wound that can, you know, acquire bacteria and you die that way. So it's truly awful.
9:26 Daniel Whiteson? And what do they usually eat? Is it mostly people or is it dogs? Or are they totally indiscriminate?
9:30 Kelly Weinersmith? Anything they can really get their hands on. So quite often they're going after livestock, or they can go after wildlife. Sometimes you find it in pets and occasionally you will find it in people.
9:41 Daniel Whiteson? And do they have the same preference for flesh as Kelly does? Like, do they prefer the muscle? Or would they eat, you know, organs and eyeballs and any sorts of things?
9:50 Kelly Weinersmith? So I don't preferentially eat wounds on animals. And they have a tendency also to go for mucous membranes and like genitalia and stuff like that. And so I would say they, they do not have similar preferences to Kelly.
10:05 Daniel Whiteson? I'm not trying to put you together in a category. I was just using you as an example.
10:09 Kelly Weinersmith? I'm feeling a little insulted, but I'm gonna, I really like parasites enough that I'm gonna rise above and decide that's a compliment. But, so this used to be in the United States, it was a huge problem. Like in 1935, 180,000 cattle died in Texas alone from this parasite. So you typically find it in South and Central America, and it was in North America for a while, tended to be in the southern states because that stage that lives off of the animals is cold sensitive. So if it freezes, that kills them, but they can come back during the summer. So you can still get them pretty far north, just depending on, on where they've managed to travel. But. This was such a big problem for agriculture that the United States said,
10:52 Kelly Weinersmith? all right, we absolutely need to do something about this.
10:55 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
10:55 Kelly Weinersmith? And so what they did was they developed in 1958, what's still called the sterile insect technique. And this is something I think you might enjoy. So essentially, they, they get the flies. Well, wait for it, wait for it.
11:09 Daniel Whiteson? I love hearing about sterility as a rule. So, yeah.
11:11 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, yeah. Well, I know that's a thing for you. I don't, I don't know. You, you started this path. I just took the next step.
11:19 Daniel Whiteson? All right, all right. Walk us through, what is a sterile insect technique?
11:22 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, so they take a stage of the flies and they expose them to radiation. And in particular, they're exposing them to low doses of cobalt. And this essentially sterilizes the male flies. And then they release loads of male flies out there. And the thing that you need to know about screw worms is that the females only mate once in their life, even though they're laying multiple clutches of eggs. So if a female mates with one of these irradiated males, the eggs that she lays will not hatch. And so by doing this, you essentially are like pulling females out of the population. Like they still exist, but they're not making any viable eggs.
12:03 Kelly Weinersmith? And so every generation, you put more sterile males out there. And over time, you can drop the population down to zero using this method.
12:13 Daniel Whiteson? Down to zero, really?
12:14 Kelly Weinersmith? Down to zero. So, so actually, we started doing this in 1958. And by 1966, the United States was free of new world screw worm.
12:22 Daniel Whiteson? How do you get down to zero? I understand that you can suppress the population because you have some males that are sterile. But as long as you have any males that are not sterile, won't you keep getting some more screw worms?
12:34 Kelly Weinersmith? They do this generation after generation after generation. And they swamp the population with these sterile males. And so they're literally like loading up airplanes and dropping airplanes full of these. No, no, no, no. This is how they distribute the screw worms. They drop airplanes full of these sterile insects.
12:51 Daniel Whiteson? If anything is going to inspire conspiracy theories about the government, then like dropping airplane loads of intentionally irradiated flies on the population. Wow.
13:00 Kelly Weinersmith? Flesh eating flies. Yeah, that's right.
13:02 Daniel Whiteson? Irradiated flies. Oh, my gosh. All right. But it's good for you, folks. Really, it's in your interest.
13:08 Kelly Weinersmith? Trust us, trust the scientists.
13:13 Daniel Whiteson? All right. So they did this and it worked amazingly. Yay, science.
13:18 Kelly Weinersmith? Mm hmm. But the problem was that screw worm was still present in Mexico. And so it kept getting across the southern border. And so this problem didn't go away. So we decided, okay, you know what? We're going to eradicate screw worm from Mexico as well.
13:32 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
13:32 Kelly Weinersmith? And so they started with the Mexican government's permission, this was a collaboration. They started dropping plain foals of sterile screw worms over Mexico. And by 1991, Mexico was free of screw worm.
13:45 Daniel Whiteson? Yay.
13:45 Kelly Weinersmith? Which is amazing. And so they ended up marching screw worm back farther and farther and farther until screw worm was only found on the southern side of the Panama Canal.
13:56 Daniel Whiteson? This seems like such good news, it must be ironic foreshadowing for some terrible twist you're about to drop on us.
14:02 Kelly Weinersmith? Um, I mean, this is, no, this is good news, full stop.
14:05 Daniel Whiteson? Okay.
14:05 Kelly Weinersmith? There were like decades where we were completely without screw worms. It's amazing. Like, go science.
14:10 Daniel Whiteson? Yep.
14:11 Kelly Weinersmith? And so Panama has this facility where they're constantly making these sterile insect males. And they're constantly dropping them in the Panama Canal region to try to make sure that screw worm doesn't make its way back up again, because it's still present south of the Panama Canal.
14:24 Daniel Whiteson? Why doesn't the South American governments do this as well? So we can eradicate this guy?
14:28 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, that's a great question. I don't know. I don't know if it's too expensive or what, but the countries that did eradicate it had American help and collaboration to sort of scale up to keep this going. But it's kind of amazing that it hasn't gotten passed because we move a lot of animals around, you know? And so like in 2000, a gelding, which is like a kind of horse, but I don't know much about horses because I hate horses, was imported.
14:54 Daniel Whiteson? Well, technically, it's a sterilized male horse.
14:57 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, thank you.
14:58 Daniel Whiteson? Sterilized surgically.
14:59 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, yeah. Not with radiation? Not with cobalt?
15:01 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, no, snip, snip.
15:03 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, got it, got it. So a snipped, snipped male horse was brought to Florida from South America. And as it was coming across the border, it was discovered that it had screw worm, and it went into quarantine, got treated, and so it didn't spread. Yay. In 2007, a dog from Trinidad was sent to Florida, and it had screw worm larvae, you know, snacking behind its eyes.
15:25 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, God.
15:25 Kelly Weinersmith? I know.
15:26 Daniel Whiteson? Poor dog.
