Pod Insights Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe Do we live in a super bubble? About this episode Daniel and Kelly explore the structure of the space between solar systems and reveal our cosmic context.
See omnystudio.com/listener https://omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript 9,617 words · 19 speakers
Speaker names marked ? are inferred from speaking time and the show’s known hosts — they are not voice-verified.
0:00 Daniel Whiteson? This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
0:04 Speaker 01 Cash flow crunch? OnDeck's small business line of credit gives your business immediate access to funds, up to $200,000, right when you need it. Cover seasonal dips, manage payroll, restock inventory, or tackle unexpected expenses without missing a beat. With flexible draws, transparent pricing, and control over repayment, get funded quickly and confidently. Apply today at ondeck.com. Funds could be available as soon as tomorrow. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
0:35 Speaker 02 Granger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation. Too much inventory? Costs climb. Too little? Production slows. Granger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need, when you need it, so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRANGER, click Granger.com, or just stop by. Granger, for the ones who get it done.
1:05 Speaker 03 Hey folks, it's Matt Altmaix.
1:06 Speaker 04 And Joel Larsgaard from the How To Money Podcast.
1:09 Speaker 03 If you travel for work like I do, you know that every trip is an opportunity to get more from the miles that you are already earning. Whether you are heading to your next client meeting or catching a flight home, those miles can go a long way.
1:22 Speaker 04 And for a limited time, new Delta SkyMiles Business Card members can earn 200,000 bonus miles, the highest miles offer this year, with a Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business American Express Card. Apply today at delta.com/podcast. Offer ends November 4th. Minimum spending requirements and terms apply.
1:53 Speaker 05 And for adults with type 2 diabetes and known heart disease, Jardiance can lower the risk of cardiovascular death, too. Prescription Jardiance, Empigliflozin 10 or 25-milligram tablets, are used to lower blood sugar along with diet and exercise in adults with type 2 diabetes. Jardiance is not for use to lower blood sugar in people with type 1 diabetes, and not for people with type 2 diabetes who have severe kidney disease. Serious side effects include increased ketones in blood or urine, and infection in the area between and around the anus and genitals called the perineum. Both may be fatal. Severe allergic reactions, dehydration, urinary tract or genital yeast infections in men and women, and low blood sugar. Stop taking and tell your doctor right away if you have nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, tiredness, rash, swelling, trouble breathing, or swallowing. Tell your doctor about lightheadedness,
2:37 Speaker 05 weakness, fever, pain, tenderness, redness, or swelling in the perineum. You may have increased risk for lower limb loss. Call your doctor right away if you have new pain or tenderness, sores, ulcers, or infection in your legs or feet. To learn more about Jardiance's 10- or 25-milligram tablets, ask your doctor, visit jardiance.com, or call 1-888-968-6648.
3:09 Daniel Whiteson? Think about where you are right now. Maybe you're in your car commuting, or you're out walking the dogs, or at home doing the dishes. But where are you relative to everyone else? How do you define it? Probably you zoom out and put yourself in a wider context, your town, your region, your whole country. Listeners to this pod will likely be inclined to zoom out even further, to all of Earth, and then the whole solar system. From there, it's very tempting to skip forward and put our solar system into its place in the galaxy, then the galaxy into its cluster, and then that cluster within the supercluster foam.
3:50 Daniel Whiteson? But have we been too hasty? Is our galaxy so simple, just a collection of stars floating around a central black hole? Or is there more nuance to our galactic context? We think of the galaxies mostly stars, but they're formed, they burn and they die. There's a constant sloshing of energy back and forth between those stars and vast clouds of raw material. Where is our solar system relative to those clouds? Are we in the midst of a galactic fog? Or are we floating through an open bubble? Today on the pod, we'll zoom out to this fascinating scene, understand the dynamics of star formation and destruction, and let you know exactly where you, we, all of us,
4:33 Daniel Whiteson? stand, galactically speaking. Welcome to Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Galaxy.
4:52 Kelly Weinersmith? Hello, I'm Kelly Wiener-Smith. I study parasites and space, and I love bubbles.
5:06 Daniel Whiteson? Well, hi, I'm Daniel. I'm a particle physicist. I love bubbles and I have all of my organs.
5:12 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, yeah, right. So that's, I was gonna ask you about the most painful thing you ever experienced in your life as a lead into why my laugh is going to be a little off today.
5:24 Daniel Whiteson? Folks, I'm going to try to restrain myself from being funny today because if I make a joke that makes Kelly crack up, she could literally crack up.
5:33 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, I could, yes, I could split a stitch. So, so what, aside from labor, the most painful thing that ever happens to me was the gallstones that tried to pass their way out of my body on Friday, but ended up getting removed surgically. The whole thing, the whole gallbladder was removed. And so I am still working on resolving my stitches. And so it hurts to laugh. So I think I've come up with a way to laugh that hurts less. And so my, my laugh will sound a little, I don't know, maybe even less annoying. I have seen, there's a couple complaints about the way I laugh. Y'all can just kiss my rear ends. But anyway, Daniel, what is the most painful thing that's ever happened to you?
6:15 Daniel Whiteson? Ooh, most painful thing that's ever happened to me. I've broken my wrist, but weirdly that didn't hurt that much. I think maybe the most painful thing is when I broke my little toe. I like massively stubbed it on a little concrete outpost and cracked it. And wow, yeah, I thought I was gonna die.
6:35 Kelly Weinersmith? Ouch. Yeah. How long did it take to heal? What do you do? Just put like a?
6:38 Daniel Whiteson? Nothing. You just tape it to the next toe and like whatever happens inside of it happens. Like, there's no surgery to correct like the little bones inside your little toe. Nobody needs it. I was like, just cut that bugger off. But I was like, no, you just tape it to the next one. That's it.
6:56 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, you know, Daniel, it sounds like if you lived in a bubble, you would have been safe. But if I lived in a bubble, that wouldn't have saved me. And so, well, you know, maybe if the whole universe was in a bubble, that would save us from some of the bumps and bruises of existence. But do we live in a bubble, Daniel?