15:26 Kelly Weinersmith? I know. And the dog made it to Mississippi. And so it could have been spreading it. But a veterinarian in Mississippi found them, reported it. It was controlled, it got treated, the dog lived, it didn't spread.
15:38 Daniel Whiteson? Amazing. But it feels like fingers in the dike.
15:40 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes, yeah, it does, right? So in 2016, there was an outbreak in the Florida Keys. We don't know how screw worm made it to the Florida Keys, but it got there and it ended up in the key deer population, which is an endangered subspecies of whitetail deer that you find in that area. And 135 of them died. That was about 10% of the population. It also infected dogs, pet pigs, cats, and a raccoon.
16:04 Daniel Whiteson? Oh.
16:05 Kelly Weinersmith? I know, super sad. But we put sterile males out, and we were able to get it under control again. So using that sterile insect technique, we wiped it back out again.
16:15 Daniel Whiteson? Wow, amazing.
16:16 Kelly Weinersmith? But this current outbreak, as I understand it, is the most concerning outbreak that's happened so far. So screw worm has managed to jump above the Panama Canal. I don't think we know how it happened. And it has been sort of creeping its way back up, heading into Mexico and getting close to the border. So Zach was just in Texas, visiting his family, and he said that they, there were like commercials about, you know, watch out for screw worm, check your animals, keep an eye out, because we really want to make sure this thing doesn't establish here.
16:47 Daniel Whiteson? Check your eyeballs.
16:48 Kelly Weinersmith? Check your eyeballs. Oh, gross. So it's been estimated that if it takes hold in the US, it could cost over one and a quarter billion dollars to eradicate it from the US if we had to deal with this again. It was recently announced that eight and a half million dollars is going to go to building another facility to raise sterile male insects in Texas. And then they're going to work with the Panama facility to try to wipe screw worm out between Panama and the US in the areas where it's taking hold. So they are putting a lot of energy and money into trying to tackle this.
17:20 Daniel Whiteson? Good.
17:20 Kelly Weinersmith? Cause it would be a big deal if it got across the border.
17:22 Daniel Whiteson? I really hope they tackle it before it gets to my house.
17:25 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes, absolutely. Well, you know, they probably don't want to go to California anyway, because it's like kind of a boring place. I'm more worried about Virginia, but.
17:33 Daniel Whiteson? They don't like mountains. They don't like oceans. They don't like beautiful weather. You're right. They should head to Virginia.
17:39 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, yeah. We've got much better wildlife here and I'm sure the wildlife is delicious. And so, you know, come to Virginia. This got weird. So.
17:51 Kelly Weinersmith? Virginia will change our motto from a Virginia is for lovers to Virginia is for screw worms. But anyway, so John wanted to know, should we worry about this problem?
18:02 Daniel Whiteson? I'm already worrying.
18:04 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes. Yeah. The answer is yes. We should worry and people are worrying and taking what seems to be appropriate measures to me. And are there any human diseases related to this parasite? I wasn't able to find any, so the parasite can infect and live in people and that's horrible. But I don't think it spreads any diseases as far as I was able to tell. And how did it manage to catch us by surprise? I would say it didn't catch us by surprise. Monitoring for this is pretty widespread. And we've been constantly sort of working to keep this below the southern border. I, to be honest, I am amazed and very proud of our efforts that it hasn't gotten above Panama more often. Like this, it's incredible that we've been able to control it to the extent that we have.
18:49 Kelly Weinersmith? So, you know, something just managed to move across the border that was infected by screw worm and we're on it again. This is probably, unless we completely remove screw worm from the face of the planet. This is something we're just always going to have to deal with happening from time to time would be my guess.
19:03 Daniel Whiteson? Well, let me take the other side of this. Let me be the screw worm advocate. You know, many things are unpleasant or eeky or gross, but then it turns out they serve some positive function in the ecosystem. If we remove screw worm from the earth, we just like delete all of them. Is there some beautiful critter that like eats screw worms? It's no longer going to be around?
19:24 Kelly Weinersmith? No, no. So I. I don't actually know the answer, but what I can tell you is that for decades, we have managed to eradicate screw worm from North America and most of Central America. And we haven't seen ecosystems collapse or something like that, you know? So it's possible that there is, that birds really liked eating screw worms and they have a little bit less food to eat.
19:46 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
19:47 Kelly Weinersmith? But I think this is one of those things where as a pro-human individual, I think that any ecosystem costs would be worth it because otherwise the, you know, the cost for our livestock and our pets and, and for, you know, endangered species like the key deer, it would be better to not have it around.
20:06 Daniel Whiteson? And then Kelly wouldn't have to think about gross pictures online as she eats her hamburger.
20:10 Kelly Weinersmith? My God, it was a horrible photo of like the head of a key deer that I won't, I'll stop. So John, thank you for this fascinating question and go science.
20:31 Speaker 03 Hey, it's Nile Rodgers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by my friend, John Legend. So you're helping Will.i.am write hooks. What made "Ordinary People" become the one song from those sound checks you knew you had to make your own?
20:58 Speaker 04 I was just writing for the Black Eyed Peas. I wasn't expecting to write something for myself in that session, but I wrote the hook for "Ordinary People" and I recorded a demo and I'm like, I would rather keep "Ordinary People" for myself. This station in Chicago, WGCI, they start playing it before we're promoting it. The song spoke for itself. It became the defining song for my first album. I knew it was special, but you never know how special it's going to be and how much impact it's going to have in people's lives. And you never believe that you're going to actually change people's lives with a song.
21:28 Speaker 03 Experience before the moment. The Lincoln Original Series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
21:37 Speaker 05 Cash Flow Crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds, up to $200,000, right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
22:07 Speaker 06 Hey, this is Mario Lopez from All Mario Lopez Daily Podcast. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla sedan with the latest features in tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops, while Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at traded. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
22:54 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay. Next up, we have a question from Robert from Richmond.
22:59 Daniel Whiteson? Thank you very much, Robert, for reaching out to me to ask this question. And remember to everybody out there, if you have a question about the way the universe works, something you want to understand, and you'd like Daniel and Kelly to break it down for you, please just write to us, to questions@danielandkelly.org. Don't ask ChatGPT. Don't read some nonsense online. Reach out to us. We really will set you right. All right, here's Robert from Richmond.