7:15 Daniel Whiteson? Well, we are trying to pop the bubble of ignorance out there and help everybody understand their cosmic context, where we are situated in our solar system, where our solar system is situated in the galaxy, and the whole context for our existence. I love filling in all those details and helping people understand really where they live. And today, we're gonna dive into that topic, essentially where our sun is in the galaxy. Is there structure out there? How does it all work?
7:41 Kelly Weinersmith? And I think all of our inner kids are excited today to find out whether or not we live in a super bubble.
7:49 Daniel Whiteson? So before we dive into it, I was wondering what people out there knew on the topic. So I went to our group of volunteers and I asked them, do we live in a super bubble? Here's what folks had to say.
8:01 Speaker 07 Well, I don't even really know what a super bubble is. So maybe? What do you think, Glenn?
8:07 Speaker 08 I have no idea what a super bubble is.
8:09 Speaker 09 I have not heard the term super bubble. It makes me think about some conceptualizations of fourth dimensionality.
8:16 Speaker 08 Considering I couldn't tell you what a super bubble is, I can't really say if we live in one, but it sounds like one of these really exciting astrophysical, maybe who knows, cool universe things. So I'm eager to learn about it. I have never heard of the term super bubble, but we probably live in one.
8:37 Kelly Weinersmith? I like the, I've never heard of it, so yes.
8:42 Daniel Whiteson? This is really exciting to me that nobody had heard of it because it means we get to share this really cool thing about the universe with everybody. Yay.
8:50 Kelly Weinersmith? We love doing that.
8:52 Daniel Whiteson? You know that great X K C D comic? I mean, they're all great, but the one about the moment you discover somebody doesn't know something really cool about the universe and how you should treat that with reverence and respect because it's a wonderful teaching moment. That's where we are today about Super Bubbles.
9:07 Kelly Weinersmith? Yeah, I mean, I think we can all agree that Randall Monroe is the greatest web cartoonist to have ever lived, right?
9:12 Daniel Whiteson? Wow.
9:13 Kelly Weinersmith? Ow, it hurts. Ah, no, I'm getting punished in the moment.
9:17 Daniel Whiteson? That's instant karma right there.
9:20 Kelly Weinersmith? Ouch.
9:27 Daniel Whiteson? I hope Zach is listening and laughing at that.
9:33 Kelly Weinersmith? All right, all right, bubbles.
9:34 Daniel Whiteson? All right, bubbles. So we're talking about the sun and the solar system's context in the galaxy. But before we get there, let's do like an overview of like, what's out there in space? How empty is it anyway? So to get oriented, remember that our situation here on Earth is very unusual. Like, the density of stuff around you is very rare in the universe. The universe is mostly very, very low density, and we live in a very, very high-density situation. The Earth, of course, is wonderful and cozy. And in like a normal atmosphere, you'll find a huge number of molecules per cubic meter, like 10 to the 25 molecules per cubic meter. It's a big number. And that's just because like Avogadro's number is pretty big and
10:16 Daniel Whiteson? gravity has gathered the Earth and the stars and all that stuff together into little dense clumps.
10:22 Kelly Weinersmith? I thought Avogadro's number was 10 to the 23.
10:24 Daniel Whiteson? It is. Yeah, exactly.
10:26 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, but this is 10 to the 25th.
10:28 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, because a mole is less than a cubic meter.
10:30 Kelly Weinersmith? Got it. Got it. I'm with you now. Okay, these are big numbers, Daniel. Big numbers.
10:34 Daniel Whiteson? These are big numbers and you know, sometimes on Earth, we want to do experiments in low density situations. Like when we collide particles together, we don't want a whole bunch of other particles around. Or when you build a plasma inside eater to do fusion, you want mostly a vacuum before you start. And so we have all these vacuums in labs. We've created these situations. You pump out all the air. And you might be surprised to learn that even in those highly specialized vacuums on Earth, we still have something like 10 to the 12 or 10 to the 15 molecules per cubic meter. Like that's down 10 or 13 orders of magnitude from your general atmosphere. So like really good work. This is not easy, but still it's a lot of molecules.
11:17 Kelly Weinersmith? When somebody says the vacuum of space, are we doing better than the vacuum of space? When we make a vacuum in the lab, or are we doing about the same as the quote unquote vacuum of space?
11:29 Daniel Whiteson? Neither. We're not doing anywhere close to the vacuum of space. The density of vacuums in labs here on Earth is much higher, is much, much more stuff in our lab quote unquote vacuums than there is out there in space.
11:43 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
11:43 Daniel Whiteson? But let's dig into that and zoom our mental picture out from the surface of the Earth. Obviously the atmosphere drops gradually, right? There's no like huge wall or gate or anything. This is not space balls where atmosphere is like contained by a huge bubble, right? Where the code is one, two, three, four. But in a funny way, there is because space officially starts at like 100 kilometers above the surface of the Earth, which I always thought was weird.
12:08 Kelly Weinersmith? There's some debate about that though, isn't there?
12:10 Daniel Whiteson? Yes, absolutely. There is. And like you can be an astronaut. If you've gone 80 kilometers above, there's definitely a debate. It's something about astronomy. So it's not just, it depends. It's a bunch of nerds arguing about it.
12:21 Kelly Weinersmith? I thought 100 kilometers was something like, uh, at that point, there aren't enough molecules to hold up your airplane anymore. And so that's where space starts.
12:30 Daniel Whiteson? Oh, that's cool.
12:32 Kelly Weinersmith? Isn't it the Von Karman line?
12:33 Daniel Whiteson? That's the Von Karman line. Yeah. And the ISS is like 300 or 400 kilometers above the surface of the earth. So definitely in space. And so if you're inside our solar system, but outside Earth and its atmosphere, then there's still stuff out there. The vacuum of space inside the solar system is not a perfect vacuum. There's a bunch of particles. Most of it comes from the sun because the sun, as we say often, is producing a lot of stuff, not just photons, but also matter. The solar wind is electrons and protons and alpha particles. These things are zooming around with a lot of energy. And so there's something like 10 million protons per cubic meter between planets. So remember on Earth is 10 to the 25 molecules per cubic meter.