23:23 Speaker 07 This is Robert from Richmond, Virginia. I was wondering how life on Earth would have evolved differently, if at all, if we didn't have the moon. So we wouldn't have tides to mix the primordial soup. We wouldn't necessarily have as much of a tilted axis. Even nocturnal predators wouldn't have the light of the moon at night to hunt. The moon has been there for so long that it's kind of interesting to see how it would be different without it. But also, there are so many planets that have more than one moon. We're kind of unique in that way. How would life evolve differently with more moons?
24:06 Speaker 07 I know there's a lot to unpack there. I appreciate all the hard work. Keep it up. Look forward to hearing from you guys.
24:12 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, this is a great question, which is exactly what I would expect for a fellow citizen of Virginia.
24:20 Daniel Whiteson? Which is what a Virginian, is this a Richmond, Richmondian?
24:23 Kelly Weinersmith? Rich Mindian? Virginian. Richard is a Virginian. A fellow Virginian.
24:31 Daniel Whiteson? And Richard is doing something which I do all the time and which I love seeing in people, which is thinking about how the universe could be different. Why is it this way? And that's like, one of the big questions of science. That's why we do science, to understand, is the way our universe works an accident? Is it happened for a reason? Are those reasons important? Do they determine why we're here? All these things help unravel, like the context of our lives. So yeah, awesome, Robert. Thank you for thinking big. Or maybe Robert's just writing a science fiction novel and needs some help.
25:03 Kelly Weinersmith? And we're happy to do that, too.
25:04 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, no problem. No problem.
25:06 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah.
25:06 Daniel Whiteson? So this question has a lot of angles. You could think about whether life would have evolved if Earth never had a moon, or you could think about what would happen if we lost our moon. So I started with that one because it's sort of like a fun science fiction scenario, like, hey, we have a moon. Are we going to have it forever? Is it possible we could lose our moon? And the answer to that is yes. You know, people think about the solar system as sort of static and this slow moving parade of planets around the sun that's been happening forever. But that's not true. The solar system is kind of chaotic. It's just on longer time scales than we mostly think about. You know, the order of the planets we have today is not the same order of the planets we've had forever. Planets
25:47 Daniel Whiteson? have migrated in and then migrated out. There are theories that we had another gas giant, that when Jupiter and Saturn migrated to the inner solar system and then back out, one of these was tossed into outer space. So there might be like a lost sibling planet out there.
26:03 Kelly Weinersmith? I like to imagine the noise it made as it got flung out into space.
26:07 Daniel Whiteson? Why me?
26:12 Daniel Whiteson? Exactly. And maybe that planet had like the best climate in the whole solar system. Maybe the solar system lost its California in that interaction.
26:20 Kelly Weinersmith? That's fine.
26:20 Daniel Whiteson? Never know.
26:21 Kelly Weinersmith? That's fine.
26:22 Daniel Whiteson? And so in a similar way, we could lose our moon. You know, something could like hit the moon and deflect it and knock it out of orbit. In fact, right now, scientists are tracking a new interstellar comet. This is a piece of the universe that comes from another star, like a big chunk of rock and ice thrown out of another solar system that's passing through ours. And we don't think it's going to hit the earth or that close, but it's moving really, really fast. And if it did hit the earth, wow, that would be devastating. And if it hit the moon, it could certainly knock it out of orbit.
26:56 Kelly Weinersmith? You know, I remember when I heard that, my first thought was, oh, all right, hitting the moon, that would be like a bummer for a lot of reasons, but that would be better. And then I'm like, wait a minute, maybe that wouldn't be better, or it would be better, but like not much better.
27:08 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah. In fact, there's a great science fiction novel called Seven Eves, which starts out with some aliens basically destroying our moon. It's never really explained how it happens, but most of the book has to do with trying to survive the destruction of the moon, because if it turns into rubble and then starts falling to earth, then you're filling the atmosphere with this stuff. And you basically have a nuclear holocaust on earth. It's end of days kind of stuff. So we don't want our moon to be obliterated into dust, but it could also just be knocked out of our orbit. We could just lose it and it can go wandering into the solar system.
27:40 Kelly Weinersmith? No.
27:40 Daniel Whiteson? And so that lets us think about like, well, what would life be like on earth if we didn't explode the moon, if it just sort of like drifted away somehow? Well, the moon plays a big role in biological experience, right? Like, we know, for example, that the moon causes tides, right? High tide and low tide. This is because of gravitational tidal forces. That's why they're called tidal forces. And the physics here is really fun. And it sounds complicated because it's gravity and all that stuff, but it's pretty basic. You know, one side of the earth is closer to the moon than the other side of the earth. And so the moon's gravity pulls on the earth harder on the closer side than the further side. So it turns the earth into something like a football instead of a sphere. It's like squeezing the earth. And the water on the earth is the squishiest bit, and so it responds the most.
28:25 Daniel Whiteson? Most people don't realize, though, that all of the earth gets squeezed. There are these things called land tides that move the distance of the surface of the earth relative to the center by meters.
28:35 Kelly Weinersmith? What?
28:35 Daniel Whiteson? Yes, as the moon goes around the earth, it squeezes and massages the earth, changes its shape, not just the water, but the land also changes its shape.
28:44 Kelly Weinersmith? Lies.
28:47 Kelly Weinersmith? That's amazing.
28:49 Daniel Whiteson? Yes, these are lies propagated by flies that the government drops over California, infected with conspiracy theories.
28:57 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, you could be dropping worse things, probably.
29:00 Daniel Whiteson? Yes, and most people know about the moon's effect on water tides, but not so much about the moon's effect on the earth, right? And also, the sun gives us tides, right? Like, the sun is much further away, but it's also much more massive. So if you got rid of the moon, we would still have tides, right? Tides are a combination of the sun's tides and the moon's tides, which is one reason why tides are complicated. Like, if you look at a tidal chart, it's never like, it goes up, it goes down, it goes up, it goes down. It's a simple sinusoid. It's complicated. It goes up, it goes down, it comes up less, it goes down more. It's really complicated, and that's due to the sun and the moon and the shape of the inlets and stuff. Tides are really complicated. Isaac Newton started working on them hundreds of years ago, and it wasn't until like 100 years ago or so that we had a pretty solid understanding of the physics there.
29:45 Kelly Weinersmith? Tides made my PhD super confusing.
29:49 Kelly Weinersmith? Because I had, you know, I had to go out and collect snails when the tide was low, and I would always think like, oh, I remember when the tide was the other day, I'm going to extrapolate forward, and, you know, it was not as predictable as I wanted it to be.
30:01 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, I know, they're complicated.
30:03 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah.
30:04 Daniel Whiteson? And people think that this complexity might have really been important for the development of life. Like, number one, if you got rid of the tides, a lot of life by the seashore would be very confused, and a lot of assumptions they make and things they rely on would be thrown into chaos. So the conditions for life on earth would be drastically different, and some things would live and some things would not live. But also, historically, people imagine that tides played a role in the evolution of life, that when you're And the border between freshwater and saltwater, you have these brackish water systems. And it's there's a lot of like mixing up that happens. And you can imagine like water sloshing up into these tide pools and mixing this bit of biochemistry, but that bit of biochemistry, and maybe that's even plays a role in abiogenesis. A lot of this is very
30:48 Daniel Whiteson? speculative, right? Like, hmm, maybe this and this seems like a compelling story. None of it is the kind of science where we can like, let's do the experiment. Let's have an earth without a moon and an earth with moons. And let's see if life starts more often. It's just sort of more like a reasonable sounding story. And that doesn't make it like, non-scientific. It just means, hey, this is the most we can do right now. Sort of think about it clearly and try to imagine. So we don't know the answer to like, could life have evolved without a moon? Would life evolve differently without a moon? But there are strong arguments to make that it's certainly possible.
31:22 Kelly Weinersmith? So estuaries are ecosystems where freshwater meets saltwater. If you didn't have the moon, would estuaries narrow?
31:33 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, there'd be a narrower band there, right? Because it'd be less mixing, right? Because the moon brings the saltwater up further into the freshwater. Absolutely.
31:41 Kelly Weinersmith? Estuaries play an important role for ecological services, and they're economically important because they end up being places where baby crabs and baby fish that we like to eat start their lives. So anyway, let's keep the moon. There, I've decided.
31:55 Daniel Whiteson? The moon makes things yummy.
31:57 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, sure. Yeah, the moon makes yummy things.
31:59 Daniel Whiteson? And the moon also affects global weather in other ways, because it changes current patterns. You know, it helps stabilize climates by mixing up the air, like it's pulling on the air as well. So it's not just water, has all sorts of effects on the air and on the land. In addition, of course, the moon provides light at night, right? It's like essentially a huge mirror in space reflecting the sun down to earth. And so any critter that like takes advantage of a little bit of moonlight for hunting is going to be disadvantaged. This is another in the category of like, things would be different. We don't know exactly what that would mean, but we can sort of speculate intelligently. And it seems certain that it would dramatically change the conditions for life.
32:42 Kelly Weinersmith? Hmm. Would it be good for our favorite creatures, which are rats? Would it help them hide at night?
32:49 Daniel Whiteson? It would. It'd be good for rats that are out at night, especially because it would be bad for owls, right? Owls that do a lot of rat eating. But also, it would be good for astronomers, you know? Having a moon is really bad when you're on the ground with your telescope and you want to look at some star and then boom, you have this huge sun mirror shining into your eyeballs. It's a lot harder to have dark nights. So a lot of our dark nights are ruined by a moon. So, you know, maybe there's a conspiracy out there among astronomers to get rid of the moon.
33:18 Kelly Weinersmith? Hey, guys. Knock it off. Knock it off. We need the moon.
33:24 Daniel Whiteson? And there's even more dramatic effects that the moon plays on the earth. It's not just the tides, it's not just the air, it's not just the night, but the earth's rotation and tilt are strongly affected by the moon. Because the moon is pretty big, like especially for our moon, right? Lots of moons in the solar system are much smaller than our moon. But our moon is big enough that it carries a significant fraction of the angular energy of the earth-moon system. So people think that the earth's rotation itself is affected by having a moon, and that the tilt of the earth is sort of moderated by the moon. So like, if we didn't have a moon, earth tilt might be even crazier, might be much deeper.
34:02 Kelly Weinersmith? That would affect seasons.
34:03 Daniel Whiteson? It absolutely would affect seasons. Or it could also have no tilt, right? And we could end up with no seasons. And so, the earth's rotation and the earth tilt is a product of this balance between the earth and the moon. And there's another fun thing that's happening there, which is that as these two are sort of massaging each other, right, tidal, and they're using their angular momentum to massage each other, and it takes some energy to squeeze the earth into a football. As it does that, it's losing some of its angular momentum, and so the moon is actually getting further and further away from us every year. And not by like some tiny amount, like microns or something. It's happening by one centimeter per year.
34:41 Kelly Weinersmith? I mean, that's still a tiny amount. I thought you were gonna tell me like a mile a year or something, but you know, I'm still concerned because I'm Kelly and I'm concerned about everything, but like, but the centimeter doesn't sound like a lot. Convince me it's a lot.
34:56 Daniel Whiteson? Well, it's not a lot for a year, but if you have a lot of years, that's a lot of centimeters. Imagine what the moon might have looked like a million years ago or two million years ago, as our ancestors are walking across the plains. They had a bigger moon in their night than we did.
35:11 Kelly Weinersmith? Dinosaurs saw a bigger moon.
35:13 Daniel Whiteson? Yes.
35:14 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, that's kinda cool.
35:16 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
35:17 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
35:17 Daniel Whiteson? Dinosaur astronomers had an easier time understanding the surface of the moon because it was closer.
35:21 Kelly Weinersmith? Now I care. Did dinosaur entomologists drop sterile insects on Californians?
35:30 Daniel Whiteson? One of my favorite dinosaur stories is somebody who reconstructed the path of the asteroid that hit the Earth 65 million years ago. And at least one of the possible paths includes a close flyby before it actually hit. So that means that dinosaur astronomers had plenty of warning.
35:48 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, wow.
35:48 Daniel Whiteson? They could have seen this thing in the sky before it hit, like weeks beforehand and prepared. But man, they didn't fund astronomy enough. So there's a lesson, folks. Fund astronomy.
35:58 Kelly Weinersmith? That's right. Dinosaur NASA should have gotten a lot more money.
36:01 Daniel Whiteson? And on that note, you know, this interstellar comet is fascinating and it's not gonna hit the Earth, so nobody should worry. But you know, if it was pointed at the Earth, then we would have very little time to do anything about it, which means we should be getting ready to do something about it before we spot these things. So like, we really should be spending more time and energy on Earth protective services, if you ask me.