13:17 Daniel Whiteson? Labs on Earth is 10 to the 12. Now we're down to like 10 to the seven protons per cubic meter. So that's down like five or six orders of magnitude compared to vacuums on Earth.
13:27 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow. You wouldn't want to go out there, people.
13:31 Daniel Whiteson? But it would be a good place to do vacuum based experiments.
13:34 Kelly Weinersmith? Sure, yeah.
13:35 Daniel Whiteson? But it's still not that empty, right? Like millions and millions of protons are out there. It's not something you could say is empty. When we talk about vacuum in physics and theoretical physics, we mean space with no extra energy and at the minimum energy state of space. And so this interplanetary space is not approaching the theoretical physics vacuum at all.
13:56 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
13:56 Daniel Whiteson? And then take your mental picture and zoom out from the solar system. And now we're between stars, right? Somewhere between our star and Alpha Centauri, for example. Now we're in what we call the interstellar medium, the stuff between the stars. And even this is not that empty, right? It turns out there's a big range of densities of stuff from 10 to the six molecule per cubic meter, which is like the density in our solar system, all the way down to 10 to the four molecules per cubic meter.
14:23 Kelly Weinersmith? Isn't this where we thought the Oort cloud would be? Or this is like when we get past the Oort cloud?
14:27 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, so there's a couple of different boundaries here. You go out past the planets, you get to like the dwarf planets and then the Kuiper belt objects. Beyond that, there's the boundary of the heliosphere where the sun dominates and it meets the interstellar wind, the galactic wind. That's a region where you're exiting the solar system. But you're right, beyond that is more stuff. So the Oort cloud technically is part of the interstellar medium because it's past that boundary. It's in a region where the interstellar wind dominates over the sun's wind, but it is gravitationally bound to the sun. So it's sort of like playing both sides of the equation, if that makes sense.
15:07 Kelly Weinersmith? It does, but but it's still so overwhelmed by the gas in that area that the interstellar medium is 99% gas and all the rocks out there are just make up 1% dust. Would that be fair to say?
15:20 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, that's right. And we're going to come back to the interstellar medium and do a deep dive into it. It has a lot of really interesting structure. But yeah, most of it is gas. It's 99% gas. And then a little bit of it is rocks or comets like in the Oort cloud and dust. There's a few cosmic rays out there, but mostly it's just gas. And it has all sorts of interesting turbulence and structure that we're going to talk about. And don't forget, out there also in the galaxy is dark matter. We're only talking right now about the luminous matter, the kind of stuff that's made up of atoms. But we know that the universe is dominated by dark matter. We know that it's spread out throughout the galaxy, but there's five times as much of it as there is luminous matter. So you can't interact with it, but it is there.
16:04 Daniel Whiteson? And so if you're just thinking about like the density of matter overall, you have to also account for that dark matter.
16:10 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, so in the interstellar space, mostly gas, little bit of dust, you're not likely to stub your toe. But so that now we're talking about what's between the stars. But what about what's between the galaxies and the intergalactic space?
16:24 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, so now we're leaving the region we've ever probed directly. Like, we've sent probes that have left the solar system just barely. Like, Voyager 1 reached the interstellar medium in 2012, Voyager 2 in 2018. But now, we're going well beyond where we've ever probed directly, and we're relying just on observations and theory and simulation. So now, between the galaxies, what is there? Well, this is something we call, very creatively, the intergalactic medium. And this is mostly rarefied plasma. So that means essentially ionized hydrogen, it's just protons. And out there, on average, it's like 1 to 10 atoms per cubic meter. So, a pretty small number, but still not that small. I mean, intergalactic space is unimaginably vast.
17:08 Daniel Whiteson? There's just so much of it. Even if you think about space between the planets as being big, and most of the space in the solar system is the space between the planets, right? Planets and the sun are rare. Like, if you randomly sampled inside the solar system, you would very rarely touch a planet or a star. And inside the galaxy, right, structure is also very rare. But between the galaxies, it's even hard to comprehend, because we have like millions of light years between these galaxies. And yet, it's still filled with stuff. There's 1 to 10 atoms out there. And actually, these tendrils of plasma, there's also structure to it. It's not just randomly distributed. All the galaxies are connected by these tendrils of plasma, these filaments.
17:49 Daniel Whiteson? And something like half of all the atoms in the universe are outside of galaxies and are inside these tendrils between galaxies. It's incredible.
17:58 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow, and how do they get there? Do they get like shot out by suns? Or they were just there from the beginning of the creation of the universe, and they just stayed there?
18:05 Daniel Whiteson? Both and all of those.
18:07 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
18:07 Daniel Whiteson? Like, there's a feedback loop where galaxies are emitting particles, right? Supernovas and shock waves and all sorts of stuff. But mostly, this structure represents the dark matter structure of the universe. Galaxies form in the deepest wells, and then there are tendrils of dark matter between these wells. And that's where you find these tendrils of plasma. So the plasma is like a tracer that tells you where the dark matter is. And also, between these galaxies, of course, is a significant amount of dark energy. Dark energy is everywhere in space. It's just a really, really tiny amount. But because it doesn't get diluted as the universe expands over vast spaces, it really starts to add up. Between the galaxies, you have to start accounting for the dark energy. And then as you zoom out, galaxies form clusters.
18:52 Daniel Whiteson? And between those clusters, most of the energy density between those clusters is not matter at all. It's dark energy.
19:00 Kelly Weinersmith? All right, so at the big scale, we're mostly thinking about dark energy. And as we zoom in, we're starting to think about gas. Let's take a break. And when we come back, I want to go back to the interstellar medium and go into more detail about what's there.
19:16 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
19:26 Speaker 10 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 make it happen fast. Rated A plus by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
19:54 Speaker 04 This is Joel Larsgaard from How To Money. As someone who travels a lot for work, I really appreciate a premium airport experience. With the Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business American Express Card, it truly feels like you can have it all. For a limited time, new Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business Card members can earn 200,000 bonus miles, the highest miles offered this year.