36:23 Kelly Weinersmith? So that's, that's two squares on your D K E U bingo card, if you're not keeping track. There's existential dread and more funding for science.
36:32 Daniel Whiteson? Especially because these things could be lobbed in our direction by aliens. So there's another bingo square for you.
36:39 Kelly Weinersmith? Yep, yep, yeah. Oh, sorry. We still got to hit on cannibalism and poop. We'll get there.
36:43 Daniel Whiteson? All right. So if we lost our moon, or if Earth never had a moon, we're looking at a very different situation for life. We know that life on Earth would change a lot, or may have not evolved, or could have evolved very differently. I don't have any reason to believe this, but my hunch is that if Earth didn't have a moon, we still might have gotten life. It just would be very different. You know, it's easy to say these conditions were required for life to turn out as we know it. Therefore, life wouldn't have evolved if you don't have those conditions. But I think it's also equally likely that life just would have been weirder and different. But the other side of Robert's question is not just losing our moon, but what about more moons? What if Earth had two moons or seven moons? What would that be like? And is that possible?
37:24 Daniel Whiteson? And yes, it is still possible at this fairly mature stage in the solar system to get more moons. We think this happened a lot with Jupiter and Saturn, for example. Some of their moons were formed as the planets formed, sort of leftover stuff that was too far out and moving too fast to fall into the planet, sort of the same way that planets didn't fall into the sun. And these moons tend to orbit in the plane of the solar system. But some of the moons have like wacky orbits, and this might be because they're captured. They're just something that came by and the gravity of Jupiter or Saturn grabbed onto it. And so the Earth could do that, too. You have some chunk of stuff from another solar system, or from somewhere else in the solar system comes by at the right angle and the right velocity, the Earth could grab it, and then we could get two moons.
38:07 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow.
38:08 Daniel Whiteson? And then we'd have even wackier tides.
38:11 Kelly Weinersmith? If you had to guess probabilistically, if something comes close to Earth.
38:15 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, zero.
38:16 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, yeah. Okay. So it would be more likely to smack into us and do damage than create another moon, right?
38:21 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, absolutely. Most likely, it hits us, or it totally misses us. But to get captured, you need to have exactly the right velocity and radius match, right? Like, you know, first your physics, you can do the orbital mechanics. At every radius from the Earth, you need a specific velocity in order to be in orbit. And so those things have to match, and the angle has to match. And so, yeah, it's unlikely. But, you know, obviously, it has happened. There definitely are moons that have been captured. So it could happen to us.
38:47 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow.
38:48 Daniel Whiteson? And so it would affect the tides. They would be even more complicated for grad students trying to plan their experiments.
38:53 Kelly Weinersmith? Trying to go get snails. Yeah.
38:56 Daniel Whiteson? It could affect the Earth's tilt and spin if it's a big thing, right? So it could have a real impact. And those two moons then would have complicated interactions. They could even like squeeze each other and induce like, you know, stuff going on inside those moons. You could end up with like a volcanic moon in the sky. That would be pretty awesome.
39:13 Kelly Weinersmith? Could we get a ring? Could they break each other apart and give us a ring?
39:16 Daniel Whiteson? Absolutely, yeah. The moon could destroy the other one or the other one could destroy the moon. We could end up with a ring. Could be really fascinating. So is this something you should worry about? It's pretty unlikely that we would lose our moon anytime in your lifetime or your children's lifetime or the next thousand years. If we lose the moon, it's pretty survivable. If the moon gets destroyed, then yeah, you'll be glad you built that bunker. But, you know, I think you have bigger things to worry about. I think you should be more worried about screw worm than moons.
39:46 Kelly Weinersmith? And science funding.
39:49 Daniel Whiteson? All right, well, thanks very much for that question, Robert. Let me know how your science fiction novel is turning out.
39:53 Speaker 07 Awesome. Thank you, guys. So basically, we don't know. And I kind of love when this happens because it's finding the edges of what we know and don't know, and it just shines a light on areas of future research, you know? Maybe if we figure out how the moon or moons might play a part in evolution, then that might help future SETI-type programs to search for exoplanets with, you know, only one moon. If we find that that's a critical part of, you know, life creation or focus on planets that have moons and ignore the ones that don't, whatever that case is. But I appreciate it. Thank you very much. And yay, go fund research.
40:45 Speaker 03 Hey, it's Niall Rogers, host of Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series. I'm driving across the country, meeting some of today's most fascinating artists. We're exploring the stories before the moment that changed everything. This week, I'm joined by rising star Sienna Spiro. Fascinating to you about impermanence.
41:07 Speaker 08 Everything about us, everything we do is temporary. And I just got terrified of that. You know, what we do with our time and how I feel like the way the world is today and how fast paced it is and how much we don't even acknowledge anything around us. How I felt temporary to the people around me and how that made me scared and how much I wanted to last and make an impact on people. And I guess to change the way I looked at things and to change myself and to change how I guess I approached everything in my life. It's important that things are impermanent because nothing would feel special. And enjoying, you know, learning to love with knowing it's not going to last.
41:41 Speaker 03 Experience before the moment. A Lincoln original series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
41:50 Speaker 09 Cash Flow Crunch. OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds, up to $200,000, right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
42:20 Speaker 10 Hey, what's up? This is Kelvin Washington from The Odd Couple with Rob Parker and Kelvin Washington. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on off-road-ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra. Two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks, combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shoptoyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
43:08 Daniel Whiteson? All right, we're back and we're answering questions from listeners and we're going back from physics into the gross world of biology.
43:15 Kelly Weinersmith? Yay.
43:16 Daniel Whiteson? So finish up that snack before you listen to the rest of this episode.
43:22 Kelly Weinersmith? Let's listen to a fantastic question from Anthony.
43:25 Speaker 11 Hello, Daniel and Kelly. I'm Anthony from Orlando, Florida. I enjoy your podcasts and learn a great deal from you both. Your recent conversation on prions was fascinating and scary. I believe there is a comment in that discussion on synthetic blood. What is the progress in developing synthetic blood for general use? Are we any closer to it being used? Would it be universal or type like regular blood? Again, thank you and love your podcasts.
43:53 Daniel Whiteson? All right, Kelly. So what is blood anyway?
43:56 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, so it's complicated. It's not, it depends, but it's complicated. So blood, depending on how you want to slice it, blood can be three or more things. So one of them is plasma. This is like the fluidy part of your blood. It's something like 55% of your blood.