20:13 Speaker 03 Yeah, card members can also enjoy 15 visits to the Delta Sky Club each medallion year when flying Delta. And you can unlock unlimited Delta Sky Club access after spending $75,000 in purchases on your card during a calendar year. Those are benefits you can get behind. You also get for one time guest passes each medallion year, so you can bring a friend or a colleague along. 15 Sky Club visits plus four guest passes? That's up to $950 in annual value. Value estimate based on $50 per visit rate to purchase additional visits or bring a guest to the Delta Sky Club. It's that kind of premium access that helps you feel right at home and at ease no matter where you're heading. Apply today at delta.com/podcast.
20:58 Speaker 03 Offer ends November 4th. Minimum spending requirements and terms apply.
21:01 Speaker 11 This is Jonas Knox from Two Pros and a Cup of Joe. Buy smart, drive for less and trade for more. That's Toyota Ford ability and it starts with a great deal on an off-road ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks. Combining power for work, tech for adventures and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
21:39 Speaker 12 Hello, hello. I'm Malcolm Gladwell, host of Smart Talks with IBM. Imagine your business depends on a system you didn't build and don't fully control. For years, it works perfectly. It's fast, reliable, affordable. So over time, more and more of your operations rely on it. Then one day, the terms change. What once felt flexible now feels difficult to leave. Moving to another provider or bringing those capabilities back under your own control could take years, cost millions and disrupt the business in the process. That's the challenge of digital sovereignty. Businesses today rely on all sorts of third-party systems.
22:21 Speaker 12 Cloud platforms, data pipelines, AI models, software tools. Most days, these systems operate quietly in the background. But when something changes, like costs go up or rules shift, organizations are forced to confront how much control and flexibility they actually have. So to understand the challenge up close, I traveled to Paris to speak with IBM's Anapaula Assis and Access CIO, Giovanni Daniele, two people who think about these questions every day. Hear the full conversation at ibm.com/smarttalks or wherever you get your podcasts.
23:15 Kelly Weinersmith? And we're back and Daniel is going to be telling us more about what is in the interstellar medium.
23:20 Daniel Whiteson? That's right. Today, we're talking about the context of our solar system, where it is and how much stuff there is around us and whether our solar system is jumping into a huge bubble in the galaxy.
23:31 Kelly Weinersmith? Sounds fun.
23:32 Daniel Whiteson? And so the important thing is to understand this bit between the stars. And something I love doing is going back in history and understanding when we understood something and what our like early silly ideas were, you know, because it's easy to just like download all of human knowledge into your brain right now. But remember that people like struggled and puzzled to figure this out. And there were many wrong paths and silly ideas entertained for hundreds of years along the way.
23:57 Kelly Weinersmith? Well, it's kind of cute to imagine that nobody in like 50 years is going to look back at us and be like, oh, remember that cute thing that the physicist thought in 2026 about, anyway, we they could be laughing at us eventually, but but let's go ahead and laugh at them.
24:12 Daniel Whiteson? So first, remember in the broader context, we didn't know that our galaxy was one of many galaxies until like the early 1900s, right? We thought we had a galaxy. It was a bunch of stars and that was it. It was just our galaxy. And that was everything. The galaxy was basically the universe and everything that was out there that wasn't actually in our galaxy, but we didn't know it yet. We called like a nebula because it was like a smeary blob in the sky. We couldn't resolve. So that's sort of like the bigger picture. But then what about inside the galaxy? Well, people tried to make like maps of the galaxy early on to try to understand the structure. But we're interested in like the bit between the stars. And it was like the late 1700s, people started to wonder like,
24:54 Daniel Whiteson? hmm, is the space between the stars really a vacuum? Or is there something there?
25:01 Daniel Whiteson? You know, and how would we know? And this coincides a little bit later with Maxwell's development of electromagnetism, the idea that light is a balance between electricity and magnetism. The energy sloshes back and forth between the two fields, but then it moves as a wave in these fields at the speed of light. And this is Maxwell's great discovery that light is a wave, which of course begged the question of a wave in what, right? And so we saw the rise of the theory of the luminiferous ether, right? This is a famous theory which was invented to explain what light is wiggling, right? Maybe there's something out there like if waves are wiggles in water and sound is wiggles
25:42 Daniel Whiteson? in air, maybe light is a wiggle in this luminiferous ether that we hadn't ever discovered before. It fills the universe. So this would be an early theory of the interstellar medium. What is out there between the stars? What allows the light to go from Alpha Centauri to us here?
25:58 Kelly Weinersmith? And so the luminiferous ether, I thought I was going to get it on the first shot.
26:03 Daniel Whiteson? Totally did.
26:04 Kelly Weinersmith? I stumbled a little. Would you find that between like Earth and Mars? Or that was just between the end of our solar system and the start of the next solar system?
26:14 Daniel Whiteson? Great question. No, it should be everywhere. If it exists, it should be everywhere. And that was key because people looked for it and they said, well, let's try to measure our velocity through this ether. If it's out there and it's a medium for light, light is wiggling through this ether, then Earth moving around the sun should be moving zigzagging basically back and forth through this ether. And if light has a constant velocity relative to the ether, then we should be able to measure light moving at different velocities as we move at different velocities through the ether.
26:44 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
26:44 Daniel Whiteson? Right? The same way that like you can catch up to sound waves in air because they have a constant velocity relative to the air. So you could catch up to them and even pass them, right? Just like when you're on a boat in a lake, you're making ripples. If you go fast enough, you can catch up to them, which it gives you a wake, right? And so if light is moving through this ether, and then as the Earth moves around the sun, we should see a change in the velocity of light. Famous Michelson-Morley experiment, of course, proved that light is the same speed year round regardless of the direction. And so apparently there is no luminiferous ether. So then people are like, oh, wow, maybe there really is a vacuum in between the stars.
27:22 Kelly Weinersmith? And you all didn't find another use for the word luminiferous ether? That's a total bummer because it just sounds so nice.
27:30 Daniel Whiteson? Well, these days is actually a proliferation of ether theories, which is very confusing because ether most generally just refers to like a theory of the substrate of space. And our current theory, that quantum field theory, where space is filled with these fields, and these fields exist in space, then that's sort of the modern ether. And that's totally cool, and nobody objects to that. But that's an ether where you can't measure your velocity relative to it. Like the luminiferous ether has a frame, it's at rest in some frame, and light moves at a constant speed only in that frame. The modern ether, quantum field theory vacuum, has no frame. And so there's a big distinction between the
28:11 Daniel Whiteson? luminiferous ether of two centuries ago and today's concepts of the ether. And in lots of pop side descriptions, you see this important distinction sort of ignored or fuzzed over.
28:22 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, all right. And I could use a quick step back and a reminder about where we are. So we've been talking about what is in space between things.
28:30 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
28:31 Kelly Weinersmith? And we've just established that we used to think there was ether between stuff, but there's not.
28:36 Daniel Whiteson? But there's not.
28:37 Kelly Weinersmith? But there's not. And so now, okay, so we're going through the history of our understanding of what was in the interstellar medium.
28:44 Daniel Whiteson? That's right.
28:45 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
28:45 Daniel Whiteson? And then in 1899, people discovered, oh, there is some actual stuff out there between the stars. Not ether, but like actual matter. There were these things called dark nebulae, essentially these dusty clouds you could see out there that passed between the stars, right? Between us and other stars, there were like these clouds of stuff, which were sometimes silhouetted against this like background star field. This is essentially the first discovery of interstellar gas. It's just blobs of gas that are out there between the stars. And so as you make more and more accurate observations of these stars, and understand like why they dim, or what you can see and what's between you and those stars, you start to build a map of the galaxy and understand like where there's dust and
29:28 Daniel Whiteson? where there's gas. And this is our first like understanding, really, of the context of our solar system.
29:34 Kelly Weinersmith? Understanding that there's gas out there, that gas isn't... Like the Oort Cloud, that's just understanding where other galaxies are out there and you're just kind of seeing them as gas? Or what is that gas exactly?
29:47 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, this is gas within our galaxy, right? Not between galaxies. This is just understanding like what's between the stars. Are the stars dots in a true vacuum? Or is there like a soup out there? And it turns out it's pretty soupy. We discovered these dark clouds of gas between the stars. And then in the early 1900s, we discovered cosmic rays, which are just particles from space that are zipping towards the earth. And if there are particles zipping towards the earth, they're zipping from somewhere, right? Which means like space out there is filled with all of these particles. So we had this growing awareness that the space between the stars is filled with gas and with ions and with electrons, just like in the solar system. And so instead of thinking of it like, here's a pocket of stuff, the star and the planets,
30:31 Daniel Whiteson? you know how now we think about like a spectrum of stuff inside the solar system? Little bits of dust all the way up to Jupiter and then the sun? In the same way, you should think about a smooth transition between the solar system and the interstellar medium, that between the stars, there is still stuff. Yes, there is a boundary where the solar wind stops dominating and the interstellar wind starts dominating. But in terms of the distribution of stuff, it's pretty smooth. And so you should expect there to be stuff out there in the interstellar medium. And it actually makes up like between 10 and 15% of the mass of the galaxy is not inside the stars. Yeah, it's between the stars. And it's going to play an important role in how those stars are formed and the health of our galaxy in forming stars, whether our galaxy keeps making stars or whether it
31:16 Daniel Whiteson? gets quenched, as they say.
31:18 Kelly Weinersmith? Don't get quenched.
31:22 Daniel Whiteson? So let's dig a little bit more deeply into what's in the interstellar medium. We said before the break that it's mostly gas, which means that it's mostly hydrogen. It's like 90% hydrogen, 10% helium. And the universe is mostly hydrogen, so that makes sense. Something that's interesting, though, is that even though there's a lot of space out there and it's not super dense, this stuff still behaves like a gas, like it interacts with itself. It's not like non-interacting, like the way The exosphere of the moon is just a bunch of particles that ignore each other. Out there, these particles are moving so fast that the mean free path is pretty short. Like, they don't go very far before they run into another one or interact with another one. They don't have to actually touch because they have charges. They can interact without touching each other.
32:06 Daniel Whiteson? So that's really fascinating. That was a little bit of a surprise to me when I learned about that.
32:09 Kelly Weinersmith? So if somebody were living out there, could they be getting power from that?
32:15 Daniel Whiteson? They could be getting killed from that. I mean, this is radiation, right? These particles are moving at high speeds. Even though it's fairly low density, these things are moving pretty fast. Like, inside the solar system, the solar wind is moving at 400 kilometers per second. Sometimes these particles have energy up to 10 keV. And in the interstellar medium, these things are even higher speeds. So technically, the temperature can sometimes be like up in the millions of Kelvin, even though the density is very, very low. So you would like freeze because there's not a lot of heat being deposited, but also you'd be riddled with all of these tiny little high-speed bullets.
32:49 Kelly Weinersmith? That's definitely worse than New Jersey.
32:53 Daniel Whiteson? It's a close call, but I agree with you.
32:54 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, I do like New Jersey, though. I was born there.
32:57 Daniel Whiteson? The other fascinating bit about the interstellar medium is what's not gas, which is the dust. And dust sounds like, you know, stuff you'd sweep up and throw away. But dust is actually super fascinating from a cosmic sense. Because dust comes from dead stars, right? Like, how do you make dust? You need heavier elements. You need those elements to stick together. You need them to form these little crystals and to gather more bits to themselves. And dust is like the seed for new solar systems and new planets, right? Our Earth formed by a bunch of dust, which bounced into itself and stuck together and formed a bigger piece of dust and gathered more together. So these are really the seeds of future solar systems, as well as the ashes of previous ones.
33:38 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, man, at first I thought you were talking about gallstone formation, and then it sounded much more beautiful. And I'm glad my gallstones, you know, stopped getting bigger before they formed planets and universes.