44:15 Daniel Whiteson? I've never understood why do they call it plasma? Because to me, plasma is a gas that's been heated up until you get ions. Is there some similarity between physics plasma and blood plasma?
44:24 Kelly Weinersmith? Gosh, you know, if I had to put money on it, our plasma came first. So I don't know the answer, but you guys probably stole it from us.
44:37 Daniel Whiteson? Fair, fair.
44:38 Kelly Weinersmith? All right. So this, it carries stuff around like electrolytes and hormones and antibodies made by your immune system. And it's the bulk of blood, like 55% of blood. It also carries around stuff that helps with coagulation. So like when you get a cut and your cut sort of clots up and makes a scab. And then about 44% is red blood cells. And inside of the red blood cells is hemoglobin, and hemoglobin is what carries oxygen to different parts of your body. And then the last part is platelets, and these are like little parts of cells that are really important for coagulation and clotting up wounds.
45:21 Daniel Whiteson? So as somebody who's naive about biology, I always imagined the blood is like, you know, it's the circulatory system. It's like the highway for the body. Everything that needs to go from one place to another gets dumped into the blood and then somebody else pulls it out.
45:33 Kelly Weinersmith? Yep.
45:33 Daniel Whiteson? And so we're talking about water, electrolytes, antibodies, red blood cells, platelets, all this stuff is just flowing through the blood and useful to some bits of the body. Is that fair?
45:41 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes, your blood vessels are the highway system moving the blood around.
45:45 Daniel Whiteson? So then why do we have different types of blood? What makes blood A or B or O or whatever?
45:49 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, right. So we've known about this for a while. So I'm just going to quick back up into history. So for a while we were like infusing blood from dogs into people or blood from lambs into people. Actually, I think it was mostly lambs and it was, there was a bit of a religious, like lambs are sort of innocent, lamb of God sort of thing. And so that's the right kind of animal to be putting into our bodies. And so for a while lamb blood was going into people. But we, we learned that not only is it bad to put blood from other animals into humans, it can also be bad to switch blood from one human to another. And Austrian physician Carl Landsteiner in 1900 started mixing up different blood from different people.
46:31 Kelly Weinersmith? And he was like, well, sometimes when you mix blood together, it coagulates and sometimes it doesn't. And it's always the same if you take blood from.
46:39 Daniel Whiteson? He wasn't doing these experiments in people. He was like doing this in the lab.
46:42 Kelly Weinersmith? As I understand it, he was extracting blood from people in his lab. And he was like, you know, if you extract blood from person A and person B, every time you do that and mix the bloods together, it clots. But person A and person C's blood, every time you do it, doesn't clot when you put them together. So what the heck is going on there? And he eventually gets the Nobel Prize in Physiology and Medicine for sort of figuring this out. And the answer is that blood have like proteins that are like sticking out on the cells. And some people have different kinds of proteins than others. And if two people have different proteins on their blood cells, then your immune system will recognize it as foreign and attack it.
47:20 Daniel Whiteson? And that's where the clots are? And the clots are like the immune system clumping it up?
47:23 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes, exactly. Yeah. And so, but so you asked, why do we have different blood types?
47:28 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
47:28 Kelly Weinersmith? And the answer, we do not know.
47:31 Daniel Whiteson? Oh.
47:31 Kelly Weinersmith? And so for a while, it was popular to postulate that it had something to do with like our ancestry and where we came from, like type A blood is maybe, you know, like hunter gatherers. And so those people actually should be eating more of like a hunter gatherer diet because their blood is like, that's what it evolved for. But the answer is that blood types show up in primates before humans.
47:53 Daniel Whiteson? Wow.
47:54 Kelly Weinersmith? So, you know, chimpanzees have blood types and we, we don't really understand. It could have something to do with differences in immune functioning. So, you know, maybe people with type A blood might be more susceptible to some virus that's swept through the population and type B blood would be less susceptible. And this variability popped up at some point and then was retained because it helped some parts of the population avoid diseases. But the answer is we really don't know, but it happened before humans came around.
48:23 Daniel Whiteson? All right. So then it can't be explained by, for example, irradiated flesh eating flies distributed on the population by the government.
48:29 Kelly Weinersmith? Guys, those flies that are irradiated, it's a good thing. It's a good thing. The science is helping us. You Californians are always jumping to conspiracy theories.
48:38 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, it's just so fun. It's just so easy. Now, now I see why they do it.
48:46 Kelly Weinersmith? It feels good, doesn't it?
48:47 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah. You don't need evidence. It just need a compelling story.
48:50 Kelly Weinersmith? That's right.
48:51 Daniel Whiteson? All right. So we have all these things inside the blood. So why do we think about synthetic blood? Why do people work on making fake blood?
48:59 Kelly Weinersmith? So right now, what we do is we get blood from donors.
49:01 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
49:02 Kelly Weinersmith? And that's great. And when you donate blood, often what happens is your blood is sort of separated out into different parts, the red blood cells, the plasma, the platelets, and they can go to different people depending on their need.
49:12 Daniel Whiteson? Oh.
49:13 Kelly Weinersmith? A major need for blood, though, is trauma. So you know, for example, if you get into a car accident and you lose a lot of blood when you get to the ER or when you get into the ambulance, they might want to try to increase the amount of blood that you have. And so donated blood gets used for that purpose. And then another important use for blood is in wartime. And here it's particularly hard to transport blood from blood banks back home because blood has a shelf life. So red blood cells are good for, you know, a bit more than a month, month and a half, depending on like where you are and what their rules are. I think platelets are good for something like a week. And so this stuff isn't good indefinitely. And it takes a long time to get it from a bank to overseas. For example, if you're talking
49:58 Kelly Weinersmith? about a war situation. And so having synthetic blood would be great, not only for these situations where, you know, it's hard to get the blood to where it needs to go, but also every once in a while, we have shortages. So for example, the Red Cross has declared blood shortages at different times. And so if you can't get enough blood from people, it would be nice to have synthetic blood. And the purpose of synthetic blood is really just to hold you over until your body can start making your own.
50:26 Daniel Whiteson? Wouldn't it also be nice to have synthetic blood? Because then you could prevent like the spread of bloodborne diseases, right?
50:31 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah. So I mean, that's worth considering. But at this point, we have a lot of complicated screening procedures to find out if blood is carrying infections. And I believe that we extract out, for example, white blood cells before you give people blood, because white blood cells, you know, could be carrying things like HIV. And so the probability that you pick up a disease from a transfusion in the United States, in the UK, is very low. It might be higher in other parts of the world, but we're very careful about screening it here.