33:50 Daniel Whiteson? But there's huge amounts of like iron and silicon, magnesium, a bunch of oxygen and carbon. There's even like nano diamonds and fullerenes out there. They're really fascinating. And some of these things are pre-solar grains, which are preserved from the original star. So things formed like in the atmosphere of the star and then there's a supernova that blasts out and spreads all these dust grains and some of them survive, right? They're not shattered. A lot of this stuff is smashed into itself and shattered and reprocessed. But some of these pre-solar grains survive and we actually find them like on the ocean floor. We can find little grains of dust that survived a supernova and zoomed across the universe and gathered together to help form the Earth.
34:34 Kelly Weinersmith? How could you know? How could you find a grain of sand and be like, I know where you came from?
34:41 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, they have really unusual isotope mixtures, which you only find like in those conditions that are formed like in the atmospheres of supernovas. It's really incredible.
34:50 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow, that is incredible.
34:52 Daniel Whiteson? And so the interstellar medium, it's mostly gas. There's a little bit of dust out there. It's like 1%, but I think that's the most interesting part. And then of course, some of it is very, very high energy particles zooming through space, cosmic rays. And so you mix all this together and that's what the interstellar medium is made out of. Mostly gas, which is actually mostly molecular, not ionized, and then 1% dust and then a few very high energy ions.
35:16 Kelly Weinersmith? All right, we are getting closer to talking about the amazing and exciting super bubble. So we're going to take a break. And when we get back, we're going to talk about how the gas and the dust are structured inside of the interstellar medium.
35:37 Speaker 13 OnDeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team, or bridging cash flow gaps, OnDeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A+ by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five-star TrustPilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes at ondeck.com. Depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank. OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts subject to lender approval.
36:07 Speaker 14 This is Troy Millings. As someone who travels a lot for work, I really appreciate a premium airport experience. With the Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business American Express Card, it truly feels like you can have it all. For a limited time, new Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business Card members can earn 200,000 bonus miles, the highest miles offered this year. Card members can also enjoy 15 visits to the Delta Sky Club each medallion year when flying Delta, and you can unlock unlimited Delta Sky Club access after spending $75,000 in purchases on your card during a calendar year. Those are benefits you can get behind. You also get four one-time guest passes each medallion year, so you can bring a friend or colleague along.
36:50 Speaker 14 15 Sky Club visits plus four guest passes? That's up to $950,000 annual value. Value estimate based on a $50 per visit rate to purchase additional visits or bring a guest to the Delta Sky Club. It's the kind of premium access that helps you feel right at home and at ease, no matter where you're headed. Apply today at www.delta.com/podcast. Offer ends November 4, 2026. Minimum spending requirements and terms apply.
37:20 Speaker 15 This is Shirley Strawberry from the Steve Harvey Morning Show. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota affordability. And it starts with a great deal on an all-wheel-drive Camry, Corolla Cross, or a Corolla Sedan with the latest features and tech. Or test drive a spacious Grand Highlander or adventure-ready RAV4. And with so many hybrid models available, you can enjoy longer trips without all the stops. While Toyota's legendary resale value means you could get more at trade-in, get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for deals and details. Toyota, let's go places.
38:02 Speaker 12 Hello, hello. I'm Malcolm Gladwell, host of Smart Talks with IBM. Imagine your business depends on a system you didn't build and don't fully control. For years, it works perfectly. It's fast, reliable, affordable. So over time, more and more of your operations rely on it. Then one day, the terms change. What once felt flexible now feels difficult to leave. Moving to another provider or bringing those capabilities back under your own control could take years, cost millions, and disrupt the business in the process. That's the challenge of digital sovereignty. Businesses today rely on all sorts of third-party systems: cloud platforms, data pipelines,
38:46 Speaker 12 AI models, software tools. Most days, these systems operate quietly in the background. But when something changes, like costs go up or rules shift, organizations are forced to confront how much control and flexibility they actually have. So to understand the challenge up close, I traveled to Paris to speak with IBM's Annapola Assis and Acts as CIO, Giovanni D'Angelo, two people who think about these questions every day. Hear the full conversation at ibm.com/smarttalks or wherever you get your podcasts.
39:38 Kelly Weinersmith? We are back and we're talking about the interstellar medium, the space between the stars. And we've established that it's mostly gas, some dust in there. How is all of that stuff structured in this space, Daniel?
39:51 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, so you might imagine, oh, it's just smooth. It's just spread out out there. But it's not. It's like a vast fluid, which means it has all sorts of stuff going on. It's like our atmosphere, right, which we model and has currents and winds and high-density regions and low-density regions. And so you can think about the interstellar medium as a vast fluid because it is interacting, right? The mean free path of these particles is pretty short, but it's also more complex than a simple fluid because often these particles are moving really, really fast or whole regions of particles are moving super duper fast. So you can have supersonic regions of this interstellar medium, right? Places where the gas is moving faster than the speed of
40:31 Daniel Whiteson? sound in that medium. Remember, you can define the speed of sound in anything, in water, in air, in steel, and it depends like on the density of the thing. Things that are denser, the bonds are tighter. And if you push on one, then the pressure wave propagates more quickly than it would if something was really low density because then the particles have to drift longer before they bump into each other.
40:53 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
40:53 Daniel Whiteson? And so what happens in the interstellar medium is you have these shock waves, these supersonic shock waves, which smash into something else. And so you get this supersonic shock wave, but that compresses the gas, makes it more dense, and that actually raises the speed of sound. So then the local flow becomes subsonic. So you get supersonic shock waves, which then actually becomes subsonic. And so it creates this really complex structure and these really interesting patterns of density. It's really hard to model because it's so chaotic.
41:25 Kelly Weinersmith? So in order to hear sound, you need like molecules to transmit it. So like if you were out there, would you be hearing these particles or not really?
41:36 Daniel Whiteson? You can technically scream and be heard in the interstellar medium. It would be very faint and very, very slow, right?
41:43 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
41:44 Daniel Whiteson? You could hear these things. I can tell you what they would sound like, you know, probably like
41:50 Kelly Weinersmith? Cool, okay.
41:50 Daniel Whiteson? Very interesting.
41:52 Kelly Weinersmith? I don't know why, but in my mind, I had imagined the interstellar space as being like a quiet, calm, still place, which is probably silly because you know, like solar winds keep things moving. There's probably nowhere in space that's actually super still.
42:03 Daniel Whiteson? No.
42:03 Kelly Weinersmith? But I hadn't imagined it being super turbulent like this. So
42:06 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah, it's really turbulent and you know, on time scales that we don't usually think about. But if you played a movie, you know, where a million years passes in a second, it would look like bubbling frothing tea or something, you know, it's a lot of stuff going on. And the most interesting stuff that goes on is that when you get dense regions, you get star formation, right? If you have a clump of gas and it cools down enough, then one of those grains of dust can start to gather other stuff near it. It's important that it's cool, remember? Because if things are really, really hot, that means they're moving fast and then gravity has no chance to pull them together. But if things are cool, that means they're slow moving and gravity can gather dust grains together, little bits at a time.
42:49 Daniel Whiteson? They stick together, they start forming bigger and bigger stuff. And that's when you get gravitational collapse, leads to a runaway effect, you get more gravity, and then you get a star forming and there are stuff around it, starts to swirl around it into a protoplanetary disk. And that's how a star is born. It's born from denser regions in the interstellar medium and those regions come from the turbulence. So the structure in the interstellar medium is the reason we have stars.
43:14 Kelly Weinersmith? The structure in the interstellar medium, but don't you only have interstellar medium because it's the region between pre-existing stars?
43:22 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah.
43:24 Daniel Whiteson? There's sort of a circular definition there, but yeah, the interstellar medium can make new stars and then it's no longer the interstellar medium.
43:30 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay. And so you could, you could imagine this process going on infinitely many times and then you just have an infinite number of suns. So how, how often does this process happen?
43:39 Daniel Whiteson? So it depends a lot on the details of the temperature of the cloud and the composition. But when it happens, it happens a lot. Like you get a lot of stars all born in one neighborhood together. And this is why, for example, stars are very often found in binary systems, like pairs of stars, gravitationally bound to each other, or even briefly trinary systems, or more long-lived systems, where you have like a binary star and another one that's more distant, so that's like effectively a binary system. So you have these regions of star formation where a huge cloud meets these requirements, where you have like little dense grains and the whole thing is cold enough. And how often it happens depends a lot on the history of your galaxy. There's actually an interplay between the stars and the interstellar medium, which
44:24 Daniel Whiteson? we're going to talk about, because the stars push back and form these bubbles. And so it's a whole complex evolving thing. And the rate at which stars form changes a lot where you are in the galaxy and over time. And it's not something we fully understand. Like some galaxies out there have stopped forming stars at all and some of them are still making stars. And this is called quenching and it's not something that's fully understood.
44:48 Kelly Weinersmith? All right. Well, we still haven't gotten to the bubbles. How do we get closer to bubbles?
44:51 Daniel Whiteson? Yeah. So you have the interstellar medium. You have these clouds of gas. Sometimes they collapse and form a star. What happens when you make a star is that it pushes back against the interstellar medium. Right? Like our sun has a solar wind and that's pushing back. The reason we call it a solar system is it's the region where our solar wind dominates. So now you have this cavity inside the interstellar medium. Right? And so the sun basically makes like a little bubble, which we call the heliosphere, by pushing back against the interstellar medium. So now imagine you have a bunch of stars, each with their little bubbles, and one of them goes supernova, right? So this blows out a huge region inside the ISM, and this can create a super bubble that's like hundreds of light years across.
45:34 Daniel Whiteson? Because remember, a supernova is the collapse of a star gravitationally, which then bounces back out and dumps an enormous amount of energy. A single supernova can be brighter than the entire galaxy. And it doesn't just put out photons, it also shoots out a huge number of particles.
45:50 Kelly Weinersmith? How many light years across is our solar system?
45:54 Daniel Whiteson? So our solar system is like one or two light years in radius.
45:58 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
45:59 Daniel Whiteson? Right? So it's pretty small, but then a supernova can make a bubble that's like hundreds of light years across.
46:04 Kelly Weinersmith? Wow.
46:04 Daniel Whiteson? And if there's multiple supernova, because remember, stars are formed in bunches, and that means they can also go supernova in bunches. They have like their cycles all synchronized.
46:13 Kelly Weinersmith? Oh, boy.
46:13 Daniel Whiteson? Then you can get a really big bubble that lasts for like tens of millions of years.
46:18 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay, so the the bubbles that we're talking about then are solar winds of some sort blowing interstellar medium out, and that is the bubble. These are not the fun bubbles that I was imagining, Daniel.
46:32 Daniel Whiteson? So you get little bubbles from solar winds, but you really get the super bubbles from a bunch of supernovas all going off at once and making these really vast bubbles. It's super cool. Also, if one happens near the edge of the galaxy, like the galaxy is a big disk, right? It's like much broader than it is thick. So if it occurs like near the top of the disk, then essentially it creates like a hole in the galaxy, and they call it a galactic chimney. Because then hot gas from inside the galaxy basically vents out from the galaxy. So you have like a little spurt.
47:06 Kelly Weinersmith? So the question that we're answering today is, do we live in a super bubble? But timing's got to matter too, right? If you get a bunch of stars going supernova all at once to make your super bubble, you would be dead if you were inside of the super bubble region, right? So it's got to go super bubble, make a bubble.
47:22 Daniel Whiteson? Exactly.
47:22 Kelly Weinersmith? And then a planet needs to like wander in or get captured and then become habitable. And then you find yourself inside the super bubble. That's how that would have to work, right? Okay.
47:31 Daniel Whiteson? Right. And remember, our solar system has existed for like almost 5 billion years. But these super bubbles last for tens of millions of years. They're very transient. And our star is moving through the galaxy, right? And its orbit takes hundreds of millions of years. And so they're created by supernova, but you don't want to be there when they're made. You're right. And so coincidentally, there is a bubble. It's called the local bubble. It's 300 to 1,000 light year wide. It has a much lower gas density than the rest of the interstellar medium, but like down by 10. And it's surrounded by denser walls of neutral gas and dust. Probably was formed by like maybe 10 to 20 supernovas that happened over the last 10 to 15 million years.