51:00 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah. And so how do the various human blood types connect to this question of like making synthetic blood? Where we have to make several different synthetic blood types?
51:08 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, so that's the great thing about synthetic blood is hopefully you don't have to worry about typing anymore, because you can make synthetic blood that doesn't have those sort of proteins sticking on the outside that are going to attract the attention of the immune system. And so it would be helpful, for example, like, you know, imagine there's an accident and somebody whose blood type you don't know is going to need a bunch of blood. You, I guess you need to take all of the different kinds of blood with you. And then you need to take the time to get a small sample of blood from the trauma patients to figure out what kind of blood they have. Or at least you need to make sure you've got enough of the universal donor's blood, which is type O, to bring with you. So it would be much less complicated if you didn't have to worry about blood typing at all. And you could just universally have a synthetic blood that you could bring with you that
51:53 Kelly Weinersmith? was more shelf stable. This would solve a lot of problems. So most of the research so far has been done on making synthetic red blood cells. So this is again, about 45% of what blood is made of. And initially, what they were doing was they just got hemoglobin, which is the part that binds to the oxygen. And they were putting hemoglobin in people. They were like, well, the important thing is the oxygen transport in an emergency to keep everything going.
52:19 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
52:20 Kelly Weinersmith? But hemoglobin interacts with other kinds of oxygen in the body. So nitric oxide is used by our blood vessels to control vasodilation and vasoconstriction. So essentially to control how open or closed your blood vessels are. And so just putting hemoglobin in meant that the hemoglobin could interact with the nitric oxide and could tinker with
52:42 Daniel Whiteson? Ooh.
52:42 Kelly Weinersmith? vasodilation.
52:44 Daniel Whiteson? That sounds bad.
52:44 Kelly Weinersmith? Or at least that was what was claimed by a meta-analysis that sort of changed the way the whole field felt about these things. And so, for example, there's a product called HemoPure, which was developed in the 90s. And it's essentially a cow hemoglobin, which has been purified. And now it's only used in compassionate use cases, like you absolutely need it to try to save someone's life, but there's some concern about it messing with vasodilation. But some doctors still use it. And in fact, there are doctors who argue that like, look, this isn't actually a massive problem because people are only using this for like a day or two before their body can start making enough red blood cells to replace them. This isn't a real long-term problem. We're overreacting.
53:27 Kelly Weinersmith? But the field has essentially decided that this pure hemoglobin route is not the best way to go. So what do you do? So there's a new company called Erythromere and they're making a red blood cell analog. So essentially what they do is they get hemoglobin. In this case, they are extracting hemoglobin from blood that has been donated, but is now past its shelf life. So if that blood doesn't get given to someone in time, they take it. They remove the red blood cell outer part. They extract the hemoglobin and then they put the hemoglobin in a lipid layer that they have made. So they essentially like enclose it in a tiny fatty capsule.
54:10 Kelly Weinersmith? It's smaller than a usual red blood cell, but it keeps the hemoglobin from interacting with the nitric oxide and messing with the vasodilation stuff. And this is actually a really clever molecule. So it's pH sensitive, which is important. So when it goes to the lungs and you have high pH, it allows oxygen to bind to the hemoglobin. And then when you get to the parts of your body that are in need of oxygen, that ends up being a low pH environment. And the hemoglobin can like let go of the oxygen and the oxygen can go oxygenate your other cells like it needs to, which is like kind of fascinating to me. Like what a cool thing to have been able to figure out.
54:50 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
54:50 Kelly Weinersmith? And it's universal, so there's no compatibility problems. You don't have to type a patient beforehand. It's a freeze dried powder. And so you mix it with saline. So you essentially get this like plastic bag that with the divider in the center and you've got the like freeze dried erythromere on one side and saline on the other side, which is like salt water. That's the same sort of saltiness as our blood. And then you like break the divider between them. You mix the whole bag up and now you've got red blood cells or you know, synthetic red blood cells that you're ready to give to a patient. And they're thinking this could be shelf stable for up to two years.
55:26 Daniel Whiteson? And they've like tried this, it works, it like actually carries the oxygen in the way that you need.
55:30 Kelly Weinersmith? They have done experiments on animals and it seems to be doing well in the animals. And it seems like their lipid case for the hemoglobin gets, you know, processed by the digestive system, the way you would expect it to, and you sort of pee it out when you're done with it. And so the animal studies so far have been promising and a lead guy on the project is Dr. Doctor. And so I feel like we have to trust that this is being done well.
55:59 Daniel Whiteson? Like his last name is Doctor and he has the title of Doctor?
56:02 Kelly Weinersmith? That's exactly right. Yes.
56:04 Daniel Whiteson? And if he was at a German university, he could be like, Dr. Professor, Dr. Doctor.
56:08 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, I, yes. Amazing. We should move him to Germany.
56:12 Daniel Whiteson? So I'm really surprised that you can replace red blood cells with something so simple. Like, aren't red blood cells complicated? Aren't they doing something else? Is there anything else that red blood cells are doing that we're not capturing with just hemoglobin in a fatty drop?
56:26 Kelly Weinersmith? Probably, but you really just need to keep someone alive for like, again, for the time that it makes for their bone marrow to make their own red blood cells. And so this is definitely just a short-term solution to keep your heart kicking so that you have time to, you know, do the recovery on your own.
56:42 Daniel Whiteson? This seems kind of amazing. Is this something you think we're going to see in hospitals and trauma centers?
56:47 Kelly Weinersmith? I think they're going to be starting experiments in humans in the not-too-distant future. So it's possible we'll see this, but, but this is really hard because like, who do you decide to give it to first? It's going to be tough to design the human trials because we know that red blood cells donated from a human work. And so figuring out the first person who you're going to be like, oh no, you're in it. This is a trauma situation. You might die, but we're going to give you this experimental thing, even though we could give you this other thing that we know would work. Uh, you know, that's a little bit difficult. And so I'm sure they're going to have a little bit of trouble designing and finding the right population to, to try this on.
57:21 Daniel Whiteson? You can imagine the compassionate use. You could give this to trauma centers and then when they are in a situation where they just don't have blood and somebody's going to die, they're like, all right, well, let's dip into the fake stuff.