48:15 Daniel Whiteson? So sort of recently on cosmic history scales. We can't pinpoint exactly which stars they are. Probably they're stars related to the Scorpius Centaurus Association of Stars. And the shape of it is kind of weird. It's not spherical and there's other like nearby bubbles that it connects to called Loop 1. And so fortunately, it formed before we got here, right? The sun orbits the center of the galaxy at like 220 kilometers per second and moves at like 25 kilometers per second relative to the interstellar medium. And so that means that we go like 20 to 30 parsecs every million years or so. This bubble is a few hundred parsecs across.
48:59 Daniel Whiteson? So it seems like about 15 million years ago, the first supernova started inflating this bubble. Five or 10 million years ago, we entered the cavity. And now we're in this super bubble. We're drifting through a little warm cloud of gas inside this bubble. And in a couple million years, we're probably going to exit it back into the interstellar medium, which is a little bit denser.
49:22 Kelly Weinersmith? So when we enter the interstellar medium, where there's all of that turbulence and it's crazy, is that going to be a bad time for us?
49:30 Daniel Whiteson? No, probably not, because we have the solar wind which protects us. We have
49:34 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
49:35 Daniel Whiteson? We're like moving within our own little bubble anyway.
49:37 Kelly Weinersmith? Okay.
49:37 Daniel Whiteson? So it doesn't really matter that much. It's just a way to highlight that there's a lot of stuff happening out there, right? There's turbulence and chaos and all that stuff and star formation and star dying and all that happens because of this structure. Like you get stars because you have denser regions and then those stars blow out, make super bubbles when they die to make less dense regions, but then those super bubbles collapse because the interior is lower density but higher temperature and that hot gas leaks out and ruptures the shell. And so you get this cycle of stuff. And so, you know, you shouldn't think of the galaxy out there between the stars as empty. In fact, it's filled with stuff and it's really dynamic.
50:17 Daniel Whiteson? And the structure out there is what determines like where stars are made and then stars explode and replenish the interstellar medium. And so the interplay between the stars and the interstellar medium really determines like, hey, is your galaxy making stars or not? Is it depleasing all of its gas? All of this kind of stuff is determined by this interaction between the stars and the interstellar medium.
50:41 Kelly Weinersmith? So, so we live inside of a bubble made by our sun, which is currently inside of the local super bubble.
50:48 Daniel Whiteson? That's right. That was made by supernovas of other stars, fortunately, before we entered this region.
50:54 Kelly Weinersmith? Amazing.
50:57 Daniel Whiteson? Exactly. And so that's the broader context of your life. We happen to be living inside this bubble and now you know all about it.
51:04 Kelly Weinersmith? That's right. And we hope that you don't stub your toes on any galactic dust or happen to get dust of any sort inside of your gallbladder or kidneys or anything else. We wish you health and this is not a great transition, but man, it hurt to laugh at Daniel's jokes today.
51:20 Daniel Whiteson? I tried to hold back. I really, really did.
51:22 Kelly Weinersmith? I appreciate it, Daniel. You can't help yourself. You're just a funny guy.
51:27 Daniel Whiteson? Looks aren't everything.
51:30 Daniel Whiteson? Thanks, everybody.
51:39 Kelly Weinersmith? Daniel and Kelly's Extraordinary Universe is produced by iHeartRadio. We would love to hear from you.
51:44 Daniel Whiteson? We really would. We want to know what questions you have about this extraordinary universe.
51:50 Kelly Weinersmith? We want to know your thoughts on recent shows, suggestions for future shows. If you contact us, we will get back to you.
51:57 Daniel Whiteson? We really mean it. We answer every message. Email us at questions@danielandkelly.org.
52:03 Kelly Weinersmith? Or you can find us on social media. We have accounts on X, Instagram, Blue Sky, and on all of those platforms, you can find us at D and K Universe.
52:13 Daniel Whiteson? Don't be shy. Write to us.
52:17 Speaker 16 With ChatGPT, you can do more than get answers. You can get things done. Whether you're leading a big project, planning an elaborate trip, or trying to balance work and life, ChatGPT can help. Give it a goal, plus things like files, notes, or project plans. Develop a trip itinerary with daily updates, or create a priority schedule. So you can spend less energy sorting out the details and more on bringing your biggest ideas to life. Get started at chatgpt.com.
52:44 Speaker 11 This is Jonas Knox from Two Pros and a Cup of Joe. Buy smart, drive for less, and trade for more. That's Toyota Ford ability, and it starts with a great deal on an off-road ready Tacoma or half-ton Tundra, two of Toyota's longest-lasting trucks. Combining power for work, tech for adventures, and style in between. Built on a reputation for quality and reliability, Toyota trucks are known for holding their value, which could mean big savings when it's time for your next Toyota. So get a great deal today and a great value tomorrow. Shop toyota.com for more. Toyota, let's go places.
53:21 Speaker 17 If you're a fight fan and you haven't seen the BKFC app yet, you're missing the world's most exciting combat sport. Bare knuckle fighting championship has changed the game. No gloves, no stalling, no boring rolling around on the ground, just pure violence and pure entertainment. The BKFC app includes live events, past fights, original series, behind-the-scenes access, merch discounts, and more. Only $7.99 a month, or $49.99 a year. Get the BKFC app at BKFC.com.
53:52 Speaker 18 Hey, I'm Niall Rogers. This fall, I'll be driving across the country, meeting some of today's coolest and most fascinating artists. We'll explore the stories before the moments that changed everything. Because every musician remembers the moment where it all began. Experience Before the Moment, a Lincoln original series on the iHeart Radio app, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
54:23 Speaker 13 This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed Human.
Previous Is Cold Fusion impossible? Next Listener Questions #33 Page updated October 31, 2026 · transcript and summary are machine-generated