57:31 Kelly Weinersmith? Yes, absolutely. Yep. Or, or you could send it to folks who are out at the front lines in a war and they might not be able to blood type someone or something like that. So they, they can't tell and they might not be able to get blood donations. And so you, yes, you absolutely can't imagine situations where having this on hand as a backup. Could get you the data that you need.
57:52 Daniel Whiteson? All right. And what about the rest of the blood? What about synthetic platelets?
57:56 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah. So Dr. Ashley Brown's lab at North Carolina State University has a platelet-like particle that is in animal testing right now. And the animal tests have gone pretty well. So essentially what they did was they've got this like very tiny nanoparticle that they made. And it's like a tiny microgel. So it's sort of soft and squishy. And they've attached to it a protein that binds with this thing called fibrin. So when your body starts to make a clot, fibrin is a protein that's used to sort of get that clot sticking together. And so essentially, your body starts dealing with the wound. And then you're putting this stuff in there, which is going to bind with the fibrin that's already in the clot, and it's going to move the clotting process along more quickly. So it essentially finds where
58:41 Kelly Weinersmith? clots are forming by having this antibody that binds with something you find in clots. Or at least that's my understanding. And so they did it in mice and pigs, and things went well. They said that they might be a few years before human trials, and there's things that they want to do, like get clumping to to work a little bit better. And this is definitely not like, oh, hey, we have created platelets again, and everything that platelets do, we're able to do with this synthetic product. But it could be a really good measure for like, again, you know, there's a trauma situation, you just got to get somebody to the point where their body can recover and take over this work on its own. And so anyway, so the the take home, Anthony wanted to know, how close are we?
59:23 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
59:24 Kelly Weinersmith? And the answer is that we've got synthetic blood components that are being tested in non-human animals, and the current designs would be universal if they work out. But we're mostly in the trial phase. And so we're still relying on blood from human donors more than anything else. There are some other products on the market that we didn't talk about, but sort of in general, at the moment, we are mostly relying on human donors. And I'm sorry for all the vampires out there. We still have some work left to do. True Blood is not ready yet.
59:55 Daniel Whiteson? I'm so glad you made a vampire joke, because I feel bad. I fell down on the opportunity to make a werewolf joke in the moon question. You know, I know. So.
1:00:03 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, my gosh, Daniel, we could have had zombies and werewolves. And you know what? Let's let's start recording again. We're gonna do this again.
1:00:13 Daniel Whiteson? All right. Well, that's exciting. And I'm also sort of surprised you're sort of like optimistic and upbeat about this. This seems like great news.
1:00:21 Daniel Whiteson? Have you spent some time in California recently? What's going on?
1:00:24 Kelly Weinersmith? No, I'm surprised too. You know, I didn't get enough sleep and you know, the so all right, here, let's go ahead and we'll, we'll do the Kelly treatment.
1:00:31 Daniel Whiteson? All right.
1:00:32 Kelly Weinersmith? It should be worth noting that we have tried things in the past that have not stuck. So for example, you know, that the straight up hemoglobin without a like lipid layer, you know, was tried and we ended up deciding this is not really the solution for us. So it's possible that will happen with these other things that we talked about today, too. So there's the Kelly treatment.
1:00:51 Daniel Whiteson? All right. A little bit of cold water, but yeah, on the whole, this seems very promising.
1:00:55 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, it does. It does. And so I am really looking forward to when the vampires can come out of hiding and we can start dating them.
1:01:05 Daniel Whiteson? Yay, science.
1:01:06 Kelly Weinersmith? That's right. That's right.
1:01:09 Daniel Whiteson? All right. Well, let's see what Anthony thinks about our answer on synthetic blood.
1:01:14 Speaker 11 Daniel and Kelly, as usual, you guys knocked it out the park. I appreciate your answers. I learned a great deal. I was particularly interested in this because I have relatives whose religious convictions would prevent them from accepting blood transfusions. Perhaps as this science develops, they'll have another choice or an alternate decision that can save their lives possibly. I appreciate your answers. Love your podcast. Thank you.
1:01:40 Daniel Whiteson? Okay. Thank you, everybody, for these wonderful questions. We love hearing from you. Please do write to us to questions@danielandkelly.org. We say we will write back to everybody and we really, really mean it. We want to hear from you so that you can hear from us.
1:01:52 Kelly Weinersmith? We look forward to hearing from you. Have a good one.
1:02:01 Kelly Weinersmith? Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is produced by iHeartRadio. We would love to hear from you.
1:02:06 Daniel Whiteson? We really would. We want to know what questions you have about this extraordinary universe.
1:02:13 Kelly Weinersmith? We want to know your thoughts on recent shows, suggestions for future shows. If you contact us, we will get back to you.
1:02:19 Daniel Whiteson? We really mean it. We answer every message. Email us at questions@danielandkelly.org.
1:02:26 Kelly Weinersmith? Or you can find us on social media. We have accounts on X, Instagram, Blue Sky, and on all of those platforms, you can find us at D and K Universe.
1:02:35 Daniel Whiteson? Don't be shy. Write to us.
1:02:39 Speaker 12 With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans, develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a prioritized schedule, so you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at ChatGPT.com.
1:03:07 Speaker 13 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
1:03:34 Speaker 06 I'm Mario Lopez from AllMarioLopezDailyPodcast. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability, and it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features in tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops, while Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at traded. So get a great deal today and great value tomorrow. ShopToyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
1:04:11 Speaker 14 Sponsored by GSK, the makers of Extenture, Depamocumab ULAA. If your asthma keeps interrupting, it may be time to try something else. Extenture is an ultra-long-acting prescription maintenance treatment for severe asthma, eosinophilic type, ages 12 and older. It isn't for sudden breathing problems. Extenture is the first and only add-on treatment that can help deliver protection from asthma attacks with two doses a year. Just one dose every six months. That's a lot of time for everything in between. Serious allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, tongue, or trouble breathing. Don't change or stop medicines, including steroids, unless told by your doctor. Report if you have a parasitic infection, common cold, sinus infection, inflammation
1:04:56 Speaker 14 in the nose, flu or flulike symptoms, joint pain, or sore throat may occur. Carry on with fewer attacks and ask your doctor about Extensure. Learn more at Extensure.com or call 1-833-393-3678. This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
Previous Why do we sleep and dream? (featuring Dr. Gina Poe) Next Phage therapy (featuring Dr. Katrine Whiteson) Page updated November 1, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated